Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
7DOO%XLOGLQJV
$QLQYHVWLJDWLRQ
RIEXLOGLQJKHLJKW
LQELRFOLPDWLF
GHVLJQ
3HWHU6W&ODLU
4XHHQVODQG*DOOHU\RI0RGHUQ$UW
THE CLIMATE OF TALL BUILDINGS :
AN INVESTIGATION OF BUILDING HEIGHT IN BIO-CLIMATIC
DESIGN
Table of Contents
1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................ 6
1.1 Introduction to the Topic ................................................................................. 6
1.2 Reasons for the Study .................................................................................... 7
1.3 Previous Related Studies of Building Height and Sustainable Design................ 7
1.4 Organisation of the Study ............................................................................... 7
2 RESEARCH OBJECTIVES & METHODOLOGY .......................................................... 9
2.1 Key Objectives of the Research Report ........................................................... 9
2.2 Scope of study - definitions of tall buildings ...................................................... 9
2.3 Methodology for sourcing vertical climate data................................................. 9
2.4 Methodology for thermal imaging studies....................................................... 10
3 LITERATURE REVIEW OF VARIATIONS IN MICRO-CLIMATE WITH INCREASING
HEIGHT ABOVE THE GROUND ........................................................................... 12
3.1 Introduction ................................................................................................. 12
3.2 Climate scale and sources of measurements................................................. 12
3.3 Urban influences on rural micro-climate......................................................... 12
3.4 Variations in solar radiation with increasing height ......................................... 13
3.5 Variations in air temperature with increasing height ........................................ 14
3.6 Variations in humidity with increasing height .................................................. 16
3.7 Variations in wind velocity and direction with increasing height ....................... 17
3.8 Variations in building infiltration with increasing height .................................... 19
3.9 Variations in air pressure with increasing height ............................................. 19
3.10 Variations in rainfall with increasing height..................................................... 20
3.11 Variations in building energy usage with increasing height .............................. 21
3.12 Variations in embodied energy usage with increasing height........................... 22
3.13 Summary .................................................................................................... 23
3.13.1 Nature and gradients of micro-climates in rural and urban areas ......... 23
3.13.2 Effect of building height on energy usage and internal micro-climates in
tall buildings .................................................................................... 24
4 FIELD MEASUREMENTS OF VARIATIONS IN FAÇADE THERMAL RADIANT
TEMPERATURES WITH INCREASING HEIGHT ABOVE THE GROUND................ 26
4.1 Introduction ................................................................................................. 26
4.2 Time and weather conditions ........................................................................ 26
4.3 Image results & observations ........................................................................ 27
4.3.1 Eastern elevation............................................................................. 27
4.3.2 Northern elevation ........................................................................... 28
4.3.3 Western elevation............................................................................ 29
4.3.4 South elevation ............................................................................... 30
4.3.5 North elevation podium .................................................................... 31
4.4 Summary of variations and gradients of radiant temperature changes in field
study........................................................................................................... 31
5 ANALYSIS OF VERTICAL MICRO-CLIMATE DATA FROM THE LITERATURE
REVIEW & FIELD STUDY..................................................................................... 33
5.1 Analysis of vertical climate data and principles from the literature review......... 33
5.1.1 Classification of vertical climate zones .............................................. 36
5.2 Analysis of thermal imaging of the MLC Centre.............................................. 36
5.3 Diagrammatic analysis of the effects of building height on micro-climate &
building characteristics................................................................................. 38
5.4 Case study of the application of temperature lapse rate to HVAC design in the
Freedom Tower ........................................................................................... 39
5.5 Summary of analysis for tall buildings in urban locations................................. 40
Acknowledgements
Krishna Munsami for his technical expertise and use of thermal photography equipment.
Haico Schepers from Arup for initial discussions of ideas.
Chris Arkins from Steenson Varming for discussions of mechanical engineering design
methods and possible applications of vertical climate.
1. Investigate the nature and gradient of changes in vertical climate in the natural and urban
environments as documented by micro-climatologists and urban climatologists and
analyse possible applications to the bio-climatic design of tall buildings. Consider how
these climatic characteristics may vary to those of low-rise buildings.
2. Investigate the effect of building height on energy usage and explore if increasing
building height could reduce operational energy usage and off-set the increased
operational and embodied energy inherent in taller structures.
3. Measure the quantitative effects of building height on the outdoor temperature of a tall
building in an urban area and compare the results to the principles and data determined
from the literature review.
4. Assess the value and applications of vertical micro-climate to the bio -climatic design of
tall buildings based on the extent of evidence. Develop conceptual bio-climatic building
tactics based upon building height as a design primer for architects and as a basis for
future research.
5. Build upon previous related studies of building height by considering the application of
micro-climatology and thermal imaging not seen in the literature and considering the
implications to architects.
2.2 Scope of study - definitions of tall buildings
Definitions of tall buildings can help to identify the differences between tall buildings and low
rise buildings. The Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat does not define tall buildings in
terms of the number of floors but by “whether or not the design, operation or urban impact are
influenced by the quality of tallness and require special measures in planning, design and
construction when compared with buildings representative of ordinary construction” (Beedle
1978, p7). Other tall building characteristics that distinguish them from low-rise buildings include
high net density (ratio of floor space to area of site) and a building height that extends above the
urban canopy.
Yeang provides a definition for skyscrapers as ‘essentially a tall building with a small footprint
and small roof area with tall facades’ (Yeang 1999, p24). His definition distinguishes between
skyscrapers, medium-rise and low -rise buildings however common to Beedle he differentiates tall
buildings by their special structural and engineering systems that result from their height.
ASHRAE defines tall buildings as those higher than 91m (Ellis, Torcellini 2005). Buildings taller
than 305 m are commonly referred to as “super tall”.
The definition employed for this report is by the British Council for Office Tall Buildings
Working Party which defines tall buildings as ‘a tall building is not a low building that is simply
extruded vertically, but one that is differently designed’. Importantly the threshold at which tall
buildings become technically distinct is identified as 20 storeys (approximately 80 metres). Step
changes occur in construction costs with increasing building height where for example structural
design must be enhanced and area efficiencies and economic returns are reduced with every
additional 10-20 levels (Strelitz 2005, pp7-9).
2.3 Methodology for sourcing vertical climate data
Little literature exists on the applications of vertical changes in climate to building design. The
methodology is therefore to identify principles and data from disciplines including micro-
climatology, urban and building climatology, atmospheric sciences and services engineering. This
includes detail meteorological data by Geiger typically measured in rural areas, climatic and
thermodynamic principles describing the moderating effects of cities by Oke, gradient scales such
Leung and Weismantle describe solar radiation as increasing 4 -5% with each additional 300m of
building height under clear sky conditions (Leung & Weismantle 2008, p6).
3.5 Variations in air temperature with increasing height
In natural environments the temperature of the air layer near the ground is determined by the
surface conditions, the transport of heat upwards and the extent of air mixing regardless of the
effects of the surrounding area (Geiger 1973, p68). This temperature is graded vertically from
warmer at the surface to cooler higher in the atmosphere. This vertical gradient is known as the
temperature lapse rate or the rate of decrease in temperature with height.
In Figure 6 Geiger shows that daily patterns, temperature ranges and peak temperature times vary
with the distance above the ground. Peak temperatures are delayed further into the afternoon
with increasing height and with seasonal influences where they can be delayed by between 1 and
2 hours in winter (Geiger 1973, p70, 71). Figure 7 shows that the variation of temperature lapse
rate and the shifting of the peak temperature at heights up to 17m are much higher on bright
days than cloudy days.
Figure 7 also demonstrates that the temperature lapse rate changes diurnally typically sitting
between + 2.0 °C (increasing temperature with height) during the night time and -2.0 °C
(decreasing temperature with height) during the afternoon for each 100m of additional height
above the ground for altitudes between 16 m and 61 m. Figure 8 shows that the temperature
lapse rate from the ground to a height of 50m is about 1.5 °C on a clear day and reduced
significantly on over-cast days. At heights above 100m the ground provides less influence on air
temperature and follows the adiabatic lapse rate of approximately 1 °C for each 100m of
additional height (http://www.tpub.com/content/aerographer/14312/css/14312_47.htm).
The Standard Atmosphere model indicates a lapse rate of approximately 1 °C with each 150m of
additional height or 6.5 °C per 1000m (http://www.aeromech.usyd.edu.au/aero/atmosphere/).
The temperature lapse rates to altitudes of 100m are inverted at night time due to the cooling of
the ground commonly causing temperatures to increase with additional height (Geiger 1973,
p80).
Oke shows that the influence of a large city on air temperature can extend up to 200-300m above
the ground and in some cases to 500m and beyond (Oke 1973, p51). The effects of a city on the
vertical temperature gradient are influenced by changes to ground surface character, increased
shade at lower levels and exposure to solar radiation at higher levels, fluctuating wind patterns
and air mixing and the impact of vertical surfaces (walls) upon solar absorption and re- radiation.
Urban Heat Island (UHI) models show that the atmosphere can be contained with an ‘urban
dome’ assuming calm air. In addition to the urban boundary layer and the urban canopy layer
Oke identifies a surface zone from the ground to approximately 50m which is characterised by
unstable temperatures (Oke 1974, p52).
Temperature is also affected by wind velocities particularly from the ground to a height of 2m
where a lack of mobility of air allows the effects of solar radiation absorption and emission to be
maintained (Geiger 1973, p120). Figure 11 shows that the vertical temperature gradient (or lapse
rate) decreases as wind velocity increases during the night time whilst the effects of wind during
the day time are negligible. Changes to air temperature due to the effects of wind reduce with
increasing height.
In summary air temperature is shown to reduce with increasing altitude. The temperature lapse
rates may vary in cities with the effects of building clustering and the UHI however studies have
shown rates of between 5.5 and 6 °C per 1000m of height (Oke 1974, p53). The greatest diurnal
and annual variability of temperature is at the ground level. The range of temperatures and the
delay in reaching maximum or minimum temperatures increases with increasing distance from
the ground (Lowry 1991, p17).
3.6 Variations in humidity with increasing height
In the natural environment humidity is influenced by the ground in a similar way to temperature
where evaporation from the ground surface is directed upwards as vapour leading to decreasing
humidity (or vapour pressure) with height (Geiger 1973, p104). Measurements show that the
humidity gradient decreases with additional height above the ground during the day and is subject
to an inversion at night time whereby the humidity increases with height. The levels of humidity
at ground level are subject to much higher variation consistent with the principles described for
temperature variations.
Figure 10 again indicates water vapour pressure decreasing with height and being at lowest levels
at 2.00pm in the afternoon and highest levels at 8.00am in the morning. This phenomenon is
reduced with higher latitude where there is insufficient convection to carry the water vapour
upwards (Geiger 1973, p108). The data demonstrates that variability in humidity is greatest up to
40 – 50m above which the range and gradient of humidity remains more constant.
Figure 11 also demonstrates that this variation of wind speed is due to the decreasing influence
of the ground at night. Random fluctuation in wind speed and direction also increases with
greater terrain roughness such as varied building heights (ASCE pp5, 7). This can occur within a
timescale of a few seconds or minutes.
In urban areas buildings and topography reduce average wind speeds in the urban canopy layer.
Figure 12 shows that the terrain roughness will reduce the wind speeds at all heights while
maintaining the trend of increasing wind speed with height. For example the reference wind
speed of 100% at 10m altitude at an airport occurs at 30m in a suburban area and at 150m in an
urban area. This logarithmic increase in wind speed with height does not necessarily apply in all
cases where for example wind speed maxima are found between 50m and 120m in Tokyo (WMO
1988, p7).
The University of Delft have categorised differing urban wind conditions for the purposes of
selecting suitable wind turbines. Figure 13 shows that tall buildings clustered with buildings of
similar heights experience greater changes in wind direction and greater turbulence than tall
buildings that rise above the urban canopy (Smith 2008, p109, 110). The effects of wind
turbulence reduce the effectiveness of wind-turbine performance which prefers a strong laminar
wind where all of the air flows in a single direction
(http://www.buildinggreen.com/auth/article.cfm?fileName=180501a.xml).
Urban areas shows a higher level of air turbulence by 30-50% but this reduces with increasing
height (Oke 1974, p65). Sharples shows that increased local wind speeds lead to increased
convective heat transfer from the building fabric influencing the heating and cooling loads at
each level (Sharples 1984). Wind direction in the urban boundary layer can change direction by
In summary it can be seen that wind speeds increase with increasing altitude due to the lessening
influence of the ground and buildings whilst air turbulence decreases with increasing height.
Higher wind speeds with height will also contribute to greater cooling of building fabric by
means of convection and infiltration (Lowry 1991, p140).
3.8 Variations in building infiltration with increasing height
Diamond shows that the flow of air into a building as infiltration varies at different levels of the
building. In medium rise apartments and with high winds air flow increases with height on the
windward facade whereas in low wind conditions the air flow reduces with height. On the other
hand air flow through the façade reduces with height on the lee side of the building (Feustel &
Diamond).
Figure 15 - Mass air flow with varying wind speeds & increasing building height
Windward side (left) and lee side (right) - (http://epb.lbl.gov/homepages/Rick_Diamond/LBNL43642-
roomvent_98.pdf)
In the urban environment air pressure is further influenced by the effects of wind around
building clusters creating positive and negative air pressure zones related to prevailing wind
directions and speeds. In the case of tall buildings these differences in external air pressure
influence the:
vertical movement of wind externally in the form of updrafts and downdrafts,
Energy usage was shown to increase with increasing height in the cooling dominated hot climate
of Hong Kong with HVAC and lift energy showing some step changes in tall buildings at 7-10
levels and again at 25 levels as seen in Figure 19 (Rovers 2008).
Figure 19 – Relationship of energy use & building height in Hong Kong commercial buildings
(http://www.sustainablebuilding.info/post-crash/files/tallbuildings-UIA-paper-010608-rovers.pdf )
Cho’s study showed that energy use per unit area can be less in the case of taller buildings with
wider floor plates than in shorter buildings with smaller floor plates (Cho 2005, pp1007, 1008).
3.12 Variations in embodied energy usage with increasing height
Embodied energy usage is increased per unit of floor area with increasing building height
(Treloar et al 2001) as seen in Figure 20. This is attributed to the greater requirement for
structural steel content for stiffening and can be seen most clearly in the upper floors.
In Figure 21 Ali shows that the average weight of steel per square foot increases with increased
height. Studies of real buildings including the Commerzbank in Frankfurt, show a significant
reduction in the efficiency of materials with increasing height and that at 36 levels the loads for
both energy and materials start increasing exponentially (Van den Dobbelsteen et al 2007).
3.13 Summary
The following conclusions are drawn for this chapter against the study objectives:
3.13.1 Nature and gradients of micro-climates in rural and urban areas
1. Oke and Geiger identify a number of broad vertical climate zones in rural and urban
environments that may be significant to the bio-climatic design of tall buildings:
roughness layer at a 0 – 2 m
turbulent surface layer at 0 - 50m (reducing to a few metres at night time)
the urban canopy layer (from ground level to the average height of buildings)
the micro-climate layer most influenced by the ground at 0 – 100m
the urban boundary layer extending from the average height of buildings to between 200
and 500m
2. Climatic conditions in the natural environment vary significantly with height with the
widest ranges being closer to the ground. Changes with height include reduced air
Figure 22 – The MLC Centre looking north with denser building clusters beyond
(http://www.sydneyarchitecture.com/images/CBD- PIC_0071.JPG)
26
25
24
Sp1
23
Sp3 22
21
Sp2
20
Li2 Li1 19.9
Figure 25 shows a variation in façade radiant temperature from 27.0 °C at the ground level of
adjacent buildings to 21.9 °C at roof level of the MLC Centre. The temperature at the lowest
point on the subject façade not obstructed by adjacent buildings measured 23.3 °C at
approximately 90m. This represents a vertical gradient of -1.0 °C with each 100m for the upper
levels which is consistent with the adiabatic lapse rate. The lower levels of the subject building
are obscured and provide no measurements however adjacent south facing low rise buildings
demonstrate temperatures between 25.5 °C at roof levels and 27.0 °C at ground level
representing a vertical gradient of 1.58 °C with each 100m for the lower levels.
Other observations include the variation in temperatures with façade material where ranges of
0.5 - 1.0 °C are seen between opaque spandrel panels and recessed glazing in the subject building.
26.6 °C
26
25
24
Sp3
Sp2 23
22
21
Figure 27 shows a variation in radiant temperature on the north-east facing façade from 26.0 °C
at the ground level to 21.4 °C at roof level. This represents an average vertical gradient of – 2.1
°C with each 100m over the full height of the MLC Centre. The temperature at approximately
120m on the north facade measured 23.2 °C representing a vertical gradient of -1.66 °C with
each 100m for the upper levels of the subject building which is higher than the adiabatic lapse
rate.
26
Sp1 24
Sp2
22.4
Li1
Figure 29 shows a variation in radiant temperature on the west facing façade from 27.2 °C at the
ground level of adjacent buildings to 25 °C immediately below the subject building roof level at
220m. The lowest point on the façade not obstructed by adjacent buildings measured 27.3 °C at
75m. This represents a vertical gradient of -1.59 °C with each 100m for the upper levels which is
higher than the adiabatic lapse rate.
The lower levels of the building are obscured and so no clear measurements were taken however
adjacent west facing low rise buildings demonstrate temperatures of up to approximately 29.0 °C
approximately 15m above the ground. On this basis the lapse rate would be -1.95 °C per 100m
for the lower levels.
The lowest temperature to the MLC Centre façade was 24 °C at approximately 175m above the
ground coinciding with a recessed plant room level. The highest temperatures recorded were up
to 44.4 °C to stone and metal facades and canopies within the street canyon to the north facing
façade of other buildings in the foreground.
27
26
Sp3 25
24
23
22
Sp1
21
Sp2
Li1 Li2 20.1
Figure 31 shows a variation in radiant temperature on the south facing façade from
approximately 28.0 °C at the ground level of foreground buildings to 22.5 °C just below roof
level. The temperature at the lowest point on the façade not obstructed by adjacent buildings
measured 23.4 °C at approximately 115m. This represents a vertical gradient of -0.8 °C with each
100m for the upper levels of the subject façade which is slightly lower than the adiabatic lapse
rate.
The lower levels of the building are obscured and so no measurements were taken however
adjacent south facing low rise buildings demonstrate temperatures of up to 26.0 °C at ground
level. On this basis the lapse rate would be -1.54 °C per 100m for lower levels.
Other interesting observations include the differences in the temperatures of the south-west
facing façade (still exposed to setting sun) and the south east facing façade (not exposed to sun
since early morning). Figure 30 and Error! Reference source not found. show the temperature
Sp3
Sp1 25
24
23
Figure 33 shows a variation in radiant temperature on the north facing subject façade from
approximately 25.25 °C at 10m above the podium level to 23.2 °C at 75m above the podium at a
spandrel panel. This represents a vertical gradient of -3.15 °C with each 100m for the lowest 75m
of the MLC Centre which represents the highest lapse rate of all images.
Differences can also be seen in the temperatures of the north-west, north and north east facing
façades. The vertical temperature differences increase from the north-east to the north to the
north-west façade as seen in Figure 32 and Error! Reference source not found.. The highest
temperatures are to the north facing podium stairs at 28.7 °C. Sections of the subject building
spandrel panels are partly recessed and therefore shaded at times of the day showing temperature
reductions of 0.5 – 1.0 °C.
4.4 Summary of variations and gradients of radiant temperature changes in
field study
The following conclusions are drawn for this chapter against the study objectives:
5.1 Analysis of vertical climate data and principles from the literature review
Chapter 3 demonstrates there are clear and systematic principles related to the vertical climate in
the natural environment. This leads to a ‘vertical micro-climate’ characterised by variations in
temperature, air pressure, wind speed and humidity with height. The gradient of these
characteristics increases near the surface of the ground and reduces with increased height (Geiger
1973, p83). Micro-climatic conditions are shown to vary more vertically than horizontally over a
given distance. There is also a greater variation in conditions closer to the ground over the course
of a day and reduced variation in conditions with increased height above the ground.
The micro-climatic data related to rural areas is extensive and demonstrates clear systematic
patterns of vertical climate. These consist of verifiable ranges and gradients of temperature,
humidity and wind speed that reduce with increasing distance from the ground. The literature
related to urban areas is extensive however until recently has not distinguished between different
climate zones with the city being limited to simple distinctions between rural and urban
environments in respect to the UHI. The literature describes the vertical climate of cities in
general terms only in respect to the extent of upward influence the city has on the UHI although
Table 1 shows the key climatic trends to be the same as in rural areas however with a large degree
of variation. Little data exists to demonstrate the ranges and gradients of these conditions except
in the case of wind speeds.
This information can however be combined with the results of the field measurements of radiant
temperatures to show that whilst the trends remain the same, temperature ranges can be much
greater within the urban canopy.
The following table summarises the key characteristics of the vertical climate data referenced in
Chapter 3 and identifies the potential influences and benefits of these characteristics to building
energy consumption and thermal comfort.
Table 1 – Analysis of vertical micro-climate characteristics in rural and urban locations from the literature
review & field measurements
Analysis of vertical climate & building height characteristics against bio-climatic
design objectives
Solar radiation Air temperature
Key characteristics – Rural areas
Solar radiation increases with increasing Air temperature decreases with increasing
altitude approx. 4-5% per 300m. height.
Solar radiation increases in the urban boundary Standard adiabatic lapse rate of -1.0 °C per
layer due to greater exposure & reflection from 100m.
lower level surrounding roofs. Temperature lapse rates can reach 3 °C
/100m up to 50m height & range from
0.66 degrees to 1.0 °C for each 100m
above.
Air temperature gradient greatest on clear,
still summer days.
Air temperature gradient least (uniform) on
overcast days up to 100m.
Other characteristics that may change with increasing height include reduced dust and
mosquitoes however these are not investigated in this study.
Table 3 – Summary of thermal imaging data for the MLC Centre considering the subject building facades &
adjacent low rise building facades
Temperature ranges measured between 7.15pm and 8.30pm in summer on partly cloudy
day
Façade orientations & Radiant temperature range Vertical gradient
height
Western façade (15 – 220m) 29 – 25 °C 1.95 °C /100m
Northern facade 25.5 - 21.4 °C 1.8 °C /100m
Eastern façade (90-228m) 25.5 - 21.9 °C 1.58 °C /100m
Southern façade (5 – 220m) 26.2 - 22.5 °C 1.72 °C /100m.
Northern façade/stair (-10 - 28.7 – 23.2 °C 6.47 °C/100m
75m)
The data suggests that the vertical gradients of temperature measured in the natural environment
are modified by adjacent buildings and other UHI factors as would be expected leading to an
increased range and gradient of temperatures with height and a cooler micro-climate above the
local urban canopy. The general trend however of reduced temperature with increased height and
increased gradients closer to the ground remain the same in the building studied as in the rural
environment. Influences other than building height may include climate zone, season and
weather at the time of the measurements.
The effects of orientation are to create a number of differing temperature gradients to differently
oriented facades. This suggests that the gradient is influenced by solar exposure with reduced
gradients being seen to the shaded eastern facade and progressively increasing temperatures and
gradients to the north and then western façade which was exposed to sunlight at the time of the
measurements. This shows the importance of considering height together with the more usually
5.4 Case study of the application of temperature lapse rate to HVAC design in
the Freedom Tower
Figure 35 illustrates the design for the Freedom Tower in New York by SOM which provides
one of few case studies that apply changes in vertical climate to the reduction of energy usage.
The study examined the annual energy required for each floor level based upon the changing
external climate conditions with height. This contrasts with the standard approach based upon
regional climate data which assumes standard temperatures at all floor levels.
The study was completed by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory in the USA modelling
the effect of changes in air temperature and wind with altitude and the energy saving benefits of
these and concluded that “environmental factors that vary with altitude have a significant effect
on the annual total building and cooling energy”.
The study also showed that lower external air temperatures and higher wind speeds at higher
levels reduced cooling loads with air temperature exceeding the effect of wind at a height of
approximately 250m (Ellis & Torcellini 2005, p283). The same study showed that shading by
other buildings had the single largest contribution to reduced cooling loads. This benefit is
greatest at lower heights where more shade is available and reduces with increased height above
the urban canopy. The benefits of shading exceeded the radiation loads reflected from adjacent
buildings.
5.5 Summary of analysis for tall buildings in urban locations
Oke describes the general influences of the urban environment to extend up to between 200 and
500m. The investigation has shown that graduated differences exist in radiant temperature
between the ground level and roof in a tall building in the Sydney CBD. These variations are
however dependent upon building clustering and orientation of facades where some buildings are
shown to have no reduction in radiant temperature with increased height as shown in Figure 28.
Whilst solar radiation increases slightly with altitude the predominant effect in urban areas is
shading and reflection from adjacent buildings suggesting the amount of solar radiation exposure
will typically increase above the urban canopy.
The range of wind speed conditions is shown by Aynsley to increase fourfold from the ground to
between 100 and 200m in a typical urban environment as shown in Figure 12. Tall buildings
Bio-climatic design requires accurate climatic data. The use of the vertical micro-climate in bio-
climatic design would require meteorological data for vertical surfaces and the atmosphere in
cities of which there is little available. Zeiler provides a GIS 3-D object oriented data model for
simulation of the urban canopy layer climate which is to be coupled with vertical surface
information (Wu 2000). This may have applications to the measurement of the vertical climate
and the assessment of any benefits that bio-climatic tactics may provide.
6.1.2 Variability of micro-climate in urban areas - the case against the use of building
height
The vertical climate of cities is not measured in the literature sourced beyond general trends and
the vertical influence of the UHI on the atmosphere. This lack of information causes difficulties
in assessing the feasibility of bio-climatic tactics based on building height.
The potential applications would be least where conditions from the ground level to the roof
level are flattened out. The thermal imaging demonstrated that in some case tall buildings show a
uniform radiant temperature from the street to roof level as demonstrated in Figure 28.
Radiant temperatures in the field study demonstrated high levels of variability in climate in the
urban environment between different streets, outdoor spaces and facades. These complex
conditions were most apparent within the urban canopy which may limit the use of passive
strategies and support the use of air-conditioned environments sealed to the outside.
Larger scale weather systems may cause stronger winds that mix the atmosphere and remove
small scale differences or micro-climatic effects flattening out the vertical variations that result
from the influence of the ground (Oke 1978, p5).
Higher wind speeds can be difficult to manage in naturally ventilated solutions and indoor air
speeds may be unacceptably high necessitating the use of double skin facades or fan forced
mechanical ventilation in lieu of openable windows.
Roof mounted photo-voltaics are limited due to the relatively small roof area in tall
buildings. Façade integrated photo-voltaics can generate between 10-15% of energy
requirements (Guthrie 2008) however requires wind and solar generation to be
integrated into the façade whilst maintaining other amenities such as day lighting and
external views. The capacity of solar generated energy is influenced by building density,
orientation, overshadowing and height. The Pearl River Tower shown in Figure 39
receives less than 10% of its energy needs from the wind turbines and BIPV
(http://chinagreenbuildings.blogspot.com/2008_11_01_archive.html).
Figure 40 illustrates that tall buildings can provide less electricity generating potential per square
metre of floor area due to the decreased availability of solar radiation on vertical facades when
compared to horizontal roofs due to their high dependency on orientation (Haase & Amato
2006). Other contributing factors are the reduced ratio of building envelope to floor area with
increasing height as seen in Cho’s study (Cho 2005, p1007) and the likelihood of shading from
adjacent buildings
The opportunities to generate significant levels of energy with increasing building height appears
to be less than suggested by current tall building designs. However greater opportunities may
exist in taller buildings that extend above the urban canopy and those situated in suburban areas
with lower building densities. These types of buildings may be less impacted by over-shadowing
and wind turbulence.
14. Other tactics consider varying façade and opening types and HVAC systems to match
climate conditions that vary with height. This would include the use of climate
responsive facades and be focused on the greater use of passive cooling in hot climates.
These tactics would lead to a building design that varies vertically to match the micro-
climate which changes with height. This would be conceptually similar to the varying of
facades with orientation to match sun movement which is a condition of meso-climate.
15. The vertical micro-climate has been applied to existing tall building designs such as
Freedom Tower in New York although this case study is limited to a super tall building
and the use of temperature lapse rate in mechanical engineering design. This project was
studied by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory in the USA who concluded that
“environmental factors that vary with altitude have a significant effect on the annual
total building and cooling energy”.
16. This may contribute to climate mitigation by off-setting increases in construction costs
and embodied energy that occur with increased height. It may contribute to climate
adaptation by optimising envelope and environmental systems in the retro-fitting of
existing tall buildings.
17. Previous studies have examined the relationship of building height and sustainable
design however these studies are primarily focused on the optimisation of HVAC design.
This study identifies the opportunity for further research, verification and development
of the proposed conceptual tactics which may contribute to a bio-climatic design based
on building height.
Ellis, P.G., Torcellini, P.A. 2005, Simulating Tall Buildings Using Energy Plus [online], Available:
http://www.ibpsa.org/proceedings/BS2005/BS05_0279_286.pdf (July 27 2009).
Emmanuel, M.R 2005, An Urban Approach to Climate Sensitive Design, Strategies for the Tropics, Taylor
& Francis, New York.
Etheridge, D.W., Ford, B. 2008, Natural ventilation of tall buildings – options and limitations, CTUBH
8th World Congress 2008 [online], Available:
http://www.ctbuh.org/Portals/0/Repository/T5_EtheridgeFord.b6a96cc4-17e2-4c6b-
9ea2-97d41f025922.pdf
Feustel, H.E, Diamond, R.C, ‘Air Flow Distribution in a High Rise Residential Building’, [online],
Available: http://epb.lbl.gov/homepages/Rick_Diamond/LBNL43642-
roomvent_98.pdf
Geiger, R. 1973, The Climate Near the Ground, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, USA.
Gifford, R. 2008, The Consequences of Living in High Rise Buildings, Architectural Science
Review,Volume 50.1, [online],
http://web.uvic.ca/psyc/gifford/pdf/ASR%20High%20Rises%20proof.pdf (26 August
2009).
Givoni, B. 1998, Climate Considerations in Building and Urban Design, John Wiley and Sons, New
York.
Guthrie, A. 2008, ‘Tall Buildings Sustainability from the bottom up’, CTBUH 8th World
Congress 2008
Available: http://www.ctbuh.org/Portals/0/Repository/T1_Guthrie.07da35be-290f-
402e-bd18-709be2c1ce31.pdf
Haase, M., Amato, A. 2006, Sustainable Façade Design for Zero Energy Buildings in the Tropics [online],
Available: