Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Vol.02 2018
www.unescoicm.org
ISSN
IS SN : 2635-8816 j
CO N T E N TS
EDITORIAL REMARK 02
WIDE ANGLE
• LESVOS ‘Islands of Hope’ Refugee Youth Program 03
• Cerebral Palsy, No Match 07
• My Karate Journey From Kenya 09
04
ZOOM
• Gender Equity in Martial Arts 13
INSIDE ICM 23
Throughout the year of 2018, ICM has carried out a wide range of projects to contribute
not only in the promotion of philosophies and cultural values of martial arts for youth
development and engagement, but also in the founding goals of UNESCO which are
peace and humanity.
Martial Arts Open School provided youth in Africa and least developed countries,
an opportunity to develop themselves through martial arts training and education.
International Youth Martial Arts Camp served as a platform for youth to communicate
with each other and train both their body and mind.
In addition, the inaugural African Regional Martial Arts Congress allowed martial arts
experts in Africa, a priority region for UNESCO, to initiate in discussions related to
martial arts, marking the first step in the region to increase awareness in martial arts
for youth and women.
This year’s ICM Insight is themed upon ‘Martial Arts for ALL’ and consists of articles
that share stories of martial arts participation beyond the boundaries of nationality,
disability, gender and more. It is a great pleasure that through ICM Insight we are able
to bring values of martial arts into spotlight.
ICM will continue pursuing the spirit in which the Sustainable Development Goals of
UN were established under: Leave No One Behind. We will exert our utmost efforts to
create environments where everyone can take part in martial arts activities, implanting
the values of peace and reconciliation in the lives of youth with martial arts.
Among different camera lenses, wide angle allows to fit more into the frame than what can normally be seen
WIDE ANGLE
by the human eye. In this section, ICM Insight will cover a wide array of contents on martial arts.
Peace Empowerment
Methodology for the
children and young Turkey
Greece
Moria Camp
Nir Zamir
Algeria Saudi
Arabia
the Middle East have generated a bouts and incidents of violence at the
existence between communities
ways and means to better these way it evolves throughout the years, would look like a typical martial arts
refugees’ lives by introducing our consistently integrating input and practice. The teaching of these values
‘Value-Do’ methodology to them in updates proposed by our instructors is experienced-based, thus has much
the context of the ‘Islands of Hope’ in the field. more impact on the target audience.
program. One of the main impact-points
of exposing youth to traditional
martial arts practice is the reduction
About Budo for Peace Unique Value Proposition
in violent behavior among them –
Budo for Peace is a Budo for Peace has a comprehensive a topic that has been and is being
registered Israeli non- educational program specifically consistently researched and validated
profit educational designed to empower kids at in many academic studies. One such
organization with the risk, guide children and young study has recently been shared in
mission to promote adults to develop effective self- the Jerusalem Post1) and similar
social harmony and non-violence control; become mindful of the evidence exists in multiple dedicated
among children and young adults, individual’s responsibility within their research campaigns conducted in
as well as train them to become community; aim to maximize their many countries. Budo for Peace
responsible young leaders in the personal potential as they mature; has in this context been awarded
future. The values our educational and practice social harmony and prestigious ‘Regional NGO of the Year’
program include: Courtesy, Self- coexistence. In this context, our by the International Peace and Sport
Control, Integrity, Humility, Social ‘Value-Do’ methodology is the only organization based in Monaco2). A
Harmony, Order, Responsibility, program in the world making use of table about extensive Psychological-
Love for Humanity, and Respecting traditional martial arts techniques Sociological research that shows
the other. In Israel we regularly and code-of-conduct towards consistent correlation between youth
empower thousands of children with guiding individuals to embrace a set exposure to martial arts practice and
this program, already for the past 14 of values and behavioral attitudes the reduction of violent behavior is
years, with great success. Students that decrease violence and enhance provided at the end of this article.
of this program include Bedouin, social harmony. The ‘Value-Do’
Christian, Jewish, Muslim, secular methodology integrates a set of 9
as well as religious communities, values in the application of selected
kids-at-risk, and youth with special martial arts techniques and exercises,
needs and disabilities. Throughout thus educating the practitioners as
our operation we have seen the they experience what to an outsider
positive impact of the ‘Value-Do’
educational system over our students
to include significant reduction of
violence among them, as well as
their tendency to maximize their
individual potential, and pursue
social harmony. This is in line with
many academic studies that validate
the connection between martial
arts teaching and the reduction of
violent behavior. Sensei Robeen
Arkia, Budo for Peace’s 7TH Dan
Education Director, Chief Operating
Officer and Chief Instructor explains
that one of the reasons the ‘Value-Do’
system is so effective – is due to the
fact that it remains dynamic in the
(C) 2018 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED, JORDAN POLEVOY, JORDAN@VEXA.COM
•O
ffer the kids and youth at Kara •O
ffer the camps’ leaderships and
Value-Do Education on Tepe and Moria Camp a ‘Value- the relevant adult-community a
Do’ course, facilitated by local program designed to decrease
Islands of Hope
martial arts instructors specifically and minimize breakouts of violent
Through our partnerships with local trained to provide this unique behaviour among the camp’s
non-governmental organizations teaching which is designed to children and youth.
already operating in these refugee inspire them towards personal
camps, and by training of local empowerment, responsible • Introduce the programs participants
martial arts sensei, instructors, conduct as they mature, and social – and through them their parents
of various styles to apply our harmony with their peers of any and communities – to the educational
methodology, the plan is to extend origin. These values are especially content of the Budo for Peace program,
our program to about 150 children critical at a time in which this i.e. harmonious coexistent, self-
for the first year of operations. audience is experiencing significant control, social responsibility, etc.
These children are inhabitants disadvantages and individual
of the refugee shelter-camps set hardships and loss.
up by the Greek government and
several international humanitarian
organization led by the Israeli non-
governmental organization IsraAid,
and classes are meant to occur in
the School of Peace3) managed by
this nonprofit organization on the
island.
3)The School of Peace is run by IsraAid with the aim to provide quality education to the 4,000 refugee children and youth on Lesvos
Island. By cooperating with Budo for Peace, IsraAid can now add physical education in the curriculum.
WIDE ANGLE • 06
Year Author Sample size Target group Methodology Martial Art Measured Effect Positive or Negative Effect among Martial Artists
Self-confidence, dominance,
1978 Duthie et al. 152 Karate, etc
Cross-sectional autonomy, achievement,
Positive among advanced martial artists
Konzak & (level of experience) General development(personality
1980 84 General
Klavora factors and physical well-being)
Karate
Richman & Cross-sectional (level of
1986 60 Self-esteem Positive among advanced martial artists
Rehberg experience+ performance)
Anxiety, self-esteem and social Positive among advanced and successful
1986 Trulson 34 Youth Longitudinal (type of guidance) Taekwondo
adroitness martial artists
McGrowan &
1989 107 Longitudinal (type of guidance) Karate Angry Positive among traditional martial artists
Miller
General
1990 Layton 93 Karate Trait and state anxiety
1993 Kurian et al. 30 Cross-sectional Taekwondo Anxiety and independence Positive among less successful martial
(level of experience) artists
Self-reliance and enthusiastic
1994 Kurian et al. 72 Youth Taekwondo
optimism
2003 Najafi 118 General Cross-sectional (type of guidance) Karate Humility and overall levels of hope Positive among traditional martial artists
Cross-sectional
2007 Kuan & Roy 40 Wushu Self-confidence and energy control Positive among successful martial artists
(level of performance)
General
Cross-sectional Taekwondo,
2007 Wargo et al. 40 Self-esteem Neither positive nor negative
(level of experience) Karate
Taekwondo,
Cross-sectional Personal growth and self-
2009 Steyn & Roux 72 Youth Hockey, non- Positive among martial artists
(comparison different groups) acceptance
sport group
Year Author Sample size Target group Methodology Martial art Measured effect Positive or Negative Effect among Martial Artists
1980 Rothpearl 152 Cross-sectional Karate Hostility
1981 Nosan-chuk 41 (level of experience) Karate Aggressive fantasy Hostility
General
Cross-sectional (level of
Daniels & Karate, Jiu-jitsu,
1990 80 experience)+(comparison Hostility
Thornton Badminton, Rugby, control Positive among advanced martial artists
different martial arts)
1991 Skelton et al. 68 Youth Taekwondo Aggressiveness
Cross-sectional
Daniels & (level of experience) Karate, Jiu-jitsu,
1992 79 General Hostility
Thornton Badminton, Rugby,
Longitudinal
1994 Edelman 15 Youth Aikido Hostility and aggressiveness Positive over time among martial artists
(school-linked program)
Lamarre & Cross-sectional
1999 51 Judo Aggressiveness Positive among advanced martial artists
Nosan chuk (level of experience)
General Cross-sectional Karate, Wrestling and
Bjorkqvist & Attitudes towards violent Positive among Male, negative among female
2001 319 (comparison different Boxing, non-contact sport,
Varhama conflict resolution karate
martial arts) no sports
Longitudinal
2001 Zivin et al. 60 Kempo Hostility and aggressiveness Positive over time among martial artists
(school-linked program)
Cross-sectional
Reynes & No difference compared to control(judo more
2001 150 (comparison different Judo, Karate, control
Lorant anger than control)
martial arts)
Reynes &
2002 8 Judo, control Negative compared to control group
Lorant(a)
Longitudinal
Reynes & Aggressiveness No effect compared to control, positive effect
2002 9 Youth Karate, control
Lorant(b) compared to judo
Boxing, Weightlifting,
Endresen & Violent and antisocial
2005 477 Longitudinal Wrestling, oriental martial Negative among martial artists
Olweus behavior
arts, non-participants
Cross-sectional
2007 Wargo et al. 40 General Taekwondo, Karate Aggressiveness Neither positive nor negative
(level of experience)
Cross-sectional
Taekwondo, Hockey, non- Verbal aggression and
2009 Steyn & Roux 72 Youth (comparison different Positive among martial artists
participants hostility
martial arts)
07 •
Adaptive Martial Arts not practical for someone in a actually starting to achieve my
wheelchair. Whether the person goals. Master Finn made adaptions
Training
in a wheelchair is the attacker or to techniques, focusing on ‘what
As a child of the 1970s and 80s, I is being attacked, a strong enough worked’ for me instead of taking
grew up watching martial arts shows embrace to control the person is a ‘by-the-book approach’, while
and movies which got me interested. near impossible. So the original still honoring tradition. In Tracy’s
At that time, training someone with technique is not practical. However, Kenpo, we have a technique called
a disability was unheard of. I was so focused on getting the ‘7-swords’. ‘7 Swords’ involves 7
So, my training was solely informal. movements exact that I didn’t open hand strikes. In this technique,
I began training myself using books. see the benefits of the underlying the steps and weight shifts increase
Looking back, the ‘training’ –if you principles each technique intended the speed and power of the strikes.
call it that—was horrible. With the to teach. Despite these difficulties in My adaptation of this technique
knowledge and understanding training, I was just happy that it fed includes keeping the hand strikes
I have now, I would say it was my desire to learn martial arts. but removing the foot movements.
horrible because I didn’t understand This still teaches the hand strikes
At the age of 31, I began training
the concept of adapting techniques and is still effective. Thus we are
in Tracy’s Kenpo after reading a
to my needs. honoring the original while making
local newspaper article about a
For example, a bearhug-a bearhug is it work for me.
school owner who had a similar
a type of attack where the attacker disability. However, it was not until This taught me that the right
uses a firm and rough embrace my new instructor, master Steve teacher is the key to success. I
to control you from the rear- is Finn, took over that I felt like I was began to advance in grade then
1)AMAA is a not for profit organization which strives to provide resources to both martial arts students and instructors alike.
If a potential student with disability wants to start training, AMAA tries matching them with training opportunities in their local area.
For instructors AMAA provides training and guidance when they have question on a disability or on adapting their content.
WIDE ANGLE • 08
My Karate Journey
From Kenya
Lona Apiyo Abiero
Start of My Journey
For relatively some time in high Mass Communication at Masinde
school, I was a prey of emotional Muliro University. Not only did I have
victimization and bullying. Many to drop out of university due to lack
can surely attest that this is the of funds, I had lost a best friend, a
most agonizing and traumatizing home, and basically, my whole life
form of bullying. I could not was lost.
protect myself or inform the school In 2015, when I was walking back
management about it. These four home from work, I heard people
years were marked with in and out shouting in some building in Kisumu
of depression and I was full with polytechnic. I peeped through, and
rage and anger. This made my saw them punching and shouting
performance drop badly from grade at the same time. Next day, I went
B to C. to check in again, and the instructor
offered me a lesson for free and
Through domestic issues, my
that is where my Karate journey
parents separated when I was 5
began. Within two month of Karate
years old. My mother had left and
training, my anger towards life
got remarried in Uganda, a different
reduced. Punching and working out
countr y. My anger grew when
helped relieve me, and I could focus
my father passed away in 2012. I
on myself more. I started going for
was only 22 years old, pursuing a
championships, and I was winning.
bachelor’s degree in Journalism and
My priority had changed and instead
WIDE ANGLE • 10
of idling, I just wanted to train and year, I was injured during a Karate
train and challenge myself in the tournament and I had to undergo a
ring. I gained back my confidence. I minor surgery.
was able to recover my self-esteem. I had to use crutches to walk and
I had doctors’ appointments after
When my relatives heard I had
started learning Karate, they
ex p re s s e d n egat i ve o p i n i o n s
claiming I was out of control, now
The aim of Karate is not to injure an opponent
that I didn’t have a father. This was
in line with a strong stereotype in but to learn discipline and give utmost respect
Kenya that martial arts, including
Karate are all about fighting and to life as you seek perfection in character.
violence. Some even said I would go
mad because of one famous female
Kenyan boxer called Conjestina
each single day. This meant that I
Achieng who is now suffering from
could not go to work anymore. But
mental issues and cannot continue
my relatives played a big role in
boxing. In Kenya, many believe
helping me pay my hospital bills and
that martial arts can cause mental
they gave me support throughout
problems, and even lead to death.
the three months in recovery. I
However, Karate is not all about
believe this change happened
fighting. The aim of Karate is not
because my family had witnessed
to injure an opponent but to learn
the positive power of Karate.
discipline and give utmost respect
to life as you seek perfection in
character.
Among different camera functions, zooming in allows to focus on a main object making its surroundings look small.
ZOOM
In this section, ICM Insight will zoom-in and focus on in-depth contents.
Gender
Equity in
Colin Higgs, Ph.D
Martial
Dr. Colin Higgs is Professor Emeritus in
Sport and Physical Education at Memorial
University, St. John’s, Canada, and a
Arts
Member of the Canadian Long-Term
Athlete Development Expert Group. In
addition to his work in sport performance
he is heavily involved in using sport for
positive youth development in developing
countries. He is the author of more than
100 publications, and is a well-known
speaker at international conferences.
I am neither a martial arts expert Equality v Equity same hurts those who are different,
nor an expert on gender equity. My and those who have had fewer prior
recent background is in Long-Term While similar, equality and equity are opportunities to develop skills. The
Athlete Development 1); a process different in important ways. Equality difference between equality and
developed in Canada to ensure the means treating everyone the same equity is illustrated below.
optimum development of Canadian – and in many circumstances this
youth and adults regardless of is the right thing to do. In other
whether they aspire to be high circumstances treating everyone the
performance athletes, or just want to
take part in the sport of their choice
Figure 1 : Equality and Equity – similar but different
for health and personal enjoyment.
In the past 15 years of working on
this project, much has been learned.
One of the key lessons learned, is
that training males and females
in the same way guarantees that
the training for either the males or
the females will be sub-optimal.
Because most coaches and martial
arts leaders are male, and the
majority of martial arts participants
are also male, it is often the
instruction and training of females
that falls short. Equality - Treating everyone the same Equity - Providing the same opportunity
Muscle strength
Specialization in single increases faster than
martial art, and on a style bone development
Post Late teen years into early
of performing, coupled making athletes
adolescence 20s.
with increasing success in susceptible to bone
competition. and joint injury early in
this stage.
At each stage of development the instructor must take into consideration four different areas on which
the athlete should be working. Those areas are:
Technical Development
These are the skills of each martial art. This is usually the area of development on which most
time is spent, particularly at the late-childhood, adolescent, and young adult stages. It is often
the area of sport development in which instructors have great knowledge, and the confidence
that they are doing the right thing.
Tactical Development
These are the strategic and tactical decisions that the athlete must make, and this decision-
making ability is often the difference between champions and runners up. However, brain
development determines how well the athlete is capable of dealing with tactics and strategy.
Before the age of approximately 11-12 children are not capable of abstract thinking. They can
deal with concrete tactical decisions such as, ‘if your opponent does this…then you do that’,
but their brains are not capable of dealing with more abstract ideas, such as, ‘try to draw your
opponent forward and then move it’.
And the optimum period of development for each capacity differs between males and females.
ZOOM • 16
Figure 2 : Increase in body height and the adolescent growth spurt Understanding Growth
The green line above shows the
200
Height, measured on each birthday
24.0
Growth: Height gained since last birthday growth spurt more clearly, and
50
club. This difference in effort and •Speed 2 : Is the speed of moving the whole
body: starting, running, stopping,
acceptance between males and
spinning, turning, changing direction.
females is shown below.
17 •
roviding time for social connections before, during and after training
P
sessions. This often contrasts with the ‘let’s get on with it’ approach of many
male instructors, who sometimes see female athletes who are chatting, as
Acceptance Results
‘wasting their time’ or being disrespectful.
Committing to the ales are generally more interested in the ‘what to do and when to do it’
M
dojo, trying hard when learning a new martial art skill, while females often learn better when
• Effort
in training, and
they are provided, and understand, the ‘why and how’ of a new skill.
practice
Making good
• Results progress in the
emales often want to receive more detailed feedback on their performance
F
martial art
than males, and when that feedback is not provided may feel that they
Feeling part of the
don’t really understand the skill, or are being ignored by the instructor.
dojo, being accepted
• Acceptance
by others around
them
Acceptance
Results Effort
Concussion
Participants can get concussions from banging heads, from being hit or kicked in the head, or from
striking their head during falls. Females, particularly teenage females, appear to be more susceptible to
concussion injuries than males of the same age who receive the same head impact.
• Protection : Use well-fitted head protection during sparing and competition, and practice safe techniques.
• Know what to do : Have a concussion protocol in place, and do not let player return to competition, or
practice, until it is safe to do so, and the player has been medically cleared to take part
in martial arts. A basic concussion protocol can be found at the end of this article.
Mechanical Injury
Females are prone to short-term and long-term injury to the ligaments in their knees(anterior cruciate
ligament), the patellofemoral joint, and around the shoulder.
• Protection : Injuries can be reduced through developing sport-specific movement abilities, along with
strength and conditioning (particularly core strength), balance and flexibility.
Psychological Injury
These are the feelings of unfair criticism, self-doubt, failure, and rejection that increase the likelihood
that a player will drop out of the club and/or the sport.
• Protection : Instruct and coach to create a positive environment where social connections are
enhanced. Balance positive and negative feedback - with more positive than negative.
Build martial arts skills to increase confidence and where possible provide positive female
role models.
• Protection : Educate your players that healthy eating is the most important goal, and that they need
adequate food energy to train, play, maintain their menstrual cycle and to ensure good
bone health. High-level training with inadequate food intake can lead to what is known as
the Female Athlete Triad.
19 •
Menstruation becomes
intermittent or stops
Concussion Treatment
The most important treatment for concussion is rest, and this means both
physical rest, and resting the brain from cognitive tasks.
‘On the mat field’ practice with light body contact, once cleared by a
doctor. If symptoms return go back to previous step.
1. Have you taken the time to educate yourself about the psychological factors that are
□ □
important to female athletes?
2. Have you educated yourself about the injuries and health issues that are more common in
□ □
females, and have you adjusted your training to take them into account?
3. Are you committed to the long-term development of ALL martial arts participants and not
□ □
focus attention on those with the most talent?
4. Do you deliberately coach to create the best atmosphere for training and competing -
□ □
instructing players on what to do to improve rather than focusing on what they did wrong?
5. Do you create an inclusive environment and actively manage relationships between and
□ □ among participants? Do ALL players feel welcomed and appreciated for what they bring to
the club.
6. Do you mix up partners and small groups during practice and training so that everyone
□ □
trains with everyone else and cliques don’t form?
7. Do you organize social opportunities for your participants outside of formal training and
□ □
competition so that they really get to know each other?
8. Do you treat all of your players equally, with the same rules applying to your best and least
□ □
talented participants if they break the rules?
9. Do you have ZERO tolerance for bullying, for harassment and for words or actions that show
□ □ sexism, racism, or lack of tolerance for participants who are different because of sex, race,
religion, poverty, or other reason?
□ □ 10. Do you treat ALL players with respect ALL of the time?
You understand how to You are on the right track, Time to educate yourself Perhaps you should not
coach young women to but need to brush up on about coaching females - be coaching females until
make them feel part of the latest information on and to put what you learn you have updated your
the team, and to perform how best to coach female into practice. coaching education.
at their best. athletes.
Based in part on and adapted from, “Recommendations for High Performance Coaches and Leaders
Canadian Association for the Advancement of Women and Sport and Physical Activity (CAAWS)”
23 •
As a UNESCO Category 2 Centre in the Social and Human Sciences Sector, ICM strives to contribute in youth
development and engagement through martial arts. In this section, ICM Insight will introduce a range of activities
INSIDE ICM carried out during the year.
Second International
Youth Martial Arts Camp Second Martial Arts
Research Initiative for
Experts
ICM and the Mongolian National ICM’s official website, ‘ICM News’
Centre News Here we share our Centre's latest news.
board. ‘ICM News’ is shared in two
Commission for UNESCO hosted
the 2018 Northeast Asia Martial Arts languages, English and Korean.
Martial Arts Research Initiative for Experts Programme Completion
Ceremony
website.
martial arts during five days and six nights of the camp. For youth
ID : UNESCO ICM
City Hall 5F, Eutteum-ro 21, Chungju-si, Chungcheongbuk-do, Republic of Korea, 27339
T +82-43-845-8864 | F +82-43-850-7349 | www.unescoicm.org