Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
OK
THE ROYAL ASIATIC SOCIETY.
1 " Dr. Biihler has found out tho key to tho Kashmirean era: it begins in tho
year of the Knliyug 25, or 307C n.c, when the Saptarshis are said to have gone
to heaven. The Kashmir often omit the hundreds in stating dates. Thus
pcoplo
tho year 24 (Kashmir era) in which Kalhana wrote his and which
lt&jatarangini,
corresponded with ?aka 1070, stands for A,221."?A tlieuamm, Nov. 20, 1875,
p. 675.
2 Since this was
written, General Cunningham's letter of tho 30th March,
1870, has appeared in the Athenecum (April 2i)th, 1876), from tho text of which
I extract the following These seem to establish the fact that the
passages.
optional omission of the liuudrcds was a common and well-understood rule so
as about " The
early the age of Asoka. passage in which the figures occur
runs as follows in tho Snhasarilm text:?
"
In 1858 I published, in my edition of Prinsep's Assays
on Indian Antiquities," a notice of the detached letters OT as
1 General
Cunningham was cognizant of the date nr = 83 as found on the
coins ot Heliocles, which he associated with the year n.c. 164, under the
assumption that he had detected the true initial date of the Bactrian era, which
" as beginning
he hud settled to his own satisfaction, in n.c. 24G."?Num. Chron.
n.r. vol. viii. 1808, p. 200; ns. vol. ix. 18G9, pp. 35, 230. See also Mr.
Vaux's note, N.C. 1876, vol. xv. p. 3.
4 BACTRIAN COINS AND INDIAN DATES.
Obv. Head of king to the right, with helmet ornamented with the
car and horn of a bull, so marked on the coins
peculiar
of Eucratides.
lie v. Apollo driving the horses of the Sun. Monogram No. 46a,
Prinsep's Essays.
1The woodcut here given was prepared for Mr. Vaux's article ou
original
this uuiquo coin of Plato, in the Numismatic Chronicle, vol. xv. p. 1.
2 Gen. o.s. 1843,p.
Cuuningluun, N.C. vol. viii. 175,and vol.ix. n.s. 1809,p. 175.
3 " The had small shields made of raw hides, and each bad two
Chabylians
javelins used lor hunting wolves. Brazen helmets protected their heads, aud
above these they wore the cars and horns of an ox fashioned in brass. They
had also crests on their helms." ? Herodotus vii. 76; Rawlinson, vol. iv.
p. 72; Xenophon Auab. v.
BACTRIAN COINS AND INDIAN DATES. 5
1Prof. Wilson's
Plates, in his Ariana Antiqua, arranged 35 years ago, and
of the will suflieo to place this con
altogether independently present argument,
trast before the reader. The Kadphises group extend from figs. 5 to 21 of plate x.
All thoso coins are bilingual, Greek and Semitic-Bactrian. The Kanerki series
commence with No. 15, plate xi., having nothing but Greek legends, either on
the obverse or on the reverse, and follow on continuously through plates xii.
xiii. and xiv. down to lig. 11. After that, the Greok characters become more or
less chaotic, till we reach No. 19.
BACTRIAN COINS ANI) INDIAN DATES. 7
Indo-Scythian Insciuttiqns.
f
Kanishka. Mahdrdja Kanishka. Samvat 9.
[Kanishka. Samvat 28.]
[ITuvishka. Samvat 33.]2
-jj IIuvishka. Mahdrdja Devaputua Huvishka. Hemanta, S. 39.
? Mahdrdja Rajatikaja Devaputua Huvishka. Grishma,
5.47.'
^ I
ITuvishka. S. 48.
| Mahdrdja Hemanta,
^ Vasudeva. Mahdrdja Rdjdtirdja Devaputua Vtisu(deva). Varsha, S. 44.
Mahdrdja Vdsudeva. Grishma, S. 83.
Mahdrdja Rdjatirdja, Shahi, Vdsudeva. Hemanta, S: 87.
Raja Vdsudeva. Varsha, S. 98.4
Indo-Scytiiian Inscriptions.
cities, and generally by the Greek cities of Asia, after tho time of Alexander, woro
lunar till the reformation of the Roman calendar of Crrsar (by inserting 07+23
= 90 cities of Asia, which
days in this year). After that reformation the Greek
had then become subject to the Roman Empire, gradually the Julian
adopted
year. But
although tliey
followed the Romans in computing by the solar Julian
year of 365d. 6h. instead of the lunar, yet they made no alteration in the season
at which their vear began = 0et. or in tho order of tho months."
(AIO2 Nov.),
?Clinton, Fast.'llell. vol. iii. pp. 202, 347.
1 Some will bo seen to have attached to the uso of tho contrasted
importance
terms for national months in olden time, as wo find Lctronue observing : " Dans
tons les exemplcs de doubles ou triples dates que nous offrent les
inscriptions
redigees en Grece, le mois qui est euonce le est toujours cehu dont
premier
fait usage la nation a laquellc appartient eclui qui parle."?Letronne, Inscriptions
de l'Egypte (Paris, 1852), 263.
2 p.
Assyrian Discoveries, oy George Smith, London, 1875, p. 380. From the
time of the Parthian conquest it that the tablets were dated according
appears
to the Parthian style. There has always been a doubt ns to the date of this
revolt, and consequently of the Parthian monarchy, as the classical authorities
have left no evidence as to the exact date of the rise of tho Parthian power. 1,
however, obtained three Parthian tablets from Babylon; two of them contained
double dates, oue of which, being found perfect, supplied the required evidence,
as it was dated according to the Seleucidan era, and according also to the Parthian
era, tho 14 lth year of tho Parthians being equal to tho 208th year of tho
Selcucid.T, thus making tho Parthian era to havo commenced ii.o. 218. This
" ....
dato is written: Month 23rd day 144th year, which is called tho 208th
year, Arsaces, King of kings."
Clinton, following Justin and Euscbius, etc., 260 n.c, Fasti Ilomnni, vol. ii. p.
243, and Fasti Ucllonici, vol. iii. p. 311; Moses Chorcncnsis, 261 or 252 n.c;
Suidas, 246 n.c
3 " surnamed Epiphnnes, son of Antiochus the king, . . .
Antiochus,
'reigned in tho 137th year of the kingdom of the Greeks."?Maccabees I. i. 10
" of the Scleucida*."?
?ii. 70, ct. seq. lu the 143rd year of tho kingdom
" . . in tho 145th year on tho 25th
Josephus, Ant. xii. 3. It came to pass
of that month which is by us called Chaslcu, and by the Macedonians Apelhus,
BACTRIAN COINS AND INDIAN DATES. 13
1 Records of the
" Gupta Dynasty (Triibner, 1876), p. 37.
It is in regard to the typical details, however, that the contrast between the
of Mauas and Ileraiis is most apparent. Matins has no coins with his own
Iiiecesamong the iufinite variety of his mint devices, nor has Azns, who imitates so
mst
many of his emblems. Butj in the Goudopharcs group, we meet again with
busts and uucovered heads, the hair being simply bound by a fillet, in which
arrangement of the head-dress Pakores, with his bushy curls, follows suit. But
the crucial typical test is furnished by the small figure of victory crowning the
horseman on the reverse, which is so special a characteristic of tho.Parthian
die illusi ration.
" or
Wc have frequent examples of Angels types of victory extending regal
fillets in the Bactrian series, but these figures constitute as a rule the niniu
device of the reverse, and are not subordinated into a corner, as in the Parthian
system. The first of the fillet iu direct connexion with the king's
appearance
head in the
Imperial scries, occurs on the coins of Arsaces XIV., Orodes (n.c.
64-37), where the crown is borne by an eagle (Lindsay, History of the Parthians,
Cork, 1862, pi. iii. fig. 2, pp. 146-170; Ttesor de Kumismatiquc, pi. Ixviii.
on the reverses of the
fig. 17); but copper coinage
this duly is already confided
v. fig. 2, p. 181).
to the winged figure of Victory (Lindsay, pi. Arsaces XV.,
Phrahates IV. (37 n.c-4 a.d.), continues the eagles for a time, but progresses
into iii. fig. 60; v. fig. 4, pp. 148,170 ; Tresor dcNumismatique,
single (Ibid., pi.
pi. Ixviii. fig. 18; pi. lxix. fi^. 6), and finally into double figures of Victory
as
eager to crown him (Jbid., pi. iii. figs. 61-63), indicating his successes against
Antony and the anucxatioii of the kiugdom of Media (Liudsay, p. 46 ; Rawliusou,
The S'ixth Monarchy, p. 182).
" arc discontinued, so that, if we are to
Henceforth these winged adjuncts
seek for the prototype of the Ileraiis coin amid Imperial Arsacidau models, we
are closely limited'in point of antiquity, though the possibly deferred adoption
"
may2 be less susceptible of proof
The period of Isidore of Charax has been the subject of much controversy.
The writer of the notice in Smith's Dictionary contents himself with saying, "lie
seems to have lived under Ihe early Roman Emperors." 0. Miiller, flic special
authority for all Creek geographical questions, sums up his critical examination
"
of the evidence to the point: Proliant scriptoreni nostrum August! temporibus
debere fuisse proximuui."?Geog. Grec. Min. vol. i. p. Ixxxv.
3 17. 'EvTivBtv 01 KO'? 'Eefla w6\h Tldpiv ical Kopbic ir6\is.
Zapayytavi), ox0
IS. 'Evt v$(v -SaKoaTOf^ Sajc&i' ~2.kvBu>v,tj Kai UapairaKrjpi), ox?^voi &Y' "sZvBa,
Bap5a ir6\n Ka\ M\v n6\ts ko\ Tla\aK t/T\ n6\is Ha) Ziyah iroAu* tvBa fiaalAda
^aKwv nal TrXrjaiov *AAc(c(^peia ir6\is
" (ko! irhrialov 'AA {aJ/5p<firoAis iroMs)'
Kwfiai Se ??. Isidore of Charax, Stuthmi Parthici," ed. C. Miiller, Paris,
pj). 253, lxxxv. aud xciii., map No. x. The text goes on to enumerate the
to and concludes : "Axp? rovrov
stages up Alcxandropolis wTp6noAis *Apox?<r/as,
iffrlv y r&v UapBuv imKpdrcia. I annex for the sake of
comparison Ptolemy's
list of the cities of Drangia, after the century and a half which is roughly esti
mated as the interval between the two geographers. seem
Sigal aud Sakastaue
BACTRIAN COINS AND INDIAN DATES. 17
pp. 301, 364; St.-Martin, L'Armeuie, vol. ii. p. 18. " l?_.._.?_-?_ Les villus
princip'tilcs sont: Zalek, Kcrkouyah, Ilissoum, Zaranj, et Jlosl, ou Ton voit k*3
mines do l'ccurie de itoustam, le Heros."?B. dc Movnard, La Perse, p. 303.
Other references to the geography of this locality will Co found in
Pliny vi. 21 ;
Ousehy's Oriental Geography, p. 205; Anderson's Western J.A.S.
Afghanistan,
Bengal, 1840, p. 586; Leech (S*kwa), J.A.S.B., 1844, p. 117; Khanikolf, 'Asie
Ceutralc,' Paris, 1861, p. 162 (S<!konhe); Ferrier's Travels, p. '130; Malcolm's
Persin, vol. i. p. 67; rottingcr's Bclooehistuu, pp. 407-9; Burnout's Ya<,na,
p. xcix.
x " This fortress is the
strongest and most important in Seist&n, because, being
at 5 parasangs from the lake, water is to be obtained
only in wells which \n\a
been dug within its encein'c. The intermediate aud surrounding country being
an arid parched waste, devoid not only of water, but of
everything else, the
besiegers could not subsist themselves, and would, even if provisioned, incutahly
dio of thirst. It contains about 1200 houses. . . . I have called it the capital
of Scisttm, but it is impossible to say how long it may
enjoy that title."?Caravan
Journeys of J. P. Ferrier, edited by II. D. Seymour, Esq., 1857, p. 419.
" Murray,
On the 1st February, 1872, made a 30 mile march to Sekulia, tlie more modern
of ScisUm . .; we found Sekuha itself amid utter desolation."?SirF.
capital finally
J. Goldsmid. From 11.Geog. Soc. 1873,p. 70. See also Sir II. Rawlinson's elaborate
"
notes on Scist&n, p. 282," Si-koheh [three hills], in the same volume. 1may add
in support of this reading of the name of the capital, that it very
nearly reproduces
the synonym of the obscure Greek 2tyd\, in the counterpart Pehlvi
ja^ja = _?-*->
8f gar or gal, which stands equally for " three hills." Tabari tells us that
in the old language, "gncr a lc sens do vol. i. p. 5),
montagne" (Zotenberg,
and Ilatnza Isfahfini equally recognizes the ger as " colles etmontcs"
(p. 37).
Tho interchange of the rs and la did not disturb the Iranian mind more
than tho indeterminate use of gs and ks. any
Seo Journ. R.A.S. Vol. XII. pp.
205, 268, and Vol. XIII. p. 377. Wo need not carry on these
comparisons
further, bat those who wish to traco identities more
completely may consult
Pictet, vol. i. p. 122, and follow out tho Sanskrit girt, Slave gora, etc. Siuce the
body of this note was set up in type, Sir F. Goldsmid's ollicial report upon
"Eastern Persia" has been published, aud supplies the following additional
VOL. IX.?fxEW SERIES.] 2
18 BACTRIAN COINS AND INDIAN DATES.
2AKA
KOIIANOT.
c. No. 63 ; Num. Cbron. vol. xix. o.s. Nos. 48, 62, and vol. viii.
Essays, pi. xi.
n\s. pi. vii. Nos. 71, 72, and 76; and likewise Mionnet's varieties, Nos. 156,
299 : Ariana Autiqua, pi. xxii. No. 118.
2 I am indebted to Mr. P. Gardner for this woodcut. I retaiu his description
of the coin as it appeared iu the Numismatic Chronicle, 1874, vol. xiv. n.s.
p. 161. It will be seen that Mr. Gardner failed to detect the worn outline of
the Monogram.
BACTRIAN COINS AND INDIAN DATES. 19