Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 4

Intelligent Traffic Management with Wireless Sensor

Networks
1
Juhi R Srivastava 2
Dr. T. S. B. Sudarshan
Department of Computer Science and Engineering Department of Computer Science and Engineering
Amrita Vishwa Vidyapeetham, School of Engineering, Amrita Vishwa Vidyapeetham, School of Engineering,
Bangalore Campus, Bangalore, India Bangalore Campus, Bangalore, India
1
s_juhi@blr.amrita.edu 2
sudarshan.tsb@gmail.com

Abstract—Vehicular travel is gaining importance everywhere, monitor the vehicles dynamically. Our proposed work tries to
particularly in large urban areas. The current technologies that leverage these features of a WSN and hence, we develop
support vehicular travel like wired sensors, inductive loops, algorithms that are intelligent and adaptive for traffic light
surveillance camera etc., are expensive and also require high control. Our proposed system works with some current
maintenance cost. Further the accuracy of these devices also technologies like variable sign boards of traffic control and
depends on environment conditions. The typical traditional proves to reduce the average waiting time at a junction and
approaches attempt to optimize traffic lights control for a make traffic regulation adaptive. The proposed system also
particular density and configuration of traffic. However, the optimizes the traffic flow by utilizing the free roads. The
major disadvantage of using these techniques is that the dynamic
developed algorithms: “Maximum Intersection Utilization” and
behavior of traffic densities and configurations change is difficult
“Empty lane with Green Light” are tested in a java based
to model constantly. Traffic seems to be an adaptation problem
rather than an optimization problem. This paper therefore tries
simulated platform called Green Light District Simulator
to address the above issue, and hence we propose algorithms (GLD) [7]. This work is based on the paper proposed by M.
which perform adaptive traffic light control using a wireless Tubaishat, et al [15].
sensor network setup. The paper aims at analyzing methods to
build an intelligent system that can blend and support some of the
II. RELATED WORK
existing technologies of traffic control and therefore reduce the The demand for wireless sensor networks is and will be ever
average waiting time of vehicles on a junction. The proposed increasing. The offered device and user mobility, the low cost
algorithms are adaptive to traffic flow at any intersection point of offerings, the minimum time for connection even under harsh
roads. Simulations of the real-life traffic scenarios are conducted
conditions and terrain where any physical media is difficult to
in a simulated platform called Green Light District Simulator
(GLD) to generate graph average waiting time versus cycles. The install are few of the reasons for migration to WSNs today.
results generated show that the proposed method is effective for In [1], M. Darbari, et al, discusses the application of Petrinet
the traffic control in a real road intersection. with concept of Multi Agent System as the workflow tool to
model urban traffic system. The orthogonal approach in state
Keywords—Wireless Sensor Networks (WSN), Average Waiting
space dimensions demonstrates the compositional method for
Time (AWT)
modeling and performance evaluation of complex traffic
I. INTRODUCTION situations.
Rise in traffic congestion, are affecting many individuals in T. Prakash, et al [2] in their work on vehicles traffic
time, energy and patience on roads. Even after improving the management has reflected congestion on the road as delays
existing road infrastructure, in some situations an average while traveling. The authors propose a path selection
waiting time for a vehicle can become indefinite on a junction. algorithm based on "stochastic turn" and path planning that
The present technologies that support vehicular travel like ensures best path suggestion to vehicles in terms of reduction
wired sensors, inductive loops, surveillance camera etc., in trip time and less fuel consumption during whole trip.
observe a vehicle in a fixed position, are expensive and require In [3], authors use Unified Modeling Language (UML) to
high maintenance cost. Further the accuracy of these devices
model an Adaptive Road Traffic Control System. They
depends on environment conditions and the traffic light control
system requires schemes that can adapt to changing traffic provide a technique for controlling the traffic in highway
flows and densities constantly. network using signals that are automatically controlled by
detectors whilst coordinating all the signals, as per the changes
In such real-time scenarios and critical applications, Wireless in traffic flow.
Sensor Networks comes as the answer. WSNs have proved that
they are best suited to meet issues of traffic as they are highly In [4], traffic congestion is revisited and to solve the problem,
flexible, robust and work well for application domains which the author proposes a framework for a dynamic and automatic
need low power, low cost and low maintenance. An important traffic light control expert system combined with a simulation
feature of the proposed WSN-based method is that it can model. The model adopts inter arrival time and inter departure

978-1-4799-0792-2/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE


time of cars on roads. The results show a sharp drop in the using WSN. Results show that the average junction waiting
average waiting time of vehicles. time is reduced and the traffic lights were set to the setting that
In [5], W. Wen presents an intelligent traffic management let most cars to pass but this may not be the best setting even
expert system with RFID technology. Based on RFID tags, the for one junction as junctions do not communicate and road
system collects and calculates average speed and average flow users might not be able to proceed because the decision about
information on each road and hence a dynamic navigation the lane at the next traffic light is different. Most cars relieve
system is set to find the shortest path that avoids congested the most clogged up lanes, but do not take into account how
roads. full lanes are in comparison with others.
In [6], a distributed artificial intelligence and multi-agent With all the studies presented above it has been identified that
systems have been proposed based on game theory to allow traffic seems to be an adaptation problem. With WSN as our
coordination and cooperation. The system provides support for framework, we devise algorithms and compare them with the
the traffic manager to decide on traffic control policies. case study of India, Bangalore city traffic regulation policies.
Results show different performances of the decentralized The results obtained show considerably reduced average
coordination process in different scenarios, allowing the task waiting time of all the vehicles at the intersection.
of the manager to facilitate the scenario and act accordingly.
In [7], the aid of predictive software is highlighted, together III. PAPER PROPOSAL
with the shortcomings of a simulation strategy that does not We propose two intelligent algorithms based on our study and
take into account traffic dynamics. field work, which are capable of reducing the average waiting
In [8], “HITS” a traffic control system is proposed to predict time of all the vehicles at the intersection when compared to
the traffic scenarios for optimal route selection by drivers with the orthodox round robin policy prevailing at present. These
the data collected at different hours of the day time (analyzing algorithms namely are Maximum Intersection Utilization and
historical traffic conditions). Empty lane with green Light.
In [9], the authors focus on sensor networks built on top of
VANET and suggest an integrated architecture for traffic A. Average Waiting Time
monitoring, management and control. The average waiting time is the average number of cycles
In [10], WSN based solution as an alternative for (time in seconds) a vehicle has to wait at the intersection
unsophisticated vehicles, is proposed to avoid frontal during one round trip of traffic flow. Through this feature of
collisions in rural highways. The work targets vehicles that GLD we intend to generate a graph of average waiting time
cannot take advantage of the current intelligent transportation vs. number of cycles spend for the above algorithms and draw
systems and services. a comparison against the conventional traffic policies.
In [11], a new proactive self-organizing protocol called CSP To achieve the above objectives, three performance
(Cluster-based Self-organizing Protocol) is proposed. The requirements are considered: 1) The average waiting time of a
protocol uses the geographic clustering and the virtual vehicle at a junction should be minimized while keeping the
backbone to structure intelligently the vehicular network to policy fair. 2) The number of vehicles at a junction should be
address the problems of high mobility, potentially large scale, minimized when a road has green light but there are no
and network partitioning. vehicles, then the vehicles on other junctions should be
M. Wiering, et al, [12] presents an adaptive optimization minimized or allowed to move by following a fair traffic
algorithm based on reinforcement learning. They have policy. 3) There should not be any delay between the TLC
implemented a traffic light simulator, Green Light District, (Traffic Light Controller) and traffic light. When the TLC
which allows to experiment with different infrastructures and gives instructions i.e., the light (red, green) then it should be
to compare different traffic light controllers. displayed without any delay.
In [13], S. Yiu, et al, discuss the current traffic surveillance B. System Model
system with inductive loop detectors and video cameras and
In this section, the system framework [15], is discussed. The
propose an alternative traffic monitoring system using wireless
sensor nodes used for vehicular detection is a magnetometer
sensor networks that offers high accuracy and lower cost
sensor which detects distortions of the earth‟s field caused by
compared. Their prototype called Traffic-Dot achieves vehicle
a large ferrous object like a vehicle. It runs Tiny OS, an
detection accuracy of 99% and accurately measures speed
operating system for sensor networks. To receive one sample,
with a node pair.
the magnetometer is active for 0.9 msec and the energy spent
C. Wenjie, et al, [14], introduce a new vehicle detection
for taking one sample is 0.9J. The magnetometer is turned off
method using the WSN technology. The authors develop a
between samples for energy conservation.
new signal control algorithm to control the state of the signal
light in a road intersection. The communication protocol adopted is PEDAMACS [15].
Our paper is based on the works of M. Tubaishat, et al, [15], The road intersection configuration consists [15] of 3 or 4
where they have dealt with a decentralized traffic light control roads. Each road consists of 3 lanes. Each lane represents a
direction in which the vehicle should turn. Centre lane goes
„STRAIGHT‟, Left lane turns „LEFT‟, and right lane turns It was important for the Orthodox policy be coded along with
„RIGHT‟. The traffic signal consists of only 2 states i.e., the other two intelligent algorithms so that a fair comparison
GREEN & RED. Each intersection consists of one ICA could be brought about between the various algorithms for the
same density of vehicles and traffic environment. These
(Intersection Control Agent) which is programmed to take
algorithms are as follows:
care of the traffic at that intersection. Sensor nodes are placed
at each lane of each road at a fair distance from the 1) Orthodox Traffic Policy
intersection to measure vehicle count and communicate Step 1: Identify the roads on the intersection in a sequence numbered from 0
wirelessly with the ICA (sending details like lane number and to 3 clockwise.
Step 2: Start by initializing all the roads to a red state.
vehicle count). Step 3: Allot a green state to all the lanes of the particular road to green state.
Fig.1 represents the overall design structure of the proposed Step 4: Maintain the green state for a particular time (say 20 cycles)
work paper that is Intelligent Traffic Light Control using Step 5: Shift the turn to the next road and repeat steps 3 & 4 for the same.
Wireless Sensor Networks. This represents the process for Step 6: Continue operation till a pause or stop command is issued by the user.
Intelligent Traffic Light Control. It shows the occurrence of
various events and deployment of the entire system. 2) Maximum Intersection Utilization
Step 1: Identify the roads on the intersection in a sequence numbered from 0
to 3 clockwise.
Step 2: Start by initializing all the roads to a red state.
Step 3: Assume any 1 of the roads to be the start, the cycle continues after 4 th
stage.
Step 4: In every stage 2 roads (opposite to each other) are regulated.
Step 5: Vehicles on every lane wait for 3 cycles for their turn (as in the normal
traffic flow) whereas the ones taking a left turn wait for 2 cycles each.
Step 6: If collision is not the concern of algorithm, free left can be provided
for all the stages.
Step 7: Algorithm follows a round robin schedule giving equal time slots to
each road.
Step 8: Continue operation till a pause or stop command is issued by the user.

Fig. 1. Design Overview of Intelligent Traffic Light Control using Wireless


Sensor Networks

Fig. 3. Maxiumum Intersection Utilization Configuration diagram

3) Empty lane with Green Light


Step 1: Identify the roads on the intersection in a sequence numbered from 0
to 3 clockwise.
Step 2: Start by initializing all the roads to a red state.
Step 3: Round robin scheduling again with equal time slots of 20 seconds.
Step 4: When there is no vehicle on 1 road (say road E) and
that road is given a GREEN signal.
Assign RED to all the lanes of that road (E)
Fig. 2. Data Flow diagram of Intelligent Traffic Light Control using Wireless Compare traffic on each of the other roads (N,W & S) and assign GREEN for
Sensor Networks road with MAX traffic for biased time (5 seconds)
Check if vehicles have arrived on road E after step b
C. Proposed Algorithms If vehicles present, assign GREEN to road E else assign GREEN to the road
with next MAX vehicle count for 5 seconds.
Based on the field work and the study conducted on the Step 5: Repeat steps (a) through (d) till time slot (20 seconds – variable sign
prevailing systems of traffic, we propose two algorithms that messages can be used for lane users) expires for that particular road.
Step 6: Shift the turn to the next road and repeat steps 3 & 4 for the same.
has been integrated into the GLD simulator and are compared
Step 7: Continue operation till a pause or stop command is issued by the user.
with the current orthodox round robin policy
1. Maximum Intersection Utilization
2. Empty lane with Green Light
(GLD). We conclude that our system is far more adaptive and
effective with respect to the conventional policy. The
simulation results that we obtain are ready to be implemented
in a real-time WSN framework. We believe that this work may
also prove to be saving on fuel. Further, the Intelligent Traffic
System along with other technologies like RFID, GPRS and
GPS can be a potential solution for traffic control.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We would like to acknowledge the support extended by Mr.
B.G Jyotiprakash Mirji (Bangalore Traffic Police
Commissioner), Mr. Kulkarni, Mr. Sudhir. Mr. Zubin, Mr.
Saikiran and Mr. Ramakanth for their contribution.
Fig. 4. Empty Lane with Green Light Configuration
REFERENCES
IV. SIMULATION AND RESULTS [1] Manuj Darbari, Sanjay Medhavi and Abhay Kumar Srivastava
“Development of effective Urban Road Traffic Management using workflow
TABLE 1: RESULTS OF GLD SIMULATIONS techniques for upcoming metro cities like Lucknow (India).” International
Journal of Hybrid Information Technology Vol. 1, No. 3, July, 2008
Time Delay [2]Tarun Prakash, Ritu Tiwari “Counter-based Traffic Management
Algorithms Scheme for Vehicular Networks”Journal of Emerging Trends in
(Cycles) (Cycles)
4000 26.7 Computing and Information Sciences Volume 2 No.6, JUNE 2011
Orthodox Policy ISSN 2079-8407
8000 26.7
Maximum Intersection Utilization 4000 22.6 [3] K.Ranjini, A.Kanthimathi, Y.Yasmine “Design of Adaptive Road Traffic
(proposed) 8000 22.6 Control System through Unified Modeling Language “ International Journal
Empty Lane with Green Light 4000 9.5 of Computer Applications Volume 14– No.7, February 2011
(proposed) 8000 6.5 [4] W. Wen “A dynamic and automatic traffic light control expert system for
solving the road congestion problem” An International Journal of Expert
Systems with Applications Volume 34, Issue 4, May 2008
The proposed algorithms lower the AWT than the [5] W. Wen “An intelligent traffic management expert system with RFID
conventional algorithm. The comparative study of the technology” An International Journal of Expert Systems with Applications
conventional algorithm vs the intelligent algorithm is shown in Volume 37, Issue 4, April 2010
Fig. 5. There is a drastic dip in the average waiting time graph [6] Ana L. Bazzan “A Distributed Approach for Coordination of Traffic
Signal Agents” Journal of Autonomous Agents and Multi-Agent Systems,
when we switch on our proposed intelligent traffic policy from Volume 10, Issue 1, January 2005
the conventional policy. The AWT of the orthodox policy is [7] Claudio Guarnaccia” Analysis of traffic noise in a road intersection
26.7 cycles of wait whereas the run of the intelligent policies configuration” Journal of WSEAS Transactions on Systems, Volume 9, Issue
we obtain a much lesser waiting time of 22.6 and 6.5 for the 8, January 2010
[8] Hoda M. O. Mokhtar “HITS: A History-Based Intelligent Transportation
two proposed algorithms respectively. System” International Journal of Data Mining & Knowledge Management
Process (IJDKP) Vol.1, No.2, March 2011
[9] Maziar Nekovee “Sensor networks on the road: the promises and
challenges of vehicular ad hoc networks and grids” Mobility Research Centre,
BT Research, Polaris 134
[10] “ Preventing vehicle crashes through a wireless vehicular sensor
network”, 24th Biennial Symposium on Communications, pages 320 – 323,
June 2008
[11] Mohamed Oussama Cherif, Sidi Mohammed Senouci and Bertrand
Ducourthial “A new framework of self-organization of vehicular networks”
Proceedings of the Second international conference on Global Information
Infrastructure Symposium GIIS'09
[12] Marco Wiering, Jelle van Veenen, Jilles Vreeken, and Arne Koopman
“Intelligent Traffic Light Control” Intelligent Systems Group, Institute of
Information and Computing Sciences, Utrecht University, Sensors &
Transducers Journal, Vol. 94, Issue 7, July 2008.
[13] Sing Yiu Cheung, Sinem Coleri, Baris Dundar, Sumitra Ganesh, Chin-
Fig. 5. Comparison of average waiting times of the three traffic policies Woo Tan, and Pravin Varaiya. Traffic measurement and vehicle classification
with a single magnetic sensor. Journal of the Transportation Research Board,
February 2006.
V. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK [14] Chen Wenjie, Chen Lifeng, Chen Zhanglong, TU Shiliang “A
The presented work is an attempt towards reducing the Realtime Dynamic Traffic Control System Based on Wireless Sensor
Network”, Proceedings of the 2005 International Conference on Parallel
AWT of vehicles at a junction and makes the junction Processing Workshops (ICPPW‟05).
adaptive as per the current density of traffic at the junction. In [15] Malik Tubaishat, Yi Shang and Hongchi Shi “AdaptiveTraffic Light
this paper, algorithms for reducing the AWT at a junction have Control with Wireless Sensor Networks, Consumer Communications and
been defined and tested on Green Light District Simulator Networking Conference, 2007. CCNC 2007. 4th IEEE

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi