Ohio Electricity Data Correction of data points in graph due to formula error for 2007 residential,

http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epa/epat7p2.html
provides a link to the sales data below. At the bottom of the page at the above address, select R
of Electricity by State by Sector by Type of Provider (EIA-861) (the only link with just an xls form
spreadsheet can be sorted to provide Total Industry Only by state.

MWH Generation MWH Sales Residential Sales Commercial Sales

1990 127,980,527 142,465,472 37,889,450 30,540,857
1991 134,036,497 145,658,320 40,942,449 32,325,493
1992 137,661,728 145,016,464 39,140,657 31,818,312
1993 135,237,292 148,570,665 41,950,456 33,298,608
1994 131,763,610 154,376,709 41,791,275 34,053,066
1995 139,343,902 158,625,546 44,010,400 35,549,248
1996 144,437,214 158,587,337 44,573,250 36,034,487
1997 142,811,248 158,508,094 43,634,915 36,373,148
1998 147,940,057 159,793,176 44,516,171 38,471,813
1999 142,330,431 164,270,830 46,628,504 39,461,042
2000 149,060,280 165,194,857 46,488,137 40,757,137
2001 142,261,807 155,797,714 47,346,163 39,372,078
2002 147,068,849 153,407,098 50,863,643 39,924,173
2003 146,638,128 152,189,238 49,620,578 44,736,571
2004 148,345,905 154,221,114 50,300,038 45,313,453
2005 156,976,323 160,176,303 53,904,244 46,869,755
2006 155,434,075 153,428,844 51,375,232 46,140,704
2007 155,155,545 161,770,827 54,375,759 48,128,512
2008 153,412,000 159,389,000 53,411,000 47,310,000
2009 135,949,000 145,846,000 51,362,000 45,337,000
2010 144,445,813 154,596,760 54,443,720 48,057,220

2008 Data is Preliminary

2009 data is preliminary: Annual generation taken from EIA monthly year to date epmxlfile1_6_b.xls for December,
2010 Data is estimated based on values for October, 2010 YTD compared with October, 2009 YTD (2009 X 1.0625
Duplicate data below is

divided by 1,000,000 to make Y axis interpretable on graphs

Columns are re-ordered from EIA format to present graph keys in sequence of customer group size
MWH Generation MWH Sales Industrial Sales Residential Sales

1990 128 142 70 38

1991 134 146 68 41
1992 138 145 70 39
1993 135 149 69 42
1994 132 154 74 42
1995 139 159 74 44
1996 144 159 73 45
1997 143 159 74 44
1998 148 160 73 45
1999 142 164 74 47
2000 149 165 74 46
2001 142 156 65 47
2002 147 153 58 51
2003 147 152 58 50
2004 148 154 59 50
2005 157 160 59 54
2006 155 153 56 51
2007 155 162 59 54
2008 153 159 59 53
2009 136 146 49 51
2010 144 155 52 54
2011 156
2012 158
2013 159
2014 161
2015 162
2016 164
2017 166
2018 167
2019 169
2020 171
2021 172
2022 174
2023 176
2024 178
2025 179
2026 181
2027 183
2028 185
2029 187
2030 189
2031 191
2032 192
2033 194
2034 196
2035 198
2036 200
2037 202
2038 204
2039 206
2040 208
Preliminary 2008 and 2009 data from:
http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epm/table1_6_a.html

Copied from above to make chart work

Column D below = Column C times ASAP Appliance Standards impact estim
Column E below + Column D times SB 221 Efficiency
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011 156 156 156
2012 158 157 157
2013 159 160 157
2014 161 159 157
2015 162 160 157
2016 164 162 158
2017 166 163 158
2018 167 164 158
2019 169 165 156
2020 171 167 155
2021 172 168 153
2022 174 169 152
2023 176 171 151
2024 178 172 149
2025 179 174 148
2026 181 175 147
2027 183 177 145
2028 185 178 144
2029 187 180 143
2030 189 181 141
2031 191 183 140
2032 192 185 139
2033 194 187 137
2034 196 188 136
2035 198 190 135
2036 200 192 134
2037 202 194 132
2038 204 196 131
2039 206 198 130
2040 208 200 129
ph due to formula error for 2007 residential, commercial and industrial sales. This version was saved on January 14, 2011

http://www.eia.doe.gov/c
e page at the above address, select Retail Sales provides a link to the gen
1) (the only link with just an xls format). This The bottom third of the ch

Industrial Sales Other Sales Transportation

69,681,659 4,353,506 NA 1990
67,856,138 4,534,240 NA 1991
69,674,159 4,383,336 NA 1992
68,831,023 4,490,578 NA 1993
74,010,054 4,522,314 NA 1994
74,473,401 4,592,497 NA 1995
73,394,154 4,585,446 NA 1996
73,888,462 4,611,569 NA 1997
72,998,337 3,806,855 NA 1998
74,292,951 3,888,333 NA 1999
74,019,337 3,930,246 NA 2000
65,098,733 3,980,740 NA 2001
58,471,510 4,147,772 NA 2002
57,827,582 NA 4,507 2003
58,558,349 NA 49,274 2004
59,354,379 NA 47,925 2005
55,869,283 NA 43,625 2006
59,218,957 NA 47,599 2007
58,621,000 0 47,401 Percent of 1990
49,107,000 0 39,000 total
52,053,420 0 41,340

Percent of 2006
ar to date epmxlfile1_6_b.xls for December, 2009
ed with October, 2009 YTD (2009 X 1.0625) for generation from epmxlfile1_6_b.xls for January 2011 and epmxlfile5_4_b.xlsx ((2009 X 1.0
total

Percent of 2007
total

nce of customer group size

Commercial Sales Other Sales

31 4 1990
32 5 1991
32 4 1992
33 4 1993
34 5 1994
36 5 1995
36 5 1996
36 5 1997
38 4 1998
39 4 1999
41 4 2000
39 4 2001
40 4 2002
45 2003
45 2004
47 2005
46 2006
48 2007
47 2008
45 2009
52 0 2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
mes ASAP Appliance Standards impact estimate
below + Column D times SB 221 Efficiency benefits
RENEWABLES - SB 221 standard

156 In 2007 Ohio generated 16.5 MW's from non-fossil sources out o
155 In 2010 generation dropped to 144.5 MW's and a total of 18.5 M
154
153
152
150
149 2011 1 0.36% 0%
147 2012 3 1.84% 2%
146 2013 5 3.30% 4%
144 2014 8 4.73% 6%
143 2015 11 6.62% 8%
141 2016 14 8.47% 10%
140 2017 17 10.28% 12%
139 2018 20 12.06% 14%
137 2019 23 13.80% 16%
136 2020 26 15.51% 18%
2021 30 17.18% 20%
2022 33 18.82% 22%
2023 36 20.43% 24%
2024 39 22.00% 26%
2025 42 23.55% 27%
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
2032
ed on January 14, 2011

://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/st_profiles/e_profiles_sum.html
ides a link to the generation data below. Click on the desired state and then select Table 5 for a spreadsheet with t
bottom third of the chart has total electric industry data.

MWH Generation MWH Coal Generation Petroleum Natural Gas Other Gases
127,980,527 115,832,650 374,481 241,585 64,159
134,036,497 117,502,355 427,742 364,566 57,312
137,661,728 121,249,946 258,124 340,236 73,545
135,237,292 123,795,912 346,002 371,452 128,520
131,763,610 119,169,558 424,488 371,591 144,300
139,343,902 120,629,428 330,064 724,821 139,069
144,437,214 128,640,943 303,872 410,269 176,515
142,811,248 125,435,419 293,908 468,934 189,767
147,940,057 129,223,181 370,838 677,578 185,762
142,330,431 123,320,141 483,998 886,446 156,424
149,060,280 129,578,544 354,412 825,154 290,353
142,261,807 124,213,236 416,698 924,416 301,949
147,068,849 132,953,065 389,119 1,766,654 206,565
146,638,128 134,769,137 410,154 1,793,583 212,523
148,345,905 128,217,071 1,388,882 1,386,257 302,628
156,976,323 136,874,551 1,390,649 2,694,229 297,392
155,434,075 133,461,552 1,355,400 2,377,189 360,009
155,155,545 133,130,679 1,147,746 3,974,897 289,273

100.0 90.5 0.3 0.2 0.1

e5_4_b.xlsx ((2009 X 1.0600) for sales

100.0 85.9 0.9 1.5 0.2

100.0 85.8 0.7 2.6 0.2

Total Generation Coal Generation Nuclear Natural Gas Petroleum

128.0 115.8 11 0.2 0.4

134.0 117.5 15 0.4 0.4
137.7 121.2 15 0.3 0.3
135.2 123.8 10 0.4 0.3
131.8 119.2 11 0.4 0.4
139.3 120.6 17 0.7 0.3
144.4 128.6 14 0.4 0.3
142.8 125.4 15 0.5 0.3
147.9 129.2 16 0.7 0.4
142.3 123.3 16 0.9 0.5
149.1 129.6 17 0.8 0.4
142.3 124.2 15 0.9 0.4
147.1 133.0 11 1.8 0.4
146.6 134.8 8 1.8 0.4
148.3 128.2 16 1.4 1.4
157.0 136.9 15 2.7 1.4
155.4 133.5 17 2.4 1.4
155.2 133.1 16 4.0 1.1
m non-fossil sources out of a total of 155 MW's generated and 161 MW's consumed. This omits line loss and power used during generation
W's and a total of 18.5 MW's of clean energy.

2011 0.42%
2012 2.14%
2013 3.83%
2014 5.50%
2015 7.70%
2016 9.85%
2017 11.95%
2018 14.02%
2019 16.05%
2020 18.03%
2021 19.98%
2022 21.88%
2023 23.75%
2024 25.58%
2025 27.38%
Table 5 for a spreadsheet with this data.

Nuclear Hydroelectric Other Renewables Other

10,663,897 181,395 622,360 -
14,832,789 154,224 697,509 - 1990
14,805,499 253,165 681,213 - 1991
10,010,661 189,613 395,132 - 1992
10,952,247 191,771 509,655 - 1993
16,768,050 232,221 520,249 - 1994
13,919,390 397,354 588,871 - 1995
15,330,830 507,368 585,022 - 1996
16,475,732 406,427 600,539 - 1997
16,422,010 423,031 638,381 - 1998
16,781,378 583,048 647,391 - 1999
15,463,762 510,785 430,961 - 2000
10,864,902 488,329 151,311 248,904 2001
8,475,016 510,835 440,717 26,163 2002
15,950,121 729,876 371,060 8 2003
14,802,733 515,744 399,087 1,937 2004
16,846,939 631,936 398,895 2,155 2005
15,764,049 410,436 435,143 3,322
2006 GEN
8.3 0.1 0.5 - 2006 SALES
2006 COAL
2006 OH GEN
2006 OH SALES

2006 OH COAL
10.8 0.4 0.3 * -

2007
10.2 0.3 0.3 * 2008
2009
2010
Hydroelectric Other Renewables

0 0.6
0 0.7
0 0.7
0 0.4
0 0.5
0 0.5
0 0.6
1 0.6
0 0.6
0 0.6
1 0.6
1 0.4
0 0.2
1 0.4
1 0.4
1 0.4
1 0.4
0 0.4
loss and power used during generation. Approximately 10% of Ohio's power comes from non-CO2-producing sources, and over 85.9% of O
Ohio Gen Ohio Sales Ohio Coal Michigan Gen Michigan Sales

MWH GenerationMWH Sales

127,980,527 142,465,472 115,832,650 100,059,737 82,366,869
134,036,497 145,658,320 117,502,355 105,978,124 84,518,543
137,661,728 145,016,464 121,249,946 95,321,939 83,840,225
135,237,292 148,570,665 123,795,912 106,368,549 87,588,602
131,763,610 154,376,709 119,169,558 98,307,389 91,159,987
139,343,902 158,625,546 120,629,428 107,444,612 94,701,134
144,437,214 158,587,337 128,640,943 112,518,309 96,301,566
142,811,248 158,508,094 125,435,419 106,970,759 97,390,660
147,940,057 159,793,176 129,223,181 100,477,394 100,506,195
142,330,431 164,270,830 123,320,141 103,239,715 103,981,006
149,060,280 165,194,857 129,578,544 104,209,594 104,772,216
142,261,807 155,797,714 124,213,236 111,845,610 102,409,347
147,068,849 153,407,098 132,953,065 117,889,087 104,713,520
146,638,128 152,189,238 134,769,137 111,347,060 108,877,193
148,345,905 154,221,114 128,217,071 118,487,269 106,606,040
156,976,323 160,176,303 136,874,551 121,619,771 110,444,563

112,556,739
108,017,697

155,434,075
153,428,844
133,461,552

161,770,827
159,389,000 Total Generation
145,846,000 127,980,527
154,596,760 134,036,497
137,661,728
1990 135,237,292
1991 131,763,610
1992 139,343,902
1993 144,437,214
1994 142,811,248
1995 147,940,057
1996 142,330,431
1997 149,060,280
1998 142,261,807
1999 147,068,849
2000 146,638,128
2001 148,345,905
2002 156,976,323
2003 155,434,075
2004 155,155,545
2005 153,412,251
2006 135,949,000
2007 144,445,813
2008
2009
2010
cing sources, and over 85.9% of Ohio's generation is from coal, with about two and a half percent from petroleum and natural gas combined
Michigan Coal Indiana Gen Indiana Sales Indiana Coal Kentucky Ge

MWH Coal Generation MWH Generati MWH Sales MWH Coal Generation MWH Genera
67,066,870 101,417,116 73,982,219 96,925,554 73,807,286
66,878,223 101,981,299 77,033,736 97,457,227 75,505,081
63,346,702 101,018,564 76,976,815 96,616,880 77,351,259
63,959,080 103,635,138 81,931,490 99,676,953 84,997,718
69,771,616 107,182,057 83,807,543 102,921,426 84,097,034
67,200,645 109,156,846 87,005,957 104,688,066 86,165,836
67,872,152 109,902,102 88,901,372 105,449,025 88,447,496
67,444,850 114,728,907 89,146,614 110,051,663 91,572,095
70,472,657 117,471,525 92,058,825 111,818,095 90,933,028
70,404,994 121,764,501 96,735,464 115,209,205 92,681,908
68,266,999 127,819,516 97,774,925 121,477,884 93,006,083
68,263,164 122,569,673 97,733,968 116,066,512 95,417,626
66,699,508 125,608,139 101,428,550 117,659,700 92,106,668
67,777,483 124,888,218 100,467,779 117,756,284 91,718,820
68,621,712 127,770,397 103,094,263 120,640,967 94,529,947
70,345,630 130,371,573 106,548,910 122,817,019 97,822,419

130,489,788 98,792,014
105,664,484
67,801,004 123,645,712

Coal Generation Petroleum Natural Gas Other Gases

115,832,650 374,481 241,585 64,159
117,502,355 427,742 364,566 57,312
121,249,946 258,124 340,236 73,545
123,795,912 346,002 371,452 128,520
119,169,558 424,488 371,591 144,300
120,629,428 330,064 724,821 139,069
128,640,943 303,872 410,269 176,515
125,435,419 293,908 468,934 189,767
129,223,181 370,838 677,578 185,762
123,320,141 483,998 886,446 156,424
129,578,544 354,412 825,154 290,353
124,213,236 416,698 924,416 301,949
132,953,065 389,119 1,766,654 206,565
134,769,137 410,154 1,793,583 212,523
128,217,071 1,388,882 1,386,257 302,628
136,874,551 1,390,649 2,694,229 297,392
133,461,552 1,355,400 2,377,189 360,009
133,130,679 1,147,746 3,974,897 289,273
130,694,310 1,437,938 2,484,391 260,924
113,824,000
119,814,000
m and natural gas combined.
 Kentucky SaleKentucky Coa West Virginia West Virginia West Virginia Coal

MWH Sales MWH Coal Generation MWH GeneratiMWH Sales MWH Coal Generation
61,096,874 70,500,461
64,193,802 71,713,851
67,067,820 73,476,309
68,149,184 81,722,246
72,485,367 79,897,442
74,548,198 82,539,467
77,018,734 84,659,818
76,835,514 87,875,331
75,850,311 86,838,802
79,098,015 89,522,933
78,316,156 90,063,054
79,975,499 90,798,578
87,266,835 83,274,246
85,219,631 84,060,540
86,521,156 86,120,511
89,351,466 89,083,113
79,539,544 23,132,431 77,643,366
73,423,735 23,624,945 71,867,808
75,159,914 23,831,118 73,352,552
74,749,164 24,441,525 72,968,665
81,429,542 24,775,708 79,628,566
80,537,427 25,976,705 78,714,219
87,244,388 26,126,778 85,219,006
91,528,877 26,247,224 89,845,529
92,822,186 26,511,261 91,213,355
94,692,596 27,144,008 93,329,226
92,865,176 27,692,998 91,202,309
81,836,725 27,669,432 80,214,404
94,761,753 28,463,122 92,951,317
94,711,554 28,296,993 92,468,983
89,749,562 28,918,612 87,588,842
93,626,285 30,152,069 91,419,556

93,815,804
88,743,435 32,312,126
91,198,488 91,477,333

Other Gases Nuclear Hydroelectric Other Renewables

10,663,897 181,395 622,360
14,832,789 154,224 697,509
14,805,499 253,165 681,213
10,010,661 189,613 395,132
10,952,247 191,771 509,655
16,768,050 232,221 520,249
13,919,390 397,354 588,871
15,330,830 507,368 585,022
16,475,732 406,427 600,539
16,422,010 423,031 638,381
16,781,378 583,048 647,391
15,463,762 510,785 430,961
10,864,902 488,329 151,311
8,475,016 510,835 440,717
15,950,121 729,876 371,060
14,802,733 515,744 399,087
16,846,939 631,936 398,895
15,764,049 410,436 435,143
17,513,878 386,435 623,376
14,937,000
Pennsylvania Pennsylvania SPennsylvania Coal

MWH GeneratiMWH Sales MWH Coal Generation

175,623,311 114,750,659 106,677,155
172,762,709 116,336,998 106,028,875
179,405,645 116,287,618 109,124,697
181,214,132 119,981,494 108,131,818
184,078,701 123,045,049 101,867,590
185,451,311 126,250,597 106,334,647
191,872,623 127,623,026 111,199,706
193,463,198 128,076,414 115,504,502
191,191,518 130,206,411 116,387,155
194,528,045 128,883,313 111,214,374
201,687,980 133,845,326 116,212,561
196,576,591 135,271,933 111,900,448
204,322,878 139,819,870 113,906,440
206,349,514 140,369,128 116,009,874
214,658,500 143,501,493 117,180,622
218,091,125 148,272,940 120,938,406

218,811,595
146,150,358
122,548,593

Other
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
 -
-
248,904
26,163
8
1,937
2,155
3,322
11,000
 Ohio Projected Sales Plus Renewables
MWH (millions)

250

2010 MWH Sales

200 MWH Generation

Industrial Sales

Residential Sales

Commercial Sales
150
MWH EIA Projection

EIA Minus Appliance

Standards

100 SB 221 Efficiency Benefits

Minus SB 221
Renewables

50

0
91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39
19 19 19 19 19 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20
 Ohio Projected Sales
MWH (millions)

250

200 MWH Sales

MWH Generation

Industrial Sales
150
Residential Sales
2010
Commercial Sales

100 MWH EIA Projection

EIA Minus Appliance

Standards

50 SB 221 Efficiency Benefits

0
91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39
19 19 19 19 19 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20
 Ohio Electricity - All Fuels
160,000,000

140,000,000

120,000,000
2009 Data available for
Generation, Coal and
100,000,000 Nuclear only

80,000,000
2009 Fuels
2008 Fuels
60,000,000

40,000,000

20,000,000

0
n n s s ar c es r
tio tio leu
m Ga se cle tri l he
ra ra al Ga u lec ab Ot
ne ne tro tu
r
he
r N o e ew
Ge Ge Pe Na Ot dr en
ta
l al Hy rR
To Co the
O
30.00%

25.00%
Percent of total electric CO2 emissions
reduced by Federal Appliance Standards
plus SB 221 efficiency and renewables
standards.
20.00% Percent New Clean Energy

15.00%
Percent of total Electric CO2 reduced

10.00%

5.00%

0.00%
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
 Ohio Generation and Coal Compared to
Surrounding States
(MWH's - 2006 Data)
250,000,000

200,000,000

150,000,000
MWH's - 2006

100,000,000

50,000,000

0
n es oal n es oal en ales oa
l
en ales Coa en ales oal en ales oa
l
Ge Sal C Ge Sal C a G a S na C y G y S ky a G ia S ia C a G ia S ia C
io i o io an n an n k c n i n i
Oh Oh Oh ig iga chig a
di dia ndia
n c
u tuc k
nt
u i
irg irgi irgi
n n a n an
ich ich i In nt ylv lva ylv
M M M In I Ke Ken Ke tV V V ns nsy nns
es est est n
W W W Pe Pen Pe