Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 10


uk: Crop-based polymers for nonwovens - Insight 2000 Who are

we ?Patents Etc.PublicationsSuccess StoriesContact
Calvin Woodings Consultant Eathorpe UK (For Insight 2000 Toronto)
The imminent large-scale production of biodegradable polyesters from
corn-starch will give nature's most abundant polymer, cellulose,
increasing competition in the nonwovens industry. Is a further decline in
the use of cellulose in nonwovens inevitable or could interest in the new
"nature-based" fibres and plastics enhance the prospects for all
crop-based materials? How will the costs of the two approaches compare?
Will the absorbency advantage of cellulose prevail over the
thermoplasticity advantage of polylactic acid. This paper compares and
contrasts the two main "natural" routes to polymers and the properties of
the resulting fibres.
Introduction: The PLA Investment
The US no longer has abundant oil reserves but does have a super-abundance
of agricultural resources capable, given appropriate levels of chemical
(fertiliser/pesticide) input, of annual regeneration. The US currently
imports 50% of its domestic petroleum consumption, yet exports 20% of its
grain production. The production of ethanol from grain was an early
example of an attempt to better balance this resource budget, and the
current PLA project appears to be part of a similar but separate program
with the objective of allowing agriculture to provide 10% of the US
chemical industry building blocks by 2020 and 50% by 2050. The program,
called the Plant/Crop-based Renewable Resources Vision at the US
Department of Energy has had the full support and co-funding of the
National Corn-Growers of America since 1997. The resulting Renewable
Resources 2020 is a broad-based coalition of agricultural, forestry, and
chemical industry experts working to create plant-based replacements for
The NCGA commenced funding of PLA research in 1994 while working with
Cargill to help them seek funding through US Department of Commerce
grants. Cargill first joined forces with Purac Biochem BV to perfect the
fermentation step and then with Dow in 1997 to build the first
pilot-plant. At that stage they projected large-scale production in 2001
to give a PLA polymer at around 50 cents/lb . This first 140,000
tonne/year Blair PLA plant would cost $300M and consume 14 million bushels
of corn per year, but to the NCGA, the market potential for PLA would be
500 million bushels per year of corn - almost as much as the current usage
in ethanol production - estimated to add 25 cents per bushel to the price
of corn.
The technological vision was bold and clear, and maybe as a natural
consequence, the marketing vision is now broad and evolving. Early
announcements said PLA would be the first renewable resource to stand
alone on price and performance in applications such as fabrics for
clothing, plastics for cups, food containers, packaging, and home/office
furnishing such as carpets.
Cargill-Dow Polymers LLC, (the 50/50 joint venture between Cargill Inc and
The Dow Chemical company formed in 1997), has, in a series of
announcements this year, made it clear they believe crop-based
biodegradable fibres to have a bright future in comparison with the
fossil-fuelled synthetics. Blair, now due to commence production of PLA in
early 2002, was chosen because of its proximity to the lowest cost source
of the dextrose sugar from which the PLA is made - a large Cargill
wet-milling plant - thereby allowing it to achieve the best possible
supply chain costs. The earlier JV between Cargill and Purac Biochem BV
brought a 34,000 tonne per year plant on stream, also at Blair in 1998, to
manufacture lactic acid from dextrose. This feeds, amongst other end-uses,
the 4000 tpa Dow PLA pilot plant in Savage MN.
A biodegradable polyester with the cost and easy-care properties of real
polyester, yet based on renewable resources rather than oil is clearly an
unmet need. It should be highly saleable in both woven and nonwoven
products as well as in many types of plastic containers. While the
publicly available information makes it clear that conventional polyester,
polystyrene and polypropylene are major targets for this new crop-based
polymer, comparisons with the old biodegradable crop-based polymer,
cellulose, are largely absent. PLA fibre is said to bridge the gap
between natural polymers and the synthetics, offering a unique combination
of properties combining the best attributes of natural and synthetic
fibres. It s positioning, in a world where the synthetics continue to
displace the natural polymers on cost/performance grounds, is excellent.
Most people are vaguely concerned that the plastics are in some way bad
for the environment, but, in the mass market at least, have not been
concerned enough to pay more for less convenient natural products.
Polylactic Acid Development
Polylactic acid was first made in 1932 by Carothers, who developed a
process involving the direct condensation polymerisation of lactic acid in
solvents under high vacuum. He abandoned the polymer as too low in melting
point for fibres and textiles and went on to develop nylon.
More recently PLA was developed as an alternative binder for cellulosic
nonwovens because of its easy hydrolytic degradability compared with
polyvinyl acetate or ethylene-acrylic acid copolymers.
Spunlaid and meltblown nonwovens based on PLA were researched at the
University of Tennessee Knoxville in 1993.
Kanebo ( Japan) introduced LACTRON® (poly L-Lactide) fibre and spun-laid
nonwovens in 1994 claiming a capacity of 2000 tpa being expanded to 3000
tpa. It targeted agricultural applications to start with, and in 1998 was
re-launched for apparel end-uses. At that time, Japanese demand for PLA
fibres was said to be 500-1000 tpa. In order to improve the
biodegradability and reduce the costs of the nonwovens, blends with rayon
were also developed.
Fiberweb (now BBA, France) disclosed nonwoven webs and laminates made of
100% PLA in 1997 and introduced a range of melt-blown and spunlaid PLA
fabrics under the Deposa brandname. The polymer was developed by Neste
Galactic Laboratories ( Belgium) provided an excellent overview of
polylactic acid polymers, concluding that 390,000 tonnes of the polymer
would be produced by 2008 at prices around $2/kg. Their estimate of 70,000
tonnes for 2002 looks about right with the new Cargill-Dow plant due to
start during that year. It remains to be seen if the price will be right
And this year, Cargill Dow Polymers LLC, as mentioned in the introduction
plan to double their 4000 tpa capacity for the polymer EcoPLA , now
rebranded NatureWorks to meet immediate market development needs". In
January they also announced the construction of the Blair plant to make "a
family of polymers derived entirely from annually renewable resources with
the cost performance necessary to compete with traditional fibres and
packaging materials". Fibre Innovation Technologies, Parkdale, Unifi,
Interface, Woolmark, Unitika, Kanebo and Kuraray are mentioned as
Development Allies.
Several other producers are still active. At Index 99, NKK ( Japan) showed
a PLA spunbond nonwoven at 15gsm with apparently excellent formation and
properties, although they later admitted that this was to demonstrate the
flexibility of their spunbond machinery, and not a commercial product.
Kuraray ( Japan) showed PLA fibres and provided some data on their
properties and biodegradation rates. PLA polymer is made in Japan by
Toyobo, Dai-Nippon Ink Chemicals, Showa Polymers, Shimadzu Corp and Mitsui
Toatsu , the latter under the LACEA brandname. Unlike CDP, MT s process
polymerises the lactic acid direct from the monomer), At Anex 2000 in
Osaka, Shinwa were showing a PLA version of their Haibon® spunbond: a
natural biodegradable nonwoven . Kanebo again promoted their Lactron®
fibre, but this time based on the CDP polymer.
The PLA Fibre Process
The CDP process, involves extracting sugars (mainly dextrose, but also
saccharose) from cornstarch, sugar beet or wheat starch and then
fermenting it to lactic acid. The lactic acid is converted into the dimer
or lactide which is purified and polymerised (ring-opening method) to
polylactic acid without the need for solvents . The family of polymers
arises in part from the stereochemistry of lactic acid and its dimer. As
fermented, lactic acid is 99.5% L-isomer and 0.5% D-isomer.
Conversion of this lactic acid to the dimer can be controlled to give
three forms, the L, D, and Meso lactides.
Polymerisation of the lactide to give polymers rich in the L-form gives
crystalline products, whereas those rich in the D-form (>15%) are more
amorphous. The enhanced control of the stereochemistry achieved in the
dimer route accounts for the superiority of the current products over
those from the 1932 Carothers approach.
In block diagram form the PLA production sequence is:
Seeds, Soil, Water, Carbon dioxide, Sunlight
Biomass, ideally corn
↓Harvest/Wet Mill↓
↓Acid/Enzyme Hydrolysis↓
Lactic Acid
Crude Polylactic Acid Pre-polymer
Crude Lactide monomer
↓Fractional Distillation↓
Pure lactide monomers
Polylactic Acids
↓Modification for end-use↓
Granules for extrusion etc.
↓Melt Spinning↓
Crop-Based Polyester Fibres
Producing the lactide with the right purity and stereochemistry to make
decent fibres is not trivial. In a recent Cargill patent, the refining
process, intended to be able to cope with crude lactic acid feedstock, was
illustrated as follows:
Feed Crude Lactic Acid to Evaporator continuously
Remove water or solvent → discard or recycle water, solvent or by-pr
Feed concentrated lactic acid to a pre-polymer reactor
Polymerize to form pre-polymer by removing water → discard or recycl
water, solvent or by-products contaminated with lactic acid
Feed in catalyst→ Feed pre-polymer to lactide reactor→Remove h
unreacted polymer
Remove crude lactide as vapour
Partially condense crude lactide →Remove lactide impurity as a vapou
Purify crude lactide in a distillation column →Remove lactide impuri
Remove purified lactide as high-boiling bottoms from the column
Before examining the claims for PLA fibres in comparison with other
crop-based polymers, we should refresh our memories with a review of the
routes to other crop-based polymers in the form of cotton and rayon
Rayon in similar block diagram form would be:
Seeds, Soil, Water, Carbon dioxide, Sunlight
Wood Pulp
Cellulose Solution
Impure fibre
Pure Wet Fibre
Bales of Lyocell or Viscose
Cotton in similar block diagram form would be:
Seeds, Soil, Water, Carbon dioxide, Sunlight
↓Grow- months↓
Cotton bolls
Raw Cotton Bales
This is clearly the simplest route to crop-based polymers for fibre
end-uses. However for many of these end-uses the raw cotton has to be
bleached to remove the waxy substances that prevent it from being
absorbent. This is done either in fibre form for waddings and nonwovens or
in fabric form for apparel:
Raw Cotton Bales/Fabrics
Impure fibre/Fabrics
Pure Wet Fibre/Fabrics
Bleached Cotton Bales/Fabrics
PLA Claims , and Comparisons with Cellulose
Fibres from the first mentioned EcoPLA polymer were said to be:
Reminiscent of PET or PS in some forms and of PP and PE in others.
Capable of giving fabrics with the feel of silk and the durability of
Fully biodegradable under composting conditions.
Convertible into nonwovens by dry- air- wet- spunmelt- laying systems.
Capable of giving improved resilience, moisture transport, breathability
and wet strength.
The price was, in 1998, said to be $3-6/kg, but capable of reduction to
$1.1/kg at full-scale production.
Additional claims for NatureWorks recently announced were:
Value-added natural-based fibres.
Bridges the gap between silk, wool, cotton and the synthetics
Superior handle and touch
"The comfort of natural fibres with the performance of synthetics"
Controlled degradability, enhanced wicking, low linting.
Excellent UV resistance and elastic recovery.
Reduced flammability with low smoke and heat generation
Nonwoven applications were listed: fibrefill, crop covers, geotextiles,
wipes, hygiene, medical, diapers and binder fibres.
Fibre Properties
On the information currently available, PLA looks like an excellent fibre
with the right technical credentials to replace polypropylene, and maybe
some polyester in nonwovens. As noted by Carothers, the melting point
still appears too low for it to challenge the supremacy of aromatic
polyester in mainstream textiles. Furthermore the hydrolytic stability
under conditions close to some laundering, dyeing and finishing processes
is borderline. Nevertheless, PLA marketing now seems to be concentrating
first on higher value textile applications, and it's biodegradability is
not featuring so prominently. There are some interesting parallels with
lyocell market development here, lyocell s fibrillation initially being
seen as a problem in dyeing, finishing and laundering but an advantage in
nonwovens. PLA s solubility in alkali could yet turn out to be a major
selling point in applications not yet thought of.
The fact that PLA has a melting point at all is, in comparison with
cellulose, a fundamentally important advantage in fibre manufacture and
disposable nonwoven processes. In durable products, its resilience and
abrasion resistance will be equally important. On the other hand, while
PLA is more wettable than PET, it does not absorb useful amounts of water.
The recent claims to a 210 oC MPt PLA require a 50/50 melt-blend of pure
D- and L- lactides which crystallize with their helical structures
interlocking. This technique, first described by Dupont, has yet to be
made on a commercial scale.
Unlike cellulose, PLA is largely resistant to attack by microorganisms in
soil or sewage under ambient conditions. The polymer must first be
hydrolysed at elevated temperatures to reduce the molecular weight before
biodegradation can commence. Claims of biodegradability can therefore only
be made where a composting infrastructure exists. Data from CDP shows that
composting at 60 oC causes hydrolytic degradation, which over 10 days
depolymerises and embrittles the polymer sufficiently for it to fragment.
Complete biodegradation to CO 2 occurs over the next 30-40 days.
Cellulose fibres degrade more rapidly and also degrade under ambient
conditions when buried in topsoil or in sewage processing. Cotton and
rayon are similar.
CDP pledges to support the development of composting infrastructure in
those countries (e.g.USA) that don t have one. However over the last 12
months, the marketing emphasis seems to have changed in favour of durable
products; the biodegradability of the fibre getting fewer mentions.
PLA burns like cellulose to yield 8400 Btu/lb energy.
Fossil Fuel Usage
The CDP-PLA process is said to use 20-40% less fossil fuel than
fossil-fuel-based polymers. This appears to be less than the saving to be
expected from obtaining the monomer from something other than fossil-fuel
and CDP admit that the process currently uses more conversion energy than
conventional polyester manufacture. In the CIRFS ecoprofiles study,
polyester was estimated to use 80 MJ/kg of fossil-fuel energy per tonne of
fibre compared with 54 MJ/kg for for viscose fibre. CDP recently 13 quoted
57 MJ/kg for PLA fibre and pledged to reduce this to 34 MJ/kg and then 5
MJ/kg by adopting alternative energy sources in future plants. (Of course
any fibre or polymer plant could choose to switch from fossil-fuel and
achieve similar reductions, at a price.)
Reduced Global warming
This is due to the corn absorbing CO2 during growth. The CO 2 is released
back to the atmosphere on degradation, so over the full life-cycle, CO 2
neutral may be a more accurate claim. Trees do the same, and any process
based on fresh biomass will show an advantage over those based on
pre-historic biomass.
Land/Chemical Usage
PLA requires 3100 m 2 land per tonne of fibre 7. US corn production used
about 260kgs of fertilizer/Ha in 1996 equivalent to 840 kgs fertilizer
per tonne of PLA fibre.
Rayon (South African forests) requires 3000 m 2 land per tonne of fibre.

Rayon (European forests) requires 8000 m 2 land per tonne of fibre.

Cotton ( Texas) requires about 20,000 m 2 land per tonne of fibre
Cotton (California 17) requires 8,000 m 2 land per tonne of fibre
Cotton (World Average 17) requires 15,384m 2 per tonne of fibre
Cotton requires 700-1100 kg fertilizers/tonne fibre 16, along with
herbicides, insecticides, fungicides, plant growth regulators, and
harvest aid chemicals (defoliants). The land has to be of good quality,
well irrigated and could be used for food.
Trees can be grown with no irrigation or chemical inputs on land
unsuitable for food crops.
Post consumer recycling
PLA can be hydrolysed back to lactic acid and repolymerised, the economics
of such a process being dependent on the price of fresh lactide. There is
no equivalent economic route for cellulose, except via the atmosphere.
Other issues
CDP pledges to address other environmental issues related to the PLA
They will encourage the use of variable rate fertiliser technology to
reduce farming emissions.
They will try to develop processes to use non-food agricultural sources
of dextrose.
They will address the Genetically Modified corn issue. (Cotton has
similar problems with GM varieties being mixed with non-GM. Some
consumer organisations are concerned by the resulting inability to
choose GM-free products. The trees used for rayon production have not
been genetically modified.)
Pollution from manufacturing processes
In life-cycle inventory terms, a comparison of the effluents from the PLA
route with those from the viscose and lyocell routes is clearly important,
and is an area where PLA should show an advantage. CDP has already made
the Life Cycle Inventory for the Blair plant available to customers and
pledged to make it available to the public. At the time of writing it had
not been received. A few general observations may however be helpful.
Wood pulping and corn processing have similar problems of separating
biomass into a variety of useful materials. Corn processing appears to
have a clear advantage because milder treatments can effect the necessary
separations, and the majority of its constituents have economic value.
Starch processing and fermentation are well-understood processes whereas
wood chemistry is much more complex. Separating cellulose from lignin is
difficult and today s processes use aggressive chemicals and produce
effluent that is hard to deal with. Furthermore the second most important
constituent of wood, the lignin currently has little or no economic value
due to the low value placed on fossil reserves.
Technology already exists to allow most of the constituents of wood to be
harvested with much reduced environmental impact, and the US Department of
Energy are funding several schemes. The fossil-fuel price increases needed
to accelerate the development of PLA will also accelerate the investments
in these new wood-processing plants.
PLA, like polyester, is likely to remain ahead of cellulose when the
effluents from fibre manufacture are considered. While lyocell is a great
improvement on viscose, it has to be regenerated in water and will always
need washing and drying.
Economic Factors
The production of dextrose and lactic acid from biomass is well
established and already a major industry. Lactic acid for polyester
manufacture has to compete with the other uses of dextrose, such as
sweeteners, and as a precursor for ethanol, citric acid and vitamin C.
Similarly, the lactide route to polyester has to compete with the other
established uses of lactic acid, in food additives, solvents,
pharmaceuticals, emulsifiers, chelating agents, cosmetics, propylene
glycol, methyl ethyl acrylate, and several fine chemicals.
Worldwide consumption of lactic acid was between 130,000 and 150,000
tonnes in 1999, about half being used in foodstuffs. Plastics,
emulsifiers, pharmaceuticals and cosmetics accounted for about 10%-15%
each. Food grade material, unsuitable for plastics or fibres cost about
90c/lb in the USA or 65 c/lb in Europe where Chinese material had
depressed prices. The cost of the purer lactic acid needed for PLA
production was estimated to be $2-3/lb. Annual lactic acid market growth
was put at 15% per year.
PLA polymer currently costs around $5/kg and as mentioned earlier, is
expected to fall to around $2/kg when production reaches 390,000
tonnes/year, estimated to be in 2008. If it converts to fibre with the
efficiency of a regular polyester resin, the staple fibre price could be
as low as $2.4/kg. At today s prices, this would put it on a par with
those other crop-based polymers, bleached cotton, viscose rayon and
lyocell: i.e. about twice the price of the fossil-fuelled synthetics.
CDP has suggested $1.1-$2.2/kg for the resin from the Blair plant in 2002,
although more recently has indicated $1.1/kg will only be possible when
cheaper waste biomass can be processed into dextrose. This could not
easily be done in the Blair location.
This is an interim report of an ongoing study and any conclusions must be
provisional and rather subjective. The promised life cycle inventory on
CDP s PLA process remains to be published and may well contain information
that invalidates some of the thinking here. The following observations are
nevertheless offered to summarise the work so far:
Pre-historic biomass, on which the 20 th century industrial economy was
founded, will, in this century, lose its pre-eminent position as a
source of chemical building blocks to freshly grown biomass.
Three major components of fresh biomass, cellulose, lignin and
carbohydrates are between them capable of providing precursors for
plastics, fibres, fuels and chemicals and will do so increasingly as the
price of fossil-fuel increases.
Cellulose is not only the most abundant polymer in biomass. It grows as
fibres e.g cotton, linen, hemp, kenaf, ramie etc., or as wood that can
be converted into fibres by purification, dissolution and
Carbohydrates in agricultural crops can be degraded to sugars, fermented
to lactic acid and repolymerised to make, amongst other things, a
synthetic aliphatic polyester, eg CDP PLA. (Some plants and bacteria
synthesise polyesters directly and other biomass utilisation projects
are based on their optimisation and extraction).
Wood processing technology currently concentrates on extracting the
cellulose, and generally burns (to reduce fossil fuel usage) or rejects
as effluents other potentially valuable materials.
Corn processing technology already separates corn into many edible
materials, some of which are converted into monomers from which polymers
can be made.
PLA resin and dissolving pulp are both nature-based polymers ready for
use in fibre forming processes; pulp having the more direct connection
with natural processes.
PLA is easily and cleanly convertible into fibres using melt-spinning
technology, whereas converting woodpulp to fibre is more complex, uses
more energy and for the viscose route at least, produces more effluent.
PLA claims environmental advantages over PET due to its reduced use of
fossil reserves, it s compostability, and its production, albeit
indirectly, from an agricultural product.
Cellulose has environmental advantages over PLA due to being present in
nature as a fibre-forming polymer, being easily biodegradable in all
processes and (in the case of rayon) using less fossil reserves,
fertilisers, pesticides, and agricultural land than PLA.
Cellulose in the form of cotton uses least fossil-fuel, but its low cost
is due to high yields per hectare achieved by the intensive use of
water, pesticides, fertilisers and defoliants.
While not a current problem for US agriculture, farmland will become
increasingly needed for food production.
In many textile applications, polyester/cellulose blends provide an
ideal combination of durability, easy care, texture and comfort. The
current low-melting point aside, PLA would be equally good.
In nonwoven applications, PLA being more wettable than polyester or
polypropylene could make an excellent coverstock or acquisition layer
fibre. Cellulose is not only wettable, but highly absorbent in
PLA binders could latex-bond cellulosics: PLA fibres could thermally
bond cellulosics.
And Finally
The US Department of Agriculture is backing research into both corn
and wood based routes to renewable energy and materials.
Corn and PLA are currently centre-stage thanks to the publicity
surrounding the CDP Blair investment, but forestry and cellulose,
despite a poor image related to past pulp and paper production
methods, can also yield fibres, and chemicals -including PLA.
PLA has all the strength and processing advantages of a thermoplastic
synthetic fibre: the higher melting point versions being technically
capable of replacing polyester.
Polyester/cotton has been the most successful textile blend of the 20
th Century: High Melting PLA/lyocell blends could replace it with
significant environmental advantages.
The rate of development of nonwoven products based on PLA, will, like
the development of nonwovens based on lyocell, depend on the relative
attractiveness of textile and nonwoven applications to the fibre
Copyright: Calvin Woodings Consulting Ltd. 2000
Corn and Agricultural Vision: Renewable Chemical Building Blocks for the
Future - PR Newswire, April 19 th 2000
Dow and Cargill in Joint Venture for New Resins , Financial Times, 25 Nov
Bonsignore PV et al, "Polylactic acid degradable plastics, coatings and
binders" TAPPI Nonwovens Conference, Marco Island, 1992
Wadsworth L et al, "Melt processing of PLA resin into nonwovens", 3 rd
Annual TANDEC Conference, Knoxville, 1993.
US Patent 5,702,826, Ehret P et al, Dec 30 th 1997, assigned to Fiberweb.
P Ehret, "Deposa Nonwovens: Deposable disposables" INSIGHT 96 San Antonio.

Bogaert and Coszach, "Polylactic Acids: New polymers for novel

applications" Speciality Polymers Session, INDEX99 Geneva.
The Dow Chemical Company, Press Release 11/1/2000.
Lunt J, Shafer, A, "Polylactic Acid Polymers from Corn: Potential
Applications in the Textile Industry", Cargill Dow Polymers LLC,
Lunt, J; Polylactic Acid Polymers: Technology and Applications for the
Fiber Industry , Nonwovens Network Seminar, Wakefield, June 2000.
USP 6,005,067 (Dec 21 st 1999) to Cargill Inc
CDP Product information -www.cdpoly.com - Jan 2000
Polylactide Polymers: Technology and Applications , Lunt, J, CDP LLC,
paper at INTC 2000, Dallas, September 27 th 2000
Ecoprofiles of Selected Man-Made Fibres , CIRFS (The international
committee for rayon and synthetic fibres) Dec 1997.
SAPPI - Private Communication
Clean Production of Rayon- An Eco-Inventory Josef Schmidtbauer,
Lenzinger Berichte No. 76, 1997
Spaar T, MSc Thesis, Environmental Science, Swiss Federal Institute
ofTechnology, Zurich.
Lactic Acid Prices Falter as Competition Toughens , Chemical Market
Reporter, 1 March 1999
Home - Who are we ? - Patents Etc. - Publications - Success Stories -
Contact - Terms Of Use
© 2005 CWC Ltd - Design by Pixelbase.co.uk