Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Buzz on
Tall Wood
The Who, What, When,
Where, Why and How on
High-rise Mass Timber
Buildings
1056 1 3 TH C E N T U R Y 1 6 TH C E N T U R Y
YINGXIAN PAGODA, HEDDAL STAVE CHURCH, KIZHI POGOST,
SHANXI CHINA NOTODDEN, NORWAY KIZHI, RUSSIA
Size:
7 Stories (at
street)
9 stories ( at
waterfront)
Over 175,000 sf
1905
T H E L A N D I N G ,
VANCOUVER, CANADA Source: A Study on Historical Tall-Wood Buildings in Toronto and Vancouver
PROJECT SIZE:
8 buildings
Covers city block
312 K sf total
LARGEST BLDG:
6 stories
190K sf
THEN:
Carpet Factory
NOW:
1889-1920 Office Complex
TORONTO CARPET FACTORY,
TORONTO, CANADA Source: A Study on Historical Tall-Wood Buildings in Toronto and Vancouver
1906
B U T L E R S Q U A R E ,
MINNEAPOLIS, MM
Size:
9 Stories
500,000 sf
Then:
Warehouse
Now:
Office above
Retail below
1906
B U T L E R S Q U A R E ,
MINNEAPOLIS, MM
Tall Wood Projects
ARCHITECT: Artec
ENGINEER: Sweco Source: Toward Taller Wood Buildings Symposium 2014
Tall Wood Projects
?
S T A R T E D J U L Y 2 0 1 5
D A L S T O N L A N E
ENGINEER: Romboll UK Limited
LONDON, UK
S T A R T E D N O V E M B E R 2 0 1 5
B R O C K C O M M O N S ARCHITECT: Acton Ostry Architects
BRITISH COLUMBIA, CANADA ENGINEER: Fast + Epp
2015
REDSTONE ARESENAL CANDLEWOOD SUITES HOTEL
DESIGN/BUILD: LendLease
HUNTSVILLE, AL
U N D E R C O N S T R U C T I O N
T 3 O F F I C E ARCHITECT: Michael Green/DLR Group
MINNEAPOLIS, MN ENGINEER: Magnusson Klemencic Associates
USDA Support – Tall Wood Competition
• Originally a $2 million Project Competition
• So many high quality submissions resulted in 2 projects
awarded $1.5 million each
• Funding provided by joint effort between Softwood
Lumber Board, Binational Softwood Lumber Council and
USDA
Source: reThinkWood
Tall Wood Winner – Portland, OR
Source: reThinkWood
Global Population Boom
Global Population
7.3 billion now
9.7 billion by 2050
33% increase
Urban Population
6.4 billion by 2050
62% increase
Source: United Nations Department
of Economic and Social Affairs
Trends in US Population
100%
90%
In 1920, the urban In 2000, it is about
80%
70% and rural population 80% urban
60% were about equal
50%
40%
30%
20% Rural
10%
Urban
0%
1790 1800 1810 1820 1830 1840 1850 1860 1870 1880 1890 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000
• Disaster Resilient
Valuable • Good Fire Resistance
Performance • High performing Acoustics
• Structural Flexibility
Designers Contractors
Government Industry
Tall Wood Motivators – Design Team
• Market Leadership
Primary
• Carbon Reduction
Motivators
• Energy Performance
• Structural Performance
Secondary - Light weight
Motivators • Speed of Construction
• Aesthetic
Thermal Resistance
500
400
300
200
100
0
Wood Concrete Steel
*Normalized Comparison
Source: Thermal Performance of Light framed Systems, CWC
Structural Performance
Stadhaus, London, UK
Architect: Waugh Thistleton Architects
Photo credit: Waugh Thistleton Architects http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tJHeLyFASEI
Speed of Construction
Source: http://awc.org/publicpolicy/statefactsheets
US Forest Land
800 759 760 756 761 744 738 747 749 751
600
400
200
0
1630 1907 1938 1953 1963 1977 1987 1997 2002 2007
800
700
Inventory (billion cubic feet)
365.1 370.5
600 347
346.7
500 363.2
363.7
400
256.4 268
300 244.6
223.4
200 174.1
148.5
100 190 214.3 217.6
128.3 163
103.7
0
1953 1963 1977 1987 1997 2002
Source: USDA-Forest Service, US Forest Resource Facts and Historical Trends FS-801. (2004).
Western US Wild Fire Epidemic
Source: http://awc.org/publicpolicy/statefactsheets
Outline
Considerations:
• Gap panels for
dimensional change
• Need Wood Structural
Panel for diaphragm
capacity
• Inconsistent lamination
grades
Glue Laminated Timber
• Manufacturers
everywhere
Graphic Credit: StructureCraft
MOSAIC CENTRE
ENMONTON, AB Architect: Manasc Isaac
Engineer: Fast + Epp
CANADA
SAUTER TIMBER PRODUCTION FACILITY
ROCKWOOD, TN Photo Credit: Andreas Sauter, Tim Clay
USA Photography
Solid Timber Panel Products
Considerations:
• Span usually governed by
vibrations
• Dimensionally stable
• Recognized by 2015 codes
and standards
• High in plane shear
capacity
Cross Laminated Timber • Dual Directional span
capabilities
Considerations:
• Requires accommodation
for dimensional change
• Need wood structural
panel for diaphragm
capacity
• Recognized as a heavy
timber floor system
Nail Laminated Timber
• Long history of use
Considerations:
• Established design
properties
• Specially ordered but
multiple domestic
manufacturers
• Horizontal applications don’t
take advantage of the
strength direction
Laminated Veneer Lumber • Relatively dimensionally
stable
• Limited Thicknesses
Graphic Credit: StructureCraft
Metropol Parasol, Seville, Spain
Design Team: J. Mayer H. Architects, ARUP Consulting Engineers
Photo Credit: ARUP
Solid Timber Panel Products
Considerations:
• Established design
properties
• Specially ordered but
multiple domestic
manufacturers
• Relatively dimensionally
stable
Laminated Strand Lumber
Considerations:
• Connection needs to be
carefully designed
• Difficult to ensure design
capacity if concrete is
poured on site
• Detail needs to
accommodate the moisture
Wood/Concrete Composites conflict between the
materials
• Folded Plates
• Solid Wood Core
• Timber Braced Frames
• Timber Trusses
• Rocking Wall Systems
• Post-Tensioned Frames
• Wood/Wood Composite
Systems
Other Mass Timber Systems
ARCHITECT: Artec
ENGINEER: Sweco Source: Toward Taller Wood Buildings Symposium 2014
ARCHITECT: Michael Green Architecture
ENGINEER: Equilibrium Engineering
PHOTO CREDIT: Source: Toward Taller Wood Buildings Symposium 2014
ARCHITECT: Shigeru Ban & IttenBrechbuhl
ENGINEER: Creation Holz GmbH Source: Survey of International Tall Wood Buildings, 2014
High-rise Structural Design Concepts
Life Cycle Tower System
www.creebyrhomberg.com
Life Cycle Tower
• Designed to be manufactured
regionally
• Up to 30 Stories
Life Cycle Tower
Hybrid Panelized
Floor System
Life Cycle Tower
FFTT System
Tall Wood
The Case for Tall Wood Buildings (2012)
Engineer: Eric Karsh
Equilibrium
Architect: Michael Green
Michael Green Architecture
30 Stories in Vancouver
mg-architecture.ca/portfolio/tallwood/
Glulam Columns
CLT Walls
Steel Beams
Strong-Column
Weak-Beam
System
www.som.com/publication/timber-tower-research-project
SOM Timber Tower
Benchmark Building
Dewitt-Chestnut Apartments:
• Designed by SOM
• Chicago, IL
• Completed in 1966
• 42 Stories
• 395 ft tall + parapets
• Concrete frame building
Structure
Wood - 0.80 cu ft/sf
Concrete 0.98 cu ft/sf 0.25 cu ft/sf
Wood + Conc 0.98 cu ft/sf 1.05 cu ft/sf
Reinforcement 5.9 psf 1.7 psf
Structural steel - 0.3 psf
Foundations
Concrete 0.14 cu ft/sf 0.09 cu ft/sf
Reinforcement 0.1 psf 0.1 psf
Dead Weight 18 lb/ft3 7 lb/ft3
Bill of Materials
* Volumes based on initial study without composite floors
40 Storey Office Building of the Future
CEI Architecture
RJC Consulting Engineers
2012
www.ceiarchitecture.com/project/naiop-design-competition-2012/
Flexible Office Shell and Core
Perimeter
Wood Trusses
Concrete Core
and Columns
Unique Floor Framing
Buckling Restrained
Braced Frame
Source: Mass Timber High-Rise Research Museum Tower in Los
Angeles Reimagined, 2015 SEAOC Convention
Alternate Design Paths
Achieving Approval:
• Testing for materials and
assemblies was common
• Onsite inspections were
crucial
• In two cases, fire protection
strategies were simplified as
the project progressed.