Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
F
ingertip amputation is a common injury of the treating surgeon. We prefer the toe pulp
around the world. The treatment for this free flap because it replaces the glabrous tissue
injury is controversial. Many techniques have over the fingertip with a similar tissue type, and
been described, including simple revision ampu- our technical refinement has markedly decreased
tation, skin grafting, local flaps, island flaps, dis- the operative time associated with this free flap
tant flaps, and free flaps.1–9 If the bone is not procedure.
exposed, allowing the wound to heal by secondary It is crucial that the treating surgeon has clear
intention can yield surprisingly good outcomes.1,2 goals to preserve functional and aesthetic appear-
No one technique is applicable to the wide variety ance of the injured digit. Although revision am-
of fingertip injuries. The optimal treatment de- putations may be the most expedient treatment
pends on many factors, such as patient preference, option, painful neuromas can occur, and the aes-
national culture, health care system, and expertise thetic appearance associated with the amputation
stumps can be quite bothersome to certain
From the Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, patients.1,2 The hand is the second most noticeable
Kwang-Myung Sung-Ae General Hospital, and the Section part of the body after the face, and restoring the
of Plastic Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of aesthetic appearance of the hand is increasingly rec-
Michigan Health System. ognized as an important goal of reconstruction.10
Received for publication February 6, 2007; accepted April 5,
2007.
Presented at the 10th Triennial Congress of the International
Federation of Societies for Surgery of the Hand, in Sydney, Disclosure: None of the authors has a financial
Australia, March 11 through 15, 2007. interest in any of the products, devices, or drugs
Copyright ©2008 by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons mentioned in this article.
DOI: 10.1097/01.prs.0000299945.03655.0d
www.PRSJournal.com 899
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • March 2008
In the national culture of Korea, the need to artery, plantar subcutaneous vein, and the plantar
restore missing body parts is based on ancient digital nerve at the level of the metatarsophalan-
Confucian teaching of respecting the body that geal joint. The donor site is often closed primarily.
was given to one by their parents. Korean patients To prevent excessively tight closure, we apply skin
invariably will demand replantation following all grafts for donor wounds that cannot be closed
types of finger injuries even though they recognize primarily.
that the function may not be optimal and the
rehabilitation period may be prolonged. In addi-
tion, patients are keen to restore the aesthetic Surgical Technique
appearance of the finger when replantation at- We prefer to use brachial plexus block and
tempts are not successful. Based on this demand, spinal anesthesia for the surgical procedure, but
we have an extensive experience in performing seven patients requested general anesthesia. All
partial second toe pulp free flaps to restore the children’s procedures were conducted under gen-
functional and aesthetic needs after fingertip am- eral anesthesia. For 15 cases, we performed meta-
putations. We have developed a technique to har- carpal block for the fingers and metatarsal block
vest partial second toe pulp for transfer by means for the toes under minimal sedation. The opera-
of a short pedicle that minimizes donor-site mor- tion was performed under tourniquet control and
bidity. This technique avoids the extensive dorsalis moderate amount of exsanguination to preserve
pedis artery harvest, and the expediency of per- the visibility of the small volar digital veins.11 The
forming this procedure has expanded our indica- skin, the medial plantar artery, and the subcuta-
tions for the partial-pulp toe free flap. The specific neous vein were harvested. The digital nerve sup-
aim of this article is to share our experience and plying the flap was used for sensory innervation. At
present the outcomes of 929 cases of second toe the recipient finger (Fig. 1), we anastomosed the
partial-pulp free flap transfer for reconstructing vessels to the digital artery and volar subcutaneous
fingertip soft-tissue defects. veins of the finger.
After adequate debridement of the recipient
PATIENTS AND METHODS finger, the defect was measured with a pattern. We
We retrospectively performed a chart review to used a zigzag incision over the volar finger, taking
collect demographic and surgical data. A group of great care to preserve the subcutaneous veins lo-
patients returned for sensory outcomes evalua- cated on either side of the joint crease. The flap
tion. One hundred fifty-six patients had more de- incision was made over the medial or tibial side of
tailed examinations using the two-point discrimi- the second toe (Fig. 2). The flap incision does not
nation test when they returned for additional extend beyond the midline so that the donor site
reconstructive procedures for associated injuries can be closed. The average flap measured 2.7 cm
or when they had medical checkups for other dis- in length and 1.7 cm in width. The largest flap that
eases. Our indications for performing this free could be harvested and donor site closed was 3.3
flap procedure are defects at the fingertips with cm in length and 2.3 cm in width. However, to en-
exposure of bone after amputations. We also per-
form this procedure for painful atrophic fingertip
injuries associated with soft-tissue deficits. We
chose not to perform this procedure in patients
who had uncontrolled diabetes and vascular dis-
eases because we had flap failures in the first two
patients with these risk factors, before the data
collection for this series.
Five surgeons contributed patients to this se-
ries that consisted of 929 flaps in 854 patients
treated from April of 1999 to October of 2006. For
reconstructing multiple defects, the surgeon har-
vested flaps from the second toes of both feet. For
occasional cases of three-finger defects, we har-
vested both second toes and a flap from the third
toe using similar techniques.
The flap is limited to the tibial half of the pulp Fig. 1. A 29-year-old industrial worker with a total pulp defect of
tissue. We harvested the medial plantar digital the middle finger.
900
Volume 121, Number 3 • Partial Second Toe Pulp Free Flap
901
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • March 2008
Fig. 4. Flap A is elevated to identify the subcutaneous vein. Fig. 6. The midline incision goes through the pulp to the pre-
tendinous layer.
additional effort for us but may enhance patient phalanx level. Occasionally, the vein may not be
sensory outcome. The volar finger veins are typi- sufficient for drainage and the flap can be con-
cally 1.2 to 1.5 mm in diameter in the middle gested. We have found that using medicinal
902
Volume 121, Number 3 • Partial Second Toe Pulp Free Flap
Fig. 7. The flap is retracted medially. It shows the arterial bleed- Fig. 8. The digital artery is now exposed along the medial side of
ing at the mid pulp of flap, which is the bleeding point from di- the skin flap.
vided arterial arch.
RESULTS
The anatomical areas for flap coverage in-
cluded 426 flaps for coverage at the nail level, 287
distal to the distal interphalangeal joint, and 216
at the middle phalanx level. Five surgeons per-
formed 929 flaps in 854 patients from April of
1999 to October of 2006. This patient group con- Fig. 9. The harvested flap will be dissected under the micro-
sisted of 747 male patients with ages ranging from scope to isolate the artery, vein, and nerve.
2 to 72 years (mean, 34 years). The demographic
data are listed in Table 1.
The overall survival rate of this procedure is with a regional flap, and one had a revision am-
99.7 percent; three flaps failed completely. Com- putation. The data are summarized in Table 2.
plications included 72 flaps that experienced ar- We used leech therapy in 58 flaps for transient
terial spasm: 15 required segmental arterial resec- venous congestion, and all of them were treated
tion and primary repair and 57 required repair successfully. Although the use of leeches consti-
with vein grafting. Of these 72 flaps with problems, tutes only 6.2 percent of this series, it does not
three failed completely, two required coverage imply that venous anastomosis is not necessary,
903
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • March 2008
Fig. 10. The donor site is closed primarily. Fig. 13. Donor toe appearance.
904
Volume 121, Number 3 • Partial Second Toe Pulp Free Flap
Table 2. Recipient- and Donor-Site Complications: erative time required to harvest a short pedicle
Arterial Spasms* and still have a greater than 99 percent success rate
No. repairing vessels that are in the range of 1 mm.
Type of of This short pedicle technique has the advantage of
Complication Repair/Treatment Cases more expedient flap elevation, less trauma to the
Recipient site foot, and less conspicuous donor-site scarring by
Arterial spasms* Segmental arterial resection 15 obviating a dorsal foot incision to harvest more
and primary repair
Vein grafting 57 proximal vessels. There is also less concern with
Total 72 kinking of a long pedicle and potential compres-
Donor site sion of the pedicle when tunneling it to reach
Hematoma Evacuation and repeated 39
closure larger diameter vessels at the recipient site. How-
Wound dehiscence Secondary closure 20 ever, the disadvantages of this technique must be
Total 59 acknowledged. The volar toe vein is tenuous, and
*Three of these flaps failed completely. Two required coverage with the surgeon must be quite meticulous in handling
a regional flap and one had a revision amputation.
this tenuous vessel. However, with experience, sur-
geons should be able to find these vessels in a
found that the mean sensory two-point discrimi- predictable fashion. Our relatively short flap har-
nation was 8 mm (range, 4 to 15 mm). Patients vest time indicates that, with practice, this tech-
younger than 35 years had better sensory recovery nique can be performed with relative ease.19 The
(two-point discrimination, 6 mm) than those survival rate is based on the number of flaps that
older than 35 years (9 mm). survived after all surgical intervention (926 of
929). However, the high survival rate does not
DISCUSSION indicate a high rate of patient satisfaction out-
Since the introduction of the microsurgery come. A high proportion of the reconstructed
field over 40 years ago, refinement of flap con- fingers do require secondary procedures.
structs and better surgical expertise have markedly Methods proposed for reconstructing finger-
improved the performance of free flaps.12–17 Given tip injuries can be controversial. Some surgeons
that very small vessels (⬍1 mm) can now be anas- prefer simpler techniques such as cross-finger
tomosed with a high rate of success, it is not nec- flaps or shortening of the digits in an effort to
essary today to harvest a bulky flap using an ex- decrease the complexity of the surgical recon-
tensive proximal exposure incision to find vessels struction. However, the surgeon must also con-
sufficiently large for anastomoses.15–20 With this sider other more optimal options based on the
technique, we have markedly decreased the op- complexity of the fingertip wound, patient re-
905
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • March 2008
906
Volume 121, Number 3 • Partial Second Toe Pulp Free Flap
ACKNOWLEDGMENT 10. Manske, P. R. Aesthetic hand surgery. J. Hand Surg. (Am.) 10:
The authors thank Elizabeth A. Petruska for orga- 383, 2002.
11. Smith, D. O., Oura, C., Kimura, C., and Toshimori, K. The
nizing the tables and editing the article. distal venous anatomy of the finger. J. Hand Surg. (Am.) 16:
REFERENCES 303, 1991.
12. Harii, K. Microvascular surgery and its clinical applications.
1. Holm, A., and Zachariae, L. Fingertip lesions: An evaluation
Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res. 133: 95, 1978.
of conservative treatment versus free skin grafting. Acta Or-
13. Buncke, H. J., and Rose, E. H. Free toe-to-fingertip neuro-
thop. Scand. 45: 382, 1974.
vascular flaps. Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 63: 607, 1979.
2. Rose, E. H., Norris, M. S., and Kowalski, T. A. Microsurgical
14. Morrison, W. A. Thumb and fingertip reconstruction by
management of complex fingertip injuries: Comparison to
composite microvascular tissue from the toes. Hand Clin. 8:
conventional skin grafting. J. Reconstr. Microsurg. 4: 89, 1998.
3. Lister, G. Local flaps to the hand. Hand Clin. 1: 621, 1985. 537, 1992.
4. O’Brien, B. Neurovascular island pedicle flaps for terminal 15. Foucher, G., Merle, M., Maneaud, M., and Michon, J. Mi-
amputations and digital scars. Br. J. Plast. Surg. 21: 258, 1968. crosurgical free partial toe transfer in hand reconstruction:
5. Russell, R. C., Van Beek, A. L., Wavak, P., and Zook, E. G. A report of 12 cases. Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 65: 616, 1980.
Alternative hand flaps for amputations and digital defects. 16. Logan, A., Elliot, D., and Foucher, G. Free toe pulp transfer
J. Hand Surg. (Am.) 6: 399, 1981. to restore traumatic digital pulp loss. Br. J. Plast. Surg. 38: 497,
6. Cohen, B. E., and Cronin, E. D. An innervated cross-finger 1985.
flap for fingertip reconstruction. Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 72: 688, 17. Koshima, I., Inagawa, K., Urushibara, K., Okumoto, K., and
1983. Moriguchi, T. Fingertip reconstructions using partial-toe
7. Kojima, T., Tsuchida, Y., Hirase, Y., and Endo, T. Reverse transfers. Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 105: 1666, 2005.
vascular pedicle digital island flap. Br. J. Plast. Surg. 43: 290, 18. del Pinal, F. The indications for toe transfer after “minor”
1990. finger injuries. J. Hand Surg. (Br.) 29: 120, 2004.
8. Shibu, M. M., Tarabe, M. A., Graham, K., Dickson, M. G., and 19. Dautel, G., Corcella, D., and Merle, M. Reconstruction of
Mahaffey, P. J. Fingertip reconstruction with a dorsal island fingertip amputations by partial composite toe transfer with
homodigital flap. Br. J. Plast. Surg. 50: 121, 1997. short vascular pedicle. J. Hand Surg. (Am.) 23: 457, 1998.
9. Takeishi, M., Shinoda, A., Sugiyama, A., and Ui, K. Inner- 20. Foucher, G., Sammut, D., Greant, P., Braun, F. M., Ehrler, S.,
vated reverse dorsal digital island flap for fingertip recon- and Buch, N. Indications and results of skin flaps in painful
struction. J. Hand Surg. (Am.) 31: 1094, 2006. digital neuroma. J. Hand Surg. (Am.) 16: 25, 1991.
907