Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
8-1
PROTECTING THE WORKER:
RESPIRATORS AND PROTECTIVE CLOTHING
Respiratory hazards are generally divided into two categories--toxic contaminants and
oxygen deficiency. The potential for either or both must be considered when addressing
respiratory protection.
Normal air contains about 21 percent (20.9%) oxygen. For breathing purposes, air
should not contain less than 19.5 percent or more than 23.5 percent oxygen. Oxygen
deficiency generates a variety of symptoms, ranging from increased breathing and
pulse rate to unconsciousness and death.
Toxic contaminants are the more common category of respiratory hazards on asbestos
abatement jobs. Those toxic contaminants are generally subdivided into three
categories, particulates, gaseous materials and vapors. Asbestos fibers are an example
of the particulate subcategory, carbon monoxide is an example of the gaseous
subcategory and mastic removal solvent is an example of the vapor subcategory. It is
possible to have all of these hazardous substances, plus others in a work area at the
same time.
8-2
The asbestos abatement industry is actually based on these first two steps. Buildings
and structures are surveyed to assess potential asbestos hazards. When a potential
asbestos hazard exists, a contractor is called upon to reduce or eliminate the hazard
through removal, encapsulation, or enclosure. Thus the third step, respirators, is
generally avoided for the building occupants.
Several hazard reduction techniques are used inside the abatement area, including
wetting with amended water, using negative air machines, prompt bagging of removal
materials, wet cleaning and HEPA vacuuming. These techniques do reduce the air-
borne fiber concentrations during removal projects, but they may not get them down to
the 0.01 f/cc level which is generally considered clean. Thus, the employer (contractor)
must proceed to the third hazard control step and provide an adequate respiratory
program for the workers. The respirators must be selected and the program established
based on OSHA standards, the actual or anticipated air sampling results, and other
guidelines (i.e., respirator manufacturers).
As required by the OSHA Respiratory Protection standard (29 CFR 1910.134), only
approved respirators may be considered during the selection process. And, the
respirators must be approved for protection against the specific hazard -- asbestos, for
example. The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) is the
testing agency which approves respirators. If the entire respirator assembly, including
cartridges/filters/hoses, passes their test, then they issue a joint NIOSH approval
number for that specific respirator assembly. The NIOSH approval number (TC
number) is like a serial number. It describes a certain model from a certain
manufacturer with certain filters.
CATEGORIES OF RESPIRATORS
There are three major classes/categories of respirators, plus subcategories for each
category. The major categories are:
• Air-Purifying
• Air-Supplied
• Self-Contained
AIR-PURIFYING RESPIRATORS
Air purifying respirators remove limited concentrations of air contaminants from the
breathing air, but do nothing to improve (or change) the oxygen content. Thus, they can
only be used in atmospheres where there is enough oxygen, and where air
contaminants do not exceed the specified range of the respirator and cartridge.
8-3
These respirators generally consist of a soft silicone facepiece and replaceable filters or
cartridges. Two different cartridge types for air purifying respirators are the mechanical
filter type and the chemical cartridge type. The mechanical filter is designed to protect
against particulate matter such as dust and asbestos fibers. The chemical cartridge is
used to protect against light concentrations of chemicals, such as solvent vapors. There
are even combination models approved for both types of protection.
Respirator facepieces (including those for the air-purifying category) are used to further
describe specific subcategories, based on the construction and face coverage. The
major subcategories are:
• Half-Mask
• Full-Face
High efficiency Particulate Air (HEPA) cartridges must be used when asbestos exposure
is a possibility. The HEPA cartridges are approved by NIOSH at a minimum efficiency
level of 99.97% on particulate down to 0.3 microns in diameter. These cartridges are
color coded purple or magenta in color, and are designated “P100”. P100 cartridges
have the highest level of particulate protection, with no exclusions.
The Half-Mask respirator covers half of the face--from under the chin to the bridge of the
nose. All, half-mask respirators are NIOSH approved. It is still necessary to choose the
correct approved model for the identified air contaminant.
The Full-Face respirator covers from under the chin up to the forehead. This greater
coverage provides a better face fit, higher degree of protection, and gives eye
protection. Many full-face respirators have four or more straps. Regardless of the
number of straps, the respirator should be put on by placing the chin into the chin cup,
then tightening the straps going from the bottom to the top.
A special sub -category of air purifying respirator is the Powered Air Purifying Respirator
(PAPR). This respirator combines the air-purifying respirator, with positive pressure
protection in the facepiece and has become the standard respirator for Class I Work
(removal of TSI or surfacing).
8-4
An advantage of using a powered air-purifying respirator is that it supplies air at a
positive pressure within the facepiece, helmet, or hood, so that any leak is outward.
Therefore, they provide a much higher degree of protection than do most half-mask and
full-face air purifying respirators.
PAPRs must deliver at least 4-6 cubic feet of air per minute (4-6 CFM) to a tight-fitting
facepiece and at least 7 CFM to a loose-fitting helmet or hood.
AIR-SUPPLIED RESPIRATORS
Air-supplied respirators deliver breathing air through a supply hose connected to the
worker's facepiece (half mask or full face). This category of respirator is seldom, if ever,
used in the asbestos abatement industry today, as it has no higher level of protection
than the PAPR, and the worker is limited by the air hose. This creates hazards in the
workplace, and reduces production by about 40%.
Self-contained respirators provide protection for various periods of time depending upon
the amount of breathing air (air pressure and tank size) and the breathing demands of
the wearer. The worker is independent of his/her surrounding atmosphere when using
these devices; therefore, they can be used in environments immediately dangerous to
life and health (IDLH).
However, since they have several disadvantages, they are seldom used on asbestos
abatement jobs. They are heavy and awkward to wear. The air supply usually lasts only
30 to 50 minutes, thus requiring a large supply of filled tanks on-site. They require more
training than the other types of respirators.
PROTECTION FACTORS
Respirators offer varying degrees of protection against asbestos fibers. The key to
understanding the differences between types of respirators (air-purifying, powered-air
purifying, air-supplied, etc.) is the amount of protection afforded the wearer. Also, the
competent person, or supervisor, must be responsible to see that each person at an
abatement site is protected to the proper level of respiratory use, depending on the
current or potential exposure. To compare these, one must understand the concept of a
protection factor (PF).
8-5
A protection factor is a number obtained when the concentration of a contaminant
outside the mask is divided by the concentration found inside the mask. This simple
formula is illustrated below.
It is virtually impossible to measure the concentration inside the mask (where the worker
is breathing) for each worker, all the time, during all the various activities he or she may
be conducting. Accordingly, OSHA assigned protection factors, based on extensive
research, have been specified for different categories of respirators. Using these
protection factors, it is easy to determine what type of respirator is appropriate to
maintain the protection inside the mask at a desired level.
Using OSHA protection factors, the contractor may select from Table 8-1 the
appropriate respirator to maintain the concentration inside the respirator below 0.1 f/cc.
OSHA requires, by regulation, at least a minimum level of protection at the PEL (0.1
f/cc).
Aside from regulatory compliance, liability management and true worker protection is
also of paramount importance. An employer may choose to protect employees beyond
the regulatory of 0.1 f/cc to address these two issues. The next logical level of
protection with regulatory agency reference would be EPA’s “final clearance” under
AHERA, at 0.01 f/cc. AHERA has the effect of saying that schools may not reoccupy
spaces in a building unless the air is at least this clean – or, ‘ this is safe enough to be in
without a respirator.’
An employer is not required to protect employees to 0.01 f/cc, but if he chose to, the
same protection factor calculation would be used to determine the proper respirator. In
either case, by comparing the calculated PF to the OSHA assigned PF chart, the proper
respirator can be determined.
8-6
TABLE 8-1
Example: Personal air sampling indicates the fiber concentration outside the mask is 3.5
f/cc (8 hour, time-weighted average).
Then:
Protection Factor Needed = 3.5 f/cc outside mask
0.1 f/cc desired inside mask
Protection Factor Needed = 35
By going to the table, any respirator with a p rotection factor above 35 should maintain
the fiber concentration inside the mask below 0.1 f/cc.
Example: The employer may also use the protection factor formula to estimate
concentrations inside the mask if the personal sampling results are available. If a
worker's personal sample for an 8-hour workday was 2.7 fibers/cc and he wore a full-
face PAPR respirator, what is his estimated exposure inside the mask?
8-7
Concentration in the mask: = Concentration outside mask
Protection Factor of mask
Accordingly, if the worker wore the respirator properly fitted and maintained, his
exposure should have been well below 0.1 f/cc (8-hour, TWA).
Maximum Use Concentration: (or, what is the dirtiest air I can wear my respirator in?)
It should be noted that protection factors should only be used when the respirator is
properly fitted, maintained, and used as intended. It should also be noted that protection
factors for a specific model (and size) of respirator may be estimated for each employee
if quantitative fit-testing is performed for each worker (see “Fit Testing” below).
Any employer who requires or permits employees to wear a respirator must have a
written respiratory protection program. This is required by OSHA in their asbestos
standard (29 CFR 1910.1001, amended, and 29 CFR 1926.1101, a copy of which is
attached as Appendix A of this manual) and respiratory protection regulations (29 CFR
1910. 134, copy included in Appendix B). The written respirator program establishes
standard operating procedures for the asbestos abatement contractor concerning the
use and maintenance of respiratory equipment. In addition to having such a written
program, the contractor must also be able to demonstrate that the program is enforced
and updated as necessary.
The OSHA regulations spell out just what must be included in a written program. Below,
these items are discussed with special emphasis on applications to asbestos abatement
work.
8-8
The Elements of a Respiratory Protection Program
(29 CFR 1910.134)
8-9
Include donning, doffing, use limitations and maintenance. See 29 CFR
1910.134(k).
9. Program Evaluation -
The written program should be kept current and pertinent to the respiratory
equipment being used at any given time. As equipment is changed, the program
should be updated to reflect the change. Also, the supervisor must survey the
work site and evaluate the program for effectiveness and compliance, with
feedback from the employees involved. See 29 CFR 1910.134(l)
During any type of fit-testing, the respirator straps must be properly located and as
comfortable as possible. Over-tightening the straps will sometimes reduce facepiece
leakage, but the wearer may be unable to tolerate the respirator during the work period.
The facepiece should not press into the face and shut off blood circulation or cause
major discomfort. At the time of respirator issuance, a visual inspection of the fit should
always be made by a second person. That person should check to see that there are
not visible openings/leaks (around the nose, for example) and that the respirator
appears properly adjusted and comfortable.
Negative Pressure Check: For this check, the user closes off the inlet of the cartridges
or filters by covering with the palms and inhales gently so the facepiece collapses
slightly. If the facepiece remains slightly collapsed and no inward leakage is detected,
the respirator is working properly. This procedure checks for the placement and function
of the exhalation valve, without which the user would have no protection.
Positive Pressure Check. This check is very similar in principle to the negative
pressure check. It is conducted by closing off/covering the exhalation valve and
exhaling gently into the facepiece. The respirator function is considered okay if slight
positive pressure can be built up inside the facepiece without any evidence of outward
leakage around the facepiece. It also checks for the placement and function of the
inhalation valves, without which the user would be rebreathing stale air, eventually
becoming oxygen deficient.
8-10
RESPIRATOR FIT TEST
There are two major categories of fit-testing, qualitative (pass/fail basis) and quantitative
(scientific measure basis). Then there are several methods within both major
categories. Only those considered most applicable to asbestos abatement will be
presented in this section.
Qualitative Fit Testing. The qualitative fit test is allowed for half-mask respirators, and
for Full-Face respirators used at the allowable limit of the half-mask (10 x PEL, or 1
f/cc). All tight fitting respirators must be fit tested at least annually.
Irritant Smoke Test. Once the asbestos abatement worker has passed the visual,
negative pressure and positive pressure checks, they can be tested with irritant smoke.
It can be used for both air-purifying and air-supplied respirators. All respirators must
have high-efficiency filters. The test substance is an irritant smoke (stannic chloride or
titanium tetrachloride). Sealed glass and plastic tubes with substances to generate
smoke are available from safety supply companies. When the tube ends are broken and
air passed through them with a squeezable bulb, a dense irritating smoke is emitted.
For this test, the user enters the test enclosure and the irritant smoke is
sprayed/squeezed into the test hole. If the wearer detects any irritant smoke inside the
respirator, it means a defective fit, and adjustments or replacement of the respirator is
required. This test has a distinct adva ntage in that the wearer reacts involuntarily to
leakage by coughing or sneezing. The likelihood of merely pretending to pass the fit test
is very low, as a sensitivity test must also be given.
The irritant smoke fit test is qualitative (pass/fail). It can and should be performed at the
abatement job site by the supervisor, or competent person.
Quantitative Fit Testing. There are more scientific methods of determining the fit of a
respirator. Those methods are called quantitative fit tests. In fact, these quantitative fit
tests are the methods used to determine a respirator's scientific and published degree
of protection (protection factor).
8-11
Regardless of the type of fit test, its advantages and disadvantages, it is necessary to
include such a test in an effective respirator program. It is the key to detecting and
correcting contaminant leakage around the facepiece to face seal. This leakage can be
critical when the contaminant is a proven human carcinogen -- asbestos.
A more extensive description of fit-testing methods and respirator use are included in
Appendix A of 29 CFR 1910. 134.
In general, the respirator program should be evaluated at least annually with program
adjustments, as appropriate, made to reflect the evaluation results. Program function
can be separated into administration and operation.
A. Program Administration
B. Program Operation
8-12
___ (1) Respiratory protective equipment selection and assignment
___ Are respirators being worn correctly (i.e., head covering over
respirator straps)?
___ Are workers keeping respirators on all the time when
necessary?
8-13
(a) Cleaning and Disinfecting
(b) Storage
(c) Inspection
___ Are respirators inspected before and after each use and
during cleaning?
(d) Repair
8-14
___ Is a procedure developed for respiratory protective
equipment usage in atmospheres immediately dangerous to
life or health?
(6) Training
8-15
when inside the work area. The OSHA regulations require “whole body covering, head
coverings, hand and foot coverings”.
Protective clothing does not include street clothes (or shoes), T-shirts, blue jeans, sweat
bands, knee-pads, and socks. If any of these items are used inside the work area, they
should remain the re until the job is completed and disposed of as asbestos-
contaminated waste. Jewelry such as rings and ID bracelets should not be worn in the
work area.
Other protective clothing/items such as hard hats and safety shoes/boots should remain
in the equipment room or work area for the duration of the project. Upon project
completion, these items can be cleaned, placed in a plastic bag, labeled as containing
asbestos, and taken to the next project.
It should be noted that this asbestos removal/control industry is, in many cases,
specialized demolition. The same general safety requirements apply here which apply
on a general construction site (hardhats, safety-toe boots, eye protection, etc).
These disposable coveralls, foot and head coverings are available from many sources
and several materials. Coveralls, with foot and head covering attached usually cost
about $1.50 each when purchased in quantity. It is important to realize that many
"bargain" prices may not be a bargain at all. The less expensive coveralls often use less
material. Accordingly, coveralls marked "XL" may be too small for many workers. Be
sure to check the construction of the coveralls as well. Double stitching on seams will
last longer, but cost more.
8-16
Man Days (no. of items / man / day + 1) + 10% contingency
As an example, a job estimated to last 20 days with 10 men on the job would be
calculated:
200 (4+1) + 10% =
1000 + 100 = 1100
Accordingly, the contractor should order 44 cases (25 per case) of coveralls for the
project. It should be noted that the 10% factor in the above formula provides a 10%
surplus. This is often necessary for project overruns. Further, when purchasing
coveralls, XXXL sizes should be bought. These can always be made to fit smaller
employees.
Protective clothing is put on in the clean room of the decontamination unit befo re
entering the work area. The following sequence should be used:
1. All street clothes, including undergarments, are removed and stored in a clean,
convenient location. Bins or lockers work well for this. It is usually wise to have a
lockbox or other means to protect valuables.
4. If separate disposal foot coverings are used, these are put on.
5. Ankles and waist are taped to take up slack in the suits and reduce the chance of
tripping.
6. The respiratory equipment is inspected, put on, and the fit checked.
8. The hood or head covering is put on over the respirator head straps.
11. Other protective equipment, such as hard hats and safety glasses (if a half-face
respirator is used) are put on.
8-17
One person should remain outside the work area at all times. It should be his/her
responsibility to ensure that each person entering the work area has the proper
protective clothing.
Once inside the work area, no employees, or others, should be permitted to leave
without going through the decontamination sequence unless it is an extreme
emergency.
Whenever an employee or other person leaves a work area for any reason, he/she must
go through the decontamination sequence. This sequence should include the following
steps:
1. Remove all gross contamination from clothing before entering the equipment
room.
3. The person should then proceed to the shower still wearing his/her respirator.
While showering, the person should be sure to soak the respirator cartridges if
they are using negative pressure respirators. The cartridges may then be
discarded in a plastic bag located outside the shower. Wash the respirator while
in the shower.
4. The person should then proceed to the clean room air-lock, dry off, proceed to
the clean room, dress in his/her street clothes, and disinfect, clean, and inspect
his/her respirator. New cartridges should be placed in the respirator.
COVERALL COMPARISON
• Tyvek
• Spunbond
• Filtered Coveralls
8-18
The following are general comparison specifications which may be considered when
choosing appropriate garments.
Tyvek
• Non-Breathable
• 4 lbs. tear strength
• 99% particulate holdout at 3 microns
• Water-resistant
• Cost: Approximately $6.00 each
Spunbond
• Breathable
• 6.5 lbs. tear strength
• 36% particulate holdout at 3 microns
• Cost: Approximately $1.00 each
Filtered Coveralls
• Breathable
• 9.5 lbs. tear strength
• 95% particulate holdout at 3 microns
• Water-resistant
• Cost: Approximately $3.50 each
General Considerations:
• Wearability: OSHA requires whole body covering, and that this covering be
maintained in an intact condition.
• Cost: This consideration must be balanced with worker protection and jobsite
conditions.
8-19