Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Daily Journal
Prepared by:
Arun Kumar Thaticherla MBAEx 11/13
Manish Bujranpally MBAEx 29/13
Manmeet Pahuja MBAEx 30/13
Praveen Kumar MBAEx 44/13
Srinivas H MBAEx 56/13
Sagar Taneja MBAEx 60/13
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Table of Contents
Sessions 1 / 2: Understanding Globalization and its implication to international
business .............................................................................................................................. 2
Session 3: Managing International Business.................................................................... 4
Session 4: Why and How do firms go global? .................................................................. 7
Session 5: Why and How do Firms go global? ................................................................. 9
Session 6: Planning the Market entry .............................................................................. 11
Session 7: Developing a foreign market entry plan........................................................ 12
Session 9: Developing International business strategy ................................................. 14
Sessions 10/11- Responsible internationalization strategy ........................................... 17
Session 12: Subsidiary formation and being a country manager ................................. 20
Session 13: Being a Global manager............................................................................... 22
Session 14: Review, Reflection and Integration ............................................................. 23
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Pull Factors
Globalization of firms
Push Factors
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
China & India, both have huge market, cost arbitrage and resources which is a rare
phenomenon.
Key points important to the course:
1. Recognize that differences matter: the world isn’t perfectly integrated
2. View the world-differences and similarities- with a balanced perspective
3. Remember that the real challenge is not just to understand differences but to address
them.
Despite all disruptive changes, the basic concepts of management still apply to businesses.
Regulatory and cultural rules/norms create obvious differences.
In every community we must remember that we do not do business in market, we do
business in societies.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
One of the frameworks that can help organizations evaluate their decision to expand globally
is the CAGE framework.
CAGE Distance Framework: The CAGE Distance Framework is a tool that can be used to
uncover important differences between various countries that companies should take into
account when deciding on their strategy. The acronym CAGE stands for Culture,
Administrative, Geographical, and Economic. The CAGE Distance Framework helps
companies because it can evaluate countries and determine the distance between them. This
does not only involve physical geographical distance, but also figurative distances between
various cultures, economies, and working methods.
Cultural differences - Culture may be defined as a collection of values, norms, rules, and
convictions that form the behavior of people.
Examples:
Different languages
Different ethnicities
Different religions
Different values & norms etc
Administrative differences -It involves the historical and current legal and political
differences between two countries. It helps the organization gauge whether these differences
are an aid or an obstacle to the expansion strategy.
Examples:
Legislation and regulations
Trade agreements
Corruption
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Geographical differences – It involves the physical aspect of the distance between two
countries and includes differences such as their size, transport and infrastructure, climatic
differences and other aspects.
Examples:
· Physical distance
· Lack or presence of borders
· Different time zones
· Differences in climate
· Geographical location
· Means of transportation
In the case ‘Play it safe at home or take a risk abroad’, the CEO of Coe’s had the following
options:
i) To focus on their current market US and look or more opportunities there
ii) Expand internationally to Mexico or Europe
The advantage of the first strategy is that they understood the local market conditioned well
and had an established brand. This was a less risky option than to go abroad. They still had
some more potential for growth by putting a store next to every Walmart and experimenting
with their product line – maybe try the rent-to-own concept for goods beyond basic
household items.
The second strategy is much riskier and can add complications, but if it works out, would
give them access to new market and tremendous potential for growth. They had already
expanded successfully in Canada, where they had about 100 stores. They also had a sour
experience when they tried to expand in Puerto Rico, where they had to suffer losses and
wrap up their business.
We are of the opinion that Coe’s should go for global expansion but start with countries like
UK, which have a very small institutional difference from US. When we apply the CAGE
framework, UK is pretty similar to US and the only unfavorable factor would be the large
geographical distance between the two countries which could lead to high transportation costs
for Coe’s.
In general, there is a large failure rate for organizations trying to expand globally. Some of
the reasons for that are:
High cost of doing business
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
International
Trade
Domestic industry Multi-domestic industry
Railroads Restaurants
Laundries Retail banking
Hairdressing Hotels
Milk Consulting
Low
Low FDI High
Market
drivers
Forces favoring
Cost drivers
global Government
drivers
integration/local
responsiveness
Competitive
drivers
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Always understand the value creation/delivery that happens in an industry. Create a mental
map of how does a firm fit into that value chain.
Levers of value:
An important criterion for a company to go global, unless “born global” like a platform-based
app – ecommerce/aggregators, is that a company needs to first establish itself in its local
market.
This criterion has been clearly illustrated with the case of Haier, a white goods leader in
China with almost 30% of market share. Haier was successful in the Chinese market due to
its strengths as mentioned below:
Rapid market response: Haier was well organized to understand what customers want and
meet their needs. For instance, when the company realized that the rural Chinese were
using the washing machines for cleansing potatoes, Haier engineers modified the design to
accommodate their needs. In another instance, considering the summer lifestyles, it created
a tiny washing machine that can be used for a single change of clothes that saved water and
electricity and was an instant hit in cities like Shanghai.
Innovation: Haier’s market responsiveness lead to an innovation culture. Haier had about 96
products and 15100 specifications. Haier was able to make these innovations with minimal
cost but was able to deliver high value to its customers.
After Sales service: Haier was able to create a customer relationship management(CRM)
kind of system back in 1990 and was able to effectively and efficiently service its customers.
Stories of extraordinary services in the most unexpected scenarios resonated across the
country adding to the goodwill and brand value of the company
Efficient Distribution: Haier was a pioneer to offer Just in time(JIT) purchasing, raw materials
delivery and distribution. It reorganized its logistics unit and introduced IT that effectively
reduced the order to delivery cycle from existing 36 days to under 10 days
As the Chinese market opened up due to liberalization, many foreign firms entered the
market. Although, Haier was still able to maintain its market share, it realized that most of the
tangible strengths were temporary and can be replicated by global competitors if they
localized. Thus, Haier required to grow beyond the local boundaries and strategizes to go to
the developed markets first before venturing into the developing markets. A part of the
strategy was that establishing a brand name in developed markets will make entry into the
developing markets easier, but the larger part of the strategy was to compete with global
companies in a developed market, which would allow Haier to learn and grow its
competencies.
A company can analyze its capabilities that can be moved from the home to foreign country
using the Relevant, Appropriate and Transferable(RAT) test and similarly the capabilities
that the company can carry from foreign to home can be analyzed using the
Complementary, Appropriate and Transferable(CAT) test
Haier focused on niche segments first, by catering to the needs of students or offices and
gained a market share with higher margins. The innovation culture helped Haier to quickly
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
develop the competitive compact refrigerators for the needs of students and offices quickly
and any other innovations that would satisfy a customer need. It later expanded its offerings
to major retail chains and then ventured into the mainstream market after a considerable
brand reputation was built. A factor that helped Haier to be easily accepted by the developed
market without an ill-conceived notion of a Chinese company is its name, it closely
resonated with German name than a Chinese name. Deliberately or not, the naming helped
mitigate the country of origin effect to an extent. It also extensively used the local resources
to best understand the market and build up the operations locally.
However, the thought of establishing itself in developed market would help gain market in
the developing market proved wrong. For instance, in India, an emerging market, needed
much more emphasis on the locals for the know-hows and was not able to leverage its
global presence easily.
In continuance to the strategy to learn and develop a competitive edge over its competitors
through innovation, Haier looks to develop smart appliances with the use of Information
technology and capture the global market and work towards its long time vision of ‘one-third
domestic sales, one-third exports, and one-third produced and sold abroad’.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
● There are some motives for going global as articulated by the managers.
Such as Growth, Profit, Efficiency, Spreading risk, Better Valuation etc.
● Better Valuation usually comes for organizations with an increase in the country
markets.
● CEMEX also emerged as global player using the Double Diamond concept.
Selecting global markets to enter, entry modes are crucial in evaluating how much of a
company’s basic value proposition can be adapted. Not all markets can be entered owing to
paucity of resources and oversight. Picking the best mode of entry and timing it right are very
important guiding principles. There are four key factors in selecting global markets or
estimating market attractiveness; market size and growth, country’s institutional context,
competitive environment and market’s cultural, administrative, geographic and economic
distance from the company’s other markets. Timing the entry correctly and avoiding the
“grass is greener” and “first-mover advantage trap” are very crucial in determining the
success of foreign market entry.
The framework lays out guidelines to evaluate the national business environment to
complement analyses of industry dynamics and international environment. The
framework helps in building a holistic picture that integrates a country’s strategy
(implicit and explicit goals and policies), context (resources at disposal for a nation,
players involved and rules of the game) and performance (country’s economic,
political and social indicators).
Economic, Social and political goals and policies of a company and how they fit with
the resources at the country’s disposal are fundamental to laying out the context.
The players involved and the rules of the game (both formal and informal) help better
flesh out the international dimension of the country. Finally, a thorough and careful
evaluation of all policies of a country and the potential impact of the range of
change/shift in policies can have on various economic, social and political indicators
of performance is warranted.
The Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, with a state-led development model has a
burgeoning population and quickly growing GDP. The country however had limited
infrastructure, limited competition which meant very low brand awareness, fragmented
distribution channels, paucity of talented human resources, high levels of corruption and a
poor IP protection regime. CareCo, ShoeCo and Medco are three companies with different
businesses and varying strategic objectives that were evaluating the Ethiopian market
potentiality and considering possible modes of entry for the same.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
CareCo’s personal care products enjoy great brand awareness in Ethiopia. Low market
potential and poor enforcement of IP laws (licensing unfriendly) mean that CareCo should
stick to local agent or importer route to enter the market with a $3 million upfront investment.
It is prudent for them to test the market out before venturing further in. ShoeCo’s ambition to
locally manufacture and export outside Ethiopia by leveraging lower labour costs and tax
incentives might not pan out. The huge investment involved is discouraging considering
market potentiality and risk s associated in the VUCA conditions prevalent in the Ethiopian
market. ShoeCo is better off going for a licensing agreement and testing the waters. MedCo,
even though in the business of manufacturing generic drugs must not discount the fact that
the poor IP regime ma not give them process based IP protection. Heavy corruption in the
Ministry of Health, who will be their major customer and fragmented nature of the retail
pharmacy channel outweigh the benefits of 5 year tax exemption, operational efficiencies
and cost advantages associated with a wholly owned subsidiary option. We believe that
ShoeCo’s interests are better served with a importing option for the time being till the market
develops further.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Market Size & Growth, Risk, Government Regulations, Competitive Environment, Cultural
Distance, Local Infrastructure, Company objectives, Need for Control, Internal Resources,
Assets & Capabilities, Flexibility, Transaction Cost Economics (TCE), and Resource-based
View (RBV) are various criteria that need to be rigorously assessed in order to zero in on the
optimal mode of entry which can point to firm-specific path of maximum value realization.
Modes of Entry
Franchising: Just as licensing, franchising also has minimal risk and investment. At the
same time, since the franchisees’ profits are linked with efforts, franchisees are highly
motivated workforce. Master-franchising, where a local entrepreneur is awarded blanket
franchise for a particular territory (country or a group of countries) with agreements to
establish a certain number of outlets over a given time horizon is another option. Cultural
and physical proximity play a huge role in reaping full benefits of franchising option.
Outsourcing: Cost-saving, lower exposure to political and economic factors are key drivers
to choose outsourcing or contract manufacturing. It however offers less flexibility to respond
to sudden market demand changes. Choosing subcontractors with solid financial footing,
flexible and JIT oriented mindsets and with ability to meet quality standards can ensure
effective benefits realization.
Joint Ventures: JV’s have a high return potential compared to above options. Cooperative
or equity JVs are choices based on mutual trust and compatibility. As with above options,
there is a fear of “nurturing our future competitor” threat in this option. Firms should
cautiously choose partner with mutual synergies without diluting competitive advantage.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Bridging cultural gaps, establishing clear objectives and mutual top management
commitment and respect are the foundational steps for a successful JV.
Exit Strategies: Even after best foot forward, firms might face certain situations where exit
might be the most prudent choice. Sustained losses, difficulty in cracking the market,
volatility of the economic and political factors, premature entry, ethical reasons, resource
reallocation or intense competition can all contribute to a firm’s exiting of a market. There are
however costs associated (fixed costs, corporate image damage, disposition of assets etc)
with such a choice. Following an incremental exit approach along with careful contemplation
and assessment of all options to salvage the foreign business and migrating as many
customers as possible will all ensure in strategically exiting the market.
The African continent is a huge market that cannot be ignored. It has a growing working-age
population that is increasingly getting urbanized and is connected. Their willingness to spend
is increasing in tandem with rising per capita incomes. Urbanization and rising mobile
connections are onboarding consumers for various segments at a rapid pace. Consumer
Companies looking to enter the market must develop a granular view of growth factors such
as economic indicators, local market trends, and statistical growth models. African
consumers greatly reward trust-worthy brands and the time is ripe to begin to win them over.
Challenges that need to be sliced and diced based on individual market and segments
comprise:
· Poor Infrastructure
· Linguistic Diversity
Winning in the African Consumer market is a nuanced game. Understanding local needs and
preferences and combining those insights with local buying behaviors can yield dividends.
Learning from and partnering with local businesses can help better tailor their offerings to the
African consumers. Investing in trading partners to establish a robust “route-to-market”
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
distribution model that is custom made to each geography and channel takes great
significance. Finally, building a large and well-equipped sales force is paramount considering
the fragmented nature of the market. Investing in technologies to train sales force to collect
data, which is scarce will help build lasting competitive advantage.
Rising working class population, increasing participation of women in the working force,
burgeoning young population and increasing disposable incomes (a function of rising per
capita incomes) are all healthy indicators for zeroing in on potential markets for expansion
for the value proposition of Wendy’s in these foreign markets. Based on all market data and
individual political, economic, regulatory, ethical and cultural outlooks of various countries
Wendy’s has to narrow down upon potential targets for expansion. If we were to advise
Wendy’s to open 1,000 restaurants in the next 3 years in all possible markets discussed in
the case, our team believes that the following combination will yield the optimal resource
allocation and value maximization:
· Kenya: 200
· Ghana: 150
· Vietnam: 50
· Colombia: 50
Wiith a population of 48.5 Million, $1,380 GNI per capita and 6.12% growth rate and
assuming 20% saving rate and 5/7th of spending on food, Kenya represents a $38 Billion
market. Similarly, Ghana roughly sums up to about $6 Billion market. Aiming for a
conservative 10% market penetration gives a potential revenue stream $4.5 Billion. A target
of 350 outlets in these two countries adequately justifies the market potential.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Sustainability issues:
a. Exponential ecological degradation over the last century
b. Widening social gap between rich and poor
We may need 3 planets if everyone in this world aspires for American or European
lifestyle..!!!
Humanistic
Economic
Sustainable Environmental
development
Social
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Paradigm shift:
The picture can't be display ed.
Exploration -
Exploitation
Preservation -
Restoration -
Rejuvenation
Restricting - Controlling -
Maximizing
Sharing - Balancing -
Optimizing
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
The CEO should be away from the day to day operational issues and should spent more time
formulating the future strategy of the organization.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
In our view, he should continue to work independently on the India operations as he would
not want to be seen as a weak leader, who is unable to cope up with the challenges faced in
India. He had done the hard work of analyzing the Indian market and built a competitive
management team which takes time and effort.
Best should not be the enemy of good. Perfection should not kill improvement. Social
solutions are never binary in nature. Binary solutions will lead to failure. Pragmatism leads to
more balanced solutions.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Tried to identify the reasons for the deviation from strategy as identified from the case
regarding the orders received, where 8 months into operations, they were nowhere close to
their target of 50 elevators in one year
Partially attributed to culture and behavior of the team recruited
Especially the nature of work carried out by TAK Matthews, as he was working for
Otis (a competitor) who were in the business of providing customized products and targeted
high rises with little emphasis on service contracts, Matthews took orders for customized
products which was against the strategy.
Also, the design engineers in Europe were reluctant to share their designs to the indian
subsidiary, which in turn delayed the production outsourcing. The design engineers might
have perceived Ronnie Dante, the engineering manager to be under qualified and hence not
worthy of their time.
Silvio was able to overcome these issues by shaping the culture of the subsidiary, orient it
more towards service by hiring younger professionals and grooming them, getting the
eurpoean designers to work with the subsidiary engineer so they understand each other’s
capabilities and build a mutual respect, and took small corrective actions as they progressed
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
● In the later half after discussing Schindler’s case class discussed and learned about
concept of Authority vs Power.
● Case discussion for ‘From Regional Star to Global Leader’, in which the class was
involved in understanding the problems of attributes and thinking.
● As of now, the organization did business only in french. All process with as per the
french culture, and recently a new member was added. Leadership thinking was
significantly french.
● The local attitude was not aligned with the global aspirations of the company.
● The issue present in Deronde International if continues would be a huge loss in terms
of a potential head and potential best market.
● Course completed with a final note from the professor about 5C’s followed by loud
applause by the class.