Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/235687528
CITATIONS READS
5 1,576
4 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Chemical Analysis of Sinnasivappu Maathirai, Lingam based siddha Herbo mineral drug. View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Emmanuel Christy Jeyaseelan on 05 June 2014.
Abstract
The aim of this study is to examine the antibacterial activity of sequentially extracted hexane, dichloromethane
(DCM), ethyl acetate, ethanol, methanol and water extracts of fruit of Emblica officinalis, rind of Punica
granatum and rhizome of Curcuma longa at various concentrations against Bacillus subtilis, Pseudomonas
aeruginosa, Staphylococcus aureus and Escherichia coli by agar well diffusion method. The phytochemical
analysis of each solvent extract was also carried out. Results were subjected to one-way analysis of variance
(ANOVA) and followed by Least Significant Difference (LSD) test. This study revealed that the ethanol extract
of P. granatum has significant (P<0.05) effect on all test pathogens except P.aeruginosa, which was highly
inhibited by ethyl acetate extract of E. officinalis. Dose response study demonstrated that the ethanol and
methanol extracts of all test plants, ethyl acetate extracts of E. officinalis and P. granatum, and aqueous extracts
of E. officinalis and C.longa were able to inhibit the test bacteria at concentration ranging from 0.5mg/100 µl to
10.0mg/100 µl. Phytochemical analysis revealed that ethyl acetate extract of E. officinalis has tannins, alkaloids,
flavonoids, saponins, cardiac glycoside and terpenoids while none of the phytochemicals were present in hexane
extracts of all test plants and DCM extract of P. granatum. Other test samples have at least one of the
phytochemicals tested. This study revealed that the sequential extraction of plant materials, in the initial step of
drug discovery, would be more effective than single solvent extraction. In order to address the novel
antibacterial agents, the active extracts of the present study could be subjected to next step of purification and
bioassay.
antibiotic on E. coli (Table 2). Inhibitory effect of et al., 2001). The present study carried out with similar
streptomycin on B. subtilis, and P. aeruginosa was assay method using 1.0 mg / 100μl of ethanol extract of
found to be higher than all other test samples. But 10.0 same plant showed better inhibitory effect against
mg / 100µl of methanol extract of P. granatum, above three bacteria including E. coli (Table 3). In
methanol and ethyl acetate extracts of E. officinalis another investigation made by Panthi et al. (2006), it
showed almost equal effect on S. aureus compared to was found that methanol extract of E. officinalis (single
standard antibiotic (50.0 µg / 100µl) used in this study. solvent extract) had the ability to inhibit the growth of
S. aureus but failed to inhibit the growth of P.
Dose response study of solvent extracts of aeruginosa and E. coli at the concentration of 100.0
test plants mg/100μl by disc diffusion method. Interestingly the
present study with lesser concentration (10.0mg/100μl)
Dose response study performed with the various clearly demonstrated that methanol extract of E.
solvent extracts of test plants revealed that these offcinalis inhibited the growth of all test bacteria
samples have antibacterial activity in concentration including P. aeruginosa and E. coli (Table 2). In
dependent manner on all test pathogens (Table 3, 4 and another investigation it has been reported that direct
5 [Supplementary data]). Minimum Inhibitory ethanol extract (1:1) of pericarp (rind) of P. granatum
Concentration (MIC) value for most of the solvent was able to inhibit the growth of P. aeruginosa and B.
extracts ranged from 0.5mg/100 µl to 10.0mg/100 µl. subtilis but was unable to inhibit the growth of S.
The result also revealed that the concentration of 0.1 aureus and E. coli by paper disc method (Nascimento
mg / 100µl or less (data not shown) had no effect on et al., 2000). However, in the present study ethanol
test pathogens. extract of P. granatum inhibited the growth of all above
bacteria including S. aureus and E. coli even at the low
Phytochemical screening concentration (Table 4). Chandarana et al., (2004)
reported that the disc diffusion assay of heated and
Phytochemical analysis revealed that ethyl acetate unheated aqueous extract of C. longa showed inhibitory
extract of E. officinalis has tannins, alkaloids, effect on E. coli and B. subtilis but did not inhibit the
flavonoids, saponins, cardiac glycoside and terpenoids growth of S. aureus. In the present study sequentially
while none of the phytochemical was present in hexane extracted aqueous extract of C. longa inhibited the
extracts of all test plants and DCM extract of P. growth of above bacteria including S. aureus at low test
granatum. Other test samples have at least one of the concentration (Table 5) These vast differences of
phytochemical tested (Table 6 [Supplementary data]). inhibitory effect between past studies and the present
study might be due to either method of extraction or
assay or sometimes both. It is obvious that the number
DISCUSSION of compounds present in the ethanol, methanol and
aqueous extracts in the present study are lesser than the
In this study comparatively most of the polar solvent
alcohol, methanol and aqueous extracts used in the
extracts revealed better activity than low polar solvent
former cases (single solvent extraction) where
extracts (Table 2). The higher inhibitory effect of polar
antagonistic effect of chemical compounds might have
solvent extracts is due to the more solubility of active
played a role to minimize the antibacterial effect.
components in polar solvents and the polarity of
Because compounds present in crude mixture may
solvents may play an important role in the inhibitory
interfere with the action of the other (Adwan et al.,
effect of plant extracts (Parekh et al., 2006). Yield
2008). Therefore the efficacy of an antibacterial effect
percentage of different solvent extracts obtained from
of a plant material depends not only on the type of
sequential extraction clearly revealed that the
solvent, type of assay and the dose used but also on the
compounds dissolved in polar solvents are
method of extraction of plant materials.
quantitatively higher than compounds dissolved in low
polar solvents (Table 1). Though, yield of ethanol
An earlier study (Voravuthikunchai et al., 2005)
extract of C. longa was greater than ethanol extract of E.
revealed that 2.5 mg/disc of ethanol and aqueous
officinalis the antibacterial effect of ethanol extract of E.
extracts of P. granatum, which were obtained by the
officinalis was higher than C. longa (Table 2). It reveals
successive extraction using chloroform, ethanol and
that the amount of yield does not always influence in
boiling water, exhibited inhibitory effect on different
inhibiting the growth of pathogen but the active
strains of E. coli by disc diffusion method but the
ingredients found in the extract play major role.
chloroform extract failed to inhibit the growth of all the
tested strains of E. coli where as in present study 1
In an earlier study it was reported that the alcohol
mg/100 μl of ethanol and methanol extract of P.
extract of E. officinalis (single solvent extract) had
granatum showed inhibitory effect on E. coli but
inhibitory effect on B. subtilis and S. aureus but did not
aqueous extract did not show any effect (Table 4). In
inhibit the growth of E. coli at the concentration of
the present study, after the ethanol extraction the
15.0mg / 100 μl by agar well diffusion method (Ahmad
residue was continuously extracted with methanol and
then by water. Therefore, the absence of the inhibitory aqueous extraction. Therefore, it further reveals that
effect of aqueous extract may be due to the absence of sequential extraction of plant material could be useful
the active constituents which would have been as far as further purification is concerned. In an earlier
extracted out in methanol. study it was pointed out that curcumin present in the C.
longa is soluble in the organic solvent but insoluble in
Negi et al. (2003) reported that the ethyl acetate extract water however the aqueous extract showed antibacterial
of rind of P. granatum obtained by sequential effect on test bacteria (Chandarana et al., 2005). In the
extraction using ethyl acetate, acetone, methanol, and present study also the aqueous extract showed
aqueous did not show any considerable effect on B. antibacterial effect on test bacteria, and phytochemical
subtilis, S. aureus, P. aeruginosa and E. coli but in the analysis demonstrated that the aqueous extract of C.
present study the ethyl acetate extract showed longa possessed saponins. Therefore, further
considerable effect on all these pathogens (Table 4). purification and characterization of aqueous extract of
Although the sequential extraction method was C. longa may provide other novel active compounds.
employed in both cases, previous was begun with ethyl
acetate and the later was begun with hexane and then
followed by DCM before using ethyl acetate. Therefore CONCLUSION
the failure of inhibitory effect of ethyl acetate extract in
the previous case may be due to the interference of In vitro antibacterial activity of different solvent
compounds that might have been extracted out in the extracts of E. officinalis, P. granatum and C. longa
later case. Hence, it is suggested that sequential revealed that the ethyl acetate, ethanol, methanol and
extraction could be more efficient when it is carried out aqueous extracts of E. officinalis, ethanol and methanol
with more number of solvents in an increasing polarity extract of P. granatum and aqueous extract of C. longa
order. exhibited higher inhibitory effect against tested bacteria.
Phytochemical analysis of above extracts revealed the
Alkaloids present in the fruit of E. officinalis were presence of tannins, alkaloids, flavonoids, saponins,
found to be active against B. subtilis and S. aureus cardiac glycoside and terpenoids. Therefore, these
(Rahman et al., 2009) and in another investigation it active extracts could be subjected to further isolation
was found that monomeric flavonoids was the active and purification of active compounds to discover novel
constituents of fruit of E. officinalis (Ahmad and Beg, lead antibacterial agents.
2001). But in the present study ethyl acetate, ethanol
and methanol extracts of E. officinalis have both
alkaloids and flavonoids (Table 6) and also these Acknowledgement
extracts exhibited good antibacterial activity against all The authors wish to thank the National Science Foundation,
test bacteria (Table 2). In another instance Ahmad and Sri Lanka for providing financial assistance (Grant No:
Beg (2001) reported that alcoholic extract of P. RG/2006/HS/05) for this work.
granatum possess alkaloids, flavonoids, glycoside and
tannins but not saponins. Also, phytochemical
screening of ethanol extract of pericarp (rind) of P. References
granatum revealed the presence of flavonoids and
tannins (Voravuthikunchai et al, 2005). In the present Adwan GM, Abu-shanab BA, et al. (2008) In vitro activity of certain
drugs in combination with plant extracts against Staphylococcus
study the tannins, alkaloids, cardiac glycoside and aureus infections. Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences, 24(4): 541-
saponins were present in the ethanol extract of P. 544.
granatum but flavonoids were found in ethyl acetate
extract. The reason for the absence of flavonoids in the Ahmad I and Beg AZ (2001) Antimicrobial and phytochemical
studies on 45 Indian medicinal plants against multi-drug resistant
ethanol extract of the present study might have been human pathogens. Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 74: 113-123.
due to the fact that it was already extracted out in the
ethyl acetate extract (Table 6). Therefore, in order to Chandarana H, Baluja S, et al. (2005) Comparison of antibacterial
find the active constituent(s) responsible for the activities of selected species of Zingiberaceae family and some
synthetic compounds. Turkish Journal of Biology, 29: 83-97.
antibacterial effect, further purification and bioassays
should be done. Duraipandiyan V, Ayyanar M, et al. (2006) Antimicrobial activity of
some ethnomedicinal plants used by Paliyar tribe from Tamil Nadu,
In previous studies (Hashemi et al., 2008; Okigbo et al., India. BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 6(35).
2009) it was demonstrated that the direct aqueous Giridharan P, Somasundaram ST, et al. (2002) Novel substituted
extract of C. longa possessed flavonoids, terpenoids, methylenedioxy lignan suppresses proliferation of cancer cells by
tannins and saponins but in the present study aqueous inhibiting telomerase and activation of c-myc and caspases leading to
extract possessed saponin only (Table 6). The absence apoptosis. British Journal of Cancer, 87: 98-105.
of flavonoids, terpenoids and tannins in the present Gul N, Mujahid TY, et al. (2004) Studies on the antibacterial effect
study might be due to the separation of these of different fraction of Curcuma longa against urinary tract infection
phytochemicals into other solvents used before the isolates. Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 7(12): 2055-2060.
Nair R, Kalariya T, et al. (2005) Antibacterial activity of some Reddy MK, Gupta SK, et al. (2007) Antioxidant, antimalarial and
selected Indian medicinal flora. Turkish Journal of Biology, 29: 41-47. antibacterial activities of tannin rich fraction, ellagitannins and
phenolic acids from Punica granatum L. Planta med., 73: 461- 467.
Nascimento GGF, Locatelli J, et al. (2000) Antibacterial activities of
plants extracts and Phytochemicals on antibiotic resistant bacteria. Sofowora AE (1993) Medicinal Plants and Traditional Medicine in
Brazilian Journal of Microbiology, 31: 247-256. Africa. 2nd edition. Spectrum Books, Ibadan, Nigeria. pp: 289.
Negi PS and Jeyaprakasha GK (2003) Antioxidant and antibacterial Stockwell C (1998) Nature’s Pharmacy. Century Hutchinson Ltd.
activities of Punica grantum peel extracts. Journal of food Science, London, United Kingdom.
68(4): 1473-1477.
Trease GE and Evans WC (1989) Pharmacognsy. 11th edition.
Okigbo RN, Anuagasi CL, et al. (2009) Potential inhibitory effects of Brailliar Tiridel Can. Macmillian Publishers, pp: 257.
some African tuberous plant extracts on Escherichia coli,
Staphylococcus aureus and Candida albicans. International Journal Valgas C, Machado S, et al. (2007) Screening methods to determine
of intergrative biology, 6(2): 91-98. antibacterial of natural products. Brazilian Journal of Microbilogy,
38: 369-380.
Panthi MP and Chaudhary RP (2006) Antibacterial activity of some
selected folklore medicinal plants from west Nepal. Scientific world, Voravuthikunchai SP, Sririrak T, et al. (2005) Inhibitory effect of
4(4): 16-21. active compounds from Punica granatum pericarp on verocytotoxin
production by enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli 0157:H7. Journal
Parekh J and Chanda S (2006) In-vitro antimicrobial activities of of Health Science, 51(5): 590-596.
extracts of Launaea procumbens Roxb. (Labiateae), Vitis vinifera L.