Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Dr Neil J. Bristow
Presentation at Salvas Sydney Breakfast Sydney, 7th June 2011
H & W Worldwide Consulting
neil.j.bristow@hwworldwideconsult.com +61240286268
Plan of Presentation
1. Australia and India the Past Relationship 2. India - Drivers for Accelerated Growth 3. The Future from a Coal Perspective 4. Summary and Implications
Key Takeaways
Australia and India have a strong long term relationship in coal Australia is well endowed with a suite of met coals ideal for India current and future needs Australia is a proven reliable, long term supplier......unlike potential new suppliers If Indias steel and power growth takes off, Australia must be prepared to meet strong demand growth for all coals Emerging India investment in Australia is a sign of things to come and of a beneficial future relationship
Plan of Presentation
1. Australia and India the Past Relationship 2. India - Drivers for Accelerated Growth 3. The Future from a Coal Perspective 4. Summary and Implications
But why does India not buy large volumes of thermal coal?
Major use of Indonesian thermal coal, particularly sub bituminous Going forward will need significantly more coal - Australian
Million tonnes
10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0%
60 40 20 0 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011an
10% 5% 0%
Australia and India Import History Semi Soft Coking and PCI Coal
India is also gaining in importance in other met coals from zero to around 12% , at a growth rate of ~20%pa! Will SSCC growth continue or move to HCC? What abut PCI?
60 50 40 30 6% 20 10 0 India Australia SSCC/PCI 4% 2% 0%
million tonnes
25%
20%
10%
80 60 40 20 0
India
Source: Australian Customs
Japan
Australia HCC
India %
Japan %
Australia NA
Source: Interocean, Salva
China USA
Indonesia Vietnam
Russia Canada
South Africa
Plan of Presentation
1. Australia and India the Past Relationship 2. India - Drivers for Accelerated Growth 3. The Future from a Coal Perspective 4. Summary and Implications
India
1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 1950 1955 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
China
Urbanization (%)
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 India China
Forecasts
14
12,000
12
8,000
6,000
4,000 2,000
4 2
0 2005 China GDP % 2008 India GDP % 2011 2014 China GDP (US$b) 2017 2020 India GDP (US$b)
Agriculture
Industry
Services
India
Exports trends to GDP continue to climb Exports from special economic zones are following China model Signs India is set for manufacturing and industrial take off in next 10 years
Industrialisation
Comparisons of India with other Asian countries India is showing strong signs of following the industrialisation route
Trade Surplus in manufactured goods -%GDP (Heavy light) (4.4%, 2%) (0.6%, 9.6%) (-2%, 7.4%) (0.2%, -0.2%)
Decade Averages Japan 1960s Korea 1980s China 2000s India 2000s
Trends to lower oil consumption Trends to lower steel consumption (thinner, higher quality steel) Trends to rising cement consumption (still in a greenhouse world?)
Growth Profile
India
Japan
Korea
China 5
Growth trends sustain high rates for long periods China potentially sustain longer due to magnitude of its population If PPP rates are considered rates are even higher
India is already moving in 4 wheels Leading development of small peoples car e.g. Nano Led acquisition to build competitive position ahead of China
India
USA
Japan
France
Germany
China
India
Brazil
Technology
Higher quality steels are likely to require more efficient BF based steelmaking Limited PCI, many BFs dont have facilities Lack of high quality met coal leading to HRCO
Raw materials
Ports and rail infrastructure required for movement of raw materials Will iron ore continue to be exported? Who will meet the requirements for met coal?
P la n ts SA IL P la n ts , R I N L a n d T a ta S te e l Lt d .
A ll IS P s b a s e d o n B F , h en c e r e qu ir e c ok e .
E ss a r S t e e l, Is p a t , J SW , JS P L , B h u s ha n , e t c .
U s e va r ie t y o f p r o c e s se s . In p ut s in c lu de s c ra p , D R I , s p o n g e i ro n , ho t m et al ( B F s /M B F s / C o re x ) .
Sp r e a d a ll o ve r In dia .
U s e ve r y s m a ll E A F s / IF s . I n p u ts a r e a ll s o lid m e ta llic s ; n o h o t m e ta l.
Wide range of technology mix India has one of everything Data difficulty India steel capacity/production likely to be under reported Major sponge iron sector due to local lump ores and poor quality coal Industry seeking investment off shore unlike China (RM basis) Major capacity under construction mainly brownfield and greenfield difficult (ArcelorMittal/POSCO/Tata Steel)
250 200
Million tonnes
150
100 50 0
Plan of Presentation
1. Australia and India the Past Relationship 2. India - Drivers for Accelerated Growth 3. The Future from a Coal Perspective 4. Summary and Implications
100 80 60 40 20 0
Imports
High case
Captive Demand Other Commercial Industrial losses Rail Agricultural Residential
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
4,000,000
RES
3,500,000 3,000,000 2,500,000 2,000,000 1,500,000 1,000,000 500,000 0
2009
Million tonnes
300 250 200 150 100 50 0 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020
Is 20% a fantasy China exceeded this for a period? Is 10% or 12% too conservative if Indias growth accelerates?
2012
78 81 84 88
2015
98 108 118 134
2020
144 173 207 270
2025
212 279 366 544
66.8 96 166 414 1029 20%pa India official forecasts have been raised from 110Mt by 2020 to ~180Mt Groundswell in industry that all too conservative Major new investments underway SAIL seeking to double and then reach 60Mtpa by 2020 Potential 52Mt capacity in next 3-4 years
Recognition that India wont wait expand steel or imports-demand is there Even at 20%pa steel consumption per capita is ~320kg/thm at 2020
Plan of Presentation
1. Australia and India the Past Relationship 2. India - Drivers for Accelerated Growth 3. The Future from a Coal Perspective 4. Summary and Implications
2020 Pig Iron Increase in Iron Ore Increase in Met Coal Production Increase Demand Demand 76 156 50 99 131 191 315 191 239 328 515 66 87 126 208
Met Coal
Iron Ore
8%pa 50
10%pa 66
12%pa 87
15%pa 126
20%pa 208
8%pa will see ~1.25 times increase in imports 10%pa will see import demand growth similar to total Japanese imports 20%pa increase is equal to current seaborne market for all coking coal Major increase in all forms of met coal,
PCI = 2.1x today market HCC = more in demand at higher rates due to rising productivity ~doubling market
Iron Ore
Demand increase (Mtpa)
8%pa 156
10%pa 191
12%pa 239
15%pa 328
20%pa 515
High growth scenario = ~double current domestic production Potential for India to become an iron ore importer,
Rio sale sign of things to come!!
8% pa will effectively cease all exports without industry expansion Likely to see India play ever decreasing role in seaborne trade Continued tension between Steel and Mining industries
Summarising Factors
All assume very significant movement of raw materials
can the infrastructure be built ? Major rail, port and road building challenge ahead
High growth scenarios look impossible but we always miss the upside
China boom, pricing, freight etc
India in 2020
Could be passing Germany for no 4 spot in the world economy Could have a vibrant manufacturing sector focusing on light cars, motorcycles, smart manufacturing and light engineering Could be the no 1 global software and programme developer Could be the no 1 met coal importer ahead of China Could be the no 1 thermal coal importer ahead of China Could be the 2nd most important iron ore importer after China Could surpass Hollywood in film exports IPL could become more successful as the English Premier League Could have turned Cricket into a truly world sport
Outlook Series
Annual forecast / report
India Unlocked
Critical sector data series
Custom Consulting
Bespoke reports / forecasts
The Salva Report - The worlds leading publication on the Indian steel, power, coal and infrastructure sectors India Unlocked - Providing all critical data on Indian coal demand and supply drivers in one location Outlook Series - Forecasting the Future for Indias Power, Steel and Ports Sectors