Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 437

c

Constitutional
Law c
Keyed to: c
Chemerinsky c
Second Edition c
c
M 
   c

 c
c c
c ccccccc
½cc
ë  

c
  cc
  c   c c  c  c
cc
  c ½c 
c  c
c 
  c c  c    c c c   c
 c ccc

c  c c 
  c c    c  c  c    c  c  c c   c
 c
c  !c c   c    c  " c# c  c cc $ cc
  c c    c  c
c  c  c c   $ c c  c
c   c # c

%  $ c cc 
 ccc  c c  c c  c  c& cc   c
 c  c c ccc  c $  c c c   cc

c c  
c  c  c c 
  c  c   c  c c   c
   c#c c
c ccc cc c c   ccc c c
'c  c c   c   c c c c c c c   c   c c  c
   ( c    cc
 cc  c c$ c) c c c c
  c
cc  c ) c
c
c cc $ c ccccc  c c & c  c cc c cc
 c cc c  c  c c c  cc cc ccc c  c
$ c c
c  cc 
c cc cc*½+,-+-½-.c/c½.0cc
)ccc
cccccc
,cÀ   À c
Table of Contents 
    
À   À  
!   "  #
  $% &
'( À )
!   * +
 ( ,"-.
  /0 1
0  /,, 
%2 !, ë  3  
!     4
    &
5 0   0  "  ! ,  (, -- 
 6
  !" )
 $   2  +
  , -(  $ "     .
!   ""  2 0 #1
7%  #
5    # 
  À"%#4
2   #&
3' !  #6
   $ 0   #+
À À #.
2   80 41
!   *04
   4 
 - 9/  "(  !  4#
$   ( !  44
""  ë0 4&
"( " 4)
3$   7  9$0 (4+
!   ë 4.
/%  &1
 ,À - !  &
*:   À0-À0-& 
3$ 0 ,  !  &#
2 À (  &4
!   $( :&6
!   À &+
/  0  ,3 %  !" ( ,0  &.
   / 0 2 6
0cÀ   À c
3 ;% !  6#
: !  64
  6&
!   7 66
  !  6)
ë% ë 6.
!   À )1
*:   À0À0)
 ,7    ) 
:(% 7: )#
 "  , )4
  À )&
   '   )6
;0  9   ))
!   À3'-  , !  ).
/"-  , !    ,3 ;%+1
$   ( !  +
" ,0  + 
/" " %0 -+#
""03:    0 +&
 'À - (      78 +)
!    </0'((+.
ë" 9À   0-   ,    .1
" " , .
3'  :0 .4
/" ,,     .&
5$" 8  0 '0 .6
$    .)
$" 9 2  - -ë -ë (" ,0 ,
,11
,2 9    0     9ë (" 
"" 1
 -   ,$   ,    ë :1 
9 - ëÀ-""  ,0 À%  ,3 
;%1#
7  7,/  , , (14
 0 ë ("  7 7  -1&
 , :16
 , ( 3   1+
9  - ,% -3 ;%1.
0  8%"1
-2 ,  ,3 / 0 ((   0
"" 
''( 2 ,À  
/ $  "  -   -""  ,À   ë (" ,
0 4
-cÀ   À c
 ,À   $  "  &
ë À%  ,À -/  6
À   !  )
$ %  7 -+
7 -ë -ë (" , ,  ,  3 = 0$ -
.
 "*     0 (,ë   1
( ë " (,"  
/  9 $,     7,>:,
, #
 - /"%  4
< " ë (" - ""  -ë (" ,3  ,
 % &
"  /  )
! 70  ,"   À , 
 ,"  +
$  7  2" "" ,À#1
( " ,3 "(   * ( #
5  8,  ?  8, 0  
$  ##
7 À  ,7" #4
0 <  @7  ?7    ,3 8      
$ %$00 < "( A#&
 :  #)
0 3   #.
ë $ 41
  0 
!    4
À   "4 
%  À ( 4#
   " 4&
   3 46
"0" "( !$&.1 $05 :-4)
$ (  4+
0   3$   74.
   * " &1
$0 " 8&
"  $    &#
7 /"0%0 &4
À $0 31)   &&
3  &)
  <7%  *&.
7" ;  % 6
 " À% 6#
7  "        6&
5"$  6+
0  $ 6.
cÀ   À c
$  3 ;%)
((0  *  )#
À  8 0)4
%   ?  ()&
/   " 7 )6
3  3 ;%))
/     )+
!      ).
/"  $ 8(,8%"-+1
7À/,3" - 2 +
 "À"     "( +#
" 709$  7  +6
 0   2(- *   9$0+)
   ( ++
!    3   .1
$    ("( À5(. 
    À.#
À    .4
   ( 3 ;% .&
$   .6
ë  ,0.)
::   ..
 <   -   000   1
 0  À%,, 14
7 $ 0,/ 0 1&
5>  1)
"     1+
!    " 7 : 1.
 '( 0  - 3 ;% 1
3 ;%    7 :  
!  ë (" ,0  À   
 ,  - '    $ 0  - #
ë  , 4
* "  !   &
$ 0 50 6
"   )
   0  +
7 7, .
/ 0 ë   1
À %  * "( 
 ,À   7  
"  "(  #
   " ,À       4
50 ,0 0  À ( 0ë (" ( &
7 7, 6
  <À %  07, )
*cÀ   À c
À%  7  .
7,,8%"    ë  #
"   # 
  -   #4
2  70  #&
2: 70  #+
   "  41
    4 
0 7  4#
!   50 44
2 0   46
8 8 4)
À  ((!   ,/"  0 4+
À À ( ,"  4.
 %  2 0 &
, /   & 
30  ""03:    &#
2"   &6
     &)
"  3% &+
   ë  &.
À   7,  "  À0 6
5" 0 ! ë  >  6#
B %   64
À  2 ë 66
À   ,  -8 6+
À  3  % 6.
'  2   )1
%  8%" ) 
2    )#
   7 )&
  /  )6
     ))
  0  ).
À    +
     + 
7  7 +#
: ë -À ë (,  +4
/ 0 2% 0 +6
$    '  ++
/    .
 :   . 
(  50 7,   .#
*"  ! ë  .4
7 "  .&
   "  .6
AcÀ   À c
7  2  .)
7   #11
!   * #1
À$7 $#1 
$    #1#
 (  ë  0 :#14
ë   /" #16
 ,"  $  #1)
ë   / 0 ë (,   #1+
2 0 *  #1
7, 0   #
2  $( :# 
 ë  ##
À   0 #4
C " " 
 "8,'( #&
 7 0  "-   "" "" #6
7  7  #)
 (  ,À  / #+
 ,   "    -# 
3" ,    # 
!   " $   -# #
3   ,À  ' 8 # 6
3 ;%" "(  !  # )
3  %   # .
 '  !  ##1
/ 7    ,3 ;%- 50 ,##
" /  "(ë (" 7 0%ë ###
 ,$ - B2, ë<4-$$##&
!   3   "( !##)
/ 50 7, 7  ##+
À   8  "" ##.
7%  "  $-#41
   #4
$ 0   ( 5 :> :#4 
 % !  #46
 % !  #4)
ë  !  #4+
 "  !  #4.
2 3 ;%#&1
/  ,#&
ë   !  #& 
7  0 8#&#
( %  3 "(  #&4
20 / #&&
5  ,-À #&6
   3 ;%#&)
XcÀ   À c
7    #&+
50 7%#&.
 !  #6 
    #6#
À  ,#64
3 ;%   #6&
 ,   ( #66
;0 " À   -#6.
 ,  (? À#)1
  2 0#)
  ,#) 
  "" ""  ,#)#
  "" ,,-   "" "" #)4
  "  $  !#)&
 , "  $  !#)6
50 7,"  50:   " -#)+
70  ;0 ë0 (#).
  2 9 (     "" ,3 ;%#+1
 " 0  #+
$"%  -  (,/0 #+ 
44$>"-   #+#
$    #+4
3 ;%" "(   #+)
2 : / #++
ë97  - 2 " 7  -#+.
  À0:   #.1
'7 0( #.
 7#. 
7% 5(( #.#
!   8?7 #.6
 '   #.)
7%  5 #.+
3' %À 2 " #..
 37%,7  7 411
0  "" , 80:41
   3   41 
      $?  41#
 ë (" ,  ,0 À  414
  41&
/ %0  "416
   41)
2  (%41+
$ "  ,%  0 41.
!   *%41
   ,*    - $ 4
%     ""   4 
cÀ   À c
%  $ 4#
 0  44
 À( 4&
%  ë À  (  "" ë 4)
7  ë 341#  4+
: ë  *"  4.
3 ,   " ,  (   , "- ' 
  4 1
7, 0  , !   ,/    " 4 
   !    4 
   <" 2 -$ 7 '2(,7 4 #
7  ,"  ë 4 4
À (   "(  À ""  ,  4 &
   À "( 4 6
7: 0  4 )
 $7 0   "" "" 4 +
À"  4 .
"3  ((   504#1
   4#
  *Dë4# 
C " " 
 04##
!    0 4#4
!   74#6
"( " ë  -ë (" ,"  ,8 0 "4#)
   5  4#+
, $%"7    , 4#.
$%  ë 441
 , 0   "  $  !2   0( 44 
$  5  44#
$ " *:"444
  0   5  , !   ,5044&
  (  ë  ë 446
0  5 44)
$  /  "44.
À   " 4&1
B " "" < 4&
½.cc
c
CHAPTER I. The Federal Judicial Power 
½½cÀ   À c
Àarbury v. Àadison 

Citation. &!@A#)@+1#A

Brief Fact Summary. /"À  @À  A- <,< "(( ,  
" @  " A=  , (  (  ë ," - 0 
0   "  ,,  ? @   ,,  A   , -" À -
%0   , "" 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ( " , !  @( " A 
     '    0    ( "  
" = -   ,    !   @ A-
"   0   0 

Facts. 7 ,  0,   ,,  -00  "  "(   
   , =   0 =0 ( ,0 "   
((    ,,   "   " -  80
, ë ," @ ë A-,4  =  , (  , ë -  
,"        ,    ,,  ? 0, , 
""  -0À  ? -         ,,  %,,   
(       , " À    , ""  
À   0""  ( " - >0" À    
"" 

Issue.  À    "" ," ( " E

Held. 3  " ,,= 

F     0 À  ? "" ,  ,"- ((" 
  " -À   0 "" 

F2  "(   ,, , (    À  ? 
"" - ( "   (    '    
  '    ,, ,   , ,"" 
 ,, , 0 " G(0   ( , -G
""   (((  "  -,    ( " 

F  ""     ,      0-


 @  A    " ,= "(  
( " 


Discussion.  "( ,À   À   ( 00  
     ,=  0     " ,
   -  ,"  ( " ,"0  
>(  , , ,  0 " 

½,c!   "  c


^nited States v. Emerson 

Citation. 46(( &.+@3ë ' ...A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , -"  "  @ë , A-"  "  
"  +!H. @0A@+A,( ,, "  0  0
  ë , 0       0    " " , 
!   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   " " ,  ,   0-
"   0  ( 

Facts. ë0   ( 0- 0  ( ë , ë ,  
 ,( ,, "   - ,+!H. @0A@+A
ë , "      -  0  0% ( "  
0    " " ,  

Issue. ë   " " ,  ,  0% ( 
" E

Held. ; "   

F '      (  @G  0 À- 0    
 ,,   GA  (  @G 0, ( ( % (
"   ,0 GA  ë , 3 ë 
, ' 0   (    >, -  -   
(( ,  (   

F   ,  0<"   , " 


( -    ,0  À ?   
  " " ,   (  - .-"0
   , " 

F  0  ( " ,  " "  7,
0   , ((  

F , 0 (     0 "( ,


0 , " 0    

F7  +!H. @0A@+A    ( (   
( 0,  " " 0  ( ,,0 -    
 


Discussion. !   "   "   "  , :0 " 0,
 (  0
@A( '-@A -@A

½0c!   "  c


-@ A     -@ A(     - 3 ë , ' 
  " ,   "  ((      

½-c  $% c


Silveira v. Lockyer 

Citation. # #1& @. 11 A-@   -&41!146@ 11#A

Brief Fact Summary.   (     >   ( -
0 0    ,,,     (   0 0   ? 
   G( - - , G,  ( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   " " , !   @ 
G GA 0 0( " 

Facts. ...-   ,,"  ( , 0-   ,
 / ( @ GGA-(( 0 "<"G  ( G  
 0     ?    G( - - , G,  (  
,, -   ,G  (G    ( 
G  (G@ G,, GA- 0  00,? " "     
 " " ,  

Issue. ë   ..." "     ,, ? " " 0 E

Held. 3  " " ,   0 0( 


, "   0:   (  ,  " " , 
   0(     -G ? 0 ?" - 
  " " ,  0  (  :  
," 0(  , " , (( -  =  " 
0 "  0G - G"  0 " G  
G  " 0( , "  ,  (   
      ("   G - G  0 G   ( G 
 " " 0? " ?0  0, ( ( " ,,    
" -  (    ( , 0(  ( !  
  , " " - ,    0 "    ,  
(      ( ,, " -  =  0   
((     -   ( - >( - % G 
(    - G  0 G  

F  " "  


G  0 À 0      ,
,  - 0, ( ( % ( " -  ,0 G 
"=     '  (       , 
 " "    0  -   "  
 , G"G ,    " , -(      
,  


½c  $% c
c
     0:   0, ,  , ( G " G
  ,G( GGG"    "   , ( 
G " G ,  " ,((   , ( 
G% ( G   0  

F   GIJ      0, , -  "( " 
 (  , ( "  -IJ " (    ,  
" "   %      '   , ,,    "  
( ( "  '   0 " -,   ,  0 " 
 ,    '  G -   ' 0 ( 0 
, " "  ((    0 "     
  G  " "      0  ,  ,<
      ,  0 "     " (  
 , 0 '   ( 0 ,"0   ,00, -   
-   , " " -   (   "
    " G -GIJ   , ,0  "   
, ,  " "       (  
  ,, ,   " , ( ( ?  ,  <<    0
(  ( G


Discussion.   ,,    0  ,  " " ,  
 "((  G(  ( ( ,"  ,,     (  0
 0,   " " G

½*c'( À c
Ex parte ÀcCardle 

Citation. )4!&16@+6+A

Brief Fact Summary. À -  ((    ,0 ,


  -(   ( " , !  @!  A,,
  ( À 0  À   @ A (   
 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 -  ( 0 !  ( " ? @( " A
((    , ,  ( - ,,   %=  À ?   
," ( " 

Facts. , 0  ,   0 ,  -,  ,, 
  À   À      ( 0
"  ,  "  (   (   , 7,0 -
0  -,-'" "  , !   @ A
7 ,  ( "   "  -0 (  ( 0( " 
((    , ,  ( 

Issue. ë  ,0  ( 0( " ((    ,    " 
= À ?  E

Held. ;   " ,,= 

F ((  = , ( "  ,   0  -
  ,  = G  ' (   
 0  0  "% G

Fë   :-  ( ,=   


Discussion.  ( <0  -0  (  = ,,  
( "        , À   
 - ( "   G  >  " , 
 0  -G      =   '"    ( " 


½Ac!   * c


^nited States v. Klein 

Citation. +1! +@+)A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -* @ ( A- 0  !  
," - %0"(  ,((  % 0  /  ( 
0 ,,,"(( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 00  ( " ((  = , 
,   -"   (  ,,   (   ,   , 
,   

Facts.  ( " , !  @( " A (  (
  ,, ,(,  ((    (   
( , ,((  "(  ," ,  0 "  (  
  -0 (    0( "       ",
: ((  0  ,  > ,,(   
 '(  " ,0@,0  A- ,0   
=    ,  (  (    =0" 00
   ," ,"  !  ((  -00    > 
 " ,  ,,= 

Issue.     >   '  ,0    ' ( 
 0  , !   @ AE

Held. 30" ,," 

F7  >0  "%  ( ,,0,,   


 =   " 0 ? = ,  ,0-0 
 "0= -  (  0 ,  ,  

F0 "(  (  (   >0  "    


       , !     
 (,,  7  0 , ,, , ( -0 
 "(      ?   


Discussion. !   *   ( ' (  0 = (   
"  (    (,(    !      
    ( ,0   "(0 '       0 
 = '    

½Xc ( ,"-c


Plaut v. Spendthrift Farm, Inc. 

Citation. &4! @..&A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,<  -@  A-   ë , <

 ( -( ,"@ ( A- H1,   '0 ,.#4@ 


A    " , 0, "  , 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 "  >  ,    (  , 
    ,=0" 

Facts. ..- ( " , !  @( " A   0
 H1@ A 1@ A@&A, "   0  ,  0 , 
 0     ,   , ( -0 "  
  ,  ,    0,-,    0 
 (     0 (   -     " 
  ( " ? 0   "(  " ( , 
 "  

Issue. À 0  >    (    ( =0" E

Held. 3((  0,," 

F0 " (    0 ,,    ( 0(( 


 - " "  >   " ( , =0"  
   

F=0" G       G   > ,,   


(  


Discussion.   @A0 0      (, 
= 0  (  -  >0    ,=0"  - ,"  ,
        (  

½c  /0c
Allen v. Wright 

Citation. 46+!)#)@.+4A

Brief Fact Summary.   , %(    0 0   
     @GGA- 00 ,,  ,'< ' "(   
 " (     ,    ?       ( 
 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   0 > (,, 0 "     
 ( , (,  , 

Facts.   , %(      - 00   0'< ' "(
   " (    -  "0   
 -  ,0 0,  ,  0 0   
 -  0  (  '( ,     ,  
 0 0, (   

Issue. ë  " 0    (  ,,   > " , 0E

Held. 3   " 

F 0 ,  0-  ë 8?@8?A G


  0  0 "   G  ,, 
0= ' 0  ,0" -    GIJ %(  
 0  0,' ' "(  " 
À G " -   ,,0    " 
 (    

F   0 ( "-  (  ?   0  


 0   '(    - ?   ,
  ," "        0'< ' "(   
(    >  "  0 (    "


Dissent.     @  A- 0-(   " 0'< ' "(
 ," (    -"%    "  '(   (  - 0 " 
  "(   >0 "0  "  (  "( 

Discussion. /   ? 0"      < " 0'< ' "(  
 ""     < "= (   0 
 0 '"( -    "% ( ,,    ,0

,.c0  /,,c


Singleton v. Wulff 

Citation. 4 +!16@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary. À (       -00À ?   
( 0À ( "  ,   G"   G  
 ,      " ( 0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ( 0<(  0 ((   
  (, 0   0      0,       
"    , (  00  

Facts. À (       - 0 (    
À < 0  (       ( " ,      0  
(      ( ," (      
( "   , 

Issue. ë (    0 0    ""   ,,   0 
"  %0  E

Held. ; ,((  0,," 

F 0>    (  


@A  (,,   = ,
@A     ((      0
>  , >          - (      
"(      , "(  

F   > - 0   ,( 0<(  0 


(( ,   (   0 (   ,,    
 0  ,,      (( , ,,  ( ,
    " "( "  ,,  (  00 " ,  - 0
  "  ,,      (( 


Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A     "  
       ,,  (  00 -     " 0  
"( " @ 0-( 0 (  ,    " ( 0 - "" 
" , "- A

,½c%2 !, ë  3 c


Elk Grove ^nified School Dist. v. Newdow 

Citation.  4 #1@ 114A

Brief Fact Summary. , -   -   ?   ,0 
 0 , 0 @ G 0 GA     ?    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. GIJ "(( , ,     " (,,
  0   , ," 0   (  ( , 
 "     ,,  (  -I   J    , 
(,,? "  0G

Facts.        -%2 !, ë @ G  GA-  
     ,  0   "0  ( -À 
3 @ G ( GA-    0 ((   ,  0 
  ( 0     0    G 2G   0 
,  ,  " " , !   @ 
G GA

F     (   0   ,, 0  
G ', G 3,((   , (-, 
 ( G  0? (  0 (  ,   0
   0  , 0 ?G80 &- 11 -  ( ? 
? " , ",      "  "( 
? " -À 70-G '   0  G, 
G I J   0 ( I 0 ? J 0   "% 
  I J   G ,   0 G 0   
  2  =    0 0     
 0 , 0 -  ,   2G ,(    
 G =0I  ( J,"0 0  " ( 
0  ? ', ?G 3  ,( ? 
,0  G3 0 "  (  0 - 
"   ? 0,   0  70? ( 
3 -?  ( -,  0 =  
0 " ,, 0 ?G


Issue. ë   (   0 0 E

Held. 3 ,0 G " ,3?     """   (,
  G G 2G00     0 .&4, > 
   00 (    "0-,  0:   0 
 ,  > "    =  0 0 "  ,"((0
   

,,c%2 !, ë  3 c


c
1c    0 (  >   (  00,    
  GIJ , ((     "   
      ","   G -GIJ    = , 
"   , , -( - 0   , 
   , !  G    ,  0: 
G"    ' (K I0J,   ,(     -
" -    G -G"0 ((( , 
,         0?  "  , "   (-?I
J    -" -       IJG7  
  6- 11    - ( "   " G (  
G?         0?G ? G
?( 0   ?G - -  : 
70G? '   0?G, (   G?"0 " ?
GÀ 0-   0    %0  

F -G "(( , ,     " (,, 


0   , ," 0   (  ( ,
  "     ,,  (  I  " J  
 , (,,? "  0/ >  ,"    
 ,,  " - (   , ,     
     0 > ,,   G 
-  ( -    ,,? ,0 %    0
G ', G -%  0


Concurrence. 0 /" > @G > GA-0 ë 8?@G
8?GA  " @G" GA =0" -   ( 
 0=   =  "= ? G  IJI,J (  0(( 
   0 "  ,  "G

Discussion.      0  "= ?   0    0(-
  0    ,,   

,0c!    c


^nited States v. Richardson 

Citation. 4+!66@.)4A

Brief Fact Summary.  - ,,< ( @,,A  0   0 
(  (0    0  0  @GGA,.4.   - 
.-)@ A, !   @ A-   "  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0   G0  : 0  G

Facts. ,,  0 -(0"(    ,  ,0  ,,0
,,    0      !  '( 

Issue.  '(    ,,     0 0   E

Held. 3((  0   " 

F ( " , !  @( " A((  <(0 
 (    -#. !+#@.6+A   '(  0-
(,," @A 0  "   '0 ( 0 @
-H+,  A@ A"  "  '   ( ,
 " '0 ( 0

F ( " 0 - ,,   ( ,= ,,  
",,     '( -   (  0  0  
,    ,   ?       


Dissent.     @ A0     ((( -  ,, 
 %0,   ",      0 " 

Discussion.  "=  0   ' (   0 (
(  ( ," 00  0  0 " 00 0  '(  

,-c   c


Flast v. Cohen 

Citation. #. !+#@.6+A

Brief Fact Summary.  (( -0 @((  A- 0 -"0 0
   '(  - %0 = '(  ,,  ,  0   ((  
"   '(        "  '   ,  
" " , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. '(  0 (((   (,, 0 
"   '0 ( 0 ,    "  '  
( , " '0 ( 0

Facts. 0 , -  ,  "    ,
.6&@ A-0-" -   =   0   ((   0 -
"0  '(        "  '   ,  
" " ,    " 0(   ((    
'(  

Issue.   ((       0 0  E

Held. ;    " 

F ( " , !  @( " A   0 ,  
 (,,@ A 0G(   %  " G,   '( 
 '- ( "   > "    (   % 

F ,  > "   '( "  0     ,
'    '0 ( 0 ,  '(  
   0      '(  
0  '(  0

F   > "   " 0( "  0 0  
  ( ,( (    ,,  0 
( 0  (    0  -H+,  


Dissent.   À @A0   > "     
"=     (   %  " 

Discussion.  ( "     <(0  '(  0


( 0 ,   0  : 0  

,c5 0   0  "  ! ,  (, -- c
†alley Forge Christian College v. Americans ^nited for the Separation of
Church and State, Inc., et al. 

Citation. 4&4!464@.+ A

Brief Fact Summary.   (  -"  ! ,  (, -


@ ( A- 0  '(    0  ë (" , 
/ , 0,!  ((   0  0       " 
 '   ,  " " , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. '(  0 (((   (,, 0 
"   '0 ( 0   "  '   ( , 
" '0 ( 0

Facts. !  ((   -5-H#- ,  -0 "  ( ,
 0 ((   00 !  !    (  "  
   ,.4.@ A- ë (" , --/ ,  ))<
 (    -5 0   0 @  A (    ,
, .1-111G'( " "  -G 000       "   
0,((  

Issue. ë   (   0 '(  0  E

Held. 3   " 7   (    "  : 
  ((   , - , , (0,  0  (   
 -#. !+#@.6+A- >00   '0 ( 0 

Dissent.   /"7 @7 A   , 0= (   "  
  ( 0"(0     ,,    ""0G  0 
(,,    ,  , "  "  G

Discussion.  0 ,  ? ",( 0"  - "= 0 
   0,((,   (    -   
  

,*c  !"c
Poe v. ^llman 

Citation. #6)!4.)@.6A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  - (  ( @((  A- 0
- %0  ,   ( 0  , (   
 0 0,"     ,   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (    ( ,  0    , 
    0   

Facts.   ( " ,     (    ( 0  
, (    0 0,"     ((   ( 
 ( 0      "(0     ,  -
(  ,  '(      "( 0  ( -  
  ,  , " , (   0 (   

Issue.   (   ?"( ,=  E

Held. 30" ,,"     "( , (      
 7  , -   ((   ,,  = ,,"   - 
        (  ,0 ,   

Dissent.   /"ë0 @ë0 A0  "   ,(  = 
,- G   , :    G >    %(  ,
      0   " 

Discussion. 0(        - ( " , !  
@( " A    0    (  3   - 
( "  "  (      ,  ( ,
=  

,Ac $   2 c


Abbott Laboratories v. Gardner 

Citation. #+)!#6@.6)A

Brief Fact Summary.     - $  @   A- 0  
=0"  .6 " "    -ë0- " @ A
 > ( (0",  ( G    " G, 0  
 ( "   ,   0

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ë  =0"  (((      ,,=
  -     ( ( ,      

Facts.  "   > (" ",   (  G    " G
@          , --/ , A (   , 0  
 , ((  "   0, 0( "   , 0
 00(,#)0",  @ ( 0" .1L, ? 
( (0 ((  A 0  - 00 ""   '     
 >0  ,     "   "   "   ( " 
 0 0

Issue.  ((   0( ,=  E

Held. ;    " 

F ( " , !  @( " A,  0 
(((   " - ( 0     (   0
    - ""  ((         >0 
  "     "   "  E

F ( "  ,  ( (   ( (0
=   "(   ( 0 "," 
00 ( , (0 "  -0 (  ,  , 
"%  0   "  ""   ((  
 ,  0


Discussion.  0  0  , $   (( (   3 
    , > @ ""        EA
     ,,=    

,Xc  , -(  $ "    c


Friends of the Earth, Incorporated v. Laidlaw Environmental Services 

Citation.  16.#@ 111A

Brief Fact Summary. ë , < ( -$ "    @ë , A-
    ,  ( 0,  "(  ,,   : 
   / "

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /  , 0    ,     


"-  ,     ,( 0  0  0  
      '(   

Facts. ë ,  3ë 0 "  "( ",,<


  -  ,-( @,,A- 0 ë ,   0"  
 0 " ,  / - 0:  0 ë , ë , 
0    "       "(  ( "
0   0 ..   ,  , , > 

Issue. ë , ?     ,0," E

Held. 3     " 

F "( 0"(  >  ,,    "( ,


   - ë ,   "  
  ,   -     ë ,   
      '(   , 

F   - ë ,   "    "( ,
   , 


Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A  " 
' (,     , , "%  " "(    0 
"( ,  -  ,  (   "   ,@   A
, "," ,0=     

,c!   ""  2 0 c


^nited States Parole Commission v. Geraghty 

Citation. 44&!#++@.+1A

Brief Fact Summary. 2 0 -,  " ,,< ( @,,A- 0 
0  ë , <  - !   "" @ë , A7   
   0 ,,     ,,,  (    
 "  0  ,( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  "    - , " ,,?   " 
" ,  ,,  

Facts. ,,    ( ,",  ( ,, 0  00
   ,  "" ?     2      
,,?  >  ,      ,,G,  (    
 "  0  ,   ( -G 0  "" =0" ,,,
 "  ,,    ,"(   ((  ,((   ( 0

Issue. À ?  ," ,      ((    


" (,,? (         E

Held. ;    "  (( , G(   % G > "  G  
   ,"(  ,= G   7%" 0  
"  (    (   %  0  ,  ,   
   > " À "( - -   , " (,, 
   ,",  (  ((( ,=  "

Discussion. , (   %  > "  ( G     ,"(  
,= -G    "    ,  " " "3- 
>      ,  ,  ,      
(  " "  ( "    -, " (,,(  
% -    G,"(  ,= -G, ,,   
((( - 0 , (,,?    (  

0.c7%  c
Baker v. Carr 

Citation. #6.!+6@.6 A

Brief Fact Summary. ((   0 - 00"((" ,   0  
  >  ,  " " 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (("  "      " " 
0 - 0  0   (  ,"(>   "  

Facts. (("  ,   0  2  , 5-H4,
 !   @ A- !  0   
  ( ,",0 "  ( " , !  @( " A
 0   0 ( (> -       
  -((   0    ((" , 0    > 
 ,  " " 

Issue.  (    0"((" " 0=   (


  E

Held. ;    " 

F ( -(("  0   0       0  


2  ,5-H4,   "  =   
           (  , 0 "  
     (,(    

F7%  - "  ((    0   >( ,
    0  (      0   ( "  
  >(  0     (  ," (
>  


Dissent.  0  -   '%, @%, A0  (> 
  (  ,"  >( " ( "   ,,     
  ,((" = (  (-  0  ( " 
 (  (   0=  0

Discussion. 7%    , ,   (0 ( " ? G (  - 
 G 0   ,  (  >:  (        
  0  : 

0½c5    c


†ieth v. Jubelier 

Citation. &4! 6)@ 114A

Brief Fact Summary.    ,"(     2   "  
  0  ,   ," "  , !   , (  @ 
G GA  0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    0(0  "  <=     GI
(    JK(  =  ,   " (
     0 " %   0KG

Facts.  ,,<((   " -5 -3" 5   @ 
G,,<((  GA- 0 "(     2   "     0
  ,   ," " ,   ,,<((  0   0
   (0  " 

Issue. /  ( "  (  Ië   


-4)+!1.@.+6AJ- E

F,-  (((  E


Held. ;   @GGA0, "= ,   Ië  

J (0  " 0"   =   - 0  
=  " ,(, ( " , !  ?@G( " 
GA0I 
J ( " I 
J   G(   
   =     "0      (0  "  
    G -    =      G=     
"0     ,=0(0  " 0"   " 0 $%0
 "- "  (0  " 0"  =   I 
J
 0   Gc

1c   G       G, :    ? 
(( ,  ,"I 
J0  = 
"0     - :   0=0 ((   
  G "  , ,   " ( ,,    <<
, ",,  ," (( I 
J  ((    
((  <<0 0    0         
Gc

c
0,c5    c
Dissent.     @G  GA,  0(   -G 
 (   (,  ,  =  , "
I((" J" "0    , G -      ,
  ((  , G"( "   ( ,  G  -
G   ?  <,((I 
JG-G ( ""  
,     0  " 0 G (( ,"    
ë  ? @G GA  /"7 ? @G7 GA 0( 

F    ( 0G,  G, <(  , 


 ?  (  ", (GIJ   I J
(  "I,  "0 0  " 0 0 ,J  % 
0    > ,"      >     
>  G (   " -   -GIJ ""  -
 -  %0        ,0"    
0   0  -   "  ((       -
     =  =0    ( G


Concurrence.    *   @G*   GA, (0 =0" 
 - G,  (   ,=  ,, " " (  
   ,      ,   "   0
 G -GIJ ,   =( ,"  "( , 
  "      0  0      G -
GIJ    " 0     % (   " 0 
 , /  "(0    - "(   ,,   , 
      , 0 ,   (("  " 
 " -,  0  G 0  G  ,G (( 
    (( " G

Discussion.    0     =0  "( "0   
 -?   GIJ  0   ,
0 - 0 0    %        -?   , 
  ,(   ?G

00c  À"%c


Powell v. ÀcCormack 

Citation. #.&!4+6@.6.A

Brief Fact Summary. ,  0     , (  @  A-  
  " "  ( ,,<  - @,,A,,  , "  
 (  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  G '""" G (   (


 =   

Facts. ë0 +.0 - ,,, 00   ( (   


 0  0     ", "" $ , 
    .10 -   %   (      (    
 -    % ," 2 ,3 ;%    
,,  - 00            
"  >,  '(   ,, (   , !  
 @ A

Issue. ë     '"""     "  >, 
, " "  E

Held. ;     " 

F ë ,  < (  -" "  ,0 0 ( % ,  
/À"%@ë ,  A-0     (   
 -H&,    "  >, , " "  (
,,0  ( " , !  @( " A0 -
 ,    ', ,"  " >, 
  ,  

F ( "     ,  ,"  ?  
 > <   , '( 


Discussion.       (    (      -( 
  ,      -    '  (  """ E
 - (   ' """  (   '  (  
"""     ,=  @ - ( "   "  (  , 
 A8       - ( " "  (   '" 0
 -     "   > "   ( , "   
 00>, , (  

0-c2   c


Goldwater v. Carter 

Citation. 444!..6@.).A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , -!    ""  @ë , A-  
   (, 0:0  ( ?  ( , ,,-! 
  7 2 @,,A-  - 00   "    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. D  ,(  (  =   

Facts. /  0:0  ( ?  ( ,- ë ,    !  
  ,,  -00    " ,   -   ? 
((    >    

Issue.   (  =   E

Held. 3    " , "    "= (

Dissent.   /"7 @7 A-0=0" -   0  


  ( -      0 - 0 ,    -  
=   (>   , 7%  -#6.!+6@.6 A

Concurrence.   /" > @ > A-0-         
(-  , =   (-        0,
   ,,,   "  "  (( ,,,    - " 
  , (  

F  $   @ A-0-      ( ,  
( , -      % ,,- (   
  "( 


Discussion.    ,"= (-2    (    ! 
 ( " ? @( " A(> = (  (  

0c3' !  c


Nixon v. ^nited States 

Citation. &16! 4@..#A

Brief Fact Summary.    -3'@  A-," ,  =0 - %  ( " 
, !  @( " A       C- ((  
"( " -  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. "( "   =   

Facts.    -,"  ,0 , !  ë ,  
ë ,À  ((-    ( , 0 ,  0=  
   ,  0," (         
 0"( " -    %  C-   "" 
       "  "" (  , (  ""    
  "     <   "( ,   3'
((  -00 C   "( "  -H#-6, 
!   @ A

Issue. ë     0             " E

Held. 3-"( "   =   

F "( "  ,    -G        
  "( "  KG "= 0  (  0  
         "  ((( " ,  

F "= , 0 "( "     % 7
  0    -=  0   "  ?
 ", %   


Concurrence.   7 / @/ A-0-,   (  
=  ,"( "    ,    G G    
   ,,     0

F  ë  @ A-0=0" -      
=   -    "    "( "      
@ 0-  - "  =  0G 0 -G   0 
   - A


Discussion.  "=   0  0"( "   =   
 0"  (  ,  %    (,

0*c3' !  c


(  - "  " ,  , G  G "( "  

0Acc
c
CHAPTER II. The Federal Legislative Power 
0XcÀ À c
ÀcCulloch v. Àaryland 

Citation. )!@4/ A# @+.A

Brief Fact Summary.   ,À    À  , 7%, ! 
 ,<( " ,  '   0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  !   @ A   ( " , 
!    "  , 

Facts.  7%, !            ,   
 ,À -((  7%- "(  ((0' À  
, 7%/  7%?   -À- , (  '-     ,( " 

Issue. À    " ,   E

Held. 3   " 

F   ,    ( -   "   ," 
 ( -     -   ( " , !  

F 0 " , !  ,"  "  (   - 
   , '  (   "  (    0 
 !G(% , (' , 0 G8  G0  G
, (       

FG$     0" -    ( ,  -"  
 ((( - ( (  - 
(  -       (,  -  G

FGIJ(   "( ( (  KIJ(   -,   


,,  -   "(   (    
(  KI/J    (0  '  -   ( " " 
-     ( " G


Discussion. À À   " "(  ,0   (   
!    ,,    ,,  0  ( ,0 
=  , 0   @G$     0" KGA

0c2   80 c


Gibbons v. Ogden 

Citation. !@./ A@+ 4A

Brief Fact Summary.   ,3 ;%   '    (    "  
3 ;%  $ 0     ,,< ( -80 
@,,A-   ë , <(( -2  @ë , A-,( 0"( 0,  
  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ""  (    0 ( 

Facts. 3 ;%   '    "     $ 0 -
  ,,(  ,       3 ;% : -3 
  / ë ,  0( 0"( 0,     -,,  ë , 0 
   ,      ,   G    0 -G  
0(   ,  -  

Issue.    ( ,0 ?(   ""    ( E

Held. 3   " 

F,,0 0 (   ""    " 


,,
  0 0- 0 ,0 -  0

F -  0    0  0- , 0""  ( 
  ,,   , @       ((  
, 0 -   A' 0 0" -0 
     0  0       -
 0  ""        


Discussion. 2   80   ,   0  ( , ""    ,
  À  @À A ,,, ""       
 ( 00 ?(    

-.c!   *0c


^nited States v. E. C. Knight Co. 

Citation. &6!@+.&A

Brief Fact Summary. " 0 ,0"( @" A( , ,  
 (- ,,   "(:0 0 ,0 !   "(  
 >      ,  0 " , 000"   , 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. '  , ""   "    ( ( 
      

Facts.  ((  <ë ,  -*0-"   0 ,  @ë ,  A-
   ( , ,   (-  0"  
  ,  0",  !   0 "  0    0
  - ë ,  "   (    ""   , 
0"0    , 0 - ,0 ("0 
  -+.1

Issue. ë  ,0    (  0   ""   E

Held. ; ((  =0" ,,"  "=      
", ,0 , (  ( " , !  @( " 
A   0?  ""      ", -  - 
    ( ,0   ""   

Dissent.   À @A- 0-0 ,0     


 0    ""  -"       "      
""  

Discussion.   "      ",   ""   
  ,   , ""  ( %   ( "   +.1
.#)

-½c   c


Carter v. Carter Coal Co. 

Citation. .+! #+@.#6A

Brief Fact Summary.  (  0    , 7" 
  ,.#&@ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G""  G   >  ,G  , (( , G

Facts.   0  :   " "0  ("     
""  "0 (   -  ,   00"0  "( ,
   -""""'""(  - ,   , ( 

Issue. ë    0    ""   E

Held. ; 0" ,," 

F ( " , !  @( " A ""   
 (-( -  - '0 ,"" 7  ,- 
 %     G""  G

F " -  ,,    ""  0  0   " 
 0 "    ""   ,, (   
"   


Discussion.    % (  ,3 ë  0      '"( ,
  , ""    , .#)

-,c - 9/  "(  !  c


Houston, East & West Railway Company v. ^nited States 

Citation. #4!#4 @.4A

Brief Fact Summary.  0 "  0 0  "(  ' -  
"0   ,,     , ("  ," (," "( 
 ' 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 " ,,   ""  -     ,
     ""       (  ,   ""  " 
     "    

Facts.  (-$  =   ,    '   '   00
"" , (" ,0   '    00, (" ,"
ë        ""  ""  0 - 00 
 ,,    0  "(    ""  

Issue. À  ,  0 "  0    00   ""      " 
   00    ""  E

Held. ; ,((  0,," 

F ( " , !  @( " A0     
       ,,- 0 "  0     
""     00 

F ( "  0 0 "  0    ""  ,
             ""  


Discussion.  0 "  "     0  - .+!
#+@.#6A$   - .&!4.&@.#&A-    0   
    (:, ""   0 ( 

-0c$   ( !  c


A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corporation v. ^nited States 

Citation. .&!4.&@.#&A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , -$   (@ë , A-


0  3 ;% -     G$   -G 0  
(     >0   00-41% %-"""0 -
"0 (   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ""          ,   ""  
(

Facts. 3 ;%   0  ( "%  !  3  < '(  ,
  ( 3 ;%" ,"    (   0    
( À , ,  " 3     3 ;% 
ë , ? - 0  (  - 0( ,"  3 ;% 
(    7%  (           3 ;%
 ë ,   (    

Issue. ë  ""   0 0  (  0  ë , ?    E

Held. 30"    "  !  ( " @( " A
   (   ((     -  ë , (   ( 
    (   ,   "(- (   
   ""    , - ""    0 0  (  0 
 ( 

Discussion.  ( " "%  0    ,.6L, ( 
"03 ;%  ,",   , ë , ( 0
      -   "  "( ""  
 = (  , .#)

--c""  ë0 c


Hammer v. Dagenhart 

Citation. 4)! &@.+A

Brief Fact Summary. ,  0  ,, "  - %0 =
, " ,,0   (      (" ,0 ( 
 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 ?(   ""    "  ( 
(  ,     " " , !   @ A

Facts. 0 ( (      (,", 


0 (  , -  (   0 4
%    0 ,46%,"  ( , % 
, , "( -"  <  4-   46< 0   '
,    - %0 = , " ,   ' 00 ?  
 ""   

Issue. 0     ("  0 "(0  
", ,0 E

Held. 3

F ( " , !  @( " A,     
""      0", À, 0 "  
"    ,       (, 0  
   ""  (  0     0 0 ( 
",   

F ( " 0   " " ,    
(    0  '  (  
", - ,,    "   " "   0 
 


Dissent.   8 /  " @" A 0

F 0   (  -,    , ""   ,,  - 
>  0 ?(  0    ""  

F ,    ,,  -    ,  0 ",   
(   -   0  (", 0     -
    = 0 "   ,0 3  0, 
   "  -GIJ,  (   ( , 
,  (0 -


-c""  ë0 c
c
" "  "      ,   ,,  
"  -   "     ,,  -  
  ( 0  


Discussion.   ? 0"    "  "=   - ""  
      

-*c"( " c
Champion v. Ames 

Citation. ++!# @.1#A

Brief Fact Summary. ((   '(   00   ,,
0 ( 0 0 ,  %      

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0      0  (,0    
""     0 ,,   ,, ,   

Facts. ë ,    +.&":0     (" ,  


%   " "  ë , 0     0 ? ""  
(  -  "   (, %      ""  

Issue. À 0  0  (" ,  %  ,"    E

Held. ; ((  =0" ,," 0  ( 0   ,  %  -


   ("     

Discussion.  ( " , !  ?  "( " (( 
  "= (""  ë0 - 4)! &@.+A3  
 ":   (" ,  %  -  0,(  0   
"= ""     00    ( 0 ? "(
 0     @"" - ( "  ( 0    
 (,( ,   00   ""  (  A @
(A   '( ,,      0    0 "    
( " (  " ' 0 ""  ( > 0" 0 
' =   , 0   

-Ac3$   7  9$0 (c


National Labor Relations Board v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. 

Citation. #1!@.#)A

Brief Fact Summary.  3$   7@G3$7GA 0 0  
ë , - 9$0@ë , A-, 000, ( - ( , - 
 0 ,  "(   ,,

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 ?(  0 ""   (  -   
    ,,    ""    (  , ""  ( 

Facts. ë ,   ,0 ( ,  !   0"  
0 --"  ((  -   " 0 - ,  -   
(   (        0  3$7(    3
$   ,.#&@A- 00ë ,  " 0 " "  
 0     0 , 0  "( ?  
,<0: 

Issue. À 0  0  (  0      ""   
( E

Held. ;    " 

F,     G       ""  -G
0    '((  " ,  ,,    
""  (- ( " , !  @( " A
 ë , ?     G,<,0G      
(    ""   ,,    ""  

Fë , ?  ,  "( ?0 ,<0:  ""  , 
, - ,,    ""    -0   
(   0   "( ?   ,<0: 


Dissent.   " À  @À  A- 0-0       > 
( ",     (  ,0  0    ""  

Discussion.     , 0 ,  ( 0 '(0""  ( ,
 !  0   ..1 0 "= -"  
  ,,     ""   ( 0  0

-Xc!   ë c


^nited States v. Darby 

Citation. # !11@.4A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , < ( -ë @ë , A-    
$  @ A, 0"""0 "'"" "  
 ( 0    ("0      '  ,
 ""  ( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 "  0      0     
       ""   -  " " G    "G

Facts.  ë ,   00  "    2 0 ë ,  " 


( 0 ((,"   ((    ë ,   ,
0    (  -0"""0 "'"" 
% %

Issue. À 0 (   "( " ,%  (00 ,   ""  
    0  E

Held. ; ((  0   " 

F""  ë0 - 4)! &@.+A  ( ,    G ( 
," ((  (    ( , ""  
 KG

F'  ,0  0      ((( "  
  0"  , 00   ""  

FG I J" "     "     
   G ( " , !  @( " A    
,  " " , !   @ A 
,"," ,  1 
 " "  0,    
    


Discussion. !   ë  (    ,  , 
""   (,"   0    0   
(  -!   ë  ,    , ""  (  (  0,
( 0 

-c/%  c


Wickard v. Filburn 

Citation. #)!@.4 A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  - @((  A-(   ,(  
 "(  ( : ,00  ' , "    
ë (" ,0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 "  0    ,   (,"   
""  -,   ,,    ""  

Facts. ((    M( , ","8  "%-( - 00  
 0  "(,     ((   (,  -  " 
 , ,(  %-  " "% ,,"  "(- % ( 
 , ,0 0  0= " ,.#+@A- 
((  ? .4 "   "  , 1    (   
,.41- - (  # -    #.    ,"  '  0  
  (   ",4.     -N)

Issue. À 0  0 (        ""   E

Held. ; ((  0   " 

F0  "     ,(   "(- "(  ,


 ""  - %0   ",    0 
   00       -  ", 0 
/     00 0 @,    0  G,(  
 "(GA-     "  0, ,,    
""  

F ( " , !  @( " A% 0   ,, 
,  0 ," "    00     ""  -     
 00 0 ,,"  G "   G"  0, ,,  
 , ""  


Discussion. /%    "   0   '  , ""  ( 
 0:   ( " 3  ( "  "   0 "( 
 (     0 ,(   "(

.c ,À - !  c


Heart of Atlanta Àotel, Inc. v. ^nited States 

Citation. #).! 4@.64A

Brief Fact Summary. ( 0 ,  0 ,.64@ A- (( -
 À -@(( A(  "  , ""  % 
((        0 0 ? (  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 "  0    ,""     
      ,   (  0    ""  

Facts.  ,À  6"      0      


"   0  ((      ,"    ,2 00
  0 "0:  " (('"  )1L, 0   ,"
     ((   0         
""    0 

Issue. À 0 (  " 00  ""   E

Held. ; ((  0,," 

F0   " ,""     0  (  % , 
0  "" 0 !  /
  0 "  (( -  0  0,, " ! 
 :  

F " 0   0"  @   


""  ë0 - 4)! &@.+A ( " , ! 
 ?@( " A(ë -# !11@.4A/ ( " 
  '"0 0 ?(    0 - "(   
 


Concurrence.   /"ë0 @ë0 A  =0" -     
 0    ""   - H&,  " " , 
!   @ A ,   " (((   0 
 0     ,  - "(""  

Discussion.  , , "  0   ,  ( " - ,
À -   (    ( "    ""  ( 
    '(  ë0       "= -0      0 
 -1.!#@++#A- ( "  H&,  " " , 
  0 (    

½c*:   À0-À0-c


Katzenbach v. ÀcClung, Sr. and ÀcClung, Jr. 

Citation. #).! .4@.64A

Brief Fact Summary. 8 ? 7  -," <    "   %  
 -  , ,  0 ,.64@ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0      >  0 0,    
""   

Facts. 8 ? 7       "  " " ( ," 


7"0"- "7 , , ( 0 , -      %
(  <   (('"  &1L, , ( ," (( 
( ,",  7  ,  , (  - ((  -8 
À0@((  A-0 0     ((  (    
""   

Issue. À 0  0  "   (    E

Held. ; ((  0   " À ,      
    ,À -#).! 4@.64A 0  "0>  
   ((  ?   "         ,,  ,  
(, "    ""  7  ((  "   >   
 - ( " , !  @( " A 0  
 0     ""   

Discussion. *:   À0     "    ,À 
 (    0 0 ,,   ( " 0-    ( " 
 0 ?  '  ," ""   

,c3$ 0 ,  !  c


National League of Cities v. ^sery 

Citation. 4 6!+##@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  -3$ 0 , @((  A- 0 
 00   , .)4" "   $  @ A-
( ,   > "   0 "  (   "(   """0 
 " 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   " " , !   @ A
 (    ?   0 " 0 ?( "(   

Facts. .)4-0 "   -"0 0 -((  ? (   
(  "(  ((   0   > "  , " "  0    
  ,( 0  0 "    '  0 "   > 0  " 
(     (    ((   0 0   ((  
 ,   " 0 

Issue. À 0  0   "( " ( ,  0 "  E

Held. 3   "   /" > @ > A   
 >           (   
0   (     ,  "( 0 ?
 ,  (   ,,     ? (  (  
'   

Dissent.   /"7 @7 A   !  ( " 
@( " A     0   ,     ?   0 0 
 0 ?""  (  ((       
  

F    @  A  ,  0 " "  >  
    " , 0 - " ,  ? 0( 
"(   0  ,,  


Concurrence.    7%"@7%"A   0   
0,  ( ,0  "(   "  0   
     G,      "   0  G

Discussion. 3$ 0 ,  !    ,  "(  " ( " 
  = (  ,     0     ',  " " , 
 

0c2 À (  c


Garcia v. San Antonio Àetropolitan Transit Authority 

Citation. 46.!& +@.+&A

Brief Fact Summary.  (( -2@(( A- 0 0   "(  
À (  @((  A-00 ,   
 G<G,,  0 "  -      , 
$  @G$GA

Synopsis of Rule of Law.      0  0 (   
""        0   ,  (-=  

Facts. À0  ( ,  3$ 0 ,  !  -4 6!+##
@.)6A      "       "(   (  GG
 ,    $<, ( 0     ? 
  0 (( 0    "( -  "( ,  
 0      $

Issue. /   ( ,  ""   ""   E

Held. 3    " 

F ( " , !  @( " A    "
,<  ,  (((  ,
  "0  0 "  ,  $0 (  "( 

F ( "  "     03$ 0 , 
  0     000 ,    (
( 


Dissent.   $   @ A%    0
@A     <
   +    3$ 0 , @ A ((   ,, 
 ," ,     ,0 " 

F  /" > @ > A=     -G", 
I     0   ""  ( J-" 0""
  ((,"= , G

F  ë 8?@8?A   0G  " 


   , 0 "   0  '   (  G


-c2 À (  c
Discussion. 2 À (   ("   
3$ 0 ,    ( ,,    ,    ,  
  0  ""  ( 

c!   $( :c


^nited States v. Lopez 

Citation. &4!&4.@..&A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , -$( :@ë , A-0  -   
 ,  2< B ,..1@ A (  %0( ,
, "(             : 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. À  ( ,, "   0, 


   ""   (((   ""  ( 

Facts. ë ,      '   , 00#+ 0 
  ' -  0   (( -ë ,     ë , 
 0     '  , ""  ( 

Issue. À 0 ( "  ( ,, " 0  (   
""   E

Held. 3((  0,," 

F ,  /" > @ > A    0 ,  
0 "  0   ""  ( 
@A   ,   
""  O@ A  "  ,   ""  @( ( 0 
   ""  A@#A    0      
""  

F 0  , 0 -  " G   ,, G
   ""     0 ?(   ""  
      '   0    ,   
( 00 :     ,,    ""  


Dissent.     @  A0   "( , 
""  "0   , 0 = ,   , ""  ( 
     " 

F  ë  @ A0 "(


@A,    
  ,"0       ""  -  => 
    "   ( (   @ A ?   
  ""   = (        00, 
  


Concurrence.    *   @*   A -     
% 0  "( ,""   = (  " 

*c!   $( :c


    (     , ,    "0   - 0    
 0,""  '  ((  0,   

F    " @" A -    ( "  
 (  ,     ,    '  , 
""   


Discussion. !   $( :  ( ," ""    ,"
.#)..&3  - "=  "(  (  ""   = (  
,"    1   ,0 -  - 0- "  
  -*      , 
, ""   = (    0
  , -      "  0  @      
""   AE

Ac!   À c


^nited States v. Àorrison 

Citation.  1)41@ 111A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -À @ ( A-    (, 5  
0 /" ,..4@A-( : " ,   "   0  3
 ( 0   ,     ( ,0 ?(  0 
""  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    "   "     00 0  
   0""    

Facts.   7:%  50  ,,..4 ,  0-  


  0   (    '       , (  -0 ( 
,   7:% ,,     "    ((  "
 0 0  (  (( ,   ,  0 0  
"    -0  (       ë 

Issue.  H#.+,   '  ,0 ?""  ( E

Held. 3((  0,," 

F(( 0  <(0 ,"$( :-&4!&4.@..&A- ( " ,


 !  @( " A  "    0 "  
  ,,    ""  

F ( " ,  ,  00 0  ,,   @ /%  -
#)!@.4 AA 0    "      
00 0  ,    "    " 


Dissent.   ë  @ A- 0-0  00 0  ,,  , '
   " ,   , ((   = , 0  ""  ( 

Concurrence.     " @" A -       , 
( "   (  ,  ,""    

Discussion. !   À "%  $( :  (  "( ( " 
? ""   = (  -    0   ( "  
" (  , 00          ""  

Xc/  0  ,3 %  !" ( ,0  c


Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County v. ^.S. Army Corps of
Engineers 

Citation. &#!&.@ 11A

Brief Fact Summary.  ",  0  0( G (   ,
 :    G0 " 0   "(  ( ","  0   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G "0 (  ",  =  ( 
", ,0 ?À0 7 ?  0,"(0 " , 
 ?(" (    G

Facts.       ( , 414@A,  / @ GGA
 (( ,  G I J"  "-( - 0 0 
, 3?   G   GH414@A:  (   0  
 0 ,," ? 0    -?IJ    ,  ?   , 
!  -0    ?G "(,  =  H414@A-
  ( .+6("0  GÀ0 7 G-G  H414@A '  
   
/        (   À0 7
  O /       "0       O
/     , 0   (  O! 0 (  
   ""  G

F   -/  0  ,3 % @ G  GA-
 ", #   0  0 - %0,G (   
,  :    G    ,"   02 
"( ,       "  0 
("0( 3-   G    , G 
   (      (    -     
, , (    -  ( " H414@A,  
 ( -!" ( ,0  @ G ( GA- ,"   
 3   "" @ G"" GA-"0    
   ( G (   ,  :    G 
 (   (  H414, G, ,    
   0 (  (   ,"0 
 G0 -  (    =     ( 
(@ A, GÀ0 7 G ,     > H414@A( "


Issue. ë (   ,H414,  '    ( 0 ,"0 
 E

c/  0  ,3 %  !" ( ,0  c


Held. 3   GÀ0 7 G  ((    '
(( ,   =    ( ? 0" G  ( - "  
 -    -, H414@A?  ,,? 0  
  ?       ,"0   G

F   =    ( ?   GÀ0 7G G, 
0 ?(  0        ,,    
""  G      '  G 0    GG  , 
!  G

F -GI(J "0 (  ",  =  ( ", 


,0 ?À0 7 ?  0,"(0 " , 
 ?(" (    G


Dissent.     @G  GA,  0(=    ë 
 @G GA-  7 2 0@G2 0GA  ë 7 @G
7 GA  0=  0 GIJ    -   = 
 -    .+6"0   0    ( ? ,
=     ' (,  0    -   -  
=   0   >    ( "
@A 0 ( 
 IJ G '  0"  ""  (   0-GO
@ A.) 0      ,0 ( ?=   
    G

F =  , GÀ0 7 G  :     
G   ,, G   ""   -G     
   ,      ,, ""  O  0-% 
 00 0 -  ,  >    ,, G   
 0:     0 0   G 0 ,,"  
 G- " %   % ,""     -GIJ 
     ,0,     ,""   
  "0    ?  -?    G -G 
"0      G     
  G


Discussion.    0  "=  0( 0     
,,  =        ""   (( 

*.c   / 0 2 c


Pierce County Washington v. Guillen 

Citation.  #) 1

Brief Fact Summary. $ 0 "  ,"0  ,"  


0 "    " 0   "   ,     

Synopsis of Rule of Law. GI7J 0H41. ..&" "      


 0 " "( 0 ,     ,""    0( , 
 "  ,   ""  G

Facts.      :"0"@ G0"GA 0"0   


0 "  ,0"(  " 0  ( ,    0  
,,0  0"-   0 " " G % 0 
, (  G & @A@A(    0 "  " G
 " " 0 0  ,(   , :  -
 -  "  -0    "% ( "%  -
"   0 "  -    -(   - 0( ,  ,
 -  -  "  -   "( "    ,(=  , 
"( " G!( ( 0 -    =  H& ,  
(     ,   , "( "   "  0   - 
      0    -, ,"(  
 ,  0 "   (  ,,   ( - ë (" ,
 (@ Gë (" GA ""   0 ( 0,,  , 
,"0   >  ("0  #!H41.-(  (  (-
,"  ,"  ,  G  "      
    , ((  ,"0  0," 
  G

F8 &-..6-  ( -02 ? @ G ( GA, - % 
      -   / 0@ 
G  GA(( ,-     H& ,0"% "( "  
       ,   6-..6  ( ?   0
 ," (          - 
    , (   "  -0 #!H41.


Issue. ë G #!H41.-(  ,"?"(   ? 
 ,  0  ,  (0" ," 0   "  ,    
 -IJ  '  ,0 ?    GE

*½c   / 0 2 c


c
1c; 7 I^       J-0 G 0   ,   ,
   ""  G - ""    "(  0 
G 0 (   "  ,   ""  -(   0 
   ""  - 0  " "  ,"    G
  0: H&  ("0  0 G I J: 
  3?   ,""  G  ,, ,    
 ? ,    , 00      G ( 0
< (,,  : ,"  ", 
     ,  G7  (  "-0  
       (, #!H41.G " 0 
,,     ,"-"    ,: 
 -  ,"   "%0--"  -0   ,  3? 
 G


Discussion.   0,     0 ? ""  ( 

*,c3 ;% !  c


New York v. ^nited States 

Citation. &1&!-44@.. A

Brief Fact Summary.  $<$  /   " "  ,.+&@ A
0  ( ,   8 (  ,  >   % 
    ,   (   ( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 " G"" IJ  0  ( ,  G
"( 

Facts. $<     "" (," " ( ë (  
  -   "    ,  ,   , ,  ( 
"  ,  >  0  (  " ,, 0  "  
    ,( 0    - (   >   %  
, "   ,   (     ,(  
 ( 

Issue. À 0 "(       '( 0  ,  ,0
,   0   " E

Held. 3((  0,," 

F  (  - !  @ (  A-0  0  
 %   ( ,    "  - %  (   
  '  , 0 ( 

F  0 ,  0 "  , ,   0 
 " 

F    >0 0 " % ( ,    
>   >0  (   , " -, 
 >0        
  '  ,,  ( 


Dissent.   7 / @/ A- 0-0  0  '  ,
   ( " ,"   ," "(   
"=    0 ?   (  >  

F    @  A0  "((   G0  
  (   ? "( ""  0 "   , 
 0    0 ?G


Discussion. ,  0,   = (  ,  > -3 ;% 
!    , (( ,0 ""   ? 
  -   ( , 
*0c: !  c
Printz v. ^nited States 

Citation. & !+.+@..)A

Brief Fact Summary. 5    , , " ,,  @G$8 GA 0 - 00
  "(   , 7 05   @ A
   >    '  ,,  (( ,   0 (0"

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G   2 " " "(    
"  ,   0 (0"G

Facts.   ,    " , %0 %  ",0


(   3 " #1-..+  "-  >    , " 
 %0 %  ,  0, "( "     -:  
 ,,@   A- 0   > "     ( ,   2 " 

Issue. À 0  >    , " 0  "    %0 % 
 >   E

Held. 3((  0   " 

F  "(      ,     ,  -  >0
  '  ,,  "  ,   0 

F (       ,   (,(  -  " 0  
  0,",  (0"7    ,    - 
 , !    0    ,    
, !  7 (0  , " ,  "(    
 ,  ,, -0   ((  ,   '  , 
   , ,   0 


Dissent.     @  A    (  (   
" " ?            (  

Concurrence.     " @" A - 0 ,   0
0  %     >   "(      " " - 
 %      (,      ""  ( 

Discussion. : '    " " ( ,"( 0  
"  ,  (0" ,"   0  3 ;% !  -&1&!44@.. A
   '  0  3 ;%    ,0  >0   0  
 ( ,   %  -   :   ,  0 " 
 >0,   '  

*-c  c


Reno v. Condon 

Citation.  1666@ 111A

Brief Fact Summary.  0 0 !   2   -
00 ë ?    ,..4@GëGA    " " ? 
"   2 " ? (  0    

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   " "  (    2 " ,"
 00      ,  %   , ,  (0"

Facts.  ë    (  ,     ,(  ," 


 "     (  ((     0    ( -
?  2   @ ( A-0   >0 
    ,  0  -0     ((  " ,  " " 

Issue. À 0  >  "(  ëE

Held. ; ((  0   "  ë  >    
 0  :  3    >   0     
    , " ,,     00(  :    ë   
 0 " -  ""   0 "  ,  
" " 

Discussion.   " " " ,  (  '   "(   
  2 " "(  0   '   (,   
 0, :   (,"  0,  (0"  - 
( " , !       (
@A  ( " ,,  
@0 " (  ,,   A@A    0 ,   
@0 " (   >     '(    ,0,  ( A

*c!   7 c


^nited States v. Butler 

Citation. .)!@.#6A

Brief Fact Summary. 7 -  ( @ ( A- % =0"  0
= " ,.##@ A    ( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 " '((, 0   , - 0 


"  ' "   '  (       

Facts.  :   0,"  (, (  "( 
,' ( (  ' , "  (  0  '  
 0,((-   

Issue. À 0 '(( ' ,( " E

Held. 3((  0   " 

F '0 ( 0(   < -"   "   ,
   -H+, !   @ A

F - '      0 (,(   


"        (    0    2 " 
( , -  0,0  -  '    ""  -
  0    


Dissent.    @ A0  ( " , !  @( " 
A    (( =  0  

Discussion. !   7 ? 0 '0 ( 0(     0
-  ( " ?   ,  " " ?    '0
( 0(    >  0 (-7      " "  
"  0 -   0   >  

**c  !  c


Sabri v. ^nited States 

Citation. &4!611@ 114A

Brief Fact Summary.     (   ,,    :0
( " ,    "  0  ( ,,

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ":0    G > (,, 


,  "    " , ,,  G

Facts.    -7 "8" @ G  GA-     (   
    À (    %   
 >        ((  :0 -  ,,    (   
"    - 11 )- 11   ,À (    
 ",,  ,  11    0  G+!H
666@A@ A-"( ,  "(    ?( 0 -,,  -0 
0  0,   (  - ,   0 ,0:
, - 0 " - 0    ,-  
  - -  ,  , 0:-0 " -0    0
 0,  ,N&-111" ?G"   ,  G 0:-
0 " -0     I J-   ( -  ,  ' ,N1-111 
  (0"  00--   --0 -  - ,",
     G  ,H666    - 0
 G   0,   , '(  > " (  " 
   0   ,   ( 0  -    
   3   (    0  =  , 0 
( 0( G

Issue. GI/J  +!H666@A@ A-(  0   ,  -- ,, ,
      N1-111,  , -   '  ,0  
  ,  GE

Held. ;  "= , >%  ( ,  G  "  > (,,
 ,  "    " , ,,  G - "=   
G0     ( 0 ((( ,  " ("  
0   , --H+--  (0   3   ( 
 --H+-+- '(  (((  (  ,
( , 0   , -,   0,(=   "  , 
  ( ,,(( ,,       "0  , G

F-G0      (  %,(    
  "(  G   G    %% %,,  (
0  ,0 "     H666@ A     %"" ," ( ,
,  ( "  - ( 0 


*Ac  !  c
c
,£  £ , "    ( 0,  0GÀ  -
G(   (   , "    ( ,,    -,   
(   " ,,  ,    G


Concurrence.     " @G" GA, 0(G,I0J
>     (  0  3   (   (( 0 ?
  ( (- ((   3   (  
:   '  , (  " G"  G ,,   ,
0 ? "  (  G" :  "= ?  GIJ 
   ,H666@A@ A((   0:-0 " -0  > 
   " N1-111,    , , %-0 ,      
 00   ,  3      (
  ,    ,    G :  "= = ,
=   "  ,0     ,    G( I0J  ( ? 
"  (     =     ? (%  (" 
   ,  0,N1-111G"        
""   -      =0" 

Discussion.   ,,    0  , 3   (   
  - -  "   (     : 
0   - ( 0((  (   %   ,"

*Xcë% ë c
South Dakota v. Dole 

Citation. 4+#! 1#@.+)A

Brief Fact Summary. ((  0  ,  0, "(  0 ,
0 ,   0( ( ( ,     
   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 3<  ,   0   
'  , '0 ( 0( 

Facts. #!H&+      , ((  0 ,,  


0 ,         ( ( ( ,
      ,0 ë%      ( 
(# L  >  - ë (" , (
(('"  &L, ,  0 ,  "% ,   

Issue. À 0 , ,"  "  %00 E

Held. ; ((  0,," 0, "",,    


"   ((  '  ,'0 ( 0( 

Dissent.   /"7 ë 8?     0,
   <, " " -  0  0,     

Discussion. 0 " (G 0 G,    - 0    
'(   

*c!   À c


^nited States v. Àorrison 

Citation.  1)41@ 111A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -À @ ( A-    (, 5  
0 /" ,..4@A-( : " ,   "   0  3
 ( 0   ,     ( ,0 ?(  0 
""  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    "   "     00 0  
   0""    

Facts.   7:%  50  ,,..4 ,  0-  


  0   (    '       , (  -0 ( 
,   7:% ,,     "    ((  "
 0 0  (  (( ,   ,  0 0  
"    -0  (       ë 

Issue.  H#.+,   '  ,0 ?""  ( E

Held. 3((  0,," 

F(( 0  <(0 ,"$( :-&4!&4.@..&A- ( " ,


 !  @( " A  "    0 "  
  ,,    ""  

F ( " ,  ,  00 0  ,,   @ /%  -
#)!@.4 AA 0    "      
00 0  ,    "    " 


Dissent.   ë  @ A- 0-0  00 0  ,,  , '
   " ,   , ((   = , 0  ""  ( 

Concurrence.     " @" A -       , 
( "   (  ,  ,""    

Discussion. !   À "%  $( :  (  "( ( " 
? ""   = (  -    0   ( "  
" (  , 00          ""  

A.c*:   À0À0c


Katzenbach v. Àorgan and Àorgan 

Citation. #+4!64@.66A

Brief Fact Summary. 3 ;%  > 0    (  >   0 
  2   0 H4@ A, 500 ,.6&@ A  
  ,   " 3 ;%?  > "    >  , 
 " " , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0  "  H&,  " " , 
 @H&,  " " A  ,,  , G( ( I J G
   G    (,  G

Facts.  (    0 00      , "(   
'0      "" , -    ,0 
    ,3 ;%     0  ,, , 3 ;%
   > "    >  ,  " " 

Issue. ë H&,  " " 0     0 
=  "    0     " " E

Held. ; ((  0,," 

F ( " , !  @( " A      
0  "  H&,  " " , ( 
(        (,  

F   - (0 ,   " 


  ( , (  
  0 00  ,   


Dissent.   À @A   " 0    
( " , !  @( " A ( - 0 0 " 
     (    -   0     ((  
   00     0   

Discussion.  "=    (( ?   ,0   H&, 
 " "     '/ H&,  " "  
   ,0    0      E

A½c ,7    c


City of Boerne v. Flores 

Citation. & !&1)@..)A

Brief Fact Summary.    (, 0   ,7   


  0  " @GGA  ( 0    
  '  ,0 (  H&,  " " , 
!   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0  H&,  " " , 
 "   " (   - "   ,  0 -
     0 

Facts. ,  ( " , !  @( " A   ( ,  
'   ,  "( " ë  -ë (" ,"  ,
8 0 "-4.4!+) @..1A-0 (  - %0 ( ,  
   ( "( , - (  0 " ,"G   
 0G  '  , 0- ,     ," ,0  ((  -
  0 "  "  @A"( 00 "   @ A    
  "  , 0   

Issue. 0      0 H&,  " " , 
 E

Held. 3   " 

F         0  H&,  
    ?      ( " ,   0 "  
 0 

F ( " % 0  "  "   (   0 -
    "  0     "       
((  " (   =  


Dissent.   ë 8?@8?Aë  @ 0A  
(-0    ((  "  - "= (  
(   

Discussion. 7        '( ,0   H&, 


 " " ,   ( "  0   
 G , G ( 0 0 ,, 0       - 
"    " (  " 0 "      
 0

A,c:(% 7: c


Fitzpatrick v. Bitzer 

Citation. 4 )!44&@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary. .) -0 "   5,  0 ,.64@ 
A-:0(    ,"  "0 0 -0     
H&,  " " @H&,  " " A, !  
 @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 " : (    0    H&, 
 " "  "( "     ' 

Facts. .) -0 "   :0(    ,"  "0 -0 
  H&,  " " (( 0   " " ,
  0,   0""   (  0 ,":0 
 

Issue. 0  0    0""   '  0   H&, 
 " " E

Held. ; ,,"  ( " , !  @( " A H&, 
 " "  0  '   ,0     
  0       7  , H&0,  - 
( "  0  0    0""    -  

Discussion. :(% 7:   ,    > ?  '(0  , 
 " " 

A0c "  , c


Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida 

Citation. &)!44@..6A

Brief Fact Summary.     0   2"0 0 -
:   0   0 "   , 0, 0   "(0
0" 0   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ""    0  0   
  0"" 

Facts.         ,- %0 , 0, 0  > 
  2" 0  ( 0     0  -0 
"% (( ,   00    0"" 

Issue. À 0  0     ""   --H+-#E

Held. 30,," 

F0 "   2"0 0    0 


 ?   0""  -%        
(  

F &,  " "     0  : 
(   0   


Dissent. 

F        " "  (    0 
   :  ,   

F  ë  0  "= 0       0"" 
  = - ( ,,  


Discussion.    " " = (   ,    ', 
 " " -    ( , = ,   0"" -
   0  00 0    , 

A-c  À c
Alden v. Àaine 

Citation. & )!)16@...A

Brief Fact Summary.     -0(,( ,,  @   A- 0 
À  - 00  "( -  ,À @ ( A   " 
(   , ,  $  @G$GA

Synopsis of Rule of Law.     0"" (  < 0  ," 0  
  ,  ,,  

Facts.    0  0 ,  -     ( 0- 
   "  ,-&)!44@..6A- ë  "  
", -(    0    -   0 "  
 "  (   À ( " 

Issue. À 0  > < 0    "(      
  E

Held. 3 ( " 0,," 

F !  ( " @( " A   = (" ,
  ,     0""  (( ,   

F ( "  0  0< 0  
   ,  "%   ,
  0"" 


Dissent.   00        ,   0"" , 
 -  -0" , 0"" ,"  " " 

Discussion.  ( " 0 '(   (,   0""    
 (  0    0""     ,      
 " "  - -     0    -
   "   0 ((  " (    

Acc
c
CHAPTER III. The Federal Executive Power 
A*c;0  9   c
Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer 

Citation. #4#!&).@.& A

Brief Fact Summary.  %      %    " 0 
!    ( "  ,  -      '  
 (0,"   ,    ,""  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.     "  0 00 0 O    
 

Facts. ;0  9 @  A"(  '     
 ,0    0 ((   

F!  %    "  , "  0 "  
( ,  

F %     0-        '   (  
%    :   "( ,  (      
( 0"0     ,    ,""  


Issue. ë    '  ", (    0  : ,  " E

Held. ;    " "%     , 0  
  '(  , !   

Dissent.     = ,          0,"
 % ( 0 , ," ,  

Concurrence.    ? (      " 

F  % 


   ? (         ((
,0  (   >    ( "  
 ( ,0   " 

F  ë0


  '   , " 0     (  , 
  

F  %, 


  (  : ((    0   
G "" G-   G  ,(  ,  G-,  
 ,  


AAc;0  9   c
Discussion.   "           G  ,G
   ((( ," "" % , ((   
(   (,  ,,   -    0 - (    
 " -       ((,0 

AXc!   À3'-  , !  c


^nited States v. Richard À. Nixon, President of the ^nited States 

Citation. 4+!6+#@.)4A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,-   , !  3'@,,A


 ,  ( ,            (    
 ( ,   / 0   %<

Synopsis of Rule of Law.         , !  @   A
     0   (  0 - (  0    

Facts.  ," / 0  - , ,,?      0 
, (  ,=  -0 ,,  " ,  
    (  0 ,,(  (  0 ,    
     , "     ,, 0 "
>    (  0 , '  (  0  (,(  

F     ,,? ">  ( " , 
!  @( " A0   


Issue.      ?,        M    = 
  (  0 E

Held. 3-     (  0 

Discussion.  ,,0 (       " , 


   M      (  0 -"0    " ,  ( % ,
 %    "    0  ", 0 
   ? ""        = 0  " ,,  
 - ( "      ( ( 0 

F ,,   (,(  0" - ( " 
 =  80 "    ,   (   >  
/  ( "  0:  , 0  (  0 -
(  0 "   0 0  ," ,=  /0
,"" (  0 , ( 
0  "(   ,,  / 00   0
0"  0   -   ? 0  :   ,  
(   ,"  " , "=    "


Ac/"-  , !    ,3 ;%c
William J. Clinton, President of the ^nited States v. City of New York 

Citation. & 4!4)@..+A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , -   , !  -/"


@ë , A    > $  "5    " ,0 
( 0 ,,   ,3 ;%    @,, A   
 (  ,    ( 0  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  $  "5    

Facts.  $  "5 ,..6@ A0    , !  @ 
  A (  @ A(   ,  ( 0'0  ,  
 0    (     " ,-0(  
     " , 0 ,  0     ? 
 "=    ë ,   $  "5 (   ",
( 0  , 3 ;%  '  %,"  ?(  
  (  ë , "(  -0 ((     
  ( 0'0    , 

Issue. À 0 0      ( , 0 ,   
   E

Held. 3- $  "5      G ( ,  - 
" -" ," GI3 @.+#AJ

Dissent.    ( 7 @7 A  (,   "=  , 
  "  ë ,   0   G ( GG" G 
0  "(0      ( G G( ,    
  ë ,  "( ,     0 

Concurrence.    *   @*   A,     (,(  (  "
G8      %   " ,    % 0   (,
( 
 ,(   , 0      G

Discussion.    ?  "%0 " 0-, 0 0


 0    ? $  "5 ( ,,  ,",   
  % (  ,    " -      $  "5 
% ( ,    "   , -  (     - 
      " ((        
     ? (  ( "        >   '( 
( 

X.c$   ( !  c


A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corporation v. ^nited States 

Citation. .&!4.&@.#&A

Brief Fact Summary. 0   0   '  0   0   
  -   , !  @   A   0 ( 
  0(   ,    -      , 
ë , -$   (@ë , A-  , 0 , 
 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 "   0 <"%0  '  0  
(  0 ( ,  ,  '  , 

Facts. !  3    @3A-0   0     
 (( "( "  ,,    -   00   
"    0(    - - ,  0  
,",  8      ,"( , $  
  @  A-(   (   ,(    
3 ;%  ë ,     , 0( ,  

Issue. À 0   0   "%0   '   E

Held. 3-  0  "   0   '    ,    "% 
       0  , 0  - 0 "((  
  0  0  ( 

Discussion.   "    ( 0 ,   "((   0,
 0   -0    '"  -  "0" 0  
,   -%  0( ((      "  
G  (  G,   " "   -  " (" "( 
((   "  (  - 3  ( ( ,  ,   
((   "0   ( =  ((        
     ,    -  <"%0 0     
   0,( 

X½c" ,0  c


Panama Refining Co. v. Ryan 

Citation. .#!#++@.#&A

Brief Fact Summary. 0   0    , !  @   A 
(  (     , 0 (,(  "

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ,  (,(   ,0 
  0 <"%0    "( 0   "0
 

Facts. 0   (  , 3 @3A0    
 ( (   (,(  "(  ' , "( "  
 7  (  -   " '  8  0 
(  ,,-" ,0@,,A 0  = ë ,  -
 0 " ,, @ë , A-," ,0 '  8  ë 
0 ( " =0  , " -  ,((    

Issue. À 0   0   <"%0    E

Held. 3-0   0,(   '   "   ( ," 
 3  ( 0  ,( 0( 0  (
,(  "( ' ,       0 ,   
  0   " "G    (  G!  !  
 @ A0      ,    0  
(  

Discussion. 0  "(  , "    @ 0 "  
    (,(  "(   (  A
0    , 0   0      0  
,    , ( " , !  @( " A  
  0  -0  ,   0     -
 ,, -"       0,  , 

X,c/" " %0 -c


Whitman v. American Trucking Assn., Inc. 

Citation. &#!4&)@ 11A

Brief Fact Summary.       (    @ GGA 
(((   0,0  0  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G 1.@ A@A, -I ( " J ( I J
  >0  >      ? >  ? - 
0     <<(  (   > "0, ,  -, 
",    ( ,  ( "  (   

Facts.  1.@A,  @GGA"  " , 


 "  0  @GGA("0 -3"  D  
@G3DGA 3D"    , (,G?>  ? 
   H1+-4 !H)41+G 1.@ A@A,  >   
G"  >    " "  , =0" , 
" -  I J I"  ,H1+J0 > "0,
,  -  >  (  (  G 3D"       
" G, <    G"% G     "  ((( G 
ë ," ,H1.@ A@A"((    0  0  (  
"  , -H, !   @ G GA 
 , ( ,  ?  ( ,   (  G 0  
(( G0  0  ?  '  ,    , 
G( (      0 (0   ,H
1.@ A@A-   , 0     "  3D 
0  G ,((  ,,"   

Issue. GI/J  H1.@ A@A,  @A  0  0  (  
" ,  "  0  @AEG

Held. 30 @GGA-0, ( " , !  


@G( " GA  -GIJ ,((   IH1.@ A@AJ  (    
" (  ? 0  (( ?0  ?  '  , 
03D?I J-? -?%I J   "  ,0  , 
   0  " "?IJ   , ?  ( 
@     ,A     0 G/  :0  0
 0 - "   "        0  0  ( 0  
 , -H, !   @ G GA ( " 
      0:  0  <"%0 0  
0 " G   0   0  ((  (    
: IJ   ,"G  

X0cc
 0     00 G0   ,  0,
 0  (  (0   "0 ,   G

F  0:  """ > "  "   ',H1.@ A@A,
 "(  "     " (  0: 
 I0  ^    J 0  2  ? 0
 0 0     "  8(,  
 (   ( " I  ^ ë -  

@   
  J7  (      - 
 0:  G  ( ,  H1.@ A@A     
" , ?   0(    G -  0: GIJ 
  ,   ,  >  ? 0  (( ?%0 
 - ,(    0 ,  '  ,  -
  ,,    0     "     ,
" (    "0  "   0?,"( ?G
      - ( "  ( 

F  0: -   G   (0 0   " I
J " -  ,((    -  (  ?  " 
 ?,  0?"I,  0 "J "?G7  
(( - ( " ,G 1.@ A@A, -I 
( " J ( I J  >0  >     
 G >  G - 0     <<(  ( 
  > "0, ,  -, ",    ( ,  
( "  (   G


Discussion.   (    0  , <  0 
 (   0 "(( 

X-c""03:    0 c


Immigration and Naturalization Services v. Jagdish Rai Chadha 

Citation. 46 !..@.+#A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,, -  @,, A- 0 ,    -
(( :   ,0 -  -     , 
 2  , !  @ 2  A ( , (   0
""0 " !  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. $ 0    0"      " (( 
( "    , !  

Facts.    , "  !  <""0
          ë , - ""03:
   @ë , A- 0 (( 0  ""0=0 ," 
  > "    ""03 @ A,  (  ,
 (!  -  2   (    (  , (0 
 -  , (  (  "    
 > "  ,  (  , (3            
  , (  ë ,  ë , 0     
  ,((     (,(        

Issue.    < G 0   G -  :  ((  
   E

Held. ; -  0     0   0   0   
(   " -  ( (    " !   
!   @ A ( "0    0   " 
   ,0   , 0   (0   
 0  -   =    "  "( "  > "  , , 
 7"  "( "        %
 (  ( ( ," "(   '  ,(  "0 
(    ( 

Dissent.   7 / @/ A,  0      ,
(('"   11  -0    G 0   G   
  ,  '   (  0  /  0   (,
G 0   -G   ( , "  "( " (( 8   
  >     =  "  "( "   -0 ?   0
  2  ,  (     "  "( "  -
 0    0  ,0    
 2  ?   -  "  "( "        
  $   @ A0       

Xc""03:    0 c


  (,(  0  "( "    " =, 
  0 3?    ?  (

Discussion. 3     0  -  ,  ,, "     
(    ,0  (     ,  0  ,"  
,  , "  "( "   

F>      0  %0G 0  G 
   ,0  (    0 
( "       0    -0 (   
"       0    '     " 
 (         !  

F   ,     "% "   
 ,  - , (   7"  "% (  ( ( 
, ,"    '  ,0 " (   <  0  
  


X*c 'À - (      78 c
Alexia Àorrison, Independent Counsel v. Theodore B. Olson 

Citation. 4+)!6&4@.++A

Brief Fact Summary.  (    ((   ( ë  , ë
,((  - 0 0<%00 " ,, ,, ( 
"0 ((" , (     

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    (    , ,, -0 0=0 
  (( (      !   
@ A

Facts.   2 " @ A   ( , (   
 0 0<%0,, ,,  "  ,  2     
,"0 " ,,"    ,  -   >   
"% ( "  0 ( ( ë  @ =0 A, ë
,((  ,,  0   - ( ë  " ((
 (    0 , (  ,     (   
   "    2  ,G0 G "   0 
(   "(   ((  -  78 -" 
ë% @ë ,  A-    = , 0   (   (( -
 'À @(( A ,((      

Issue. ë    >    , !  @  A '    
 '    ((" , '  ,,  E

Held. 3      '   (( '  ,,    
     =  "  0  '   ,,   ,,    
= -  :  -     , ,, 
(( ,, 8 , - (("   ,   (  "
  (("    -0  0 0      "0
    ( ((, ,, 

Dissent.   @A     ,  " 0 


(    '  ,  ,     G (    ,(  
'  ,-     ,, 0   ,(  G

Discussion.  (("   --H - ,  -    '  
,,  @A(( @ A, ,,     (( (( ,,  
   ,   -  ((" ,, ,,        
, ("     ( " ,

XAc 'À - (      78 c


 !  @( " A   ( , (    , 
,,   @A       =  "     O@ A    
( ," -"  (    O@#A ,,  " = 0 
 ( ë  @4A  ,,  "   

XXc!    </0'((c


^nited States v. Curtiss-Wright Export Corp. 

Citation. ..!#14@.#6A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , - </0@ë , A- ( ", - 


  , 0" 0 "  ,'  8 
 " (  ,0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  <  0   0 ,"  000 
      , !  @   A ,, 0
,, 

Facts. 0 (  :0       ," 
       (   7 0    ""   
" '  8  0    ë ,   , (  
,, " 0 7  ,   '  8 

Issue. À 0   0 <"%0    "  ,, 0,, E

Held. ; -      , 0,, 

Discussion.    ," ,,     ,0 " , 0,, 
" ,,  ,  0 "       
, 0,,   ,     !  ?   (  , 0 
   !  ?, 0( " -        0 
=0   ' , 0  ,,      
         , ,"    -
(", 0,, ,,   (   

Xcë" 9À   0-   ,    c


Dames & Àoore v. Regan, Secretary of the Treasury 

Citation. 4&#!6&4@.+A

Brief Fact Summary.    , !  -""  @   A-  
  " ,( 000  0 " ,!   , 
 "  ( G '  0 " G

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    , !    (   "  
!  :  0 , 00 "  -   , !  
:   "   0"(" 

Facts. 83 " 4-.).- !  "  !  ("   
  0     ,:    !   .+-
    0  '  0 " 0(   "0 0
( 0 0  0 "  !    >0!  
:    " 0        " 0  
"  @A ,,-ë" À @,,A 0 "0
  '  0 "       ? ( 

Issue. ë    , !      " ,!  :  
00 , 0 E

Held. ; '  0 "    " ,  ,,      0 
, !  :     , !     (  ( 
 " 0 , 00 "  0'  0 "  -  
0     (  ? -  (     "   -
0       ( ,   -0 0 
 (    (   :  , 0  -    ?    
((( 

Discussion.    , !     0 "  0( 0 
 " ,!  :  0 , 00 "    ?   -  
  0 0( , 0 "   '  0 "    
 ,   .4.-,-0   (  "( " , 
 " 0 "   ( " , !  ?    
  , !      ( (  (   "  -
   , !     (   "   -   -
 "       "=, 0(  ( 0  >  
   ?  

.c" " , c


Hamdi v. Rumsfeld 

Citation. PP!PP- 4 6##@ 114A

Brief Fact Summary.     -;  ""@GÀ"GA ,  "
"@G   GA-, ,  ( (( 0À"?  ,   
 !     " " 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    ,,  " " (,,    
0 "   - 0 "   " " , ,,
 - (  " G:   !     " "  
0 " 0,((   ,   ,   ,  
  "% G

Facts.     , ,  ( (( 0À"?  ,    
 " " 3    ,  ,,   (

Issue. 

F/   !  0 "  !  : !  
   " " -   " "    ,  G?(,
 ((0,    !  (  ?G,0 
G? 00 " ,0  !  ?G  E

F/  ((( "  ,  0   " " 
 0   ,  E


Held. 

F  8?-@G8?GA0, ( " , !  


@G( " GA-   "  0, !  ,
((  ,      ?    
((( -     0   :   " <
" 7   ,, ,,    0 "   - 
0 "    (  (  :,! ,
À  @G!ÀGA-,0  !À:    
G    ((( , G0 G -0: (   G
    ( " - 11  %  ( "  -
G  ,  ,0 "  0     0-, 
, (,   ( -  ," 
 (     '  , ?   ((( , ?
0  :     G  0I'  J-8?
  0(   !  0 " ,"0!  


½c" " , c
c
:    " "  -8? 0  IÀ J- 
(0 ,À0 (  ,

F   (  - ,  ( @ GGA    !  ?
:    "( % '  -  0    
  0      (    -    
((   ,    +!H 4     "
 "     " ,-,  0,,0- ( 
 ,À"   " :  -À"   , 
( 8? ,   IÀ    J 0 - 0 
G (     ,,    ,,G0  2 " ? 
    -G0 ,  G G    2 " 
, ( 00  ( G8? 0: "(   
   -À"?   G 0, ,"(     ? 
0 " G - 0 " ?     0 ,0
0  !     0  !   "= 
  
G: <   %0 0   ,   " 
" "     , ,   ,  ,-,
((   2 " ? ,   ,    "% G
 - ( "  "   ,G  '0  
, "  G


Dissent. 

F  @GGA    @G  GA 


0  GIJ ((  '  %  , "   
  :         ?0  "  ," ( 
( "   '  ?  ( G  -      G  
   >0     @A"( 0  ("(  0-@ A
0    (   ,  ( G =   0  
0 G:   (  , G

F    " @G" GA   " 0 À"? 
G  ,  >     2 " ? (  -I ( " 
J%   '(  (  <0   G



IJ 2 " ?          
  "    " " -      -"(  
ë   KIJ '  ?         (  
(      =  = <0 0KIJ   
 ',  " <"   " -  , 

,c" " , c


  -   - (       "( 
"%0,

F  ë  @ A  7 2 0@2 0A 
(  ( =    -GIJ 2 "  , 
 "     :    "( ,   
 ,  2 " " G =       ,(    
" 0 " -      G    G -
 '   0    ,     
  ,     00  -%    "( " ,À
"À 0-0  "%  "  , :    = 
%(  , 


Discussion. 8?"%     0  ( "  " , 
  

I J%0 ((       ,0 "(  30 
( ,00" 7  >   0   ,   
     (  0  " :  ( 0" 
 00 ""  3? """  (  "    
  O  "  " (  """ "  (( ,
 ,0 
  0I    0  8? =   0 "   
(,(  (( "    "   ,   
"   - (   " ,0  '",   
,  '     0 ,       "  "   
      , (,(  -  ((   @   ( 
0  ,0 " /  0  "    ,  % %
,    "  0 , 3? :  
  -GIJ (  !       , '  
  '0     " 0: " ,,-"    
    ,         % G

0c3'  :0 c


Richard Nixon v. A. Ernest Fitzgerald 

Citation. 4&)!)#@.+ A

Brief Fact Summary.  <"0 "  '( ,   , ,   , 
,,0      " (=   ë , -   , 
!  3'@ë , A-"  "  ,0  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    , !  @  A       
"" ," "0 ,   ,,(    

Facts.  ,,- :0 @,,A- , ," =     <
"0 "      "    (    , 0   <  
     ,   , 0: ,  
" " ( 0/   ,,  0 ,, G(  '( G 
G  "% ,  G ""   G "  G( ,   -
 ë ,   (   "    ,  ,, /   
     "   0 ë , ,  ,,  "( 
 ,, 0  ë , " , "" =0"  0,  
"" ," 

Issue. ë       "" ," , %  ,,( E

Held. ; -    "" ," ," ,,  " ,( (  
   ,0 " "    (,( ((  ""   " 
,"   ? > (     "  ""  "( , 
  ( " , !  @( " A    0 
  ?   0      (    

Dissent.   7 / @/ A,    (       

Discussion.    "   "(   "'""   ,   
"(   , ,, ,-       = ""    ,
 "0 % ( (  , -      "  ,"( " - 0
  0 0  ( 

-c/" ,,     c


William Jefferson Clinton v. Paula Corbin Jones 

Citation. & 1!6+@..)A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , -   , !  /"


@ë , A  , '  0 ,,- @,,A-   
2 ,%   ë ,  0( (  ( 0,  , 
  ,,, 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0    =  "( "" ,"   
   ,,, 

Facts. ..4- ,,,  0  ë ,  00 '  @ A-
   ë ,  2 ,%  .. ë ,  
( %  ,    ,,    "( %0   ( % 
,,"     ""    (  ë , ?      "  '
       =    -  (          
    0 (  , = 0    ,,,   %0
( "0 

Issue. ë     "" ,"  0 "  (  ,, E

Held. 3- 0   "" ," ,,,   (,(  


   > ,     (   0  (     
,,  ( " , !  @( " A 0   " ,"
  ( ,,      "  ,,,%   
 ( ,, 0   0 ""  ë , ?  (,  
0" ,       =   0 % ( ," ,
"0 "       '  -     ( ,
,,(  , '  7À  - ( "      
  0 ,(  00  0(   

Discussion. 0 ë , "   "  ' ( - ! 
  @ A,,     "( "" ," "0 
0 0,  %(  ,  %,, -    
ë , ? 0"       (   

cc
c
CHAPTER I†. Limits On State Regulatory And
Taxing Power 
*c$    c
Lorillard Tobacco Co. v. Reilly 

Citation. &##!& &@ 11A

Brief Fact Summary. À   (          0

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  I      @@   @ @ 

 
  !J    ,  " 
G  - "   "    
'(  (     " " ""  ( " 
(  -  "  ,   "  03 '-  %   
  0 "      , >   (     - " 
  "     0     0 "     -  
 "  '           G

Facts.    ,À   (   0  0   0, "%  
 ( 0    0 0    0      

Issue. ë À   ?    "    ( " , !  ?
 0 ,""  ( E

Held. ;   ë 8?@G8?GA0, "=  0   0


 ," %, :0""  (  I    J     
,  " 
G  - "   "     '(  (     
" " ""  ( " (  -  "  ,
   "  03 '-  %     0 "    
 , >   (     - "   "     0
     0 "     -   "  '    
       G

F  0:    ,  ((     ,
G     (   "    ?    
"   ,         > ?  ( 
   "   I J   0 "   ? 
    ,  "   ( =  O -0 "   
%0   ""  ( "  "   " 
      ,   ""  0 ?G
 ,  ( > G %0    (   "  '   
          ((G    G   
  "  G-       G?,    0  ?    
"   "(    -"      
   =  ?G


Ac$    c
c
1c  ,-8?   ë0" ,
GIJ     0     , "%   (   0
( (    , (  (    0   
( "     0 ((  0  (( 
, 0   , 0( ( ," "0  <0
 ( G "  "      0  ,0 
 - "= G 0 IJ(   ?"      
( 00  "(0 "0  '(    0
    0  , "%   0 G8? GIJ
  ,      2   (  "( " 
, (  " 0  , "%   0 G

F8?0 - -  0  ,  ,(0, 


I  J    -GIJ    (,  0   
 2  ? , I J     ,    
  ( "( ?   0 G ( " :  
 0 0( ,  0 - ,  0
   0    ,"     ,  "  , 
:      ,,  GIJ " 0 0(  -  0 
    "(    "",,,"
  "%   0  "  G

F8? G  2   ,   


  0 0 , "%   0  "  '   
       ?     ( 0 0   G


Dissent.     @G  GA, (=    7 
2 0@G2 0GA  /"7 @G7 GA-0 0(
       0 (   ,,,     G -
 "   "   ,,        ((    GG -
 I J"     -  ,,    0   -   
""     ( " G

Concurrence. 0   " @G" GA, (0(


0 =0" "   G= (, -I J 
   0 "  %  , (   ((    
 -    ((( -    ( > "   :  
?"" ?G  -" G  = ,   0     
     " " G

Xc$    c


Discussion.   ,,    0 '"( , I    J,  (( 

c$" 9 2  - -ë -ë (" ,0 ,,c


Florida Lime & Avocado Growers, Inc v. Paul, Director, Department of
Agriculture of California 

Citation. #)#!# @.6#A

Brief Fact Summary. , ,,  ,"   


$"  "      ,   ,(   "," 
"%  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /   ,   ' ,,    - 0  
 ' - ( " , !  @( " A   
( "(    

Facts.  ). ,,? 0 -00  " ,   
 -(    (  ,,  G +L,
-  0 '0  % G -  "% 0  ((   
   ,0 00  " ,  0   -
   0,     , -,"%     
0"      , ,?  > " ,+L 
((  - $" 9 2  @((  A- 0  ,
  ( "  , !   @ A

Issue. /      ,,  ,    - (( E

Held.  "     < ' 

Discussion.     %0  ,G"(  ,  


  0  ( "(   ,  00    ""  G   
(  - "           " , 0-
 (   " ,   

½..c,2 9    0     9ë (" "" c
Pacific Gas & Electric Co. v. State Energy Resources Conservation &
Development Commission 

Citation. 46!.1@.+#A

Brief Fact Summary.   0    0, ,   (   0 


( ( -( "(  - ,,   ( "" ,
 ( (    

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ( "( ,      "( " ,
 ,((  =  ,0  - ( " , !  
@( " A ,       ( "   0   ,   

Facts. ,( "( ""  ,,   0 


(- "   0 "  , ( ,0<     
,,-,2 9 @,,A   ë , -,?   0 
    9ë (" "" @ë , A     
( "(     " 0 ,.&4@ A-   ,    
( "  , !   @ A

Issue. /   ( "( ,      "( " , ,
((  =  ,0 E

Held. ; -  (0"" , ( (  "(  


,  ?  =  , (0   0 

Discussion.  ,,   ""(  ,,?  ( "(  


  0  - 0  (  0  (   ,  
   , ,    ,  0 "  -, 
    0    ( "  0 -,   0,
 (0  0    ,  0   , 0-0    
,  0 "    0  ,    0 -    
   (    , , 00   ,  "0
>  , -       ,   ( "(  
0      ,   "    0-    
,,  0  0 - "   0   , /
 0 ,0- (" (( ,  ("  ( -
  ((  "(  G  G    ( "( 

½.½c -   ,$   ,    ë :c


Hines, Secretary of Labor ad Industry of Pennsylvania v. Davidowitz 

Citation. # !& @.4A

Brief Fact Summary.     0   0  0 ,  
  0 (  ,   , ( "(    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. , ,  0 "  '   (  (, 
  "(    ", 0-    ,M ,  M
"( " - ,  -  , '  0 

Facts. .#.   (   0 @   A- >   
 0   -(  ,"  0   ( - 
 " (    ' -     0 @   A
(  , 0  0     0  ((  -
ë :   @((  A- 0     0 >(   -
  0 ,    =   , " ,   


Issue. ,   0 "   '   (  (,    
 , ,  -"( " - ,  - , 
'  0E

Held. 3 ( " , !  @( " A  0   
,,  0 " (  , ,""0 0   

Dissent.    %  @ A%0 " "(   '  
 0   ",   ,  ( "  %    
""        ,  , ( ( 

Discussion.  ,  0 "   (  ""0-: (


/  ,  0 " (  "(   ,  0 ,  -   
, ,  - ,  0 0   ,"
  "

½.,c9 - ëÀ-""  ,0 À%  ,3 ;%c


H.P. Hood & Sons, Inc v. Du Àond, Commissioner of Agriculture and
Àarkets of New York 

Citation. ##6!& .@.#.A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , -ëÀ ""  ,0 À%  ,


3 ;%@ë , A   ,,-9 -@,,A-7 "%
  -    "%,  ,, 0      
"""   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  "       '(,( 
 (    "   

Facts.  ,, 7   ,"%   "%," 3 ;%( 


 ,,  ,(3 ;%-  ë , 
   ,,  ,  ( 0    ,   
   "( "%    >    À  - ë ,   
  , ,("% ((  ,"  ' 0( 0
(   (  "% , >  (( ,"% ,,
 0  0 ë"""   

Issue. À       , (>  ("%   ""  
 0  "       (    "
   E

Held. 3-3 ;%?  " 0     ( """   
  -  ((  ,, ,0  " ,   ""  
 "       

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A   "  
     '(,(  (    "
     " ("   " 0   "   0,
   ""   ( " 7 2 0  G8  "
,     ""   -   ,"   , (     0 
(     ,,    "%  -"  " 0 
 '(    -  "   0 - '  " 
   , ,  O     ,  0   G

½.0c7  7,/  , , (c


Aaron B. Cooley v. Board of Wardens of the Port of Philadelphia 

Citation. &#!@ A ..@+&A

Brief Fact Summary.    >  (  ( 0  "0 
, (-( , 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0 (  0 ""    '  ,
 (   0 ""  

Facts. +1#-      >0 (   0 , (@ 
A (0  "0 ( ,  ,   ( 
,,- 7,/  , , (@,,A ë , -7
  @ë , A- 0  ?   - 0 ""  
 ? (  0  0 ""  0  " '  =  
""      ë ,   0 , (  ,(
(  ,     ,,  )+.,0 @ 
A-         0 (    -  -( 
 0    0   

Issue.   0 (  0 ""   '  ,  (   0 
""  E

Held. 3- ( " , !  @( " A     G   
'    G,=  ,   0,""   ( "   
   (  0    ,""      -
 > ," 0 0     ( 0 -
0  0:      (   ,,    ""   
( "     0,(    >  
,"  -0  0   (       
0, ""  ( 0 (     ," '  0 ( 
 ""    -  0   '   ""  (  
 ?  '  , " ( ,,   ( "  "     , 
,  "(       (" (" 

Discussion.  ( " ,   ((( 8    "  "
 0  , '  , 0    

½.-c 0 ë ("  7 7  -c


South Carolina State Highway Department v. Barnwell Brothers, Inc. 

Citation. #1#!))@.#+A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,-7 7  -@,,A 0   


( 0 ( ,%   0        
""  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   (0 0" % ( 0


 0  "(       ""      
 !   ? @ A""   

Facts. ( (  % ,  0  


 0 ( , -%  ? 0 ,  '  
.1 ,  0 '   1-111(  ,, 0     
      ""  - ,  ? ""  
    =  , " ,  0 -  "0 
  "(  "%,,( 00       

Issue. ë   "( 0   0,%     
   ? ""   E

Held. 3-   0 "0 0,% (    0  
   ? ""    ( " , !  @( " A
, ( 0    0   0,"   ,
(    ( "   0: 0 
 ( 0  0  -  ?  0   
 " -   ((( 

Discussion.     (" ""   %0 , 0  
 " "(  "    (   ,"  
" 0   ""    ,  "    "  , 0  " ,
 0   0 "   %     0  ( 
     ? ""   

½.c , :c


Southern Pacific Co. v. Arizona 

Citation. # &!)6@.4&A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,-   ,:@,,A-  "0 


" , (    ,  "    ë , -  ,
@ë , A      !   ? @ A""  
 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0    <  ,  ,  "   <  
  ? ""   - ( " , !  @( " A
    ,, 0    "(    ""  

Facts.  :$"$,. @ $A-(   (  , ," 


4( 0  )1, 0 :      " (  , 
 ,, ë ,     ( "      
( "            ? ( (   
       - ,   < 0,   ( (  ,0 
 (  ,   ?  ,,    ""  

Issue.     , ,   ,  "   "0  0,  0  
     ""  E

Held. ; -  (  0,     ""  - (   
"( "  ,  - ,    ? ""    ( " 
  "   0 , 0  4( 0  " )1
, 0   ( " !   , 0   0-
,"  0-   0 "( - G(  (    
 ( ,, ,,  "   "G ( "  
  "  $"(        ""   - $ 
(    ,    ,  "% ( " 0   
( "   0    ," 7 -#1#!))@.)+A-
   0, 0 

Discussion.  ( " "   "    ' ,      
 0,    -(   ,  "   -"(    ""   
( "  "   "       0 ,      
     "% ((     , ,,   ""   
, ","  "   >0," , 0     , 0 
  ? ""   ,"   ,   ,  0,    
 0 -    0    :? 0      

½.*c , :c


ë ,      #1L"  0:  0 
 

½.Ac , ( 3   c


City of Philadelphia v. New Jersey 

Citation. 4#)!6)

Brief Fact Summary.  ( " , !  @( " A 
ë , -  ,3   @ë , A  -(     ," ( 0,
>  3   -   ""   , !  
 @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   - 0 ""   -" , <  
    <,<     

Facts.  ë ,   (     ( 0 "(," G >
  0        " ,   KG  
""    "  "(  0 0 (  - ,  
 ,  ,,-  , (@,,A 0     0 
  ""   ,   G   G     
 (             ""  
  " 0 ,  (  ( " ,3     
     0"   ,    -     
   ""  

Issue.   , ""   ,   (   ," 0
 (0 0"  ,""      E

Held. ; - 3     ( 0<,<     ( 3   , 
  ""            ""       
        ""  0  " 0  0
 (    ,  , :   0"      "0
0  ,""  ,"      " -   0 0(
0, 0          "( ,,          
0 

Dissent.   /" > @ > A     % 3     
  (  "(,   ,   ,  ,       
  , - "    %      ?   

Discussion.  =  ,   ( , ""   -0   


( "      ,  ,, -   (( ,
 "

½.Xc9  - ,% -3 ;%c


C & A Carbone, Inc. v. Town of Clarkstown, New York 

Citation. &!#+#@..4A

Brief Fact Summary.  - >    (   
 , ,  ,   0-  0   0 ""   , ! 
  @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  $0 "  "   ,   (  
( 0(0 ,<,<  "(   , 

Facts.  ,,- ,% -3 ;%@,,A-      


   ,3 ;%  ,      ,     
 ,     ,  - ,,(   >0<
:    0    0  (   ,  ,
,   "% ( 5  (  0, ="  ë , -9
  -@ë , A-"( (   -(     
"  '"  ,, 0=,  ë , "( 
       =   ë , ? 0"   
  ""   

Issue. À   0 "    ,   (  ( 0
(0 ,,  "(  , , E

Held. 3-   >0   (   ,    
 ""   

Dissent.   ë  @ A     ,,       
       ,,     ,
(   -        (    = 0       0 
,  "   ,     ,"    ""    
  ," 00    ,  "=  0   ' 0 
ë"""   

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A   
0 "  "   ,   (  ( 0(0 ,,  
"(   , / (    ",""     " -
,   ,  ( (     " ,  
  "(, ( 0    >  "(    <( 0   
0  -  0", " ,"   7      
,0  ( 0"(  -0,  ," -, "% -
  ""   ,  

½.c0  8%"c
Hughes v. Oklahoma 

Citation. 44!# @.).A

Brief Fact Summary.   (    (,"      
  ""   , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   , ""   ,    
 "(    ,      

Facts.  ,,-8%"@,,A    (  G(  "  (
(" ,           (    , 
 G ë , -/"0 @ë , A(   ' "" "
  - 0       ""   ,  

Issue. ë ,,?    ""   E

Held. ; - ,,? ( 0 %0," ,          
""   ,   ( " , !  @( " A
  0       ,   0>,   (
3-  ?  0,"    :   " "    ? 
 0,     > > @A      0 
   " 0    ""  O@ A     0" 
(( @#A    "  ("  ((   
 "00    ""   ( "   "    ?  0" 
            " "  (   

Discussion.       %  ,,   ""    ?   - 
, 

½½.c-2 ,  ,3 / 0 ((   0"" c
Hunt, Governor of the State of North Carolina v. Washington State Apple
Advertising Commission 

Citation. 4# !###

Brief Fact Summary. 3  0   ,,- / 0 


((   0"" @,,A- 0 " "(-
    ""   , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ,         ""  
 ,  "  ,,    ""  

Facts.  ë , -3@ë , A-     >0 (( 


   G0  ((  !0 -G    !  
ë (" ,0 @!ëA  ,/ 0@0 (( <(0  A
,,  00  "-  (  >    !ë ,,
 0    ?   0      ""    0
/ 0((   033 ,      0
    0( (( , 0  ,,

Issue. ,       , ""   ,
  "  ,,    ""  E

Held. ; -,    " "(- ,   , -   
""   

Discussion.       , 0(( 3- ' (,3
(( 0   / 0  "  '(       "(  -"  
3? 7 ( 0/ 0(( ,""% 0(( ?     ? 
0 -  0,, - ,  "  0  (( 0  
37   / 00  %, 0 ( - ( " ,
 !  @( " A  3   ( 0, , 
 , ""   

½½½c''( 2 ,À c


Exxon Corporation v. Governor of Àaryland 

Citation. 4#)!)@.)+A

Brief Fact Summary. À -( 0(  "(   ,  ,"( 0
0      -   ""   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.     "     ,,"     (( 
  "( "        ""  

Facts.  ,, -''(  ,  @,, A- (  "
 (     À    ,À ( ( 0(  
 ,  ,(  "( ,"( 0 0        > 
 (0      (  "(   ,  À   ,, 
,  ,   "(   "  , À 0   
À  - (   ,      (À  
,,      ( " <,<  (   ,,  0  -
00 "  ,,    ""     
"( "         ""  - ,, (   ( 
0  - À ,((    -(0 0  ,, 

Issue. ëÀ ? "( "        ""       ""  
 E

Held. 3-   ( 0"( ,"( 00    (  
0 ,,    "  ,  "(        0 
    (     - (  ,,   0 -(    
( "- 0   <  <,<  "(   "%    
""     =  "( "      "(       0
  "     ,,"     ((   ""   (  
    "% -(   ," -,"(     "  0 

Dissent.    7%"@7%"A     ,  "= , 


 ""( "    "0    ""   0  "% 0 
,    ,,  (    0       <,<      
= ,   0"         "  <  0
 ,     ""   

Discussion. 0  À 0 ,",    , -  " 
0 ,                ""   (   
   "% -(   ," -,"(     "  0 
0  "0( "   

½½,c''( 2 ,À c


 (   , -0"     ",   -   
""   - ( " , !  @( " A   
  "     ,,"     ((   "( "     
   ""  

½½0c/ $  "  -   -""  ,À   ë (" ,0 c
West Lynn Creamery, Inc. v. Healy, Commissioner of Àassachusetts
Department of Food and Agriculture 

Citation. & !+6@..4A

Brief Fact Summary. À   ? -"( '<  "%  - 
(  ( ,"  -  0  0   !  
 ? ""   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   (0 -"( '   ,(  


(  ,        <  (  , (- " 
0    ""        ? ""   

Facts. À     (0 -' "%     - 0 ,
   ( ,   (  ," '     
À   ? ,"    ë , ? -  -""  ,À   
ë (" ,0 @ë , A- ,   (  
(   ,,-/ $  "  @,,A-"%  ( <,<  
"% 0  (0      =    0 

Issue. ë  À         ? ""   E

Held. ; -   ? "%'         ""   "   " 
    ,0-      (  ,    0 
       ,,? ,  0    "
    0-0%0  (   0-  ,,,

Discussion.  (0  , (( ,"'    ,"%(  


 À   ?(0    ,"  -         
""      ((  "   ,   "   
  0<,<  "(  /  " ' (    
 , 0(   '- ? (( 0    (( 
 0         , <     -   0 
 '-  ",       ,   ( 0," 
0 ,   "(   "%,  "(  "  ? 
""   (  

½½-c ,À   $  "  c


State of Àinnesota v. Clover Lead Creamery Co. 

Citation. 44.!4&6

Brief Fact Summary. À  0   ,"%(    -


 ,      0  0 " (( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ,       !   ? 
@ A""   ,    "(    ""     
'    (   , 

Facts.  ë , -À @ë , A-     0    ,"%
(    - ,     -       ,"%
((     '( ((    (  ",   "0 " 
    ,,- $ , "  @,,A,   =   -00
    , ("   "  ,  0"  ,  
((  " (    

Issue. ,        ? ""   ,  
 "(    ""      '    (   , E

Held. ;   - -  0( "%   G   '  
 G,      ( " , !  @( " A  
      "              
  (  ," 0"% (   (    ( "    
    (  "   - " ( 0   " À  -
 ( "   "  0 ,    '    (<,<
 (  

Discussion. ,  ((0("   " ((       
"  , "(  "-  (   ,  ((   -   
"(    ""   "-  "%( "  " ,   
    0 (%00   0   ((  
   À   %    , 0, ,"     '(  ,<
,<  ,"   0 ,   <,<  (      '00   
  G   '  G 0,       ("0
  ,  0      0    ( (  " -
         ', >(   

½½cë À%  ,À -/  c


Dean Àilk Co. v. City of Àadison, Wisconsin 

Citation. #41!#4.@.&A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,-ë À%@,,A-( 0     "%


 ë ,  -  ,À -/  @ë , A   (  :( 
  " , "  - 0  ë , ? "%( 0 
  ""   , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ,            -  
(  "      ""     ""   , 
 

Facts.  ë , (   0(  : "% ( 


&" ,   ,,-"%   0 "%,","  
/  -6&+&" ," ë ,    "%" ,"" , " 
  ,,       "% ë ,   ,,  
  (      ""  

Issue. ë   (  "      ""  
  ""         >       E

Held. ; -  "           0   ( ( 
 -    ""   ë ,  ?  (   <  "%
(   ,",  "(  ( " , !  @( " 
A    (  " 0    ""   ( " 
   ë ,      (  (   " 
, "   ' ,"    "%(   
ë ,  ?   À  - 0   %   !   
      ,  (  

Discussion.  ( ,, ,    ' "%(  :  


GI8J   -  0  -" (  ,( , " G

½½*cÀ   !  c


Àaine v. Taylor and ^nited States 

Citation. 4))!#@.+6A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , - @ë , A- ,  ,"0 -


 0 À ? ( 0 "(,  ,  0   
""   , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.     ,,"   " 0    ""  
(  0        "( (  0,"0   ? 
 "  < 0

Facts. À -  (   ? ,   ,"(  <  (  -


(   "(,  ,  ë , (      À 
"(    G0    G0 ,   ,  " " 
"(-   (    ""   , (  ,  
ë , "  "  "  0À ?    
      ""   ë  "  ë , ? "
 ,((    

FÀ     ,    ,   


Issue. ë     ,,"   " 0    ""  (   
     "( (  0,"0   ?   "   0E

Held. ; - ( " , !  @( " A(  (  
 "  "  0 "  , 0" (   0   
""  "   ,,  /    "  , -   "   
    0" ((  ((       
 " "    - ( "   " À     
 " "       0"  =  

Dissent.     @  A %  ,À     
   " 0 ,   ,  ,  À      
 , 0      

Discussion. À ?             %0 ("  , 
, -          "   0"  
,À   "(0" À ? ,0 ,     , -À 
 '(     (        " "0   
   ,"" 0 -  0 "   0  - , 
    >  

½½Ac$ %  7 -c


Loren J. Pike v. Bruce Church, Inc 

Citation. #.)!#)

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,-7 -@,,A 0     


ë , -  ,:@ë , A(    (, ( 
   ,,  00    ""   , ! 
  @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /       0  <   ,,   0" 
(     ,,     ""     - ( 
    "(  ""      '    ( 
 , 

Facts. : > ( 0:,,  ,  "  


(%     ((  0 " ,, $ % - ë , 
 ? ,,0 , ,0 -   ( 0 ,,-( 
,"0"( -," (0 ( ," : ,
(%0(      (%0   ë ,    ,
   ,, N)11-111      = 

F ,,,    =   0 


       ? ""   


Issue.  "      """   E

Held. ; - ( " , !  @( " A (  ,  "0
   "       """   /  
 "  ,,   0"     ,,     ""  
   - (     "(    ""     
'    (   , /      0"   "  
"   0    "( 

Discussion.  (( , >    (     (,
0    - 0"     -  ?     
:( "(  0( 0 N 11-111(%0(

½½Xc7 -ë -ë (" , ,  ,  3 = 0$ -c
Bibb, Director, Department of Public Safety of Illinois v. Navajo Freight
Lines, Inc. 

Citation. #&.!& 1@.&.A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,-3 = 0$ -@,,A-%0"( -


 0    , ?"0 0 ,  
   ""  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   "0    ?  " 0  ,  
  """   , !   @ A- ( " 
, !  @( " A" %  ,, ,   ,  
"   ,  0-(  "-   0   % (0
   ""  , ," ,      "(  -  

Facts.    , (  >0%   "0 %  -
    >   0"0 -       (   (  
 ,, 0   00   ""     
      ""   , "    = 

F ë ,, ,, >  ë ,  -7  


 ,, @ë ,  A-," ,0  ë   " 
  ( %0 ,"N4-&11N4&-+&1  ",( 
 >  


Issue.       >0 ( "0 E

Held.   /"ë0 @ë0 A,     "(  
( 0,  ,  , 0 À  - ,  "     0( "(,
  -  -   ,0    0     ( " 
  %    %   ((0   0 
 "0 À  -   0    ,  G  %0G-
  00,       ( "    "  
"0    ,   0   0"0    
: 

Discussion.    (  0  0 - - "0   
(             ,   G  G(  ,
"         0  ",( 
      """   

½½c "*     0 (,ë  c


Raymond Kassel v. Consolidated Freightways Corporation of Delaware 

Citation. 4&&!# .

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,-   0 (,ë  @,,A
6&<,   -     0% " 61, 0 
,,    0    ""   , !   
@ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0   0  00  ,   "(-, 
,  , ,   "0   ""    -  0  
     !   ? ""   

Facts.   0  ,  "0  : ,% 61,  ,, 6&<
,%         "  !    ,
6&<,   ë ,    -0   
 ,    , 06&<,  ,"? 0 

Issue. / ?  0,, 0 "0 ,    ,    
   ""  E

Held. ; -? %< 0"      , ( 
(        0,,? %"   " ,    "(  
%0"(    6&<,     " %   
     

Dissent.   /" > @ > A     ,   ( " , 
!  @( " A    ((        0  ,  
( "    , ,0?  +1-   3 
    6&<,% 

Discussion. , ( (         "0% 61, 


  ,6&,   ,  -   (  0  ?   
        ,,0  %   % ( 0
     0, ,         ? ""  
 

½,.c( ë " (," c


CTS Corp. v. Dynamics Corp. of America 

Citation. 4+!6.@.+)A

Brief Fact Summary.    ,( <( %  ( 0


" (  ,,-ë "(," @,,A ( 
 ë , -(@ë , A 0     ""   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.         ?  00 "  
,,   ,  ,,       ""     @A  
> ((  <  <,<  ,,  O@A      0 
"(   @A(( "  <( (     
   

Facts.    ,? ( %  (    > GG  
(- >0(   00  , %   
((  "= , ( ' 0         ,, .6L, 
ë , (   ,, -    ,,?  % 
)&L  -  , ( ' 0          >  ,,
 0      "   %      ,  (  
        ""   ,      
,((  ,,"   

Issue. ë  ""   , !   @ A    
- 0 ( %   E

Held. 3-   "0( %     ""      , 
   "(  """   -   
    "00    ""   ( " , !  
@( " A     "   ((  
<(  ( "  ,?  
    0 0  ,,  "    -  0   
(       ( ,    ,   
,"   0  00  (  ,  "   -
  " 

Discussion.          0( %     




F   > ((  <  <,<  ,,  

F      0 "(   


½,½c( ë " (," c
c
1c(( "  ( (     
   


 - (" (( ,  (     ,( À 
"( -  ( 3;  ,",, 0(   
( 

½,,c/  9 $,     7,>:,,c


Western & Southern Life Insurance Co. v. State Board of Equalization of
California 

Citation. 4&!64+@.+A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,- /  9 $,   "( @,,A-
 0 ,"( ',      ,,0  
   !   ? @ A""   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 -(   -" 0   (  
   ,,   ""  

Facts. ,-( ("0  0 -  "( 0  


'<,<      '((  <,<    ?   ,(
"( 0 ' ,   0      ,
  "(   ?    0   , ,, 0  
 00    ? ""    ,(  
 ' -  ,,((      

Issue. 0 0    (     ,,""  E

Held. ; -   ' ( """    0 " : 
   G,0    " ,   0  ( ,   
""  - %     ( ,0 :    
    ""    0 G

Discussion.   0 0    0 ""  "0   
  , -0 " , (       ,,""  

½,0c - /"% c


Reeves, Inc v. William Stake 

Citation. 44)!4 .@.+1A

Brief Fact Summary. ë%   <  " (-,"    
(     -  0 ( ,   <      ,,- -@,,A
0"       !   ? @ A""   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   G"% (( G   0 0,0 - 
(( G"%  0G-     ? ""   , 
 <     

Facts. ë% (   " (-  <,<     
,&1  $ -ë%"( "  ( 0 ( ,         
,, 0" <,<      ë%,    ? 
""   

Issue. À  0 ( ,   <     E

Held. ; - 0 G"% ((G" ,  <        
, ("   ,    ,(  ,   "% 

Dissent.   $   @ A     %    '   ( ,
"(  "  ? ""      ( 

Discussion. /    " G"% ((G-           0
 " - ""       ""   ?  " 
, <       ? ""    ((   '  
 0 "   "(     ""  

½,-c< " ë (" - ""  -ë (" ,3  , %c
South-Central Timber Development, Inc v. Commissioner, Department of
Natural Resources of Alaska 

Citation. 46)!+ @.+4A

Brief Fact Summary.   , % >    , %" (  %
,   '(

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0  <    " , <  (  - " 
    ,(      ""  

Facts.  , %" ( 0-   0 (   


 (( ,  > "  (  %" (  - (   
"% 0 (, "   

F ,,-< " ë (" -@,,A,   %0


=(   > "     !   ? 
@ A""    %"  G"% ((G
  , (  ,"     

F ,((    " 0 :  %? ( 0


 > " 


Issue. À  -0 "% ((-"(  > " G<  "G"% 
((  0 """   E

Held. 3- "% (( ' ( "  ("%    
((,     G"% ((G  "(       
""   "%  ((-  0,  ( " ,
 !  @( " A-,""   (( - , GÀ% G 
(    ?  '  , 0  "%    ((0 
 0 G  "G"%   - ( " , %  ((
 " "% -  ( 0"%  - % 0"  ( ,  
    ( 0"%   " "% 

Dissent.   /" > @ > A     %     
(( 0 ,   ,  %   ( 0     %
(        "(  "     , -,  
,, ( "     ? ""       
(

Discussion.  % " "   G"% ((G    "( 0
 > "  " ,      -G      -

½,c< " ë (" - ""  -ë (" ,3  , %c
  - (   ,   G  " "(  
    0  ,,   ,("% 

½,*c"  / c


Toomer v. Witsell 

Citation. ##4!#+&

Brief Fact Summary.  ,, -"  <,<  "" ,  "
@,,A- 0 $"( 0   , <,<    
      ,,     0    0 "" 
 ,  " " , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ,     " " ?   0 "" 
 - ( " , !  @( " A"   "    
 " 0 :  ,   , -         , 
 "  "  ,  :  ,   

Facts.     "(   , ,,  ""  "(
  11" 0     "(   ,,     0 
,  " " ?   0 ""   ,,   
 (( ,       "(-  ' ,   "(  
 0"( ,,  " 

Issue. ë    " 0 ,  ,  "     
" " ?   0 ""     ((      -
  ,,   "( ,   ,   E

Held. ; - (( ,  " " ?   0 ""    (
,  3-   ( (  =   " 0      , -   0 
""    ?   , 

Discussion. 7  ,  ,   0 ""  -: , " 
=    > :  , 70   -  
 "0 :  ,        ,  "
'     ,  "   :  ,      
 " 0 <   "       <   ,

F   (( ,  (   - 


 ?  "( ((  - (( ,   0 ""  
  ,   <:  (À  -   
<  ,  "      , (  "   
 "   , -     


½,Ac! 70  ,"   À ,  ," c
^nited Building and Construction Trade Council of Camden County v.
Àayor and Council of the City of Camden 

Citation. 46&! 1+@.+4A

Brief Fact Summary. "(  >041L, "( %0 <


, (=      ,  -  0    " " , 
!   ? @  A  0 ""  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    0 ""  (    @  
 A," "00 <   ,  "   "  -  "
  G," G(  0    ," (  0   "( "  -   
G    G,  "0 " 

Facts.  ë , -  ," -3   @ë , A(   
(=      41L,"     ,,-! 70 
 ,"  @,,A 0       0 
""  - 0 " 0 <"     - 
ë ,      0 ""  @A((    @A
 (  "    "(   @A (  
  " 0 <        <,<     

Issue. ë      " " ,  ?   0 
""  E

Held. ; -   0 ""  (     ," "0
0 <   ,@A  "   G," G(  0 @   
"( " A@ A   G    G,  "0 " 

Discussion.    <(    "0      


  0 ""   -"   "     "   
 G," G(  0 @    "( " A -"   "     
 G    G,  "0 " 

F -       ,"   0 -    , -(,
        0 ""  

F  -  (( <      "  -


 -  0    0  


½,Xc! 70  ,"   À ,  ," c
c
((   ( 0  8<,<      ( 
' (,   0 ""  (  


½,c$  7  2" "" ,Àc
Lester Baldwin v. Fish and Game Commission of Àontana 

Citation. 4#6!#)@.)+A

Brief Fact Summary. À   > 0 , ,0,<,<   
 ,, -$  7     @,, A 0   
,, 0     0     0 ""  , 
!   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   -"( 0 , ,<,<     
0-     G," 0G  (   
  0 ""  ,  

Facts.  ,,     À"( 0 0, <,<    
       0  " -((  %<0-   )Q"  
'(   ,        ,,   À   
  0 ""  ,    "(       
:  ,"         ,

Issue.      "( 0 ,    (
G," 0GE

Held. 3-         0   
," 0  (     0 ""  ,  
8  (  G(  0 GG"" G 0(   , 3 
0   -"    :  -       >

Discussion. %  00" 00       0 


     "  (( , " À       0 
""  ,  À  - > ,( (  0"  
   ,   0, !  3<     ( ,"  
 "%   ( 0 0 , 

½0.c( " ,3 "(   * ( c


Supreme Court of New Hampshire v. Kathryn A. Piper 

Citation. 4)1! )4@.+&A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  -À * ( @((  A-  ,3 
"(  -  ( 3 "(   - ((     
(( - ( " ,3 "(  @(( A-   3 "(    
   (    ((  "       0   
  0 ""  ,  " " ,  @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  (( (  G," 0G   


   ,  0   "  3 "(   
 "     (  ?  =  

Facts.  ((     ,5 " ( 3 "(  - 
  3 "(     ( 3 "(  
( , - 4 , 3 "(  ( "   ( " 
 ((     ( " ,3 "(   0     0 
    0 ""  ,  " " ,  

Issue.   ( ,G," 0G  , (     
" " ?   0 ""  E

Held. ; - ( ,G," 0G  , (     


" " ?   0 ""  

Dissent. 0 /" > @ > A     %  ( , 
    ,      ,,  ," (  > ,   
       0   , (       
    "0   ( 3 "(    "%  (,
    3 "(        , "0       
      " " ?   0 ""  

Discussion.  ( ,    "    , (  0 (  
   " " ?   0 ""  8<,<     
 ,     " %   0(("  (( 
(  G," 0G (   "0     

@A       , ,,    " @ A  "0 <
         (  ?  =  

 ( " , !  @( " A        ((
3 "(  ? = ,,  3 "(      G    G
,  "0   ((   -
½0½c( " ,3 "(   * ( c
 "    "(      (  ?  =  
½0,cc
c
CHAPTER †. The Structure Of The Constitution's
Protection Of Civil Rights And Civil Liberties 
½00c7 À  ,7" c
Barron v. Àayor and City Council of Baltimore 

Citation. # !@)A 4#@+##A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,-7@,,A-,    ë , -  ,


7" @ë , A,%0 ((  "(   , ,
" " , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  7,0  ((   0 " - 
  0 " 

Facts.  ,,   ë ,      ,  0  " 
"%0  ,    ,,"   % ((  
= "(   , %0  , ," " ,  

Issue. ë  ," " ,  (( 0 " E

Held. 3  À @À A0, ( " , !  
@( " A   ,"     " "  , !  
 @ A((     0 "      
,"   -  " "  ((  " H1, 
 (   '   ,  (  0 " / 
( ,  0 " "  ,  ((    - ( " 
 ,  0:  À  - " "   "  % 0,
 (  ((      -     ,    
 ?    ( " = 

Discussion.     0 , ,  0 "      
    (  " "      00 
  "  , ,  0 "     - " "   
 00 0 ((    

½0-c0 <  @7  ?7    ,3 8      $ %$0
0 < "( Ac
Slaughter-House Cases (Butchers' Benevolent Association of New Orleans v.
Crescent City Livestock Landing and Slaughter-House Company) 

Citation. +#!@6/A#6@+)#A

Brief Fact Summary. 7   0    ,  0 0"( 
( 0  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    " "  , !  
 @ A((  ,"     " " (   
(  0 "" ,-  :  (

Facts. +6.-$ ( 0 0"(   3 8   0  


      $ %$00  "(  7  ?
7    ,3 8  0       
" "  ,       " ( -   " >( 
 0  (  0 "" 

Issue. ë   " "  ,  "%  7,0 
((     E

Held. 3 ( " , !  @( " A    
" " ,  (   (  0 "" ,-  -
:  (-   > -ë  -  0 ""  ,
" " "    ,    , (  0 "" ,  
:  (   0(( ,  ( < /" "    
" " ,    "   " ,,  - ,, 
," 0   ,0 "  " "    ("0    
,"     (  ," (   ,  0 " 

Dissent.    (  @ A     :  ,   :  ,
 !   (  

Discussion.   " " ,  ((       
" " ,    0 (   ,   ," "
 -0  @ , " " ,  0 0   0  A
 " "     0  "   0  , %  - " "   
,    0   00  G3  "%  ,   
 0  (  0 "" ,:  , !  G,   " 
( : ,  0   ?  0 -  ,   
00 -   (       (   (  0 "" ,
 :  , !  - :  , 

½0c0 <  @7  ?7    ,3 8      $ %$0
0 < "( Ac
  , ,      0 ""  
 -G :  ,       (  0 "" ,:  ,
    G  (  ," 0 

F 0 "   ,,  (  0 "" ,:  , 
!   " 0,  " " ,  

F -  :0 ë   ,  " " , 
 -  "(  $ ( ,, ?  
    ( ,((  


½0*c :  c
Saenz v. Roe 

Citation. & 6!4+.@...A

Brief Fact Summary. ,(    ,   ,    
 ,,  " (    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. !    0 ""  , !  
 @ A- " (    "   ,       
    

Facts. ,  "0  ,   , ,:   ,,


  "   , ,"  ( "        ,
     (  -7  ë @ (  A   " ,
 0   >( 0   ( "  = 
"( " ,    ,((  ,," 

Issue. ë   ( 0   , ,"   ,, 
 "      0 ""  ,  E

Held. ; - ( " , !  @( " A((   ? 
 " "   0 ""  ,   ,    ( " 
  "     > "     0    0
  < :   " (  0 ""  =   :    "   -
   ,   =       ?  0"     0" (  
= ,,  " "0 >  0  :  

Dissent.   /" > @ > A

F >  %  ,   0 ""  , 
    ((   ,    ,    
 > , ,O  0,    > " 


Dissent.     " @" A

F" %  "= (( " 0   0 "" 


 ,   ,"    0 < 
 -   -    0 ""  , " 0
" ,    " "   0 ""   
 , 00 


Discussion.   " " ,   
G(    : 
 !  -  =  =   ,- :  , 

½0Ac :  c


!  ,       3   ,   
 0  (  0 "" , :  , !  G 0 >  , 
 (  0   , !         0 
""  (   0  ( " %    
 "    ((    0  : ? 0    > 
,  0   

½0Xc0 3   c


Twining v. New Jersey 

Citation. !)+@.1+A

Brief Fact Summary. 3   ? ( 0= " ,   ,   
,"" , ? ,  ,   0    " " ? ë 
  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  (   , 7,0 " ((   0
  " " ? ë   -, (       ,  ( 
,

Facts. 3   (  = "      " , ? , 
 ,   " 0 0 3     , ,   (  
  00 "(   ,<" ë , -0@ë , A-
 0     ë      0 ""  ,
  " " , !   @ A

Issue. ë   " " ,  "%  00  ,<"
((    E

Held. 3-(   , 7,0 " ((    ,  (, ë  
,$

Discussion.   ' "(,""(   "    7,0 - 


   ,   0      ?    3 
  -     0    ë ,    "(  
 " - ,<"-  ,  ( ,

F0(   , 7,0  ((    , (   
 (  ë   ,  " " , 
 - 0, ,<" 


½0cë $ c
Duncan v. Louisiana 

Citation. #.!4&@.6+A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , -ë@ë , A 0  "(     
  =  ë , "     ë  ,$

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  '" " , !   ? @ A
0  ," 0 ((     (   
" " ,  ? ë   

Facts.  ë ,  0  "  " , "(    - (   
(  ( N#11,  ë ,  >  =    
 $  (   ,(  ( " ,  
ë , "   ,=     " " ë   

Issue. ë   " " ? ë   "%  '" " 0
= ((    E

Held. ; - '" " 0=  ((     ( " 
, !  @( " A  ," 0=  '  
" (    (  (  (( ,=  ( 
 ,  0  :  ((  "(-    =0 
 -   (  "  0 ,     -
 (  "  '  (0  ( 0(  " 
  ,=    , =( ,   
%   0,  "'""(           =0 
 "( À  -       0   (    
" 

Concurrence.   07%@7%A  /"ë0 @ë0 A 


      " " "%    7,0 ((  
   0=  %       '( " 
(  (    7,0   ((G   (G  % ( 
=0 G,""0 00(    7,0    " " 
, 7,0 ((    G

Discussion. !   " " ,  -  " G (  
(  ,, -  -((   ( ,G7   =  ," 
  " ,=   (     " " ? ë    
( ((    

½-.c  0 


!    c
The Civil Rights Cases: ^nited States v. Stanley 

Citation. 1.!#@++#A

Brief Fact Summary. 8  ,      (  , "00 
,"  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. !   " " , !   
@ A-0    ( (  ( 0 " (  
:  

Facts.  3 -""   -  0  , 0( ( ,
     - 0  , ( (  
   ë ,     ,  0 ,+)&@ A-
 =   (     , > = " , -(  (-
   ( ," " "( 

Issue. ë   " " ,  @ A(  " 
(  :  E

Held. 3-  " " ,   (   - 
 :  0  " " ,  - ( 0
 0-  0 (  :  - 0 0 G 0 ,   G ,, 
0  " " ( 

Dissent.   @A%  0  %  


 , ,,   " "   ((  

Discussion.   " " ,  (    

F  " " ,  0 0  (  ,  
" " 0(((  0 

F  " " ,   0 0  ( 
 0 (  0 


½-½cÀ   "c
Àarsh v. Alabama 

Citation. # 6!&1@.46A

Brief Fact Summary. À -  ? / -   , ( 0,  "(0
    0   (     "

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (     % 0 "   ( ," ( 
,   =  !   @ A

Facts. (  %  "     


 ,    (  ' (, , 2,( 0(   
( ( À -  ? /      ( "    
,   -À    ( " ,      %À  
  0  0 "? < ( 0  

FÀ " (( 0         
" "  ,  


Issue.    ((  (     E

Held. ; -(( -    % 0 "    ( " , 
!  @( " A,  0: ,%  "(  <
 ( 0     ( "  ( ,   (  
   "  (  "  À 0- (((  ((  
 0  '(  %  (  " 

Discussion.  "  (  ( ((   ( - "    
((    -    % -   (  ,   (  
 , ((  @ A (    - = ,  0," 
    , - "?  "( À  

½-,c%  À ( c


Jackson v. Àetropolitan Edison Co 

Citation. 4.!#4&@.)4A

Brief Fact Summary.    -% @  A- " ,  ( -
À ( "( @ ( A-"   ( ( ," ( 
,  ,  ,,      0(  
 " " ? ë   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ,(             
  ,,    '       0 

Facts.   (  (    ( '      


     "   0   ? " -ë -(  
  ( , ë  ,    -     (   " 
       -   "    %  "( , 
       -    (( ( 0   ,  -
 -  (  ,,    

Issue. ë  ( ,  (  (     E

Held. 3-  "   ,,    '       0 
,    =   " " , !   
@ A         =    '      0 
      (  ( ,"0( ,    
"(     ,     

Dissent.   0À @À A      (  "( -
  '     0         (( "  (  ,    

F :((   0"%  

F    '          ( 

F -   ((   "(  


Discussion.      (   "" ,"  " " , 
   -  0     ( ,   0 
(  "( -     0     - 0    
   "  ( ,   %%,    ,,    ' 
    0   , (  "  ,    
,   ,

½-0c%  À ( c


c
1c  (  "( -  "   

F  ( ( ,"  ( ,@   ,   A- 
 "%  

F 0 "  0  -  0  -      
  "      


½--c   " c
Terry v. Adams 

Citation. #4&!46@.&#A

Brief Fact Summary.  ë , -  ë " @ë , A- ' 
" "      ë ,     000  ,(( , 
, " " , !   @ A   ë , 
  " " ,   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (  ((   " ,     000
  -  "%0  =  , " " ,  

Facts.  ë ,      , ' (0:(  % 
((  ë , ? " "     ë ,   ( <
(" ," ,,   - ë , ?  <      
"  ë "("    ,,    , ë , 
 "  (( , (   '  % ," 0 ( 
 , " " ? ""     - 0 ,  ë , 
0    (      0      
:      "  , À  - ë , 0  , 
" "   0  ((  G ,<0 0   G 
,, -0(,3 0   @,, A- 0   "  0  
 , " " ,  

Issue. ë (  -  ,-(  , , " " E

Held. ; -(  0: ("     ( ,

Discussion.    ë ,    ,  (( , , 
" "  ""     ë ,     
     , ë , ? ("    (,   
  " 0    - (  % , 0  ,   ,, ,
 =

½-c   3 c


Evans v. Newton 

Citation. #+ ! .6@.66A

Brief Fact Summary. (  , ,  0  7@  A
 (%À-2 0      (    0  
 >  ,  " " , !   
@ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 8( 0(% ( ,  , -     = 
  " " ,  

Facts. !(  -    À-2 0    (%,


     "   -7,À0        
"   (% (%   (     3 0     
  0   ,  0 0( (% ë ,  - 
À0  ," 7,À0  @ë ,  A   "        
,,    ?    0       (( (  
     ' ,3 0 ," (% ,, -0(,3 0 
@,, A-    00  ,  " " ,  ? >
(  

Issue.  ( 0(%( ,  ,   =    " " ,
  E

Held. ; - %( (   '   ( 0(% ( ,

Discussion.   -    (% ' ' "(  ,  ( (% 
   0 " (  ( ( "%  < - "   
"  /  ,"( " ,"     -  0
(    "  (%," ( (   

F% (  "(       "" À    


   ( "


½-*c"0" "( !$&.1 $05 :-c
Amalgamated Food Employees ^nion Local 590 v. Logan †alley Plaza, Inc 

Citation. #.!#1+@.6+A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((0     " "  ,"(  , (% 0
    ((0    ( ,   0(%  ,, <   
 0   ' -"0 ( ,  " " 
 0 ( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ((0     ( ,  , -  


" " , !   @ A(( 

Facts.  ,,-$05 :-@,,A ( " (  


/  ( "% @/  A  /   "(   "(   ë , -
"0" "( !$&.1@ë , A-(%     ( (%(
   (% 0      -     "   ,0  
( (%(      ,""   = (% 0   
((0      ,""        ,,? 
((  0  ë , ?   ,(% 0 "(   "( ,/  
=    ( " ,,"  =     
(% 0  (  ,,? ((  

Issue.  (     ((0     ( -   


" " ,  (( E

Held.  ( " , !  @( " AÀ   "-# 6!&1
@.46A- (  ((  "  "       ( ((  , 
" "  ((  ( " 0:  (   ((0  
 " -     %  À  ( "    "  
((0   (  (  -     , (  - 
 " "  , (    '    " " 0 ( , -
    '    " " 0 ,((     
((     -    "(          0 
 " "  ( (  ,    " , ((     

Discussion.   ,(% 0(  ( - ( , (   ((0


  - (     " " ,   "  (   
((  ,(  - "   ? 0  " "   0 ,  

½-Ac$ (  c


Lloyd Corp. v. Tanner 

Citation. 41)!&&@.) A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( - @ ( A,   -   ,  
" ((   0 "" 0( 0 5 "/ ,

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    " "  , !   
@ A"  -(  ((      ((      
( ((  =    (      ((  ,   (( 

Facts.    -$ (-$@,,A-  ' ""   ((0"
0 0 ,,        %   "
    0  (  -    ( (   
, 0   ,,  @  A "( " 83 " 4-.6+-
 ( &      " 0  0  " ((   
  >   ,  -  " "(   -"
   (      ( 0      , 
( "  (  >   , ( "  0  0   ," ( 
 %     0 "

Issue. (     ((0"(    ,,   
 ? , ", ( 0    ,      "? 
(  E

Held. ; 

F$05  ,  ,"    (% 0$05 


   G     ((     ((0  
((    0(G

F ,0 " ,((  0 , (     ? 
 " "  0  G    ,""
' G


Discussion. (  "  '  , ", ( 0 0  (    
  ,    -(      > (  ,", 
'  

½-Xc0   3$   7c


Hudgens v. National Labor Relations Board 

Citation. 4 4!&1)@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary. %0" "  (%  ,,     
 ((0" 0  "0 , "    (%    ,
 ( 0,   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (   ((0"  , >  ,-


  , -    =   > "  ,  " " , !  
 @ A

Facts. 7    %    %   (%    
 8 ,      3ë * ((0  -
     -0  @  A,  (%    "0, ,
- 0  "0 ,  ((0        %    , 
  

Issue. (   ((0"( (% 0,    " "  , ( E

Held. ; 7   ((0"  , >  ,-"   
" " 0        ,  ( 

Discussion.  "=    0,$05     0,$ 


"" %% ,  "-   ,   ,
-     (  <   (     
    " "  

½-c   * " c


Shelley v. Kraemer 

Citation. ##4!@.4+A

Brief Fact Summary.   ,  0     ( 0
<  ,"0( 0 (, "8      
(( -  @(( A-,<" - ,    "0
     ,   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  , " ,(  0 "    

Facts. .-$ -#1  0    0&)


(   "" 

F  0 0 "  ( ,  '&1   , (   
  G ( ( , 3 0À0 G " ,<
" ,"  & -   ++ 

F80 -.4&- (( - ,  -( ( , 


,":0 

F ((  -* " @((  A- 0  %     ((  
  (  0(  "  


Issue. ë = , " ,(   " 0 " "  E

Held. ;  "" ,50  @++1A- ( " , ! 
 @( " A    " 0 ,,  0  0 
= 

Discussion.  ( "           
ë  " "" " "- 0     , " ,
""   = 7-        ,"
(    000   "  , ,0 " 0 "  
0  (      "% " (   0 "    
 - ( "   " ((    

½.c$0 " 8c


Lugar v. Edmondson Oil Co. 

Citation. 4&)!. @.+ A

Brief Fact Summary.  (( -$0@(( A-  ((  -" 8
@((  A"  (  (( ," ( 0, ((   , ( 0 
  - ((  ,  '( (    ,, '  ( =0" 
"  (( ? ((  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  G,   G    @A    
'  ,0      @ A   ,"     (   

Facts.  ((   <( ,% (   (( - ((  
" 

F   ( "  ((  ,  '( (       
 , (( "0  ((   ( 0  

F   0  ( =0" ,"      ,,
'  7- (( " ( , ((  

F 0  ,  "   "    , 
"  <, ,   - =0  "  " 
, ((  ? ,      0   0 , " 

F ((   >     ((   0 0= 
   % ((   ( , 


Issue. /  (  (  ?    0   , 0 "   
     E

F  " , ( =0"    ,"  '  ,0
(  0  0      E

F  ((  G  GE


Held.  , ( " , !  @( " A,  -
<( "    ,  -  ( "      '  , " 0
(  0       - ,"(     - (  ," 
   (    - ( 0   ( "       ,
0  ,,- 00  0 0 0,   ,"  ,,-
           

½½c$0 " 8c


c
1c;    '( (            , (0 
 , 

F; G(  ( ? =((  ,,   : ,((   


,,  : (  ?  ?,(( , 4
" " GG=((G  >  " 0" 
 %0 ,  ,, %  0 ,   ? (  


Discussion. 7   ((    (       (,   ,,-  
     ?  ?   ,,      (   ,< (
(,  - ((     ,  ?  ?

½,c"  $    c


Edmonson v. Leesville Concrete Co. 

Citation. &11!64@..A

Brief Fact Summary.  (( -" @(( A- =    
0 0   "( - ((  -$    @((  A-  
ë ë0  - ((   ,  ( "(  0  ' 
%(    (    % ,((  
   00  "N+-111"0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. '  0(  "(  0   (  ,",  
 (  

Facts. ((   %  =  =  %0,((  
((   0((  , 00  -"0 "(  %("
0   >(" ë0  - ((    ,#(  "(  0 
'  %(   ," = ((  >   '(,  '  
 <  7- !  ë , /  ë ,$    
 >      

Issue. À (  0   ( "(  0  ' =   
 E

Held. 3

Fë "0    ,     "  


", ( =    >( 0 , =

F7    ,((    ( "(  0  "
 "   -0 $0 -  


Discussion.  "= ((  <(    $0 '  0
7  * % @.+6A 0  -(  "(  0     
'   ,"  -  , -  7-  - ( " , 
!  @( " A(       "    
0 " 
@A '    0 "    O@ A  
  ( ,"00 " ,-@#A   =   
00     

½0c7 /"0%0 c
Burton v. Wilmington Parking Authority 

Citation. #6&!)&@.6A

Brief Fact Summary. ,,  (- 0 "  (%000 - , 
  (( -7@(( A- "(      %

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (     "    G " G  (
'         -   ,    (  (  

Facts.    , " (    0 " ((  0 
,, (( -   (%000  (    ((  -
/"0-ë  %0 @((  A   (( , ((   
(   > (%0, , (  ,  , (%0
, > - ((     ""   ( (    0 
.&+- (( (%   00 (     ,, ,, 
((     ("(  ,      ,  

Issue.    ,0 " ((    E

Held. ; 

F  "  ,  0    "(   ,"


0 " ,  ((    (     , 

F ,, ((      ,,"     0  (%0


00   " "          ,,    ," 
 ?  "    , -G "   (G '  -   
 G   (  ( -((  ( 0   " 
 "G

F/      ((   " (   -  4
" " , !   @ A((  ,  
     0 " 


Discussion.  ((  ,,"  , ,, ((  %0  0
       ,, ((  "  '  , ((   ",
0 "  0 "  "     "  ,0   ,"   (
7       "  G 0(G, 00     0
 ,  , ((  -       =  " , 
4" " ,  

½-cÀ $0 31)   c


Àoose Lodge No. 107 v. Irvis 

Citation. 41)!6#@.) A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  -  @((  A- >      $>7
 %  (( -À $0 ? @(( A->  ((  "    
 ,        -(( ?  ,   " G  G

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 7 0       "  (  
  

Facts.   ,=   , 4 !H.+#

F((  (       08  " "  
0   ( "  ( " 

F((   0   0>  -     0 ((  


 >  , 4" " , !  
 @ A,    " " "  (( 


Issue.     ,    (    - 0  (  
 E

Held. 3  0   "  ,      $>7 


,,  "(      " 0 ( , (( "% G  
G

F $>7( (   0 ,0  ? 


" "  (0 ( 

F   ,>  0     " 0 


"  0(( ,-( -   > ,,  
     , -    "   (   ( 
,((       7


Dissent.   /"ë0 @ë0 A    =    0
À @À A    ,(( "     
,  0   "   >  "(  " 

F    0   "    >0     
     <          
 0"%  " 0  "= 


½cÀ $0 31)   c
c
1c   0  "    ,-"( '>  " " , 
 -  , 0    ," ,>   
  , %  >           ,
     -  ,((     


Discussion.  "=   '((         ((
 (       0  "   
   (  "% (      =  > 
 

½*c3  c


Norwood v. Harrison 

Citation. 4#!4&&@.)#A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  -ë  3  @((  A-  (  ,
,    00   ,À  ((?  ' % 0(0" 
" (0" 0  " ( 0 ' %    
(  - 0 0   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  >  , !   
@ A      (      ,(  - 0 0   
  0   "

Facts.  " ,(    À  ((         " 
 0 0

F   ,À  (( ## <(0"(  ,  ' % 
   ( (      (0" 0- " ,
 (    0    

F ((  -  @((  A-"   " (  


   (      >     (  ( 
 

F ((  ,   ,,    À  (( =
  ' % 0(0" ((  0   (( 0  ' % 
  0 0 (    -       ((0 0 0 
- ,   ?  0 ,  0 0 
 

F  ,  0(0"    


Issue. ë   , (0"  ,  ( (       > -
   " " ,   "(    " , (    
   " "  ( E

Held. ;  ( " , !  @( " A,    ( -
 ( "  =   0     0  " 
(     ( " ,  ' % 0(0" 0  
0  ' % 0(0" ,",0  -,   -  , 
 (     ((   " '       0 
 , (0"  " -  (    -  ,, , 
      " -  , - , >  , 
  ( "   G ?   0 > 

½Ac3  c


  - ,( 0   ",  0 0   -  ,0 0
0,  (     "G

Discussion.   (        "( ,    , 
(      0 7  (( 0    "  - 0 "  
 0 ( , 0 0>         ,, 
  ,     "

½Xc  <7%  *c


Rendell-Baker v. Kohn 

Citation. 4&)!+#1@.+ A

Brief Fact Summary.    -  <7% @  A- 0       , 
," (     , (,"  (  
     , ,      ,"

Synopsis of Rule of Law.       "(    (      
( ,

Facts.     (       ,,  0 
", (    

F  ( -*@ ( A-  "   , (   
   (    0--  (  " ,"
( 0  

F    ,     À    ,.)   
  (  ,  ,      ( ,  ,
.1RL,  ? ( 0 0 

F.))-   ,   ( ,    < ,, % 
"%00     (0,.)+-,       , ,
0    ?  ,   ((0 ( ?  " 

F     (  (% 0 " , (  ,    
     (  ((  "  ,   &
    (     00,"


Issue.  (   ?  " ,  ,,       "= , 
  ? (      E

Held. 3    0      "(  ,      
 00 0  (  ,     0     - ( ,
(   "     ,   "    0     
 ( ((       

Dissent. 7       " , , ,"        0 -
  '  '         -  ? "       
      (      ,  "   ( 
0 "      (  

½c  <7%  *c


Discussion.   ( 0,0  0  ( 0 0     
0     (     "(   
"  0 "  ,     ,    '  , 
  "%  (  "0 "    

½*.c7" ;  % c
Blum v. Yaretsky 

Citation. 4&)!..@.+ A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -;  % @ ( A- À  (  
 ,  ," 0"   ,    , ,    
  0" ? :  ""  (  0   ,   
, 0 ,    ë   , 4" " , 
!   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.              "(   
        

Facts. À  (    0"   (,   ,3 ;%, " 
( , 0   

F   0  >   0,    :  


"" @!A,(  (    (  ,((( 
( ( " 

F !"   (        , ,
  0"  ,  (   , 

F.)& !   (    ,     
, ( 0   ,  (   ,   
  ,,"   0 0    


Issue. ë     0" ""  , À (  
,    ë  0    E

Held. 3       (  " =0" "  (  (  
,    (  = 0   ,  "%     (   , 
   ,  (          ,    
 ?  0 = ( " 0 

Dissent.  "=   "(,  (  " "  :0 ,        
   ( " , (  -   =  0  "  , "  
  0  G" =0"  G (   0  0 -    
 0"        (  , ,   

Discussion.  "= (     ,  '" ,  "0    
  (       ,


½*½c7" ;  % c
c
1c7 0  =    0  (    -

F    (   ,(        '    ( 
 (   0, 0 " ,   -

F (      '  (   G   '  ( 0 
,   G


½*,c " À% c
Reitman v. Àulkey 

Citation. #+)!#6.@.6)A

Brief Fact Summary.    ,,( ( 4( 0 0 " ,"
 , 0  ,(   "      (( ,
((    (  -ÀÀ À% @ (  A-     - "
@  A-   && , , , , 0  "(" 
   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   '   (( ,   0   0 
 "

Facts.   (    ("    =      -(  


   ,   "   (   "(   (" -HH&
& , ,  (  (    ,  >    ,
 >"" - 0 -, -(  0 -         " 
,  %      (   -  (   0= 
  ,"0 0    

F( 4 (  ,   ,   (  ,  
"(0    ( 4       ,
, 0   ,  (  (  ?  
 " 0     0  0((  

F  ,( 4 , (   (   0 ,
" ( ((  

F   " , "" =0" 0 ( 4


   HH&& , ,    
0    ?  "" =0" " ,( " 
 ( 4       >( ,  
0    " " , !   
@ A


Issue. ë( 4        "   0"% E

Held. ;  ( " , !  @( " A,,"  0, 
,( " 

F (       (   " 


  0  0 "  "" ,"  
 0   -  , -      


½*0c " À% c
c
1c ( "   ,-  0 (  0  
, , (( ( ,  -     0 (  
 "


Dissent. ( 4 ,   "-    ,  = 
% ( , %   (      G(    
  ,  ((  ,, G "= ?       

Discussion.   0   =  ( 0 ' 0< "   ,, 
 "% (   0 "      0 "   - 
    00   % ( 

½*-c7  "        c


Brentwood Academy v. Tennessee Secondary School Athletic Assn. 

Citation. &#! ++

Brief Fact Summary.  ,      -0 , 00
    ( - "( ,+4L,(      5  
,, (  0   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. GIJ  ?  0   "        
0 (      " ,   ,,    ,  -
   0,, 0     ?     G

Facts.   ( -     @ G ( GA- <,<
(," "  (( 0     (( "0 ( (  
0      ( ? " "   +4L,  ? (   -
.1, "-"( &&(     -GIJ  ?  "%0"  
 0  -   ,  "   0" "  (, 
,  <(  ""  "    ?   0 (( -
  (( - (         " "   - (  
"      (  " 0 0 0  G  ?  
7,@ G7GA.)   , G(  '(  ? 0I0J? 
  ? 0: (    0      ( 
= 0    ((       ?G 7 
 ((      0 ((   " 0 0
 0  (( ..6-  ( (  ,0  "  (

G 0:I0J   ,((       ,I  J
0    "( -G G:I0J (   , 
   "" "  (I  JG "   " ,"..)
( 00    -7  " @ G  GA-(  ( 
" " ,  (    ( ,      
 '  0G ,  G 0  (    (   
  -      00   ,   
" "  , !   @ G GA

Issue. GI/J      (  0     "( 
"0( (      "   0   000   
,  0 " "  GE

Held. ; GIJ  ?  0   "        0
 (      " ,   ,,    ,  -   0
,, 0     ?     G

½*c7  "        c


c
1c  ë  @G GA-0, "= - 0:   
  ( (               - "= 
 0: G,  " "    ( -IJ "  
"(     ( ( ( 0  ," 0 " 
0: -  ,     (  0:   
   " "  ,   ( ," G >  -G  
"  ,,-0 ,-    ?  '     
  0 ? "0 (    ?"  ,    , 
  ,?G

F      ,  ( " , !  @ 
G( " GA  '"   " ,  >   '  '   , 
   0   G  ,"  ?  '  ,?  ( -?G
G   (  ? 0, 0 " -    -?GG 
(  (   ?,((=     
0  IJG    ,  G" (    K 
  ?0  ,  ?G-G     0 ( , 
  GG  ?  0 " ( -? 0 "  
?  I J"0 " ?G

F "=   '" I  0 !  J 0: GI J  ,,
  3-   " "  (-   0 ,   - 
  0:?  3   0  <
"G -  0: ,"I0 !  J0  (( 
 ,  , G  -, - ,,  , I ? J
" "  (      ,     "  -" ,
 "(        "    0G

F(( 0I0 !  J  -  0: +4L,(   
   " "  ,  (  G "-  ' ,+4L,
 " "  (-   0:,(    (    
,, 0 ,,( (   0  " ,  
(  0G -GIJ    0:   - 0
0  - (  ,, -"    
  "0 ( ,"  (  "      
'  , ( " G


Dissent.     " @G" GA,  0(  
/" > @G > GA-  @GGA   
*   @G*   GA= "   -GIJ   ,    (
"  ?  " ?! -  ,(  0:?      
   0:( ," ( ,O   -  - 0   
0 " O 
½**c7  "        c
"   ( 0 "  "= ? 0<<     
  ? @A , " ,  0    << 
'    <   ( "   "     (  ",
 , "   " ( G
F" , 0 0   ,  (    " 
 G,       G     
  (  (  0:0"  0     
G    '  ( ,,  G -
   G '    ( (    0,
0 " I J-    G     -
G "   (G  '        ( 
 


Discussion.    0 0:   0  G  " G  
"=        ( , -   G, "= ?  
 "   ( ,   -,, " 0: ,    -
,  - (  '"( "00  <<=   - 
      0 -" " -" -"0  -,   -
  0 -   "  "  '  0:  "( ,-
  -( ,, (   -  , ,0  -( " -   - -
 G

½*Acc
c
CHAPTER †I. Economic Liberties 
½*Xc0  $ c
Allgeyer v. Louisiana 

Citation. 6&!&)+@+.)A

Brief Fact Summary.   "(    ((   ,,  -
$ @,,A: ,     ," 3 ;%- 
,, 0    ,,   ,,  ?  (  
, 0  "( ,"0      ,   (  
 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   "  0      (  :  ,
  0   ë   , !   @ A

Facts.  ,,     ( 0, 0( ,"0
   ,,  -  ( ,   : 0  
 

FÀ  "( ,3 ;%@A   ( 


 ((    ,,    ," 3 
;%    = , ,,  

F  ,,, 0    ,,   
:   -   "   0    
,,   , ,,  ?  

F ë , -0 @ë , A-(  , "  "   
( ,"  0  (( ,"3 8   ë ,  
  , 0 ,,  ?  ( ,  $ 
(  ë , ?  


Issue.    #6, $     ,  " " ,
  E

Held. ;       (   ( ,  (  
 ,,0     "G  G ë   
"  G 0, :  ,   = " , , O ,  
 ", O %   O     ,0O
(   %  -,((    "  
(( -      0  ,  ((   
"  G  "((  0 ,    ,: ? 0
   " , 

½*c0  $ c


Discussion.    ( " , !  @( " A  :  
(  ","  (, :   (   " (0
(   ( (7- 0   "    
 ?    ( "  ,     0

½A.c$  3 ;%c


Lochner v. New York 

Citation. .+!4&@.1&A

Brief Fact Summary.    -$ @  A-   ,"  " ,
0 3 ;%    "  " ,  % % %  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   "  ,  (  ? 0,  - ,
 ,           0" ((    ( ,(  -
,   , 

Facts. 3 ;%(   "  " ,  % %" 
61(  %-1 (    % "   ( " 
  ,"  " 

Issue.     ?  ,    % ? 0"%  0 "0 " , 
%  % ,-    -(((  '  , ( ( E

Held. 3       0, , 0   ,(  0-


  "0   % %

F 0(    (,   (    4
" " , !   @ A

F7% ?  (   (  ,  0"%0 ,   , 


  % 

F   (   ( ( ,      
   (    , %  


Dissent. 7       (((  '  ,   ? ( ( - 0 
(   ,   ",0 % 

F  8 " @" A 0    ,,G  G 
      00 ,  " (   , 
%  ( 0 '   0% % 

F  @A-  7 / @/ A-  ë @
ë A,  0"  ,0 (, (( ,
( 0(  ?    %     ,0 %  
  (  "  "    ,  %0 
  


½A½c$  3 ;%c
Discussion.  "=  :      ,   (  ? 0
  0   %  ((  (  %  "  
"(  (  "(  %  , "   -
 %   ((  0   ' "  ,0 

½A,c((0  *  c
Coppage v. Kansas 

Citation. #6!@.&A

Brief Fact Summary.    -((0 @  A- ,0 , 0 *  
 (   "(  ," %0 "( = "" " , 
 , "( " 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   (  ,"    ,   (  ? 
, "  , ë   , 4" " , !  
 @ A

Facts. .1#- *   0  (  0  0  :,
"(  (   "(  ,""%0=  ( "( ?  , 
= (( 

Issue.   (  "( ,""%0 "( "  ( ? 
  " " E

Held. 3"( "      "  0 " 70( 
  0 "   "( " ?<?,     -  "(  
   ,  "( " ," "  ( "    ( ,,  

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A    ,
(   ( "( " -  ,0,"=0 ,00( 
, "7  "(  "(  ,     (  , 

½A0cÀ  8 0c


Àuller v. Oregon 

Citation. 1+!4 @.1+A

Brief Fact Summary.    -À @  A- ,0 , 08 0  
 "   0, % ,"  , 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0  0 (    !   
@ A-       

Facts. .1#-8 0(   "0  "%= 1 ,  
  "(  -, " ",    0,  -G 
( 0:," - " , -  0 , 
 "  , " G

Issue.      "0  0,"? %  E

Held. ; /" -% " -  (  ,%   (     
   ? ( ( (   , 0  (    (  <
0,"  (" (,  ,, (0

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A , "   
 0(     ( ,"?        
,     (  % ,"      " , ((
/"  "(  "( "(   "(      
 

½A-c%   ?  (c


Adkins v. Children's Hospital 

Citation. 6!& &@.+#A

Brief Fact Summary. .+- ë ," (       """
0 ,"  -   ,  0  " 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  , ""       ' (
"   '      ( (  ,  

Facts.  ë ," "( ( "(  ,0 "(  " 
%  (   " """0 

Issue.   ,'0,"""0 , "  E

Held. 3 (((  "? , ",      
   > (( " ( " ,"""0 (   
  "(  "(         

Discussion.    ,   0    ?  0, , " %  ( " 
, !  @( " A '(   0: " "   " 
0"(    " ( "           
  " >  """0   "( , -  0,
   "     0 0  ( , %  ,,
" %  

½Ac/   " 7 c


Weaver v. Palmer Bros. Co. 

Citation. )1!41 @. 6A

Brief Fact Summary.  " (  ( (    ,   
, ,",   ((  -" 7 @((  A- ", ,",  
  "  ,  0    

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ",0, "   ,    


 0        (     ,  (0
( 

Facts. ((  ",   #"",   ,)&1-111 , 


 

F  "( ,((0  , " ,"0  " " 


    " , 0"    0 

F 0 "        " (    ,
 ( ( ",    ( , ,,0

F ,          "    :( 
( ,"   ,",0


Issue. ë  (  , 0  ,  ",     !  
 @ AE

Held. ;        "  , (   " 0
 :-         

Dissent. ,  0     ( ,   0 0   ,   
(  (  ", ,",  -  = , ( 0  ,
 

Discussion.  (          ?   ,
 0   "       ,  ,  

½A*c3  3 ;%c


Nebbia v. New York 

Citation. .!&1 @.#4A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -3 ;%@ ( A-    """ ( 
,"%   -3 @  A- 0  0     
> ,"%    """

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    , (      "(  "    
(" (  , ( 0    (( 

Facts.    """"%(  .S>7-  -0     -  
> ,#S-  ,   

Issue. ë      0""" ( ,"%    E

Held. 3  (    ( <0   ,"%
(       "  ,( 0G "( ,"  0 
"% G

Discussion.  " (( :0   ,  "


 0     ( "          ,,  (( 
  0-      (  (( ,  0  
 ,(,    00 -   

½AAc/     c


West Coast Hotel Co. v. Parrish 

Citation. #11!#).@.#)A

Brief Fact Summary. / 0    0 """," "  
(( -/   @(( A-( ((  - @((  A-  
"""

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /0  0      ë   ,
 !   @ A

Facts.  ((   "% ,    """,N4&1( 4+<


 %  0    ,,   ( ," (( 

Issue.   ,'0,"""0 ," "  E

Held. ;     %   ?  (

F  '(, ,%     0  00(  


    ,  , %  " , "" 


Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A    0
"  , (   (  ," "0 % 
 0 ,   " -    = , (0  0 ( 
  , "" ,"   , ((0 "   0 %   
"(  ë (   ( " ?   

½AXc!      c


^nited States v. Carolene Products Co. 

Citation. #14!44@.#+A

Brief Fact Summary. . #-0 ( (       (" ,
%"" "%"'  , "%,   ( (  
:   "0( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /     '   ((, "  0 - 
  ( , =  <0   0    0 ,   
  -  '   , (( ,   ( " 

Facts.  ((  -   @((  A-   , ""  (" 
,GÀG  ("( , %"" "%   0  " 
 "% "

F7 , ( 0  0-0      1  ,   0


"'   GÀG( 0  (    , 
((0,  ,  "  


Issue. ë   À%,. #   ë   , &" " , 
!   @ AE

Held. 3    ,,     ((   0,0   ( ,(


 0 (     " ," "% 

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A(  "(   ,   
   "%0,  0    ,"  0 ((,   
  ,,    ,     , 

½Ac/"  $ 8(,8%"-c


Williamson v. Lee Optical of Oklahoma, Inc. 

Citation. #4+!4+#@.&&A

Brief Fact Summary.  8%" 0  (   ( 0( ,",0
(0 0   ( (,"("0 ("  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   0     "   
=        0" 0 "   

Facts.  ë ,8%"   0"0  ' ,(? 


(    !   @ A       
      , , ( ( 

Issue.    "0 ,,( E

Held. ;  ( " , !  @( " A0   ë 
   4" "  %    - 0 ,   
  -   ,,( ,0

Discussion.    '"( ,        ,   
  - ( " (      ,G ((  G0  0  
  "%0(    ,  0 "  ( "  
0   -     , 

½X.c7À/,3" - 2 c


BÀW of North America, Inc. v. Gore 

Citation. &)!&&.@..6A

Brief Fact Summary.    -7À/@  A-  0 "0 -  ,,
        "0   ( -2 @ ( A-( 
  "0     "0 -( N4"( "0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  "0 "  "( ,   ?  0"   
( 0,  0  (  0   G0   '  G

Facts. ..1-  ( (  7À/,N41-111,":   


 ", ."    %          
(  ,"  (   (  ""0    

F-   "  "( (  ( "0 
 0 ((0,  ,  ( '  #L, ?  
 - ( "(        7-,  ,
 (  #L   ,   

F"0  (    " 1L,      '( 
 "  "0     "   "0   
(('"  -111  ","    

F8(( - ( " , ",  ?  (     


 ( "0    "( ,
  , "(  - , "(, "
     N "0 


Issue. ë ,N "( "0  ( ,  '  
 "E

Held. ;   G0   '  G "    @A  0 , (     , 
<   O@A  (    "( "@A ( "0 
 ,,       "    (  : "(  "
 

F <     " ""  ( (  


"   ,  ,    , -  (      


½X½c7À/,3" - 2 c
c
1c ",( "0   &11"  ", ( ? 
"0 C8(    (-&1.!
44#-# )- ( " , !  @( " A
  " ( 4"  "0    0
'  

F     0    ,     ", "



Dissent.  !   @ A 0   ,
         "     ( "  
"     G( "0  ??G

Discussion.      (  :  ,"  (  ( 7 
,        ( "( ,(   0
   

F ( "  (  <(0  "    '  ( 
 "(  0   , ,,  " 
(   0  "  ( " "( ,
   ( "-   ", '    


½X,c "À"     "( c
State Farm Àutual Automobile Insurance Co. v. Campbell 

Citation.  #&#@ 11#A

Brief Fact Summary.    0  ,  - 
(,    "( ,  ,- = - 
(((  -     "(     ",
"(   ( "0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /  :0   ,( "0 -  
0 (  ,"I À    J"  ((  
G@A  0 , (     
,  , ? " O@ A  (    ( " ,,    
(,, ( "0 O@#A ,,      ( "0 
   =   (  : "( "(   G

Facts. /  0 , - "( @GÀ"( GA@    ,    
G"(  GA "( (  '  < 0 7 0 - -À
"(   0 0  , 0     -   
%  ( "     À"(  ,      
  " À"( ?  , (    3   -   -À
"( ?   - "À"    @ G  GA-  
    ,,       ,     ( "  = 
  "(  ?( " N&1-111      "(  G 
     , -   ,  -I "J (  
   -  (  (  G     -
= ,À"(  11L,=0" ,N+&-+4.    
0 " -    , (   ' N#&-+4.   ( " 
 - "(  À"( ((    
"(      , ((    ,      
 ( -0   ,  " 0 À"( -    0
G ,0  "  (     ? 8 (?  G
  8 (    (  ,     (  " , 
 .+.- !( "   À"(  , ? (( - 
"  ,    =0" ë (  " , (( -À"(  , 
,  0    - 00G ,-,- ,, "
  G =   "( ? N 6""(   "0 N4&"
( "0     "(   N" ( 
N &" !( "     ( 

Issue. GI/J  -I   "  J-,N4&"( "0 -


  ,"(   "0  N"-  '   

½X0c "À"     "( c


, ë   ,  " "   , !  GE

Held. ; -    " , N4&"( "0   '   
,  0:    (     " "(   
( "0  ( , GIJ ë   ,  " " 
(   "( ,0   '    ( "  ,  G7 
I À    J-     '"  G0 (  G  0   ,
( "0 
G@A  0 , (     ,  , ? " O@ A 
 (    ( " ,,    (,, ( "0 
O@#A ,,      ( "0    =   
(  : "( "(   G    

F ,    G (     ,  , ? " -G  
  " "(, 0 (   (      =0 G   0
  
 "  (  ((  "O  
 ,,    %   0,   ,  ,  O 
0 , ,    O    (   
    O "   , " -%  -
  -"   G  :  !( " ? 
 "0,   G,  (  , 
   "(  G - "=  0:  !( " 
G ( "0 (       
"(  ?"G  , ( "0  
(   0  "    

F      0 (  , G"(  0< -
( "0  ' G - "=  0: 
GIJ= (   ((       "  - --
( -,   ' 0 0 <0  ( "(   
"0 - 0, 0 -  ,  ( GÀ  -GIJ  ',
  -      ( "(0  4&<
<G  0:  N""(    "(  
"(  - (     "0    ,       "
( 

F ,0 (    G  (    ( "0 
 ? (  : "( "(   ?G 
  -GIJ "      !  , 0 
 "(  ((   N1-111, ,,,-IJ",  
 N4&"


½X-c "À"     "( c
c
( "0 G  , %"(  "%0 
 " 


Dissent.   @GGA,  0( 0    '( 
 G 0(I À   
@ @  J ë   
(     (  0 ? '  ??    ? ,( 
"0 G

F    " @G" GA ,  0(00G 


     : ,( "0  G

F  7 2 0@G2 0GA    0(00


( "0    ( 0 ,   2 0 0: 
GIJ  ,       <( "0  -
"   G -  0 GIJ ?    '    ( 
 30    <=0"  ? 0( "(,
 -?IJ  ?,   ' 0 0 <0  
( "(   "0 - 0, 0 -  ,  ( ?G
  -G= ?  ,  , 0   
 0 "  "0  G


Discussion.   ,,  0 '"( , I À    J,   (( 

½Xc" 709$  7  c


Home Building & Loan Assn. v. Blaisdell 

Citation. .1!#.+@.#4A

Brief Fact Summary.  (( -" 709$ @(( A-  


À (  "00   ,",  0"00 ,( ,<
 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   " "(  0 ,(  (  
    0"     = ,

Facts.  (  ë ( - À  0  (  À À00 
À"$  "    %  ,,",   ( 0  
 ( ( (  ,  "( '   ' (,    " , 
 ( 0 , 

Issue. ë  (      , !   
@ A "(0  0   (  (  E

Held. 3    = ,   "  , ë (  ' ,   
"0(   "   ,    :   ë (  (( 
" 0      À   0   0" 
0 " ((   ,,     0  "    
,, "00   "  '           "( 
( 

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A(   (,
"("     (  ," 02   -  
 ( "  ,  (   7-,   (   ,, = ,
,  ,   @   , 00 "" ,  "   A-  
%    

½X*c 0   2(- *   9$0c


Energy Reserves Group, Inc. v. Kansas Power & Light Co. 

Citation. 4&.!411@.+#A

Brief Fact Summary.    ,*   0  ( ,0     
"% (  0 (  ,"000 (  , ,  
0 "  0 ( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    0 (, '(     
"(" , 0

Facts.    - 0   2(@  A-  ( -


*   9$0@ ( A  ( (, 0   ,,  
 0    ( "0   "

F*  ( ( 0(  ( ,"  0  0 


(  , ,  0 "    ( 


Issue.   (   ,   , !   
@ AE

Held. 3  0 '   ,    " ,0  , - 
*  "(  ?  '(   -     0" 
   0   (         "%  

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A  <( ,
  "0   0 "  ,  (  
@A     
"(" , (   O@ A  "("    0, 0" 
  @#A          0"   (( 

½XAc   ( c


Allied Structural Steel Co. v. Spannus 

Citation. 4#+! #4@.)+A

Brief Fact Summary.  (( -  @(( A-"    
(  (,  "( .)4-À (      7  ,  
@ A( : 0  "(    0,   
(  , "( % ,"( ,  1   "   
((   ,,     , 0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ,   "   -,"    
"(  " ( ( ,   ,   ' 0  (- 
0     '  0    0" ( ( 

Facts.  (( , (  (, "( 0 6&  "(    
   (   >L,  0 "   -"(  " ,  ,
   (  0 "   - "( "  ",,  0
    " 7- "(  ,  "  (  ( " , 
  

FÀ (  >0  "( " 11 "( 


(  (    , -( (  ,00 , ,   
 ,,   "( % ,  1   
"( 

F  "" ,.)4- ((   À ,, 3 , 
"(    0   "( ? (-  % 
, "( ,1  -   0 (( , ,N+&-111 
 


Issue. ë À ?     E

Held. ;         "( ?  0  "(     
", 0 ,0, (  (     -( " ""  
0    ( ( " , !     
,  '(  " , "( ?  0 "( "(   
 '(    (    0" " -   0 
 "  0  :  " (  "

Dissent.   /"7 @7 A0    0 ( 
( ," 0,  0 (    "0(    
 -7      "(   "

½XXc   ( c


 "(  '(     ,  =    >, 
"(         "

Discussion.  "=      ," 709$  7  - .1
!#.+@.#4A- ((       " (   0,= ,,
 , 0  ,    -    " 0     
 ,    (  , ,"( 

½Xc!    3   c


^nited States Trust Co. v. New Jersey 

Citation. 4#!@.))A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -   ,3   @ ( A-0 ( 
( 0  ,  ( ,( 0    (0 
"   -0   0   , .)1? -(   > 0
  ( ,(0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 2 "  ,   0 "     = 0  


    ,       (  (    , 
"   0 (     "(   ( ,  (  
" , 0  0, "" 

Facts. 3 ;%3   ,"  @ A7     ((


  (    0     ( 0 (     
.61-  % ,   -(    "" .6 3 
;%3      0 " ,  ,   
( 0 "%  ( "   - .)1? - 3 ;%3   ( 
 - (   0 0       (0 
"   "   0  0    ?  0
 (        - !   "( ,3 ;%  
  @   A- 0  00  ( , 0 0    
 "(  0 ( "    

Issue. ë   ( ,    0 "(  0,3    


  E

Held. ;    (   ," 0 0 -" ,, 
' 0  0      (    = ,   "  
 ,,   "    "(0   -  ,
 "   : 8      ? ("  (  ,-"    
"(     -   ,  (  , "( 
  "      ( ,  (  " ,,  "   (  
       "  , 0 0, 00:     
 "  ,"              ? 0

Dissent.      (  ((  0,( 


 0 " -       0    <"%0

Discussion.   , 0  (   - (    '    
0 "0,,    ?  0  "= 

½.c!    3   c


,   ,<     "   00  "( ,
 (   (  ( 

½½c$    ("( À5(c


Loretto v. Teleprompter Àanhattan CAT† Corp. 

Citation. 4&+!4.@.+ A

Brief Fact Summary. 3 ;% > ( "  5  0
 ((   3 ;%,((     "%0, 
((  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ( " ( (, ((   :   
0 "  %0   , !   @ A
 0 , (    "    

Facts. .)#  ( -  ("( À5@ ( A- 


( " ,"((      0 ( "  '0 -, 
( "   ( (    &L, 0    0: ," 
 ,   ("  0 

F.)#- 3 ;% 0  (  (0G


 ,    ,     , ( ((  G

F ,((      0"  '  ,   ? 
( (  


Issue. ë "- ( " ( (,((    :, 
0 "   G%0GE

Held. ;  ( ?  ,   %0     (  ( 
(  0

Dissent.      (   =    ,  ((   ( "  
(  "(    "    (  %0-  "( ( 
(  (     0

Discussion.  "=       , 0    , 


   (  (     , >    %0   
     (,  0  ( 

½,c    Àc


Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Àahon 

Citation. 61!#.#@. A

Brief Fact Summary.    -   @  A- "   
 ( -À? @ ( A-" ,7 ( "     
0    (  0 ,  "0 "0  ( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. %0 ," 0,((      ,  


   = " , ((     

Facts.  (  0 0   , , > ,"  
 >    "      0  "   
  ( ? " 7-   (  0  . (   "0
,"0   %0,   (  ? "   

Issue. ë   %0, "( ? ((  0 E

Held. ; /   00 , " %0 > , 0   -
 "(( (  (   "   %,>0  , 0 
0  0   0

Dissent.   0  %0   0 (  ( ,"" - 
0 "  , 0"%0 , -  %0

Discussion.   0    (   >  , 0 
7-   ,     0,     ( %  
     " 0     " ,

½0cÀ    c
Àiller v. Schoene 

Citation. )6! ) @. +A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -  @ ( A-0 50    -
" ,   ( ,( 0  ( ,    (( 
    ,    "(   -  % ( (( ,
  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    ,((    > %0

Facts.    ,50 ,  " ,,     ," 
((     "((   ",(     
(   "(   ((    -     % (   
  

Issue. ë   0 %0E

Held. 3/ ,  -     '  (   0( 
 ,  ,((      - (- ,0    
 ( 

Discussion.    #,      "0,%0 ' 


@A  "
"(,  0 "O@ A  '   0 ,  
'(  @#A  , 0 "   - ( " , ! 
 @( " A 0  , ,       ( 
'( ,, 0 ,   

½-c   ( 3 ;% c


Penn Central Transportation Co. v. New York City 

Citation. 4#+!14@.)+A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -3 ;% @ ( A-(  0
(     -   (@  A-,"0,,  0
  (,2 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ,          0" (   - 
  %0ë"((         %0

Facts. .6+-      &1<   0 " 7 "( 
 "  ,,  0 (,  ' 0 " (   
    0 ,,  ( 7- ((    

Issue. À  (     (" ,  "% 
,, 0%0 >0= "(  E

Held. ;     ,   (  ,  "  
  (,,"  " G     G,"  " 

Dissent.   %0    (   %0"( %      
 ,"0 0  "% 0         
 :  ,        "0 

Discussion.    ? 0"   0   (( ,  ( 
((  , "0  ,,  ( ((    (  
 , 0    "  , ((   " -  (  
 0"   (  0 0   ,  0   ,  " <
 

½c$   c


Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council 

Citation. &1&!11#@.. A

Brief Fact Summary.    -$ @  A-   "  
 ,((      ,      
 ,  0,  ( -  @ ( A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. , 0(   "   , , 


(     (   0   ?   -  0 
G%0G > G= "(  G (  

Facts.    (  , ,N.)&-111.+6    


0 <," "  7-.++  0  (  7 ,
À0 " @ A    0 ?   ((  ( ((  
," " -       " (    
 0    ? 0(   = , ,0    " 
 ( 0 ,   %0, ((      ,   
(( 

Issue. ë  <  0 "(    %0E

Held. ;      ,  (   ," 0   0 
  -         0  ((  
(     ( " , !  @( " A  
" (  ,(  % %   ,(  ((  ( - 
%0 0, " ,  ?  0    
(   ((  0 7  , '"(  ( "     ,
%      "   ((  ,",0= ((    
, -  -    ? ""(( (    ,"
0 - %0  

Dissent.    7%"@7%"A0  "=      
' (   (   ((      ' 
  

Discussion.  "=    ( , 0    %0


@A   
((    ,,  (   , ((  @ A    0  
"   ,(  , ((   "=  ,  0
 ( , ((   (   ""((  0  "  ,
  "0  %0 '  

½*cë  ,0c


Dolan v. City of Tigard 

Citation. & !#)4@..4A

Brief Fact Summary.    -ë@  A-(( ,( " '(  : ,
 ""  0  ( - ,0@ ( A-((  ( " 
    1L,    , % (

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 2   - >   "  %0   
( " (   , (  ((  7-%0 , 0 " 
  > "  0 (( "(,  ("  
"" 

Facts.  ( ,  (" (   0 (-  
 >       7     &L, ( 
(  (0 (   "  ,,   0  
0   "  , (  0   %0(0 
   0    >0     ("  ,
 (  (  ( À  ë0 , ,(  
 %

F   (" 0   ((     7  ë 
 11< ,( (( ,( "    : , 
  "  ( ((  ( "-    
,)-111 > , -(('"  1L-,  ? ((  ,  "  


Issue. ë   ( , > 0<,<   " "%0E

Fë G  ' G '    G 0"     G ( "E

F, -    >  0 ,      "  
(=  "(, ((  (" E


Held. 3

F ( ,,0  0"    (      ( 
,  (%0 '( ","(    ,  ,
(  "   , (      0" (( ,
 0,,

F  > " "  G0 ((G "(,   (" 


½Acë  ,0c
Dissent.    , " 0 ((         "( 
   ((       ?  (   0  0
-"(  0,   ( , 

Discussion.  "=     , G ( ,>     G   
 0 0   ,    8  -,  G    
  (G     ,   ,   > , G   G
 - "=  "("  "   %  (

½Xc::   c


Palazzolo v. Rhode Island 

Citation. &##!616

Brief Fact Summary.    - ::@ G  GA-    ( -
     À0 " @ G ( GA- 00  ,
  ?   0  ((    (  ( ,-   
, " "  , !   @G GA

Synopsis of Rule of Law. , ,((  G  ( , " , 
((       ,((    G- ( ,    

Facts.     (  ,  ,/   -  !  
 -"  ,   ? ((    0       
0 ( -  "(  "(     =     ( 8,
   ? " ((   ( ((  -   ((    
  - "   ((     ,  (   
G (  ' (G," , " G (  ' (G  0 ,
 ((     G"( 0( (( (    ,  (  
  ((  (     G  (  ' (  , -,  
 = -        0  ( ? G((,   
 0 % ((  "(   , %0  , ,
" " - 0(  0 ë   ,  " " G

Issue. /   GI J ?    0 - ((   I ( JI   ? J
( I%0,J((  "(   , , 
" "  EG

Held. 3   *   @G*   GA  "= ( 0: GIJ 
   ( , " , ((       ,((  
 G    "   " ,    I   J
(( *     G  0  " -  ( ,-0  
,  0  (0 " 0 , ,,   0 
%0 -    - >, - 0? I 0J
"   ,(  ,? > "(    %0 
 /   0( " , , "0 " 
 , -%0   "   - ( 0"( ',, 0
  0?  " ,,   -  '   0 ,  
     " < %  '(  -  , 0 " G*   
  @A " ( @A G"     "  ,  
> ,   ,,  

½c::   c


 ,   <"(  G  -GIJ %  (   
 "(  0 " " (    "  
 "(   , % G

Concurrence.   ë 8?@G8?GA, 0(8?


 0: " ,,>  (     -G   "(
  (   0  "  > ( (( I   J
  G8?0 GIJ(    "  ((  ,I 
  J ,  0 ( 0 %0 !   -
 ,    " < %  '(    ," ,, " 
'"  -  0  0" (  "  ">  ((  
   (  (       ,  '(  G8? (   "= ? 
    " 0 G 0  %(0  %  ((  
," (  , I   J>  "(     >  
((      ,, , ' 0 0    , " < % 
'(    "0  "(    %0    , -    ,
 ,     ? ,"?G

F  @GGA , 0( ( ,  0 0


 "((   08?? (-G"   " 
@ ( , A"   ?IJ,IJ-?(  (  ?, -?
 > ( ,  (%0@0- '(  -
 %0A  0 " G0 G ,
  '   "  ( % K   0( 
  ",           %0 
? " < %  '(  ? %   
 "   , , ( ((  , ",    
  G

F    @G  GA (  (  


0 G  0 "  "(  ,%0,
((  ," (     G  G%0     G
G (" IJG - (    ((( (  0
     0 -  , ((   
"   0 (    ( 


Discussion.    0   ,,  =  (( I   J , ,
 %0  

,..c <   -   000  c


Tahoe-Sierra Preservation Council, Inc. v. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency 

Citation. &#&!#1 @ 11 A

Brief Fact Summary.    ,""(  (00   (" 


$%     

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  I   J-G ,    , 
"(, "    (( , 0 %0 "- 
 ( ,  (  , - ? "(("(  
    "     ?G

Facts.  "    (    ( -  00
0  @ G ( GA- >0 "  ,   >   0 "(,
 (" %   ,    ,,  ,"0  4-.+-0 
6-.+#    ,,  ,"0  )-.+#( &-.+4  , 
   ( ("   ((    =   ( ? 
= ,( ,# "  (( ,   (   %  
(    ë (" -    " ,,    , %  
    (" " ( ,-G0:G G "
 " B G@GBGA    -    @ G   GA-
0  , -111  ,"( "( (  ,    
   0   % , (( , 0G" ,  0G
0 <," " G   ( " -  "     G " , 
( -   G    0   : (  
? "(      > "  , 0?G

Issue. GI/J  "" (" "( 0 ( ,  0


"(    < (    %0,((   >0"(   
 %0  , !   GE

Held.     @G  GA-0, "= -,    


 ( "   :   I   J," % (    ? 0" 
I @         @J- (( 0 0 - ((  
    0     ( ,%0  0    ," " T
( %0  0 %0  ( %0 - 0 "  G 0
 "(    ,"  G 0 ,     (   (, 
(  ,((   %   ,  8  - - %0 
  G 0%0G- 0 %0 -    , > 
  , G((  " ,,  , 0 "  G    -
GIJ 0 0   >  ,((  ,(  -  -
 0 ( 0(   -  -"% 

,.½c <   -   000  c


(((     0( %0  0(    ,  ,
"    ? 0 %0-?    G  ,   
  0  ,  "G   %0 I    " J ,"0 " 
 0' , 0 "  ,,G

F I @ J G  "(    >   0 (  
,? "   , ?, GG!  -  ? 
"    ?,$ ?,  "(    >,  %07
0 " G  ' "   ( 
"   , , ( " G   "( :  
GG 0:  ,  GG" 11L.&L
 0 , ",   ((,I   J
     # <"""((   " - 
  ,  I @ J11L > "    GIJ0 -,  "(   
         "( (  " -   
((          (  , G  - I 
  J," %"  (( 

F "=  , (  G  ( , " -" 


  ,-  "(    %0G   "( G"  
"   0 0( " -0 :0 -  -
 % G -G   "( ( 0 "    -
      -, <"0  0 -    
, G -GIJ  > "(  ,      ,
((     0 " ( (    '(   
0     "%0G  - "=   G     
?  ,"?,  "0 =  ,  >  "= 
  (  "(     0 " -  "
 ((    , (   GG "   ? (  
0  G( ("  IJ ?GG

F    G ,    , "(, 


"    (( , 0 %0 "-  ( 
,  (  , - ? "(("(  
    "     ?G2   ","   
"      % ( " -"    0  "( 
,,"      "%00  - "=  0: 
GIJ  "  " 0    ,      
 " < %  '(  -   ë ? (  -(   ?
((    "( ?  " ?, , 0  G


,.,c <   -   000  c
Dissent. 0 /" > @G > GA,  0(=    
@GGA    " @G" GA  0=  
,   %0           ,  '
  -   G  "   < (0  G
 :  "= ,>0,  0 0 - 0 
 "= ? # ",0 >  ((  "= ?  , (( 
I @ J   " ,  < (     ?  
"     ,   - "=   %0   "( -
   "  ( (((  >  :  "= ? 
0" ,   ? 0"   ( -G- < "-< (0
  G    %0   0=  0    " ( 
    G  %0(( ,  ((  (    ,"
0 " %0G

Discussion.      0  "=  0( 0    
 0: ,,    (( %0 (    

,.0c 0  À%,,c


Hawaii Housing Authority v. Àidkiff 

Citation. 46)! .@.+4A

Brief Fact Summary.    - 0 @  A-,   
   ( -À%,,@ ( A- (  ,      0
     ,, (   ("   "0    ?
  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 8 ((  "  % ,   ,, (  (  
= , 0( (( - 0"(   (

Facts.    (,       "0(,   ,
   ,    >     " ,"    ( 
  (   (" ( ( -   " ((    
(    G ,,   ( (( G (       
 "  0      (  > ,
"%   ,  ?   ,      "  ( 
  (  

Issue.    , 0, ,"        ,
  (,,  "( %0    ,E

Held. 3 $ 0     $ ,"  ,( ,
  - %(     ,  ((    (  
 0" ( (( 

Discussion.       ,  (  "0(,( ( 
  ,  "(:    "% "((  ,  - 
( " , !  @( " A  "   '  , " "
 (((      ,  ( "

,.-c7 $ 0,/ 0c


Brown v. Legal Foundation of Washington 

Citation. &+! 6

Brief Fact Summary.   :0  ,    ?  
@G8$GA-0"   ( , 0   ,    
 0   %0

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  / 0? G >  ,   
0     0 ,    (  8$G G 0 
%0G

Facts. À   -0   ,/ 0- 8$( , 0   , 
     ,/ 0? (0"       / 0( " 
I        J- ( " , !  @G( " 
GA,   0   ,"8$   ((  ,  , 
((   , ,  ,/ 0  ? 8$(0"
G@A 
 > "  ,   (    < 0  -@ A  > " 
,     ,    (  8$-@A 
 > "       % (      8$  
$ 0,/ 0@A-@A  > "  "  
,    ,"8$ ,'< ' "(<     
(( G

Issue. /    ?%0,8$    ,%0 >0G= 



"(  G(  & " " E

Held. 3    @G  GA0, "=    ,


" "  ,  %0,((  -  %0,((  G= 
"(  G ((   ?  - 0 "  0 G= "(  G 
"   

F7    -   ,G(   ?   : - 
"(      : G  G@A= "(   
"        ,        (   @ A
- ( , / 08$ -        
"  ( 8$ / 0G / 0? 
G >  ,   0     0 ,   
 (  8$G G 0 %0G

F8  -GIJ >     ,   ,  
,,   , 0" (  - -   %0 >0
 ( " ,?= "(  ?  ?G


,.c7 $ 0,/ 0c
Dissent.   @GGA,  0(=    /"
 > @G > GA-   *   @G*   GA-    " 
@G" GA  GIJ     ,/ 0" 
: (  ((  -( 0"(  - 0 ,"    ,,  
?  ?   ,  ((         ,  ,   0 
(0" 0     ' (,< (    = 
"(   ,"   ,,  ((    ,"%   , ((  
% G

Discussion.   ,,    0% ," " ? %0   '  
, =  %0, ((  

,.*cc
c
CHAPTER †II. Equal Protection 
Romer v. Evans
Citation. &)!6 1@..6A

Brief Fact Summary.  "( (  0   


 "0 " '  0     -" @  A- 
  ("    ( -  @ ( A  ,  ' 
À  -   (  0   " ' (     

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ,     ," 00    (  - 
 0    0     "  0"     

Facts. (  " "  (  ((    0 
" '  (   ,> (( 

F      0  ,  '  0"
0  (   "( 7-  (  ,  0
       


Issue. 7  000(  0 " (       
" "    >  , !   @ AE

Held. ;  0  " ,,, 0(,:    


%," 0 "   , >(  "    " "  
 , " ' "%  " >      , (( 
 0   

Dissent.  "=   0  ,  , ,0" ' 


 (, (   (          , 
  0 0( ,"( ,   "  0(?    (  
"%  "  ( ( 

Discussion.  "=   " "    "0 0(
  0  "   "( ,      
 ,  0    ' ( , >  , 
!   @ A  (( 

,.Ac"    c


c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
,.Xc!    " 7 :c
^nited States Railroad Retirement Board v. Fritz
Citation. 44.!66@.+1A

Brief Fact Summary.    " ,, "( 0 (  ,,
    0  ,     , 7-.)4-0   " 
   "  %( .+, (  ,  , - 0 
        "%  (0",    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0   =    ,   " 0 

Facts.  0  " , %  % , 


" (      (  -(    -( (     ,"
  "(    ,( "   %  .)4-0 
"      "  %(,( "    " -
    " ,.)4 , %      ,
    "   " ,          ,
( "  -     "   ",   " ,   

Issue. /   ,,%   0    0


, >  , !   @ AE

Held. 30 ((    "  >   "  


  "   ,    "(    0   >  " 
 ,   "  0     >, ,     ,  
G  G        , 

Dissent. 0  ((        -     0  
,  ,"  (   "((  "(  (    (   
0 "  

Discussion.  "=    ' "  ,    0   0    :0
 "   , ( "   0     " (   
  ,   0         0,     
 

,.c '( 0  - 3 ;%c


Railway Express Agency, Inc v. New York 

Citation. ##6!16@.4.A

Brief Fact Summary.  (( - '( 0  @(( A-    0 ( 
   , %  ((  -3 ;%@((  A-   ( , 0
  0      "          ,   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ((       


      "(   ,    0    ,   0

Facts. (( (   -.11   % 3 ;%     -


((    ,   , %   0      ((  
(  ( , ( 0   0        , 
 

Issue. 7  , 0  ( ,  "    -  ((     >
  , !   @ AE

Held. 3  ,   (( , "  
 %, "0  >  ,  
(  

Concurrence.    , 0         (  > 0


  0

Discussion.  "=      0   0 (0(
,     , ((       ("  
 ,   0 ((,     (  

,½.c3 ;%    7 : c


New York City Transit Authority v. Beazer 

Citation. 441!&6+@.).A

Brief Fact Summary.    -3 ;%   @  A- , 
"( "      ( -7 : @ ( A- 0   ,,
"    "0%,     (  (    >
  , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.     >  ,  ,
"   ,(   0((,,

Facts.  ( (( ,=           0  ,
0"    "   ,,   , -   
0,  - ' 0 &L

Issue. ë   ? 0(    >    , 0 "( " 
"    E

Held. 3  (  ,     ?     0   =  , ,  
 ,,  

Dissent.  "((  ,   "   "  0  
 " 0  " (  "( -  0    "    
  

Discussion.  "=  =    "     < ,  
      0  0"   -         
    0"     ,  ,    (  - 0    
(  "   ,   (   - "=   "( ==0" 
 ,    ?"0 " 

,½½c!  ë (" ,0  À c


^nited States Department of Agriculture v. Àoreno 

Citation. 4#!& +@.)#A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  -À @((  A-    0, "( ," 
(( - !  ë (" ,0 @(( A.)- (( 0 
  ,, ((   (0"   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ë "0 ( ((0( 


  ( "   0 "    ,     

Facts. .64 , "((0"     (       


 "   0   ,  G0(,    
  -    ,  0 G.)- (( 
0   ,,    0( ,  (    00  

F ((   &6<    0 " ,# "
  0 -   "    , "(   7-
 , "(      ,"   ,
  ((    "


Issue. ë   ,,G G   >  , ! 
  @ AE

Held. ;   , "(  (    (  ( ,
, "( "(       (( 

Dissent.  0      ( ,,    0( 
(0    ,  "0    >   "%  
0  

Discussion.  "=  0:   , " "   " 0 
(( ""  0 " (    0 ((  "( 
((0( 0 ,      ' (     ,
  (   

,½,c ,  - '    $ 0  -c
City of Cleburne, Texas v. Cleburne Living Center, Inc. 

Citation. 4)#!4# @.+&A

Brief Fact Summary.    - ,  @  A-   (  ( "
  ( -  $ 0  @ ( A-,    " ,0(" , 
"     ""  ,((  , ,  "  
0( G> <  ( G      >  , 
!   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. $ 0  0     "      
"      0" 0 " (( 

Facts.   (  0((  ,"(     , 00(
" , "      '(  #(       ,4
"       >  ( (( , (  ( " 
   ((

Issue.   "    (,G> <  ( G   = 0     
>  E

F   (  ( " > "  E


Held. 3  0( (  ,,  ,"( =  ( 

F3      , >0 (0("  ( "


   "0 "    >      
   ( "  >     "        


Discussion.  "    >,    ( > <  (     %
,  , "  ( (   0(     
  ,"%     

,½0cë  ,c


Dred Scott v. Sandford 

Citation. 61!#.#@+&6A

Brief Fact Summary.    -ë @  A-    %  
,   /  "(  0 ,     : ,
   , , "

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  À "("      ((  
:  

Facts.      À  %  /    - 
 "(     ' ,   -  ( ,@ ( A-,  
    ,   ,:  (

Issue.    : , !     , ,    "E

Held. 3 0,"  , !   @ A    
  G" G  "  ,   "(  
    ((      0 

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A "(  0: 
  ( ( 0          " 

,½-c* "  !  c


Korematsu v. ^nited States 

Citation. # #! 4@.44A

Brief Fact Summary.    -* " @  A-( <" - , 
   "   "  ,  ( - !  
@ ( A-"   '(      " ,

Synopsis of Rule of Law. $ 0   ,    0 , 0 0(
   =    7-( 0(    "  " " = ,   '   ,
  

Facts. 8À .-.4 - ""02  , /  "", !  


"   (   ,(      ' ," "  ,
$ -, 2  , ,  "(  "    ,, ( 
  ," 0  , (0   0     ,    " 
   ,  ,  0 "    "    
  " 

Issue. /   ( ,0  '   '  ,( 
  ," /    "  E

Held. 3/   ,"  - ( (  !  
"  ""       0 

F    ' ,"    ,  "    
    ,    0(-   ( ,(      
 ,  '(  " -, 0(   ' ,"  


Dissent.   %À( @À( A    0  '"( , " 
"     "%    -  "    
 -   "  " ? (  (((  ,   G ( 
0     ""  -"" "( 0G    
  0

F   % @% A       ," 
  "   ,,,   


Discussion.  "=    ' ,  3" -,0( ( ,
(       !   @ A7-
 ,    ,   " - ,%    %    -
 0 "  "( 0, - ((    0 (   " 
   0  "  0 , /  

,½c$ 0 50c


Loving v. †irginia 

Citation. #++!@.6)A

Brief Fact Summary.     -ÀÀ $ 0@  A- "  
(    50, " 0/ 0-ë    ,
0    ( 0"' "0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ,     "   "" 
           , "( 0    

Facts. À   - %"$ 0- " -      ,
50   " / 0-ë.&+   " 50
 ,, -    , 0   0  "0 
      =7 =0   (      , &  -, 
        ( 

Issue. ë    (   ( -   ,50@ ( A-( 
 "0    >  , !   
@ AE

Held. ;  0 , ""       ,    >
  ,   = ,(         
 " ,  ,/ ( "  "( "   

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A    =   
     > ((       %,  
 "  (( ,       (    0 ,   
(     (  "0    ,   

,½*c"  c
Palmore v. Sidoti 

Citation. 466!4 .@.+4A

Brief Fact Summary.   0   ,  (   
 ( -(    (   (-  " 
%"

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G  ,,  ,( = -  -= , 
 , " 0,,"   , " , 
((( (      G

Facts.    -$" @ G  GA-  ( - 
@ G ( GA-          (     À 
.+1-       ,  < < ( " .+-
  (  0  , 00  -   0 
    03 0-  " -@GÀ" GA-    
"   (  "    0      , 
  0   " ,GIJ , ?    " , " ? 
 , %(   ,,    ," "  , " 
0, - - "  , 0" "   '
  (" 0" "  ( 0,, 
   ,  , ? ,  ,  ,   (  
   "   0        -    
À  -,  " (    0  " 
   ( (  - ,, ,"   0":   " G

Issue.    ? 0 0   ,     "  "  ,
   , !   E

Held. ;  ( " , !  @G( " GA,  0: 
    0    ,    -  0: 
"(,        G  ? """  0
 "   G " GIJ    % 0
 (( ,,,   "    =    ,(    ( , 
   0(  ,  "  0G -GIJ  
 ( =       "    "     
 , -  -    -0  " ,, ? ,,  
(  "      0  (  ,,  ,
(  ( =   "      (  ?G

Discussion. 0( =    -  ,,   , 0- 
    ,,  , ( 00 "%0   " 

,½Ac   0 c


Plessy v. Ferguson 

Citation. 6#!&#)@+.6A

Brief Fact Summary.    - @  A-       
   , 0 <0(    %

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0 0,    

Facts.    )M+ M+ %       , 
"' 

F   ,$ (  0 (  G (   >G 
, %      ""00,    " 
 ( (  


Issue.   $   ( 0, (   E

Held. ; $ 0  (       4" " , ! 
  @ A       %     >
 " ,  (0 ,    >-  ,   
,     , -   ,  

Dissent.   0      > ,0    " , 
  % ( % ,  (    7  >0    
( -  0   ( 0:  , 0 

Discussion.  "=       >       
   ,,   7-  "   " 0 0 " , 
( (   , - 0    G (   >G"" -    
,> 

,½Xc7 7,c
Brown v. Board of Education 

Citation. #4)!4+#@.&4A

Brief Fact Summary.    -7@  A-   (  , %-
0  ,"4,,      (      
 " (         0 0 0 G (   >G

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   "       > 

Facts. *  --ë  50 (      0 0   
    ,   0            
   %    > "  >

Issue. ë  0 0, (          (   ,
" 0( > (( E

Held. ; 0 0  ,   "   >- (,  0   
, 0,,   ,,   ((   ,G (   >G 
( (   (     >

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A =   0, 
   (, ,,  (    " , 0    
        (          
,  0:   , -  ?     0 0   
  > 

,½c/ 0 ë  c


Washington v. Davis 

Citation. 4 6! .@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary.    -/ 0@  A- %",    
" / 0-ë(   "         
   " , %(  ,     

Synopsis of Rule of Law.     ,     0"   
     0" "(  ((  

Facts. / 0-ë >  ( ,, ((  ", 0


0(    (    -      )< %0
 (( 41,+1  

F  %  .)1,  "       


  "= , %(( %, 


Issue. ë  "( "    0 ,  "0  %  ( 
 ", > 0 E

Held. 3   "   0   ((     "   ,
  %    ë (( "(    ,  
 "

Dissent.    (    "    , ((      
(  ,, = ( ," 

Discussion.  "= ,   ,   "  ,>, 0 , 
=    ,      "    (   , 0,
  -     > " "   "(   

,,.cÀ %  * "(c


ÀcCleskey v. Kemp 

Citation. 4+! ).@.+)A

Brief Fact Summary.    -À % @  A-  %"  ,
" 0 ( ,,  =       3 " 
 0 "    " " 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. " ,     ,( 0  '   ,
(( , "  " "  ,, "

Facts.      "   ,    ,,< ( ,,  
 , %  = ,  0         
  00 0"  0  (  

F  ,,   7         0 " ,   
  ,  ,   0 (  ,  "


Issue. ë  ,    0    (  0
   (   ?      E

Held. 3" ,     ,( 0  '   ,(( , "
  "  ,, " 7       00  
 (  "  ( 

Dissent.  7   (   0   0   


 (  "   7  ,   - ((,  00  
  

Discussion.  "=  (    ,     0 (  ,  0
0  (    (    , " ,0(, -     
( ,  0( 

,,½c ,À   7 c


City of Àobile v. Bolden 

Citation. 446!&&@.+1A

Brief Fact Summary.    -  ,À  @  A- #<(   
" (   -   "=   0        
0     0  %((-   %"

Synopsis of Rule of Law. $ 0  (("   > -, (( 
 "":    0( ," 

Facts.      #<(  " ,(   


     "=        ",,   0  
  0,0 "   ( -7 @ ( A- 0   00  
   ,,    " ,  -      %,  %(   
    ,   " ,((  ,," 

Issue. ë  <0   ","( 0   0 ,  %   , 
   E

Held. 3  ,((  

F     ( ,0 "   ( ((  ( 


 %(  ," 0"      ,
  , " "  , "    " (( 
À<" "  0      ,   
((  "":   0( ,"   0 
" " "       (( 
(  0 , ((


Dissent.   7 / @/ A0       , "= ( 
 (     "  

Discussion. (  "- " 0(   "  (( 
" , (   0 "   "   0"% 
0 " ,0,

,,,c"  "( c


Palmer v. Thompson 

Citation. 41#! )@.)A

Brief Fact Summary. % -À  (((  (  ""0( - % ( "
0 0      "

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ,,0 "    ( , 
:      >   , !   
@ A

Facts.   "  0 0  ""0(   0 0  :-( 0,
 (%      (   , 0 00 "" , 
%:   ,  ,    (  (   0 0 , 

Issue.    0, ""0(     >   %:  
 "" E

Held. 3 "   ( ,    ( " , !  
@ A         , "  , " 
  ,

Dissent.   "   0  "0, (       -
(% ( "  , , (( ,G( ( 0 0( G

Discussion.      ( ,,  :   > 0"   


 "  - 0( "   0    

,,0c   " ,À      c


Personnel Administrator of Àassachusetts v. Feeney 

Citation. 44 ! &6@.).A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -  @ ( A- 0    -   
" ,À   ? @  A- (  0( ,   " 
  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0        "(  0   
  >  , !   @ A, 
  " ((    ,  0  

Facts.  ( "   00( ,   ,    <   , 
  (  -     "00 " 

F ë , (    "(= (( ,


" -  " ,     " 


Issue. ë  0( ,        >  , ! 
  E

Held. 3   ,,  ,,   (       
( ,   ,   ,   ' <   ,   '  0 , " 
 " 

Discussion.      0   (        ,     
 "  L,      " -((    0  " ,
"  7- ((  ,   0   

,,-c50 ,0 0  À ( 0ë (" (c


†illage of Arlington Heights v. Àetropolitan Housing Development Corp. 

Citation. 4 .! & @.))A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -À ( 0ë (" (@ ( A-
((    -50 ,0 0 @  A-, :0,( ,"
0 ," "<," -<"  0  :0    (   
0 "

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ë "  ,,     0 "   
   "  " 0 " (( 

Facts.  (   .1  ( ,,"  <
"         >  (  0       
   ((  ,,  " 

Issue. ë    :    >  , !  
 @ AE

Held. 3      >  ,  ,   :     
     "  

Discussion.     "(    , "  ((     
    :0     : , 0 <," "     .&1? 
,- 0 <," "     > 

,,c7 7,c
Brown v. Board of Education 

Citation. #4.! .4@.&&A

Brief Fact Summary. , 0  0 0 7 7,


-#4)!4+#@.&4A@7A-    0=0   
(((  "  ,  0 0

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    "   >  , =0"  , ( " 
, !  @( " A

Facts. , 7- " ,  ,    "  00    
/  "      ( (  0 0     " -   0
0 ," ( "  (((  "  ,  0 0

Issue. /  ((( = "  , "0     0 0E

Held.   " ,    , >   

F ,  / @/ A       " 
"( 7   (    /   
   ( "(    ( 0 "  ( 
    " 

F7  ,    ,(  " - ( "  "   
         , - %0   
(( (( , > 0    "(     
,7>   "    (((   , , '  
,  "    ,   , >    (   % 
, (,,  (     ",   
"( " ,7


Discussion. (,"   0   %0,,, (( ,7- 
 (  7   %0, 0 0  , 0"( 
7 ( "  ((  "  ( 0  0  - 
  >0     >   "( ( < - %0 
=  ,    ?( "'":  , '  

,,*c  <À %  07,c


Swann v. Charlotte-Àecklenburg Board of Education 

Brief Fact Summary.    00 0 0 7 7,
-#4)!4+#@.&4A@7A-7 7,-#4.! .4@.&&A
@7A- 0,,    ( ,,    ?(  
I7MJ

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ( ,ë    -      
      0 "  "( 7M

Facts.  % ,7-"      0" 0 , ( <
7 0 0   " ë ,     0 - 00ë  
     -  "  - 7

Issue. 

F/   ( ,ë   7E

F/  ((( ,  %  E

Held.     -  (((       ,  0
 "  "( 7 

F "   (=0 G"    , 


 G
FÀ ">     '  ,= -   
 0(, G ,G,   ?  
F0 <    (  G"%,  " (  0 0 
G G  :    -G      
  "    ? "% (   ,( 
  =  0 0
F  "   ,    0 0    " - 0 
  0"        
F7 0 (((  "  -  - 0  "      0
  %  ,   0, "(0   
( 

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A"   
,    "     0 00(    0 0 
  "  -    '       
G ,G  ,,  0 0 


,,Ac  <À %  07,







c
,,XcÀ%  7 c
c
Àilliken v. Bradley
Citation. 4+!))@.)4A

Brief Fact Summary.    ,  ,ë -À0   "   
, ë  ?  "     , 0 0    
       ?   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ë     , 0    " 
    0 0    "     ,, 

Facts.  "(  0  ë      , ë   , 
  > ,"   ,  0    " ( -
,&4   -0 ë   , ((   0 
0,"  ,(  " ,  0   "

Issue. À ë      , 0      0
 0 0  E

Held. 3    ,, 

F ,  / 70 @70 A-0, "= -    
" (,,  (( (     ,
      ,,    G (  OG' 
       "% "   

F  ( ,  "     "     ( ,  
 (  -  "  , 0  "  
  ,   0 0 -,     
  , -, "  ,    0 0 -
   "  "    -      

Dissent.   7 / @/ A0  ( " , !  
@( " A  %0ë    "        ,
 0  G ,I J 0 "      , 0 0 
 >  0 "  G/ 0   "   (   ë  
"(   -"          "( (  0  ?
0  0  

Discussion. À%   ,    7 7,-#4)!4+#@.&4A


@7A- 0  ( ,,    "   0 0(   
!À% -   0  (   >  ,  0 ,7
   ,"  -0  0-   0>   0À%  
    0 0   -       ,,  0 0 
 

,0.c7,,8%"    ë c


Board of Education of Oklahoma City Public Schools v. Dowell 

Citation. 4.+! #)@..A

Brief Fact Summary.    -7,,8%" @  A- 0


 , ë <"(   0 0(

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ë       '    


  >  "(  = 0 0      ( 
0 0

Facts. .) - ë "(  0 0(, 8%"  
  ".+&- 7,(  (@GGA, 00   
    "     ,         
 (  -ë - @ (  A- 00 ë =  
,,  ë    0 0     ,     
,((  - ( " , !  @( " A0  

Issue.   0 0      , "     E

Held.     " ,,   

F ,  /" > @ > A      
     ,,G G   ""   , 
  " 0  "  0 , 0 08  
 ,   " 0     0 0   0" 
(       ,- "  " " 
0 ,(  "

F > ,   ë ?   =  
  '   (   ,   "  (  "
  ' (  - 0    "%00, ,, "  
  


Dissent.   0À @À A   - ,,8%"
 ?    "( ,  .1L .1L<    À 
,   (   0 0 0     ( 

Discussion.  "= ? ("   , 0,    
       , 0 00    % 0 
0 0  = ( ,    = (    "       
"(  ( 0    (,

,0½c"  c
Richmond v. J.A. Croson Co. 

Citation. 4++!46.@.+.A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  - @((  A  -   


(=   À 7  !:@ A   (( -  ,
"@(( A- 00    ((   >( ,  
,  " " , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    >0" "> "  0  :  
,(  "  <" ((  >( 

Facts.  ((  (('"  &1L %- - L,  ?  
   "     ( ,".)+.+#  
 ( -   (  0   ((  - > 
#1L, ",("     À 7   ( 
@   M    &L" " "  A-  ("  
 ,À 7   (  ((  -<"      -   
(( - 00>   

Issue. ë      " " 0 ,> ,  E

Held. ; ,((  0,," 

F  ë 8?@8?A  ((   0  


   ( " ( -"   ( 0(  "  
(   " -8?  <   , 
"    =    - - "   "( 00 " 
         

F0  :     (  "  
   (( ( "  8? %   
G ((   ( G0"  (: ,0 -  "  
 (           "   
(   0  - #1L> 0   "
,,     


Dissent. 

F  0À @À A- 0-   ( " , 
!  @( " A  <0 0 , <


,0,c"  c
c
% 0 , ",  ((  (  %
,," (0" 0  

FÀ   G 0G ,     =    -


  "=  "0   00 ,  -"  
 0  =0      " 


Concurrence. 

F    @  A-0- 00   ,


"  ((( -, -  " "  , -,    
 0( 0 -    (( ?   
   ( " ?   0

F  @A    "  (( 


 , - 0 ,        "  0
 -      "( "      
" " ,  


Discussion.  ((0,"      "  (( 
   0  ,    "=   00     
     <   0 "     "  (  "

,00c  -  c


Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Pena 

Citation. &&! 11@..&A

Brief Fact Summary.   -< 0    


,  0 (= -      , (- 00 ,  0 "  
   "      " >( ,  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ,  ,  0 "    =    

Facts.     "     ,,  0 
(= À2 - (" -   ,  , ,0
       G   "   0   G
À2   0        0 " ? ( 
 ( "(" <         " 
  0 

Issue. ë  ," " ? 0 , >(  >  ,  0 " ? 
 ,     E

Held. ; ,((  0   "   ë 8?@


8?A-0, "= - '    " "  > "    
"  -4++!46.@.+.A- ,  0 " 0 ,
" " 3"  -    ((  <   ,- 0 , 0
 " " 

Dissent.     @  A      , 0 " 
 ,     =   ,  2  ,     
   "  (  "-  0     =  
   

Concurrence.   @A0 0    "( 0


0 "   = ,  ,

Discussion.  '      ,  ,   0-
8?-   ( , "  "  0 ( "      

,0-c2  70 c


Grutter v. Bollinger 

Citation. &#.!#16- # # &-&6$ #14@ 11#A

Brief Fact Summary.     "  7 2 -@ G  GA 
    À0  #+0 ( 0 6$   
!   ,À0$@ G$GA (   0 
 - $   =   ((     ë -
 00 $? " (     " " , !  
 @ G GA

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ? >   ( 
?    , "     , "( 0  
 0    , ,,"      

Facts.  ë  % $?  ,   , 


"     -   ( , ,((    8 ,  
  (  $  0  " -  ((?   
   (, $? " (  0 G 
    (  ,     ,   ,"0(     
 " 0 -% ,<"  - ( 3 "  - 
""" "0  (      " 0,"  G $
? 0GI J  0G?" ?,I  (  J"    -G 
G  I J   "% >     , $G0
    (- $?    (  ,       
 " 

Issue. 

F/    ,   $ ,  "   ,E

F/   $? (   , "( 0    E


Held. 

F;  $ "( 0  0        


G0         , $? ((  
" G  ë 8?@G8?GA-0, "= - 0
    0 ,,"0I !! J- , (( 
       "( 0    -= , 0  , 
   "  8?  , (((  ,  


,0c2  70 c
c
  :0 ,  , G"   :  
  0    G-" 0G  ,   
 ,    , "( 00 "    G
8? ,  I !! J"   ( "    , <  
0 "   "  (  ", $ , 
G" G  ( , (  0 ,(0( (  
 -   G" G  ,   ,     
 ,      0 ( !   ( > 
  " ,"" "( -  G     
" , '   ?( ?,  ', :   , 
 ((G  - $? (0"G " ,
  (  "      ," (0">G
 -=      >- "   > " ,
 :      , G/  0  ?( ?,   
"  -   ? "  (0""  ", '   0   
((     - "% ((? 
     ,0,  ,  (( "( , 
 :     ', <  "  (0" 
("G8?    , $?    (   
    -         

F;  G$? "  (0"   "%,  


(G8?   = 00" "     - 
 G  >  ' ,   <   G $
G ,,     %   <   G "=  
  "  $?  <  " (0"G   
   " "  , ,  0( G


Concurrence. 

F  7 2 0@G2 0GA   ( 7 @G7 GA, 
0(  0G       - %
 "   - " G -G" 
"      "%   >  > (( G


Concurrence/Dissent. 

F  @GGA    " @G" GA   


(0( 0( =       
>   ,(   "= ?   -   "   , 
 G (  


,0*c2  70 c
c
0 "  "    , -  <(    
' (G

F"    (0( 0( 


G  I J %      ," ,  " 0,
   "  G


Dissent.   /" > @ > A--   *   @*   A
"   0  $? G"        
  G  ( , 0     G(   G

Discussion.    -0 ( " ?   I2: 70 J 


( " ? "    00,," 

,0Ac2: 70 c


Gratz v. Bollinger 

Citation. &#.! 44- # 4-&6$  &)@ 11#A

Brief Fact Summary.      "   0    (( ,
" -   =  ,"- !   ,À0? @ G!   GA 0 ,
$  -  -  @G$GA     0  00$? " 
(    0    " " , !   @ 
G GA

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ( "( "      -G"     1
( - <,,, (   0 " -   0 ?  (  
" ?((     , -        G

Facts.  !   ? $ 0 ( (  "=0 (( ?" 


>, 8  ( 0 "  !    0 (  
" ,    "0 0  ," - , 0 ,((
 ,<" - (3 " -   " 0   ( -
 <,, "  ,0 "  !   ? $ 0    
    G>, G(( -       "" 

Issue. 

F/    ,   !   ? $ 0  ,  "   
,E

F/   (, !   ? $ 0 ?"  (  0 - 
 , "( 0    E


Held. 

F;  I !! JI     J

F3   > @G > GA0, "=  G !   ? 


 ( -"     1( - <,,, (   
0 " -   0 ?  (  " ?((   
 , -        G "= 
 0  I7%% J  GIJ "  (0"I 7%% J
   "(   0   "    
( , ,      ?    G  - 
  "  >  I7%% J ( 


Concurrence. 

,0Xc2: 70 c


c
1c  ë 8?@G8?GA  0   , 
I  J,"        "0,  
(    G (  ," 0, :   ,
(( GG < <    G

F    " ? @G" GA       G ?  ,


 "0  "    0 (    
>  G


Dissent. 

F  ë  @G GA    0(  "  
   " 0 I2 J((  I7%% J
 " -       

F  7 2 0@G2 0GA ,  0 


G0 "   "%  " ((   0   ( , ' 
 G -GIJ  0   0( 0  ,:  (  
     % "   %         
 " ,  ,,     '( G -,     
G, (( , 0 > -G"( (  G


Discussion.    -0 ( " ?   I     J  
( " ? "    00,,"    0"( " ? 
0"    ,0 " ,,,"  
2 0?  ? 0"  ," ,,,"   (  

,0c   " c
Easley v. Cromartie 

Citation. &# ! #4@ 11A

Brief Fact Summary.    ,   0  ?   0(   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G       "= <"   @ 
(('"  >  A      ,  0 (
,,- ( %0  0     "      
 0      0" ( =      
"(      0(( ( "    
 0    0  0, 0    G

Facts.       3   0     ( ",

  0 ë  <=0  (  

Issue. /   G( ",G3? 0,  0 
ë E

Held. 3   ( 7 @G7 GA-0, "= -,      
          ,(,  (  00      
 "0 /"   00"= <"     -
"""  G 0      <  0(( 
   G "   G?( ",?" 0  0  ?  0
  -G= " ,    ,  "  
G '(  0   G     0 
0    G 0  ?  (  ,"(   G    0  "  0 "
"(  ,  G (  I J  -   -    
 0" ( '(,  0    0((  
 (,, 0   G

F      ë ? ,0 ,G  G  
"   ,G  , ," G ë ? % 
,0  " % G  (( ,,   ,   
,0"        ,(   
( "         7  0: 
 ë ? ,0    , G  ?  ( -  (0,
  -    ,<"  0((Gë  
G (     , 0   (
,,3- I   J, , "  - 
" ,- (( ë ? =0" G


,-.c   " c
c
  =0  "(     , -  "=  0 
 ,0 


Dissent.     " @G" GA,  0(=    /"
 > @G > GA-   *   @G*   GA  @G
GA" 0    ,         
- ""  "  :  ,   "= 
((  - "=     ,  0,  ,    "   
,((  -     ,   0 - "= ? 
 " ,  ? ,0  0 '(  "  - "= ? G, 
 " ,  G

Discussion. 0       -   0 0: 
     ,    ((  (((   
((    "=   ,, -      

,-½c   c


Frontiero v. Richardson 

Citation. 4!6))@.)#A

Brief Fact Summary. , "  $   0    ,     , 
   (  -   ,   "    ?( , 0" 
" ( "(    (   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 2  <   , -%  , -" (  
 

Facts. 7   -   "" " ,   (  ,(( ,>, 0,
  >  -"    , -    (( -
  "" "    (  ,   (   ," 
,,  ((   - @  A- 0  (      >
( , ,,   ," " , !   @ A

Issue. ë    ,, 0,,   (   , ,   "     ,0  
  ," " ? 0 , >( E

Held. ;    " 

F  /"7 @7 A "  (   ,
 "0  " !    > " , 
 ,0  <   ,  ((( 

F 0 " ,,        00 0    


"  "    0   ,  -7  
-GI/J      ,? =  -?    
G"     G    G


Concurrence.   $   @ A  =0" -  0  '<  
 ,     (   =    

Discussion. 7 0 0  <   ,     =    
  (  , -00 0 ,< 0"( 
 (   ,,       ' 

,-,c0 7 c


Craig v. Boren 

Citation. 4 .!.1@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary. 8%" " ,,  %00   " " 


,  "(,# L  (( -0@(( A- 0  
,,       " " , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 2  <   , "   ,  "    
 > "  (  "  

Facts.   ,8%"(     ,G'0G# L " 


  0 , "   0 ,+  00   - 00 
   >  ,  " " ,  

Issue. ë  8%"     >  ,  " " 
,  E

Held. ; ((  0   " 

F  /"7 @7 A0  (    


 "   ,    ((  :0   ( , -
 0  <   ,"   "(0 "  =   
      " ,  =  

F ë  >  ,  =          
  ,, ,  7  (     ((  ?-0
  @((  A-              =   
-  


Dissent.   /" > @ > A       
      (((  ,  ,0  <   , " - 
   "    ((   ( " , !  @( " 
A  G(   G  0 =( = 

Discussion. 0 7      "      (((  ,  ,
0  <   , "      0  ,"     
 =  "    "(0 "  =  @ "  A "( 0
0 "  =  @ A     @ "  A   @ A

,-0c!   50c


^nited States v. †irginia 

Citation. &+!&&@..6A

Brief Fact Summary.  50À   @5ÀA    0 < ' 0 
    ,50   - !  @  A-" 
  ( -50? @ ( A- ' ," ,"5À    >
( 0 ,  " " , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   " (   0    ,"((0
>    "        ,0  

Facts. 5À 0,( 00 -"     0  '(    


 0      ,0+#.-5À   '   "  
,  0 0  ,((  -  (  "(   
( " ? (0"   -   >, 
, ,     (  ,"   , 5À?  
 

Issue. 

Fë     ", '0"        , ,"5À


  >( E

F, -  (((  "  E


Held.     "    " " ,   ((( 
 "   "" 5À

F  7 2 0@2 0A  0  @ - "  A
   (((  ,  ,0  <   "

F2 0     ( 00  ,  0 0 < '
  -   (     5À 
   " - 0  ' ," -,  , 0
(( 50

F2 0 0   5À? G   " ,0G 


"(   (0" -  5À? "     % 
,"  -       ,<  0  0


Dissent.   @A    "= (  0
  "     ((( 0  <   , 

,--c!   50c


Discussion.   0 - "= (  (   ( -  >  
, 0," " À, ( " , !  ? (( ,
5À?  0 < '    0 < ' -   %,
"(  (( ," 50?    0    " ,
 >  , (( ,,  5À50   = ,  
 "    

,-c2 0  c


Geduldig v. Aiello 

Citation. 4)!4+4@.)4A

Brief Fact Summary. ,(         "(  , 
"( ,(   "(   %  "(       
(    "( ,"%0 -" ( 0        
' ," 0   , '(   (0"

Synopsis of Rule of Law. !    0  (((   > 
 - 0       G  ((  G

Facts. ,(         " (( "  %  "(  -
(  ,( "  ,      %  "(    ,
   (,   ,,  '  "0    (
,   ( 0      0 00   " 
 0  <   ,

Issue. ë   ' , ( 0 <       " " ? 
>  E

Held. 3((  0,," 

F  ,            "  '  
 " -          ",,  " 
"   '  ,, "  

F   0 0  (0"   ' ,    , " 
"  - ,  '    
" ,,0,  


Dissent.   /"7 @7 A0   0( "    
( 0 -      " 0 " 

Discussion.  "=      0  0 (  "  ,
    0 -   ,      , , 
  0  '

,-*c8 8c
Orr v. Orr 

Citation. 441! 6+@.).A

Brief Fact Summary. $ ,  , " > "  "  ( 
"   - "     > ( " 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /"(         "  - 
 "  ,     , '

Facts.    ,( ,    "    ,
 , (  0 ( 0   "      " 
 ,    (  0    " >( 

Issue. À     " ( "  "  "  'E

Held. 3

F (  -  , "0  ' (' , ,,
     , , (      '"   " 
    " -    ((",
"     

F7  0  <  ,    ? (( =    
0  <   ,-   ( "  ,     ,
'


Discussion. 8 8    0,    0  ,
 (' ,,  ,       " ( 
0"    "    ,, 0   , 0 -   
    

,-AcÀ  ((!   ,/"  0c


Àississippi ^niversity for Women v. Hogan 

Citation. 4&+!)+@.+ A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -0@ ( A-   " À  ((
!   ,/" ? @À!/A 0(0"       ,0    0  
  , >( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   " (   0    ,"((0
>    "        ,0  

Facts. À!/    0 < ' 0  "    ,À  (( 
 (    >, ,"   ?  0(0"-   
  "     , 0" 

Issue. ë  ( ,, "   0     > E

Held. ; ((  0,," 

F(( 0 "    -  ë 8?@8?A 
  ,À  ((   "(    ,( 0
0  ' 0 (-   " %
((     À  (( (  ,À!/

F8? 0  "   0 "(0 " 


 =  @0  , A  - À!/ "   
 0 ,"      "-      
( 0 0 < ' 0(0"


Dissent.   $   @ A0   (   ,,  0:  
= -       <(   0(0"  ( "        
   0   <     ? " 

Discussion.  "= ,   À  (("  " 0 " " 
 0(0"  -   ( ,0"   0(    , 
  %,= 0" <=   ( -    " 
       0"     >  ((   @  
  0(0"  (0"    0   "A-      0
(( " 

,-XcÀ À ( ," c


Àichael À. v. Superior Court of Sonoma County 

Citation. 4&1!464@.+A

Brief Fact Summary.    -À À@  A- 0   ( 
, 0   ?    "   0 "  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   " (  ,( "  ,"  >:     
 0 ( 0 

Facts.    - " , "(- )< <"  '
  6< <, " 7  ,?    ":    
" - , "    0  "     0  
 (    (    , >  ,  
" " , !   @ A

Issue. ë  ,  (     (( ,> E

Held. 3((  0,," 

F  /" > @ > A  ( ,  ,  ((,
 "     - > 0 0  ,    , 
 ?  0  =      0 ( 0 

F "=     " %    =     ( 0
  ,"    0    , "   
  0,     ,"   -"  ( 0  ,
  ,, 


Dissent. 

F  /"7 @7 A((  "      
((   ," "= 7   ( 0 0 
( 0  "( =  

F -7 0 ,      , " 0
 0  <     "  ,,     0 0 ( 0 
0  <   À "( -   0  < 
    ,,   0  <    

F    @  A  -00   (  


> 0 , - (    (,   ( 
0 ( 


,-cÀ À ( ," c
Discussion.   >  "= ?    08 8-441! 6+
@.).A-    "(   "  ((  G     0  <
  ,  0   , -G   ,  0   ,,
        "   - "  

,.c %  2 0c


Rostker v. Goldberg 

Citation. 4&#!&)@.+A

Brief Fact Summary. ,,?  0 - 00 À       @ÀA
  >  , ," " , !   
@ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ,  0 " "  ,     , -   
   "(0 "    "           

Facts.  À > "    0 + 6 0         
 (( , À  "      "   " 
,    /"   >  0         

Issue. À  ,  0 "  >  "  0         E

Held. ; 

F  /" > @ > A , "= -0 (" 
 =  , À (   (( ," ( "  
" ,    -  "(0 "   

F  "  - >   " @ 0(A  0  ," 
 7  , - 0  0"    "  
   , " 0 ,( ,,À "   ,,   
 ,(( ,, " -" <" (   ,  
" <  (    ( -, " 0 ( ,,
,"  0 ," 


Dissent.   7 / @/ A  -00   =  ( ,"  
(    0  ,"    -     0  " 
, (  

Discussion. 0- >     "     "0 -0" 
   ((       "(0 "   @( 0,,A
     "      @ >0 "  0  -   
"   0  ,"  0(A

,½c, /  c


Califano v. Webster 

Citation. 4#1!##@.))A

Brief Fact Summary.    <0     ,   ,,   ,
" " -  " ?   ,   %   0   @0 
0A  ->, 0" , 0 0    , 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0 " "   "  0   ,"   
       " 0 

Facts. .) -   ,,      " ,0<0   
 , ," " (-   ,        ,G 0 
" 0 -G   0 ( ,".&1"  6&
, "  6   , -, "  0  ,    "  -
 0 0 0  0 " 

Issue.    ( ,"     ' ((   ," " , ! 
  @ AE

Held. 3 ( " , !  @( " A    0,0 
7 -4 .!.1@.)6A-  0 ,  0  "   "(
0 "          0  0  0 
0(  " " - ( "    0"  "  <
0   ," - "   " (,  "

Discussion. , 0 -, "   -4++!46.@.+.A-   


( "  0  :  0,(  "  0
= ,  "  0  - ,   =    - 0  
 ,   =  "      - 0 "     > 
   "   0 

,,c30  ""03:   c
Nguyen v. Immigration and Naturalization Service 

Citation. &##!&#@ 11A

Brief Fact Summary.   0 0:  (,    !  
"  (    

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  , ,  0   (   >
  -G"      ?   I 0 J ,  
G"(0 "  =    " "   "( G G   
    " ,  =  ?G

Facts.    -30 @ G  GA-   ( " -.6.
5 " (  - (7 @ G(  GA-!  : -
" 5 " :       '   (  .. - 
  ( 0  , '     -  ( -
 !  ""03:   @ G3GA- 0 (( 0 
0     ""00 ,    (   ( 0 
   0   5 " :    ((   7,
""0((  @ G7GA/  ((  ,  7 ( 0- 
(  >  ,( 0 ,"   " 0     
 7 =     ? "  !  : -  ,
   "( +!H41.@A-  ,  , "  G 
, % : , : " G :  ( 

   (  ((  -  &  =   "+!H41.@A
  >  @GGA

Issue. /   +!H41.- 0> ,!  :  (  


 (  !  :   -   G >( 
0  "   ë   , ," " G-    > "  
 ,,   ( 0   " , ,   : U

Held. 3-    >     *   @G*   GA
0, "= ,       00 *      
G 41.@AIJ"(  , > "    ,: ,    
, %: "  "(  % "    : 
(   " G   GIJ        - - 
H41.@A@4A >  , ,,"   (  % , : (   , - 
, : (   " 
 0"O ,(     
, O ,(  G -G0 ?  "(  > "  
" ,  ,, ," " "       0,,,   
   (    (  ( : 

,0c30  ""03:   c
 " , ( , - "( ,  > " ,(   (- 
"  - = ,  "(0 "  =  G

F , , 00   (   -G"  


      I 0 J ,  ?"(0 " 
 =    " "   "( ? ?      
 " ,  =  ?G

F , 0 "      0 (      0
(  ,      (  "    0" , 
,"   , -," G  ,  (  
     00  G  , - " ,,
    (    ,  (  "  
  ? ,   -GI,J  "    "   
 0 (,, 0(  "( ,,,   , ,
"%0 0  " ( ,  "      ( 0
  " ," (  (  G

F  0 "    G   "     


: (   "  "  (( (  (= 
  (  0: - ,"" -  -     , 
 -    (     : ( --
 !  G   GIJ  ,: "  
   - (( ," 0,  (  : ( 
      , -  ,  
   0 ,:  ( " %    0 
   (,"     (( ,
"  ( -" 0,  (G8  - -
GIJ  " ((   ,"  , - " , 0
   -  ,  , 2  .<"    
 ( -   , % 
  -     "    , , ?   
 ,% ( 0,   ,    ,
 %G ,,           ",( :   
"% , 0  - , "  %,  (-
, %   (- " %   0 -
      ,   "   
 -G0      , 0- (,,   
(( ,  (" ,  (  : ( -
""   " 0 :    ,  ,
( , !  - 


,-c30  ""03:   c
c
  0      -,(( (( G


Dissent.   ë 8?@G8?GA,  0(-  
ë  @G GA-  7 2 0@G2 0GA  /"7 
@G7 GA= 8?   ,((    G ""0
3:   @3A   ' 0 (    = ,,  '<  
 , "  +!H41.@A@4A<< -   ,      
  ,       " ,"(0 "  =  G
0 "=   ((  0    -     "= 
     

F8?:  "= , ( :0    ?(( - 
  "0   ((  -  0  "= 
"(    '(  "( ,          (  
 - "=  "     , '<    - ,
  "     , >     (   G,
  , (      0    G    - 
       "= "   ,      -   0  
    , '   , 


Discussion.    0   0   ((      
 0    -     "=  ((  0    , 
    - ((      

,c2"  c


Graham v. Richardson 

Citation. 41#!#6&@.)A

Brief Fact Summary. : >      !  :   ,
 !  ,  ,,     0  , ,   , 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.      0  0     =    

Facts.   ( - @ ( A-    ,   ,        ,
0      , ,,       ( 
 0      > " , : ,       
>  ,  " " , !   
@ A

Issue. À : 0       :     
" " ,  E

Held. 3,((  0,," 

F   7%"@7%"A  G(  G, (( , 


 " "  "(      :  -  
,,0 0   >( ,  

F7%"-0, ( " , !  @( " A-


       0  % ,    
 -    =    

F ( "    ? G  (  "  , 
 , , :  G "( 00 "   ,(( ,
  -      


Discussion.  "(0,        " " 
( 0  -     0    =    

,*c    c
Foley v. Connelie 

Citation. 4#&! .@.)+A

Brief Fact Summary. 3 ;% (  <:  ," 0((   


( "  (( -" @(( A-  ,  ((  ,   
(  '"    ,    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /      ( 0 -  , 
  0    =       

Facts. 3 ;%(  <:  ," "0  ( ,,  /  
((     ((  ,   (  '"  ,    
 -   - 00 , >( 

Issue. À   "     :  "( 0 ( , E

Held. ; - 0       ,  ((  0,," 

F ,  / 70 @70 A , "=    
            G       
:    G70   "    0  -,
,, - = <:  -   G  ,(
  G ( ( -  -  '  , (, , 
"" 

F  "   <:    :  -    
  0<:     (  ,:  
<:   '      (  ,( ,,  0 :  


Dissent.   0À @À A0  0,  ,   
(   (((  0  ( ,( ,,   > ( <
"%0  - "(   0 , (( 

Discussion.  "= 0   ,     -"     
   0 0 G ( 0 G   0 ((( - 
    

,Ac"  3%c


Ambach v. Norwick 

Citation. 44!6+@.).A

Brief Fact Summary.   (  -3%ë0 -        0


 ,    ,3 ;%    0 , %,!  :  (

Synopsis of Rule of Law. -%  ( ( - (  G,"  0,
I  J0 " -G       0 

Facts. 3 ;%   ,   ,, (  (      0  
,!  :  (-  ,  %:  (    , 0
:   0   %:  ,    ,  %:
     > " , ,     "   0 -
 00  > "    " >( , 

Issue. À      0 ,    , 0  0 


 " " ? >  E

Held. ; ((  0   " 

F  $   @ A0   >  :  (
   "%  0 0, (( ,  
'  0 0 " ,   "(  ( ( 
   -4#&! .@.)+A

F(-    G (( ,    


,   0 " - (( -: ?  
 (   G, 0 - ,  -       ,
:  ( ,


Dissent.    7%"@7%"A0  3 ;% >  
(-      %  ((  ,"
  

Discussion. 3% '       " 0   ,0 " ,
!  "= ?   03%-    : ?   
 " 0  0   0 "  "(  ( " , !  
@( " A0 0 (( ,,  0"     
 " "=    :    ,  (  - 
 0     ( -     0  
( 

,Xc   ë c
Plyler v. Doe 

Citation. 4&)! 1 @.+ A

Brief Fact Summary.  '     , 0""0 , (  $ 0
 (  ,   0 - 00 ' ?      > 
 ,  " " , !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   "   , (    ,
"  ""0 

Facts.  '    0,"    (     , 
!  :   0  

Issue. À  '   "    (    0 
 " " ,  E

Held. 3((  0,," 

F  /"7 @7 A 00   ,  ,   
  0 ",   "   (    
 " " ,   -    
   , 7 0 ( 0 (  ?
 0   0  ,    G"(
,"  ( ,=  G

F "= 0        "   ,
 (     ,   ,  7   "  
     (  @  ,A     
," 0-    (((  -  ((   
"( G, 0 (-G "= 0   0
"  ,  ,    0 "= - 
0 " 


Dissent.  ,  / 70 @70 A G  ,   "(  % 
  ' ((    0     ( ,(  -G
  ( " , !  @( " A,(0  <  
((  -  0  0    '( , (   , 
,"      0 

Discussion.    - "=   0  0 ((  > ,
( @    ,, ,  0 , (  EA-   0 
 0      ,0," 

,c   ë c
0 "     "  -  ,"00 00 ,
  

,*.cÀ   7,  "  À0c


Àassachusetts Board of Retirement v. Àurgia 

Citation. 4 )!#1)@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary. À    >   ( ,,    (0&1  
  ( -À0@ ( A-0  "(    "   " >
(    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0  ,     =      

Facts.   (  ,,  ,"  , À     
!( &1  -  (   > "(     -0
(  '"= ," (  "   (    
(  , = ,   (  0 !  ë - 00
 "(    " ,À       ", >( 
  

Issue. À À    0  ,  " "(    " , ( 
,,  E

Held. ; ((  0  

F ( " , !  ? @( " A"=   0
    0  " ( ( -  (  
"  ( ,G(( , > " G       , 
0  - ( "          
((  ,     

F % (     ,,  "  (  ,
' 0  ,    ,(  ,     0 -
  0  (         1? #1? 0
À    >  (   ,,,    0 ,41-
    > "     "       , (  
      , 0 0  (' -  - ( " 
,  >(  

Dissent.   0À @À A  -00 0% 


," 0  (( , 0   ,  -    
 "0      "  (   "  "(
" 

Discussion.   0,À0 0  ,    =     


  2      "0"      (  @,,  
((0&1 (   '"  - A- "00  "=  
%0 0 ( ,0  ,     @, '"( - ? 
  0-%00 - 00 -  ( - A

,*,cc
c
CHAPTER †III. Fundamental Rights ^nder Due
Process And Equal Protection 
,*0cB %  c
ùablocki v. Redhail 

Brief Fact Summary.   ( - @ ( A-   "0      ,
/      >0 ("0 ,/     < "
 "   , ((

Synopsis of Rule of Law. À0  ," 0- > "( 0    
,,    "   ,    " ,0 (

Facts.   (  <,< %"0 -,"    (  


"   ((  (    "( ,0(  ,"  " ,    
N#-)11   ((( "    ( ? "0   , ( "  )-.)4   
0  (  00 '(( " , "0 (  
    (        ,  "   0 
 ((

Issue.   /    ?  ,    0"  ,  " " ? 
>  E

Held. ; ,((  0,," 

F  0À @À A , "=   (   "0  
," 0  ,   0,  ,    '  ,
 07  , -  "  "( 0    ,    
 "      ,,       

F  0    0   0  - >0   ((
 0  ,"(    (     ,   0 
"0 ( ( 0  (( 0    0 "
( " , "0  -   "       

F        ((  , ((  ,  
  "   > "  -"  0   ((  -  0
"   ,"    -       
  7  ,  ,0 " ,   - "    ,,    
 0 "     c

Dissent.   /" > @ > A0 "0   ," 0
 00       0 ,      > 0 
    (      

Concurrence.     @ A  =0" -     0
   > 0 - ( " , !  @( " A  
   "( "    0,"0     (  ,  (    ë 
  ,  " " , !   @ A

Discussion.   ( 0      0     "     
,,     "= (, 
/      0 <
 - (  " /      (( 0   
 ?          , "  , -  ,   
 (  "  ,:   > 0 "0  ," 0 
/   (0 "  0(    

,*cÀ  2 ëc


Àichael H. v. Gerald D. 

Citation. 4.!1@.+.A

Brief Fact Summary. À "( 0  ë     " 2 ë-   ,
,? (   " 0  (  , 0 -       
2 ë   "  0

Synopsis of Rule of Law.     0"   ( 0 ( 0 ," ( 
 0  ' , ( 0 , 0, 

Facts.         -À "( 0  ë     
"  02 ë  ,"   -5ë- 2 ë    
,    ,  2 ,"   "" 0 ?  - 5
(    ,, (0 -ë3   À   .+L  5? 
0, /  ë2 ë   ( -À  ë 0  
5ë  (     ë2 ë      ë 
" *À   ,( 0  5ë,? (      
( "    @A,,  0 <"(      , 
"0  ( "("    0    ,  ,   ,"0 

Issue. ë,? (     ( À ,," 0 (  
E

Held. 30,," 

F  @A , À ?   0, 
' 0( <  (  "( (  ,5ë( , -
        ,0 ,"     
( =   


Dissent.   /"7 @7 A  -  0 "= ?      0 ,  
(    ,"   0 0         "  
 ,"    (    ë-2 ë-À 7 , 
     ,,,  " "" "=   "

Discussion.  "=,,      "=      !   
@ A  ,(  , - (( -000" ?     
   ,  (  0  ,"  00  @,   
 (   ( ,, (0-"( 0 " "  "  ( 
  A/   7 ? ((       ,  @,  
,"   "     ë-   (  ,  ,"    
0"   ,0 EA  ,0" 7 ?   >      ë
À ?     
Àoore v. City of East Cleveland, Ohio 

Citation. 4#!4.4@.))A

Brief Fact Summary.    -À  :À À @  A-   ,",,  
    0 , 0 , 0   0  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   "   "( 0  ,0 (  ,  ,
  0 ,% ( 0  

Facts.   ?  0  ( ,  0  0 ,"   
 > - - 0:  ,  0 ,     G 0 ," G 
" , "(   -     , 0  -  
  -      0 " ,    , , 0 ,"  
 0    ( N &,  ( & =

Issue. À      ,, 0 ,"  "   "  "  ,
      "  ," ,E

Held. 3((  0   " 

F  $   @ A "( 0        , 
0 <,"  0 0 0( ,   00       
   -(-"0 

F - , 0," " "       '  ,"  0
 (  ,       0     -   " 
'  ," "  '  ,"   ," "   0  
," 0 0    "( 0   0 
 ,, 0 ,"  "   ' "  ,    


Dissent.     @ A0   ,  0 , , 0 ," 
,  "  -         " "  
 " ((     ,,    ? 0 , 

Discussion.  "=  ,, 0    (, ," 0   
   "=   ,"       0  ,"    
"    " ,""   0 - ( " < 0

,*XcÀ  3  %c


Àeyer v. Nebraska 

Citation. 6 !#.1@. #A

Brief Fact Summary.    -À @  A-    , 0 02 "
1< <   ,    00  0,, 000 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0,(   '    ( ,     

Facts.   ( -   ,3  %@ ( A-"  0   <0 
00 -  <0 00 ((( 0  , =" , 
  0   

Issue. À   ,3  %, 0<00  E

Held. 3  " À  @À  A G"  % 0 , 2 "00 
     0  ",G  - ,,     (   ,   
(( ,  ,   ,  (  ,  '(   

Discussion. À    = ,,    " %  <2 " " 
,0  //   00     "   " -  
 ?   ,  0"0   ((G"   -G ,0  0(  " 
À     ,= (  (  (" , ," 0M"( 0  
  M     ,  ( " , !  @( " A

,*c'  2  c


Troxel v. Granville 

Citation.  1 1&4@ 111A

Brief Fact Summary.     - 0(  ,   ' 3 ' @   A-  
 " -  ( -"" 2  @ ( A-,  0 - / 0  
     ,  0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    ,(   G -  -,  G 
," 0  "  0 "( 0  

Facts.   ( 7' @À' A  (   "   ( 
0  -  (  "   ,   ( -À' ""    " 
   (   -À' ,  0   ' 3 '  (  ?
 , À' ?   - (       ( 00  
 -  ( ? (,(((   "  ,,  ," 0(  ?-
  / 0  :0 ,  0   ( - 0(   % ,=
  "    ,  

Issue. ë  / 0   ,     (    0, E

Held. ; ( " ,/ 00,," 

F  ë 8?@8?A     0,  , " 
," ,(    7  , -   " (   '   ,
"( 0  ,   
F8?( "( 
@A     >  ,, 
(  0 ( ?     00 @ A     "
 (  ,0  ( " "(-    ( "(,
(       ,  7  , -      
0  (     ( ?  (,    , 
 

Dissent. 
F    @  A          -  
/ 0( "  %    ,c
1c  @A0     0>  ,," 
-    0  
F   *   @*   A      ,   > 
   (      (  ( ?  0 

Concurrence. 
F  ë  @ A0     ,     
     ,  0  " 
F    " @" A   ,,"  0    
/ 0 "( 0   <0 0,( ?     
,( 

Discussion.  (    ,  ,   -     
  ((   ,  (    0  ,,     
 (        ,     
,A½c%  8%"c
Skinner v. Oklahoma 

Citation. #6!&#&@.4 A

Brief Fact Summary.    -% @  A-        : 
8%"?  " :@ A 0   ( ", >
(    

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0 ,, (0 ," 0- >0"( 0    
 ,  

Facts. 8%" , G "G (  -G 0   " " ,
" ?"0,    0"( ?  8%"  -   ,   
, ,  8%"     ","( " 8%"(  G
 "    = ,   :       , ,,,  
,  0  , ,"   ë0  -  ( 
( 0     0 "

Issue. À     :  0  , 0  , ,    0"
( E

Held. 3( " ,8%"0  

F  /"ë0 @ë0 A   :, ,,    


0  ,,      " -   0  
,,    (,,    "  

Fë0 = ,       @  0"( A
" :: " @  0"( A  ,      
 "ë0 ?    " ,, "( "  "   
  8  "   : " ,,   - >(  
 


Concurrence.  ,   @ A  =0" -       ( 
0 -00   ,(     0 

Discussion. %  (   ( " , !  ?00  , 0
 ( " !%   ,  ( 0(  - "= % 
   : (     >( (( 

,A,c2   c


Griswold v. Connecticut 

Citation. #+!4).@.6&A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  -2   @((  A-   ,( 0,"-
  -"   " (    "  (  (

Synopsis of Rule of Law. " "   : ,(   0 " " 
 

Facts.  ":   , ""  (-     0
0  ,  (     '  ë ,   
$ 0 ,       , ( 0,"   
"  " ( ( 

Issue. À  0 "   , ( E

Held. 3((  0  

F  /"ë0 @ë0 A   G( "  IJ,"   " ,"
( ,0 , 7,0 G(-    ,  
G  ( ",   % 0 G     " " , ! 
  @ A     0 G(   ( G 00  
" , " "   7,0 

Fë0  00   "  (    , : ,(    
(    , ( -  ",   -  " 
  , "  ( 0      (  
'  ,   


Dissent.   07%@7%A  @ A   " , 
   ,,   -        ( , (    - 
 "  ,  0  0 (  - = 

Concurrence. 

F  À @À A0        ë 
 0 -   "   G    ?"(  (,  
  ?Gc

1c  7 / @/ A  ( 0 -  0 (( , 
   , (  , 0 '    0" 
(  0 (   0  ( 

F  2 0@2 0A   3" " , !  
 @ A0  "  0    ( ( -
  -       0   (


Discussion.  (, 2     ,  0   
 " - ,, 0  ( " ? (  " G G 0
( ,,  
Eisenstadt v. Baird 

Citation. 41&!4#+@.) A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  -7@((  A-   , 0 (0(,
!        0 ( ,"  ,    

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   "  "   " "   ( 0
   , (

Facts. À       ,( (    0 (   0
@A" 
(       ( ( ( 0 -  ," 00  ( (O@ A
0 ( ( "     ( ,"  ( ( 0 @#A  "    
 ( ,"  (   ( ,  

Issue. À     "   " " ( ( 0 "  E

Held. 3((  0,," 

F  /"7 @7 A G, 0(  "   0-"   
0,  -"  0 - , ," 0 "  
"   ,"  ,, 0(          0 G


Dissent.  ,  /"70 @7 0 A0    0  " " , 
!   @ A 00   "  "     ( "% 

Discussion. 0(   0 0:     - 0 (  '  
"   -  

,Ac  / c
Roe v. Wade 

Citation. 41!#@.)#A

Brief Fact Summary.    -  @  A- ( 0 0   '   
( 0 ,">0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.    "   ,, "?   (  

Facts.     ( 0 ( 0  0 0   , ' ,
( 0"    (,  ,"( ,"0  

Issue.  ' "    0 "?   (  E

Held.   - ( 0 "  0 (     "? , 
  % 

F  /"7 @7 A( "  0  0  -


  ' ( ,""     0    " ? ,  
 

F  , , "  -  ( 0" ( " "%    
 00  ",( 0 

Fë0  "  -   "  0  "        
"  

Fë0 "  -   "  (  (  - ' (   , 
 , "   %


Dissent.   /" > @ > A  -0  00  <"  ((,,  
 "=  ( % " ,= 0    

Discussion.  0(    '  , 0       0"? 0
 " ( 0  ?  <"  (( 0   ,    :0 
 0 -  " ,((     -&1&!+##@.. A

,A*c    c


Planned Parenthood v. Casey 

Citation. &1&!+##@.. A

Brief Fact Summary.    "    @ A.++<+.-0    0 


/ -41!#@.)#A   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   0,   0

Facts.    "    > -"0 0 -"0 ,"    
4  ,  (  -"    ( 0  @0   = ( 
(," A" ""  0  "   0   ,   , 
(  

Issue. ë  "    ,  ,   ?( <  (, 0 E

Held. 3((  0  

F  ë 8?@8?A- *   @*   A-ë  @


 A , ( " , !  @( " A-0GIJ 
 ,    0 ,  ?  (, '   -," 0-,   -
, "   ,", 7  ,   "   ,    ,
(     ,"  "( ,  G
F8?-*   -       ( "  ,,"0
   "   , ,     (-GIJ , 0((  
 , ?  ,0  %    .)#3 (" ,
         "(  '(  ,   "  
  ,    %0G
FG    '  -  , (  ,  -, ((  ,,  ( 
     (," %0  ,  ,      G
F7       ( , 0( 0 -  " % "   
    "?   ," - 0  "     
   "? 0!     0 (     
" %0 "(     0
F " (  ",""%0 "    "  ( 0 
,    
Dissent. 
F ,  /" > @ > A       "((    
 >  ( "   0
F  @A    "((    -    
   ( -     

Concurrence.    7%"@7%"A 0 ( (     
      ( ," 
Discussion.  "= %  0"   , , "      ,
         (   ( ,  0  ( " ? 
"( (    

,AXc  0 c
Stenberg v. Carhart 

Citation.  1 &.)@ 111A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -@ ( A- % ,=, 0  , " ,
3  %?    0 < G(   G

Synopsis of Rule of Law.     (   0  ' ( , 
" ?  

Facts.   (  3  %( ( ,"    0ë0  
"  ,( 0 -  , "  ,    " ,   " ,   0 
(   "   - " " " -( ,,   ,  ,"
   3  %":  ( ," , G( G(   

Issue. ë  3  %     "?  ( 0 E

Held. ; ((  0,," 

F   7 @7 A  " (" -  0 "?  
  0  "  ,     ' ( 3  %  , 
" ?    ( (     , " , 

F3  %    ,( 0( (      ,   
,"0,  %0  "   0


Dissent. 
F  @A      , ( " , !  ?
@( " A = (   = 0 
F   *   @*   A 00     <( (  0 
    > ,  
F    " @" A      ,= (      / -
41!#@.)#A- " 0 =  "

Concurrence. c
1c  ë 8?@8?A       ,  

@A   "   ' (-@ A  , " "" "  
  > "(    "? 0 
F  7 2 0@2 0A>  ,((   ,0 
    0 ,   >  (  -   0 
,,   - 

Discussion.  0   ( "     "   
"   ' (  0,"? 0  0- " %   
00"( , ( " "  (,      "0   

,X.cÀ   c
Àaher v. Roe 

Citation. 4# !464@.))A

Brief Fact Summary.  / , ë (" "   À   , ,, "    
  "     

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ( " , !  @( " A    0  
( 

Facts.   / , ë (" " ,0,, "        
G"     G0 "  0 -"0      "  0
 

Issue. À   0 ,0,  "  " 0     0
< (   E

Held. ; ((  0,," 

F  $   @ A    G 0 G 


    0  0 "      ,  "? 
    

F " "%  "  (, 0  ( 0,( 0 
%  "-     (    ,0 "(0
  ( "  (     ? (  


Dissent.   /"7 @7 A     ,0"    "
  "%0 (    , " 

Discussion. !  0 "= (- "   0 " ,0,
       ,0  -   (0    ,0 
" 0    

,X½c    c


Planned Parenthood v. Casey 

Citation. &1&!+##@.. A

Brief Fact Summary.  "      @ A (   
" "" ,"  ,   (   ' ( ,"  " 0  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ( ,(        "? 0
   

Facts.    "    > -"0 0 -"0 ,"    
4  ,  (  -"    ( 0  @0   = ( 
(," A-" ""  0  "   0   ,   , 
(  

Issue. ë   ( , > " (     "(0 E

Held. ; ((  0  

F  ë 8?@8?A0  <,0"0 - ( 


""    0   0  - ,"0 -  
 0 (   ,     ( 0  
   -   (      "? 0 

F8?  00      (    ,"0  , 0 ""<


 ," ?   "0 -  (0   ,"0 


Dissent.  ,  /" > @ > A0        "( 
         "    (  "       
 0   (  0     , ,   

Discussion.          (      " 


    %  "- "        

Concurrence.     @  A  "= (-   (  
       0  , =0  0  > , ,
 
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c c
c
Bellotti v. Baird 

Citation. 44#!6 @.).A

Brief Fact Summary. À    > " ""0  ,"  
(   , (0 ,   - ( =0 "     

Synopsis of Rule of Law. "? 0 "   (  - 0    
  (  (     

Facts. À    > " -""  (  ," (   , 
0 >       0     -  
(  ( ,  "   "  0"%    - ,   -
       

Issue. À  ""? 0 (  E

Held. ; ,((  0,," 

F  $   @ A0  0 ,"  "  
    ,(  "%    , ",, (0

F ( " , !  @( " A(      
(   "?    "  ( 0    
  -  (  G ,    G,0=  "  ,
(  7       (    0   
>  ,( 0" %0 -     


Discussion.  "(,7    0,    , "" "0 
( 0  (   0     ,, (0

,X0c: ë -À ë (, c


Cruzan v. Director, Àissouri Dept. of Health 

Citation. 4.)! 6@..1A

Brief Fact Summary. 3 :? @À :A(   0"  " ," 
0  0 -       , ,,    ,3 ?  À :? (  
0   ,- 00       , " 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   0     "0 0 0 (  0 

Facts. À    , "  >   À :? (     À 
:?    00    0   À :  
,  ,       ,  ((-        ,
 (    

Issue. ë À   0"      "( 0      ,"(  (  E

Held. ; ((  0,," 

F ,  /" > @ > A  "  "     
  ""  -    "       , " 
 "  -  " "     ( 

FÀ  ,      ( 0 ,"(  ? " 
   -   ,           0  -
= 


Dissent.   /"7 @7 A  -00     0À :? 
     0 "  

Concurrence. 

F  ë 8?@8?A - "( :0 ( " , 


!  @( " A      "        
,"  0 

F  @ A -   (     ( ,  
  ( "%0        - ( (   
,,   


Discussion. /  ( "           > 0 " - À 
:? ,"  ,,   "   ( ,-  ( "   À    
    "0      ((   ,"(  

,Xc/ 0 2% 0c


Washington v. Glucksberg 

Citation. & !)1 @..)A

Brief Fact Summary.   (  -2% 0 (    " (  
@ (  A % / 0( 0       

Synopsis of Rule of Law.           (    !   
@ A

Facts.    0 " (    %0  " / 0  
( 0       

Issue.        0(   0     E

Held. 3((  0  

F ,  /" > @ > A    ": "   
   /   " ,  (   %   ,
 , 0

F ( " , !  @( " A         
    0 "  " - ,  (( - " 
,  -        0  ,0     
(  0
", -( 0     ,  "   (  
 2   ,/ 0 "( 0     ( 0
     - "          


Concurrence. 

F  ë 8?@8?A -    > ,


  "  "(  ( "  %,   %0 ,   
   ,       0  

F    @  A 00 / 0   
,  - ,   (    " (( ,   "0
   

F   7 @7 A    -    ,", 
0 G 0""   ?    -G ," "
G 0 0 G

Discussion.  ( "        ,( "0
      ' O   ( ( 0     - 
    0      

,XAc$    ' c


Lawrence v. Texas 
Citation. &.&!&&+- # 4) -&6$ &1+@ 11#A



Brief Fact Summary.     -2  $  @GÀ$  GA  2 @GÀ2 GA
@    ,    G   GA-           (   
 '   , 000   '
Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ":0 0 ,  "  ', 000 
" -   ,  " " , !   @ G GA
Facts.  (     À$  ? "  (  (     
  ,     ( /  (     " - ,    -
 - 000   '        0  0 ' 
 H 16@A-(  GIJ(  "" ,,  ,  00    '  
  ,  "  'G    , GIJ   '  G ,
G@A 
   (, 0  , (   " , (  OG@7A 
(  , 0    , (   = GH 1@A
Issue. 
F   "%  0,(   ,  "  ' 00  " 
E
F     ,    00  (  ,   '  '  , 
    ë   ,  " "   E

Held. 
F3-      , ë   ,  " " ,  
  '   G,   0"     = ,    (  
(  , ,  G
F;  ( " , !  @G( " GA       I  
 @!J-2 0  ":0  ' (   
 *   @G*   GA-0, "= - 0 :0 ( " ? 
,"0,   I  J-   %   ' ,      %  
( " I  J,"     ,
G      ,  
," 0(" '  00  "       , " 
  "%   0   ,  0" G*   
  -       G %(    (-  
  ," 0 -    ,(     0
(   " G -GIJ ,, ,I "= J% 0  " 
   (   ( , , "  (   
  0  , (   G3 0  "  !  2 " 
  0" 0    0  ( ,(   *   (   
 ? @G  A 0(,"I  J 


IJ( "% ((      - , 0 0"= 
      ((  ""  ,,   ,(0
( 0 ( O      ( 0"  0 ,"
 % -     " (   - 0 " , 
(   (-    ( ,, (0- ,",?  ?(    
ë   ,  " " À  - (  '  "  
"    " (   
Dissent. 
F  @GA-/" > @G > GA  " @
" A    0=  :  "= ? ((,  ,  
 @( , -GIJ ? ((   @           
(   @0G      G  A,
@A ,   G  G 
 >    O@ A    = G  0G "O@#A 
 G     G  0  0G  0=  
 0 Iü J  ,   <(0 
F"  ,   =0? "    
,   G""   G ""    '  0   ( 

Concurrence. 
F  ë 8?@G8?GA  =0"  -  ,  0 
(  " " ,  ? ë   -     
>    " " ,  *   -0, 
"=  ,       >  8?   G ' 
 "% " '  >  ,  "%0(<< 
<<  = " G -G ' ? "   " '  
" -  "%0" ,,," '      " "  
    G -GI"J (( , 0(-%     " 0(- 
    ,,   ,        >  G

Discussion. 7    - ( "    (    I    @!J
 "=   
GIJ !  - ",I  J    0- (( 0
,   0 (  -=     "( G
F*       ,   @  
GIJ  ,   @ 
  (   =0"  ,     ,  -
 - '  ""G

,.c/   c
Whalen v. Roe 

Citation. 4 .!&+.@.))A

Brief Fact Summary.   ,3 ;%"  : "(   , " 
 ,(      - ( (-0,     0 0
"% 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0 " " "    ,(  ,","  
   

Facts.   ,3 ;%  0(  ," 00  (  0 ,
    0 0"%     ": :    ,  ,"

Issue. À  0 " "  ,(   ," 0: ,(  E

Held. ; ((  0  

F    @  A0    ,,     "(  
: ,(   ,   0   0(  "      
0 (   "%0    

F   (  0 (     "  0 ,         
 ( (0  "  (  ,         
 0  


Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A 0      ,(  
  -      "( "     ,(    % 0  , ,
    -   % 0      (  ,:    

,½c :  c


Saenz v. Roe 

Citation. & 6!4+.@...A

Brief Fact Summary. ,   > ,"  ,,  "  , 
"0 0  ,, ,   ,   "-   "  "(      ,
 ," ? (   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  "  " 0 <    "    " 
(  0 ""  =   :  , 

Facts. ,   > ,"  ,,  "  ,  "0 0  ,,
 ,   ,   "-   "  "(      , ," ? (   
 '"( -," ," 0,":  0  , N )&M"-  ,
    0  ,N4&6M"

Issue. À   " 0 <:      0    E

Held. 3,((  0,," 

F    @  A    0 ""  , ! 
  @ A0 :  ,        
  " "  : ,     0     " 
           0      

F,   "   -       
" N"      0 "(  -  
 " "   (((      


Dissent.  ,  /" > @ > A (( ,  ,   0 "" 
 ,         0    (,G G >  
 :     -  0   

Discussion.   0"   >    ( , 0     (  0 
""   0-        " : ,  0   

,,c(  50 7,  c


Harper v. †irginia State Board of Elections 

Citation. #+#!66#@.66A

Brief Fact Summary. 50    0 0   7,  - 00 ('
  !   @ A

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ('   >  ,  " " , 
 

Facts. 50  (' ' 0N&1    ,     ,0  
    0   '   " " ,  

Issue. ë  ('   >  ,  " " ,  E

Held. ;    "   /"ë0 @ë0 A  '    0  
  ,  
 ,, '   -   
 " 0  ,, '

Discussion. 7   0 ," 0- ,   0 0      : 
 (  - ,      ((( 

,0c*"  ! ë c


Kramer v. ^nion Free School District 

Citation. #.&!6 @.#.A

Brief Fact Summary.    -*" @  A-  ,  0       -
 3 ;%   >0((    (    0     
   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  "0 0  "     "( 0  
  

Facts. 3 ;%$ >    (, ((      ,
  0    0                0
 "      , 00        %, ((  
  (  ,   0 - %0         
 " " , !   @ 

Issue.   3 ;%      "( 00 "   E

Held. 3((  0   ,  / @/ A   ?  0" 
   "   0   "   G  ,,  G/     "
, '  '  " " "      @       0 A
  "    @   =    ((   
 A  -   

Dissent.     @ A0   ,  -    G (  
  "     0 ,,0 "   '  G   , ( 
  ,  (  - 0   ,  

Discussion.  0   ," 03 /      
 "  0        -   ""    
"( 0   0   

,-c7 " c
Ball v. James 

Citation. 4&!#&&@.+A

Brief Fact Summary.   = 0"( "  ë @ ë A-  
         :   , ë    ,   
   < - <    ",((" 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 0 "   ," (( -  "    0  "  
    ,  <    

Facts.  ë "(  #6-111  :  ë ? (" ((  ( 0 
  #6-111 -  0       , ë     ,   ,
 ë    ?   (    ,       

Issue. ë   0  " , ë   > E

Held. 3    @ A   ( ,, ë = , 
 ( ," ((<   > "          (    0  "
 0 "  =  

Dissent.   7 / @/ A0  ,, ë     "= 
  /    ë (    (    :  
   <(   <  ((  (( 

Discussion.  "=  ,,    :, ,, ë   
0 , ,  0-   0  "   (  - , ,  - 
 <(  - <   (( 

,c   " c


Reynolds v. Sims 

Citation. #).!+)1@.64A

Brief Fact Summary.  ,,  0   ((" ,  " 0      
.11,      ((0   0 '   "  ( 
 " 0   , <00(( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. "   -    ((      -
   

Facts.   , " >  ,    0        - ,,  0 
  (("  0  '   !   ((" -  > , 
((    (   "= ,    , (  

Issue.      ",(("   0 "     >( , E

Held. ; 

F ( " , !  @( " A GIJ 0   ( ( ( -
  G,  0     (,  ""  0   
,  0  - 0  ,     (  ( ,    
 

F0 ,   0    ( ((" ,  -     
     -((" ,   0     ,  <(  - <
 ( 


Dissent.   À @À A0       "  
"( ,  0     (> - 0    , 
( " 

Discussion.    "      (( (("  , !   
@ A
 <(  - <   ( " 0   <=   ,(>   
,"0 0"  >  
G  ' : ? 0     -  
" : G

,*c7  2 c
Bush v. Gore 

Citation. &4! 6)@ 111A

Brief Fact Summary.  (  0  111(      ,?   
 ( "   G  ,       ,"   G

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G  "  " "( "   (     , 
( "   ,  """ > " ,<   " ,         
," 0G-GIJ(   , ,,  ,  (-    
   "(   > "  , >(  ( 
 %G

Facts.    0  111          G 0 
( ,      -  0    "   ( , 
,, (  ,"  "G   -G(  , TT 00-  
  G  G    (-=  G ( " 
  G  ,       ,"   G    (  ,,,  
  ,,      "    0  

Issue. ë  ( "  ?     >  , !  
 @G GAE

Held. ;  ( " , !  @G( " GA,"     ,
GIJ > 
,       -  '  ,  '(  -"  (,,  
 " ,"( " 0     -  (        
(   ,"        ""(  , 0 G 
( "  GIJ  "  " "( "   (     , 
( "   ,  """ > " ,<   " ,   
      ," 0G ( "   GIJ(   , 
,,  ,  (-       "(  
 > "  , >(  (   %G ( " 
  GIJ   =     ((  0((  (  "  
   , ( ,       >(( ,",," 
  "      0"   (  -  -   GG 
 ( - ,      -     """(     
(  ," 0,     (   ,       
, 0   =,, 8   "  ( "  -, (  "
, >(   ( 0   (  " "( ' G

Dissent.     @G  GA-  7 2 0@G2 0GA-  /"
7 @G7 GA,  0(     
GIJ   0    
("  (   ,  "0 " ,  0      / >    
 " 0,   -0   -   (  ( ( , 0 
 ,   ( 0 ,   G =      ,  >  
    G  G =  " G  ,,, 0   ,  "0   
,,    "( 0 " 0  " "            <<,
 " <<  , 0 "("0  "  =  =   0," 
 ( G - =  :  ( "(  "   
G  " ,(   "= ,       "  (( ,
 %,=0 0  ,   " " "   =  "
    %  ,  ,"     ,   
,   ?   8 0- -  0 "  %"(    
   ,  ,  ?     -   ,   ( ,     
3? ,   =0  "(0,  ,G
F  ë  @G GA  /"7 @G7 GA  G "
    ,     ,"  , 0 
 ( ,   ("( ,, 0 "  - (( "0
  ( 0     ,  0@    0A
  "0 G -GIJ%  "= -I  J,  " 
(   "(   > "  ,    , " 0,
  G

F2 0-  - 7   (, ( "( 


=  , -GI J 0  >   ,  ?  ,  
  (  0,  ," -  ,      
((  " 0:  ,  ,G

F7 ,  0(-( ,  =    -2 0


 7   - (  ,  %0,  (  (    -
G( "  0 -(    0>  - >  
   -       (( ?  (  % / 
' (-(   ?"  %    (   0 ( 
 "0G7   0 - ,     ((     
  ,   ( 0     (  G '(  ( ( ? ," 
      G7 G ( "0     -
( "0    ,"  Gc


Concurrence.   /" > @G > GA-  @GGA-    
" @G" GA, 0(0 0 ( "(- 0 (  
  ,  ( "       0  =0   
  -H-     ( , G  "(  ,  ( 
( ,  0 " G -GIJ        - ( " 
0    " ,   ?  '    - ,     -
   >  ?  7- (     - 
"   ",,  0  ?     0 " ,((0   
 ,      '(   "(     0     " G
  "(        " (  ,G((" ,     G -
   ( "  (  G 0  G G    <(  -
(  ( ,"?  0    " G3    '  G, 0     >0 
0,"((  "%   G - 0=      (   
"(    >  "   

Discussion.   "(       ,     0 '" 
 ,,  =     "( 0  ,  ',(    

,c7   c


Boddie v. Connecticut 

Citation. 41!#)@.)A

Brief Fact Summary.     -7   @   A- 0 0   ( -
 ? @ (  A  ( - 0  N61( 0     ( 
" 0  ,,  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ,"0  ," 0   :  -  "     
:    

Facts.   0  ,    N61( 0  -, ,, 
 ,  - , ,      0    0   >(   
 

Issue. ë  "00 0  (( 0,     >  , 
 " " , !   @ AE

Held. ; ((  0  

F  À @A   "0  ," 0


   0 " "  "( 0   "  ((,
   -,"0  ," 0     -  "  
  "  0 

F >0( " ,, (( ,     , 
 ( 
 ,    ,, "( 0  " 
   -  > "    


Dissent.   07%@7%A0   ,   <  ,"0 -    
 ( , ( 0 -  , "  (  

Discussion.  "=   ," 0   ( (     ,  


    (    0   -  "   ( , (  
 ( " , !  @( " A 0    

0..c!   * c


^nited States v. Kras 

Citation. 41.!4#4@.)#A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -* @ ( A- "( , ,,   %( ( - 
   ,, ,0,   (  0    ,  0" %( 
( ,  (  , 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 7%( ,0 ," 0

Facts.   (   "("  , - -   "   ( 
   (        "","    " ,  (  ,,
  (,, ,,  %( ,0, 

Issue.  0   , ,   %( ,0E

Held. 3    "    7%"@7%"A  %(  
," 0 ," 0   -      > ,  , 

Dissent. 

F    @ A 0:    G 0: - ,,    G
     ( / %( ( -  (  "
 "   , ,   , 

F  0À @À A  (   " "= , 0
G,  "(  ( (  G


Discussion.  "= ,,   0"  
," 0-  (  , 
,,     ,0    0"   %(

0.½cÀ$7 $c
À.L.B. v. S.L.J. 

Citation. &.!1 @..6A

Brief Fact Summary.    -À$7@  A-   ,  ,,(( 
    0  ," 0 >   ( ,   , (( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ,( 0    ,," 0

Facts.       , "     (" -  ( -$
@ ( A-  ,(    0 (  ( (, , N -111
((  =0" 

Issue. À   (  ,(( ,0 ?  ,  E

Held. ;    "   7 2 0@2 0A0  (  "" 
,,  ((  =  - "  0 ( "   ,, 
 > "    '"  ,  ," 0   

Dissent.     " @" A  0 ( 0 ,,     "
           0((    

Discussion. /   ," 0   0   -  0 ë  
      , ,    >( "(-    
 "= 0  '( 0 0 -    ,,"    

0.,c$    c
Lewis v. Casey 

Citation. &+!#4#@..6A

Brief Fact Summary.        ,:- 00    ( ,0 ,  
 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.     (    > (        
 - "  0 '(  

Facts.   (  -  " @ (  A- 0     -$    
   ë (" ,  @   A- (   "(<<  0"  -
 0  (( 0   -"0    (   0        "
      

Issue. ë(    0 (- ( ,"    !   @ AE

Held. 3    @A(   ( "   0 
( ,= - 0  : 0  7  , -  (    0 0 

Dissent.     @  A0  ( " , !  ?   
0    (     0 0 

Concurrence.     " @" A0  =0" -   (     
   0,,    0  << ,, ,(  

Discussion.  "=    ,       , "(-  "    
 " 0  ,, 0  -   "= ,  (     %0,
"-  0  : "( 

0.0c (  ë  0 :c


San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez

Citation. 4!@.)#A

Brief Fact Summary.  (   0  ,,(      0( 
   ' - 00  ?   ",,0    ((  '    >
(    (  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  G," 0G,(( ,>   

Facts.   , ' (  ,, ("    ,  ,     
(   ",,0,     " ,       "% 
( ,,   ( 0 '(  , ,"((  '    ((  '   
0  ( (    ( 0  ((  ((  (   (   0 
     ( > ,   ,  " " 

Issue.   ," 0,(( ,  " " E

Held. 3   " 

F,  ," 0- , ,, 0     =  
 
F   " ,    -    '( 
0  >   ,    "( ," 0 
  (  0     " >",  
,"       03 0       
 (   (    ' 
F/ '("( (  - ,    ,  , '  
  , -  %   %0 ,  

F - ((       >   '     
 0" 0 "   
Dissent. 
F  /"7   00" 
@A ,0  ",  , ' 
% 0   -@ A  '("( 0     
 0  ? (     c
1c  0À 0 0? G,"  G (   "( , 
0 ,, 0 0   À 0    
"(  '  ,0 (     " " (( 
((    0, '     0 -"%0
," G   '     ( , 0  <
     -G " (((  0     "  -
  À (( "  0     


Discussion.   ," 00          0 
   ,  0 0  "       (     -
 "= 0 ( ,   (  " " ( , 0    =  
  "( ,     0, ,,    , >(   

0.cë   /" c
Daniels v. Williams 

Citation. 4)4!# )@.+6A

Brief Fact Summary. ë  @  A % "0 ,=        "  
=

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 3 00 0 "   ( ,   - 
,ë  

Facts.    "  =8  -  (( ( ,    /" 
@ ( A-  (   "  ( ?  00     ( , 
G  G  , ","  = 

Issue. ë  00   0 "  >  (   ë   E

Held. 3À   00    > "(  0 !   

Discussion.  (( ,ë   (   ,"  0 "   ,  
     0 " ,0 ( ? 0    , 
'     "  , 0

0.*c ,"  $  c


County of Sacramento v. Lewis 

Citation. & #!+##@..+A

Brief Fact Summary. $  @ ( A ( 0 "     ( /  
"   (( - (   (  %     

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 2 " G %     G   G   , : 
G     " "  " 0    - 0 "  ,, 0  
  

Facts. ( ,,   (0,0  (  ,    ( 
 " (  , ((0- "     (   ( ,, ,,  (  
 ( 0   0  (  ,(11"(/  0"%  ( ,-
 "     ( 0       0  - 
 (  ")1,   (      

Issue. ë ,,       (      , ( 00< ( 
 E

Held. 3 ( ,,  "  (0, ( 

Discussion.  ( ,,  0 =  0  =0"  " , (  
 % ( ""  , -   G %0G 
  !   

0.Acë   / 0 ë (,   c


DeShaney v. Winnebago County Dept. of Social Services 

Citation. 4+.!+.@.+.A

Brief Fact Summary.    -ë  @  A-   "  ,   
   -  ,  ,   "      , = ë0 
 "    0  -  ( -/ 0 ë (,   @ ( A- 
"0 " ( 0 0   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ë   (  ,," 00 "   " 
(   ,"      

Facts.      .). (    .+1 ,  0   ," 
, " /      "      , ,"  ,
  0      (      ,        .+ 
 ( (    ?   ( =   (   (  0"0 
  0 ? "   %          
((    ,, 0,"  -   (  ,      , ,  -
.+#    "   (, "   , "0   
"=   ,  0( ,"  ,      ,
  

Issue. 7 ,0   (    ,"   , ,   (    
      ( E

Held. 3  ? , (  "  ,"        , ë 
  0   "   ,(  ?  -   > (  (  
   (    , "  ,

Dissent. 

F  /"7 @7 A


    (      (0" ( , 
 ( %    7  ,   0    , 
-   ,,"  

F   7%"@7%"A


 "= ,    ,      
, 0 ,,


Discussion. / (    (     % -     0   (   
(  (    -    ,   ,   -    
,,"   " ","    " 

0.c2 0 *  c


Goldberg v. Kelly 

Citation. #.)! &4@.)1A

Brief Fact Summary. 3 ;%        0,   (0"    
 "    , ( 0  (   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 2   ->,  ( ,(    0" ((     
 ,   , 

Facts. 3 ;%         0  " ë (    " 


  ,0"      "  (( ,"  "     > " ,
(  0, %

Issue. ë      ë   ,  " "   "    
( "   (  0    0E

Held. ;       0(      0" ((  0    , -  
"   0     "     0   ,  "(   

Dissent. / ,     ,  0  ,    , !  
 @ A/ ,   (0"     ,  0   ,

Discussion. 7    (        ,  - "=  0 ((  0
 "  0    G G"(   ( ? ,  ,", 

0½.c7, 0   c
Board of Regents v. Roth 

Citation. 41+!&64@.) A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -@ ( A-   0 (,      
        (   '(,     

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ( ,((  0   ,   >   ,   
"   0"   "    ,

Facts.    - 7, 0  @  A-   0 (,  >   
, ,  ,  "( "     - ,   , "( "   , 
  ,     ,         ( 0/  
 !   , .6+<.6. " ë0     00 
   , ,0     0 "0  "(    ë  
0 

Issue. ë       (    ë  0 E

Held. 37  0    ( -    ,0 ( ,   
, "   

Dissent.        (  '(, 0"     (( 
% , 0 "     ,"

Discussion.   (  ((  0  =     < 
( ,    0   "(   ,  3((  0  '  ? 
'(  -     ,  (  '( 0  8  -    
 "0   (-( ",",0 =   , - 0   
 

0½½c2  $( :c


Goss v. Lopez 

Citation. 4.!&6&@.)&A

Brief Fact Summary.   ,  (    "    (  ,"  0
  ,   ,    (   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ?   0" ((  0  - (    
ë    0 %  ((( (  0 

Facts.  8     ((  ( ((,(1  '( ",
" ,     '(       0     "  -, 
  =   (  -   (  , 0   ,   (   ((  -
$( :  @((  A    (  ," "     ",(1 - 
 0

Issue. ë "     "   ((  ? ( 0    (   
 0 0E

Held. ; 8"  0  0 ,"  ,(  
  " , "   

Dissent.  "=      0, 0      (  
 0   "  ,  ","   "  
"( = ,   

Discussion.  "= (     " ,( 0 0   "%0 
"  "  " (    (   ? (  (-   
"   ,   0 >  0 (   0 -  0  "  
 , " (      "    

0½,c ë  c
Paul v. Davis 

Citation. 4 4!6.#@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary.    -@  A-  (  ,-         
0,(   %  (,    ( -ë  @ ( A-   "  
 ( =   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ( -(," " " 0        "( "    
  ((  ,ë  (( 

Facts.      (  ,$  -* %   "  ,( 
(,  -  " "0 "0  , 0  00  " 
 (  (0  , " "  0  0 (  0  "  
" " (   - ( ? 0    -  0    " 

Issue. ë    (   ( ,     00" G  (, GE

Held. 3* %   '   (   00 (  = " , (
      ,   ?    (   ( ,   
((     (    ë   

Dissent.      , "  %     (   - 
  , ( =  ,    ( (     ( 

Discussion.  ( 0,"0  "     (    ,      , 
0    ( - " " ,," ,  ,
,  "(  - ( "0   ( ""

0½0cÀ   0 c
Àathews v. Eldridge 

Citation. 4 4!#.@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -0 @ ( A-    %     0
    , ,        0   (   ,"0 " -
  ( ?   ,    "  0

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  (((   ( ,(    0   "   0
#,
@A (     ,,  O@ A  %," %   ( 0 , 
  @#A   , 0    , 0 

Facts.   (     0,      0 ,      0  
    " ,   0 "    0(  - 0  
  "   (  0     0     (   - '(0 
,0 ( 0(( ,  (  > " (  ,"( 
    7-,   (  , (  ,"- 0  "  ,
  "-  (     "     ", 
       ,

Issue.   , ë      ( ?        , 
0    0E

Held. 3    0  > (  ",     ,  ( 
"  (  , "(   > "  , ë   

Dissent.  "0  , -0 " 0  " ,,    0

Discussion.    ,,    ,  -2 0-    ,     " 0
    0  , '( " (  (   , -   ,
   0 0  "   " - , ,0 "   (  
((     - (   (-(  (,,   

0½-cc
c
CHAPTER IX. First Amendment: Freedom Of
Expression 
0½c 7 0  "-   "" "" c
Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. v. Federal Communications Commission 

Citation. & !6 @..4A

Brief Fact Summary.    0  >      "(   (,
   (0""0

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   , 0 " (     ( 
 ,  $  0    ( , (         
'(   <    =    

Facts.        "  "( ,.. @ A- > 
  "(    " ,     " ,  
      "   "(   0 " ,   
"% " ,,, "( "(  ,  "0  

Issue.   ?" < ?"  , , ",  ( ( E

Held. 3  "(    ,   ,     ,  ( 
        " ,    "( ,,  
0 "  0"  (   ,     =  G"  '0
          =  "   ,  G

Dissent.       ,(0""0  <   ,  0
  (     "" ,"0 0 
",   '   ,   

Concurrence.  <  0    =    

Discussion.  "= = ,      00 "(,,0     " 
   0  (( ,  > "   0 , (
   0( "       , -  < 
 

0½*c7  7  c
Boos v. Berry 

Citation. 4+&!# @.++A

Brief Fact Summary.    -7 @  A-  (  0 ,, 
"   / 0-ë     (    ( ,  
 0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  <   ( ( ( ," 


 =       -  0"       
"( 0        

Facts. / 0-ë  (  ( ( ," ( 0 0 &11, ,
, 0 "  ,  0  0 , 00 " G( "GG( 
  ( G     (  0,,    "    -
G$*885G

Issue. ë       " "  0,  ( E

Held. ;   (    0  (   ( "((  (
(     <   0, 00 ,"   "( 0
0 "    ((, <   0

Discussion.   0, (%    "    


 ( , (   (%  0 00 "( "  (    
((   0  (  

0½Ac (  ,À  / c


Republican Party of Àinnesota v. White 

Citation. &#6!)6&

Brief Fact Summary. À  0 , 0G ,=,, -


0" =0 -G,"G I0J      (  0(
  G   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. À ? G  G    " " , 
!   @G GA

Facts. 0 À      .)4-=0 0,     = 


 0 T G  GT, 0G ,=,, -0
" =0 -G,"G I0J      (  0(  G
,,(      ,  ..6- ,    -2 0 
/  @ G  GA-,=0 (G     :0 À 
( "        " - , - G"(  0
0    -  0     G  G 
"(   ((   ,>    G  ? G
  -       (( ,   -,,  
     0..+ >  (," $  7@ 
G7GA %0   G  G  ,  70 "
 ,   

Issue. GI/J    " " ( "  À ( " (  
,=   ,"0     (  0(  G

Held.   @GGA-0, "= - "":   ( , 


   ,
GIJ  -     (  =
 ," 0      ( ,,, 0>  (  , 
,  0- ' (  ',  0(    <<  
 '  -,  '(             G  ( , 
 (        G ? ? -?? -?
?%  -??I J "   ,   ?G -G 
 ,   "   "- 0  0  -
   ,="    - ((    " 
"    " ,     "G

F     "      (   
 ( , (   ,  " "   - ((  ,
   ((     G!   <   - (   
   (     @A  -  @ A
"( 0    G


0½Xc (  ,À  / c
c
 -G       - "  "  
 ?   "  I J(   '( ?G 0:  
 (  0      G ,,  "( 0= ,   

(  0 "( ,   = (  0 ((  ,
 "( ,   = G

F, "(  (    ,   "G"( G 


   (   " 0 ,  -G%,  ,0   
(  ( 0G"(    G0 (  =0 
    ((  "  "   ((   ( G
7   ,- G     
   "( @ ((  ,"( A   G G 
        "    ( ,
0 (( -   ( ,0 (  G -G
%,(  (, ,0 ( 0  G "= 
  GIJ=0 ? %,(  (  00    0   
   0   "( , >=  -0  G
 -   =    (        -
G 0=(  (  0     (      -
(  0    "(0(   ?((  ?, ( ,
"(   "( 0      G-G"( G 
 ,  ( "    =0 G 0     
((  (  ( - "( (   -     
( 0 G , À ( "   
(( "  G  G ( 

F  0: G   >, , G G  ,
 ( ,  " " , " -G  0 G  
  ,, (    "%  " "(     
,   '(  "  "  , ( "( GG  "( 
 ,,0 "        0 0 
 ,("(0GG/     0 " ( 
 ,"""0  ,"   0  G


Dissent.     @G  GA,  0((  ë 
 @G GA-  7 2 0@G2 0GA-  /"7 @G
7 GA=   0 GIJ ?  (      , ( " <<
 (( , "( ,= (   "( -
 "(=     " , "? '(  "  "  
, ( "( ?     ,, G -  0 
À  

0½c (  ,À  / c


"( 0   0  "    G5 ,"     C-
=0  0 -G   "%0   "  -=0 G  ( 
  %  "  , "        
G

F  7 2 0@G2 0GA,  0((  


  @G  GA-  ë  @G GA-  /"
7 @G7 GA= 2 0 0 G -?   
 -?((  -I  J,,      ,(,, -
  " "  ,  -,"    0    
 ,,  "  =   ( (   G 0  
G?   0       0  , 0   '  
(   ",  ,( G


Concurrence. ë 8?@G8?GA, 0( '( 0 
0     =   8?,    ,=   "  
(   ( ,=0  , =0 "( "     %  
" ,  -,  =       - "    
(("(0 >   -", " " ,", 0
,, $ 0    0  " , 

F   *   @G*   GA, 0(G  I0JI J


 IJ <   (   , 
' (    > 0"( 0
0 "    GG/À " - -    ( ( 
    %   , "    " %   
' "( =,, G -GIJ >     (( 
 0  (   ,,(, "G


Discussion.   ,,    0     " "  (( 
( ( 

0,.c ,   "    -c


City of Renton v. Playtime Theaters, Inc. 

Citation. 4)&!4@.+6A

Brief Fact Summary.    - , @  A-( :0  0
 ,"      

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0  <   , "      
 , "   ( "    < (( 

Facts.    ? :0 (  "     ,"0 "  


-111, ,    --(%  -   "(     
,"  

Issue.   :0  , " " , ", ( 0 , 
 ( - "    -@ ( AE

Held. 3        0    ,,  , 
           , -  
 <  0

Dissent.   (      "      ,  '( 
  , -   <   0

Discussion. 7          "(   -  <  
  <  0   =  " -( -"      0 
  0     0 "        "
    ,""

0,½c3" ,    c


National Endowment for the Arts v. Finley 

Citation. & 4!&6.@..+A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( - @ ( A-   ,  0, 
( ," ,    -3" ,  @  A-  " 
"0,,  0    ,   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ,   0   ((  ,  
 ( 

Facts.     ,  0  (  ,0,  (( , 
,         (  ,"   ,  ""   
    "  0,0,(=  - ((  0 
    =  .+.-(  % ("( (    0 
 , (=   (   -0 ( "  
     G0    ,    ( ,     , 
" ( G

Issue.      ,   ,  ,  " " 0
,  ( E

Held. 3      ,  , ", ( 0  
   0 

Dissent.  G    ( G  "%    <(    
  ' "( ," 0   "%  <    

Discussion.    >      , ,    " 
 '(%    ,  0   , -   <  
 

0,,c!   " $   -c


^nited States v. American Library Association, Inc. 

Citation. &#.!.4@ 11#A

Brief Fact Summary. ,0     (,,  ,  ( 
  -    0,   "(   % ?   
" 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. GIJ        IJI,  J '   0 
, -"%0 : =0"    0 "%     
 >  ((( > G

Facts. 0     ?    @ GGA"     
,  (0( (        (,,  ,  ( 
   0 ,  %(0("0     
(        ( ? " "  0 

Issue. ë      " " , !   @G GAE

Held.  ( ,   G0        (
,,     ,  (  =   " ? ?  ( ? 00 
   "    ?G "(   ?  ,
=0" 0(0(      0%   
 -  , 0  "  ( ,,(0(    
 ,   -  0:    0 0  "  "
(0("      -G        ,(    = 
((   '   0 , -"%0 : 
=0"    0 "%      >  ((( > G

F ( :   ? 0" ,      G  %G-
" 0 %"    (        
(  (   (  "  "     0 , 0
,   (   %      ,  
  =   0"   (  %, ,      
    "   ( ,   (  
0 > ,,"-  %, "  " 

FG7  (   ? ,  , 0 ,     ( ?
 " " 0 -        - 
  '  ,0 ? ( 0( G


0,0c!   " $   -c
Dissent.     @G  GA,  0(-00  
   (   :  G,"  ,  G , 0
,  '"( -G  ,   %  (  %     -
   (  ' (    ,  0 ,"0 G  ,  
G  % G0 (  ,   ,  G  % G- % 
  (   (   G  % G-    GIJ     
 (( 0, (    ( 0 ," ",
"  = ,       (   ( G  
      G 0,(  (  
( G G"( "       (,2 " ,0 
 , 0, " " 0 G

F  ë  @G GA  7 2 0@G2 0GA, 
 0(0 0  ? 0(-  00 
"( G  2 " ?    
  ,( 0    G - , G  %0
 I J   '  ,  ( 0(   -H+
  
"   (       " " ? 0 
,,  ( ,   %    G > ,
 -      0 GIJ      ,
  "(           
(0   -   "(  ,(  GE
 -GIJ    %?    " ",
 @     "0, "0 (A 
"( 0 <   "","    ? 
  ,  G  -,   (
  ,  ( "( ,   %0  
 0%     


Concurrence.    *   @G*   GA, 0( 0:0
  , 0  ,  ( " , !  @G( " GA-  
 ", ,   "   %  0 "  , " 
    (  - <((  0 "  ((( *    
 0:  "( 0      G( 0 0    ,"" 
((( ," G

F   ( 7 @G7 GA, 0( 0 ((


,,", 0     G '"0    > "  > 
 (  G3       ( "(    
   (((  -     , ,
   7    %0  G " ( <      
 (( 0,  = ,  ( 


0,-c!   " $   -c
c
  G  G      0" ,   ?  =  -
  '       =  -      -
    , 0 =  -"       % 
( <  "-  =  - ,((G


Discussion.  "( 0:    "= (  - ( 
  -   0   00(     
=  0  0  

0,c3   ,À  ' 8 c


Near v. State of Àinnesota ex rel. Olsen 

Citation. +#!6.)@.#A

Brief Fact Summary.    -3 @  A- (  ,"(0 
  ((    (    :0 ( . )  (  
(  0      G" -   ," G

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0 " "    '(      0   
= 

Facts. . )-À ( ( 0 ( ,   (( -( 
"0:  G" -   ,"    -    G  
    "   (  ,"0( 0 
 0(    . )-   (        
   , "  G  0  G( 0  , 
"      ,  ((-     ,(0( 
  

Issue.    =0(   ,"(0"0: (  


,  " " 0 ,, ", ( E

Held. ;   =   ( 0 (   (( 
 "   -   (    (, ( 

Discussion.  (   (   " :  0 "   -
 0     " , (  0 " ( , 0
 ( ," 0  "(   %    (   
(((  -,  "            
"  ,, - 0 " " "( "" %

0,*c3 ;%" "(  !  c


New York Times Company v. ^nited States 

Citation. 41#!)#@.)A

Brief Fact Summary.    - 3 ;%" @  A-(  ' (,"
(  ë ,  ë (" "   ( - !  @ ( A- 0
 =, (   0    = (: 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.      ( "(0    ,   ",(
 , '(    "   0,0 " = ,

Facts.    (    ' ( ,"(<  ë ,  ë (" "  
  " ,   <"%0 0 5 "/ "    
 ,     0(    ( ""    0=,", 
(  0 "(" ,   = ,,  

Issue.    > ,(  E

Held. 3 0 " ,   ,, = ,,   '(  
 ( 

Dissent.    (((   ,     ,  ( 

F  / 70 @70 A


 0      "
 '   "%  , =      

F   7%"@7%"A


 0    ( , 
"   0  0, ( 0  '     


Concurrence.  0 "  0(   (0,  

F  07%@7%A


 ( "  , (     
   (-= (  

F  /"ë0 @ë0 A


 (( ,  " " , 
!   @ A (  0 " ,"
(( 0 "  0,"    0 "  < "

F  /"7 @7 A


      
7-  -"        ,,"
G" "0G"("   


0,Ac3 ;%" "(  !  c
c
1c    @ A
" , "  (     
   -       "  ,  (  
(   

F  7 / @/ A


 0 "  "    ,(,
"0   (     ( , (  

F  0À @À A


  (,  (,
(  ,  (    0  


Discussion.  "=  "(    0 ,   ( 
0 "    (  ,""("   " ,

0,Xc3  %   c


Nebraska Press Association v. Stuart 

Citation. 4 )!&#.@.)6A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -@ ( A-  ( 00 ( 
 0 ," 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 20          ( 0 
( (    ,-  "     > 
=(   

Facts.   (   ë 0    (  ( , 
 ,,  ,   G 0 "( G" 

Issue.   00   ,  0 ,, ", ( E

Held. ;  0 "  , "    , 0  ,   
"("   (  ",( ( 0 

Discussion.   "       0 , ( ," (  
 ? 0,  0 ,   ( (  (,    -
    (  , 0 (  , ? 0 

0,c '  !  c


Alexander v. ^nited States 

Citation. &1.!&44@..#A

Brief Fact Summary.    - ' @  A-  %  0 
     , 0   (0(( %  0  ( - 
!  @ ( A-  ",, ,    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (  "  = , 0 
""  ,  

Facts.     # %  0À     )
    #8               ,4
"0: #  (      6  ( -, N11-111  ( 
  , ,     -    ,,  
    N."(, 

Issue.       %   ( 
( E

Held. 3 ( " , !  @( " A =   0"  
      ?  " "  0 -  " ,
     0" " , !   @ A

F  "    :  ( " ( 


Dissent.   : ((  ,   ( 

Discussion.  "=  "( :   ,,(  0 ,"


 > =0"              ( 00  
   ,    %          -  
 <   

00.c/ 7    ,3 ;%- 50 ,c


Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc. v. †illage of Stratton 

Citation. &#6!&1@ 11 A

Brief Fact Summary.   >     (00


,  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ( ,        0  
   (( G""     ,, GG
     ( ?   ( 0 (  ,    
( 0,G

Facts.   -/ 7    ,3 ;%-@G  GA-


  ( 0  ,   ?  0 !  
   - /   -8-0 0,  ? / -@G   GA-
(       ?  (,80  ( -50 ,
@ G ( GA 61,  ,  G?   ?  ,"
?00(?(    ((  , (( ,("0 ? ?, 
 0  ( "( H61#G 61# >  > ,
G "G," "  ( " ,   0 "  ,
,"!( 0  ( "-  ( "   ( ,, 
  , % (   ,    ((  - (  ,
"   ( "

Issue. ë G 0  "%0"  "  00 <<  
,  0  0 "    0( "  IJ  " " GE

Held.     @G  GA,      " 0 " ,"( 
  0   ?   - G  ,  (   G( , - 
   ,G<<  0("(  0   ,  ",
  G (    , 0 ((0  " (  
G (  ( 0," (( G -      "(0
("0  0 G " ,", 0G (   "   
0, -   0:  "( ,<<  0G 
( ( G

F   0:  (       (  0      


  <G ( ,,- ( ," - ( ,
   ?(  G -      "( , ",
(      G     (((     
 ,,   (  0 "      ((   G
 "= 


00½c/ 7    ,3 ;%- 50 ,c
c
,  ( ,        0     
((G""     ,, GG 
   ( ?   ( 0 (  ,    
( 0,G  -    (( G"" 
?   ?G("0   ,G -G  0 ( 

F :     G: " , ," 0 " ,
    ( %  0    ( " G  0: 
  (   ,,  ,   - , "  
(   - "( ,G =     "  ( ,:  
0 0 (   G-0 ", (   (  
    

F      (( ,  (, 
  ( T (  ,     ( ,,


Dissent. 0 /" > @G > GA,  0(  0
     0- 0  " 0"   , " ( 
     > 0 G( " > " ,<<   -0 
    0 -  G >  0 0
"  "      ((   

Discussion.    0 0:   (  "   
((   ,    ((   0 0" 
 "    (( -"( 0 "= ((  " 0" 

00,c" /  "(ë (" 7 0%ë c


Thomas And Windy Hemp Development Board v. Chicago Park District 

Citation. &#4!#6

Brief Fact Summary.  0  0 ,0 ( ( -( 
  >0     "  (% ( " , 0

Synopsis of Rule of Law. I 


J ((    G  0  "   IJ 
 = <"    (  < " -( -"  0,  ,
( ,"G

Facts.   ( -0%ë @ G ( GA- 0 ,0( 
(% ( ((  0  (     0 
  ( "(G?I0J(  "  -( -(-  
  0" ,,   -? 00     ? I0J "I0J 
"(, ?G(( , ( "    (         -
  ( 4     0   ( " (  
'  4        # "  0  
 ( "    ,( "  =  -  ( "  ( , 
 -((     ,  ,( "  =    (((, 
" " (  (    ( - 00  "  " ,   " M
( ((       , = ,((- 2  
(   , %ë @ G(   GA (       
 ((     -" /   "(ë (" 7@ 
G   GA- ((  "   (  G 0 
 0:,"=G  (  0  ,    ( " -   
      ,    00     
, 

Issue. GI/J  "((%  >0   ( " , 


00 <    " -     " " - ( 
, 0   I 
À  JE

Held.   @GGA- , "= ,     


"  " G(    " ,0 "   ( '( -   
  0        " ,  0 "( "    "
"  ?  , (0( 6<)<  0?G
   I 
À  J- > 7,   @ G7GA  
,"(  0       7 =  ,"   , 
   ( " I 
J     " G(  ( 0  
  (   ( IJ   ?       -G

000c" /  "(ë (" 7 0%ë c


  0  %    "  0  ,   (    "0-
 0 ,"?  ,,   -   (  %  ? ?
?(I J" ?G ( - I 
J  (    ," 
"  (  , 0 0G@A  (=   
"(  , ( ,   ,( 0   >"  " O@ A
'(  =  ,  "     O@#A   "   
 ,00 ((   ( "     ,(, G

F ,I 
J((      G  0  "   
     = <"    (  < " -( -" 
 0,  ,( ,"G  0  (  
  "% =0"     ,  ( 3 , #0 ,
  0( "    % ,( "   -   
  ""     - G  
 ( (%G (( ,   G "( 
 ,"  ( -  (  , (%, -(   
0  -,-"( "     %ë ?  -  
,  ,"0     G

F 0:    -" -( "   
   " " , ,,0 ,00   "
       -  > G" -( -
"  0 >   0  ,,?     
 =  ,,  =  G ,  0
   0,,"(    ( ""     , 
 =   ( ,    "       0   
 ,G ", " G - (("  
 (  =   + , ((   -    , 
 "   ( , 


Discussion.   ,,    0    ,,     G < 
" -( -"   GG  = <"    (G

00-c ,$ - B2, ë<4-$$c


City of Littleton, Colorado v. ù.J. Gifts D-4, L.L.C. 

Citation. &4!))4@ 114A

Brief Fact Summary.   >       ( " 
(00   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G?  =  (   ,,  0  
  "     (  " " " "   
(  0 G

Facts.    - ,$ -@ G  GA-    >0
      > G     G -  (  
 ,,G   G - >   (( 0,  (   
,"     -((  :0 0  ( ,
  "  , -    0 "           
,-   >   "%    41     
       -,   ((        
 ( -B2, ë<4-$$@ G ( GA-(        , 0
G % G    (   : ,      
 (  0  0    ?     
, 

Issue. /  G ? ?   ?  0 IJ"    " " ? 
 > "    0  "   ("(=  ,"    
  0  GE

Held. ; -"    > "    ( 7 @G7 GA-0, "= -
, ,GIJ   0=  -    0 -
(   ," 0?      ( ," ?G

F -7 ,,     G?  =  (  


,,  0    "     (  " " 
" "   (  0 G -G ( 
 ( K(    0 =  ,,  
  <   " " "G -=0 %   
       ,  -    0   ,"
I 
J-     ,7,     "  
,       7       "    
"   0     =  -,    ((   '    
 "(     (  -   ((    
    G     =  -        , 
'(  "  


00c ,$ - B2, ë<4-$$c
c
   "   ( G -  0 "    G "( 
0((  (( "(  0     %  
(  ((   (  ,  ( , ","  
$ "" G, -  ( ,=   , 0 
     0   0  " 

F7    GIJ  @      A  0 "( 
  ( ,   "(  
    -  %   -    
    (  =  ,  
 ( G ,
     , 0 -  ( ,  0:  0  
 0   ((-,      


Discussion.    0   0  I0
  
ë   

 @   !ë@J  ( " , !  @G( " 
GA(( I 
 À  J> ,  

00*c!   3   "( !c


^nited States v. National Treasury Employees ^nion 

Citation. &#!4&4@..&A

Brief Fact Summary. 0 ( ( 0,   "( ," 0(,
"%0 (  0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0 " " ,  "( ," 0(, ( 
   (     = -=  0%0(  

Facts. ,   "(   (  ," 0"(  ,0 0 (  
0  ,   =     = 

Issue. ë  ( "(  , (  ,0 (  " " 
 0 ,,   "( E

Held. ;        "( ? 0,  (   "(  %
"(  ,  '(   0 "  "( -  :  7    
,   ( (  0,    "( ?  " " 0  
"(  ,     =  '( 0 0    ,,  ( 
( 

Dissent.         " " , !  
 @ A ((      ( 0 

Discussion.   (   ( -  ( 0"(  , ( - 
0   0  "( ," 0 0 8  - "(
 "(   ((   ( % - ,,( -  
"((  ,    "(     ( (,

00Ac/ 50 7, 7  c


West †irginia State Board of Education v. Barnette 

Citation. #.!6 4@.4#A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -7  @ ( A-   ? /  , 
( 0  0  !  ,0 (  0   - 
/ 50 7,? @  A- -  (   '(  ," 
0 =   >  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0 ( %   > (     " " 
, !   @ A  0,  ( 

Facts. .4 -   (  ,    (( ( 0  0 
 ? ,0  ,    ,   ,    '(  ,"
   "   ," À  -     
G,  G  =  >   0  (   , N&1(  
= " ' #1   (  % , ' (,  ? 
/    ( 0 0 0   0   ,7     ' (

Issue. ë   "( 0( 0     " " ,  E

Held. ; "( 0   ,0,0 ( ?   0 
   , 

Dissent.   0      (   0 0:  (

Discussion.  "= ,  0,(      , 0  


0   (  ( 0 , %     
( -    0    ,0  ,    ( 
"  0 (  0 ( "   " 0 :  
 

00XcÀ   8  "" c


ÀcIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission 

Citation. &4!##4@..&A

Brief Fact Summary.    -À  @  A-    ,  (( 
'   ,   ( ,     ,8
 -    0  0 8 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  (  (  $  >0   ,   ,
 ,( (    =    

Facts.  8 (     -(     "  
 0 ("     , ,   (0 " 
        "        ,   ' 
" 0((  ' " ,       - 
      , N11, 0 8 

Issue. ë  8( 0   , " "(0     
 " " , !   @ AE

Held. ; 3,", (    0  ( ,  

F8 (   ,,      ,,  (


( ,           


Dissent.  " 0    ,   

Concurrence. 0   -    0    ,  


0 , ,"     ("  '"( , " (
0 , 0   (   ((  (   

Discussion.    , "  (    0: 0  8, 
 0(  (  "      ,  =0    
,  ( (  (  7 0 " -   
  (( 0 (   

00c7%  "  $-c


Buckley v. American Constitutional Law Foundation, Inc. 

Citation. & &!+ @...A

Brief Fact Summary.  > ( ?   0  " -
 " (   ( 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   ( (   , " " " 
  ((0( 

Facts. :  " 0          0(    0(  
  (  - > (    %0, 0  " 
0   "     (    

Issue. ë    > "      " " , !  
 @ AE

Held. ; ,,",((  

F  0  > "  0 (( ( (  


,0"  ,=  

F$ 0( , (      "  =  
  ( 


Dissent.     , ? ( " "  0 ,0 ( 
 " " ,      

Concurrence.  >0  0"  0  ,      = 
  

Discussion.  %, > "       ( À    
    >       0 0 0 7 ( 0 
  - (    %  ((  (   , - (    
,  ( 

0-.c   c


Rust v. Sullivan 

Citation. &11!)#@..A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( - @ ( A-   0 (  
,  "     À  (     ," (0(

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  0 "     ,(0"  0 
!   @ A-,   , (0"  0  
      (   

Facts. .++-  ( ("0   0 (  ,  " ,"
0  À  (     " ,," (0

Issue. ë       " " ,   ( 0 
 <     ,"0E

Fë      (,  ,  > " ,


 0E


Held. 3 0 " "  , (0"  ' ,  
 0  ?     :   '  ,," 0- ,0 ( 
0

F3  0  >  (  ,, 0   - " 
    % ( (  ," , (0"


Dissent.     <   0 , ( (    
 ,"? , "   "  ,," (0

Discussion.       <     (   - ,   
( , (0"> " (0 0 -  ,- 
 7   "   0-(       (   (0" 

0-½c$ 0   ( 5 :> :c


Legal Services Corp. v. †elazquez 

Citation. &#!&##@ 11A

Brief Fact Summary. 0    0<(,((   0


 (  0 <" -      "( 
 (   "%0 0"    ,   ,  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G/  (   (    - 0 ?   ,0
   "   (( ,  0" 2 " ? 
  G

Facts.  $ 0   (@ GGA-("0  0 .)4-  


   - $ 0   (@ G  GA<(,( 
  ? "  0 , ((  0 (  <" 0
 ( 0   5 0 0:    , ," 
  ," ( (    - 0 0:   (   
   (  ,  0    0    (, 
&14@A@6A- (   0 0 - '    ? 0 ? (  -
  ', , G   ,,"    0  ' 0
 ,,   , ,  ( G (     (  
G( IJ ,"00    , ,    
    ,       "  ((   , !  
 G - -  (  , ,  
 00 , 0    "G,  , 0    (  , ' 0
G

Issue. /   (  , , 0 (   ?  "(   
  ? 0 ,"( 0 0       0 " " ,
 ' 0 ,    -    " " 0 ,  (  E

Held.    *   @G*   GA  "= (*   


 0:  (   (Iü    JIü J-0  0(0"
     0       (     ,," 
(00  ,     -   ,  
((( ," (0(   , (0"  0   (  
,,   C,      @ GGA 0 G  0 
  "( "     ( ", 0 (  
( ((  (  ,," (0G ( " , !  @ 
G( " GA(  G  00  " 0   ( 
 - ?"    ,     ' ,  ?G  ( ,
 ,  (0"  

0-,c$ 0   ( 5 :> :c


 0- ,  0 " ?    0     " , 
(0"   (   ( " Iü J ( ,    ? 
 0    0 "  ( -      ( ,  

F       G  (<  ,0       
   0 "   ,  ( % G      
 % GIü J 0 " ? (   ( %   " ( ,
,"( 0 (0"?G  ,    GIJ 
 0 "  ( % -,  ("  (   (
 - -  -       (( , 
  , :   =  -     ,,   (  " 
,,   ( G7    GIJ ,
 (<     ((   I0 " J  , ( %
 :  "," 0 ,      '(  ,  0 
   ,   ,"(   ( %  G

F7  ,   -7      ? (0"G  0 
, (   ( -(" 0 " " 0 G  ',
H&14@A@6A-    "(  (       ? 0   
 0 " ?  ( %      ( %, 0   ,, 
/ , 7    ( 0 / , 7    ( %,
 0 "   ?     :  0 "  ( 
      0   ,"Iü J

F7 ,   GIJ 0$   0   


( 00"         0  "  0 
 ,  "  "      "   
(  %   0  " ,"      
0 "        0 % 0 
(    0" (   (     (( 
,0,   " -"  0    ,,    
,"    ,  ,0, = G
 -7  0:  H&14@A@6A   > 
   ( ,G      " (( 0 < 
   " ,0( 0 G -   ? 
 G    ,  >  ,    I J
        ((   (  
     <0 0"     ,((  ,  G
G7  %0(    ,  0   ( 
  -  "    (   (  '( (
 "  ( , ((  '  , =( 0 


0-0c$ 0   ( 5 :> :c
c
  ,"      G -00
   , ,   ?  -   
   0 -%     ,,  

F "=  GIJ $ !  - - ,,  % 
( "0  ,   ( , 0,  '   
      "(    0    2 " ? 
 ( ,  ,"= 0    
( " 2 " , 0    " / " 
 0 0 "(    ,,    
 ," 0" = 0 /  (   (    - 0 ?
   ,0   "   (( ,  0"
 2 " ?   G


Dissent.   @GGA,  0(0 /"
 > @G > GA-0 ë 8?@G8?GA0   
" @G" GA= 0 H&14@A@6A    0  ( -
 G ,   ( ,,   ( 0(0"G -H&14@A@6A 
G   IJ( ," " IJ    ,  (G, 0 
0 "= % 0 , -G((   ((  
 ( ,( <,"(    G  -  0  
 ,     (0"-     (     (   0  ,
 ,0"  " G"( G G   ,, G/  %     ( 0
(0"   - " -  ' "  (    GIJ 
 ,     ( 0      -  0 " 
  ( ,"  ( 0(0"   "   0,0
 ,"    ,  (G

F!%  "= -  ,Iü J   0   
"  (  - 0  GIJ (   "( 
    :   ,0- Iü J  ? 
,0  0? 0 0G:  (     
0 "  ( 0"  "= "  0 Iü J 
"= ? 0"   , ,0G  %   ' 0" "
, '(     ,0G -
 (0  "= ? 0" , ,   ?  ? " 
-0    ( "  

F  GIJ $     (    ,"


( %0    0  ( -  0     
 (  ,"    ( Iü JG


0--c$ 0   ( 5 :> :c
Discussion.    0 '"  "=    Iü J   
,,   

0-c % !  c


Schenck v. ^nited States 

Citation. 4.!4)@..A

Brief Fact Summary.    - %@  A-   "  ((  ,
0//

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /  ( (   ( 0 , 00 "
0   ( ( -    (   

Facts.     "  "   ,   ,    , 
(0 "(  , G ;0 G (0  , 
 ( - !  @ ( A-0     (    
 (0 ,.)  00   " 

Issue.     ?  '( , (, ,(   (    
" " , !   @ AE

Held. 37      ( , '(  00 (," 
     

Discussion. 3 ,"  0  ,"   ?  


 - "  , "  "%  (   (   > 
0-G VG    "  ( (    ,
 

0-*c % !  c


Frohwerk v. ^nited States 

Citation. 4.! 14@..A

Brief Fact Summary.    - %@  A-   , "(0 
   -"  , ,  " ,  ( - !  
@ ( A

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (       0    ,, 
"     0 !   @ A

Facts.    (        ((    " 
    >    , 0  (0 ,.)

Issue.    ?  " "  0      E

Held. 3 (    ((     "      =    
  (( 0  ,, 

Discussion.    ((   0        0 
 7    0  %     0  
           ,  (    ,, 

0-Acë  !  c


Debs v. ^nited States 

Citation. 4.! @..A

Brief Fact Summary.    -ë @  A- ,0 , "(0 
   "  0 0 (        1  


Synopsis of Rule of Law. (  (  , (( ,  ( - - 
((  ,, 

Facts.    0 " ,(  (  -8(( 0  


 " ,  (      , ,     ,  "  , 
?" ?, (0     ,  ,,  ,

Issue. ë     (  0 '( " ,  E

Held. 3 ( " , !  @( " A    0 ,
 "(0  0  0   ,  ( - !  
@ ( A

Discussion.          , % ""  ,"  


  ( 0  ((         ,    - ( " 
  0     

0-Xc "  !  c


Abrams v. ^nited States 

Citation. &1!66@..A

Brief Fact Summary.    - " @  A-   , (0 
2 "0 "       ,"   ( - ! 
 @ ( A-0//

Synopsis of Rule of Law. !   >  , (     ,  ( %   
 

Facts.    (       ,  ( 03 


;%     (   0 ;      
   "     0 " , ,"
   0  0   00   ,",!  0 " -
 000    0  "(- -  ( , 0 " - 0
00     0     

Issue.     (   ,    >  , ?  ( E

Held. ;      ( , ( "    " ,

Dissent. ( "       ( %      ( 
       ( -   G"% ( ,  G, 
'0     %  ,? 0

Discussion. 0  "  ( (    ,
 -  ,,   0       , -  
  %   %       ,  
 0  

0-c2 3 ;%c


Gitlow v. New York 

Citation. 6+!6& @. &A

Brief Fact Summary.    -2@  A-(   "" ", ,
   !    0 (0  !  
0 " 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.      ,        
 "(  '        ( (    

Facts.     0 "       ,  
 ," !      " " , $ ,/0 ,  
         "0 , ((    0:.. 
(    0(? ", ( ( , (   ," 3 ;% 
 >  

Issue. ë   ( 0    (    ,  " " 
 0, ", '( E

Held. 3           "  , '  0   ? 
( (     ? ( (     , (   0 
( "  "  ,  ,  ""  

Dissent.   " (  (  (   ( 0  ( 
  

Discussion.  ", ( ( ,   0(   ( %


0  (   ,   ,  (    "  0 (     
0   , , :  

0.c/  ,c
Whitney v. California 

Citation. )4!#&)@. )A

Brief Fact Summary.    -/ @  A-   ,0:00(
 , ,, -     ""(  (
0 

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   " (  0:0,    
"" ," , ,,  0  0 0  ( 
  

Facts.     0 " " ,   (    
,   , 0(0-.." - 0( (  0: 
     " " " , "" $  ," - 
 >  8%-,     (( 0(? 
  "    , 0(    " ,  "
 0 -     ,"  " ,  

Issue. ë   ( -   ,,? @ ( A  "@ A  
  " " 0 , :  E

Held. 3         '  ,( (     
 0"   0(  :  ," "0 " ," ( 7 0
" " ,0:  -     " " ,(0 
  '(  (  0,0  (  ,   , 0
0 "  

Concurrence. 30 ," (   "  (   "
,    ((     ( (         " 
  ,  " 0  

Discussion.  ( " , !  @( " A(  "(   ,   
  0   ,    "  0" (( (    0
,  ( -     0   " " (  0   
0:, 0 "    (  , 

0½cë   !  c


Dennis v. ^nited States 

Citation. #4!4.4@.&A

Brief Fact Summary.    -ë  @  A- 0  0 "
@ A 0:0 ""  ," 

Synopsis of Rule of Law. ""  ""    > , 0, ( 
0 

Facts.  "% ,,(  %0 ,    0


  0  ( -!  @ ( A-(-(     ( 
"  0    ,0:  (0: 0(
   (     0 0:0 ""  ,
" %0 0  0  ,  ( 

Issue. ë      " " E

Held. 3         " " , !   
@ A   ((     

Dissent.      " " ,  

F  07%@7%A


  ( 0   "  
""""( , 7,0 

F  /"ë0 @ë0 A


          
( 0 ,"," 0:, (0(


Concurrence. ë ,   "  0   0    ( 0  
  = ,  <0 0"0 ( ,  0  

Discussion.  (( ,  (  0 " ,"    - 
  (  ,0  0   0 "      (   
  ,  ,," 

0,c7  0 8c


Brandenburg v. Ohio 

Citation. #.&!444@.6.A

Brief Fact Summary.    -7  0@  A-**'*  - 


  , 0,   ,  ( -8? @ ( A-
"  "  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (  (   0   "" "
  

Facts.         ( ," ="* 


" ,"      ( %0    '   ,(  -, 
 0    ,"   (( 0  0 
0 -   "%0 ,   G 0  G

Issue.    ,""   ,"-    ,   ? 
 " "  0 E

Held. ; 8 , -   (   "        

Discussion.  , "  (  ,   @A"" "O@ A
% ,(0 0@#A  ""  0 

00c( %  3 "(  c


Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire 

Citation. #&!&6+@.4A

Brief Fact Summary.    -( % @  A-   , 0,,   
  ,,    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. G00 G (  ,", ( 

Facts.       0     0   ,   
 $ "(      0 0 G% G 0
   -( ,,       (  8    - 
      À     -G2" %  GG
"   G    0  0  " " ,, 
   (   

Issue. ë  ,0 (  ?  " "  0 E

Held. 3       %     , (     
(  ( ,   ( 

Discussion. 00    %      ( 0  
( %      %  ,""   ""

0-c20 / c


Gooding v. Wilson 

Citation. 41&!&+@.) A

Brief Fact Summary.  ((  -/ @((  A-   , 0((   
   00  ( ,,  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   "   ,   (  
(   (  (( (   '( 

Facts.  ((     , 0   00     " 
 "    G; , -?%   GG, (  " 0
? (  G "  ""    "  ((    0"  
,""       ( 0 

Issue.   2 0    E

Held. ;   , ,       <,00    
,00   , -          (( 

Dissent.      

F  / 70 @70 A


       , 
  , (  ((

F   7%"@7%"A


      ""  
    " 0 00   ((   ,",G,00
 G


Discussion.  "=     , ,    ""  , 
 "7       "  0       "(  
 -       

0c5  ,-À c


R.A.†. v. City of St. Paul, Àinnesota 

Citation. &1&!#))@.. A

Brief Fact Summary.    -5@  A- =   , 0 
  0 ?      ,  (   

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  ,  ,,00 "  ," ( 


      , ( 

Facts. ..1-    "  =  "  ,   0  ( 
  , % 0  ,   ( -<-À @ ( A-
 (       7 <À  8 -" "  " 
(  0 ( (  ((  -  "  %  % 
 0    "

Issue.            <  E

Held. ;      ,   <    
, ' (,  " " , !   

Concurrence. 

F  7 / @/ A


       
  

F   7%"@7%"A


  0   00,00
 


Discussion.   (  ,00    ((  ,-0  
 0  " 8 ,00    (,," ' 
  7  , ( , ( (  -      - 
      

0*c   3 ;%c


Feiner v. New York 

Citation. #41!#&@.&A

Brief Fact Summary.    -  @  A-   ,   ,
 , 0 (0 0 ( (   %    0   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. /     ( 0 ,-  ( " 
  ( 

Facts.      00(,)&(   0     % 0


(( ,  (         " 0-   "  0 "% 
  " (,, $ - 0 "(  (     
 (     " ( (    (0    (0,,8 
,,  %     (%0-   ,  "      

Issue. /   (,  ( (  E

Held. ;            0 ( , 
   ,  (  > 

Dissent.  ,   ""   =    ,( 
  ((  ( 

Discussion. (     0,  (    


      (     , - (  0"   
"0 (   , ""  0    ? , ",
( 

0Ac7    c


Beauharnais v. Illinois 

Citation. #4#! &1@.& A

Brief Fact Summary.    -7  @  A-   , 0  
    ",(  "  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   (  (   (   "  0   ( ,
( " (   

Facts.   ( - @ ( A- "  '(  (   
(  0( ,  "    (  -(0: 
   0  0        ,  "(0, 
G " - "   , ( (  ((  - 0  (   -
 3 0G   " "  (((, /  $ 0 ," -


Issue. ë  ( ,G  G ë   (   ,"( 0 
 0(E

Held. 3$    "   ,00     0" (( ,
, 0   , "  

Dissent.    <          ,  %
    

Discussion. $   0    ,00   ,   , "
'(         ,,  ,       0   
  , -    = , ( 0    " (  

0Xc50 7%c
†irginia v. Black 

Citation. &#+!#4#- #&#6-&&$ &#&@ 11#A

Brief Fact Summary.   (  -07%@G (  GA- 0  


  "" ,50  0  0

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   0   ,    
"  - (((  G   0 (",    , 
" G

Facts.   (      , 050?  < 0  -H+ <4 #
@..6A-(  -GIJ  ,, (  (   -  ,
"0 (  0(,(   - -    -  ((  ,
 -0  ( (  (      (  ,  
 0 , 6,     0,   (",    ,
 " (  0(,(   G

Issue. 

FÀ      0, "(  G " (  
0(,(   GE

F  "" ,50?    0  0G 


" (  0(,(   G  ,  " " , ! 
  @G GAE


Held. 

F;   ë 8?@G8?GA-0, "=  G -


     " " -"    0   
" G0I !JI    J- 0 "   
(  0   0 , '( -0,00 
 "  -( I  ^    J-  " " 
    G   G-G "(    "      ( % 
"  ""    '( , "",,
  ( 0(,  G  ( %   
G     G  -G(    (  
  ," , ,     (,  0   -   
," (          G   0,
  ( ,"0 ( 8?  -GIJ  " " 
( " 50  0    "   
0  (   ,","  ,( 0


0c50 7%c
c
"0" 0 -50"   0    ,"0" 0 
0,  0? 0(      0,"( 0   G
 - "=    0Iü"    J 
G <   "(     , ( G- G
   ( ( , I  J?   ,   
      ?G

F; G "" ,50?    0   0 (", 
  , "         ,"G
 


  (" ,  (   (                "  
  0       "    (   ( "   =  
       0      ,   '    
 0( ,      , % 
7%(   ,  - (  "% " %   = 
,     "   0  ,   ( ,  ,     
( "    ""    - (  -     (    
   ,,  0 ,   (  -  
 (   %,  (( ,   , 0 " 
"    (     000     (     "
7  " " "    (     00   (
( 


Dissent. 

F"  ,  0(0 GIJ -  0 


"    "           "  <<
0 , ,(    G  - '(  "(   
"(    > 


Concurrence/Dissent. 

F  @GGA    " @G" GA 


(-  =0" (-  ( =  0 
 "=   " (   0  " -  
"=      ("<, <   (   , 

F  ë  @G GA-   *   @G*   GA  
7 2 0@G2 0GA, (0 =0" (
 0( =      G <  ( (,
  0IJ"      ,,      , "
  0  


0*.c50 7%c
c
   -   (" 0 ,  ( "      
  0  0G =  , , ,Iü"J0 
   -( Iü"J <        
0(   G,, (( ,   ,G =   0 
 (",   (  G    , ,0, 0
(     G7  GIü"J ' (         -
    ,    "( 0    - 0  
   ( O <    0"  
"  =  00( G


Concurrence. 

F    @G  GA -   0


"( G " G>,   %,   
" "  ( 


Discussion.    0 '"  =  ((  Iü"    J 
 , ,  ,   ,  "

0*½c !  c


Roth v. ^nited States 

Citation. #&4!4)6@.&)A

Brief Fact Summary.    -@  A- 0  0 ,  
0    

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 8     ( ,(   ( 8   "   
'"  (( 0 (   

Facts.   ( - !  @ ( A-( (   "0,
G   - -    %-("( -( - ( ,   G
     , 0      "  '  '(  "  
 % >   

Issue.     (   (    " " , !   
@ AE

Held. 3 ,   0  (    0  (((  
,     8    G""    G

Dissent.   ( 0 ( ,  00"  % -,  ,
  , -   

Discussion.     ( , '         " " 
(       "      '  ,0    
" ," , ,   0    G " ,"    - '
' -,,      " " , (
 ( , " G

0*,c    c


Paris Adult Theatre v. Slaton 

Citation. 4#!4.@.)#A

Brief Fact Summary.    -   @  A-   , 0
     , 0(0(,"  

Synopsis of Rule of Law.  "  0   ' ,   "0  0 
    0"      0, "" 

Facts.     "    -2 0 .)1,   ," 
         G (0( G  0G  "0G 
       '  " ," (       

Issue.          E

Held. ;    0"    00""     "  
' , " 

Dissent. 

F  /"7 @7 A


((   ,      
        (  " " 0,  ( 
     0"   ( " ," 0 '( (- 
    '   ((

F  /"ë0 @ë0 A


8     ' (  
" "  "   0,      0
-  ,   , ",  


Discussion.     ,,  ,        0 ,   
""         ( 0 "" ,"   
(,     '   ,"     

0*0cÀ  ,c
Àiller v. California 

Citation. 4#!&@.)#A

Brief Fact Summary.    -À @  A-   , 0  ,
 ,   ( 0   ,   

Synopsis of Rule of Law. 8    %  %   ((  (   
 '-(  '(  ,,    -    
  - -(-  ,  

Facts.   " "   "  ,GG"  ,    (  , 
"            0 "   = 
  "  :0 "     

Issue. /    " ,   " E

Held. 3 "  0 "   (   (  , ' 
 ( ,"  - '  , -  ' ,0  8  
"   (G -G(  ,,    '  ' "(," " " 
( 

Discussion.  ( " , !     0:    ?   
( 0 :  ,",,      "     ( ,  , 
     ""  7  - (0(     
   

0*-c3 ;%   c


New York v. Ferber 

Citation. 4&+!)4)@.+ A

Brief Fact Summary.   ( -  @ ( A-   ,  0
(0(  ,3 ;%  

Synopsis of Rule of Law. (0(      ' (

Facts. ! , (0("          0 
,"    ( 0     (     
"  0   0 ,6 00  '  

Issue.  (0( ,",   "      E

Held. ;  (      ,(0(    ,
 "     

Fë  , "         

F  0 0  ( ,"  (   ""  00 
 0  

F   , 0  00  '  "" 


Concurrence.  (   , "  ( , '      - -
 ,"   

Discussion.   (   ," 0 '(    ( ,
   0"      0 ? , " =  '  '(
" 

0*c ,   ( c


Ashcroft v. The Free Speech Coalition 

Citation. &#&! #4

Brief Fact Summary.    ,0  00  ( ,
(0(    

Synopsis of Rule of Law.   &6@7A, 0(  ,..6@ 


GGA G   G   0  , " 00   
",, ( 

Facts.   '    ' 0,  (  0 (0(   '  
 (     ( G '  '("0 ((  ("    ( 
 0   G (    "( , "0 
    (   0 , (      &6@+A@7A, 
(  G?    (-0 (0(-,"-  -( -"( 
"( <0   "0 ( -?? -((   -," 000 ' 
'(? ( ?    (?  (  "0  
( Gë    0 - "  (    
    (, (   - (( ,   GIJ
   ,  ( 0(0(  0 "   ( -
0  '     (0( G  &6@+A@A(   " 0
 "(0   0, ( ,  "% ((  
  00  '   (    0   &6@+A@ëAG , 
(0(    '  '("0  ?  -(" -(  -
  -    "   "( ? ( ?" 000
'  '(?G

Issue. /       " " , !   @ 
G GA  G(   0,  , (        
IÀ J(0(  I  JGE

Held.    *   @G*   GA,    0  I  ! 
  J-G 0  (0( ,"  '  '( (   , 
 ?   ( 0   '(   (( G! I  J- 
0   > " (0(     ,     (( 
G 0"  (     "0        ,
(