Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Alache Fisho-Oridedi*
ABSTRACT: The doctrine of prohibition of interest payments – riba under Islamic law has had
significant effect on international transactions with Islamic law flavour. The applicability of this
prohibition to international contracts has been the source of much debate within the international
commercial community and across the various schools of Islamic law. The need for the structuring of
business transactions to adhere to the dictates of Islamic law while ensuring that the transaction
remains profitable and beneficial to the parties has led to the evolution of various transactional models
that are applied in the Islamic states. This study focuses on the concept of prohibition of riba in a bid to
understand its applicability in modern international business transactions. In conducting this research
I have adopted an analytical and historical approach and conclude that the concept of prohibition of
riba remains a current doctrine widely applied throughout the Muslim community albeit not uniformly.
Thus a good understanding of this concept is required by persons involved in transactions involving
Islamic law and the transaction must be structured to conform to the dictates of Islamic law in order to
make them legally enforceable.
_____________________
*The author is a Senior Legal Officer in the Commercial Law Department of the Nigerian National
Petroleum Corporation. A Barrister and Solicitor of the Supreme Court of Nigeria, she has a strong bias
for commercial contracting and legal project support in the Oil and Gas Industry. She is currently a
postgraduate student of CEPMLP University of Dundee, Scotland, where she is pursuing an LLM
Degree in Petroleum Law and Policy. E-Mail: alache.fisho-oridedi@nnpcgroup.com
TABLE OF CONTENT
Page
1. INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………….3
4.3.1 Mudaraba......................................................................................16
4.3.2 Muradabah....................................................................................16
4.3.3 Musharaka....................................................................................17
5. CONCLUSION...................................................................................................17
BIBLIOGRAPHY
2
1. INTRODUCTION
contractual relations flowing from these transactions often give rise to peculiar
transactional practices and norms in the various jurisdictions in which the different
rights and obligations of a contractual relationship exist. These norms and practices
range from those attributable to the juristic doctrines of the different schools of
Historically, trade in the largely Muslim Persian Gulf flourished primarily amongst
adherents of the faith who by virtue of a common belief system, generally enjoyed
prevailing Islamic law. However the discovery of natural resources in the region led
to an explosion of international trade and commerce with the attendant dilution of the
the region were often in a superior commercial position having the investment funds
as well as the technical know-how for the transactions. Thus these investors dictated
the terms of the transaction and determined the governing law of such contracts which
Following an era of economic nationalism in the early 1960s, many of the states in the
Persian Gulf in a bid to assert control over their natural resources and harness the
interests and there was a shift in the transactional dynamics as the states gained the
3
advantage position. Coinciding with this era was a resurgence of Islamic thinking and
a global rebirth of the Islamic system.1 Many Islamic states began to insist on the
application of the Sharia’a in their regions and sought the conformity of all commercial
transactions both domestic and international with the dictates of Islamic law.
which is translated as interest, undue profits or excessive gain from a transaction. The
international contracts concluded under Islamic law. While its effect is sometimes felt
in contracts for the sale of goods particularly where there is delay in the payment for
the capital lent to the customer would be repaid plus interest at a rate agreed
money and the value of the service of lending. This type of transaction is prohibited as
riba under Islamic law and consequently transactions so financed may be declared
While usury is regarded negatively in most parts of the world, what is typically
frowned upon is excessive interest charges and not the payment of interest as a whole.
Under Islamic law however, the payment and receipt of interest –riba- is strictly
injustice and therefore inconsistent with Islamic concepts of fairness and justice.
1
Sharawy, H., Understanding the Islamic Prohibition of Interest: A Guide to Aid Economic
Cooperation between The Islamic and Western Worlds, 29 Ga. J. Int’l & Comp. L. 153 2000-2001
4
communities, the scope of its application within financial transactions is not as easily
defined. The question become not really the prohibition of riba, but what qualifies as
riba and how does its prohibition affect international trade in Islamic states?
The paper commences with an overview of the Islamic legal system and examines the
The paper adopts a historical and analytic approach in addressing the issues raised and
concludes that the prohibition of riba has far reaching effect on contractual
relationships entered into in Islamic law states and it must be carefully considered by
Islamic law also known as Sharia’a is regarded by its adherents as a divinely ordained
system of law which has roots in the pre-Islamic customary laws and norms of the
Arabs of the Persian Gulf states.2 Islamic law is derived primarily from the Quran
which is the holy book of Islam and the sayings and practices of Prophet Mohammed.
Most Muslim scholars agree on the general classification of the sources of Islamic law
into primary sources which consist of the revealed sources and secondary sources
which are the unrevealed sources. It is worthy to note that the sources of Islamic law
2
See further Khadduri, M., Nature and Sources of Islamic Law, 22 Geo. Wash. L. Rev. 3 1953-1954
5
are hierarchical in nature with the Quran resting unchallenged at the pinnacle.3 The
main sources of Islamic law and a selection of the other secondary sources are
described below.
The Quran
The Quran is the first and most important of the sources of Islamic law. It is
considered to be the direct words of God revealed to and transmitted by the Prophet
“To Muslims, the Quran being the very word of God, it is the absolute authority from
which springs the very conception of legality and every legal obligation.”
As the highest source of Islamic law, all other sources must conform to the Qur'an.
Indeed the other sources only become tenable in situations where the Quran does not
Sunnah:
These are also referred to as hadiths and are the traditions or known practices of the
Prophet Muhammad. This source includes many things that he said, did, or agreed to.
matters which were reduced into writing for future reference. Many issues concerning
personal conduct, community and family relations, political matters, etc. were
3
Also See Khan, K., Juristic Classification of Islamic Law, 6 Hous. J. Int’l L. 23 1983-1984
6
addressed during the time of the Prophet, decided by him, and recorded. The Sunnah
Qiya
In cases when something needs a legal ruling, but has not been clearly addressed in
the Quran or Sunnah, judges may use analogy, deduction and legal precedent to
decide new case law. Quite obviously, the application of reasoning and deduction in a
case often leads to the adoption of accepted principles established in earlier cases.
This source has been compared with the Common law doctrine of judicial
precedence.4
Ijma
situations when a specific authority on the issue is absent in the Qur'an or Sunnah.
Ijma is developed from diverse opinions of jurists based on the Quran and/or Sunnahs
which over time consolidate into a consensus on the issue under consideration.
Ibrahim in his paper states that once a consensus has been established it becomes a
4
Ibid
5
Ibrahim, A., The Rise of Customary Businesses in International Financial Markets: An Introduction
to Islamic Finance and The Challenges of International Integration, 23 Am. U. Int’l L. Rev. 661 2007
– 2008, p. 679
6
Hassan, F., The Sources of Islamic Law, 76 Am. Soc’y Int’l L. Proc. 65 1982, p. 67
7
2.1.3 Other Sources:
There are other sources of Islamic law whose classification lack universal acceptance
amongst the various schools of Islamic jurisprudence. They are often based on the
discretion of the judge and application of principles of equity, justice, fair-play and
morality and so are open to interpretation. Since these are subjective terms, it goes
without saying that the application will differ based on the personal bias of each
individual judge. Perhaps this is the reason for the non-acceptance of some of these
personal choice of a judge to achieve justice [equity]; istislah - the desire to reach a
good or beneficial result and avoid a harsh judgement and istidlal and istishab which
differences in interpretation of the dictates of the Quran and this led to the
over 50 of such schools, but currently the two main sects of Muslim jurisprudence are
the Sunni and the Shiite sects which are each subdivided into four schools of Islamic
thought. 8 The four Sunni schools are the Hanafi, Shafi’i, Maliki and Hanbali while
the four Shiite schools are the Ibadi, Zaydi, Ithna and Imami. These schools were
named after eminent Muslim scholars who evolved peculiar theories of legal
7
Ibid, at p. 68
8
Childress, C., Saudi-Arabian Contract Law: A Comparative Perspective, 2 St. Thom. L. F. 69 1990, p
74.
8
The Majority of the Muslims around the world are Sunnis [prevalent in Saudi Arabia,
U.A.E., North Africa, Turkey and Central Asia) while about 10-15% are Shiites [Iran,
Iraq, Central and South Asia).9 While the two sects share many common beliefs such
as the supremacy of the Quran and adherence to the five pillars of Islam, there are
acceptability of some of the Sunnahs and the application of the doctrine of riba.
It is specifically stated in an early revelation in the Quran that “God hath permitted
trade and forbidden usury.”10 This restriction is anchored on the principle that the
[forbidden] in Islam to accumulate wealth that is not a product of work. Thus wealth
that is generated from the payment of interest qualifies as haram and is expressly
targeted at such areas as family, inheritance and criminal law,12 the applicability of
9
See Blanchard, C., Islam: Sunnis and Shiites, Congressional Research Service, Jan. 2009, available at
http://www.fas.org/irp/crs/RS21745.pdf [last visited 13th July 2009).
10
the Quran, 274
11
Quran 4:161.
12
Childress, C., supra note 8.
9
3.1 Overview of Islamic Law of Contract
Two fundamental principles of Islamic law of contract are the concepts of riba and
The word riba is derived from the Arabic verb raba which means to increase, grow or
rise above.13 Although riba generally refers to usury, some Muslim scholars have
given it a much wider scope to cover any increase in wealth and/or income that results
The literal translation of ghahar is fraud but the conceptual translation usually refers
to risk, uncertainty or hazard.15 The prohibition of ghahar stems from the Quranic
prohibition of games of chance and therefore under Islamic law, transactions having
an element of speculation are frowned upon. In practice, contractual relations that fail
to clearly define the existence and availability of the object and the consideration of
prohibited.16
This is one of the most significant principles in Islamic finance and thus is key to the
13
Shihata, I., Some Observations on the Question of Riba and the Challenges Facing ‘Islamic
Banking’, 5 Y.B. Int’l Fin. & Econ. L. 23 2000-2001, p.25
14
Ibid
15
Kamali, M., Islamic Commercial Law; An Anlysis of Futures and Options, (Islamic Texts Society;
Cambridge, England, 2000), pp 84 – 97.
16
Hassan, K. & Lewis, M., Handbook of Islamic Banking, (Cheltenham, UK: Edward Edgar
Publishing Limited, 2007).
10
prohibition of riba has universal application across the different schools of Islamic
jurisprudence and has remained relevant in current day. However, the interpretation of
Under Islamic law, a sale is described as “the exchange of a thing of value by another
thing of value with mutual consent.”17 Certain conditions precedent are inherent in a
contract for the sale of goods: the goods must be in existence at the time of sale; the
seller must have ownership of the goods as well as physical possession, the sale must
be instant and not deferred to a future day, delivery and price must be certain and the
The terms and conditions of the sale must be compliant with the above and a seller
must state clearly the cost of production of the goods and the profit margin he is
adding on to the cost in order to ensure that the contract does not contravene the
entering into a contract tainted by Riba is that such a contract will not be enforced by a
court. An application of equitable remedies by the court may result in the parties being
Islamic law prohibits the payment of interest on loans obtained by a borrower from a
lender on the grounds that such interest payments are forbidden as riba in the Quran.
17
Usmani, M., An Introduction to Islamic Finance, [The Hague: Kluwer Law International, 2002), p.
38.
18
Sloane, P., The Status of Islamic Law in the Modern Commercial World, 22 Int’l L. 743 1988
11
The argument put forward by jurists is that the pre-determined interest charged by a
lender represents a gain that is risk-free and not attributable to any work or risk on the
part of the lender. A loan of currency is recognised under Islamic law and referred to
as qard and interest payments on such a loan may be permissible if it is proven that
such interest payments were made willingly by the borrower and were not a condition
of the qard. 19
it appears that the original concept for the prohibition of riba was based on the
modern transactions however, loans are used as working capital and money to make
more money. It appears therefore that it does no moral injustice for a lender to be able
to receive uplift or a return on his money in view of the concept of time value of
Some Islamic countries have accepted the inclusion of some interest payments in
commercial transactions in their jurisdiction while others strictly prohibit same. In the
transactions is legal. In Iran however, such transaction will be illegal and void on the
basis of the prohibition of riba.20It is interesting to note that this illegality does not
extend to banking operations outside Iran as it appears that Iranian banks do receive
19
Saleh, N., Unlawful Gain and Legitimate Profit in Islamic Law, (Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, 1986), p. 44
20
Ansari-pour, M., Interest in International Transactions Under Shiite Jurisprudence, 9 Arab L. Q.
1994, p. 158.
12
and pay interest on foreign transactions.21 Banks also pay interest inside Iran. The
Does the prohibition of riba apply to transactions between Muslims and non-
Muslims? The general rule under Islamic law is that where the transaction is
conducted within an Islamic state, riba will be prohibited. However as to the question
where the transaction is conducted outwith the Muslim state, the Hanbali school is of
the opinion that riba within this transaction will not be prohibited. The other schools
hold different view on this.22One of the views is based on the principle that property
of non-Muslims is not protected under Islamic law and therefore it would not amount
parties.
The prohibition of interest payment has been settled firmly in Islamic law as the
various schools agree on the fundamental principle that the payment of interest is
arrangements have evolved over the years that while remaining in conformity with the
dictates of Islamic law, ensure that an investor in a transaction earns some return on
his capital invested in that transaction. This has resulted in the emergence of Islamic
banking as a niche service provider and Islamic project finance, a method of financing
21
Ibid, p.159
22
Saleh, N., Unlawful Gain and Legitimate Profit in Islamic Law, (New York: Cambridge University
Press, 1986)
13
a project that applies the returns from the project to the repayment of loans structured
for the carrying out of the project. In this section, we will examine some of the more
The concept of Islamic banking which was birthed in the last 30 years has evolved to
concerned with the development and promotion banking products tailor-made for the
Islamic society which conform to Islamic principles, law and traditions while
banking.
Since wealth accumulated without work is classified as haram, one may simplistically
bank. However, Islamic law fundamentally recognises the principle of shared risk as
work entitling a financial institution to an addition on the principal sum that was
“an Islamic bank should share in the risk with the entrepreneur...Islamic
banking implies zero rate of interest but not zero rate of return...”24
The first truly Islamic bank was established in Mit Ghamr, Egypt in 1963. Currently
there are about 200 Islamic banks operating in over 70 countries which include
23
See Sharawy, H., Understanding the Islamic Prohibition of Interest, 2 Ga. J. Int’l & Comp. L. 153
2000 – 2001, p. 166
24
Siddiqui, S.H., Islamic Banking: Genesis & Rationale, Evaluation & Review, Prospects and
Challenges (Karachi, Pakistan : Royal Book Co., 1994), p. 49.
14
Muslim and non-Muslim countries with a portfolio of over USD200billion.25 In
Pakistan, Sudan and Iran for example, there has been a national transition of the
1983, a new banking law was enacted in Iran that enforced the complete abolition of
interest by March 1985 In Iran it was only in the shape of changing names. In Sudan,
by a directive of the Central Bank issued in December 1984, all commercial banks
were required to stop dealing with interest and to negotiate the conversion of existing
Foreign transactions were to continue on the basis of interest until an alternative way
became available.26
evolution of Islamic project finance. The term project finance refers to a model of
financing in which debt and equity plus a level of credit enhancement are combined
for the development of a capital intensive project and the repayment of the loan is
made primarily from the project revenue. 27 In conventional western style banking, the
terms of the loan agreement will inevitably include payment of interest on the capital
Since Islamic law prohibits the payment of interest, Islamic banks have developed
different financial products that achieve the aims of project finance without
25
Islamic Institute of Islamic Banking and Insurance, The Islamic Banking System, Status of Islamic
Banking Today (2003), www.islamic-banking.com (last visited 28th July, 2009).
26
Rachagan, A., Islamic Banking in Malaysia, JIBRL 88
27
Hoffman, S., The Law and Business of International Project Finance, (2nd Edition), (New York,
U.S.A.: Transnational Publishers Incorporated, 2001), p. 6
15
contravening the dictates of Islamic law. Some of the more popular of these products
4.3.1 Mudaraba
This is a form of trust financing where the bank acting as investor, provides all or
most of the funds required for the facilitation of a project and the entrepreneur
provides as his share of the risk allocation the expertise and technical know-how for
the facilitation of the project. Profits derived from the revenues of the investment are
split between the bank as investor and the entrepreneur in a predetermined ratio which
may involve decreasing participation by the bank as the capital sum is recovered.
Where there is no profit, the bank loses its capital investment and the entrepreneur
This model was used in Saudi Arabia by the Islamic Development Bank for the
4.3.2 Murabadah
This is often referred to as cost-plus financing. In this model, the lending bank
purchases the product which the borrower requires and resells such products to the
interested party at cost plus a mark-up. The bank must clearly state in the loan
documents what its cost was and the mark-up applied on the price in other to ensure
that the transaction is in conformity with the dictates of the law. This form of
financing is usually employed for short-term facilities with tenors of between one to
28
Seniawski, B., Riba Today: Social Equity, the Economy and doing Business Under Islamic Law, 39
Colum. J. Transnat’l L. 701 2000-2001, p.722.
29
Ibid
16
five years and was used in Algeria for the financing of gas turbine engines for a power
plant project.30
4.3.3 Musharaka
the traditional joint venture structure where partners to a project have joint
investment, decision making and profit sharing rights. The lender bank therefore
becomes a partner to the transaction and is therefore entitled to a share of the profits
received by the project. The Saudi British Bank in 1997 structured a US$72 million
musharaka facility for a group in Saudi Arabia and the funds were used for the
5 Conclusion
inevitable that challenges arising from the application of the prohibition of riba will
arise particularly when one of the parties is a subject of Islamic law jurisdiction.
When one considers that the Persian Gulf holds about 75% of the entire crude oil
reserves in the world, it is clear that international trade will continue to grow in the
region in the future. This means therefore that an understanding of the transactional
30
See Bilal, G., Islamic Finance: Alternatives to the Western Model, 23 Fletcher F. World Aff. 145,
158 (1999).
31
Supra note 25, p.724
17
The prohibition of riba under Islamic law is probably the most important principle of
commercial transaction under Islamic law. The management of the application of this
principle in international transactions is very important and has led the financial
community in Islamic law states to develop products that though in practical terms
operate and have the same effect as interest charges in conventional style banking, are
structured in such a way that they do not run afoul of the dictates of Islamic law.
Investors in Islamic states must of necessity have a grasp of the concept and
transactions must be structured to conform to the dictates of Islamic law as applicable in the
different jurisdictions as regards the prohibition of riba. Also in the personal opinion of the
writer, perhaps Islamic law jurists should open the arena of discourse on the need for a
distinction between interest payments on personal loans and interest charges on loans
18
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS
Hallaq, W., The Origins and Evolution of Islamic Law, (Cambridge: Cambridge
Hassan, K. & Lewis, M., Handbook of Islamic Banking, (Cheltenham, UK: Edward
Iqbal, M. & Llewellyn, D., New Perspectives on Profit Sharing and Risk,
Saleh, N., Unlawful Gain and Legitimate Profit in Islamic Law, (Cambridge:
International, 2002)
Siddiqui, S.H., Islamic Banking: Genesis & Rationale, Evaluation & Review,
Prospects and Challenges (Karachi, Pakistan : Royal Book Co., 1994), p. 49.
ARTICLES
Bilal, G., Islamic Finance: Alternatives to the Western Model, 23 Fletcher F. World
Aff. 145, 158 (1999)
19
Childress, C., Saudi-Arabian Contract Law: A Comparative Perspective, 2 St. Thom.
L. F. 69 1990
Hassan, F., The Sources of Islamic Law, 76 Am. Soc’y Int’l L. Proc. 65 1982
Khadduri, M., Nature and Sources of Islamic Law, 22 Geo. Wash. L. Rev. 3 1953-
1954
Seniawski, B., Riba Today: Social Equity, the Economy and doing Business under
Islamic Law, 39 Colum. J. Transnat’l L. 701 2000-2001
Shihata, I., Some Observations on the Question of Riba and the Challenges Facing
‘Islamic Banking’, 5 Y.B. Int’l Fin. & Econ. L. 23 2000-2001, p.25
Sloane, P., The Status of Islamic Law in the Modern Commercial World, 22 Int’l L.
743 1988
INTERNET SOURCES
Blanchard, C., Islam: Sunnis and Shiites, Congressional Research Service, Jan. 2009,
available at http://www.fas.org/irp/crs/RS21745.pdf [last visited 13th July 2009)
Islamic Institute of Islamic Banking and Insurance, The Islamic Banking System,
Status of Islamic Banking Today (2003), www.islamic-banking.com (last visited 28th
July, 2009)
20