Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 78

LUXURY HOUSING FOR YOUR GEAR!

PANASONIC’S LATEST WORK OF ART


SOUND & VISION

A/V Cabs & Extras From Sanus, BDI & Others Can The TC-65AX900U UHDTV Live Up To Plasma’s Legacy?

TESTED
PIONEER’S
$2,000
FLAGSHIP
DISC PLAYER
P62
JUNE 2015 VOLUME 80 NO.5


Where Technology Becomes Entertainment ™ soundandvision.com JUNE 2015
HEAVY METAL: Paradigm’s Prestige Speakers Use High-Tech Drivers For High-End Sound
ULTRA HDTVS

CHOCK-FULL &
• RECEIVERS • SPEAKERS • AMPLIFIERS • PROCESSORS • BLU-RAY PLAYERS

FUTURE-PROOFED
FROM ATMOS TO AURO, MARANTZ’S NEW
AV8802 SURROUND PROCESSOR
IS READY FOR EVERYTHING

NO WIRES,
ALL GLORY
THE DYNAUDIO XEO 6
WIRELESS SPEAKER
SYSTEM CUTS
THROUGH THE HAZE

MUSIC AND
A WHOLE LOT MORE
soundandvision.com

THE NILES AURIEL MRC-6430 TAKES THE CURVE


MULTIROOM AUDIO CONTROL TO ANOTHER LEVEL CONTROVERSY
WHAT GOOD IS
A CURVED SCREEN,
AND ARE THEY REALLY
HERE TO STAY?
www.definitivetech.com
DEFINITIVE TECHNOLOGY W STUDIO

SPEAKER OF THE YEAR


CES 2015

The Definitive Technology W Studio Wireless Soundbar was named


Speaker of the Year at this year's CES.

And while we're honored with the accolade, we can't say we're
surprised. We created the Definitive Wireless collection to redefine
what multi-room wireless music systems should sound like.

Because we understand you want flawless audio quality no matter


what room of the house you're in.

WHAT OBSESSION SOUNDS LIKE


JUNE 2015 Volume 80 No. 5

ON THE COVER Chock-Full and Future-Proofed: Marantz LOG ON TO soundandvision.com and sign up to receive our
AV8802 surround processor. Additional gear from Dynaudio, ON THE new, free eNewsletter for first-rate, up-to-the-minute reporting
Niles, Panasonic, Paradigm, Samsung, and Sanus. WEB of everything that’s hot in the world of home theater.

64 34

30 State of the Arc

COLUMNS FEATURES
Rob Sabin Track One: State of the Arc Why TV screens are curved.
Upgradeitis 8 by Bob Ankosko 30
John Sciacca The Connected Life: Luxury Housing Spruce up your home
Apple Watch(es) Home Automation 19 theater with these unique upgrades. 34
Al Griffin Ask S&V:
All About Atmos—and Auro-3D 21 Escapes The Sky’s the Limit.
64
Ken C. Pohlmann Signals:
Saving Hi-Res Audio 22 62
Michael Antonoff Apptitude:
VR for the Rest of Us 24
THE DEFINITIVE TECHNOLOGY
IRELESS COLLECTION

Brings the latest music Audiophile–grade Audiophile–grade Sound Bar System Transforms existing speakers
services to existing wireless speaker wireless speaker with Wireless Streaming into a music streaming system
audio systems

You shouldn’t compromise on sound quality when you’re not in your designated listening room.
The Definitive Technology Wireless Collection brings our award-winning, high-performance sound
to a family of wireless products that bring audiophile grade sound to any room in your home.
WHAT OBSESSION SOUNDS LIKE

Available at:

definitivetech.com
18 42

DEPARTMENTS REPORTS
Letters Help for lightning strikes, and is
your calibrator color blind? 12 TEST REPORTS P38-65
Marantz AV8802 Surround Processor
Perfect Focus
New gear, top news, how to, and more. 16 Hitting new heights.
by David Vaughn 38
New Gear A look at the hottest new A/V
gear and gadgets. 28 Dynaudio Xeo6 Loudspeaker
Rage against the machine.
42
by Mark Fleischmann
Entertainment Gone Girl, Fury, The
Theory of Everything, and more. 66 Panasonic TC-65AX900U LCD Ultra
HDTV Picture near-perfect.
by Rob Sabin 46
Premiere Design LG 65EG9600 4K OLED
UHDTV 74 Phase Tech nology Teatro TSB3.0
Soundbar Three in one.
by Mark Fleischmann 52
Paradigm Prestige 15B Speaker
System Paradigm’s silver surfers.
by Mark Flesichmann 54
38 Niles Auriel MRC-6430 Multiroom
Audio Controller Old school, new tricks?
by John Sciacca 58
Pioneer Elite BDP-88FD Blu-ray Player

58 Format warrior.
by Al Griffin 62
52
66
46

soundandvision.com ON THE
WEB
Visit The “How We Test” link on our Website for a
detailed explanation of our testing regimen and a list of
our reference gear. soundandvision.com
oldenEar’s

TrackOne
June 2015
3D Array Soundbar ®

is “Absolutely
Unbelievable”
— Darryl Wilkinson, Home Theater Magazine

UPGRADEITIS
A Reader Asks, Fairly, “Is It Worth It?”
I received an e-mail recently from reader Francesco Tenti in
'$UUD\ )) Huntington, NY, politely complaining about the speed with
which A/V technology seems to be progressing.
“Most exciting soundbar demo I heard” “Back in the old days, when you purchased a good audio
— Brent Butterworth, Sound Vision Magazine
system, you were set for years to enjoy high-quality music,” he
:HFDOOWKH6XSHU&LQHPD'$UUD\TXLWH wrote. “You were not attacked by new technology and pushed
VLPSO\´DQH[WUDRUGLQDU\KLJKHQGORXG to update your equipment every other day. With the digital
VSHDNHUV\VWHPGLVJXLVHGDVDVRXQGEDUμ revolution, it seems that whatever is new today is kind of
,WLVGHVLJQHGWRFRPELQHWKHIRUPIDFWRU outdated the minute you take your new gear home.”
RIDVOHHNVW\OLVKVRXQGEDUZLWKWKHSHUIRU He went on to say, “We went from 5.1-channel surround
PDQFHRIDWUXHKLJKTXDOLW\FRPSRQHQW
BY ROB SABIN, systems to 7.1, 7.2, 9.2, 11.2, and now Dolby Atmos systems,
V\VWHP7KHFRPSOHWHXOWUDKLJKSHUIRU
PDQFHV\VWHPZRXOGLQFOXGHDSRZHUHG
EDITOR for which you need new electronics and speakers. Traditional
VXEZRRIHUDQGDUHFHLYHURUVHSDUDWHVSOXV HDTVs are becoming obsolete; the new 4K is here, but there
WKH'$UUD\DFKLHYHVVXSHUEWKUHHGLPHQ are no products to view through it, so people will have to wait for new programming,
VLRQDOVXUURXQGSHUIRUPDQFHZLWKRUZLWKRXW buy new disc players, and so on. Is it really worth it? Is it really worth it to have a new
UHDUVXUURXQGVSHDNHUV,WVWKLQFDELQHW technology where the human eye cannot see the difference? The list of new and evolving
LVFRQVWUXFWHGRIDLUFUDIWJUDGHDOXPLQXP technology is endless, but does it really provide more visual and listening pleasure, or is
DQGFRQWDLQVVL[RI*ROGHQ(DU·VVLJQDWXUH it just self-serving?”
FDVWVSLGHUOHJEDVNHWEDVVPLGUDQJHGULY Lest you think Francesco comes at this as a reticent Scrooge unwilling to part with a
HUVDQGWKUHH+LJK9HORFLW\)ROGHG5LEERQ few shekels to update his ’70s-era gear, he went on to describe a modern system any of us
7ZHHWHUVDORQJZLWKRXUEUHDNWKURXJK' would be proud of, including a Cambridge Audio A/V receiver, GoldenEar speakers mated
7HFKQRORJ\WKDWFDQFHOVLQWHUDXUDOFURVVWDON with an SVS sub, an Oppo Blu-ray player, and a 50-inch Panasonic plasma TV. But having
GLVWRUWLRQIRUWRWDOVRQLFLPPHUVLRQ invested in that, I can perhaps understand his frustration and guess it might strike a chord
among other readers.
It’s a fair question. We at Sound & Vision plead guilty to
There will always
planting those seeds of upgradeitis, though we don’t
automatically get behind every new thing the industry
be something new
shoves down our throats. Until Atmos came along with its around the corner.
+LJK9HORFLW\)ROGHG +LJK'HÀQLWLRQ&DVW%DVNHW discrete, object-based height channels, we told readers not to
5LEERQ7ZHHWHU +9)5 %DVV0LGUDQJH'ULYHU
bother with 9.1-channel and 11.1-channel systems; and until Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD
Master Audio came along with discrete 7.1-channel soundtracks, we said pretty much the
“Awesome just got redefined” same thing about 7.1- and 6.1-channel systems. We’ve not been boosters of curved TVs (see
— Darryl Wilkinson, Home Theater Magazine
our report on page 30), nor fans of the poor-quality 3D playback that has plagued that
7KH'$UUD\VRXQGVDPD]LQJDQGWKH technology since its introduction.
H[SHUWVFHUWDLQO\DJUHH$O*ULIÀQRI6RXQG  But it’s true that the advances seem to have accelerated in recent years, and we’ve
9LVLRQZURWHWKDWWKH'$UUD\6\VWHPμGH come to accept that there will always be something new around the corner, often just after
OLYHUHGDWOHDVWRIP\PDLQULJ·V>7ULWRQ you’ve updated your system. So, is it worth it? The answer is always “sometimes,” but more
7ZR7RZHUV@SHUIRUPDQFHμ&KULV0DUWHQV often than not lately, it’s been “yes.” It’s worth it to have the experience I just had testing
RI7KH$EVROXWH6RXQGUDYHG´DVRXQGEDU
Panasonic’s top-of-the-line, 65-inch 4K television which, from 7 feet away, blew my socks
V\VWHPVRJRRGWKDWDXGLRSKLOHVPLJKWEX\
LWIRUPXVLFSOD\EDFNDORQHLIDVNHGWR
off with its picture quality on a native 4K download of Men in Black 3 (see review page 46).
UHFRPPHQGDVRXQGEDUWRSOHDVH It’s worth it to actually remodel your living room to accommodate Atmos ceiling speakers,
ÀQLFN\K\SHUFULWLFDODXGLRSKLOHVWKLVZRXOG as our own David Vaughn did, and to hear that bird in the Atmos “Amaze” trailer flap fully
EHP\KDQGVGRZQFKRLFHμ$QG+RPH around your room above your head and have everyone in the family flip out at how cool it
7KHDWHU·V'DUU\O:LONLQVRQVXPPHGLWXSSHU is. (His two-part upgrade diary, “Atmos Makeover: A Space Odyssey,” can be found at
IHFWO\ZKHQKHUDYHGWKDW´WKHZLGWKDQG soundandvision.com.) It is worth it to strap on a decent pair of headphones, plug them into
RSHQHVVRIWKHVRXQGVWDJHZDVDEVROXWHO\ a standalone asynchronous USB DAC, and hear for the first time what’s really in a well-
LQFUHGLEOHμFDOOLQJLW´DQLQVWDQWFODVVLFμWKDW mastered hi-res audio file.
LV´DPXVWOLVWHQWRWRSRIWKHVKRSSLQJOLVW Will there be other things coming up behind these technologies? No doubt. Will they be
VRXQGEDUWREHDWZKHQLWFRPHVWRVRXQG worth it? We don’t know yet. But for now, anyway, we’ve got plenty enough
EDUVDZHVRPHMXVWJRWUHGHÀQHGμ upgrades to keep us busy.

Customer Service And Subscriptions LOG ON TO soundandvision.com


www.goldenear.com soundandvision@emailcustomerservice.com, call (800) ON THE and sign up for our free monthly
Follow us on: 264-9872 (international calls: 386-447-6383), or write to: P.O. WEB eNewsleer. You’ll get exclusive tips,
facebook.com/goldenear Box 420235, Palm Coast, FL 32142-0235. Please include your trends, news, and reviews from your
& twitter.com/goldeneartech full name, address, and phone number on any inquiries. favorite S&V writers.
oldenEar’s New “World Beating Triton Five” – Mark Fleischmann, Sound & Vision

“They absolutely rock the speaker world’s foundation to the core … delivering the
kind of musical bliss some pay upwards of $10,000 for” – Caleb Denison, Digital Trends

“ Showstoppers … they sounded obscenely good”


– Jerry Del Colliano, HomeTheaterReview
Dual 6 High-Definition
Cast Basket Bass/Midrange In keeping with GoldenEar’s tradition, the Five’s auspicious debut at the
Drivers in a D’Appolito Array
2015 CES Show had a jaw dropping effect on the world’s audio press.
Sound&Vision’s Rob Sabin wrote that the Fives were, “spectacularly open and
transparent with wide deep sound staging” and “nearly brought me to tears
High-Velocity Folded thanks to the tremendous detail the Fives rendered on a Buddy Holly recording”.
Ribbon Tweeter (HVFR)
Stereophile’s Herb Reichert wrote, “These loudspeakers disappeared better
than any I have ever heard” and then added, “While the music was playing I
Linear-Phase Balanced swear I could see nymphs and goddesses dancing around the soundstage”.
Crossover Network
Normally outspoken writers like Sound&Vision’s Darryl Wilkinson said, “I
am running out of superlatives”, and HD Living’s Dennis Burger raved, “Quite
frankly stupefying … bowled away doesn’t scratch the surface”.

Angled Front Baffle to


“ The value for the money here is clear off the charts”
Precisely Align and Focus – Chris Martens, HiFi+
the Driver Array to Ear Level
GoldenEar’s goal is to deliver to you absolutely the best sound possible for
the money. Superbly lifelike three-dimensional imaging, ultra high resolution,
tremendous dynamic range, extraordinary deep bass response, silky smooth
Frequency Dependent high frequency extension along with you-are-there clarity and presence are
Damping Bass Loading
all a result of GoldenEar’s most advanced components and technologies.
Best of all, the Fives will deliver exceptional performance with moderately
priced receivers, while also allowing you to appreciate the subtle qualities
Non-Parallel Front and Rear Baffles of the world’s finest audio components. And, just as importantly, they deliver
and Side Cabinet Walls to Better state-of-the-art sound quality with two channel music as well as multi-channel
Control Internal Standing Waves
home theater, including Dolby’s new Atmos technology, when paired with our
perfectly matched center channel, surrounds, height speakers and subs.

“ Best Sound for the Money at CES 2015”


– Robert Harley and Neil Gader, The Absolute Sound

The Triton Five is already adding illustrious new awards to GoldenEar’s


impressive collection. Although many focus on value for the money, some
Four Inertially Balanced 8
Planar Infrasonic Radiators;
writers, like Sound Advice’s Don Lindich, go further, giving them “Best Sound
Two on Each Side of Cabinet at the CES Show” and writing, “this is a cost-no-object preference for me”.
HD Guru’s Gary Merson gave them “Top Pick Speaker at CES” and wrote,
“They blew us away … breaks new ground, outperforming competitors costing
thousands more”. SoundStage’s Doug Schneider awarded a “Best System”
Accelerometer Optimized
Non-Resonant Cabinet honor. You owe it to yourself to visit your nearest GoldenEar dealer today!

Triton Five Tower


$999 ea.
www.goldenear.com
PO Box 141, Stevenson, MD 21153 (410) 998-9134
Like us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter!
facebook.com/goldenear twitter.com/goldeneartech
oldenEar’s
ForceField Subs:
“Near perfect... June 2015 Volume 80/Number 5
Editor-in-Chief: Rob Sabin

a tour de force”
— Andrew Robinson, HomeTheaterReview.com
Executive Editor: Claire Crowley
Managing Editor: Courtney McKinnon
Senior Editor, Technical Editor, Video: Thomas J. Norton
Audio Editor: Mark Fleischmann
Technical Editor, Audio: Mark J. Peterson
Editors-at-Large: Bob Ankosko, Darryl Wilkinson
Contributing Technical Editors: Kris Deering, Michael Fremer, Barb Gonzalez,
Al Griffin, Steve Guenberg, Michael P. Hamilton, Daniel Kumin, Fred Manteghian,
Geoffrey Morrison, John Sciacca, Michael Trei, David Vaughn
Contributors: Michael Antonoff, Anthony Chiarella,
Lauren Dragan, Corey Gunnestad, Fred Kaplan,
Josef Krebs, Ken C. Pohlmann, Leslie Shapiro, Kim Wilson
Music Editor: Mike Meler
Movies Editor: Chris Chiarella
Logistics Manager: John Higgins
Technical Consultant: Joel Silver, Imaging Science Foundation
Art Director: Heather Dickson
Copy Editor: Ken Richardson
)) Web Monkey: Jon Iverson
)) Contributing Photographer: Jorge Nunez
))
MANUFACTURING & PRODUCTION OPERATIONS
VP, Manufacturing & Ad Operations: Greg Parnell
“Thunderous...Room-Shaking” Senior Director, Ad Operations: Pauline Atwood
Advertising Coordinator: Joseph Robinston Vinoj
— Al Griffin, Sound Vision Magazine $UFKLYLVWThomas Voehringer
*ROGHQ(DU·V)RUFH)LHOGVXEZRRIHUVDUHWUXH General Manager: Keith Pray, NHLWKSUD\#VRUFFRP
RYHUWKHWRSVXSHUVXEVWKDWDUHHVSHFLDOO\ Associate General Manager: Ed DiBenedeo,HGGLEHQHGHWWR#VRUFFRP
UHPDUNDEOHIRUWKHLUFRPSDFWVL]HDQGXQXVXDOO\ National Retailers, Classifieds: Laura LoVecchio,/R9HFFKLR$VVRFLDWHV
ODXUDBORYHFFKLR#VEFJOREDOQHW
DIIRUGDEOHSULFHV$OOWKUHHLQFRUSRUDWHWKH Sales Coordinator: Rosemarie Torcivia, URVHPDULHWRUFLYLD#VRUFFRP
VDPHDGYDQFHGWHFKQRORJ\DQGFRPSRQHQWV
LQFOXGLQJ'63FRQWUROOHGKLJKSRZHUGLJLWDO Marketing Director: Shawn Higgins
DPSOLÀHUV RUZDWWV XOWUDIDVW
ENTERTAINMENT GROUP MANAGEMENT
ORQJWKURZKLJKJDXVVPDJQHWVWUXFWXUHGULYHUV 3URGXFWLRQ'LUHFWRU Kasey Kelley
RU DQGSUHVVXUHFRXSOHGGRZQZDUG (GLWRULDO'LUHFWRU'LJLWDO Chris Mauro
ÀULQJTXDGUDWLFSODQDULQIUDVRQLFUDGLDWRUV )LQDQFH'LUHFWRU Adam Miner

,QDGGLWLRQWKHLUXQLTXHO\VKDSHGFDELQHWV DIGITAL GROUP


DUHQRWMXVWDWWUDFWLYHEXWDUHDOVRSXUSRVHIXOO\ 'LJLWDO'LUHFWRU(QJLQHHULQJ Jeff Kimmel
FRQÀJXUHGIRUGUDPDWLFSHUIRUPDQFHEHQHÀWV 6HQLRU3URGXFW0DQDJHU Rishi Kumar
6HQLRU3URGXFW0DQDJHU Marc Bartell &UHDWLYH'LUHFWRU Peter Tracy

“Extraordinary bass prowess... TEN: THE ENTHUSIAST NETWORK, LLC


Chairman: Peter Englehart VP, Sales Operations: Ma Boice
I’ve never heard a sub this small Chief Executive Officer: Sco P. DIckey SVP, Financial Planning: Mike Cummings
go that deep” EVP, Chief Financial Officer: Bill Sutman
President, Automotive: Sco Bailey
SVP, Automotive Digital: Geoff DeFrance
VP, Editorial Operations: Amy Diamond
— Steve Guttenberg, The Audiophiliac EVP, Chief Creative Officer: Alan Alpanian EVP, Aermarket Automotive: Doug Evans
EVP, Sports & Entertainment: Norb Garre SVP, Content Strategy, Automotive: David Freiburger
:LWKWKHLUKLJKRXWSXWFDSDELOLW\VWXQQLQJ EVP, Chief Content Officer: Angus MacKenzie SVP, Digital, Sports & Entertainment: Greg Morrow
LPSDFWVXSHUEO\PXVLFDOEDVVDUWLFXODWLRQDQG EVP, Operations: Kevin Mullan VP, Digital Monetization: Elisabeth Murray
SVP, Enterprises: Tyler Schulze SVP, Marketing: Ryan Payne
EUHDWKWDNLQJLQIUDVRQLFORZIUHTXHQF\FDSDELOL EVP, Sales & Marketing: Eric Schwab EVP, Mind Over Eye: Bill Wadsworth
WLHVWKH)RUFH)LHOGVKDYHUHFHLYHGWKHKLJKHVW SVP, Digital Operations: Dan Bednar
SUDLVHIURPFULWLFVH[SHUWVDQGNQRZOHGJHDEOH CONSUMER MARKETING, ENTHUSIAST MEDIA SUBSCRIPTION COMPANY, INC.
OLVWHQHUVDURXQGWKHZRUOG*HRII0RUULVRQRI SVP, Circulation: Tom Slater
5HVLGHQWLDO6\VWHPVUDYHG´WKHLUWKXQGHUÀOOHG VP, Retention & Operations Fulfillment: Donald T. Robinson III
WKHURRPμ$9)RUXPVSUDLVHGWKH´PRQVWURXV
TEN: THE ENTHUSIAST TEN: THE ENTHUSIAST
RXWSXWIRUVXFKDVPDOOVXEμ0DUN)OHLVFKPDQ NETWORK, LLC NETWORK, LLC
RI+RPH7KHDWHUZURWH´,ZDVGXPIRXQGHGμ 831 S. DOUGLAS ST. 261 MADISON AVE.
EL SEGUNDO, CA 90245 NEW YORK, NY 10016
RYHUWKHLU´ORZIUHTXHQF\EDUUDJHVZLWKÁRRU PHONE: (310) 531-9900 PHONE: (212) 915-4000
VKDNLQJFRQÀGHQFHμ$QGWRWRSLWRIIWKH%ULWLVK
Back Issues: To order back issues, visit www.circsource.com/store/storeBackIssues.html.
ZULWHU6WHSKHQ0D\UDYHG´WKLVDVWRQLVKLQJ Reprints:&RQWDFW:ULJKW·V0HGLD RXWVLGHWKH86DQG&DQDGD 
ER[FDQSUHVVXUHORDGDURRPOLNHDQDQJU\ WRSXUFKDVHTXDOLW\FXVWRPUHSULQWVRUHSULQWVRIDUWLFOHVDSSHDULQJLQWKLVSXEOLFDWLRQ
6LOYHUEDFNμDQG$QGUHZ5RELQVRQZDUQV Subscription Customer Service:(PDLOsoundandvision@emailcustomerservice.com,
FDOO   LQWHUQDWLRQDOFDOOV 
´<RXUZDOOVÁRRUERDUGVDQGFHLOLQJPD\MXVW RUZULWHWR6RXQG 9LVLRQ32%R[3DOP&RDVW)/
FUDSRXWRQ\RXμ$QGDV'HQQLV%XUJHURI7HFK 3OHDVHLQFOXGHIXOOQDPHDGGUHVVDQGSKRQHQXPEHURQDQ\LQTXLULHV
Canada Post:5HWXUQXQGHOLYHUDEOH&DQDGLDQDGGUHVVHVWR,0(;*OREDO6ROXWLRQV
7HOOREVHUYHGWKH\DUHDOVR´VKRFNLQJO\PXVLFDOμ 32%R[/RQGRQ211&%
$Q\VXEPLVVLRQVRUFRQWULEXWLRQVIURPUHDGHUVVKDOOEHVXEMHFWWRDQGJRYHUQHGE\
7(17KH(QWKXVLDVW1HWZRUN·V8VHU&RQWHQW7HUPVDQG&RQGLWLRQV
ZKLFKDUHSRVWHGDWKWWSZZZHQWKXVLDVWQHWZRUNFRPVXEPLVVLRQV

www.goldenear.com
Follow us on: &23<5,*+7%<7(17+((17+86,$671(7:25.
facebook.com/goldenear 0$*$=,1(6//&$//5,*+765(6(59('35,17(',17+(86$
& twitter.com/goldeneartech
oldenEar has Engineered Our New Triton One
to Perform Like a $20,000+ Super Speaker!
“Revelatory … cosmically orgasmic … astounding performance-vs-price …
these speakers absolutely embalm the competition” – Darryl Wilkinson, Sound & Vision

“ Triton One shames some speakers costing ten times


as much … it is an absolute marvel”
– Caleb Denison, Digital Trends

Two 5.25˝ High-Definition Cast-


Basket Bass/Midrange Drivers
“ Best High-End Value at CES 2014 … Sandy has
w/ Multi-Vaned Phase Plugs created a speaker that defies its price point”
– John Sciacca, Residential Systems
Optimized Dual-Chamber
Upper-Bass/Midrange Enclosure “ Best of CES 2014 … stunning realism … the sound
with Angled Rear Walls
was truly grand and majestic” – Roger Kanno, SoundStage
High-Velocity Folded Ribbon
Tweeter (HVFR) w/ Zobel Network “ Best Sound for the Money at CES 2014”
– Jonathan Valin, Kirk Midskog and Neil Gader, The Absolute Sound

Introducing Triton One, an evolutionary speaker that builds upon advanced


Open-Cell Polyurethane
Foam Damping Pads and
technologies that have made Tritons mega-hits around the world. Stereophile
Complex Internal Bracing called them, “A Giant Killer Speaker” and Robert Deutsch further added, “it’s
not unreasonable to compare the sound of the $4998 Triton One with speakers
costing tens of thousands of dollars more”. This new top-of-the-line flagship was
engineered to deliver even better dynamics and bass than the extraordinary
Triton Two, along with further refinement of all aspects of sonic performance.
Three 5˝ x 9˝ Quadratic Sub-Bass How well have we succeeded? In the words of HD Living’s Dennis Burger, the
Drivers in Semi-Line-Source Array
Triton One delivers, “… the sort of upper-echelon performance that normally
only comes from speakers whose price tags rival a good luxury automobile”.
Hybrid Phase-Perfect
Electronic/Passive Low
Frequency Crossover Triton One “creates visceral, tangible waves of pure
audio bliss” – Dennis Burger, HD Living

Great sound is what it is all about and the Triton Ones deliver, as The Absolute
Linear-Phase Fully Balanced Sound’s Anthony Cordesman wrote “they provide sustained musical pleasure
Crossover Network
and exceptional realism … extraordinary sound quality and value … one of the
best buys in speakers … highly recommended”. The Ones were specifically
Four Inertially-Balanced Quadratic engineered to excel with all types of music as well as movies. Best of all, they
Planar Infrasonic Radiators: offer previously unheard of value, as Brent Butterworth wrote in Sound & Vision,
Two On Each Side of Cabinet
“I heard a few people saying the Triton One sounded like some $20,000-and-
up high-end towers, but I disagree: I think they sounded better than most of
them”. Hi Fi+’s Chris Martens raved the Ones are, “jaw-droppingly good …
one of the greatest high-end bargains of all time with a dazzling array of sonic
characteristics”. And Darryl Wilkinson summed them up best, “A Masterpiece
1600-Watt 56-Bit DSP-Controlled … GoldenEar has fully ushered in the Golden Age of the Loudspeaker”. Hear
Class D Digital Amplifier them for yourself and discover what all the excitement is about.
Accelerometer-Optimized
Non-Resonant Cabinet
w/ Non-Parallel Walls

Triton One Tower


$2499 ea.
www.goldenear.com
PO Box 141, Stevenson, MD 21153 (410) 998-9134
Like us on Facebook! Follow us on Twitter!
facebook.com/goldenear twitter.com/goldeneartech
?djheZkY_d]j^[D[m

Jh_jedI[l[d
\hec=ebZ[d;WhJ[Y^debe]o®
“ GoldenEar’s new Triton Seven is downright unbelievable …
gets my vote for the high-end audio bargain of CES 2013 …”
– Chris Martens, HiFi+

7mWhZM_dd_d]Jh_jed#I[h_[iF[h\ehcWdY[_dWCeh[
9ecfWYjI_p[WdZ;l[dCeh[7¢ehZWXb[Fh_Y[
7jjhWYj_l[9WX_d[jI^Wf[?dYehfehWj[iH[WhmWhZ
HWa[\ehWJ_c[#Wb_]d[Z"9e^[h[djMWl[BWkdY^
Jm_d+$(+ò9Wij8Wia[j8Wii%C_ZhWd][:h_l[hi"
I_]dWjkh[>_]^L[beY_jo<ebZ[ZH_XXedJm[[j[h
:kWbI_Z[#cekdj[ZIkX#XWiiHWZ_Wjehi\eh
IkXmee\[h#gkWb_jo8WiiF[h\ehcWdY[
F[h\[Yj\eh>_]^#h[iebkj_edH[fheZkYj_ed
e\8ej^Cki_YWdZCel_[i
Those Lirpa Lovers

Letters We welcome
questions and
comments

E-mail them to HTLetters@sorc.com. Please note: Questions about the features and functions of a
particular product are best directed to the manufacturer. Questions about what product you should buy are
best directed to a dealer who knows all the details of your system, your preferences, and your personal habits.
Based on Geoffrey Morrison’s April 2015
review of the Lirpa MZ1-949r soundbar, I
purchased one. The review failed to mention
that the electronics require a dedicated 30-amp,
120-volt feed. This info can be found in fine
print on page 944 of the user’s manual. Also, no
mention was made as to the best placement for
this soundbar. I placed mine as pictured in your
All submissions are considered the exclusive property of Sound & Vision magazine and TEN: The Enthusiast
April issue, directly in front of my 45-inch TV.
Network. We reserve the right to edit letters for brevity. Due to the volume of mail that we receive, we regret Because most of the TV picture was blocked
that we cannot respond to every letter. (and, as you mentioned, had a red tint), I
turned it off and discovered
those inky blacks you always
talk about.
F. Richard Firth
Sarasota, FL 

Seriously How can a soundbar tint an image red? Oh,


yes, it’s from Lirpa Labs! That explains

INTO AUDIO
everything!
Steve Hanson
Austin TX

It’s good to be reading Geoffrey Morrison again


since 1974 (“The Greatest Soundbar Ever,” April). Nothing
says perfection like a bunch of $8 plastic
speakers designed 40 years ago. I’m immedi-
ately getting one for my 36-inch Toshiba CRT.
I’m not one to be fooled by this 16x9 LED
craze, and when it’s over, I’ll be the one
laughing.
Chris Gregory
The perfect Shipped Supported Roanoke, VA

gear. free. forever. I was elated when I saw the article on the Lirpa
Labs MZ1-949r soundbar. I was fortunate
enough to find the Lirpa self-propelled phono
cartridge at a yard sale about 10 years ago. The
motor was still functioning, but there were a
couple of problems with its operation. My wife
suggested we rotate the tires and that solved the
See our full product selection or sign up problem. I guess with it going round and round
for our email newsletter and catalog at in the same direction, it wore down the ones on
the inside. We eventually had to get replace-
crutchfield.com/svs ment tires from Monster for $50 each, and it’s
1-800-319-8843 working perfectly. I did find out later, though,
that I could have gotten them from Monoprice
for $2 for the set, with free shipping. I missed
out and never was able to find the Lirpa Labs
steam-powered turntable but will keep
checking eBay.
Thanks so much for the fine journalism, and
I’m looking forward to the next Lirpa
invention.
Jim Wilson
Via e-mail

We received a number of e-mails from longtime


readers about our review of Dr. Lirpa’s latest
advance, mostly positive, a couple not-so,
including one from a clearly very serious reader
in Columbus, Ohio, who thought Lirpa product
reviews represent a waste of otherwise good space
in our magazine, and a similar note from our
general manager after I informed him that the
good doctor never buys advertising (with
products like his, he doesn’t need to). But we hear
from Lirpa so infrequently—barely once a year,
in fact—and his inventions and claims are
12 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
LETTERS
typically so outlandish that we can’t resist dipping This is a good subject that we can look into, but If you do your research on the dress controversy
into the other side of A/V madness. Long live for now, I’m going to throw this out to our readers (wired.com ran one of the better scientific
Loof.—RS and experts more knowledgeable than I. Does explanations I’ve seen), you’ll discover that this
anyone have experience where a conventional ordinary image was actually kind of extraordi-
ZZZZZAP! surge protector proved to be the critical fuse nary. This photo, by the nature of its subject
I’m a longtime Stereo Review/Sound & Vision between your gear and a significant lightning matter (which was in fact a blue and black dress)
subscriber, and I don’t believe I have seen my event? Are there installers and engineers among and the sunlit background behind it, sat on the
particular issue discussed. I have spent years you who understand the nature of how these edge of a particular boundary of human vision
upgrading my home theater and finally got to strikes snake into our equipment and have wherein we are usually able to easily eliminate the
where I wanted to be—55-inch Panasonic methods to mitigate the concern? Send us your effects of background color on the foreground
plasma, Yamaha A/V receiver, and an Oppo story, and we’ll share.—RS subject. That photo, it turns out, just messed with
Blu-ray player—only to have it all destroyed in our eyes—or our heads, depending on your
an instant by a bolt of lightning that struck my That Stupid Dress perspective. Our collective perception of it hardly
home. Standard surge suppressors are of no use I am nauseated from hearing opinions on the qualifies as a reason to abandon display
when it comes to lightning. Was there anything I viral white/gold versus black/blue dress calibration.
could have done to protect my gear? controversy. But at least there has been a That said, there are indeed some real and
Brian Newell scientific explanation that credits the physiology consistent variations in our visual perception of
Via e-mail of each individual’s eyes with the different color among those suffering from color blindness,
perception of color. a condition that is almost strictly found among
This brings us to the argument of the validity men. I reached out to ISF’s Joel Silver on this, who
CORRECTIONS of TV picture calibration. Based upon the commented that “with 7 to 10 percent of the male
In our April New Gear department, pricing for the scientific community agreement on this current population being afflicted” by some level of color
Triad Inroom Bronze LR-H Dolby Atmos Speaker burning sociological issue, it would lead to the blindness, “this is one of many reasons we use
should have been listed as $1,000 each, not conclusion that any calibration process would be meters instead of our eyes. This is also one reason
$1,000 per pair. flawed by the color perception of the person that novice calibrations are often worse than the
performing the technical process. And different right factory calibration.”
The editor’s response to a letter in the April issue technicians adjusting the same set would possibly If you’d like to test your own eyes for color
about factory image settings for TVs (“Why Yes, produce different setting levels according to that blindness, one resource is the Website of
They Should”) cited Joel Silver (a technical individual’s unique color perception. Enchroma, a company that makes color-boosting
consultant to Sound & Vision) as founder of the Does this not diminish the value of profes- glasses for the color blind. Visit enchroma.com
Imaging Science Foundation. In fact, he should sional or even novice color adjustments? Isn’t it and click on the link for “Color Blindness Test.”
have cited Silver as a co-founder along with Joe valid to simply adjust for the most pleasing And in case you’re wondering, yes, I took the test
Kane, who first championed consumer awareness balance for the primary viewer? and found out I have normal color vision.
of image quality and remains among the industry’s Bruce Domenella Whew!—RS
most respected experts. Bradenton, FL

® Star Panels &


LED Lighting
Advanced star ceilings with
shooting stars, meteor showers,
3D LED Moons, and even sound
Theater Curtains Theater Seating
Custom Home Theater Curtains, Not all seating is created equal.
plus the highest quality Hardwood frames, commercial
commercial drapery and tracks. quality springs and foam, plus
Virtually anything you can 100% top grain leather provides
dream, we can create. the comfort you deserve and is
a better long term investment.

Theater Decor Complete Theater Interiors


Everything for your Home
Theater but the electronics.
Call to speak with a product
expert, or to receive our free
color catalog and informative
CinemaShopper newsletter.

Visit us at CinemaShop.com or Call Toll Free 1-866-243-1001


7DQQR\·VFODVVOHDGLQJ'HÀQLWLRQ
ORXGVSHDNHUKDVHYROYHG The new
%FmOJUJPO%$5JBOE%$5J
nPPSTUBOEJOHNPEFMTSBJTFUIFCBS
GPSBDPVTUJDQFSGPSNBODFXJUIOFX
QMJOUIT JOUFHSBUFEFOFSHZHSPVOEJOH
TUBCJMJTFSXFJHIUTBOESFWJTFE
DSPTTPWFSTXJUIVQHSBEFEDPNQPOFOUT
3FUBJOJOHUIFTBNFTVNQUVPVTTUZMF
BOEOPXPGGFSJOHBOFWFONPSF
BSUJDVMBUFNVTJDBMQSFTFOUBUJPO 
%FmOJUJPO5JFWPMWFTUIFEFmOJUJPO
PGDPOUFNQPSBSZMPVETQFBLFSEFTJHO

The Definition )LQGRXWPRUHDWWDQQR\FRP

of sound.
Evolved

Revox Joy S119 Network Receiver and G Shelf Speakers

For almost six decades, Revox has produced audio products known for exemplary performance and a level of
technical perfection that comes with meticulous Swiss-German engineering. From the legendary Revox A77 reel-
to-reel tape machine through today’s elegant and imaginative Joy systems featuring full 24 bit /192 kHz playback
support, Revox develops products that blend elegant European design with innovative technologies and unparalleled
digital expertise. Revox. Exquisitely engineered. ox Joy S208
mote Control

www.tcgroup.tc/ReVox
Revox is distributed in North America by TC Group. 335 Gage Ave, Kitchener, ON N2M 5E1, Canada | Tel: +1 (519) 745 -1158
Perfect focus
NEW GEAR, TOP NEWS, HOW TO, AND MORE...
Edited by Claire Crowley

Taking TV to
the Next Level VP: Everyone in the Alliance is in saturation of any particular color, so
Introducing the Ultra High Definition Alliance agreement that we need to agree on even without expanding the color
a standard and to do so with relative gamut, HDR can create richer colors
When we first heard about the Ultra of optimizing consumer experi- speed. One of our objectives is to in addition to higher contrast.
High Definition Alliance, an industry ences. The innovations under allow innovation to bloom on top There’s a huge benefit to
coalition that has set its sights on consideration include 4K resolution, of those specifications, so as the widening the color gamut beyond
establishing new standards that high dynamic range (HDR) video, technologies continue to evolve, we the current Rec. 709 specification
raise the bar on video quality, we and wide-color gamut. anticipate companies will strive for (which is 25 years old this year). But
were eager to learn more, especially even higher levels of excellence. it’s hard to explain to a consumer
after perusing the “who’s who” list of S&V: What are the Alliance’s goals? The Alliance is currently working to because they don’t know what
member companies: DirecTV, Dolby, VP: The goal is to define what a establish specifications and best they’ve been missing. The exact red
LG, Netflix, Panasonic, Samsung, higher-quality UHD experience practices for so-far-undefined home of a London phone booth or green of
Sharp, Sony, Technicolor, Walt should mean for consumers and to entertainment features. Specifica- a freeway sign in Los Angeles are
Disney Studios, Twentieth Century establish and communicate quality tions up for discussion are con- both examples of colors that do
Fox, and Warner Bros. We caught standards for new video technolo- fidential until the Alliance makes a not currently exist in the consumer
up with Vince Pizzica, senior execu- gies that will allow industry players to specific announcement. display color space. That means that
tive vice president of strategy at align and seamlessly integrate their whenever they are represented on
Technicolor, to find out what makes offerings. Color depth, luminance, S&V: Which advance will benefit TVs, you are actually not seeing
the UHD Alliance tick. and color space are all within remit of consumers most? them as they are in real life
the Alliance. It’s necessary for the VP: While the extra resolution of
S&V: How and why was the UHD Alliance to address fundamental UHD provides enhanced quality, S&V: When can we expect to see
Alliance formed, and what is its issues for HDR like, “how bright especially on larger displays, we’re HDR content from Hollywood?
mission? should bright be?” and for color most excited by higher dynamic VP: We’re expecting HDR titles,
VP: The UHD Alliance is a collection gamut, “how wide should the color range video, which will provide a graded to an interoperable standard,
of companies from across the space be?” and then determine how radical increase in video quality. HDR to be available later this year.
creation, distribution, and display we explain these benefits to is not just increasing brightness.
ecosystem that have aligned to consumers. At Technicolor, we believe that S&V: Any closing observations?
agree on interoperable open enhancing dark shadow images is VP: We expect the adoption of HDR
standards and best practices for S&V: How will the Alliance equally important. HDR technology displays to be very rapid once
the latest innovations in video accomplish these goals, and what is allows us to both raise the ceiling consumers can experience those
technology, with the ultimate goal the timetable? and drop the floor, to the point where displays at retail. TVs next to an HDR
VP: The UHD Alliance is committed dark blacks and gray gradients display will look strangely washed
• Vince Pizzica to establishing an open, collabora-
tive framework. What we want
reveal incredible detail that the
consumer has never before been
out, pale, and dull in comparison.
—Bob Ankosko
to avoid is new innovations in able to see. Expanding the dynamic
consumer technologies that are not range also has a side benefit of An extended version of this interview
compatible with other devices or increasing the perception of appears on soundandvision.com.
specific pieces of content that are
only available on certain devices.
A single, open specification will
eliminate the “chicken and egg”
scenario of content and hardware
availability.

S&V: The press release announc-


ing the Alliance talks about a
“technology road map.” Can you
elaborate?

16 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


This Just In...
By Mark Fleischmann

Live DSD Audio


Streaming
is getting a tryout in April from
Sony, Korg, Internet Initiative
Japan, and Saidera Paradiso.
The streams feature the Berlin
Philharmonic in two concerts at
the Spring Festival in Tokyo...
potential subscribers, 91 Super Bowl XLIX. DirecTV is Sonos interface became
percent now get pay-TV, but the first operator to carry it, available as a free app
half would cancel it after though presumably others upgrade in January...
getting HBO streaming... will follow...
Sears’ Connected
Dish Network’s CBSN, the 24-Hour Solutions
AutoHop, News Channel shops are popping up at
the ad-skipping feature in its just launched by you-know- 200 Sears and 300 Kmart
Hopper DVR, got thumbs up who, has come to iOS stores. More than 100
in federal district court, along devices, and Android featured products will
Sling TV year, says DisplaySearch. with the PrimeTime Anytime support is imminent. It is include garage door
launched following its The panel module accounts and Slingbox technologies. already available on openers, locks, monitors,
introduction at January’s for 70 to 80 percent of TV However, while Dish claimed browsers, Roku, Amazon motion sensors, thermo-
Consumer Electronics Show. pricing, and many victory over the networks Fire TV, and Windows Phone stats, and wearables...
The app is available on iOS, value-added features are litigating against it, the judge 8.1...
Android, PC, Mac, Roku, and embedded in it... did agree with Fox that Expanded Hotel TV
Amazon’s Fire TV and Fire TV transfer of recordings, and The FCC Slammed Options
stick, with LG and Samsung Traditional TV copying to watermark Viacom are being tested by Marriott
smart TVs to come... Viewing Plummeted commercials for ad and ESPN with $1.4 million in with streaming services
12 percent in 2014 over the skipping, violated the fines for transmitting such as Netflix, Hulu, and
Six New Ultra HD previous year, says a retransmission agreement... Emergency Alert System Pandora. Cost undeter-
Services Nomura study, with Netflix, et tones to promote Olympus mined...
will make their debuts in al. luring away eyeballs in the Comcast Is Busy as a Has Fallen, a movie about a
2015, according to research U.S. In the U.K., Ofcom Bee terror attack on Washington. The Parents Televi-
by Fairmile West, many of measured a smaller 4 rolling out IP-only video “Danger to public safety,” sion Council
them using efficient HEVC percent drop... gateways, including the Xi3, declared the commission... is petitioning cable
compression. But content arriving early this year, and operators to remove We TV
scarcity and production Xbox One Is Getting the Xi4, just approved by the Sony and Spotify from their bundles, citing the
problems are going to be DTS-HD FCC. The company is also have agreed to bring the reality show Sex Box. This is
hurdles... surround for Starz, Encore, working on a new audio streaming giant to 64 the first time PTC has urged
and Movieplex subscribers, generation of the XG1 million PlayStation users. the removal of an entire
Two “Proof of enhancing more than 2,000 HD-DVR gateway and is Sony’s Video Unlimited and channel...
Concept” UHD movies, TV episodes, and mulling over smaller IP Music Unlimited services will
broadcasts hit Time Warner original programs. The devices that consume less be renamed PlayStation National TV Safety
Cable’s closed-circuit streaming version of power... Video and PlayStation Music Day
SportsNet, including an NBA DTS-HD is also used by as they move to the delivers the disturbing
season game and a high CinemaNow and Ultraflix NBC Universo, PlayStation Network... message that a kid goes to
school football champion- Streaming Network... the new network for Latinos, the emergency room every
ship. Cameras and made its debut with a URC Is Combining 45 minutes due to TVs that
everything else in the signal HBO’s Streaming Spanish-language version of its two control systems, Total tip over or are poorly
path were UHD capable... Service Control and ccGEN2, secured. So dump that
would attract 17 percent of converging their software to heavy CRT set, make sure
Panel Prices U.S. broadband households, ease purchasing, training, your flat panel is secured
will have a strong impact on says research from Parks programming, and with a safety-certified mount,
profitability of TV makers this Associates. Of those marketing. The company’s and get more information at
safekids.org/tv...

soundandvision.com 17
Hands
ClearView Clio Bluetooth Speaker
ClearView Clio Bluetooth
Speaker
Performance
Features
Build Quality
Value
By Bob Ankosko

Crystal Clear house, including an acoustically live


kitchen and living room, a carpeted
family room, a small guest room, and
THE VERDICT
Clio is an unobtrusive, one-of-
a-kind speaker that is capable of
PRICE $349 AT A GLANCE
a decent-sized bedroom.
producing clear yet confined
I listened to a broad selection of
sound with limited volume and
THEY CALL CLIO THE FIRST music on Pandora via my iPad, and
invisible speaker. And even though Plus the sound was generally clean and
bass potential.
it’s not really invisible, when you put Q Blends into any décor clear no matter where I set up the
this unique specimen on a kitchen Q A cinch to setup speaker, but it can’t play very loud
counter, end table, or fireplace Q Clear, clean sound with and bass output is limited, neither
mantel, it’s pretty darn hard to spot vocal and acoustic music of which is surprising given Clio’s
with its low-profile base and acrylic diminutive size and light weight (just
glass “windshield” that disappears under 2 pounds). Moving Clio closer
into the room.
Minus to the wall bolsters the bass but at
The flexible and slightly curved Q Volume and bass are the expense of clarity; vocals, in
windshield (my term, not theirs) is limited particular, can sound cupped if you
actually a dipole speaker that Q Sound is confined move the speaker too close to the
radiates sound to the front and back Q Pricey wall (remember, it radiates sound in
when excited by a couple of small both directions). standout, along with anything
piezoelectric actuators hidden in the ClearView describes Clio as a from acoustic guitar master Will
base—one for the left channel, one on the front indicates status (white stereo speaker capable of delivering Ackerman. Rock—old and new—
for the right channel. High-frequency for standby, red when using the “panoramic room-filling sound,” but didn’t fare as well, often sounding
sound generated by the acrylic lone minijack input, and blue for that’s quite a stretch. Clio can fill a thin and congested. The signature
panel is supplemented by a 2-inch Bluetooth). The speaker is available small room with sound, but it’s not crunch-guitar crescendo leading
“woofer” that fires down from the with a Charcoal, Silver, or Dark terribly full-bodied, and it’s definitely into to the chorus of Weezer’s
bottom of Clio’s base; rubber feet lift Bronze base. not panoramic. In an e-mail “Undone (The Sweater Song)”
the base just enough for the speaker exchange I had with a company lacked the power it’s known for. If
and a tiny port to breathe. Here, There, Everywhere executive, he admitted that, like you’re looking for a party companion
Clio is super simple to set up and Setting up my Samsung Galaxy S5 many compact all-in-one systems, or just like to rock out, you’ll be much
use. Decide where you want to put it, and iPad for streaming was quick “separation is not great” and said better off with a conventional—albeit
run the supplied power cord to a and easy. Press and hold the they chose to exclude spatial much clunkier—speaker setup.
nearby AC outlet, and either plug in Bluetooth button to put Clio in processing because they didn’t want If you’re intrigued by Clio, as I
an iPod or other audio source or pair pairing mode, select “Clio” from the to degrade the sound. ClearView is was, ClearView offers a 60-day,
it with your Bluetooth device of list of Bluetooth devices on the planning to offer an accessory cable money-back guarantee, so go
choice. (Someday we’ll be able to phone or tablet you want to use, and for those who want to use two Clios ahead and try it. Worst case, you
dispense with the power cord for truly start streaming. It’s that simple. If you as a stereo pair. send it back.
wireless sound—it’s coming, don’t plan to use more than one Bluetooth All that aside, Clio is fine for
worry—but for now, we’ll just have to source, Clio automatically connects background music and casual
tolerate those unsightly wires.) to the most recently used device, or listening in spaces where bulky
Controls are minimal like the Clio you can select Clio on the device you speakers are not practical or SPECS
itself: Four buttons on the right side want to use. welcome. It’s particularly adept at Driver Configuration: 1 down-
of the base for volume up/down, I spent several hours setting up reproducing acoustic music, firing 2-inch woofer, clear acrylic
mute, and Bluetooth pairing. An LED Clio in different rooms around the particularly vocals. Gavin James’ glass dipole transducer with left-
acrobatic falsetto and right-channel peizoelectric
on “Nervous” (Live actuators • Amplifier: Custom-
at Whelans) was designed Class D • Controls: But-
remarkably clear, tons for mute, Bluetooth mode,
as was Scotty volume up/down • Features: LED
McCreery’s status indicator on front panel •
baritone on “The Dimensions (WxHxD, Inches):
Trouble With Girls” 12.75 x 9 (to top of acrylic glass) x
(Clear as Day). The 3.75; 12.75 x 1.5 x 3.75 (base only)
interplay between • Weight (Pounds): 1.9 • Con-
violin, cello, and nections: 3.5mm analog audio in-
guitar on Natalie put • Accessories: Male-to-male
MacMaster’s minijack audio cable, microfiber
“Farewell to Peter” cleaning cloth • Available Colors
(Yours Truly) was (Base): Charcoal, Silver, Dark
also an acoustic Bronze • Warranty: 1 year, limited

Clearview Audio • clearviewaudio.com


PERFECT FOCUS

The Connected Life FCC Panel Mulls


Cable Security
john sciacca The CableCARD was intended to liberate the
TV from the dreaded cable box, but spotty
implementation doomed it. Now the security

Apple integration ban that mandated the card is


sunsetting, and a long-envisioned down-
loadable successor is being considered.
Watch(es) Determining how that should work is the
task of the Downloadable Security Technol-

Home ing time seems to be one of the Watch’s


ogy Advisory Committee (DSTAC). The
Federal Communications Commission has

Automation ancillary functions.


More exciting for me are the potential
benefits the Apple Watch could bring to
appointed 18 people to the committee from
a variety of backgrounds.
Recent bipartisan federal legislation orders
home automation and control. I already the committee to set “performance objectives,
For years, I’ve considered the use my iPhone and iPad to interact with technical capabilities, and technical standards
wristwatch a generational virtually every aspect of my Control4, of a not unduly burdensome, uniform, and
barometer. I was born in 1970 Crestron, and Lutron controlled home, so technology- and platform-neutral software-
and have worn a watch for as could my wrist become the next point of based downloadable security system” for set-
long as I can remember. I started off with a must-have control? top boxes, TVs, and anything interacting with
Mickey Mouse model, then went through a Watch apps from Honeywell, Lutron, a cable, satellite, or telco-TV system.
Swatch phase before moving on to a Casio and Alarm.com are already announced, Yes, the cable, satellite, and telco-TV indus-
calculator model, then graduating to which will offer simple and intui- tries are represented via Comcast, Cable-
a Gucci and eventually settled on tive interaction with your vision, Charter, Dish Network, and AT&T
a luxury Swiss dive model home’s HVAC, lighting, and Labs; plus their tech suppliers Arris, Evolu-
when I could finally afford security systems, but the tion Digital, and Nagra. But consumer elec-
it. I got it in 2003 and still Apple Watch could harness tronics manufacturers are also on hand in the
wear it literally 24/7, and I geofencing and Siri to facili- form of Samsung, Sony, Vizio, and TiVo, as
can’t tell you how many tate automation in new and are tech giants Google and Amazon. Other
times a day I roll my left exciting ways. committee members hail from the consumer
wrist over to check the Geofencing uses GPS or advocacy group Public Knowledge, Columbia
time or date. other radio signals to define University, and on the content side, the
I notice other people geographical boundaries to Motion Picture Association of America.
my age and older are also create a virtual barrier, and Chairing the committee is attorney Cheryl
usually wearing watches. once this barrier is broken, Tritt of Wilkinson Barker Knauer, a
events or activities can be trig- communications-related law firm.
gered. Imagine leaving your Whether this will result in a new genera-
Will Apple’s spin make “house boundary” and having the tion of cable-ready TVs and other devices
wearing a watch cool doors lock, the lights turn off, the security remains to be seen. The last time the FCC
again? arm, and the HVAC go into an away mode, mandated a cable-ready solution, the Cable-
all automatically. With locational aware- CARD, it was widely supported at first by TV
ness, the watch could know which room makers, but only grudgingly by cable opera-
Some as jewelry or fashion pieces, but most you are in and automatically configure tors, who objected that the unidirectional
as functional timepieces because, well, they itself to control that for you. Say, walking standard didn’t support lucrative bidirectional
just always have and that’s what they’re into your bedroom and knowing the TV services like video
comfortable with. But people born after the you want to control, or walking into any on demand.
late ’80s just don’t seem to wear watches room and just tapping the watch to turn When a bidirec-
anymore. That generation prefers referring on the lights. tional Tru2Way
to an omnipresent smartphone. Crestron offers something similar with version became
As I write this, Apple’s Spring Forward its PP-100 PinPoint Proximity Detection available for volun-
event just finished and the company finally Beacon, which can tell iOS devices which tary compliance—
announced details on its long-awaited room they are in; but the watch could take no mandate—a few TV makers supported it,
Apple Watch. With a starting price of $349, these features to the next level, and the but it went nowhere. Eventually TV makers
the watch will be available on April 24, company is already looking at ways to gave up on both versions, and now it’s hard to
meaning at least some of you reading this integrate its automation systems with find a recent model with a CableCARD slot.
will be wearing a watch on your wrist for the Watch. Today most CableCARDs are deployed in
the first time in many years. Apple certainly has a track record for set-top boxes, which defeats the no-box intent
There was certainly a massive wearables reinventing or reimagining a product cat- of cable-readiness. And most of those set-top
trend at this year’s International CES, and egory as they did with the iPod, iPhone, boxes are rented, preserving a profitable line
there are definitely facets of the Apple and iPad. And these iDevices all went on to item on the cable bills of millions of subscrib-
Watch that seem very appealing—and cer- play huge roles in the tech industry, literally ers. How convenient.
tainly far beyond the realm of just being a reshaping the way systems were designed, Will this time be any different? The com-
timepiece. With health monitoring, alerts, installed, and used. Will Apple’s spin be mittee will conduct its meetings in public
messages, phone calls, and the ability to enough to make wearing a watch cool and and deliver its first report to the FCC on
use Apple Pay to spend money more necessary again? Time will tell. September 4.—MF
securely and quickly than ever before, tell-

soundandvision.com 19
Hands
Focal Spirit One S Headphone
Focal Spirit One S Headphone
Performance
Build Quality
Comfort
Value

By Steve Guttenberg

The Joy of Listening


PRICE $249
my average-size ears, it’s
HERE WE GO AGAIN. THAT’S AT A GLANCE almost an over-the-ear. Ceremony CD, the One S
what I remember thinking when I In any case, it’s a plumbed the depths of
heard that Focal, France’s largest Plus closed-back Hausswolff’s lowest
speaker manufacturer, was going to design and does church organ stops. There’s
Q Smooth tonal balance
start making headphones. After a decent job of no flab down there! Even
Q Euro design flair
Beats by Dre opened the blocking Prince’s extra funky “Cream”
floodgates, a number of speaker external noise. didn’t rattle the One S. The
and electronics companies that Minus The One S uses beat goes on.
never made headphones started the same 40mm More audiophile-oriented
Q High-ish head-clamping
jumping into the market. We all Mylar/titanium fare, like trombonist Thurman
pressure
know about Bower & Wilkins and dome driver and ear Green’s Dance of the Night
Klipsch, but then there was KEF, cup as the Classic, but Creatures CD upped the One
NAD, Polk, PSB, RBH, and the two headphones S’s credibility. The sound was
more—so when Focal joined the skill set than crafting headphones. differ in fit and finish. transparent and very open
pack a few years ago, it wasn’t a After all, speakers “play” the room; The three Spirit models for a closed-back head-
shocker. Thing is, making great headphones only have to make your are tuned differently: The phone, with solid, clearly
speakers is a completely different ears happy. Apparently, that’s harder Pro is the most accurate, the defined bass. The One S’s keen
than it seems. Classic has a bit more bass and balance was beyond criticism.
Focal currently offers three sweeter highs, and the One S has
Spirit series headphones: the more bass than the other two,
Pro, Classic, and the model though it’s definitely not excessive. THE VERDICT
I’m reviewing here, the The engineers alter the position of Focal’s latest-generation
One S. Focal doesn’t the driver in the ear cups, bass headphone strikes a keen
specify whether it’s venting, and damping materials in balance of resolution and a
an over- or on-ear each model, but no active sweet tonal balance.
because that processing or electronics are used.
depends on The Pro is $349; Classic, $449; and
how big your the One S is $249. NAD’s sweet Viso HP50 headphone
ears are. For I like that the ear cups swivel side did nothing to alter that opinion. It
to side and vertically to conform to was less transparent on Joel
virtually any size/shape head, but the Frederiksen’s gorgeous Nick Drake
One S’s moderately high head- tribute album, Requiem for a Pink
clamping pressure made wearing Moon. Vocals in particular sounded
this headphone for more than an incredibly present and natural; the
hour or so a bit of a challenge. The One S just let them be.
One S was conceived as a portable A quick switch-over to the newly
design, so it’s going to be listened revised Bowers & Wilkins P5 Series
to on the go in noisy environments, 2 on-ear headphones put the One
with phones and MP3 players. S’s accomplishments in perspective.
One thing’s for sure: It’ll stay put on The P5 S2 is super easy to listen to,
your head! but Frederiksen’s vocals and the
The 56-inch-long cable is recording venue’s room sound were
user-replaceable and sports an more fully brought to life over the
Apple-compatible in-line remote/ One S. They’re both excellent
mic, conveniently located just a few headphones, but the Focal Spirit
inches from the left ear cup. You One S revealed more about the
also get a semi-hard, zippered travel sound of my recordings.
case and a soft travel bag. The
hinged headband allows for
compact storage. SPECS
The One S doesn’t overtly boost Type: Closed-back, on-ear/over-
or bloat the bass; it’s nothing like the-ear • Weight (Ounces): 9.9 •
Beats’ or V-Moda’s fat bottom ends. Impedance: 32 ohms • Sensitivity:
On Anna Von Hausswolff’s splendid 102 dB/1mW

Focal • focal.com
20 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
PERFECT FOCUS
Will VidiPath
Q&A Succeed CableCARD?
In the beginning, there was broadcast TV, then

al griffin cable, then cable boxes, then cable boxes with


security, then an FCC ban on integral security—
the CableCARD was required instead. The intent
was to develop a robust market in CableCARD
All About Atmos-- TVs and retail set-top boxes. But the Cable-
CARD failed to gain traction, the security inte-
and Auro-3D Atmos-enabled speakers to the front and
rear of your current system. A wireless
speaker solution might sound good in
gration ban expired last December, and the cable
industry is ready to move on to a new solution
that would be both secure and IP-based. One
I’m planning a signifi- theory, but the reality is that there aren’t any possible solution is VidiPath from the Digital
cant overhaul of my good options available for Atmos setups. Living Network Alliance (DLNA).
home theater and am Also, wireless speakers still require a power A/V receiver owners may recognize DLNA as
leaning toward using cable, which essentially defeats the whole the standard-setting outfit that enables receivers,
the configuration wireless notion. computers, and many other devices to share
suggested for Auro-3D: 10.1, with Since you can’t easily run new wires, I’d media over a home network. DLNA’s VidiPath is
four corner speakers and one recommend going the Atmos-enabled a new way for set-top boxes and other devices to
overhead voice-of-god speaker. In speaker route. Atmos-enabled speaker securely deliver pay-TV from cable, satellite, and
replacing my current A/V receiver modules, which are available from telco TV operators. It has the support of Com-
with separates, I am concerned companies like Def Tech, Atlantic cast, Time Warner Cable, Cox Communications,
about buying amplifiers that I can Technology, Pioneer, and Onkyo, are and the cable-industry R&D arm CableLabs.
keep over the next several advances designed with angled drivers that bounce DLNA is getting ready to certify VidiPath devices
in surround sound tech/ sound off the ceiling to convey overhead from 20 companies—potentially including not
features. Here’s my question: When effects in Atmos-encoded soundtracks. just set-top boxes, but smart TVs, smartphones,
using height speakers, is it important Such modules can either be placed on tablets, and gaming consoles.
that they be amplified at the same top of or near your current speakers. Will VidiPath get the FCC’s nod as the Cable-
power as those near ear-level? And you don’t have to worry about CARD’s successor? DLNA has asked to be part
Quest Fanning / Brooklyn NY compromised performance since Dolby of the FCC working group that is examining
strongly recommends this solution for options. In the past, the FCC has pushed its own
Yes. Since the audio signal directed to those who, like yourself, are unable or AllVid gateway specification, which has the sup-
individual speakers in object-based Atmos unwilling to retrofit their home theater port of Best Buy, Google, Sony, and TiVo, among
and channel-based Auro-3D systems are with in-ceiling speakers. others—but no cable companies. We’d love to
full-bandwidth, it’s important that each see a solution that has the support of both the
speaker receives the same level of power. I am new to the world of home consumer electronics industry and the pay-TV
This will be true for both height and theater, but I’m building a house providers.—MF
ear-level speakers. When planning your soon and want to plan for the
system, you should seek out amplifier possibility of a home theater setup.
combinations that deliver equal power—a I like the idea of having in-ceiling
7 x 200-watt plus a 3 x 200-watt model, or speakers running the surround
two 5 x 200-watt models, for example. As sound. Is it possible to set up a Dolby
for future advances in surround sound, Atmos system that exclusively uses
amplifier tech is unlikely to change
much—they are perhaps the most stable
in-ceiling speakers?
Jonathan Huizingh / via e-mail
Petitioners Protest
components of any sound system. You
won’t have to worry about replacing them Yes, but to be honest, that strategy is not
Cable Billing
in the near term. recommended anywhere in Dolby’s As the regulatory wheels grind
literature for home Atmos installations. through the proposed mega-
For Atmos, the height speakers (either merger between Comcast and
Should I amplify my height in-ceiling or Dolby-enabled models) are Time Warner Cable, activists
speakers at the same power meant to extend the sound coming from are turning up the heat, filing a
the main (ear-level) speakers, as well as petition with the FCC protest-
as those near ear level? convey vertical effects such as rain falling ing TWC’s billing practices.
or helicopters flying overhead. Dolby has Bruce Kushnick of New Net-
even created a naming system for Atmos works Institute and Tom Allibone of Teletruth
I have a 7.1 setup and am interested in layouts that specifies the number of main say that TWC added “made-up fees” to its Triple
upgrading my receiver/processor to speakers plus subwoofers and height Play, charged rate increases to all subscribers in
one that supports Dolby Atmos. My speakers: i.e., 5.1.4 (five main speakers, one exchange for free Internet service to schools but
situation won’t allow me to easily run subwoofer, four height speakers) or 7.1.2 never provided the service, sold broadband ser-
new wires. Is there a good wireless (seven main speakers, one subwoofer, two vices that were never delivered, and price-gouged
speaker option for adding channels height speakers). its way from $22.95/month to $93.16/month for
from a receiver/processor? Or would Of course, home theater installations standard basic cable service from 1992 to 2014.
I be better off trying to retrofit/hide that use all in-ceiling speakers are fairly Have a look at their annotated bill (above). In
new wire runs? common; I’ve experienced a number of related news, Comcast and TWC have extended
Mason Guy / via e-mail them that conveyed an effective surround the merger’s end date to August 12, 2015, while
sound experience. If you do go that route, the FCC and Justice Department continue the
Along with buying a new receiver, I’m sure you’ll probably be happy with vetting process. The merged entity, if allowed,
upgrading your system for Dolby Atmos what you get. Just don’t expect it to would succeed Comcast as the nation’s largest
will entail one of two things: adding necessarily deliver the goods with cable company.—MF
in-ceiling height speakers, or adding Atmos-encoded soundtracks. soundandvision.com 21
PERFECT FOCUS
FCC Boradband
Signals Goal Supports UHD
In its 2015 Broadband Progress Report, the
Federal Communications Commission has
ken c. pohlmann voted to change the definition of broad-
band from 4 to 25 Mbps for downloads
and from 1 to 3 Mbps for uploads.

Saving Hi- That got the approval of Netflix CEO


Reed Hastings. He said consumers need 15
Mbps for a single Netflix Ultra HD stream,
Res Audio hi-res audio compares to a reasonable
and higher speeds would also foster ser-
vices such as video-conferencing and home
reference such as Compact Disc. Easy, monitoring, so 25 Mbps is “baseline for the
Hi-res audio is having right? Well, of course, it’s not, and it’s next five years.”
problems. Not your naive to suggest it. FCC chair Tom Wheeler (below, left)
garden-variety prob- Some argue that comparison testing is didn’t get a unanimous vote, however. Dis-
lems. These are the life- flawed and inherently fails to demon- senting commissioner Michael O’Rielly
threatening problems. Where do I begin? strate the benefits of hi-res or indeed any (right) derided the new definition, saying
Well, Neil Young used Kickstarter to high-fidelity playback. But unless you UHD is “not expected to be widely adopted
raise $6 million to fund his Pono project can demonstrate the improvement, why for years to come.” Apparently he hasn’t
and deliver it into the hands of music should people buy hi-res files? The retort seen sales figures and projections on the
enthusiasts. Good for him. Good for comes quickly: Why stay rooted in the fast-growing UHDTV market. But com-
music. Good for hi-res playback. Of 30-year-old CD standard? Even if the missioner Jessica Rosenworcel (center)
course, nothing is ever that simple. difference is slight, let’s err on the side of pushed for an even more ambitious goal, a
Mr. Young’s bright spotlight spilled caution and use hi-res. download speed of 100 Mbps: “Anything
over onto hi-res itself, and people took a I have a modest proposal. It avoids the short of that shortchanges our children, our
closer look. For example, David Pogue central question because the answer to future, and our new digital economy.”—MF
conducted an informal listening test the question will never end all the argu-
comparing Pono to an iPhone. In Mr. ing, which is an industry unto itself.
Pogue’s test, listeners preferred an Instead, I propose that those who stand
iPhone over a Pono. Partly in response to profit the most from hi-res make a
to that, hi-res audio is now urgently short-term sacrifice, for a potential long-
controversial. term gain.
Other listening tests are appearing, My proposal starts with this premise:
and a certain “piling on” appears to be Consider, for example, your phone, your
taking shape. Some are calling Mr. television, your computer or tablet. Each
Young a charlatan, or worse. In a follow- new generation is better than before; you
up article, Mr. Young responded to Mr. expect that, and that’s why you buy into
Pogue’s criticisms in a friendly and sup- each new model. And, adjusting for
portive way—you know, the way adults inflation, the price of those products
respond to each other. In the blogo-
sphere, things are quite different. The
stays constant or, factoring in their
improved performance, often drops.
Amazon Goes to
Meanwhile, sellers of hi-res music the Movies
want to charge you a steep premium for Jeff Bezos—movie mogul? Don’t be sur-
it. They cannot obviously demonstrate prised if the next movie you see at the local
Hi-res audio is now the benefit and usually don’t reveal the cineplex was bankrolled by Amazon. Says
urgently controversial. provenance of the product (a whole Roy Price, VP of Amazon Studios: “Our goal
other kettle of fish), yet they demand is to create close to 12 movies a year with
a premium. production starting later this year.” Amazon’s
So here’s my proposal: Sell hi-res Original Movies would be exhibited in the-
formerly good-natured debates among music files for the same price as any aters before moving on to Prime Instant
audiophiles is taking a turn for the worse other file. Once the cost issue is Video. Of course, Amazon has already pro-
with commentary ranging from childish removed, maybe people will just treat duced content for the small screen, including
to downright unprofessional. hi-res files like any other, and tempers a couple of dozen pilots and eight series,
The world has enough worries and will calm. Then we can debate something most recently including Bosch, an L.A. crime
doesn’t need the supporters or denigra- really important, like how many angels drama based on the bestselling novels of
tors of hi-res audio to add another one, can dance on the head of a pin. Michael Connelly.—MF
particularly since hi-res audio is a prime My friends in the music industry, con-
example of a first-world problem. Seri- sider this: If people can hear the benefit
ously, can’t we all just get along? Appar- of hi-res, they’ll buy more music—you
ently not, and the juvenile name-calling win. If they can’t hear it, they won’t buy
now popping up on everyone’s search less music. Now, I don’t really care about
engines is going to diminish hi-res audio. music industry profits. I just want people
The solution seems easy. Let’s set up to have a fair opportunity to listen as
some rigorous critical listening tests carefully as they want and never be dis-
and determine how the sound quality of appointed. Also, it would be good if the
zealots took a chill pill.

22 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


elevating
the furniture experience

AV FURNITURE | ENTERTAINMENT SEATING | ADVANCED ACCESSORIES

We design and build the most innovative, stylish, highest quality


AV furniture and home theater seating on the planet. Forget one-size-
Ä[ZHSS(UL_[LUZP]L]HYPL[`VMJVUÄN\YH[PVUZHUKWLYMVYTHUJLLUOHUJPUN
HJJLZZVYPLZHSSV^Z`V\[VJ\Z[VTPaLM\YUP[\YLZVS\[PVUZ[OH[Ä[HU`KLJVY
-YVTV\YJ\Z[VTPaHISLTLKPHJHIPUL[ZHUKH\KPVYHJRZ[VWYLTP\T
SLH[OLYTLKPHJOHPYZHUKTVYL[OPZPZM\YUP[\YL[OH[PUZWPYLZ

*\Z[VTWYVK\J[ZHYLI\PS[[VVYKLYPU[OL<:(\ZPUN[OLÄULZ[
TVZ[Z\Z[HPUHISLTH[LYPHSZ8\PJR:OPW^P[OPUKH`ZHUKJHYY`
HILZ[PUJSHZZ3PML[PTL>HYYHU[`

:LLHSS^LVLYH[SalamanderDesigns.com
PERFECT FOCUS

Apptitude
michael antonoff
From Smug to
Snug: VR for the
Rest of Us
Paul McCartney and Candlestick Park are
more likely to be linked to endings (the last
Beatles concert, 1966; the last big gig at the
Stick, 2014) than new beginnings. But thanks
to an innovative app that incorporates a 360-degree perspec-
tive from the stage of McCartney’s performance of “Live and
Let Die” at the San Francisco ballpark, the man and place will
now be coupled to the birth of an exciting way for everybody Versailles, and appraising a wall of TVs showing different
to enjoy music like never before. YouTube videos. Exploiting the magnetometer in the phone,
Simply called Paul McCartney, the free app available on you flick a magnet controller along Cardboard’s edge to
Google Play from Jaunt, Inc., allows you to use a modest make a selection.
headset to wander the stage, look down at the audience, look With the phone perched inches from your eyes, the display
up at the lights, gaze at band members, see the pyrotechnics, captures your peripheral vision as if you were seated in front
or scrutinize Sir Paul at the piano. of a big screen. An important distinction from traditional
By the way, the experience is not meant for viewing on a home theater is that the picture doesn’t end at the TV’s bezel.
television or computer. You need to be looking everywhere to see the entire show. My
With the smartphone absorbing the functions of so many most important accessory was a swiveling desk chair. You’ll
dedicated devices—cellular phone, music player, video player, want to watch the performance more than once since what
camera, camcorder, voice recorder, map navigator, and por- you see as McCartney sings “this ever-changing world in
table gaming device—it should come as no surprise that it’s which we’re living” depends entirely on where you’re looking
also a virtual-reality headset. at the time.
What’s remarkable about the phone’s entry into VR is that If you plan to use your phone’s built-in speaker, make sure
its screen, accelerometer, and gyroscope replace the most to turn up the volume before you enclose it in Cardboard. For
expensive components of a head-mounted display. Download superior sound and its own volume control, use a Bluetooth
one of the growing number of free or paid apps, and place the speaker. But the best way to experience Paul McCartney is
phone in a tab-to-slot box made largely of corrugated paper private listening. Cardboard accommodated my wired stereo
called Google Cardboard. headphones, delivering audio that was louder as I looked at
the band than when I turned to the audience. Better still were
a pair of Bluetooth headphones that beyond being wireless
Your smartphone is also a virtual- had their own volume controls. Still, the app doesn’t approach
reality headset. the audio sophistication of a demo I once experienced where
I donned a dedicated headset and “walked” between musi-
cians to lean into the sound of each instrument.
Peer into the box’s stereoscopic lenses and turn your head Being nearsighted, I found the viewing better without
every which way. The effect is astounding. The 360-degree glasses. The picture resolution is dependent on your phone’s
view is not unlike what Linda Blair would have seen as she screen. I used a Moto X with a 4.5-inch display that easily fit
surveyed her bedroom in The Exorcist. Objects appear to into Cardboard once I took off a thick protective case. By
have depth, an illusion created by the app’s split screen seen showing two fields of the image side by side to create the pas-
through lenses that anyone who has ever held a View Master sive 3D effect, resolution is sacrificed. The overall effect is
toy will instantly recognize. But this is a View Master with worth it, but it would seem the perfect opportunity for a
sound and motion. The app’s performance was latency free, developer to take advantage of the higher-resolution Retina
and though I was disoriented at times, I felt none of the nau- Display available on newer Apple iPhones.
sea sometimes associated with virtual reality. According to a Google spokesman, “There are a number of
Cardboard comes on the heels of Google’s withdrawal of apps in the Apple Apps Store that can unofficially work with a
Google Glass, the company’s enhanced-reality eyewear. The Cardboard viewer. However, the Cardboard SDK [Software
$1,500 frame, which contained a tiny connected computer Developer’s Kit] does not yet officially support iOS.”
display and camera, was offered to invited geeks who were In the app, the voice of the 72-year-old McCartney didn’t
quickly dismissed by others as glass-holes. Google has taken soar like the Wings of 1973. And the explosive light show
the opposite tack with Cardboard, whose homey name sug- seemed a little too close for comfort. Still, he was in better
gests a device affordable by anyone and whose main require- form than his subsequent appearance on the Saturday Night
ment is already in your pocket. Live 40th Anniversary Special.
Demo apps include rotating objects as if they were in So, how cool is gazing into a cardboard box? Let me count
your hand, chasing a hat in the wind, touring the Palace of the ways.
See google.com/get/cardboard.

24 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


So Pure. So Stylish.
Solo.
Arcam’s world-class reputation for state-of-the-art home cinema and
high performance Hi-Fi systems has now been applied to a soundbar.
The new Solo bar and sub have been designed to make Arcam’s
legendary sound quality accessible to a wider audience, setting a new
standard for music and movie reproduction from a soundbar.

For more information on these landmark products


or to find your nearest stockist visit www.arcam.co.uk Bringing music and movies to life
PERFECT FOCUS

Reference Tracks
mikemettler
Jorma Kaukonen Fingerpicks His Way Through

Photo by Barry Berenson


an Unhurried Embryonic Hi-Res Journey
To modify a phrase,
fingerpicking guitar
maestro Jorma laugh) In terms of microphone
Kaukonen just placement, did you tell Justin
keeps on innovatin’. For over a and Larry [Campbell, producer
half-century, Kaukonen has fol- and guitarist] where you want
lowed his own path and applied everything positioned?
his folk roots to variations on JK: No, what I talk with them
psychedelia with Jefferson Air- about is, “How do you want me
plane and free-form blues with to approach this? How do you
Hot Tuna, not to mention his want me to hold my guitar?” I’ve
own solo rock and unplugged been playing long enough, so I
outings. On his acoustic-driven can hold a guitar pretty much in
new disc, Ain’t in No Hurry (Red any way necessary. And what I
House), Kaukonen continues to realized when we worked with Al
push forward on tasty, intense Schmitt back in the day [as pro-
tracks like the hopeful timeless- ducer on various Jefferson Air-
ness of “In My Dreams,” the tra- plane and Hot Tuna albums] is
ditional riches-to-rags lament of Al is a master of microphone
“Brother Can You Spare a Dime,” placement. As it’s been explained
and the down-home grit of “The to me, I guess the demon in get-
Terrible Operation.” Observes ting sounds not just for record-
Kaukonen, “One of the cool ing but also by ear is phase can-
things about the way the album album where [mandolin player] we’re talking. I’ve got a Marantz cellation and phasing problems.
is mixed is there’s this magnifi- Barry Mitterhoff is in the left preamp, and I have a Michaelson What I see is his talent in being
cent, transparent presence of all channel, and you’re in the right & Austin valve tube amp. The able to place microphones where
the instruments, no matter who’s one. last time I put new tubes in it there is none of that, or it’s mini-
playing and where they are. You JK: I listened to the CD on my 20 years ago, it cost me about mized. I’m also aware of the cre-
can hear them all; they’re there.” tube stereo yesterday, and yeah, a thousand dollars. I’m using ation of a sonic landscape where
Kaukonen, 74, and I recently Barry and I are left and right on Polk Audio speakers I got from you have various and sundry
discussed his recording tech- “Brother Can You Spare a Dime.” my dad, but when I feel like lis- instruments in whatever range
niques and the hi-fi gear that’s I would never have deigned to tening to rock ’n’ roll the old they occupy. Al’s able to put
served to enhance listening expe- want to mix one of my own way, I put on the JBL 4312s them together in an ensemble so
riences all throughout his life. records because I just don’t have [studio monitors]. everything can be together, and
The man may not be in a hurry, those sensibilities. But when I that helps people discover more
but he sure is getting somewhere. listen to this stuff, it just sounds MM: Some of your live record- about what I’m playing.
live to me, which is cool. ings are available in 24-bit on
MM: You made some interesting HDtracks. You must like that, An extended version of the
choices in terms of stereo sepa- MM: Tell me more about your considering the subtleties and Mettler-Kaukonen No Hurry
ration on certain tracks on this stereo gear. detail apparent in how you Q&A appears in The S&V Inter-
JK: OK, well, fingerpick. view blog on soundandvision.
you’re going to JK: Anything at 24-bit is happen- com.
love this. I have a ing. I don’t download, because I
couple of turn- live in an area that has moderate
CD
tables—a Thorens download speeds. But my guys,
LABEL: Red House
and a Denon, plus like Jason [Guip, engineer and
AUDIO FORMATS: 44.1-kHz/16-bit
one you use to drummer], are totally into this PCM Stereo
digitize records. stuff. They tell me we have to do NUMBER OF TRACKS: 11
I’ve got a 20- it because guys like us will love it, LENGTH: 46:55
year-old high- so I go, “Rock on.” Everything is PRODUCER: Larry Campbell
performance Sony thought out, as you know. Things ENGINEER: Justin Guip
Photo by Scoy Hall

CD player that don’t just happen by accident, so


plays CDs the way guys like you will notice.
it was meant to be.
My amps—now MM: Oh, I definitely notice. (both

26 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


NewGear
THIS MONTH’S HOT STUFF...
D Nyrius Aries Home+
Wireless HD Streaming
System
Everything else is going
wireless, so why not your TV?
With the Aries Home+ you can
stream video and surround sound from a Blu-ray
player, cable/satellite box, gaming console, or
laptop to a TV up to 100 feet away. Comprised of a
transmitter and receiver, the system is said to send
uncompressed 1080p video in real time with zero
latency through walls, floors, and ceilings without
interfering with devices operating over Wi-Fi or
Bluetooth. Double Your
Pleasure: The transmitter
has two HDMI inputs so
you can connect two
sources and switch
between them plus an
HDMI output that loops
through to a local TV. The
receiver has one HDMI
output and a built-in IR
remote extender that
sends commands back to
A Electric Mirror Gallery the receiver. A 5-foot HDMI
Kitchen TV cable is included. Price:
Tired of cranking up the sound on the TV in $250
the adjoining family room and straining to Nyrius • (855) 293-7253 •
watch CNN while eating breakfast? Or nyrius.com
maybe cartoons and Cocoa Puffs are your
thing (we’re not here to judge). Either way,
you’ll appreciate having the sleek Gallery TV
in your kitchen. Its 15.6-inch 720p/1080i
LED/LCD screen is set in a 20 x 13-inch
faceplate that mounts flush in the wall.
Mirror, Mirror: Faceplate options include
black, white, green, and mirror glass,
brushed stainless steel, or you can go with the full Iris mirror so the TV “disappears” when it’s
turned off. You can feed audio to existing speakers or order the optional WallWaves invisible
speakers. Waterproof remote included. Price: $1,899-$2,099, depending on faceplate
Electric Mirror • (425) 776-4946 • electricmirror.com

G Energy Connoisseur CS-30 Soundbar


The speaker gurus at Energy have finally gotten around to
adding a soundbar to the Connoisseur series they trotted
out a couple decades ago. About time, eh? The bar sports
a predictably simple stereo design with two 0.75-inch
textile dome tweeters, each paired with a 3-inch woofer,
and is equipped with Dolby Digital and 3D surround
processing. You have the choice of an optical digital
input (cable included) or analog inputs for older TVs.
If you want to listen to music, the CS-30 supports
Bluetooth wireless streaming and aptX coding for
improved sound quality. Worth the Wait: A wireless
subwoofer with a side-firing 8-inch driver and slot port
rounds out the package. The sub pairs automatically
with the mothership and is
rated down to 27 hertz. Price:
$600
Energy • (866) 441-8208 •
energy-speakers.com

28 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


A Gibson Les Paul Reference Monitors
The iconic Les Paul guitar, axe of choice for countless guitar gods, is echoed in the design of three powered monitors: The LP2
($599), LP4 ($799), and LP6 ($999). Each is a two-way, biamped design with a 1-inch titanium tweeter and non-woven carbon
woofer (4, 6, and 8 inches, respectively). System power, rated at less than 0.2 percent THD+N, is 103 watts for the 10-inch-tall
LP2 and 247 watts for its big brothers, which stand 14 and 18.5 inches tall. Sweet Sunburst: The face of each speaker is carved
maple—just like the guitar—and available in three classic gloss finishes: cherry, cherry burst, and tobacco burst. The speakers
accept RCA and balanced TRS/XLR inputs and have multi-position switches for adjusting bass and treble.
Gibson • (800) 444-2766 • gibson.com

J Ion Audio Aire LP


Bluetooth Turntable
You think you’ve seen it all, and
along comes a wireless
turntable. With the belt-driven Air
LP you can stream vinyl treasures
to any Bluetooth speaker without
the “restriction of cumbersome
hookup cables.” (Why you’d want to
do that is another matter, but you have
to admit it is cool and hipsters will dig it.)
Auxiliary Bonus: The table sports a
minijack input for bestowing wireless
action upon other source components and
has a USB port so you can send audio to
your PC and create digital files using EZ Vinyl/
Tape Converter software (USB cable included).
Air LP comes with a set of RCA cables and a 45
rpm adapter so you can spin/stream some Bill
Haley while you Rock Around the Clock. Price:
$149
Ion Audio • (888) 800-0681 • ionaudio.com

soundandvision.com 29
State of the

Curved screens are here,


but why? By Bob Ankosko
Are curved screens going to place as a whole, we’re curious to
take over the world? If you see if it takes root considering there
walk into one of the 500 Best is really only one proponent [Sam-
Buy stores featuring Samsung’s sung] kind of creating the category.”
impressive Entertainment Experience display Indeed, 2015 is shaping up to be
area, you might think so at first glance. Styl- a pivotal year for curved screens.
ish curved-screen TVs are front and center Over the next 12 months, we’ll
in the ultramodern space, displayed under learn whether they have what it
glowing “Curved UHDTV” signs that beck- takes to capture the imagination of
on you to come over and take a closer look. a fickle TV-buying public driven
But the reality is, curved screens are still new largely by price. But for now, there’s
and account for only a tiny piece of the over- a more pressing question: Why
all TV market. The Consumer Electronics curved screens in the first place? Do they up to 36 percent—not
Association (CEA) and retail sales tracker bring tangible benefits to the viewing experi- insignificant.
GfK project worldwide shipments of 3.4 mil- ence, or is the curve simply cosmetic? “There’s also more of a sweet
lion units this year, up from just under a mil- spot to the TV,” Schinasi continued. “A lot of
lion units in 2014—an impressive jump but Doubling Down folks say, it’s curved so therefore it’s distorted.
not unheard of for a new category and still In what amounts to its most ambitious offer- There’s actually less [geometric] distortion.
less than 2 percent of the global market. ing to date, curved screen models account for We’ve done extensive studies with UC Berke-
Curved screens are so new that you can’t about half of Samsung’s 2015 UHD TV line- ley to look at the perception of objects on a
really call the phenomenon a bona fide trend up or about a quarter of all models. As of this curved screen to discern when and if they
just yet, observed Paul Gagnon, director of writing, two dozen curved-screen models in can’t be comprehended. As long as you’re not
TV for IHS Technology (formerly NPD Dis- sizes from 55 to 78 inches were listed on the at the very extremities and looking at the
play-Search), a research firm with expertise in company’s Website. Most are new models, a screen from anywhere in that sweet spot,
the television market. “There’s a trend in that few of which were not yet available, and all even from the left or right side, a curved
it went from nothing in 2013 to something in but one are 4K/Ultra HD (UHD) resolution. screen actually delivers less geometric distor-
2015,” he said, noting that IHS expects curved So why curved? “First and foremost is tion than a flat screen. That translates into
TV shipments of 700,000 to 800,000 in the aesthetics,” said Dan Schinasi, senior market- more ideal viewing conditions.” (More on
U.S. this year—about 2 percent of the total ing manager for TV product planning. “It’s a this in a moment.)
market. “As we look at the curved market- differentiator, and it looks beautiful, but there Having sung the praises of curved TVs,
are considerable technical merits as well. If Schinasi is quick to point out that the com-
you’re at the proper viewing distance, a pany also sells plenty of flat screens. “If
• The Consumer Electronics Association and
GfK Research predict big growth for curves in curved screen offers some there’s a strong preference for
2015. unique advantages. It slightly one or the other, we have it.”
increases your field of view,
and there’s somewhat of a Academia Weighs In
correlation between field of The study Schinasi refers to was
view and immersion. The conducted in conjunction with
curve is very gentle—it’s not Martin Banks, professor of
like it wraps around you, but optometry and vision science at
you get about a 4-percent the University of California,
boost in field of view. It also Berkeley and principal investi-
helps minimize stray reflec- gator at the Visual Space Per-
tions, so if you have lamps in ception Laboratory, and Mari-
your room, reflections are

reduced, by some calculations, Samsung
Dan Schinasi of na Zannoli, PhD, a postdoc-
toral researcher at the univer-

30 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


“A nice feature of the curved screen is curved, the slant angle is reduced,
• LG 55EC9300 screen is that it does reduce so an object on the screen will appear to be
the set of positions in a room less distorted than it would have been when
where lamp placement viewed on a flat screen.”
would reflect off the screen
and into the viewer’s eye,” Curved, Schmurved
Banks said. “And that’s a fair- Vizio, the second largest seller of TVs in the
ly significant effect. Even if U.S. behind Samsung, wants nothing to do
you’re sitting to the side, you with curved screens and even went so far as
still get a positive benefit. It’s to produce a fake ad entitled “Revolutionary
completely independent of Anti-Curved Glasses” that pokes fun at
position.” curved screens (search “anti-curved glasses”
Geometric Distortion. on YouTube). Done in the style of a hard-sell
The relationship between a TV pitch offering “anti-curve glasses [that]
curved screen and geometric turn your curved TV into a beautiful flat
distortion is more compli- screen,” the ad opens with a man holding his
cated. “We head and grimacing while a
focused in the
research on
• Martin Banks (top)
and Marina Zannoli
voiceover asks: “Is your new
curved TV causing you frustra-
what’s called the (boom) of UC tion?” The video logged more
wide-angle dis- Berkeley than 205,000 hits in three
tortion that peo- months.
ple can see with John Hwang, director of
widescreen pan- product management, HDTV,
els,” Banks explained: “We wanted to point
explained. “Even out in kind of a humorous way
though images some of the things we think of
presented on the and have experienced with
screen may be curved screens to kind of send a
correct in shape message to consumers that says,
for a person at hey look, our focus is to
the recommend- improve the overall experience,
ed position, and we feel from a Vizio view-
viewers tend to point that curved TVs do not
see objects near do that.”
the edge of the In making the argument
screen as dis- against a curved screen, Hwang
sity. We contacted Banks and Zan- torted. The criti- said, “The most obvious thing you
noli to learn more about the study’s findings cal thing is what we call the slant don’t see is a uniform image. Even
on how a curved screen affects field of view, angle. Imagine a line coming out from a front view, you’re not see-
reflections, and geometric distortion. perpendicular from the point on ing a rectangular-shaped screen—
Field of View. They characterized the the screen that we’re looking at it’s kind of bowed at the top and
research as a formal study that will eventually (somewhere off to the side). bottom, and when viewed from
be published in a scientific journal, and con- Imagine another line from the different angles the picture gets
firmed that with a curved-screen UHD TV, a viewer’s eye to that point. The slant angle is distorted pretty massively in a nonuniform
viewer sitting at the recommended viewing the angle between those lines. When that way. Even with a flat screen, if you go off
distance of 1.5 times the height of the screen angle becomes greater than 30 degrees, per-
will experience a slightly expanded field of
view of about 4 percent and around 2.5 per-
ceptual distortions start to arise. When the • LG 65EG9600

cent for a standard HDTV. Interestingly,


“those values aren’t very dependent on lateral
position (sitting too far to the left or right)
unless of course you’re way off to the side,
which no one would do,” Banks explained.
“The numbers also depend on the curvature
of the screen. We used Samsung’s current
65-inch (diagonal) screen, and the radius of
curvature was 418cm [which is Samsung’s
standard curve].”
What does the expanded field of view
mean in the real world? “We found that an
increase in field of view does have a positive
effect on immersion,” Banks said. “Does a
4-percent increase have a positive effect on
immersion? I don’t know. A tad unlikely, but
in the right direction, anyway.”
Reflections. The question of a curved
screen’s ability to minimize stray reflections
reveals the study’s most noteworthy finding.

soundandvision.com 31
STATE OF THE ARC
color filters simultaneously, which means
color may not be as accurate, whereas OLED
makes its own light, so you don’t have any of
• Samsung
JS9500 Series
those issues.”
Like many, Alessi sees aesthetics as the
primary benefit of a curved TV screen. “If
you read a lot of the reviews, for example, I
think the general consensus among the expert
community is that a curved screen doesn’t
really add anything to the picture, and most
people seem kind of happy that it doesn’t
detract from it as much as they thought. So I
think it’s mainly an aesthetic thing. When you
get to the larger screen sizes, there is an
immersiveness of the picture that appeals to
some people. It does kind of draw you in a
little bit, especially when I see our 65-inch
OLED, but it’s more of a personal choice.”

What About Sony?


How about Sony, which introduced the first
curved-screen TV in 2013 but has since
pulled back on the category. What’s its cur-
rent stance on curves?
Taka Fujita, vice president of home enter-
tainment, said in a statement: “There are
benefits to curved TVs and benefits to flat
TVs. While Sony was the first to introduce a
curved TV to market and does now offer a
curved model in other regions, we do not
currently plan to carry these models in the
U.S. We look at each market individually and
angle, you’re skewing the image, but you’re because of its superior viewing angles. There determine our product offerings accordingly.
skewing it in a more natural perspective as are no sacrifices in picture quality when you In the U.S., most people tend to hang their
opposed to an unnatural curved perspective.” curve an OLED.” TVs on a wall, so an ultra-thin [flat] TV inte-
Hwang also takes issue with the often- Although LG makes curved LCD TVs, it grates better into the American lifestyle. Sony
heard statement that a curved-screen TV can does not sell them in the U.S. “We decided to will continue to evaluate the market and will
deliver a more immersive experience than a keep our regular LCD lineup all flat,” Alessi consider introducing curved TVs again in
flat-screen set with the same screen size. explained. “There are some downsides to the U.S. when we think the market condi-
“Unless we’re talking about an extremely curving a TV screen—with reflectivity, with tions are appropriate.”
large IMAX-like screen, the curve doesn’t viewing angles, especially with a non-IPS
really deliver the whole immersive experi- (in-plane switching) screen [IPS panels pro- The Big Push
ence that’s promised by some manufactur- vide a wider viewing angle than the VA, or Samsung has come out swinging and appears
ers.” He also claims curved-screen sets that vertical alignment, technology used by Sam- intent on building a market for curved-
use full-array direct LED backlighting— sung]. We’ve done a lot of side-by-side com- screen TVs, leaving some industry pundits to
which Vizio is introducing across its entire parisons between our curved wonder if there’s more to the
lineup—exhibit “some extremely strange
moiré effects. We’re curious to see if some of
OLED and some of the competi-
tive curved LED screens, and • Paul Gagnon of IHS
Technology
story than the obvious desire to
be different.
the competitive products incorporate tech- there are distinct differences in “I think Samsung is looking
nology that solves this.” picture quality, especially when to continue to cement its posi-
you get a little bit off axis. tion as the premium TV brand,”
A Happy Medium OLED doesn’t have the narrow observed Stephen Baker, vice
At LG, which holds the number three posi- sweet spot like an LCD does. president of industry analysis for
tion in U.S. TV sales, curved screens are “If you were to compare an the NPD Group, a top-ranked
reserved for its growing line of OLED TVs, OLED and LCD side by side, market research firm specializ-
which comprises five new UHD OLED mod- both curved, the superior black ing in consumer electronics.
els with screen sizes from 55 to 77 inches. level and viewing angles of “The curved screen is an upsell
“For us, curved is a great way to show off OLED is what’s going to strike on a big screen—an enhance-
the attributes of OLED, which is a totally
different technology [than LCD] with perfect
you right away, even if you get • Stephen Baker of
just a little off axis,” Alessi contin- NPD Group
ment for that really big televi-
sion.” TV manufacturers operat-
black levels and vivid colors,” said Tim Alessi, ued. “Now, if you were to do ing in a competitive market are
director of new product development. “The detailed measurements, it may looking for ways to prevent 4K
other thing about OLED is its extremely slim come out that the color accu- from becoming commoditized
form factor, which enables us to do different racy is better as well. When you as prices come down, Baker
things with design. Our first OLED, you may curve an LCD, you’re taking noted. “I think it’s an industry-
recall, had a clear crystal base. The overall something that was meant to be friendly way to maintain some
aesthetic was very attractive. Our belief is flat and curving it so there’s the kind of premium in pricing.”
that if you want a curved screen, the best way possibility of misalignment and IHS’s Gagnon has another
to experience that is with an OLED TV light going through adjacent theory.

32 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


“OLED has been a topic of NPD’s Baker thinks it’s too the middle and your field of vision is better.
great interest by both Sam- early to tell whether curved It’s similar to going to an IMAX theater.”
sung and LG. Both compa- TV will prevail but said, “My Best Buy doesn’t comment on sales, but a
nies have been talking about gut is that it has more legs spokesperson said “a curved TV is something
it as the next generation of than 3D. Whether or not it many customers look for” and noted that they
display technology for many really adds value, I’ll let con- are “primarily part of our premium HDTV
years. I think it’s quite clear at sumers decide if they see a assortment. Because of this, our Ultra HD
this point that LG has figured value proposition there.” and OLED products are really the only avail-
OLED out with their solu- “I have a difficult time able models that have a curved screen. For
tion, but for Samsung, it’s saying curved—a design- both Ultra HD and OLED, having a curved
back to the drawing board. related attribute—is some- screen complements the incredible picture
So rather than cede new thing you can capture a pre- quality found in those TVs with an immer-
technology to LG, they’ve mium for in the market,” sive IMAX-like viewing experience. Custom-
become one of the leaders of said IHS’s Gagnon, but he ers have always gravitated toward technology
being able to do curved
LCDs. And, oh, by the way,
• Tim Alessi of LG acknowledged that it’s still
too early to make a call one
improvements that focus on picture quality,
and the combination of curved screens and
it’s quite difficult for LG to way or the other. Ultra HD/OLED does just that.”
curve LCDs because of the Retailers we spoke with
IPS panel technology they report success selling curved To Curve or Not to Curve
use.” TVs and seem to have It may be too early to predict if curved-
Meanwhile, Chinese bought into the notion of screen TVs will catch on, but we know
brands, such as Hisense and curved screens presenting a through our conversations with retailers that
TCL, have curved screens on more immersive experience. some shoppers are attracted to the design
their 2015 product road “IMAX-like” came up in aesthetic, while others have no idea curved
maps but are waiting to see conversations with Best Buy, screens exist—let alone offer subtle benefits
how curved plays out in the the country’s largest elec- they may or may not perceive—until they see
marketplace before fully tronics retailer, and India- a display or the salesperson directs
committing, Gagnon said. napolis-based hhgregg, their attention to one. We also know
Convincing consumers to which operates 228 stores that many enthusiast readers of
pay the higher price com-
manded by curved screens is
• Brian Markwalter of CEA in 20 eastern states.
“The trend right
Sound & Vision abhor the idea of a
curved screen. Will the findings of
a huge challenge, he added. “From our point now is new 4K technology, and UC Berkeley’s research sway them?
of view, we see the curved attribute as being everybody is going to the larger Probably not, but we’ll see. Ultimate-
more related to design and aesthetics than an size televisions,” said Jeff Clark, ly, the success of curved TVs will
improvement in consumer enjoyment. And who manages sales training and come down to whether the TV-buy-
as a result, it’s subject to things like fashion, management development for ing public relates to the modern aes-
and you know fashion is in the eye of the hhgregg, which devotes about 10 thetic and thinks it can bring value to
beholder. It’s tough to ask the consumer to percent of its TV inventory to the entertainment experience. And,
pay 300 bucks more for this TV that has a curved TVs. “Overall sales of as LG’s Tim Alessi noted, that’s a
fashionable attribute.” curved sets are better than what we personal choice.
But Schinasi said price premiums are not expected. And the nice thing about the
“quite that black and white.” The higher pric- screen being curved is you’re able to sit in
ing on some of Samsung’s curved-screen TVs
is not just for the screen. “It’s also for the step
up to 4K in many instances and the TV per-
formance itself—the backlight performance,
which contributes to brightness and color
accuracy.”
Another factor is the material cost of
curved panels. “We know curved panels
themselves carry a roughly 20 to 30 percent
premium,” Gagnon noted, “which leads me
to believe Samsung is not making much
money on curved sets.”

Curved Here to Stay?


“I think curved screens will have staying
power,” said Brian Markwalter, senior vice
president of research and standards for the
Consumer Electronics Association, producer
of CES, the world’s largest consumer
technology show. “It’s definitely differentiating
and attracts some attention. I think we’ll see
combinations of improved display character-
istics and form factors. We saw a 65-inch
curved OLED at 2015 CES that weighs 35
pounds. That’s a pretty stunning form factor,
and the picture is better than what most
consumers have.” • Samsung JU7500 Series

soundandvision.com 33
Luxury
Housing
Spruce up your home theater with
these unique upgrades.
You’ve got the gear, but when it comes time to show it off, can you walk the walk? There are many approaches to
displaying or hiding your home theater equipment and a multitude of furniture, mount, and accessory products
out there. Here are just a few that, we think, put their own unique spin on your personal space.

Flexible Flying
BDI offers many high-quality standalone home theater cabinets, but its
Semblance modular system, offered in various configurations for storage,
office, or theater use, offers an uncommon level of design flexibility. The
pre-selected 5423-TJ system ($6,840 as shown) is available in natural
stained cherry, walnut, espresso stained oak, and chocolate stained
walnut; dimensions are 79.5 x 130 x 22 (HxWxD). The open-backed shelves
feature fingerprint-resistant micro-etched tempered glass shelves and are
16.5 inches deep to accommodate tighter spaces, while the Mirage main
cabinet when included boasts a 22-inch depth for hiding larger compo-
nents. Optional wire-management kits conceal cables and route them
down the back edges of the thick side panels for a clean, contemporary
look. Additional modules include enclosed storage units with opaque
glass doors and soft-close hinges, desk and drawer units, and others.
bdi.com

34 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


You’re Fired!
Bello’s newest line of A/V furniture, including the
Manhattan cabinet shown here ($1,000), puts the heat
on with a highly adjustable Spectrafire Plus electric
fireplace that offers users control of flame colors (five
of them), speed, and intensity, as well as a thermostat
for the integrated space heater. There’s even a remote
control and sleep timer. Measuring in at
26 x 76 x 18 inches (HxWxD), the
cabinet comes in cocoa finish with
black trim and handles TVs up to 175
pounds and 80 inches diagonal.
There are dark-tinted tempered glass
doors that pass IR signals to the four
hidden component shelves, a built-in
cable-management system, and
internal air slots to allow convection
cooling of your gear.
bello.com

Yes, You Can Sit on It


Theater seating can range from low-budget specials you
might think twice about putting in your home to high-end,
uber-pricey lounges and sofas with fancy flourishes and
custom upholstery. Salamander Designs now offers an
attractive alternative to its premium, custom seating in the
T3 recliner ($1,300 each), part of its AV Basics line. By
offering a standardized package, the company keeps costs
down and quality up. The T3 is shown here in black bonded
leather—the only color it comes in—with included black
steel cupholders. You get solid construction in a motorized,
“wall-away” recliner at an affordable price. Of course, if
you’re looking for something fancier, you can always visit the
Custom Configurator at the company’s Website to create
your own dream seating arrangement from any of their
premium lines.
salamander.com

Third Screen’s the Charm


Diamond Case Design is both furniture maker and home theater installation company, so they come
at their products from a “what’s possible” perspective. Example: the Triple Play (starting at $5,999),
which can house up to a 70-inch main television plus two hidden screens up to 32 inches on
retractable wings. It’s offered in two standard styles, a modern design (shown here with a 65-inch TV
and speakers) and traditional styling with raised
doors, fluting, and crown moldings. Dimensions
are typically 81 x 76 x 22 inches (HxWxD), though
every piece is made to order and customizable
for size, style, and finish (including a match to
existing furnishings). For additional cost,
Diamond Case can even motorize the wings or
add matrix switching for the TVs.
diamondcase.com

soundandvision.com 35
Sweet Reflections
Mirror-hidden TVs that make themselves visible when powered up aren’t brand new,
but Hiframe’s approach is unique. You start with your own flat-panel TV and purchase
any of Hiframe’s self-contained designer wall cabinets to enclose your set behind the
glass, either mirrored or various colors. At top, the Dual Electric Fireplace wall (102 x 79
x 16 inches (HxWxD), $21,495 as shown) accommodates TVs up to 80 inches and
integrates electric fireplace units that use LEDs and water vapor from refillable water
cartridges for a convincing flame effect; it’s seen here with a 65-inch TV and is available
in Mirabello Mirror or Black glass, both of which allow the TV image to pass through
when the set is active. At right, the Kastiel Cube (87 x 87 x 4 inches (HxWxD), $19,495
as shown) handles TVs up to 70 inches behind mirror or black glass; the custom-order
outer frame is included (there are several colors/designs to choose from). Both models
can be outfitted with LED edge-lighting around the frame.
hiframe.com

Sonos Sitting Pretty


The Sonos wireless multiroom audio system is so popular now that, in almost Apple-like fashion,
third-party accessory makers are stepping up to provide customized solutions. The recently introduced
WSS2 pedestal floor stands from Sanus ($100/pr) are made to support the Sonos Play:1 speakers (below)
or the larger Play:3 (left) in either horizontal or vertical orientation. Stand height is 34 inches, and three
different mounting brackets are included to accommodate the two models without blocking the power or
Ethernet ports. Features include an integrated wire channel through the column and base that hides
cables, adjustable carpet spikes and rubber feet, and a choice of black or white finish.
sanus.com
TEST REPORT

Hitting New Heights


By David Vaughn
there are connectors for HDMI,
headphone, Audyssey mic, and

Marantz AV8802 Surround auxiliary analog audio/video.


The rear panel is well laid out and
accommodates 15 individual

Processor that have twice the reserve than


balanced and unbalanced output
connections. This includes dual
subwoofer outputs with XLR and RCA
PRICE $3,999 AT A GLANCE what was in the vaunted AV8801. connections for each. These are on a
As with its predecessor, the build single channel, but there are
IT’S BEEN A LITTLE MORE THAN Plus quality of the AV8802 is outstanding. independent level settings for each
two years since I reviewed the Q 11.1 channels with Audys- In addition to the upgrades listed subwoofer. Note that even with all
Marantz AV8801 surround processor sey MultEQ XT processing above, the unit has a dual-layer these connections, a maximum of
(Home Theater, May 2013, and Q Dolby Atmos, Auro-3D, and copper chassis that’s carried over 11.1 independent channels may be
soundandvision.com), and I liked DTS:X surround from the AV8801, which helps isolate playing at once. There are seven
that model so much, it never left my Q Full 4K video processing the electronics from outside HDMI 2.0 inputs, three outputs
system. At the time, I thought it was upgradable to HDCP 2.2 interference. (Monitor 1 with ARC, Monitor 2, and
the best-sounding pre/pro I had ever If you’ve liked the look of past Zone 2), dual component inputs/
owned, and I had no real desire to Marantz AVRs and pre/pros, then outputs, and enough gold-plated
upgrade anytime soon. That all
Minus you’ll be happy to know that the analog inputs and outputs to satisfy
changed last fall when Dolby Q Limited range for remote design philosophy hasn’t changed. most every audio need you could
announced that Atmos for the home sensor The AV8802 has the same classy think of. Rounding out the features on
was on its way. I started thinking how curved front panel and sparse layout, the back panel are a moving-magnet
I could finagle four extra speakers which includes a volume knob on the phono input, dual antenna hookups
into my room—because for some feedback HDAM-SA2 modules, right, a source select knob on the left, for Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, HD Radio
reason, I have this overwhelming along with improved jitter-reduction a power on/standby button, and a (AM/FM) connection, a single set of
desire to stay on the cutting edge of circuitry for the optical, coaxial, and simple porthole display showing the XLR balanced inputs, and a second
home theater technology, regardless HDMI inputs. If that’s not enough, selected source and volume level. USB input in case you want to
of the personal expense. the engineers also included a There’s a flip-down door beneath the permanently attach a storage device
lower-noise toroidal power porthole that reveals navigation and loaded with music and photos.
Upping the Ante transformer (derived directly from other controls along with a large Video processing is handled by an
The AV8801 was tricked out to the the PM-11S3), 768-kilohertz/32-bit traditional LCD. In addition to the Analog Devices ADV8003 chip, which
nines with virtually every bell and DACs (AKM4490), and capacitors plethora of discrete control buttons, performs admirably. Additionally, the
whistle that could be found at the
time in a pre/pro, and the same is true
of the AV8802. Networking goodies
include Apple’s AirPlay, Pandora,
SiriusXM, Internet Radio, Spotify
Connect, and Flickr. In lieu of the
four-port Ethernet hub that was on
the AV8801, there’s a single Ethernet
jack on the rear, but now you get
Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, as well as DNLA
1.5 support for streaming audio files
from your local computer network.
The upgrades don’t stop there.
Marantz’s engineers dissected every
critical component for the AV8802—
including the transformer, the DACs,
the HDAMs (the company’s
proprietary amplifier modules),
and the filter capacitors—and relied
on trickle-down technology from
the company’s Reference line,
specifically the PM-11S3 integrated
stereo amplifier. The 11.1-channel
preamp section utilizes balanced
outputs. Enhancements include
brand-new, fully discrete current-

38 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


THE VERDICT SURROUND PROCESSOR
Marantz AV8802 Surround Processor Noticeably improved sound quality over its prede-
Audio Performance
MARANTZ AV8802 SURROUND PROCESSOR
Video Performance cessor plus Atmos, Auro-3D, and DTS:X surround pro- PRICE: $3,999
Features cessing make the Marantz AV8802 a top-notch Marantz • (201) 762-6500 • us.marantz.com
Ergonomics
Value upgrade.

AV8802 has 4K video processing with respond from 16 feet away to either more flexibility (such
the ability to scale current sources to the factory remote or my URC as only equalizing the
UHD (3840 x 2160), and while the universal. Of course, if you use an RF subs or telling the
initial units shipping into retail won’t remote or control system with a software to only
comply with HDCP 2.2, Marantz says receiver hub, it won’t be a problem. measure below 200
it will begin offering a free hardware hertz for further
upgrade at some undesignated point Setting Up customization), which
in the future in order to conform with Marantz has the best user interface I agree with
the new copy-protection scheme system I’ve come across (shared by completely. That said, I
(you’ll have to pay for one-way sister company Denon). It’s extremely think Audyssey and theirr
shipping). One thing I love about intuitive, and it looks pretty, too. implementation partners are trying to front, four SS150 surround speakers
Marantz’s video implementation is the When you fire up the AV8802 for the keep things as simple and automated mounted approximately 6.5 feet from
ability to customize the video output first time, a guided setup “assistant” as possible to make standard the floor (not conforming to Dolby’s
by source, so if you want the will greet you and walk you through calibration a plug-and-play solution recommendations for Atmos, but I
1080p/24 signal from your Blu-ray hooking up the various components for their customers. own them and there’s no other way
player to be unprocessed but your to your new toy. The only downside to place them in my living space),
cable/satellite signal to be upcon- of this setup is that I’ve never been a Another Format War? four Atlantic Technology IC-6-OBA
verted to 1080p or 4K, you can make big fan of hooking up wires while the Dolby isn’t the only company out in-ceiling speakers for Atmos height
this choice in the setup menu. unit is powered up, but if you need it, there promoting new audio formats duties, and dual subwoofers—a Hsu
The included remote is competent it’s there. Regardless, once you have that make use of overhead height Research VTF-15 MK2 and an SVS
in its layout and fits nicely in your all your amplifiers hooked up—I used channels. Along with Atmos, PC-Ultra. Amplification is provided
hand. Thankfully it’s backlit, so it’s a total of 11 channels in order to Auro-3D was also well received at by a Parasound Halo A 51 for the
easy to see in a darkened room. take full advantage of the Atmos last September’s CEDIA Expo, and three front speakers and L/R
However, as with my reference capabilities—you can then perform as I write this, DTS’s answer to the surrounds, with a Parasound
Marantz AV8801, the remote sensor an Audyssey calibration by plugging object-based Atmos system, DTS:X, ZoneMaster 1250 bridged to six
on the AV8802 is quite a bit less the supplied mic into the front of the is said to be nearing introduction. channels for the rear surrounds and
sensitive than those on my other AV8802. Marantz, in an unusually thorough four Atmos overhead speakers.
components, and in my space, it only My first calibration didn’t go very commitment to future-proofness, When I finally got to audition
responds to commands if you are well, with the unit setting my trims has you covered on all three fronts. Atmos-enabled discs at home, I
within 15 feet of the unit. While this much too low, especially for my The AV8802 ships with Atmos found that they really help draw you
may not be an issue for most folks, I subwoofers. Perplexed, I ran through capabilities, and an Auro-3D into the film much more than I had
sometimes watch or listen from an the process a second time, which firmware upgrade costs $199. The anticipated. In The Hunger Games:
adjoining room, and these pre/pros worked perfectly. I may not have had company also told us that, before Mockingjay, Part 1, the Capitol has
have been the only pieces in the mic situated properly the the end of 2015, a DTS:X update will grown tired of District 13’s rebellious
my rack that won’t first time. be available (no decision has been ways and decides to bomb its
Whether you’re a fan made about whether this will be free citizens into submission. We’re taken
of Audyssey or not, I or incur a nominal charge). What’s into the command center of the
love how the more, while Atmos and Auro-3D, at district as the explosions begin, and
company’s auto least, normally require you to commit wowza!—your fight-or-flight
calibration simply nails in advance to different speaker instincts will have you ducking for
the speaker distances locations for some of the surround cover as the roof seems ready to
down to a tenth of a channels, Marantz plans to mitigate cave in. This is just one of many
foot, at least in my this by allowing a unified speaker scenes that make great use of the
space. The AV8802 has layout for all three formats, leing additional channels.
the Platinum Suite of you switch easily among them to Unfortunately, the number of
Audyssey technolo- accommodate different soware. Atmos-enabled titles on Blu-ray can
gies, including MultEQ Format war? Not with the AV8802. still be counted on two hands—and
XT32, Sub EQ HT, and the number of really high-caliber
LFC (Low Frequency Look Out Above! movies for the moment is limited to a
Containment). My audio system consists of three couple of fingers. But thankfully,
Additionally, the unit is M&K S150 speakers across the Dolby has a new derived-surround
Audyssey Pro–ready for
even more acoustical
calibration accuracy
when implemented by
a qualified professional
using Audyssey’s Pro
Installation Kit. My
colleague Kris Deering
has opined that
Audyssey should allow

• A sleek flip-down
door covers the front-
panel controls. soundandvision.com 39
TEST REPORT

Test Bench • The supplied


remote is backlit
and nicely laid out.
Marantz AV8802 Surround Processor
algorithm—Dolby pro in my rack, which was
Surround Upmixer head and shoulders better
(DSU)—which allows than the AV8801 on
you to take full two-channel listening, but
advantage of your the AV8802 has closed
Atmos-enabled system the gap considerably in
with traditional this regard (at only
channel-based audio two-thirds the price of the
tracks. The additional $6,500 Krell).
speakers definitely add This superb audio
to the atmosphere of quality came to light on
movies. For example, the song “Second
there’s a scene in Choice,” from the Marti
Captain Phillips where Jones album Live at Spirit
pirates storm a Square. It features a bass
container ship. The guitar, some bongo
Frequency response at preamp outputs of Dolby Digital decoder: Le only way the ship can drums, and Jones’
(aqua): –0.04 dB @ 20 Hz, –2.11 dB @ 20 kHz. Center (green): –0.04 dB defend itself is with fire fabulous voice. The bass
@ 20 Hz, –2.12 dB @ 20 kHz. LFE (purple): Normalized to level @ 40 hoses (talk about is tight, and the layered
Hz: +0.01 dB @ 20 Hz, upper –3 dB @ 118 Hz, upper –6 dB @ 121 Hz. taking a knife to a gun track transports you
fight!), and when the directly to the live
Analog frequency response, Pure Direct mode: camera switches to the performance. The
–0.14 dB @ 10 Hz perspective of the Marantz picked up the
–0.04 dB @ 20 Hz pirates, the Atmos subtle aspects of the
–0.01 dB @ 20 kHz overhead speakers recording, such as the
–0.05 dB @ 50 kHz come into play and add bassist’s fingers sliding
to that feeling of the along the strings. This has
Analog frequency response w signal processing: water coming down on you—a fact I become one of the first audio
–0.84 dB @ 10 Hz verified by manually turning off the recordings I use to test out new gear,
–0.25 dB @ 20 Hz amp supplying power to the and the AV8802 definitely made it
–3.29 dB @ 20 kHz overhead speakers to gauge the shine.
–55.14 dB @ 50 kHz effect. My only gripe with the
upmixing was that there was some Conclusion
Response from multichannel input to main output: –0.13 dB @ 10 Hz, occasional score bleed to the front I could wax poetic about the
–0.04 dB @ 20 Hz, –0.01 dB @ 20 kHz, –0.06 dB @ 50 kHz. Analog ceiling speakers that could prowess of the AV8802 for several
THD+N: less than 0.008% @ 1 kHz w 100-millivolt input and volume overpower the dialogue, but this more paragraphs, but alas, the
control set to 82.5. Crosstalk w 100-mV input: –92.21 dB le to right, might have been because the front dreaded word count has caught up
–93.16 dB right to le. Signal-to-noise ratio w “A” weighting: –130.38 overhead speakers were set a tad hot with me. After experiencing Atmos in
dBrA.—MJP by Audyssey. (Dolby needs to release my home, I have to admit: There’s no
test tones on their demo discs.) way I can ever go back to a
VIDEO The Marantz sailed through our HDMI benchmark tests when While I was wowed and amazed conventional five- or seven-channel
processing an HDMI signal, with the exception of the Chroma by Atmos and DSU on movies, the system. Furthermore, when the
Resolution test from the Spears & Munsil HD Benchmark disc, where two-channel performance of the considerable improvement in
the lower right box showed some rolloff of the chroma signal. This AV8802 is what really blew me away. two-channel performance is
culminated in a failed score, but this failure is not uncommon in AVRs The hardware upgrades done by the factored in, this is an easy upgrade
and processors, and the deficiency didn’t show up in my normal Marantz engineers revealed to consider. In fact, the AV8802
viewing of theatrical material.—DV themselves in critical listening tests. would be my first choice for our Top
The soundstage is deeper and wider, Pick of the Year, and it will be tough

SPECS Auto Setup/Room EQ: Audyssey MultEQ XT32 •


Video Processing: Analog Devices • Dimensions (WxHxD, Inches):
and voices are crisper and clearer
when compared with my AV8801. I
recently had a Krell Foundation pre/
to knock off its perch as the rest of
2015 plays out. Highly recom-
mended.
17.3 x 15.3 x 7.3 • Weight (Pounds): 30.6 • Video Inputs: HDMI 2.0 (8),
component video (3), composite video (4) • Audio Inputs: Coaxial
digital (2), optical digital (2), stereo analog RCA (7), stereo analog XLR
(1), phono (1), 7.1-channel input (1) • Additional: USB (2), Ethernet (1),
Wi-Fi antenna (1), Bluetooth antenna (1), IR remote (1), AM (1), FM (1)
• Video Outputs: HDMI 1.4a (3), component video (2), composite
video (2) • Audio Outputs: Stereo analog (2), 13.2 pre-out XLR (1), 13.2
pre-out RCA (1), ¼-inch headphone (1) • Additional: RS-232 (1), 12-volt
trigger (2)

• The Marantz’s rear panel packs 15 individual


balanced and unbalanced outputs.

40 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


Simply...Beautiful.
Elegant Audio/Video Furniture that Enhances your Home and Television

PR45

Curved Wood Furniture Metal and Glass Wood Cabinets with Fireplace Computer Desks

SCAN THE CODE


A Division of Twin-Star International, Inc.
twinstarhome.com | bello.com
TO SEE THE
LATEST BELL’O
PRODUCTS
TEST REPORT
Dynaudio Xeo 6 Loudspeaker

Rage Against Performance


Build Quality
Value

the Machine
Xeo Hub, Link, Extender,
Connect
The transmier is the 6-inch-wide
Xeo Hub (purchased separately for
$300). One is required for every
system, and a single Xeo Hub can
By Mark Fleischmann
handle up to three pairs of

Dynaudio Xeo 6 Loudspeaker


PRICE $4,000 as reviewed
“The TDAA design
consists of a PCM-
IN THE HISTORY OF CIVIL UNREST, AT A GLANCE PWM modulator
there has never been anything quite device and a PWM
like the audio rebellion. People are Plus power output device. This
using half-inch-thick A/V receiver system accepts a serial PCM
Q Built-in triamplification
manuals as tinder and then throwing digital audio stream and
Q Wireless link to sources
their receivers onto the flames. converts it to a PWM audio
Q Musically versatile sound
Doghouse-sized stereo amps and stream, providing a large-signal
preamps are being spray-painted in PWM output. This digital PWM
the dead of night with slogans like Minus signal is then demodulated,
“Where’s the wireless?” Wrist-thick providing power output to drive
speaker cables lay coiled on curbs,
Q 16-bit transmission ceiling the loudspeakers. Thus, no
next to garbage cans, where DAC is needed in a Xeo system,
passing dogs do what comes and one of the reasons for the
naturally. Just the other day, I turned Xeo 4. They are for two-channel use sound quality is that there is no
on the TV and saw a guy in a only; there is no matching center. If conversion loss. Also, our
Dynaudio T-shirt giving a speech to you want to try a 2.0 system for your engineers are able to program
an angry mob. “Burn your cables!” home theater, you’re free to connect a the DSPs to optimize each amp
he shouted. “Sell your amp! Ditch disc player and other sources to the for the drivers.”
everything that currently clogs up Hub in stereo downmix mode. A little receiver module sits
your system!” The Xeo 6 mini-tower, reviewed atop each speaker. It is
here, mates one of Dynaudio’s nonremovable and includes
Rebel Yell famous textile-dome tweeters with a power, volume plus, and volume
Kidding aside, those quotes are pair of 5.5-inch magnesium silicate minus buttons. A small display
straight from Dynaudio literature (I polymer-cone bass drivers in a has a pinpoint LED that glows
added the exclamation points). The 33-inch-tall rear-ported enclosure. blue for active signal reception,
Xeo speakers rebel against the The slim cabinet, in white or black flashes red for signal hunting,
conventional architecture of audio satin lacquer, has a magnetically and glows red for off. Below that
systems: They are active, meaning attached grille and outrigger feet that is a line of white LEDs that light
self-powered, so kiss your amps allow the speaker to be leveled on up for signal hunting and volume
goodbye. They all but eliminate spikes or dampers. setting.
analog signal paths by handling Each speaker gets 150 watts of On the back of the speaker is
preamp and crossover functions in internal amplification, with 50 watts a power jack—and no other
the digital domain and employing going to each of the three drivers. jacks!—plus a trio of three-way
switching amplifiers. Triple zone The amplifier technology is licensed switches. One sets Left, Right, or
selection is built in. And they are from Texas Instruments, having been Mono operation. Another selects
wireless, receiving signals from a first utilized by TacT Audio and zones Red, Green, or Blue. The
Xeo Hub. All signal sources are wired originally developed by Denmark’s third switch is a boundary
into the Hub. The only wired Toccata Technology, a company TI compensator that shapes bass
connections to the speakers are their acquired in 2000. They are not Class according to speaker placement.
power cables. D, Dynaudio says, but TDAA, which The Natural setting maximizes
There are two new second- stands for True Digital Audio bass response; Wall and Corner
generation Xeo models, the Amplifier. Dynaudio’s Michael adjust for progressively more
floorstanding Xeo 6 and stand-mount Manousselis explains: room reinforcement.

The Xeo 6 appeals to a listener who wants a


simplified music system.
42 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
THE VERDICT SPEAKER SYSTEM
The Dynaudio Xeo 6 active DYNAUDIO XEO 6 SPEAKER SYSTEM
wireless speakers are a great- PRICE: $4,000 (Xeo 6, $3,700 pr; Xeo Hub, $300 ea)
sounding way to uncluer a Dynaudio • (847) 730-3280 • dynaudio.com/us
two-channel music system.

speakers, so you can add extra pairs USB input, and an Ethernet input, the was lined with LP shelves, and 4.5
of the Xeo 6 ($3,700/pair) or the latter for updates only. Auto Play feet from the corners. This afforded
compact Xeo 4 ($2,100/pair) to work finds the active source. The Hub little wall or corner reinforcement, so I
in second or third zones with does not natively support Bluetooth chose the Natural EQ setting. I
independent source and volume or AirPlay (though a Bluetooth toggled to Left for the left speaker
control for each. The Hub’s front is solution is on the way). and to Right for the right speaker. The
bare except for a pinpoint LED that The transmitter has a toggle Zone setting was Red, though I didn’t
glows blue when the transmitter is switch for three frequency IDs. use more than one zone.
active and red otherwise. On the Position A corresponds to the The Xeo Hub went onto my rack,
back are two analog inputs (one 2.4-gigahertz band. If there’s a lot of where it received digital coaxial input
RCA, one mini-jack), two digital Wi-Fi traffic in your household, B or C from an Oppo BDP-83SE universal
inputs (one coaxial, one optical), a shifts the frequency up to 5.2 or 5.8 disc player and analog input from a
GHz. Transmission from Hub to Denon PRA-S10 preamp, the latter
speakers has a bit depth of 16 and a serving a Micro Seiki BL-21 turntable
sampling rate of 48 kilohertz, slightly with Shure V15MxVR/N97XE
above CD quality but below the 24 cartridge. The first Hub I tried worked
bits and higher sampling rates of except for its USB input; the second
high-resolution audio. While the Hub sample worked fine. There was no
can handle 96/24 sources, they are AVR-type auto setup to run, no
converted to 48/16 for transmission. DAC-type software installation. All
However, that’s lossless 48/16 PCM, three transmission frequencies any missing pieces. [Ed. Note: I’d say
using the KleerNet platform, with no worked flawlessly in my RFI-rich remarkably even in the bass; see
lossy compression or discarding of urban New York City apartment page 44.—RS]
data. Efforts have been made to environment, with Hub and speakers With the 16-bit transmission
reduce jitter. Transmission distance is in the same room. system, playing CDs made a lot of
claimed to be about 65 feet. The sense, and I raided my tall Boltz
Hub’s remote control has buttons for A Lot of CDs and a Little shelves day after day. The Xeo 6
power on/off, volume up/down, mute, Vinyl seemed especially adept with
input, and zone selection. Dynaudio’s signature sound isn’t recordings that underwhelm through
In addition to the Xeo Hub impaired by the lossless wireless my less forgiving Paradigm/Pioneer
transmitter, Dynaudio offers other transmission. It’s a big, smooth, and Era/Peachtree systems. For
options. The Xeo Extender ($180) feel-good approach that flatters any instance, Jan Akkerman’s Minor
handles difficult transmission kind of music or recording. This Details, an album pieced together
conditions, such as long corridors, particular version is especially from MIDI files e-mailed among his
partition walls, or line-of-sight dynamic, perhaps thanks to the band members’ various home
distances of up to 164 feet. The Xeo internal amplification. The silky, studios, usually sounds canned—yet
Link ($180) is a separate receiver box slightly reserved top end is typical of the Dynaudio tweeters smoothed
with analog RCA, digital coaxial, and Dynaudio textile tweeters. The over the mechanical-sounding
digital optical outputs. It can be used tower’s dual woofers offer taut bass backing tracks and lofted the guitar
to feed a powered sub, headphone that reaches down through musically over them like a virtuoso. Similarly,
amp, or even another audio system, relevant frequencies with ease. I with King Crimson’s Live at the
which might include an older hesitate to say the bass response is Orpheum, a schematic account
generation of Xeo. The Link can run in even, because our Test Bench of the current incarnation’s power-
the same zone with the Xeo speakers, measurements can make a better ful three-drummer lineup, the
taking over their volume control and assessment of that, but I didn’t sense Dynaudios seemed to find more tone
input selection, or in a separate zone,
independent of the speakers. This
effectively makes the system
multisource as well as multiroom. The
forthcoming Dynaudio Connect hub
is said to add Bluetooth as well as
Wi-Fi-enabled app control of the
Focus XD and second-generation
Xeo systems.
Setup was easy. I placed the Xeo
speakers in my room’s best
two-channel position with their
baffles 3.5 feet from the wall, which

• The Xeo 6 is available in a


white or black finish.

• The Xeo Hub transmits signal sources wirelessly up to 65 feet.

soundandvision.com 43
TEST REPORT

ON THE See soundandvisionmag.com


WEB for full lab results and technical definitions
• The Xeo Extender extends the Xeo Hub’s reception range.

Test Bench
Dynaudio Xeo 6 Loudspeaker

color and cohesion than my usual best-case piano recording, Karl


equipment does. Engel’s Schumann Edition: Das
The beautifully recorded Klavierwerk IV, a Telefunken box set. C

Thompson Family CD never sounded Every pitch was clear, the left hand
better. The voices of siblings Kami had appropriate (but not overstated)
and Teddy poured out of the weight, the top end was sweet and
speakers like melted butter, while the open, and the midrange coherence Xeo 6 (purple) +0.84/–4.59 dB, 200 Hz to 10 kHz; –3 dB @ 42 Hz, –6 dB
emotionally charged voice of their enabled the pianist to practically sing @ 36 Hz.—MJP
mother, Linda, and the cantankerous Schumann’s elegant melodies.
baritone of their father, Richard,
imaged solidly with their own unique
timbres. Carlos Kleiber’s reference-
Movie Cameo
For a brief movie demo, I relocated
SPECS Xeo 6: 5.5 in magnesium silicate polymer-cone
woofer (2), 1 in textile-dome tweeter; 6.75 x 33 x 10.5 in (WxHxD);
standard Deutsche Grammophon the Xeo speakers from the short-wall 32.3 lb
recording of Beethoven’s Symphony position I use for two-channel music
No. 7 with the Vienna Philharmonic to the long-wall position I use for my
gave the Dynaudios straight As for surround system, and I fed them with to Wall and was pleased to hear how the near-zero-footprint status of a
fine-tuning of the famous string a PCM stereo downmix from the adroitly the bass response adapted soundbar. But the Xeo 6 undeniably
sound and overall lushness. Oppo’s coaxial output. This speaker to different room acoustics. Dialogue appeals to a listener who wants a
Vinyl was a trip in itself. On the title position afforded more wall was quite clear, and with 50 watts simplified music system and has floor
track of the Clash’s London Calling, reinforcement, as I found minutes going to each driver, the bombastic space for a modestly sized pair of
the dual woofers swung authorita- into the Tom Cruise sci-fi vehicle movie’s relentlessly repetitive loudspeakers. It is easy to set up and
tively (notwithstanding the line “we Edge of Tomorrow (Blu-ray, DTS-HD time-warp battle scenes came use. Its ingenious architecture affords
ain’t got no swing”) and brought out Master Audio). As helicopters through with magnificent dynamism. flexibility in speaker placement and
the doomy bass line and meaty drum swarmed London, bass congestion When I paused the movie, the multizone use. And though pricey, it
sound. The speakers also met the became apparent. So I switched the system would power down after a does cover the cost of speakers, six
more subtle dynamic demands of a boundary compensator from Natural minute or so, but unpausing the disc channels of amplification, and—via
player instantly powered it back up. the Hub—what amounts to a wireless
I started this review by whimsically preamp. While those with growing
suggesting that folks might buy a Xeo hi-res audio libraries should note the
system and throw their AVRs onto a 16-bit limit of the transmission
bonfire. Let me get serious long system, that doesn’t prevent the Xeo
enough to note that systems based 6 from loving all kinds of music. I
on active wireless speakers or AVRs certainly loved
(or soundbars or stereo preamps, for having it
that matter) are aimed at separate around.
audiences. Wear whichever
T-shirt fits you best. A Audio editor
Dynaudio Xeo system Mark Fleischmann is
won’t replace all the also the author of the
functionality of an annually updated book
AVR or achieve Practical Home Theater
(quietriverpress.com).

• The Xeo Link receives wireless signals from the Xeo Hub
and also outputs analog and digital signals.
• The Xeo remote control
handles speaker volume and source
selection.
44 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
It’s here. The redefinition of your audio and video experience.
The Emotiva XMC-1 combines precision 7.2 HD surround decoding,
balanced audiophile multichannel preamplification, and full 4K
video management with the power of Dirac Live™. Whether you’re
running the latest movies or high-definition audio, get ready for
the most powerful, immersive experience you’ve ever had.

The all-new XMC-1. Stunning performance now. Modular and


upgradable for the future. Covered by a 5-year warranty. Designed
and made in the USA at our Tennessee production center.

Redefine your experience with the XMC-1. $1999.

emotiva.com | 615.790.6754
TEST REPORT
Panasonic 65AX900U LCD Ultra HDTV

Picture Near-
2D Performance
3D Performance
Features
Ergonomics
Value

Perfect
copyright management. There’s a
menu setting that can make the set
compliant with 4K sources offering
4:4:4 color up to 10 bit. In addition, the
TV has a wide color gamut option that
is said to deliver 98 percent of the DCI
By Rob Sabin
specification, which is now a target for
future Ultra HD content with enhanced

Panasonic TC-65AX900U LCD color and should be deliverable by the


coming UHD Blu-ray format. That

Ultra HDTV gamut is available to the Vivid,


Standard, Home Theater, and Custom
picture presets. However, it’s not clear
front, it’s pretty much all screen, with whether the set will recognize content
PRICE $7,199 AT A GLANCE only a fine, narrow bezel on three that has been specifically created for
sides and a larger band on the the DCI gamut and play it back
WHEN PANASONIC LEFT THE Plus bottom that has the Panasonic logo faithfully with the creator’s intent, or
plasma market in late 2013 to the Q Stunning color and a stylish blue power indicator instead see the more narrow Rec. 709
whimpers of videophiles worldwide, Q Gorgeously detailed 4K (defeatable). If you don’t like the gamut and then apply an algorithm to
the company committed to playback aesthetic, or you find it impractical artificially pump up the colors to take
delivering an LED-backlit LCD that Q A boatload of picture (the set weighs 115 pounds with the advantage of the wider gamut. This
would rival the image of their tweaks stand, and my 36-inch-wide cart is what’s done with all of the wide
best-ever TV—the ZT60 that was barely supported it with a few inches color-space options on today’s
their plasma swan song. The first hanging off each side), you can displays while playing today’s Rec.
Panny Ultra HD LCD to follow, the
Minus always mount it on the wall. 709 content. We always recommend
edge-lit TC-65AX800U (reviewed Q Not quite plasma-like Connections around back include watching in the native color gamut for
January 2015, available at sound- blacks and shadow detail four HDMI inputs—one with ARC, all which the content was created to
andvision.com), was a fine TV, Q 3D ghosting version 2.0 compliant and rated at 18.2 avoid unnatural and inaccurate color
though hardly a breakout set. But in Q The price gigabits per second for 4K content up effects; the value of a wide color
late 2014, Panasonic rolled out their to 60 hertz, and all with HDCP 2.2 space is questionable in the absence
flagship AX900U series at 55 and 65
inches, the latter of which we now
review here. Samsung’s 2015 SUHD models or
And, on paper at least, what a set it Sony’s new top-line entries will have
is: a full-array, local-dimming back- this year. And it’s worth noting that the
light (with an unspecified number of Panasonic’s breathtaking ticket starts
zones); Panasonic’s Studio Master to approach the $8,999 cost of LG’s
Drive, which uses a “high color-space new 65-inch 4K OLED, which, by
LED backlight” to deliver rich color nature of its technology, should
and “a wide color gamut that surpass it at least in black-level
approaches the level of a plasma performance.
screen”; a high-performance IPS However, none of that changes
(in-plane switching) panel that pretty what this really is: a statement piece
much annihilates the restrictive from a manufacturer with tremen-
viewing angle afflicting most other dously deep engineering talent,
LCD HDTVs; today’s de rigueur 3840 brought to bear on a premium LCD
x 2160 Ultra HD resolution with full HD UHDTV. Let’s take a closer look.
3D playback; and more picture
tweaks than any heavily instrumented Future by Design
gearhead could ever want. The industrial design of the
All of this comes at a price, and a TC-65AX900U captures attention by
steep one at that: $7,199, with the set its very nondescriptness. The
available only through special order at tabletop base is a large 33-pound
Magnolia Home Theater. This for a TV, slab of metal that attaches to the
I might add, that is already a bit less panel and hides completely behind it
than state-of-the-art, despite Panason- while propping it up; imagine your
ic’s best effort to future-proof it last iPad leaning against a brick, and
year with cutting-edge technology. you’ll get the idea. The bottom edge
To begin, the TC-65AX900U boasts of the panel rests fully on the surface
none of the latest HDR (high dynamic of your furniture, and the panel cants
range) brightness-boosting tricks that back ever so slightly. Seen from the

• With a narrow bezel on three


sides, the TC-65AX900U is almost
all screen.
46 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
THE VERDICT HDTV
Panasonic’s statement Ultra HDTV sucks you in with its alluring image PANASONIC 65AX900U LCD ULTRA HDTV
and doesn’t let go, but its high price is a deterrent. PRICE: $7,199
Panasonic • panasonic.com

of content designed to take but these require you to hit the OK wand (with an integrated
advantage of it. button on the remote to enter Netflix button) and a squat
As with Panasonic’s earlier UHD full-screen viewing each time the set touchpad Bluetooth
models, there’s a DisplayPort powers up. There’s a Full Screen remote that I found useful
connection that might be tapped alternative, but what’s lacking is a for turning the set on and
by PC gamers or for industrial hybrid setting that grants full-screen off, controlling volume, and
applications. Three USB ports viewing at turn-on but gains manual delivering voice commands
(one version 3.0, the others 2.0) all access to one of the more elaborate from the built-in micro-
successfully played a 4K-resolution Home Screens with a push of the phone. Panasonic’s TV
test clip stored on a thumb drive with Home button. Other smart features Remote2 app for iOS and
H.264 compression, but none could include voice commands, a pop-up Android is superb and offers
play the same clip encoded in H.265, camera, and a proximity sensor; when a SmartCalibration feature
better known as HEVC. However, that someone walks by the powered- that provides access to a full
technology is on board for playing down set, it can bring up an Info Bar range of calibrator adjustments
Ultra HD off the streaming platform
via Netflix or other services.
with weather and messages and
provide access to your Home Screen
without ever having to call up an
onscreen menu.
• The sturdy prop stand lets
the panel rest flush on your
(Presumably, external 4K source through voice command and facial Audio quality through the three furniture.
devices, such as a UHD Blu-ray player recognition. Every morning—and built-in speakers was average for a
or streaming box, will provide their every time I left the room and flat-panel TV. The Toslink optical detail in dark scenes). The Motion
own HVEC decoding before re-entered—the TV greeted me with audio output downconverts all Picture Setting control engages
delivering a signal to the TV.) my Info Bar as I sat down at my studio multichannel Dolby Digital and DTS backlight scanning to improve
The TC-65AX900U features desk some 15 feet away. Don’t worry, soundtracks presented to its HDMI motion rendition; I left it off for most
Panasonic’s Life+Screen smart TV the sensitivity is adjustable, and the inputs to two-channel PCM stereo. of my evaluation, but in its Weak
GUI, which defaults to a widget-laden whole feature is defeatable, as is the Any soundbar you attach to it should setting, it reduced blur on test clips
Home Screen when you turn on the intrusive “Smart Viera Banner” that ideally have direct digital inputs for all to an acceptable degree without
TV. You can choose different periodically tacks an advertisement your devices if you want the best introducing noticeable soap-opera
templates for each user, some with to the onscreen ticker when you sound quality. effect. The Pro2 preset turned off
access to weather or a scheduler or adjust the volume. most of the TV’s multitude of
your favorite streaming services Two remotes come with the Setup automatic contrast and color
(Netflix, Amazon, Vudu, Hulu, etc.), TC-65AX900U: a full-size backlit The TC-65AX900U is THX certified adjustments by default.
and comes with both standard THX Out of the box, color for the Pro2
and THX Bright Room modes. Each setting was exceptional, showing
offered a reasonably accurate image white balance and color points with
out of the box, with the color balance Delta E errors well under levels
leaning just a bit too much toward detectable by eye; blue was a touch
red in the mid-brightness range and underrepresented in the middle
color point errors essentially tones, but that’s about all. (See
undetectable. I used these modes Test Bench.) Still, a full calibration
quite happily for a few days of casual improved both. After calibration, the
off-air broadcast viewing and was 2.3 gamma setting delivered the
impressed by the engaging images closest average to my 2.2 target
they produced. But they lock out key across the full brightness range from
calibrator adjustments, including 10 to 100 percent.
controls for 2- and 10-point white The set passed most of our Video
balance, a wide range of gamma Test Bench battery, but it struggled
presets (1.8.x to 2.6) plus 10-point with a 1080i interlaced signal
gamma fine-tuning, and a color delivering the chroma and luma
management system (CMS) to resolution test patterns from
adjust color points of all the primary my Oppo Blu-ray
and secondary colors. After I took
baseline measurements on the
usable presets, I settled on Pro2 as
closest to dead-on accurate for dark
room viewing. Panasonic’s backlight
local-dimming feature is called
Adaptive Backlight Control, which I
eventually moved from its Min
default setting to its Max setting to
achieve the deepest blacks (though
setting it to Mid or Min proved
helpful for extracting more shadow

• At 2.4 inches
thick, the Panasonic
wall-mounts nicely. soundandvision.com 47
TEST REPORT SPECS
Dimensions (WxHxD, Inches): 57.4 x 34.1 x 2.4 (without stand); 57.4 x 34.0 x
See soundandvision.com 14.0 (with stand) • Weight (Pounds): 81.6 (without stand); 114.7 (with stand) •
ON THE
WEB for full lab results and technical 3D Glasses: Passive, 2 pair included, extras model TY-EP3D20U, $19.95 each
definitions • Inputs: HDMI 2.0 with HDCP 2.2, 4K/60Hz compliant (4, 1 with Audio Return
Channel); component video (1); composite video (1, shared with component
video); DisplayPort, 4K/60Hz compliant (1); Bluetooth audio pairing • Out-

Test Bench puts: digital audio optical (1) • Other: Ethernet (1), USB (3), SD card (1)

Panasonic TC-65AX900U LCD Ultra HDTV


player. These issues went
away with a 1080p input
• All four HDMI
inputs are version
BEFORE Calibration 2.0 compliant.
signal, and to be fair, I never
detected any real-world
concerns with 1080i
broadcasts, which looked
stunning. Meanwhile, the
viewing angle from the IPS
panel was outstanding; I
had to step about 50 to 60
degrees off axis in either
AFTER Calibration direction from 7 feet away to
see any drop in contrast,
and even then, the change
was subtle. This is the best
I’ve seen among LCDs.

The Look of Love


Wes Anderson’s The Grand
FULL-ON/FULL-OFF Contrast Ratio: 17,500:1 Budapest Hotel took home
Oscars this year for both
MEASUREMENTS were taken with a DVDO AVLab TPG 4K generator, costume and production
X-Rite i1Pro2 Enhanced spectroradiometer, Klein K10-A colorimeter, and design, and the pristine 1080p Blu-ray while watching on the Panasonic. The
SpectraCal CalMan 3 calibration soware. transfer communicates the director’s set did equally well with the more
PRE-CALIBRATION measurements were of the Pro2 preset with default personal love affair with color in both muted gray wool uniforms of the state
seings. Post-calibration, in Pro2 with the Adaptive Backlight Control set the dress and architecture of the police and depicted snowy land-
to Max, black level measured 0.0022 foot-lamberts and peak brightness imaginary Republic of Zubrowka. In scapes and winter street scenes with
measured 38.5 -L, for a contrast ratio of 17,500:1. With Adaptive this movie, the worn woodgrain notable neutrality; no tingeing toward
Backlight Control set to Off, black level measured 0.051 -L for a fixtures, orange-and-lime-painted red or blue. Various fleshtones
contrast ratio of 774.5 -L. lobby desk, and badly dated provided by the ethnically mixed cast
AVERAGE Delta E for pre-cal grayscale was an excellent 1.6, with a high asparagus-green rug of the Grand were rendered with a level of subtlety
of 2.8 at 70 IRE (70% brightness). Calibration improved this to a Budapest’s run-down 1970s décor and delineation reserved for the very
near-perfect 0.8, with the 10 IRE window measuring 2.1 and all others contrast dramatically against the best displays.
below 1.0. (Delta E is a figure of merit that indicates how closely a saturated red and burgundy carpets The richness and accuracy of the
display adheres to the Rec. 709 HD color standard. Levels below 3 are and polished walnut of the hotel’s color on the calibrated set was indeed
considered visibly indistinguishable from perfect.) pre–World War II heyday. The plasma-like, a fact well proven when I
DELTA E for pre-cal color gamut averaged 1.0, also superb out-of-box TC-65AX900U delivered all of it with finally ran it alongside my reference
accuracy, with blue the farthest from alignment at 2.4. Calibration mesmerizing purity. Close-ups of the flat panel, a well-tuned 60-inch
improved this to 0.6. deep-purple uniforms of the hotel Panasonic ST60 plasma from the
PRE-CALIBRATION gamma averaged 2.32 with the 2.2 preset staff, each edged with a bead of red company’s last year in that category
engaged. Calibration resulted in average gamma of 2.16 using the 2.3 chord, showed a striking richness. (review at soundandvision.com).
preset. At one point, lobby boy Zero (Tony Scene after scene, the two sets were
VIEWING angle was about the best I’ve seen for an LCD thanks to the Revolori) and his bride Agatha shockingly identical—always a
Panasonic’s IPS (in-plane switching) panel type, with no fading of (Saoirse Ronan) plunge through surprise given the potential variance
contrast or color-shiing visible at even 50 to 60 degrees off axis. There the top of a delivery truck from a among different televisions tuned at
was some minor streaking of the backlight visible in the same area on two-story height and land safely different times, but even more so
full-field gray paerns that I aributed to the repeated rough handling on a giant cushion of pink boxes watching Grand Budapest where
and extensive travel of my heavily used sample; this was not visible in containing gourmet desserts. Of such a wide color palette was tested
program material, and I dismissed it as a defect in my specific unit. course, not one of the boxes breaks over the course of the film. It was only
Some very subtle haloing around lines of LED clusters behind the or crushes, and the characters’ heads when I encountered a black-level
screen could also be detected with test paerns, but this was also not pop up from among these delightful torture sequence that the plasma
visible with real content. pink cubes, each box wrapped in a proved itself the superior performer. In
THE TC-65AX900U passed our processing tests except for 2:2 cadence sky-blue ribbon that perfectly Chapter 7, Zero and M. Gustave, the
tests for SD and HD, and the chroma and luma resolution tests for 1080i matches the uniform Zero has hotel’s legendary concierge (played
HD signals (it passed both for 1080p). The cadence results are typical donned as a disguise. It was one of by Ralph Fiennes), are in a taxi racing
and largely meaningless, as is the chroma resolution result. The luma many colorful and evocative shots that through a town in darkness, and as
test result is more unusual, but I saw nothing to suggest any issues with practically knocked me off my chair the taxi follows the camera, its
HD broadcasts, the only 1080i signals most people will ever watch.—RS

The TC-65AX900U is one of the very


48 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com best LCD televisions I’ve ever seen.
REA D & LI S TE N

new
Cable Survey
from
stereoplay
14 Cables Tested
Download Comparative
Files & Listen for Yourself

tinyurl.com/q7t2y2n

Other cables filter your music.


Wireworld cables let the most music through.

Technology that channels musical expression.


© 2015 Wireworld, Inc. DNA Helix U.S. Patent #8,569,627 www.wireworldcable.com
TEST REPORT
• A pop-up camera
is provided for facial
recognition.

headlights beaming straight into the glasses. On the default 3D picture with no narrative line—breathtaking became harder to detect as I moved
lens, the plasma exposed all kinds of preset, the image was among the and hypnotizing. further back, and they remained
details in the shadowy architecture brightest 3D presentations I’ve seen, To get a sense of the difference most prominent on tight shots, but
that sped by, including both the stone and highly detailed given the full HD between native 4K versus 1080p even at 16 feet, there was still some
textures and even the two-tone color resolution delivered to each eye. I upscaled to 4K, I fed the TC- detectable benefit on some scenes.
treatment on one of the buildings. was initially very encouraged, but 65AX900U three versions of Men in Caveats: I used two different inputs
The TC-65AX900U initially failed crosstalk ghosting was rampant and Black 3: the 1080p Blu-ray upscaled on the TV, and there may have been
to grab these out of the shadows, quite severe on many scenes across to 4K by the TV, 1080p upscaled to unknown mastering differences
leaving instead vague outlines of the Avatar, Coraline, and Flying Swords 4K by the Marvell chip in my Oppo beyond resolution in the 4K
building edges and roof lines, and of Dragon Gate. Changing head BDP-103 player, and native 4K from download versus the exceptional
none of the subtle color shadings the position could only partially mitigate Sony’s server. It wasn’t a perfectly 1080p Blu-ray transfer. But as a
plasma delivered. I could put the two the issue, and there were no menu controlled experiment, but after consumer, I’d easily choose the
sets on equal footing for this dark adjustments available to rectify it. duplicating my calibrated settings more pristine 4K version over 1080p
scene by temporarily bringing the Coraline, as an animated feature, on a second HDMI input using the scaled up, at least for this movie and
gamma preset down to 1.8, the was the best of the three demos, but TV’s copying feature, I connected even using these generally excellent
lowest setting, though with obviously I’m afraid that’s not saying much. On the Sony server to one and the Oppo scalers for the 1080p. I’m sold now:
washed-out results on brighter these three movies, the only ones I to the other. I started the movie on A good 4K display with native 4K
scenes. Placing the Adaptive had available to try, 3D was pretty both sources and ran the Blu-ray programming is the real deal. Bring
Backlight Control on Mid also much unwatchable. player about 20 seconds ahead of on the content, and the naysayers.
helped, but with some sacrifice of On the other hand, viewing 4K the Sony server playing the native
deep blacks. A more permanent content on the TC-65AX900U was 4K. So, after seeing a scene or a fine Conclusion
solution was to just use the 10-point nothing short of a giddy treat. I detail in the Blu-ray version on one So, what have we got in the end? A
gamma adjustments to tune by eye looked at Ultra HD test patterns from input of the TV, I had just enough flagship TV from a company best
at and below the 30 percent my DVDO generator, a test clip of time to switch the TV input to the known for their superb 1080p
brightness level. But there was no demo footage downloaded to a flash 4K version and view the same plasma image quality, going all out
combination of settings I found that drive from Ultra Definition Showcase exact scene. to prove they can bump things up to
could provide the same shadow (uhdcontent.eu), and movies and In this case, the advantage of 4K Ultra HD resolution and achieve the
rendition as the plasma while also nature shorts from Sony’s Video became quickly apparent from the same level of performance, all while
delivering its deepest blacks, which Unlimited 4K service via the FMP-X10 7-foot distance. The Oppo’s wearing the handcuffs of inherently
the TC-65AX900U just never 4K server. When I watched this upconversion was marginally inferior LCD technology. It is, if
achieved, either in its letterbox bars material from my 7-foot viewing sharper on some scenes than the anything, a noble cause. But did
or elsewhere in the image. distance, there was never a moment Panasonic’s built-in scaling, though they succeed?
Usually, the most detailed scenes when the TC-65AX900U failed to not by much and only infrequently. Well…mostly. There’s no doubt the
scaled up from 1080p blow me away with its But the native Ultra HD had an TC-65AX900U qualifies as one of the
Blu-rays—close-ups on tremendously fine detail almost luminescent, three-dimen- very best LCD TVs I’ve ever seen, with
characters, showing and incredibly rich, sional quality, thanks to the obvious an image that was alluring, engaging,
facial hair and other saturated colors. In a additional detail, better-etched and eminently satisfying each time I
textural details in skin stunning short called edges around objects, and the way looked its way. More often than not,
and clothing—were Beneath the Blue Sea, a the extra pixels seemed to somehow it was indeed equivalent to my
rendered with equally close-up of some clown enhance bright highlights. In the reference plasma in its superb color
fine precision whether I fish playing among the opening sequence, for example, rendition and, on most scenes, in its
was looking at the native anemones—think Finding there’s a tight close-up of the back contrast. Nonetheless, even with its
1080p plasma or the Nemo—offered all the of some knee-high black leather sophisticated full-array backlight and
TC-65AX900U’s detail and fluorescence boots worn by one of the characters. much effort put into calibration, I
internally upscaled that I’ve seen on the actual The fine teeth in the silver metal never quite got its deep blacks to
image. But there were a creatures in aquariums. zipper running the height of each rival my budget Panasonic ST60
couple of moments on The fine, crisp edge boot were obviously sharper in the plasma, which cost $1,700 two years
longer camera shots around a red-and-green native 4K, and they picked up the ago. Given the TC-65AX900U’s price,
when I thought the sea dragon (basically, a light better and had more dimen- and with 4K OLED knocking on the
plasma delivered fancy seahorse) made it sionality. Similarly, the tight door from elsewhere, it
perhaps a tiny amount of pop off the screen, and I close-ups of the creatures, would have to perform
additional sharpness. was taken with how gadgets, and faces better than anything
These moments were accurately the Panasonic inhabiting the rest of the available, in any technology,
rare, however, and I reproduced that just- movie were enhanced to garner my highest,
found no fault with the below-the-surface light with you-are-there gotta-have-this recommen-
scaling of 1080p content I’ve experienced as a precision (particularly dation. But I’ve no doubt that
on any test patterns. recreational diver. I would noticeable when the those who seek out the best
not have believed it, but a camera was on the deep that LCD technology has to
3D and 4K great 4K display like this ruts and wrinkles of a offer today will find many
Panasonic supplies two one can indeed make now-worn Tommy Lee thrilling hours in front of this
pair of passive 3D well-shot material—even Jones). The effects marvelous television.

• The backlit full-size


remote features a
• A small Bluetooth
remote includes a
dedicated Netflix buon. built-in mic for voice
50 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com commands.
TEST REPORT
Phase Technology Teatro

Three in One
TSB3.0 Soundbar
Performance
Features
Ergonomics
Value

By Mark Fleischmann

tighten the screws, and snap them

Phase Technology Teatro into the back of the soundbar. You


can mount the bar to the wall (using

TSB3.0 Soundbar Phase Tech’s famous 0.75-inch soft


(silk) dome tweeters. To widen the
the supplied hardware) or set it on a
table in front of your TV. Nine
threaded inserts (but no keyholes)
soundstage, these drivers are are provided for wall mounting. I
PRICE $738 augmented by two side-firing 1-inch opted for table mounting.
AT A GLANCE drivers, which the company calls Associated equipment included a
THIS MIGHT SEEM A RADICAL “full-range” Spatial Field Expanders. Pioneer Elite VSX-53 A/V receiver
concept, but what if a soundbar were Plus In previous models, these side-firing along with the surround-channel
just a speaker, or two or three? What Q It’s like having three top- SFE drivers were soft domes that speakers and subwoofer of my
if it had no internal amplifiers, just drawer speakers were easily damaged—as I proved by reference system: a pair of Paradigm
some really good drivers, a Q Balanced performance grabbing a bar at the sides and Reference Studio 20 v.4 speakers for
thoughtfully engineered crossover, Q Passive design allows crumpling them. In the new model, surround duties and a Seismic 110
and sets of speaker terminals, like benefits of an AVR evidently idiot-proofed for people like subwoofer. Also in the loop was an
any other quality loudspeaker? me, they are 1-inch aluminum Oppo BDP-83SE universal disc
Is this kind of soundbar a good Minus inverted domes, not convex soft player. All movie demo material was
idea? That depends on what kind of domes, and are protected by a guard on Blu-ray Disc, and all music demo
system you want—or, more Q Passive design requires an structure. material was on CD.
specifically, whether you want a AVR With two woofers and a tweeter for
standalone audio/video receiver in each channel, complemented by the Like Three Speakers
your system. For some people, the bar’s two SFE drivers, the Teatro This latest Teatro was the best-
AVR is like the guy you’d cross the company’s name. Phase Technol- might strike you as a tough load to sounding passive soundbar I’ve
street to avoid, someone who ogy’s nine speaker lines cover a drive. But its sensitivity seemed to be heard, outpacing even my memories
confuses and bedevils you. For broad range of needs. One of those reasonable during the audition, and of Phase Technology’s own Teatro
others, the AVR is the key to a lines is Teatro, with three soundbar recommended amplifier power is 15 PC3.0 (which earned a five-star
cornucopia of features, the models, of which the TSB3.0 is the to 100 watts, within range of pretty performance rating). Both behaved
cornerstone of a system that unlocks newest. All three models are passive much any AVR. exactly like three top-quality
all your desires. bars, and each is the equivalent of The bar is 43 inches wide, loudspeakers built into a single
The Phase Technology Teatro three speakers built into a horizontal cosmetically suitable for a screen of enclosure. Due to woofer size,
TSB3.0 is the kind of soundbar that enclosure. The TSB3.0 ($738) and 50-plus inches (though that isn’t a though, the new TSB3.0 was
requires an AVR. Because it has no V3.0 ($1,272) have two-way driver strict requirement). On the front of the equivalent to three compact satellite
built-in amp, it’s classified as a arrays, while the PC3.0 ($1,696, extruded-aluminum enclosure is a speakers, whereas the PC3.0 was
passive soundbar. Ironically, despite reviewed in 2009) is three-way. perforated metal speaker grille that more akin to three monitors.
the general connotations of the The TSB3.0 differs in woofer size, conceals the woofers and tweeters. I preferred the new model with its
words passive and active, an ampless however, with 3-inch polypropylene The Spatial Field Expanders are on smaller woofers, mostly because—
passive bar opens up more cone drivers versus the 5.25-inch the ends along with the ports. for whatever reason—it sounded
possibilities than an amp-equipped woofers in the other two models. That On the back are three speaker bigger than I remembered the PC3.0
active bar. By doing next to nothing, reduces the bar’s height by only a terminals using L-shaped Euroblock to be, creating an even more
the passive bar gets more done, by quarter of an inch, but the real (often referred to as “Phoenix”) convincing, even more blast-worthy
allowing the rest of your system to do difference is in the depth measure- connectors. These accept bare wire, soundstage. The top end was polite
more. Maybe we should call it a ment, which is 2 inches less than that so I used my cable of last resort, an all the way down into the middle
passive-aggressive soundbar. of the other models. In other words, 18-gauge bare generic cord with range, mitigating digital nasties from
this is a flatter bar that hugs the wall banana plugs at one end and bare the presence region. And it sounded
Great American Speaker tighter. Each of the three channels is wire at the other. It wasn’t hard to slip wider than the physical dimensions
Maker served by two woofers and one of the wire ends into the Euroblocks, dictated, with credit most likely going
Phase Technology is the storied
American loudspeaker manufacturer
founded by Bill Hecht in the 1950s
and run by his son Ken. Among other
innovations, Bill invented and
patented the soft-dome tweeter in
1967, and his devotion to coherent
phase response is celebrated in the

• The wall-hugging TSB3.0 is 2 inches slimmer


than Phase Tech’s other soundbar models.

52 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


THE VERDICT SOUNDBAR
Phase Technology’s Teatro TSB3.0 soundbar dispenses with PHASE TECHNOLOGY TEATRO TSB3.0 SOUNDBAR
the fancy stuff and provides the performance you’d expect from PRICE: $738
three well-engineered and great-sounding speakers. Phase Technology • (855) 663-5600 • phasetechnology.com

will ever accuse Sly’s burly


baritone of being a musical
instrument, it did give the
bar a chance to sound
deep-voiced, playing
against type as a
small-woofer weakling. The
bar rebelled against its
width in more than one way.
Yes, it sounded wider than
it looked, but it also was
spatially deeper—and the
to the side-firing drivers. I should add localization was less speaker-bound
that my asymmetrical long-wall than just about any other soundbar I
speaker placement worked against can recall. C

the side-firing drivers by denying Parkland (Dolby TrueHD)


them access to nearby, unobstructed dramatizes the assassination of Presi-
side walls—but they improved width dent Kennedy, and even with half a Le Channel (purple) +1.04/–4.06 dB, 200 Hz to 10 kHz; –3 dB @ 156
anyway, even when firing different century of perspective, the film is Hz, –6 dB @ 128 Hz; impedance minimum 4.41 ohms @ 326 Hz, phase
distances at highly diffused side deeply affecting as it uncannily angle –43.28º @ 198 Hz; sensitivity 88.5 dB, 500 Hz to 2 kHz.
walls. humanizes all-too-familiar figures and
I watched The Hunger Games: events. Fittingly, the bar responded Center Channel (green) +0.67/–2.86 dB, 200 Hz to 10 kHz; –3 dB @ 152
Catching Fire (DTS-HD Master Audio) by treating dialogue as a human, not Hz, –6 dB @ 125 Hz; impedance minimum 4.39 ohms @ 330 Hz, phase
twice, first with an 80-hertz crossover, mechanical, phenomenon, free of angle –46.34º @ 183 Hz; sensitivity 88.5 dB, 500 Hz to 2 kHz.—MJP
then at 100 Hz. I knew the first option obvious artifacts and coloration. It
was wrong for the 3-inch woofers, was hard to keep my analytical hat on
though to the bar’s credit, the
disconnect wasn’t obvious until the
during this movie, so my notes
stopped there.
SPECS 3 in polypropylene woofer (6), 0.75 in silk-dome
tweeter (3), 1 in aluminum full-range driver (2); 43 x 6.75 x 2.25 in
aggressive effects kicked in. With (WxHxD); 12 lb • Inputs: Euroblock speaker terminals (3)
either crossover, the bar did brilliantly Vocals Out Front
with voices, delivering them with Moving back to happier territory:
natural tone color that remained The original Beatles CD releases, single volume level for material Senegalese music translates into an
consistent on or off axis, something circa 1987, are much maligned by ranging from the declamatory vocals American milieu, you haven’t heard
that was especially apparent in the some audiophiles. Having grown up and clarion electric guitar of “Ticket N’Dour’s cover of “The Rubberband
wild trajectories of the jabberjay with the generally inferior U.S. vinyl, to Ride” to the reserved acoustic Man.”
attack. While voicing was on the I’d say the old CDs compare guitar and voice of “Yesterday.” It’s not uncommon for some
gentle side—with movies or favorably. Sure, they do have a bit of Cellist Nancy Green and pianist people who love sound to conflate
music—the bar refused to roll off the a bite, but a lot depends on how the Frederick Moyer performed Mario product category with product
nerve-shredding assault of the speakers treat it. Here the Teatro Castelnuovo-Tedesco’s Complete quality. These are usually the folks
baboons. shone. Not only did the soundbar Works for Cello & Piano on a superbly who insist that all soundbars are bad
Escape Plan (DTS-HD Master make the mildly acerbic midrange recorded Biddulph CD. “Best bar for because—well, they’re soundbars.
Audio) has Sylvester Stallone and on Help! palatable, but it also music, ever,” I enthused into my But like loudspeakers in general, bars
Arnold Schwarzenegger behind bars detached the lead vocals from the notebook. The cello was rich, full, can be good, bad, or in between.
in an action-packed prison thriller that instrumentation, pushing them out warm, and not unlike a human Phase Technology’s Teatro TSB3.0 is
puts the following words into front, where they voice—and well imaged in context the kind of soundbar that ennobles
Ahhhnold’s mouth: “You hit like a belonged. And it with the just slightly more diffused its product category with great
vegetarian” (easily the best line that was consistent piano. It was a big, generous performance and even, dare I say it,
screenwriters have given him since enough to let sound, the kind that makes you audiophile voicing. It rocked the
“Hasta la vista, baby”). While no one me use a fall in love with the music, if you Beatles and survived The Hunger
weren’t in love with it already. Games—and if you’re not willing to
Youssou N’Dour’s Nelson listen to it before you judge it, you
Mandela is a fun listen, full of probably hit like a vegetarian.
rollicking rhythms. The Teatro
made the percussion snappy and Audio editor Mark Fleischmann
incisive, and once again it rendered is also the author of the annually
the voice as a warm human updated book Practical Home
presence. If you don’t think Theater (quietriverpress.com).

The Teatro behaves like three loud-


speakers in a single enclosure.
• The TSB3.0 houses two Spatial Field Expander drivers,
as well as a tweeter and two woofers for each channel.

soundandvision.com 53
TEST REPORT

Paradigm’s Silver woofers in the center) have 5.5-inch

Surfers
By Mark Fleischmann
X-PAL drivers, ART surrounds,
Shock-Mount isolation mounting
systems (shared by the center’s
3.5-inch X-PAL midrange driver), and
high-temp voice coils.
As to the parts that aren’t
self-explanatory: The PAL in the X-PAL

Paradigm Prestige 15B drivers refers to pure aluminum,


which combines light weight and
stiffness with highly pistonic (that is to

Speaker System towers, the 95F ($2,499 each), 85F


($1,999 each), and 75F ($1,499 each);
a single monitor, the 15B ($799 each);
say, piston-like) movement. The PPA
(Perforated Phase-Aligning) tweeter
lens, which covers the tweeter, has
PRICE $6,145 the 45C center ($1,299) and larger concentric rings of holes that
55C ($1,699); and a dedicated diminish and then disappear as they
AS I SAT DOWN TO WRITE THIS AT A GLANCE surround speaker, the 25S ($999 approach the center. Besides having
review of the Paradigm Prestige each). Finish options include a protective function, the lens (a
speaker system, I couldn’t get a Plus midnight cherry, walnut, and black variation on the more common
seemingly unrelated subject—the Q Advanced driver designs walnut veneers, and piano black. phase plug) blocks out-of-phase
Pono hate—out of my head. No Q Fine-grained, transparent, Prestige is closer in price to Studio frequencies to provide what the
joke, folks: I sat at the keyboard for dynamic playback than to Signature. The 15B monitor, literature calls “smoother, extended
hours mulling it over. What chance Q Compact but powerful reviewed here with the 45C center, high frequencies with incredible
did I have to convince readers that a subwoofer costs only 100 bucks more per pair detail and higher output.” The FEA
$6,145 speaker system is worth than the chunkier Studio 20 v.5 (I use (Finite Element Analysis) pole-piece
hearing when a $400 music player is Minus the v.4 in my reference system). While directly behind the tweeter dome has
greeted with language like “don’t the 15B’s boxy 0.75-inch fiberboard a contoured cavity that scatters
buy” and “snake oil”? Q Boxy, non-curved enclosure lacks the sweet curved reflections and expands the tweeter’s
OK, I know I’m preaching to the enclosures sides employed in the latest Studio low-frequency extension from 1,800
converted. You probably wouldn’t be line, the edges use a lock-joint hertz (with a conventional pole-piece)
reading Sound & Vision if you weren’t construction for greater structural down to 1,200 Hz. This allows a lower
open to the idea that a well-designed Between Signature and rigidity than is customary from the crossover point to the woofer,
speaker system has the power to Studio usual 45-degree-angle box cut. And resulting in potentially smoother
bring you closer to music. That’s The Prestige series is brand new. It when you remove the magnetically off-axis response.
what the Paradigms did for me when lodges between Paradigm’s attached grilles, you may notice that The woofer surrounds—the
I informally played a few recent top-of-the-line Signature speakers the 1-inch-thick baffle has a visual flexible piece that attaches the
additions to my high-resolution and midpriced Studio series, with the economy lacking in the overbuilt- circumference of the cone to the
music library (more on them later). I slim-and-trim Millenia and value- looking Studio as well as a new basket—feature ART (Active Ridge
felt as if a curtain had been lifted and oriented Monitor further down. (If you tweeter lens and other driver-related Technology), with ridges overmolded
music was in the room with me—not don’t want to pay $400 for a music refinements. I like the massive robotic onto the cone, for greater excursion
just recorded music, player, you may be a Monitor kind of look of the Studio just as much, but and what is claimed to be a 3-decibel
but music. guy, and that might even be a shrewd that may be a matter of taste. Perhaps gain in distortion-free output
decision on your part.) it’s a guy thing. compared with that of conventional
The Prestige lineup includes three Paradigm loves acronymic surrounds. The Shock-Mount
tech-speak, so your head may spin isolation mounting system on all the
when I tell you that the 15B and 45C woofers and the center’s midrange
have 1-inch X-PAL fluid-cooled uses rubber inserts and gaskets to
tweeters with PPA tweeter lenses and decouple the drivers from the
FEA-optimized pole-piece enclosure, controlling interaction
assemblies. Meanwhile, the 5.5-inch between them along with sound-
woofers in both speakers (dual polluting resonance and vibration.

54 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


• The high-tech Prestige drivers boast a variety of sound-
enhancing innovations.
THE VERDICT SPEAKER SYSTEM
Paradigm Prestige 15B Paradigm’s Prestige series speakers PARADIGM PRESTIGE 15B SPEAKER SYSTEM
Speaker System
and Seismic 110 sub employ unusual PRICE: $6,145 (15B, $799 ea; 45C, $1,299; Seismic 110, $1,650)
Performance
driver design to achieve remarkable Paradigm Electronics • (905) 564-1994 • paradigm.com
Build Quality
Value transparency and punch.

Brushed-aluminum finishes and make the darned thing fly off the sub compared with that of the smaller
matching concave dust caps give the and hit the wall. Studio 10.)
woofers and midrange a sleek The sub supports both XLR and The Hobbit: The Desolation of
appearance that complements the RCA connections and meshes with Smaug had cavorted with my Seismic
snazzy-looking tweeter lens. Paradigm’s Perfect Bass Kit for com- 110 sub before, and so the roaring,
Incidentally, Paradigm designs and puter assisted room correction. It is thundering emergences of Smaug
builds its drivers in-house. just the awesomest compact sub ever, and Sauron came as no surprise. I
If you opt for a tower model, you’ll and I say that after years of using it. actually dialed the sub back from the
get a polished steel and aluminum Associated equipment included initial settings used for most of the
base with reversible feet. Don’t want the whole menagerie: a Pioneer Elite music demos (below). The 45C
spikes to damage your hardwood VSX-53 A/V receiver, Oppo BDP-83SE delivered precisely enunciated
floors or carpet? Unscrew the spikes universal disc player (for movies and voices that had no chestiness or
and reverse them, and you’ve got music), Panasonic DMP-BD87 Blu-ray honking coloration, with especially
blunt nubs instead. player (for music and streaming), impressive low-level resolution in the
Lenovo Windows 7 laptop, Audio- sotto voce conference between
Oh, and the Sub Quest DragonFly v1.2 USB DAC, Gandalf and Thorin at Bree. When
The Seismic 110 subwoofer ($1,650) Meridian Director USB DAC, Micro setting up the speakers with test
we mated with the Prestige has been Seiki BL-21 turntable, Shure V15MxVR/ tones, I noticed that the center had a
part of my reference system since it N97XE cartridge, and the phono stage slightly brighter tonal balance than
came out four years ago, and for of a Denon PRA-S10 preamp. All that of the monitors, and I worried
which a formal review here is long movie demos (and the first music that the less-than-perfect timbral
overdue. Paradigm spent a lot of demo) were on Blu-ray Disc. match would affect lateral panning. In
time and money refining this unique practice, however, it wasn’t a But of course, the musical segments
sub, and the results are both visible Live Long and Image problem. The 15B summoned a are the meat of the movie. The
and audible. Refinement and transparency are roomy sound for the orchestral score monitors were dispassionate
The 37-pound sub’s die-cast Prestige’s prime directives. The 15B and rolled Smaug’s liquid rumble like enough to reveal the artifice in the
aluminum chassis may look massive monitor and 45C center offer a melodious tidal wave from front to raucous gospel scene; the reverb
in photographs but is actually just finer-grained mid and high back. (Smaug sounded most like its seemed faked. But the subsequent
13.5 inches tall. Its 10-inch front-firing frequencies than the Studio 20 I have voice actor, Benedict Cumberbatch, gigs were stunningly believable, with
copolymer polypropylene cone is enjoyed for so many years, in moments of stress.) Most the funky beat punching through
built in two parts, with the flat outer especially with harmonically rich impressive of all, I was able to watch thick club and theater ambience and
cone locked onto the voice coil by an instruments like violins and cymbals. the entire movie with a single volume Brown’s vocals defiantly riding,
unseen inner cone with I-beam They also offer a clearer window into setting and no dynamic range emoting, and punctuating over the
cross-section support arms. An hi-res content and are a little more control—a first for the Hobbit movies. top. It was as if the satellites and sub
inverted surround made of candid about the flaws of both When the soundtrack stepped up its were having a torrid love affair.
overmolded Santoprene—a material associated gear and content. The various all-channel assaults, listening A Most Wanted Man (DTS-HD
that combines the characteristics of Prestiges aren’t forgiving speakers; comfort remained high, and I was Master Audio) brings to life the
vulcanized rubber and thermo- mating them with a midpriced or able to lose myself in the movie. Hamburg of John le Carré’s novel.
plastic—has corrugations to allow better receiver would be worth the Get On Up is the James Brown The gritty surround ambience
“extreme excursion” while remaining investment. (I should note in passing biopic coproduced by Mick Jagger. generated by four 15B monitors was
stable and centered. You’ve got to that the Studio 20, with its 7-inch The sub was delightfully forceful in so real, it competed with both the
see the driver moving, as well as hear woofer, has the advantage in bass. the scene where Brown’s plane is narrative and the acting prowess of
it, to believe it. I’m surprised the But the Prestige 15B’s 5.5-inch caught by anti-aircraft fire in Vietnam.
850-watt RMS Class D amp doesn’t woofer may be more appropriately

• The Prestige line is available in walnut, black walnut, and


piano black finishes, as well as the midnight cherry shown here. soundandvision.com 55
TEST REPORT
• The Seismic 110
houses a 10-inch
Paradigm Seismic 110 Subwoofer
Performance
Features ON THE See soundandvisionmag.com
WEB for full lab results and technical definitions
woofer in its compact Build Quality
13.5-inch cabinet. Value

with Zubin Mehta leading the


Bavarian State Orchestra in the
Vienna Musikverein, got a treatment
Test Bench
from the Paradigms that was nothing Paradigm Prestige 15B Speaker System
short of mesmerizing. With these
speakers, the 96/24 DTS-HD Master
Audio 5.0-channel soundtrack set a
new standard in my listening life: I’ve
never heard an orchestra as vividly
and realistically imaged as this
outside a concert hall. It was a
perfect storm of hi-res content,
surround soundtrack, tweeter
lenses, and rubber gaskets. The
strings had more tone color than I’ve
ever heard in recorded music—yet
despite the almost obsessively
focused imaging, there was no edge,
just a fully fleshed-out account of
dozens of people playing stringed C

instruments in one of the world’s


greatest concert halls.
I auditioned Led Zeppelin’s
Physical Graffiti (96/24 FLAC from 15B (purple) +4.64/–1.19 dB, 200 Hz to 10 kHz; – 3dB @ 60 Hz, –6 dB
HDtracks) with the two aforemen- @ 52 Hz; impedance minimum 4.55 ohms @ 193 Hz, phase angle
tioned USB DACs, the Meridian –49.38º @ 5.9 kHz; sensitivity 86 dB, 500 Hz to 2 kHz.
Director and the AudioQuest
Philip Seymour Hoffman and Willem DragonFly v1.2. The Paradigms 45C (green) +2.68/–2.13 dB, 200 Hz to 10 kHz; – 3 dB @ 86 Hz, –6 dB
Dafoe—and that’s saying a lot. I felt surprised me by preferring the less @ 72 Hz; impedance minimum 4.17 ohms @ 1.1 kHz, phase angle
as if I were on the streets with the expensive DragonFly’s warmer –56.89º @ 108 Hz; sensitivity 89.5 dB, 500 Hz to 2 kHz.
characters. And although I’ve sat midrange and more relaxed
through loads of nightclub scenes in presentation. While the Seismic 110 Seismic 110 (blue) Close-miked response, normalized to level @ 80
movies, the one summoned by the sub pounded out John Bonham’s Hz: lower –3 dB @ 18 Hz, –6 dB @ 16 Hz; upper –3 dB @ 181 Hz
Prestiges was unusually claustro- mighty kick drum, the speakers with Cut-Off Frequency control set to maximum.—MJP
phobic; my fight-or-flight instinct was panned Jimmy Page’s guitars for gold
in high gear. The center
and sub were a perfect
marriage for voices of
and came up with grunge—but a
cleverly recorded, multifaceted, and
endlessly engaging grunge.
SPECS 15B: 5.5 in aluminum-cone woofer, 1 in
aluminum-dome tweeter; 7 x 12.13 x 9.38 in (WxHxD); 16 lb • 45C:
both genders, never Te Amo, Argentina (from Yarlung 5.5 in aluminum-cone woofer (2), 3.5 in aluminum-cone midrange,
localizing in the sub. In Records) has cellist Antonio Lysy 1 in aluminum-dome tweeter; 18.38 x 7.5 x 10.5 in (WxHxD); 32 lb •
fact, the 80-Hz sub performing solo and other works by Seismic 110: 10 in polypropylene-cone woofer; 850 was RMS,
crossover worked Ginastera, Piazzolla, Bragato, Golijov, 1,700 was peak; sealed enclosure; line-level stereo and LFE in,
beautifully for and Schifrin (yes, the same Lalo mono XLR in, USB for PBK EQ, 12-volt trigger; 13.75 x 13.5 x 12.56 in
everything. Schifrin who wrote the Mission: (WxHxD); 37 lb
I hadn’t intended to Impossible theme). It was recorded
use season 3 of House with vacuum tube equipment onto
of Cards as demo material, analog tape and delivered to my The final and unanswered are rare. Speakers that beat my
but having heard the system via LP, and as heard through question: Will Paradigm add either a reference system on orchestral
ominous, airy opening the 15B monitors, it provided a Dolby Atmos–enabled model or an material are rarer. But speakers that
theme dozens of times, I laid-back but solidly imaged account Atmos module to the Prestige line? do both are practically unheard of. I
couldn’t help feeling that this of the cello. If I hadn’t known better by Rumors are flying, but for now, all I learned a lot—and had a lot of fun—
was the best iteration yet. My that point, I’d have thought the can say is: I hope so. with the Prestige in my listening room.
binge-viewing buddy said: golden mellowness was a property of The Paradigm Prestige series And living with the Seismic 110 sub
“This sounds amazing.” the speakers, but the shape-shifting combines state-of-the-art design, continues to be a joy.
Prestiges were just adapting to the ingenious engineering, and superb
Reference content, as great loudspeakers often build quality with voicing that I found Audio editor Mark Fleischmann
Orchestral do. Occasional accompaniment on cinematically and musically unerring. is also the author of the annually
The Blu-ray Pure Audio this album includes a piano, and the Speakers that allow me one-setting updated book Practical Home
release of Mahler’s system called attention to the gentle enjoyment of action movies, with no Theater (quietriverpress.com).
Symphonies Nos. 3 and 5, wooden-hammered attack. dynamic range control intervention,

• At just over 12 inches high, the


15B mounts well on stands. Refinement and transparency are
Prestige’s prime directives.
56 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
Save $50-$100

SALE On Our Best


SoundBase
Systems.

60
DAY
HOME TRIAL

“The New ZVOX SoundBase Is A Smart


Alternative To Skinny Sound Bars.” CNET

Our new ZVOX SoundBase® home theater systems are bigger than ever – up to 42" wide – so they are compatible with virtually any size
TV. And they sound better than ever – with improved tonal balance, more expansive virtual surround sound and remarkable bass from up
to three built-in powered subwoofers. Before you buy a sound bar or conventional home theater, use our 60-day home trial and hear how
good a great SoundBase can sound.

What The Critics Say About ZVOX:


“Best buy.” “Home audio product of the year.” “Audiophile quality.”
Consumer’s Digest CNET Stereophile

• Improved PhaseCue® • New AccuVoice® • aptX Bluetooth allows • Low-profile (3.5" high)
technology gives you technology delivers for wireless music designer cabinets
three-dimensional sound incredibly clear streaming from your virtually disappear
from one cabinet. vocal reproduction. phone or tablet. under your TV.

Fantastic home theater sound does NOT have to be complicated, cluttered or costly. New ZVOX SoundBase systems range in size from
17" to 42" and are now priced from $169.99 to $599.99. They are available through the zvoxaudio.com web site or from over 600 retail
outlets including Magnolia Home Theater stores (in select Best Buy stores), Amazon.com, Crutchfield.com, Paul’s TV, Karl’s TV, ListenUp
and many other retailers. For dealer list visit zvoxaudio.com.

®
Free Shipping & 60 Day Home Trial
zvoxaudio.com | 866-367-9869
® ZVOX, SoundBase, PhaseCue and AccuVoice are registered trademarks of ZVOX Audio LLC. Bluetooth is a registered trademark of Bluetooth SIG. © 2015 ZVOX Audio LLC.
TEST REPORT
Niles Auriel MRC-6430 Multiroom

Old School,
Audio Controller
Performance
Features
Ergonomics
Value

New Tricks?
The back of the MRC-6430 is
arranged logically, with source inputs
taking up the left side of the chassis
and speaker/amplifier connections
on the right. An Ethernet jack
By John Sciacca provides connection to your home’s
network, and a USB Type-A
connection is used for configuring.

Niles Auriel MRC-6430 There are loop outs for each source,
making it easy to add an extender

Multiroom Audio Controller chassis or to share sources between


the MRC-6430 and a home theater. A
paging input allows connection of
PRICE $4,070 as reviewed the optional Niles DBI-2 doorbell
connecting six sources, along with interface that will chime through the
HOUSEWIDE AUDIO DISTRIBU- minijack infrared emitter connections speakers.
tion systems varied little in their AT A GLANCE to control connected devices. The The speaker connections for
design and feature set for many MRC-6430 has four zones of zones 1 through 4 utilize Phoenix
years. Whether they were from Niles, Plus onboard amplification (rated at 30 connectors that accept up to
Elan, SpeakerCraft, NuVo, or watts per channel into 8 ohms, 45 14-gauge wire, and each zone also
Q Incredibly simple setup
Russound, you could essentially watts into 4 ohms) with preouts for includes analog RCA preouts that are
Q Terrific home theater
count on them offering six analog connecting two other externally individually configurable as fixed or
integration
audio source inputs, onboard amplified zones. Two MRC-6430 variable, providing a lot of installation
amplification for six stereo zones, Q Easily handles both analog chassis can be linked together, flexibility. For instance, you could
and connections for a variety of and IP sources doubling the number of audio zones. bypass the internal amplifier and use
controllers, usually including an There are numerous control something more powerful, assign a
in-wall keypad. Minus options, including free iPhone, iPad, zone to a dedicated headphone
The problem was, those systems and Android apps, as well as both amplifier/wireless transmitter (not
were designed with traditional, Q No native sources Mac and PC desktop control. Beyond only could you listen to any source
minimally interactive sources in mind, Q Typical Class D sound those, Niles offers three additional you desire, but you’ll still hear the
things like CD changers and cable quality options in the form of the nHR200 doorbell even when wearing your
boxes that didn’t provide any handheld touchscreen remote “cans”) or add a subwoofer for more
feedback and were controlled with ($870), the nKP7 slick in-wall bass in a zone.
simple commands like “Play” and company has been at the forefront of seven-button keypad ($200), and the As the MRC-6430 communicates
“Channel Up.” When smart sources custom audio installation for years, nTP7 7-inch in-wall touchscreen with Niles control devices over the
like iPods, music servers, and Internet manufacturing more than 500 ($1,000). I’ll discuss these in greater network, all interfaces must be on the
radio came along—devices that individual products, including detail in a bit, but no matter how you same network. The single-gang nKP7
required two-way metadata feedback speakers, amplifiers, control prefer to interact with your audio keypad connects to the network and
for making an informed listening systems, and home entertainment system, Niles has a control solution operates using Power over Ethernet
selection—those old audio accessories. Niles is now part of available. (PoE). The nTP7 touchpanel fits in a
distribution systems were left behind Core Brands (a division of Nortek double-gang wall box and can be
and quickly replaced with scalable, Technology), alongside other audio Setup positioned in either portrait or
next-generation solutions like Sonos. names like Aton, Panamax, Elan, Auriel is intended for professional landscape orientation; it operates via
Many of the new systems, Proficient, and SpeakerCraft. Suffice installation, but it’s so easy to install either a local 12-volt power supply or
however, don’t really play nice with it to say, Niles understands and configure, it really can be PoE. The touchscreen also includes
legacy gear. Or integrate easily with distributed audio. tackled by a tech-savvy enthusiast, Wi-Fi if a hard-wired connection isn’t
home theater systems. Or offer any The heart of what Niles calls “the especially if the home is already available. The nHR200 touchscreen
kind of wall-mounted control options. Auriel ecosystem” is the MRC-6430 wired for a distributed audio system. handheld remote connects via Wi-Fi
With the Auriel MRC-6430, Niles is multiroom audio controller ($2,000), (You can download all of the setup and configures by USB connection to
looking to bridge the gap between a component that’s completely and configuration documentation the MRC-6430. One hiccup I
old and new and hopefully deliver the devoid of any front-panel controls from Niles’ Website.) encountered: Because the nHR200
perfect balance between both. (short of a power button). It has no
onboard sources and can’t play any
Meet the Auriel Family tunes out of the box. Instead, it
Niles was founded in 1978, and the includes analog inputs for

58 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


THE VERDICT AUDIO CONTROLLER
Auriel is a breeze to set up, provides control over legacy and modern NILES MRC-6430 MULTIROOM AUDIO CONTROLLER
sources, and offers home theater integration along with a variety of PRICE: $4,070 (MRC-6430, $2,000; nHR200, $870; nKP7, $200; nTP7,
easy-to-use interfaces. $1,000)
Niles Audio • (800) 289-4434 • nilesaudio.com/auriel.php

• The nTP7 can be


installed landscape
IR-controlled component is a breeze.
A huge number of IR devices are in
could get sloppy
and confusing, but
or portrait. the database, divided into eight Niles smartly • The nKP7
keypad
categories (such as CD, set-top box, designed the (below)
and Blu-ray) and then sorted control GUIs to look offers direct
alphabetically by manufacturer, and identical across all access to
then by device. Supported devices (handheld your favorite
IP-controlled devices are fairly limited remote and sources.
at this point—essentially, Elan and single-gang keypad
Yamaha tuners along with media excepted). This not
servers from Sonos, Yamaha, and only ensures a
Autonomic and models based on consistent
Logitech’s Squeezebox platform. experience but also
Once you add a source, you can makes for an easy
rename it, assign it an input on the learning curve. The
MRC-6430, link it to an IR emitter iOS app is
output, and adjust the audio gain optimized for
from –6 to +6 decibels to level iPhone and iPad,
volumes between sources. If you’re and I really
supports onlyy a limited using a home theater receiver, its appreciated the
selection of Wi-Fi encryption
yp inputs are also assigned so the option of having both
options, it wouldn’t connect to my MRC-6430 can control it. Favorite PC and Mac control, as I
network until I adjusted the channels can be assigned if you’re frequently have my laptop
encryption settings in my wireless using a set-top box, making for easy open when listening to
access point. Once I changed the recall later, especially via the nKP7 music and love being able
settings to an encryption it keypad’s one-touch-to-music to control the audio system
supported, I had no further issues. feature. from the desktop.
With all devices connected, you Zone configuration allows for The All Media home page
can perform the configuration using naming each zone, setting defaults gives a quick snapshot of
any of the control apps (iOS, Android, for tone and volume (bass, treble, the entire system, showing
PC, or Mac) or the nTP7 touchpanel. and loudness, along with turn-on and status of all listening zones
Pressing and holding the onscreen maximum volumes for each area), along with volume control.
Niles logo presents an “Installer and choosing whether it is part of Tapping a zone shows available Radio, SHOUTcast, and Slacker.
Access” screen that prompts for a wholehouse music (WHM) and sources (if nothing is playing) or While the MRC-6430 was able to
four-digit password. After you enter doorbell events. displays a Now Playing screen with control my Marantz AV8801
that, you get configuration options The remaining configuration template buttons optimized for each preamp—and display tuner feedback
for Chassis, Sources, Zones, User options allow you to tweak settings source. For example, on my Dish info—Auriel’s integration with a
Interfaces, Home Theater TV, to the user interfaces, connect the Hopper, I could access channels and Yamaha Aventage receiver at my
Handheld Remote, and Keypads. nHR200 to your Wi-Fi network, and DVR commands, while my control of custom installation showroom was
Chassis configuration allows for assign favorites to the keypads. Kaleidescape included the where it really shined, linking with
adjusting network settings, adding a While it might seem like a lot of steps, necessary transport and navigation Yamaha’s streaming features and
second MRC-6430, and taking in reality, the entire process is buttons. A gear button provides letting me browse all of the supported
advantage of one of Auriel’s coolest incredibly fast and took me less than quick access to tweak settings (like services like Pandora, Spotify,
features by configuring a home a half hour. bass, treble, and loudness), Rhapsody, and Internet radio
theater receiver for control. The activating WHM, or putting a room stations. Niles said it hopes to add
MRC-6430 interfaces with a variety of Control: My Way, Your into do-not-disturb mode (blocking this level of integration for other
IP-controllable receivers, including Way, Any Way WHM and doorbell). receiver brands.
models from Denon, Onkyo, Integra, With such a variety of control Playing smart IP sources (Sonos, Where other audio distribution
Marantz, Pioneer, and Yamaha. options, things for example, or Fusion’s Ovation systems merely offer an output to
Sources are grouped into IP- or music server) displays metadata feed a home theater system, Auriel
IR-controlled devices. Adding an including album art, artist, and track embraces this integration, doing
info. The current Sonos driver much more than just sharing sources.
supports Spotify, SiriusXM, Deezer, The MRC-6430 can power a home
TuneIn, and Pandora, letting you theater display on and off and switch
browse them easily from the Auriel inputs as needed for each source,
interface. I transferred my music and the TV can be controlled via one
collection—including multiple hi-res of the MRC-6430’s hard-wired IR
albums—to a Fusion Ovation and outputs or from the IR blaster built
effortlessly browsed the content into the nHR200 remote control.
along with online services like Jazz This—along with the home theater

• The MRC-6430 has a clean


front panel with no buttons.

soundandvision.com 59
TEST REPORT
• Niles offers free
control apps for iOS
and Android.

SPECS Power Output: 30 was (8 ohms), 45 was (4


ohms) • Dimensions (WxHxD, Inches): 17.25 x 4.94 x 12.88 • Weight
(Pounds): 18 • Inputs: RCA analog audio (6), RCA paging/doorbell
input, RJ45 Ethernet, USB-A (for configuration) • Outputs: RCA analog
audio source loop outs (6), RCA analog audio preamp outputs (6), RCA
paging/doorbell loop out, minijack IR emier (6), Phoenix-type speaker
connectors (4)

receiver other rooms, letting the nHR200


control—allows easily roam and control any part of
the MRC-6430 to the home, while a “Media” button lets
become far more you select different options within
than just an audio each room. The remote gave me
distribution system, control over all the necessary
entering the realm of buttons of my Hopper and
an integrated Kaleidescape, and the 2.4-inch
entertainment control color touchscreen displays all Listening to Auriel
platform. media server metadata, letting I’ve spent the bulk of this review
The nTP7’s me browse my music on the talking about the Auriel’s installation
touchpanel’s 800 x Fusion and choose Pandora and its control interfaces, without a
480-resolution screen channels on the Yamaha. The word (yet) on audio quality. The truth
has sharp, bright graphics remote is rechargeable and is, for most housewide audio
and is very responsive, comes with a nice charging/ distribution systems, I find that the
waking automatically as docking station. interface design and interaction are
you approach. Later this While the nKP7 keypad is by far the most important aspect of
year, Niles will add the most unassuming the overall user experience. Most Conclusion
intercom support to the control option of the often, these types of devices are Without question, Auriel offers a ton
system, including bunch, there’s a being used to drive in-ceiling of great features, with numerous
station to station, brilliance to its utter speakers in non-audiophile listening control options, and it can interface
station to front door, simplicity. The spaces like kitchens, dining rooms, with legacy, analog audio gear and
and station to keypad’s four backlit or bathrooms. play nice with many new
mobile devices. Favorite buttons That said, Auriel certainly sounds IP-controlled sources. It also adds a
Also, part of Auriel’s (which can be custom plenty good. Since the amps are ton of value by integrating with and
road map is adding
HVAC and lighting
• The nHR200
sports a 2.4-inch
engraved via a Niles
dealer) offer one-touch
4-ohm stable, they can handle two
pair of carefully chosen speakers in
controlling a home theater receiver
and TV, making it a true part of a
control, conceivably color touchscreen. access to your preferred larger spaces. The sound is fairly housewide entertainment system.
making the nTP7 an music, immediately typical of what I’m used to hearing Sure, an onboard Internet tuner—
excellent fixed point of always-on turning the zone on and playing the from mid-level Class D amplifiers, preferably with support for Pandora,
control in the home. source. Many things can be with audio that is midrange forward Spotify, and other streaming
People do love the idea of a touch- “favorited,” including TV channels, and bass shy. Compared with an services—and AirPlay inclusion
screen, but for sit-back-on-the-couch playlists, radio stations, and older Niles ICS system I have (which I would be some sweet icing on the
channel-surfing control, nothing streaming audio channels. Being lauded in a previous review for its cake. But when you throw in the fact
beats a handheld remote. And the able to walk into a room, press one superb amp) and a multichannel that Niles plans on adding video
nHR200 is a pretty terrific solution, button, and have your fave channel Lexicon DD-8 amplifier (an example intercom, as well as some automa-
with an intuitive layout and start playing is the kind of no-brainer of a terrific Class D amp), the Auriel tion control and support, Auriel can
rubberized buttons that feel nice in control that will have you listening sounded noticeably thinner and not ultimately be the backbone of a really
the hand. A “Rooms” button selects and enjoying the system more. as musical. powerful system.

• The MRC-6430 audio controller has inputs for six sources.

60 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


HARBOR FREIGHT
QUALITY TOOLS AT RIDICULOUSLY LOW PRICES

How Does Harbor Freight SUPER COUPON SUPER COUPON

FREE
Sell GREAT QUALITY Tools
at the LOWEST Prices?
We have invested millions of
dollars in our own state-of-the-art
quality test labs and millions more
20% WITH ANY PURCHASE

7 FUNCTION
in our factories, so our tools will go
toe-to-toe with the top professional
brands. And we can sell them for
a fraction of the price because we
cut out the middle man and pass
OFF 14 ANY SINGLE ITEM

LIMIT 1 - Save 20% on any one item purchased at our stores or HarborFreight.com or by calling
800-423-2567. *Cannot be used with other discount, coupon, gift cards, Inside Track
DIGITAL
MULTIMETER

$
LOT 90899 shown
98025/69096

VALUE
99
the savings on to you. It’s just that Club membership, extended service plans or on any of the following: compressors,
generators, tool storage or carts, welders, floor jacks, Towable Ride-On Trencher,
Saw Mill (Item 61712/62366/67138), Predator Gas Power Items, open box items, LIMIT 1 - Cannot be used with other discount, coupon or prior purchase. Coupon good at our
in-store event or parking lot sale items. Not valid on prior purchases after 30 days
simple! Come visit one of our from original purchase date with original receipt. Non-transferable. Original coupon
must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per customer per day.
stores, HarborFreight.com or by calling 800-423-2567. Offer good while supplies last. Shipping
& Handling charges may apply if not picked up in-store. Non-transferable. Original coupon
must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one FREE GIFT coupon per customer per day.

550 Stores Nationwide.

WOW SUPE3 GARLESCO


R ! R ! 9 PIECE FULLY POLISHED
PE ON 26", 4 DRAWER PE ON UPON!
SU UP TOOL CART SU UP COMBINATION LLON, 100 PSI
CO CO WRENCH SETS S PANCAKE
SAE OIL
WINNER LOT 95659 shown
61634/61952 LOT 69043/42304 shown
OR
AIR COMPRESSshow
– Truckin' Magazine SAVE
n LOT 95275
SAVE
$3999 59
METRIC 55% 60637/61615
LOT 42305/69044
SAVE
• 580 lb. Capacity
60% 99
$180 $ 99 99$279.99
REG.
PRICE YOUR CHOICE!
$

LIMIT 4 - Good at our stores or HarborFreight.com or by calling 800-423-2567. Cannot be used with other discount
or coupon or prior purchases after 30 days from original purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplies last.
5
$ 99 PRICE
REG.
$14.99
LIMIT 8 - Good at our stores or HarborFreight.com or by calling 800-423-2567. Cannot be used with other discount
or coupon or prior purchases after 30 days from original purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplies last. or coupon or prior purcha ses
or HarborFreight.com or by
calling 800-423-2567. Cannot
LIMIT 4 - Good at our stores after 30 days from original purchase with origina
Valid through 9/8/15. Limit
REG. PRICE
$89.99
be used with other discoun

one coupon per custom


t
supplies last.
l receipt. Offer good while er per day.
coupon must be presented.

WO1.5WHPSUELPEECTRR COIC POUPLEONSA! W


Non-transferable. Original

W
Non-transferable. Original coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per customer per day. Non-transferable. Original coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per customer per day.

W O SUPER COUPON!
10 FT. x 17 FT. PORTABLE
GARAGE
U
S U
CO
P
R !
PE ON
27 LED PORTABLE
WORKLIGHT/FLASHLIGHT
LOT 67227 shown
LOT 69039 shown 69567/60566/62532
60727 SAVE
SAVE

$64
SAVE
OVER

$
OVER
122
62286 $ 35
62%
$177 68
Batteries $ 99 2 REG.
PRICE
LOT 68862

• Extends from $ 7499


199 99 6 ft. to 8 ft. 10"
included $7.99
$ REG. PRICE
REG. PRICE $299.99 $99.99 discount
discount Cannot be used with other s last.
Cannot be used with other s last. by calling 800-423-2567.
by calling 800-423-2567. or HarborFreight.com or l purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplie
or HarborFreight.com or l purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplie LIMIT 9 - Good at our stores or HarborFreight.com or by calling 800-423-2567. Cannot be used with other discount LIMIT 3 - Good at our stores er per day.
LIMIT 3 - Good at our stores after 30 days from originaValid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per custom
er per day. ses after 30 days from origina Limit one coupon per custom
or prior purcha ses or coupon or prior purchases after 30 days from original purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplies last. or coupon or prior purchal coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15.
or coupon l coupon must be presen
ted. Non-transferable. Origina
Non-transferable. Origina Non-transferable. Original coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per customer per day.

R ! R ! 4000 PEAK/ R !
PE ON PE ON PE ON 72" x 80"
SU UP LOT 69227/62116 SU UP SU UP
SUPER 3200 RUNNING WATTS
QUIET MOVER'S BLANKET
CO 62584/62590/68048 shown CO • 70 dB 6.5 HP (212 CC) CO LOT 66537 shown
Noise GAS GENERATORS 69505/62418
RAPID PUMP SAVE ® Level
LOT 69729/68528/69676 shown
3 TON $85 LOT 69675/69728
HEAVY DUTY
STEEL FLOOR JACK SAVE
$200 $
CALIFORNIA ONLY

99 SAVE
$ 99 5
$ 74
REG. PRICE $159.99
99 • Weighs 74 lbs.
299
REG. PRICE $499.99
66%
REG. PRICE $17.99

LIMIT 4 - Good at our stores or HarborFreight.com or by calling 800-423-2567. Cannot be used with other discount LIMIT 3 - Good at our stores or HarborFreight.com or by calling 800-423-2567. Cannot be used with other discount LIMIT 8 - Good at our stores or HarborFreight.com or by calling 800-423-2567. Cannot be used with other discount
or coupon or prior purchases after 30 days from original purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplies last. or coupon or prior purchases after 30 days from original purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplies last. or coupon or prior purchases after 30 days from original purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplies last.
Non-transferable. Original coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per customer per day. Non-transferable. Original coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per customer per day. Non-transferable. Original coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per customer per day.

U
S U
CO
P
R !
PE ON FOLDABLE ALUMINUM
SPORTS CHAIR WOW SU18PEVORLTCOCOUPRDONLE!SSR U
S U
CO
P
R !
PE ON
RETRACTABLE AIR HOSE REEL
WITH 3/8" x 50 FT. HOSE
3/8" DRILL/DRIVE
LOT 62314
66383 shown

SAVE WI KEYLESS CHUCK


TH
$15
• 250 lb. SAVE LOT 69265/62344

37%
Capacity
54% LOT 69651 99 SAVE 93897 shown

68239 shown $90


$ 24
REG. PRICE $39.99
99 Includes one
18V NiCd
battery and
charger.
$ 2299 $ 5999
REG. PRICE REG. PRICE
99 t
$34.discoun $149.99
Cannot be used with other s last.
by calling 800-423-2567.
LIMIT 5 - Good at our stores or HarborFreight.com or by calling 800-423-2567. Cannot be used with other discount or HarborFreight.com or l purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplie LIMIT 5 - Good at our stores or HarborFreight.com or by calling 800-423-2567. Cannot be used with other discount
or coupon or prior purchases after 30 days from original purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplies last. LIMIT 6 - Good at our stores
ses after 30 days from origina Limit one coupon per custom
er per day.
or coupon or prior purchases after 30 days from original purchase with original receipt. Offer good while supplies last.
Non-transferable. Original coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per customer per day. or coupon or prior purchal coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Non-transferable. Original coupon must be presented. Valid through 9/8/15. Limit one coupon per customer per day.
Non-transferable. Origina

• 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed • No Hassle Return Policy • 550 Stores Nationwide


• Over 25 Million Satisfied Customers • Lifetime Warranty On All Hand Tools • HarborFreight.com 800-423-2567
TEST REPORT

Format Warrior
By Al Griffin
Setup
I evaluated the BDP-88FD’s

Pioneer Elite BDP-88FD video performance using a


Sony VPL-VW350ES

Blu-ray Player an elegant look to match,


with a black, brushed-
4K-resolution projector and
an 80-inch-wide screen. A
Marantz SR6004 A/V
aluminum front panel and receiver and a GoldenEar
PRICE $2,000 only a choice selection of Technology speaker
AT A GLANCE the most essential control system handled the audio
buttons. chores. The player provides
WHAT’S NEW IN THE WORLD OF Plus The slender remote a range of presets in its
Blu-ray? 4K, that’s what. Expected to Q High-quality 4K video control has a backlit Video P. menu—accessed
arrive sometime in late 2015, the upconversion keypad and includes by pressing the Video P.
UHD Blu-ray format should offer not Q Superb detail enhancement buttons to carry out most button on the remote—
just UHD-resolution video but also and noise reduction functions without requiring such as modes for content
high dynamic range (HDR) Q Excellent digital-to-analog you to visit the player’s captured with digital
capabilities, an extended color audio conversion surprisingly spartan cinema, conventional film,
gamut, and up to 16-bit color onscreen menus. One key, and regular HD video
encoding, among other advanced labeled YouTube, whisks cameras. Picture modes
features. Something to get excited
Minus you directly to the are further grouped into
about, right? Q As pricey as it is heavy BDP-88FD’s lone streaming Projector and Flat-panel
Now that I’ve dropped that tidbit, Q Slim feature set compared video option. (The player categories.
let me tell you about the Pioneer Elite with competition doesn’t have built-in Wi-Fi, I didn’t see much
BDP-88FD, a universal player that can so you’ll need to buy an difference when switching
handle Blu-ray, Blu-ray 3D, SACD, optional dongle to between the Pioneer’s PJ
DVD-Audio, regular DVDs, and CDs— first open the disc tray: In contrast to wirelessly stream those cat Film and Digital Cinema
just about everything except UHD cheap BD players, where the platter and swimming baby videos modes, though I did flip
Blu-ray. And it lists for $2,000. lurches out clumsily after you press you love—admit it.) Other buttons of regularly between them based on
Excited? No? Well, let’s see if we can Open, the Pioneer’s tray glides out note include Short Skip, which jumps which movie clip I was watching. The
work you up. smoothly and confidently like the 30 seconds forward, and Replay, player’s adjustment menu also
Pioneer’s latest, greatest BD player sunroof of a luxury car. The player has which jumps 10 seconds back. provides an extensive range of noise
has Marvell Qdeo processing and
3:2 HD 2:2 HD MA HD 3:2 SD 2:2 SD MA SD VIDEO LUMA CHROMA
can upscale video signals to 4K/60p
CLIPPING RESOLUTION RESOLUTION
resolution with 4:4:4/24-bit color.
PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS PASS
Along with the disc formats listed
above, it can play up to 192/24 FLAC
files from an attached USB drive or
stream them via DLNA.
The BDP-88FD has dual HDMI
outputs so you can send video and
audio signals out separately to a
display and a receiver/preamp.
There’s no multichannel analog
output, but the player does have a
fancy ESS Sabre32 DAC to feed its
balanced and RCA stereo analog
outputs.
At nearly 30 pounds, Pioneer’s
flagship is crazy heavy for a Blu-ray
player. That’s because it has a
double-layered chassis and a
tri-chamber interior (with separate
compartments for power supply,
digital processing, and audio circuits)
and is designed to minimize vibration
through sheer mass. The care put
into the construction of the BDP-
88FD is instantly apparent when you

• The 30-pounds, the BDP-88FD is elegant and


solidly built.
62 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
THE VERDICT BLU-RAY PLAYER
Pioneer Elite BDP-88FD Blu-ray Player Pioneer’s flagship 4K-upcon- PIONEER ELITE BDP-88FD BLU-RAY PLAYER
Performance
Features
verting universal disc player is PRICE: $2,000
Ergonomics something special, even if it’s late Pioneer • pioneerelectronics.com
Value to the party.

reduction and detail enhancement


settings, including a Super
Resolution slider that only works
the player has a Direct mode
(accessible by pressing a button on
the front panel or on the remote
SPECS Dimensions (WxHxD, Inches): 17.1 x 5.1 x 13.3 •
Weight (Pounds): 29.5 • Video Outputs: HDMI 2.0 (2) • Audio Out-
when video is being upscaled for 4K control), which turns off video and puts: Stereo balanced XLR, stereo RCA, coaxial digital, optical digital
output. Used sparingly, this proved digital audio outputs to eliminate any • Other: LAN, RS-232C, USB (2)
very effective with otherwise possible interference with analog
soft-looking film-based content, audio performance.
punching up detail without adding When I compared the BDP-88FD On “Wrapped Around Your Finger” appreciate Pioneer’s flagship, I find it
any ringing noise. with my circa-2005 Sony CD/SACD from the SACD of the Police’s Every hard to recommend buying a
player, the differences weren’t subtle. Breath You Take: The Classics, $2,000-listed universal player when
Performance The Pioneer’s sound had notably drummer Stewart Copeland’s crisp, the UHD Blu-ray format is due out in
Images scaled up to 4K by the greater presence and was less veiled. expressive fills sounded vivid, just a matter of months (we hope).
Pioneer looked uniformly great on Transients displayed superior clarity especially in counterpoint to the Even if I considered the Pioneer
the Sony projector. Its performance and snap, and imaging was wider song’s sleepy, dub-like pace. Layers of based solely on audio performance,
was certainly on par with that of my and less constrained than what I guitar, keyboards, and percussion in my music-listening habits have
Oppo BDP-105 player, which also heard from the Sony. the relatively expansive mix also had a largely migrated to computer and
features 4K upconversion with Listening to “Blues Dream” from clear sense of separation and depth. streaming audio. Like many other
Marvell Qdeo processing. The best Bill Frisell with Dave Holland and Elvin folks, I find that it’s a rare day when I
example of how well the BDP-88FD Jones, I noted how Frisell’s guitar Conclusion play an actual CD, let alone an SACD.
worked to squeeze every last drop of sounded wonderfully full and Pioneer’s BDP-88FD is an excellent Complicating the situation further
detail from Blu-rays came in an A/B fleshed-out, and the shimmer of universal player. Built like a brick is Oppo’s BDP-105D universal player,
test I performed during my recent Jones’s lightly brushed ride cymbal house. Equipped with outstanding which, at $1,299, is a considerably
review of the Sony. Switching came through with detail and air 4K video upconversion. Capable of better buy than the Pioneer. Similar to
between footage from The Amazing intact. Bass, too, was solid and well making CDs and SACDs sound the BDP-88FD, the Oppo provides 4K
Spider-Man on Blu-ray and the same defined. awesome. That said, as much as I video upconversion with Marvell
content in actual native 4K from a
Sony 4K Media Player, I found it
nearly impossible to detect any
differences while seated 8 feet away.
It was only when I moved my face
close up to the screen that I could
see the detail advantage provided
by the actual 4K source.
Pioneer also positions the
BDP-88FD as an audiophile CD/
SACD player, outfitting it with a
balanced stereo output instead of a
multichannel analog one. To that end,

Qdeo processing. But it adds all of


the following: Darbee Visual
Presence technology, dual HDMI
inputs (so other sources in your
system can take advantage of the
player’s high-quality upscaling/
processing), 7.1-channel analog
outputs, a USB Asynchronous DAC
input, and a headphone amp output
that takes advantage of the ESS
Sabre32 DAC. Oh, and it has Netflix,
Vudu, and Pandora plus a Roku-ready
MHL input for additional audio/video
streaming content.
Pioneer or Oppo? Or just wait for
those UHD Blu-ray players to arrive
later this year? I know what I’d do, but
if you’re set on a universal player that
simply provides superior upcon-
verted 4K video and killer CD/SACD
playback, Pioneer’s BDP-88FD won’t
disappoint.

soundandvision.com 63
Escapes BY Kim Wilson
PHOTOS Plinio Rangel

THIS HIGH-END DIY HOME THEATER RISES


ABOVE PANAMA CITY

The Sky’s the Limit

64 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


LUXURIOUS WOODS
This theater’s
electronics, BG Radia
in-wall speakers, and
Digital Projection
Titan projector are all
housed in their own
luxurious custom
wood enclosures,
which match the
room’s warm
decorative trim.

Located in a 10,000-square-foot apartment


that comprises the entire 52nd floor of The
Point condominiums in Panama City, Pana-
ma, this 26 x 16 x 10-foot home theater
adheres to the recommended proportions for well-
balanced acoustics and good sound distribution.
Real estate developer and longtime home theater buff
Octavio Vallarino designed his own dream theater. Picture
quality was so important to him, he refused to limit the
budget in this one area. The Digital Projection Titan 330
projector is paired with a Schneider Cine Digitar Ana-
morph 1.33X M lens and a Stewart StudioTek 100 screen.
Vallarino chose BG Radia in-wall speakers due to their
detailed and transparent sound. JL Audio F-113 subwoof-
ers were chosen for their ability to reach extreme low fre-
quencies; they also blended perfectly with the in-wall
speakers. Other gear includes a Bryston SP-3 surround
processor, Krell and Adcom power amps, and an Oppo
BDP-105 Blu-ray player.
Vallarino worked closely with Chris Huston of Rives
Audio with respect to the design of the sound isolation and
acoustics. Richard Bird, also from Rives, handled the room
calibration. While optimum sound reproduction was the
primary goal, it was also imperative to ensure complete
isolation from the apartment’s floor and ceiling. For
improved sound diffusion, two ceiling coves were created
by constructing soffits around the room with a center cross
member. The room includes a total of 12 wood cloud diffu-
sion panels and four RealAcoustix FAST panels. Installa-
tion of the HVAC system was equally critical to sound
reproduction in an effort to prevent an increase in the
noise floor. Optimum airflow, temperature, and humidity
control are critically important in Panama’s tropical envi-
ronment.
The final touch was leather theater seating from Cineak.
While Vallarino didn’t do all the work by hand, he thor-
oughly researched and supervised all phases and aspects of
the theater’s design and construction. “My sons and daugh-
ters and eight grandchildren all enjoy this home theater,”
says Vallarino. “This is my passion and favorite pastime. I
watch a movie practically every day.”

Readers, we need your help!


Are you a do-it-yourselfer or
custom installer with a great
theater to share with our
readers? We’d love to hear from
you. Please send your stories
and photos to kimwilson@
DISAPPEARING ACT cewriter.com.
At the front of the theater, the
BG Radia le, right, and center
speakers and JL Audio F-113
subwoofers blend seamlessly
with the wall color. soundandvision.com 65
Entertainment
Reviews in High Definition

Reference
Excellent
Good
Poor
RATINGS

Fair
BLU-RAY PICTURE
3D-NESS
Gone Girl SOUND
EXTRAS

shadows. A slight loss of detail


during some panned shots is a
rather minor compromise, as is the
faint artificiality in a cloud of fine
sugar in one key scene.
As with his work on The Girl
with the Dragon Tattoo, sound
designer Ren Klyce has crafted a
subdued multichannel mix, this
time in DTS-HD Master Audio
7.1. This is largely a dialogue-
driven movie without a lot of
ostentation, as even the circum-
stances of the pivotal disappear-
ance are left to the imagination, to
lend further suspense. But the talk
is always clear, ambient effects are
deftly utilized with a healthy
restraint, while the musical score
by Oscar winners Trent Reznor
and Atticus Ross helps to enliven
Fox
long, slow stretches. This isn’t to
say that there are no standout

If You Seek Amy... moments: A nice hard thump on a


window provides a welcome sonic
jolt, and a crucial confrontation in
a master bathroom features the
Here’s a truth-pill for all of you single folk out there: with a script adapted by Gone Girl most realistic shower I’ve ever
Sometimes marriage can really suck. Don’t take my word novelist Gillian Flynn, masterfully heard in a film.
for it, though; instead, spend some time with the Dunnes, leads viewers down a path where Surprisingly, considering the
Nick and Amy (Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike). After a we think we’re finally beginning typical treatment of Fincher’s films
nigh-fairytale meeting and courtship, their to understand the facts of the case on Blu-ray, the bonus materials
seemingly idyllic life together develops and their deeper ramifications… here are few, but they are enjoyable.
cracks. The deterioration is expedited over but a sudden bombshell proves us His audio commentary is lively,
the years by family troubles that lead to dead wrong. The rest of the film is blunt, and informative on a wide
money troubles, and contempt and nothing that we expected it to be, range of topics. The beautifully
infidelity follow. For Amy, marriage is a and for very different reasons, produced companion book,
daily humiliation. For Nick, it’s a trap, one now we simply can’t look away. Amazing Amy: Tattle Tale—
from which he yearns to escape. Captured at 6K by frequent ostensibly a story for kids—ties
But only one person could have Fincher collaborator Jeff in slyly with the movie. There’s also
predicted the sudden disappearance of Cronenweth, the image has a a unique printed code for a Digital
Amy. Suspicions of foul play arise stunningly natural visual quality. HD copy of Gone Girl, redeem-
immediately, with Nick at the center, and BLU-RAY A series of gorgeous 2.4:1 pictures able at a host of online retailers
his life becomes a slow-motion train wreck. STUDIO: Fox, 2014 lures us into this deceptively including iTunes and UltraViolet
His predicament is made worse not only by ASPECT RATIO: 2.40:1 charming world, all the more partners.
AUDIO FORMAT:
the revelation of people’s worst nature amid DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 irresistible thanks to the effortless The subject matter is harsh stuff
the scandal but by the increasingly hostile LENGTH: 149 mins. abundance of texture throughout, in more ways than one, and it calls
media focus as the escalating search for MPAA RATING: R even the minute bumpiness of to mind that old joke: Marriage
Amy uncovers a string of unpleasant DIRECTOR: David Fincher paper. Facial nuances are plain to isn’t a word… it’s a sentence.
STARRING: Ben Affleck, Rosamund
realities. Director David Fincher, working Pike, Neil Patrick Harris see, impressively so in the inky OChris Chiarella

soundandvision.com Are you asking me if I killed my wife?”

66 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


FURY THE THEORY OF EVERYTHING
Sony Universal
IS IT WRONG TO ROOT FOR ABOUT TIME
THE BAD GUYS?
As World War II is nearing an end in Europe, a Sherman 1963, Cambridge University. Defying medical wisdom
tank is dispatched to a crucial crossroads in order to cut which gave him, at age 21, only two years to live after
off a battalion of German soldiers trying to regroup with being diagnosed with the Lou Gehrig’s Disease, Stephen
their comrades for one last push against the Allies. In Hawking stretches his lifetime out to take on two other
command of the American force is a battle-hardened army sergeant great challenges: to write a brief history of time and, with a single
nicknamed Wardaddy (Brad Pitt), who has promised his crew he’ll get eloquent equation, to produce a theory of everything.
them home alive, but when the taskforce is attacked on the way to the Director James Marsh’s film is a romantic battle between science and
rally point, he has a difficult decision to make—press on and defend the religion, between a physicist and a medieval poetry scholar, black holes
position or go back for reinforcements? He should have chosen the and the heavens. As Hawking puts it, he belongs to “a religion for intelli-
latter because when they finally reach the crossroads, they discover they gent atheists” because “I have a slight problem with the whole celestial
are outnumbered, outgunned, and unless things go perfectly, War- dictator premise.” Space-time singularity, tracing back to when the
daddy’s men won’t see the conclusion of the war. universe was born, is at the heart of Hawking’s PhD thesis; then he sets
I sat down with high expectations for this movie due to the trailers about disproving it, showing that the universe has no boundaries.
and was initially very disappointed. The main characters are about as Meanwhile, his disease progressively strips the use of all muscles, not
unlikable a group as you’ll ever meet, and while I realize that writer/ affecting his brain but gradually stealing his ability to express his ideas.
director David Ayer was attempting to say the war made them this way, The strikingly composed widescreen images block parts of the
he went a bit too far; by the end of the first act, I was rooting for the screen, isolating Hawking as his disease imprisons him. Contrast is
majority of the tank crew to take a bullet. This was a real turnoff, excellent, with inky-black dinner jackets, bright-white dresses, a
although as more time went by, I started to get more into the movie. mixture of vibrant colors, autumnal hues, and restrained but rich
Thankfully, it improved immensely in the second act, and I found it pastels, all solid. Exteriors have plentiful depth, and everything is
worthy of my time. insanely detailed. Thin stripes in corduroys are visible as are hair
Sony mastered the film in 4K, and the resulting 1080p presentation is strands, freckles, and grain in wooden walls.
breathtakingly good. While the color palette is heavily dominated in At the point of his connecting the birth of the universe with black
cold grays and isn’t necessarily as pretty to look at as a garden landscape holes, violently rhythmical strings stream from the surrounds with the
demo loop, the detail in the image is mesmerizing. Facial pores are rest of the orchestra in the front channels, building from a slow start as
lifelike and revealing, along with the stitching in the war-torn fabrics. Hawking works on his formulas to a crescendo as he makes his
There are a few scenes where the primaries breakthrough and immediately afterwards
burst to life, especially in the second act takes his first fall. Natural-sounding
when the crew receives a much-needed atmospherics are mixed with an almost
break from the hostilities. imperceptible ever-present ticking clock,
Not to be outshined is the masterful suggesting time and life slipping away.
audio track, which starts out quiet and Dialogue from Cambridge upper-class
reserved, followed up by frenetic battles voices is always clear.
with bullets and tank shells whizzing and Commentary by Marsh is insightful and
booming through the soundfield. The final educational, pointing out the film language
act will surely be used as a demo showpiece and meaning he tried to get across visually.
as the men do everything they can to stop Ten minutes of interesting deleted scenes
the advancement of the German battalion. BLU-RAY BLU-RAY come with Marsh explaining why such
Supplements include four behind-the- STUDIO: Sony, 2014 STUDIO: Universal, 2014 surprisingly good moments were cut even
scenes featurettes that take a closer look at ASPECT RATIO: 2.39:1 ASPECT RATIO: 2.40:1 though they add to the film. A featurette on
AUDIO FORMAT: DTS-HD Master AUDIO: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
the production, especially the use of the Audio 5.1 LENGTH: 123 mins. actor Eddie Redmayne tells of his learning
Sherman tank as the focal point of the story, LENGTH: 135 mins. MPAA RATING: PG-13 to play Hawking in various stages of
along with some deleted/extended scenes MPAA RATING: R DIRECTOR: James Marsh physical decline and showing that disability
and a photo gallery.ODavid Vaughn DIRECTOR: David Ayer STARRING: Eddie Redmayne, can be no handicap.OJosef Krebs
STARRING: Brad Pitt, Shia LaBeouf, Felicity Jones, Emily Watson,
Logan Lerman Charlie Cox

soundandvision.com 67
ENTERTAINMENT MOVIES

LUCY DON’T LOOK NOW


Universal Criterion Collection
BETTER LIVING THROUGH DEATH AND BAD OMENS IN
CHEMISTRY VENICE
In films like La Femme Nikita, The Fifth Element, and The Don’t Look Now is a weirdly captivating creep-show of a
Messenger, director Luc Besson presents the mysterious movie: dark, vaguely Gothic, crudely energetic, occasion-
transformation of unthinking, undeveloped, unambitious ally ridiculous—in short, it resembles a lot of other films
girls into educated, sophisticated, strong females. He also directed by Nicolas Roeg in the ’70s (Performance, Walk-
includes large dollops of action, striking visuals, and sound that deliver about, The Man Who Fell to Earth, Bad Timing). This one’s about an
boffo home theater. artistic couple, living (inexplicably) in a huge house on a huge estate,
Box-office smash Lucy is based on two concepts: that humans are whose daughter drowns in a nearby pond; the couple takes solace in
more concerned with having than being, and that evolution can take us Venice, where he has a job restoring an old church; she meets two old
beyond these limitations. Besson enters the mind of ditzy young Lucy sisters, one of whom—the blind one—sees the spirit of the daughter,
through rapid editing of images. When a Chinese gang kidnaps Lucy and many other hobgoblins, too; meanwhile, it turns out that the
and surgically implants a packet of a new synthesized drug in her husband has a bit of a sixth sense as well; trouble, chaos, and the cruel
intestine to smuggle, it breaks open, releasing into her bloodstream. hand of fate ensue. Donald Sutherland and Julie Christie are all in as the
From then, the editing only gets more manic as her cerebral capacity grieving couple: fully engaging, alluringly attractive, and hinting at
expands from the normal 10 percent to 20 and so on. This airhead gains more complex depths to their characters than the script ever does. They
the ability to fight like James Bond, then levitate objects, read minds, also frolic with convincing tenderness and passion in what may be the
and finally evolve in consciousness, Matrix style, to perceive the longest, most erotic sex scene ever to feature two Hollywood movie
universe at work. stars. All the acting is persuasive, except for the little girl and her
The bright widescreen compositions in this ace transfer puts Lucy at brother, at the beginning, who look as if they’re waiting for their cues.
screen center, the many close-ups revealing natural skintones, pores, Anthony Richmond, Roeg’s frequent D.P., films Venice as you (or at
and freckles. There’s plentiful detail throughout, with weave to wool and least I) have never seen it: grim, foreboding, nearly empty on the brink
texture to textiles. Deep blacks of bad-guy suits are set off by bright of winter—the gray flipside of the otherworldly carnival that it often
white shirts and the rich, vibrant colors of red Chinese décor. evokes. The colors are deliberately muted, the better to bring out the
The surrounds really kick in after 30 minutes, when Lucy’s brain blazing reds when they appear as the prelude to disaster: blood, spilled
starts to change and action begins to erupt in a highly immersive printer’s ink, the occasional hat and schoolbook, the red raincoat worn
soundtrack. Deep rumbling, tension-inducing electronica music and by the daughter at the beginning and by another diminutive creature
effects, and the wide-ranging score by Eric Serra are well separated into near the end. It’s not eye candy, nor is it meant to be.
all channels. There are few effect pans but In any case, Criterion Collection
lots of trippy noises floating effectively all captures the effects to a T. Earlier DVDs, by
around. The resonating brittle explosion of Warner Bros. and Paramount, were
a gun going off next to your head is speckled with artifacts and color-coding
followed by booming reports all around in problems. Not this one: It’s been a while
mass shoot-outs. When Professor Morgan since I saw this in a theater, but my
Freeman lectures on the theory behind memory tells me Criterion gets the goods.
brain evolution and Lucy expounds on the The sound, mastered from the original
philosophy of expanded existence, every 35mm audio track, is also crisp, clear, and
word is clear… if you can follow. dynamic; the music plays a moody part in
The only extras are two featurettes. One, this film, and the disc gets it right. The extra
limp, has directors and stars discussing the BLU-RAY BLU-RAY features are, alas, among the studio’s
production against clips and behind-the- STUDIO: Universal, 2014 STUDIO: Criterion Collection, 1973 drabbest: Except for interesting, delightful
scenes footage; the other, interesting, has ASPECT RATIO: 2.40:1 ASPECT RATIO: 1.85:1 reminiscences by Sutherland and Christie,
AUDIO: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 AUDIO FORMAT: Linear PCM 1.0
neuroscientists theorizing about cerebral LENGTH: 89 mins. LENGTH: 110 mins. they consist mainly of one cast or crew
capacity. Heady stuff.OJosef Krebs MPAA RATING: R MPAA RATING: R member after another, going on about how
DIRECTOR: Luc Besson DIRECTOR: Nicolas Roeg awesome the others were.OFred Kaplan
STARRING: Scarlett Johansson, STARRING: Julie Christie, Donald
Morgan Freeman, Min-sik Choi Sutherland, Hilary Mason

soundandvision.com
68 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
ENTERTAINMENT MOVIES

JOHN WICK THE JUDGE


Lionsgate Warner Bros.
ALL STYLE, NO SUBSTANCE HOOSIER DADDY?

Action films come in various flavors: Some are more Uber-lawyer Hank Palmer (Robert Downey Jr.) has it all:
story-driven, others less so. John Wick is clearly on the a lucrative career defending crooked millionaires, a
low end of this scale, with no plot to speak of, instead masterpiece home in suburban Chicago… and a
relegating itself to a 100-minute nonstop shoot-out, a dysfunctional family he hasn’t seen for 20 years. When
movie where taking a breath is as impossible as taking the film his mother dies, Hank returns to rural Indiana to attend the funeral and
seriously. Playing unapologetically to a testosterone-addled, teenaged grudgingly console his father (Robert Duvall), a stoic judge who had
male demographic, the film is furious and explosive on the one hand, long ago thrown the book at him, sentencing his son to four years in
yet flat and characterless on the other. But if pure adrenaline-infused reformatory. When the judge is involved in a hit-and-run accident,
action is what you seek, John Wick may be right up your alley. Just don’t Hank must mount a defense, despite his father’s seeming desire to be
expect it to make any sense. found guilty. Along the way, we uncover not only the truths surround-
John Wick is a very dark movie, not only because of its subject matter, ing the accident, but the Palmers’ toxic family history as well. There’s
but also in terms of its cinematography. It makes for a good challenge to also a rekindled romance between Hank and his childhood sweetheart
reproduce these dark images adequately on home video, and the (Vera Farmiga), the only individual who has flourished in this Hoosier
Blu-ray does an admirable job. Blacks are incredibly deep in the backwater.
high-definition transfer, giving the image remarkable visual depth, Cinematographer Janusz Kaminski explains The Judge’s metaphor of
without ever breaking up in darker areas of the 1.85:1 frame, and reluctant revelations through stark contrast of light and shadow, and
without losing all-important shadow detail. Much of the movie takes both ends of the spectrum are gloriously portrayed. Whites possess a
place in seedy, neon-lit locales and gaudy, pulsating nightclub settings, purity and depth, while blacks are rich and powerful, and the fine
allowing the Blu-ray format to fully flex its muscles, pumped with rich gradations from mere shading to total darkness are lovingly rendered.
hues and vibrant colors, while also ensuring natural-looking fleshtones Mid-level contrast is squashed (a conscious choice), and colors,
in daylight scenes. especially during courtroom scenes, are intentionally muted, sometimes
The brutal stylistic choices the filmmakers made in terms of story becoming nearly monochromatic. Fleshtones are realistic, and fine
and visualization are also carried over into the sound department, details—fabrics, Downey’s skin, and the hodgepodge of Duvall’s hair
where viewers are assaulted with a Dolby TrueHD 7.1 audio track, and scalp—are irreproachably resolute. Despite noticeable edge
which is also encoded in the new Dolby Atmos format. The Atmos mix enhancement, this is a fine transfer.
has the benefit that it is not strictly limited to discrete channels but The Judge’s soundtrack is unspectacular: the highest complement one
instead creates a magnificent three-dimen- can pay. Those who value nuance over
sional soundfield where even the subtlest brute force will find much to love here. The
spatial placements come through without dialogue track is clean, focused, and
the traditional channel confines. This unfailingly articulate. There’s a dearth of
presentation truly gives you the sense that deep bass, but your subwoofers will, when
you’re immersed in all of the excitement, necessary, thunder with punch and
with ambient sounds, special effects, and authority. Thomas Newman’s evocative
the music enveloping you as you watch the score is perfectly blended, and subtle
film. An incredible frequency response and atmospheric cues—courtroom murmur,
super-modern bass extension make this restaurant patrons, and the sounds of
audio track scream for vengeance, just like nature—flirt and flutter among the
the titular character does. BLU-RAY BLU-RAY surrounds to excellent effect.
Lionsgate’s release also offers a few bonus STUDIO: Lionsgate, 2014 STUDIO: Warner Bros., 2014 Fans of The Judge will revel in the
materials, such as a commentary track and ASPECT RATIO: 1.85:1 ASPECT RATIO: 2.40:1 abundance of extras. The Judge ends with
AUDIO FORMAT: Dolby TrueHD 7.1 AUDIO FORMAT: DTS-HD Master
a series of featurettes that take a look at the with Dolby Atmos Audio 5.1 almost as many questions as it begins but
production with behind-the-scenes footage LENGTH: 101 mins. LENGTH: 141 mins. the title, closing scene and Dobkin’s
and interview clips.OGuido Henkel MPAA RATING: R MPAA RATING: R commentary provide answers.
DIRECTOR: Chad Stahelski DIRECTOR: David Dobkin OAnthony Chiarella
STARRING: Keanu Reeves, Willem STARRING: Robert Downey Jr.,
Dafoe, Dean Winters Robert Duvall, Vera Farmiga

soundandvision.com
70 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
The New Dayton Audio MA1260 Whole House Audio Amplifier
• 12 channels (6 stereo zones) in one convenient enclosure
• Efficient Class D design delivers superior sound quality
• Listen to any two sources in every room independently
• Bridgeable channel outputs provide additional power on demand
• Installer-friendly setup and connections
Distributed By:
For additional information about how much more and less Dayton Audio’s 725 Pleasant Valley Dr.
Springboro, OH 45066
MA1260 amplifier can bring to your whole-house audio system, 1-800-338-0531
visit parts-express.com/svm. Installer/contractor inquiries welcome.
ENTERTAINMENT MUSIC

HAND. CANNOT. ERASE.


STEVEN WILSON
for Hand. Cannot. Erase. was smart and deceptively simple,
as he told me back in February: “The main starting point for
me was, ‘Let’s do something completely different.’ ” One
thing Wilson chose to do was to approach this material from
a female perspective. The underlying story line of H.C.E. is
based on a woman who died alone in England in 2003 and
whose body was not found until two years later. How does
someone like Joyce Carol Vincent, who clearly participated
in the general social fabric and professional domains, fall off
the map in our seemingly perpetually connected world?
That underlying sense of uneasiness is palpable all through-
out the album.
Wilson’s relatively untapped pop sensibilities come to the
forefront with the treatment he gives his vocals on both “3
Years Older” and the title track—they’re lighter and airier,
and properly centered with minimal effects. “Perfect Life”
features dead-center narration from Katherine Jenkins
before Wilson’s shimmery repetition of the phrase “we’ve got
the perfect life” moves into the front right channel before
Courtesy of kScope

fading back in the mix as the band instrumentation moves


to the fore. That track bleeds into “Routine,” where Wilson’s
leads mesh quite nicely with Israeli chanteuse Ninet Tayeb,
whose vocals float dreamily across the front channels before
caressing your ears from the rear, supplemented by a
Could there be an artist under more pressure to put forth brilliant, plaintive piano figure. It’s a bit of a false lull, as the song explodes in all
original music in surround sound than Steven Wilson? For all intents corners immediately after that.
and purposes, Wilson is the poster boy for the 5.1 audio universe—in There are plenty of all-channel-assaultive jams to be had here. “Home
fact, no one else comes close. Wilson has also long been the go-to Invasion” commences with an insistent metallic groove, as Marco
surround remix-master for special-edition catalog reissues-cum- Minnemann’s crisp hi-hat punctuates Adam Holzman’s rear-channel
revitalizations for the likes of Yes, King Crimson, XTC, ELP, Tears for organ riffage. Wilson’s dark-dream fuzzed-out vocals buttress rear-
Fears, Simple Minds, Hawkwind, and Gentle Giant—and, rest assured, channel razor-slide guitar from Guthrie Govan, setting the table for the
even more Wilson-helmed 5.1 releases are forthcoming from many of direct transition into “Regret #9,” which culminates in Govan’s soaring
these and other artists. And then there’s his own body of solo surround solo and Wilson strumming (yes) a banjo at its close.
work, as well as what he’s realized in 5.1 for other bands he’s been a part And then comes the full-on “Ancestral,” which commences with a
of—including Porcupine Tree, Blackfield, Bass Communion, and Storm buried, marginally distorted Wilson vocal countered by Theo Travis’
Corrosion. flute and Tayeb’s wailings, just ever-so-slightly reminiscent of Clare
Ever since he began focusing on his solo career in 2009, Wilson has Torry’s seductive runs on Pink Floyd’s “The Great Gig in the Sky.” The
continued to up the 5.1 ante rather than repeat past glories and familiar tempo changes gears at will, moving from prime headbanging territory
mixing patterns. That said, how could he possibly top the nonstop to a Zappaesque xylophone and kick-drum passage before resuming at
all-channel excellence of his triumphant 2013 release, The Raven That full throttle. This is textbook for how to
Refused to Sing (and Other compose dramatic shifts, retain theme
Stories)? For one thing, I resonance, and then bring it all full circle.
personally consider Raven’s The H.C.E. circle truly closes with the
lead track, the uber-intense beautiful arrangement for “Ascendant
“Luminol,” as my 5.1 Here On…,” featuring a bed of angelic
benchmark, and I use it as my young male vocals courtesy The Cardinal
surround litmus every time Vaughan Memorial School Choir, which
I’m evaluating and/or delicately moves from the rear channels to
auditioning new gear. Where the front and back again, cleansing H.C.E.’s
could Wilson possibly go BLU-RAY uneasiness with a hopeful ambiance.
next? LABEL: kScope When you’re at the top of the summit,
That question is answered AUDIO FORMATS: 96-kHz/24- one can easily succumb to the weight of
bit DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1,
quite heartily by his 96-kHz/24-bit LPCM 5.1,
having to continually outdo prior
just-released fourth solo 96-kHz/24-bit LPCM Stereo achievements. Not Steven Wilson. His push
effort, Hand. Cannot. Erase., NUMBER OF TRACKS: 29 to go beyond the boundaries of surround
Photo by Lasse Hoile

which, while available in a LENGTH: 3:14:34 (2:44:56 music, sound and achieve something new and
29:38 studio documentary)
variety of formats, is best PRODUCER: Steven Wilson
aurally exciting with every release Cannot.
experienced in 96/24 on ENGINEERS: Steve Orchard, Be. Denied.OMike Meler
Blu-ray. Wilson’s manifesto Laurence Anslow, Brendan Dekora,
Steve Price, Charlie Dodd, Joseph
E-Shine, Daniel Anglister
soundandvision.com
72 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com
Instant Information
for Our Readers...
PAGE# MANUFACTURERS PAGE# MANUFACTURERS
Made To Order
25. . . Arcam Limited
+44(0) 1223203200
arcam.co.uk
61. . . Harbor Freight
. . . . . Tools
(800) 432-2567
harborfreight.com
TV LIFTS
C4 . . . Audio Plus
. . . . . Services 71. . . HSU
(800) 663-9352 (800) 554-0150
audioplusservices.com hsuresearch.com

51. . . Audioengine 13. . . Needle Doctor


audioengineusa.com (800) 229-0644
needledoctor.com
73. . . AV Science
(877) 823-4452 71. . . NuPrime Audio
nuprimeaudio.com Smooth and Quiet
7. . . . BDI
(800) 428-2881 37. . . Oppo Digital,
bdiusa.com . . . . . Inc.
(650) 961-1118
41. . . Bello
oppodigital.com
. . . . . International
. . . . . Corp. C3 . . . Polk Audio
(732) 972-1333 (410) 764-5275
bello.com polkaudio.com

71. . . Celsus Sound 15. . . ReVox


celsus-sound.com ReVox
Made in the USA!
(519) 745-1158
14. . . Cinema Shop tcgroup.tc/ReVox
(866) 243-1001
cinemashop.com 23. . . Salamander
. . . . . Designs
12. . . Crutchfield
(800) 350-6859
(800) 555-8347
crutchfield.com 69. . . Sonus Faber
sonusfaber.com
C2-3,5 Definitive

SHOWCASE
. . . . . Technology 27. . . SVS
(410) 363-7148 (877) 626-5623
definitivetech.com svsound.com Conceal ANY TV up to 65
Optional Swivel Action
73. . . Diamond Case 15. . . Tannoy Advertise in our
. . . . . Designs tannoy.com
Showcase Classified
5 YEAR WARRANTY!
(800) 616-5354
49. . . WireWorld
diamondcase.com
. . . . . Cable section today! Perfect for a home theater,
45. . . Emotiva Audio . . . . . Technology
the foot of a bed, or
. . . . . Corporation (954) 474-4464 as a room divider.
wireworldcable.com Contact
(877) 366-8324
emotiva.com
57. . . ZVOX Audio Laura LoVecchio www.diamondcase.com
8,9, . GoldenEar
10,11 Technology
(866) FOR-ZVOX
zvoxaudio.com
(718) 745-5025  
(410) 998-9134
goldenear.com
or
laura_lovecchio@sbcglobal.net

soundandvision.com
Information listed in this index is done so as a courtesy. Publisher is not liable for incorrect information
or excluded listings. Advertisers should contact their sales representative to correct or update listing.
PREMIERE
DESIGN

OLED
Obsession

LG 65EG9600 4K Ultra HD OLED TV LG • (800) 243-0000 • lg.com

2015 is shaping up to be the Year of the Ultra HD as the remarkable, the set weighs only 44 pounds (total shipping weight with
balance begins to shift from everyday HDTVs to 4K/Ultra the stand and everything is a reasonable 71 pounds).
HDTVs with their higher-than-HD 3840x2160 pixel To bolster OLED’s inherent contrast benefits, LG uses a four-
count. The latest projections from the Consumer Elec- pixel “WRGB” layout that adds a white subpixel to the traditional
tronics Association show UHD shipments growing exponentially over red, green, and blue to boost light output and “render a wider range
the next few years, jumping from 1.3 million sets in 2014 to 4 million of more accurate colors.” (Another benefit of WRGB is that it
this year and tripling again to 13 million in 2017. Before long, UHD will makes it easier to mass-produce TVs at larger screen sizes, which
become as commonplace as HD. might, in part, explain LG’s dedication to OLED.) The 9600 is com-
One of the finest UHD specimens to hit the market of late is LG’s patible with HDCP 2.2 copy protection, supports HEVC and VP9
65-inch 65EG9600 ($9,000), one of seven 4K OLED models previewed codecs for streaming UHD content, and comes with two pair of
at CES this past January. The introduction of several UHD models was a passive 3D glasses.
momentous occasion for fans of OLED as it confirmed LG’s commit- Beyond the promise of a stunning picture—something we’re anx-
ment to a category that (at least for now) has been shunned by Samsung ious to confirm with a hands-on review—sound is not an after-
and other top-tier TV players. (We’ll see how things shake out down the thought on this TV: It’s equipped with a speaker system designed by
road.) Harman/Kardon, a company that knows a thing or two about sound.
The first thing you notice when you lay eyes on the 9600 is how imag- TV smarts and connectivity are handled by LG’s webOS 2.0 platform,
es stretch to the very edge of its frameless screen. More impressive is which is said to facilitate an intuitive and easy-to-navigate experience
how skinny the screen is—about a quarter of an inch at its thinnest with quick transitions between online streaming and broadcast or
point. LG calls the ultra-modern design “Art Slim” and indeed, it is cable channels. If you happen to get bored, you can always talk to the
striking in an artful kind of way. Even diehard enthusiasts who abhor TV using the Magic Remote’s voice control feature. With any luck, it
curved screens will find themselves seduced by this sexy thing. Equally will listen.—Bob Ankosko

Sound & Vision (ISSN 1537-5838) (USPS 504-850) June 2015, Vol. 80, No. 5. COPYRIGHT 2015 BY TEN: The Enthusiast Network Magazines, LLC; Published 10 times a year (January, February/March, April, May, June, July/
August, September, October, November, December) by TEN: The Enthusiast Network, LLC., 261 Madison Avenue, 6th Floor, New York, NY 10016-2303. Periodicals postage paid at New York, NY and additional mailing
offices. Single copy price is $5.99. Subscriptions: U.S., APO, FPO, and U.S. Possessions $23.94 for 10 issues. Canadian orders add $10.00 per year and international orders add $20.00 per year (for surface mail postage).
Payment in advance, U.S. funds only. POSTMASTER: Send all UAA to CFS. (See DMM 707.4.12.5); NON-POSTAL AND MILITARY FACILITIES: send address corrections to Sound & Vision, P.O. Box 420235, Palm Coast, FL
32142-0235. Mailing Lists: Occasionally, our subscriber list is made available to reputable firms offering goods and services we believe would be of interest to our readers. If you prefer to be excluded, please send your
current address label and a note requesting to be excluded from these promotions to TEN: The Enthusiast Network, LLC., 831 S. Douglas St., El Segundo, CA 90245, An: Privacy Coordinator. Subscription Service: Should
you wish to change your address or order new subscriptions, you can e-mail soundandvision@emailcustomerservice.com, call (800) 264-9872 (international calls: 386-447-6383), or write to: Sound & Vision, P.O. Box 420235,
Palm Coast, FL 32142-0235.

74 JUNE 2015 soundandvision.com


HIGH PERFORMANCE
WIRELESS AMPLIFIER

®
The First Great-Sounding Wireless Music System
7KH3RON2PQL$KLJKSHUIRUPDQFHDPSOLðHUHQDEOHV\RXto
easily stream over Wi-Fi your favorite music services, Internet
UDGLRDQGPXVLFOLEUDULHVWR\RXUH[LVWLQJFRPSRQHQWVSHDNHUV
$OORI\RXUPXVLFDQ\ZKHUHLQ\RXUKRPH

polkaudio.com/omni
3RON$XGLRLVD'(,+ROGLQJV,QF&RPSDQ\3RONLVDUHJLVWHUHGWUDGHPDUNRI3RON$XGLR,QF3
INTRODUCING THE CX SERIES Cambridge Audio’s totally new CX series is set to revolutionise

CX SERIES
entertainment in the digital age. The CX series is a range of high-
performance hi-fi and home theatre components offering a unique
combination of class-leading sound, advanced networking capabilities,
large color displays and exceptional build quality and design.

CXA60
STEREO AMPLIFIER

CXA80
STEREO AMPLIFIER

CXR120
AV RECEIVER

CXR200
AV RECEIVER

CXN
NETWORK PLAYER

CXC
CD TRANSPORT

WWW.CAMBRIDGEAUDIO.COM

www.audioplusservices.com www.facebook.com/audioplusservices www.plurison.com www.facebook.com/Plurison

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi