Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 24

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com

NOVEMBER 2010
KPI Report Sponsored By

www.spanlink.com
www.cisco.com
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

 
Introduction  
It  can’t  be  denied  that  social  networks  have  become  a  part  of  the  personal  and  
business  fabric  of  the  modern  world.    The  development  of  social  media  as  a  channel  
for  marketing,  sales  and  customer  care  purposes  is  well  underway.    However,  for  
most  organizations,  the  maturity  of  this  new  customer  outreach  medium  as  a  
business  resource  can  fairly  be  classified  as  being  in  its  infancy  stage.    It  can  also  be  
fairly  said  that  the  industry  is  rapidly  embracing  the  concept  of  utilizing  this  new  
channel  as  a  means  of  interacting  with  customers  and  that  some  organizations  have  
made  significant  strides  in  institutionalizing  the  tools  and  methodologies  involved  
that  comprise  their  social  media  strategies.  
     
On  Sept.  28,  2010  Chad  McDaniel,  President  of  In  The  Know  extended  an  invitation  
to  participate  in  an  on-­‐line  survey  considering  the  key  performance  indicators  and  
operationalization  of  social  media  response.    The  call  for  participation  went  out  to  
members  of  “Execs  In  The  Know”  and  “Worldwide  Contact  Center  Professionals”  on-­‐
line  communities  as  well  as  a  number  of  more  traditional  networks  of  industry  
experts.    The  strong  response  to  Chad’s  call  for  participation  is  a  testament  to  the  
importance  that  organizations  around  the  world  place  on  the  development  of  their  
social  media  strategy.    
 
In  reviewing  the  survey  responses  we  encountered  a  number  of  surprises,  
confirmed  many  long  held  industry  tenets  and  learned  a  great  deal.    We  look  
forward  to  the  discussion  and  calls-­‐to-­‐action  that  sharing  this  data  and  our  analysis  
will  generate.  
 
Best  Regards,  
 
Chad  McDaniel         Jeff  Bishop  
President,  In  The  Know       Founder,  Next  Move  Services  
P:  866-­‐991-­‐3555         P:  678.644.5494  
E:  mcdaniel@justcareers.com     E:  jbishop@nextmoveserv.com  
 
 
http://www.execsintheknow.com/     http://www.nextmoveserv.com/  
 

  1   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

 
Executive  Overview  
435  executives,  managers  and  staff  level  representatives  of  companies  considering  
social  media  as  a  key  component  of  their  customer  outreach  strategy  responded  to  
the  invitation  to  take  part  in  the  “KPI’s  For  Social  Media  Response”  survey.    
Participants  in  the  survey  varied  across  a  wide  spectrum  of  functional  areas,  market  
segments,  organization  sizes  and  geographic  locations.    Demographic  information  
on  survey  respondents  and  the  organizations  they  represent  can  be  found  in  
Questions  1  –  7  (below)  
 
The  Pointy  End  of  the  Spear:    
In  reviewing  the  data,  we  found  that  the  driving  force  behind  the  adoption  and  
development  of  social  media  for  business  purposes  in  most  organizations  are  
Marketing  and  Sales  leaders.    This  is  not  a  surprise,  as  these  functional  groups  have  
traditionally  constituted  the  early  warning  system  related  to  customer  preferences  
and  marketplace  change.    In  this  case,  Marketing  and  Sales  leaders  have  identified  
social  media  as  a  new  means  of  reaching  out  to  and  serving  customers.  
 
As  has  been  the  case  in  more  traditional  mediums  (e.g.,  phone,  email  and  chat)  
Customer  Service  and  Technical  Support  organizations  are  fast  followers  of  this  new  
social  media  trend.    These  groups  have  traditionally  been  responsible  for  
implementing  reactive  approaches  and  methodologies  in  managing  the  support  of  
existing  customers.    The  tipping  point  (institutionalization  of  a  medium)  typically  
comes  when  Sales,  Marketing  and  Customer  Care  organizations  have  all  embraced  a  
new  channel  and  begin  to  develop  standard  operating  procedures,  KPI’s  and  
consolidate  the  organization’s  approach  to  the  new  channel.  
 
Segmentation:    
When  considering  beginnings  of  social  media  and  the  consumer  centric  nature  of  
the  medium,  one  would  expect  that  this  channel  would  be  an  important  focus  area  
for  B2C  organizations.    The  survey  data  confirms  that  this  is  the  case.    However,  
participant  demographic  data  and  responses  to  survey  questions  also  indicate  that  
social  media  is  an  important  topic  and  area  of  strategic  focus  for  organizations  
characterized  as  B2B  (or  categorized  as  both  B2B  and  B2C)  across  a  variety  of  
market  segments  and  companies  of  all  sizes.    Companies  having  a  B2B  focus  actually  
represent  the  majority  of  survey  respondents.    
 
 

  2   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

 
Social  Media  Operations:    
In  reviewing  the  data,  we  were  surprised  to  find  that  the  majority  of  respondent  
organizations  utilize  highly  manual  and  low-­‐tech  automation/tool  sets  in  managing  
their  social  media  customer  interactions.    The  fact  that  only  a  small  percentage  of  
participating  organizations  have  operationalized  the  processes  for  customer  
outreach  and  that  a  relatively  small  percentage  of  companies  record  these  customer  
interactions  is  an  indication  of  an  area  of  need  across  the  industry.    We  believe  that  
this  represents  a  significant  opportunity  for  service  and  technology  providers  to  
develop  solutions  that  will  facilitate  the  maturation  of  social  media  customer  
response  strategies  for  their  clients.  
 
In  addition  to  the  lack  of  sophisticated  tools  and  processes,  it  was  found  that  no  
clear  industry  standards  exist  in  the  area  of  KPI  and  ROI  metrics.    We  believe  that  as  
the  medium  matures  and  becomes  a  mainstream  customer  outreach  channel,  
standards  will  be  developed  and  institutionalized.    This  also  presents  an  
opportunity  for  solutions  providers  to  assist  clients  in  the  development  of  standards  
and  expedite  the  adoption  of  the  medium.  
 
Insource  versus  Outsource:    
As  would  be  expected  in  the  evolution  of  a  new  customer  outreach  channel,  the  
majority  of  respondent  organizations  indicate  that  social  media  duties  are  being  
handled  by  a  relatively  small  numbers  of  staffers  (5  or  less  FTE’s).    The  survey  data  
also  reveals  that  most  of  the  labor  being  expended  in  the  management  of  customer  
interactions  via  social  media  comes  from  internal  company  resources  (insourced  
functions).    At  this  point,  a  very  small  percentage  of  the  headcount  focused  on  social  
media  activity  for  respondent  organizations  is  outsourced  to  BPO  firms.  
 
It’s  not  uncommon  for  new  types  of  customer  transactions  to  be  relegated  to  
internal  staff,  especially  at  the  earlier  stages  in  the  development  of  a  new  channel.    
This  is  certainly  the  case  in  the  evolution  of  social  media  as  a  customer  response  
channel.    Most  organizations  tend  to  relegate  outsourced  work  to  mature  offerings,  
proven  channels  and  standard  transactions  (i.e.,  commodity  transactions  using  
outsourcers  primarily  for  labor  arbitrage).    We  believe  that  this  represents  an  
opportunity  for  BPO  firms  to  differentiate  themselves  by  developing  social  media  
solutions  in  order  to  assist  client  organizations  in  building  processes,  tools  and  
strategies.        
 

  3   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

 
As  social  media  matures  as  a  means  for  customer  outreach,  we  anticipate  that  
volume  and  headcount  allocated  to  outsource  firms  will  increase  significantly.  
 
Conclusion  
In  reviewing  the  survey  data  and  considering  the  early  stage  of  development  of  the  
channel  as  a  business  resource,  we  believe  that  the  evolution  of  social  media  
response  represents  a  significant  opportunity  for  companies  looking  to  this  channel  
as  a  means  to  communicate  with  and  serve  customers.      Similarly,  we  believe  that  
the  evolution  of  social  media  response  represents  a  sizeable  opportunity  for  
solutions  and  technology  providers  to  develop  value  propositions  and  increase  their  
market  share  in  target  client  segments.  
 

  4   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

 
Survey  Response  Details  
 
Question Answers Skips

01 What is your level within your organization 437 4


99% 1%

0% 25.5% 51% COUNT PERCENT

Executive 219 50.11%

Management 187 42.79%

Staff 31 7.09%
 
Comment:  With  50%  of  survey  participants  being  classified  as  executive  level  and  
43%  being  classified  as  management,  it’s  clear  that  social  media  response  is  a  high  
focus  area  and,  in  many  cases,  a  strategic  initiative  for  the  organizations  that  
respondents  represent.  
 
  Question Answers Skips

02 What is your role wthin the organization? 438 3


99% 1%

0% 13.5% 27% COUNT PERCENT

Customer Service – Operations 114 26.03%

Marketing 96 21.92%

Other 76 17.35%

Sales 66 15.07%

HR 28 6.39%

Technical Support - Operations 24 5.48%

IT / IS 16 3.65%

Communications 13 2.97%

Public Relations 5 1.14%

Comment:  41%  of  respondents  represent  Mar-­‐com,  PR  and  Sales  functions.    Social  
media  is  clearly  an  area  of  focus  for  business  development  purposes  (re:  company  
visibility,  sales  channels  and  customer  acquisition).    With  over  31%  of  respondents  
coming  from  Customer  Services  or  Technical  Support  operations,  it’s  clear  that  this  
medium  is  also  viewed  as  a  means  for  serving  existing  customer  needs.  
   

  5   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips

03 How large is your organization in terms of revenue? 435 6


99% 1%

0% 19.5% 39% COUNT PERCENT

Under 25 million 167 38.39%

1 billion+ 92 21.15%

101 million - 1 billion 70 16.09%

26 – 50 million 55 12.64%

51 – 100 million 51 11.72%

Comment:  Based  on  the  level  of  participation  of  respondents  across  a  wide  
spectrum  of  company  sizes,  it’s  clear  that  social  media  is  viewed  as  a  key  area  of  
focus  for  companies  of  all  sizes.  
 

Question Answers Skips

04 What is the primary focus of your organization’s business? 435 6


99% 1%

0% 21.5% 43% COUNT PERCENT

Business to Business 183 42.07%

Both 164 37.7%

Business to Consumer 88 20.23%


 
Comment:  B2B  companies  represent  a  majority  of  respondent  organizations  (i.e.,  
42%  of  respondents  categorize  their  organization  as  B2B  and  38%  respondents  
indicate  that  their  firms  serve  both  B2B  and  B2C  customers).    This  is  an  indication  
that  social  media  is  not  solely  a  consumer-­‐centric  channel.    B2B  organizations  
clearly  view  social  media  as  a  means  to  engage  prospective  customers  and  as  a  
method  for  supporting  existing  customers.  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

  6   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips

05 What industry best represents your company? 438 3


99% 1%

0% 24.5% 45% COUNT PERCENT

Other 197 44.96%

Telecommunications 67 15.3%

Financial Services 45 10.27%

Healthcare, Pharmaceutical, Biotechnology 34 7.76%

Consumer Products 33 7.53%

Retail 16 3.65%

Travel & Hospitality 16 3.65%

Electronics 14 3.2%

Food & Beverage 9 2.05%

Transportation 7 1.6%

 
Comment:  The  diversity  of  survey  respondent  industries  indicates  widespread  
interest  in  social  media  across  a  number  of  diverse  market  segments.    In  analyzing  
the  “other”  category  selection,  we  found  that  the  majority  of  the  respondents  
selecting  this  answer  represent  B2B  organizations  (i.e.,  BPO,  software  and  other  
technology  solution  providers,  consulting  firms  and  other  business  service  providers).      

  Question Answers Skips

06 Where is your company headquartered? 435 6


99% 1%

0% 40.5% 81% COUNT PERCENT

US 352 80.92%

EMEA 30 6.9%

Canada 21 4.83%

Asia-Pacific 14 3.22%

Other 10 2.3%

Latin America / South America 8 1.84%


 
Comment:  The  majority  of  respondents  (over  85%)  are  based  in  North  America.    
However,  survey  participants  hail  from  a  number  of  locations  around  the  world.    
Our  conclusion  is  that  social  media  is  not  only  a  hot  topic  and  growing  channel  for  N.  
American  companies,  but  is  also  on  the  radar  of  organizations  worldwide.  
 

  7   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips

07 What regions do you have responsibility for? 437 4


99% 1%

0% 36.5% 73% COUNT PERCENT

US 315 72.08%

Other 55 12.59%

EMEA 22 5.03%

Canada 22 5.03%

Asia-Pacific 14 3.2%

Latin America / South America 9 2.06%

Comment:  As  identified  in  Question  6,  the  majority  of  survey  respondents  were  
North  American.    This  is  consistent  with  the  demographic  makeup  of  the  industry  
communities  and  networks  invited  to  participate  in  the  survey.    However,  it  should  
be  noted  that  in  many  N.  American  companies  Sales,  Marketing  and  Customer  Care  
leaders  based  in  the  U.S.  and  Canada  have  responsibility  for  nearshore  and  offshore  
locations  as  well  as  oversight  of  home  country  operations.    As  a  result,  we  expect  the  
strategies  and  standards  implemented  by  N.  American  organizations  to  significantly  
influence  the  development  of  global  social  media  response  strategies.    
 
Answers Skips
Question How recently has your company started a customer response strategy with
08 social media (i.e. responding to customer inquiries, etc. through social 439 2
media) 100% <1%

0% 20% 40% COUNT PERCENT

We have not started 173 39.41%

Within the last 3-12 months 111 25.28%

Last 13-24 months 82 18.68%

Within the last 90 days 37 8.43%

Greater than 24 months 36 8.2%


 
Comment:  With  over  64%  of  respondents’  companies  embarking  on  a  social  media  
strategy  in  the  last  12  months  or  less  (over  39%  having  not  initiated  a  strategy  at  
all),  this  is  clearly  an  emerging  channel  that  represents  significant  opportunity.    As  is  
typical  in  the  case  of  emerging  channels,  a  great  deal  of  “storming  and  norming”  can  
be  expected  before  standard  processes,  tools,  metrics  and  the  definition  of  social  
media  leadership  is  established.    This  represents  significant  opportunity  for    
organizations  across  all  market  segments  to  differentiate  themselves  and  carve  out  
 a  leadership  position.  

  8   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips


In your opinion, does your organization view social media as a: Check all
09 that apply
430 11
98% 2%

0% 27% 54% COUNT PERCENT

Opportunity 392 53.55%

Revenue Source 158 21.58%

Cost 99 13.52%

Threat 83 11.34%
 
Comment:  75%  of  survey  respondents  view  social  media  as  a  revenue  generating  
channel  or  source  of  opportunity.    A  small  number  of  participants  (25%)  see  this  
channel  as  a  threat  or  simply  as  another  cost  burden  to  their  organizations.    We  
believe  that  as  the  medium  matures  and  as  more  companies  embrace  social  media  
as  a  means  for  customer  outreach,  the  number  of  firms  who  see  this  channel  as  a  
burden  will  decrease.  
 
Answers Skips
Question Does your company view social media as a consumer Peer to Peer
10 community or as a formal channel with company resources assigned to 435 6
monitor, mitigate and respond? 99% 1%

0% 21.5% 43% COUNT PERCENT

Business to Business 183 42.07%

Both 164 37.7%

  Business to Consumer 88 20.23%


 
Comment:  80%  of  respondents  view  social  media  as  a  means  of  serving  business  
customers  or  both  business  customers  and  consumers  (42%  B2B  and  38%  both  B2B  
and  B2C),  with  only  20%  identifying  it  as  a  B2C  only  channel.    We  believe  that  this  is  
an  indicator  that  social  media  (which  started  primarily  as  a  medium  for  individuals  
to  “keep  in  touch”)  is  approaching  a  level  of  adoption  that  makes  it  a  significant  
business  forum  as  well  as  an  individual  communication  forum.  
 

  9   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips

11 Where does management of social media fit into your corporate 434 7
organization (who is responsible)? 98% 2%

0% 23.5% 47% COUNT PERCENT

Marketing 202 46.54%

Multi-divisional 72 16.59%

Customer Service 55 12.67%

Communications 41 9.45%

Public Relations 24 5.53%

Sales 19 4.38%

Technical Support 13 3%

HR 8 1.84%

Comment:  Mar-­‐com,  Sales  and  PR  functions  represent  66%  of  survey  participants,  
indicating  that  the  individuals  leading  the  charge  in  the  majority  of  respondent  
organizations  have  responsibility  for  business  development  and  company  
positioning  in  the  social  media  marketplace.    This  is  typical  of  new  mediums  and  
evolving  technologies  (i.e.,  Mar-­‐com  and  Sales  functions  leading  the  charge  in  
exploring  new  customer  outreach  channels  while  support  organizations  tend  to  be  
 
fast  followers  in  implementing  reactive  solutions  to  engage  customers  after  a  
 
channel  has  been  proven  as  a  preferred  means  of  customer  interaction).  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

  10   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips


Which of the following has your organization operationalized for
12 understanding where the conversation occurs or identifying relevant 418 23
comments to respond? 95% 5%

0% 29% 58% COUNT PERCENT

Manual search and discovery 242 57.89%

Free listening products 70 16.75%

Paid customized collection (you determine the sites)


and engagement platform
56 13.4%

Paid listening platform


(using providers data setavailable) 50 11.96%

Comment:  58%  percent  of  respondents  indicate  that  internal  processes  for  engaging  
customers  through  social  media  are  manual  in  nature  with  17%  indicating  that  their  
organizations  utilize  unsophisticated  (free)  automation  tools.    This  is  a  clear  
indicator  of  the  need  for  tools  designed  to  facilitate  customer  interaction  via  this  
channel  and  represents  opportunity  for  these  types  of  technology  solution  
providers.  
 
Question Answers Skips

13 Which of the following is your organization utilizing? Check all that apply 422 19
96% 4%

0% 15.5% 31% COUNT PERCENT

Alerts based on key words (i.e. your corporate name) 273 30.74%

Manual surfing of sites 248 27.93%

We act when Debbie in Marketing see something she


doesn’t like or an executive response is required as a
166 18.69%
result of complaints to “C” level executives, media
response, etc.

Bots or spiders to monitor a host of sites automatically 107 12.05%

CRM connection to sites 94 10.59%


 
Comment:  The  data  indicates  that  management  of  social  media  response  activity  is  
highly  manual  and,  in  instances  where  automation  exists,  the  tool  sets  and  processes  
utilized  are  fairly  low-­‐tech  in  nature.    As  noted  previously,  this  calls  out  the  need  for  
automation  and  represents  an  opportunity  for  the  providers  of  more  sophisticated  
solutions.  
 
 

  11   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips


How would you characterize your response to social media?
14 Check all that apply 428 13
97% 3%

0% 14% 28% COUNT PERCENT

Passive monitoring 248 27.43%

Proactive marketing and customer outreach


220 24.34%
using social networking

Overt response
174 19.25%
(you respond as an agent of the corporation)

Internal employee communication and feedback 121 13.38%

Mitigation (your endeavor to take it offline


with the complaint
95 10.51%

Stealth response (you respond but


not as an agent of the corporation)
46 5.09%

Comment:  54%  of  respondents  indicate  that  their  organizations  engage  in  pro-­‐
active  customer  engagement  via  social  media  channels  (i.e.,  proactive  marketing,  
overt  response  and  problem  mitigation).    In  addition,  13%  of  respondents  utilize  
social  media  channels  as  a  means  of  proactive  interaction  with  employees.    This  is  
an  indication  that  the  majority  of  respondent  organizations  (77%)  are  actively  
engaged  in  social  media  in  some  form  and  have  established  a  presence  on  behalf  of  
the  organization  in  these  forums.  
   
33%  of  respondents  indicate  that  their  organization’s  interactions  with  customers  
via  social  media  take  the  form  of  passive  or  stealth  monitoring.    While  this  
percentage  represents  a  significant  portion  of  respondents/participating  
companies,  we  believe  it  to  be  a  further  indicator  of  the  immaturity  of  social  media  
as  a  customer  interaction  medium  and  the  relative  earliness  in  the  evolution  of  
companies’  strategies  and  response  to  this  emerging  channel.  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

  12   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips


Which functional groups within your organization incorporate social media
15 into their customer outreach strategy? Check all that apply 416 25
94% 6%

0% 17.5% 35% COUNT PERCENT

Marketing 309 34.18%

Sales Organization 174 19.25%

Contact Center 167 18.47%

Public Relation 155 17.15%

Other 70 7.74%

PM (Crowd-sourcing) 29 3.21%

 
Comment:  As  noted  previously,  the  vast  majority  (74%)  of  respondent  
organizations’  social  media  efforts  are  being  led  by  Mar-­‐com,  Sales  and  PR  functions.    

Question Answers Skips

16 How large of a community have you built? 409 32


93% 7%

0% 30% 60% COUNT PERCENT

Under 1,000 followers 244 59.66%

1,000 - 10,000 followers 107 26.16%

Greater than 10,000 followers 58 14.18%

 
 
Comment:   The  majority  of  respondent  companies  have  yet  to  form  social  media  
communities  of  substantial  size.    This  is  further  evidence  of  the  fact  that  most  
organizations  are  at  a  relatively  early  stage  in  the  development  of  their  social  media  
response  strategies.    Given  the  vast  networks  and  communities  that  exist  and  the  
trend  toward  greater  use  of  social  media  across  the  population,  this  data  is  a  
testament  to  the  opportunity  for  further  growth  and  expansion  in  this  area.  
 

 
 
 
 

  13   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips


Are the same social network channels monitored and utilized for both
17 sales/marketing and customer care?
423 18
96% 4%

0% 29% 58% COUNT PERCENT

Yes 243 57.45%

Not Sure 96 22.7%

No 84 19.86%

Comment:  Over  57%  of  respondents  indicate  that  both  Sales/Marketing  and  
Customer  Care  utilize  social  media  channels.    This  is  further  evidence  of  the  fact  that  
Mar-­‐com  and  Sales  functions  tend  to  take  a  leadership  role  in  the  early  development  
of  customer  interaction  channels,  with  Customer  Care  organizations  following  this  
lead  as  specific  channels  come  to  represent  the  medium  of  choice  for  customers  to  
communicate  with  the  company.  
 
It  is  expected  that  for  the  foreseeable  future,  Sales  and  Marketing  organizations  will  
continue  to  lead  proactive  social  media  efforts  with  Customer  Care  organizations  
being  fast  followers     initiating  reactive  service  and  support  strategies  to  serve  
existing  
  customers.

Question Answers Skips


How many FTE’s within your organization are assigned
18 to social media response? 425 16
96% 4%

0% 22.5% 45% COUNT PERCENT

One to Two 191 44.94%

None 88 20.71%

Three to Five 75 17.65%

Greater then Ten 43 10.12%

Six to Ten 28 6.59%

 
Comment:  83%  of  respondents  indicate  social  media  response  staffing  of  5  or  less  
FTE’s  within  their  organizations.    This  is  further  evidence  of  the  early  stage  of  
development  of  the  channel  as  a  means  of  customer  outreach  and  speaks  to  the  
opportunity  for  organizations  to  differentiate  their  social  media  market  presence  by  
developing  a  comprehensive  customer  outreach  strategy.  
 
 

  14   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips

19 Are these FTE? 372 69


84% 16%

0% 39.5% 79% COUNT PERCENT

Shared resources 293 78.76%

Dedicated resources 79 21.24%

Comment:  The  fact  that  a  significant  majority  of  resources  applied  to  social  media  
response  are  shared  is  an  indication  of  the  lack  of  activity/volume  being  handled  by  
these  staffers  and  of  the  relative  early  stage  of  development  of  companies’  strategic  
planning  and  capabilities  in  this  area.  
 
  Answers Skips
Question

20 Are these FTE? 374 67


65% 15%

0% 25.5% 51% COUNT PERCENT

Insourced 304 81.28%

Both 51 13.64%

Outsourced 19 5.08%

Comment:  The  vast  majority  of  staff  assigned  to  social  media  customer  outreach  is  
internal  (81%  insourced).    This  is  not  a  surprise  given  the  stage  of  development  of  
this  channel  and  the  fact  that  most  organizations  tend  to  relegate  outsourced  work  
to  mature  offerings,  proven  channels  and  standard  transactions  (i.e.,  commodity  
transactions  using  outsourcers  primarily  for  labor  arbitrage).      
   
The  data  indicates  that  the  early  stage  of  development  of  social  media  represents  an  
opportunity  for  BPO  service  providers  to  create  value  added  solutions,  assist  clients  
in  developing  social  media  strategies  and  provide  tools  and  technology  capable  of  
assisting  clients  in  operationalizing  the  channel.    We  believe  that  BPO  providers  who  
are  able  to  build  upon  this  opportunity  will  be  well  positioned  to  drive  growth  in  
this  space  and  capture  additional  business  as  the  segment  matures  and  volume  
increases.  
 
 
 
 

  15   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips


Do you record and monitor the interactions of company
21 representatives and customers via social networks? 429 12
97% 3%

0% 21.5% 43% COUNT PERCENT

No 184 42.89%

Yes 156 36.36%


  Not Sure 89 20.75%
 
Comment:  Documentation  and  recording  of  customer  interactions  is  a  basic  
component  (standard  operating  function)  of  most  customer  response  channels.    The  
fact  that  only  36%  of  respondent  organizations  record  social  media  interactions  
with  customers  represents  a  significant  risk  to  these  businesses  and  an  opportunity  
for  service  providers  and  tools/technology  developers  to  facilitate  this  effort  for  
client  companies.  
 

Question Answers Skips


Please tell us about the method of recording social network contacts?
22 Check all that apply
344 97
78% 22%

0% 13% 26% COUNT PERCENT

Marketing contract tracking system 128 25.35%

Web log 101 20%

Other 94 18.61%

CRM ticketing system 94 18.61%

Knowledge base system 88 17.43%

 
Comment:  The  lack  of  consistent  tools  and  repository  of  social  media  transactions  
(customer  interaction  records)  across  the  respondent  population  is  further  
evidence  of  the  opportunity  for  tools/technology  developers  and  service  providers  
to  offer  value  to  potential  clients  and  capture  market  share.    As  the  channel  matures,  
we  expect  to  see  social  media  interaction  tracking  added  to  CRM  and  Knowledge  
Base  systems  capabilities  as  a  standard  function  of  these  types  of  systems.  
 
 
 
 

  16   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips


What ROI parameters have you established to measure social media
23 response? Check all tha apply
369 72
84% 16%

0% 8% 16% COUNT PERCENT

Response Time 143 15.59%

Resolution rate (problems solved,


127 13.85%
questions answered etc.)

Active Subscribers (% of subscriber


120 13.09%
base who actively participates/respond)

Referral Rate 105 11.45%

Impression/view rate - (% of
impressions/views/contract for each medium) 100 10.91%

Subscriber Churn/Loyalty 78 8.51%

Community Involvement (% of inquiries handled by


the community of consumers, end users vs. traditional 73 7.96%
sales/support)

C-Sat (similar to traditional call center C-Sat


70 7.63%
and Net Promoter survey)

Other - please describe 62 6.76%

Rev/Attach Rates (sell through rate, revenue


per contact, etc.) 30 4.25%

Comment:  The  lack  of  standard  metrics  and  SLA’s  across  the  respondent  population  
is  further  indication  of  the  lack  of  maturity  of  this  channel.    It  is  expected  that  
standard  metrics  will  evolve  over  time  as  they  have  for  other  customer  interaction  
channels  such  as  phone,  chat  and  email.  
   
Despite  the  fact  that  Customer  Satisfaction  is  reflected  as  a  lower  %  choice  as  a  key  
indicator,  it  is  expected  that  as  the  channel  matures  standard  mechanisms  for  
measuring  and  reporting  the  level  of  positive  impressions/customer  satisfaction  
will  evolve.    Our  view  is  that  response  time,  time  to  resolution  and  various  
sales/attach  rate  metrics,  as  well  as  measurement  of  community  involvement  will  
be  key  to  future  measurement  of  the  success  of  companies’  social  media  
 performance.  
 
 
 
 
 
 

  17   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers
Based on the previous question, what do you see as the top two most
24 important/effective key performance indicators (KPI’s)? 356

0% 8.5% 17% COUNT PERCENT

Resolution Rate 59 16.57%

Referals/Lead Generation 53 14.89%

Response Time 45 12.64%

Subscriber Community Size 41 11.52%

Revenue Generation/Conversion Rate 37 10.39%

Impression/Contact Rate 34 9.55%

Customer Satisfaction 32 8.99%

Customer Loyalty/Churn 28 7.87%

Subscriber/Community Involvement 27 7.58%

Comment:  
Respondent  identification  of  top  KPI’s  varied  dramatically,  with  resolution  rate  and  
referral/lead  generation  being  the  leading  answers  by  a  relatively  small  margin.    As  
in  the  case  of  question  23,  the  varied  responses  to  question  24  (i.e.,  “what  do  you  see  
as  the  top  two  KPI’s?”)  are  an  indication  that  standard  industry  KPI’s  have  yet  to  be  
established  for  social  media  channels.  
 
However,  in  reviewing  respondent  suggested  metrics,  we  identified  a  trend  that  
appears  to  align  with  the  type  of  organization  and  functional  responsibility  that  
respondents  represented.    In  the  case  of  Sales  oriented  respondents:  referrals/lead  
generation,  customer  churn,  revenue  and  sales  attach  rate  were  selected  as  the  
primary  KPI’s  for  social  media.    In  the  case  of  Marketing  and  PR  functional  
respondents:  impression,  community  size  and  active  involvement  of  community  
members  were  selected  as  the  primary  performance  indicators.    Customer  Care  and  
Technical  Support  respondents  tended  to  select:  response  time,  resolution  rate  and  
customer  satisfaction  as  key  metrics.      
 
As  in  the  case  of  traditional  sales,  marketing  and  customer  care  channels;  we  believe  
that  each  of  these  metrics  holds  value  to  organizations  in  measuring  performance  
and  results  of  various  social  media  initiatives.    We  expect  specific  KPI’s  to  vary  
depending  on  the  strategic  and  tactical  goals  of  each  organization,  but  adhere  to  the    
 

  18   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

belief  that  the  evolution  of  the  social  media  as  a  customer  response  channel  will  
require  that  some  number  of  industry  standards  for  measuring  results  be  
established.    This  (establishing  of  standard  KPI’s)  will  be  a  significant  factor  for  BPO  
organizations  as  volume  increases  and  companies  begin  to  consider  the  value  
proposition  (ROI)  involved  in  outsourcing  the  handling  of  these  transactions  to  
service  providers  (companies  that  outsource  transactions  traditionally  utilize  KPI  
metric  goal  setting  and  on-­‐going  performance  measurement  of  vendor  results  to  
gauge  the  success  of  their  outsourcing  strategy).  
 
 
Question Answers Skips
What languages are you currently engaged in social networks?
25 Check all that Apply 415 26
94% 6%

0% 39.5% 79% COUNT PERCENT

English 408 78.46%

Spanish 43 8.27%

French/Canadian 27 5.19%

Other 25 4.81%

German 17 3.27%

 
Comment:  English  clearly  represents  the  lion’s  share  of  languages  currently  
supported  (over  78%)  with  Spanish  and  French  Canadian  representing  the  next  two  
largest  languages  selected  by  respondents.    We  believe  this  is  related  to  the  North  
American  centric  nature  of  the  respondent  population,  but  is  also  an  indicator  that  
the  growth  of  social  media  as  a  customer  outreach  channel  is  likely  to  be  driven  by  
N.  America  and  English  speaking  European  based  organizations  as  has  been  the  case  
with  more  traditional  channels  such  as  phone,  email  and  chat.  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

  19   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips


In terms of degree of difficulty in dealing with social networks rank the
26 following regions (1,2,3,4 or N/A) 376 65
85% 15%

0% 28.5% 57% COUNT PERCENT

N/A 212 56.38%

Region 1 - North America 123 32.71%

Region 4 - Asia Pacific 18 4.79%

Region 3 - EMEA 13 3.46%

Region 2 - South America 10 2.66%

 
Comment:  While  it  is  to  be  expected  that  English  language  support  will  represent  
the  majority  of  social  media  customer  interactions  in  the  near  term,  our  view  is  that  
challenges  encountered  in  supporting  other  languages  and  non-­‐English  speaking  
geographies  will  follow  the  general  trends  found  in  traditional  channels  when  
expanding  customer  outreach  programs  to  global  customers.    Most  companies  have  
developed  capabilities  that  facilitate  interaction  with  customers  in  the  native  
language  of  the  customer  base  via  phone,  email  and  chat.    The  fact  that  the  majority  
of  respondents  (56%)  selected  “N/A”  when  considering  degree  of  difficulty  in  
supporting  social  media  channels  is  an  indication  that  language  is  not  a  barrier  to  
advancing  social  media  response  strategies.    

  20   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

Question Answers Skips

27 What social networks does your organization monitor or utilize in proactive 401 40
customer outreach? Check all that apply 91% 9%

0% 11% 22% COUNT PERCENT

Facebook 308 21.6%

Twitter 292 20.48%

Blogs 231 16.2%

YouTube 176 12.34%

Captive Forums (forum administered by your staff) 103 7.22%

Other 96 6.73%

Non-captive Forums (forum not administered by your staff) 96 6.73%

Text/SMS 65 4.56%

MySpace 59 4.14%

Comment:  As  expected,  the  three  leading  forums  (Facebook,  Twitter  and  YouTube)  
represent  the  majority  of  social  media  channel  interactions  that  respondent  
companies  are  currently  utilizing  to  engage  customers  (over  54%).    However,  it  is  
interesting  that  other  forums  (Blogs,  Captive  forums,  Text/SMS,  etc.)  represent  a  
significant  portion  of  the  forums  that  organizations  utilize  for  customer  outreach  
(over  45%).    We  believe  this  to  be  an  indication  of  the  continuing  evolution  of  social  
media  as  a  customer  response  channel  as  well  as  the  fact  that  the  forums  of  choice  
will  continue  to  change  over  time.    In  order  to  be  competitive  and  to  meet  the  needs  
of  customers,  companies  intending  to  utilize  these  types  of  forums  will  be  required  
to  continue  to  monitor  trends  and  evolve  their  approach  in  order  to  remain  relevant  
and  provide  contact  options  that  align  with  customer  preferences.  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

  21   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

 
Question Answers Skips
What is holding your organization back from effectively dealing with social
28 networks? 398 43
90% 10%

0% 31% 62% COUNT PERCENT

The organization is still evaluating the impact


of social networks on the business 245 61.56%

functional separation of responsibilities 53 13.32%

Executive views social networks as a distraction 40 10.05%

Inability to secure budget 38 9.55%

Do not know how to proceed 22 5.53%

 
Comment:  The  fact  that  67%  of  respondents  are  in  evaluation  mode  or  don’t  know  
how  to  respond  to  the  social  media  phenomenon,  combined  with  disjointed  
ownership  of  respondent  company  strategies  (13%)  is  a  further  indicator  of  the  
relative  immaturity  of  these  customer  outreach  channels.    As  noted  earlier,  the  early  
stage  of  the  segment’s  maturity  represents  significant  opportunity  for  organizations  
providing  technology,  tools  and  services  that  will  facilitate  further  development  of  
the  channels.  
 

Question Answers Skips

29 Would you participate in a multi social network vendor consortium? 413 28


94% 6%

0% 30% 60% COUNT PERCENT

Yes 247 59.81%

No 166 40.19%

Comment:  60%  of  respondents  indicate  a  desire  to  participate  in  some  form  of  
social  media  consortium.    This  bears  further  discussion  and  evaluation  as  to  what  
types  of  consortiums,  industry  associations,  conferences,  knowledge  sharing  
forums,  etc.  would  best  serve  this  interested  constituency.  
 

  22   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential
 

KPI’s For Social Media Response

 
Summary  
As  indicated  previously,  we  believe  that  the  industry  is  currently  at  a  very  early  
stage  of  development  in  the  area  of  social  media  response.    We  find  the  tools,  
processes,  metrics  and  standards  required  to  establish  this  medium  as  a  mature  
component  of  most  companies’  customer  outreach  strategies  to  be  sorely  lacking.    
We  feel  that  this  gap  represents  a  significant  opportunity  for  technology  and  
solutions  providers  to  differentiate  their  firms  by  developing  the  required  
technology  and  service  delivery  capabilities  on  behalf  of  clients.  
 
We  also  agree  with  the  60%  of  respondents  to  Question  29  who  indicate  a  desire  to  
participate  in  an  industry  consortium  on  this  topic  and  recommend  the  
establishment  of  this  type  of  consortium  with  working  groups  (sub-­‐teams)  focused  
on  specific  areas  of  interest  and  tasked  with  creating  industry  standards  and  
providing  guidance  to  technology  and  solutions  developers.  
 
 
 
 
 
 
Download  this  report  @:  
http://www.customerresponsesummit.com/survey_intro.php

  23   Next Move Services, LLC


www.nextmoveserv.com
 
  Proprietary & Confidential

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi