Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
com
-....
Lou;j,JAa ........ ~ (Im-«tI~ " " )
'-fruiI"'c.dwrirwl _ _ eo-d~<t_
by appointment
1600 Arch Street· Suite 1603' Philadelphia, VA 19103' 215-587..a000
www.PortraitMiniatures.com
SOUREN MELIKIAN
The November Impressionist and modern sales
45 pointed to a shift in aesthetic pre ferences.
MARKETFILE
73 Artist Dossier: Emile-Jacques Ruhlmann
77 Jori Finkel
78 Auction Reviews
88 Databank
PLEASE VISIT US AT
THE AMERICAN INTER:\ATlONAL FI:\E ART FAIR
PALM BEACH, FEBRUARY 3"8, 20lQ
BOOTH # 302
...•
,,
Ca rn elia G.,cia
EDITOR IA L ASS ISTANT EUROP E
Elizabelh Ung ar Robed Logan
COPY ED I TOR
SA LES RE PRESENT A TlVE. EUROPE
,. , .44 2085794836 r' <'44 208579 5057
LT 8 " OLOI.O .••• ,.' CO~.. N'
Lou ise Bt oui n
,'" ~.o 0, o~ . " I O~' " .CO ."' CIlA I R~AN & CEO
L.uraR ie ra Maria Be'MI Gi~ica
AR T DIRE CTO R
SA LES OIRE CTOR. AUSTRIA . GE RMA NY.
David .... Ie'a nder Arnold GE R~AN - SPEA~ I NG SW ITZERLAND , 601 Wes t 26t h St reet. Suit e 410
PIlOTO EDITOR SP ~ I N
New Yo rk. NY 10001
,.,.4930787 ,7256 " < '49 303462 ' 536
Mafia Fa u<l.lvana Mo'gan mb.,o. ' •• ,tooIMom tet +12124479555
IN TE R N S f ax + 1212 6 27 8 6 03
ART+
J ean Ruffi n
S"-LES REPRESE N T A TIVE , a r ia nda uci i onm ag@a rt inf o.com
rRAN CE, BENElUX,
FRENC Il- SPE AK ING SW IT ZER L AND
,., ' J3 '~ 006 03 10 1,, '33 I~ 006 0392 To subscri be,call + 1800 777 8718
j . . o" u'hnOw. ,.dQo-', in Nor th or South Amer ica
AUCTION
Romi na Provenzi or +1954 653 39890u tside
SALES D IREC TO R. UK , I T A L Y, GREEC E t he Americ as: or go online at
,."U 20 79859616 I., .4410 79959670
rprovo01 iO. rt iofo.(om
www.artinfo.com/su bscriptions.
An nual subscri ption ra tes'
InM Ka nooni ko.a S80 in t he U.s"
S"-LES OIRECTO R, CIl INA, RUSS I"- S100 in Ca nada (GST includ ed),
1. 1'86 ' 0 64 ' 75338 I.> .8610 8257 7038
i ' .no"ol .o ~ ••• "'o'MO'"
S1200utside the U.S. and Canada,
S;;'leym8n Okan
SA LES OIRECTOR. TURK EY, For su bscri ption inquiries,
CONTRIBU TING EDITORS MIDOLE E,,-ST address changes and general
.... nn E. Be ,man, EHog al e Blauer , " " 905367052"
Margare t B Caldwetl. Chlrles Danz iger, .o .. oO.",ofo.eo m customer serv ice. e-mail us at
Thoma s C, D. nZl ger. Dav id D' Arc y. ara@the mags t ore.com.
Abilla il R. [ ,man , Jo, i Finkel. For cuslom repr ints.
CM ~ Gree nberg, Judith Gur~,
cal l +1877 652 5295.or go onli ne
Christine Schwa,lz Har He y.
Simon He wiH .A nne Ho rton, a I www .wrighlsrep rinl s.com.
Clin Ion R. Howell. P. ul J e'omack.
Jonalho n Keats, Car olK ino,
""""'.. I~"' '''O''''1O'I') ._ ... _''''.''.
Lee Mindel. Susan Moore.
,'_...,,_""
............'."'.V.......... "',."" ...,'lC,'"""....'''''.
t'
""-~---"' ...--,,-'''''''
Amy P.ge . J u n Bo nd Rafferty . NV"""'.C_'~"""
Ba "ymore Lau rence Sche re' , .... ,..-....,"' .... """"."EIt __..._ ....
....1I.n Sch wart zma n,
Plula We ldeger. An9 U' Wilk ,e .. ""'..... ,,'-bM"'_
" ..":""".... p"'.,,,,..,'.'..,"--_, ...
- ,...... ....,''''_,,"'-,
. "...,,"" .......'_. ,_'''_ ..._ ..........
.................
mlO """
...''''''' __
Oan ie lZ itkha
fOUNDER
Label Conscious
AT LEAST NINE SIGNED FRANZ possib le cons ignment. After
fai led to se ll. HNobody ques·
l ioned Ihe authent icity," says
Hi ndman.
labeled works. adds, "To te ll a
person who Silent $ 100,000
on a work that ii's worthless
Klines that ha~e traded o~er he cas! doubt on the labels, The Kline is now back is pretty ha r Sh ,k
the past five years at major Martin turned down the deal. on Raimondi's wall. ~I sti ll It may seem strange
auction houses-including "I remember those,H confirms think it's grea t: he says, that so much doub t is possi'
Christie's London and New Martin. "They came from though he does recall Ihal he ble aboul lhe oeuvre of so
York; Ko ller, in Zurich; and Italy, and there was a ba tch was initially dubious of the its well-known an artist. But,
Tajart in Paris-may be fakes. of them.~ au thenticity because CobbS remarkably for someone of
All are untitled ink-on-paper The priciest of the is belter known for an ti ques Kline's stature, he has no
works from the early 19505, disputed Klines, Untilled. than for postwar art. Bu t the catalogue ra isonne and his
and all have identical block- 1953. brought E;S2.850 firm's owner assured him tha t estate is not active. This
leiter Kline signatures.On {SI65.000j at Ch ristie's the work was from a reputa- leaves the held vulnerab le to
Ihe reverse of each is a label London in July 200S. (The ble collector. disreputable deal ing. "There
from I he Grace Borgenicht ar tist's works on paper wi t h Two more of the are a lot of troub led Klines in
Gallery. at 1018 Madison other provenances have suspect Klines have the market. and nobody
Avenue. in New York. fetched as much as appeared at Cobbs since knows where they're from.
S665,OOO at auction.) In Raimond i's acqu isit ion, It's a buyer-beware si tua-
Are fake Klines selling 2004 two ol hers went for i nclud ing one that was tion: says New York dealer
more than SIOO,OOO each in hammered down at S25,000 David McKee. who repre-
on the open market? separate sales at Christie's i n July 2009 and another sented the Kline es tate in the
Tha t provenance is New York. "Christie's upholds that sold for S28.750 in 70s and for years, together
suspect, accord ing to William the highest standards when October 2009. The July with the late New York dealer
Mac Chambers, a New York establishing the authenticity buyer returned the drawing Allan Stone, informally
priva te dealer who was a of the wor ks t hat we se ll and to the house on Ihe advice of ve i led the artist's works for
Borgenicht employee for 23 Iodate has not received any the New York dealer Armand Christie's and Sotheby's.
years. "The label is not our concerns ques t ioning Ihe Bartos. who had seen "What we are left with
label." he states. "It's a fake provenance of any of these ano ther Kline with the same now is opinions, because
labeL" Chambers will no t works, " says a spokesperson provenance in the booth of there's no consti t uted enti t y
provide a facsimile of the for I he firm. "We are investi- an American dealer at Art Ihat can wri te certificates for
genu ine article. explaining ga t ing t he malter f ur t her." Basel in 2007 and fou nd t he Kline: says Foster. "I hope
that that would make further Last November, a Kline label unconvincing. Cobbs that changes in the fu t ure. tfl
forger ies eas ier. He notes, with the Borgenicht prove- took the piece back but JUDO TUllY
however, that Ihe size and nance was withdrawn by the resold it to a buyer whom CFO
t ypeface of the ones on the se ller at t he 11th hour f rom a Dud ley Cobb Charac terizes
Klines are incorrect. In any sale at Vienna's Doro theum. as "one of the major New
case, a former colleague of Another of the suspect York art dealers: who had
his recently examined t he Klines so ld in October 2007 missed it at I he July sale.
gallery's so ld-works arChive for approxima tely S5.000 at " The firs t buyer said he
and no Klines were recorded the Cobbs Auctioneers, in didn't want to put it in his
during its existence, from Pe terborough, New collect ion with that label on
1951 to 1995 (Grace Hampshire_The buyer was it." says Cobb. "If we thought
Borgenicht died in 2001). the Massachuselts pr ivate something was signed Kline
Chambers, who has dealer John Raimondi. He and was bogus, we wouldn't
alerted several auction subsequen lly consigned Ihe handle it "
houses when Klines bearing drawing to New York's L 6: M " The trade in Kl ine
the Borgenicht label have Arts, where. aggreSSively forgeries is extensive, and
come up for sale. says he pr iced at S250,OOO, it found there have been a lot of
found out abou t the putat ive no buyer. He I hen consigned Klines offered by major
coun l erfe its by chance it to the Chicago auc t ioneer auction houses that are
several years ago when the Leslie Hindman, which made extremely questionable:
New York dealer Mary-Anne the work Ihe cover lot of it s says the Kl ine scholar and
Martin called him about four December 2008 sale. au t hor Stephen Foster. who
SUCh works that had been Estima ted at S50,OOO to whi le declining to comment Thl. work"" paprr.i<OId . 1 Chrl'lle"Now Vorkln 2004
brought to the gallery for $70,000, the drawing again on any of t he Borgenicht- ... Fran,Kline. ma y ""I be .ulhenllc_
Desert Intrigue
IN NOVEMBER 2007, the oil- Masdar; Jeff Koons, whose
Yet wi thout some firm
faith that sales would be
made, how could galleries
for a series of "hyperphotos"
01 the monumental Sheikh
Zayed mosque by photogra-
riCh emirate of Abu Dhabi large sculpture Diamond justify the cost of transport- pher Jean-fran~ois Rauzier.
launched a contemporary- (Red), 2006, anchored the ing some of their most At fairs like Art Basel,
art fair in conjunction with Gagosian Gallery's stand; va luable works so far in this most big sales happen on the
Art Paris. In 2008, amid Ihe fran~ois Pinault,the mega- economy? PaceWildenstein, first day; here deals weren't
global financial meltdown, collector and ownerof for instance, spent some finalized untit the last hours,
the fa ir experienced such Christie's; and Anupam 5100,000 to Ship Alexander and exhibitors remain cagey
poor sales and low allen- Poddar, India's leading Calder's monumental 1969 about them.Gagosian has
dance that last June, with the collector of contemporary mobile Ordinary. Priced at announced the sale of a
world 's econom ies still ailing. art. What role the patrons 545 million, it didn't sell, but Willem de Kooning painting
the French partners canceled played no one involved would another of the gallery's and a work by Anselm Reyle
the upcoming event. say, which only added to the Calder mobiles,the but won't say to whom,
Seemingly immune to the event's air of mystery, 5B.5 million La douche, did Hauser," Wirth reports that
debt crisis and eager to fan Most of the top exhibi- find a buyer, which was an Asian collector acquired a
the media attention tors, who traveled with prized rumored to be the Roni Horn sculpture and
surrounding its estimated inventory pieces to thislar- Guggenheim Abu Dhabi. another buyer a Gerhard
527 billion Saadiyat Island flung destination, may be As to the emirate's Richter, Thaddaeus Ropac,
cultural complex. where the assumed to have expected to elite, it has only begun to who says he sold the TDIC a
Guggenheim Abu Dhabi and Tony Cragg sculpture and a
Philip Taaffe painting and
"It's about learning how that another collector is
things work here. It has interested in commissioning
a Cragg, deems the fair "a
taught us patience." good experience, but diffi-
Louvre Abu Dhabi are now cult. There are a lot of
under construction, the emir- middlemen", [Were it not
ate directed ils Tourism for theTDlc sales], we
Development and Investment wouldn't be as happy."
Company (TDIC) and the Abu Other dealers are phil-
Dhabi Authority lor Culture osophic, "Th is isn't really
and Heritage (ADCH) to about sales,N remarks Hauser
launch their own fair. Billed '" Wirth's Florian Berktold.
as a "cultural platlorm: the Ma..... an RKhmloul'slnstlllaUon Beirut C.oulc~ouc,at DlsORIENTatlonsli. "It's about learning how
hastily assembled-and thus make major sales to the TDIC take an interest in art. To things work here.NDeclaring
all the more impressive-Abu and AOCH or to the ruling al- demystify the held for all the Abu Dhabi a future "cultural
Dhabi Art which ran from Nahyan family, although Rita novice aficionados from hub: a booster ish Mathias
November 19 to 22, featured Aoun-Abdo, the TDIC'S MEN AsA- the acronym for the Rastorfer, of Zurich's Galerie
such blue-chip galleries as cultural-division head, denies Middle East, North Africa, Gmurzynska, says, "Th e TOIC
Aquavella, LSo M Arts and that assurances were given. and South Asia region-a has taken this over and made
White Cube, plus al'l array of Dealers certainly didn't seem panel discussion was held on it into a majorfair, It's a 10-
panel discussions, exhibi- fazed by the Guggenheim collecting in which the year plan.N
tions and desigl'l workshops. Abu Dhabi's claim that its usually elusive iiberdealer Just days later, neigh-
Although some events acquisitions committee was La rry Gagosian pa rticipated. boring Dubai panicked global
appeared to have been recy- still being formed, possibly New collectors we re financial markets by asking
cled from recent editions of because they were satished also targeted by some for a six-month moratorium
Art Basel, they were fresh to that the Louvre Abu Dhabi smaller exhibitors, such as on its impending 54 billion
the region. There was also a
stellar patrons committee,
was actively buying. Last
February the museum paid
London's Waterhouse So
Dodd, which brought art
debt payment. Will Abu Dhabi
bailout its fellow emirate' At
,
among whose members were
Norman foster, the architect
nearly 528 million for
Mondrian's 1922
priced from 55,000 to
51.1 mil1ion. According to Ray
press time, the U.S. was on
Thanksgiving holiday, l
of the emirate's soon-to-be- Composition with Blue, Ffed. Waterhouse, he sold "a lot" Muslims were celebrating
built Zayed National Museum Yel/ow and81ack at the Saint and received two commiS- Eid, and the world remained
and the zero·carbon city, Laurent-Berge sale. sions from state entities, one in suspense. + SARA H DOUGLAS
'7
.... IM.,:!!
MASTER DRAWINGS
NEW YORK
/ANUARY ~3 T1lROUGII 30
For Ihis weeklong event, now in
its fou rth year, 22 Uppe r East
Side galleries- including Addison
Fine Arts, Simon Dickinson,
Crispia n Riley- Sm ith and David
Tunick - are bringing out their
best works on paper, from the
SOTHEBY'S 16th through the 20th centuries.
Old Master Dr aw ings, JANUA"Y ~7 First-limer Didier Aaron, of Pa ris,
Importa nt Old Master Paintin gs, Including London and New York, is show-
European Work s 01 Art, JANUARY ~s ing 50 18th-century examples
Important Old Master and 19th-Century I rom France. look for 18th'cen-
Pa intin gs, jM'UARV 30 tury tre asu res at Stiebel, Ltd. as
One of the ricr.est offerings in these three sa les weU, including Ihe French artist
is Anthonv Van Dyck 's unusual Two Studies of Charles Parrocel's watercoklr
a Bearded Man, above, depicting the same ~gure Mlrriage Ceremony al a Mili/dry
in two distinct moods. Painted around 1620, whi le Encampment, above
I r.e arlist was working in Rubens's studio, it is
" estImated at S5 mimon to S7 millio n. Also on the
block is Ihe Outch painter Hendrick Goltz lus's
Jupiter and Antiope, painted in 1612, atlhe height
of the artist's ca reer. Re<:enlly restituted by the
Oul ch government to the heirs of Abraha m Adels'
i)erger, irs estimated at S8 mi llion to 512 million. !
.......
Naked
Ambition
PREVIEW: RYAN
MCGINLE Y AT
THE BREEDER
GALLERY
To some, the name Ryan Mc- I'()" I
()~ \ '11 \\
Ginley is inseparable from the
freewheeling group of down-
town New York artists that 1"!·MWit
included the late Dash Snow.
To others, he is the creator of
sub tly cap tivating photos of Best known for transforming empty spaces into solid
his friends. The 32-year-old masses, the British artist Rachel Whlleread. 46, rose to
photographer lal"lded on the stardom in the 1990$ with her etherea l resin casts. Now
R'y.n j,jcO",Jc/y', E,~, art world map several years her two-dimensional pieces are gelling their first airing
porl,.,t _yeo . ....
A/OO~,_".,Uoe.o .., ago with images of figures in "Rachel Whiteread: Drawings," on view at the Hammer
borh C·", ... " ,,_ that elegantly meld a Sllap-
20090Ith. Museum, in Los Angeles, from January 31 through May
..U.nl"...", shot approach with an astute 3. Featuring work s on paper, sculpture al"ld other objects ~
sense of timing and structure. spanning more than two decades, the show will travel from ~
From January 14 through Feb-
ruary 20, McGinley makes his
Grecian debut at the Breeder
LA. to Dallas's Nasher Sculpture Center and then the
Tate Britain in London. lis curator, Allegra Pesenll, of the
Hammer Museum, spoke with Andrew Russeth.
,,
•!
o
Gallery, in Athens, with a
show of 40 color and black- Whlte.ead It though t 01 u a scutptor, but irs ne~r b«n disclosed that
drawing it II(t .... ty a YI IIII ~r l of her prIKtiee. 1n he< studio, she e~n ha,
I
and-white pictures from three !
recent series. In "Road Trips·
he captures his friends on the
two separa te rooms-one for sculpting. one lor drawing-and she work,
in tire two medIums in pa.al\el though indepen<!entIV. In the caSf! 01 ~
Water Tower. 1998, lor In dance, she USM drawings to show how to cast
,,•
go, while in wMoonmilk" they tI1 e work. l' lI!1 tport it and color tI1 e resin, but $he also drew very beaulolul
appear in unusual, dramati- images 01 it on lop 01 photoo;;raphs 01 Ih e build ing against the s\(y~ne. !
These draw i.... s serve a s her inlimate diary. Many of her site'specill<: •
cally lit locations, such as in
caves, Of the more formal,
work s nave been des lroyed, ~ke House. 1993, or displaced, "ke Plinth,.
2oot. wtIrch moved Irom Trafalgar Square to ttorage. so her drawongs ,
l
penetrating black-and-white
portraits in the third series,
can help trIKe her career dewetopment While l'isiting her london studio
in prepara tion lor tI1l$ exhibrtion, I learned tha i $he accumulatet ICUId
objectt Illat ., Iorm her work. ranging from streks 10 dental casts to shoe
,
F
some are conventional head strelc hPf$, m<my 01 which she J>ick M up on trips wrlll her la ther. who Wat ;
a geogra phy teache •. !
shots, while others focus on
different sections of the body.
such as a naked torso of a
Rachel has compared the"" found and cotlected obtech to ske tch-
oook s, They thus belong to an e xtended notion 01 draftsmanship, whe re by
·,!
jumping slender male.
>
lhe act ollhinklng . nd preparirog a
wor~ of . rl is not only e xpressed on
paper but it "so reflected in three '
·!
1
d,mensio ..., objKh. The study
extenas Irom paper to objKt For
Rachel the$e obtecb act as me-morlel.
in muc:~ the $lime way as hPf Oraw'
i.... s do, and irl iluence her sc ulpture
Sl mila ~y. More Illan 200 of these
very pe rs.onal, broo;;raphical ltems a re
shown in oilri n-e, . alongside sculptures
Irom local coketors.
ERIK KOEPPEL
THE AMERICAN LANDSCAPE
EX HIBITI ON ON V I EW DE CEMBER 2 00 9
~~~~'A~L~L=\~'=F~I=N_D~L~A7Y~G~A~L~L=E~R=I~E=S~I=N~T7E~R~N~A~T~I=O~N~A~L=,~I~N~'7C~.~~
124 EAST 57TH ST REET · NEW YO R K, NY 10022 • TELEPHONE: 2 12-42 1-5390 ' WWW.WAL LYF1NDLAYCOM ~
P A LM BE A CH ' NE W YORK ' LOS AN GELES ' B A RCELO NA
I
Chinese e.~rt ~rce l a in Irom the
prioate collection 01 the late Penn-
sylvania dealer Elinor Gordon. Among
!
tm. other lots is a Chi ppendale
hgu red-mahogany stant-front de sk,
circa 1170, far right. from Marble-
head, Massachuse tts, whose high
estimale of SI million reflects the
edreme ra rity of its bomoo form. A
pair 01 late 18th-century ~rtrai l s
01 Anna Hopkins Turne r and Caleb
Humiston Tumer, right. by J. Brown,
is estimated at S30,OOO to S60,OOO.
GALERIE LUDORFF
KONIGSALLEE 22' 40212 DUSSELDORF· GERMANY· TEL. +49 (0) 211-}26566 ' FACSIM ILE +49 (0)211-323589
WWW.LUDORFFCOM . MAlI.@LUDORFFCOM
BEACH BOUND
IT'S NOT JUSTTHESUN.
TWO SPARKLING FAIRS IN
PALM BEACH LURE COLLECTORS,
CURATORS AND DEALERS
TO FLORIDA
Now in its 55th edition, the anracts a more academic bny...r Umbellifcrae chair. botlOm left,
Bru ssels Antiques and Fine Art than some other fairs,~ which ,he An Nouveau maSler
Fair (BRAFA) has exploded in size BRAFA is ch""k ·fnll of superb made for himself, at Gale ri e
amI innucncr iothc fiw years paimings, including J a mes Tiny Esveld . ami a 1971 ink-on-
since it moved into the renovated Ensor's dramatically colorful The paper drawing of a woman , top
Tour & Taxis development in the Sellcn Deadly Sins, 19U, top ldt, by the Belgian painter Paul
ciIY'S center. Tonted as ,1 morc righI, priced ,u €7 50,000 , S I.ll Delva u ~, from Ga lerie Beres, of
affordable yet equally high-quality million ) at the booth of Ronny Paris, Also gracing this year'> fair
ahcrnmiw to TEFAF Maastricht. Van de Velde, of Amwerp; lA is an ilU10vation: m:asnres from
8NA~", which runs from January Parsie"''':, I 88o, righI, a depiction Liege mnsenms, bunring eight
21 through 31, hosts around 11.0 of all aCtreSS by the Belgian anist masterpi&ces by such names as
exhibitors, (""enly split octwttn Alfred Steyens, for €ljO,ooo Gauguin and Picasso,
,R Belgian and iUtcnlalional dealers. (Stl4,l56 ) ,{I ,he booth of ~The an tl1<{rkel has picked up,
This year'> panicipants Boon Gallery, of Brussels; and the fair is full of bigger galleries,
include "umerous .. eterans, such fernand Leger's beautifnlly and we have a waiting liSI,~ says
as Antwerp's Axel Vervoordt, balanced abstract lAudsUJpc, BRAFA president Bernard de LeyI',
known for his 13Std,,1 mix of 1919, below, from Barcelona's ~ H igh-qllality obiects continue 10
c"erything from ancient stawary Glileria Manuel Barbie. Other sell, There is more of a re<:ession in
to avant-garde painting, and the eyecatching works are a €S6,000 finding Ihem than in selling them,~
An 0«0 dealer Je ~n 'J aeq ues (S I1S,57} ) Emile Galle 1901 - Jean Bond Rlfteriy
Dutko, also of Paris. Attending as
well are 15 newcomers, among
them J ean'Paul Perrier, on ... of
four Bar",lona dealers exhibiting
for the first time; tribal · art expert
J acqu e s Germ ain. of Montreal;
and RenaisS311~e ·an dealer
J oanna Booth, of London , who
i, m"king her debut here because,
she says, ~BRAFA has a greal
reputJtion, known for qualil)'
and range of early pieces, and il
..
) ~ '.
,
" •
r.'
•
--.
....
;
der Rohe 's 1929 Barcelona couch. leit. whiCh attend·
ees devoured. Then. lor three Sundays in November, ~
~
the pa inter Will Cotton translermed Partn ers'
Spad e ga llery into a bakery (Iep right) selling real
versiens 01 Ihe cen lec\iens he depicts.
The partners beh ind "Cake Happening"- Kree mart,
,,,
!
dedica ted Ie letting "artists explore dessert as a medi"
urn: and Ameriean Patrons o f the Tate -are planning
a more elabora te edi tion for Paris in June. Rubell. who
,
has merged arl and nourishmenl at her parents' Miam i
!
museum. prom ises a future gastro'aeslhe tic projec t
100, "Food is la~ i ng a more cen tral role in our culture: ,i,
she says, "It also happens 10 make an ideal med ium for
ephemeral art: !
P.... RIS On "iew at Emmanllell'errOlin from Janlla~' '9 through l<1arch [3 is -Considffing Henr),," a show of new paintings by the
+
Miami·based contempora ry Roma",ic paimer Hernan Bas, • LONDON The New York-based scu lptor-filmmaker Manhew Barney
present' new drawings along with slO~'board, for hi,la[est work in prog ........ Anciem ft"nings , an opera based on Norman
Mailer', 198; ES"ptian IIMd, at Sadie CAles HQ from Jalluarv:>8 through March 6 . • NEW YORK Berlin· based .rriSl Tino Seh ·
gal, known for orchestrat; ng encounterS among people, hils the C"ggenhe;m's rotunda w;th partie;pan" tra;ned to ;nteract w;th
muse"m v;s;tors, from J.n"a~· '-9 through ,\ larch rO, • 011 Jalluar)' ,-8, Chr;S{;cs is offering 1,0 lot&, indud;ng painting!., f"m;.
rure and African and Oceanic art, from the collection of [he esteemed Li[chfield Counry, Connec,icut, anriques dealer l'eter Tillou,
W.... SHlNGTON. D,C. !n dumy Gallery of design opens January ,6 with an inaugural show of work in metal by 5hlo",0 HMmh,
Cosmil spa
Foro BuoMparte 6~
20121 Milano, Italy
+ 3902725941
+390289011563 fax
wwwcosm itit
e-ma il inlo@cosmit. it ..
• •
'_ _
. ._-
.£-_.!4.01t.-
_ _ r-.ilaDo ...
g
_ ..... _
PaintingRx CQN'TTOUCHACRVUC
Con_empor.1)' plcl", ... ""rti<:ut.-.rty if done In K 'yllc. ""ould
not Hele .... d •• Ine. solv. nloun desl'oyl"" pllnt "WK ."I
",1n11ng. r" .y_·I,equl.e ... y~lndol,,,.c le .... I"'" N YI
In 2006 collector Sieve Wynn pu t his elbow tlltNew Yorlleon'lIfIj>Ot.ry·.rtcle ..... l ...1Ie' TonIr _ _ . "You
c.... . ..1Iy dull .... Inllngwllh .lealh... _ I ....• For eelUnll rI<I
through Le n'!ve, the 1932 Picasso for which he 01 HuH._ 1111 " .... Glvol",,"',uw. dry-cle.ning __ _
had paid $48.4 minion and was in the process of ..... t.-.I-"1/ ... _ .....' L 8utlor se. Io<II I I.IM .........·ee.
selling for a cool $139 million. Sounds lik.e a night- .. lIs __ ..... him ........ clell wlthllll I.o_.po,.-
"""yo. - ...... . ti ..... 'ou ju., ..... to b<1ng_h.wo,k bock 10 I""
BEAUTVISSKIN'OEEP
- An Inl.n .. Clnnlng-r.movlng I"" v. ,nl.h .nd oy .. p. lnl-po •••
Ihl mo. 1risk 10. polnllng. bee. uteln doing 00. con.."'... un
solvenl. lh ol CM . '1""1 1"" p. lnl .., ..... ,.c • •- tey. ~.'coGr ... l
• New Vork-tr ..ed conn",.IOr. GI.otovsky .uggesl. 11111 In mod
c•••• • IIgtrl surloc. 01 .... 1. . _ th.n nee ... . ry ,.1 her Illin lull
• • rn I.h r..,IC'".l lli ime-d.rke ned v.,nls h I.....1Iy m .. klng Ihe
I"""V •• howe ..... ,eslore. "",y c.,.lulty rlmov. lt.nd .pply
.no lh •• COlt. Oeco,tonilly. 100''''1", uw • •• nl.h wlltl>e
'e,lKed with onelllli I. ..... r.m." • • G.-•• sI ... d GI.olonk,
. .et 111111"" p. Klk. ol l ""C"""" new c...... to 1""_01
... OId_wilh glue or wu tlo ...... tt<'IbM. -som. r ... loren
1.. .....,._I""'_.lo'.. inloIcI ... lnhng .. bulit'. ju.lnol
I'ut." .. y.Glvolovlky. "Ilvokl ll ......... 'ou ..... 10 llell I""
_pllnll<>g._I""lag.. II.-
lESSISMORE
Th. gIft . .. 1con .. nsu .. mong con.."'.lo... . nd d...... 10 Ih.1
•• Iillie . hould be done . 1 po .. I...... - It som"h lng Il ju.I ""nging
Ihl ru nd 1.1>eIr1.1ng.1I·1 be.1 nollo Inl ..... n• •• •• , . Grol.1.
O..ld HIli. olNew Vo,k·. BI"y·HltlGI W. rl.l. I grett: -Cleaning
• p.lnll n g 10n'l pol iOh;" g Ito . k pleUI 01• ~.e, ." GIYoiov slry v.ri e.
hi •• ppro IC," In "".1 occo. dlnll 10 Ihe •• Iue . nd pu'po.e ollhe
plcl", •. "III" . . rei lly imporllnl .. orlo .... ./1 reeomm..,d IIIe mo.t
con ......" •• _,ooell. "h. . . YL ""Wsju" lor someon.' ,own
p...on.ltf'Ijoymenl . .... ml9hl domo' • •" Acco,dlng 10 Ken Mose ••
"".d of Ih.B'OOktyn Mutlum c.......... lloncle""rtmetll. ......."-
U... c ... lsh,-sloring. lurndllng. "'lpj>Ing.nd m ...... t l"9 •
.,...... In . .... n_' ... ' .......... Ih.tligllt. ....... ldity. _ t . nd
I.......... _"'.donol um_1t In I"" 11...1 pile • •
SHERRY l11LL YlN E ARTS 102 S, Tejon Street, Suite 1100 Colorado Springs. CO 80~3
719.685.1 S77 sherryhillfinearts.com
: .. -'. " ..
BY CASH DAN
MARIN!YANTONYCROOK
PHOTOGRAPHS
·t..
tion brochures. Bllt viewe rs insisted 011
Top: The I rtl.r • • tudlo.
interpret ing the pictures, rather than
,.,;:,"'
I tiny room"" t he third
ftOD< ol lhe r am b ~ n g
Ge<><gi . n house he
fo.;using, as he wished, On how they were ,
. h..es w ~hh l . l. mll y . created. "When r was doing the hotel
~
1,)Ii
Cloc~w l sefrom larle ft:
N~ wY"'k.2008;
Gibbs. tlklng ' bru k
In the~ounlry . ld. n . ...
inter iors, people would start analyzing
that they were aboUiloneliness or isola -
tion," he says. "lSoJ r moved to fa~ades,
,,
!
hi. house; . nolh., New
Yorlr drlwlnglrom thinking that they had less meaning." !
2008; I nd Typlc. 1 He followed those pictures with a series
Inl .... I<>I". 2006. oM
olhlsurlydeplc l lon. of baseball pitchers in balletic positions
olhotel roomsb.se<I [shown at the lora Reynolds Gallery in
on • • c. llo n broc hures.
Vlew... would.t. rt 2.008 ) and then with portraits of New
Inte rpre ting the d" ..... York, lOlldon and Paris lalldmarks,
Ings •• • bout lone line ss
or l. ol.llon. so. h. including the Chrysler Building, Big
u plol ln • • "lmo •• d Ben and the Eiffel Tower. These draw-
to l ~l de • • t hlnk lng
thl tlhe y had I.... ings, first shown at Timothr Taylor in
m,,"nlng : 2.008, have garnered Gibbs the most »
• !. ••
'11 !Utl ~
WlL!c)
"W1l.
f!J~
@ •
~ ~ ~
~B@W
January 8 - March 6 , Z010
The Punch of
Expressive Art
At the November Impressionist
and modern art sales, the market
took off like a Fauvist rocket.
THE GR EAT PA R A POX O F TH F; ART MAR ~ F.T was re"ea led to the
full last NO"ember atthe New York sales of Impression ist and 45
modern ar t- it is boo ming more than cver, as if the pers is-
tente~onOlll i c troub les had no bea ri ng on the urge to ~oll ect.
Underlining the paradox, it took one of th e casualties of the
recession to demonstrate its astonish ing bldlishness.
T he sensationa l Novem ber 4 auction at Sothe by's,
whe re S6 paintings and sculptu res rea li zed nearly $[ R ~ mil-
lion, incl uded an outstand ingco!!e<.:t ion wh ich, a<.:cord ing to
rumor in the art trade, tumb led on to the market as a result
o f a DutCh businessman's financia l problems. T he sa le con-
fi rmed beyond possi blc doubt that the o nly problem regarding
Impressionist and modern art, as in virtu a lly every other a rea
in the market, is the shortage o f supplies.
Unt il the N ovember sales, Imp ression ist and modern
wo rks o f art dese rv ing se rious attention c a me up in such sma ll
numbers following th e financial earth quake of autumn lo0 8,
that they made a ha lf-convincing case for the continued good
health of the market in one of its mo st important a reas. In psy-
cholog ica l ter ms, it is not easy toarguet hat a ll is well because
second-d i"ision pietu res continue to fetch higher prices than
thei r int ri nsic me rit wa rrants.
T he problem was il lustrated by the l\"O"em ber} sale at by Pau l Signa<.: in [9 ' ~' l\ana l in its <.:omposit ion. wh ich does
Chr istie's, whid inaugurated th e Impression ist and modern not rise abo" e the level o f a picture postcard, Thc Old Harbor
art wec k. Disturbingl), thin, the session yielded e"idcnce of at Calmes owes its vibrancy to thc brushwork that transforms
buyers' eagerness to pounce on anything worthwhile, but it Ihestructure.
hard ly allowed One to draw defin it;,'e co nclusions about the Remembering the distant days when he laid down the
o" crall upward tre nd. However, it pointed to an intc resting foundations of the Di" isionist movement, Signac juxtaposed
sh ift of aesthet ic preferences that the Sotheby's sale confi rmed Ihick dots and short strokes of color- pink, yellow, green and
on a spectacula r scale that followingnening. bille-that ma ke the seascape swa)' and sing. The Cannes scene
Fou r pictu res out of the 46 lots that camc up at Ch ri stie's shot up to $3.8 million. For a picture exe<.: uted }O years a fter
were of a suffi<.:ient cali ber to gh'e real s ign ificance to the ir the heyday of its style b)' a n artist who does not rank among
performance. The first to appe ar was a seaside "iew painted the most hig hly rated Impression ists, this is a stagger ing score.
www ~ " " NF().C()'" I JAN uARy 2010 ~ " ' t ~ UC " ()N
left arm akimbo Jnd the other hanging down, the Arab boy and MiJd~) was painted by Kandinskyin 19}2. toward the end
seem~ about to speak. The intense brick-red color of the face of his Ihuhau$ period. With the contfJsting colors of abSt raCT
and {he torso, set off by a simp le bla"k outline and the solid for ms that see m to collide with each other, the picture com-
off-white background make the startling image leap off the mands instant attention. The biggest shape, a bla ck wedge
wal l. Unusually for \'an Dongen, the eyes are not rendered with a toned blue disk lodged in the top corner glares at the
natu raJislica lIy wilh a fierce Slare, bm painted a monochrome viewer as if it were an eye. It gil'es thecomposition a d istu rb -
ma roon that fills the eyelid. The hoy thus has a blind gale in ing Surrealist fed while betraying the austere Kandinsk(s
the mannerof Amedeo Modigliani, whose influence is IImni,- unexpected awareness of Joan Miro's impish interpretation
takable here, jusl as van Dongen 's awareness of Matisse's stylc of Surreali sm at the time . Krass !/Ild Alild rea lized an impres-
at that moment is blatant. Thu e is a hypnotic 'lua!;ty to Ihis sive $10.6 mill ion, again exceeding the upper estimate.
pictu re which, according to an i Ils.:riprion on the stretcher, was Pred ictably, M iro himself did extremely well. Fcmme.
exe.::uted in Egypt. Fascinated, b idders ran up Jelllle Arabe to Oiscau, an ultra -simpl ified abstract composition of blobs Jnd
SI}.8 mill ion, rOllgh ly 2.0 percentO\'er the high estimate. And cllf\'ingstrokes in wh ic h red and black dominate on the glar-
with that, a second auCtion record for an anist marked by the ingly white canvas brought nearly $ ... 8 million with the buyer's
Fauve tradition was set that evening. premiu m. T he picture was dashed off in a day sometime du ring
Proof that the defining factor of success that session was September 1972. when the Catalan-born artist seemed to be
the ex pressiveness of the work, regardless of the style, came spewing f lIry byspl urging color. Expressive is too weak a word
ha lfway through when the fourth highest price was pa id for a to convey the thrust of the brush or the shriek ing intensity of
composition of geometrical forms. Kra$5 ,,,,J M ilJ (~Dramatic itscolorscheme.
~ ..... The wildest excesses of Picassochurning out one-day car-
TOon-type pic tures were enthusiastica Ily fought over. Taking
seriousl)· pa intings produced hy the hardline Communist aftist
as a pro"ocation to the bou rgeois establ ish ment, bidders went
after a Buste d'/'ommc as if it had beensome \I nforgettable 1I1as-
terpiece. The bill for this ~ portrait,~ dated October 5, 1969,
was a prodigious $ [0,4 million
Later, another grimacingca ricarure by Picasso brought a
stll pendolls$8.1 million. Expedited by the arr iston Janliary 8,
1947, Femme a" chapeau verI has little to recommend it other
than a famous signature.
The intensified search for exp ressiveness is changing
the price scale in modern a rt. Until reecmly the work of Emil
Nolde was avidly sought whene,'er it predated the s)'stem-
atic destruction of his paintings ordered by the l'\ali regime
which branded his work as "'degenerate art.~ A picture such
as Uppiger Garrell (~Luxllria1lt Garden") painted in [945
would ha"e ins pired little interest. The d ose·up view of
flowers ismorecontrolled in its brushwork and more balanced
in its color scheme tha n the Expression ist artis!"s earl ier paint-
ings. Alrhollgh the colors of the flowers a re intense, it betrays
a search for ha nnon}' that runS counte r to the original aims
o f Exp ressionism. The result is magnificent. Although the
composition is well -balanced, the flaming reds of the anemo-
nes, set off by dark emerald greens and hy the delicate pale
pink of other fl owers, give it an explo-
The p.olel O.nuuoe ..
sive strength that remains highl)" d' .... nbyEdgarD ~ gao
expressil'e. This masterpiece from a In Ihe mld·tS90. when
he was no longer Illhe
prev iously neglected phJse of Nolde's he~hl ofhISI,II. II<
oeuv re matched the middle estimate as pow en .sllllm"" ~ ed
lodlmblo . ,e mlrl<-
it made $2..6 million . Nottoo long ago it a ble $10.7 mlIiIOfl. II',
might hal'e crashed lInwantcd. I sl ' IISIWr>g hgure
... !>en you conslde' 111 . 1
Anothe r case of shifting inter- paslelsunOfllybe
ests was offered by Fernand Leger's /.es d[sployed 101 sl>o,l
period s olilme
trois I11l1sicie>1s. Dated 19}Z, the scene is Ilihey .relo be
handled in a figll fJI , pseudo-Naif » .hleldedlrom b dlng.
style. The ins istent black outlines and rhe toned grays stand
Qut aga inst a solid acid -yellow background. The faces are
eerily simi laT. As an image , Le5 troi5 "'''5iden5 catches the
eye from [0 yards away. Leger is pa rticu la rly admired by
21st-century art collectors for his "cry different, abstract
"mechanical" pe riod, when he rd entlessly pa inted manu -
factu red machinery parts. On November 4. at S(}[hehy's,
the figural Uger triggered competition that sent it nying to
$5-7 million with sales charge, nearly double the expected
highof SJ million.
As expressiveness goes up, su btlety recedes. Pictu res
of c\'cry kind that would have pitched connoisseurs against
each other a generation or so ago a re nOlVeasily overlooked.
Some splend id acqu isitions could be made at the New York
autu mnsales.
At Christie's, a be autiful Paris \' iew of the Quai
Ma la quais on the Idt bank o f the Seine done by Pissarro in
'90., stood oul. The rive r is Seen from a h igh vantage point,
with the Institut de Fra nce \'isible far away. Countless touches
or pale colors daintily applied create a splendid atmosphe ric
eifect. A poetic melancholy pervadcs the sophisticated com-
pos ition. But ne ither melancholy nor sophistication are in
demand these days. The important landscape, wort hy o f any
50 great IllIISeUrn, did not even match the middle estimate 3S it
wem for $2.1 5 mi llion with buyers premium.
Anot her equally poetic lan dscape, th is time by the great
Corot, cost only $866,500. T he master-
o.spltelts gloom y
. sp«!. To marl de piece, done in the later 1860s ncar Ville work by a towering figure of mid-19th-cclllu ry French painting
le mplck. 'sl9lS d'Anay, where the a rrist Iived, is ill mint that is subdued, both in mood and cxe<.:ution.
Porlroll duMorqui'
S<lmml.chl..e<! I brl!- condition. Italso has a 10nghistOf)' in the At Sorheb(s, simila rly llIode ra te prices were paid for
~on t $4.3mllllon.Yet l U.S.,going at least as far back as its fi rst works of the same ilk. An adm irable Paris<.:ilysca pe pa inted
m . .lerlul lo n<lsc. peby
Corolw.. boul/hlfor auction appearance in New York at the by Pis sa rro in 1899, duly signed and dated, was a rea l cou p al
whit omounle<! to a Amer ican An Association on Januar)· $2.11 million, even though the price was substantially more
1lnl,lm Ht
$8665 00. Thai price 8, 191. 6. lts pri<.:ewasslightlymorethan than the high estimate. Nothingquitecompa res with the view
le.tlled to Ihe current Christie's high estimate, but Ihis simply of the southwest wing or the Louvre pabce and the Jardin des
"'lfIlncoltcto<l •• tt
from tile nuanc e<! to shows how low Ihe best experts' expec- Tui lerics seen in the misty white light of a snowy day. The Hear-
Iheu preulve. tations Can be when it <':(}Ines to a great impossi bil ity of conveying in a catalogue the pale light and the
mu ltiple nuancesof white and off-white with tou<.:hesof gray
and purplish brown may in part account for the cornparati\-e!y
lukewarm response that such a masterpiece elicited.
Howner, other failures to trigge r the kind of enthusi-
astic bidd ing that greeted the appea rance of cxpressive works
suggest thar the main cause for the modest performance o f the
admirable Pissarro lies in the art itself, not in the cata logue
re p rodu<.:tion. Moments earlier, a rare riverside landscape
in exquisitely del icate shades done by Sisley around 1870, as
Impressionism was beginning to emerge, sold below the low
estimate for S I.s million. You can almost fed the coolofeariy
spring in this spa ring!), painted gem.
Aesthetic perception has changed, renecting a broade r
cultural break with the past. Shades and nuances no longer
appea I in a world to wh ich COntemplation is al iell. The '1uest for
the instant punch delive red by expressiveness can on Iy intcnsify
as the attemionspan ofcontemporarysocietygets e\'ershorter. Ell
SOU~ E .... nl ~lA .. I S TH EI NTE~N' TIONA L EOITOR Of ARI+AUC TION
IN THE I.AH 196os, D.lllicl Kal~. "isired ;) tu re from , 893 that he acquired years ago at a
now-shutrered g.ll1cryon 571h Street in New Ch ristit'5 5:l lt in $cOlland.
York. He reca ll s Ill,HI'clinga! reproduct ions Daniel Katz Ltd. occu pies thtu f100f"S
of W;l g rcat Rogie r ,';In der Werden, a g reat of an d tgant , 8th.century lown hooSt
H ans Mcmling, a greal \'':111 Gogh, a greal that was formerl y horne to the famed I.eger
Frago nard and a grear Picas$Ow hanging 011 Gal leriesand, lon g bdort that, to priulighte r
5' the receptlOn-MCa wa lls bUllhcnlind ing, once Gen ticman Joon Jack50n's boJ(ing academy,
he passed through Ihcdooblc doors, Wnmh ing where, Katz tt ll s mt, Lord Byron famously
c"'c pliona l ... jusl some nice pin:cs of blC: knocked out another Eng li sh nobleman in the
16th-century fu rniture, a few Stile Epoqu c ea rly 19th cen tury. ThJt isoneof a Sirtam of
oo,n:tsand a Bouchcrdraw i ng.~ Wh ..1l' WCIl' anecdotes thai nowsdu ring my mtttings with
Ihe maslt'rpicccs on "jew out front? They had Katz, which lake place O\'ersel'eral days du(' 10
bun sold ),c3Tsago, ,hcga Jlery staffinf.:...med the dealer's ralherperipaletic schedu le. At 6 "
him. - I [houghl TO m),sdf,w hC5.1YS, -'What do Katz, a self-dCiCritxd polymath, with inf~I"C'SIS
they h,\\'(' to show for thcmscll'('S?'- ranging frollllllod~rn danc~ to Isla Illi, c~ra m·
Thai is one qucstion thaI, after 43 ics, isold·fa shioned and profc§SOtial. Eloquent
years bu ying and se llin g tht lin est Europc:an and with th(' silky ,'oic.: of an English SI3gt
scul ptu res, (rom 1{ tn ~i S5anCt bronzes to actor, hc has the ai r o f somconc from a nOI her
' 9th-century ma rbles, Kat~, need not 311swer. cCTliury. He is composed despite the mll sc ular
EI'idence o f th e London dea ler 's s ucce~s is tics associated with his Tourette's sy nd rome,
e\"erywhere in his sumptuous O ld Bond Street wh ieh he ac k nowledges offha nd ed ly.
quarters. 111 addition to the works on display If is th e summer aun ion seaso n in
in ex hibition spaccs, irwcmory itcmsa re scat- London, and Kat~ has d('cided to sho w at
te red here and there: a po lych romed- wood the gallery, for Ihe lirstt ime, se lections frorn
Mad o nn a and Ch rld on a chair :Itld a pan e l his own coll('({ioll. Sur prisin gly, it do('s not
from a circa ' 'ISO Florentintc<l$sOlle, or wed- contain Renaissanc(' or Old Ma ste r seu 11'-
ding chest, that K at~acquiftd ftcem l)" ftom a ture. -I never wanted IOcoliecl the same art
sma ll auc tion houSt in Stockho lm. I sit with as I dea lt in,~ he says. - BeC 3US(, if you do,
him ill his oflicr/stud)', whtrt ht is lean ing you nCI'(' r wa nt 10 se ll the grea t things YOoU
back in a wNthered Ittgt'"II;y itathe-r a rmchai r, ha,·('. and th<'rdore you don't have anYI h ing
his handscbsped beh ind h,s head and one kg grea[lOsd l. ~
comforubly propped on his an tique French He focused iniriaJI)'on ll:llian p;!i11lmgof
desk. A!x,.,e him hangs the statd), Portrll;t of th(' ' 5th a nd 16thcentu ries,lh('n Flemish and
all Architect, an ()l Ion ca nl'as anributed to the Gt rman pictu res. In thc('a rly 19805, he 11"('111
mid '7lh- to mid ,8th-centu ry Jul ian painte.. Ihrough a brief Frtnch hnpressio llIst phase.
FrancescoSohmtna. Kat1. ld ls mt Ihat it has Finall y, about 15 years ago he tx;:alll(' in ter-
dispbced, forrhe mOomem, William Nicholson's ested in loth -centu ry British a rt. Hebooght a
Yormg \'(IOIIIIlII;1I While, a Whi stkftsque pic- Waltt r Sicktrr nude, Dal'id Bomberg's redis-
"I traced the history," he says, "managed to collectors, hc acknowledges that "ther often business," he says as we wind down the COll -
buy it from a country-house pri"ate collection go off on their own, because I'm not so good I'ersation, '"and I'm not sayingI'm beyond that,
and sold ittothcJ. Paul Getty Museum when at keeping contactlwith theml and offcring because ['TIl interested in making money and
itwas juststartingollt. It was their fi rst major things." H e does make his wares accessi ble, ru nn ing th is business, a nd I'm lasei nated with
acquisition, and it was a lot of money at the though, and collectors in New York this month prices achie\·ed. Bur:It the end of the dar, the
time - many millions of dollars- and Iwas can seck out his booth at the Winter Antiques thing for me is the object, the work of art." ff.
fine Art, Gale rie Urs Meile, Platfo rm you need to understand that the gene ral
Ch ina, Pekin Fine A TIS, ShanghA RT and policy announcement from wh ich the
Three Shadows Photography Art Centre, rumors sta rted is a prohousing po!icy,~
making the I' illage a mandatory dcstina- exp laincd Meg Maggio, the foundcrof
tion for arts profess ionals I'isiting the city Pek in Fine Arts and a longtim e Beijing
and for local collectors and enthusiasts. resident. The idea, she said, is '"to get
Some Eu ropean artists hal'e ar ri ved, people living on the city outsk irt s OUt
indudingNOI Vital, who JUSt completed to measu re some of the spaces and dctcr- of makeshift P;"I{ (all); (literally "flat
a lavish new stud io com pound. Ch ina's mine the e xact sile of the lots. Then houses,~ often one-story shanties I and
Peoples Dailyrecentlycalled the d istrict again, it might start within the next few into newly constructed 1011 (aug (Ill lilti-
~one of the nation's artistic hotbeds. ~ years, or nOl at all. I n other words, many story( buildings. That is a grcat housing
But despite its local prominence people eithe r were not pril'YIO informa- program of the Beijing city gOl'ernment ,
and international ,'isibility, rumors have tion that would d irect l)" affect them or and will improve many people's !il'es. We
i,
been circulating in recent months that
much of Caochangdi (a long with other
wondered if a decision made today might
be reversed tomorrow.
a re told by ourdeveIoper and A i Weiwei
that while there was init ial concern that ,
artist I'illages and STUdio compounds Change is nothing new in Cao- this new prohousing polic y would affect l
in northeast Beijing) are being cons id- changdi, a neighborhood which has us, it is now clear that it will not.~
,~
ered for demolition 10 make way for
nCw gOl'ernment pro je(ls and b usiness
been redefined continually ol'cr the past
50 years by a series of political agcndas
Meanwhile, just nort h of Cao-
changdi in the Bcigao studio complex, ",
development- including, oddl)" enough, and econom ic shi fts. Once the site of the mood this past fall was less opti-
a "cultural d istrict." Last fa ll, when imperi3 t gra"es and ga rdens, it was trans- mistic. The artist Liu Ding told me that
I asked artists and deale rs li"ing alld formed intoa farming vill age sometime because of plans to build J theater and
more time and for compens.uion. At press tioning its ,-alidity and the situation was
time it was uncertain how much respite far from being resolved.
tht)' had bcen granted - thc first cI'ic- The recent confusion aboUT who
tion deadline had passed and a new one has the right to rent, to build and to
had not)'et been set. Although there was destroy in Caochangdi demonstrates
alread)' snow on (he ground, heat had how uneven and minimally regulated
been cut and running water was interm it- dcvelopment, coupled with shifting or
tent. Anists lila), be reimbursed the rent confl icting nJtional, municipal and "ii -
they paid in advance, but itwill be much lage agendas, have allowed sud districts
harde r to recoup the money they spent to thri\'c but ha\'c also made their long-
on renovation. For their part, the artists term sUf" i"al uncertain. At the same
knew that sinking mone)' into property {i me, ru mors or no rumors, Caochangdi
theydidn'town wasa gamble, especially shows no sign of slowing down. Studios
considering that if land is deemed desir- are still being built, and new galleries
,, able for other uscs, cI'en long·termlrases are launching, including Taibng Top
, lished lcgal gu idelines, chaos can arise worms may not dream of thc Silk Road
when disputes between tenantS and or e,-en of an Hennes scarf, they llIay
landlords escala te. [n an extreme inci- find that spinn ing even the most beaut i-
dent a few months ago, the Caochangdi fu Icocoon may not always insulate them
branch of Seoul's reputable I'KM Gallery from forces beyond thcircontro1. lF
I-
FROM ABOVE,
~~J!!JIl!! >' Th~lIug.
">'C, 1980.in"'ic~a ~ 1
Hoeh' . collectlon;
Andrt.Ut<>!cldJiJD'. 5.
200T . r>dChr!sloph
Bac~ e l'sX - MA5TR£f:
(Unplu~~ e d},2007 ,
both in the collection 01
Stn eandCh i<l r.
Rosenblum,
OPf>OSITt:,
Mlchl el Ho e ~ amid hi s
collecllon . .. ~ic~
Inclvdeu number ol
photograph. along
w l l~conc e pludv
orl"",tedpl e<:es,
,,,
!
!
••••
• •
Find more magazines at www.magazinesdownload.com
fROMTO~
.-.ndy W.rlloI'. FI_.n.
196"; .nd IIlIflilNfo"
SIeve"", 8ou"".1. T991.
boltls.old In •• ecenl Flnl
Open . . .1 ClwIlIl.'L
OPPOMTL
CLOCKWISl:fRO"T~
~'.S~ddenlJr,1"
Z007 ,. wo,~ belo"1lI"1l10
Je<emy Sl eln ~ .; G.ego.
Hlideb •• I>dr. TMende
J<J,1en<J(·R .."""dlng
V""lh ·1.2009;.nd
tbtlstopbel Wool',
Untllled,2009,
bolh.mongtlle
R""",blum" holdl"1lL
un~y~;lable to ttlem
in termsof plite and ~cce$$, iru;luding a mas'
sive CtlfistopherWoot painting, which they bought last June at the
Alt Basel booth ot New YOlk's Luhring Augushne galiery,
"It's undeniable tha t the market change has affected mv
coliecting: saysJelemy E. Steinke, a story editor and consu ltant
to leading hlmmakers, who primarily acquires work by young art-
isis such as Paul Chan and Kalup Linzy, "Bu t I collected more last
year than I did in the hve years betore the boom,"
Having run out of space to display hiHOliection in his sizable
BrOOklyn brownstone, Steinke lends artwork s to friends, rather
than relegate them storage. Hoeh. who has expanded lIis focus
from black-and'white photogr aplly to iru;tude conceptual works,
is laced wilha similar space crunch in his downtown Manhattan
lolt. To remedy the situation, he has placed some of his 1,000
works-including pieces by Spencer Finch, NanGoldin, Vik Muniz
and Wolfgang Tillmans-in storage but has also lenl pieces to
institutions like the Museum 0 1 Contemporary Photography in
Tokyo and the Contempor ar y Arl Galleries at the University 01
Connecticut's Storrs campus.
Steinke and Hoeh are t ypical 01 their generation in their
commitment 10 arl and art makers, and to keeping pieces in public
view, "Aside from buying those works on their wiSh list that they
didn't have access to orlost inbidding wars. these collectors are
realiy interes ted in commissions and special unique works: says
Oavid Maupin, of New York's Lehmann Maupin gallery. "I\'s about
.'
6,
TO MANY, THE NAME R uhlmann is synonymous with Collectionneu r, a supremely soph isticated series of
French Art Deco. The preeminent furniture designer of interiors, brought him international fame, as well .
his time and rhe lasl great ebenisre, he worked in the Much of the furnilU re b ter served as models fo r
tradition of such 18th-centur)· exemplars as Andre - pie<.:es he crafted for clients, generally with slight
Cha rles Roull e and Jean - Henri Riesener. H is graceful variations in wood and ornament.
forms, howel'cr, we re distinctly modern, appealing to Toward the end of his career, Ruhlmann
rhe era', style SfrlerS, including Baron Henri l elt: Ac!<ca1925 transilioned illlo more modern designs,
de Rothschild, the maha raja of Indo re and wolnutcabine!with many using metal, but it is his gleaming
iyory deta itofrom
the couturiere Jeanne Pa quin. '·Rllhlmann,~ De loreruoG.nery wood creations that Jre most sought
pronounces Philippe Garner, internalional huRuhlm.nn '. after today. The finest examples were
head of ::,olh-cemu r,· des ign at Chr istie's, InnovaUvefu.uu executed between 191 6 and 1925, in
legs-contlnuou. to the
~is beyond fashion ." cabin. tra !h", than materials such a, Brazilian ro,ewood,
Born and raised in Paris, Emile-Jacques (or Jacques-Emile, .Uac,,"d. Bek>w:The
de. ;gner·. ivory Macassar ebony, tortoiseshell and i"ory. 73
sourcesdiffer) Ruhlmann took over the family pa inting and dec- marque try coblnet His designs a rc nOlable (or their tedmi-
orating business upon his falher·s d eath, in ' 907. Although ne,·er :~~~r~9.~~~:~~~~' cal demands. Ruhlmann insisted Ihathis
trained as a designe r, he began sketching furniture as ear ly as .round$2million. drawings be translated with the utmost
1897 and first showed his work pub- precision, and often ,he crafts-
lidy in the 1911 Salon d·Automne men had to invent new tech
exh ibilion, where he scored an niques 10 real ize his visions, such
instant hit with the Parisian upper as the rl/,eal/ leg, continuous to
class. In 19 19 he and decorator the cabinet frame. Fluting, rib -
Pierre Laurelll founded thedesign bing, bead ing and inlay were his
hrlll Etablisselllenr Ruhlman n primary decorative accent"
& Laurent. Tothe profession born, although he made use of figured
the designe r knew his audience lIla rq ueuy, as in Ihe 19l[ ama-
frOllllhesta n . ~Li keitor nCl,sTyle ranth wood co rner cabinet
i, fa,h ion. And the lower classes adorned with ivory flowers that
ne'·er set fashion, ~ he told the mag- sold at Christie's Paris in 2006
azine Art ct Decoratioll in 19::.0. for f l .S8 million (S! mi lli on),
In itially using outs ide con - the auclion record for his work.
tractors, the compa ny began doi ng The ma rket for luxu ry
its own work in 19::'}, ultimately goods collapsed around the time
employing a staff o( skilled cabi- of Ruhlmann's dcalh, in 19J} ,
neullake rs, finishers, upholste rers with the world in the mid,t o f
and draft"'1Cn in two locations the Great Depres,ion and design
and expanding into all aspects of becoming mass -mark et. Art
ime rior decor, from lighting and Dcco fell out of fashion shortly
mirrors to textiles and flatware, afler. Its re,·ival hegan in ' 97~,
By the time of the legendary '9~5 with Drouot"s auct ion in Par is
Exposition desArts DecorJtifs et ofco\ltllrier Jacques Doucet"s
Industriels Modernes «(or which collection, the first sale to focus
An Deco was nallled) Ruh lmann exclus ively on Art Deco. In
was the foremost designer ill May 1979, Christie's New York
Paris. AI the fai r, his Pavilion d'ull offered its first Ruhlmann pieces,
WHEN I WORKED ATT HI S .I' AGAZINE 11,"1' years ago, I edited a profile of Gestures aren't made to hang on museum
Gabr iel Orozco that has stuck wilh me cI'er since. The artist described his walls- o r are made not to hang there.
mo rc ephemeral projeCTs- such as when he rolled a g ray pbsr;c;nc hall GeSlU rfs cannot be colie(lfd. They operate
tha!weighed as much as he did th r ough the streets of New York, or when outside the art market. They tease the art collector.
he asked neighbors of the Museum of Modern Art, where he had a show in And gestures cannot be repeated . To quote 77
199}, TO plant oranges on their windowsills for anyone to ha ppen to sec. Robert Irwin, a great artist of the prrsem-tense (who,
He distinguished these works from the big, expens ive art produc- it shou ld be ,aid, colonized leftover or unsanctioned
tions of the 19805. M] wanted rodtange thescale,and that meant giving in MOMA spaces decades before Orozco): "A lways
to sma ll things, to intimate gcstures,~ he said. "A 10\'1' affa ir that lasts one changing, ncvCf twiee the same.~
weekend Can much you morc deeply than nne that lasts 10 yea rs." Gestures, in short, cannot last- and getting
His hopelessl)' romantic statement I think gets at the poWfr of artistic back to Kilke, they a re honest aOOm thfir imperma -
gestu re, to ,udden Iy overwhelm u , - the co"I' de {o"dre feeling of bei ng nence in a way that great oil paintings and bronze
boulrversee that the Frellch hal'e so many terms for. And I\'e been thinking scu lptures, with tbeir claims to monumenta lity,
about what hf sa id nOw that MaM A is staging its big Orozco rflrospf(li\"f. immortality or generations -old provenance, are nOt.
For me the success of the ,how wi II depend in large pa rt on its abi lity to rec ' Which just might be why we kee p trying to
ognize the artist as more than a SClllptor who reinvents objects (the Citroen prese,,"ethem anywar. b oer since Tristan TZJfa and
DS he famously tJ"J.lIsiormed into La D.S., 1993, or his Pillg Pond Table, Ihe Dada gang CUt their hair onstage in the name of
'998, wh ich reim-ellled the fam il iar table -tennis game). Thf mUSfUln" rea I art, art historians ha,'e been busy swef pi ng up the
challenge will be tocapture some of the arti,!"s moree\'ane>eent, poet ic, loose ,t rands tosee what they could make of it . And
Cage -like and koa n-worthy exper iments. For Orozco might be a sculptor, various artists have figured OUI a war to profit from
photographer, draftsman and pai nteron occasion, bm his ephemeral work it-with Tino Sehgal sdlingnonobjects like perfor-
made of humblf, somftimes homely, stuff is Ithink his most powerful. mances as works of art, and Orozco se lling highly
The question that I keep circ Ii ng around is how, or why. W hat makes disposable thing" like yogurt lids, for a price.
an ephemcJ"J.1 exper ience like the sight o f oranges on windowsi lis so power- Theseartists know a fleetinggeslure fuclsour
ful? Wh)' did itseem so r ight when Orozco first nailed a flimsy plastic )'ogurt nostalgia- not for whal was, but for what was prom -
lid toa wall? Howcan a chance encounter re,onate for many years? ised but neverdeli"ered: the idea l (not rea l) relationsh ip
That la,t que,tion is the ,tuff of e legiac poetry, from lamentations promised by the ,hon-lived affair, or the unadulter-
for the loss of good men in Old English sea ba lbds to Rilke's rumination ated happiness promised by a flash ofbeamy.
on unearth Iy desi re. R ilke's Duilm Elegies especially points us in an imer- So it's hard to say exactly how MOMA should
esting di rection because o f its fmphasis On transifncf: expe riences fadi ng acknowledge thf oranges that Orozco used some '5
to the point where life is one big ,'auishing act, with lovers trying toshicld years ago to momentarily br ighten the days o f some
thcmselves from the void with eac h other's face andeach of us, "no maner passersby. Butit'sdea r what the muscumshould not
what we do, always in the poslUre of someone JUSt departing. n do: ffplicat e or reSlJgf the work. The oranges have
[n the art context, 1U0, th e fleeting gesture has some of this poi- long since been thrown away. Only the ghost of the
gnancr- power not just from the p resence of that gesture, but from the image remains true to color- a ghost that arguably
absellceof so much else. haunted the artwork from its "ery inception. !f!
Warhol's ::.o-inch-square Self-Portrait, 1965, which had Ileen con- The fashion IegendValenrino picked up Clockwise /rom
~igned by Cath), Naso, who worked as a reception ist for Warhol's famed David Hockney's iconic though somewhat cenler:A tC~, I.lift".
DOMldh~d ' .!968
Factory while a teenager, sold for a hefty $6, T}0,500 (est. $ ' - ' .5 million ) awkward Califomia Art Collector, 1964, Ufttllle<l(DS$120)
to the jewelrr titan Laurence Graff. The artist had gi\'e n it to Naso as a for $5,'58,500 (est. $5 - 7 million), $Old/orS4.898.500
ondJoonMll<M!I',
token of appreciation for he r service. ~The star~ ali gned ton ight because of Utttllle<l!958ol1
Warhol ruled then'ening, as a work on pa per, Untitled ( Roll of the material," sa id the Sotheby's senior spe- brought S5.4S8.500,
whilethesl... t
Dollar Bills), T961. (est. $l.s - }.s mil- cialist Anthony Grant. Sotheby' •• Andy
lionl,sold to the dealer Larry Gagosian PhiJlipsde Pury & Company wrapped WuhPr, 2000ne
DoII. rsm .. 19&Z.
for $4,n6,500. A smalle r version of up the week with a minor though lively auc- . cored. v<rtlglnou.
the artist's painting Trmafish Disaster, tionon Novemller I l.. ThetOp-lor honor was S4l.7&2.500.
found a bnyer- New York art trad - shared by Yayoi Kusam a'sdensely abstract [llfillit)'
ers Jose Mugrabi and his sons - for Nets (T. \V.A.), ::'000, which sold to the Paris col-
$ 1,l.Ol.,500 (est. $1.S - l. million). leccor Marc Simoncini for S R41.,SOO, and Warhol'S
Rnt the main attraction of the 1964 single Rrillo Soat' Pad Box scul pture in silk-
evening- and the entire season- was screen ink and house painton plywood, which sold
Warho]"s sil kscreen portraying his fa\'or- to a telephone bidder. Simonci ni carne back to nab
iteco mmodity, the almighty doll ar. The Ed Ruscha's small l.OOl. acrylic On cam'as Mea" as
opening bid for 1000ne Dollar Bills Hell (est. $400 - 600,000), for $590,500.
(est. $8 - !Z million) was $6 million. Wh i!e most of the low-key action was con-
Instantly, the Sotheby's special ist Alex fined to anonymous telcphone bidding, there were
Rotter shouted ~$11. million~ from his a few familiar faces in the salesroom, including twO
telephone bidder and a rapid a scent New York dealers: Paub Cooper, who bought Dan
began, in million -dollar increments, to Walsh's Vlltitled, 199 1, a la rge-scale and decidedly
the hammer price oi$39 million. minimal abstraction (cst. $30- 50,000) for $37,500;
The anonymous seller, ru m ored and Edwa rd Tyler Nahem, who grabbed Hernan
to be Pauline Karpidas, the London - Bas's lushly fignrati\'e ~ 006 canvas The to"ely
based col lector known for showing her Martian for $98,5°0 (est. $80- 1::'0,000).
conrempora ry art trove on the Greek One of the strongesT showings was a rare-
island of Hydra, acquired the pai nting to-market grou p of five framed black-and-white
for $385,000 at the Robert Scull estate photographs de picting birds in flight by Fel ix
salein Nm'emocr 1986. T heSculis- col- Gon za lez·Torres from 1994, which realized
lectors who made their fortune with a SS41.,500 (CSt. $l.SO - 3S0,OOO).
Checker taxicab /leet known as the Sculls A stunning installation by Olafur Eli asson,
Angels- boughtthework from Richard , "'J light, composed of halogen lights, steel stands,
Bellamy's Grecn Galler), around 196::. and a fog machine and included in his survcy show at
for an unknown but no doubt minus - the Museum of Modern An laSt yea r, sold to a teie -
cule price. One l\"ew York- based trade phone bidder for S}61,500 (est. hOO - 500,000).
sonrce close to the Warhol market said Despite Ihe sa Ie's modest total, Phi nips's auc -
the buyer was the Greek shipping heir tioneer and chairman Simon de Pury said afterward:
and collector Phi li p Nia rchos. ~It's a distinct ly Ilener mood.~ f£ JUDD TUl l Y
L&MArh
4 5East7BthStreei
'<
-(f) •
Farher,Mi ki o Watanahe, AI~"arlder
centuries, includi ngworl<s byCassatt. GallerySelections Befele in, JaMes stewart. Ciovanni +12128610020
Dewing, Hassam, Ho mer, Hoppe r, Casadei, Harold A l tMa~, ~th Frankli n, j~fo:?tlmgal lerv· corn
Prerlderg ast. Sargent. SIl,nn. Andrew CDS Gall ery Kaoru Saito, Joseph Sweeney,Mart.n www.lmgalle ry.com
Wyet h, Ja-, e Wyet h, Step hen Scolt 74 East 79thSt reet L~wis,Joh n Sloan, Armin Landec k, Important worksof 20th Ce ntury
You ng and others +12127719555 Ma ~;e H:no and ;ntroducing He nry andCon:emporary Art
cdsgalle ry@aol.com Moorearld Tracy Zi~gler
Adl e rli: Con krl g hl Fln e Arl
M. Suth e r la ndFln e Arh , Ltd
« I
-::::J •
24 East71stStreei www.ar tne\.com/g allery/112614/
cd s·gal ler y.h tml Hauser& Wlr lh 55 East BOth Street
+12123080511 32East5gthSt reet
Con:emporary and Modern art from the 2nd Floor
ma i l:?tadle rc on~rjg ht a r ts. com
+12117944 g70 +111114904 28
www.adle rconkr ighta rts.co m Three Americasand Europe. The _ast
in_Mtory 01CDS Gaiery comprise~ newyor k@hause rwi rth.com into@msuthe rland .com
20ln CenturyEuropeanarJd LatOn
AmericanModer n Art. Worl<by
Arch' penko, Arp, Cal der, Delaunay,
paint ings, sculptures and dr aw,p,g sby
internatic na artists: Bonnard , Cuevas.
www.hauserwirth.com
Ida Applebroog:Mona Lisa.January
19through March6, Tuesday thro ugh
www.artnel.com/msutherland.htrnl
, ,
Fi9ari, Gra,.,cko, Le Pare, Malta,
G1e'les,Gros.z, Le Corbus er, Kupka,
Lipch itl, Mack, otero, OZe nfant, Porter.
Soto, Uecker, Va rdanega Monday
Morellet. Nevel son, Pollack, Reveron,
Soto, Spencer, Sterne, Torres ' Garcia ,
Vasa rely, Vuillard, Jo hn Walker, others.
SaturdaY,10-6p.m.
"
1111139.1 60.000
($5.1 ml ion)
Sothebv"s Chinese
• Co ntemporaryArt
2008
• SothebV'sChinese
Cerarrucsfi:
WO""ksof Art
ChrISt",,·SChnese
• Cc ntemporaryArt
Ca tGl,lo·Qllng
Tr.-eeWC<"ks f rom 2007
the serie-;'FOOJteen • Chlistie'sCtwese
Dra·"i~ forAsia·
Cerarmcsfi:
Poclf.c cO'\OmlC Worksof Art
Co·operation..'2001
Chris!ie'S~Kor>g
November 7
111117".300.000
($9.5mU/on) 2006
ZengFanzht
Mask SenesNo. 6
Ov"isti~'s Hong Kong
May2008
$/I1I75 ."16.SOO
(S97mlion)
An.mperi,..yeIlow-
jadebow\I'.i\h
Oiir1loogrrwk
Sothe by' sHong Kor>g
October2009
$IIK12,gIO, OOO
($1.7m. ioo)
l••
•