Explorer les Livres électroniques

Catégories

Explorer les Livres audio

Catégories

Explorer les Magazines

Catégories

Explorer les Documents

Catégories

0 évaluation0% ont trouvé ce document utile (0 vote)

6 vues18 pagesfile(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)

© © All Rights Reserved

PDF, TXT ou lisez en ligne sur Scribd

© All Rights Reserved

0 évaluation0% ont trouvé ce document utile (0 vote)

6 vues18 pagesfile(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)(1)

© All Rights Reserved

Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 18

1, 61±78

P. V. L A D E a n d R . D E B O E R {

Many different expressions have been proposed Un grand nombre d'expressions diffeÂrentes du

for the effective stress principle for porous principe de la tension ef®cace ont eÂteÂ proposeÂes

media, but none has clearly been acknowledged pour les mateÂriaux poreux, mais aucune n'a

as being the correct one. It should be possible to vraiment eÂteÂ accepteÂe comme parfaite. Il devrait

determine the correct expression, because this is eÃtre possible de deÂterminer la bonne expression,

a fundamental principle of mechanics. Following vu qu'il s'agit laÁ d'un principe fondamental de

a review of the candidate expressions proposed meÂcanique. ApreÁs avoir examineÂ les expressions

for soil, concrete and rock, a comprehensive proposeÂes pour le sol, le beÂton et la roche, les

expression is derived involving the factors auteurs ont deÂriveÂ une expression globale qui

observed in experiments on `arti®cial rock'. In met en jeu les facteurs observeÂs lors d'essais sur

this new expression a distinction is made de la «roche arti®cielle». Cette nouvelle expres-

between the compressibilities of grains and sion fait la distinction entre les compressibiliteÂs

skeleton due to total stresses and pore pressures. des grains et du squelette dues aux contraintes

This general and more comprehensive expres- totales et aux pressions interstitielles. Les reÂ-

sion is then tested against the experimental sultats d'eÂtudes expeÂrimentales servent ensuite aÁ

evidence. The expression may be specialized for veÂri®er la validiteÂ de cette expression geÂneÂrale et

(a) granular materials with separate grains with plus eÂtendue. L'expression peut eÃtre modi®eÂe

contact points and (b) solid rock with inter- pour (1) les mateÂriaux granulaires aÁ grains

connected pores. The new expression for the seÂpareÂs avec points de contact et (2) la roche en

effective stress contains most of the previously place aÁ interstices interconnecteÂs. Cette nouvelle

proposed expressions as special cases. Based on expression de la tension ef®cace contient comme

results of compression tests on quartz (with cas particuliers la plupart des expressions

hard grains) and on gypsum (with soft grains) it proposeÂes anteÂrieurement. A Á partir des reÂsultats

is shown that Terzaghi's effective stress principle d'essais sur du quartz (aÁ grains durs) et du

works well for most geotechnical applications, gypse (aÁ grains tendres), on montre que le

but signi®cant deviations occur at very high principe de la tension ef®cace de Terzaghi

stresses. s'applique aÁ la plupart des cas geÂotechniques,

mais qu'il se produit des eÂcarts importants

KEYWORDS: compressibility; constitutive relations; quand les contraintes sont treÁs eÂleveÂes.

elasticity; laboratory tests; pore pressure; stress analy-

sis.

The formulation of the concept of effective stress strains is controlled by the intergranular stress. It is

for porous media such as soils is most often therefore called the effective stress ó9 and according

attributed to Terzaghi (1923). In the context of to Terzaghi (1923)

developing the classical one-dimensional consolida-

tion theory for water saturated clay, he realized that ó9 ó ÿ u (1)

two stress components make up the total stress ó This equation has been shown to hold for soils

acting on an element of soil: the intergranular stress for most practical purposes. Only for extremely

óg and the neutral stress or pore water pressure u. high pressures are deviations from this expression

For soils, the intergranular stress provides the suf®ciently large to be measurable. Further discus-

sion of the relation between the intergranular and

the effective stress is presented by Skempton

Manuscript received 23 November 1994; revised manu- (1960).

script accepted 30 October 1995.

Discussion on this paper closes 2 June 1997; for further Signi®cant deviations from the effective stress

details see p. ii. calculated from equation (1) have been measured for

Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore. porous media such as concrete and rock. In these

{ UniversitaÈt Essen. materials the contact areas and the compressibilities

61

62 LADE AND DE BOER

of the different phases are quite different from those EXPRESSIONS FOR THE EFFECTIVE STRESS

in soils. Numerous investigations have been carried Whereas Terzaghi is credited with the discovery

out to determine the nature of the effective stress of the effective stress in 1923, he did not

principle for geological materials, and several formulate `the principle' until 1936. However, in

candidate expressions have been proposed in the 1913 Fillunger speculated that the pore water

literature. pressure itself does not have any in¯uence on the

Since Terzaghi's expression may be inadequate strength of porous media. He repeated this

for some porous media, then what should be the hypothesis in 1914, and in 1915 he reported the

de®nition of the effective stress, and what is it results of unjacketed tensile tests on cement and

expected to mean? The de®nition used here and its masonry specimens. Fillunger (1915) observed that

meaning is as follows: The effective stress is the a pore pressure of up to several hundred atmo-

stress that controls the stress±strain, volume change, spheres acting inside and outside the pores in the

and strength behaviour of a given porous medium, porous media had no in¯uence on the strength of

independent of the magnitude of the pore pressure. the solid skeleton. He had in other words realized

The pore pressure may be zero or negative, or it the effects of the effective stress at an earlier date

may be positive and very large, but the effective than Terzaghi. Fillunger (1936) was also the ®rst

stress must be expressed such that it produces the to clearly state that constitutive equations should

same material response for any pore pressure. It is be formulated for the `surplus pressure over the

to be expected that some properties of the given weighted pore water pressure', not for the total

porous medium will be part of a more comprehen- stress.

sive effective stress expression, unlike the simple The effective stress is often expressed as the

expression in equation (1), which does not involve difference between the total stress and some

any material properties. In thermodynamical terms, fraction of the pore pressure:

the effective stress is governed by the motion of the ó9 ó ÿ çu (2)

solid constituents of the porous medium.

There are several reasons why it is desirable to in which ó9 is the effective stress, ó is the total

clarify the concept of effective stresses for porous stress, and ç expresses the fraction of the pore

media in general. The correct formulation is pressure that should be employed to make equation

relevant to conditions of high stresses and pore (2) express the effective stress.

pressures in concrete and rock. Such conditions Table 1 gives a summary of expressions for ç

may occur in connection with engineering projects proposed by various authors. It is divided into two

at great depth, including petroleum reservoir sections, because many investigators have appar-

operations and consolidation of geological strata. ently found that different expressions should be

The stresses encountered below pile tips and used for (a) stress±strain behaviour, and (b)

around deep tunnelling and borings for nuclear strength behaviour. The following comments are

waste deposits can also be extremely high. added to the tabular presentation:

Material developments, manufacturing techniques, In Table 1(a), the value of ç 1 corresponds to

and applications involving ¯uid ®lled porous media Terzaghi's original expression. Hubbert & Rubey

such as ceramics and powder metals may also (1959, 1960) present a theoretical proof for this

bene®t from a correct formulation of the effective value of ç, but this proof has been disputed by Nur

stress principle. And ®nally, `. . . it is of philoso- & Byerlee (1971). The suggestion that ç

phical interest to examine the fundamental princi- n porosity is an intuitive proposition whose

ples of effective stress, since it would seem effect is to eliminate the pore pressure when the

improbable that an expression of the form porosity is zero (solid material). Schiffman's

ó9 ó ÿ u is strictly true' (Skempton, 1960). The proposition (1970) that ç should be bounded by

concept of effective stress should be based on 1 and n is also presented as intuitive rather than

principles of mechanics, and it should be possible with rigorous proof, and he did not explain what

to derive an expression for ó9 whose validity can controls the value of ç between these boundaries.

be determined by comparison with appropriate Skempton & Bishop (1954) presented a for-

experimental data. mulation with ç (1 ÿ a) in which a is the

A review is given of the expressions proposed contact area between particles per unit gross area

for the effective stress in porous media. This is of the material. However, in separate articles based

followed by a detailed analytical development of a on the same experimental evidence from tests on

new expression for the effective stress. Appropriate lead shot, both Bishop (1955) and Skempton

experiments are devised to check the salient fea- (1960) argued that this formulation could not be

tures of the new comprehensive expression. Finally, correct, and that the contact area between particles

a discussion is presented of the results and their plays no role in formulation of the effective stress.

relevance to porous media such as soil, concrete An expression that has been supported by many

and rock. authors in more recent years is one involving the

EFFECTIVE STRESS FOR SOIL, CONCRETE AND ROCK 63

ratio of the compressibilities of the solid material experiments it can be argued that obtaining B

(i.e. the grains) Cs and the skeleton of the porous greater than unity from a time-independent (i.e.

medium C. The expression creep-independent) formulation should not be

Cs possible. Thus, the formulation in equation (4)

ç1ÿ (3) cannot be correct. This problem is further addressed

C

below.

is derived from principles of mechanics. Adams & The last expression for ç in Table 1(a) was

Williamson (1923) found that the compressibilities suggested by Suklje (1969), who presented a short

of most rocks are much higher than those of their and straightforward analytical derivation of ç. This

constituent minerals. However, the value of C expression is not well-known, and it has not found

decreases with increasing pressure towards the widespread acceptance.

value of Cs (Zisman 1933, Brace 1965), which is Table 1(b) indicates two expressions for ç

essentially constant for most rock types (Bridgman associated with strength. The ®rst expression was

1925, 1928; Brace, 1965). Thus, the ratio Cs /C presented in an elaborate development in Skemp-

attains magnitudes that increase from near zero to ton's classical paper from 1960. He showed how

approaching unity at high pressures. Nur & Byerlee the effective stress at failure may be related to the

(1971) presented a rigorous derivation of the grain contact area per unit area of the plane a, and

expression in equation (3), and they also performed the angle of intrinsic friction and the angle of

an experimental study in which Weber sandstone shearing resistance. Skempton showed comparisons

was tested to determine the factor ç for this rock that indicated reasonable agreement between the

type. They determined the value of Cs from an expression and experimental results. However, he

unjacketed test on the sandstone, and they found did not indicate at which point in a shear test a

that the ratio Cs /C was not negligibly small. Their switch should be made from ç corresponding to

predictions of effective stress using ç 1 produced stress±strain behaviour to ç corresponding to fail-

too low values, whereas the predictions using ure. The authors have not been able to locate any

equation (3) were excellent. other papers in which this expression has been

Associated with the expression in equation (3), veri®ed or further elaborated.

Bishop (1973) demonstrated the analytical develop-

ment and formulation of the change in pore

Table 1(a). Expressions for ç for stress±strain beha-

pressure under undrained conditions resulting from viour of soil, concrete and rock

an ambient change in total stress. The resulting

expression for the pore pressure coef®cient B ç Reference

(Skempton, 1954) for a fully saturated porous me- 1 Terzaghi (1923, 1936)

dium became Hubbert & Rubey (1959, 1960)

Äu 1 Skempton (1960) and many

B (4) others

Äó Cw ÿ Cs

1n n Hoffman (1928)

C ÿ Cs

n porosity Fillunger (1930)

in which Cw compressibility of water 0´048 Terzaghi (1945)

10ÿ5 vol/vol per kPa. The same expression may Lubinski (1954)

be deduced from Geertsma's formulation (1957) for Biot (1955)

changes in pore space. Bishop (1973) observed that n < ç < 1 Schiffman (1970)

equation (4) indicates that if the solid material

(grains) were more compressible than the water (i.e. 1 ÿ a Skempton & Bishop (1954)

Cs . Cw ), `. . . then Äu/Äó will be greater than a effective grain Bishop (1955, 1960)

unity, which indicates the caution which must be contact area per Skempton (1960)

unit area of plane

exercized in making simplifying assumptions. The

possibility that Cs is greater than Cw is slight in 1 ÿ Cs /C Biot (1941)

real soils and rocks which are fully saturated, but or Gassmann (1951)

might be contrived in arti®cial two-phase systems 1 ÿ K/Ks Biot & Willis (1957)

. . .'. Whether equation (4) is correct cannot be Geertsma (1957, 1966)

Cs 1/Ks Skempton (1960)

tested with real soils and rocks, because Cw is

compressibility of Sera®m (1964)

approximately 25 times greater than Cs which is in solid material Nur & Byerlee (1971)

the range of 0´001±0´003 10ÿ5 vol/vol per kPa for (`grains') Bishop (1973)

most geological materials (Bridgman, 1925, 1928; C 1/K

Zisman, 1933, Skempton, 1960; Brace 1965). Note compressibility of

that all coef®cients of compressibility are given as skeleton

10ÿ5 vol/vol per kPa for easy comparison of 1 ÿ (1 ÿ n)Cs /C Suklje (1969)

magnitudes. However, without performing any

64 LADE AND DE BOER

Table 1(b). Expressions for ç for strength behaviour of The analytical development concerns an expres-

soil, concrete and rock sion for the pore pressure parameter B Äu/Äó

ç Reference previously discussed. Following this derivation, the

consequent expression for ç will be given and

1 ÿ a tan ø/tan ö9 Skempton (1960) discussed in relation to different types of porous

ø angle of intrinsic

friction

media.

ö angle of shearing

resistance

EFFECTS OF PRIMARY FACTORS ON B

1 Terzaghi (1936) The primary factors that affect the value of B

McHenry (1948) are considered to be those associated with the

Handin (1958)

Robinson (1959) porous medium itself: the skeleton, the grains

Handin et al. (1963) (solid phase), the porosity, the water (¯uid), the air

Murrell (1963) (gas) and the degree of saturation. Secondary

Walsh (1965) factors are considered to be those associated with

Brace & Byerlee (1966) the testing technique. These include the measuring

Brace & Martin (1968) system and the membrane that surrounds the

Garg & Nur (1973) specimen. The secondary factors have been taken

into account in the analyses of the experiments to

be presented, and they will not be further

elaborated here. A detailed presentation of these

One of the reasons that further efforts in this factors was given by Lade & Hernandez (1977).

direction are absent may be that most investiga- The primary components that enter the expres-

tions dealing with failure in concrete and rock sion for the parameter B are illustrated schemati-

have indicated that a factor of ç 1, that is cally in Fig. 1. The grains indicated may be

Terzaghi's original expression is perfectly adequate cemented together to form a connected frame, or

for interpretation of failure conditions in these they may be individual particles touching each

materials. In the process of shearing concrete and other at very small contact points. The skeleton

rock, micro®ssures develop and open up, and at and the grains may exhibit nonlinear elastic

the time of peak failure, suf®cient deterioration of behaviour with changing pressure, but they will

the solid material has occurred that the compres- be treated as piecewise linear elastic for which the

sibility of the skeleton has increased substantially. necessary properties are determined in the im-

Therefore, the expression in equation (3), which is mediate vicinity of the current stress point. The

most often employed for the stress±strain beha- pores are uniformly distributed and interconnected,

viour, approaches unity near failure, even at high and the ¯uid in the pores is linearly compressible.

con®ning pressures. This means that the expression Fig. 1(a) shows that changes in total con®ning

in equation (3) has the potential to capture the pressure, Ä(ócell ÿ u), while u constant, produce

effective stress for both stress±strain and strength both linear compression of the skeleton as well as

behaviour. This will be further discussed below. volumetric compression of the grains themselves,

Further and more detailed reviews of the early unless the grains are volumetrically incompressible

thinking behind the effective stress principle and (corresponding to Poisson's ratio for isotropic

the historical development of the theory of porous grains, ígrains 0´5). The corresponding coef®-

media have been made by de Boer & Ehlers cients of compressibility are de®ned in Fig. 1. In

(1990). general, the values of Csks (compressibility of

skeleton due to change in total con®ning pressure)

and Cgs (compressibility of grains due to change in

FACTORS AFFECTING PORE PRESSURES IN total con®ning pressure) would be expected to be

POROUS MEDIA different from zero.

As seen from Table 1, any realistic expression Fig. 1(b1) shows the response to a change in

for the effective stress for porous media involves pore pressure, Äu, while (ócell ÿ u) constant. For

the compressibilities of the skeleton and the grains the purpose of explanation, the effect of Äu is

(solid material). The analytical development pre- shown in two stages. The change in pore pressure

sented below involves a more detailed treatment of causes a volumetric compression of the solid

the compressibility of the grains than previously grains (unless the grains are isotropic with ígrains

presented in the literature. Appropriate laboratory 0´5). This results in Cgu compressibility of

experiments in which highly compressible grains grains due to a pore pressure change. The grains

play a paramount role are then performed to pro- are then adjusted to contact each other again, and

duce results for comparison with the analytical ex- this results in a volumetric change of the skeleton.

pression. This is expressed by Csku compressibility of the

EFFECTIVE STRESS FOR SOIL, CONCRETE AND ROCK 65

(σcell 2 u), u (σcell 2 u) 1 (∆σcell 2 ∆u), u 5 constant

Initial condition Linear compression 1 Volumetric compression

of grains ⇒ volumetric of grains (unless

compression of skeleton νgrains 5 0.5)

(a) ∆Vsks 5 CsksV0(∆σcell 2 ∆u) ∆Vgs 5 CgsV0(∆σcell 2 ∆u)

Initial condition: ∆Vgu 5 (1 2 n)V0Cgu∆u ∆Vsku 5 V0Csku∆u

grains in contact

(b1) For grains in contact:

(1 2 n)Cgu 5 Csku

skeleton due to a pore pressure change. As may be between the `grains' and the `skeleton' as the

seen from Fig. 1(b1), for a granular material these porous material changes from a distinctly granular

two compressibilities are related to each other material to a rock with pores. In the following,

because (Skempton, 1960; Bishop, 1973): `. . . the equation (5) will not be assumed to be generally

components of strain along any continuous path true.

across the solid skeleton within the element are It is evident that a comprehensive treatment of

equal to those within the solid material of the the volumetric compression of porous media

skeleton': requires several coef®cients of compressibility as

C sku C gu (1 ÿ n) (5) reviewed above. Four compressibilities rather than

two, as employed in previous analyses, have been

Although this appears to be correct for a granular de®ned. The fact that these compressibilities are

material, it may not be correct for a highly real and that they play signi®cant roles in the

cemented porous medium in which the individual behaviour of the porous material will be demon-

grains are not distinguishable. Although the pores strated from the experimental results to be

are interconnected, the shapes of the pores may be presented. Whereas the relation in equation (5) is

such that the overall compression of the skeleton is likely for granular materials, none of the compres-

small compared to the compression of the solid sibilities will be assumed a priori to be related to

phase (`grains'), as suggested in Fig. 1(b2). In fact, each other.

it becomes increasingly dif®cult to distinguish Fig. 1(c) shows the effects of a change in pore

66 LADE AND DE BOER

`grains´ compress, but little compression of skeleton ⇒

(1 2 n)Cgu . Csku

(b2)

u u 1 ∆u

∆Va 5 nV0 12 S

u ∆u

2

(c)

Fig. 1. Volumetric compression of porous material due to (a) con®ning pressure; (b) pore pressure in (b1)

granular material, and in (b2) solid rock with interconnected pores); (c) Volumetric compression of pore ¯uid and

gas

pressure on the compression of the water (¯uid) element and the interior volumetric compression of

and the pore air (gas). The compressibility of the components of the element. This results in the

water Cw is constant, while the compression of air following equation

(gas) follows Boyle's law.

The expression for the parameter B is derived ÄV sks ÄV sku ÄV gs ÄV gu ÄV w ÄV a

on the basis that volumetric compatibility must be (6)

obtained during an undrained stress increase

between the exterior reduction in volume of an in which the individual quantities are expressed in

EFFECTIVE STRESS FOR SOIL, CONCRETE AND ROCK 67

terms of the respective compressibilities and EXPERIMENTS TO STUDY THE EFFECTIVE STRESS

stresses PRINCIPLE

Most previous experiments to validate analytical

ÄV sks C sks V 0 (Äó ÿ Äu) (7) expressions for the effective stress have all been

where V0 total volume of the element, and performed on real geological materials for which

the compressibility of the grains (solid material) is

ÄV sku C sku V 0 Äu (8)

more than an order of magnitude smaller than the

ÄV gs C gs V 0 (Äó ÿ Äu) (9) compressibility of water. In addition, real concrete

ÄV gu C gu (1 ÿ n)V 0 Äu (10) and rock typically have very small porosities. It

is therefore dif®cult to measure all the required

ÄV w C w nV 0 SÄu (11) quantities with suf®cient accuracy to determine

whether the small quantities are correctly included

where S degree of saturation, and from Boyle's in the formulation. For example, the appearance of

law the compressibility of the solid phase Cs in

1ÿS equation (4) is dif®cult to check for real materials,

ÄV a nÄV 0 Äu (12)

u2 because it is approximately 25 times smaller than

the compressibility of water.

where u2 (u1 + Äu) the absolute pressure in the It is evident from equations (13) that the most

pore air after application of an increment in pore signi®cant effect to verify is that relating to the

pressure. compressibility of the grains (solid phase). Because

Since the expression for B to be derived will be the effective stress formulation is based on

used to check the principle of effective stress for a principles of mechanics, it should be valid for all

fully saturated specimen, it will be assumed that types of materials, and it is not important to

S 1, that is the effect of the compressibility of perform the experiments on real porous materials

the air is not present. It should be noted, however, such as concrete and rock. True principles of

that the in¯uence of the degree of saturation S on mechanics may be checked with any suitable

the measured value of B is always very pro- material. In the present case it is important to

nounced. The B-value test (in which the cell obtain pronounced grain compressibilities to deter-

pressure is changed by Äó while the specimen is mine whether the proposed formulation is correct.

undrained and the corresponding pore pressure The approach taken here was therefore to fabricate

increase Äu is measured to form B Äu/Äó) is specimens of several compressible materials such

the best indication of the degree of saturation of a as balsawood, basswood, and acrylic plastic. Porous

specimen of porous material. Typically, the value specimens with different porosities were desirable

of B is close to 1´0 for saturated soils. B-values to verify the effect of porosity.

smaller than 1´0 may be indicative of incomplete

saturation, but other factors may cause B to be-

come lower than unity as indicated in the fol- FABRICATION OF TEST SPECIMENS

lowing. Several lengths of square rods of balsawood,

Substitution of equations (7±11) into equation basswood and acrylic plastic with cross-sections

(6), solving for Äu, and dividing by Äó yields of approximately 6´3 6´3 mm2 (0´25 0´25 in2 )

were purchased. The rods were cut into lengths of

Äu 1

B approximately 5´5 cm and stacked to form cubical

Äó Cw (1 ÿ n)C gu ÿ C sku specimens. Fig. 2 shows a photograph of the six

1n

C sks ÿ C gs C sks ÿ C gs cubes produced for this study. The square rods were

(13) carefully glued together over the full contact areas

using glue products appropriate for the wood and

Comparison of Bishop's equation (4) with the plastic, respectively.

equation (13) shows that the difference between The three materials had different compressibil-

the two formulations relates to the compressibility ities. The compressibilities of the two wood types

of the grains and the skeleton due to the pore were likely to vary with con®ning pressure,

pressure. In Bishop's approach the compressibility whereas the solid acrylic plastic was likely to

of the grains (solid phase) is taken as one value, exhibit reasonably constant material compressibility

but in reality the compressibility varies with within the pressure range to be employed. One

respect to the agent that compresses the grains, cube of balsawood, two cubes of basswood with

as shown schematically in Figs. 1(a) and 1(b). different porosities (obtained by changing the

Thus, Cs in equation (4) is taken to represent Cgu , distances between the square rods), and three

Cgs and Csku . If these three values are set equal cubes of acrylic plastic with different porosities

and substituted into equation (13), then Bishop's were produced. The differences in porosity are

equation (4) is obtained. clearly seen in Fig. 2.

68 LADE AND DE BOER

Fig. 2. Photograph of one balsawood, two basswood and three acrylic plastic cubes fabricated for the study of the

effective stress principle

Following the glueing process the plastic cubes when pressurized. Several cycles of additional

were milled and the wood cubes were carefully sealing and testing did not change this outcome.

trimmed with a sharp knife to produce ¯at surfaces Table 2 presents the relevant properties of the six

along all sides. To prevent water from penetrating test specimens.

into the wood during pressurization, the wood

cubes were dipped into liquid latex rubber three

times with suf®cient time between each dip for the EXPERIMENTAL SET-UP

latex rubber to dry completely. The B-value tests were performed in a triaxial

Although great care was taken to seal the wood cell with steel cell wall to minimize the expansion

cubes, it was clear from the test results that the of the cell during pressurization. Fig. 3 shows a

densest basswood cube was in fact imbibing water schematic diagram of the set-up. The `arti®cial

Specimen I.D. Number Material Volume, V0: cm3 Porosity, n Compressibility of

skeleton, Csks

(vol/vol per kPa)

BAL 1 Balsawood 203´2 0´436 See Fig. 7(a)

BAS 1 Basswood 204´3 0´442 See Fig. 8(a)

BAS 2 Basswood 177´1 0´281 Unknown

AC 1 Acrylic plastic 182´7 0´459 0´172 10ÿ5

AC 2 Acrylic plastic 168´4 0´319 0´100 10ÿ5

AC 3 Acrylic plastic 168´6 0´205 0´081 10ÿ5

EFFECTIVE STRESS FOR SOIL, CONCRETE AND ROCK 69

Dial gauge

σcell

cell pressure measuring device

6.4mm stainless

steel cell wall

rubber membrane

cover holes on 4 sides

of cube specimen

pore pressure measuring

device

rock' specimens were contained between a stain- stainless steel plates were cut to cover the holes

less steel cap and base and surrounded by a 0´6 (i.e. the pores). The side lengths of the square

mm latex rubber membrane. To avoid membrane plates were smaller than the sides of the cubical

penetration into the pores along the four exposed specimens, thus allowing these to deform freely

surfaces of the cubes, four 1´0 mm thick square during the experiments. After installation, the

70 LADE AND DE BOER

specimens and the triaxial cell were fully saturated the scheme of isotropic cell pressure and pore

using the CO2 method described by Lade & pressure variations shown on the two diagrams

Duncan (1973). were adopted. The balsawood specimen began to

show excessive creep and possible collapse at the

highest stresses indicated.

Measurements Fig. 7(a) shows the compressibilities and their

All experiments were performed by exposing variations calculated from the data in Figs 5 and 6.

the specimens to varying isotropic pressures. The Fig. 7(b) shows a comparison of measured and

vertical deformation of the cube was measured by a calculated values of B. All were calculated to be

dial gauge through a thin pin screwed into the cap. 0´996, whereas the measured values of B were

The volume change from inside the specimen was unity or slightly above. Values of B higher than

measured by a regular burette-type device, whereas unity should not be calculable from the analytical

the volume change from the triaxial cell was expression, because this would imply that a higher

measured by a high pressure device described by increment in pore pressure could be generated than

Lade & Overton (1989). The cell pressure and the the increment of cell pressure imposed on the

pore water pressure were measured by Bourdon- specimen. The higher increments in pore pressure

type pressure gauges as well as by more accurately measured in the experiments are generated by

sensing electrical pressure transducers attached to creep, which in turn is obtaining its energy from

the volume change devices. the stored potential energy in the specimen. B-

The volume change from the cell was corrected value tests performed on sand at very high

for the intrusion of the pin and for the expansion con®ning pressures indicate that the pore pressure

of the cell due to pressurization. No other correc- increments can be several times the applied cell

tions were applied to the measured quantities. pressure increment, as shown by Yamamuro &

Lade (1993). This contribution from creep is not

included in the analytical expression presented

Interpretation of measurements above. Consequently, B greater than unity cannot

The corrected volume change from the cell be predicted. Fig. 7(a) indicates that all compres-

represents the volume change of the skeleton, sibilities associated with the skeleton and the

ÄVspec, as shown in Fig. 4. For compressible grains, grains (solid phase) of the balsawood are much

the volume change of grains is obtained from greater than the compressibility of water.

ÄV grains ÄV skel ÿ ÄV spec (14)

This is also illustrated schematically in Fig. 4. Basswood

The compression of the basswood shows a

different character to the balsawood, that is the

Accuracy of measurements compressibilities are lower and they decrease with

Although the compressibility of the acrylic increasing pressure. This is demonstrated in Fig.

plastic was much higher than the relatively small 8(a), which also indicates that the compressibilities

values of compressibilities of real rock (0´001± associated with the basswood are all greater than

0´003 10ÿ5 vol/vol per kPa), the accuracy of the that of water. Fig. 8(b) a comparison of measured

volume measurements from the triaxial cell was and calculated B-values for the basswood speci-

not suf®cient to allow detailed analyses of the men. In this case the B-values at lower isotropic

experiments on the plastic specimens. However, pressures were below unity, and in each case the

they were accurate enough to allow qualitative B-value calculated from equation (13) is very close

analyses in support of the proposition presented to the measured value. Note that one value of B

below. The experiments on the wood specimens was determined during unloading of the specimen,

produced results from which each type of com- and this value is quite different from the others.

pressibility could be determined, and these experi- Nevertheless, the B-value calculated from the

ments are analyzed in detail in the following. appropriate compressibilities is reasonably close

to the experimental value. Thus, equation (13)

appears to capture the mechanics of the B-value

EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS FOR WOOD CUBES test with good accuracy.

Balsawood

Figures 5 and 6 show the measured data for the

balsawood specimen. Because the balsawood was ANALYSIS OF COMPRESSIBILITIES

very compressible, each of the components in- Based on the compressibilities shown in Figs. 7

dicated in Figs 1(a) and 1(b) is clearly visible in and 8, it was attempted to throw further light on

the diagrams in Figs 5 and 6. In order to establish the relation between the compressibilities by

all the compressibilities occurring in equation (13), evaluating the expression in equation (5). The

EFFECTIVE STRESS FOR SOIL, CONCRETE AND ROCK 71

σcell

∆Vskeleton

∆Vspecimen

(circular grains maintain their volumes)

(circular grains compress into square grains)

isotropic compression test

values of (1 ÿ n)Cgu are calculated and compared that the value of (1 ÿ n)Cgu is greater than Csku

with the values of Csku in Fig. 9 for both types of whenever B is lower than unity. Equation (13) also

wood. For balsawood the two values are equal, thus indicates that B-values lower than unity are ob-

supporting equation (5). However, for basswood tained only when the third term in the denominator

(1 ÿ n)Cgu is initially greater than Csku before the has a substantial value, thus showing that

two terms become equal at higher pressures. They (1 ÿ n)C gu ÿ C sku

again show substantial differences for the one set >0 (15)

C sks ÿ C gs

of measurements performed during unloading.

Comparing the results in Fig. 9 with the measure- Since Csks is always the largest of the compressi-

ments of B in Figs. 7(b) and 8(b), it is evident bilities, thus making the denominator positive, then

72 LADE AND DE BOER

∆Vskel

described by Csks 5

V0(∆σcell 2 ∆u) 73

39

141 106

0

B 5 1.038

Balsawood cube

V0 5 203.2 cm3 108 141

0

200 n 5 0.436 B 5 1.000

178 141 39

74 108 73

(σcell 2 u): kPa

B 5 1.045

0 106

141 141

39 74

∆Vskel 0

110 108 described by Csku 5

0 39 V0∆u

100 0

74 74

B 5 1.015 0

0 39

0

0 1 2 3 4 5

∆Vskel: cm3

Fig. 5. Compression of skeleton of balsawood cube due to changes in cell pressure and pore pressure. Values of u

in kPa are given at discrete points

∆Vgrains

described by Cgs 5

V0(∆σcell 2 ∆u)

200

202

B 5 1.038 ∆Vgrains

described by Cgu 5

(1 2 n)V0∆u

169 169

B 5 1.000 201

239

u: kPa

135

V0 5 203.2 cm3

134 236 n 5 0.436

100 169 203

100 Values of (σcell 2 u): kPa are

B 5 1.045

202 235 given at discrete points

135 170

66

B 5 1.015

135 203 236

100

69 73

105 242

0

0 1 2 3

∆Vgrains: cm3

Fig. 6. Compression of `grains' of balsawood cube due to changes in cell pressure and pore

pressure

(1 ÿ n)C gu ÿ C sku > 0 (16) evaluation of equation (16). The B-values for each

of these specimens were measured to be essentially

whenever B is lower than unity, as for the bass- constant for pressures up to 7000 kPa, that is the

wood. plastic specimens showed linear behaviour in this

Although the measurement of volume changes range of pressures. Constant values of B between

from the triaxial cell were too inaccurate for de- 0´54±0´63 were obtained for the three specimens.

tailed analyses of the experiments on the acrylic The analyses showed that the ratio in equation (15)

plastic specimens, suf®cient data were obtained for would have to be between 0´2±0´5, that is not

EFFECTIVE STRESS FOR SOIL, CONCRETE AND ROCK 73

C(vol/vol per kPa)

Cw 5 0.048 3 1025

15 3 1025

5 3 1025

Csks

Basswood cube

Max. pressure

4 3 1025 Measured

Balsawood cube during

3 3 1025 (a) unloading

10 3 1025 (a)

2 3 1025

Cgu

1 3 1025

Csks Cgs

Csku

0

0 100 200 300 400 500 600

Cw 5 0.048 3 1025 (σcell 2 u): kPa

5 3 1025

B

1.1 Measured

Cgu

Calculated

Csku

1.0

Cgs

0 0.9

0 100 200

(σcell 2 u): kPa

B Measured 0.8 (b)

1.10 (b) Calculated (B 5 0.996

in all cases)

0.7

1.00

Fig. 7. Variaton of (a) compressibilities and (b) mea- ured and calculated B-values for basswood cube with

sured and calculated B-values for balsawood cube with difference between cell pressure and pore pressure

difference between cell pressure and pore pressure

B-values. Again, this provides con®rmation of the

inequality in equation (16). This means that the

Csku(1 2 n)Cgu: vol/vol per kPa

10 3 1025

compressibility of the grains due to a pore pressure

increase must be higher than that of the skeleton. (a) Balsawood cube

For the acrylic plastic specimens, this may be en-

visioned as illustrated schematically in Fig. 1(b-2).

The experimental results show that the expres- 5 3 1025 Csku( ) = (1 2 n)Cgu( )

sion in equation (15) is always zero or positive.

Therefore, the analytical B-values from equation

(13) will not exceed unity, while the expression in

equation (4) would produce B-values greater than

unity for both wood specimens. For these speci- 0

0 100 200

mens, all `grain' compressibilities are clearly (σcell 2 u): kPa

greater than that of water, as seen on Figs. 7(a)

Csku(1 2 n)Cgu: vol/vol per kPa

Measured

and 8(a). The characterization of the various during

unloading

compressibilities of the solid phase (`grains') as

1 3 1025 (b) Basswood cube

one property is not correct, and it leads to the Max. pressure

erroneous expression in equation (4). (1 2 n)Csku

The value of Cgu represents the compressibility

of the grains (solid phase) due to an all-around Csku

pore pressure change. This is what is determined 0

from the volume change measured in an un- 0 100 200 300 400 500 600

(σcell 2 u): kPa

jacketed test. In comparison, the value of Csku

must be somewhat smaller and not nearly as easy Fig. 9. Comparison of compressibilities of skeleton and

to determine for cases where the solid phase `grains' due to pore pressure changes for (a) balsa-

cannot be distinguished as separate grains. In fact, wood cube, and (b) basswood cube

74 LADE AND DE BOER

as the `points' of contact grow, i.e. are ®lled in Suklje (1969). As the compressibility of the

with solid phase material, it becomes complicated skeleton Csks decreases with increasing pressure

to determine what is `grains' and what is towards the limit represented by the compressibility

`skeleton'. The dilemma is indicated in Fig. 10. of the grains (solid phase) Cgu , the ratio of Cgu /Csks

As the contacts grow, they eventually reach approaches unity and the effective stress may be

diameters equal to the grain diameter, at which expressed as

point the pores vanish. At this limiting condition, Äó9 Äó ÿ nÄu (21)

the compressibility of the skeleton equals the

compressibility of the grains Such an expression was intuitively proposed by

C sku C gu (17) several authors, as seen in Table 1(a).

It should be noted, however, that the pressures

Thus, it is necessary to study the two ends of the required to make Cgu /Csks approach unity would

spectrum using separate expressions for the com- also cause large amounts of grain crushing and

pressibility of the skeleton. consequent reductions in the porosity, n. The

results of two K0 -compression tests, one on quartz

sand with very hard grains and the other on

THE EFFECTIVE STRESS PRINCIPLE gypsum sand with very soft grains, are shown in

If the effective stress, Äó9, is de®ned as the Fig. 11 (Yamamuro, 1993; Bopp, 1994). These two

stress that produces the same volume change as a sand types may be representative of extreme

particular combination of the total stress Äó and characteristics with regard to their potential for

the pore pressure Äu, then using the left-hand-side particle breakage. The experiments were performed

of equation (6), this volume change may be written in a thick-walled steel cylinder in which the

as 3´81 cm dia. (1´5 in) sand specimens were com-

C sks V 0 Äó9 C sks V 0 (Äó ÿ Äu) C sku V 0 Äu pressed to vertical stresses a little beyond

800 MPa. The reduction in porosity n and in the

(18) compressibility of the skeleton Csks with increasing

from which pressure may be calculated from the data presented

C sku

Äó9 Äó ÿ 1 ÿ Äu (19)

C sks

1

This equation represents the general expression for

the effective stress in a porous material.

For separate grains with small contact points,

the expression in equation (5) for the compression

of the skeleton may be substituted into equation

(19) to produce

0.6

C gu

Äó9 Äó ÿ 1 ÿ (1 ÿ n) Äu (20)

Void ratio, e

C sks

which is similar to the expression suggested by

0.4

Quartz sand

0.2

Gypsum sand

0

(a) Separate Gradual (b) Solid rock with 0.1 1 10 100 1,000 10,000

grains with transition interconnected

contact points pores Vertical stress: MPa

Fig. 10. Schematic illustration of gradual transition in Fig. 11. Results of one-dimensional compression tests

porous material from (a) separate grains with contact on quartz sand and gypsum sand shown on e against

points to (b) solid rock with interconnected pores log (stress) diagram

EFFECTIVE STRESS FOR SOIL, CONCRETE AND ROCK 75

in Fig. 11 for each of the two sands. The 1

consequent increase in solid fraction (1 ÿ n) is 0.98

shown in Fig. 12 and the decrease in skeleton

0.96

Factor, η

compressibility with increasing vertical stress is Dam foundations and abutments,

shown in Fig. 13 for the two sands (note the 0.94 tunnel linings, mine shafts

difference in scale on the vertical axes). The

0.92

volumetric compressibility of the solid phase of Deep wells, mine pillars

quartz is Cgu 0´0027 vol/vol per kPa (Bridgman 0.9

0 20 40 60 80 100

1925, 1928; Skempton 1960; Brace 1965), and the Vertical stress: MPa

value for gypsum is taken to be Cgu 0´0020 vol/ 1

vol per kPa. The variation of the factor ç, given in

equation (20), can now be calculated for the two

0.8

sands.

Fig. 14 shows the results of calculations of ç for Quartz sand

quartz sand and for gypsum sand. The results for 0.6

Factor, η

these two extreme sands appear to be relatively

close, even though their compressibilities are Pile foundations, points of

0.4 concentration in mine pillars

substantially different, as shown on Fig. 13. It is Gypsum sand

0.2

Conventional and nuclear explosives,

1 deep focus earthquakes

Gypsum sand

0

0 200 400 600 800 1,000

0.9 Vertical stress: MPa

Solid fraction: (1 − n)

Quartz sand Fig. 14. Variation of factor ç with stress for quartz sand

0.8 and gypsum sand. Probable maximum stresses for

various geotechnical structures and conditions are

shown for comparison

0.7

0.6

seen that ç generally decreases from close to unity

with increasing stress. Since the solid fraction,

0.5

0 200 400 600 800 1000

shown in Fig. 12, does not vary much with

Vertical stress: MPa pressure compared to the variation of the skeleton

compressibility, it is the latter that has the most

Fig. 12. Variation of solid fraction (1 ÿ n) with stress signi®cant in¯uence on the value of ç.

for quartz sand and gypsum sand Indicated on Fig. 14 are also the probable

maximum stresses encountered in various practical

engineering facilities (Murphy 1987). It is clear

0.006

that ç is very close to unity in the range of

Skeleton compressibility: 1/kPa

0.005 found. Further, ç does not decrease signi®cantly

until stresses are reached that are highly unusual in

0.06 0.004

engineering practice. In practice it would not be

Skeleton compressibility: 1/kPa

between unity and the actual value of ç in the

0.04 0.002 range of stresses up to and possibly beyond

100 MPa. Nevertheless, signi®cant deviations from

0.03 0.001 Quartz sand

Terzaghi's proposed effective stress principle occur

0.02 0 at higher stress magnitudes, as suspected by

0 200 400 600 800 1,000

Vertical stress: MPa Skempton (1960).

0.01

Gypsum sand

0

0 200 400 600 800 1,000 Solid rock with interconnected pores

Vertical stress: MPa

For the other limiting case of solid rock with

Fig. 13. Variation of skeleton compressibility with small interconnected pores and low porosity, the

stress for quartz sand and gypsum sand. Note differ- expression for Csku from equation (17) is sub-

ence in vertical scale for the two diagrams stituted into equation (19) to produce

76 LADE AND DE BOER

C gu SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS

Äó9 Äó ÿ 1 ÿ Äu (22) The concept of effective stress for porous media

C sks

has been addressed in many studies in the past.

Table 1(a) shows that this expression for the These studies and the resulting expressions for the

effective stress is similar to that proposed by many effective stress have been summarized. An analy-

authors, if Cs is taken to be equal to Cgu . Note, tical expression for the undrained compression of a

however, that no previous studies have distinguished material element based on compressibilities of

between the different compressibilities of the grains (solid phase) and skeleton is then derived.

skeleton and the grains associated with the total In the consequent expression for B Äu/Äó, a

stress and the pore pressure, as done here. distinction is made between the compressibilities

Experiments on Weber sandstone were presented of grains and skeleton due to total stresses and

by Nur & Byerlee (1971) to show that the ex- pore pressures. This distinction results in a new

pression in equation (22) captures the effective and more detailed evaluation of the effective stress

stress behaviour of the sandstone with very good in porous media such as soil, concrete, and rock. A

accuracy. These authors also presented a theoretical series of experiments was performed on `arti®cial

derivation of the coef®cient ç shown in square rock' specimens made of square rods of balsawood,

brackets (with Cgu Cs ) in equation (22) for solid basswood, and acrylic plastic glued together to

rock with interconnected pores. form porous cubical specimens. The data from

While equation (20) applies for granular materi- these experiments are used as an aid in evaluating

al as indicated in the left-hand-side of Fig. 10, the the general, analytical expression for the effective

expression in equation (22) applies to solid rock stress. This expression is then specialized to form

with interconnected pores as shown in the right- two distinct expressions for the effective stress in

hand-side of Fig. 10. A transition from one to the (a) granular materials consisting of separate grains

other condition appears to involve a change in the with small contact points, and (b) solid rock with

contact area a per unit area of the plane. A interconnected pores. For various special condi-

gradual transition may be achieved by multiplying tions, these expressions are shown to be similar

the porosity n in equation (20) by a factor such as to most previously proposed expressions for the

(1 ÿ am ) in which the exponent m is to be effective stress. Terzaghi's proposed effective stress

determined experimentally. This intuitive relation principle works well for stress magnitudes encoun-

would have the properties of producing the tered in most geotechnical applications, but signi®-

expressions in equations (20) and (22) for a 0 cant deviations occur at very high stresses.

and a 1, respectively. However, developments

beyond those given above are beyond the scope of

the present study. ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The experiments on the `arti®cial rock' speci-

mens were conducted in the Department of Civil

Engineering at University of California, Los

Failure Angeles. The research presented here was sup-

Both expressions for the effective stress in ported by the Air Force Of®ce of Scienti®c

equations (20) and (22) contain the compressibility Research of USA under Grant No. 910117, by

of the skeleton Csks in the denominator. In the the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, and by

process of shearing soil, concrete, or rock, the Stiftung Volkswagenwerk of the Federal Republic

material dilates, the density decreases, the structure of Germany. Grateful appreciation is expressed for

loosens up, and the value of Csks consequently this support.

increases with increasing shear strain. For granular

materials the process of dilation has been de-

scribed in texts on basic behaviour of soils. For REFERENCES

concrete and rock the process of initiation and Adams, L. H., & Williamson, E. D. (1923). The compres-

growth of microcracks and subsequent coalescence sibility of minerals and rocks at high pressures.

of these features into larger pores are associated J. Franklin Inst., 195, 475±529.

with volume expansion as explained in basic texts Biot, M. A. (1941). General theory of three-dimensional

on concrete behaviour and rock mechanics. The consolidation, J. Appl. Phys., 12, 155±164.

consequent increasing compressibility of the ske- Biot, M. A. (1955). Theory of elasticity and consolidation

leton reduces the ratio Cgu /Csks towards zero and for a porous anisotropic solid. J. Appl. Phys., 26,

182±185.

the value of ç in both equations (20) and (22) Biot, M. A., & Willis, D. G. (1957). The elastic

approaches unity. This compares well with the coef®cients of the theory of consolidation, J. Appl.

experience reported by many authors, as listed in Mech., 24, 594±601.

Table 1(b). Thus, ç 1 is adequate for interpreta- Bishop, A. W. (1955). The principle of effective stress,

tion of failure conditions in porous media. Tekniske Ukeblad, No. 39, 1959, 859±863. Also

EFFECTIVE STRESS FOR SOIL, CONCRETE AND ROCK 77

Norwegian Geotechnical Institute, Oslo, Publication pressure in mechanics of overthrust faulting: A reply,

No. 32, 1960, 1±5. Bull. Geol. Soc. Am., 71, 617±628.

Bishop, A. W. (1973). The in¯uence of an undrained Lade, P. V., & Duncan, J. M. (1973). Cubical triaxial tests

change in stress on the pore pressure in porous media on cohesionless soil, J. Soil Mech. Foundns Div., Am.

of low compressibility, GeÂotechnique 23, No. 3, 435± Soc. Civ. Engrs, 99, No. SM10, 793±812.

442. Lade, P. V., & Hernandez, S. B. (1977). Membrane

Bopp, P. A. (1994). Effect of initial relative density on penetration effects in undrained tests, J. Geotech.

instability and behavior of granular materials at high Enginng Div., Am. Soc. Civ. Engrs, ASCE, 103, No.

pressure, University of California, Los Angeles, GT2, 109±125.

California, PhD dissertation 1994. Lade, P. V., & Overton, D. D. (1989). Cementation effects

Brace, W. F. (1965). Some new measurements of linear in frictional materials, J. Geotech. Engng, 115, No.

compressibility of rocks, J. Geophys. Res., 70, 391± 10, 1373±1387.

398. Laubscher, H. P. (1960). Role of ¯uid pressure in

Brace, W. F., & Byerlee, D. (1966). Recent experimental mechanics of overthrust faulting: dicussion, Bull.

studies of brittle fracture of rocks, MIT, Cambridge, Geol. Soc. Am., 71, 611±615.

Mass. Unpublished paper quoted by Sera®m (1979). Lubinski, A. (1954). The theory of elasticity for porous

Brace, W. F. & Martin, R. J. III (1968). A test of the law bodies displaying a strong pore structure, Proc. 2nd

of effective stress for crystalline rocks of low US Nat. Congr. Appl. Mech., Ann Arbor, 247±256.

porosity, Int. J. Rock Mech. Min. Sci., 5, 415±426. McHenry, D. (1948). The effect of uplift pressure on the

Bridgman, P. W. (1925). The linear compressibility of shearing strength of concrete, Proc. 6th Congr. Large

fourteen natural crystals, Am. J. Sci., 10, 483±498. Dams, Paper 48.

Bridgman, P. W. (1928). The compressibility of thirteen Murphy, D. J. (1987). Stress, degradation, and shear

natural crystals, Am. J. Sci., 15, 287±296. strength of granular material, in Geotechnical Model-

de Boer, R., & Ehlers, W. (1990). The development of ing and Applications, (ed. Sayed M. Sayed), Gulf

the concept of effective stresses, Acta Mechanica, Publishing Co., Houston, Texas, 181±211.

Springer-Verlag, 83, pp. 77±92. Murrell, S. A. F. (1963). A criterion for brittle fracture of

Fillunger, P. (1913). Der Auftrieb in Talsperren, O È sterr. rocks and concrete under triaxial stress, and the effect

Wochenschrift fuÈr den oÈffentlichen Baudienst, 19, of pore pressure on the criterion, in Proc. 5th Symp.

532±556; 567±570. Rock Mechanics, (ed C. Fairhurst), Pergamon Press,

Fillunger, P. (1914). Neuere Grundlagen fuÈr die statische New York, 563±577.

Berechnung von Talsperren, Zeitschrift des O È sterr. Nur, A., & Byerlee, J. D. (1971). An exact effective

Ing.- und Arch.-Vereines, 23, 441±447. stress law for elastic deformation of rock with ¯uids.

Fillunger, P. (1915). Versuche uÈber die Zugfestigkeit bei J. Geophys. Res., 76, 6414±6419.

allseitigem Wasserdruck, O È sterr. Wochenschrift fuÈr Robinson, L. H., Jr. (1959). The effect of pore and

den oÈffentl. Baudienst, 29, 443±448. con®ning pressure on the failure process in sedimen-

Fillunger, P. (1930). Auftrieb und Unterdruck in Stau- tary rock, Colorado School of Mines Quart., 54, No.

mauern, Proc. 2nd Trans. World Power Conf., Berlin, 3, 177±199.

9, 323±329. Schiffman, R. L. (1970). The stress components of a

Fillunger, P. (1936). Erdbaumechanik? Selbstverlag des porous medium, J. Geophys. Res., 75, 4035±4038.

Verfassers, Wien. Sera®m, J. L. (1964). The `uplift area' in plain concrete

Garg, S. K., & Nur, A. (1973). Effective stress laws for in the elastic range, Proc. 8th Congr. on Large Dams,

¯uid-saturated porous rocks, J. Geophys. Res., 78, Edinburgh, Vol. V, C.17.

5911±5921. Sera®m, J. L. (1979). In¯uence of Interstitial Water on

Gassmann, F. (1951). U È ber die ElastizitaÈt poroÈser the Behavior of Rock Masses, Chapter 3 in Rock

Medien, Vierteljahrsschrift der Naturforschenden Ge- Mechanics in Engineering Practice, (eds. K. G. Stagg

sellschaft in ZuÈrich, 96, 1±23. and O. C. Zienkiewicz), Wiley, London, 55±97.

Geertsma, J. (1957). The effect of ¯uid pressure decline Skempton, A. W. (1954). The pore pressure coef®cients

on volumetric changes of porous rocks, Trans. AIME, A and B, GeÂotechnique 4, No. 4, 143±147.

210, 331±340. Skempton, A. W. (1960). Effective stress in soils,

Geertsma, J. (1966). Problems of rock mechanics in concrete and rock, Conf. on Pore Pressure and

petroleum production engineering, Proc. 1st Int. Suction in Soils, Butterworths, 4±16.

Congr. Rock Mechanics, Lisbon, I, R. 359, 585. Skempton, A. W., and Bishop, A. W. (1954). Soils, in

Handin, J. (1958). Effects of pore pressure on the Building materials, their elasticity and inelasticity,

experimental deformation of some sedimentary rocks, (ed. M. Reiner) North Holland Publishing Company,

Bull. Geol. Soc. Am., 69, 1576±1577. Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 417±482.

Handin, J., Hager, R. V. Jr., Friedman, M., & Feather, J. Suklje, L. (1969). Rheological aspects of soil mechanics,

N. (1963). Experimental deformation of sedimentary Wiley Interscience, New York, 123.

rocks under con®ning pressure: Pore pressure tests, Terzaghi, K.v. (1923). Die Berechnung der DurchlaÈssig-

Bull. Amer. Ass. Petrol. Geol., 47, 717±755. keitsziffer des Tones aus dem Verlauf der hydro-

Hoffman, O. (1928). Permeazoni d'Acqua e loro Effeti dynamischen Spannungserscheinungen, Sitzungber.

nei Muri di Ritenuta, Hoepli, Milan. Akad. Wiss. Wien, 132, 125±138.

Hubbert, M. K., & Rubey, W. W. (1959). Role of ¯uid Terzaghi, K.v. (1936). The shearing resistance of

pressure in mechanics of overthrust faulting, Bull. saturated soils and the angle between the planes of

Geol. Soc. Am., 70, 115±205. shear, First Int. Conf. Soil Mech. Foundn Engng,

Hubbert, M. K., & Rubey, W. W. (1960). Role of ¯uid Harvard University, I, 54±56.

78 LADE AND DE BOER

saturated concrete and rock, Proc. Am. Soc. Testing Yamamuro, J. A., & Lade, P. V. (1993). B-Value

Materials, 45, 777±801. measurements for granular materials at high con®ning

Walsh, J. B. (1965). The effect of cracks on compres- pressures, Geotech. Testing J., GTJODJ, 16, No. 2,

sibility of rock, J. Geophys. Res. 70, 381±389. 165±171.

Yamamuro, J. A. (1993). Instability and behavior of Zisman, W. A. (1933). Compressibility and anisotropy of

granular materials at high pressures, University of rocks at and near the earth's surface, Proc. Nat. Acad.

California, Los Angeles, California, PhD dissertation, Sci., 19, 666±679.