Mobile Edition Jobs Travel Auto Classifieds Photo Store/Gallery

LOCAL NEWS BC NEWS

part of bclocalnews.com

BC Local News - News

1 COMMENT EMAIL LETTER PRINT FOLLOW

TEXT SHARE

Promotions in Abbotsford
Get HBC Rewards
by Alternate Moving Systems 01/05/2011 - 06/05/2011 Book your move with Alternate Moving Systems, provide your HBC Rewards account number to your
QUICK VIEW

Get a FREE Playhouse Plan

by Willson Design Group 08/25/2010 - 03/03/2012

QUICK VIEW

SCROLL :

Business Search
What Where
File Buy Abbotsford News Photos Online

(type a keyword or listing name)

An RCMP officer writes a traffic ticket in Surrey.

(Address, City, Province or Postal Code)

Abbotsford, BC

By Jeff Nagel - BC Local News Published: March 31, 2011 4:00 PM Updated: April 15, 2011 9:49 AM
Recommend

RECOMMEND ON FACEBOOK
Sign Up to see what your friends recommend.

Only a sucker would pay their speeding ticket without a fight now. That's the street wisdom circulating on web discussion forums where motorcycle and car enthusiasts trade tips on how to beat their traffic violation tickets in B.C.'s congested courts. They point to the case of Michael Podger. The Kelowna heavy equipment salesman was ticketed by police in November 2007 for making an illegal lane change without signalling. He disputed the ticket, but delays in the court system dragged the case until January of 2009, when Podger representing himself successfully persuaded a judge to toss out his ticket on the grounds that his right to justice within a reasonable time had been violated. Since then others often repeat speeders have been boning up on constitutional law to challenge their own tickets. If it takes longer than 10 months for their ticket dispute to be heard, they can make a strong case for a judicial stay of proceedings, citing Podger's case and other rulings as precedent. It's not necessarily a slam dunk. Challengers have to prove they were ready to proceed on each appearance date in other words it was the system, not their own foot-dragging, to blame for the delay.

They also have to show they suffered prejudice from the delay. The judge in Podger's case agreed he experienced stress and was deprived of three days of pay when he took time off work to prepare his case and attend court. Podger was reluctant to be interviewed by Black Press, but said he's used the delay argument several times to persuade authorities to cancel his traffic tickets. He's also coached more than a dozen other motorists on how to use the case law. "Most of the time it gets stayed," Podger said. "I'm the only one that's had to go fight it that I know of." Surrey lawyer Daryl Brown, who gave him some advice, said Podger is far from the only driver beating tickets on the basis of unacceptable delays. "More people are becoming aware of the ability to make these arguments," he said. "You've got guys who aren't first-timers," Brown added. "They've got a few tickets. And they're looking at losing their licence if they get any more." The jam up of traffic tickets is just one more symptom of a court system in crisis in B.C. By 2010, an immense backlog of 58,000 disputed traffic tickets had built up. The Provincial Court of British Columbia, in its Justice Delayed report, blamed staff cuts at the ticket-processing centre in downtown Vancouver for the clog, because there aren't enough employees to input the data and schedule dispute hearings. Officials at B.C.'s Ministry of Attorney General claim the problem is in decline, with the backlog easing to 52,000 tickets as of January 2011. But ICBC statistics show the number of traffic tickets being disputed has steadily crept up from about 11 per cent up until 2007 to 15 per cent in 2010. More than 75,000 violations were disputed last year 20 per cent more than five years earlier. They add to the pressure on traffic courts, where Justices of the Peace (JPs) hear most challenges, and also to a lesser degree to the caseload of regular provincial court judges, who must hear any challenges based on delay because JPs can't rule on constitutional matters. "The ministry is aware of the backlog and is considering its options for ways to reduce it," said attorney general ministry spokesperson Linda Mueller. More staff to enter tickets and schedule hearings would help, she said, but staffing priority goes to the areas of greatest need criminal cases and serious civil or family law cases. ICBC officials note more than 60 per cent of tickets disputed are upheld in court, although that's down from 68 per cent found guilty five years ago. And when ticket challengers win, B.C. municipalities lose out. Cities get $63 million a year in traffic fine revenues shared by the province to help with policing costs. Surrey alone receives $5.9 million annually. It's not just traffic ticket dodgers who might otherwise take their lumps and pay up who are emboldened by delays in the system. Accused criminals and the defence lawyers who represent them increasingly see a good chance to quash cases based on delay, particularly when they see their trial date set 16-plus months away and stacked with multiple other trials on the same day. There's less incentive to plead guilty even when the case against the accused looks air-tight or accept an early plea bargain offer from Crown unless it's attractive. The Justice Delayed report warned the growing

Sardis Home for Rent

MORE INFO

JUNK?
MORE INFO

lawn mower repairs

MORE INFO

ABBOTSFORD, Furnished 2 bdrm. Grnd

MORE INFO

1996 CHEVY LUMINA APB Aircared

MORE INFO

Corcoran
MORE INFO

G & M Landscape
MORE INFO

Camperland RV Resort
MORE INFO

HK PLUMBING
MORE INFO

BILL'S PRESSURE WASHING Driveways, Fences,

MORE INFO

PLACE YOUR AD HERE

RECENT COMMENTS

Lee Hanlon Katherine Heppner is bang on the money! Kuddos to you Katherine!! L. Hanlon, CD CF Army Reserve (Ret.)

Abbotsford News - Give Harper a majority 6

hours ago

CalebKyoto Please put your glass in one bag, plastic in one bag, newspaper in one bag, corrugated cardboard in one bag, noncorrugated cardboard in one bag, metal cans not exceeding 500ml in capacity in one...

Abbotsford News - Trash to cash Abbotsford looks at curbside composting 16 hours ago

April Lee Anne Sandford Are you implying that a person can only work in the same town as they live? Not many mainlanders would have a job if that were the case.

Abbotsford News - Federal candidates Q&A: Dave Murray, NDP 20 hours ago

rhiebert "...Apparent BBQ Fire"; so

case backlog and lengthening delays mean defence lawyers are more motivated to proceed to trial because of the potential for charges to get thrown out over delay and, if the case does go to trial, it becomes harder to prove older allegations as witnesses become harder to round up or their memories fade. "The best defence here is to set the thing for trial," said Samiran Lakshman, president of the B.C. Crown Counsel Association. "Why would you plead guilty in that environment? That same type of analysis and advice is being provided across the province." Fewer cases being resolved early mean even more pressure is piled on a system already creaking under intense backlogs. "It's a bit of a catch-22 for the system," Surrey defence lawyer Marvin Stern said. "The system starts using its resources in hearing these delay applications." Stern said delays have worsened over the past year. He sometimes shows up to court in Surrey to find his client is one of four trials slated to go ahead in the same courtroom that day. Prosecutors then must decide which trial will proceed and adjourn the rest. That can mean another trial date sometimes the third one to be set 20 months or more after charges were laid, a time period that provides strong grounds for dismissal. To avoid that outcome, prosecutors may offer a better plea bargain. Stern gives the example of someone charged with impaired driving and driving with a blood-alcohol level over 0.08 where another trial date adjournment will mean the case will almost certainly be tossed. "They may accept a plea bargain to a charge under the Motor Vehicle Act of driving without due care and attention," he said. The driver pays a $368 fine and gets six penalty points but avoids a possible jail term, a criminal record, a one-year driving prohibition, mandatory safe driving course and required use of an ignition interlock system. "It's a huge advantage to the client," Stern said. "When the courts are overbooked, Crown are more likely to do that." Paul Pearson, a criminal defence lawyer in Victoria and local spokesman for the Canadian Bar Association, said long delays harden the defence bargaining stance. But he rejects suggestions defence lawyers and accused criminals are rubbing their hands in glee over court delays and how they can exploit long waits. "Most people charged with criminal offences stress about that every single day," Pearson said. "It's by far the worst thing going on in their life. And they want an answer yes or no, guilty or not guilty sooner rather than later." Lawyers usually aren't paid more money when they have to make many court appearances, he said, and they must be ready for trial on repeated occasions. "The thousands of people waiting for their trials are agonizing, losing sleep, literally having nightmares every night about the process," Pearson said. "They don't make the news. But they're the ones that are actually paying the price for the delays in the justice system and the lack of judges." jnagel@surreyleader.com

what if the aroma from steaks and/or chicken where only apparent and not really BBQ'd? I think a BBQ should be quite obvious; makes me lick my chops just thinking about...

Abbotsford News - Man taken to hospital after apparent barbecue fire 1 day ago

wascobi last I checked, youre still able to live and work where ever you please. remember freedom?

Abbotsford News - Federal candidates Q&A: Dave Murray, NDP 1 day ago

what twitter is saying about

#abbotsford
ValleyVoiceChwk Greens Face Dairy Farmer Bias: Hoskins unfazed at being excluded from meeting http://tinyurl.com/3o9wa... #chilliwack #abbotsford #langley
reply retweet fav orite

Abbynews Maroon 5 coming to #Abbotsford!!!!! Maroon 5 has announced a fall date in #Abbotsford during its North American... http://fb.me/zL0PMGq1
reply retweet fav orite more than 2 new tweets

Abbynews Maroon 5 coming to Abbotsford!!! Maroon 5 has announced a fall date in #Abbotsford during its North American tour.... http://fb.me/vwSKiAX3
about 1 minute ago reply retweet fav orite

Join the conversation

TRAFFIC FINES
- Range from $81 for driving on a sidewalk to $598 for driving without insurance. Fines for excessive speeding run from $368 to $483 and police are also now issuing thousands of $167 tickets to distracted drivers who talk or text on cellphones.

Legal aid commissioner Leonard Doust and Legal Services Society chair Mayland McKimm.

Legal aid: What happened to justice for all?

By Sheila Reynolds A middle-aged woman finds herself in the midst of a bitter fight for spousal support she never anticipated. She can't afford a lawyer, and turns to legal aid for assistance. A victim of abuse, her situation is complex, but not as difficult as the legal maze that has now consumed her life. She's found that people she thought she could count on to help simply can't, because of a lack of funding and resources. "It's systemic discrimination" against those unable to fund their own justice, she says, adding most in her situation simply abandon the process because it's so damaging. Between 2002 and 2005, government funding to Legal Services Society of B.C. (LSS) the provider of legal aid was cut by 40 per cent and 85 of the legal aid offices in B.C. were closed. Between April 1, 2009 and March 26, 2010, the society saw funding cuts to family law, including dispute resolution and category one criminal law offences such as breach of probation or failure to appear. Immigration and refugee law services were also cut. Some services have since been restored. Five LSS regional offices, including the one in Surrey, were closed last spring but were replaced with local agents private lawyers on contract with the society. And LAWLine, the LSS's telephone legal advice service, was replaced with an expanded, province-wide call centre. But many feel access to legal aid remains insufficient. Statistics show that in Surrey alone, just over half of the applications for legal representation for family matters were approved in the past year, while about 60 per cent of immigration applications got the go-ahead. Legal aid for criminal and child protection issues fared better, but applications were still denied for nearly a quarter of the cases. Veteran lawyer Leonard Doust says legal aid should be treated as an essential service. Doust, leading the Public Commission on Legal Aid an independent group representing six legal bodies headed a recent inquiry into legal aid in B.C. His resulting report, Foundations for Change, released in early March, summarizes that "the overwhelming majority of submissions spoke to the general failure of our legal aid system, the negative repercussions for needy individuals and families, and the consequent adverse impact on our communities and justice system." The report suggests federal and provincial funding cuts have left the system unable to meet basic needs and that it's the working poor and marginalized people who suffer most. It is an absolutely essential social service, Doust said. Without it, people can be, and indeed they are... deprived of the other essential services in our province, particularly social welfare. Its like the four-legged chair missing one leg: It falls. In addition to making legal aid an essential service, Doust laid out eight other recommendations, which included re-establishing regional aid offices, making more people eligible and giving legal aid workers better pay and support. The legal aid system in B.C. has changed dramatically since its introduction in 1979. While the direction at that time was that legal aid representation had to be provided to those who couldn't afford it for some areas of law, the rules were changed in 2001 and legal aid is no longer mandatory. For the most part, the Legal Services Society agrees with Dousts findings, endorsing the notion that legal aid should be recognized as an essential public service and that significantly more funding is needed. But the chair of the society also believes a fundamental shift is necessary in the way legal aid and those using is viewed.

Access to justice is often examined from the perspective of judges and lawyers, says Mayland McKimm, but when seen from the perspective of those caught up in the system often against their will the view is much different. "It is essential that we look at the justice system from the bottom up, not the top down, in order to understand its relevance to the resolution of legal problems that people face in their lives," the longtime family and criminal lawyer told members of the Law Society of B.C. in early March. What judges and lawyers say is not necessarily what the average resident and those "ensnared" in the system want to hear, he said. He said in consultations with more than 100 people, it was found many legal aid users had more immediate and basic hurdles to get past child care, poverty and transportation issues before they could begin to worry about getting a lawyer. For many, especially in remote communities, the biggest barrier to justice is just being able to get to the courthouse. "What does it matter if there are more lawyers, or that they all agree to slash their fees, if a single mother looking for child support has no one to look after her kids while she's in court?" he asked, suggesting improving accessibility like having more flexible court schedules or daycares in the courthouse would go a long way to improving the legal aid system. A second significant component to access to justice, said McKimm, is helping people understand how the legal system can assist them and making them less afraid of the process in general. This, he said, could perhaps be achieved by integrating legal services with trusted social services instead of sending people to lawyers. "We were told more than once that arming the travelling community health nurse, the local social worker, or an aboriginal elder with information about child protection law or welfare rights and a list of who to contact for help was more important than having a lawyer available," said McKimm. Financially, he said, LSS is working on reducing the cost of large criminal cases so that more resources are available for access to justice initiatives. "If we can lessen the resources financial and judicial that the guns-and-gangs cases eat up, there may well be more resources available for access to justice initiatives and legal aid," said McKimm. "At the end of the day, what people really want from their justice system is resolution of their problems so they can get on with their lives." Legal aid, but at what cost? Leonard Dousts call to action last month for increased legal aid services may be applauded by some, but not the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. Gregory Thomas, spokesperson for the federation, said citizens shouldnt be on the hook for the $47 million in recommendations suggested by the Commission on Legal Aid. Taxpayers dont trust defence lawyers to do the right thing with their legal aid money, Thomas said. Look at the B.C. Rail trial the two defendants pleaded guilty, but not before seven years of legal wrangling that earned their defence lawyers $6 million. Thomas also quoted the Pickton trial where the serial murderers defence lawyers billed taxpayers $11.7 million. If defence lawyers ran legal aid, we would need to close every school and hospital in the country, because there would be no money left for anything else, he said. sreynolds@surreyleader.com Twitter: @sheilaleader

MORE IN JUSTICE DENIED SERIES

PART 1: Courts in crisis Lack of sheriffs adding to court system delays

PART 2: Victims in limbo Faces of delay: Matthew Heenan

PART 3: Defence on the offence Legal aid: What happened to justice for all?

PART 4: Policing fallout Faces of delay: Torie and Jessica

PART 5: No cash for courts Court disarray 'deplorable', NDP critic says

OPINIONS Editorial: Justice denied - This is an election issue Column: The many travesties of justice Letter: No faith in justice system Letter: I read this article while my blood boiled Letter: Justice system isn't working

TEXT 1 COMMENT EMAIL LETTER PRINT FOLLOW SHARE

COMMENTS
COMMENTING ETIQUETTE: To encourage open exchange of ideas in the BCLocalNews.com community, we ask that you follow our guidelines and respect standards. Personal attacks, offensive language and unsubstantiated allegations are not allowed. More on etiquette...

Comments for this page are closed. Showing 1 comment Sort by Subscribe by email Subscribe by RSS

Maybe the real problem lies with the cops giving out too many tickets instead of catching real criminals. The RCMP have fallen from a respected institution to a bunch of "proven liars" relegated primarily to filling the coffers of local municipalities. Since the system rarely works for anyone these days I applaud anyone who can use it to their advantage especially in the area of traffic infractions. The lack of funding is not the issue it's the bureaucracy that has slowed things down to a crawl. The snivel servants who work within the system are as much to blame for it's failure as anything else. They need to clean up their mess, put in a full days work and streamline their own creation before one more cent is offered up. More money would amount to a bigger mess and if you want proof just look at the healthcare system. Our tax dollars don't go towards patients it goes towards paper pushers sitting behind desks. Not everyone can work for the government.......oh wait I was wrong with the amount of taxes we pay now.....we all work for the government. We need to slice off a big chunk of the fat at all levels of government and let these bottomless drains try and earn it in the real world.

Reactions

From Twitter

One more retweet from BCGutters

RT @Abbynews: Defence on the offence [Part 3 of Justice Denied series]: Why not fight? Court delays a disincentive... http://bit.ly/foKheq #abbotsford

Abbynews 3 weeks ago

From Twitter Defence on the offence [Part 3 of Justice Denied series]: Why not fight? Court delays a disincentive... http://bit.ly /foKheq #abbotsford

Trackback URL

MOST READ STORIES

MOST READ IN ABBOTSFORD NEWS
Abbotsford man arrested for cocaine trafficking in Quesnel Abbotsford News Apr-20-2011 NDP surge into tie for second: federal election poll BC Local News Apr-18-2011 Twelve charged after stolen-vehicle sting in Abbotsford Abbotsford News Apr-19-2011 Abbotsford Police officer acquitted of assault Abbotsford News Apr-21-2011 Get ready to Rock 'n Roll All Night: KISS is coming to Abbotsford Abbotsford News Apr-26-2011 Update: Barbecue fire investigated as arson Abbotsford News Apr-25-2011 Candidates clash at UFV Abbotsford News Apr-20-2011 Abbotsford Police officer on trial for assault Abbotsford News Apr-21-2011 Victoria-bound Bruins heap blame on Heat Abbotsford News Apr-21-2011 Bad ending to good deed at BMX track in Abbotsford Abbotsford News Apr-25-2011

THIS WEEK | LAST WEEK

MOST READ IN FRASER VALLEY

Abbotsford man arrested for cocaine trafficking in Quesnel Abbotsford News Apr-20-2011 NDP surge into tie for second: federal election poll BC Local News Apr-18-2011 Twelve charged after stolen-vehicle sting in Abbotsford Abbotsford News Apr-19-2011 Abbotsford Police officer acquitted of assault Abbotsford News Apr-21-2011 Keith speaks as confidentiality agreement expires Chilliwack Progress Apr-20-2011 WHL commish called on quotes Chilliwack Progress Apr-21-2011 Border delay prompts 911 call Chilliwack Progress Apr-18-2011 WHL tries to explain Bruins move Chilliwack Progress Apr-20-2011 Get ready to Rock 'n Roll All Night: KISS is coming to Abbotsford Abbotsford News Apr-26-2011 Update: Barbecue fire investigated as arson Abbotsford News Apr-25-2011

MOST READ IN BC
RCMP investigate suspicious death Campbell River Mirror Apr-22-2011 19-year-old woman dies in Maple Ridge crash Maple Ridge News Apr-22-2011 Social media helped protesters find Stephen Harper in Burnaby Burnaby NewsLeader Apr-19-2011 Earth Day: Will you accept this challenge? Kamloops This Week Apr-21-2011 UPDATE: YouTube video shows black rat sipping Starbucks syrup Richmond Review Apr-23-2011 Seven Last Words of Christ Abbotsford News Apr-21-2011 Coke, guns, cash Four arrested in major drug bust in Quesnel Quesnel Cariboo Observer Apr-19-2011 'JackQuake' lifts NDP into second, poll shows BC Local News Apr-26-2011 Easter weekend events calendar Cloverdale Reporter Apr-21-2011 No terrorists allowed for PM's visit Campbell River Mirror Apr-21-2011 more local news from around bc

site map
Election + Local Election + From Around B.C. Home News + Local News + BC News Sports + Local Sports + BC Sports + Abbotsford Heat Business + Local Business + BC Business Entertainment + Local Arts & Entertainment + BC Arts & Entertainment + TV Listings + Movies & Theatre listings Community Lifestyles + Local Lifestyles + BC Lifestyles + Health Opinion + Local Opinions + BC Opinions + Letters Weather Horoscopes Lotteries Obits Blogs Photo Store/Gallery Classifieds Auto Travel Jobs Flyers Mobile Edition RSS

customer service
Contact Us About Us Advertising Information Terms of Use Privacy Policy Paper Delivery Sign up for a Paper Route

partners
Alberta Community Papers BC Community Papers BCLocalNews.com BCClassified.com BCDailyBuzz.com BCJobNetwork.com BCLocalHomes.com BCLocalEvents.com BCRenoNation.ca Black Press Flyerland.ca GetawayBC.com Honolulu Star Advertiser Newlocalhome.com Washington State Community Papers UsedCanada.com

e-edition

Latest Edition View every page of our most recent print edition, as well as an archive of past print editons.

Copyright

. All rights reserved.