Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Mid-Semester Assessment
Student Name
Chau Thi Minh Trang- S3210047
The event: In May 1945, German ended its occupation in the Netherlands, hence, taking
this advantage, Indonesian decided to raise an army for their liberation. Learning form pervious
successful Japanese posters, Indonesian leaders used propaganda posters with the image about
the Indonesian army and the message “And now Indonesia, enlist as a Volunteer”, thus, the
liberation army was recruited noticeably (‘War posters 1940-1945’ 2010).
1. 2 Apollo 11-the first flight landed the first human on the Moon (1969)
On July 16, 1969, Apollo 11 was launched into space. There were three astronauts
onboard including Michael Collins, Edwin “Buzz” Aldrin and Neil Armstrong. The space rocket
had been launched successfully from Cape Kennedy, Florida aiming at the Moon. According to
the estimate, millions of people around the America were watching this event. After an intensive
roar, the spaceflight took off into the sky, taking the hopes of “landing the first man on the
moon” with it (BBC News, 1969). Two hours and forty four minutes after the take off, the space
rocket speed up and reached 24,545 Mph, taking the astronauts out of the orbit and coming
straight to the Moon. According to the US Vice President Spiro Agnew, this event opens a "new
era of civilization".
On July 20, 1969, the first human put the first step on the moon surface. This moment has
been watching by tens of millions of viewers so far. On July 24, 1969, after crashing through out
the earth’s atmosphere at 25,000 Mph, bearing the heat nearing 4000i F, the space rocket fell to
the Pacific, several miles from the recovery ship. The first trip attempting to land the first human
on the Moon was successful (Time, 1969).
By broadcasting this event through BBC TV, audience was able to see the scene, and had
strong feeling about the first man landing on the Moon.
Typhoon Babs, one of the worst natural disaster occurred in October 1998, went through
the center of Philippines (Los Angles Times, 1998a). Usually, Philippines is truck by tens of
cyclones every year, however, at that time, due to a phenomenon called La Nina, it had to suffer
one of the worst storms in its history. Babs destroyed everything from houses to people. In
Manila, many public facilities such as schools, offices, hospitals, roads were closed. Babs’
devastation caused extremely bad effects to the power and communication lines, many regions
near the center lost the electricity and phone lines (Los Angles Times, 1998b). Also, according to
the President Joseph Estrada, it caused floods and landslides, which destroyed crops, including
coconut plantation and rice fields, the value of which could be up to a hundred million USD
(BBC News, 1998a). Urgent evacuation had been executed immediately; more than 300,000
people were being forced to leave their homes. After destroying the center of Philippines, leaving
more than 124 deaths, most of who were buried deeply under the mudslides, 100,000 homeless
people, thousands of collapsed houses and buildings, Babs now was heading toward southern
China and Hong Kong (BBC News, 1998b)
Online newspaper was used as the most significant tool to circulate disaster’s
information to viewers.
On 30 September 1999, at 10.35 AM, the nuclear accident occurred in small nuclear plant
in Tokaimura, about 130km northeast of Tokyo, Japan (BBC News 1999). The accident was
caused by mistake of three workers when they enrich the radium batch to 18.8% - U235, much
higher than previous using –less than 5%. These workers had a lack of training and proper
qualification, hence, they do not understand to the damaging effects of the 18.8% enrichment
application (‘Tokai-mura Criticality Accident’ 2007). There is no explosion, even the amount of
nuclear fission released over control. Three workers were contamination radiation poison and
other 46 workers suffered less contamination after uncontrolled nuclear chain reaction (Los
Angeles Times 1999). After 58 minutes of the incident, local authorities had received an
informing form the plant (Los Angeles Times 1999). The Kyodo News had broadcasted
frequently the news and warning from the Government (BBC News 1999). At least 160 people
within 350 meter radius of the facility were ordered to evacuate. Further, within a radius of
10km, residents were asked to stay in home, shut all windows and limit using fan or air condition
in order to avoid substance from the air. If they have to go out, make sure that the car windows
are closed. The restriction was launched for more than a day until official news declared danger
had passed in Tokaimura (Los Angeles Times 1999).
Part II
During the war, propaganda is considered as a key tool to encourage entire nation support
to the war effort (Aulich 2010). “A picture is worth a thousand words”. Indeed, words are
powerful but sometimes the images are better when they can reach the viewers’ attention and
touch their emotion. Therefore, a poster with an impressive image and simple and direct message
through the war can struggle for “heart” and “mind” (Aulich 2007). In the first phase of
liberation process on May 1945, the propaganda poster “And now Indonesia, enlist as a
Volunteer” with the image of Indonesian army is considered as the “weapon of mass
communication” (Aulich 2007). It takes an important role in not just call more volunteers, but
also encourage the Indonesian morale to be ready their liberation (‘War posters 1940-1945’
2010). At that moment, the communication technologies in Indonesia were very limited; hence,
the propaganda poster is the most popular media by the flow from urban to rural areas.
Later, a thousand posters were continuing used in next phases of the liberation. On 17
August 1945, Indonesia has a complete liberation, ending 60-year occupation of the Netherlands
(Viet Bao 2005). This is claimed that the propaganda posters contributed practically to the
victory of Indonesian in 1945 (‘War posters 1940-1945’ 2010).
2.2 Apollo 11-the first flight landed the first human on the Moon (1969)-Broadcast TV
BBC TV officially broadcasted live the event of Man’s first landing on the moon from
Lime Grove Studios in London in July, 1969 (Gilmour, 2009). The producers created a program
named Apollo 11 consisting of 27 hours coverage the moon landing from start to the end. Patrick
Moore, a presenter said that this was the “most exciting event” he has ever reported and it’s great
to be here to contribute on this superb documentary (Harvison, 2009). TV broadcast gave
audience the feeling that they were able to see the truth. Also, according to Harvison 2009, this
program already made an “awe-inspiring story, arresting, and intelligent” to viewers. However,
live broadcast of the first moon landing had its disadvantages. The quality of the video was not
good enough because of the limitation of the signal. Thus, it could not transmit accurately
images to audiences. Compared to other communication technologies, TV broadcast really gave
the audience the impression about this event.
Because of the strong destruction of Typhoon Babs, many remote areas of the central
Philippines already lost communication (Los Angles Times, 1998b). With the widely circulation
of newspaper online such as BBC, CNN, and Los Angles Times, the information about this
natural disaster was sent to people around the world. Immediately, any newspaper online from
many countries started with the big headline about this event, and the number of victims,
homeless people were updated frequently. Newspaper online already played an important role in
delivering news to victim’s families, but also calling for supports. Beside that, newspaper online
was considered as useful data for searching, and storing easily.
The majority of public outside Vientiane – capital of Laos does not access the internet or
read national daily newspapers, such as Vientiane Times or Vientiane Mai (Lao Voices 2007).
Even national newspapers are sold in towns but most Laotian does not choose to buy newspapers
when they have to afford the lives’ cost (Lao Voices 2007). There is no local newspaper, most
accidents are spread by word of mouth, sometimes are posted in national news sites, Prabang , a
blogger in Travel blog said (Travel Blog 2010). Be similar with internet and newspaper, mobile
and land line phone also are available in provinces, but not popular because of its cost.
Therefore, in provinces, the information usually is spread by word of mouth practice among
public every day (Lao Voices 2007). Word of mouth is doubted about its accuracy compared
with the national news, however, due to its free cost and high speed, word of mouth is still used
significantly in the case in Khammuan province. There are no photo along with many bizarre and
unclear details around the boat’s story, such as an unknown fisherman and his dream, a boat
becoming quick hardened when pull onto the land, and strange pleasant smell from dead body of
two-head calf. People still believe it, and flock to the temple to see the boat. “I was surprised to
see a big crowd surrounding the boat,” said the abbot (Samsomboun 2009). This event is a
striking example for effective worth of mouth practice in Lao in the current.
The question raised in here is that “Indeed, Chinese authorities removed all information
about this attack in media coverage for opposing the copycat or hiding the truth about the
Chinese society under governing of Communist Party?”. The state reports through five school
attacks ignored the wider causes of the attacks and illustrating them as “isolated incidents”
caused by mental-illness individuals (BBC news 2010). Some Chinese commentators suggested
that it might be the revenge on society which heavily controlled by authorities of Communist
Party. Besides that, others think that the big gap between rich and poor in the “rat-race” of
Chinese economy can be a possible factor behind the attack series within only two months (CNN
news 2010).
Part III
Analysis of a Digital Communication Technology: Online video in the protest of Daewoo
workers at Pupyong (2001)
The protest of Daewoo workers in 2001 is the striking example for unfair application of
labor laws that caused many dispute and conflicts with the workers, trade unions and the Korean
government. There are many traditional communication technologies, such as TV, newspaper,
worth of mouth and also digital techs, such as online newspapers, pictures and forums used
during this event, however, this paper aims to analyze the roles of cell-phone video – the
propaganda technology and also compare its features with other technologies. Finally, the paper
discusses about the way Korean government used to duel with the problems caused by the video.
Firstly, the paper examines broadly the prominent characteristic of cell-phone in order to explain
why cell-phone video used significantly in the protest. If in the past, cell-phone is essential as
‘battery-powered microprocessor’ with one transmitter and receiver cell-phone now might
dominate the future internet (Keshav 2010). By feature of high speed and convenience, cell-
phone helps people around the world interacting efficiently (Malek, 2005). In the ‘bloody’
protest, the cell-phone allowed people in the strike and those were not presented in this struggle
stay in touch. Thank to camera application of cell-phone, a participant in this strike had recorded
a video about the police’s attack over Daewoo workers. This video was sent to the mass public as
a message that the protester wanted to transmit.
The cell-phone video was made by an activist witness, not famous journalist corporation
like BBC, CNN or New York Times. This video opened a new kind of media war - Daewoo
protesters had successfully used videos against the police….”since then, everybody comes armed
with camera” (Kyoto journal 2005). Every citizen can be a reporter. They had their own
appropriate technologies following their movements (Kyoto journal 2005).
Right away the attack, this ‘amateur’ video was sent to Korean publics and upload on alternative
websites in Korea (Kyoto journal 2005). The highlighted feature of video camera is connected to
live net-casting devices, so the circulation of these video will be quick, inexpensive and
authentic. At this point, the cell-phone video is more effective than word of mouth which is
doubt about the accuracy, limited by the distance and takes time for physical communication. In
addition, this video is more reliable than the information on traditional television and newspapers
which is censored by the government.
South Korea is the only nation whose online alternative newspapers had impact on the
government’s election. Since the video was broadcasted widely, Korean government had to duel
with the noticeable increase of anti-government waves. Dan Byong-ho, the head of the militant
Korea Confederation of Trade Unions also had a speech against the government. Dan said “the
workers are the only victims of the government's wrong economic policy” (BBC News 2001a).
The government is demanded an apology, clear explanation and responsibility for their ‘brutal’
action (BBC News 2001b & Dwtubon 2001 ). Not just in Korea, online communities around the
world were shocked by the video from South Korea, whose the President – Kim Dae-jung was
received the Nobel Peace Prize award recently (The Human Right Feature 2001). The video is an
evident for the economic crisis and the conflict between labor unions and the government in
Korea. Also, it revealed the truth about brutality of Kim government who lay with “sweet
advertises of democracy” for his Nobel Prize (The Nadir 2001).
Be different from China and India, Korean Government do not solve problems by
filtering or ban the online sources. In the case of Daewoo workers’ protest, the video was still
widely circulated on next days, until now, it still exists on many alternative webs in Korea
(Dwtubon 2001). Perhaps, they did not care about the public opinions. Despite the existence of
anti-government waves in this protest, the police of Kim government were continued to suppress
the workers. On 19th February, the number of participants grew up to 3,000 including students,
workers and activists for denouncing the government’s attacks (The Nadir 2001). To duel with
this problem, the government had severer actions responding the protesters. The case is
prominent example for the open and equal access to the internet in South Korea, the nation with
‘un-open’ and ‘un-equal’ political democracy.
References:
Ahmed, M 2008, “Citizen Journalists told to stop using Twitter to update on Bombay attacks”,
The Times, 27 November, viewed 11 August 2010,
<http://technology.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/tech_and_web/article5245059.ece>
Archives of global protest 2001, “South Korea: Daewoo Workers Strike”, Archives of global
protests, February, viewed 10 August 2010,
<http://www.nadir.org/nadir/initiativ/agp/free/imf/asia/korea/index.htm>
Arrington, M 2008, “First Hand Accounts of Terrorist Attacks in India on Twitter, Flicker”,
TechCrunch, 26 November, viewed 11 August 2010,
<http://techcrunch.com/2008/11/26/first-hand-accounts-of-terrorist-attacks-in-india-on-twitter/>
Aulich, J 2007, War posters: Weapons of mass communication, Thames & Hudson Ltd, UK.
Booden, C, 2010, ‘China mostly silent on latest school attack’, 13 May, the Santa Cruz Sentinel,
viewed 10 August 2010, <http://www.santacruzsentinel.com/world/ci_15744255>
BBC News 1969, “1969: Apollo 11 takes off for the Moon”, BBC News, 16 July, viewed 13
August, 2010,
<http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/july/16/newsid_4091000/4091551.stm>
BBC News 1998a, “China next for Typhoon Babs”, BBC News, 24 October, viewed 15 August,
2010, <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/198673.stm>
BBC News 1998b, “Typhoon Babs ravages the Philippines”, BBC News, 24 October, viewed 15
August, 2010, < http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/200375.stm>
BBC News 1999, ‘Nuclear accidents shakes Japan’, BBC News, 30 September, viewed 11
August 2010, <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/461446.stm>
BBC News 2001a, ‘Daewoo workers hunt boss in France’, BBC News, 20 February, viewed 14
August 2010, <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/1187587.stm>.
BBC News 2001b, ‘Daewoo demonstrate against police violence’, BBC News, 14 February,
viewed 14 August 2010, <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/1277161.stm>.
BBC News 2008, “Mumbai rocked by deadly attacks”, BBC News, 27 November, viewed 11
August 2010, <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/7751160.stm>.
BBC News 2010, ‘China children hacked to death in new school attack’, BBC News, 12 May,
viewed 11 August 2010, < http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/8676613.stm>.
CBS News 2010, ‘China School Attack Leaves 9 Dead’, CBS News, 12 May, viewed 13 August
2010, <http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/05/12/world/worldwatch/main6474808.shtml>
CNN News 2010, ‘China prepared for school attack’, CNN News, 30 May, viewed 11 August
2010, < http://edition.cnn.com/2010/WORLD/asiapcf/04/30/china.school.attack/index.html>
China View 2008, “59-hour Mumbai terror siege comes to end”, China View, 29 November,
viewed 11 August 2010, <http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2008-
11/29/content_10430375.htm>
Dwtubon 2001, ‘Ignoring the Court’s Judegement, the Government Illegally Attacked Daewoo
Workers’, Nodong Net, 15 February, viewed 14 August 2010,
<http://dwtubon.nodong.net/english/main.html>.
Gilmour, D 2009, “My moon-landing jam session”, Guardian, 2 July, viewed 13 August 2010,
<http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2009/jul/02/apollo-11-pink-floyd-session>
Global Voices 2008, “Mumbai, India attacks 2008”, Global Voices, viewed 11 August 2010,
<http://globalvoicesonline.org/specialcoverage/2008-special-coverage/mumbai-india-blasts-
2008/>
Hadl, G 2001, “Korean Protest Culture”, Kyoto Journal, viewed 10 August 2010,
<http://www.kyotojournal.org/kjselections/koreanprotest.html>
Harvison, A 2009, “Apollo 11 – A Night to Remember DVD review”, DenofGeek, 5 Jun, viewed
13 August, 2010,
<http://www.denofgeek.com/Reviews/262459/apollo_11_a_night_to_remember_dvd_review.ht
ml>
Independent media center 2001, “South Korea workers struggle against layoffs”, Independent
media center, 22 February, viewed 10 August 2010,
<http://www.indymedia.org/pt/2001/02/100162.shtml>
‘Japan's Nuclear Criticality Accident at a Fuel Conversion Facility”, Japan Atomic Industrial
Forum, 9 December, viewed 8 August 2010, < http://www.jaif.or.jp/english/news/1999/1209-
1.html>
Kenedy, H 2008, “Gunmen attack hotels, train station in deadly Mumbai wave of terror”, NY
Daily News, 27 November, viewed 11 August 2010,
<http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/2008/11/26/2008-11-
26_gunmen_attack_hotels_train_station_in_de.html>
Los Angeles Times 1999, ‘Japanese nuclear accident –September 30, 1999’, Los Angles Times, 1
October, viewed 10 August 2010,
<http://www.international.ucla.edu/eas/newsfile/jpnnuclear/991001-lat1.htm>.
Los Angles Times 1998a, “Killer Typhoon Babs Forces Evacuations”, Los Angles Times, 22
October, viewed 15 August, 2010, < http://articles.latimes.com/1998/oct/22/news/mn-35119>
Macleod, C 2010, ‘China responds to rash of school attacks’, 12 May, USA TODAY, viewed 13
August 2010, <http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2010-05-12-china-students-killed_N.htm?
loc=interstitialskip>
Richburg, K.C 2009, ‘China’s netizen hold authorities new standard’, 9 November, the
Washington Post, viewed 12 August 2010, <http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-
dyn/content/article/2009/11/08/AR2009110818166.html>
Sangsomboun, P 2009, ‘Mysterious boat resurfaces’, Vientiane Times, 18 July, viewed 5 August
2010, < http://www.vientianetimes.com/2009/07/18/mysterious-boat-resurfaces/>
Sengupta, S 2008, “At Least 100 Dead in India Terror Attacks”, The New York Times, 26
November, viewed 11 August 2010,
<http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/27/world/asia/27mumbai.html>
Time 1969, “To the Moon and Beyond: Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin”, Time, viewed 13
August, 2010,
<http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0, 28804, 1981290_1981366_1981789,
00.html#ixzz0wv8yiGYe>
‘The Daewoo workers need you Support!’ 2001, South Korea: Daewoo Workers Strike, viewed
10 August 2010, <http://www.nadir.org/nadir/initiativ/agp/free/imf/asia/korea/index.htm>.
Travel Blog 2010, ‘Lao Dogs, Police Motorbike Cruisers and Dirty Mekong Beach Retreats’, 29
April, viewed 7 August 2010, <http://www.travelblog.org/Asia/Laos/West/Luang-
Prabang/blog-493931.html >.
Viet Bao 2005, ‘Ha Lan cong nhan ngay doc lap cua Indonesia sau 60 nam’, Viet Bao, 16
August, viewed 1 August 2010, < http://vietbao.vn/The-gioi/Ha-Lan-cong-nhan-ngay-doc-lap-
cua-Indonesia-sau-60-nam/70020712/159/>
World Nuclear Association 2007, ‘Tokai-mura Criticality Accident’ , July, viewed 11 August
2010, <http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf37.html>
‘Workers’ rights fade in glare of Nobel halo’ 2001, Human Rights Features, viewed 14 August
2010, <http://www.hrdc.net/sahrdc/hrfquarterly/Jan_march_2002/skorea.htm>
World Socialist Website 2001a, “South Korean government orders massive police assault on
Daewoo workers”, World Socialist Website, 24 February, viewed 10 August 2010,
<http://xml.wsws.org/articles/2001/feb2001/dae-f24.shtml>
World Socialist Website 2001b, “South Korean president boasts to US investors of crackdown
on Daewoo workers”, World Socialist Website, 17 March, viewed 10 August 2010,
<http://xml.wsws.org/articles/2001/mar2001/kor-m17.shtml>
World Socialist Website 2001c, “Daewoo workers battle police in South Korea”, World Socialist
Website, 3 March, viewed 10 August 2010, <http://xml.wsws.org/articles/2001/mar2001/lab-
m03.shtml>