Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 25

. .

- .. - - .

.

I _ Ii III

TABLE 'O'F 'CONTENTS

• I I r r

• il t !

~I I _.. ..

.. ...: i 'II'

&

. -

..

..

,



. . - '.

, I·

1 I t,

, ~

I ~

-'

, ~

• 'I ",.- Ii JI*

• •

'I. • I I r

II

.

~ -.I.

-.

- --' =- •

- ..



-" .

- ...

• - II - ..

.I 11 ,. III

t

'ri '1

,J,. ~',

, ~

• .. - I •

A pp!-_ ,0"'" ··.··1 -1- -N;:j-~T' -'. -M,<'E-; D"N~."··T--I ',: .

'! ,", ", .-:.' "11 -',_, il ... ~~I.:."Io. ~~'::_." ..

- .



[ -

"I

- .

- , ..



,

l •

I. J I

• :1-

... -

-, '

ii - ~ ~ . II

~

Challenge ,'., to ,

1-;- ",_ '_. _ ] ',_ < __ ."~ _ '. • • _r'.. .' II ..

", • • - ... IIio I ~ ~

" ,~1..1:1Therespondenl cl1a1lenges the quaHfication·of'the arbitrator

Dlsqualincation for - .

1.-2.1 - Approached.by one party r , " .,. I I.,.

1,.2.2 Called for interview' by one party ... . .' ....- .

Estoppel '.' "". !, t '.r :,' ,",

~.~.l , Party who appoints an arbitrator subsequently estopped frOm~,ascer-

tainingtha; arbitrat or 'h··~ 'QS~, no a"u'I" th .ority .~ - ...... '" - .;-, · .

,:1:-.'"',,-,--,-,, ',·C-".' ""':'~"~ ::~."." :.,.-J,.-: f.: _1 ,,':, ,'·"a,.~ ;c,_:.,_---", ' .. ',::',_.: .. " ,' __ .• -'~',._:,' _ '''_

; :1,:3.2- "Is anewlyappointed solicitor estopped"uonl questioning the·arbittat.or's

ju n· fsdictlon ~? . · . ,.~ _

' - ;-- '--' ': - " ,,'. ,', "' .. "', ,'~, it'

1- DIV' valid ' it 'y. v of .

l r ~ I" _ _ .• ,,,., "', ","_ . .:.___ _ .l: . .. .' . ..:. _

1.4.1 Respondent developer claimsthat ehulered IDstitute~df Arbitrators, has made an 'invalid appointment and that theaiblfr~tor' bas, DO' pow~rto, 'c~ll a

_' preliminary meeting ,- ' " - : '. - .:. t '

1.4.2 Appointment letter from nominating body signed by'-pe~oD-'other than

that person named in contract _ '.- "-, ,,' '_' v • •

" -, '1.4.3' "Rcspon~ent asserts the ciS:im,lUit bas not Cb.mpiied 'Wit~'· ~~~condition

related t.01 arbitrator's appointment ., -:' ~

'ii.' 1"1 :"

'1'- 4,·..--1 ·4,1' R,:-' "--:',~,' . ""10' . ""D" d - en ,-": t .q:' ue ,-s······~· tlo "n~, 'S' v .... ·a~' "~I, id lity of a'~,p-'p'~'o·:· dn :~ tm > ::, .. : ~.~ :,t'~ -:., · ... .... _ ~

. . ',": .- : ,_esp, .,.,,", ',"<' ,c' __ _ _.' • _ ",;I,J" ,_ _ '. .'.' ' _ ,',

':. ~'14 5 - Party contends appointment invalid asmade out of time - ·

1:4:6 V~Udity'~~f~nilat~ral ;ef~r~nc~ for -th~ appointment of;~ arbitrator -',

- "II • .. (' . I _. I 'L •• I .~. I

. ;1:4.'7 - I • Conditional appointment of arbitrator - ~' - - -". " .' ."

, 'bill -- b d 01; t 'Ii, -. - )., - - - ~I _. ··'th'·

1.4w8 The appointment of an arbitrator must be m~_-e m sn,~t :coll)platice~Wl-

, , ; • - I' • • ~ • II ~ _ ..' ~ • II _ I , "'""

the,' contract " . , ~ _

~--" ,,_," -' ,,'" ":'" iii .- .. - .. ',I .- i!:',-" - -.. ~ •• '.~ ~ _ ~:. :.-

1.,4.9' Party attempts to nominate third arbitrator _ ' _, " - r

1.4.10Wbetber 8,D appointmentis valid where a.Jdjn~er-Do~ /:"~a~ tie'elt~~~e~

-. . , ~ iIi<.. ~. t-· i 1 •

-p' ""n'" .. ~ nr' .--) -t·, 0':', ".'" th :-' be d ; 'a' -.-, te 0::":'" 'f"·;' t'-: h :' .. at a:;- 'p,-, ;:P'-",- om tm ~,n·:~!·· .

: : - ,< :,,~ ·,U'. . : :' " .. ,.'-.: ' ',. . :-. ~ ~ '.~> . :_.I. l~', ' l!' _; _~'_;.' . .:" _ I, . ," 1 :~ .. '. .. ~_.:. ".' I _, .. _'=t' __ '¥.'~] _' ) _

. '" _.' , ' -~'.' I' to ._:,. . ~. ~ -:;. - I'" .-.~.~ .-

..

• r

. '

. -

. ,

r

d



F I

,

. ,

~. , ,

., , ,

-

. -

_"

I •

, -

. .

- -,

. ~

,

.. II \

.

- .

.. ' .

-

r >, , I'·

. -

, .

-'

, ,

~,..

vn

• ...-[I~·

ix

~

.,.11' ~'9'

g":'''",)

. . . ~ I

"'[ . - .~. j

XI'iII

tv" !I!..A

I, .. :.!'~

~'

Ixxvii·

'l~:' .. """ lAMA

1

I

,

-

'1,

'1'



,

2

,

3 4,

'",4·il, i

- . .

6-,

.

, '

(' _.'

. ,

~"1'

~

. - 8

.. ,1:,"-::-

I,; ".

n ;;I

- . ......_

'12'"

I 'I ..... _

... ' )

1,3, ~1 fi .... '~'-

I ,. 'I

.,

,',_ J

- - - (

1'9!

I i

1 I

I

I ,

I I

I

I ~-

I

1

I ,

)

1

( ,

., OJ

I •

. ,;

I L1'

I I "

. I

. .

r-'

~ .

- 1l'1I I

.

, ,

, ;

'IS '2':"5'"

. . . . '

, -. -c.

27

, ,

d . t meet sp·"ecific requirements of arbi~

,AII'hi.nU:l',H, clUulifi"-utiotts •. ··.,0 no

'11-,,1 ion n~rt tl.r;.nl

.-

_<\ d hoc N'lll,tllJR,N,j,(llrI1,N -

• ..1 i I ':lt~I'~I'en" In arhitratien after dispute arises .' .... 'U .. ' .

WhfOllr"I' I he ~nlhH,e(lu·'r t. conduct of the parties amounted to an: . 'ad hoc'

(II 1"1,·11 tratln 11 anrceme 11,1

n

( 'tl- "'1'1'1~' C' )-li I~ i ". ' .• ' 1 1')1 I-'~'-~ f 'C' h" (': '1', -, '11'1: "I

~'l ". II, [II 'I _." II 1 I, n ~'L', L, n :1 I - .. . ~

. , .• 'Cc-' .I·~ W·· ... ··.· ....• · ..• ···tr'I!'I-I-1I'u. 1:·l-I-I~I,III,l·"III~I.l .. 0.' ~,r'·,:"~f]'w,a,r'(l is II, condition precedent to' a cause of action

'_ ;11' ,11_.. I -, . , ,ii," _ I " \.~ II 'I. _ ~J _. . '_' 1,__.. . ~ ~-, --' _ - '_ '.

WII""I~I.'l U r'IIII~:t:!I,\II'I-A 1,,- :'I'~ t ''1]- be referred to engineer's decision as a condition

.' I11I 'ill 1.1' - . I '\iiIl 'I'I \,,1_ (1, ,/11,:;.1 W' ,1_"1 ;~, ~ \J. "W! ' ... l- _.: - -'. _'.. . .. ,.J



Jl-I'!I~ • .• ~ :7~ 'it! I ·1' f~' 'ii l·ll· II ~"I ")'1' 111, ~ '. r ~1' 'I' I'!' C· ".',, .

, .. 1,,,_ . ' _ ~ "< I I \J., ,'-_-'' .. II ,rill (~, It'l' ._-111,1

Lh~lut~ fl.,.. to VlulkHly 01'

J':\ I .1 Compllancc with oontrnct, prerequisite to. trigger written arbitration

I ~ ~'_II ~ C :ll1,1~~ 1'.1'1 _ ,~ ~ ~ ~ I

~"rt"'; _. r'i'N'I"(]II!'l,(lc:'11Ii uuestlons validity of arbitrator's appointment as, architect's

- - '. . - - c - -' I. I ~ - =. - -, =' ') .,., . - , ,~ .' > •• .." _.Y. .. .

111~' n ,'~"- ~ "'; .1l.~, ·I~'. i I:i~' I" U 11'-C'Jj. 11.11,1 (;. bee '1]'" 'I~ ssu l';~ c I' ~

'I -J ._ 11,.1 .. _. _. " I Ii _I !~ I ,_L ,"_. 11111] '~II ~~ '_ ~ V~J _.,_ _,,~ LJ ' ,Ij~ ~I .,.

~ -:.. - - -

:- -,._'. ~, __ I ~-- ~._ ~: W· . "11- t-'~.!Ii i~:", I .. ,'(I~. !I, "~1 \' rll ~. i V ~"I~ -1-' 'C~:I~S ,0'. - .1 [-~I a rc .. '~. 'I" '1:1 t.'-', IC1ct ",S~:, fin a '.1-' C···· :,e. :"r- t ... if nca te time bar " i. s .arbitrati on '.

~~ ,.~1- ' ~I . ~ .. ~·~Ii.'\tj Iiall _, v" ~,) '_1 ,._,,~J ,w "I_ .. C _ '. "__' _c, . - ,1._ a ~ .' ,I , .•. r, '-

.~st.opp] · .

i'i'n'l'l.y usserts other party estopped from proceedin '~." with 'arbitration

W.IJ'~Unn' u party .b; .~~lloppet~ by convention from denying theexistence of

r.r11rl1 t I 11'1 'I \Iii.l 1 ~ til t··· ii '(" "1'1 "0' II .t:, t· 'I U if', -

'·'1 _ I.. 111" I I, J _ It ._ 1-)· '~·i" II, J,:_.II,I\,_ 1_,'I,'i.1~

J. -~, ' ' ~ I ~~ Ir, .' "1-1' '~,it I. ".'" :f'-I~

_ I~, .• ,'n "__! .,__:_ ~ >~ I

• ,,5,,:[ ~ .. ontruct contalns COl flieting, dispute clauses. .: . " .

IIJ 'I' tl ;r" '1-'!IIr\ 1,'-1 v' t{fl'l·i, d - 11:~"'I"!Ii,II- "l~ ,t, '1-:1.11'" . 't"· .1 . __ ', '. - "'. - ... .- .. '.-. - - . - ·t' "(-I .. h . - '. ~ -ill; . I 'iii -.. ,

," . I!e. '-".' ,I It ,~,'·,.~10n agreemen n the contract is not signed? ,;

Pnl'11CS u,rcc to arbltrute ill mistaken belief that contract contains an

11'1-'- ;1, ~ ~, I"~ 'I' I. I!I " 1-'1 iii 'ifli '( t" 1111- u· J k - ,. •

I'I. '·."_._.-'II'~il.i t,ll :,t, I-~ ~:,." ""_'n-' I} r ' ~

., _ ,I P I I

1 .' ~ • I

HxiN'I.hl~' Dispute . · l' ,

,:.f1JWh~·;r:~ r,d.~·.r:lrtlit,I·~liro~ ag' '~emellt may be too ~esirictive tocover an

exlstinu dispute " '~I. -- • _ .: - .... ,'.'., .... ;;: ... -~ .. - .-'-' --,'.' "',. -

- II _; ._," .' -' I_ _'" 'f,:.. ~I-' . ,['. _ I· . ~ ._ ~

[1:1],\ ~'.I i'll" ted 11"\f! - J . ~ \ r 1 ~

II! • !,1 , •

('::~" 7- l M i9111,-r.p-~ I~' "IMr~111'llll t "il'(r','~ I~ _.. ' . . . · IL. flo

-- I ,- ~= L. ~,I "_' '. ,1.,[ Will: '-~,~~-~ .asserted options o'p"en to "arbitrator and

I 1';,-· 11-"1"1 Ii,! '~'lIi' . ~,! ~.- -- ,." L -' r_:J-~:_ ~! "-; .~--. - - .

"I: ,(, ,~, 10 ~

• - 'I I 1 r _ I

rvlisl:nke·· is r' J I I' . " ..,... '.

, •.• , ",~r f,w'ln'(j~r.lorC!~811h:. where arbltratitin baSe,d:om:~a.mislai;e of

. • I ... ,II II' _ - I - I I

- ' -

. - -

.I I_I I J ..

. \,7 " 1I1~.~nUt)' wbcthel' Ul~ ',t1.1ity!·nV'8Ud~t:es an arbitI'~n.-.I·_··,t:."l··ro··,:·.-: .. 'n-', C'·.". rl'.· .. ,a~_:u·,·_~s~-_ •. · .• ~e·."".,

IN:i 1- '~" 'I~ '. ,!I,-"'I- ~ \"" 'I': ~ rl l ill. I : ~ 'I' '1- a - --

_ _ _ ""-I I II __ I 'Y'I 11 II~JII." I

, - -

. . H ,.~, I' t '1 I··l - 1 • -

L~_ ~ ,~; ,~ _1 .•. ~ -l) 111_]~ ll,'_ - ,-;~\,-~~:,I,l~_,",'~ '\"I~ t:·' , I,',~ . '\-~j I·'!II.(·,)~' 'r'II. - Filii, f?lO' :-'. '1"',','··· (-)-.- -"I·" h' __ , . II - -, .' .... ,I ,I, ~ _. ~-

I, '_.. I!, '.' I . 'il" .' ilL.!l .,' ~' II . , \l 's·-~ g

.' . "'_ M '- ,- ' . '- I '. I.' - ' '.1 ~. :' :__ __:_ ,1.;,_ ~ , ;l c' ~ t,l-

.. ~ nrtl nl~l. net Rl"tnud ·hlcnrpon-lted by r~f:)"'r-- =_. "~.'" .. 11)1- .~. ~ .. I:

(")"I=::Ti'''I-1 'lil"'11,~t"_'I~IiiiIIi"I·-.-,1 I~(]-' 'I_~ " ')-. -,~,~' .... ,., ..... __ ' ·.,r ·",\-,c'-',-enc·e .. ,~. , I ~'.~

.. ' . It, I~, ." ,III.:=' '\;rJ ,~'111'll' ,III "I,I'.'~"IMIO., VII! dis I,U-" 1'1:\, bv arbi tr ~~~ ~ _ - ~.

, -·-~-'~"}lr' <.\oJ . ~ J ",J. t, .. ' '-,8'1,IOi'll.

1'Ni - ., tiI'I~1

I .... ,1 ... 'II! .

, I 'I' I'

I_It.)!. . ~

-

. .

~ .



'2"7-'

I':: I

'.

2~1 0-

28""

.;-'.

, .

'30 ·3':'3"

I ..

1.',-, -.

3_' "

.~

-'g'-' '.i&:"

ifJ, .... ·



39

'3"9-:-"

J .. '

. . I

" .. .' ~r,'

4,1'

..

44-

,

4'-'6'·'

:','

. .L,.

·-0"" :ll' .....

,51.

5'1

J'

·5····4·,-

,I, _

"~'6'c_· ,)_.:1

5-'1'

I

57

. ,5,19'

60

,

-

,''2

w'

6Jiii'

. jl

6"_-'

I

,

'I

. ~ . . .

- J- (' '.

I I I ,

• ',' J

- I ,'r '

• • r

.. I

" r-l

~'",!i'

, •

- I

-

-. .

.. .

I •

~ I

, '

I •

. .

~ t. W'

• .. ,_"lere 8 tenant wanted an expert not an arbitrator,'

Ai \1 t IrI,- . "I~i 1 y~l. of

:-. , .~

~".,2.1 Party. questions arburator'sauthortty unilaterally to set, J .' t '''~I'I .'~ ,~lin1i_:_

n- Iftlt"y~" . 'i"l,A ·· .. tin s - ·

I~' _I_,' . IJil~'·<) '" .'...,! I'~_'~,I • r • ~ .II I"

'3" A" bl." " dill' .'

.,.:..... Artntrator directs '8 party to be represented at 8 nlecting 'f e"p rts

DI,. ~~~I"irttl ,of , ',; "' .. ' .; I ~ ~ •

1t3.1 Arbitrator dies during in erlocutory stage ' ,,' ,

3.3.2 Arbitrator dies during a long hearing l :' , ' " .• ',

Examination by - ,

3.\1 Respondent accuses arbitrator of adopting an inquisitorla; role 3,4.' - When. the parties agree that the arbitrator can act inquisitorially

Functus officio . . .' ; : j

3.5.1 Joint arbitratorsdisngrce and 'umpire appointed "

Prior disclosure 'of contents of award to one party "

3.5 ... ,. Losing party telephones' arbitrator '(' , :

Independent advice - "I . ,-" . , • • - .'

. '~.6.1 Arbitrator .decides it necessary to consult a third party , ., ,

Jurisdiction '. ": ~ r •

r '.7;]": Challenge of-arbitrator's jurisdiction at commencement 0,' bearing

h t d Id t" h .' .," di ".,

3.7'12 Arbitrators ave 'no power t,OI uecice tneir own jurtsdictton ,I

.' ,Ii ., 'b'·' , d f" II II d' [ii, I

37.3 .. Threat of injunction against arbitrator on grouncso no junsnrcttcn

: .. '.' '. -Dispute in excess of jurisdiction' \ . " ":, ."

Etl.:S Did :arbitrator have jurisdiction in -dispute under ICE contract- when

'ill [J -~ . f'- t' '1'· . It"·- d:)I,,_ . ru: 't'e'··· to engin 'e:--'c' sr for hls decisio ~n~'''1 .I;IS disputed? J

quesnon ,Ol_' reference 0" .l,a~ !.~IIS'p _~" .. _,I' c_',< .. 1 ,.' ~=~ ,I.,I~·,:: ~'" ._ .. ~:." , .,.:.'-:' <2 ,_ .. '.I,_:.~, Ji_-'-_ I~" ,.'>~_, .,',~:, - I, . "

- ~i. 7.6 Respondent asserts that the ctaimant.has failed to serve a noticeto refer a

required 'll· tbe contract

'1 [_,

I

, I

.. ..

p

, ,



. , .

lll~ 10'1 'I (J '1' l'(}~,"

j 1 ~,' '"1 I, ~'

]·46'·····

,':'_I'JI

14/'9' .

'-J"':-

!.- .' ~

3~_,,1'8"I

'_ I ." I

I _r. ~!I_~-.

3- ,1"'·,'

"---; I

_ ".,

3 '1'-0-

,

,,Ii'" ~:

~ •

. • ,

I •

3'· 1'- 2~--1

,:

,

_ !f..~' _.' :

. J, ~ .

~J • .:

!"

"



3- '13·1,-,.

" ~ -"",

. '., . - ,':

3 1'1'4:-'

. "

. -,' ~.'

- _ .

.

,. _ ..

l'I:,ent-

- . " I 'J ,ilr ':-_ ~ ,-, " c·,.,.J , '

LO-'I!L'!IC ,'i ,. ··d'- ,0-:. eum '-I~I'nt-", . b.llit' "s' ,t' '.' "r:_J, 1I~ --" .,''-I,~'C~, il,I' _:WJ 1- I'._~'-l ~" ,.1.' , .

, 'ug "I ," ." , iii ,,", "rr I " '. 1 ,~, ~~

~··3.8.1 . ··_.:C!,r destructi'In 0.1 arl·J ,", " ' _. .. "

-I ,. - h'~I~' 'rlil I'

an: .d b ef "": ':f'" C' award ' ·'.d '", _ ,-,'--.:. l~ 1'iJ'CI[I'ld,":,t~illn'" Ii,' :';-[ -.-:_ -.l "~,__ I :-. ~, ~. 1,1, '.: ~

[ [, •• 1 ,-",'~, ,'",,_ -,' ,.,19,_ _ d t --oy'c:' 1D 'te> [ 1,1,1.,1, - ,[, '-'.-

3_· 8"" '2"" A'-' r""b--I[II,t'j'r:~a·i·,t'o('lr:--,J's· notes i:'II_~:S'. rr ,,' :1., _ I, ,'" ,,~ - -

_ ;l!I~"'iII:~' .,-'.",._I-I-··]I_'~'I :'. ',", r, ,-,','::, _. -.

Mic tak,'~:: 'b'y' , .. " ',-) " k' ,~II!I!ln~:-" ,I tlj m~ I'-'Itl~takc ~'in

' d of ma "[llg iii _ "D,- I .• _

31~9;-_1 A.rbitr,a,[t1or . aeeu , ~"e,~, l~'" ~.' ,._:<., .-[ . Ii -, ~ - - - • _ ~

, Non'"'imp,a".~a1i.ty of, _ .. ,~,,:' 'cc,'·,'led.e of one pa,rty.., .~._ .,. -

3 10" l' A''" rb"'I-"tr' 'ator I'S'- p., t'~,rs··,o;nalll, ,know. - g ~ h . . .' a" '.' - '.11.,11 -Il:.ri:' -'"

' , ,'. . . Ii" "', '.. " _.' _. . - . jI t P S- I' ..' ~ ,', II~' I' . ' - i

. ' ", :.... . .., 1 . nnectJon WI '.. . : ,L~,: .c>_ ....,

·3.10.2 Arbitrator's close persona . C~'··arbittatj~n award set '~"(:I'de~":"-,I:" '(,

3' 1:-1 0"-13' P···:;a,·~ rty to ·a',r'bit.ratilon Is:e.eks to ."a.eve ·~·.L .: '. ~t"h'~" ···'.···h· "'e-~r-'- p' 't :t",y":'

.,.' ~' - '- - -. .' . . " · h ,- " WI'''' 0 'I 1 ' " , . ~.

arbitra tor's previous professional relat.JOnRJlpcl"hll~.·. ·.p •... r··"v']~,O"I-·,·u· .... ]-'y. ".1 acted for '~\I-"["_~

, .. " -_" "-' [--~.' ,. ~ I, ' h t h ,,. P" artner II aSI II 1, '. , I < " ' _ l,_ '.,' III. -~-

3- 1'0:" 4 Ar"" rbirrator d,:'-'J~SC'OI'V'erlsl '(,'-:,8", ms nar ,-: !,~.' ~.;' '_'-' --'--.:'

_ : .. ",1 ,,'.I!I!i<~:' ,~'i-'.·· .. '~· _'."1., .. :,:," "._c·II: .. ,:_: ,.~.,\., '.- :,..... -'. a

claimant . f h . lth of one p'~'arty, ," and is, accused 11..']'" bias

3.10.5 Arbitrator enquires o"ea.,'O " . ....., -.\ ;.; . , . ..

. 3~10.6 Friend of 8rbitr~tor ~~,~ointe~asd.eXJ'e~rt· ,'"'>-dvoc,~ I :3.10.7 Arbitrator accused of-bias towarc 5 a pa I.y sa. .

N10te taking

3.11.1 Gen.eral guidance . ,

3.11~2 Shorthand writer unable to take note

Own kn .. ·::"r-··o' rwledge 'U[,":s:::le': " 'o:·:,'f-~.; .,' . _

,- I L, - - -'. - -- , '.' -- " . 'I -" -. . . . _, Iili

'- .. ' 3~'.,1",2~ ••. ~1.· Arbitrator holds contrary view to experts-s-how far can he use iJ. < Or ..

· . . .'11

knowledge? "....,' :." < , "

3.12.2 . Arbitrator's personal knowledge of a recent relevant rent agreement 3.12.3 Where arbitrator's special knowledge notable to be-used " 3 12 4 Arbitrator's personal 'knowledge of the facts in dispt ie .. 3:12'~5 Ca~tion' exe~cised. by' ~n arbitrator in using his own kncwledze and

it

experience. · , . .

3~12.6 Important to makeparties aware of what is in the arbitrator's mind

. _

3.12.7 The arbitrator has received written closing submissions but .. neither p.art

- . 1.:_1.1,- ",'

has addressed a legal issue:~hioh the arbitrator considers is releva ;~It

.. 3.12.8 ~bitratoroWn,knowledge, in 'e.l~ parte · hearing " ...

·P'Olst award involvement _. -. : r , _ ~ _ _ I _ •

-;II oii • I I

3.13 1 Successful party claims award does not cover' all ~es referred to

ar':'I" ··'·b'·\"l,'(tr"-~a;,·,·t:'li1l!IIO"-' DI" I, _ _ •• - - ~.~ _ =-., , _

:, ':, 1 .. """ _,:. _ 1 ,,~' ,":' ',',,':' _'. I r ".. .' •

.. •• !Ill ... • "I I ""! j"

~ ~ (I'~ I

_ .

I •

PlOW: zer ·S·:- 'O-_f·I'

• •••• .• It _. '" :~ .

'3~14 .. 1 Can an arbit 'r .. ·'a .. ator's de" ,,": .~'. < ,. • , • • ;'. " , ", .', ."~

. '8 .. :IIU: ccessfu . ,'ll·Y·.···; . ....:' ',I,e I,' ~r S"eCISlon on 'an mterlocuto9' .matter be ,challenge· ,

,'.' ".,.... . ... ,I, .. ..:: __ '~.'- .. ~ J . • _. • • _ _.

• • ,': .. - fk II· •

. 3.14~2· Power>ofan'arbitratol."'r··::t~o"··\'s··[:trik-,-=·tlll''.-',.' "':'I" .. ,.t·,e ... ~: ';': . ~ __ .. :: .... , •. _,.

3 14 3 C -" d .. .. "-' I I, xe OUI case. lor want 'of p eoQ-eCUtiOD

~ 0 ..•.. ..• •.... '.-onsl 'eration to take into account in s1:n·~'kl:m·' ,'.~':-- ~ .... '.11+0',', "f', ','p' ~ oseco. ioJJ

. . ~_ · 3, 1'4 4 -R'es'p'ondent - _- '-'-1-' ..' ri . - - " . -- - •• g OU,~ lor :wan .. ,., --: 1 • c> .. • .

. • -0, l'O. ' . '.::;:;'·',.',11 .. ""' .. app'les':to arbitrator to strike o','·,u· ·t""" the claiman 'tl~'S- c'aim,for

'want of,':· p'" "'r'-'o:""s"'e'~ 'C" ution -. -. _ .. i~ .• '._: I. ' .. : ~ I ~', ::-:..'. ,~.' 1'1' .1'<1":':' ,;h~A~/~' ';;. ,l.l',.: .. , ',.- ., .

··,1_".",,0. .... ,: .... :' .. ~-<J .. !:[.'.·I.,-:,.I.",.,~._,. ~ _ _ _ _ .

I , ! ' l



._

_

,

" . -

, ,

_ " I

. _ .

• - - ~ I

• I '-31 ~ ~ ••

,

.. .

, I



-3:':·'.15

! .-

"

. ,



I

- 4-"1

r·' -

~ i '.

4·2····

f.' •

_ 111I':__·_::·

.

"

I _

• I •

~ -

"_

~ .

. ~

" .

4

. '

I :.

i ".51

'. - j ..

. . ~ . ) "

- ...

.. _ .. I I -- ..

- - ....

• .... I

• . ,._ "I

11

- .

. .

.

--

Removalor

'3Ll'S,"1 'R ' -

_, '", .- • , ~. ·.e,s,po'nd,e'nt s ~.' ''' .. k ~ . ~ . Co.' .... ,_. L

". " ,-." .' :. e,e.. 8, remo'v81 f'~ "-.'b I' - .

that the ,arbit.r'ator ,i,g~ ,nO'f'ed:-' a I e g"'al'~ ~ I. 'ar' 'ltratOI on grounds of bin and-alie'R'-e.s

3 - 5 '-' ,.'. I. potnt ,_.,

.. ,1 ~'.2 P'a"rti,e.s wish to- . . ... " -=:" '._:' I .. '. ...,

"- .',' remove '~b'li -

- Ap pe'tl' dix ""'A'" M"- .'. d" ,-, ~ '- . ,ar 'ltra:tor :

" . '.' ,I .. , '. " ~, 0 . 'el R' e- · . ~

',' - • :c' ." - .,.I·-vocatl· on- -A --' . . -

Appendix "~B "" __ 'Ni··. " _.'. "". -, .'", 'ng,re.em.ent

'.- ... ;". ·,.ew Agreem,ent "

3.15.3 One pa-ty.·· diss ':' t-_,(i:" d":' ., .~.'., .. .... ' - -

3.1,5~4, R[eS'IJ'·'o-.n·;-·d~-e·-'n .. ··.t"··. ···.~k_JS ae . with ,arbitrator'

'. :.:," __ ~> .. , ..... ,." .. see' s remc -" 'I' f'_' '.

tialir y. .- .'.- ,"' .. '·':,·~··,ova. O'~ arbitrator 0:0 around S'· o,····f~) Iack o····f·~ ,;l1lft11:'p'ar"" .'.

• .', .' . " ..... • ."....,.. ' r= -. I ora' .. : .. ..'.. _" ''', ". . , .' '. '. J' ~' . . I... Q.U: . :_'. ,'-

3 15 5 I bi . I.

_ .. ',.c·-d·~' . s ar::itrator's shareholding.~·· in Ic1omp·· .. ·'8·:"D·y··. a,~·s·····-;-:_:' ... , ... ~" ·ti. 'd:' c ,lIth·l. . .... -'.'-:-'.- ". - ..... -,'-'. I-I '-' .

. glo3:':,uIDS,:'6for removal for mis~nduct1 '.' , . " ,,~l ," '"s~C1ale:, wit one party a

• L,.~·,·" 'A,rbilrator has ~CO' . ·t, .. ,,.' .. ' .. ~ .. , . ". ' "

Resignation .. '.' c.··.·.· ' ...• ,'rnneC:lon:wnh one of the-parties

3.16.1 Arbitrator resig·· r- n· .. rs s nd "'ii, " ' ..

away '1" :c., '. "~n' parnes hold him 'responsible for "costs thrown

. . . I •

Appendix "A "-ModJ.·-, .-,o... '. ...•• ' ..

3.16.2 Three arbitra·:teo.·.'r.At·rg]·breu,enma":''_·'JenR-~eWs~·]~gnthAti···~rbltrafltor on b~S resi~atbiOJ1.-,,, f"

... ' '".' <,. L,. ',. . , , .• 'c.,· '8'" on O' on"e ar "Itr'a·to· r' "at e DI'n'nlli'ng' 0'"

hearing. Is termination ofheatiIi~ '~ncl/~rtbe~;o~ee-dirt~in~~~ble?'~: ..•. -

'212-

2_1"2'

-; _ .

I,., 'il

22:·r."

:__ . "-

n- _ .. '

4

,

'2"25-:""

r '.

::.:."~ ::::.J

~:1"

£~1"

2-3· .. ····0·/-,·J

•· ... 1.

I

'23' ~ ,~- "2~I

• • ~ I J •

[ ~. " "

234>······:- ,

- _. .' '

2-4·····,-r2:·

r • _ '.

__ • J :'.~:::: j

...

A' .. W'A" R"on;

, ' .. >~ ~':'-' :'.' :-;.'

. .

Action 'o'n, .'

4.1.1 What 'effect 1 has, ,an atbithltor'S'8ward on subsequent High Court

:'p· .. ··r··o·! xeed tn g·····:','s··-'?:· - .~. ~ r •

.. :'. . ...... __ : .....•• "'. :: .. '. ,,' ,-. '.1 !.'

cr .. " " •

4.1.2 Effectiveness otan award in a "name borrowing" arbitration Appendix "A"-Modelof a "Name Borrowing" Agreement .. "

Appeal from .'

4.2 . .1 Parties rights of appeal from award. : - . · , u'-

J ':4,.,,2 .. 2 Where court will order further reasons _ i ' - r : ~ •

4.2.3 A ward-appealed on ground that the arbitrator failed to "state reas6nS' hi

" · 'ffi ... ,'!II' .. ' d ." 'I\'~ - I 7' L

, . ,SU'.·. : cient .. - etail .. - . ~

24:5

2'-";4" 7'~

." f

":'''.'', I

'25=-" -:Oi

. . _" I'

.' ',_'. ':.~ I ~ •

2- 5"~~2':'

. ,"

. . .:, " ~

2_5-:2"",

.. ~" ,I, . ,

. ",._,

, -

2· 5""3-"

'I '. _ •. ,I

'. - :'; - _-'"

.

258'

: ....

2~·5':·.:··9·;-;···

··.·r· . 1'- ...

: ' .. ' ._: J' :',.'

, 1

Co .... n asen t .

. I.... ~ ....

4~3.1 Ensure that terms-of sertlementinconsentaward are within arbitrator's

. ...' . ....., - -

"".

.. ,. d '.. t· · - ~ . I ~

J'i u·· .; "r:I' . S:~:-·J-· C" .... ,'., '.):, .0.' .:' 'n"~' - . L • I

" _., '_"_"_ _' . " .

Appendix "A" Typical Consent Award -.- .

4.3.2 Arbitrator requested to countersign consent awardthe terms ofwbich

!h_ ~ . • • I ~ -=. -. I

, ~used him anxiety. '.. ..' """ . _. ,,' ",' ",." . '..,. . . , ~ ~6~

. 4.3.3 Arbitrator receives terms of settlement whichappear tobe ambiguous '267

4.3.4 Disagreement as to terms of settlement ,.,: . ; .: .269

4.3.5 Disagreement between the parties as to whether t:he d~pute li~' ~en.. , ..

. settled .. · - " ' ,270

Enforcemen t _' ' _ - . 270

'. I 4.4.1' FolloWing- an ~i1W8r4 ~ri favb~' o.~ ·th~· '~Iaim~t, the respondeni gp~ ~o

• I . • II ~ II, 7 _" ! ,. I - r, 27,:, 10' .,"',

. gr' ound .... .,-.... , 'i,\ ~b·~ . . . dt ' :" .• " • ._ , "."

4.4.2 Where award unenforceable without post '. u.;p.ute" 'agr~~ment ~ , .

r 2':[8·'..:0('

~ r_:",. _ . _.'_'_

284,

2·8:-···~

'_ '_ J.;J

- ..

28::;"15:':'

r.: -r -: . ['

• I

-

.

"consumer"

';'4.4.3' · Enforcement .of award out of time

. -

Errors in or on the face of " ~ ", ' ,.;.

4.5.1 Generally where .an arbitrator can correcterrors.aild Wherhe ~e c~ot

4.5~2 Claimant alleges fact on face' of award shows arbitrator to •. ave Jtt~de an

. .. ,; .. • "i1 _.. •

error ofcompu1sbon r • , - '-'; ~ 1 ' , ; , • ..- .,' ..

I -

- I;

. - ~

'XX' '-. 'JX~ "

. . . ~. .

. - \ .:.- r. "...

I I _'. ,_ _ _:_ L

r
1
J
1.
,
r
r I
1 j
1 ! 1
I
.
1
,
'I
,
, ! I '_ 'Ii "
,
( "
i'
,
r
- I'
I,
I, I

I. ,

'I!I T

- .

··4," 101':

'_-.- '!~ _.-:l~.

4- "}':2:'

.

, • I •••. : ..•

~ _!i!. _ .. __ .

..

s ~;

,:=' _:',

'.' II - .

I ····(\1L;)~I-, .iAI m ake iii ··r·,~:(-r~-. 'I {':l zard f' I l

--!l "c."" ·\~~~ .. I ~(.J,': - ·J.~I[fj'I[_'·· " .. ~ I.:~I II ~. - _l"· ]', - "_"_ - (' sts 0" tn ter O· . CU 1[-'

t ~7' ,--, ,~, -d 1'1.',0"', respect o,~- 'C'O:SI ,~~< ',', '- ue 1:1' :' _I,' -,olry

'·tl,., ~ Applic aden for Interim a:\\rar-.I' - J

I' '; ro ~t""lI 111l, ~~, __

,.' 47' .. , Awor, I 'Final Save as to Taxation of Costs" ,

,~$:7:4 Wh'~'nana~bil,~iltor should not have published an Interim Award

4.7" -:=: W·,:·' here in, " interh 1- award mav not be Fin .' a

II !II ·'·;!I W'_I- .... '-li_, II, . I.!!!!! _'_'_"<1."._ iJ

I~! '.'- «1' ~,'~(1~ '1-,.,·\1,:;1 :, _ Ii'·,~ .... 1 I '\';_ •

..... -4", 'p (_,I .... -'W"'~"~'I-'lril-l' I~S"~ 0',· rea '-:"'0 .• ned award and when should it b 2 given?

" ...• 10.. 1::1· ,~' .,' ,I· . ,~. , _' I. .. -'- .... _ --

,,',8,... Thearbitrator's approach to writing a reasoned award

~.b.3 .:nreplcscnted party not clear whether they ,wa~t reasons or no"

4.,8,.4, In 18, pre-As, 1:916 Act reference IBn unrepresented party requests '-,,~a,SIOI~'1),

. I

after award is published I

4 Q '5:·' Party reque sts . ':e' trospective r e>9'8_'.· son -''S after award

_ ,10.. . "I, .. _" ',1' ',<_.'.'.' ,'."'. ," .', :', '.'-:: c'" .. ,,' .. ': .. _ .. ". " ,. - .... _ .. ' .• '" .. -' .. ~ -',' -: - -

f_ I I' _:

4.8.:> Request for reasons, not particularise

4.8.7 Request for "open" reasons ,I' , , . ,

4.8.8 Where an arbitrator fails to give further reasons even thoughordered to

do s~ by the CO~_l t , _

,4"·;-:·,·.-8':. 9--:.' 'Exten -I to which reasons should b .· .. ·e given for factual find I~n' tgs II'D':~ a····· r 'ent

.,t..".. ,- '.'--' .. .. H.," _ •.. l "'._-' '-'. . .' - I, ,'- '~".' , -,_"_,,,_' .. _, __ .' ". ,'I .. ,," _", 'i' ,~., .' _., "

- .',' ", : ..

r13"V:-' -1+ e: W" . '-, d ,'411", s'~'p'" u t, "'e""

_ ¥ l.~·: l_~ .. _0j' •.•. __ • ',',J _ ~'I ,._ .• j _ ; •• '~"

4.8.:0 When parties do not.require.areasnned award.

m - •

. Appendix "A'-:l'ypical Agreement to dispense with reasons 8.52(1).

Remitted

I " _

. ~ ,

I ~ .. 9 .. ! .J\ward remitted following procedural nnshap. ' " ' .

4.9.2 Power of the arbitrator on remission of award'. ,

4 9 3· 1- th ,t rtI Ii d- iii :. - • ,

.>~I:S t ae court'sjunsdtction to. remit award under s 22 AA '50 (s68(3) AA

:i96{unlimited? ' . . -,.. - .,---:_- ." ..... , .... , , '. ....'1'- ._,.-'.~ .,<,.'>" .. , \"

. -,.. .

Specifi '·C,·. p~;,eri to.-_.··rm· nanc :'e·~. '"-

• _' .;.. .• ' •• _ 1;-' •• - ,'._ II 1i, • ! I ' • _ _'" '. '.

[_ • ~ r _ _... .. I

4.10.1 ,Arbitrator requested to award' ~pecific p'erftir~an~~ . ,'. " .» .-

'T-- i!II' • II!! f ' ", ~'- _'-".,

.. J,nun,glo

, 4.11.1 ~bitrato,. ',s~~~rd.in danger of:_~ingpublished after statutorytime limit 4.11.2 Where an ar -iltrator takes an - inordi~: - t~ · ti> -<-'-~k . hi',-,-,d

following the con.c_~s.i~n of the hearing" '. nate nne to' make jns awar

' •. "'~eighlng the evidence _ '- -, . · " · .. -

4.12.1 How to weight the evidence wh .... ,'. '-" d'('·.'~'f·';···,~" "." ""'"

" , ' _._.~n_ra.~ng IJD award

. I

C',A U,.' I '_ S·-',:, E'-- OIF 'A_,:..::,. C"~--'T~ 'I" '0.-=-".: N':":' .t

---.- _. .. [ ". ~. ',.' ."

•• - I - ._

.. ' .

. I

• I

" .

II

• I M _

, ...

~

-,i~,', "-'--"~U""""I- '. f"~'

,',' ._-,=,,'W,I_ :_. '.'" i' I' '_,11, I • ~ :

.

-. ~

S- 1- 1- .. · .. iii'.. 'b- .- - .... : 1 • , I

;. .. .' -Isput, between par':ies conceD in" 0' ~-. . '1'·- : ., · ~ -

- , ~ ~" ~- .:__ ~.-, .'-. ~"~,:-~ acc'r'UB of cause ef a' c····t··.'II!O--':·'D

• -' -- • '- 1 .. 1 l_- .• ~.~[',.l '!'.~ V . ..,.,1"1.1",1 _',' " ",

,';.



..

I L

11.01 ..••• ,.-

, . .

, ,_.

31" .

1 . I

3' ."

I [',

.

- - _J

,,31i11 )'1,\

1· '-"0'-

, .

r _'.,~

,3319

3~:',OI

34:31

3- . .., JI

·3t4:3,

"4'i'I,l~'

. . ,_' ,

346 34,91 ",41:,9-"1

,1 r

3,5',)1,'

-,' II,

3,'-j'1

"'~~

,J~

'-5'"

·:IJ .... ".

" • 1

" - .1 .'

- , .

"

,~· ... 163

363 ,363

I ,

"

- •

.... - _

I· ,

I-

.,.- ~I"':__

_ J _~.

• L

.Ii

"

..

-,

-

C~

-

ICI_'

. -

.~- ~.

"11"""'" .... ......

O I-~

I.'" ....

"J

-~- ._,.

9- _ .

,l .. ~.,,~.

~ I'" !--~

.-

L

DO'"

r-~.-:.

I~l-;~.''''''''~''!II!''''' ~ ,~~ .. ~~~~~~~.

e

9 "-"ii ,"'"

. ,

. _,_'"

_-

...

L . .

- ~-~.

-- _ .... __ .-



...... _

- ........

-,.:...

.1'

a • _

~ .

I .

.,

t:

-,

, "

II U II
" III
I .. ,
,I '1,1 II' I I

I

I ~

i .. II' •

I~ I

-'

, h III

, I ,

I I II I 'il '_)1,"11
fi
I
ii' , flilil' ' I ..

_J

I I

- I

I ~

...

. - liil •

- ,

13·-:: ·'7·

- ." I

• ! - 1 II '.

- ,



! -

, ~ I •

I \

. ',.

.

- 2-

1 " (:

. . f ."

,1,4 •. ·

( 'J' ~

• I ~

I •

I _ .II'

, .

""

. -

. '

., I

• -.

I., ,r



J I ~

- .......

• ~ j.

I I

~ I

I' \, ~ 'I \ 1 IL 'J \ 'j

I' 1 ~,

.'11 ':, '1 .1 ~I "l4

· Expert ' I~ .~ ~

143 1 Generally , ,c. II " . -I ... _,'

,,14"3·2 'One; party appoints-an 'expertrtbe 'oth:"',puty ,-~i .. s tuuo ,.,

14:3:3 'Expert appointed by the arbitra tor . ",

, ' : Appendix ~~ t\ n-S~~dar4 ~~~e~~o~?n 'exp'=,rt ':"v,!c~I1C~ , -

1434 USing a second expert witness I ~'.'.

'14~3:5 Admissibility of expert evidence . ~ " " I' , ,.' .• .

14.3.6:. Whether the arbitrator has power to orderthe d-'sclo,'.lr,~·:'f a

f

report

:.i4.3.7' ~ BXpert witness, dies just-bofore'the·.he,n 'C. ,

.~.; · 14~3.8 Distinguishing 'between:' evidence 'of .w't nesses . L.

'716~1 710

112 113 '776 '7~'1J~

,'. ,

1

780

78t

- .

I

wi tn e sses

~. ',. ( "" t. __ " ..... __ ~ ~

'1- 4":-' ·3,'" 9-ci Ex ,':'p-.: iert evidence in ", complete C::··::'IO·-···ln-'- t ra d~·.;,c,--,-":ti'·"·~·:·n-.': . Ii ~~

...:...:.., '.'!iI,. "II!'.·.': .. 1 .. ' ... _', .. '.:.:._' ,~ .. ' ,:___.'-'.~-.'" .".'. _. ,._.'- ... _:,.__:_;. ....• '_.,--,',, _, .. " .. 1" .. : '. "-:":' .. "" ,.", - ... -_,,1;. '._"~ !~_l ... ' I •

': 14.3.10 Expert witnesses unable to' agree on any, mattersofIact t~ J:".!r', t 14.3.11 Neither expert's evidence preferred by the' arbitrator

-~'.... 14.3.12 Party prompts own expert while giving evidence. _ f. : '. .

14.3.13, Problem of hearing ~xpert evidence on lengthy,Scot ·)~br_,I;c I,ll,' ' "

· ~ 14.;3.14 l)ie're.spondentmakes an application d~~ing]thehe;~,ri1 ',g ',0 have I1t~ kY 782

witness of fact. called as an expert , ,.. . . . . ~ . I' ',",

.. 1'· 4/'- 3~·; '·1-· 5~" .,4.· ... e:::-~, .. -,e:: ,m,~·:·lp .. · '·11 'D-'~:"'Y':'(= , .... '. '.,i.,'~ .. ·'" sh ,.- .. I!!i .. :" ,',' •. ', ,',-.-:."- .... ,, .. ,- .. ~., -.",' '. ,_... ,I Ii.,· _ ~ _ ,~ ... _ ... ). '1--: ': . 't' y .. ' 'W·',tJI

, . I,' .:. ~II,A.. ,~'~ ':' ee WIS. esto appear Bll·: n e spe :t witness t r the " ,_' .

preVIOUsly employed .him ".~" . ',' _" . ',_ .' .

, -

1 ..



III

'xy.y-· -

.. " I. ' .. ',:,' .... ,

• ,.: :" : ... : •. ,'. 'LI _

-

., -II

r I

,);_:-: evidence in his report from 'annther e .per

. '.' '1'1'~:-; ·I·~'e, ··d· '. '~EJP; '::-',e~'-':" :~ ..

.... ,_I_._ . '.' I, .... ,4 .~.'" ",.

, .

We- '! :~' ternat : ~e agenda items' or the option of" ri ,-' na 1

-

:-~:,~::s. fresh evidence to the arbitrator after publicaiion IOJ:~



i' .1-1 op:_ -, rtuaitv of maki ,g snbmf don tOI arbitrm 10.'- .on . h"'~i 'i'a th·; : <. facts

.. ' .. "'.' .. ' , "e "_ .l!a:._ ....

- ,

After .·i-I- "'~I'O' 'an adioumment req 'U- -·OJS~·~t' to .. ·· the claim 1'8' . t t'_'O~1 see 1:_. II' ·g:.-·.··I)

~, '. .J, ." .':' .',. - _.. ':~l l'_ 1- . . ___:... [:II'" - '_ " . _. ','.' _ 'I -. .. ",' '-. I, ~·,Wt~" -'1 ,": '" • i . '-.. . ~.' .'':'''': I'll 'I. : _: .~!.._ _ .. _ ,_' _ l ' •• " " } _:_.~.::.__ l~_. ~J • ,I, " _~', -.: i

I, I_-.~'=:·~, .'," J -. ;-, ,rtIi - \··S'I -~ "1 '~'.' :'m~ -t,-. th ~.' claim - an-~ nt e'ails t';O"1 -m' ia '~,ft, an .. ~·'" ~ y~' f -Uf'1 ther 'wn:'~ ritten S.")U-'b'-II[n 1!@:S·""lli'O."'·ID··~~ I ~I

~. . ... ~ ". - -, - - - - 'Il1,0;. 0 _ _' _- , .'t: .' . ~"" .-' '_.~,_-.....;..:.._:c . ,. ',".- I, . l.i '. ',' ., ,. ' .. ' _','::' ~ I.' _-' > _- . " ': _"_ .. _,,1 _: . ' .. ,_. _ .~: ... _ '. --=- I .-:,. ". 0,.' . _ _. ' .

• r .'"

kev .... ritness \-~'h' '0" C···anD''I''·IIIQ'·····t .. , b .. ···e:·~~ av .'~::':'Ia..':. ble for the hearins seeks ,·!O.· .. -·,I ~_I'_It,V'I'~

"" . ~ ""' J~JL.... ,~~ _. _ ._: ... - ,.11 ...• '.' -- " .. _ au, 1_: ... ,'.' 1-1·,:..1. I, .::_.' ,[~ ... _I'''I''~' ii3_',.~: ['. , . ~

e·~I-~,.,:-I,' I',~ I',,_-' the arl itrator in, the absence of' the other party

,,.\-L~~i "O:=-'~11r recei .. ves eviden ce ~;D" a ;b:[·s·' .. ence 0",·:/·' both ':,' part ies

dIii.~L~·,u,g_~_..~ ",~. ,", "_',' _.' ", ", . L . ....:. I."" '.~. "'. _',._. ",. ,',_--,:,:, . .:__: .. .:_··_'_·I· .. ' _~_'._ll, ._-=- .

. .

.. \, ""~.tIa.cDr determines dispute without bearing eithe ~ party

~-'-'I":~ admissibility of documents, into, an "exparte" hearingnot previously

. ,~' '~':i iat is, hearsav evidence?

.J . ,

- ~e~:]" evidenc is now, prima facie, admissible unless parties :-', ee

,.".,..10._ ~~~,I!!!!!!.~~~", .: 1"< . ~ -==-_' of le:'li~' ,;'. ence are to apply

ree uests consent to refer to a.letter rather th an callins the

,

=- - 1-

- . ,

,-', i~l~

-

. . ,

f:'~~;' of legal professional privilege

.... .. ~1 d' ," Ii! l' U II'~' d d-' [!Ii

Litisation pnvuege ann non-pracusmg iega (Y'lqU8111,lie,'-:' 18,·-· visers

::; 1_],-' l'ri-rlIe.:;e ""-can be claimed by, Don-legally qualified 8' __ VI: "t~_·,?

'-', _I '~;\_I""" ,,~-~~ in rent review .r · ~'ri bitrations

• 1 ["I," 1 ' •• 1, l~~ •• _,_. :_:_~. I_I .~, .. '~ •• il. '_ B: .. ,. ,', ',_I, ., .. _ --..:.' ;1','

'~~\i.'i;c;d material referred to at a pre', I; ,-i,ary .. meeting, .

.: ' i'O"'" "'"'~"." . 0" ~e':' C<O' mfiden U··II,aJ··,·~·-·· doc .. · .. ·:u':'·-m:··:!·,e·-~nl ts .

_,_--.!III!!!II!.r!i.i.";'IIiiiI ........ r . ·l. =) .'_':__' =,.":.:1, ,I ., .~ .. , ' .. ' .... " .. " ' .. __ . ",. c ' .. '-=--_"_' _" _c~"" .', -'. -

,'~: ei Jt ad due , ed at hearing from a privileged document

.. '-j if es .c\ rithout prejudice' offer may not be privileged L _

~_i J' .:::' i.;,.'~-.;,_,.'·-,!,c·'c.-. of a "without prejudice" letter to; the .arbltrator?





biects to exchange of proofs of evidenc - ' . _

~~ .... w.oa'lIll"~~.;!!!fWd state I~. snts of witnesses offact may be used at. a hearing

Iill !I·

, .

c. "

I'~- O-i~-'

.. ' .'-:._' .

" ,

8:~,·6 \ .

(Jl'-II

(r" l" • I

81··'7'·"

, L '.'



'8.:.12') .,1 I .. ~'.:" .

8~21

8_2-" .'

'. .

I .'~ . ·_.il !

I.' -:'2~·~·· 3~'

" .. ". .

,,_. ~.-."

826~'

I :~'I,~' I

, .-

J

:81~_"" I

.1'1&'

8- .. - '2:-

"1 ".

- ..

~~-:~'3"': .. ·3~··

(": "'- - . .' .'

. ..

,::~··L3·:·,'S·.'·1

r .:"',

844:"'1::-,

I .... -

_ .. ' I

84j~·:1

-

E . pert determination . . d s san arbnrator or an "jn~epe,_,_- e t ,~~pert(l

",_~l"'~"',-~_ether perd~on is;~~~~~e~~a~n~~~pe', be successfully chalh nge: }

1 ,2 ',ben can a determms ,'d, "_ ..? '_

._I '!I!'.. . :_.- .. - ende ... it expert Of arbitrator · " . . '~, 01'(""-:

' .3 1 depenc ,enlex,_, iert not bound to act JudICIa" y . , .

It' The 'independent expert ,'".'." '. '·f·'·, dispute ..

] .• ~ DI-"Ie~ t-',e·'-nrun· .... ination in the absence oa-,~]s_J':"I'- ."d-I'e:'c"""'d""-e:' t '10" ','. determine a p'reliminary

.~' ,-". " " mila tera y "".... e, , .",. _ " , ,

.6 Can an independent expert U'I · ''-', ,. .. ,872

"J~"'.? .. _ a sons for - hi f:s'" determinatl on? 872

'.,." ,I ' '" """ "ee re"""", , _,-, ~', ._ .. _ ._

S·-, '. -'uld···· an 'm·'···: .depe mden t. exper glV< "<": " :~. , .-

7'_, . 1 " 0' I I ], , .. ', (I .• 1., I .. 1 ,_:' ::..>. ._. _'.

:. 1 J, ~~:. .. _:: ..... _. _ . . • •

. ' '.'

Genera I' y ... .r

- .. -~):'. _,I: .. -.". I, ':.'

, 1'" 6'-:'· 1" _1-1 Generally ..

. c' •. l. __ . '. '. ._

Appendix '"A t<Arbitrator's Terms Appendi» ""BI"" Time Sheei

A' "plpel~n~-d·· .• ~1~~ 'Bin Expense Sheet

. , L. :. .._) '. ~ ._A... _

A ... pendix "C" Typical Fee Statement _

. . . .

'Ion agreement of - ., . . ,

':<""6"~"" '2'cloJl~PJartv agrees to arbitrator's 'fees, :tbe other doesnot . ~ .. r : _ •

-. "....., -.'~ "'" " d--~' tc .' rbit . at 10-=- r"S-' 'r- equ 'est · [it> 0" .... , sign terms: ~ the

16~2~2 Neither party responca m artntr .• ,'" .\_ c.'_' .• · .. ·e; .'~., 897

arbitrator subsequently seeks a commitment fee 99

8-· ..

16.2 .. 3 Party considers arbitrator's fees too high '=,. ,_

-. , -. '. ". , the A: [ 'to . to r's F'e'es

16.2.4 Fees How does the party with liability 'to pay Jt'-e'.Lr-<ra~or~/<_

.[ '1:' .,,,, .. :;.,' .. .'_'-:'. ,".-.:'-,, ··· .. :· .. fl: ~.,' :-Ih·'····l·f······c:;·· ' h;········:-,I·hL···,,·:"·~:h··[····-·----·I .. · .. idv b:··.·- en naid by 'the other

challenge the amount 0 sucn · ees Wen t.eylave area-_y Ii een paicoy tn 901

' - '.

party? ' 903

Non payment of ' , __ , " , , _. ~ : .: _

16.3.1 Parti,es agree~rbitratot's terms at prelimmary meeting; but' fail 10 return 903

them signed. They also fail to pay interim fees subsequently requested , , 91'1

6.3.2 Cheque 'for interim fees is not honoured _ -. ' '. _ .' .

16.3.3 . ~ 'bearing becomes protracted and runs: conSiderably over 'the t~,mec:,s:t aside by~hearb~trator; consequently he finds himself considerably exposed fo' feeS 912

out~t~ndm~ _:VhIC~. h~:~a~~ot recover for several mouths', " '91S

16· 3-' 4· P a yment of arb··ltr··a··'to· 'r-"s . rut f k I

.'.' '. ',' ">C'.I., " .' '. 0 -o'-poc et expe-- se .

163.5 One~~ o~ent~paYbalf Ofth~~bitr~t~~':;ees only 'on ~oJ1~ction of 916

-3_ rard ' __ . , , . .. "

., 910

16', 3'6 Arbitrator, ·· .. bi··)j-;'iI'>·h-:· .:,,'. ':.1 . '.' I' .' ... , __ .... ; .: . iii! _

.• - .1 .., .... " pu .ses award and partIes do not collect

- 'N" --I

A· , .. ;' .. , ,

- ...... -. ·· .. 1. TI10I'1

- - - . . . .' I 1 I'" _

.'. E-'---:-:'R""T"-" n-···E··;'T·-·E·· '·MIN - ,_'. '.

' ". , " . ",' ,

r, L·.I'~._ ._ .. ,_, _'. .

. 6-'

. '.

I .

..

. .-::: E' S'--'

P- --, "'--:"

• I ",:._ ____:_ l •. _.

J

, ' ...

, .

..

16'- 2"'~'

i" ....

. ,,:::::' "Iii·" ,

,

. .

,

I I

'H5~J 8[~',

. i!~1j; ,

IH54+ 1"5.4

a,S5 85'fj 8SYI 85191

8:7·'5·:

. .

. '.

87'5

8'~:7'57

,'. _'1' '.

8S'S'

L • I' ~

.-.,'

. ~- .

,890

'8.9..1, '-892

8·····"9~;'5·c:·

"-' ,

[ . ':',-':'

Sn,s,,'

., _'

r

I

_ ,

-J.

-

, -



-.

" -

_.

..

. _

_I •

17' ?':"-

I ,'. j.

, ~ 1!1\~

'"

. . I

-

.

~

..... _ f

'"-t • II!

17-'5'"

_ I _ ... " .,_

.' ...

. .~' ;6-:-:

- ~ -

""

I I

;, .

·~1~··:~7 7-

, ~"

• ~ iI-

- 'Ij ~

1_

!

'17'8'

, ' " 'r.- .

- ! 'W".:- I

1~1' 9""

• ~. ,!!. <

I _

I ,

~ .,.. .. ~ ..

~~ - .Or,d . ,". ,olf . ' ~,- I. ~ , -, ,,":}. I ~'~ f ..... ~!.. : & I • I ~ I.L: ~ ..

17.5..1 Respondent seeks to interpose his expert·eartietmto ,the hearing ~ ,.

Par(y~s right 1:0 be pr'esent throughout .' ..'" ':,~~.' . ~~:.~ · · .

_ .. 17.6.1 Re,spondent con:Sistently.:riIde·tQ,;th~e·,;~rbitrator. : ,; . '.~.; ~ <",~ ; ~.' ·

. " _ i - 17 ~6~2 Arbitrator :exc1Udes 'tJbj,ecti.bna'ble ',p,arty; · : .. .';, '1 .. _' ". ,-:.; ,- " .• • ," ~ • ~ "

~

Po' ... ··s~·t··'p· "'0'·':"0' e' ··m····' e" ··n····'l··,: o-:-:-:·'f','" ,~. - .. ~~ I_~' ~ - - .. ~" •• J • ; I

j.~. :_.I,~ ··.·:.1. ~ .. :._._.~.I.! " .. ~' .. ;~."~- __ .. ;_<."_"J_' __ ''.~- .. _' '}... _ r.

, I.

. 17.7.1 Postponeniein' requested due to nuo ... availability',of lZounael.· 1:: ',' , ",

'. ' 11.7 ~2 .~,espondent :Wishes ',to' ,postpone stait~of bearing ',; ", -'-' " ! ~'. : ~

Pr';·'·~~.e.""n',c·.·::e"-· .. o·::~··f';;a'~ s:'t·I'-a::n':·g'i,e'-'·.'f'· 1':-·1' ,~. ~.' -- 1_~ - .. , ~ . .1 ~I

_ 'J ~L,. ; •... ". .~ .. ~. ,'_. , ... 1. 1._., ~:_ . .1 ,,:' .,: _

-, . ,J'!; d .. -, '.' · II!

:' 17~8 .. 1 -Attendanc!e of pe.rson -Dot iny .;ve ••. In·, .sprute ',: .. : ' - : , r, -

l7 .. 82 Confidentiality of arbitral pro~~"edings :- J~~'."'- . :.', .,.' ,

;- Ri' I:' ~·:D,L'l··-· t'; 0······· , 'l.·~'~"e-· ; . :,. ',:' J • '.' • '\'. ;~ ~~, ; '_" - •• ', •• ' . • t.:~ .-: · - .

r ..... ',oil ~',.' .. ',: ,llill''I':,:. _ ,-.' _ _.. · 'I; _ - II.. .. Ii! ,~._.,,~.

17,.:!t:l One .putywants ,to':.hav,ffmal hearing the:other;wmus ,'~dcicumenls my"-

TA'" 'IL'" E', u O·· .. ··'F-· 'C""0" 'N" _- -- r_.

'., . '. .. '-~ ,',J :~. I.'~· I. 'I,· 'T' 'E-' N':: ··'T· j:~'~

. . _., '_""= t : .. ..:_. l_,', j ~ 1 . II '. 1_ ~I

- 1;

1,6,,,3'OF7 Parties settle. but make D:"0<'" agreement co ... meern nin ill' the ,gl' :b·'·":,t!, ,,··t'· '_.!il .,',

. - ,. _,'"" "- .. .. / '0, - __ 'I;.,;;"._" ..• .' ""I. ',: I.!'~,' :.ICS," ',,-, u.. ·llltr'B·I'o'r~" 'Ic'es

and neither accepts lia.'bi.lity··, for them I,", . . .. .:._._..".- .• , ,." .... ,. - ..' ' .• -:' .• ' .'.'-'.'

• _. " ~: -" . __ • • •• • • 7 I

Appendix ~A .~- Typical points of claim ' ~

. Arbitrators, securitv for I I ~_ I ~ • •

!IP.l I .. • to II ,. _ _ I •

16,~,4~1 Generally

... ·6. .2. Failure by one or both parties 10 comply 'With a direction of tbe arbitrator o provide security for his, fees and expenses - -

Appendix '~.A ~~' Typical Directio ... ",·.'D····. for pr ocedure "~o'·:·:·,r··-' ,d·'·-·e~··.'a'~li,",It!'n- g .. : .... 'WI",··,,-·iII!th·,-·,·· th e a rbi

l __ I ;~JtI'l • _-. _l~ ... l I ... : .. _ .... J ~··_l·.:.· .. _"",1.,")," ~ ... ~ .. ~,l_./. _,!._ .•..•. ~_.'! 1 ,'~, .,.f'.-, ," II. ," Ij •• ·.·: .... '1.", I".~

trator's security for costs ' , r ". . , . '. '. •. . •. ~ .

Appendix "B" Typical Perem ptory " .... Or d er followin g" failure t .. o .. ··"· p·· .. · .. rovidese c' or' rity

- -:: .- .-' -- _.. -' ".1 ;:- .. ' ... 1,.- .--'.' " .. ,~.,:_) . _~' ",,',!,:,,: ..... ', ., .. ,_-",._", ,: '-'~'D':"':'_"·,IL~":'·'., .. o._,U_ .. '.::> , .. _'i,',L,·)·····.·i'.I,;·'. ~,::A,~.~ I. : ....

wh e'-;' '0-" d hre .'. cte . . " . . - '!;. - ~, ,.

n . "I.~'~. .: .. '_ ,JlI ' .. ~. _·_:_.""IL,'_·- ."

16.4.3' ... aat to do with a substantial sum lodged With. the arbitrator 8.S security

for ~I':~, .. ' ". . sts . . _. ."

.1,1._- _' 1U3 _. I~ _. _"

16.4.4 Arbitrator.anticipating ex parte hearing, sets.level of securityfor his fees . and expenses. Respondent unexpectedly'turns ltp,-'aaimantinsiststha~responde'nt

be directed, 'to, p'a;\l ,3. moietv of th e',"~, s'~.,:·e·. C'. ,'uir' ,-.liiIlc'f~y .. i.'~' • - ,

ri •• ._- J . I '."._' - ',_' .' ".. . -_! _' . J l. :. 'I

1645 Hearin'" adjou nne d 0";' ·I'n·"·· application 0· .... ··('·;: resp o -r nd ent U'" Jn rder circu mstances

, '.'-,rio' _I ~. . " .. ' .' _'_'~o .' ",' ,b ' , ..• :' ':,:: "" .. ' .. '.'.I~··.!. "J' (: ',1.::.'1 ,~ .L . ,'~:...:. '.1, _', '_'-'. ,,-I~.DI :' ~.::.:: .'_.~,I~l ... ..:: ~, .. L,-,,' .:::.:: -' i.JLi' .. " ' . .1. "'1 .~ .... '.: .:~ "~"

claimant asks arbitrator to direct That respondent put up some security for arbitrator's fees and expenses-c-all previously provided bythe claimant. Arbitrator

so directs, ... Respon d ~":Jj;'nil t d .. I,o··.····e,: -:5'." not comply ..

- • j •• _I _!." '. . _l:~ _I' _ '._' .. '_ ,'I', ' .. _' _I .' .•••• l',: ',' i:. I, •

116 .. 4, .. :6' Sec un rritv for arbitr ator 's fees-after -:_ com ~. man y ...... put in (""0-', )1 iquida t .. ion

- - ", "_. -'.1 ILi ., DI~ < .',1..1_, ..... '~.' '. _._.~ u.,_:_.-"... -, .. 1 ~! c 1 .",. ,,' . -.' ',_ ,.I ., 'C.', ,.I~_ -,),.,_,.~,...: ..

,..

-

Ie ..

'H' "':" E-"~ A······ R:, I.:) , N' .•... I' G':':' ':_

. " ,'.,". I 1','" '. . '.

." '.' . I' [', ,- .. "'"', _' ~~ '._ .", ",.1

• I

~ . ~ . -

• .. j

I t _

• -=

_.

-

.' -117'·,.'," '1': A,.',····",d':J~O·,u:: rnm nrnent o .. :'f:~·

• :_.", - I l', ,,_ .. ," I .. ~_ I I '111 • . 1.1 _", .' . _'. _. .:. ," '.:

" ..... -- ;. I!!I .-. I ..

";7' 11 Parties J~:IOiDt"l\1' request a djou .. rnm e.::'·D'.t-~ 0"·'[1':' hearinz ."'

. I _, '." J I .--{t·, -'! . ' __ .I , _K_ - _JI _. __ ' ,I __ I _ . "_:1 ",l!'[' t· ",_- .. :', "'_"' : .~..:<. II~ "r.

,17··~,1" .. 2. .A, hearing is set and 'C'D,e or both.parties fail 'tOI tum .up .. ~, .' - ~,'

I ---'__ - ~ ~ • l I - • ; ,

- I • . - . -- t ~ -

.. - -1':'17,'.""" '1'-' 3'~'~', A< diourn imen it req -U-'AS""'I"le" d 10''::'" cons .. sider supp .. dementarv exp err's report

•..• " ~iC:' II!'.~.' c:'-~,~ WI" ,I.:, JI. _:, n :_: '::-:',1. :~l" ·.:.·".:'~.'.~W',·~I,.:-~II,i .'.,'~:I ~'::-:" :~:,:.)!"_,\.i~, .:..:...:. , .. ::i, .. >'",( ". ,,~, .1"'1'<. :._, -::""',';,::_1 .. ~'. ,,_~,,_:._,::.:'" - . ~

Agreed bundle - ·

17 .. 2.1 Noagreed bundle delivered 10 the arbitrator ..

17.22 Parties fail 1.0 prepareagreed bundle and. produce their own '

,

Evidence ~ J e ~ ~ -. l ~. - _. I~

" -17:3 .. 1 ,When relaxationof strict rulcscf evidence-is permissible :

1732 Counsel c-onstantly.objects to Ie a,ding , ,question,s, '.', .: ',~ , ,

fill. •

In.terv·e.:ntio:nsl I· ~ .. ~ f .: ~ j • ~ - - ~ ~ k".

I, f- 11: ,. d- d'-' "b' ,., Ii "

. '.11.4,;,1 Arbitrato['s,topscoWlSe, .. f[,.ter JI.ong .. wm.e: surmtssion··. . _. - -

17.4~2 WbeD .it is p',ennissible for an arbitrator to interrupt cOUDSel: -, ~,'''.- -- ; l

~. -,.;,1-7.4.3 _ Arbitrator in.temtptscounsel indicalin.g his acceptance' ,o£.point being

.m~a.ld,e i . ~- ~.' _. ~ ~ " '1 .... " -.;- ~ _ ,.

"I • --- -.

I •

9r~3-=-'.I:

I' I

- I~?-_ .

"I' .7'.,'

r .'

91,27'

931

~ ;', " '.

i

s 3'::;'· 3' '.:,!

, .'

. ,

:~" ~ , ._:

9·-·'·"3.!-6'c·

.', ,J 1,.1

._. I . __

-

,.. .

.

n'3-:'-J8"'';I 'I.

ig·.····4':t··

. '_ ,_,I.

. I "

" . - ; i, ...:~

94,:1 ~9·41. ·9··~···· ·4·:" . 2·.:-·:·-·· ..

. - - . ~ -,

9"'4':'3'['·

I .~. ~t " ""_ '; I

I _.11 ....

9-44"

I' '~. ~

r ,I __

· -'

- .

944

._'~;;

". ",1 "',

_-. '.. I _l

II

.' . r 6-'

••••. .1 "

94· .. ~,,'

94"1"~'

,""1'" .',

'or,: f .....

9_-

:,., Ir ttli7) l~.·.:~ll~"

94'·9

I .. , ,,':_',

" ,...:_ .

9_75, '0'"

,: •. - •. ~ I ' .

f.- .'., '_ I~ ..

9,C'4'" ~~'l~;

9·'15 .. ···',6<

--:-.1. ('I -' .. .' . '. I j_ .. ' :- -. . _--

95~~'~

,-_ .·u

· ," '-'

"'g- '. -5~' '7'

:: " o[ '-.-,.'_ •

. :=' .; .. ~ ,"

9'57'.'

• I I'

- - - .

n5··'·~·9·'·'·

!;I. -:,', 1

:9· ···6'-:·~'O-····

",_ "_".' : •••.. 1 _ I

-

·

,!nll~iO' ,. . ,~ :r~u.~-

:""'1" ····1·- .

':_.' : I·, .

. '

9-6'3"

I "~,:I

l '.l

", . _.

"7 .. 1 I" "I

I ~

'119 .... 1 ~I

, , .. / 'II~

2'''0''

I'

2" O"~' ~l

I

__ . _ II: _. "J

~

, J

..

t

r . -

n ,

( .

~. '.' \

II I I ~ I~l

II II:

an'" I"

.

- 'iii _. __ .

" ,

.. L

l!lil ..... ;""'!I'._ I I_n ~

subject of the reference

19:,: "']' 2' .", A~" . b'" . .11 t"l , -- . ., t··· ',,,''''.--: 'I. h .. ~ ',,":"1

.. > '1 ' " .• ,~- '~'"'' 1 .1" r[: .. 1 o"r WI~ I' 1 ~ 61

fth f

,_'r' [ •• - ,_.o.~~_. -., .-.---

01 .r e rl'~, eren ce

_ l _ ~,. • 1_, _ I j •

"'"''9''' :' 3

I •

I ' __ ' [ .

", ':.: ,It ' , .'" :.,!

-ty.,.

_. rl

When f n arbitrat 'D.i· ficulties C1J risin f:rl' un

. 9 2::·· ~ 1," -:'.,. e q u 1:111 rem ,,- [.::;-.1111' It: , : I. I·' "Ir' I: 1_ '~' I

L. •• .. iii .. ._,~. , , ., _ ~, , . . ..1, ,_, I , .

, 1;112=-" 2·- IO':""I"l"'CiJI r""'3'r'-ty··,' ·'·'C~ If "I c ii, !~I~ 10"···· l~ri'll~tll~·gl'll~oir to·.,·: insp .liC:C~I"

.. ' :11 iii _,,::C:"'. .. r.· . .' I I.' .. ,"",' . L ILn .' 'I.JI, 1111"·,, .- . ~- " I .. " I i _

SI!O"~'I th e a r 'b·'-'-·II" tra 0-" r {'.)'··.r-f·~·c~l.r· ,10. t' (J .. 11l'ipIC'_' ,t 1'1' ,':1 visl t 101 t.· ike evidence

.... .' _ ~_,," ' .. '. .! 1 .. _:. ,,:_. '. ~ _:, .. , ,lin _.1 "I._I~ ,,1.1l ,' . ''.-''

19 2 3 I·'· espondent ignores 01'1 arbltrutor's '-- ir

'''.. till _ it· _',' ." 1-'- ~ .. .'. .. '.' I·," '" ." ,1_:_.J,_j" ,I .. - ., t· _ ' . "I - '. '- _.- ,,' ,- ".

access for arbitrator's inspection

'Ri') 1"1 I f til . . ~,~··!·_cgr \,',,1 0:.,: parties ,St:

- ~ -

,,-91,,31 Th ie : ·llIg·~·.J1t,,· of par li'iOiU t, I~ In II I·~I.

_!" r. _' iIi-. "- .. " . I' ~_, ~-._(_l _ '-I ~. II' I~I\I _",g·1 - 1':_1 __ ,'

_. ,

..

"

Of -.

" ~

- 2~ -::'0', ' I" 1"

_.' .. ,~,:J1IIl J

...



!II I" ,

[" ['-' . [ .' ,I r • j (- ~I •

I_I _ _,I .. _ ,f1CL. I ,_

. ,III'n- a~". I IC"'~'" , .. dm ~D',

,_ " ~ I ',' I • III -

I~ '=< .. .

_.~ a cO-i-Qund

J.

J •

..

, - . ,

I .. 11

,..

i ..

• _ r .... .. -

, -

. .

7 •

L •

.

• _ H



. t ~ -

, - - ,I I"·. I ..-

(_,U'~-<I~;· In; '_- '-1-',0111' I~'JI',' I(ln,' ~" _,~~-_I_

2,l.,l ... 4, '1,~S,SI of "Mi conduct" in 'R,<~' en -·1 Revlew I, '::11. ,,-'1-

- -,. _.. - - ,I I_l I_I •• l. I ,_I._ _', II.'. '" l _ 1._1 iii Ii I

Serious,irregularity~faillre: by thetribunal to corn :1"1', ' illh ,,; .• -I'~I ,_i, ,~' :,_'-,,~I ~:'Ir", IIl1J"'C'{

- '. --

,san,c'ti,o'ns

21.to·L.,~1 Failure 'tal di, lo : docnmen 'tD' '", 212.2- Whether to refuse adjoumme u coul : lb· conducting the proeeedin .. DC'

.. - -- -- _. ·1"-") - .. ~- - 1'-' . ..~. ,_I '. '~

Arbitrator com ,~- ie ·.,5·.··· to ';~'·:!I'C·- _,'[lJ.,~1 C,i_'-o:'-n:'--'I' f'-'!',lil -~~",: IliIO,-1 .. ~~\,,:II:" :1- en i\:~_-I ud do: ' 'i-I" iii' ~·l. _ .. -, '1-' ~,lj"If)I--~i_'~ 1-:-- '1·'· :-r

. - - V "'1 ._~'~' ~ .~. ~., ~ . JiI~l ... 'J' " .- ': .. 1 _ 1"'_ _ ... ) 1. __ 1'\.1 I., l._~~· '. -.,_' I . _,~l,. 1._,', =e. _ _ I

2,~1, ,~2.,4 Arbitra to r-·' fa ,,;.)- ~ ',·10-'·'· d leal '.'1.: 'Ij t' '11- ~i; I-n·· ,·1-' 'I'r.l· 1-~;I.IIi!i' ,'~,:.: thi e . 1~--'7I1 -~j,~'-, -,'t 1", i~' j-:'I! ,-_ .. 1 - - l .~. ,-~:~' I-I' .. ;,1.1

. - - .~ .... -,. '--.' _. -"I. ,-,~ .... - . _'",",,'A, ,_'.'. . _ Jj '_' ,~I._: '_' ' .. fi "'ili )lli_1 . _'In, 1 __ I Sk' _ III ,I.t., I ~ I_I r _ I Ii til 1101 .1 I, _ " I~I

• - 1 __ :

21 .. ,2~.5' "- -'be:n an inj udicious --:;~':i"'t1 a~ . r I ", ,0·- ·'1(---' the arbi II~ r-···-·' 1-: ..

- -. - - _. • -. - _ I I J • • .'~ ~ I ,I ~ I; III [lilt I 1_ • - ',_, . ~ if..1r,._i ; ". 'Jl_ r. __ l ~.

Serious irregularity challenging the award 21.3.1 Failure by the tribunal 1,0 'com' ~Ily 'i'I~,1 ':.,(s~,'~(2)( a» .

:2-;1-· -3,-;-2/1 Ar .; bitr 'ator exceeds h-:--IIiIS:~' p .. o .·'.I,W· -·'''·:·C: -- rs bv ,'-:;'U1'n-1 ~

" , .'1 - It', I ,_-._ - _ -, ,t_- -' ,.- A,_:..' - . "_'~ .1._,-, - _ ... ::_:",_ . _' - ,jiI' .' 1'1, 'Y III,. 1 ",_:__-

when the rules penni' only specific discovery (.,,6{)(b»

2- -11 - 3->1 '3-1 F- :;/a~,ii1i' ure 'b-J'Y- ~, t· 'h·'~ e a r bi tr -a-' ·t· or t-I'O;· cond uct ·"liI,,'JiII p" rocei d["I·I"I-' >~ill 'I~I, __ -

_'._,'.·,111[--·_.-" '--' .'_.-' __ ':. __ .,~ . -_::: 1_ .. 1" . __ >: __ ._ .. c- ~_._ ... __:-_'._'. - __ • --- ~ .. _."_,,._,._,~_ ',_!.,II!,W _ •• _.I,.,J,.~,,_, _I,-,I_l ----'_.

the procedure agreed by the parties (s.68(2)(c)

21..3.4 Failure by the tribunalto deal s .. ~.th "U the j~-;:-ue:s that W:.'C :-J~U','

(s .. 68 (2) (d)

[2,--')--i. 3-,·'·"1 '5~:,,1, U- Jneerta iintv o.·-··-,r-:-~ am •• ib .• -::"l~:g<· ·u.·-J"";'t··,y·-I~' as Ii 1'0: I,.· 'I]:,e-:' effect I,' ~:"f the ,'~-pIW· '-· •. '~'ai'rldIE I (' Sii'~'.·'·~II(~:-'1 '1:(')' 'I

_-_ .. '!Ik -'I!Ii._ . _-". , _-"" , .. __ - __ ., __ ,., .. _ ' . _", ..• ,C __ '~ , ._, ". __ -,. •.. _. II_ II - - - -_. - - ._- - ,- - .,~--,~_.-.: - ' ..

',2- ~l'!,-'~_-"jl .. ,6-"1 An aw rard 11\r obt ained by fraud (:si-1681(2.)"'I'-'(·:':-:)-···-'.)'1

_ !!I'!~'!!I! _ " Ul ' __ "',' .. ~.l • __ , ~g I._·_l ._. ,.l_.lo-; ". ,".'[ ._ '. ' _.-_' _,_l' _. ) ' .••.. ,_ l~l.~ - . '.1." . '/ ... ,' ,1[,/ I

2,1".3,~7i A.D award is, made wi thou ,. being dated 0. __ 1' statim .the

arbitration in COD trave nti on to s ... 68(2)(b) A' "'96 lO'~;

21 . .../1.8;'.D arbitrator admits. toan Irregulanty On the .. "'~ rd ,; •• t.'f )(i"I (\ . "I) -(1.:"-

' .. isconduct immunity from suit.

',_~l ~,'~l~-l :0:-;': t,hl ..•.. arbitrator

. ,

IO,f the Appointing Body .



'ti IlIii_,

·1-1 O~--·'···· u :~: 1:1' R-:-_-

.... , '. I 'i 'I i ....

.. j "_. - - ' '

. . I

..

·'r·~

I

's I":

, .-

I ~



• ,

. .

... . ,_

,I -

. ~

..

! •. - .. , ,1- I~I

I l _. __ ..

"I· -" : ... --. 7- - . i

- ..

I . ~_ .l I' ~_'.)

110-··,··'1-'.)":- ,

I '. f ' . ~ ":_:'

.10 ,',' n'IOI -j

,

, .

24, ,24,~i-

..



'2"'4.":: 2""

• r', •

. .... : .' 1,- IIII~ ""',,,,

2"""4:' 3-~:;

" . ! 1.- ,',

- -_.

~ " -

';':4": "5'~

~, i_-.!II: ....

: ,

.

,

':-"4'" '6

21 .. 11,'.':'"

'"

24·' 8""

i-. _ ,'.

( ,.:. ( .. ,:"

( _ .... "_::

,

2- 4:'1. 9':~'

','J I

- - -:~ :-:. -I~' _/

.. .

24 "1'11

.

, _ I." .. r

24/ '1'2":'·

. . . .

_ J,-:-- • _' _ 1._. 'I

_ _ L

..

" , ,

. "

24'1' 3'

r- ,.,. ,,~.'

,,~ • I

24' 14~',

[I . r , _I

..

'"

'2:' iS~'- .,."

I ':"'!--' .

_ ,

( - ,

. 2'~':5'~'-']' I

""~;', .:: I_"

, "

"

=

, ,.

't,09']

Assignment of claim "- _ , :- __ " -. ., '", to a third party right to arbitrat ", Hl91

24.1.1 Receiver of clawaitt compaoyasslgns, ,I ", ',C ' , '. • • ' '" ',I,e a

dispute , . 1091

, ~. L 1092

' Bankruptcy of " ,-' , · _ .-_ -_- bOt"atlan

24.2.1 Party is ptn into bankruptcy during a~ll r,'c 1002

D~~of' ~ 1~

"~.- 24:···I·,··:'·-:··3·~~,/ .. :1- Pa rty d :'l;:'~'S:~ d .. uring reference " 1.09,4

,_ 'I"" ..•.. !. , .J .... '·.V." _·"·-"~.·' . .'I·--

Disputes as to . - , '., d' ' - 098,

~~'~41. "4' :1'- "~W~-, 'h th - laim .a nt belie ves that there are joint re·s,plo'n.I'~e'nt:s and the

~ I,~,' .,' en '"i e, IIC:lty. i 1,>': ,':. I,," ,:,.':.-.' ... 1'" '~.' ,- -. "'-

res~~dent 'avers that there-iS ~ third patty to the contract which the c~~imant denies 1098

II b !

"" Illness of '. . 1102

24 .. 5.1 Party requests indefinite determcnt' due toillness __ . 102

: Liqnidation or.- ~ . ' '. ". 1103

·24.0 .. 1 Power of arbitrator to. proceed when party put Into' comp~~ory

-:'llquidation' ',' .:.' .: ' ' ,

. 24.6 .. 2 Party in liquidation; original assignor's right to arbitration

~ '-"4 ~", .' . ,-.'" ,.,' t li "d' t·-[!!II dut ." r - f' . "

I • 2 :';~6\1:3 Claiman t goes into' creditors voturr I ary iquic :.8. :1.0n. mmng re'. .erence

. .

Loss of confidence in arbitrator "-.107

. .

a "

_24~7~1 During a hearing' a party loses confidence inability of the arbitrator to

grasp satisfactorily the problems being arbitrated . .. --

Personal contacts with · ~ : '. · L • I ~ ~

2-'4-' 8' 1- A b Ii found ~ 'h I" " - '

.", .. ~ Arbitrator tounc to have regularcontact With -one- party"'

~ . 'R" ~" hl"- i!I' "" ~ - - •• ,

" _ _':':e:"Cel'V',ers:;~lp:, In. ~ ~

24.9.1 Party put into receivership during arbitration ' , r : . " , '

.. " .~Ile· .·;lu·.·'"c~'t~'a-:;,n':lt~: ·r:e,·· spon dent '--

", • .....:., ... ( ."~'. . ." 'L{··· ",.' -' .. ::_., .' ."' • " "': .~. I .

. "

, .

24.10.1 Respondent fails to acknowledge arbitrator'sletters _'." 1111

_24.10.2 ~espondent persistently fails to comply with 'arbitrator's directions lU5

24~lO.3 Respondent engaged in delaying tactics .,,' - - '. ' 1115

In rep udiatory ,< brea C" "h'--;-' 1'1'1'11

. _l!' - . :. . .,._ : _ (_._ ," -,', 'J ... I r .': ". I., -i1 : •. " .,..! .! :

. .' , [ . . .' -~.

24.11.1 When a respondent seeks a declaration that the claimant has- repudi-

ated the Arbitration Agreement '. - --- ___,...,.t) ."," 1117

Impecuniosity of . _ , .. . 11.9

24.12.1 The:responde~t (counter-claiina-n~,·t'-!.)···"···1 ,a,~d.· ~lli!Ii't';.s·· :t-o~-'b':'''e_:'''m~''': g ..... to uall -"Y' - ou rt o·'··f.'·:~··fu->.· md s 11.1.9

. .• . '. ,. . .. _,. 1,;1,.1..1., I, I ,.~. , I ' , .• , I'" ' 1 1 1 I I ,. , ,

Role reversal ...- . -_., - "" '.~ -c :," --- ·~,'o'~ .. 1120

';1 . - .'.,' . -I, <.' '., .' .. ".. .. :. ,_. , . . . '.' , . '. ~" " -: - " ,I

24.13.1 Respondent becomes claimant 1120

24.13.2 Tenant avers that he. not the landlord sh . lid' b h-1 "'1'·- tt.l

Written A···· g-'r'-e" .e m' ie n t .~. (- . -. ' _:<~,'.,:, ._,: ':' .. ) .. , ~>, .. ":OUI 1_:: .: ·-le" .. the :"'IC-, annan t~, . , ... c. ."

. _. , ; ., .. r ' t • _. •. ,. '0" . . ~ . _. - ..." '" -' - -' ., ? I

'"- ~;:I'-"- < -..' ::.' '." _ _ '. .~. . _ . .... ll:;

24,;.14~1 One P'; arl}r attem '·PI't.,S:',~· ,. 'O~'-:.·I res [Iii 'I' c··· , fr -, ,--:, '. " '1 iii ,," " - " • 1'1 - ~:1, .

J '..., 1 ~'.. om a"n ,'- I' " j _'

.. - . -.: -_i'.:.",~ .. _: 'Li., .. ': I' ear' ler'8'llree:"m'I' ent "-J .'.

~. _"--: . ."~'·IC' :::_.~-, '':0' ":"'=,."_",, .. 1_,

~ "f

" ~

l1U3 lli04,

lI-'lnrt .• i~')

110~' 11081 1108 1110

-,. "

1110 1111

I~

" .

.

• I

, j •

...... ;

"

I" • II

...

t L

I ~}

Prj IIJ~DU"I- in .ary ]~iC!'UII e '0··· .. '0··1 -

_' - ". _l_~ II I '_ .... .1'_.1" n I." Ij;'I. _!I' " '",': rl! ~

, . .

·25.1,.,1 Preli nin \s··1.1·,ry::: .. , 1".~'riS:~s··· ue of ," po -"I'''~n' ·t- Lf·· :~·I·' I" .

- - .. _ . . -'" .' .", .' ._,'. '. ; I" o· '.'~ a w

"_, - _" , '1" '-'"." " ".,."r" . ,_-

• I - ~- -" - ,1 ",'"_-"' ; • __ 1-. ' , •

" .

. ~

I ~ _. -

~ .Ii·

"'. ,

112J

1125

~ I f!.1 -. J

.. - . ~.,..

• L

" "

- ·11-·1I1i

XLTI"-.

. .'

, .

. ~

.....

.. "



f'

~ I

'iii "'Ii "
..
1 '\ ~
~ ~ I"

..

"X~'·,'r'

I . ",

lIlli' .

,'"

-'.", "'.

", t.

. ;

. '~' '''''; .

~I" ~"

- .,..

I I

tb

- . ,

1:0

L.

..

• ,J

..

I

1

1

1

1

},

I

j

I

;

f

~ •

,

.'

3- --

,

3- .~ .,

. -

pjii.-

3,2,'1

I.· ..

,.' ~ .

, p

._ -

N'C'E

'. - - --:- '1 '.' '.' ; "-

S· 'Pl ·'E···-'C··-"'·P··- -rCPERFOc<MA .....

, .I :: 1 ..":" '.~. _:_ . .~~ • ..

-

.- .

13131 1'.331 133'1 13'J.~

I,

13,3.1

131JS 1335

, . .

3-"2" . ')-1 C· -. '-II"

• /,.. t ·J1oswg . • . 'c ns

. 32.1.1 Advocate's closing 5ubmlSsJO ,\

32.2 Copied to both sides . d b . r.bitrator not sent to other side

3-'12.:'" 2···· .1"- Do ·:iC.··u··mentsl receivec I'-.y aroi .~ I:_-" .. , -

II"" ! :_. 1.1 . )bll!:__ _..:, .' .' "_.'. _ I. "...

- .

32.3 . Opening . . . '.~ .

.. 32.3.1 Counsel's opening subnusSJons . . ..

..

3_-3, .'

.•. 1' liii' .

OJ

34:

, .

" .

"_ - f!

. ,.

'34'1"

O[ •• ,' •

"' .. "

~_. 1,.'1 _

3-4,[~2i

'" - -

..

34' 3""""

. _:. '_ l~.·'

I ". !I!I'. ,1_

3'-'4·,1 '4,1

I' ". -' ...

;3' "4:' S··'_'

=:: .~ .. .,._1

347

[ ,oo_,:

j ,"

'I ,:

. . . ~ . .

34/ 18'~"

I "-.

_ - {"liIIl .

3-4' 9

. I .' - .

• .(1' ',_1 J

. - "

, . _ ",-',.'

.

. .

..

. ,

,

~_

. .



VA'"' L'U' 'E-' A-' ·D···· D" .... E-::-'- D:- 'I' 'T:- ~A" X .... ··

_ _-':i~ __ ' .... J r . :'" /·L .... ~ ~I . ,.::-:.1 . : .~ .:_1 ,. ..:....... _':

V-'a)1 d' d d' I' 1339

~.:,-.:ue: a:I.'.I.e·;_ '·,S.x· __ ,

. '3;:-i 1· .1' Generally·(· . 1339

33:1:2 11teVAT position when a party settles . H.'M· C····; stc . dE' . 134~

A· - . d~' ;a!..·'A- ~~:' A····-· .. :· -' ed M·': in u tes 0" ··fl~ M'-·:- eetlng h .. etween !, .,_,<,1 .•. _.~US'I~Olms, anc .!1~·,X.C:ISre:

'p- p' e- n' - . - IX'" !Ire ..... e« .:.' gr' ·e·- 'e'" II I I···· '. ' .• " . '. . .. -'-- .' . .

. ':".': ' .. :,";_,1,," ;,'.". -:: .. ~.' ..• _:__,! \._·,._· I~ .. ·,.1. ,_ ',:c.:",:_. ,,: .. _ .. , '," ~ ._

(VAT ()ffice) and LawSociety-23 October 1991 · 1350

'_" ·····3"~3:1· 3··-"Th·'·e':c·t'r"e·····.a·'t·'·m"e·n'·t·_··r··o-:f·· .••. V····-'A~.·T· and damages and "offers' to settle 1354

r=--" (' _,I. ~_.l· I.: " ~ " j.~ I '_I I . i '.::_ ~. I, L I ," I Il - . _l ~ _- '_ ~ '... _ ., -. - ••

• •

. ~ -

'1"31-" . ,".),

1:3.5 .. ··

1'3.58 1358

"

Appeari .. ln'-·lg.·. for bl·l. oth side _-S~-I

I _ .·l . . 1, ':""" ~";.'.. 1 I, - j. I . :..' ". . - .: .. - . '.~. .

'-3,~'4',··-, 11 -BI':'o·:,··t~'h-- pa ... irtles ·w·"'" ··l·~I£i!lh·· t ... o ... ···· call same Wl .. itness

::)'...... ·.iI.·. ~ .~:. _. .. ' .. " : .. ': _c I .... ,' .: '1. '.: .. _ LJ: .' '. .' .- .. ' ": _.,'. ' ..•.. , .' -' ..... ." -;' '.';' ',' .. ..:' <' .

.... • '_ J

Compellability to give evidence ~ . ~

34.2.1 Generally ;. .

34.2.2 Witness caned by claimant refuses to attend hearing .. Respondent alleges

h- hi it · . 11·t h~ j' 1'3~ 61-

that tt 1,,5: 'WI'. ness IS centra '110 1- 'IS case. :.~:l.~ ••

Illness of 1362

34.3.1 Persistent interruptions to hearing through witness's incapacity 1:6 ..

. di .' 'rt d·' it ,j ., _'613

Le[8·i'..ID,g questions a~, .... I prompting witness _ ~ ~ ~ IL~ ' ...

34.4.1 When leading . questions' should be .allowed 'and when-prompting 8

'W" .· .. ·Ji'·n~le···. s--:::'s·:: J~~. un I' acceptabl e:, I '1' '~l:;: ' .

.. \ __ .,111"1.'" II-,ll'" ,.-_1< I ._, ... _ ·._,1- I.', I', -.iil"

Hostile/objectionable behaviour . , 13M

. 3~.5.1... When a witness's behaviour in giving .evidcnc,,',be.comes. unacceptable \J~

Order of _. - 13~:'~.

34.6.1 Counsel requests that expcr' be called befo(i);witness,c' o···facl r

Perjury, committed by ... . I.' • :. ... ; ... - . -- .. 136

,'34;7,1 Witness clearly Iy·~/~:i~ng:.'~·, under 08.1'11-1'1 a~'n-"'di~' s·:··.'o,··HI\r,·'C~~I~t·-I·O·· "z+-s::' - uty "'-0'" l-···\O···S-·'II-·r-· . l"'h~' 't· .. -U1t'h-

'- . I.' -. ' .. .1 . I ".~ ". ',. I" ." . . . .' I II' I I . --' 1 .'. 1 ,: I I '.

• -- .• - . ~. tl • ~-. ," [~_l . '. '_ I' -I '\ _ .. '. 1 '" I -:' _ • • • .! . ~._ .' -

of witness statements I· • , ~ -"-' . ~~ '- -' -._ '- •. '.' --. t ~I~ ~

~ - ,'~ L l,

Proof of evidence -- "l\~'

"~ ,

34.8.1 Generally . . . . 'llic: .. ·,!·'

• .. I_ 1

Question, refusal toanswer '. .. . .

349.1 Witness who previously' ag-·.~I~'I' c[1 to' .'. 'I'I"Y"III\I ·\'J~:~I-" ."-" -. ' . :' ': . J' ...

- ... '.' _ .. :".l., - ~-. I_<i" ''W ~ 11"_;CllC~r III _-.~'I-_' .. :~I, '\lISle:! tt)1 ':'_, : 5[0

" . ..

r: I _

" 1 •

I. I... •

, .

.- ,"

...



r~ I

Ii

1 _

35·"

'- .

A-- ).

.

~ J ,

..

] 1 1

1 '1

-

AF-~

"_ .'

I ,

3,

,~'

3-

.

,

· 3. -3'"

1_"

3-- I

Ii!

3'

,

I j

3- ,

r.: I

3w

I

- "", I

.'. .

'--- I" .

;;

1-'

,,' ,

7

..

o

..

..

Qlle$tiOl1 of

. ' : .~ <: ~"Ii!'" ..... ,,,.iji>., .. ;_. ''-:'' .f'; jr k.ti'!li

oec IS on O"I~'

.~.-.

. '!i!j!; ,,".'

'-

, ..

E',~~",,;,

, . ,

-

,~ ..... :- e" . ,,,:,,,,iiiiff'y'

I~l '. J ... - _I

'0""-' "Ir'" th·, e .. "··1

.!. -,. .. , . .'

. " .

.A , ~- .

• I ...

..

I ••

• ...

-Ii

)

11 !-I"li02"·'(:>

~_fl~I_." "._

'14031

]"406" .. ,

... . . :~::',

'. ,';

='. _ -'c' •...•

14091 142····9 .. ;,'

~ I - J .

'1431,

143:7 "1'" 4 .. · ;"'84·~·····" ",

.,' I .......

:"14901 '14'99

15<0·· .. "'5'::'-

- " ... ~ .-.-

~ .. 5;1:01

1'55 .

. - - . :

'" _, ,

'1" .. ::- '::[_' ..

,

"

i ·

.

l

(

I

, ..

· · ·



. ,

'_ .

• 1!

I

I _ •

. . -

I ~

I •

~ - ..



'~_,UJ,CS Or>1 -)i trat ion and Appe~ 1990

."1. I~' - ~, Arbirratiou Ru~11 '~'S, No, 125

-',r ~:f-' lee "_'.': l,I,Jc'::.91197

>'~l~ Draft N,.\, LGIA Rules 1991

I,Jr;) The J< .r Arb'tralion Rules (18 July 1988)

_-' '7 ['cnfl Proposed Amended JCI' Rules 1997 _. , ".,

: I~, J ,T I .ontracrs, Sui .. Contracts and Arbitration Rules- . Not, to UselS

The Roya) Institution of Chartered Surveyors: Appointmem of arbitrato',' "> ind'el'~'ellr(r,e.- n'II' exp erts pnr .. ticularly in commercial property rent ._'~v_"')J'·e2.W';.,. d-',IJ '- 'I '18ID:d

' " "- ,- do, ,- "c, :,.0, [, ,il. ,,' "- -'. '--' -" ,,",,-. ,JJSpur

piliey statement on alleged conflicts of interest ':e'_

.2~ Institution of Civil Engineers' Arbitration Procedure. (1997) .J • '" OJ'' be Conslruct;o,· .. m I' nd ustry M,,·'o·····:·d,-·e···~1 A'~' rbitra tion ('·:·-'CI'~,.·M~.·.·····.-:·A·.::·,)\· Ru .. les

. - ..• 1, ._", . ".,'._:I_ -': __ 'C' ... """,,, .... ' ... ,', _),.,,_'. II ,- ,., .. '_', ,'" " _' .. _:'J. ,_.':,_)

- ',-,:" .

..

r

.

..

- .. 'I

I •

. .

t _

I •

. ,

" ,

• r

.

-. ~ ~

- , .J

• t

I ~ I

11.'

+ -

..

, .

• i

, -



1 •

. . - •



'. r-

, I ~ •

.- " ~ ...

I • ..'

1 .. ••

. -

-

&

-

., . ..

~ ..

-

..

..



.. ,

1

I ~ • I

. ~ '. .

II'

...

. - ...

_

I I

, L

, .

I I

, -

• I

..

- - • PI ...

. . _



• I,-

• J

,. - -

I I' ..

, ~

( .

- I

'I, •

I - !

• - I

~ .... Ii

r" .. II

I

.. .._ r l ,-I!I' I ...

,

1-

!.i

- ' ..

-- , &

..

..

'.

: ,..

t -

. .,

I If .' I .. I ......

-

.

. .

-

_... -II! .. I I'_

- I

.. ...

"'

. .

_I

1 ,

" .

.~

• j

• rf':1I'

~

.

. ..

, • I

... , . '.

t .f' ';" 1 • II ".! .. ..' II

.... 11 '! -)Il

•• i III I • - .. !_

,I": :1; .. & ..

J~':' tfI' . J~

16J6

6" " ~

., [I

15J.:·,

J6:t

169

II

,~6IJO

,. 6"':"-

'-. 'J!'

! • • I

"'.. :.

- " -

167'~

1705

.-

-

!..-