Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
EXjj`dKXc\YËj)''.
Y\jk$j\cc\ife`dgifYXYc\\m\ekj
cffbjgi\jZ`\ekkfXNXccJki\\k
YXkk\i\[YpjlYgi`d\%Efn\m\e
E8J8nXekjkfg`Zbk_\]fid\i
kiX[\iËjYiX`e]fik`gj
feiXe[fde\jj%
3YVTUa
\SaUR
/YNPX
dN[ By STEPHANIE BAKER-SAID
Photograph by BRAD TRENT
<[NS_RRgV[TQNfY^=QbSX" '>QccY]DQ\URgQ\[UTY^d_
QS_^VUbU^SUb__]Qd=_bWQ^CdQ^\Uiºc=Q^XQddQ^_èSUc_^$'dXCdbUUd
Q^T2b_QTgQid_QTTbUccQWb_e`_VdXUÂb]ºcbYc[]Q^QWUbc8Yc]UccQWU*
I_eb]_TU\cT_^ºdg_b[
EcY^WQgXYdUR_QbTd_cSbYRR\U_edXYcSQ\Se\QdY_^cDQ\UR^_g$(
RUWQ^_^U_VXYcbQ^dcdXYcdY]UQWQY^cdcdbUccdUcdc¶GQ\\CdbUUd\Y^W_
V_bUhQ]Y^Y^WX_gQ]Qb[Udb_edgY\\`\Qi_edCdbUccdUcdcQbUY^XUbU^d\i
bYc[iRUSQecUdXUiYW^_bUbQbURed`_dU^dYQ\\iTUfQcdQdY^WUfU^dc !((RY\\Y_^g_bdX_VgbYdUT_g^cDXU
DQ\URcQYT R__[ºc]UccQWU_çUbUTc_]UdXY^W_VQ
·@QcdcX_bdVQ\\T_Uc^ºd`bUTYSdVedebUcX_bdVQ\\¸dXU_`dY_^cdbQTUb `bUfYUg_VdXUSbYcYc*dXQdgUºbUQ\\R\Y^T
deb^UTRUcdcU\\Y^WQedX_bbUSQ\\cdU\\Y^WdXUQccU]R\UTWb_e`_VQR_ed d_bQbUUfU^dcQ^Tb_edY^U\iV__\_eb
$ DXUbYc[]Q^QWUbc`Qbd_VQdbYRU_V]QdXU]QdYSQ\]_TU\]Q[Ubc cU\fUcY^d_RU\YUfY^WgUSQ^`bUTYSdbYc[c
[^_g^Y^dXUÂ^Q^SUg_b\TQcaeQ^dccdQbUTRQS[QdXY]R\Q^[\iQ^TQ Q^TbUgQbTc
TURQdUU^ceUTQSS_bTY^Wd_`U_`\UgX_gUbUdXUbU DQ\URQbWeUcdXQdXYcd_biYc\YddUbUT
?^\icYh]_^dXc\QdUb=_bWQ^CdQ^\UiUh`UbYU^SUTYdc_g^b_ed gYdXXYWXY]`QSdbQbUUfU^dc[^_g^Y^
DXUg_b\TºccUS_^TRYWWUcd]UbWUbcQTfYcUbQ^^_e^SUTY^4USU]RUb aeQ^dc`UQ[QcZUhhU]`gV_bdXUYbcXQ`U
dXQdYdXQTgbYddU^T_g^YdcceR`bY]UbU\QdUTX_\TY^WcRi)$RY\\Y_^ gXU^`\_ddUT_^QRU\\SebfU8USYdUcdXU
QVdUbdXUÂb]ºcdbQTUbc]YcZeTWUTX_gVQcdQ^TVQb`bYSUc_VdXUTURd <QdY^1]UbYSQ^TURdSbYcYc_V!)("dXU
g_e\TVQ\\DXUYbbYc[]Q^QWU]U^dXQTVQY\UT S_\\Q`cU_VXUTWUVe^TÂb]<_^WDUb]
Taleb’s literary DXU<URQ^UcUR_b^DQ\URQRQ\TY^W]Q^gX_\QRU\cXY]cU\VQ`XY\_c 3Q`YdQ\=Q^QWU]U^d<@Y^!))(Q^TdXU
success yielded _`XUb_VbQ^T_]^UccXQcQ^UUbYU[^QS[V_bdY]Y^WdXY^WcbYWXd8Yc SbQcX_VdXUECcd_S[]Qb[UdY^?Sd_RUb
a multimillion- ]_cdbUSU^dR__[H\Y6`UW_GkUb.H\Y=adUWhcZh\Y<][\`m=adfcVUV`Y !)('d_^Q]UQVUg
dollar advance
on the book he’s BQ^T_]8_ecUSQ]U_edY^=Qi" 'Zecd]_^dXcRUV_bUdXUceR 1cdXUV_e^TUbQ^T]Q^QWUb_V>Ug
now writing. `bY]UÂQcS_b_S[UTW\_RQ\]Qb[UdcQ^T\UTRQ^[cd_Q^^_e^SUQd\UQcd I_b[µRQcUT5]`YbYSQ<<3QXUTWUVe^T
Âb]XUbQ^V_bcYhiUQbce^dY\XUS\_cUTYd
Y^" $DQ\URReY\dQ^Y^fUcd]U^dcdbQd
UWiRQcUT_^_`dY_^cdbQTY^W9dgQc
TUcYW^UTd_Re\\Ud`b__VY^fUcd_bcQWQY^cd
R\_ge`cgXY\U`b_ÂdY^WVb_]bQbUUfU^dc
8Yc" iUQbdbQTY^WSQbUUbXQcRUU^
]Qb[UTRiZQS[`_dc\Y[UgXU^XU\eS[UT
_edY^dbQTY^W_`dY_^cTebY^WdXUcd_S[
]Qb[UdSbQcX_V!)('V_\\_gUTRi\_^W
Tbic`U\\c·9Vi_e\_cU]_^Ui_^QcdUQTi
RQcYcQ^TdXU^]Q[U]_^UiY^Q\e]`i
gQi`U_`\UdXY^[i_eºbUSbQji¸XUcQic
GXY\UDQ\URXQccdU``UTRQS[Vb_]
UfUbiTQidbQTY^WXUbU]QY^cQ^QTfYcUb
d_CQ^dQ=_^YSQ3Q\YV_b^YQµRQcUTXUTWU
Ve^TÂb]E^YfUbcQ9^fUcd]U^dc<@9d
_`U^UTYdcT__bc\QcdiUQbe^TUbdXUTYbUS
dY_^_V=Qb[C`Ydj^QWU\#&DQ\URºcV_b
]UbdbQTY^W`Qbd^UbQd5]`YbYSQE^YfUbcQ
LES JORGENSEN
XQcQc_SQ\\UT2\QS[CgQ^@b_dUSdY_^
@b_d_S_\]Q^QWUTRi@Q\\_`1^Wce`e^
QV_b]UbDQ\URcdeTU^dgX_ºcXUTWY^W
40
BLOOMBERG MARKETS MAY 2008
b_eWX\i!RY\\Y_^_VS\YU^dY^fUcd]U^dc
QWQY^cdSUbdQY^UfU^dcdXQdSQ^SQecU]Qb =8LCKPGI<D@J<J
[UdTUS\Y^UcDXUÂb]XQcQ^_dXUb# K_\]fccfn`e^Xi\Xdfe^k_\i`jb$dXeX^\d\ek
]XccXZ`\jKXc\YjXpjZXec\X[kf\iifij%
]Y\\Y_^`_dRUddY^W_^\QbWU`_cYdYfU
Ze]`cY^Y^TYfYTeQ\cd_S[cQ^TYcbUQTiY^W =8CC8:PF=¿
QcY]Y\QbdXYbTVe^TcUfUbQ\dY]UcdXQd
cYjUQ`Ubc_^VQ]Y\YQbgYdXdXUVe^TccQic E8II8K@M@KP
·>QccY]Q^T9cXQbUdXYcWU^UdYSÃQg¸ G\fgc\_\[^\]fin_XkÈdXb\jj\ej\É
IP
cQicC`Ydj^QWU\Q_^UdY]U3XYSQW_`Yd \m\ek_fl^_k_`e^jk_Xk_Xgg\e\[`ek_\
?@JKF
dbQTUbgX_gQcQcdeTU^d_VDQ\URºcQd gXjkiXi\cpdX[\j\ej\Xkk_\k`d\%
>UgI_b[E^YfUbcYdi·GUºbU^_dY^dUbUcd
UTY^dXUc]Q\\VbUaeU^d`Qi_edcGUgQ^d
dXUY^VbUaeU^dXeWU`Qi_edc¸ J@E>C<$<M<EKGIF989@C@KP
A
@kËjXj\m\i\\iifikfcffbXkXj`e^c\gifYXY`c`kp
f]Xj`e^c\\m\ek#c`b\Xjb`e^ÈN_Xk`jk_\
Q\URXQcW_^UVb_]RUY^W gifYXY`c`kpf]nXi6É
Q\UQTY^WGQ\\CdbUUdXUbU
dYS¶XUbQY\cQWQY^cdUS_^
_]YcdcQ^TaeQ^dYdQdYfU CFNMFC8K@C@KP
]_TU\]Q[Ubc¶d_Q]Y^Y G\fgc\d`jkXb\cfnmfcXk`c`kp]ficfni`jb%
Y^cdYdedY_^gX_cUQ``UQ\ 9Xeb`e^`jc\jjmfcXk`c\YlkmXjkcpdfi\
[Xe^\ifljk_Xem\ekli\ZXg`kXc%
bUQSXUcgU\\RUi_^TdXUbUQ\]_VÂ^Q^SU
=_bUdXQ^#' S_`YUc_VH\Y6`UW_
GkUbQbUY^`bY^dY^dXUECQ^TdXUE;9d
K?<9C@E;=FC;<;
c`U^d!'gUU[c_^dXUBYkMcf_H]aYgRUcd Dfjkg\fgc\kXb\i`jbjY\ZXlj\k_\p[feËk
cU\\Ub\YcdQ^TYcRUY^WdbQ^c\QdUTY^d_"' befnXYflkk_\d%@kËjc`b\Zifjj`e^k_\
\Q^WeQWUc9dUfU^_edbQ^[c1\Q^7bUU^ jki\\kYc`e[]fc[\[%
c`Q^ºc]U]_YbcH\Y5[YcZHifVi`YbWY.
5XjYbhifYg]bUBYkKcf`X@U^WeY^" '
Q]_^W" 'RUcdcU\\Ubc_^1]Qj_^S_] JKI<JJK<JK@E>
DXUceSSUcc_VH\Y6`UW_GkUbXQc\UTd_ :;F Jki\jjk\jk`e^`j[Xe^\iflj#Xj\m\ekjefk
Zfm\i\[Ypk_\k\jkn`ccY\`^efi\[%
Q$]Y\\Y_^QTfQ^SUV_bdXU5^W\YcX\Q^ 888 K
WeQWUbYWXdcd_QV_\\_ge`R__[QSS_bTY^W JUN
d_Q`Ubc_^VQ]Y\YQbgYdXdXUTUQ\9dºcdU^ Source: Nassim Taleb
dQdYfU\idYd\UTH]b_Yf]b[Q^TgY\\UhQ]Y^U
X_gd_\YfUY^Qg_b\TgUT_^ºde^TUbcdQ^T
DQ\UR^_gSXQbWUc]_bUdXQ^& cQii_eXQfU^ºdbUQTYd_bi_ebUQTYdRedi_eºbU^_dW_Y^Wd_T_Q^i
V_bc_]U_VXYc\USdebUcQSS_bTY^Wd_dXU dXY^WY^bUc`_^cUY^QdbQTY^W_bbYc[]Q^QWU]U^db_\U¸cQic2b_g^
<_^T_^C`UQ[Ub2ebUQeQÂb]dXQd`\QSUc QV_b]Ub=_bWQ^CdQ^\UibYc[]Q^QWUbgX_SQ\\cDQ\URQVbYU^TgXY\U
RecY^Ucc`_\YdYSQ\Q^T]_dYfQdY_^Q\c`UQ[ TYcQWbUUY^WgYdXXY]dXQdRQ^[cºbYc[]_TU\cQbUecU\Ucc
Ubc8UgQb^cQeTYU^SUcQWQY^cdRU\YUfY^W >_gUfUbiR_TigQ^dcd_dQ\[QR_ed·R\QS[cgQ^c¸dX_cUXYWX\i
g_bcdSQcUcSU^QbY_cQ^T]Q[Y^Wc_SQ\\UT Y]`b_RQR\UUfU^dcdXQdSQ^SQecUXQf_SDXU>QdY_^Q\1Ub_^QedYScQ^T
^Q[UT_be^XUTWUTRUdc_^dXUVedebUdXQd C`QSU1T]Y^YcdbQdY_^ºc<Q^W\UiBUcUQbSX3U^dUbY^8Q]`d_^FYbWY^YQ
S_e\T\UQTd_TYcQcdb_ec\_ccUc XQcY^fYdUTDQ\URd_dQ\[QR_edX_gd_YTU^dYVidUSX^_\_WiR\QS[cgQ^cQc
DXU]UccQWU_VH\Y6`UW_GkUb¶ Yd`bU`QbUcd_cU^TXe]Q^cRQS[d_dXU]__^Q^TRUi_^TDXUEC6YbU
gX_cUdYd\UTUcSbYRUcQRYbT_^SUdX_eWXd 1T]Y^YcdbQdY_^`Qbd_VdXU4U`Qbd]U^d_V8_]U\Q^TCUSebYdigQ^dc
^_dd_UhYcde^dY\YdgQcV_e^TY^1ecdbQ XY]d_QTTbUcc" UhUSedYfUÂbU_èSUbcd_dQ\[QR_eddXU`b_RQRY\Ydi
\YQY^dXU!'dXSU^debi¶XQc`U^UdbQdUT TYcdbYRedY_^_VV_bUcdÂbUc8UºcWYfU^dQ\[cQR_edbYc[]_TU\cV_bdXU
GQ\\CdbUUddbQTY^Wb__]ccQic1Qb_^ EC4U`Qbd]U^d_V4UVU^cUgXUbUXUºcQ]U]RUb_VdXU8YWX\Q^Tc
2b_g^QbYc[]Q^QWUbQd7bUU^gYSX 6_be]Q@U^dQW_^c`_^c_bUTcdeTiWb_e`_^bYc[
3_^^USdYSedµRQcUT1AB3Q`YdQ\=Q^ DQ\URYc^_cUSebYdiUh`Ubd^_bT_UcXUS\QY]Q^ic`USYQ\[^_g\UTWU_V
QWU]U^d<<3gXYSX]Q^QWUcQR_ed(& c`QSUdUSX^_\_Wi9^cdUQTdXUcUWb_e`cgQ^dd_XUQbXY]dQ\[QR_edX_g
RY\\Y_^Y^XUTWUVe^TQccUdc·I_eSQ^ºd d_Q``\iXYcYTUQc_^SXQ^SUQ^TTUSYcY_^]Q[Y^Wd_dXUYbc`USYÂSÂU\Tc
41
MAY 2008 BLOOMBERG MARKETS
?^UTQi\Qcd4USU]RUbDQ\URcd__TRUV_bU# d_`UhUSedYfUcVb_] <_^T_^gXUbUXUºcS_^TeSdY^WbUcUQbSX
C_SY}d}7}^}bQ\UC16bQ^SUºccUS_^TRYWWUcdRQ^[DXUUhUSedYfUc gYdXQS_\\UQWeU
Y^S\eTY^W3XQYb]Q^4Q^YU\2_ed_^XQTWQdXUbUTQd@bQWeUºcÂfUcdQb 9dºc]eSXdXUcQ]U]UccQWUXUTU\Yf
8_dU\1bYQgXUbUUQSXb__]YcTUTYSQdUTd_QVQ]_ec]ecYSYQ^V_b UbcY^]_bUV_b]Q\cUddY^Wc?^UTQi\Qcd
QS_^VUbU^SU_bWQ^YjUTRi@QbYcRQcUTRecY^UcccSX__\5C3@51@ :e^UDQ\URWUdce`Y^Vb_^d_VQR_ed$
DXU`b_\YVUbQdY_^_VRQ^[]UbWUbcXQcbUce\dUTY^VUgUbRQ^[cQ^TQ `U_`\UQd=Y\\Ubºc1SQTU]iQGUcd<_^
WbUQdUbS_^SU^dbQdY_^_VbYc[cDQ\URgQb^UTQSS_bTY^Wd_Q`Ubc_^gX_ T_^\USdebUc_SYUdid_dQ\[QR_edR\QS[
QddU^TUTDXU`b_RQRY\Ydi_VQTUfQcdQdY^WRQ^[Y^W\_ccXQcY^SbUQcUT cgQ^cCebb_e^TUTRiQ^dYaeUcQ^TQÂcX
bQdXUbdXQ^TUSbUQcUTXUcQYTDXUbUc`_^cUgQc]edUTQ^TQddU^TUUc dQ^[cdeçUTgYdXTUQT_g\cXURUWY^cXYc
gQ\[UT_edgYdXS_`YUc_VH\Y6`UW_GkUbdXU`Ubc_^cQYT dbQTU]Qb[QddQS[_^7QeccYQ^cdQdYcdYSc
1R_edcYhgUU[c\QdUbC_S7U^bUfUQ\UTdXURYWWUcddbQTY^W\_ccY^ ^Q]UTQVdUb!)dXSU^debi7Ub]Q^]QdX
RQ^[Y^WXYcd_biQ^^_e^SY^WdXQdYdXQT\_cd$)RY\\Y_^Ueb_c'"RY\ U]QdYSYQ^3Qb\6bYUTbYSX7QeccgX_
\Y_^Q^TR\Q]Y^W#!iUQb_\TdbQTUb:Ub_]U;UbfYU\ SXQbdUT`b_RQRY\YdYUc_^QRU\\cXQ`UT
DQ\URºcVQ^S\eRXQcWb_g^VQb SebfU9^QRU\\SebfUXYWXVbUaeU^Si
RUi_^TdXUY^fUcd]U^dQ^T UfU^dcQbUbU`bUcU^dUTQddXUd_`_b
bUcUQbSXS_]]e^YdiGXU^ ]YTT\UQ^TY^VbUaeU^dU`Yc_TUcQbU
DQ]`Q6\_bYTQµRQcUT?TiccUi SXQbdUT_^dXUUTWU_bdQY\_VdXUSebfU
=QbY^U5h`\_bQdY_^9^STYcS_f DXUdQY\YceceQ\\idXY^bUÃUSdY^WbQbU
UbUTQS_\_^YQ\UbQcXY`gbUS[Y^ \_gY]`QSdUfU^dc
dXU1d\Q^dYS?SUQ^\Qcd=QigYdX 7QeccYQ^cdQdYcdYSc]YWXdg_b[Y^SQcY
!'d_^c_VW_\TQ^TcY\fUbS_Y^cfQ\ ^_cRedYdSQ^ºdQSSebQdU\iXU\`SQ\Se\QdU
eUTQdc_]U% ]Y\\Y_^7bUW cd_S[]Qb[UdfQ\eQdY_^cDQ\URQbWeUc
CdU]]dXUS_]`Q^iºcS_V_e^TUb ·GYdXcd_S[cgUT_^ºd[^_gYVgUºbU_fUb
XQ``U^UTd_RUbUQTY^WDQ\URºc `QiY^W¸XUdU\\cdXUQeTYU^SU
R__[CdU]]TUSYTUTd_^Q]UdXU ·>_cU\VbUc`USdY^WcdQdYcdYSYQ^Y^
cYdU·DXU2\QS[CgQ^¸C__^QVdUb VY^Q^SUYcecY^W7QeccYQ^cdQdYcdYSc¸
dXUdg_]UdV_bSXQ]`QW^UY^<_c Y^dUbZUSdc<_bT:_X^5QdgU\\Q^US_^_
1^WU\UcQ^TR_^TUT_fUbdXUb_\U ]YcdQ^T`bUcYTU^d_VAeUU^cº3_\\UWU
_VbQ^T_]^UccY^\YVU Qd3Q]RbYTWUE^YfUbcYdigX_ºccYddY^W
DQ\URXQc]QTUU^U]YUcd__9^ Y^dXURQS[·1\\]_TU\cQbU2QiUcYQ^¸
1eWecdH\Y5aYf]WUbGhUh]gh]W]Ub XUcQicbUVUbbY^Wd_dXUdXU_biTUbYfUT
dXUaeQbdUb\iZ_eb^Q\_VdXU1]UbY Vb_]!(dXSU^debi2bYdYcX]QdXU]QdY
SQ^CdQdYcdYSQ\1cc_SYQdY_^SQ]U SYQ^DX_]Qc2QiUcdXQdQ\\_gcV_b
_edgYdXQc`USYQ\6`UW_GkUbYcceU TQdQd_RUS_^cdQ^d\iQTTUTd_SQ\Se
Taleb dismisses the dXQd`eR\YcXUTQcUbYUc_VSbYdYSQ\bUfYUgcQ\_^WcYTUQ^QbdYS\URiDQ\UR \QdU`b_RQRY\YdYUc
A
bell curve averages of ·8USXQbQSdUbYjUccdQdYcdYSYQ^cQc`U_`\UgX_R\Y^T\iQcce]UdXY^Wc
mathematics pioneer
Carl Friedrich Gauss. Q^T^_dXY^WS_e\TRUVebdXUbVb_]dXUdbedX¸cQic@UdUbGUcdVQ\\dXU Q\URcX__dcRQS[*
Z_eb^Q\ºcUTYd_bQ^TQ`b_VUcc_b_VY^V_b]QdY_^cicdU]cQ^TaeQ^dYdQ ·2QiUcYQ^Yc^USUccQbi
dYfUcSYU^SUcQdDUhQcDUSXE^YfUbcYdiY^<eRR_S[ Red^_dceèSYU^d¸
5fU^XYc_^UdY]US_\\UQWeUcTYcQWbUUgYdXXY]B_RUbd5^W\UQ DQ\URgX_c`_bdcQ
>_RU\\QebUQdUY^US_^_]YScgX_dUQSXUcQd>UgI_b[E^YfUbcYdiºc cQ\dQ^T`U``UbW_QdUU
CdUb^CSX__\_V2ecY^UccY^=Q^XQddQ^cQicDQ\URºcR__[YW^_bUcQ Q^T]ecdQSXUQ^TQ¿&
]Qcc_V\YdUbQdebU_^bQbUUfU^dcSQ\\UTUhdbU]UfQ\eUdXU_bigXYSXYc R\QS[CgQdSXgQdSXYc_VdU^aeYS[d_dQ[U
_VdU^ecUTd_QccUccbYc[cY^Y^cebQ^SUQcgU\\QcÂ^Q^SU·8UºcbUÃUSd _çU^cU1dQS_^VUbU^SUY^9dQ\iQWb_e`
Y^WQ^_`Y^Y_^dXQdÂ^Q^SYQ\]Qb[UdcQbUc_bd_V_ed_VS_^db_\¸5^W\U _VcdeTU^dcd_\TXY]XU\__[UT\Y[U
cQic·9dXY^[Q\_d_V]YcdQ[UcQbU]QTURed9T_^ºddXY^[XUXU\`cec E]RUbd_5S_dXUc_]UgXQd`Qe^SXi
e^TUbcdQ^TdXU]YcdQ[Uc¸ 9dQ\YQ^`XY\_c_`XUbQ^TQedX_b_VdXU
DQ\URºcR__[R\U^TcXYWXRb_g`XY\_c_`XYSQ\]ecY^WcgYdXaeQcYcU\V ^_fU\H\YBUaYcZh\YFcgYDQ\URcQic
HULTON ARCHIVE/GETTY IMAGES
XU\`QTfYSUdXQdQ``UQ\cd__ebVQcSY^QdY_^gYdXceSSUccQ^TSXQ^SU XU`b_]`d\igU^d_^QTYUd
_SSebbU^SUcGXY\UCdU`XU^3_fUiºcH\Y+<UV]hgcZ<][\`m9êYWh]jYDYc! 6_b]_bUdXQ^QTUSQTUDQ\URXQcRUU^
d`YCY]_^CSXecdUb!)) `eb`_bdcd_WYfUUfUbi_^UQb_QT]Q`_^ dbiY^Wd_dbQ^cV_b]XY]cU\VVb_]dbQTUbd_
X_gd_RUS_]UdXU^Uhd2Y\\7QdUcDQ\URbU]Y^TcecdXQdc[Y\\cQ^TXQbT `XY\_c_`XUb·2idXUQWU_V# 9gQcU]_dY_^
g_b[QbU^ºdQ\gQicU^_eWX·8QbTg_b[`\ec\eS[YcgXQdWUdci_eQZUd Q\\i_edcYTUdXUg_b\T_VÂ^Q^SU¸XUcQic
Y^cdUQT_VZecdQ2=G¸XUcQic_fUbTeS[QdQTY]ce]bUcdQebQ^dY^ Cebb_e^TUTRiQS_\\USdY_^_VQ^SYU^d
42
BLOOMBERG MARKETS MAY 2008
Hedge fund
manager Mark
Spitznagel says
he and Taleb aim
for ‘infrequent
huge payouts.’
cSe\`dUTB_]Q^XUQTc?bdX_T_h3XbYcdYQ^YS_^cQ^TdX_ecQ^Tc_Vf_\ _`dY_^cdbQTUb?^CU`d""!)(%6bQ^SU
e]Ucc`bUQTdXb_eWX_edXYcceRebRQ^X_]U^_bdX_V=Q^XQddQ^DQ\UR 7Ub]Q^i:Q`Q^dXUE;Q^TdXUEC
XQcSXeb^UT_edQcUbYUc_VdUSX^YSQ\`Q`UbcQ^TR__[c8YcÂbcd]QY^ cYW^UTdXU@\QjQ1SS_bTQ^QWbUU]U^dd_
cdbUQ]R__[:cc`YXVmFUbXcabYgg.H\Y<]XXYbFc`YcZ7\UbWY]b@]ZYUbX `ecXT_g^dXUfQ\eU_VdXUT_\\Qbd_
]bh\YAUf_YhgGG>_bd_^" !gXYSXXQc!& `Q`UbRQS[cY^ cX_bUe`dXUECSebbU^dQSS_e^dTUÂSYd
`bY^dY^dXUECgQcdbQ^c\QdUTY^d_" \Q^WeQWUcQ^Tdeb^UTXY]Y^d_Q DQ\URgQccYddY^W_^SebbU^Si_`dY_^c¶
WebeY^c_]UÂ^Q^SUSYbS\Uc gXYSXWYfUY^fUcd_bcdXUbYWXdd_Rei_b
DQ\URXQc\UQb^UTQR_ede^SUbdQY^diÂbcdXQ^T2_b^Y^d_Q`b_]Y^U^d cU\\QSebbU^SiQdQc`USYÂUTUhSXQ^WU
7bUU[?bdX_T_h3XbYcdYQ^VQ]Y\iXUcQicXUgYd^UccUT<URQ^_^ºcdbQ^c bQdU¶dXQdXQTS_cdXY]`U^^YUcDXU
V_b]QdY_^Vb_]XUQfU^d_XU\\gXU^SYfY\gQbUbe`dUTY^!)'%1ddXU _`dY_^cUh`\_TUTY^fQ\eUdXQdTQi·9XQT
dY]UXUgQcQ!%iUQb_\TcdeTU^dQd2UYbedºc7bQ^T<iS}U6bQ^S_<YRQ ^_S\eUgXQdXQTXQ``U^UTd_]U¸XU
^QYcQ^U\YdU6bU^SXc`UQ[Y^WcSX__\dXQdgQcTQ]QWUTTebY^WdXUgQb bUSQ\\c·GUgUbU\eS[iGU]QTUQ\_d_V
8U\YcdU^UTd_QTe\dcdU\\XY]dXQddXUS_^ÃYSdg_e\Tc__^U^T_^\id_ ]_^UiRedRiQSSYTU^d¸
gQdSXYdTbQW_^V_bQ\]_cd!'iUQbc8YcVQ]Y\iºcX_]UY^1]Y_e^Y^ 16bU^SXS_\\UQWeU:UQ^=Q^eU\
^_bdXUb^<URQ^_^gQcTUcdb_iUTY^!)("gXU^XYcWbQ^TVQdXUbV_b]Ub B_jQ^\QdUbgb_dUQR_eddXUU`Yc_TUY^Q
4U`edi@bY]U=Y^YcdUb6_eQT7X_c^gQcQ]U]RUb_V`Qb\YQ]U^d ]U]_YbTYcWeYcUTQcQ^_fU\SQ\\UT@Y:f]W
DQ\UR\UVd<URQ^_^d_QddU^TdXUE^YfUbcYdi_V@QbYcQ^TdXU^W_dXYc _b7Ug\=YSXU\<QV_^!)))Y^gXYSXXU
=QcdUb_V2ecY^Ucc1T]Y^YcdbQdY_^Y^!)(#Vb_]dXUGXQbd_^CSX__\Qd ^Q]UTDQ\URQ^TSQ\\UTXY]dXU2_RRi
6YcSXUb_V_`dY_^cbUVUbbY^Wd_dXU\UWU^T
QbiSXUcc`\QiUb
¹9XQT^_S\eUgXQdXQTXQ``U^UTd_]Uº 1VdUbdXYcÃe[UDQ\URcQicXURUSQ]U
_RcUccUTgYdXReiY^W_ed_VdXU]_^Ui
DQ\URcQic_VXYcRYWcS_bUY^ _`dY_^c¶`edcQ^TSQ\\cgX_cUcdbY[U`bYSU
SebbU^Si_`dY_^cQbYcY^WVb_]
YcUYdXUb\_gUb_bXYWXUbdXQ^dXU]Qb[Ud
`bYSU_VdXUe^TUb\iY^WcUSebYdi1^QWbUU
]U^dd_cU\\YcQ`ed_`dY_^+Q^QWbUU]U^d
dXU!)(%@\QjQ1SS_bT¹GUgUbU\eS[iº d_ReiYcQSQ\\_`dY_^
1di`YSQ\dbQTU]YWXdg_b[\Y[UdXYc*
=YSb_c_Vd3_b`YcdbQTY^WQd#%DQ\UR
dXUE^YfUbcYdi_V@U^^ci\fQ^YQgXUbUXUcQicXUVU\\Y^\_fUgYdX g_e\TReiQ`ed_`dY_^QWbUUY^Wd_cU\\
_`dY_^c1^_`dY_^cS_^dbQSdQ\\_gcRedT_Uc^ºd_R\YWUQ^Y^fUcd_bd_ Q^_dXUbY^fUcd_bdXUcd_S[QdQcdbY[U`bYSU
Rei_bcU\\QcUSebYdi_bY^TUhQdQ^QWbUUT`bYSUQdc_]UVedebUTQdU _VcQi"%Y^dXU^UhddXbUU]_^dXc8Uºc
Dg_iUQbc\QdUbXUW_dXYcÂbcd\Ucc_^Y^Â^Q^SYQ\e^SUbdQY^di RUddY^WdXUcd_S[gY\\VQ\\]eSX]_bUdXQ^
DAVID STRICK
1VdUbQRbYUVcdY^dQcQdbQY^UUQd2Q^[UbcDbecd3_b`DQ\URZ_Y^UT YdXQcT_^UXYcd_bYSQ\\i]Q[Y^WdXU_`dY_^
6bU^SXRQ^[9^T_ceUj^_g`Qbd_V3b}TYd1WbYS_\UC1QcQSebbU^Si SXUQ`d_Rei9VdXUcd_S[VU\\VebdXUbd_
44
BLOOMBERG MARKETS MAY 2008
" XUg_e\TUhUbSYcUdXU_`dY_^ 6bQ^SUºcRYWWUcdRQ^[QcQ^_`dY_^cdbQTUb
Q^TV_bSUdXUY^fUcd_bd_ReiQd 9^dXU]YT!)) cgXU^XUgQccdY\\Y^
"%`_S[UdY^WdXUTYVVUbU^SU9V XYc# cDQ\URV_e^T_eddXQddXUcSbQdSXi
dXUcd_S[T_Uc^ºdVQ\\dXU_`dY_^ f_YSUXUºTQddbYRedUTd_d__]eSXcX_ed
Uh`YbUcQ^TDQ\URXQc\_cd_^\i Y^WY^dXU`YdXQTQ]_bU_]Y^_ecSQecU
dXU`U^^YUcXU`QYTV_bYd 8UXQTdXb_QdSQ^SUbDXUTYcUQcUdU^Tc
9^!)(&DQ\UR]_fUTd_6Ybcd d_cdbY[Uc]_[Ubc_fUb% DQ\URgQc^ºdQ
2_cd_^9^S^_g`Qbd_V3bUTYd c]_[UbUhSU`dV_bdXU_TT6bYTQigXU^XU
CeYccU7b_e`gXUbUVU\\_gdbQT g_e\T\YWXde`Q`Y`UQVdUbQW__TdbQTY^W
UbcSQ\\UTXY]·>QccY]dXU4bUQ]¸ gUU[1VdUbdg_iUQbc_VbQTYQdY_^dbUQd
bUSQ\\c4U]UdbY_c4YQ[_\Y_cQV_b ]U^ddXUSQ^SUbTYcQ``UQbUTIUddXU
]UbS_\\UQWeU1d6Ybcd2_cd_^ UçUSdc\Y^WUbQ^TDQ\URcQicXUbU]QY^c
DQ\URdXU^"(ReY\dgXQdXUdUb]c `QbQ^_YTdXQddXYc`QbdYSe\QbR\QS[cgQ^
Q·]QccYfU¸`_cYdY_^Y^_ed_VdXU gY\\bUcebVQSU
A
]_^UiSQ\\c_^5eb_T_\\QbVedebUc
Philosopher ?^?Sd!)!)('XUgQccYddY^WQdQb_g_VTUc[c_^6Ybcd2_cd_^ºcdbQT Q\UR»cV_\\_gY^WWbUg
Karl Popper, Y^WÃ__bQd@Qb[1fU^eU@\QjQY^=Q^XQddQ^gXU^XYcTbUQ]SQ]UdbeU Y^!)))gXU^XURUWQ^
a Taleb hero, said
trying to prove DXU4_g:_^Uc9^TecdbYQ\1fUbQWU`\e]]UdUT""&`UbSU^dY^dXURYW dUQSXY^WQ^UfU^Y^WWbQT
a theory false WUcd_^UTQiTb_`Y^ECcd_S[]Qb[UdXYcd_biDXUSbQcXSQecUT5eb_ eQdUS_ebcUQd>UgI_b[
is the best test. T_\\QbVedebUcd_cebWUQVdUbdXUEC6UTUbQ\BUcUbfU`e]`UT\YaeYTYdi E^YfUbcYdi8YcS\Qcc_^
Y^d_dXURQ^[Y^WcicdU]\_gUbY^WY^dUbRQ^[R_bb_gY^WbQdUcDQ\URºc ]_TU\VQY\ebUY^aeQ^dYdQ
`_cYdY_^cUh`\_TUT_^SUQWQY^·GUQ\\[^UgdXQdXUTYTgU\\dXQdXU dYfUÂ^Q^SUQddbQSdUT\Y[U]Y^TUTcde
S\UQ^UTe`_^dXQdQ^T]QTU#%]Y\\Y_^µ$ ]Y\\Y_^¸4YQ[_\Y_ccQic_V TU^dcY^S\eTY^WC`Ydj^QWU\1VdUbdXU
dXUce]dXURQ^[]QTU_^DQ\URºc`_cYdY_^c·DXUUaeYdYUcWeicRU\_gec S_ebcUgbQ``UTe`Y^dXUUfU^Y^WDQ\UR
dX_eWXd¹GXiTYTc_]UWeie`cdQYbc]Q[UQ\\dXYc]_^Ui_^QTQigXU^ g_e\TW_d_dXU?TU_^SQVUY^=Q^XQd
UfUbiR_TiW_d[Y\\UT/º¸ dQ^ºcDbY2U3Q^UYWXR_bX__TV_bTbY^[c
DXU`QiTQiV_bDQ\URgQcRYWGYdX_edTYfe\WY^WdXUQ]_e^dXU gYdXcdeTU^dcQ^TGQ\\CdbUUdaeQ^dc
cQic)'`UbSU^d_VdXU]_^UiXUºcUfUb]QTUgQc_^2\QS[=_^TQiY^ d_dQ\[QR_edUfUbidXY^WVb_]`bYSY^W
!)('·DXUbUQbUS_^SU^dbQdUT`_S[Udc_V\eS[¸XUcQic1VdUbQVUg _`dY_^cd_dXUVQY\ebUc_VfQ\eUQdbYc[
]_TU\cgXYSXRQ^[cecUTQY\id_TUSYTU
X_g]eSXd_gQWUbY^dXU]Qb[Udc·9d
¹?ebQY]gQc^_dd_]Q[U]_^UiºDQ\URcQic RUSQ]UQ^e^_èSYQ\]UUdY^W`\QSUV_b
`U_`\UY^dUbUcdUTY^aeQ^dYdQdYfUÂ^Q^SU
Uh`\QY^Y^WXYcÂbcdXUTWUVe^TºcUç_bdd_ Q^TdbQTY^W¸bUSQ\\c1ABºc2b_g^
`b_dUSdQWQY^cd`\e^WUc¹9]Q[U
QedX_b_VH\YDc_Yf:UWYcZKU``GhfYYh
K]`Ym &$$*"
DQ\URaeYd2>@@QbYRQcY^!)))Q^TcUd
^_S\QY]c_VRUY^WQR\Ud_RUQd]Qb[Udcº e`5]`YbYSQY^7bUU^gYSX3_^^USdYSed
RbY^WY^WC`Ydj^QWU\gYdXXY]5]`YbYSQ
gQc^ºd\Y[U]_cdXUTWUVe^TcDXUBec
]_^dXc_Vf_\QdY\UdbQTY^WdXU]Qb[UdSQ\]UTT_g^Q^TDQ\URWbUg cYQ^Â^Q^SYQ\SbYcYcQ^TdXUS_\\Q`cU_V
R_bUT9^!))!XU]_fUTd_E^Y_^2Q^[_VCgYdjUb\Q^T^_gE2C <_^WDUb]3Q`YdQ\=Q^QWU]U^dQVdUb$
17QcSXYUV_`dY_^cdbQTUb8U\QcdUT\UccdXQ^QiUQb+XUcQicU^T\Ucc RY\\Y_^Y^\_ccUcXQTc`__[UT]Q^iY^fUc
]UUdY^WcQ^^_iUTXY] d_bcDQ\URRUWQ^_çUbY^WXUTWUVe^TS\Y
9^!))"DQ\URdeb^UTXYcRQS[_^GQ\\CdbUUd8U]_fUTd_3XYSQW_ U^dc`b_dUSdY_^QWQY^cdQR\_ge`\Y[U
d_RUS_]UQ`YddbQTUbQ^T]Qb[Ud]Q[UbQddXU3XYSQW_=UbSQ^dY\U <D3=Ri_çcUddY^Wc_]U_VdXUYbdbQTUc
5hSXQ^WU9^dXU`YdXUcQgX_g_`dY_^cQbU`bYSUTY^bUQ\]Qb[UdcbQdX gYdX_`dY_^c
UbdXQ^Vb_]]QdXU]QdYSQ\]_TU\c1ddXUdY]UXUgQcg_b[Y^W_^XYc 5]`YbYSQU^TUTe`QSdY^W\Y[UQce`Ub
@X4Y^_`dY_^`bYSY^WQddXUE^YfUbcYdi_V@QbYc4Qe`XY^UgXYSXXU Rb_[Ub_bS\UQbY^WX_ecUV_bReiY^W_ed_V
STEVE PYKE/GETTY IMAGES
S_]`\UdUTY^!))(Q^TgbYdY^WXYcÂbcdR__[8mbUa]W<YX[]b[.AUbU[! dXU]_^Ui_`dY_^c1VdUbc`U^TY^W]Y\
]b[JUb]``UUbX9lch]WCdh]cbgGY\Ui!))'1VdUbdg_iUQbcDQ\UR \Y_^c_^S_]`edUbcicdU]cQ^TWYfY^W
]_fUTRQS[d_>UgI_b[gXUbUXUg_b[UTQd3923G__T7e^TiQe^Yd dXUYbc_VdgQbU`b_WbQ]cS_TU^Q]Uc\Y[U
_VD_b_^d_RQcUT3Q^QTYQ^9]`UbYQ\2Q^[_V3_]]UbSUQcW\_RQ\XUQT 9W_bDQ\URQ^TC`Ydj^QWU\g_e\TT_g^
_VÂ^Q^SYQ\_`dY_^QbRYdbQWUQ^TdXU^Qd@QbYcRQcUT2>@@QbYRQcC1 \_QT& _`dY_^`bYSUcUfUbi^YWXd
46
BLOOMBERG MARKETS MAY 2008
Q^T`b_TeSURYTc_^# µ$ RYWR\_S[cWUddY^WdXU]SXUQ`RiReiY^W CY\fUbSbUcd1ccUd=Q^QWU]U^d7b_e`<<3
Y^Re\[DQ\URcQicDXUW_Q\gQcd_`b_dUSdY^fUcd_bcQWQY^cd]Qb[Ud gXYSX]Q^QWUcQR_ed! RY\\Y_^
SbQcXUc;^_gY^WX_g]eSXdXUig_e\T`QiV_b_`dY_^cdXUdg_WeQb DQ\URQ^TC`Ydj^QWU\]_fUT5]`YbYSQ
Q^dUUTY^fUcd_bcdXUig_e\T^ºd\_cU]_bUdXQ^!#`UbSU^dQiUQb·?eb d_]YTd_g^=Q^XQddQ^Y^" #Q^T
QY]gQc^_dd_]Q[U]_^Ui¸DQ\URcQic·9]Q[U^_S\QY]c_VRUY^W SXQ^WUTdQS[V_bc_]US\YU^dcD_`b_Âd
QR\Ud_RUQd]Qb[Udc¸ Vb_]\_gf_\QdY\YdidXUiRUWQ^cU\\Y^WQd
5]`YbYSQTYT_ed`UbV_b]dXU]Qb[Ud9^" YdcbUdeb^cb_cURi dXU]_^Ui_`dY_^c¶dX_cUS\_cUd_dXU
QR_ed& `UbSU^d_^dXURQS[_VXYWXf_\QdY\YdiQ^TdXURebcdY^W_VdXU ]Qb[Ud`bYSU_VdXUe^TUb\iY^WcUSebYdi9^
T_dS_]ReRR\UDQ\URcQicDXU^UhdiUQbQVdUbdXUCU`d!!dUbb_bYcd º #Q^Tº $5]`YbYSQ`_cdUTc]Q\\`_cY
QddQS[c^Ubf_ecY^fUcd_bcSQ]UÃ_S[Y^WDXU^f_\QdY\YdiTb_``UTQcdXU dYfUbUdeb^cDQ\URcQic5QWUbd_V_Sec_^
cd_S[]Qb[Udc\_g\iTbYVdUTT_g^bU]_fY^WdXU_``_bde^YdYUcd_`b_Âd gbYdY^WH\Y6`UW_GkUbQ^TcdY\\QVbQYTXU
Vb_]gYTU]Qb[UdcgY^Wc9^" "5]`YbYSQ`_cdUTYdcg_bcdiUQbQc cQicdXQdXYcSQ^SUb]YWXdbUdeb^DQ\UR
Born in Lebanon, bUdeb^cVU\\QR_ed!"`UbSU^dDQ\URcQicgXY\UdXU4_g:_^Uc9^TecdbYQ\ cXeddUbUT5]`YbYSQY^" $Q^TbUdeb^UT
Taleb collects 1fUbQWUTb_``UT!'`UbSU^d QR_ed#( ]Y\\Y_^d_Y^fUcd_bc·9gQcVUT
Orthodox ·9[^UgXUgQc\Y[U\id_\_cU]_^Ui]_cd_VdXUdY]URUSQecUYdgQc[Y^T_V e`¸XUcQic·9ZecdgQ^dUTd_gbYdUQ^T9
Christian icons
and sculpted Q^Y^cebQ^SU¸cQic:UQ^;Qb_eRYQ^5]`YbYSQY^fUcd_bQ^TSXYUVUhUSedYfU XQTgbYdUbºcR\_S[¸
Roman heads. _èSUb_V<_^W3XQ]`7b_e`9^SdXU>UgI_b[µRQcUTXUTWUVe^Te^Yd_V H\Y6`UW_GkUbgQcYdcU\VQR\QS[
cgQ^¶Q^e^Uh`USdUTXYdDXUR__[
cgY^WcVb_]QTfYSU_^X_gd_TYcdY^WeYcX
RUdgUU^`_cYdYfUQ^T^UWQdYfUR\QS[
cgQ^cY^UfUbiTQi\YVUd_be]Y^QdY_^c_^
DQ\URºcXUb_;Qb\@_``UbdXU1ecdbYQ^
R_b^" dXSU^debi`XY\_c_`XUbgX_
QbWeUTdXQdcSYU^dYÂSdXU_bYUccX_e\TRU
dUcdUT^_ddXb_eWXQddU]`dcd_fUbYVi
dXU]ReddXb_eWXUç_bdcd_`b_fUdXU]
VQ\cU·9Vi_eQbUY^RQ^[Y^WQ^T\U^TY^W
ceb`bYcU_edS_]UcQbU\Y[U\id_RU^UWQ
dYfUV_bi_e¸DQ\URgbYdUc·@edi_ebcU\V
Y^cYdeQdY_^cgXUbUVQf_bQR\US_^cU
aeU^SUcQbU]eSX\QbWUbdXQ^e^VQf_b
QR\U_^Uc¸
8UQTTc\Ydd\UdY`cceSXQc*·7_d_
`QbdYUc9Vi_eºbUQcSYU^dYcdi_egY\\
SXQ^SUe`_^QbU]Qb[dXQd]YWXdc`Qb[
^UgbUcUQbSX¸
DQ\URXQcQV__dY^QSQTU]YQ8Uºc^_g
QfYcYdY^W`b_VUcc_bQddXU<_^T_^2ecY
^UccCSX__\gXUbUXUºcS_^TeSdY^W
Uh`UbY]U^dcgYdX4Q^7_\TcdUY^Q^
QccYcdQ^d`b_VUcc_b_V]Qb[UdY^W_^dXU
`ciSX_\_Wi_VbYc[Q^TTUSYcY_^]Q[Y^W
DQ\URgQ^dcXQbT`b__VdXQd`U_`\U]Yc
ZeTWUbYc[c9^_^U`Y\_dUh`UbY]U^ddXUi
`_cUTdXUV_\\_gY^WaeUcdY_^d_`QbdYSY
`Q^dc*·I_eºbU_^fQSQdY_^Y^QV_bUYW^
S_e^dbiQ^TQbUS_^cYTUbY^WÃiY^WdXU
^QdY_^Q\QYb\Y^Ud_cUUQc`USYQ\Yc\Q^Ti_e
XQfUQ\gQicg_^TUbUTQR_edCQVUdicdQ
dYcdYScY^dXYcS_e^dbicX_gdXQdYVi_e
ÃUgdXYcQYb\Y^U_^SUQiUQbdXUbUg_e\T
RU_^USbQcXUfUbi! iUQbc_^QfUb
BRAD TRENT
QWU9Vi_eT_^ºddQ[UdXUdbY`YdYc
UhdbU]U\ie^\Y[U\ii_eº\\bUfYcYddXYc`Qbd
48
BLOOMBERG MARKETS MAY 2008
_VdXUg_b\TQWQY^G_e\Ti_edQ[UdXUÃYWXd/¸5fUbi_^UQ^cgUbUTiUc =UTY_SbYcdQ^gXUbUYVi_eXQfUQ\QbWU
Qcce]Y^WdXQd_^USbQcXUfUbi! iUQbcgQcQ]Y^Y]Q\bYc[ cQ]`\UdXUQfUbQWU_VQ^Y^TU`U^TU^d
1^_dXUbWb_e`gQcWYfU^dXUcQ]U`b_R\U]UhSU`ddXUigUbUd_\TdXQd YTU^dYSQ\bQ^T_]cUd_VfQbYQR\UcgY\\
Q^QfUbQWU_V!Y^! ÃYWXdc_^dXYcQYb\Y^USbQcXUc1\dX_eWXYdºcdXU S_^fUbWUY^dXU]YTT\U9^DQ\URºc_dXUb
cQ]UbYc[]QdXU]QdYSQ\\i# `UbSU^dbUVecUTd_ÃigXU^`bUcU^dUTgYdX T_]QY^5hdbU]YcdQ^QfUbQWU_edS_]Uc
dXYcg_bTY^W·DXYc_^UY^UfUbiHiUQbcVbQ]Y^WYcc_]UdXY^Wi_eXUQb XQfU\Ydd\U]UQ^Y^W9VVY^Q^SYQ\]Qb[Udc
QbUW_fUb^UTRiUhdbU]U]_fU]U^dc
Q^Te^Uh`USdUTUfU^dcgUcX_e\T^ºdRU
DQ\UR_çUbcdY`cd_]Q[UbQ^T_]^Ucc V__\UTY^d_RU\YUfY^Wg_bcdSQcUcSU^Qb
Y_cXUcQic·GU^UUT]_bUSXedj`QXºº
g_b[Y^i_ebVQf_b*¹7_d_`QbdYUc9V XUcQic·9Vc_]U_^UdbYUTd_T_cdbUcc
dUcdY^WRUV_bUdXUcd_S[]Qb[UdSbQcXY^
i_eºbUQcSYU^dYcdi_egY\\SXQ^SUe`_^ º('dXUig_e\T^_dXQfUdUcdUTV_b"
`UbSU^dT_g^¸
QbU]Qb[dXQd]YWXdc`Qb[^UgbUcUQbSXº DQ\UR\Y[U^c]_TUb^TQiÂ^Q^SYQ\
]Qb[Udcd_]UTYSY^UY^dXU!( c
gXU^W_Y^Wd_QX_c`YdQ\Y^<_^T_^
S_^SUb^Y^W]Qb[UdSbQcXUcY^Â^Q^SYQ\bU`_bdc_^DF¸cQic7_\TcdUY^ _b@QbYc]e\dY`\YUTi_ebbYc[_VTUQdX
#(gX_X_\TcQ@X4Y^`ciSX_\_Wi RiV_ebdY]UcXUcQicCY]Y\Qb\iaeQ^dc
5hdbU]UcQbU]_bU\Y[U\iY^VY^Q^SUdXQ^Y^dXUbUQ\g_b\TDQ\UR Y^SbUQcUbYc[RiTU`\_iY^WÃQgUT
cQic1dQS_^VUbU^SUV_bbYc[]Q^QWUbcY^<_^T_^\Qcd:e^UXUecUT Â^Q^SYQ\d__\cTUcYW^UTd_bUTeSUYd
dXUV_\\_gY^WY\\ecdbQdY_^*·CQi9cQ]`\UVb_]dXUg_b\T`_`e\QdY_^ XUQbWeUc
Q^TVY^Tdg_`U_`\USe]e\QdYfU\i!$VUUddQ\\GXQdºcdXU]_cd\Y[U\i 6_bDQ\URdXUY\\cRUcUddY^WVY^Q^SYQ\
Q\\_SQdY_^V_b7QeccYQ^/?^UQ^T!#/>_YdºccUfU^Q^TcUfU^¸ ]Qb[UdcQbUQfY^TYSQdY_^_VXYcYTUQc
9^gUQ\dXYdºcdXU_``_cYdU·9VgUcQ]`\UVb_]dXUg_b\T`_`e\Q <Y[U]UTYSY^UdX_eWXXUYc^ºd_VVUbY^W
dY_^Q^TWUddg_`U_`\UgX_cU^Udg_bdXd_dQ\c!$]Y\\Y_^`_e^Tc UQciSebUc
gXQdºcdXU]_cd\Y[U\iS_]RY^QdY_^/¸XUQc[UT·CUfU^Q^TcUfU^/
Stephanie Baker-Said is a senior writer at
>_Ydºc% Q^T!$]Y\\Y_^]Y^ec% ¸ Bloomberg News in London.
8UWYfUcdXUcUdg_T_]QY^cTYVVUbU^d^Q]UcDXUVYbcdXUSQ\\c ssaid@bloomberg.net
50
BLOOMBERG MARKETS MAY 2008