Pengamatan Pertama (28 HST)

Ulangan 1
p4b2 p3b4 p2b2 p3b1 p1b4 p2b3 p1b2 p3b2 p1b1 p4b1
16 20 18 20 16 18 18 18 16 20
18 17 16 18 17 16 17 17 16 16
17 16 18 18 17 20 16 21 16 16
20 19 16 17 18 18 20 18 19 18
16 18 17 20 16 18 18 18 18 16
18 18 20 18 18 21 16 20 14 19
17.5 18 17.5 18.5 17 18.5 17.5 18.66667 16.5 17.5

Ulangan 2
p2b1 p4b4 p1b1 p2b4 p1b3 p2b2 p3b3 p1b2 p3b4 p2b3
16 20 18 16 20 16 18 18 19 15
18 17 16 20 16 18 20 16 17 20
16 18 17 18 18 20 23 15 16 18
17 20 18 16 17 16 19 20 19 16
18 16 14 16 16 18 20 16 15 18
20 18 18 15 14 17 23 15 18 16
17.5 18.16667 16.833333 16.83333 16.83333 17.5 20.5 16.66667 17.33333 17.16667
 Ulangan
Perlakuan
p2b4 p3b3 p2b1 p4b4 p1b3 p4b3 1 2
19 22 18 18 18 18 p1b1 17.00 16.60
16 23 16 19 20 16 p1b2 17.80 17.00
18 24 20 20 16 18 p1b3 17.80 17.40
15 20 18 22 19 20 p1b4 16.80 17.60
20 22 16 18 16 17 p2b1 17.60 17.00
17 21 20 20 17 16 p2b2 17.00 17.60
17.5 22 18 19.5 17.66667 17.5 p2b3 18.00 17.40
p2b4 17.60 17.20
p3b1 18.60 17.00
p4b1 p4b3 p3b1 p1b4 p3b2 p4b2 p3b2 18.40 17.20
20 16 15 17 18 19 p3b3 22.20 20.00
19 18 17 18 15 18 p3b4 18.00 17.20
14 20 22 18 18 20 p4b1 17.20 17.20
16 19 15 20 16 17 p4b2 17.40 18.00
17 18 16 15 19 16 p4b3 17.80 18.20
18 16 22 16 20 18 p4b4 19.40 18.20
17.33333 17.83333 17.83333 17.33333 17.66667 18 Total 288.60 280.80
Rata-rata 18.04 17.55
 Nilai Beda Dwi Arah Rata-rata taraf Faktor P dan B
P/B b1 b2 b3 b4 Total Rata-rata
Total Rata-rata
p1 33.60 34.80 35.20 34.40 138.00 34.50
33.60 16.80 p2 34.60 34.60 35.40 34.80 139.40 34.85
34.80 17.40 p3 35.60 35.60 42.20 35.20 148.60 37.15
35.20 17.60 p4 34.40 35.40 36.00 37.60 143.40 35.85
34.40 17.20 Total 138.20 140.40 148.80 142.00 569.40
34.60 17.30 Rata-rata 34.55 35.10 37.20 35.50
34.60 17.30
35.40 17.70
34.80 17.40 FK 10131.76
35.60 17.80
35.60 17.80 P/B b1 b2 b3 b4
42.20 21.10 p1 16.80 17.40 17.60 17.20
35.20 17.60 p2 17.30 17.30 17.70 17.40
34.40 17.20 p3 17.80 17.80 21.10 17.60
35.40 17.70 p4 17.20 17.70 18.00 18.80
36.00 18.00
37.60 18.80
569.40
Analisis Ragam
Sumber Ragam DB JK KT Fhit F.05
Ulangan 1 1.9012 1.9012 5.44 4.54 *
Perlakuan 15 29.1388 1.9426 5.56 2.40 *
P 3 8.4737 2.8246 8.09 3.29 *
B 3 7.8438 2.6146 7.49 3.29 *
Interaksi PB 9 12.8212 1.4246 4.08 2.59 *
Galat 15 5.2388 0.3493
Total 31 36.2788

Uji Mandiri Faktor B

S x bar 0.42
B SSR 0,05 LSR 5%
2 3.01 1.26
3 3.16 1.32
4 3.25 1.36

Beda B terhadap p1
B Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
b1 16.80 - -
b4 17.20 0.40 - 1.26
b2 17.40 0.60 0.20 - 1.32
b3 17.60 0.80 0.40 0.20 - 1.36

Beda B terhadap p2
B Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
b1 17.30 - -
b2 17.30 0.00 - 1.26
b4 17.40 0.10 0.10 - 1.32
b3 17.70 0.40 0.40 0.30 - 1.36

Beda B terhadap p3
B Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
b4 17.60 - -
b1 17.80 0.20 - 1.26
b2 17.80 0.20 0.00 - 1.32
b3 21.10 3.50 3.30 3.30 - 1.36

Beda B terhadap p4
B Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
b1 17.20 - -
b2 17.70 0.50 - 1.26
b3 18.00 0.80 0.30 - 1.32
b4 18.80 1.60 1.10 0.80 - 1.36
Berbeda
Nyata

Terdapat Interaksi

Uji Mandiri Faktor P

S x bar 0.42
B SSR 0,05 LSR 5%
2 3.01 1.26
3 3.16 1.32
4 3.25 1.36

Beda P terhadap b1
Notasi P Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
a p4 16.80 - -
a p1 17.20 0.40 - 1.26
a p3 17.30 0.50 0.10 - 1.32
a p2 17.80 1.00 0.60 0.50 - 1.36

Notasi Beda P terhadap b2

a P Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
a p1 17.30 - -
a p2 17.40 0.10 - 1.26
a p4 17.70 0.40 0.30 - 1.32
p3 17.80 0.50 0.40 0.10 - 1.36

Notasi Beda P terhadap b3

a P Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
a p4 17.60 - -
a p1 17.70 0.10 - 1.26
b p2 18.00 0.40 0.30 - 1.32
p3 21.10 3.50 3.40 3.10 - 1.36

Notasi Beda P terhadap b4

a P Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
a p1 17.20 - -
a p2 17.40 0.20 - 1.26
b p3 17.60 0.40 0.20 - 1.32
p4 18.80 1.60 1.40 1.20 - 1.36
Notasi
a
a
a
a

Notasi
a
a
a
a

Notasi
a
a
a
b
Notasi
a
a
a
b
Pengamatan ke 2 (35 HST)
Ulangan 1
p4b2 p3b4 p2b2 p3b1 p1b4 p2b3 p1b2 p3b2 p1b1 p4b1
23 28 25 28 21 24 23 24 20 26
25 23 23 25 23 22 24 23 21 21
24 24 26 26 22 26 21 28 21 22
27 27 23 24 24 25 25 25 25 24
23 26 25 28 21 24 23 24 23 20
25 25 27 25 25 28 21 26 19 25
24.5 25.5 24.833333 26 22.66667 24.83333 22.83333 25 21.5 23

Ulangan 2
p2b1 p4b4 p1b1 p2b4 p1b3 p2b2 p3b3 p1b2 p3b4 p2b3
21 27 24 22 26 22 25 23 25 22
24 24 21 27 22 25 26 22 24 25
22 26 23 23 24 26 30 20 22 24
23 26 25 22 23 22 25 25 26 22
25 23 20 23 22 24 26 21 22 23
25 25 23 22 20 23 30 22 25 22
23.333333 25.16667 22.666667 23.16667 22.83333 23.66667 27 22.16667 24 23
 Ulangan
Perlakuan
p2b4 p3b3 p2b1 p4b4 p1b3 p4b3 1 2
26 29 23 24 23 25 p1b1 22.00 22.60
23 31 21 26 26 22 p1b2 23.20 22.20
25 30 26 25 21 24 p1b3 23.20 23.40
21 28 23 28 24 28 p1b4 22.20 23.80
28 29 22 24 22 24 p2b1 23.00 23.00
24 28 25 25 23 20 p2b2 24.40 23.80
24.5 29.16667 23.33333 25.33333 23.16667 23.83333 p2b3 24.20 23.20
p2b4 24.60 23.40
p3b1 26.20 22.80
p4b1 p4b3 p3b1 p1b4 p3b2 p4b2 p3b2 24.80 23.20
25 22 21 23 24 26 p3b3 29.40 26.40
24 24 22 25 21 24 p3b4 25.60 23.80
20 25 28 24 24 26 p4b1 22.60 22.80
22 24 21 26 22 24 p4b2 24.40 24.40
23 23 22 21 25 22 p4b3 24.60 23.60
25 22 29 22 26 25 p4b4 25.40 25.20
23.16667 23.33333 23.83333 23.5 23.66667 24.5 Total 389.80 377.60
Rata-rata 24.36 23.60
 Nilai Beda Dwi Arah Rata-rata taraf Faktor P dan B
P/B b1 b2 b3 b4 Total Rata-rata
Total Rata-rata
p1 44.60 45.40 46.60 46.00 182.60 45.65
44.60 22.30 p2 46.00 48.20 47.40 48.00 189.60 47.40
45.40 22.70 p3 49.00 48.00 55.80 49.40 202.20 50.55
46.60 23.30 p4 45.40 48.80 48.20 50.60 193.00 48.25
46.00 23.00 Total 185.00 190.40 198.00 194.00 767.40
46.00 23.00 Rata-rata 46.25 47.60 49.50 48.50
48.20 24.10
47.40 23.70
48.00 24.00 FK 18403.21
49.00 24.50
48.00 24.00 P/B b1 b2 b3 b4 Total Rata-rata
55.80 27.90 p1 22.30 22.70 23.30 23.00 91.30 22.83
49.40 24.70 p2 23.00 24.10 23.70 24.00 94.80 23.70
45.40 22.70 p3 24.50 24.00 27.90 24.70 101.10 25.28
48.80 24.40 p4 22.70 24.40 24.10 25.30 96.50 24.13
48.20 24.10 Total 92.50 95.20 99.00 97.00 383.70
50.60 25.30 Rata-rata 23.13 23.80 24.75 24.25
767.40
Analisis Ragam
Sumber Ragam DB JK KT Fhit F.05
Ulangan 1 4.6512 4.6512 5.60 4.54 *
Perlakuan 15 53.3287 3.5552 4.28 2.40 *
P 3 24.8837 8.2946 9.99 3.29 *
B 3 11.4337 3.8112 4.59 3.29 *
Interaksi PB 9 17.0113 1.8901 2.28 2.59
Galat 15 12.4488 0.8299
Total 31 70.4288

Uji Mandiri Faktor P

S x bar 0.32
P SSR 0,05 LSR 5%
2 3.01 0.97
3 3.16 1.02
4 3.25 1.05

Beda dua Rata-rata

P Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
p1 22.83 - -
p2 23.70 0.88 - 0.97
p4 24.13 1.30 0.43 - 1.02
p3 25.28 2.45 1.58 1.15 - 1.05

Uji Mandiri Faktor B

S x bar 0.32
B SSR 0,05 LSR 5%
2 3.01 0.97
3 3.16 1.02
4 3.25 1.05

Beda dua Rata-rata

B Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
b1 23.13 - -
b2 23.80 0.67 - 0.97
b4 24.25 1.13 0.45 - 1.02
b3 24.75 1.63 0.95 0.50 - 1.05
Berbeda
Nyata

Tidak Terjadi Interaksi

Notasi
a
a
b
c

Notasi
a
a
b
c
Pengamatan ke 3 (42 HST)
Ulangan 1
p4b2 p3b4 p2b2 p3b1 p1b4 p2b3 p1b2 p3b2 p1b1 p4b1
28 34 30 33 26 30 28 29 24 31
30 28 28 29 28 28 28 28 26 25
29 30 30 31 28 32 25 32 25 27
32 33 28 28 30 30 30 30 29 29
28 32 29 33 27 30 27 28 27 25
30 31 31 29 32 34 25 30 24 30
29.5 31.33333 29.333333 30.5 28.5 30.66667 27.16667 29.5 25.83333 27.83333

Ulangan 2
p2b1 p4b4 p1b1 p2b4 p1b3 p2b2 p3b3 p1b2 p3b4 p2b3
25 32 28 28 31 28 30 28 31 28
29 30 26 34 28 30 32 26 28 31
26 31 28 30 30 31 35 25 27 29
28 32 30 28 29 26 31 30 32 28
30 30 24 29 28 28 32 25 28 30
31 31 28 28 26 26 35 26 31 28
28.166667 31 27.333333 29.5 28.66667 28.16667 32.5 26.66667 29.5 29
 Ulangan
Perlakuan
p2b4 p3b3 p2b1 p4b4 p1b3 p4b3 1 2
32 35 33 23 28 28 p1b1 26.20 27.20
30 36 32 32 31 23 p1b2 27.60 26.80
32 35 30 30 25 27 p1b3 26.40 29.20
27 34 30 29 27 25 p1b4 27.80 29.40
34 36 29 30 21 26 p2b1 30.80 27.60
30 34 31 32 25 24 p2b2 29.00 28.60
30.83333 35 30.83333 29.33333 26.16667 25.5 p2b3 30.00 29.20
p2b4 31.00 29.80
p3b1 30.80 27.40
p4b1 p4b3 p3b1 p1b4 p3b2 p4b2 p3b2 29.40 27.60
30 28 25 28 28 30 p3b3 35.20 32.00
28 30 26 30 26 28 p3b4 31.40 29.20
24 31 32 31 28 31 p4b1 27.40 27.20
26 30 26 32 26 28 p4b2 29.40 28.60
28 28 28 26 30 26 p4b3 25.80 29.40
30 27 34 28 30 30 p4b4 28.80 31.00
27.66667 29 28.5 29.16667 28 28.83333 Total 467.00 460.20
Rata-rata 29.19 28.76
 Nilai Beda Dwi Arah Rata-rata taraf Faktor P dan B
P/B b1 b2 b3 b4 Total Rata-rata
Total Rata-rata
p1 53.40 54.40 55.60 57.20 220.60 55.15
53.40 26.70 p2 58.40 57.60 59.20 60.80 236.00 59.00
54.40 27.20 p3 58.20 57.00 67.20 60.60 243.00 60.75
55.60 27.80 p4 54.60 58.00 55.20 59.80 227.60 56.90
57.20 28.60 Total 224.60 227.00 237.20 238.40 927.20
58.40 29.20 Rata-rata 56.15 56.75 59.30 59.60
57.60 28.80
59.20 29.60
60.80 30.40 FK 26865.62
58.20 29.10
57.00 28.50 P/B b1 b2 b3 b4 Total Rata-rata
67.20 33.60 p1 26.70 27.20 27.80 28.60 110.30 27.58
60.60 30.30 p2 29.20 28.80 29.60 30.40 118.00 29.50
54.60 27.30 p3 29.10 28.50 33.60 30.30 121.50 30.38
58.00 29.00 p4 27.30 29.00 27.60 29.90 113.80 28.45
55.20 27.60 Total 112.30 113.50 118.60 119.20 463.60
59.80 29.90 Rata-rata 28.08 28.38 29.65 29.80
927.20
Analisis Ragam
Sumber Ragam DB JK KT Fhit F.05
Ulangan 1 1.4450 1.4450 0.62 4.54
Perlakuan 15 82.5800 5.5053 2.36 2.40
P 3 35.7700 11.9233 5.11 3.29 *
B 3 18.4500 6.1500 2.64 3.29
Interaksi PB 9 28.3600 3.1511 1.35 2.59
Galat 15 34.9950 2.3330
Total 31 119.0200

Uji Mandiri Faktor P

S x bar 0.54
P SSR 0,05 LSR 5%
2 3.01 1.63
3 3.16 1.71
4 3.25 1.76

Beda dua Rata-rata

P Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
p1 27.58 - -
p4 28.45 0.88 - 1.63
p2 29.50 1.93 1.05 - 1.71
p3 30.38 2.80 1.93 0.88 - 1.76

Uji Mandiri Faktor B

S x bar 0.54
B SSR 0,05 LSR 5%
2 3.01 1.63
3 3.16 1.71
4 3.25 1.76

Beda dua Rata-rata

B Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata LSR 5%
b1 28.08 - -
b2 28.38 0.30 - 1.63
b3 29.65 1.58 1.28 - 1.71
b4 29.80 1.73 1.43 0.15 - 1.76
Berbeda Nyata

BERBEDA NYATA DAN tidak TERDAPAT INTERAKSI

Notasi
a
a
b
c

Notasi
a
a
a
b
Pengamatan ke 4 (49 HST)
Ulangan 1
p4b2 p3b4 p2b2 p3b1 p1b4 p2b3 p1b2 p3b2 p1b1 p4b1
31 39 33 36 31 35 32 34 26 34
34 33 32 33 32 32 31 31 29 28
32 35 34 34 33 36 28 35 28 30
36 36 31 32 35 34 34 34 31 31
31 37 33 36 32 33 30 31 30 28
34 36 34 32 38 38 28 33 28 32
33 36 32.833333 33.83333 33.5 30.5 30.5 33 28.66667 30.5

Ulangan 2
p2b1 p4b4 p1b1 p2b4 p1b3 p2b2 p3b3 p1b2 p3b4 p2b3
28 36 30 33 34 30 34 30 36 32
32 34 29 38 32 33 35 28 32 34
28 33 31 35 34 34 38 28 30 32
30 35 32 32 32 28 34 33 36 30
32 35 26 32 30 31 35 28 31 33
34 34 31 31 29 28 38 28 34 30
30.666667 34.5 29.833333 33.5 31.83333 30.66667 35.66667 29.16667 33.16667 31.83333
 Ulangan
Perlakuan
p2b4 p3b3 p2b1 p4b4 p1b3 p4b3 1 2
39 40 36 28 32 33 p1b1 28.80 29.60
35 40 35 36 34 26 p1b2 31.00 29.40
37 38 34 33 28 32 p1b3 30.00 32.40
33 38 33 34 31 30 p1b4 32.60 33.40
36 41 32 33 25 31 p2b1 34.00 30.00
32 38 34 36 28 28 p2b2 32.60 31.20
35.33333 39.16667 34 33.33333 29.66667 30 p2b3 34.00 32.20
p2b4 36.00 34.00
p3b1 34.20 30.00
p4b1 p4b3 p3b1 p1b4 p3b2 p4b2 p3b2 33.00 30.40
32 31 28 32 30 33 p3b3 39.40 35.20
30 33 28 34 28 30 p3b4 36.00 33.00
28 35 34 35 31 34 p4b1 30.20 29.80
28 34 30 36 30 30 p4b2 32.80 31.00
31 31 30 30 33 28 p4b3 30.40 32.80
33 30 36 32 32 28 p4b4 32.80 34.60
30.33333 32.33333 31 33.16667 30.66667 30.5 Total 527.80 509.00
Rata-rata 32.99 31.81
 Nilai Beda Dwi Arah Rata-rata taraf Faktor P dan B
P/B b1 b2 b3 b4 Total
Total Rata-rata
p1 58.40 60.40 62.40 66.00 247.20
58.40 29.20 p2 64.00 63.80 66.20 70.00 264.00
60.40 30.20 p3 64.20 63.40 74.60 69.00 271.20
62.40 31.20 p4 60.00 63.80 63.20 67.40 254.40
66.00 33.00 Total 246.60 251.40 266.40 272.40 1036.80
64.00 32.00 Rata-rata 61.65 62.85 66.60 68.10
63.80 31.90
66.20 33.10
70.00 35.00 FK 33592.32
64.20 32.10
63.40 31.70 P/B b1 b2 b3 b4 Total
74.60 37.30 p1 29.20 30.20 31.20 33.00 123.60
69.00 34.50 p2 32.00 31.90 33.10 35.00 132.00
60.00 30.00 p3 32.10 31.70 37.30 34.50 135.60
63.80 31.90 p4 30.00 31.90 31.60 33.70 127.20
63.20 31.60 Total 123.30 125.70 133.20 136.20 518.40
67.40 33.70 Rata-rata 30.83 31.43 33.30 34.05
1036.80
 Analisis Ragam
Rata-rata Sumber Ragam DB JK KT Fhit F.05
61.80 Ulangan 1 11.0450 11.0450 4.35 4.54
66.00 Perlakuan 15 123.7600 8.2507 3.25 2.40
67.80 P 3 41.7600 13.9200 5.48 3.29
63.60 B 3 55.7100 18.5700 7.32 3.29
Interaksi PB 9 26.2900 2.9211 1.15 2.59
Galat 15 38.0750 2.5383
Total 31 172.8800

Uji Mandiri Faktor P

S x bar 0.56
Rata-rata P SSR 0,05 LSR 5%
30.90 2 3.01 1.70
33.00 3 3.16 1.78
33.90 4 3.25 1.83
31.80
Beda dua Rata-rata
P Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata
p1 30.90 -
p4 31.80 0.90 -
p2 33.00 2.10 1.20 -
p3 33.90 3.00 2.10 0.90 -

Uji Mandiri Faktor B

S x bar 0.56
B SSR 0,05 LSR 5%
2 3.01 1.70
3 3.16 1.78
4 3.25 1.83

Beda dua Rata-rata

B Rata-rata Beda dua rata-rata
b1 30.83 -
b2 31.43 0.60 -
b3 33.30 2.48 1.88 -
b4 34.05 3.23 2.63 0.75 -
*
Berbeda
*
Nyata
*
Tidak Terjadi Interaksi

LSR 5% Notasi
- a
1.70 a
1.78 b
1.83 c

LSR 5% Notasi
- a
1.70 a
1.78 b
1.83 c