Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
system planning
L. Michi, G. Donnini, C. Giordano, F. M. Pompili, S. Lauria, L. Calcara A. L’Abbate
Scavo, E.G. Luciano, B. Aluisio, Ch. Astronautic, Energetic and Electrical Energy Systems Development Dept.
Vergine Engineering Department Ricerca sul Sistema Energetico (RSE)
Dept. of Grid Planning and University of Rome “La Sapienza”, S.p.A.
Interconnection Rome, Italy Milan, Italy
Terna S.p.A. luigi.calcara@uniroma1.it angelo.labbate@rse-web.it
Rome, Italy
chiara.giordano@terna.it
Abstract — High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) technology parallel, also classic line-commutated CSC (Current Source
will play a more central role in the future grid development Converter)-HVDC technologies are expected to be further
than it had in the past due to the technological developments, applied in Europe.
the increasing use of renewable energy resources and the more
ambitious European goals. These evolutions introduce new Given this background, after recalling the key benefits of
challenges in power transmission planning and have an impact HVDC, the present paper provides an updated review related
on the choices of technology and the geographical location of to the HVDC evolution and developments that have been
interconnection projects. This paper will give a brief undergone by European Transmission System Operators
introduction on the benefits that HVDC can provide to the (TSOs) in the latest years. Considering the transmission
power system, focusing on their penetration in the European expansion plans of ENTSO-E (European Network of
system, before dealing with a more detailed description of key Transmission System Operators for Electricity) [7][27],
HVDC projects in the Italian network. particular attention has been paid to describe the key HVDC
projects in the Italian system.
Keywords — HVDC, interconnection, Pan-European power
system, transmission planning The paper is organised as in the following. Section II recalls
the main features of HVDC technologies. Section III deals
I. INTRODUCTION with the environmental impact of these systems. Section IV
Meeting the energy and climate policy targets set by the shows evolution and aspects for HVDC use. Moreover,
European Union for 2030 and beyond will pose several Section V reviews projects across the European system and
challenges towards the development of the European power the Italian network. Finally, Section VI draws concluding
system. Concerning the European transmission grid, the remarks and sets future outlooks.
critical goal will consist in the optimal network integration of II. KEY HVDC FEATURES
massive amounts of electricity production from variable
renewable energy sources (RES), especially wind and solar. The first HVDC installations date back to 50ies; nowadays,
This has to be framed towards the realization of the Energy HVDC is a widespread and worldwide used transmission
Union, while maintaining adequate levels of system technology, counting on a long operational experience. In
reliability, in a liberalized context [1]-[4]. To handle these fact, this technology exhibits characteristics that have already
issues, the traditional approach, based on the realization of made it attractive and preferred over HVAC transmission for
new High Voltage Alternating Current (HVAC) transmission selected applications, such as i) very long distance lines,
assets, may not be sufficient any longer, also given economic especially for bulk power transport, ii) longer submarine
and socio-environmental constraints faced by overhead lines cable links, and iii) interconnections of asynchronous
(OHLs) infrastructures. Also, the need to increase system systems (in full or back-to-back scheme) [11]-[13].
flexibility has to be highlighted. Outside Europe, a large, rapid boost of HVDC development
In this context, among various potential measures and and penetration is being experienced in the latest years in
available technologies, a key role may be played by advanced several countries, especially in China and India [6][10]. The
High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) transmission devices. most impressive evolution of this technology concerns the
Because of their features, these technologies are already ongoing development of Ultra High Voltage Direct Current
widely used and preferred over HVAC for selected (UHVDC) overhead corridors at levels of ±800 kV and
applications. ±1100 kV voltage range for tie lengths spanning 2000 to
4000 km and transporting 6.4 to 12 GW power.
Furthermore, HVDC assets may provide the system with
environmental benefits with respect to conventional HVAC Thanks to its speed and flexibility, the HVDC technology
transmission technologies. The ongoing progress and fast can provide the transmission system with different benefits
developments in power electronics, on top of the traditional such as: transfer capacity enhancement, power flow control,
characteristics of HVDC, may impact to further extend the transient stability improvement, power oscillation damping,
typologies of HVDC applications in the European system. voltage stability and control, rejection of cascading
disturbances, absence of reactive power.
This trend makes HVDC emerge as boosting technology in a
mid-to-long term horizon in Europe: this concerns especially The ongoing progress and fast developments in power
the most advanced self-commutated VSC (Voltage Source electronics, coupled with HVDC traditional features, may
Converter)-HVDC systems due to their characteristics [5]; in lead to further deploy this technology to improve operation
The situation of the Sardinian power system is very In addition to the RES integration and the improvement of
particular. A high percentage of load is supplied by old the system’s flexibility, the use of HVDC technology can
thermal power plants which have big capacity, some of them also increase the exchange capacity between congested zones
are coal power plants that should be dismantled in agreement and with the foreign countries, guaranteeing the integration
with the Italian National Energy & Climate Plan (NECP), of European markets and the energy transition.
sent to the European Commission in January 2019, which An application of these goals is the project “HVDC
confirms the coal phase out by 2025 [29]. The past and Villanova-Fano” between Centre-North (IT_CN) and Centre-
future integration of very large amounts of variable RES, South (IT_CS) sections. This is a critical area for
especially wind and solar, into the power system, decreases bottlenecks, so the new HVDC will transport the energy
its flexibility and the reliability. To face the huge produced by RES from the South Italy to the North, where
commissioning of RES plants in this region, in 2011 the the load is higher. As consequence, this project results to be
SA.PE.I. cable, i.e. the interconnection from Fiumesanto important to solve congestions across Italian market areas
station (Sardinia region) to Latina station (Lazio region), was and to decrease the price differentials between Italian market
commissioned, improving the stability of the Sardinian zones IT_CN and IT_CS.
power grid. It is based on a CSC-HVDC with nominal
voltage ±500 kV and 1000 MW of capacity. Moreover, Fig. 6 shows also planned interconnection
projects, which will guarantee the increase of exchanging
The current Sardinia-Corsica-Continent link, named energy volumes at more competitive prices. This makes
SA.CO.I. 2, has been completed in 1992. In particular, the possible to increment the competition in energy markets and
cables terminals have been substituted and the two new the available power for the safe operation of the electrical
stations in Codrongianos (Sardinia) and Suvereto (Tuscany) system.
have been realized. However, it has now reached the end of Detailing the planned projects on the northern border, there
its useful life. The final loss of this connection would result are three interconnection projects with France, Switzerland
in: and Slovenia. Currently, as introduced in Section IV, only
• the lack of maintaining adequate levels of reliability in the Savoie - Pièmont link (between Piossasco, Italy, and
Sardinia; Grand’Ile, France) is under construction.
• the loss of connection between the Centre-North area of
Italy and Sardinia, with a reduction in transport capacity This is a modern example of synergy between highway
between these market areas; infrastructures and electric energy ones. With its route of
• a deficit in the supply of the forecasted Corsican demand. about 190 km, mainly installed along highway roads and
viaducts (inside in the Frejus Gallery), it could represent a [8] S. Rüberg, H. Ferreira, A. L'Abbate, U. Häger, G. Fulli, Y. Li, J.
Schwippe, "Improving network controllability by Flexible Alternating
reference for the installation of future underground
Current Transmission Systems (FACTS) and by High Voltage Direct
transmission lines, also considering its almost null territory Current (HVDC) transmission systems", REALISEGRID Deliverable
impact. D1.2.1, Mar. 2010. http://realisegrid.rse-web.it
[9] Inelfe project http://www.inelfe.eu
These aspects could also play a key role in the reinforcement [10] S. Rüberg, A. Purvins, "Comparison of AC and DC technologies for
projects for already developed transmission grids which need long-distance interconnections", REALISEGRID Deliverable D1.3.3,
new energy corridors but have to face many territory Mar. 2010. http://realisegrid.rse-web.it
[11] ABB HVDC http://www.abb.com/hvdc
constraints as well. [12] Siemens HVDC http://www.energy.siemens.com/nl/en/power-
This HVDC link also boasts another important feature: it is transmission/hvdc/
constituted of two independent multilevel VSC-HVDC [13] General Electric HVDC (formerly Alstom Grid HVDC)
systems with overall rated power equal to 1200 MW (see https://www.gegridsolutions.com/PowerD/catalog/HVDC.htm
[14] L.A. Koshcheev, "Environmental Characteristics of HVDC Overhead
Fig. 7) [32]. Transmission Lines", Third Workshop on Power Grid Interconnection
in Northeast Asia, Vladivostok, Russia, Sep. 30 –Oct. 3, 2003.
[15] A.L. Figueroa-Acevedo, M.S. Czahor, D.E. Jahn, "A comparison of
the technological, economic, public policy, and environmental factors
of HVDC and HVAC interregional transmission", AIMS Energy, Feb.
2015.
[16] ICNIRP, "Guidelines on limits of exposure to static magnetic fields",
Health Phys 96(4), pp. 504–514, 2009.
[17] CIGRE, "Electric Field and Ion Current Environment of HVDC
Overhead Transmission Lines", Joint Working Group B4/C3/B2.50,
2011.
[18] Arc Math, High Voltage Direct Current.
http://envirostudies.net/development/hvdc/
Fig. 7. Layer of Piossasco -Grand’lle HVDC project [19] Europacable, "An Introduction to High Voltage Direct Current
(HVDC) Underground Cables", 2011.
With the exception of the interconnection projects in the [20] M. Salimi, "Prospects for Compaction of HVDC Transmission Lines",
north of the peninsula previously recalled, all planned CIGRE-IEC Colloquium, 2016.
HVDC systems are for subsea cable links. This depends on [21] C. Humpert, "Long Distance Transmission Systems for the Future
Electricity Supply – Analysis of Possibilities and Restrictions",
the connection capacity but also on the link length and on the Energy, Vol. 48, pp.278–283, 2012.
seawater depth. [22] J.C. Molburg, J.A. Kavicky, K.C. Picel, "The design, construction and
operation of long-distance high-voltage electricity transmission
Among these projects, as introduced in Section IV, the only technologies", Argonne National Laboratory, Nov.2007.
one under construction is the “MonIta” interconnection [23] S.J. Sutton, P.L. Lewin, S.G. Swingler, "Review of global HVDC
(phase 1, 600 MW), between the centre of Italy and subsea cable projects and the application of sea electrodes",
Montenegro. The project MonIta concerns a link at 500 kV International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Systems, Vol. 87,
pp. 121-135, 2017.
DC voltage level, with a rated power of 1200 MW in bipolar [24] M. Ostojić, M. Ćalasan, "Magnetic field of the bipolar HVDC cable
configuration, equipped also with marine electrodes and Italy-Montenegro in the sea and in the land section", CIGRE SEERC
being built with CSC technology thyristors [33]. Conference, Portoroz, Slovenia, Jun. 7-8, 2016.
[25] F. Muzi, L. Calcara, S. Sangiovanni, M. Pompili, "Smart Energy
VI. CONCLUSION Management of a Prosumer for a Better Environment Safeguard",
This paper provides an overview of main aspects that have 2018 AEIT International Annual Conference, Bari, Italy, Oct. 3-5,
2018.
contributed to the choice of HVDC with respect to HVAC [26] F. Muzi, L. Calcara, M. Pompili, S. Sangiovanni, "The New Prosumer
technology. In particular, these characteristics have been Tasks in the Energy Management of Buildings", Proceedings of 2018
dealt with under different points of view, among which IEEE International Conference on Environment and Electrical
technical and environmental aspects. Given the pro and cons Engineering and 2018 IEEE Industrial and Commercial Power
of HVDC use, the main applications have been presented, Systems Europe, 2018.
[27] ENTSO-E, "Ten-Year Network Development Plan (TYNDP) 2018",
considering the different historical periods and the reasons 2018. https://tyndp.entsoe.eu
behind the choices. Finally, in planning framework, the main [28] C. Vergine, F. Vedovelli, M. Rebolini, A. L'Abbate, "Updates on
European and Italian projects were detailed, highlighting the HVDC penetration in the European power system: goals and
technologies used and the issues that they propose to solve. applications by TSOs", 2018 AEIT International Annual Conference,
Bari, Italy, Oct. 3-5, 2018.
REFERENCES [29] European Union, National Energy and Climate Plans
https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/energy-strategy-and-energy-
[1] European Commission, European Energy Union, 2015. union/governance-energy-union/national-energy-climate-plans
http://ec.europa.eu/priorities/energy-union/index_en.htm [30] Terna, "Piano di Sviluppo 2019", 2019. http://www.terna.it/it-
[2] European Commission, "Energy infrastructure priorities for 2020 and it/sistemaelettrico/pianodisviluppodellarete/pianidisviluppo.aspx
beyond - A Blueprint for an integrated European energy network", [31] F. Vedovelli, C. Vergine, C. Giordano, "2018 Pan-European
COM(2010) 677 final, Nov. 2010. coordinated TSO planning", 2018 AEIT International Annual
[3] European Commission, "Long term infrastructure vision for Europe Conference, Bari, Italy, Oct. 3-5, 2018.
and beyond", COM(2013) 711 final, Oct. 2013. [32] R. Benato, A. Chiarelli, S. Dambone Sessa, R.D. Zan, M. Rebolini, M.
[4] European Union Council, "Conclusions on 2030 Climate and Energy Pazienza, "HVDC Cables Along with Highway Infrastructures: the
Policy Framework", Oct. 23-24, 2014. “Piedmont-Savoy” Italy-France Intertie", 2018 AEIT International
[5] J. Arrillaga, Y.H. Liu, N.R. Watson, "Flexible Power Transmission: Annual Conference, Bari, Italy, Oct. 3-5, 2018.
The HVDC Options", J. Wiley & Sons Ltd., 2007. [33] S. Barsali, P. Pelacchi, D. Poli, F. Bassi, G. Bruno, R. Gnudi, "HVDC
[6] M. Rebolini, "CIGRE Atlas of HVDC Systems with Italian TSO technology overview and new European network codes requirements,"
Experience", HVDC International Workshop, Venice, Italy, Mar. 28- 2017 AEIT International Annual Conference, Cagliari, Italy, Sep. 20-
30, 2017. 22, 2017.
[7] ENTSO-E, "Ten-Year Network Development Plan (TYNDP) 2016",
2016. https://www.entsoe.eu