Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Madness?
Mergers, Acquisitions,
and Divestitures
CONTENT
^ 4 Executive Summary
Human beings take risks. In business, Why do so many MAD attempts fail?
one of the riskiest moves company This paper discusses why failure hap-
stakeholders can take is to acquire and pens and how to prevent it by following Despite continued
merge with another company or to the overriding best practice in successful record setting in global
divest part of what they have. Despite acquisitions, mergers, and divestitures:
the best initial intentions between the preparedness. Knowing how to prepare, deals, at least half are
merging companies, many mergers, what to prepare, and when to prepare. doomed to failure.
acquisitions, and divestitures produce
results far below expectations. For At what point in going MAD does failure
some companies, the experience can most often occur? The paper identifies
be more than maddening – it can be the phase in the merger and acquisition
deadly, ending with the demise of the process where the breakdown occurs.
business. And it describes what is required to
prevent that failure.
Will your merger, acquisition, or divesti-
ture (appropriately enough, the acronym Finally, what do you need to assure both
is MAD) succeed or fail? If you answer sanity and success? This paper presents
that question with historical eyes that the steps to swiftly and precisely exe-
look back at major mergers for almost cute a migration path using a specific set
20 years, you might as well toss the of solutions for successful mergers,
coin. Your MAD journey has a 50–50 acquisitions, and the divestitures that
chance of failing. Such a high failure rate often result. These solutions support
should raise a red flag to any company a flexible IT environment, the important
getting ready to go MAD. premerger assessment phase, and the
critical postmerger integration support
However, despite these odds, mergers – without which the whole MAD deal
continue to increase unabated world- can go bad.
wide, and the failure rate is keeping
pace. Companies will continue to make
the same mistakes – unless they can get
advice from white papers like this one.
Trusted information
Build an accurate business
case for the merger based on
common suppliers, customers,
and products, and faster con-
solidation of financial reporting
Months
The Pitfalls of Postmerger often overestimate potential synergies There may be other factors that hinder
Integration and underestimate costs created by the your ability to retain top employees,
merger. As a result, mergers frequently such as undefined or duplicate roles,
A flexible and unified IT environment fail to achieve expected revenues. the lack of consolidated employee data,
facilitates postmerger integration by or incompatible HR systems.
maximizing interoperability, shortening Customer Loss
development time, and enabling seam- One of the top priorities in a merger is Supplier Consolidation
less integration internally and across determining which customers are profit- In a merger, cost reduction through
merged companies. With such an envi- able and creating a plan to retain them. consolidation of suppliers can add val-
ronment, your IT organization can deliver Surprisingly, the failure to successfully ue to the supply chain. However, in
significant value in the postmerger inte- transition customers to the newly many mergers, these consolidation
gration phase. merged entity is a common postmerger opportunities are often overlooked. You
story. This failure can happen for many miss opportunities for collaborative
A flexible IT environment can help reduce reasons, such as lack of consistent efforts with partners in product devel-
the risk and effort of integration. In such CRM processes, product duplicates, a opment, materials management, supply
an environment, IT can unify the IT infra- changed product portfolio, loss of a chain, manufacturing, marketing, and
structure of the merged companies by trusted sales team, and inconsistent sales.
setting an order of priority and consis- pricing, maintenance, and support.
tently communicating changes to the Poor Tracking of Key Performance
employees, customers, and partners Employee Attrition Indicators
impacted by the merger. In addition, a It is important to understand that when A successful merger depends on man-
flexible IT environment helps your IT team employees leave as a result of a merg- agement having visibility into the per-
to drive cost savings by identifying and er, it is not the underperformers who formance of the combined companies,
eliminating redundant data, processes, defect; it is usually the top employees. but this may not be possible with dispa-
software, or systems. One study of failed acquisitions found rate systems and databases. Neverthe-
that management attrition rates soared less, the ability to measure and analyze
A flexible and unified IT environment is 47% over the three years following the key performance indicators, even
one of your best defenses against the acquisition, with employee satisfaction before underlying systems are integrat-
pitfalls of postmerger integration, which dropping by 14% and productivity drop- ed, is mandatory to understanding the
include the following. ping by 50%.4 According to a study by success, partial success, or failure of a
Hewitt Associates of Asia-Pacific com- merger or acquisition. Without the abili-
Overestimating Synergies panies, top HR issues in mergers, ty to track performance, you cannot
It is not difficult to overestimate the value acquisitions, and divestitures include identify issues early enough to avoid
and underestimate the timing of a merger retention of key employees, compliance problems and the resulting loss of reve-
without the right data or tools to evaluate with applicable laws, and alignment of nue control.
and calculate synergies. Merger makers culture, compensation, and benefits.5
4. Merger & Acquisition Integration Excellence – Executive Summary (Best Practices LLC online database,
www3.best-in-class.com/bestp/domrep.nsf/Content/2660176D3C73C34485256DDA0056B49C!OpenDocument, 2000).
5. “The Real Cost of the Deal,” Hewitt Quarterly Asia Pacific, volume 5, issue 1 (Hewitt Associates LLC, 2007).
Across manufacturing and over 25 in many mergers and acquisitions, the For more information on SAP Strategy
industries, SAP has decades of exten- application also enables you to expedi- Management and other enterprise per-
sive experience in global mergers, tiously and completely decouple a busi- formance management solutions, go to
acquisitions, and divestitures. From ness unit you need to spin off, or www.sap.com/solutions/performance
this experience, SAP has learned how decouple an unwanted unit you gained management/pcm/index.epx.
to apply specific SAP® solutions and in an acquisition.
services to facilitate an end-to-end Business Planning and Consolidation
solution. SAP resources – ranging from Before, during, and after the acquisition To manage and monitor the performance
merger, acquisition, and divestiture and merger, strategy management of your mergers, acquisitions, and
consulting services to the application functionality helps you drive execution divestitures, you need accurate, timely
building blocks that result in a flexible across the enterprise. It helps you man- financial and operational data so you can
IT platform – help you navigate through age your goals, initiatives, and metrics effectively plan, budget, forecast, and
the preassessment and postmerger for performance in a way that enables analyze. During a merger or acquisition,
phases with confidence and speed. everyone in your company to truly you also need the ability to integrate
understand how your goals affect day- corporate and departmental planning,
Solutions for the Premerger to-day and long-term operations, how intelligently model cost scenarios, and
Assessment Phase to support them, and how to measure perform sensitivity analyses to deter-
success. Only when decision making mine operational budgets based on
The SAP solutions and their roles in is honed and all accountable individuals strategic plans and assumptions affected
supporting the phases of mergers, are linked and aligned to your goals, by the acquisition, merger, or divestiture.
acquisitions, and divestitures, beginning initiatives, and metrics can your organi- Lastly, you need a way to ensure a fully
with the crucial premerger assessment zation achieve its short-, medium- and documented audit trail and compliance
phase, include the following. long-term objectives. with guidelines for consolidating and
reporting company information internally
Strategy Management In the broad term, with SAP Strategy and externally for the new entity.
The SAP Strategy Management appli- Management and solutions for enter-
cation is part of SAP solutions for prise performance management, your For use during the premerger assess-
enterprise performance management – company can improve its agility, align- ment and postmerger integration phas-
a comprehensive set of solutions that ment, visibility, and confidence to opti- es – and beyond – the SAP Business
help your company capitalize on the mize control and gain competitive Planning and Consolidation application
value of your existing data assets. advantage. Enterprise performance can meet your budgeting, planning,
Because extension of the enterprise is management solutions cover enterprise consolidation, and reporting require-
implicit in most acquisitions and mergers, planning, financial consolidation, profit- ments in a single application and user
you may require other solutions in the ability and cost management, financial interface. It supports the full array of
enterprise performance management performance management, and analyt- top-down and bottom-up financial and
set of solutions, in addition to strategy ics. All SAP solutions for enterprise operational planning needs, as well as
management. performance management can integrate the consolidation processes necessary
with SAP Business Suite applications; to ensure a timely financial close. As a
SAP Strategy Management helps you SAP solutions for governance, risk, result, you can gain the confidence to
make the right decisions during the and compliance; and the SAP meet increasingly stringent regulations
execution of an acquisition and align the NetWeaver® technology platform. and reporting requirements across the
acquired company’s growth strategy globe. For IM&C companies, global
with yours. As divestitures are implicit trade and environmental compliance
All other product and service names mentioned are the trademarks of their
respective companies. Data contained in this document serves informational
purposes only. National product specifications may vary.
www.sap.com /contactsap