Nama : Osali Oskar

Nim : 22180085
Kelas : B1
Mata Kuliah : Perencanaan dan Pemodelan Transportasi
Dosen : Endri,S.T M. T
Jawaban Tugas 1

1. Analisalah pergerakan pada keempat zona, sesuai dengan metoda :

Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 18 67 88 57 230 300 1.50
2 75 27 98 69 269 250 1.00
3 29 135 27 38 229 420 2.00
4 99 85 67 33 284 650 2.50
dd 221 314 280 197 1012    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.90 1.39 0.89 2.61     1.76
Dengan Faktor Pertumbuhan, E = 1,76

Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 31.68 117.92 154.88 100.32 404.8 300 1.50
2 132.00 47.52 172.48 121.44 473.44 250 1.00
3 51.04 237.60 47.52 66.88 403.04 420 2.00
4 174.24 149.60 117.92 58.08 499.84 650 2.50
dd 388.96 552.64 492.8 346.72 1781.1    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.08 0.79 0.51 1.49     1.76
hasil pembulatan
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 32 118 155 100 405 300 1.50
2 132 48 172 121 473 250 1.00
3 51 238 48 67 403 420 2.00
4 174 150 118 58 500 650 2.50
dd 389 553 493 347 1781.1    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.08 0.79 0.51 1.49     1.76
 a. Metode furness

Iterasi ke-1
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 27.0 100.5 132.0 85.5 345.0 300 0.870
2 75.0 27.0 98.0 69.0 269.0 250 0.929
3 58.0 270.0 54.0 76.0 458.0 420 0.917
4 247.5 212.5 167.5 82.5 710.0 650 0.915
dd 407.5 610.0 451.5 313.0 1,782.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.031 0.713 0.554 1.645     0.908

Iterasi ke-2
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 27.8 71.7 73.1 140.7 313.3 300 0.958
2 77.3 19.3 54.3 113.5 264.3 250 0.946
3 59.8 192.5 29.9 125.0 407.3 420 1.031
4 255.1 151.5 92.7 135.7 635.1 650 1.023
dd 420.0 435.0 250.0 515.0 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000     0.990

Iterasi ke-3
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 26.6 68.6 70.0 134.7 300.0 300 1.000
2 73.1 18.2 51.3 107.4 250.0 250 1.000
3 61.6 198.6 30.8 129.0 420.0 420 1.000
4 261.1 155.1 94.9 138.9 650.0 650 1.000
dd 422.5 440.5 247.1 510.0 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.994 0.988 1.012 1.010     1.000

Iterasi ke-4
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 26.5 67.8 70.8 136.1 301.1 300 0.996
2 72.7 18.0 51.9 108.4 251.0 250 0.996
3 61.3 196.1 31.2 130.2 418.8 420 1.003
4 259.5 153.2 96.0 140.3 649.0 650 1.001
dd 420.0 435.0 250.0 515.0 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000     0.999

Iterasi ke-5
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 26.4 67.5 70.6 135.5 300.0 300 1.000
2 72.4 17.9 51.7 108.0 250.0 250 1.000
3 61.5 196.6 31.3 130.6 420.0 420 1.000
4 259.9 153.4 96.2 140.5 650.0 650 1.000
dd 420.2 435.5 249.8 514.6 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.000 0.999 1.001 1.001     1.000

Iterasi ke-6
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 26.4 67.4 70.6 135.6 300.1 300 1.000
2 72.4 17.9 51.8 108.1 250.1 250 1.000
3 61.4 196.4 31.3 130.7 419.9 420 1.000
4 259.8 153.2 96.3 140.6 649.9 650 1.000
dd 420.0 435.0 250.0 515.0 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000     1.000

b. Metode Detroit

Iterasi ke-1
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 29.2 79.1 67.0 127.0 302.2 300 0.993
2 81.0 21.3 49.7 102.5 254.4 250 0.983
3 62.6 212.5 27.4 112.9 415.4 420 1.011
4 267.3 167.3 85.0 122.5 642.0 650 1.012
dd 440.0 480.1 229.0 464.9 1,614.1    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.955 0.906 1.091 1.108     1.000

Iterasi ke-2
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 27.6 71.1 72.6 139.6 311.0 300 0.965
2 76.0 18.9 53.3 111.5 259.7 250 0.963
3 60.4 194.7 30.2 126.4 411.7 420 1.020
4 258.3 153.4 93.9 137.4 643.0 650 1.011
dd 422.3 438.1 250.0 515.0 1,625.4    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.995 0.993 1.000 1.000     0.990

Iterasi ke-3
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 26.8 68.9 70.7 136.1 302.5 300 0.992
2 73.5 18.3 51.9 108.5 252.1 250 0.992
3 62.0 199.2 31.2 130.3 422.7 420 0.994
4 262.4 155.6 95.9 140.4 654.3 650 0.993
dd 424.6 442.0 249.7 515.3 1,631.6    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.989 0.984 1.001 0.999     0.993

Iterasi ke-4
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 26.5 67.7 70.8 135.9 300.9 300 0.997
2 72.6 18.0 51.9 108.3 250.8 250 0.997
3 61.4 196.3 31.2 130.4 419.3 420 1.002
4 259.7 153.3 96.1 140.4 649.6 650 1.001
dd 420.2 435.3 250.0 515.0 1,620.5    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.000 0.999 1.000 1.000     0.999
Iterasi ke-5
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 26.4 67.5 70.6 135.6 300.2 300 0.999
2 72.4 17.9 51.8 108.1 250.2 250 0.999
3 61.5 196.7 31.3 130.7 420.2 420 0.999
4 260.0 153.4 96.3 140.6 650.4 650 0.999
dd 420.4 435.6 250.0 515.1 1,621.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.999 0.999 1.000 1.000     0.999

Iterasi ke-6
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 26.4 67.4 70.6 135.6 300.1 300 1.000
2 72.3 17.9 51.8 108.1 250.1 250 1.000
3 61.4 196.5 31.3 130.7 419.9 420 1.000
4 259.8 153.2 96.3 140.6 650.0 650 1.000
dd 420.0 435.0 250.0 515.0 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000     1.000

c. Metode rata – rata

Iterasi ke-1
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 30.6 96.7 105.3 117.3 349.8 300 0.858
2 108.8 39.0 117.3 141.9 406.9 250 0.614
3 56.6 194.8 32.3 78.2 361.8 420 1.161
4 217.8 122.6 80.2 67.9 488.5 650 1.331
dd 413.8 453.0 335.0 405.3 1,607.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620.00  
Ed 1.015 0.960 0.746 1.271     0.991

Iterasi ke-2
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 28.7 87.9 84.4 124.8 325.7 300 0.921
2 88.6 30.7 79.8 133.8 332.8 250 0.751
3 61.5 206.6 30.8 95.0 393.9 420 1.066
4 255.5 140.5 83.2 88.3 567.5 650 1.145
dd 434.3 465.5 278.2 441.9 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.967 0.934 0.898 1.165     0.971

Iterasi ke-3
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 27.1 81.5 76.8 130.2 315.5 300 0.951
2 76.1 25.8 65.8 128.2 296.0 250 0.845
3 62.6 206.6 30.3 106.0 405.5 420 1.036
4 269.8 146.1 85.1 102.0 603.0 650 1.078
dd 435.6 460.0 257.9 466.4 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.964 0.946 0.969 1.104     0.977

Iterasi ke-4
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 25.9 77.3 73.7 133.7 310.7 300 0.966
2 68.9 23.1 59.7 124.9 276.6 250 0.904
3 62.6 204.7 30.3 113.5 411.1 420 1.022
4 275.5 147.8 87.1 111.3 621.7 650 1.046
dd 432.9 452.9 250.8 483.4 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.970 0.960 0.997 1.065     0.984

Iterasi ke-5
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 25.1 74.4 72.4 135.8 307.7 300 0.975
2 64.5 21.6 56.7 123.0 265.8 250 0.941
3 62.3 202.9 30.6 118.4 414.2 420 1.014
4 277.7 148.2 88.9 117.5 632.3 650 1.028
dd 429.6 447.1 248.6 494.7 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.978 0.973 1.006 1.041     0.989
Iterasi ke-6
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 24.5 72.5 71.7 136.9 305.5 300 0.982
2 61.9 20.6 55.2 121.9 259.6 250 0.963
3 62.0 201.6 30.9 121.7 416.2 420 1.009
4 278.5 148.3 90.4 121.5 638.7 650 1.018
dd 426.9 443.0 248.2 502.0 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.984 0.982 1.007 1.026     0.993

Iterasi ke-7
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 24.1 71.2 71.3 137.4 304.0 300 0.987
2 60.2 20.1 54.4 121.2 255.9 250 0.977
3 61.8 200.7 31.2 123.8 417.5 420 1.006
4 278.7 148.3 91.5 124.2 642.7 650 1.011
dd 424.83 440.18 248.36 506.63 1,620.00    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.989 0.988 1.007 1.017     0.995

Iterasi ke-8
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 23.8 70.3 71.0 137.7 302.8 300 0.991
2 59.2 19.7 53.9 120.8 253.7 250 0.986
3 61.7 200.1 31.4 125.2 418.3 420 1.004
4 278.7 148.2 92.4 125.9 645.2 650 1.007
dd 423.3 438.3 248.7 509.6 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.992 0.992 1.005 1.011     0.997

Iterasi ke-9
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 23.6 69.7 70.9 137.8 301.9 300 0.994
2 58.5 19.5 53.7 120.6 252.3 250 0.991
3 61.5 199.7 31.5 126.1 418.9 420 1.003
4 278.6 148.2 92.9 127.0 646.8 650 1.005
dd 422.3 437.2 249.0 511.5 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.995 0.995 1.004 1.007     0.998

Iterasi ke-10
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 23.4 69.3 70.8 137.8 301.3 300 0.996
2 58.1 19.4 53.5 120.4 251.5 250 0.994
3 61.5 199.5 31.6 126.7 419.3 420 1.002
4 278.6 148.2 93.4 127.8 647.9 650 1.003
dd 421.6 436.4 249.3 512.7 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.996 0.997 1.003 1.004     0.999

Iterasi ke-11
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 23.3 69.0 70.7 137.8 300.9 300 0.997
2 57.8 19.3 53.5 120.4 250.9 250 0.996
3 61.4 199.3 31.7 127.1 419.5 420 1.001
4 278.5 148.2 93.6 128.3 648.6 650 1.002
dd 421.1 435.9 249.5 513.5 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.997 0.998 1.002 1.003     0.999

Iterasi ke-12
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 23.3 68.9 70.7 137.8 300.6 300 0.998
2 57.7 19.2 53.4 120.3 250.6 250 0.998
3 61.4 199.3 31.7 127.3 419.7 420 1.001
4 278.4 148.2 93.8 128.6 649.1 650 1.001
dd 420.7 435.6 249.7 514.0 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.998 0.999 1.001 1.002     0.999

Iterasi ke-13
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 23.2 68.8 70.7 137.8 300.4 300 0.999
2 57.5 19.2 53.4 120.3 250.4 250 0.998
3 61.3 199.2 31.8 127.5 419.8 420 1.000
4 278.4 148.2 94.0 128.8 649.4 650 1.001
dd 420.5 435.4 249.8 514.4 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.999 0.999 1.001 1.001     1.000

Iterasi ke-14
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 23.2 68.7 70.7 137.8 300.3 300 0.999
2 57.5 19.2 53.4 120.3 250.2 250 0.999
3 61.3 199.2 31.8 127.6 419.9 420 1.000
4 278.4 148.2 94.0 128.9 649.6 650 1.001
dd 420.3 435.2 249.8 514.6 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.999 0.999 1.001 1.001     1.000

Iterasi ke-15
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 23.2 68.6 70.6 137.8 300.2 300 0.999
2 57.4 19.1 53.3 120.2 250.2 250 0.999
3 61.3 199.1 31.8 127.7 419.9 420 1.000
4 278.3 148.2 94.1 129.0 649.7 650 1.000
dd 420.2 435.2 249.9 514.7 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 0.999 1.000 1.000 1.001     1.000

Iterasi ke-16
Zona 1 2 3 4 oi Oi Ei
1 23.2 68.6 70.6 137.7 300.1 300 1.000
2 57.4 19.1 53.3 120.2 250.1 250 1.000
3 61.3 199.1 31.8 127.7 419.9 420 1.000
4 278.3 148.3 94.1 129.1 649.8 650 1.000
dd 420.1 435.1 249.9 514.8 1,620.0    
Dd 420 435 250 515   1,620  
Ed 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000     1.000
d. Metode seragam