Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Agriculture is the primary source of livelihood for nearly 55% of Indian population, feeding 1.3 billion
Received 28 February 2020 people and contributing significantly to the country GDP. Tractors play a crucial role in increasing agri-
Accepted 22 April 2020 cultural productivity. Indian tractor industry has come a long way in terms of production capacity and
Available online xxxx
technology in last few decades. Govt. of India is promoting eco-friendly vehicles through Faster
Adoption and Manufacturing of Hybrid and Electric vehicles (FAME) scheme. This paper presents a review
Keywords: of Indian tractor market and points out the government measures to curb the air pollution due to agri-
Electric tractors
cultural machinery. Incorporation of electric drives in tractor and agricultural machinery offer several
Electric vehicle technologies
Indian tractor market
advantages including better energy efficiency and expanded functionalities. State-of-art electric vehicle
Agricultural machinery technologies and latest electric tractors being introduced worldwide are presented in this work. The arti-
Electrification in farming cle discusses the benefits of electrification of farm machinery and present the challenges in its implemen-
tation for agricultural in India. Though high torque, low maintenance, low operational cost and zero
emissions are strong reasons for electric tractor adoption, however, very high initial cost, lack of charging
infrastructure and lack awareness towards vehicle emissions are major deterrents.
Ó 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 2nd International Con-
ference on Advances in Mechanical Engineering and Nanotechnology.
⇑ Corresponding author. Tractors are the modern work horse and traditionally been used
E-mail address: ashish.malik@jaipur.manipal.edu (A. Malik). on farms to mechanize several agricultural tasks and activities.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.585
2214-7853/Ó 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 2nd International Conference on Advances in Mechanical Engineering and Nanotechnology.
Please cite this article as: A. Malik and S. Kohli, Electric tractors: Survey of challenges and opportunities in India, Materials Today: Proceedings, https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.585
2 A. Malik, S. Kohli / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx
the U.S. (95%), Brazil (75%) and China (57%) [6]. However, thanks
to the increased support to farmers by nationalized banks in form
of low interest loans, better agricultural policies by government
and improved penetration of tractor dealerships in rural India,
level of mechanization has seen strong growth in recent decades.
Indian farm machinery market was valued at Rs. 320 billion in
2015–16 and is expected to grow at a CAGR of 5.74% to reach Rs.
400 billion by 2019–20.
Tractor market is among the biggest segments in the category of
farm equipment in the country, with annual sales of 600,000–
700,000 units. Local tractor production in India started in 1961,
and at present there are 16 domestic companies in addition to four
global brands manufacturing tractors on Indian soil. Regarding
market share, five companies in India account for more than 80%
Fig. 1. Benefits of Smart Farming.
of the share in the tractor industry – Mahindra and Mahindra,
TAFE, ITL-Sonalika, Escorts, and John Deere, with Mahindra and
Mahindra being the largest player. Currently, India is the biggest
Modern tractors are used for ploughing, tilling, planting fields,
manufacturer and market in the world for tractors. Fig. 2 shows
reaping and harvesting, in addition to routine lawn care, landscape
that tractor production has seen ups and downs in last few years
maintenance, moving or spreading fertilizer & pesticides and clear-
[6,7]. The country produced 619,000 tractors in 2013, accounting
ing bushes. Tractors offer multiple advantages [2], such as:
for 29% of the total output worldwide. However, there is a sharp
downturn during 2015–16, due to a reduction in farm incomes
Wide range of models and options to suit specific tasks and
because of decline in production of major crops as well as softening
requirements. Starting with compact tractors in a horsepower
commodity prices with lower procurements by the government.
range of 15hp for small farmers growing vegetables up to
Interestingly, as per latest figures from Tractor Manufacturers
40hp for heavy duty landscaping jobs, digging, hauling or
Association [8], FY18 had closed with a record 22 per cent growth
ploughing on large gardens, fields & pastures, orchards and
and sales volumes of 711,478 units, compared to 582,846 units a
vineyards. Bigger rigs (in range of 80 hp and above) are used
year ago. Within the tractor market, the 41–50 HP segment is the
for mechanizing complex farming tasks using farming
largest selling unit, followed by the 31–40 HP segment (Fig. 3).
equipment.
Versatile in design and manufactured to perform a wide range
of tasks in field.
3. Air pollution by tractors
Power and durability to run over rough terrain and pull extre-
mely heavy loads, making them effective in tough farming or
Regulation of emissions for off-road vehicles in India started in
landscape tasks.
1999 through Bharat Tractor Emission (Trem) Stage-I, which was
Ease of transmission and operation with power shift transmis-
implemented for agricultural diesel tractors. In 2003, the imple-
sion and hydrostatic transmission to simplify operations
mentation of Stage-II set PM emission limits for the first time [9].
These limits were further tightened in 2005 through Stage-III.
The aim of this study is to present electric tractors as an alter-
However, the emission standards of Stage-I, II and III had one set
native solution to polluting IC engine-based tractors. As the auto-
of limits for all engine capacities, which was not justified. At pre-
motive industry is witnessing the paradigm shift towards electric
sent, tractors are under Bharat Stage IIIA regulations, which was
mobility, the farming tractor industry must not fall behind with
implemented in 2010 and 2011. These limits followed the Euro-
traditional diesel engines. Several tractor and farm machinery
pean Union’s (EU’s) Stage III and differentiated the emission stan-
manufacturers such as John Deere, Fendt, Solectrac, Rigitrac, Claas,
dards for off-road vehicles by engine size. Engines larger than
Escorts, Kubota and Schaffer have been working on electrification
37 kW (50 hp) have more stringent limits. Table 1 summarize the
of farm machinery and showcased their electric tractor prototypes
emission limits of all Bharat stage standards. The Automotive
at different trade exhibitions [3] and pilot scale implementations
Research Association of India (ARAI) has published a summary of
are in process. This paper is studying the benefits and challenges
emissions regulations [10] that propose emission standards for
associated with adaptation of electric tractors in Indian scenario.
Please cite this article as: A. Malik and S. Kohli, Electric tractors: Survey of challenges and opportunities in India, Materials Today: Proceedings, https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.585
A. Malik, S. Kohli / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx 3
Table 1
Bharat stage emission limits for agricultural diesel tractors.
Please cite this article as: A. Malik and S. Kohli, Electric tractors: Survey of challenges and opportunities in India, Materials Today: Proceedings, https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.585
4 A. Malik, S. Kohli / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx
650 V and 100 kWh capacity lithium-ion battery pack. Battery can 5.1. Advantages of electric tractors
be charged either with 400 V and up to 22 kW via a standard CEE
outdoor socket, or by a standard CCS type 2 plug to recharge up Electric tractors have a numerous advantage when compared to
to 80% in just 40 min. diesel counterparts, such as sustainability, agronomic process effi-
American manufacturer John Deere [20] unveiled its electric ciency, technical efficiency, higher safety, improved ergonomics,
tractor named SESAM in 2016 with total power output of up to cabin space, operator comfort and safety, comfort and reliability.
300 kW (402 hp) from two 150 kW electric motors for each axle
receiving supply from Li-ion battery pack of 130 kWh capacity. Zero Emission
Indian manufacturer Escorts [21] has launched its zero-
emission electric tractor Farmtrac 26E aiming for vineyards and Electric tractors produce zero CO2 and NOX emissions and other
the horticulture market. This compact tractor is driven by regular type of air pollution. It is often argued that the electricity used for
constant mesh transmission via a 19 kW (25.5 hp) electric motor charging is sometimes generated by coal based or fossil fuel-based
and 21 kWh Li-ion battery pack providing about 6 h of working power plants. However, the supply of clean electricity into the grid
time. from renewable sources (solar/ wind) is continuously increasing
Swiss manufacturer Rigitrac [22] has introduced Rigitrac SKE and hence eliminate emissions.
50, a fully electric driven compact tractor utilizing 4 electric
motors, 1 for the front axle, 1 for the rear axle and 1 on each power High Torque
take-off (front and rear) with total power output of 50 kW (68 bhp) Farming activities demand very high amount of torque. Unlike
receiving energy from 80 kWh (400 V) Li-ion battery pack IC engines, electric motors provide constant torque in low speed
Please cite this article as: A. Malik and S. Kohli, Electric tractors: Survey of challenges and opportunities in India, Materials Today: Proceedings, https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.585
A. Malik, S. Kohli / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx 5
region from start and provide constant power in the high-speed optimization of powertrain structures. When compared to conven-
region [18]. They have the potential to produce more torque than tional tractors, electric tractors are very quiet [25] and lack vibra-
IC engines. This characteristic of electric motors is ideal for farming tions, hence offer silent, smooth and comfortable ride reducing the
activities such as ploughing. stress for driver during long working hours at the time of
harvesting.
Improved Dynamics using In-Wheel Motors
Low Running Cost using Renewable Energy
In terms of dynamics, controllability and flexibility of electric
drives are superior to any other solution. Conceivably, a tractor If a farm uses renewable power such as biogas, solar or wind
could have separately controlled electric motors on each wheel, power, charging and operating the tractor will be CO2 neutral
increasing maneuverability and saving weight by eliminating the and extremely economical. At the same time, the high-capacity
need for steering linkages and transmissions. Such arrangement battery can store excess power and feed it back into the grid. EVs
allows all-wheel drive and all-wheel steering possibilities. can be charged with renewable energy like SOLAR and WIND
Research has shown [23] that by active control of electric pow- energy at home or workplace or at public charging stations.
ertrain, the steady-state and transient dynamic characteristics of
the vehicle can be manipulated without changing the common Less Maintenance & Longer Life
chassis parameters such as mass distribution and suspension
elasto-kinematics. Furthermore, the low response time and high The number of moving components in an EV are far lesser com-
controllability of electric motor drives can bring significant bene- pared to an IC engine vehicle, hence electric tractors will have
fits for the feedback control of vehicle yaw rate and sideslip angle longer working life and reduced maintenance cost than conven-
in emergency conditions. tional ones. Use of electric drive for implements instead of hydro-
static drives further increase the savings with reduced hydraulic oil
More Comfortable with Reduced NVH amount.
Please cite this article as: A. Malik and S. Kohli, Electric tractors: Survey of challenges and opportunities in India, Materials Today: Proceedings, https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.585
6 A. Malik, S. Kohli / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx
and pave the way for full autonomous and connected tractor fleet nity. India being a cost sensitive market; high initial cost will be
performing farming tasks with minimal human intervention. biggest obstacle in success of electric tractors in India.
Replacing hydraulics with electronics enhances safety from Majority of Indian farmers often lack enough skills for using
dangerously high hydraulic pressures, hose leaks, high power advanced machinery. Electric tractors with advanced driver infor-
draws on the engine and excessive heat loads. Smart controls for mation display (user interface) will pose a challenge. Although
thermal management of battery pack and electric drives ensure electric tractors without clutch and gear box are comparatively
increased safety. easy to drive, digital controls demand thorough training of farmers
for efficient and smooth operation.
Precise Control of Implements
Lack of adequate charging infrastructure
The application of electric drives on implements provides mul-
tiple benefits for implements such as enhanced controllability of India is struggling to supply 247 electricity to every individual
power flow, optimized power distribution across implement struc- in the country. In this context, charging of electric tractors will be a
tures, simple plug & play operation for implements [28]. challenge, particularly in rural areas. It necessitates the installation
Unlike traditional common architectures, the electric tractor of solar farms in the vicinity to provide renewable off-grid supply
will provide an adequate number of controlled power outputs. of power.
Power electronics will enable precise control of independently con-
trolled drive systems incorporated in design of the implement.
Locally controlled electric motors can overcome the restrictions 7. Conclusion
of mechanical and hydraulic solutions meeting the requirements
of attached machines. The ISOBUS is the necessary communication This study presented a short survey about the potential for elec-
bus between tractor and implement [29]. AEF (Agricultural Indus- tric tractors in India. The referenced literature show that electric
try Electronics Foundation) is developing standardized tractor- tractors are being proved to be successful in the field, but still in
implement interface, enhancing the usability of interchangeable nascent stage even in developed countries. Electric tractors are
electric implements and tractors. the perfect companion for a farmer due to lower operating costs
over entire lifecycle and a major step to controlling emissions.
However high initial cost and lack of charging infrastructure are
6. Challenges for Indian scenario major deterrents to acceptance of electric tractors in India.
Though low levels of tractor penetration in India at present
Agriculture profitability is strongly dependent on the agricul- indicates strong potential for tractor sales, strong government sup-
tural equipment used, the infrastructure and the workforce. port in form of availability of finance for agriculture mechanization
Agricultural equipment comprises all mobile and stationary and rural development is needed. Government can help introduce
machinery and equipment used for indoor coupled with electric tractors by setting up centers for leasing electric tractors
high-speed transport and present a particularly tough challenge and its implements to small and marginal farmers on pay per use
for electric propulsion systems. through PPP model with tractor manufacturers. Bigger farmers
with large farms should be provided financial assistance in the
Extreme operating environment form of subsidy for the purchase of electric tractors and allied agri-
cultural equipment.
The operating environment for farm machinery in Indian sce- The electric tractor technology is promising and undergoing
nario is quite extreme due to dust, dirt, high humidity and temper- continuous improvement. However, the ecosystem for wide accep-
atures up to 4648 °C in summers. It demands durable and reliable tance and large-scale usage in India will definitely take decade
power electronics components and efficient thermal management worth of time.
for electronics components, battery pack and electric motor. Active
thermal management to cool the systems will deplete the battery
faster. Declaration of Competing Interest
Battery technology The authors declare that they have no known competing finan-
cial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared
The major challenge is battery efficiency. Existing battery tech- to influence the work reported in this paper.
nologies have yet not achieved the power density and energy den-
sity to compete with IC engines based conventional tractors in the References
field work. Mere increasing the battery size adds to high cost and
weight of the vehicle, which reduces the overall efficiency of the [1] J.D. Parker, L.J. Akinbami, T.J. Woodruff, Air pollution and childhood respiratory
vehicle. allergies in the United States, Environ. Health Perspect. 117 (1) (2009) 140–
147.
[2] H.P. Binswanger, The Economics of Tractors in South Asia, Agricultural
High initial cost Development Council, New York, 1978.
[3] Agritechnica Event (https://www.agritechnica.com/en/).
[4] Annual Report, 70 Years of farmers’ journey, Indian Council of Food and
The initial cost of any electric vehicle (including electric trac-
Agriculture, (2017).
tors) is 2–3 times higher than similarly capable IC engine-based [5] Annual Report, Agricultural Statistics at a Glance, Govt. of India, Directorate of
vehicle. Battery cost contributes around 30%–50% of the total vehi- Economics & Statistics, (2016).
cle cost. Though cost of Li-ion based battery pack has decreased [6] Report, Indian Farm Mechanization Market, Indian Council of Food and
Agriculture, (2017).
from more than $600 per kWh in 2010 to approx. 150$ per kWh [7] Report, Sector Report: Tractors, CRISIL, (2018).
lately, electric tractors are still beyond reach of farming commu- [8] Tractors and Mechanisation Association of India (www.tmaindia.in/).
Please cite this article as: A. Malik and S. Kohli, Electric tractors: Survey of challenges and opportunities in India, Materials Today: Proceedings, https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.585
A. Malik, S. Kohli / Materials Today: Proceedings xxx (xxxx) xxx 7
[9] Z. Shao, An Emissions Inventory for Agricultural Tractors and Construction [20] F. Lambert, John Deere unveils latest all-electric tractor prototype for zero-
Equipment in India, International Council of Clean Transportation, 2016. emission agriculture, (2016-12), (https://electrek.co/2016/12/05/john-deere-
[10] Indian Emissions Regulations Booklet, Automotive Research Association of electric-tractor-prototype/).
India, (2016). [21] Escorts Agri Machinery Ltd (https://www.escortsgroup.com/agri-machinery/).
[11] N.N. Clark, NOx/Fuel Tradeoff for Powertrain Technologies, International [22] J. Breen, Fully electric Swiss tractor is now a reality, (2019-01), (https://www.
Council on Clean Transportation, 2013. agriland.ie/farming-news/fully-electric-swiss-tractor-is-now-a-reality/).
[12] R.D. Reitz, G. Duraisamy, Review of high efficiency and clean reactivity [23] L.D. Novellis, A. Sorniotti, et al., Torque vectoring for electric vehicles with
controlled compression ignition (RCCI) combustion in internal combustion individually controlled motors: state-of-the-art and future developments,
engines, Prog. Energy Combust. Sci. 46 (2015) 12–71. World Electric Vehicle J. 5 (2012) 0617.
[13] J. Du, W. Sun, et al., Experimental study on fuel economies and emissions of [24] S. Wang, J. Jouvray, T. Kalos, NVH Technologies and Challenges on Electric
direct-injection premixed combustion engine fueled with gasoline/diesel Powertrain, SAE Technical Paper 2018-01-1551 (2018).
blends, Energy Convers. Manage. 100 (2015) 300–309. [25] U. Sandberg, L. Goubert, P. Mioduszewski, Are vehicles driven in electric mode
[14] S.K. Mandal, A. Maity, Current trends of Indian Tractor Industry: a critical so quiet that they need acoustic warning signals? Proceedings of 20th
review, Appl. Sci. Rep. 3 (2) (2013) 132–139. International Congress on Acoustics, (2010) Sydney Australia.
[15] S.E. Lucena, A survey on electric and hybrid electric vehicle technology, [26] B. Kvezereli, Why electric tractors lead cars in the race to self drive, (2018-09)
InTechOpen ISBN: 978-953-307-287-6. (https://innovationanarchy.com/electric-tractors-lead-cars-race-to-self-drive/
[16] R.O. Magalhaes, M.V. da Assuncao, et al., Review on applications of electric #.XE9RAVUzbIU).
vehicles in the countryside, Ciencia Rural 47 (7) (2017) 1–9. [27] L. Xia, China’s first driverless electric tractor starts working, Xinhua (2019-01)
[17] J. Caban, J. Vrabel, B. Sarkan, et al., Analysis of the market of electric tractors in (http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2019-01/27/c_137779454.htm).
agricultural production, MATEC Web of Conferences 244 (2018) 03005. [28] J. Scott, Improving tractors, implements with electrification, (2017-03-29),
[18] M. Ehsani, Y. Gao, A. Emadi, Electric vehicles, Modern Electric, Hybrid Electric (https://www.agriculture.com/machinery/tractors/improving-tractors-
and Fuel Cell Vehicles, CRC Press, New York, 2010. implements-with-electrification).
[19] Press release, ‘‘Fendt e100 Vario: The battery-powered compact tractor”, Fendt [29] ISOBUS Brochure, AEF: Powering Agricultural Electronics, Agricultural
(2017-09-18) (https://www.fendt.com/int/fendt-e100-vario.html). Industry Electronics Foundation (https://www.aef-online.org/home.html).
Please cite this article as: A. Malik and S. Kohli, Electric tractors: Survey of challenges and opportunities in India, Materials Today: Proceedings, https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.04.585