Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Baseline Survey
On
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to thank the following people and organizations for their support in
this survey.
- The National Department of Health, STI & HIV Prevention. A number of staff
of this department were assist us to conduct the study including planning
and administration issues, assistance and support in data collection and
reviewing the data and report.
- The consortium Team leaders, who was involved in most of the stages of
planning of the survey. He assisted the research team in each district by
supporting the data collection process and liaising with facilities as
required.
- The consortium DIC staffs, who contribute immensely through assisting the
data collecting team during data collection.
- Mr. Tofael of UNICEF who advised on the sampling methodology and also
supported the survey and encouraged the research team from its earliest
stages.
CONTENTS
Acknowledgements............................................................ 2
List of Abbreviations........................................................... 4
Foreword......................................................................... 5
1 Introduction ................................................................... 7
1.1 STIs and HIV in Bangladesh ...................................... 7
1.2 Justification of the study...................................... .. 7
1.3 Objective of the study........................................ .. .. 8
1.4 Methodology ................................... ............ 8
1.5 Sampling Frame ...................................... ............ 10
2. Limitations ........................................................................ 12
List of Abbreviations
CI Confidence Interval
FC Female Condom
Foreword
It gives us a great pleasure to be able to present this summary report of the results
of the first baseline assessment of RPDO Consortium. It lays out a wealth of data;
the success stories and the challenges that confront us as we strive to improve the
delivery of care for HIV/AIDS & Sexually Transmitted Infections. This can serve as
an entry point for prevention services that stand to reduce the rates of both HIV
and other sexually transmitted infections.
I would like to take this opportunity to thank all those involved in this massive
task, especially a core group from the consortium, and the STI & HIV Prevention
Unit of the Government. Without their tireless commitment this survey would not
have been successful.
Executive Summary
The primary objectives of the survey were to ascertain the current status of the
HIV/AIDS epidemic and the risk of behaviors among the Hotel & Residence based
High risk population in a aim to increasing access to STI/HIV prevention services,
and reducing new HIV infections. Furthermore, it is anticipated that findings will
inform the selection of measurable indicators for ongoing monitoring and
evaluation of the national STI programme. Data were collected by a pre-set
questionnaire which was tested in four locations (district) of Bangladesh. Detailed
information on specific aspects of the HIV and STI prevention and management
was obtained by interviews with 343 respondents at national and provincial levels.
This survey estimates that:
- Local Administration plays a vital role in this context. 37.8% of the
respondents say that the police mostly harass them.
- Most of the respondents are primarily literate (i.e. 83.4%)
- Average age of the respondents are 23.59 years
- Average daily income of the targeted population of this survey is Tk. 166
- Very poor attitude of savings. 73.2% have no savings and
- Due to the financial crisis most of them choose this profession
- 98.5% know about the primary information of HIV/AIDS but in major
- they know, condom is the only way to prevent STD & HIV
- 38.5% of the respondent know proper use of condom but only 6.7% of them
use condom in the last week
- Usually the clients dislike to use condom
- Most of them do not want to take any suggestion from any physician
regarding STI treatment
1. INTRODUCTION
Sexually transmitted infections (STIs) have become a global burden; the World
Health Organization (WHO) estimates that about 340 million new cases of curable
STIs occur each year in people aged 15-49 years. The low knowledge on HIV and
STI that are seen in the selected districts are associated with the possibility to
spread of HIV in the region.
STIs constitute a major public health challenge to Bangladesh. It is estimated that
approximately 13000 thousand Bangladeshis were infected with HIV at the end of
2003. STIs are associated with transmission and acquisition of HIV infection.
Several studies have shown that treatment of curable STIs reduces HIV
transmission. Prevention and early treatment of STIs is therefore a high public
health priority in Bangladesh.
1.4 METHODOLOGY
Survey design
The study will follow a cross-sectional design and will be conducted in 13 districts;
such as Tangail, Jamalpur, Jessore, Narayanganj, Narshingdi, Khulna, Jhenidaha,
Kishorogonj, Netrakona Satkhira, Gazipur, Mymensingh, and Bagerhat at different
geographical locations. Both qualitative and quantitative methods (using
pre-structured questionnaire) will be used in gathering data and information.
n = z2pq / d2
Where,
n = the desired sample size (when population size is ≥ 10,000)
z = the standard normal deviate, usually set at 1.96, which corresponds to the 95
percent confidence level
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 9
Therefore,
= 384
However, the above sample size is not appropriate for our study. Because, our
target population are # 2558 hotel base sex workers, and 742 residence based sex
worker i.e. a total of 3300 sex worker which is provided by RPDO Consortium.
Hence, if the population is < 10,000, the required sample size will be smaller. In
this case, calculate a final sample estimate (nf) by using the following formula:
nf = n / 1 + (n/N)
Where, N is the total population size
Accordingly, the required sample size will be:
nf = 384 / 1 + (384/3300)
= 384 / 1 + .11636363
= 384 / 1.11636363
= 343.973943
= 344 (App.)
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 10
Target Population**
Category Percent Cumulative Percent
Residence Based 27.1 27.1
Hotel Based 72.9 100.0
Total 100.0
It should be noted that, because of the sampling technique used, the respondents
do not make up a representative sample of the population of Bangladesh or of
their particular quota category. However, the sampling plan ensured that
respondents were selected from most of the Hotels and some specific residence of
the selected towns. Very few individuals approached for an interview refused to
participate, further limiting potential bias.
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 11
Thus, though not statistically representative, it is believed that the survey findings
are indicative of the HIV/AIDS knowledge, attitudes and behaviors of those in the
categories of interest and are therefore useful for program guidance.
Based on the objectives of the survey and specific information needs, structured
questionnaire will be developed to interview the sampled individuals. To
fine-tune/finalization of the questionnaire, a dry run of the questionnaire will be
conducted in real field situation.
A total of 9 (nine) data collectors were assigned to collect the data from
pre-determined-sampled individuals following a data collection schedule which
take about 23 days.
In data entry and processing user-friendly database (which will follow standard
skip and range rules) was designed using popular software MS-Access and the
consistency checking, recoding and verifying of data during processing period/time
was done through world famous sophisticated statistical software SPSS.
Data in this survey were analyzed to describe/narrate the current situation of the
targeted groups in the specific areas based on the study objectives.
Quantitative data was analyzed using two possible ways-uni-variate and bi-variate
analysis using the software SPSS to generate tables with statistical tests. MS
PowerPoint was used to generate graphical presentations of information.
As with any such survey, there are potential limitations that are discussed here to
prevent misinterpretation of the results.
Age Distribution1**
300
251
250
200
150
100 62
30
50 0 0
0
<12 years 12-18 years 19-30 years 31-40 years >40 years
The graph clearly expresses the scenario of the age distribution. One of the most
highlight area may be the 12 to 18 age group. 62 percent of the respondents are
persisting in this group.
As we have not verified the age through any other sources but only what they’re
saying, there is a possibility to turn this result in a slightly different way.
Marital Status**
1
** indicates the core questions from UNICEF
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 14
Dependency Status**
Between the age 19-30years, most of them were started working as a sex worker.
Out of 343 respondents, only 3 persons found who have age more than 31 years.
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 15
99% of the respondents say sexual act is the main source of their income. None of
them received any types of financial assistance from their family. The average
daily income found Tk. 166. The minimum daily income found Tk. 50 and
maximum Tk. 600.
Daily Income**
Most of the respondents earn Tk. 100 to Tk. 200 per day and more specifically
most of them are 19 to 30 age group. Only one member found who earned more
that Tk. 600 per day. 89 respondent answer that they earn less than or equals to
Tk. 100 per day through sex act.
Savings Status**
Out of 343, only 19 respondents have savings more that Tk. 50. A majority of 73
respondents says that, they have a minimum amount of savings (less than fifty
taka). As a result, most of them came in to this profession. 275 respondents out of
343 say about their financial crisis and they were derived to this profession to
overcome the situation.
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 16
A job may add significantly to family incomes and give women a degree of
independence, but exploitation is widespread and job security non-existent. The
recession and lack of bargaining power of women due to gender inequality, keep
many of them who work in the informal sector trapped in poverty by compelling
them to accept risky and socially neglected profession like Sex Work with low pay
and poor working conditions.
There is a major job gap compared with the available female workforce in
industrial countries. The survey results predict that this job gap will continue to
widen, resulting in a flow into unemployment of increasingly alarming proportions,
particularly for young females and women.
The survey result also indicates that all of the hotel and residence based high risk
populations are forced to choose this profession, not by their own interest. The
following table indicates that less scope of work (financial crisis) forced the
surveyed population to turn their life in this profession.
Women trafficking is emerge issue now a days. The above scenario also indicates
the vulnerability of not only the respondents but also the local administrations
who are quite fail to control the issue of trafficking. A key alarming information is
that, 11.8 percent said that they were picked-up to this business by the brokers.
As a result of greed, 14.8 percent women came to this business, which indicates
the week controlling systems of our social security.
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 17
The following table address the key issues on a more concentrated ways through
separate in different marital category.
A total of 149 married women came to this profession and the need of finance is
the key point to turn on this line.
Though most of the women are picked up from rural areas, they are relatively
having the basic education. 77.8% percent (267 respondents) have formal schooling
of at least class I to X. Only 16.6 % respondents found illiterates. But there is only
a few who have studied more than class 12, and none of the respondent found as a
post-graduate.
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 18
The following comparative analysis indicates that, most of the respondents of age
group 19-30 are quite in a literate stage including 2 graduations.
Education Total
9th- 11th- Degree
Age in Illiterat 1st-5th 6th -8th 10th 12th and
years e Class Class Class Class Above
<12 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
12-18 3 14 32 13 0 0 62
19-30 43 94 65 31 16 2 251
31-40 11 11 4 3 0 1 30
>40 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 57 119 101 47 16 3 343
At present, 100 percent use of condom is one of the major ways to prevent the
rate of HIV/AIDS. Uses of condom during sex act, also treated as a part of safer sex
practice. So the proper use of condom among the high risk population is very much
essential to implement such a program.
As a primary result of survey, 97% of the surveyed person response positively, that
they have at least a primary concept on condom. A few (10 respondents) says that,
they don’t have any knowledge about condom. Most of the respondents of this
leman groups stands on 19-30 ages.
But the most interesting findings are that, 206 respondents out of 343, doesn’t
know how to use the condoms.
Though 97% of the respondents knows about the condom and 38.5 % can use the
condom properly, due to ignorance, force of clients and different various region
only 6.7% can use the condom in a regular basis. The following table indicates the
irregularities on condom use.
High-risk group behaviors regarding condom use are consistent with their low
levels of knowledge and stated lack of concern. Only 18.4% of respondents
reported condom use the last time they had sex, and 76.7% reported having ever
used a condom. Such low levels of condom use among this important group are
alarming.
The scenario of last time condom use is much serious. The rate is higher among
the residence based high-risk groups. There is a scope to learn from each other
among the hotel based high-risk groups but the scope is limited between the
residences based.
Most of them know the sources of condom. They treated the pharmacy and the
general/grocery shops as the main source of condom.
Condom Availability**
Condom availability Number Percentage (%)
Family Planning Workers 73 9.6
Health Workers 99 13.1
Pharmacy 325 43.2
General Shop 188 25
NGO 63 8.3
Don’t Know 4 .5
Others 2 .3
Though a huge number of NGOs work on this field only 8.3 percent of the
respondent says that, they collect condoms from the NGO workers. The govt. and
NGO level initiatives can’t play a influential role regarding the condom
availability. Only 31 percent of the respondent goes to this group (FP workers,
Health workers and NGO workers) for collecting condoms.
Client contact**
197 respondent says that, they receive two clients per day in an average. Only one
respondent answer that, she take six clients per day. The age groups of 19-30
contact most of the clients.
The following table indicates the same result during the survey.
Out of 343 respondents, 273 of them faced problem with clients regarding using
condoms and 55 of them says that some times they faced problems to use condom
with clients.
Other than that, the clients, whom they enforce to use condom, tortured the high-
risk group in many ways. This type of behaviour of clients indicates the
susceptibility of the high-risk group and violation of the human rights. Most of the
time the law enforcements agencies ignore this type of matter, which encourage
the clients to continue the behaviour in it.
The respondents were asked about their general perception on HIV/AIDS. Out of
343, about 98.5% (i.e. 338) respondent says that they are heard about the
HIV/AIDS. Most of the respondent in all categories are aware about HIV/AIDS.
Knowledge of HIV **
The NGOs are playing a leading role in spreading the message (28.2%) to the mass
people. Next to that, friends and TV media played a vital role to disseminate the
message of HIV/AIDS. Significantly only 80 respondents say that they heard the
information on HIV/AIDS from the health workers, which should be the most prior
source of information.
Source of information**
Media Number Percentage (%)
Radio 47 6.5
Newspaper 6 .8
Billboard/Poster 23 3.1
TV 171 23.1
Friends 201 27.2
NGO Workers 208 28.2
Family 1 .1
Health Workers 80 10.8
Clients 1 .1
Others media 1 .1
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 24
TRANSMISSION OF HIV/AIDS
The impact of AIDS on women (especially the hotel & residence based high risk
group) is severe, particularly in areas of the world where heterosexual sex is the
dominant mode of HIV transmission. In this sub-continental, women are 30% more
likely to be HIV-positive than men2. The difference in infection levels between
women and men is even more pronounced among young people.
A very few respondents addressed that; HIV/AIDS may transmitted through mother
to child. This indicates their low level of perception about this issue. Moreover a
significant number of people were still in dark by thinking that, this may be
transmitted through taking food, sharing dress, handshaking or through mosquito
bites.
“Condom use is a easy way for safer sex practice” this message is known to most
of the participants. Total of 311 respondents responses positively about this issue.
A significant proportion of the respondents bore some misconception on
prevention.
2
2004 Report on Global AIDS Epidemic-UNAIDS
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 25
Poor knowledge levels are reflected in the lack of concern the sex workers feel
about becoming infected themselves by the HIV/AIDS. Only 16.2% of sex workers
that they worried “a lot” about getting AIDS, and almost ¾th of the respondents
(234 persons) reported not being worried at all.
250 234
200
150
100
53
30 19
50 3
0
Very low Moderately low Low High Very high
The above graph shows that, most of the respondents feel that, HIV in a very low
risk to transmits them. Only 3 of them identified themselves as a high risk
community. Aware is very much and also immediately required to change the
perception of their existing knowledge.
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 26
298 out of 343 respondent says that, there is a high possibility of HIV transmission
if any one doesn’t use the condom properly during intercourse. But this is all they
know. Still some of them don’t know about the transmission through sharing
needles and syringes.
Only 21 respondent says that, they always take physicians suggestions and that’s
4.3 percent of the total respondent.
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 27
Knowledge and health seeking behaviours for STIs was higher than for HIV, but was
still not ideal. 39.9% of SW’s don’t even go to a recognized physician though they
have got the STI symptoms. A huge percentage of them are used to take the local
treatment. And the most shocking information is that, 97.4% of the respondents
have the symptoms of STI. Too much menstruation, pains at abdomen, itching at
urinate and pains during intercourse are the most common symptoms found during
the interviews.
Symptoms of STD**
Symptoms Number
Itching with menstruation fluid 87
To much menstruation fluid 133
String with menstruation fluid 46
Ulceration in the vagina 15
Itching in the vagina 50
Ulceration or itching into vagina 24
Pain during menses 47
Pain at the abdomen 138
Itching at the urinate 147
Pain during intercourse 131
Pimple or ulcer in the anus 0
No symptoms now 21
Others 0
Most of the respondents say, they are not interested to afford the government
health services. In the last six-month, only 120 of them gone to Sadar health
complex for treatment but only one respondent say that the service provided by
the government are good.
Most interestingly, 65.9% of the respondents are not interested to make any
comments about the quality of government services. Only 35 percent of the total
surveyed population avail services from govt. But most of them are not satisfied
with the services provided from govt. level.
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 29
F HARASSMENTS/VIOLENCE/ABUSE
The following data represent that, 274 of the total respondent are harassed in the
last six-month which is 80 percent of the surveyed population.
Verbally Abused**
Abused Number Percentage (%)
Yes 274 80
No 69 20
Total 343 100
One of the important parts of the questionnaire is the status of violence against
the high-risk population women. All of the surveyed persons says that, they are
harassed at least in a single way (verbal or physical) by the police, rogue, clients
and other influential parties.
Tens of thousands of women and children are trafficked from Bangladesh each
year. One of the poorest countries in the world, poverty provides traffickers with
people who have no alternatives for survival. They trust the offers of work or
marriage abroad, which promise security but instead lead to slavery. The
defenselessness statuses of this trafficked woman make them more insecure to
talk and to deal with the practical life. As a result the hitchhikers take the floors
to dominate them. And thus the scope of harassment is created.
Category of individuals**
80% of the respondents say that they faced harassments in the last six-month.
Surprisingly, police is the major actor on this issue. Next to that, local goons and
the clients take the chance to harass the high-risk groups.
Harassed
Yes No Total
Target 1:Residence
75 18 93
Population Based
2:Hotel Based 199 51 250
Total 274 69 343
In general, 75 out of 93 residence based high-risk group and 199 out of 250 hotel
based high-risk group says that, the above-mentioned community harasses them.
They also say that, especially policy take the opportunity most of the time and
they compare the police community with the local goons as the local goons and
police have no basic differences in attitudes.
Baseline Report of RPDO Consortium 31
4 Recommendation
Conclusions
The study showed that the high-risk group in the target areas had a very few
knowledge of the existence, spread, diagnosis and even prevention and control of
HIV/AIDS. They, however, needed a vast support in terms of enhancing the process
of transforming this knowledge into practice or behavior and action. The study
showed that HIV/AIDS had devastating effects on individuals, families and
communities. It had led to death, in addition to affecting specific categories of
the population in different ways.
The misconceptions about the causes of HIV/AIDS are dying away, although people
still lack ways of telling for sure who is or is not HIV positive. They are mostly
unaware about the services from different parties including GO and NGOs. There is
need to sensitize this group of community for receiving the services and appeal to
them to make use of these services.
References: