Analysis: offers for 30 tons per hour fresh water chilling system.

1,00 Offering party Bestworld Perkasa Ltd (LL 11690) Shenzhen Brothers Ice System Co., Ltd Shenzhen Brothers Ice System Co., Ltd Speed Freeze Technology Pte Ltd
Base Jakarta Utara, Indonesia Shenzhen China Shenzhen China Singapore

2,00 System description 30T/hour water chiller ICW720T-R2W containerized chiller ICW720T-R2W containerized chiller 30 tons/hour instantenuous water chiller
Fresh water flow-rate m³/hour 30,00 30,00 30,00 30,00
Water in temperature °C 26,00 37,00 37,00 33,00
Water out temperature °C 1,00 0,50 0,50 1,00
Refrigerant Type R717 ammonia R22 Freon R717 ammonia R717 ammonia
Evaporating temperature °C -5,00 0 & -4.0 5.0 & -5.0 -5,00
Condensing temperature °C 40,00 36.0 to 38.0 36.0 to 38.0 38,00
Type of refrigeration system design Type Direct expansion with electronic control Direct expansion Direct expansion Gravity flooded

3,00 Compressor number Qty 1 set 3 sets 3 sets 1 set

Compressor type Type 1-stage industrial economised screw 1-stage commercial hermetic screw compressors 1-stage commercial open screw compressor 1-stage industrial economised screw
Brand SRMtec Bitzer Bitzer SRMtec
Technology/origin SRM Sweden/Fujian China Bitzer Germany/Beijing China Bitzer Germany/Beijing China SRM Sweden/Fujian China
Model SAA20M-HAMA 1 nos. CSH9593-210 & 2 no. CSH7583-100 1 no. OSKA95103 & 1 no. OSKA8591 SAA20L-HAMA
Cooling capacity kw 981,00 1.300,00 1.590,00 1.230,00
Compressor efficiency COP 4,54 4,11 5,30 4,46
Power consumed at the shaft Bkw 216,08 316,00 300,00 275,90
Installed motor power kw 280,00 370,00 340,00 300,00
Motor starting method Type N.A. Star-delta Star-delta Variable speed drive

4,00 Evaporative condenser number Qty 1,00 2,00 2,00 1,00

Evaporative condenser type Type Evaporative condenser Evaporative condenser Evaporative condenser Evaporative condenser
Coil material Type N.A. N.A. N.A. Stainless steel SS304
Cabinet material Type N.A. N.A. N.A. Stainless steel SS304

5,00 Water chiller Qty 2,00 1,00 3.00 diferent type (??) 1,00
Evaporator type Type Falling film hollow plates SS304 (Bronzed) Plates heat exchanger type Shell & tube, plate chiller, ice bank Falling film hollow plates SS304
Technology/origin Fujian Snowman/China Icesta/China Icesta/China Daussiny B.V/Holland
Water flow-rate m³/hour 2 nos x 15.00 m³/hour 1 nos x 100.00 to 120.00 m³/hour (??) 1 nos x 100.00 to 120.00 m³/hour (??) 1 nos x 30.00 m³/hour

6,00 Water tank Qty By buyer 2 sets 2 sets 1 set-by buyer

Type Local fabricated, concrete Containerized & insulated water tank Containerized & insulated water tank Locally fabricated concrete tank
Storage capacity (estimate) N.A. 2 nos. x 50 tons 2 nos. x 50 tons 1 nos. x 100 tons

7,00 Pumps Qty By buyer 2 nos. x 100-120 m³/hour 2 nos. x 100-120 m³/hour 1 nos. 30.00 m³/hour to chiller
1 nos. 50.00 m³/hour to point of usage
8,00 Miscellaneous
Refrigerant By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Compressor oil By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Expendable (nitrogen, welding gas) By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Installation tools By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer

9,00 Installation material Set 1,00 1,00 1,00 1,00

Incoming power supply and board By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Incoming water to condenser & chiller By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Moving equipment to final location By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Structural material Set 1,00 Containerized Containerized By buyer
Civil works By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Cost from destination to final location By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Structural foundation for machinery By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Incoming connection for power and utilities By buyer By buyer By buyer By buyer
Warranty 12 monhts 12 monhts 12 monhts 12 monhts

10,00 Installation 1 supervisor & 3 men (Myanmar)

Air ticket Not specified By buyer By buyer Included
Visa fee Not specified By buyer By buyer By buyer
Food and accommodation Not specified By buyer By buyer At site by buyer
Local transportation Not specified By buyer By buyer At site by buyer
Labour Not specified U$100.00 per head per day U$100.00 per head per day Maximum 2 months from arrival

11,00 Commissioning Included Not mentioned Not mentioned Included

Delivery C n F Medan port C n F Medan port C n F Medan C and F Medan

12,00 Price U$257,000.00 U$409,800.00 U$482,800.00 U$290,000.00

13,00 Remark
Where supplier has an advantage and where extra cost is incurred
Where the supplies is questionable