Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Of
CHEMISTRY
Session 2010-11
Hitesh Rana
X11
Common Adulterants/Contaminants
in food and Simple screening tests
for their detection
Modern-day diets high in hydrogenated vegetable oils instead of
traditional animal fats are implicated in causing a significant increase
in heart disease and cancer.
This was the lipid hypothesis: namely, that saturated fat and
cholesterol from animal sources raise cholesterol levels in the blood,
leading to deposition of cholesterol and fatty material as pathogenic
plaques in the arteries.
A 1957 study of the largely vegetarian Bantu found that they had as
much atheroma - occlusions or plaque build-up in the arteries - as
other races from South Africa who ate more meat.5
All of these studies pointed to the fact that the thickening of the
arterial walls is a natural, unavoidable process. The lipid hypothesis did
not hold up to these population studies, nor did it explain the tendency
toward fatal clots that caused myocardial infarction.
The irony of Gotto's letter is that De Bakey, the famous heart surgeon,
co-authored a 1964 study involving 1,700 patients, which also showed
no definite correlation between serum cholesterol levels and the
nature and extent of coronary artery disease.10 In other words, those
with low cholesterol levels were just as likely to have blocked arteries
as those with high cholesterol levels.
The book was sponsored by makers of Mazola corn oil and Mazola
margarine.
Stamler did not believe that lack of evidence should deter Americans
from changing their eating habits. The evidence, he stated, was
"...compelling enough to call for altering some habits even before the
final proof is nailed down... the definitive proof that middle-aged men
who reduce their blood cholesterol will actually have far fewer heart
attacks waits upon diet studies now in progress."
His version of the Prudent Diet called for substituting low-fat milk
products such as skim milk and low-fat cheeses for cream, butter and
whole cheeses, reducing egg consumption and cutting the fat off red
meats. Heart disease, he lectured, was a disease of rich countries,
striking rich people who ate rich food, including 'hard' fats like butter.
It was in the same year, 1966, that the results of Dr Jolliffe's Anti-
Coronary Club experiment were published in JAMA.12 Those on the
Prudent Diet of corn oil, margarine, fish, chicken and cold cereal had
an average serum cholesterol of 220, compared to 250 in the meat-
and-potatoes control group.
However, the study authors were obliged to note that there were eight
deaths from heart disease among Dr Jolliffe's Prudent Diet group, and
none among those who ate meat three times a day. Dr Jolliffe was
dead by this time. He succumbed in 1961 from a vascular thrombosis,
although the obituaries listed the cause of death as "complications
from diabetes".
The compelling "proof" that Stamler and others were sure would
vindicate wholesale tampering with American eating habits had not yet
been "nailed down".
The problem, said the insiders promoting the lipid hypothesis, was that
the numbers involved in the Anti-Coronary Club experiment were too
small. Dr Irving Page urged a National Diet-Heart Study involving one
million men, in which the results of the Prudent Diet could be
compared on a large scale with those on a diet high in meat and fat.
With great media attention, the National Heart, Lung and Blood
Institute organised the stocking of food warehouses in six major cities,
where men on the Prudent Diet could get tasty polyunsaturated
doughnuts and other fabricated food items free of charge.
But a pilot study, involving 2,000 men, resulted in exactly the same
number of deaths in both the Prudent Diet group and the control
group. A brief report in Circulation (March 1968) stated that the study
was a milestone "in mass environmental experimentation" that would
have "an important effect on the food industry and the attitude of the
public toward its eating habits".
Most animal fats - like butter, lard and tallow - have a large proportion
of saturated fatty acids. Saturated fats are straight chains of carbon
and hydrogen that pack together easily so that they are relatively solid
at room temperature. Oils from seeds are composed mostly of
polyunsaturated fatty acids.
The process was used on both cotton-seed oil and lard to give "better
physical properties", to create shortenings that did not melt as easily
on hot days.
When one hydrogen atom is moved to the other side of the fatty acid
molecule during hydrogenation, the ability of living cells to make
reactions at the site is compromised or altogether lost. Trans fatty
acids are sufficiently similar to natural fats that the body readily
incorporates them into the cell membrane; once there, their altered
chemical structure creates havoc with thousands of necessary
chemical reactions - everything from energy provision to prostaglandin
production.
Certain forms of trans fatty acids occur naturally in dairy fats. Trans
vaccenic acid makes up about four per cent of the fatty acids in butter.
It is an interim product which the ruminant animal then converts to
conjugated linoleic acid, a highly beneficial anti-carcinogenic
component of animal fat. Humans seem to utilise the small amounts of
trans vaccenic acid in butter fat without ill effects.
The unstated solution was one that could be easily presented to the
public: eat natural, traditional fats; avoid newfangled foods made from
vegetable oils; use butter, not margarine.
Although the AHA had committed itself to the lipid hypothesis and the
unproven theory that polyunsaturated oils afforded protection against
heart disease, concerns about hydrogenated vegetable oils were
sufficiently great to warrant the inclusion of the following statement in
the organisation's 1968 diet heart statement: "Partial hydrogenation of
polyunsaturated fats results in the formation of trans forms which are
less effective than cis, cis forms in lowering cholesterol concentrations.
While 150,000 copies of the statement were printed, they were never
distributed. The shortening industry objected strongly, and a
researcher named Fred Mattson of Procter & Gamble convinced
Campbell Moses, medical director of the AHA, to remove it.13 The final
recommendations for the public contained three major points:
restrict calories
substitute polyunsaturates for saturates
reduce cholesterol in the diet
Other organisations fell in behind the AHA in pushing vegetable oils
instead of animal fats. By the early 1970s, the National Heart, Lung
and Blood Institute, the AMA, the American Dietetic Association and
the National Academy of Sciences had all endorsed the lipid hypothesis
and the avoidance of animal fats for those Americans in the 'at risk'
category.
Since Kritchevsky's early studies, many other trials had shown that
serum cholesterol can be lowered by increasing ingestion of
polyunsaturates. The physiological explanation for this is that when
excess polyunsaturates are built into the cell membranes, resulting in
reduced structural integrity or 'limpness', cholesterol is sequestered
from the blood into the cell membranes to give them 'stiffness'.
The problem was that there was no proof that lowering serum
cholesterol levels could stave off CHD.
Adulteration in food is normally present in its most crude form,
prohibited substances are either added or partly or wholly substituted.
In India normally the contamination/adulteration in food is done either
for financial gain or due to carelessness and lack in proper hygienic
condition of processing, storing, transportation and marketing. This
ultimately results that the consumer is either cheated or often become
victim of diseases. Such types of adulteration are quite common in
developing countries or backward countries. However, adequate
precautions taken by the consumer at the time of purchase of such
produce can make him alert to avoid procurement of such food. It is
equally important for the consumer to know the common adulterants
and their effect on health.
NOTE : Safe limits have been prescribed for above metals in different food.
Continuous use of food contaminated with these metals beyond safe limits
may cause these diseases
Bacterial
contamination
20 Bacillus cereus Cereal products, custards, Food infection (nausea,
puddings, sauces vomiting, abdominal pain,
diarrhoea)
21 Salmonella spp. Meat and meat products, Salmonellosis (food infection
raw vegetables, salads, usually with fever and chills)
shell-fish, eggs and egg
products, warmed-up
leftovers
22 Shigella sonnei Milk, potato, beans, poultry, Shigellosis (bacillary
tuna, shrimp, moist mixed dysentery)
foods
23 Staphylococcus aureus Dairy products, baked foods Increased salivation,
Entero-toxins-A,B,C,D or especially custard or cream- vomiting, abdominal cramp,
E filled foods, meat and meat diarrhoea, severe thirst, cold
products, low-acid frozen sweats, prostration
foods, salads, cream
sauces, etc.
24 Clostridium botulinus Defectively canned low or Botulism (double vision,
toxins medium-acid foods; meats, muscular paralysis, death
A,B,E or F sausages, smoked vacuum- due to respiratory failure)
packed fish, fermented food
etc.
25 Clostridium.perfringens Milk improperly processed Nausea, abdominal pains,
(Welchii) type A or canned meats, fish and diarrhoea, gas formation
gravy stocks
26 Diethyl stilbestrol (additive Meat Sterlites, fibroid tumors etc.
in animal feed)
27 3,4 Benzopyrene Skoked food Cancer
28 Excessive solvent residue Solvent extracted oil, oil Carcinogenic effect
cake etc.
29 Non-food grade or Food Blood clot, angiosarcoma,
contaminated cancer etc.
packing material
30 Non-permitted colour or Coloured food Mental retardation, cancer
permitted food colour and other toxic effect.
beyond safe limit
31 BHA and BHT beyond Oils and fats Allergy, liver damage,
safe limit increase in serum
chloresterol etc.
32 Monosodium Chinese food, meat and Brain damage, mental
glutamate(flour) meat products retardation in infants
(beyond safe limit)
33 Coumarin and dihydro Flavoured food Blood anticoagulant
coumarin
34 Food flavours beyond Flavoured food Chances of liver cancer
safe limit
35 Brominated vegetable oils Cold drinks Anemia, enlargement of
heart
36 Sulphur dioxide and In variety of food as Acute irritation of the gastro-
sulphite beyond safe preservative intestinal tracts etc.
limit
37 Artificial sweetners Sweet foods Chances of cancer
beyond safe limit
Fungal contamination
38 Aflatoxins Aspergillus flavus- Liver damage and cancer
contaminated foods such as
groundnuts, cottonseed, etc.
39 Ergot alkaloids from Ergot-infested bajra, rye Ergotism (St.Anthony’s fire-
Claviceps purpurea meal or bread burning sensation in
Toxic alkaloids, extremities, itching of skin,
ergotamine, peripheral gangrene)
ergotoxin and
ergometrine groups
40 Toxins from Grains (millet, wheat, oats, Alimentary toxic
Fusarium sporotrichioides rye,etc) aleukia(ATA) (epidemic
panmyelotoxicosis)
41 Toxins from Fusarium Moist grains Urov disease (Kaschin-Beck
sporotrichiella disease)
42 Toxins from Yellow rice Toxic mouldy rice disease
Penicillium inslandicum
Penicillium atricum,
Penicillium citreovirede,
Fusarium, Rhizopus,
Aspergillus
43 Sterigmatocystin from Foodgrains Hepatitis
Aspergillus versicolour
Aspergillus nidulans and
bipolaris
44 Ascaris lumbricoides Any raw food or water Ascariasis
contaminated by human
faces containing eggs of the
parasite
45 Entamoeba histolytica Raw vegetables and fruits Amoebic dysentery
Viral