Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
Indian writing in English has been more than hundred and fifty years of age today. All
types of literary writings are available in Indian English literature. Indian English fiction
has acquired new dimensions after globalization and liberalization of Indian Economy.
Indian fiction writers have got national and international awards in recognition of their
them with literary forces outside and within India. All this enhanced their awareness,
There are many men and women writers who handled and depicted contemporary issues.
Traditional themes like Indian poverty, superstitions, culture, child marriage and
illiteracy are now replaced by the themes like crumbling family relations, devastating
effects of globalization, exploitation of employees etc. These writers came from highest
centres of learning in India. The writers like Chetan Bhagat, Amish Tripathi, Shashi
Tharoor, Arvind Adiga have presented variety of untraditional themes with innovative
techniques. Women writers like Kiran Desai, Arundhati Roy got coveted Booker prizes
for effective presentation of realistic social, cultural and political situations in India.
Sudha Murty is one of the prolific Indian writers in English today. She has written four
novels, four books of short stories and two novellas. Though a female writer, she does not
deal with the issues related to women only. Main thrust of her writing is the deep
psychological upheavals in the minds of Indian youth in the age of globalization. The
1
Indian economy changed drastically in the last decade of the twentieth century and the
first decade of twenty first century. Sudha Murty encountered the ill impact of
globalization on today‟s generation from the social and psychological point of view.
Sudha Murty‟s writing is a wonderful combination of old Indian and the new twentieth
reflect a rare combination of philanthropic attitude and logical thoughts. Her writings
take us deep into the human mind with all its complexities. The delineation of characters
depicted by her represents new reality which is revolutionary feature in modern literature.
She is not a feminist in traditional sense who fights for women‟s cause. She writes about
men and women both struggling for their own existence in globalizing India. It will be an
interesting and innovative attempt to find out about her writing in detail through this
study. The present study interpretes and analyzes Sudha Murty‟s literary works critically.
The term critical study has a broad implication. It involves analysis of themes, characters,
narrative devices, setting, language and style. The limitation of time and space has
restricted the researcher to narrow the topic. The study focuses on critical analysis of
themes, characters, narrative devices and setting employed by Sudha Murty in her literary
works.
THEME
Term theme refers to a central idea around which the action of the novel is woven. It is
the subject matter of a novel. Novelist writes with some purpose. He/she intends to give
some message, attack some undesirable attitudes in person or society, propagate some
ethics among the readers, present a social problem, narrate historically important events
2
with new perspective etc. In short, a novelist writes with some intentions. He does not
write in vacuum. There is generally one prominent theme and other less prominent ones
to support it in every novel. The supportive themes may emerge through parallel themes
Indian fiction writers in English have been writing on the themes related to castes, classes,
urban divide etc. A novelist may deal with a one or more of the above themes
simultaneously. Arundhati Roy in her The God of Small Things deals with the
faces that wear masks etc. In fact the greatness of a novel depends on the effective
It is interesting to note at the outset that though a woman, Sudha Murty‟s themes are not
restricted to women‟s issues only. Her writing shows a remarkable shift in overall
for the sufferings of women as if men and women were born enemies and marriage was a
license to carry out an agenda of exploitation of women by men. Sudha Murty is perhaps
the first Indian writer in English to reason out the issue by blaming one woman for the
miseries of other woman along with the man in the family. All her four novels
demonstrate the strained relations between two women in the same family.
Another theme that Sudha Murty deals with is the eroding effects of emerging capitalism
in Indian society on the close human relations. Liberalization in Indian economic system
brought scores of opportunities for the Indians to acquire riches. Young boys and girls
3
got a chance to go to the first world countries and avail of modern amenities easily. On
the one hand, it changed their social and financial status. On the other hand, it created
tension in the traditionally close domestic relations. Sudha Murty artistically dealt with
There are some minor themes in her works. Indians overall are superstitious. They
believe in the caste system, particularly while fixing marriages. Horoscopes, auspicious-
ominous moments, customs, traditions, conventions, religious faiths play their roles in
everyday life of Indians. Contradictions in the life of Indians are immaculately put
CHARACTERIZATION
Character normally is a being with human or human like qualities in a work of art. It is an
introduced in a work of narrative fiction. Characters thus exist within story worlds and
play a role, no matter how minor, in one or more of the states of affairs or events told
about in the narrative. Character can be succinctly defined as story world participant”1
name into an identity. The skill with which writer achieves this change decides the
4
Traditionally characters were divided into hero, villain and minor characters according to
their roles in the novel. Sometimes they were called major and minor characters
depending upon the slice of action they performed. Traditional division of characters into
flat and round characters is also done away with in the recent times. Use of the terms like
protagonist and central characters for hero show a shift in our concept of hero, who in the
past was expected to be virtuous, brave and dynamic. Today we have characters from
subaltern section of the society. Bakha in Untoucahble, Munoo in Coolie, Balaram in The
White Tiger, Velutha in The God of Small Things, Rukhamani in Nectar in a Sieve, and
Art of characterization has acquired new dimensions with the recent discoveries in the
field of psychology and anthropology. There are descriptions of upheavals in the minds
of the characters along with the descriptions of their physical properties. Readers are
expected to read the minds in order to find out the reality behind characters‟ actions.
Characterization becomes deep and authentic by writer‟s efforts to place his characters in
One of the peculiar features of Sudha Murty‟s characters is that they come from middle
class milieu. They are either from teaching field or from service sector. Sudha Murty
links them with the traditional Indian society and ultramodern western society
simultaneously. Most of the young characters engage themselves in their personal and
professional developments. The old characters are attracted towards riches but are
5
conventions possess them even in the modern world of technology, which results into
If we compare Murty‟s female characters with the female characters of other Indian
women novelists, one notices that Murty‟s women have positive attitude to life. They
believe in hard work. They are exceptionally optimistic in their approach to life. Kamala
Markandaya‟s Rukhmini resigns to fate. She is a helpless being at the hands of cruel
destiny. Tanner evacuates her from her traditional house. Her children ditch her. society
ill treats her. She bears it all passively, without grumble. Powerful forces outside rule her.
Murty‟s women shape their own destiny with planning and purpose. Mahashweta and
Mridula do not go down to circumstances. They rather work to bring about a change in
external situation.
Sudha Murty‟s characterization lacks depth. She fails to delve deep into the
psychological upheavals of her characters. Young boys and girls fall in love and get
married. There are no romantic outings of the two. This seems rather odd. Modern boys
and girls with high educational qualifications and awareness cannot be expected to get
Sudha Murty has placed confrontation between two women at the centre of action in all
her novels. Even a modern boy hands over his wife to his mother immediately after
marriage. As a result, characters do not contain any other dimension to them. She could
have shown her characters with reference to other characters in order to provide other
6
In spite of these flaws her art of characterization is simple and straightforward in keeping
with the tradition of story telling in India. As a result, Murty‟s novels, novella and short
stories appeal to the cross section of Indian readers today. Great Indian story writers like
R. K. Narayan, Mulka Raj Anand and Ravindranath Tagore before them were Murty‟s
models for story writing. She stood out as an exceptional story teller because or her
allegiance to the Indian tradition and not because of blind copying of the westerners. It
goes on to demonstrate that India has changed but Indians have not changed.
NARRATIVE TECHNIQUE
The way in which the story and action is unfolded is called narrative technique. Writer
can use first person narration in which character itself narrates the incidents and episodes
in its life. First person narration generally uses flashback technique to recount its life. R.
That long Silence used this technique. Some times writer creates a narrator who unfolds
the action through its eye. Raja Rao‟s Achchakka in Kanthapura and Emily Bronte‟s
Nelly and Lockwood in Wuthering Heights are the best examples of the use of this
technique. The writer employs this technique in order to keep his distance from the
characters. Third type of narrative technique is the writer itself takes the reigns of action
of the work in his hands. Most writers follow this technique. Chaman Nahal‟s Azadi,
Anand‟s Coolie, Adiga‟s The White Tiger are some of the notable examples of the use of
this technique.
One of the innovative techniques in the twentieth century was stream of consciousness
technique. This technique was based on the presentation of the thoughts, emotions and
7
feelings of the characters as they occurred to them. M. H. Abrams describes Stream of
that undertakes to reproduce, without a narrator‟s intervention the full spectrum and the
continuous flow of a character‟s mental process, in which sense perceptions mingle with
conscious and half conscious thoughts, memories, expectations, feelings and random
associations.2 Virginia Wolf‟s Mrs. Dalloway and James Joyes‟s Ulysses are some of the
notable examples of the use of this technique. Unfortunately this technique did not take
firm roots in British literature. We do not find any novel in Indian English using this
technique.
One story can be narrated in different ways by different writers. Nectar in a Sieve, That
Long Silence, Inside the Haveli deal with women‟s issues. Rukhmani in Nectar in a Sieve
narrates the story of her life. Geeta‟s story in Inside the Haveli is narrated by the writer.
Meaning of a work of art partially depends upon the narrator‟s view point. Shashi
Deshapande‟s That Long Silence has dragged negative criticism simply because the
protagonist herself is a narrator. Readers feel that she has been unjust to her husband.
First person narration becomes one sided story of a narrator in which he/she might try to
narration has more authenticity as it has a touch of impartiality. It provides bird‟s eye
One of the salient features of good writing is its potential to force readers‟ participation in
the process of writing. It is not the writer alone who writes. The readers are equal stake
holders in the formation of the text. Metaphoric death of an author signifies the birth of
8
readers in the creative act. Real author creates co-authors who guide and monitor his/her
a work of art. Sudha Murty unfortunately fails to create co-authors and co-readers. She
presents, explains and interprets her characters leaving very little for his readers to do.
This may suit traditional Indian method of story telling. Though it makes her works
unilateral, she remains a centre of attraction for the neo readers of India. This must be
SETTING
Setting of a work of art is a background against which the action takes place. Novel is
generally set in imaginary or real geographical area. It also has the element of time in it.
R. K. Narayan‟s novels are set in the imaginary locale of Malgudi. Mulk Raj Anand‟s
Coolie is set in the rural and urban areas of India. Kiran Desai‟s The Inheritance of Loss
is set in the north-eastern parts of India. Appropriate setting adds to the cohesiveness of
the work. It helps to enhance the thematic significance of the novel. If the novel deals
with the disastrous effects of caste system, India is the best place for its documentation.
South Africa is a good place for a writer writing on racism. It is difficult to find British
writer writing on the theme of discrimination based on the caste and race with the British
setting.
Pramod Narayan wrote that “Setting in a novel has two main components; as place and as
time. Place is where the action unfolds; house, cities, planets, nations etc. place as setting
could also be social spaces; families, ethnic groups, diaspora and immigrant
9
communities. Time is the time within which action unfolds; historical periods, seasons,
Time is an important factor in the description of setting, which plays significant role in
shaping the character of a person. We cannot have references to railways and airways in a
novel written in or about seventeenth century. In the same way, reference to internet,
mobile phones, supersonic aeroplanes are unavoidable in a novel that is set in a twenty
first century. Novel on Indian freedom struggle may not attract Indian readers today.
Sudha Murty sets her novels by weaving the threads of traditions and modernity in all her
works. Indians of the old generation even today boast of their social and cultural heritage.
Many Indians are proud of it. Sudha Murty sets the action of her novels in the villages
and rural tendencies that exist in big cities. Juxtaposition of rural life with cosmopolitan
life of the cities makes her work representative of overall Indian life. It also helps her to
Sudha Murty today comes from Bangrulu in Karnataka. Though Maharastrian by birth,
she has settled her business empire and philanthropic work basically in Karnataka.
Naturally she is well acquainted with the people and their life styles in that area. Her
characters possess Kannada names like Akka, Appa, Avva etc. This does not however
mean that her novels are regional in scope and appeal. We find people with such
characteristics elsewhere in India. Her skill to enlarge the canvas of her novels is
noteworthy.
Two novels Dollar Bahu and Mahashweta are set partly in the USA and partly in
England. Gouramma in Dollar Bahu goes to her son and daughter in law in the USA for a
10
year. The writer places her squarely with American atmosphere expecting some change
in her attitude to others. There is no change. Dr. Anand in Mahashweta goes to England
for further training in medical field. Though Sudha Murty transports her characters to the
first world countries, they do not have much interaction with the people in those
countries. Chandru is almost nonexistent in the USA. We rarely come across him in the
family or society. The same can be said about Anand in England. He seems to have gone
Sudha Murty‟s novels are set in post-independence India, particularly the period of
economic liberalization of the last decade of the twentieth century and the first decade of
the new millennium. India was going through a new phase of economic reforms. Indian
boys and girls acquired new skills in Information Technology sector which opened the
gates to America for better opportunities. Sudha Murty dealt with the new generation of
Indian writing in English has been more than hundred and fifty years of age today.
Almost all major and minor forms of literature have been handled by hundreds of men
and women writers from India during this period. It will not be an exaggeration to say
that with the exception of epic, all types of literary writings are available in Indian
English Literature today. Very fact that Indian writing in English is recognized as a
separate entity like British, American or South African literatures today, testifies its
vigour and potentials. Writers have written on different themes like Indian poverty,
superstitions, culture, child marriages, illiteracy, blind belief etc. Though major chunk of
11
this writing have been fiction and poetry, Indian English writers have not been lagging
Basic Indian ethos demands long narratives and recitation of poems. If we look at our
own literary traditions in Indian languages, we find Puranas, Vedas and Epics like
Ramayana and Mahabharata filled with stories. Poetry originated and flourished in the
India has been a fertile soil for literary activities for centuries. Indians have produced
voluminous literature in Sanskrit, Urdu, Bengali, Marathi, Telugu languages. This shows
that Indians had never been new to literary activities. When British rulers brought English
language along with them for various political, administrative and cultural reasons,
ground was already prepared for Indian English writing. Initially there was a problem of
its nomenclature. Some people called it Indo-Anglian Literature. Some others called it
“The Sahitya Akademi has recently accepted „Indian English Literature‟ as the most
suitable appellation for this body of writing. The term emphasizes two significant ideas;
first that this literature constitutes one of the many streams that join the great ocean called
Indian literature, which though written in different languages, has an unmistakable unity;
and secondly, that it is an inevitable product of the nativization of the English language to
Indian English literature can roughly be divided in three phases for the sake of
12
Narayan, Mulk Raj Anand and Raja Rao wrote voluminously on poverty, illiteracy, child
depicted the life of villagers and illiterate simpletons in his The Guide, Financial Expert,
Swami and the Friends, The Bachelor of Arts. Anand voiced his concern for the lower
caste and lower class people in India in his Untouchable, Two Leaves and a Bud and
Coolie. Narayan combined message and humour whereas Anand‟s novels had a
seriousness of purpose in them. Narayan was ticklish and Anand was angry in his tone.
Raja Rao‟s novels The Serpent and the Rope and The Cat and Shakespeare were
nonviolence that worked behind Indian freedom struggle. These three novelists adopted a
simple narrative technique from Indian tradition of writing in Indian languages. All these
writers believed in social reforms through writing. Hence their novels were termed as the
Kamala Markandaya, Attia Hosain, Anita Deasai and Ruth Prawar Zabawala are some of
the notable women novelists in this era. Markandaya wrote on the sufferings of the Indian
women. She selected poor, illiterate women characters and depicted their miseries in
novels like Nectar in a Sieve and Coffer Dam. Anita Desai has presented the condition of
alienated boys and girls in the big city like Culcutta in Voices in the City. Writers of this
We have dozens of men and women writers in the post independence phase as well. The
list is so long that it is better to avoid naming them all here. Khushawant Singh, Manohar
Malgonkar, Chaman Nahal, Arun Joshi, Amitav Ghosh, Babhani Bhattachaya are some
13
of the notable figures in this period. Women writers like Shashi Deshpande, Jai Nimbkar,
Male writers of the time shifted their attention from traditional themes to the the themes
based on national issues like Indian freedom struggle, partition riots, Hindu-Muslim
divide and East West encounter. Though Khushawant Singh‟s Train to Pakistan is
Muslim unity through love and sacrifice. Manohar Malgoonkar‟s Bend in the Ganges
passes the similar message of the importance of unity and fraternity for the Indians.
fanaticism on the innocent people from both the communities. Babhani Bhattacharya‟s So
Many Hungers deals with the theme of social, political and economic exploitation of the
disadvantaged Indians during the famine of Bengal in early forties of the last century.
Women writers of this period changed their focus from presenting their women
characters as scapegoats to the presentation of their claims as living human beings. Anita
Desai in her Cry the Peacock presented a woman who asserted her rights as an individual.
Jaya did not want to face the pangs of infertility alone. She wanted her husband to share
her life just as she shared his life. Shashi Deshpande was more vocal in her novel That
Long Silence. Her Maya was not prepared to keep quiet any more in front of the
traditions. If we compared the themes handled by the women writers in this era with the
women writers in the previous era, one clearly noticed that passivity of women characters
of the past was replaced by their active response to the situation in this era.
14
There are traditional women writers like Rama Mehta and Jai Nimbkar who believed in
the traditional roles assigned to them. Rama Mehta‟s Geeta in Inside the Haveli was a
good example of a woman who combined the old and new in her development. Though
an educated girl from cosmopolitan city of Bombay, she did not revolt against the feudal
atmosphere in the haveli. Though she lived within the four walls of the haveli, she did not
refrain from taking steps to open the gates of haveli to other children and women.
Nimbkar‟s Vineeta in Temporary Answers chose her own way of life by taking up
voluntary social services. She did not abstain from taking conjugal pleasures in the
Third phase in Indian English Literature is marked by men and women writers writing on
untraditional themes with innovative techniques. Globalization had provided them with
ample opportunities to interact continuously with the writers from various first world
countries. Some of these writers visited universities abroad which gave them exposure to
Indian English fiction has acquired new dimensions after liberalization and globalization
of Indian economy and subsequently Indian society. New themes, new narrative
novel writing. Indian fiction writers have got national and international awards in
India connected them with literary forces outside and within India. All this enhanced their
15
Arundhati Roy got a coveted Booker Prize for her novel The God of Small Things in
1997. This was the first international award for Indian writer. Naturally Indian writers‟
spirit got a special boost. This novel dealt with the exploitation of women and outcaste
boy in patriarchal Indian society. Ammu Ipe and Velutha suffered due to the
discriminatory attitudes of the people in authority. Pappachi and Mammachi family had
two separate yardsticks for Ammu and other members of the family. Ammu was tortured
because she had a sexual affair with Velutha. But the same offence of her brother Chacko
was overlooked by the parents. Even the secular communist party of India was not free
from caste bias. Party ditched Velutha at the time when he needed their help the most.
Roy attacked the religious fundamentalism and political forces in India for their
Kiran Desai was the second to get the Booker Prize for her novel The Inheritance of Loss
in 2006. Dehumanizing effects of globalization and separatist politics are the two major
issues dealt with in this novel by the novelist. Biju went to America on a forged passport
with a hope to achieve riches there. But he had to come back to his home in ragged
clothes. Gyan and Sai fell in love but had to tear apart due to the turbulent political
movements in the area. The judge Jemubhai Patel had to lead a lonely life of imposed
segregation in the hilly areas of Kalimpong after his return from England. Each major
Arvind Adiga was the next writer to get the Booker Prize for his novel The White Tiger in
2008. The entire story is woven around its narrator Balram Halwai. It is a story of an
illiterate village urchin who acquired riches through fowl means. The boy first became a
car driver of a businessman Ashok which helped him to visit centers of business,
16
administration and politics in Delhi. He learned his lessons and became a millionaire by
adopting unscrupulous ways. The novel in a way justified Balram‟s act of making money
in modern India.
Besides the three Booker Prize winning novelists in this era, there are novelists like
Upamanyu Chatterjee, Shashi Tharoor, Chetan Bhagat, Amish Tripathi, Shobha De,
whose works stand out as worthy of mentioning in the contemporary Indian English
Literature.
Upamanyu Chaterjee came into limelight with the publication of his novel English
August; An Indian Story in 1992. His other novels are Last Burden (1993) and The
Mammaries of Welfare State. His novels dealt with the theme of poverty and sexual
discrimination in Indian society. Shashi Tharoor‟s The Great Indian Novel artistically
linked today‟s India with the land of past three thousand years. Characters and events in
Mahabharata and characters and events in modern Indian political life sarcastically
Chetan Bhagat and Amish Tripathi are the most popular Indian English novelists in the
Indian youth today. Bhagat‟s novels have broken all the past records of sales in English
fiction. Problems of youth and their attitude to life are fascinatingly drawn by Bhagat in
all his novels. His heroes questioned the traditional Indian value system like reverence to
elders, fidelity with spouse, abstinence from alcohol and faith in religious practices. His
characters drank alcohol and had premarital and extramarital sexual adventures. But this
does not mean that they are bad. Though iconoclast, they loved life. They were secular,
17
adventurous, energetic and independent. His novels like Five Point Someone and Three
Mistakes of My Life have been adapted to films as 3idiots and Kai Poche respectively.
Amish Tripathi‟s The Immortals of Meluha, The Secret of Nagas and The Oath of
Vayuputras impressed the millions of young Indian readers by their narrative technique
and detail descriptions. He is considered to be the first pop star in fiction. Amish
presented Indian myths, legends, folklore and linked them to modern India with an eye on
future. This changed readers‟ views about Gods, demons, cultures and history. Bhagat
Shobha De stands out as a prominent woman writer of the globalization period of Indian
English literary history. Women novelists of the past wrote about the life of Indian
women with restrain. Their compromising protagonists combined the old cultural values
and their demand for self identity. They came out of their limited world of children and
hearth but did not revolt against their families. Shobha De is different. She presented a
totally new woman in her Starry Nights (1992), Strange Obsession (1992), Snapshots
(1995), Small Betrayals (1998). Her protagonists came from higher social class and
One of the notable features of these writers is that they come from highest centers of
learning in India. Chetan Bhagat comes from Indian Institute of Technology, Amish from
Indian Institute of management and Tharoor from Indian Foreign Services. Their
18
Writings like Bharati Mukherjee‟s Jasmine, Jhumpa Lahiri‟s The Namesake, Manju
Kapoor‟s A Married Woman, Chitra Banerjee‟s Food Travelogue and Anita Nair‟s Ladies
Coupe are considered diasporic. Their protagonists are torn between the riches of the first
Sudha Murty is one of the well known female writers in India writing in English today,
writing on the dominant issues related to women in modern India in the age of
relations with women and women‟s relations with other women. Her four novels deal
with the ideas and aspirations of educated girls and their struggle for space in traditional
Indian society. Girls stand out as individual human beings in her works.
Though the history of literary criticism dates back to Aristotle (383 to 322 B. C.),
feminism is a recent branch in criticism. Friederich Angels and John Stuart Mill in their
books, The Origin of Family, Private Property and the State (1869) and The Subjugation
of Women (1884) respectively were the first writers to articulate the problems of women
and probable solutions to them. The two books were the social and political documents
on the condition of women in the west particularly. They were not literary commentaries
Current forms of feminism grew out of the „Women‟s Movements‟ and „Consciousness
Raising Groups‟ of the 1960s in the first world countries. Spade work done by the socio-
political thinkers like Martin Luther King, Mahatma Gandhi, Abraham Lincoln, Mahatma
Phule and the like brought out to the front the miserable reality that women all over the
19
world needed to be treated as respectable individuals. Women themselves realized that
they were as good as men in all walks of life. Naturally women and some chivalrous men
clamored for their rights in social, political and administrative fields. The social and
political movements thus became interdisciplinary with the passing of time. Elaine
not only women characters in the novels of men but also in the novels written by women.
Simone de Beauvoir‟s The Second Sex is considered to be the first book on feminism. She
wrote about the portrayal of women in D. H. Lawrence‟s novels in this book. She found
that women were assigned stereotype roles and stereotype language in his works. She
objected to that and expected to present women in all variables. This followed by
feminist criticism found that women were considered weak, dependent and subordinate in
comparison with men characters. She was „Eve‟ who was blamed for the fall of man from
paradise. Her biological and libidinal capabilities were questioned in order to be able to
enslave her. Distinction between social and literary aspects of feminism has been
commented upon in the following way “The feminist movement was literary from the
start. In literary criticism, it began with the realization of the political significance of the
images of women produced and promoted in literary works. As a polemical movement its
primary concern in literary criticism was to explore and combat the stereotype
Feminism reached India with the spread of English writings in India. But people soon
realized that it can not be applied to Indian English writing as it is. Condition of women
20
in India was different from the condition of women in the west. Indian society is divided
into castes. Women belonging to outcaste sections of the society lived a life of an animal.
Indian Dalit literature showed the cruel treatment meted out to them as child-mothers,
prostitutes and keeps. It is a fact that feminist movement did not reach them for a
Indian female sex has always been partially treated by the family and society. Girl child
always got secondary treatment in the family. Husband wife relations were always tilted
in favour of husband. Husband took all the decisions not only related to family matters
but also to the matters related to her personal life. She had no say in the selection of her
own husband. She was considered ominous if husband died before her. In short, she had
no personal identity, social status, economic independence and separate voice. Condition
of western women was slightly different. They were educated, independent and protected.
Their problems were different from the problems of Indian women. They wanted to be
recognized as individuals like male members around, whereas Indian women wanted to
be alive.
Domestic and social structure of human relations in India is rigid. The oldest woman in
relations is the one who took decisions on all the matters related to women in the family.
Daughter in laws were always supposed to be living under her fold. The clothes that
daughter in laws wore, places they visited, women that they could accompany and the
men they could talk to were decided by that woman. In a way, she mastered the minds
and bodies of all the women in the family. She was the cause of pleasures and pains of
the women in the family. Hence Indian feminist writers had to attack not only orthodox
21
Condition of woman had been terribly awkward in both the families, the family of her
father and also the family of her father in law. She did not have any voice in her in laws‟
house. She was not allowed to make any suggestions, express her opinion or speak out
her mind to her husband. She was the first to get up and last to sleep in the house.
Ironically her own father and mother abstained from „interfering‟ in her affairs after her
marriage. They did not like their own daughter to come back to their house in the feat of
anger or revolt. Thus the condition of Indian girls worsens after marriage.
Another point that must be categorically noticed is that Indian women suffered not only
from domestic, social, cultural and religious sanctions but also from other women in the
family and society. Woman was the enemy of woman in Indian circumstances. In fact, in
a social set up where women, particularly young ones were not allowed to have freedom
of speech with men, elderly women took total charge of newly married girls in family.
One had to take in to consideration this aspect of woman‟s life while commenting on the
Fundamental difference between the girls from the third world countries and those from
developed countries is that the girls from advanced countries are educated, independent
and confident whereas the girls from the third world countries are illiterate, dependent
and diffident. Naturally the cry of the western girls was the cry for identity. Their basic
needs of hunger, clothes and shelter are fulfilled. They looked for something beyond that.
Indian subcontinent girls craved for the fulfillment of their basic needs because their very
existence was endangered. Their first requirement was existence; that of the western girls
22
Different critics have looked at feminism from different angles. “Mainstream feminists
reading of texts by some African women writers like Mariamma Ba provides the critique
of this standpoint and examines the direct and indirect roles played by some women in
the sustenance and perpetuation of patriarchal oppression. The focus is on elderly women
who often are so ignorant, selfish and manipulative that they make life hard for younger
women.”6
Indians are caught in two minds after the Government of India accepted the policy of
liberalization and globalization in the last decade of the last century. Indian youth was
attracted towards the riches, glories and pleasures of the new age. They used modern
They were tempted to possess all those riches. They wanted to wear international clothes,
eat untraditional food items. Man woman relations in the west attracted their attention in
On the other hand, they were also pressurized to follow Indian culture which expected
strict adherence to old value system. Joint family system, respect for parents, restriction
on the movements of women are some of the characteristic features of old Indian culture.
The new age demanded boys and girls to leave their houses. The old age expects them to
While talking about new Indian woman, Madhumati Adhikari said, “The emerging new
women are rebellious, recalcitrant and self-assertive. Economic independence makes her
23
confident and articulate. The emerging New Woman strives for her identity but still she
has to depend for emotional support on her family. There are characters in literature who,
either live in the conventional old style or are a combination of the old and the new. New
Woman is marked by her struggle for her identity and individual aspirations. She is
neither subjugated nor defied but a human person desirous of living in society as a
responsible member with equal rights and freedom to pursue her own goals.”7 Above
discussion on feminism shows that there are varying opinions on the nature and
Feminist movement started with a purpose to liberate woman from man‟s shackles,
particularly from husbands. Feminist thinkers believed that possession of phallus by man
provided him with an authority to exploit woman. Man and patriarchal family system
were held responsible for the abuse of woman in society. This was true in India and
abroad to a large extent. Sudha Murty has deviated from this traditional concept of
Rama Mehta‟s Geeta in Inside the Haveli, Ann in Jai Nimbkar‟s Come Rain, Jaya in
Shashi Deshpande‟s That Long Silence, Maya in Anita Desai‟s Cry the Peacock showed
the women characters whose personality was eroded by the domination of men in the
family. Simone de Beauvoir observed, “ A husband regards none of his wife‟s good
qualities as particularly meritorious; they are implied by the institution of marriage itself;
he fails to realize that his wife is no character from some pious and conventional treaties,
but a real individual of flesh and blood; he takes for granted her fidelity to the strict
24
regimen she assumes, not taking into account that she has temptations to vanish, that she
may yield to them, that in any case her patience, her chastity, her propriety are difficult to
conquest. He is more profoundly ignorant of her dreams, her fancies, her nostalgic
Murty did not blame „husband‟ for a precarious condition of a woman in the family. She
held one woman in the family responsible for the wretched condition of other woman in
the family. Gouramma in Dollar Bahu and Radhakka in Mahashweta are the main
culprits in Vinuta and Anupama‟s tortures. Chandru and Anand had negligible roles in
the sufferings of their wives. It will not be wrong to say that Murty has put forward the
Marriage imposes some restrictions on men and women both. Man is expected to play a
passive role in relation to his wife in family and society. Even if he sees the unjust
treatment given to his wife, he is not allowed to intervene in the domestic affairs.
Marriage is a social institute in India which implies that the newly married girl is
assigned to the parents and relatives. Husband becomes one of the many proprietors of
the girl. Hence condition of women can not be studied without relating them to other
The most significant aspect of Sudha Murty‟s writing is that she has freed the traditional
politicizing issues in feminism. It is true that condition of the women in India hundred
years ago was pitiable. Women did not have any voice in her family or society. Man took
all the decisions on her behalf. She did not have any identity whatsoever. Male generated
25
cultural traditions imposed different sanctions on women. Not only the women from
lower caste but those from upper castes suffered at the hands of men arrogance.
Women world over protested against their exploitation through writing. Even some
chivalrous men raised their voices against the discriminatory treatment meted out to them
in society. Some social workers talked about injustice done to them from time to time. A
blamed men for women‟s sorrowful existence. They propagated that men chauvinism,
their physical properties and men favourable traditions caused women‟s sufferings.
According to some of them, marriage was a sure source of tortures to wives and therefore
women should not enter matrimony. It must be said to the credit of these feminine writers
and feminist critics that they were right to a large extent. But they were wrong in their
assumption that only men were the enemies of women. They had forgotten to go deep
Creative writing is a cultural construct. It invariably reflects on the personal culture or the
collective culture of the populace. Poetry, for instance belongs to a first category; novel
belongs to the second category. Characters that novelist chooses come from some cultural
background. Their movements are guided, governed and groomed by a dominant culture
in them. This is true also about feminist writing. The writer who wants to deal with issues
related to women folk necessarily has to deal with the attitudes of the human beings of
the society.
It is true that women in India were discriminated against, at times ill treated. They were
restricted to their houses. Women were held responsible for the misfortune that befell
26
their men. A widow was prohibited from participating in religious functions of the
family. Life for them was an ordeal. But it is unfair to blame men squarely for their
sorrows. When men were not allowed to take initiative in caring for their women,
responsibility to look after their daily needs fell upon the elderly women, particularly
mother in law of the family. Mother in law provided them with food, clothes and shelter
and medical aids. Mother in law and daughter in law lived together for a major time of a
day.
The hierarchical relations between the „original‟ women of the family like daughter,
mother, grandmother and „other‟ women like daughter in law, mother in law and
grandmother in law surfaced through occasional bickering among the women. Many
times debate did not reach men of the family. Many times men preferred to keep away
from women‟s issues. This means that women were close to each other in times of their
happiness and unhappiness. Therefore it is wrong to accuse only the men for women‟s
sufferings and exempt other women from their roles in the exploitation of the fair sex.
Sudha Murty has fictionalized the encounter between two Indian women and highlighted
the victimization of one at the hands of other woman. Anand left Anupama to his mother
and went to England alone for further studies. Anupama‟s problems started with his
departure. Radhakka made it known to women in the area that Anupama did not bring
any dowry with her, that she had to look after all expenses of the wedding. Remarks hurt
Anupama. She got wild with Anupama when Anupama informed her about Girija‟s
27
When Radhakka came to know about white patches, she was elated. It provided an
opportunity to her to snatch her Anand from Anupama. She cooked stories to tarnish her
image in Anand‟s mind. She insulted Anupama‟s father and sent her back with him.
Throughout the novel, Anand acted as a passive spectator and audience to his wife‟s
hardships. It was Radhakka and not Anand who tormented her throughout. The same kind
of strained relations between two women are found in Gently Falls the Bakula, Dollar
There are three obvious influences on the writings of Sudha Murty. First her narrative
style is influenced by the ancient Indian writings in Epics, Puranas, Vedas and
features of Indian life. Thirdly, her attitude to her writing is influenced by her voluntary
Stories from our ancient literature had a touch of utter simplicity in their narration. These
stories had a straightforward plot with beginning, middle and end. Most of the events and
episodes were explained by the writer himself. There was nothing complicated or
hairsplitting in these stories. They contained message for the readers to be followed in
their daily life. Not much was left to the imagination of readers.
Sudha Murty‟s novels followed the similar technique. She introduced her major
characters in the initial few pages and never deviated from their basic features. She
concentrated throughout the novel mainly on the happenings related to these characters.
Other characters peeped in and out without adding much to the main action of the work.
28
Her writings therefore attracted those readers who did not want to go into the
Sudha Murty believed in the ancient values like love, affection, sacrifice, reverence,
compassion, consideration etc. Naturally, she included all these principles in her writing.
Good fought its battle with the bad and ultimately wins it. Villains had to repent and
sinners were punished in her works. Trouble shooters lost their faces and wrongdoers
rectified their errors. She showed considerable sympathy for the deprived and derelict
sections of the society like poor people, women and senior citizens. She believed in the
It has been a well known fact by now that Sudha Murty has been a chairperson of Infosys
Foundation that works in the field of education and public health particularly in rural
areas. She admits the impact of J. R. D. Tata‟s advice that “Never start with diffidence.
Always start with confidence. When you are successful, you must give back to society.
she has travelled extensively in rural and urban areas of India and Indian subcontinent.
This has given her authentic first hand information about social, cultural and economic
conditions of Indians. She has made use of all her experience in the writing.
She is a wife of a doyen of Indian IT industry Nararyan Murty. She has seen the changing
phases of workers in the industry. The changing faces of neo millionaires in India and
their negative impact on the family relations constantly appear in her writings. She has
seen the India before and after liberalization very closely. All this is reflected in her
29
writings. Though industrialist, her writing is an outcome of her continuous wanderings
among the farmers, peasants, villagers, children and youth in the rural India.
Sudha Murty was born in Shiggaon in North Karnataka on in India 19th August 1950. Her
father Dr. R. H. Kulkarni had been a surgeon who along with his in laws looked after her
Science. She was a recipient of Gold Medal at both the degree examinations.
She worked as Development Engineer at Pune, Bombay and Jamshedpur units of Tata
opportunity to interact personally with JRD Tata, who advised her to look at her wealth
from the trustee point of view and not from owner‟s point of view. His personality had a
She met N. R. Narayan Murty at Pune, fell in love with him and ultimately got married
with him. Couple has a daughter, Akshata and a son Rohan. Akshata got married with a
British citizen of Indian origin, Rishi Sunak, The son assists the couple in the various
Sudha Murty has been helping various sections of the Indian society through Infosys
Foundation. The wide range of her voluntary work covers the sectors like health care,
education, empowerment of women, public hygiene, art, culture and poverty alleviation
30
at the grass root levels. She has so far set up fifty thousand libraries. She has built ten
thousand public toilets in rural area and several hundred toilets in the city of Bangalore.
She constructed two thousand three hundred houses in flood affected areas. She has
helped people affected by natural disasters like tsunami in Tamil Nadu and Andaman,
earthquake in Kutch-Gujarat, hurricane and floods in Orisa and Andhra Pradesh and
drought in Maharastra and Karnataka. She spends her major time, money and energy in
these activities. Two institutes of higher learning, the H. R. Kadim Diwan Building
housing the Computer Science and Engineering department at IIT Kanpur and the
Narayan Rao Melgiri Memorial National Law Library were endowed and inaugurated by
Infosys Foundation.
Novels
2) Mahashweta (2005)
Novella
31
9) The Mother I Never Knew (2014)
Marathi film „Pitruroon‟ is based on her story. Sudha Murty also acted in Pitruroon and
Prarthana. Her novel Dollar Bahu was adapted and televised on Zee TV in 2001.
2) C. S. Desai Prize for the first rank in the university Exams in Karnataka
3) Youth Services Department Prize from the Government of Karnataka for having
4) National Award from Public Relations Society of India for outstanding Social
5) „Attimabbe‟ award for her book „Computer for School Children‟ in Karnataka
6) „Karnataka Rajyotsava State Award for her achievement in the field of literature
7) „Ojaswinni‟ award for excellent social worker for the year 2000
32
1) To critically study Sudha Murty‟s writings from social, cultural and literary
point of view.
2) To analyze her four novels in detail in order to be able to place her in the
5) To analyze Murty‟s women protagonists and compare them with the past
women protagonists.
7) To read into her non-fictional prose to find out her commitment to society.
8) To find out the effects of liberalization on the female section of Indian society.
Hypothesis
Sudha Murty has been a voluminous writer in English today. She has written on the
effects of globalization on the close relations in Indian family. She has also written on the
man woman relations in modern India. She is closely linked with the old and new in India
which makes her Indian English writer in real sense. Her narrative technique resembles
the narrative technique in old Indian literature. Her characters come from rural as well as
urban India today. Her writing is a direct reflection of her experiences in philanthropic
works.
33
She has written sufficient number of books in English. These books deal with various
issues. This gives ample choice for the study of her works for Ph. D.
Sudha Murty is a versatile personality in modern India. She has been playing three crucial
roles in her life. She is a creative writer. Secondly, she is a chairperson of Infosys
Though the three roles are complementary to one another in her life, study takes into
consideration Sudha Murty as a writer. Her experiences in the field of social service and
administration are reflected in her writing. So they are not studied separately.
Sudha Murty is a talented lady. She writes in Kannada, Marathi and English. She has
translated some of her works in English, Marathi and Kannada. She has also acted in a
Marathi film Pitruroon. She has blog and sends letters to her followers. The study does not
This is a critical analysis of Sudha Murty‟s literary works. The study comments on the
themes, characters, narrative techniques and setting. Study of these four aspects will throw
Studies in Indian English Literature have gained ground and momentum in India recently.
Various Indian universities prescribe a special course in this wing of literature because
many options in the selection of texts and writers are available to the syllabi framers.
Books on different forms of literature like fiction, poetry, drama, biography and
autobiography are easily available in the market which facilitates the selection and
34
classroom teaching. Thousands of Indian students have been studying this literature for
Sudha Murty is a living writer in this area. She has acquired two important positions in
India. She has taken up social work in the field of education and public health through
Infosys Foundation of which she is a chairperson. Secondly, she has written extensively
on various topics. Her writing has a touch of reality as she travels across India, meets
people of all kind and writes on them in her novels and stories. It will not be wrong to say
that she knows ground realities of Indian life very well. Thus her life and writing are
Sudha Murty has written four novels, two short story collections and a vignette. This has
a corpus of about fifteen hundred pages which is sufficient for doctoral study. It is
remarkable that she has combined old and new in her writings. She frequently quotes
from Indian epics and scriptures and provides a new insight to them. Her characters come
from all walks of life across India. She has shown the gloomy side of glamorous capitalist
Indian families.
Though a woman, Sudha Murty does not blame men for the pitiable condition of Indian
women in the modern world. She is exceptionally impartial to her characters. Hence she
blames men and women for the sufferings of women in the family. Other women writers
have written on the sufferings of women with gender bias and politicized the entire issue.
Sudha Murty has sensibly put forward different aspects of women‟s life and left it to the
35
Sudha Murty is a writer with a social sense. Thousands of boys and girls have been
migrating to America and England for better financial opportunities. Murty has shown
the temporary nature of this life. Her works therefore became eye openers to the Indians.
Literature entertains but it also instructs. Sudha Murty has taken up the second function
of literature more seriously. Though there are occasional articles and research papers on
Sudha Murty‟s literature, there are few full length studies on her literature. This study
hopes to fill the gap because it has made an indepth study of all her literary writings from
all angles.
Indian English Literature has become one of the important components of syllabi at
school, college and university levels in India today. Indian English poetry, fiction, plays
and autobiographies are invariably prescribed in the syllabi. Sudha Murty‟s short stories
and novels are prescribed in school and college curricula. Murty‟s writing shows a
remarkable fusion of ancient Indian culture and modern Indian society. Though she does
not approve of each and every aspect of Indian traditions, she upholds some of them as
valuable even today. She has a reference to the advantages of joint family system in all
her novels. Students can learn about the importance of family in modern times.
One of the most noticeable aspects of her writing is the lucidity of English language
employed by her. It is unfortunate that most Indians believe in high sounding diction and
complicated syntax. Sudha Murty has successfully shown that simple straight English can
also express ideas in literature. Instead of playing the game of hide and seek with English
36
language, she has used Indian words wherever possible. This is a lesson for all the
Sudha Murty has quoted extensively from Sanskrit writers like Kalidasa and Bhavabhuti
in her works. She picks characters and incidents from old literature and throws new light
on them in the new context. This clearly shows her Indian roots. Upcoming writers can
learn from this. India has English medium schools not only in urban areas but also in
rural ones. Boys and girls need stories to learn English through entertainment. Sudha
Murty‟s stories can cater to this need. Her stories are the ideal blend of English language
Methodology
Major part of this study is carried out in library. Researcher procured all the books of
Sudha Murty from the market and went through them carefully before finalizing the
topic. There were many ways to approach Sudha Murty‟s works. The researcher selected
a topic „Literary Works of Sudha Murty; A Critical Study‟ in consultation with the guide.
The researcher went through various research articles on Sudha Murty‟s writings.
Researcher read seminal books like K. R. Srinivas Iyenger‟s Indian Writing in English
and M. K. Naik‟s „History of Indian English Literature‟ in order to gain the idea of this
literature. Researcher studied Ph. D. theses of other students related to present study in
order to get the idea of the art of dissertation writing. Researcher discussed her
37
Suggestions for Further Research
The study has critically analyzed themes, characters, narrative techniques and settings in
Sudha Murty‟s novels. Study in stylistic and linguistic analysis of the four novels can be
taken up for further research. Sudha Murty‟s works have been translated into various
Indian languages. Translation studies could be a potential topic for further research. Her
Dollar Bahu was adapted for a television serial on Zee TV in 2001. One of her short story
was transformed into a Marathi film named Pitruroon in which she herself had acted.
Research to compare the story in print media and electronic media can be taken up in
future. Sudha Murty has been active in social services in India and abroad. She has
visited the remotest areas in Maharastra and Karnataka to gain the first hand information
of the conditions there. There is a close connection between her social work and her
writing. One can study the impact of her social work on her writing. Thus there are
38
REFERENCES
4) Naik, M. K. History of Indian English Literature. Delhi, Sahitya Akademi. 2006. P.4.
5) Thorat, Ashok and Others. A Spectrum of Literary Criticism. New Delhi, Frank
7) Adhikari, Madhumalati. Enclosure and Freedom; The God of Small Things. In Bhatt,
Indira and Nityanandan (Ed,) Explorations: Arundhati Roy‟s The God of Small Things.
7) Murty, Sudha. How I Taught My Grandmother to Read and Other Stories. New Delhi,
39