Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
on
Financial Services
March 2010
Entrepreneurs' Perspective 13
PE in Financial Services 18
- By Sanjay Doshi, KPMG India Private Limited
In his interview for this report, Dhiraj Poddar of Standard Chartered Private
Equity points out how the Financial Services sector is an attractive point of
entry for investors to gain exposure to the domestic consumer and
infrastructure sectors. Apart from sectors within BFSI, providers of
technology and analytics services to this industry present another attractive
investment opportunity, he adds. Poddar says PE investors would also look
forward to investing in the capital intensive and long gestation business of
Life Insurance.
Siddharth Shah of legal advisory firm Nishith Desai Associates traces the
evolution of financial inclusion in India. Highlighting how from the time of the
Sahukars and Shroffs (money lenders) in pre-colonial India to the advent of
institutionalized banking, the banking sector in the country has witnessed
3
sweeping changes. The nationalization of banks in 1969 led to the
expansion of branch network increasing lending to agriculture and small
business and pulling in millions of people into the formal financial system.
In his article, Samir Bali of Ernst & Young points out how the rapid growth of
microfinance has been aided by partnerships with PE firms and banks. The
revision of mobile phone banking guidelines (to enable low value
transactions), the Unique Identification Number (UIN) programme and the
establishment of a ‘Credit Information Bureau’ to encourage safe lending
practices, will provide the framework to boost further growth. He, however,
cautions that as the Indian MFIs develop a pan Indian network and increase
in size, the lack of common standards for technology, product design, the
gaps in legal and regulatory framework and the ability to tackle multiple
borrowings will pose challenges. Bali predicts that the sector will witness
consolidation over the next few years as some of the better capitalized firms
(including PE-backed ones), embark on acquisitions for expanding their
reach and size.
Indicating how a fact-finding study by the RBI observed that some of the
microfinance institutions (MFIs) appeared to be competing to reach out to
the same set of poor, resulting in multiple lending, Shivi Agarwal of legal
advisory firm Dhir & Dhir highlights the need for a general regulatory
environment for the microfinance sector that can provide oversight,
independent of the organizational form of the MFIs. The article provides an
update on the status of the Micro Financial Sector (Regulation and
Development) Bill, 2007 (which had lapsed) and on the steps towards self
regulation within the sector.
4
While writing on the payment business, Manek Fitter of Ernst and Young
highlights the factors which will throw up huge opportunities for PE in this
capital intensive and technology driven sector. The growing acceptance of
electronic payment systems from the presently low penetration levels, a
supportive regulatory stance, initiatives like the formation of the National
Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) and the issuance of UIN, coupled
with the rapid growth of telecom infrastructure and the existence of evolved
and proven payment systems, will help this sector achieve healthy and
sustainable long-term growth in India.
5
Private Equity and M&A
in Financial Services
PE Investments in BFSI - By Sector Value*
Microfinance
2% 11% 7% NBFC
18% Broking
13% Banking
Financial Tech
3%
14% Investment Banking
13% Stock Exchange
14% Mutual Fund
Housing Finance
4% 1%
Asset Reconstruction
Others
* Jan ‘04 - Dec ‘09
Microfinance
NBFC
3% Broking
3% 14% 23%
Banking
2%
Financial Tech
5%
Investment Banking
5% 20% Stock Exchange
6%
8%
11% Mutual Fund
Housing Finance
Asset Reconstruction
Others
* Jan ‘04 - Dec ‘09
3000 60
US $ Millions
2500 50
2000 40
1500 30
1000 20
500 10
0 0
6
PE Investments in MicroFinance PE Investments in NBFCs
Amount (US$ M) No. of Deals Amount (US$ M) No. of Deals
200 18 400 12
180 16
350
160 10
14
300
140
12 8
120 250
10
US $ Millions
US $ Millions
100 200 6
8
80
150
6 4
60
4 100
40
2
20 2 50
0 0 0 0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
600 12 7
500
6
500 10
400
5
400 8
US $ Millions
US $ Millions
300 4
300 6
3
200
200 4
2
100 2 100
1
0 0 0 0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
National
Stock Exchange Stock Exchange 375 General Atlantic,
SAIF, Goldman Sachs Jan-07
Indiabulls
Financial Services NBFC (Consumer Finance) 143 Farallon Capital Jun-06
Source: Venture Intelligence PE Deal Database * Jan 2004 to Dec 2009 – by Investment Size
7
M&A in BFSI
By Sector - Volume
Banking
15% 11% Broking
6%
5% NBFC
16% 3%
Financial Tech
Asset Management
18% 26% Investment Banking
Housing Finance
Others
45 41
40
35 32
30
30
25
25
20 16
15
10
5
5
0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
8
M&A in BFSI - Deal Type*
15%
23%
Outbound
Domestic
Inbound
62%
Source: Venture Intelligence M&A Deal Database * Jan 2004 to Dec 2009 – by Investment Size
9
In
fra Mi
c
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
7.00
Se stru rof
rv ct in
ic ur an
e e ce
Pr F
ov ina
id nc
er
s e
to
St F
In o Ba Is
su ck E nki
ra n
nc xch g
M e a
or D ng e
tg is s
ag tri
bu
e tio
/H
ou Br n
C s o
o m i n g ki n
m Fi g
As er n
Pe se cia anc
rs t l e
on Re Fin
al c on a nc
Fi
na stru e
In n ct
ve ce io
st Se n
m rv
C e i
this report. Fund managers from about 50 firms participated in the poll.
on nt B ces
su an
m
er king
F
M ina n
ut
ua ce
lF
un
d
What PE / VC Investors Think
Here are the key highlights of a poll conducted among Private Equity & Venture Capital firms for
10
How Investors Rate Each Sector
100
80
60
40
20
Mutual Fund
Broking
Banking
Insurance Distribution
Asset Reconstruction
Investment Banking
Microfinance
Commercial Finance
Infrastructure Finance
Consumer Finance
Stock Exchanges
-40
-60
11
Despite the regulatory bottlenecks, most investors
Is the "banking sector
consolidation / acquisitions surveyed feel the appetite of MNC banks to acquire
by foreign banks" theme still valid? fast-growing Indian banks has not dimmed. "PE
investments in this sector have been limited not
because of lack faith in the theme. Restrictive
covenants on voting rights and related matters,
No
Yes coupled with concerted activism by select
40%
60% shareholder groups in various private sector banks,
have been the dampener," said one of the investors
surveyed.
12
Entrepreneurs’ Perspective
Interview with Gajendra Nagpal, Founder & CEO, Unicon Financial
GN: The PE investors have brought a lot of experience to the table and have
helped us in the growing up process. They have helped us to get in to the
culture of maintaining a strong MIS and fiscal discipline. Although being a
private company, we behave very much like a public company in terms of
maintaining accountability and functioning of our board.
13
Entrepreneurs’ Perspective
Interview with P.N.Vasudevan, Managing Director, Equitas Microfinance
PNV: This year, around 30 leading NBFC-MFIs that account for around 85%
of the Indian market have come together to form Alpha Micro Finance
Consultants with a view to make available credit bureau services to MFIs in
the country.
Through this exercise, MFIs will be able to identify each of their members
individually with their unique ID. This ID will empower MFIs to be completely
certain of any borrower’s prior exposure to other MFIs.
14
Fund Manager Interview
Dhiraj Poddar
Standard Chartered Private Equity
VI: What is your outlook for the Microfinance sector in 2010? Will the
much anticipated SKS IPO catalyze more investments into MFIs? Will
the regulatory uncertainties in the segment act as impediments to
investments in this sector?
DP: A successful IPO by SKS should act as a catalyst for more listings by
micro-finance companies that may have reached optimal size and scale.
The microfinance companies, given their fast pace of growth, would remain
capital hungry. Their listing will help to broaden the investor base that can be
tapped, in addition to PE (as source of funds.)
The sector, along with opportunities, does have its challenges, and
regulatory issues are one of them. I think companies with strong systems,
high quality management teams and discipline can make the difference in
overcoming some of the issues.
15
VI: Tell us about your investment in M&M Financial Services (Mahindra
Finance) and your expectations from this investment?
DP: Mahindra Finance is focussed on rural and semi urban markets, which
are under-banked and currently serviced by either money lenders or some
public sector banks. The company is mainly into vehicle financing – Utility
Vehicles (UVs), cars and tractors. It is also building its mortgage finance and
insurance distribution businesses.
We are also very excited about Mahindra Finance’s foray into mortgage
lending, where again the company will be addressing a highly under-
penetrated market.
VI: What do you think are the key issues facing PE investors in
Financial Services?
DP: One of the challenges for PE investors is that most sizable financial
services companies have the ability to access public markets with ease.
This takes away the need for PE capital. Also, most PE investors in India do
not have specialised operating knowledge in the sector, which limits the
extent of value addition.
I think PE investors will either need to specialise over time or take earlier
stage bets. Valuations are another issue – especially in certain sub-
segments. Brokerages were trading at steep valuations earlier and now
(valuations of) microfinance companies look rich.
16
Exchanges enjoy very high entry barriers and in some sense, the winner
takes it all. So, it is important in our view to pick the right platform as well.
VI: Are you excited by ancillary services to BFSI (for example Back-
office to funds, technology providers etc.)
VI: Any other segments within the sector which excite you?
DP: Insurance – especially Life Insurance is exciting. There are high entry
barriers – in the form of distribution reach, branding, service quality etc. The
value increases over time as the pool of underwritten business grows so
long as the risk management is sound, which is great from the perspective
of a long term investor. In India, most life insurance businesses are capital
hungry and will take time to accrue value – which PE investors would be
better positioned to understand and appreciate.
17
Private Equity (PE)
in Financial Services
By Sanjay Doshi
Director, Corporate Finance,
KPMG India Private Limited
YEARS GONE BY
The Indian financial services sector has attracted private equity capital in
excess of USD 4 billion during the last 3 years1. A significant share of this pie
was absorbed by brokerage houses, microfinance companies, stock and
commodity exchanges, and mortgage and consumer financing institutions.
However, in comparison to 2007, when the sector attracted private equity
capital in excess of USD 3 billion; 2009 was one of the most challenging
years the sector has seen, with private equity inflow significantly reducing to
2
the tune of USD 300 million .
1&2
Venture Intelligence
18
While this sector was severely affected with reduced inflow from private
equity post the global financial crisis, as well as the liquidation of global
financial organisations like Lehman Bros; it demonstrated remarkable
resilience due to a combination of factors such as systematic stability,
conservative credit policies and robust regulatory monitoring.
The sector has kept pace with the growing needs of corporates and other
borrowers. Banks, capital market participants and insurers have developed
a wide range of products and services to suit varied customer requirements.
Moreover, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has successfully introduced a
regime whereby the interest rates are largely determined by the market.
TRANSFORMATIONAL CHANGES
In view of the current global financial market turmoil, the RBI has decided to
continue with the current policy and procedures governing the presence of
foreign banks in India, thereby indicating a deferral of the opening up of the
banking sector for foreign players. Given the current regulations on the
restrictions of voting rights and equity stake in banks, banks in need of
capital are likely to continue to face the challenge with limited avenues to
access capital funds.
19
This change has consequently forced the distributors to focus more on
distribution of insurance products (which provides high commission on the
first year premium) as compared to the mutual fund products.
Infrastructure spending
20
The key success of financial inclusion relies on ensuring access to various
financial products and services to the low income groups at a reasonable
cost. Considering that rural retail markets are expected to reach USD 58
6
billion by 2015 , and financial products have yet to reach this section of the
society, there is a tremendous opportunity for various players to penetrate in
the sector.
Consumer spending
Consolidation
The various sub-sectors within the financial services are likely to go through
a consolidation phase given the number of players operating in the sector
and also the current market dynamics. Some of the key drivers of
consolidation include:
4
Restrictions on access to funds may drive weaker banks to merge with
stronger banks
4
Fragmented broking industry is likely to undergo a consolidation phase
with large players providing a wide spectrum of financial services and
mid-sized players having a niche carved out for themselves
4
Asset Management companies on account of overcrowding of space
and the recent change in regulation
21
With the impending implementation of the Swarup committee report, the
brokerage and distribution companies are ideally placed to transform
themselves from a mere distributor into wealth managers providing advise
that is primarily driven by customer needs than the commission structure of
the financial product. With the expected size of USD 1 trillion of wealth
management industry7, early movers stand to gain a higher share of the
highly promising wealth management market.
Microfinance
Insurance
7
Celenet
8
Intellcap
22
4 Non-life insurance: Many of the private sector insurance
companies who have entered the market pre-2001 have achieved break-
even. However, given the potential available for lowering the combined
ratio (i.e. loss plus operating expenses), decline in commissions, and
expected improvement in underwriting and operation efficiency, these
companies are expected to improve their future profitability.
Although, there are significant opportunities for private equity players in the
insurance domain, some of the key challenges include:
With the introduction of IFCs, large NBFCs and Corporates may look
forward to create IFCs with aim to achieving higher growth trajectory
thereby requiring capital infusion on regular basis. Further, the expected
growth in retail and asset based financing (at an estimated CAGR of 20
percent over next 5 years)9, NBFCs is likely to need an infusion of capital to
meet its financing requirements and also to maintain capital adequacy.
9
SSKI, Cris Infac, KPMG analysis
23
Private equity infusion has been a favoured route by many players in the
sector and the trend is expected to continue in future.
The housing finance market, which faced a slowdown during the recent
downturn, is also expected to pick-up. However, with increasing
competition in the housing finance market, there is likely to be an increased
focus on the Loan against Property (LAP) business. A high risk and higher
return product, LAP provides an opportunity to mortgage financiers to attain
a higher growth rate and earn higher returns.
Ancillary sectors
Banks
CONCLUSION
The views and opinions expressed herein are those of the author and do not
necessarily represent the views and opinions of KPMG in India. The
information contained is of a general nature and is not intended to address
the circumstances of any particular individual or entity.
24
Sanjay Doshi brings with him over 12 years
Sanjay Doshi
Director,
Corporate Finance,
Email:: sanjaydoshi@kpmg.com
25
Evolution of
Financial Inclusion
By Siddharth Shah, Principal & Chittaranjan Datar, Associate,
Nishith Desai Associates
1
(www.rbi.org.in)
26
Early credit delivery in India:
Credit delivery in India right till its colonization by Britain was mainly through
indigenous money-lenders and country bankers, who still hold sway in the
villages and towns. Institutional banking was brought to India by the British
with the setting up of banks in presidency towns.
2
Money lenders acts passed by various states seek to cap rates of interest and deny certain modes of recovery to
unregistered lenders.
3
14 banks were nationalized in 1969 & a further 8 in 1980 under the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer
of Undertakings) Act, 1970 & The Banking Companies (Acquisition, etc.) Act 1880 respectively. Nationalization
was guided by Article 39 of the Constitution which puts the onus on the State to direct its policy towards securing
(b) that the ownership and control of the material resources of the community are so disturbed as best to sub serve the
common good; and
(c) that the operation of the economic system does not result in the concentration of wealth and means of production
to the common detriment. Statistics seem to suggest these objectives were achieved by the nationalization.
27
However the need of the hour in 21st century Indian economy is to ensure
the delivery of banking and financial services at an affordable cost to the
vast sections of unbanked, disadvantaged and low income groups. That
said, a recent survey by the RBI found that between 1995 and 2006, the
number of registered traditional moneylenders increased 56% to 19,627
from 12,601. Though much harder to quantify, unlicensed lenders are
believed to have made similar gains, the survey says.
With the RBI playing facilitator more endeavors like the Banking
Correspondent and Business Facilitator models seek to take credit closer to
the needy through “branchless banking”. The Mahatma Gandhi National
Rural Employment Guarantee Act, 2005 envisages payments through “no-
6
frills” bank accounts for work done by participants. They will also be eligible
for bank credit through such accounts. The Government in an initiative
aimed at regulating micro-finance activities with a view to ensuring smooth
passage of credit to the underprivileged and unbanked sections of society
has drafted the Micro Financial Sector (Development and Regulation) Bill
2007. The bill is under consideration of the Parliament and once passed
would lent itself to regulating the channelization of requisite funds to the
micro-finance sector.
5 Introduced by NABARD and RBI in 1998-99 for small and marginal farmers
6 Bank accounts opened with no balance requirements with basic banking services including credit.
28
The MF industry, which is at the forefront of facilitating financial inclusion, is
seeing consolidation. Also funding from the traditional sources like banks is
being augmented by a keen interest from Private Equity funds and Venture
Capitalists. Some shining examples are Sandstone and Sequoia’s
investment in SKS Microfinance and Sequoia’s investment in Equitas. More
abounds on the horizon. The recent Union Budget promises to see the roll
out of more bank-channeled funding for poor and marginalized persons. All
such well meaning measures implemented well, efficiently and effectively
will certainly lead to greater financial inclusion.
To quote the American realist and literary critic William Dean Howells, “An
acre of performance is worth a whole world of promise.”
29
Mr. Siddharth Shah is a Principal at Nishith
Desai Associates (www.nishithdesai.com).
As head of the Corporate and Securities
practice group, he has led several of the
capital market transactions involving
domestic and overseas offerings. He heads
the firm’s Funds Practice Group and is a
member of the firm's M&A and Banking and
Structured Finance groups. With over 13
years of professional experience, he brings a wealth of knowledge and
understanding of the capital markets.
30
Microfinance -
Path to Selfsufficiency
By Sasha Mirchandani
Prashant Choksey
Anil Joshi
Mumbai Angels
31
Albeit the Indian economy is booming and showing robust path ahead, but it
also the house to one of the largest poor in the world. In order to achieve
long and sustainable growth it is very important for a nation to take its entire
populace together. The Government nationalized banks to ensure that the
banks reach the masses. However, even till today a significant portion of the
population is still not associated with any formal financial institution mainly
due to strict banking norms and collateral based finance. This gap created a
need for different financing model especially catering to the needs of the
poor who could not offer collateral. A few years back, the success of
Grameen Bank (GB) of Bangladesh grabbed the attention of many people
around the world. The GB model has shown the way to reach up to the
maximum number of people without even accumulating NPAs. In fact, their
loan recovery rate was astonishingly high at around 98%. This model also
brought a lot of social changes into the society.
Associations:
Bank Guarantees:
32
Community Banking:
Cooperatives:
Credit Unions:
The members are people of some common bond: working for the same
employer; belonging to the same church, labor union, social fraternity, etc.;
or living/working in the same community. A credit union's membership is
open to all who belong to the group, regardless of race, religion, color or
creed.
A bank unit is set up with a Field Manager and a number of bank workers,
covering an area of about 15 to 22 villages. The manager and workers start
by visiting villages to familiarize themselves with the local milieu in which
they will be operating and identify prospective clientele, as well as explain
33
the purpose, functions, and mode of operation of the bank to the local
population. Groups of five prospective borrowers are formed; in the first
stage, only two of them are eligible for, and receive, a loan. The group is
observed for a month to see if the members are conforming to rules of the
bank. Only if the first two borrowers repay the principal plus interest over a
period of fifty weeks do other members of the group become eligible
themselves for a loan. Because of these restrictions, there is substantial
group pressure to keep individual records clear. In this sense, collective
responsibility of the group serves as collateral on the loan.
Group:
The Group Model's basic philosophy lies in the fact that shortcomings and
weaknesses at the individual level are overcome by the collective
responsibility and security afforded by the formation of a group of such
individuals.
Individual:
This is a straight forward credit lending model where micro loans are given
directly to the borrower. It does not include the formation of groups, or
generating peer pressures to ensure repayment. The individual model is, in
many cases, a part of a larger 'credit plus' programme, where other socio-
economic services such as skill development, education, and other
outreach services are provided.
Intermediaries:
34
programmes). Lenders could be government agencies, commercial banks,
international donors, etc.
Non-Governmental Organizations:
NGOs have emerged as a key player in the field of micro credit. They have
played the role of intermediary in various dimensions. NGOs have been
active in starting and participating in micro credit programmes. This
includes creating awareness of the importance of micro credit within the
community, as well as various national and international donor agencies.
They have developed resources and tools for communities and micro credit
organizations to monitor progress and identify good practices. They have
also created opportunities to learn about the principles and practice of micro
credit. This includes publications, workshops and seminars, and training
programs.
Village Banking:
35
Although urban migration continues, three out of four of India’s poor live in
rural areas of the country where poverty is a chronic condition especially
among the scheduled castes and tribe communities.
It’s been seen that the economical development of the country depends
upon the way people live and spend. So from the last five years it’s been
seen that Microfinance companies in India did a good job and are keeping
the same. In fact some of the MFIs made it to the Forbes’ list of leading
Microfinance companies. Lured by its 100 per cent growth and the fact that it
seems immune from adverse global developments, private equity
companies and venture capitalists are upbeat on investment in MFIs.
It is estimated that MFIs would need over USD 3 to USD 5 billion over the
next 4 to 5 years. MFIs mainly need money to meet mandatory CAR
specified by RBI and to invest in branch network, human capital and
technology. Experts say the sector is immune to developments in the global
economy, with 25 per cent returns over a three to five-year period. Also, the
sector is growing at 100 per cent yearly. Experts say there are very few
opportunities at this growth pace, with such low delinquency on loans.
There is a rush to fund this segment, as there is a good amount of money to
be made,”
Note: This article has been prepared after taking inputs from various books and articles.
The purpose is to share basics on the industry and not to infringe anybody's rights.
36
Firm Name: Mumbai Angels Venture Mentors
Website: www.mumbaiangels.com
Prashant Choksey:
Cell: 9820036111
37
Tapping the
Bottom of the Pyramid
with Microfinance
By Samir Bali
Partner - Business Advisory Services & National Leader, Insurance Sector
Ernst and Young India
38
Lending Growth of MFIs Trends in disbursement (MFIs)
120 20 350
80 250
INR Billion
Million
The progressive growth witnessed in the sector has been supported by two
underlying factors. First is the expanding reach of MFIs and the
establishment of their pan-India presence. Second is the increased
participation of private equity funds and banks. As these entities are
bringing in more funds, the sector is getting further integrated with the
capital markets. Approximately 11 private equity deals, amounting to
USD143 million, were finalized between January 2009 and October 2009 as
compared with eight deals worth USD61 million during the same period last
year. The massive growth of the sector has been supported by some key
initiatives undertaken by MFIs:
39
Furthermore, reforms undertaken by the government are also significantly
aiding the sector’s growth. The ‘unique identification program’ is a step in
the right direction as it will meet the objective of reducing customer
acquisition costs. Moreover, the RBI is also encouraging banks to increase
lending to the weaker sections of society. Organisations like the Rashtriya
Mahila Kosh have played a significant role in wholesaling, advocacy, and
market development. These initiatives are helping the sector to expand in
an orderly fashion, but MFIs still face fundamental issues that need to be
addressed:
Product design: A challenge for MFIs is the assumption that pure debt is
expected to improve the standard of living for people. There is a need for
a mechanism for monitoring of the end-use of the finance.
40
While the Indian microfinance sector does have significant similarities with
the structure of the microfinance industry in other parts of the world, it is
expected that one of the key impacts to the future direction of the sector can
come from the evolving regulatory environment and the opportunity to the
microfinance institutions to change the nature of the entity that they operate
through. There is a need for interventions at a systemic level as well from
within the industry in the form of creation of self regulatory bodies. There is
also likely to be an increased pressure on the MFIs to effect changes in their
processes to achieve significant cost savings and enhanced technology
usage; those that are not able to adapt will become targets for the other
more successful institutions.
The sector is likely to witness some consolidation as a key trend over the
next few years. As large MFIs have proliferated even the remote parts of
India, they have created their own niches, in terms of geography or sector.
As these entities grow further, with the help of capital from promoters, PE
funds, or through the IPO route, they will embark on an acquisition led
growth strategy to expand their reach and size. As the industry evolves,
there will be an opportunity for the leaders to establish the norms that will
become the industry standards and benchmarks for the others.
Sources:
u “Microfinance lenders to stop multiple loans,” Mint, 17 December 2009, via Dow Jones Factiva,
© HT Media Limited
u “An Overview Of Microfinance Industry,” Cygnus, September 2008
u “Equity Investment in Indian Microfinance: A guide for practitioners,” Institute for Financial Management and
Research and National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development, May 2009
u “Microfinance: Treading a Fine Line Between Financial and Social Objectives,” The Wall Street Journal,
16 December 2009, via Dow Jones Factiva, © 2009 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
u “Microfinance lenders to stop multiple loans,” Mint, 17 December 2009, via Dow Jones Factiva,
© HT Media Limited
u “Microfinance: Treading a Fine Line Between Financial and Social Objectives,” The Wall Street Journal,
16 December 2009, via Dow Jones Factiva, © 2009 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
u “Microfinance finds favour with private equity players,” The Press Trust of India Limited, 16 April 2009, via Dow
Jones Factiva, © 2009 Asia Pulse Pty Limited
u “Uganda looks to Bangladesh's BRAC to ease poverty,” Reuters News, 13 May 2009, via Dow Jones Factiva,
© 2009 Reuters Limited
u “Russian govt to set up fund for lending to small businesses,” Prime-TASS News (Russia), 9 February 2009,
© 2009 PRIME-TASS News Agency
u “UIN to expedite fin inclusion,” The Times of India, 5 December 2009, via Dow Jones Factiva, © 2009 The Times of
India Group
u “Does m-banking offer us financial inclusion?,” Financial Express (India), 15 January 2010, via Dow Jones
Factiva, © YYY Indian Express Pty. Ltd.
u “An Invisible Revolution in Rural India,” The Wall Street Journal (Online and Print), 4 January 2010, via Dow Jones
Factiva, © 2010 Dow Jones & Company, Inc
u “India Top 50 Microfinance Institutions,” Crisil rating, October 2009
u “News,” The African Microfinance Network Website, http://www.afminetwork.org/news.html,
accessed 20 January 2010
u BRAC 2008 Annual Report
u “Data & Reports,” Grameen Bank website,
http://www.grameen-info.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=346&Itemid=416,
accessed 20 January 2010
u “Microfinance India – State of the Sector Report 2008,” SAGE Publications.
41
Samir Bali is a Partner with the Business
Advisory Services practice at Ernst &
Young and the National Leader for the
firm’s insurance industry vertical and
brings with him over 20 years of
experience of in the area of financial
services. Samir has worked on several
strategy and restructuring initiatives for
financial institutions and banks in India,
USA, Europe and Sri Lanka. He has also
worked with international and domestic
companies on their diversification and
entry strategies for insurance, credit
cards and other FS businesses. He has
also led engagements on process
improvement and technology for clients
in the financial services arena.
Samir Bali
Partner - Business Advisory Services &
National Leader, Insurance Sector
Ernst and Young India
42
Dhir & Dhir Associates
Regulatory Framework
for Microfinance in India
By Shivi Agarwal
Dhir & Dhir Associates
The microfinance sector has witnessed near vertical growth during the
recent years. The “State of Sector Report-Microfinance, N. Srinivasan”
points out that during the year 2008-09 there was a 60% increase over 2008
in the clients being serviced by mFIs and a 30% growth in the total
outstanding microfinance loans during the same period. On the other hand
the sector received phenomenal access to funds in 2009 by way of private
equity, fund raising on debt markets and securitisation of loan portfolios.
43
Organizational Framework for Microfinance
Microfinance has been defined as the provision of thrift, credit and other
financial services and products of very small amount to the poor in rural,
semi-urban and urban areas for enabling them to raise their income levels
and improve their living standards.
The other model that has developed is where the microfinance loans
continue on the books of the banks, but they are originated and managed by
mFIs. Such loans may originally be granted by the bank itself, or the mFI
may securitize and sell its own portfolio of microfinance assets.
However, such loans are eventually treated in the books of the banks as
direct credit exposure to the end borrowers and therefore are subject to
44
higher regulatory burden, including know your customer guidelines and
regular reporting and provisioning requirements, which is not well suited to
the nature of microfinance business and clients.
On the other hand from a regulatory perspective, NBFCs are subject to the
regulatory supervision of RBI. They are required to be registered with the
Reserve Bank of India and are required to maintain minimum net owned
funds of Rs. 20 Million1. Non –Banking Finance Companies are also subject
to prudential norms, including provisioning for bad and doubtful debts,
capital adequacy based on risk weight of assets, deployment of funds etc.,
which norms are different for deposit accepting and non-deposit accepting
companies. For example while a deposit accepting NBFC is required to
maintain a minimum capital ratio of at least 12% of its aggregate risk
weighted assets on balance sheet and of risk adjusted value of off-balance
sheet items, there is no capital adequacy requirement for non- deposit
taking NBFC, unless it is a systemically important NBFC.
Similarly, while non deposit accepting NBFC are only required to give a
thirty days prior public notice in case of transfer or change in management
or merger or amalgamation, deposit accepting NBFC are required to obtain
45
prior approval of RBI, so as to ensure that “fit and proper” character of
management of the NBFC is maintained.
While there is a general regulatory framework for NBFCs, there is need for a
general regulatory environment for microfinance sector, which can regulate
the sector and its participants independent of the organizational form of
MFIs. The need for this is highlighted by some of the observations made by
RBI in its Master Circular on Micro Credit dated 1st July, 2009. The RBI
pursuant to a fact-finding study on microfinance conducted jointly with a few
major banks observed that some of the microfinance institutions (MFIs)
financed by banks or acting as their intermediaries/partners appear to be
focussing on relatively better banked areas, including areas covered by the
SHG-Bank linkage programme.
In this regard, the Micro financial Sector (Regulation and Development) Bill,
2007 was introduced in Parliament, which has however lapsed since then.
The Ministry of Finance has now invited comments and suggestions on a
draft document on regulation and development of Microfinance Sector,
which retains the provisions of the lapsed Bill. Some of the key features of
the draft are highlighted and discussed below:
(iii) Allowing MFO to take deposits from their members, subject to such
organization having been in existence for over 3 years, having promoters’
contribution of Rs. 0.5 million and having a suitable management structure.
1 While not for profit companies incorporated under Section 25 of the Companies Act are exempted from
requiring registration with RBI, the inherent non-profit nature of such companies, stymies accretion of
valuation and therefore, does not make this a viable option for private equity investors.
46
The limit and terms of the deposits would be determined through delegated
legislation.
(iv) Creation of a reserve fund of 15% of its profits by each MFO. It may be
pointed out that as against this, the Task Force on Supportive and
Regulatory Framework for Microfinance constituted by NABARD under
chairmanship of Mr. Y.C. Nanda had recommended reserve requirements
of 10% of savings in the form of bank deposits as at the end of the second
preceding quarter for mFIs mobilizing deposits upto Rs. 0.25 Million and of
15% for deposits mobilized above Rs. 0.25 Million. Such reserve
requirement was therefore, independent of the financial performance of the
mFIs business and provided a greater safety net for members. It had also
recommended that mFI mobilizing deposits above a particular cut off should
be registered with the RBI. The draft also does not create different
regulatory framework for deposit accepting and non-deposit accepting
MFOs. However, it is possible that this distinction may emerge in the
delegated legislation.
(v) NABARD has been vested with regulatory and monitoring powers. This
aspect of the proposed legislation has come under most criticism,
particularly on account of being anti-competition, since NABARD is an
active and significant player in Microfinance sector.
In addition to the above, significant steps have already been taken towards
self regulation within the sector, beginning with the adoption of the Voluntary
Mutual Code of Conduct formulated in 1996 under the aegis of Sa-Dhan, a
national level organization of MFI’s after the microfinance crisis in Andhra
Pradesh. Sa-Dhan is also reportedly working on a revised code to deal with
issues like high-handed recovery tactics, lending limits, overlapping of
loans, cash flow examination of borrowers and non-poaching agreement
between members, which is expected shortly. Microfinance Institution
Network, an association for NBFC-mFIs is undertaking preparation of a
similar code of conduct.
The creation of the right regulatory environment for micro finance will,
therefore, have to be based on legislative protection as well as self
regulation. On the one hand, legislative initiatives need to be refocused to
look at the sector as a whole, including the inter-linkages between providing
of credit and other financial services as a holistic model of micro finance,
with focus on providing sufficient consumer protection and security nets to
that section of society which has least ability to absorb losses. On the other
hand, it is necessary that such legislation should not stifle the ability to
innovate and adapt, which is necessary to make microfinance customized
and relevant to the diversified clientele that it should serve, leaving sufficient
room for intelligent self regulation.
47
Dhir & Dhir Associates The author, Shivi Agarwal, is a partner with
the Firm and specializes in private equity
and real estate.
Shivi Agarwal
Dhir & Dhir Associates
Advocates & Solicitors
Delhi Office: D-55,
Defence Colony,
New Delhi -110024
Ph: 91 11 4241 0000
Fax: 91 11 4241 0091
shivi.agarwal@dhirassociates.com
48
Payment Business
in India
By Manek Fitter
Partner - Business Advisory - Financial Services
Ernst & Young India
49
Electronic modes of payment in the retail segment are likely to gain
significant ground. At present, electronic retail payments account for 12%
(in terms of value) of total retail payments in India. In comparison, in mid-
2007, retail payments through credit and debit cards alone stood at 51% of
overall transactions in Australia, followed by 47%, 40% and 37% in Canada,
France and the US, respectively. Although modern payment systems have
taken decades to develop in advanced economies, this transformation is
likely to take place much faster in emerging markets due to the presence of
already evolved and proven payment systems. This is evident from the rate
at which electronic payment systems are replacing traditional ones in India.
Over the last five years, electronic retail payments have registered a CAGR
of 57.2% in India to cross USD109 billion (INR5 trillion) in FY09.
Opportunities galore
50
Mobile payments: The growth prospects of the mobile payment
business cannot be underestimated in a telecom market that is adding
8–10 million subscribers every month and is expected to have more than
half a billion mobile users by the end of 2010. Given the way mobile
phones have penetrated the length and breadth of India, mobile
payments have the potential of becoming the biggest non-cash payment
solution in the country.
There are several reasons why the payment business is likely to attract
more and more private equity (PE) players in times to come.
51
Secondly, with the emergence of several niche areas within the payments
business, there is room for significant deal activity as banks may seek to
enter or expand in certain niche segments while exiting the others. One
such trend could be of banks hiving off their POS operations. In the Indian
context, ICICI Bank has been the first to do this by selling its POS terminal
business to First Data Corporation (FDC) for USD80 million. Similar
initiatives by other banks will offer investment opportunities to the PE
players.
Conclusion
52
Manek Fitter is a Partner with Business
Advisory team with Ernst and Young and
brings with him over 12 years of experience
of in the area of financial services. He has
led strategic direction, re-structuring,
transformation and performance
improvement assignments across a host of
banking, capital markets and other industry
players and to several PE firms interested in
investments in the sector. He has been
associated with the public sector banks for
various growth initiatives and MNC / private
sector players for their entry and expansion
initiatives.
Manek Fitter
Partner
Business Advisory - Financial Services
Ernst & Young India
53
Listing of Advisory Firms with Special Focus on Financial Services
Firm Name : Collins Stewart Inga Pvt. Ltd.
Website: www.csinga.com
Website: www.ey.com
54
Listing of Advisory Firms with Special Focus on Financial Services
Website: www.in.kpmg.com
Tel: 91-22-39896000
Fax: 91-22-39836000
Mr Abizer Diwanji
Executive Director – Corporate Finance
Head – Financial Services
adiwanji@kpmg.com
Mr Sanjay Doshi
Director – Corporate Finance
sanjaydoshi@kpmg.com
55
Boston
London
Mumbai
Strategic Advisors
Unique Approach
San Fransisco
strategy consulting. We advise leading firms on private equity related issues such as investment
opportunity due diligence, portfolio company performance, firm investment strategy and operating
strategy. Parthenon has conducted over 600 commercial due diligence assignments over the last 3 years
for private equity investors across the globe. For further information please contact:
57
Looking to raise funds for your BFSI Venture?
Venture Intelligence is your one-stop information point for your fund raising process.
As India’s largest Deal information Bank, Venture Intelligence provides the most
exhaustive information on Private Equity and M&A activity in the BFSI industry.
58
Venture Intelligence, a division of TSJ Media, is the leading source of data and
analysis on Private Equity, Venture Capital and M&A deals in India.
Venture Intelligence products are a one point source for information and
analysis on:
Private Equity, Venture Capital and M&A deals
Companies looking for investors and M&A deals
New Funds being raised
Databases
Profiles of all Private Equity, Venture Capital and M&A deals since 2004
Includes searchable profiles of all PE/VC firms and PE/VC-backed
companies
Newsletters
Daily & Weekly formats for practitioners in the deal ecosystem
Sector-focused monthly format for entrepreneurs
Directories
Private Equity & Venture Capital Directory
Directory of Early Stage Investors
Investment Bank Directory
Conferences
Venture Intelligence conferences are a leading platform that bring together
investors and entrepreneurs in a focused manner that facilitates discussion and
networking. Speakers at Venture Intelligence Conferences are typically
investors, entrepreneurs and CXO/Boardlevel executives from accomplished
companies.
Contact :
TSJ Media Pvt. Ltd.
83/2, 1st Floor, 3rd Street, Karpagam Avenue,
R.A. Puram, Chennai-600028
Tel: +91 44 42074195. Email: info@ventureintelligence.in
Web: www.ventureintelligence.in
India's Largest Deal Information Bank
www.ventureintelligence.in