Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 12

British Journal of Anaesthesia 1995; 75: 157–168

Capsaicin and pain mechanisms

J. WINTER, S. BEVAN AND E. A. CAMPBELL

Selective actions of capsaicin increase in membrane permeability to cations, par-


ticularly to calcium and sodium ions [9, 31, 115]. The
Capsaicin, the active ingredient in hot chilli peppers, capsaicin-induced accumulation of calcium ions or
has selective actions on unmyelinated C-fibres and the flux of radiolabelled ions such as rubidium (in
thinly myelinated A primary sensory neurones [37, place of potassium) and guanidinium (in place of
100] (Table 1). Most capsaicin-sensitive fibres are sodium) has been exploited to quantify the effects of
polymodal nociceptors which respond to a range of capsaicin-like molecules [115]. Cultured DRG from
sensory stimuli including noxious pressure, heat and avian species do not respond to capsaicin with such
chemical irritants [51, 100], and are the most abun- ion fluxes, and birds are insensitive to capsaicin and
dant class of nociceptive fibre. Nociceptive neurones will eat chillies [115].
are likely to release glutamate as a rapid central The membrane ion channel activated by capsaicin
neurotransmitter, and also express neuropeptides is unique and is insensitive to conventional calcium
such as calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP), and sodium ion-channel blockers such as the di-
substance P, neurokinin A and somatostatin which hydropyridines, -conotoxin and tetrodotoxin re-
can be released into the spinal cord during intense spectively [5, 115]. It is blocked, however, by
stimulation [103]. The tachykinins (e.g. substance P ruthenium red [5, 115]. Ruthenium red appears to be
and neurokinin A) and excitatory amino acids relatively selective in its actions at low concentrations
(EAAs) (e.g. glutamate) cooperate and are thought since it attenuates the effects (activation of
to increase synaptic activation of dorsal horn neur- nociceptors and release of sensory neuropeptide)
ones via EAA receptors [103]. Noxious stimulation induced by capsaicin but not other sensory nerve
in the peripheral nervous system results in long-term stimulants such as bradykinin [2, 34, 69]. Capsaicin
increases in spinal excitability which may contribute activates a number of biochemical systems and
to central mechanisms of allodynia and hyperalgesia increases the concentration of cellular cGMP, diacyl
[103]. Much of the neuropeptide synthesized in the glycerol [33, 36, 115] and nitric oxide [4], and
dorsal root ganglion (DRG) cell body is actually stimulates inositol tris-phosphate turnover, and
exported peripherally rather than centrally. In arachidonic acid release [114]. However all these
peripheral nerve peptide release can contribute to biochemical events are secondary to calcium entry
neurogenic inflammation. and do not play a role in the initial activation of
Although initial local application of capsaicin in sensory neurones by capsaicin.
humans is algesic, repeated application leads to
desensitization, and high concentrations can block
C-fibre conduction and result in long-lasting sensory
CAPSAICIN ANALOGUES
deficits. These properties of capsaicin may explain
its efficacy in treating some painful conditions in The biological effects of capsaicin are dose de-
humans, for example cluster headache, reflex sym- pendent. This fact, together with structure activity
pathetic dystrophy, post-mastectomy pain, post- data from a range of capsaicin analogues, points to a
herpetic neuralgia and diabetic neuropathy. specific membrane receptor for capsaicin. The best
evidence for the existence of a receptor comes from
capsazepine (fig. 1), a highly selective competitive
The capsaicin receptor/channel capsaicin antagonist which inhibits [6] the excitatory
Most mechanistic studies of capsaicin-induced ac- effects of capsaicin in both in vivo and in vitro
tivation of nociceptive neurones have been made experiments. Capsazepine itself does not appear to
using cultured sensory neurones and isolated nerves be analgesic [82] which argues against the existence
in vitro. These studies have shown that capsaicin of an endogenous activator of the capsaicin channel
induces a depolarization, during which there is an that binds at the same site as capsaicin. In fact it
seems that capsaicin analogues must have some
agonistic activity to show efficacy as analgesics. Two
(Br. J. Anaesth. 1995; 75: 157–168)
examples are olvanil (NE19550) and nuvanil
Key words
Pain, mechanism. Pain, threshold. Toxicity, neurotoxicity.
Analgesics non-opioid, capsaicin. Polypeptides, substance P. JANET WINTER, PHD, STUART BEVAN, PHD, ELIZABETH A.
lons, ion channels, pharmacology. CAMPBELL, PHD, Sandoz Institute for Medical Research, Gower
Place, London WC1E 6BN.
158 British Journal of Anaesthesia

Table 1 Subsets of cutaneous afferent units excited by capsaicin. Modified from Szolcsányi [100]. Data from
rabbit, rat, cat or human studies. Application of capsaicin is either by close arterial injection, intradermal or
topical

Excitation by Excitation by Excitation by


C-afferents capsaicin A afferents capsaicin A afferents capsaicin

Mechano heat Mechanoheat G-hair


High threshold High threshold Field
mechanoreceptor mechanoreceptor
Low threshold D-hair SA 1
mechanoreceptor
Mechanoheat Cold SA 11
insensitive
(chemonociceptor)
Warm
Cold

PROTONS

Low extracellular pH can stimulate some sensory


neurones by opening ion channels [5]. Recent
evidence suggests that one type of response to low
pH (elevation of the concentration of protons) is via
activation of the capsaicin channel itself, suggesting
that protons may be the endogenous activators of
these channels [7]. The pH of ischaemie or inflamed
tissue can fall into the range that directly activates
capsaicin-operated channels, and contribute to the
pain which can accompany these pathological con-
ditions [5]. Both capsazepine and ruthenium red
block some proton and capsaicin-evoked responses,
for example, smooth muscle contraction [66], CGRP
release from smooth and skeletal muscles (see e.g.
Santicioli and colleagues [88]) and nasal irritation,
consistent with the hypothesis that capsaicin and
protons operate via the same mechanism [5]. In
cultured DRG neurones, however, capsazepine
blocks capsaicin-induced but not proton-induced
ion fluxes [5]. It remains to be determined whether
the protons open capsaicin-operated channels di-
rectly or act indirectly via the release of another
mediator.
Figure 1 Structures of capsaicin and analogues.

REGULATION OF CHANNEL DENSITY


(NE21610) [14], each having some capsaicin-like
agonist actions, and both having analgesic properties Capsaicin sensitivity itself is dependent on the
(fig. 1). continued presence of nerve growth factor (NGF) in
Another, ultrapotent capsaicin analogue, resini- adult DRG cultures [112]. As expected, the sustained
feratoxin (RTX, fig. 1) has become a useful tool in proton evoked current and RTX binding are also
studying capsaicin-sensitive neurones. Owing to NGF regulated in culture [7, 112]. In vivo, sciatic
capsaicin’s low affinity and high lipophilicity, nerve section or systemic treatment of animals with
identification of a capsaicin-binding site using radio- capsaicin, which results in a chemical axotomy are
labelled capsaicin, has not been successful. However both treatments which are likely to deprive DRG
specific, saturable, capsaicin displaceable binding neurones of their normal supply of retrogradely
has been shown using RTX as a binding ligand [97]. transported NGF from peripheral targets. In both
This naturally occurring irritant activates sensory cases capsaicin sensitivity decreases. This phenom-
neurones and nociceptors in a manner identical to enon is probably not due to death of NGF-deprived
that of capsaicin [10, 96, 110]. Further studies using DRG neurones [111, 113 and Woolf, Hu-Tsai and
high energy radiation-inactivation analysis of the Winter, unpublished observations]. During develop-
[3H]-resiniferatoxin-binding protein have suggested ment, the majority of DRG sensory neurones require
that the receptor complex has a molecular weight of NGF for survival, whereas in the adult animal NGF
270 kD [95]. [3H]-resiniferatoxin has been used to has a more modulatory role and is not needed for
localize binding sites to the dorsal horn in rat spinal survival [58]. Recent studies have shown a key role
cord sections, and to DRG but not superior cervical for NGF in inflammatory hyperalgesia [56, 116].
ganglion (SCG) sections [112]. Concentrations of NGF increase in inflamed tissue
Capsaicin and pain mechanisms 159

[56]. Antibodies that neutralize NGF completely Capsaicin stimulates the release of glutamate and
inhibit development or reverse the established neuropeptides (GCRP, neurokinin A and substance
hyperalgesia (both mechanical and thermal) that P) from the peripheral and central terminals of
follow an injection of complete Freund’s adjuvant sensory neurones [29, 39, 53, 60, 61, 62, 68]. This re-
(CFA) into the rat paw [116]. In vivo and in vitro lease is a direct consequence of the agonist action of
studies have shown that NGF regulates several capsaicin and occurs by two distinct mechanisms.
characteristics of nociceptive neurones, including The influx of calcium through capsaicin-activated
the content of the neuropeptides substance P and ion channels triggers release independent of action
CGRP [57, 113] as well as capsaicin sensitivity. The potential generation and propagation. The
contribution of NGF-dependent upregulation of depolarization evoked by capsaicin also generates
capsaicin/proton sensitivity to inflammatory hyper- action potentials that propagate and activate distant
sensitivity is presently unknown. regions of the nerve to release glutamate and
neuropeptides. Although capsaicin initially
DESENSITIZATION
stimulates neuropeptide release, it has a longer-term,
inhibitory effect which is one likely mechanism for
The ability of capsaicin to desensitize nociceptive its analgesic and anti-inflammatory actions [14].
neurones has been well documented [45]. However, After capsaicin treatment, noxious stimuli no longer
two distinct phenomena have been reported under release glutamate and neuropeptides despite the
the general heading of desensitization. The first presence of near normal levels of neuropeptides in
phenomenon is a classic pharmacological de- the nerves [3, 8, 76, 101]. This inhibitory effect of
sensitization where prolonged or repeated applic- capsaicin has been attributed to inhibition of the
ations of capsaicin lead to a progressive decline in the voltage-gated calcium channels [9, 31, 83, 87], which
size of subsequent responses to capsaicin. We are responsible for the normal, nerve-evoked release
propose that the term desensitization be reserved for of transmitters from the central and peripheral
this specific effect. The second phenomenon is terminals. A block of transmitter release would
“functional-desensitization”, where a challenge with inhibit the transmission of noxious signals between
capsaicin leads to a reduction or loss of respon- nociceptive sensory neurones and spinal cord
siveness of the neurone to other stimuli. The two neurones and reduce or eliminate neurogenic inflam-
phenomena often occur together but can be separated mation evoked by neuropeptide release from the
when low concentrations of capsaicin are employed. peripheral nerve terminals.
Under these conditions, the responsiveness to There have been several reports that capsaicin
capsaicin is reduced or lost selectively and responses inhibits voltage-activated calcium currents.
to other types of noxious or innocuous stimuli are Capsaicin inhibits these currents in rat DRG
unchanged [33]. The functional desensitization seen neurones by a mechanism that involves a capsaicin-
with higher concentrations of capsaicin is believed to evoked influx of calcium with a resultant increase in
be the basis for the analgesic and anti-inflammatory intracellular free calcium concentration [9, 31, 87].
effects of capsaicin. The inhibitory mechanism has not been fully
The process of desensitization appears to be elucidated but is likely to involve activation of an, as
calcium-dependent and little or no desensitization is yet, unidentified calcium-dependent process. Some
seen when calcium is removed from the extracellular metabolic modification of a key molecule, perhaps
medium [21, 120]. It seems likely that the increase in the ion channels themselves, is suggested by the
intracellular Ca2+ concentration evoked by capsaicin finding that the inhibition outlasts the period of
promotes desensitization by stimulating a calcium- agonism by capsaicin. This mechanism means that
and calmodulin-dependent cytosolic enzyme, pro- the analgesic and anti-inflammatory effects of
tein phosphatase 2B (calcineurin). Calcineurin is capsaicin are restricted to capsaicin-sensitive
inhibited by a complex of cyclosporin A and its neurones and occur at the low concentrations
cytoplasmic binding protein cyclophilin [59] and required for agonism. Other mechanisms of func-
capsaicin desensitization is almost abolished when tional nerve block, such as depolarization block of
the cyclosporin-cyclophilin complex is introduced action potentials, may also contribute to the cell- and
into the cytoplasm of rat sensory neurones [119]. agonism-specific effects of capsaicin.
Conversely, treatments that raised the intracellular
concentrations of cyclic AMP increased capsaicin
DEGENERATION / NEUROTOXICITY
responses in sensory neurones [85]. These findings
suggest that sensitivity to capsaicin is regulated by Capsaicin has a spectrum of effects on sensory
phosphorylation of a key intracellular protein which neurones ranging from excitation to cell death. Many
could be the receptor/ion channel itself or an DRG neurones degenerate following neonatal
associated protein. Activation of calcineurin may capsaicin treatment. The mechanisms of capsaicin-
also be responsible for functional desensitization, induced neurotoxicity have been studied in vitro in
which could involve calcium-dependent dephos- DRG neurones cultured from neonatal animals
phorylation of other intracellular proteins such as [114]. The damage is partially osmotic and partially
ion channels or enzymes. This hypothesis is con- through calcium entry, causing activation of calcium-
sistent with the observations that capsaicin-induced sensitive proteases among other mechanisms [114].
functional desensitization requires the presence of In vivo the severity of these effects depends on
extracellular calcium [89] and is blocked by the factors such as the age of animal at the time of
capsaicin antagonist, ruthenium red [2, 67]. treatment, and the route of administration, as well as
160 British Journal of Anaesthesia

the dose of capsaicin used. Systemic injection of terminal degeneration and impaired nociception
neonatal rats kills many DRG neurones [47]. In tends to be irreversible, as regeneration does not take
adult rats, many C-fibre terminals degenerate [22, place even if the cell bodies of capsaicin-sensitive
23] after large systemic doses of capsaicin, but most neurones survive. Both osmotic lysis and action of
cell bodies survive to respond vigorously to this calcium-dependent proteases may play a part.
“chemical axotomy” by attempting to regenerate
[110, 112]. After perineural application of capsaicin, In vivo studies—hyperalgesia and analgesia
C-fibres degenerate distally and extensive axonal
sprouting can be seen from the proximal nerve [63, ACUTE PAIN
84, 112]. Levels of the growth-associated protein Animal studies—systemic
(GAP-43) and its messenger RNA increase, and the
ability to form neurites in culture increases dra- As outlined above capsaicin mediates its actions
matically if the cells are taken from capsaicin- through a specific membrane receptor. This results
pretreated animals [110, 112]. Although the neurones in an initial excitation of sensory neurones followed
with capsaicin-damaged axons attempt to regenerate, by a period of insensitivity to noxious stimuli. The
they do not reinnervate their targets in vivo, and the time course of this effect ranges from a few hours to
sensory deficit is essentially permanent. Following several months in adult rats receiving either small
systemic capsaicin treatments, neurodegeneration acute doses (1–10 mg kg1 s.c.) or larger doses which
can also be seen by a silver staining method in parts deplete unmyelinated primary afferent neurones [47]
of the brain [86]. Capsaicin treatment also causes (single dose of 50 mg kg1 up to cumulative doses of
depletion of the neuropeptides substance P and 950 mg kg1 in total). In such high doses capsaicin is
CGRP, and the enzyme fluoride-resistant acid phos- neurotoxic when administered to neonatal animals
phatase (FRAP) from the DRG neurones, and and hence the resultant effects on sensitivity to
appearance of vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP), noxious stimuli can be lifelong though the results
similar to the effects of surgical axotomy [46, 112]. from analgesia tests are conflicting.
In adult rats that have been treated neonatally
with capsaicin, analgesia to noxious mechanical,
Summary of mechanism of action of chemical stimuli, or both has been noted by several
capsaicin (see fig. 2) groups [38, 42, 80]. In contrast, the responses to a
Desensitization is a capsaicin-induced loss of re- thermal challenge are not so consistent, with some
sponsiveness to further capsaicin treatment. It is groups reporting an increase in thermal nociceptive
reversible. Desensitization is calcium dependent and thresholds [40, 80] while others saw no change [19,
probably involves activation of a phosphatase which 42]. In mice similar results were noted, with
inactivates the capsaicin channel. significant analgesia to chemical [42] but not to
Functional desensitization is a loss of sensitivity to thermal stimuli [40, 42]. Nagy and yan der Kooy [80]
a range of noxious stimuli and underlies the analgesic have suggested that the variability in results may
effects of capsaicin. Functional desensitization is reflect either the different dosing regimens which
reversible and may also depend on calcium- have been employed (number of applications/
dependent dephosphorylation of other intracellular concentrations used) or the considerable variability
proteins such as enzymes or ion channels. in responsiveness which has been noted after ad-
Neurotoxicity is induced by high doses of ministration of single high doses of capsaicin to
capsaicin. Neuronal damage such as axon and neonatal animals.

Figure 2 Scheme showing some mechanisms of action for capsaicin. Broken arrows indicate the more speculative
pathways.
Capsaicin and pain mechanisms 161

Similar results are obtained following systemic after 10 weeks’ application of either 0.075 % (Axsain,
treatment of adult animals with capsaicin Genderm) or 0.75 % capsaicin cream, McMahon
(35–950 mg kg1 s.c.). Although earlier studies sug- and co-workers [76] showed a significant reduction
gested that such doses produce mitochondrial dam- in the extravasation response to mustard oil with no
age [50] and sensory neuropeptide depletion without change in the accumulation of either substance P or
nerve fibre degeneration [49, 99] more recent studies CGRP in the ligated sural nerve. These observations
show C-fibre terminal loss [22, 23]. Animals showed suggest that the reduction in vasodilatation response
a clear reduction in chemical and mechanical cannot be correlated directly with changes in skin
thresholds [44] and an increase [13, 40], no change or peptide levels.
a small reduction [44] in thermal thresholds. After topical application of capsaicin to the skin
When much lower doses are used and recording C-fibre activity directly in the sa-
(1–10 mg kg1 s.c.) short-lasting (a few hours) an- phenous nerve Lynn and co-workers [64] noted a
algesic and also anti-inflammatory activity have been loss of sensitivity to pressure while the sensitivity to
observed in a variety of animal models, both acute heat was lost or enhanced dependent on the vehicle
and chronic [14, 15, 43]. However, the potential used. McMahon and co-workers [76] were unable to
therapeutic usefulness in humans of such a treatment see any thermal analgesia in rat paws even after 10
is limited by low oral availability and the narrow weeks’ application; in fact the 0.75 % capsaicin
window between the doses required to show an- cream produced hyperalgesia for the first few weeks
algesic activity and those which produce side effects of treatment.
such as hypothermia. The available data suggest a separation between
the effects of topical capsaicin on the afferent and
Animal studies—local efferent function of primary afferent neurones. From
the animal studies it seems that the efferent function
The limited potential for the use of systemically is more readily inhibited, which implies either a
administered capsaicin has led clinicians to use possible involvement of different subpopulations of
topical application of capsaicin in their clinical fibres or suggests that the mechanisms involved in
studies. Studies in animals using local or topical local peptide release are more sensitive to capsaicin
application yielded conflicting results. A reduction, than those involved in sensory signal transduction.
an increase or no effect on nociceptive thresholds
following topical skin application of capsaicin in
animals has been noted [18, 51, 64, 76].
Much of the variability may relate to the number Human volunteer studies
of application and different vehicles used to apply Topical application or local injection of capsaicin in
the capsaicin to the skin and hence possible normal human skin resulted in a concentration-
differences in the rate and extent of skin penetration. dependent burning sensation and a flare response
It is well known from human studies with topical [17, 48, 94]. Within the area of flare, mechanical and
capsaicin that it often requires days to weeks of thermal hyperalgesia were apparent (primary hyper-
treatment to see significant analgesic effects [93, algesia) [17, 94]. Extending beyond the area of flare
104]. Kenins [51] reported that local application of there was an area of secondary (mechanical) hyper-
capsaicin (1 %) to rat skin resulted in an initial algesia [36, 54, 94]. Both the acute effects and the
excitation followed by a period of desensitization to hyperalgesia diminished with repeated capsaicin
noxious chemical, mechanical and thermal stimuli, administration.
effects which were highly vehicle dependent. Carter Repeated application of a 1 % solution of capsaicin
and Francis [18] saw no change in thermal threshold over several days to the forearm resulted in a
following three times daily application of either 1 % reduction or complete abolition of the flare response
or 5 % capsaicin for 4 days. However, at the end of evoked by either noxious heat [17] or the chemical
this study an i.c. injection of 0.1 % capsaicin irritant, mustard oil [48]. Pain thresholds to both
(3.3 mmol litre1) produced a marked increase in these noxious stimuli were increased in these same
withdrawal latencies suggesting that the lack of effect subjects. The flare responses to injections of his-
of topically administered capsaicin was the result of tamine and vasoactive agents such as substance P,
poor bioavailability. In contrast three topical VIP and somatostatin were also reduced in capsaicin-
applications of 1 % capsaicin over a 24-h period were pretreated skin [3, 8, 101]. Simone and Ochoa [93]
sufficient to cause a marked reduction in the plasma investigated the effect of 8 weeks’ topical treatment
extravasation evoked by either 5 % capsaicin or with Axsain (0.075 %, Genderm) in normal subjects.
antidromic nerve stimulation. Lynn and co-workers Heat-induced pain thresholds, which were initially
[64] noted that a single application of 1 % capsaicin decreased after 1 day of capsaicin treatment, became
to the skin was sufficient to reduce the vasodilatation elevated by 3.5 C after 6 weeks. There was no
evoked by nerve stimulation. Surprisingly the skin change in the thresholds for touch, cold, low
levels of substance P, a possible mediator of temperature or mechanical stimulation. The flare
vasodilatation, were still reduced several days later response to histamine was, however, reduced.
when the vasodilatory response had returned to Therefore, there is some evidence to support the
normal. Similarly, 2 weeks after intradermal in- therapeutic use of topically applied capsaicin. There
jection of capsaicin, a normal vasodilatory response also appears to be good potential for development of
to antidromic nerve stimulation occurred despite compounds with an improved therapeutic profile
depressed levels of substance P [64]. In contrast, compared with capsaicin.
162 British Journal of Anaesthesia

ARTHRITIS
treatment (Zostrix, 0.025 %) in 31 patients with
rheumatoid arthritis of the knee. In contrast,
Animal studies McCarthy and McCarty [73] using 0.075 % capsaicin
There is a wealth of information implicating cream saw no significant improvement in seven
capsaicin-sensitive primary afferent neurones in the patients with rheumatoid arthritis of the hands. In
inflammation (neurogenic) and hyperalgesia support of the findings of the former study Weisman
associated with animal models of peripheral inflam- and co-workers [109] have recently reported that
mation. From these animal studies it is well es- application of topical capsaicin (0.075 %) for 6 weeks
tablished that the synovium in joints is richly produced a reduction in inflammatory mediators,
innervated by peptide (substance P)-containing including substance P, in the synovial fluid of
nerve fibres and following induction of arthritis in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.
rats there is an increase in the levels of substance P
in the joint [70]. Conversely, neonatal capsaicin Osteoarthritis. As in the case of rheumatoid arthritis
treatment or treatment of adult rats with a dose of substance P has also been implicated in the patho-
capsaicin which is known to deplete substance P will physiology of osteoarthritis. Substance P concen-
reduce the inflammation and joint injury [24, 55]. trations are increased in the plasma and synovial
Injection of substance P or capsaicin into non- tissue of patients with osteoarthritis [72, 78], Sub-
inflamed joints will induce a mechanical hyperalgesia stance P has also been suggested to enhance cartilage
which persists for several hours [25, 26] and which destruction [1].
can be inhibited by a substance P antagonist while Two earlier double-blind studies demonstrated a
substance P injection into inflamed joints is known to significant improvement in pain relief following
enhance the inflammation [55]. treatment with capsaicin cream in patients with
After inflammation it has also been shown that osteoarthritis of the knee (0.025 % for weeks, 70
substance P levels are increased in the DRG and this patients) [28] and hand (0.075 %, 14 patients) [73]. A
seems to be accompanied by increased axonal more recent multicentre double-blind trial involved
transport [32, 116]. The elegant studies of Schaible 113 patients with osteoarthritis of the knee, ankle,
and co-workers [90] demonstrated that following elbow, wrist or shoulder [1]. In patients given
inflammation the high threshold sensory fibres 0.025 % capsaicin cream four times daily for 12
become sensitized to movement in the normal range weeks 81 % using capsaicin improved compared
and initially insensitive sensory fibres become with 54 % receiving vehicle based on the physician’s
mechanosensitive and may show spontaneous ac- evaluation with similar results obtained when com-
tivity. Thus, these sensory fibres will contribute to paring the data from the patients’ evaluation (visual
the ongoing pain associated with the arthritis and analogue scale).
peripherally they will enhance inflammation by
release of neuropeptides. As discussed above when
capsaicin is used systemically in low doses short- NEUROPATHIC PAIN

lasting analgesia is observed in acute tests. Perkins Animal studies


and Campbell [82] demonstrated that this was also
the case in models of monoarticular arthritis in rats The majority of clinical trials using capsaicin have
induced by uric acid or Freund’s adjuvant injection investigated its analgesic efficacy after topical ap-
into the knee where capsaicin (6 mg kg91) reversed plication in conditions of neuropathic pain. There is
the mechanical hyperalgesia for several hours, there- little experimental evidence, however, on its effects
fore this analgesic effect is not the result of in animal models of neuropathic pain. Adult rats
neurotoxicity. which had been neonatally treated with capsaicin
(50 mg kg1 s.c.), did not develop the thermal hyper-
algesia which normally arises after either chronic
constriction injury or partial ligation of the sciatic
Human studies
nerve [77, 91]. In contrast, in the same animals
Rheumatoid arthritis. The normal human synovium which had received a partial ligation, mechanical
receives innervation from substance P-immuno- hyperaesthesia and allodynia developed as normal
reactive fibres which are associated with blood vessels [91]. Yamamoto and Yaksh [l17] administered
or as free fibres which extend into the intimal layer capsaicin intrathecally (15 g / 15 l) 2 days after
of the synovial membrane. However, in chronic constriction injury and determined thermal paw
rheumatoid arthritis the number of free fibres is withdrawal thresholds to a thermal stimulus 5 days
decreased and there is a reduction in the staining for later. Although the results were confusing it was
substance P-containing fibres in the intimal layer clear that the capsaicin-pretreated animals showed
[71, 81]. This reduced staining may to some extent no significant hyperalgesia on the ligated paw
reflect increased release as synovial fluid levels of compared with vehicle-treated animals. Kim and co-
substance P exceed plasma levels in most types of workers [52] applied capsaicin (0.05–2.0 %) directly
arthritis suggesting direct release into the synovium around the nerve 1 week after ligation, and studied
and synovial fluid [72]. thermal withdrawal latencies for up to 8 weeks.
To date the clinical studies using topically applied Animals treated with doses of 0.1 % or higher
capsaicin report conflicting results. Deal and co- showed a significant, dose-dependent increase in
workers [28] reported significant reduction in pain withdrawal latencies on the ligated paw compared
intensity and joint tenderness after 4 weeks of with the contralateral paw.
Capsaicin and pain mechanisms 163

Table 2 Clinical trials with topical or locally administered capsaicin where significant improvement in pain scores
was demonstrated compared with vehicle. The concentration of the capsaicin cream used is given together with
the duration of treatment in brackets (d, days ; wk, weeks ; mth, months ; yr, years)

Condition Dose of capsaicin Reference

Post-herpetic neuralgia 0.075 % (6 wk) Bernstein and colleagues [4a]


0.025 % (4 wk) Watson and colleagues [107a]
0.1 mg/ml (5 wk) Bjerring and colleagues [8a]
0.025 % (8 wk) Peikert and colleagues [80a]
0.025 % (4 wk) Srebrnik and Brenner [94a]
0.075 % (6 wk) Watson and colleagues [108]
0.075 % (2 yr) Watson and colleagues [108]
Diabetic neuropathy 0.075 % (8 wk) Scheffler and colleagues [90a]
0.075 % (8 wk) Capsaicin Study Group [16]
Post-mastectomy pain 0.025 % (4 wk) Watson and colleagues [107c]
0.075 % (6 wk) Watson and Evans [107a]
0.025 % (8 wk) Dini and colleagues [30a]
Stump pain 0.025 % (1 wk) Rayner and colleagues [85a]
Reflex sympathetic 0.025 % (3 wk) Cheshire and Snyder [20a]
dystrophy 0.075 % (10–24 wk) Sinoff and Hart [94a]
Trigeminal neuralgia 0.05 % (15–20 d) Fusco and colleagues [38a]
Oral neuropathic 0.025 % (5 mth) Epstein and Marcoe [37b]
pain
Osteoarthritis 0.025 % (4 wk) Deal and colleagues [38]
0.075 % (4 wk) McCarthy and McCarty [73]
0.025 % (12 wk) Altman and colleagues [1]
Rheumatoid arthritis 0.025 % (4 wk) Deal and colleagues [38]
Cluster headache 100 l of 10 mmol litre91 (5 d) Sicuteri and colleagues [9la]
100 l of 10 mmol litre91 Fusco and colleagues [38a]
0.025 % (7 d) Marks and colleagues [71a]
Fibromyalgia 0.025 % (4 wk) McCarty and colleagues [74]

These studies, therefore, implicate a role for although some of the trials claim to be double blind
capsaicin-sensitive nerves in the thermal hyper- this effect of capsaicin will clearly distinguish it from
algesia which develops in these animals. However, placebo. With repeated application, however, this
the doses used are considerably higher than the unwanted side effect diminished.
0.025–0.075 % topical capsaicin cream which is used The Capsaicin Study Group [16] studied a total of
clinically. 277 patients (138 capsaicin 0.075 %, 139 placebo)
with diabetic neuropathy and reported significant
improvement in all measures (pain, walking, work-
Human studies
ing, sleeping) after administration of capsaicin four
Despite the limited experimental evidence from times daily for up to 8 weeks. Most studies have been
animal studies, the possible therapeutic usefulness of of a similar duration although Watson and co-
topically applied capsaicin has been the subject of workers [108] followed 83 patients with post-
many clinical trials in the area of neuropathic pain herpetic neuralgia for up to 2 years and found that in
(see table 2). In general, conditions involving 86 % of the subjects the improvement in pain scores
neuronal damage and subsequent development of was either maintained or further enhanced with no
neuropathic pain respond poorly to conventional serious adverse effects.
analgesics. For this reason the possibility of a novel
approach to the treatment of such patients has
OTHER CLINICAL INDICATIONS
received considerable attention in the past few years.
Clinical trials (see table 2) demonstrating significant There have been several studies reporting the efficacy
improvement with topical capsaicin have been of nasal application of capsaicin in the treatment of
carried out in patients with post-mastectomy pain, cluster headache (see table 2). Patients applied the
stump pain, reflex sympathetic dystrophy, oral capsaicin daily for up to 7 days with a resultant
neuropathic pain and trigeminal neuralgia. However, significant improvement compared With placebo and
the greatest numbers of patients studied have been in in some cases complete disappearance of symptoms.
the fields of diabetic neuropathy and post-herpetic The mechanism by which capsaicin provides relief in
neuralgia where the efficacy reported in the early such patients is unknown though substance P
trials has led to subsequent large multicentre studies. containing neurones of the trigeminal nerve have
In small numbers of patients the early reports been implicated in the symptomatology of cluster
demonstrated a significant improvement in pain headache.
scores after treatment with capsaicin. In general the More recently the efficacy of topical capsaicin has
effects of capsaicin took several weeks to develop and been assessed in the treatment of the pain associated
in most studies there was a significant number of with fibromyalgia (table 2). After 4 weeks’ treatment
patients who dropped out in the early weeks owing to with 0.025 % capsaicin patients reported
the irritant properties of capsaicin which produced a significantly less tenderness; however, there was no
burning pain following application. Therefore, significant change in the visual analogue scale for
164 British Journal of Anaesthesia
Table 3 Clinical trials with topical administered capsaicin where significant improvement in pruritic symptoms
was demonstrated compared with placebo. The concentration of the capsaicin cream used is given together with
the duration of treatment in brackets (wk, weeks)

Condition Dose of capsaicin Reference

Psoriasis 0.025 % (8 wk) Kurkccuoglu and Alaybeyi [53a]


0.025 % (6 wk) Ellis and colleagues [37a]
Haemodialysis 0.025 % (6 wk) Breneman and colleagues [12a]
Notalgia paraesthetica 0.025 % (6 wk) Leibsohn [54a]
Brachioradial pruritus 0.025 / 0.075 % (2 wk) Goodless and Eaglstein [40a]
0.025 % (3 wk) Knight and Hayashi [52a]
Aquagenic pruritus 0.025–1.0 % (4 wk) Lotti and colleagues [59a]

pain. As mentioned above the beneficial effects of


capsaicin can take several weeks to develop, therefore
in this study perhaps a longer treatment period or
the use of 0.075 % capsaicin cream would have
shown better efficacy.
One further area which has also received attention
is the use of topical capsaicin in the treatment of
pruritus. Itch is believed to be mediated by a subset
of capsaicin-sensitive nociceptive neurones and
blocking C-fibre conduction suppresses itch [65, 75].
In human volunteer studies capsaicin treatment
inhibited the itch after histamine and allergen
challenge and has subsequently been shown to
reduce the itch associated with a variety of clinical
conditions (table 3).

The future
Capsaicin analogues
The potential therapeutic usefulness of an analogue
of capsaicin which retains its selective action on
primary afferent neurones and analgesic activity but
is devoid of unwanted side effects has prompted Figure 3 Time course of load tolerated by hind limb on the
third day after Freund’s complete adjuvant (A) or 24 h after an
several groups to try to develop novel therapeutic intra-articular injection of uric acid (B). (!) Capsaicin,
drugs based on capsaicin. 20 mol kg91 s.c. ; (") ; capsazapine 100 mol kg91 s.c. ; (!)
Earlier structure-activity studies suggested that it capsazepine 100 mol kg91. (Modified from Perkins arid.
was not possible to produce an analogue with Campbell [82].)
significant antinociceptive activity but with reduced
excitatory effects [41, 98]. The latter group noted
that potent analgesic activity could not be separated showed improved oral activity over capsaicin and
from a profound hypothermic effect evoked by all of NE19550, significant analgesia was only seen, at
the analogues studied. However, more recent studies doses which produced profound hypothermia [14].
have claimed analgesic activity with analogues of This compound, NE21610, has also been studied
capsaicin which lack pungency and have a reduced in humans though only with local administration.
side-effect profile [11, 12, 20, 92, 118]. Brand and co- When given intradermally NE21610 was much less
workers [11] reported significant thermal and mech- excitatory than capsaicin but was still effective at
anical analgesia and anti-inflammatory activity fol- inhibiting burn-induced hyperalgesia and allodynia
lowing administration of NE19550 (olvanil, N-(3- [27, 79]. Genderm, the manufacturer that markets
methoxy-4-hydroxy-benzyl) oleamide, fig. 1), an the currently available capsaicin creams (Zostrix,
analogue which lacked the acute toxicity of capsaicin. Axsain), is also reported to have an analogue in
This compound also inhibited both the early and late development which is less irritant than capsaicin.
phases of the formalin response [35] and reduced Chen and co-workers [20] described a series of
yeast-induced inflammation in mouse paws [15]. As analogues based on substitutions at position 4 on the
well as activity in these acute assays this compound aromatic ring, a region which Szolcsanyi and Jancsó-
also showed dose-dependent analgesic activity in a Gábor [98] highlighted as being essential for pun-
model of chronic pain, adjuvant-induced mono- gency. Several of these analogues were non-pungent
arthritis [14]. Further modification of this molecule and showed reduced activation of vagally mediated
substituting an aminoethoxy group for the hydroxyl blood pressure reflexes yet retained marked antinoci-
group on the aromatic ring (NE21610, nuvanil, fig. ceptive activity. More recently, Walpole and co-
1) was claimed to improve solubility, and make the workers [105, 106, 107] reported a series of structure-
compound more effective when administered orally activity studies based on different parts of the
while being less irritant to the skin. Results from our capsaicin molecule and described a rational basis for
own laboratory demonstrated that while NE21610 the design of compounds with increased potency.
Capsaicin and pain mechanisms 165

The data therefore suggest that it may be feasible to 7. Bevan S, Winter J. Nerve growth factor differentially
develop an analogue with the required profile of regulates the chemosensitivities of cultured adult rat dorsal
root ganglion neurons. Journal of Neuroscience 1995; in press.
antinociceptive activity and minimal unwanted side 8. Bjerring P, Arendt-Nielsen L. Inhibition of histamine skin
effects. flare reaction following repeated topical application of
capsaicin. Allergy 1990; 45: 121–125.
Capsaicin antagonist 8a. Bjerring P, Arendt-Nielsen L, Soderberg U. Argon laser
induced cutaneous sensory and pain thresholds in post-
Recent data with the capsaicin antagonist herpetic neuralgia. Quantitative modulation by topical
capsazepine support the hypothesis that some degree capsaicin. Acta Dermatology Venereology 1990; 70: 121–125.
9. Bleakman D, Brorson JR, Miller RJ. The effects of capsaicin
of capsaicin-like agonism is essential for a capsaicin on voltage-gated calcium currents and calcium signals in
analogue to show analgesic activity. cultured dorsal root ganglion cells. British Journal of
Capsazepine is a novel competitive antagonist of Pharmacology 1990; 101: 423–431.
capsaicin which selectively antagonizes capsaicin- 10. Blumberg PM, Szállási, Acs G. Resiniferatoxin—an ultra-
potent capsaicin analogue. In: Wood JN, ed. Capsaicin in the
induced activation of nociceptors [6, 30, 102]. In Study of Pain. London: Academic Press, 1993; 45–62.
animal studies capsazepine showed none of the 11. Brand LL, Berman E, Schwen R, Loomans M, Janusz J,
known side effects of other capsaicin analogues; Bonne R, Maddin C, Gardner J, LaHann T, Farmer R, Jones
however, it had no analgesic or anti-inflammatory L, Chiabrando C, Fanelli R. NE-19550: a novel, orally active
activity when administered on its own at doses up to anti-inflammatory analgesic. Drugs in Experimental and
Clinical Research 1987; 13: 259–265.
75 mg kg1, but it was able to inhibit capsaicin-
12. Brand LM, Skare KL, Loomans ME, Reller HH, Schwen
indueed, analgesia in both acute and chronic pain RJ, Lade DA, Bohne RL, Maddin CS, Moorehead DP,
models in a dose-dependent manner [82] (fig. 3). Fanelli R, Chiabrando C, Castelli MG, Tai HH. Anti-
This absence of analgesia with capsazepine alone in inflammatory pharmacology and mechanism of the orally
inflammatory pain models argues against the pro- active capsaicin analogs, NE-19950 and NE-28345. Agents
duction of a structurally related capsaicin-like mol- and Actions 1990; 31: 329–340.
12a.Breneman DL, Cardone JS, Blumsack RF, Lather RM,
ecule that promotes pain and inflammation by Searle EA, Pollack VE. Topical capsaicin treatment for
interacting with the capsaicin receptor. treatment of hemodialysis-related pruritus. Journal of the
American Academy of Dermatology 1992; 26: 91–94.
13. Buck SH, Deskmukh PP, Yamamura HI, Burks TF. Thermal
Summary of efficacy of capsaicin and its analgesia and substance P depletion induced by capsaicin in
analogues in vivo guinea pigs. Neuroscience 1981; 6: 2217–2222.
14. Campbell EA, Bevan S, Dray A. Clinical applications of
Capsaicin is a cell-specific peripheral analgesic. capsaicin and its analogues. In: Wood JN, ed. Capsaicin in the
Agonism, that is ability to open capsaicin-operated Study of Pain. London: Academic Press, 1993; 255–272.
channels, is required for efficacy. 15. Campbell EA, Dray A, Perkins MN, Shaw W. Comparison of
capsaicin and olvanil as antinociceptive agents in vivo and in
There is growing evidence for efficacy of capsaicin vitro. British Journal of Pharmacology 1989; 98: 907P.
in a range of pain conditions. 16. Capsaicin Study Group. Treatment of painful diabetic
A better window between analgesic doses and neuropathy with topical capsaicin. A multi-centre, double-
doses which produce side effects is required for an blind, vehicle-controlled study. Archives of Internal Medicine
orally active therapeutic drug. 1991; 151: 2225–2229.
17. Carpenter SE, Lynn B. Vascular and sensory responses of
However, topical applications are effective and human skin to mild injury after topical treatment with
without side effects. capsaicin. British Journal of Pharmacology 1981; 73: 755–758.
18. Carter RB, Francis WR. Capsaicin desensitisation to plasma
extravasation evoked by antidromic C-fiber stimulation is not
References associated with antinociception in the rat. Neuroscience Letters
1991; 127: 49–52.
1. Altman RD, Aven A, Holmburg CE, Pfeifer LM, Sack M,
19. Cervero F, McRitchie HA. Effect of neonatal administration
Young GT. Capsaicin cream 0.025 % as monotherapy for
of capsaicin in several nociceptive systems of the rat. In:
osteoarthritis: a double-blind study. Seminars in Arthritis and
Bonica JJ, Liebeskind JC, Albe-Fessard DG, eds. Advances
Rheumatism 1994; 23 (Suppl 3): 25–33.
in Pain Research and Therapy, Volume 4, New York: Raven
2. Amann R, Donnerer J, Maggi CA, Giuliani S, DelBianco E,
Weihe E, Lembeck F. Capsaicin desensitization in vivo is Press, 1983; 87–94.
inhibited by ruthenium red. European Journal of Phar- 20. Chen IJ, Yang JM, Yeh JL, Wu BN, Lo YC, Chen SJ.
macology 1990; 186: 169–175. Hypotensive and antinociceptive effects of ether-linked and
3. Anand P, Bloom SR, McGregor GP. Topical capsaicin relatively non-pungent analogues of N-nonanoyl
pretreatment inhibits axon reflex vasodilatation caused by vanillylamide. European Journal of Medicinal Chemistry 1992;
somatostatin and vasoactive intestinal peptide in human skin. 27: 187–192.
British Journal of Pharmacology 1983; 78: 665–669. 20a.Cheshire WP, Snyder CR. Treatment of reflex sympathetic
4. Bauer MB, Simmons ML, Murphy S, Gebhart GF. dystrophy with topical capsaicin. Case report. Pain 1990; 42:
Bradykinin and capsaicin stimulate cyclic GMP production in 307–311.
cultured rat ganglion neurons via a nitrosyl intermediate. 21. Cholewinski A, Burgess GM, Bevan S. The role of calcium in
Journal of Neuroscience Research 1993; 36: 280–289. capsaicin-induced desensitization in rat cultured dorsal root
4a. Bernstein JE, Korman NJ, Bickers DR, Dahl MV, Millikan ganglion neurons. Neuroscience 1993; 55: 1015.
LE. Topical capsaicin treatment of chronic postherpetic 22. Chung K, Klein CM, Coggeshall RE. The receptive part of
neuralgia. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology the primary afferent axon is most vulnerable to systemic
1989; 21: 265–270. capsaicin in adult rats. Brain Research 1990; 511: 222–226.
5. Bevan S, Geppetti P. Protons: small stimulants of capsaicin- 23. Chung K, Schwen RJ, Coggeshall RE. Ureteral axon damage
sensitive sensory nerves. Trends in Neurosciences 1994; 17: following subcutanous administration of capsaicin in adult
509–512. rats. Neuroscience Letters 1985; 53: 221–226.
6. Bevan SJ, Hothi S, Hughes GA, James IF, Rang HP, Shah 24. Colpaert FC, Donnerer J, Lembeck F. Effects of capsaicin in
K, Walpole CJS, Yeats JC. Capsazepine: A competitive inflammation and on the substance P content of nervous
antagonist of the sensory neurone excitant, capsaicin. British tissue in rats with adjuvant arthritis. Life Sciences 1983; 32:
Journal of Pharmacology 1992; 107: 544–552. 1827–1834.
166 British Journal of Anaesthesia
25. Davis A, Perkins MN. The involvement of bradykinin B1 and 40a.Goodless DR, Eaglstein WH. Brachjoradial pruritus: Treat-
B2 receptor mechanisms in substance P-induced mechanical ment with topical capsaicin. Journal of the American Academy
hyperalgesia in the rat. British Journal of Pharmacology 1994; of Dermatology 1993; 29: 783–784.
113: Suppl. 26P. 41. Hayes AG, Oxford A, Reynolds M, Shingler AH, Skingle M,
26. Davis A, Perkins MN. Capsaicin-induced mechanical Smith C, Tyers MB. The effects of a series of capsaicin
hyperalgesia in the rat: involvement of NK1, bradykinin B1 analogues on nociception and body temperature in the rat.
and B2 and interleukin-1 receptors. British Journal of Life Sciences 1984; 34: 1241–1248.
Pharmacology 1995; in press. 42. Hayes AG, Scadding JW, Skingle M, Tyers MB. Effects of
27. Davis KD, Meyer RA, Turnquist JL, Pappagallo M, Fillon neonatal administration of capsaicin on nociceptive thresholds
TG, Campbell JN. Cutaneous injection of the capsaicin in the mouse and rat. Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology
analog, NE21610, produces analgesia to heat but not mech- 1981; 33: 183–185.
anical stimuli in man. Society for Neuroscience 1992; Abs. 18, 43. Hayes AG, Skingle M, Tyers MB. Effects of single doses of
128.1. capsaicin on nociceptive thresholds in the rodent.
28. Deal CL, Schnitzer TJ, Lipstein E, Seibold JR, Stevens RM, Neuropharmacology 1981; 20: 505–511.
Levy MD, Albert D, Renold F. Treatment of arthritis with 44. Hayes AG, Tyers MB. Effect of capsaicin on nociceptive
topical capsaicin: a double-blind trial. Clinical Therapeutics heat, pressure and chemical thresholds and on substance P
1991; 13: 383–395. levels in the rat. Brain Research 1980; 189: 561–564.
29. Del Bianco E, Santicioli P, Tramontana M, Maggi CA, 45. Holzer P. Capsaicin: Cellular targets, mechanisms of action,
Cecconi R, Geppetti P. Different pathways by which and selectivity for thin sensory neurons. Pharmacological
extracellular Ca2+ promotes calcitonin gene-related peptide Reviews 1991; 43: 143–201.
release from central terminals of capsaicin-sensitive afferents 46. Jancsó G. Pathobiological responses of C-fibre primary
of guinea-pigs: effects of capsaicin, high K+ and low pH sensory neurons to peripheral nerve injury. Experimental
media. Brain Research 1991; 566: 46–53. Physiology 1992; 77: 405–431.
30. Dickenson AH, Dray A. Selective antagonism of capsaicin by 47. Jancsó G, Kiraly E, Jancsó-Gábor A. Pharmacologically
capsazepine: evidence for a spinal receptor site in capsaicin- induced selective degeneration of chemosensitive primary
induced antinociception. British Journal of Pharmacology sensory neurones. Nature 1977; 270: 741–743.
1991; 104: 1045–1049. 48. Jancsó G, Obál F, Toth-Kasa I, Katona M, Husz S. The
30a.Dini D, Bertelli G, Gozza A, Forno GG. Treatment of post- modulation of cutaneous inflammatory reactions by peptide-
mastectomy pain syndrome with topical capsaicin. Pain 1993; containing sensory nerves. International Journal of Tissue
54: 223–226. Reactions 1985; 7: 449–457.
31. Docherty RJ, Robertson B, Bevan S. Capsaicin causes 49. Jessell TM, Iversen LL, Cuello AC. Capsaicin induced
prolonged inhibition of voltage-activated calcium currents in depletion of substance P from primary sensory neurones.
adult rat dorsal root ganglion neurons in culture. Neuroscience Brain Research 1978; 152: 183–188.
1991; 40: 513–521. 50. Joó F, Szolcsányi J, Jancsó-Gábor A. Mitochondrial
32. Donnerer J, Lembeck F. Analysis of the effects of alterations in the spinal ganglion cells of the rat accompanying
intravenously injected capsaicin in the rat. Naunyn- the long-lasting sensory disturbance induced by capsaicin.
Schmiedeberg’s Archives of Pharmacology 1982; 320: 54–57. Life Sciences 1969; 8: 621–625.
33. Dray A, Bettany J, Forster P. Actions of capsaicin on 51. Kenins P. Response of single nerve fibres to capsaicin applied
peripheral nociceptors of the neonatal rat spinal cord-tail in to the skin. Neuroscience Letters 1982; 29: 83–88.
vitro: dependence of extracellular ions and independence of 52. Kim K-J, Jeon BH, Kim WS, Park KR, Choi S. Effect of
second messengers. British Journal of Pharmacology 1990; capsaicin on causalgiform pain in the rat. Korean Journal of
101: 727–733. Physiology 1992; 26: 143–150.
34. Dray A, Forbes CA, Burgess GM. Ruthenium red blocks the 52a.Knight TE, Hayashi T. Solar (brachioradial pruritus)-
capsaicin-induced increase in intracellular calcium and response to capsaicin cream. International Journal of Derma-
activation of membrane currents in sensory neurons, as well tology 1994; 33: 206–209.
as the activation of peripheral nociceptors in vitro. 53. Kroll F, Karlsson JA, Lundberg JM, Persson CG. Capsaicin-
Neuroscience Letters 1990; 110: 52–59. induced bronchoconstriction and neuropeptide release in
35. Dray A, Dickenson A. Systemic capsaicin and olvanil reduce guinea pig perfused lungs. Journal of Applied Physiology
the acute algogenic and the late inflammatory phase following 1990; 68: 1679–1687.
formalin injection into rodent paw. Pain 1991; 47: 79–83. 53a.Kurkccuoglu N, Alaybeyi F. Topical capsaicin for psoriasis.
36. Dray A, Dickenson A. Capsaicin, nociception and pain. In: British Journal of Dermatology 1990; 123: 549–550.
Wood JN, ed. Capsaicin in the Study of Pain. London: 54. Lamotte RH, Shian CN, Simone DA, Tsai E-Fun P.
Academic Press, 1993; 239–253. Neurogenic hyperalgesia: psychophysical studies of under-
37. Dray A. Mechanism of action of capsaicin-like molecules on lying mechanisms. Journal of Neurophysiology 1991; 66:
sensory neurones. Life Sciences 1992; 51: 1759–1765. 190–211.
37a.Ellis CN, Berberian B, Sulica VI, Dodd WA, Jarratt MT, 54a.Leibsohn E. Treatment of notalgia paresthetica with
Katz I, Prawer S, Krueger G, Rex IH, Wolf JE. A double- capsaicin. CUTIS 1992; 49: 335–336.
blind evaluation of topical capsaicin in pruritic psoriasis. 55. Levine JD, Clark R, Devor M, Helms MA, Moskpwitz MA,
Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology 1993; 29: Basbaum AI. Intraneuronal substance P contributes to the
438–442. severity of experimental arthritis. Science 1984; 226: 547–549.
37b.Epstein JB, Marcoe JH. Topical application of capsaicin for 56. Lewin GR, Mendell LM. Nerve growth factor and
treatment of oral neuropathic pain and trigeminal neuralgia. nociception. Trends in Neurosciences 1993; 16: 353–359.
Oral Surgery Oral Medicine Oral Pathology 1994; 77: 57. Lindsay RM, Harmar AJ. Nerve growth factor regulates
135–140. expression of neuropeptide genes in adult sensory neurones.
38. Faulkner DC, Growcott JW. Effects of neonatal capsaicin Nature 1989; 337: 362–364.
administration on the nociceptive response of the rat to 58. Lindsay RM. Nerve growth factors (NGF, BBNF) enhance
mechanical and chemical stimuli. Journal of Pharmacy and axonal regeneration but are not required for survival of adult
Pharmacology 1980; 32: 657–658. sensory neurones. Journal of Neuroscience 1988; 8:
38a.Fusco BM, Geppetti P, Fanciullacci M, Sicuteri F. Local 2394–2405.
application of capsaicin for the treatment of cluster headache 59. Liu J, Farmer JD, Lane WS, Friedman J, Weissman I,
and idiopathic trigeminal neuralgia. Cephalalgia 1991; 11: Schreiber SL. Calcineurin is a common target of cyclophilin-
234–235. cyclosporin A and FKBP-FK506 complexes. Cell 1991; 66:
39. Gamse R, Molnar A, Lembeck F. Substance P release from 807–815.
spinal cord slices by capsaicin. Life Sciences 1979; 25: 59a.Lotti T, Teofoli P, Tsampau D. Treatment of aquagenic
629–636. pruritus with topical capsaicin cream. Journal of the American
40. Gamse R. Capsaicin and nociception in the rat and mouse. Academy of Dermatology 1994; 30: 232–235.
Possible role of substance P. Naunyn-Schmiedeberg’s Archive 60. Lou YP, Franco-Cereceda A, Lundberg. JM. Omega-
of Pharmacology 1982; 320: 205–216. conotoxin inhibits CGRP release and bronchoconstriction
Capsaicin and pain mechanisms 167
evoked by a low concentration of capsaicin. Acta Physiologica analog, NE21610, prevents the development of the
Scandindvica 1991; 141: 135–136. hyperalgesia following a burn. Society for Neuroscience 1992;
61. Lou YP Franco-Cereceda A, Lundberg JM. Different ion Abs. 128.2.
channel mechanisms between low concentrations of capsaicin 80. Nagy JI, van der Kooy D. Effects of neonatal capsaicin
and high concentrations of capsaicin and nicotine regarding treatment on nociceptive thresholds in the rat. Journal of
peptide release from pulmonary afferents. Acta Physiologica Neuroscience 1983; 3: 1145–1150.
Scandinavica 1992; 146: 119–127. 80a.Peikert A, Hentrich M, Ochs G. Topical 0.025 % capsaicin in
62. Lou YP, Karlsson JA, Franco-Cereceda A, Lundberg JM. chronic post-herpetic neuralgia: efficacy, predictors of resp-
Selectivity of ruthenium red in inhibiting onse and long-term course. Journal of Neurology 1991; 238:
bronchoconstriction and CGRP released induced by afferent 452–456.
C-fibre acivation in the guinea-pig lung. Acta Physiologica 81. Pereria da Silva A, Carmo-Fonseca M. Peptide containing
Scandinavica 1991; 142: 191. nerves in human synovium: Immunohistochemical evidence
63. Lynn B, Pini A, Baranowski R. Injury of somatosensory for decreased innervation in rheumatoid arthritis. Journal of
afferents by capsaicin: selectivity and failure to regenerate. Rheumatology 1990; 17: 1592–1599.
In: Pubols LM, Sessle BJ, eds. Effects of Injury on Trigeminal 82. Perkins MN, Campbell EA. Capsazepine reversal of the
and Spinal Somatosensory Systems. New York: Alan R. Liss, analgesic action of capsaicin in vivo. British Journal of
Inc. 1987; 115–124. Pharmacology 1992; 107: 329–333.
64. Lynn B, Ye W, Cotsell B. The actions of capsaicin applied 83. Petersen M, Wagner G, Pierau F-K. Modulation of calcium-
topically to the skin of the rat on C-fibre afferents, antidromic currents by capsaicin in a subpopulation of sensory neurones
vasodilatation and substance P levels. British Journal of of guinea pig. Naunyn Schmiedeberg’s Archives of Phar-
Pharmacology 1992; 107: 400–406. macology 1989; 329: 184–194.
65. Lynn B. Capsaicin: actions on C fibre afferents that may be 84. Pini A, Baranowski R, Lynn B. Long-term reduction in the
number of C-fibre nociceptors following capsaicin treatment
involved in itch. Skin Pharmacology 1992; 5: 9–13.
of a cutaneous nerve in adult rats. European Journal of
66. Maggi CA, Bevan S, Walpole CSJ, Rang HP, Guiliani S. A
Neuroscience 1990; 2: 89–97.
comparison of capsazepine and ruthenium red as capsaicin
85. Pitchford S, Levine JD. Prostaglandins sensitize nociceptors
antagonists in the rat isolated urinary bladder and vas
in cell culture. Neuroscience Letters 1991; 132: 105–108.
deferens. British Journal of Pharmacology 1993; 108: 801–805.
85a.Rayner HC, Atkins RC, Westerman RA. Relief of local stump
67. Maggi CA, Patacchini R, Santicioli P, Giuliani S, Geppetti S, pain by capsaicin cream. Lancet 1989; 2: 1276–1277.
Geppetti P, Meli A. Protective action of ruthenium red 86. Ritter S, Dinh TT. Capsaicin-induced degeneration in the rat
toward capsaicin desensitization of sensory fibers. brain and retina. In: Wood JN, ed. Capsaicin in the Study of
Neuroscience Letters 1988; 88: 201–205. Pain. London: Academic Press, 1993; 105–138.
68. Maggi CA. The pharmacological modulation of 87. Robertson B, Docherty RJ, Bevan S. Capsaicin inhibits
neurotransmitter release. In: Wood JN, ed. Capsaicin in the voltage-activated calcium currents in a sub-population of
Study of Pain. London: Academic Press, 1993; 161–189. adult rat dorsal root ganglion neurones. Society for
69. Maggi CA, Patacchini R, Santicioli P, Giuliani S, Delbianco Neurosciences Abstracts 1989; 15: 354.
E, Geppetti P, Meli A. The “efferent” function of capsaicin- 88. Santicioli P, Del Bianco E, Geppetti P, Maggi CA. Release of
sensitive nerves, ruthenium red distinguished between calcitonin gene-related peptide-like (CGRP-LI)
different mechanisms of activation. European Journal of immunoreactivity from rat isolated soleus muscle by low pH,
Pharmacology 1989; 170: 167–177. capsaicin and potassium. Neuroscience Letters 1992; 143:
70. Mapp P, Kidd B. The role of substance P in rheumatic 19–22.
disease. Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism 1994; 23: 89. Santicioli P, Patacchini R, Maggi CA, Meli A. Exposure to
Suppl 3, 3–9. calcium-free medium protects sensory fibers by capsaicin
71. Mapp PL, Kidd BL, Gibson SJ, Terry JM, Revell PA, desensitization. Neuroscience Letters 1987; 80: 167–172.
Ibrahim NBN, Blake DR, Polak JM. Substance P-, calcitonin 90. Schaible H, Neugebauer V, Schmidt RF. Osteoarthritis and
gene-related peptide and C-flanking peptide of neuropeptide pain. Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism 1989; 18: 30–34.
Y-immunoreactive fibers are present in the normal synovium 90a.Scheffler NM, Sheitel PL, Lipton MN. Treatment of painful
but depleted in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. diabetic neuropathy with capsaicin 0.075 %. Journal of the
Neuroscience 1990; 37: 143–153. American Podiatric Medical Association 1991; 81: 288–293.
71a.Marks DR, Rapoport A, Padla D, Weeks R, Rosum R, 91. Shir Y, Seltzer Z. A-fibers mediate mechanical hyperesthesia
Sheftell F, Arrowsmith F. A double-blind placebo-controlled and allodynia and C-fibers mediate thermal hyperalgesia in a
trial of intranasal capsaicin for cluster headache. Cephalalgia new model of causalgiform pain disorders in rats. Neuroscience
1993; 13: 114–116. Letters 1990; 115: 62–67.
72. Marshall KW, Chiu B, Inman RD. Substance P and arthritis: 91a.Sicuteri F, Fusco BM, Marabini S, Caimpagnolo V, Maggi
analysis of plasma and synovial fluid levels. Arthritis and CA, Geppetti P, Fanciullacci M. Beneficial effect of capsaicin
Rheumatism 1990; 33: 87–90. application to the nasal mucosa in cluster headache. Clinical
73. McCarthy GM, McCarty DJ. Effect of topical capsaicin in Journal of Pain 1989; 5: 49–53.
the painful osteoarthritis of the hands. Journal of Rheu- 92. Sietsema WK, Berman EF, Farmer RW, Maddin CS. The
matology 1992; 19: 604–607. antinociceptive effect and pharmacokinetics of olvanil fol-
74. McCarty DJ, Csuka M, McCarthy G, Trotter D. Treatment lowing oral and subcutaneous dosing in the mouse. Life
of pain due to fibromyalgia with topical capsaicin: a pilot Sciences 1988; 43: 1385–1391.
study. Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism 1994; 23: 93. Simone DA, Ochoa J. Early and late effects of prolonged
(Suppl 3) 41–47. topical capsaicin on cutaneous sensibility and neurogenic
75. McMahon SB, Kotzenburg M. Itching for an explanation. vasodilatation in humans. Pain 1991; 47: 285–294.
Trends in Neurosciences 1992; 15: 497–501. 94. Simone DA, Baumann TK, Lamotte RH. Dose-dependent
76. McMahon SB, Lewin G, Bloom SR. The consequences of pain and mechanical hyperalgesia in humans after intradermal
long-term topical capsaicin application in the rat. Pain 1991; injection of capsaicin. Pain 1989; 38: 99–107.
44: 301–310. 94a.Sinoff SE, Hart MB. Topical capsaicin and burning pain.
77. Meller ST, Gebhart GF, Maves TJ. Neonatal capsaicin Clinical Journal of Pain 1993; 9: 70–73.
treatment prevents the development of the thermal 94b.Srebrnik A, Brenner S. Capsaicin in the relief of postherpetic
hyperalgesia produced in a model of neuropathic pain in the neuralgia. Journal of Dermatological Treatment 1992; 2:
rat. Pain 1992; 51: 317–321. 147–148.
78. Menkes CJ, Renoux M, Loussadi S, Mauborgne A, Bruxelle 95. Szállási A, Blumberg PM. Molecular target size of the
J, Cesselin F. Substance P (SP) levels in synovial tissue and vanilloid (capsaicin) receptor in pig dorsal root ganglia. Life
synovial fluid from rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and osteo- Sciences 1991; 48: 1863–1869.
arthritis (OA) patients. Journal of Rheumatology 1993; 20: 96. Szállási A, Blumberg PM, Resiniferatoxin, a phorbol-related
714–717. diterpene, acts as an ultrapotent analog of capsaicin, the
79. Meyer RA, Davis KD, Turnquist JL, Fillon TG, Pappagallo irritable constituent of red pepper. Neuroscience 1989; 30:
M, Campbell JN. Intrademal injection of the capsaicin 515–520.
168 British Journal of Anaesthesia
97. Szállási A, Blumberg PM. Specific binding of resinifera- pain syndrome and the effect of topical capsaicin. Pain 1989;
toxin, an ultrapotent capsaicin analog, to dorsal root ganglion 38: 177–186.
membranes. Brain Research 1990; 524: 106–111. 108. Watson CPN, Tyler KL, Bickers DR, Millikan LE, Smith
98. Szolcsányi J, Jancsó-Gábor A. Sensory effects of capsaicin S, Coleman E. A randomized vehicle-controlled trial of
congeners. I. Relationships between chemical structure and topical capsaicin in the treatment of postherpetic neuralgia.
pain producing potency of pungent agents. Arzneimittel- Clinical Therapeutics 1993; 15: 510–526.
Forschung/Drug Research 1975; 25: 1877–1881. 109. Weisman MH, Hagaman C, Yaksh TL, Lotz M. Preliminary
99. Szolcsányi J, Jancsó-Gábor A, Joó F. Functional and fine findings on the role of neuropeptide suppression by topical
structural characteristics of the sensory neuron blocking agents in the management of rheumatoid arthritis. Seminars
effect of capsaicin. Naunyn-Schmiedeberg’s Archive of Phar- in Arthritis and Rheumatism 1994; 23: Suppl 3, 18–24.
macology 1975; 287: 157–169. 110. Winter J, Dray A, Wood JN, Yeats JC, Bevan S. Cellular
100. Szolcsányi J. Actions of capsaicin on sensory neurones. In: mechanism of action of resiniferatoxin: a potent sensory
Wood JN, ed. Capsaicin in the Study of Pain. London: neuron excitotoxin. Brain Research 1990; 520: 131–140.
Academic Press, 1993; 1–26. 111. Winter J, Evison CJ, O’Brien C, Benowiz L, Lindsay RM,
101. Tóth-Kásá I, Jancsó G, Bognár A, Husz S, Obál F. Mulderry P, Woolf C. Neurotoxin damage evokes re-
Capsaicin prevents histamine-induced itching. International generative responses from adult, fat sensory neurones.
Journal of Clinical Pharmacological Research 1986; 6: Neuroscience Letters 1992; 146: 48–52.
163–169. 112. Winter J, Walpole CSJ, Bevan S, James IF. Characterization
102. Urban L, Dray A. Capsazepine a novel capsaicin antagonist, of resiniferatoxin binding sites in sensory neurons:
selectively antagonises the effects of capsaicin in the mouse co-regulation of resiniferatoxin binding and capsaicin-
spinal cord in vitro. Neuroscience 1991; 47: 693–702. sensitivity in adult rat dorsal root ganglia. Neuroscience
103. Urban L, Thompson SWN, Dray A. Modulation of spinal 1993; 57: 747–757.
excitability: co-operation between neurokinin and excitatory 113. Winter J, Woolf C, Lynn B. Degenerative and regenerative
amino acid neurotransmitters. Trends in Neurosciences 1994; responses of sensory neurons to capsaicin-induced damage.
17: 432–438. In: Wood JN, ed. Capsaicin in the Study of Pain. London:
104. Vedder H, Otten U. Biosynthesis and release of tachykinins Academic Press, 1993; 139–160.
from rat sensory neurons in culture. Journal of Neuroscience 114. Wood JN, Coote PR, Minhas A, Mullaney I, McNeill M,
Burgess GM. Capsaicin-induced. ion fluxes increase cyclic.
Research 1991; 30: 288–299.
GMP but not cyclic AMP levels in rat sensory neurones in
105. Walpole CSJ, Wrigglesworth R, Bevan S, Campbell EA,
culture. Journal of Neurochemistry 1989; 53: 1203–1211.
Dray A, James IF, Perkins MN, Reid DJ, Winter J.
115. Wood JN, Winter J, James IF, Rang HP, Yeats J, Bevan S.
Analogues of capsaicin with agonist activity as novel
Capsaicin-induced ion fluxes in dorsal root ganglion cells in
analgesic agents; structure-activity studies. 1. The aromatic
culture. Journal of Neuroscience 1988; 8: 3208–3220,
“A-region”. Journal of Medicinal Chemistry 1993; 36:
116. Woolf CJ, Safieh-Garabedian B, Ma Q-P, Crilly P, Winter
2362–2372. J. Nerve growth factor contributes to the generation of
106. Walpole CSJ, Wrigglesworth R, Bevan S, Campbell EA, inflammatory sensory hypersensitivity. Neuroscience 1994;
Dray A, James IF, Masdin KJ, Perkins MN, Winter J. 62: 327–331.
Analogues of capsaicin with agonist activity as novel 117. Yamamoto, Yaksh TL. Effects of intrathecal capsaicin and
analgesic agents; structure-activity studies. 1. The amide an NK-1 antagonist, CP, 96–345, on the thermal
bond “B-region”. Journal of Medicinal Chemistry 1993; 36: hyperalgesia observed following unilateral constriction of
2373–2380. the sciatic nerve in the rat. Pain 1992; 51: 329–334.
107. Walpole CSJ, Wrigglesworth R, Bevan S, Campbell EA, 118. Yang JM, Wu BN, Chen IJ. Depressor response of sodium
Dray A, James IF, Masdin KJ, Perkins MN, Winter J. nonivamide acetate: a newly synthesised non-pungent
Analogues of capsaicin with agonist activity as novel analogue of capsaicin. Asia Pacific Journal of Pharmacology
analgesic agents structure-activity studies. 1. The hydro- 1992; 7: 95–102.
phobic side-chain “C-region”. Journal of Medicinal Chem- 119. Yeats JC, Boddeke HWGM, Docherty RJ. Capsaicin
istry 1993; 36: 2362–2372. desensitization in rat dorsal root ganglion neurones is due to
107a.Watson CPN, Evans RJ. The postmastectomy pain activation of calcineurin. British Journal of Pharmacology
syndrome and topical capsaicin: a randomized trial. Pain 1992; 107: 238P
1992; 51: 375–379. 120. Yeats JC, Docherty RJ, Bevan S. Calcium-dependent and
107b.Watson CPN, Evans RJ, Watt VR. Post-herpetic neuralgia independent desensitization of capsaicin-evoked responses
and topical capsaicin. Pain 1988; 33: 333–340. in voltage-clamped adult rat dorsal root ganglion (DRG)
107c.Watson CPN, Evans RJ, Watt VR. The post-mastectomy neurones in culture. Journal of Physiology 1992; 446: 390P.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi