Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
��3�b0'830�0
··-··-,....
wEtln11wRr --,n..._.111 . w••••••.,... :au
. ... .. .. !WWW," .. •••�n•
�•'-"-·"ii";..-.-,...t ;:il,,I
�---
............
---·-·········-·
--
_ ___
.. ... ,
a, & n � n {; n.
G,)b8�a� "<Dr,; Gova6v
1919
CJ1 ra l"'l C, o c,.., C) s " CTl a3 9 C, c.c a3 � c:- o c- � c- c..- 03 o " a3 J--- c-
c, ._, �� <.J"3C e3 D :::l D c- o c.:> c.:> C1""lc.:> c..:> 'j J cn<.13'.:S :> J c..:, a., �c..:> 0. c,
o :, CY c.., o 3 C ,a 3 o en o.:, o:, :, o o r'" ...
3 o, (j 9 a
c- oi g7 ,a , a f] 3 c- , (j :::) c2- (j 0.. c- � D � g_, 't. 33 G ,f 11 � 3' 3"
11 ..... ra D � ra c J, C, � 07 9 d
'-"
o-" Q,) 9 D CJ o c-'5' '0
c, -c... '
,"".) C, '- ;2_ -s c:, C, D
f"l
n � \,,,I.J
C- lj' 07 ""'-l :)
O C,.) C::-
a., c:3 {j _,w O C :> C, J C,
D
o ,a '� c.:>
C, C, EJ .:,� J'--
o., C- a , � ,a, J'-- 1� J" 0 Qj 3 � fc3 c, D c, 1f"'lj g... (3 � g,' 1r-.:> <f3;:; 9
0
073· J' g,
9 C, C, 0,, ." C, 0..) (.3 0 ,a 0..:, C- C- .., ,-5. 0 0 'j I
a., • 1 c- 0:, a3 ° --- \.....:J
D
(J C, c..c a.:, 1 en C, <f3 a.:, D ra C, 3 c-
o er<;; c,> m 3 ... � o '1 o � c, ---
<8� c.:, a3 9 �3 9 c, g g, c-cv
• 0 10 C- 3 ,-.r;. � a3 c.:, c, 0,, a, .:,- . a.:> O' D Cl c, C..:> � 9 ''
�' c, C..l � J 'CJ Q,7C..l v v O '3 :> c, C- c, a3 C-/c3 � c, c,
.- f1 J ' J c.,... D C.... 0 c, o., Oi Ll CF' 3 C- ,"".) D J'3 n O <J'3 c,
'° D 3 9 (.3 0 D
a, 0 '1
,a c, c..:> c, '0 07- 'j C..C C..l C J°" J"-
(] 9 3 (j 9
�8't5� �o�c'1 0 9
<:.:> &,c- f]&3c9�C3 C, c-C-�
c,
.: 1n .:, 'n c..:> .J- a., o, c, · 3 D a3 c,,
a3 C..:> --� f1 . C�., a.3 t: tr m f1 0:> o �- � i�cgra1 � c, C-'> c.:,
�
5 a.:, 6.) J'J CJ c:JJ a.., c,
3"" J'-- ,a O Cj 9 C- � '.j C..... 9 f1
, 3 (J d D 3 3' � Cj f-' cc - /) � .., &_, � � 9 3
• c, a c, g7 c 3 t5 8, � � J ' c,
:::,
S �O) 9 l' <J3 ' ;:S a, 3 (j c.:> 11 3 3 c-
c:, 3 3 w (l g' o., or� g_.? C.§
'j ·
3 er� 3" a.:> o ,a c:, a, •
c ,.--:, g7 0 g_, c, /]
0) j " ra
,a \J C3 3 3 � ci
g o a., 3 :, · c, c- 3 C, C, c9 , c, 03
3' u- �. '1 c.- c,' en g"' 3' 9 o 3.. t o � OJ c, c- oc, 3 OJ a, o Cl.) c.:> 3'
c:, 3
cg §3&9 '3J --
���8 D Ql
�3 •
g..g t°ig"1J'"3 J
3 g '" ��3'�
{J g_CT 07 0· 0 Q.)3 /c3 J' � (j c, � .? o..:, (Y �'3 D ..,
1 'c Cw 9 c.:,
C... o> c, '0 \J a... ,o O O O 3 D '),..
0 . cJ a3 cS er\ Q
g... 3 (7' C..l c.:, cS C, 'J fJ g_ 0 a:, ():> c., 3'- C, 9 0 c,. f] (Y �
c;,. c., .0, '-JI"' D.. C, C, 0 3 c., � -:,
c- C, C, a,
g ,a g_ c, ° ·� J', C,
D C..l ca ·3 � A�
0..:)
I 9 ·a.:, gi '1 o ·g � c:.> 9 o 07 07 c- a3
� ' C,.l t, - r"" C"" C... ., �0 07 C, �· O c..:> C- C.:, 0 a, .., ,._ \J" � r C c(.,,> C"" 0 � 3
·& c; c;,. (7' 0,:, 9
0 C, 3 f] .;, 3---
3 ' O
t &, 1- c:33 3, i� ..
� gr-� � � ,rn 3--J r 3'" 3" �°i J� g..
C .. 9 Q.) 0 0 e' 3 . 0 $' 3... I] C � � 0
q,. °" � & ra cc c- :1-- � g' � s O 0 C t" c�> cl ra 'g 0., 3
c., cS Q.) " c- c,, s � o •
c..::, 0 3 C..l CT 9 07
,a
O 0:,3 Q.3� (j a3 Q) 0 c, 9 g- 0 0 (., 11 c-
C..l d"l c- c..:> 3 md � c, c:, r:t c- o o o> c.:, cl>
3'· c- o 0..:>t).:> c- <Y'1 3 � (/ 't, (_TC"' o , j o c- 3' c g.,ci: Cl 0, &,
� C & c, c, c, F' :j � c, � 9 g.. 3 c- c..:> 3 g1 � a3 � 3
..id°3
"t,-
C::%> �
-·Ca') c,_ 3 D � O ra � �r"l 3 ,a I j , C, �� =, Q"\ "°"' Q.7 cl 3 3 C,...
.:,- Q3Q.;> � 0
- c,...
3... � CD O c,, C o,, a: "'.._ � , 0j ... o Q.)9 '-' c, o- .._ c, 07 ...J
-.:D c.:>
,c, .:,- C:, c, D 3 c, 3 ;:> 3 Jc3 C- . c.:, (j o..:, C.., 0 c.., ,a
•QJ r� ·� � J' Q.) C1 > .. J" 8 a3 C.:,
S (j c, 3 � CL .' "· d 3" 0, C- (3 C.,
Q.)
C,
9 3 0) 0
Q3 c;.:, ,<.,
c.:, \-7 � 0 g � C,
C-Ll �
... �
r'l
g c-
C""�
3'" � 3 fj
g., C CTC> c.:, (j �
1• 1 '1
< c:., c., Q.)
� c-
:,
c-11 _:, � c.:, j
3 � a, (7'
9 Q.) 9 0 3 0 v C, .t":l
3 D f'c3 c.:> 1 a.:, c- ..,
CT � C::- c:....
·v � � n o d 9 c- 9 c- � c..:> en '
():> -� � • ,� • .- a:> ,a ' f3 c, Jc3 a, C"" � <J3 D • 0
.,..
- r -< ,• c,;, 9 � ,.. r,; 0 'd 0 C.,
:}
a;)
L
• '<)_[.l ""}
·o
00
lW
3 9 ,a cJ C,.l (, c,V> 3... 0 D
l�M
3"• c,r 9 9
c, " C:a> ci � ·C, � C- d' c., c, fu C,, C- J r:/' � c., t,; ,a C""
'0�
c
c:- · '" ' , ra C, 3--- cS c- ' j 3' 3'· ca ra t, c:- 3"· cv d · ..]- 11 cS " "
jTD
cu C-(j
3· 3' a;, 0 � c, c., � g.. 9 O 3'- 0"1 CTt(j c.Z> l""l �D l""l
O ti 'J "'� ·g-7 3 0 c..:> O:P � CY Ij 0,:, I j -<a �
C:-
c., 9 � 4 (, 0 C. $ (, 0 t) ,g
r - � fj
,a J'"l ,:)� \...:I s � 3 �� C, I 0 C,.) O
Q_ 9
� I f-' . I t ' • C- I I I ,.. Q.:) '1 C- I . I O C-: I " I I C,
ft,�"1C'1D&0l> '808cYld�D�-O� �m�-O�D�Ob� ce�
bO!tlao2»ob a�sa�<'>!O��-
AI(AIT - AKThl H3JlaHHble l(asKa3cKoti apxeorpaq>uqecKOH KOMHc
cieA.
BypHarnee'b I(apTHHa - C. ,n. Bypuawee'b. l(aprHHa fpy3iH H.IIH
OfiHCaHie fiOJIHTHllecKaro COCTOHHiH
- uapcrB'b l(apTaJIHHCKaro u l(axeruuc-
Karo Ttt<PJIHC'b 1896 r.
Ma1ep.iaJibI - II. r. 6yTKOB'b. MaTepiaJrb1 A·.1151 Hoaou
�6 ucropiu I<aeKaaa c'b 1722 no 1803
MaT rO�b·l�11.a II V· ens. 1869 V·
i�o. �· �0006��30�0L a�a(')ona�L. ·
JMMtz3. o�ol)M[)�O. fpaMOTbl fpaMOTbl H .IJ.pyrie HCTOpH11ecKie .ll.0-
I<y•MeHTbl XVIII croJieriH, oruocHm,iecH K'b fpy-
3 JH.
303. °6. 3"0306�doL 01)a(')ona�L.
66
� a.3 0 Q.) C:- C:- CU c, C>,(j c, C- CF c, ':JO C-
'j c- "cS c, 0 ..,.,__ ,a c, C v,J/ c.:, o.:,c:, c.:, 9 C-d C-
vJ "
Y. ""'
.., · c.:, '1 c., CJ CJ �c:, 3-- � � n c.:, 9 � c, CT\ d? C,
vJ a3 <:.:> 3--(1 O .,_ D 9 /] a., 3''j o> Cl O f1 3"-18 3'°' C-
3
c:,., 3� cu� r 3
,a g 3 g,a F'" � '1 c- 3g C, g...c:�.
9 � 0 �
I
C,
c:.:> ,a
C.&:
3--a.11 �
Q.) 0
CT\<:..")
,a O 0- °' 0,:, y � c.:, � I#"':l. c,, f] c.:, c-
3'- __., C, l;j ,a or- $ C, 'c.:, (Y C, C- 0 0
� c-
9 J- 3
fr
CT\ " 3- ra o O"\ <J3 c:- Q.) vJ 9 s C,
o ,a " · " c, c.c c, 3 ..
c.:, s c.:, 3 9• 3-- O"\
9 c- o 0-D v c.:, 0.,
c- C c:- c, <>"o>
a3 c.:, Cl
,a
� 3*gl 3- c.. ra d r, 8 �cJ g-� � t.," 13 (] 11
o ' C '1 O c, cu 3- "" f1 � c.,
«»
g: t
g, 5° go} en o cu <>" 13 c-
� � Cl O c:, ,a c.. · � «» '} 3'- 3
" c- c..'.> c-
g ,a 0 9
o C, c- CT\ 3 3 c- 0 ,c..:> 11 3' '1 c:- 3' C, C, c- .,_ . c- fr
'1 3 (, ,a g7 � g-- g, ,a J'c.:, c- &:> 0 g._� ,a �'cd3 � oSo> 'g QJ
c-
,a Q.) 9 c, l"'l o..:> C:- 3- C- 0 c--do> -�c.:> c, D c, � c, c, c., �
f3 " 'oj " Cl,./ c:- c:- 11 c:, D '1 ,� j <13 Q.) c- � c,, ' C,
D <!;' cg 8 .. f1 i� � � <l'3 0 J' a.:> cu � � c, fl �3 a3 3' MS.
3'
3cS
07 c.:, .. 11 __..,
, o g " a., ..,... c.:,
- c, c.:, c.:, 0 3
o o c- 07
<t3 v c..-, f3 c..
c;, c.:,
3--
c:.:> c:, 9
o..:> <:.:> c.:, :l 9
.... c»
o3
c..-, " ,a c, JS c 3" .... c., c:,
3" s � ,a Cl9 � g--c 13 c9 Cl 3"-c¾ 3,a g7<:.:>
c.:,
� c,,
c- '1 fr 11
c.:,
cu c:, ;3
3 c- '1 ,a 02 c- o> c-
0
� 0..) c-: c,, c.:, c:,, 0 0 3 c, 0
� O C�,
� C:- l"l C- c;,· ,a fl v
c, o c, v
,a et: c,, c�, t5 <:.."> c, 3d 3' 9 c:- ct' g7 r] CJ 3,pl ,a c..'.> �3
� fr
c, CT\ � c, 3" J'- C:- Q.) 9. 9 Ql /'J Cl v 3' 9 0 '3 0..:>
0 J- 3' 9 9 cu c;,Cj O"\ C,
c.:, 0 a.:> c.:, � c, ,:,....
J- fr
C)
c,, c- CJ � C, �
C,
CT\
3" g_
d
9 s O ra &, 07 s �
J- c.:,
J ° ,a " o> crt C, v
3Cl dCJ c:- c-D 'j ,a l:j c, c, Q.) C, 9 ,a c- C C,
CT\
��
� c..-, ", � .(} <:.:> c.:, CJ 9 ,a a3 c:- 9 � ""� c, g �C �
c.:> 3-- ' j n c, '>... 3 9 o,:, v n , j .......... Q.) ._
07 0 D �
'3 (, � g:,ra 3" g.. t� g'5 3cg c- g..o ct'C 3 J8 O.'I
a3 9 3 !-' cn Qt(] c- 03 CT\ ��� 3--,a CJ C, C, ..
c:, 5� 3" o f " CJ O"\d3 c, a.:, o 3' Q) ,a
3' g_ 3"
c-
3' C 9 c..-,
3C CJ
J
o..:> c.:, c.:, c, 3'-- O o.> c, n 11 �
0
Cl cS g7 g-' '<13 c:.:>
CT\
/1 ci ,a 9 '1 3- .. c.:, alC Cl <:fi> � 'j o c, O.'I Q)
a> Q.)
13
3� d33c � 3 0:, l'cS l'��f]�erg.. c- a3
0 F" ,a
f3 J- '1 C:- 0 O"\ 9 I C.:, 3 0.> en C.:, I 'O l3 . �
fl 0 Q.)
3 9 g-, c.. o> c.:, Cu ,a c9 3 C, Q.) 0 g- <:.'.)
en g f" 0 � 3- 0 'i' g_ � � g- er � � c,> � � g' 3'
'1 3 i
� ,., c,,., c.:, c- o, et 9 9 eJj . fl c- 07 � C c, o..:> ..-,, 3
0 c,,
3-- 5 '#
Q.) 9 vJ c., g c- � cB <l'3 0 <f3 g_ f) . 3' ,a y Cl c..-, ' Cl 3'
c:, � f] a., � � C a: � 3 o '1 a;, ,..'fl C>
g.. � "C- IO
cS C.,
07 C, '- J - a.3 3 Q.) c:- (r 9 C.:, \...:JI
9 3 C.:, � 3 I �
C, 3"' Cl o> ,,...� ,....:, ?... C � g_ c::- 07 C, 0. ,.Cf' Cl 9
.._, 0, '0 J- O"\ ,..c;. Cw O o:> ... c '-3 0 0 ><, 0,j
c.:,
c:P C,
. g_ � 9 � Cr g.. c.:, C,.:> � C, '1
0 ;;'3 3 3' 9
0 <
i
C,
c-
c,
� 07 3' , .:s 3-' c.:, c.:, cc Q.)
'1 c,Q;) l'"l
c;-c, c, ..,.. ..... 9
c;,3 c- ,j /3 " �<t> c
C- ,._ 3 c-
Cj g-7 3 - 3 cu c/J vJ C:>> � t CJ
..,.,__ c, c.:, D \_:J - 07
3 - Q.) _'.i <>7 c., C, C, \J" c:.:, C,
J -� g' ,a 0 �
O 5'3,a f] '1 � ,acSg'J'J---cP
� I 1
'C" I I I C- 1 I C.:, �
°' ClI-c9 t 9 O"'\ C-'.>
'1I
. C, c, t
� 0.) c- ,
�
a
aooooL a�vnLAo&ao�L juMm3n� aacnnnoL u6�MO(?[J 6 bM�ao, �a(°)L
u
V� "t:>MO oo, . oL ,'.) mL 60 O,'.) M L,) ab,'.) QlMM .3oA M 36D6.'.) OL' MM O(')MO d,) O ·
. a,'.)18,'.) 3o(')Moo XI OljM, �6n0t'O,'.)O'l L.3.:iMLnmnL ,)f ,)6�:.)0j�<' j3:.1'll :.1 3M
Q)M8nooL �vaM<'-,�o�oou · 06�u OJOLMv �u b\)6 v3�v6()L6v6'1l() �M�r"l
�0� M, b l)6 oo�'Diou�v6oo, b\)5 Lb3vo�6 UuQJvU-JO uaoMb[J C>u ("\<BO°'jOO
.�v. �ao�twla oLn 8MbC? . �1 MMa juM0,30� ao<tsaooL I cnu3nv60, L uOMdv60-
oae1�0 vvL3�\0U¢ �u avMm3�-&uaoonooL Lu'B0uC'OOu uM J3M6QJ um �v
m\)3ov6mn du�u (?� 5oJo L.3uMLJo,oL "3vJoooL oubooL 0u8v0MoonL 0m30L
� b� u clan�o\)O,. ilao� ouaM oLo6o od��noo�o 0�3605 m�3.n05cn d '-'>
oonA 8vb�MOJ�O 0.)0(")60030�000 aaez30L 8C"lo QJoO�O� ��o5ndbv01
bMc:-8 3 L.:ij.:,M0?3,'.)�Md(j Ql,) a ,)O)O'J30L al"J,'.)6�('1')(7) 33,'.)/:l 6oL d'bM�63.'.)c;::'M
Ov. L�v<'>Loa,ol> LvaD<nM J""Mf) 3u'ao5 �u0LM 'CJ<::1D00t:1o 30MvoC"\6nL� Q?v
. 3odJMOOU 00(?D� O�M doJo�n. 03\)�oo\)�0 O�M hM�ao oJ ov3C'o6�
'�u' \Ja\)LO')v5v30 U3v�oo�Q)O O�M bM�ao L�v<4>L [) {r)f)L d0Joonl., JMc::�-
1
O<>Jv o d�m3oc:io ao<&DDOOU anav('r)O'>. nu o�Mo8M00w db�av3(!)� Jvo AL (?v
l,�1�� oua��MJ3D3�MOoL ot,,,d6Mo�L . �da6o(?v L�jl)h0,30�Mdn. JuMcn
·30�0 OMO �a �MML a,�o>e1uu 'ijv�MoL� oL)5L�u{?c'JC:: dO O�M �v3vM(? 5n
1
[)
\)a \Jufao5o�) o�v3nMdn
·au6 a\)&)O,� \)u 8mDc:io mv3ol,o •
n6o<'>o0.) Q>\) 'Boa(Y)3aO{pOOOO)O 6nJn aM
. oJ·h:nca\) (?v 0 �av6�<?otlMooo� 8o8vMoo 0�oouL vn5���0 (?0o. Jut,,,cn�C'n
06� MM8 l>J�Ml>'C)�O l,00�3ooocn �) d[JM tj 36o�O�(Y) �u . 6ua�3·ocin JvM
'mn�o
j
.. . . , ·. ' . .
69
a
"· '13 n c- c.c O 9 3, c.c c.c � ()3 Q.:) � C 0, ,a � 3' cu � c- Q.) 9 � D ,a 9 C- c.:> 3 � CU (j
<::> " c.>
' :s Cl'" c, e.:> � c- c, a.J e.:, c.., ' j c, 3 ' � 07
c- c.:, a., " 3 c.>
c.:, c:,� c.:, 3 3'- c.:, • 0.) ::>
' ::s a 3 C!>
" ,a
, c, c.:, Q.) o• c.. � er � o " � c- 3'
3 ,a
c,
3'- � � rJ g' , O> rJ c.9 9 O> 9 c.9 c- J' o• o c" C "
!l, 0 , c- c- c- 3 � � � 3'- f3 �
0 j , j c., ... oC, 3 t, � C,) 0..) o3 (;, C.:> � c:..:, 3 c:..:, 0 <:,:) 3 9 (, 3 r"l � (,-)
0, Q.) Q.) O"'l
3 ' C,,J
° 3 ' � 07 0,'1 c- 0, 3'"- C, 9 9 � &- c::- a o:» 3 C, � r, c;:
f] c.:> 3 0 \...:J � Q,) 0 .?t
O � '1] 4 0-
C, 3 '13 o, Ci.> Q.)
C ,6 C �
'-
· C- 3 ..;, c, �
"'.)..._- C"" v O 9 c.., CJ :, r r;; �- � Cj � 0- S er\ 3
C.:, 0 c, v . C; , o <::.c ,. j ._.:J "" C..C r � C:, '--=' C"" 3 D c.:> O � Cl c,
,a C, c8 Cl � C,.l G, 3 3 c..c c:- <Y c., O C C,:) C) \J g_ '1 9 3' C,) C, � � • Q,.? a.. "l Q.)
" J'J 3 1:: 9; 11 � �3 c- 5> � g, � {J t 3'- gi fJ O 3 � J'J g"I J,, c, a., 3 g... � ,a
c::- <::> 3'- en 3 � c- ,a c- 0
3 CJ: (V 3 t" ':t c- 3 0, 0 Q.) c- � 0 -31 c0 _:;; � d, ,a d C, c;;
g.... 3 ,a o:> 0-'.> g7 - � C, C, rJ O 3 ,a c- O'\ Q.) Q) Q.) g, 3- c- 0 g, "" ' :;S 3'- y c.9 rJ O> S-
c.:, g' ..g3 � a., o3 �3 d ,!f' ,!s o ::,,, c.9 ft o, � J o v � 3 a3 � c- a., c.9 c., � ,a �
I
3"' c- � %
3 3
ci c.:, o O'\ rJ ·. J- rJ c- g, ,5 - � g;; (j tr a., 9; "J3 cg. 2_ c.. c, <=i g c... C 3
'<13 <::> 9
'l � � °"° � ,a � �, c.:, � g._ . � � c.:, n. c.:, g"' C g1 � � � � ...r.3 � <:v ,.s[' ,a 3 cr �
C, \.J"
0 Q3 0,., Q.) C, c, v- 07 "' � "' -.J-
� c,
' ;S C- (Tl C., C,) ,
o o7 e..:> j
�- Q.) ', ;j C:, _, CF" v
= Q..) 3 c,
.-.o
""' c::, c- CJ
,..,. v � o c...J o c §! s CJ "" ,.g '�::S � Q.) Q w C<" c.,
a3 (j 3 c.9 c., c.. 9 c- � oP c,. er " c- o � a.,
O
3
3 '<13 o (j 3 C, 01 c, C-
'J 3 � c- 3 d� 0 a, g, O> O> t c,-
g.. ti ,a c3 2: ,a C, 5 c:, 0 rJ '-l3 g' d rJ Q.) c.c n� ?
c,. c.., 07 0 l"'l ' w /J w O'\ r� C, O C, 5' n c.:, �, C"' a., d f" .
,�
C, C..l c..:> C, -
..,
-
�a 3
t.;a.;, ('> ... "'},
()7 C, 0 ' j
C,
'Oi ,.. 7 ':)
W lo r r.: D -<:J3 cS c., c, 0 � 9 .
:) 3 """ - '-wJD "' ,l"":l
:$ • O:> "'.)..._ 0 ' j C,,) ()> t;> � C.>,. <::.:, ,l"'l
;J
\J C.:> '<f3 (Y C, 0" C"" c.9 � 94-
9 ,a a3 ,..\Jc;. C.:> c- 3 c.:> 0
3 ,a �c, c, C:, {J , I c., .J - ,.., 0 C, t¥, I'
'O'\ <J3 C- O"l C.:, a., (j U. <t' 0 C- ;J Jo &, ci 0, g' {J 3'- O � C,.. � ""'
c, o 9 3 3
8' ,a c, >< ,ac, c.c ° ,a l"'l n 3-- 0 = " " ,,.,_ o• � o 9 & Q.) 3 C> fJ
07 c, 0 ()) � ,..._. Ql J c.:, � O,> C=> , :S � 9 07 cg C- � f3 "- C- 0 CT ('j Cj Cu O 0'1 C.:> 0
o rJ cJ: c.:, < 3 O> o c, c, a:, 9 g c, <13 9 c, c- o O"l e,.:, ,,., c� c.:, ,a
C- c, c.:, 3°1· 3 ,a <l Cl"' o,3 0 C- ,a c., 3. c- 3'
cu Cn c, (j c, c, c- J,, ':J.. � d _c, {J ,a c, ' :l J,, c, � C-
o 0
� � c- J'J cg " c- {l co Q 9 c.:, g.. 3- 3- ,a 'J � 3 � ,; c..:> � oP � c., r.f � 9 3 ra t g...
� Cit'" D --- ' c.:> C 07 (',, c- 0. C.:> 9 c.,- <Tl 3 3 C.:) , � 3 O") 9 � o.3 V C, O:'I r':L
<::) o3 C.::, 0, '33 ,. C:: C,,) C, <;.) Cl.) c., ,a
l"":l O c., c, � '--3 o3 0 07 C.) 0 O'"'\ 3 r\J� r:,,._ <:.,j CU C:-
or c, "'.)..._
�- 3-..0
� 3 9 C...:> �I ,..c., c, C,.. g... a.:>
7
g'l c, C- v ...C- \J'
,j CT\ C ,a 3 07 '\...?' c .... 0 . 0 � 3 ::re:, 0 C7"' 3
a.> g, ,a _p1 g_, � g... 3' ,a ,a o> g... 'J_ c.c Q, d c- 3 g.. oP § ""J c- � ia o3 d
3'- J'
,,f!.- � c,
�::,
,a 3'- � 3 c, _v cu · 3 c, 9 c,
9 d �o 3 v 3' J,, o l1 3 3
3' c::, c, �- o:> Q.)
�
03 c, 9 3... 3-'- Q.) ,-, c., ,.., n e=> o · en o Q.)
cg 5 c-- ,a go C, s 3'- c.9 " � · o c.., o � 2f' d <S rJ •3:1 ' :i g, 3 3 t - <::> w
gi g 0 c:!3 J � '3 07 c.9 ;!° � � 3 % 3 ,a o {J g7 v
9 � c e7 o 'g, � � § 3- 0 {J -<13
n ' c:, 3 ...... . c - 3 o · r:,, � c- c- :> «::.:>
..:>
D 3ll' � CA.) e.:> o o:, c- o 9 c y".") a,
, j c., S' � O> 0 � D O _ 'O O ... C-
O
Q.) � 0 � C S
3 Q) " 3 ,a 0> <:l ,a c- '13 & 3 o, g.. c.:, o C, & c.r o
Q.) 3 C 3'- ,a C, C, rJ 3' C, c.:, CF
=
O O C, ""'13 c- C, C,
= 3'- o, c- 3'- cl. � 3 rJ
'<.13 � g s Q) g- c.:, � a, g c.:, g �� c.:, C, o ,a 3 1-- rJ rJ 3 0 3'-
3'- c.:i O 3 c... 3
0 c.:, l"'l g:: Cw C"' � c.., . �
0.) 3
� �°
Cl ,a ' .:l c.:, D a:> c, Clli> c,,, J ' o..:> Q) � ' a., 3- � c- l,,,
f1 \J' Q"l j g· g:! 3 C, c.:, c.:, 3 0 0'1 c... g... g'
,
9 3 9 c- c, J'- ,.., c- 07 c- c, 3 ()a
g-t c., 8 (; /J � � C c.£: 3 c8 C, 0 � <.J3 /J <::) 3 3 � C, V.. 0 9; C- I 5 (', � � � C- C, �
,a O 0- rJ J O c- 07 O> 3" C, , C 9 d d a, cc, g... c- 3 3'- 0 a, Q
C, cj r
�
s3 g... 1g �) '-J' Q.) J c.:, � � 0 'g
5,J1 D f'
'1 � Cw C, g... 0 0 ,a
3'- J C- J C- c,
cg 9 J1 g. .;> <13 0 c- 3'- Q.) c.9 o>
C"' J- 0 c, 3'- � 3 c, /' <: C>
'e
c.9 C,;> 1a J •
Q.l r c:: c- 0,, "'.)..._ 0 n c... c- C:.) c.., C, c- 7 OJ 9 "'.)..._ ...,._,_ Cl - ......
3 '-" er c.:, U J- c, ' :l c- <- c:, o • oP .oP Cl"' c.., 0:> 9 0 a:, 3 <:.;1 J - J- c.. 3 � o, , o,
c, 9 r"l cP c, 3' c1. · o o 3 CJ 3 c.,- c.., c.:,
CF' o o o c,
I
c9I c.> 3I •g1 c.c: °' °
I I I C- I I I I I I I I
C, C, ' j 3 c.:> o c- c:> 3 3 <:.:> c-
C, 9 I I t I � C c- l
41
.:ia d:, a<:'oo, , M M3 D <:'i,.:i o 3 .:ibo.:i6a VI -3 a ,,(!).:iL o� h<:'.:i9.><:' 0rJ 'vM 'J: '1,
� .;)MO)�<:' L "bn�avoct3M b\)a\)�O,�ol, a�63oa,�o o�l,� �\) 'aolJv..}3�.,)L,
aJa(')C?�o Ll)ca-od30�0 ����3\).
L,"j�MO") 3D�Mdo a�Aa,�3L\)jr,�nonl, �t,\)a�ci�oo�\)� {!)� a\) 6L \)30JO-
uno��� 3� b6�6& VI-n 8 �a 33�M t) �3D in� ·3\}MO'>'c:) �O L\)a\)AO") �oL tJ 3D
t:'\) do o�noo dD�BMMa\), M M8n�o u JO d30� (?M Mom3\)6 'a DM&3oo�n
n ::, M , cJna�n & l,b3 \) [)�O?I) J;)GM_&a �noe,i MOOO') 3\)P\)(J a\)a M�� (')� l,"81.}ha>-
�nl, vne6o on �� L �a\)MO')�oL tl3D�� ua dn &t:'[J OO U o" 6l, i:>J 'C)0'><4>J �'Ot:>�,
JM:J <> 'J �o 'an \)c.? ao6\), MMan�l.J�-0 aol>�\)63 n 8 ri,v3D'O� d�M��� li\lJ � 6� 6-
a�no�M J�nool, aooM 'an�an 6o�o L�a,)MOOC?ol, voabo (?\)'C)MO'>M.
'OJ�b�LJ�D �O 6'"3v�Aa M noo a\)'an6�n � obM3MnooL 'C)ClJ �OO�o3 3 000 -=>"'o
ooL �fl3�M 'aoL�'l3[)MOGn a\)8M8b\)63D�O O�M. �o�o b\)60� 'Od3 D ��o
L3aut",��oLonoL \)�60 cl 6t,�n \)A3 00 3.)bo \)63 ao-V!-ol, t,\)a�&>a,�oL voa-
6oL �aMonnMnooL� �\) Jwa"Gt) M a()LVM�cnnool, '06�-0\)MO 0030Lnoooo.
�"'O<a.:iLoOn<:'o .:, ol., (?O->(?O t'?3"V<:'o, �("')83<:'o o 3,>b0->63 an C?JD I., , a o�
a
r:i<aM M l,l>, o, .;> 6»�&/M'C)CL.:i � ,) 'i'.'.laoM M L o,.>6,.)a clM M 8D<:'OOL ao'C)�300,
.:>Mo,3D <:' nMoL VO 6.:icl D • 800,0 V� -><:' MOoo, b.:i (:'b oL 0')3 00'>cln 3D O 6 oO "
ez3bo'I, D <:'O 3" b �.:, I:?.:, 3»� Ma,.)3 �,), . t!3D C"'SD ML J'O cc!)�M 'Cl<:' 0 ->C?M�d O.
61) 0 o li oo�o l;tl"D0::J M, ba<:''<lnaV::, ("}Oo 3McoOOJrJ M O ub ("')a�n 'ooL 3oMM
OoOo-(?-> 0 ::J M a b("')<:'(")� L<l3 ohM, A("')a nL .:l(?MAdobl)O» o->68�oonO w<:'o ·
tJ M � .:, o, <>6 (!l.:>0?.> 6 ->� 3->30 0ol»-> (J:<> d<:' onM oOoL b» 6 -><t> E oD� <:'Ol:J M , 3 .:ib-
0"63 a n<anL F,M �o<:'MD 0, 00') 0.)6 8ML ':)<:'a.:i. D�o,8.:i »80.:i3 a .:i 080<? 0 cloL o",
M Md L vB�<'>0')3D� M ai:)�D ot>M3 Mn2>ol, �a bn�'(Joa VtjMO 3o�Mo n oL �u
D�OM UD0M(?\).
3L vaol)3 <"> �r.J L no,noo 0v6 3M3 0�.:>.
. � �l>o cno l> bnt:'a v�cnoL D c:' �av oLn ML6 vO�t,., �� 8MvV�M (?� a Mv�30-
6v l, �aan Jv� 003o�o ou, mocnJM L 3[)0MD 1 -u onno �r,l> 3vb0\)60 V I 3v-
3o�3D���o a�oM8v&>oMOv. a oLo cJ3o�v (? v (?vbL6t> L (? M8bM�o L
L3 vAL� MLa�c:'°' � J(:'vt3Doouv3\)6 {? � l,fMM [J (? oaooMa vJOM [J O (? O U 03 n
l> 3\)AL n 01ob v()6v \)�a t?D o v8bocpMoovL . aDC/JD 3vbOv63a� C? \) j �Mcn�nL
ovaDq)ML &v3�[J6ov68v VMQ [J&al) Dl, (? O J � Mav��� o bMOJ[JOn Lo6�8 (?3("'!
c:'D� aoo� 6oaL . avO, 30� w�a(T)D (? o06va,, MM8 d �oDM JMnLOno6 bo�
a vo�o L o�t:'dO Lb3� �vOO[) n�'Oa�C'O °6Mvb3v nJ a 6n oM�.) (? � 3vb0.)63
V I �v&>v8'r16o o -o�o OtfM JO�[)O, A(T)a �\) vl) au O en 3nOMD 1 -L (? v M rJL-
9'>� ,� L 8o:J 8h�M OM � I), . J[JO&>D o mv:30L 8bM03 8oL a t) O'>v'C)�,��00, ' Li:>
JvM0>3[Jt::'ML a oAoL vt,,6vv�a� o o o vOC-\)dJM[J O{? v ( (? . o'Jhvaoo3n�0
1�v300,o-.>60. t. 303. ov a . 33) 2•
l «BoJJblHCKiA... n0Jry1:1HJJ'b yKa3'b ,lleJJaTb TaAuo ripHrOTOB.JJeuiH Kb 11�p�H-
4cK0My noxo.D:y..• H CKJIOHRTb t<apT·a JJHHCKOro uapR BaxTaHra M npOt?HX'b xpuc•
-riaH1) K"b nOJtb3aM'b PoccLe, yeeppR11 HX'b B'h 6;raropacno.no1KeHiH nerpa I H e6ua
.D:e.>fCHBa R HX'b B'b rocy.Di,apeBOM'b nox,poBkTeJJb�TBe».
2' 3nOAJ I ,,l.l)aaD 3���6'a ao�nl,.:, l,06.)� 8nbo dJDC'l.l 3&30.:,: ,,� 3.:, c.)3�('t') I (!>�J
JA.:, ,)3 �\lbOit)J �M �,:,�l; ��t)Vtj M -a36n2>.) �� (?�(!lnG�.:,GL a('flh3�� � 3moG AnLh3-> ...
bn �avO(Z3Da 3....b�.:,Gal, an�,a�.): 8M(!>O al")�!')� 6�3 a .)a��M... on iMOL aa t� Mo,,
BM8tlO�M, &��ia�,.., 8t)�f a)a\)(!>M (!>3 a"�aJ 'anG� a6a��[J {? a(Y)ao1�3J "···
12
MM(? OLvu oL ( U vJOO> bo Lvb [J �av0�(") (!>vMOv°ora<i 06'�0(\'){!)v, tl3D�v
(? vMOv l,D�6 o vM 0�36a 6 va Lv8b [J (? ((JM
o oD aa o L aMahAo 6 o . 3-0MOJOO>
1b(r)oO l,o�n (dMML,3\)8LJ3AD0D�M600, v80J OUD 0(? v JO(? O O MM8 va M8ra o
�vM [J 3v l,vJvM0>3D�ML0030L <r3MOv(!> L vbnez3o()')('P) {!)v uv
MMD(? {!)va��33D
c>0 6 uo o f o o386DOM (? v, MMa e,:i ooovo ' JvA003Dc>O>v aMv3v�M oohM3v60
o0M[J d [J aoAJOO o l,vMo[J 0 t:" [J O(? D6 (? v M'JL011.'> f\'>M o L v80DM-J\}'3JvL o \ldO
8ML3�v8 (? 0L �3D 6L J3nt1v60L vvMbMD 0 (? 6 [J 6 (OJ3D 35) 1 •
a "oA � a a D <BD 3 obo �6 00 oLo o()O \)O [J OCC)c:'0 O�M M'C)LO>v bDc:ra vncn oL
v 06 u (? v(? OC<"l0>, M Ma 0Mu3 o m�M o 0330 0 vM DOv(?DOM (? v �v (!?M8v (? {!)�
va 'CJ b[)O�cir> r'ltJ("'T:)• MM8 3DOMD I -mv6 oovbbaMOM030 Lv8hD (?M(i) aM3 a a
C? D O v Lv3vM0>3D�Ml) 0D (? 6o [J MDOoL 8Mv6o3DO(!>v· va ooMa o L {!)v 8 ob o
oov6�an)\)'bM[J • (? vMOv oLo �6 o (!)v'C)tjM3 bDO� o3 ov�vdJM [J OOL aMahAD6 o
0�3606.
MvJO a o �D O'>v30LvL vM o d�O (? v, aMv o 6v\)e;ae?DoD Vo 6 (? vb[J (!)'J�av
lo'J<Bav DM�0v aDcnDL M 'C) UO>v hD ciav o 'lso Lvm30L ahM t:" M{? <nvM� e,:i o
(?v b8vM [J Ov ovov o v (? v avMOM Jv0vMv �vdJMOO> (? v l,vO(!>rJ8ci(T){!) vv
r
L r] �OtjM iooAn I .8oL \) d3Dc>D0�v(? ((? , orJMva ocJ30�0. (? v300, o v60 35).
a\)oAva 3 vbOv60 ao�oa vMO D l, 0L�M3 \): J[J 0MD I -L a0L o3n 8 MOOJ 'C)
�0L j()MOO> ()")\) bhaMOv dD 'CJ 0>3v�v {!>v aiv(? JOl)l, <ao r1�ov ((? . o'CJ Mva o
''83 0�0 o 33D 36 (? v 5yrKOBo MaTepi a.,1 hl I , 1 6).
2 03�ol,l, l �22 V· JDOMD 1-8\) a D <n D 3vhov6 0L . OMM oL 01'CJM30Lo\)-
6M3 o l, J()MOO> d[J 8MrJ0>3vc>v, MMa oL a\)�D l,3vMLDmoL l,1)8\�3MD0L
8ov(?3D0u (?v va ooMa a D CZ3D Lv�J �M (? �DJDOL D b(? v (? vUUDaM{?v, .
\) avGmv·6\)3D 0>v3 o l, (? vVtjMOo � c>vc13 MOO>t)MO> L3uALoml, 'BnJLo M (? v {!)v
n3 a(r)[)Ov{?v, lJv6-:.8 �[J OMDL aML3�0L ·aDLvbD O o6MODOO a M'CJ 30�M
(? v l O>t) l, -:.{? cJ DtJM o � o � 36D 6 Dhmv (? ( ByTKOBo I , 1 9) .
3vbOv60 aD<z3D a L o b uM'<:)�00, 30 .000--40 .00Q ' i·vA oLJvo o "c3,a3�vM�,
1
8l,vAv�\){? ov6f(l0 vJDb ovO�v dJM� {?v ''8\)6jMAra o �vOOvbvJv M'f'JLmv
bDc:ia v0'80l)v {!)v d e,:i nDM e,:i v''33A oL a Mmmao6 e,:io 3 aMa e,:i M (? Ob[)a .. 6 D6-
Jo6 o l,003alj 1 7 23 v-l,v 3DOMDL DL i:>80v30 �vMDOvb (?dO 8 o m30 (?�, 7 36-
J [J bol,003ol;-J0 oL {?vo dMv {?v v�3 o {?v, a u 0Ava Lo30Acn3o e,:i{'Y")G tot00,b6
'"aol, u [J M<Y>D0 t:"v (?-JO vMv, vMvaD C? <lo6, vclo��hv6 oLvJD6 (L. � bo o do; � 03.
34 .. � 'CJ o· 330, 6yTKOB1> . MaT. I , 30-3 1 ) .
•
I <4 a ,,) �M.)a aoor4>b<" �8 o31"10tJ�) 0 n6 ., tJ3D �\) . � 306°6 D V->a �{!laj&f'L �..) 3r-- 6aa &>t)l.,&l"l
I
L "3C:D O)O L oJ .:iMo,30 t:'M ML 3.:ico o,l, <?.:io<naM, °''O au� 02> 0 a.:i l, LMn C'D-
000)�o .:>M OJ'0 °'3 b<">Q>� (ByTKOB'h� :MaTep iaJi bl I , 57i rn. 1 1. 58-59 :
62-63 Ql.:i aolJoM6 . JM'O'hobLJ oL Tragic a vertentis Belli Persic i
h istoria sub I I. t. "3"C'o'a3�c>o IlpucoeJJ.HHeHie fpy3iH K'b Pocciu,
8 Q MM ir 3,:,3 Mo, 6 9). ,:,L D' rJJ'::Jc.>a�o,,:,� (?Oao,.:,a<'> Ql" 1,.:,J .:,Mo,3 o C' M l,0>3 ol,
M -oL m I) bo C'a vO 'l) o l, a ooM ,:,e:.,o,J a 'OC'O -,�a(') l,,:,3 C'D cntl>L jMoLoo.:i 60,.:,
,, acn.:iM3D C'M0.:i": ioM o,.:i30L.. L.:iL� anOC'M{? j,*)0,30�,:, Ma'ao � ,:,o,Mo-
3 00, cp " 'at.Ja �o� a 6M()l; Vofi.:,do 'Oavo('l� ao0 Man Oom.:, <;?.:, aoM oL 0>3 0L
&.:>oo aoo, . 3DO�D �O(?at) oLn mo 'C a ���MOl)Q-J (') 8.:> a�oio 6\), MM a 8 ol,
8o oMao :. a MO�'Oo O w� o <:?" 3"'00DQ>,'0Mo0-oc, o aaez30 3.ib�il63ol,.:,o,3ol, 'ao
Loez30AnL n o,�3'Bo L.:i'l3,:,MoL,:, t?,). l, .:.o bM3 MoOoc,o 0(?2,0C,ot.1 aofio6.:i .:i{r,
6n O.:i3Q),:,, MMQloL.:io 3.:ib0.:,6� . aD -Vl - od o,.:,3 0L Mf obM Ooo, 0'30.:i Mb .:i G'ao
Q).:il,.:,b(:>o Ool, 630.:,/.-io,3.:i oo,b(")3,), 3oOMo I �.:.M.oLboO-o c-o O� M: �,)bo
�D °', n O oQ>nMri Ool, g,M ML,:,o aDCZ3D a,)060 .:,33.:,Mo.:i36MO.:il, .:,/., 0 dcio LM 1
½ L oo, o l, 8oez3 ol, .:,<t,c',oo, 3 o bo,:,63 V I -o n6<?,:, l,.:i(?aD l,.:,J�°'30C'Ml, L ila�
'bc?a Mol, a.:ibc,(")OC'.:,(? � ,:il,.:,bC'oO'QC'O::I M (?.:> LiVM MD{? .:iLoo a (")b�o 0 (")� ¢,
.:i'aO�bv6o l, o�OoMO"<!)('t)M& MMa O'O��OM�a oC' M Oo ,)M 3.:,3 M o i o 6 .:i <?"
bo �av' o � (')l, Q>.>'OJ oo, �03 .:ii:!> �oO Mn l, L.:, ba <::>o0> 3 "bO.:. 63ol, ,:,o, 3 oL a o t, o
IJ-oM 3o ciol, ,:,�L � n �o O.:i .:,/., �D°'dao (ByTKOB1,, M.aTepi aJJ bl I , 63}.
II 01 � 3 n.
76
)' n c.w n a__ -<J'.3 a3 or ,a OJ Q.:J c- c,... c:- r.,_ Cl <:...:> 0> ,a ,a D s o, c c.c n o ' 9 o Q l"'!l �
,1 , :1 ? c:.:, w . n c.:> "".),.._ v j
1
') C..,_
) Ll
)'-
c..::> :> :1 ·CJ � cS
3' C- o..,'j C.:,7 01f] j 0, 9 O'c.,3- Cf" 0, v � c., ::::> er 3 '
3
o, 0 ::> �- .,.__ O' J"'"? ' :1 - c ..,
I
J"'" v C- J
c-0 C... � c:- ?;" oc- c.:,j ,�j v c..:, � C- 9 c-C.- � (::l
..J C.:) � � ..., C, �
w �t>. c..:> 3 �r� � 3 c..c:3 Cl or-�
� Q..J '1CY c-
� v C(I �
1). Q C- C..)
'J,'
v c- I.-:' • CY . . �
c, (j /J ' j :) �3 ' j <J 3 (,.rJ O
CTl v :> � C- C"" fc3 �- 9 C- -:, c...:> C> j -j J c..:>J c.., e,..., i, '
e,.;,. �
'0 ,a CJ 1 j . I] C..::> � C- � V C.:, '.'.) c:.,; C- U :') S CL , :j v v C.., c v Q.) (> c, c.:> l"':l 0,,
I
cT 3'- :> c'.f '13 fJ ' � c :> a.J g' 5 �, ':. <>' = � c- fJ � � 3 -<l'3 '5 · g,' 's � 0 3'- 3'- ..... c, '.J :>
�1 j r- � _,, � t- :, �0 15 � � %3 � :, Cj � :, <., <"-;;., �- 3 � _f" <., � tc.., J 'j""' '10- o,
C- c..;, (!3 C, z 3 Co-' :> , j w • '.'.) o c U <J'3 C:> )'- � o cP _. C:.:, (_) u ::> CJ
,
0:>
f'3 � 3
r] c..c5-- � (j13 ,a 3 r " c�� g., 3'- '3,.. d3
C-
(J � c- ,a
c_-., v � c.3 a.1 ,a ,a j' � f J Q.J d �- g,
L.:J
,.. c. ' i C.C J ,..� - C�� 3 J"- v
v J � a3 ,..._, � 3 v v � C- 3 "".) 0"1 � �
V C,;)
v v C- v '-- '- "" f3 3 v :> � en a.:> .....,. / o C..,
Q,) � C
9 a.:> 0' C; '.) I -., V 7 07
,3 0'
3' - 3-- 9 l),
('lj Q,) c.:,
er o '.) V O' c.... 3 O,> 0
'"'
' l""::t 3 r V n
I
� Ll (Y C-
<.:> c.;, 9 :) j C , � o:> :> < :> � :>
c..:> C c,
' - j (, c, �
rL:1< , J '.'.) a... C- Ct a.>
C- 9 c
".)
) a3 f' /o J' v -.. (., Cl) v 0,
J a I v ·::, ,. � (] f3 � -�
03 3. � D en 0"1 � <J3 f"'l v ra
J
u 0,. c, 3 .. .. � lo a.> � 3 C>' <J 3 Q.)v vCU 3 v Cr\
c, c,
0,:, a, v
c,
Q.) C-
(,y 9
c..:> :, 3 gc:-:, v O;> ? � C- Cl
v � :> 3 �C,.) � C.C , :>:J s O'
c..:> c.:, CT\ Oi v Q.) Q.) -:> Co) C- 9 c, a..> vC- c.$ ' .:J � a3 07 � U O Jc3 C.... � Q.) :> Id c-·
O' 3·- 3 c.>� 1'- � C§ c- c., cu c.> O> :, ,a C.5 '1 3' c., a,. 9 d :> c, ::> C.:1 & 3' v ::> :,
(
v c:- v v
j c- u .ra r
o3 J 3 o c.., c:r, 3....
'-><,
=> gc; � 3 V
r.l
� cc, '3 c- s "
.. c., ,a c.n Cl
c., It-
I ' Q.) -:,
o u, Q.)
o '.) '.) '.) Q.) u 3 )"" /] c.., 0, D D O '3
J
I
();J a C
C-
3 ,.. (;. ( ] O' Q ::)3 V � (] I j
()) /J (3 '1 C-- ra c.::, -j ,a L � 3 � �, '.) 3 ' /] � <J'3 CF' �
�(;, � 0 0'�'1 en .. :'.>�;,�& Su� J°"'t 3.... ·
c, C..)
c,
,a ' ,....
' Q..) s � c..:>
_, er _ 3
C>· Q.) c..:, :> j ,a C
D c.:>
CF' ,.. c c:- v
.�DD &, c.:) 9 v
Q.) c,.. en
c..:> c.c.
v :, c.... c..:> o, g� 3
�
-..
en c..... :> c- c- c- \....'J <J3 m :> 3 9 :> f1 c, c:., ,� er
a· Q J3 J 3 �- � 1/ c; c- v C, lo ·11 f]
J v- (] C.C v c_, (.Tl O' 3... v 9 ,a c_:, J" 01 (3 3 � 3
'1 ]' V · '.) a.> :) J3 '$ <., J '.> { l 8 :) 3 fo 3' 3 fl c.;> 3'- <.,
3 ' 3 J8 � {J O' {J (}
�� c- c.., 3 � 1-- r f 1 s ... a3 c r1 J
r ::> g �
)'
� 3 � � .., ()J g> gt � �;, ::> 3
j �"'J. c, er $ .� CF D D .) C1"' r <; ()I 9 a., c, 9 . '0 s �
c:r1J c.9 ra ,a )'-� (/ (Y 9 :) c; er (Y a3""3, cul] c.:, ,a 3'c I C )'-C::> ,1 c., 9. 9 '0
D
v g"l D v C:- C:>
..)
� :, v v C- '1 3 c..:> � <.J 3 � :> O' C- :> '1 c, a., c,
Q.> en Ca., "' O.>
c.:> c..:, lo ::> 3 C..:> '.) ,,::, (.$ • • � C.., C · en c...:> m. (9
r c;. c.:> v C- Ca> O' 3 . ... ,� 9 � 3 S U: 'O 'l C C- /c3 a3 ':> c, '-v
L.:1 ...o G"'l � c, o of' D c� c.., 3 � ( j er v Ot"' 3, C,j ,I":) J c.c a..> ,0 'o,
c
J""
c,
c- <.J3 3
.... 3 S
Q) C)
C � c- c.-..; ·3"" 3 � 3 v � ·::) <Y O" 3 o, o :, S 3 3 �
3 3 r o3 ° g
3 Q) J g � t.9 � c,> 3'- � (3 g.. C- C- f" ]'- g> (>' � J- Q.l '1
it g I q:. .,<;3 • J8 f g.. g'
c- 9 3
t:.:>
9 g :> � � :f J'- f;f/ c'.,ZJ.. g-1 c-� A (J 3 3 g._,� ,a c..:i fJ
....... -6
\...T
3 t ..;>- u 1 S O
a., <::..:>
c9 ' j c.., 07 �
:> 3'
c{j �
:> �"· ' j :) :) C- a.:> c.l 0:> Ll
as :> c.> o3
D a3 ]' � g �
'-' -... v
3
a..> o3
' c.c :> OJ C-
° :>
fJ => :..,u (] :l :l
3 3
Jc,
J--
9 t- �. c- �.. 3 � �v rJ 12 � � c, (Y 11 g, 9 3 C 1 �� :> e=' g, � cf � f
C C, �... � ::> 3 3 :> c..:, c:..:> <Y d3 .. • f3 C..:)
- c..;,
3 c.�
ff s a.,) 3"-
:;) 03 � � C.>.
(:_) c9
C,,J O>
o, C.., 9 ':-6' 0,., O' � , a c- o:, '.) :) (_) c.:r C 0, 0 � V V 3'"
i,
I
I
v v 9 , c, (c;. c..:, v v 3 � C- n Q) C- 3'- o;, c!. .
� .) �
3 )' � 0> :>
C, g .:, 3 c,P C- C-
,a {J Q.) (j c..:, � v oi
3,.. 9
'j c...:> t- 3 ' (3 J'" " �
v 3 3 C a o, o CJ.)
9 o � c, c:..., 9 fj :> cJ � c- o:, 3'<13 13
�
<:T C- a> /] fJ c, f3 (} 3"- :, � g- :) 3 er o c, CJ: g' v
.. 9 cf> . &
I
,a c g3 c- a3 :J
�--:- � C..:> J CJ: cr. p'::) a.,,a c� � r Q.) 3' ... ..W 3' 5 rJ � 1'- r J f" o .8j J'..
fJ3 c, � 9 oz 3 J ,o c..;, v c:., c, 3 Cl Q.) ".) c..,
C,,:)
3 0 :> c, b 3 c.., ' • 0- . a3
...,, J� c, C- � (>' 'j r.l r">..
3 a... v v � cS C.\ i.. O' c.9 a.:> _.-,., Q . .:). ,,-. cS
-:, 0..) C, -
..
a, ,a O' c.., c- ,a � en' J ,.g <J3 c- er I j ,� :,
1
Q (.;) ,..�
c., 0
""" D c., CJ' j � <:, c, O U C
�- .. x-
__,
•
-..,1 t I I C- l I I (, I '.)
::>
I
"0 :.) c...:> c., c..:> c..:> o
I I I l C:, � (r 9 l (J
3
t ,a '-' I 0# ••·
C::-,�
1· ',: -�
,• :� r·
V �1
r:--'
� I CJ • 1�
,a 3
l
O 'J � O ana�ep6o6<i � oo¢v�� (?"> fo6v6 (?0 0 �Mv(? J��O'>• 'r) � � OOOMboG ca�
•
78
I I l . o, � 3 n.
.-
1
a
•• • «He npHHK11,. "IT06bl JIC cropHTt,C'H c·b T�·pna�111 1, nepcaMH)) (B)'TKOB'b
od33). 1J\3);
•
�a
J. fTlM���O.JbnlJ.) �_) na ��'11""}�6 C' .,�1<n3J �O"J,) .>O t'JvMf)l, OU �OOM-
�3 ��("' QJ-:, 3 .)�)�r;30 3�68\Jr�6J OJ ( 3 ,�MoJ c:'o�6,. nJ3 a),
o3 · I I {?\) ByTKOB'b� MaTep i8Jihl I� . 274, 275). av2>M�a � 3 vM °'30C'00L
o l)M(?v L b30081) �3D��a L o�Aoobo �a �v vo 6 (? i;, � O (? 'CJC'M0\'.) 8�aMo� o 6oL
�v «'>0Go010L aoo�3A('t)o ol, t?v0oo �eL � Ln�'B o vA 0voo6o6.
�a o O o aoG al)6L� h MMUOO eo oC'v(? M D Lo ooo G (?fl (?M <3 il�.a J [)Jv6oAn6o
a�
I I-o 80 60L6M0>� rJ3oM 30 �D La� oaoAomo L an cn oG LM�M8M6 I -L Ul)-
�o6e,o oM aMOOJ'cjC'(')L 00--(? h3�0'0 (:'M3ol, (3MO <J C'0030 C' OU) bo eooo
aMLv oA�, MMa AoGo o>o MLa�C'oroL OM�oo\} (pv oL M a o al)L LvMMQ(?
0 b�� l,l)�dD �oLM G �Ct)l)�o OvG vd C'o 3L (?\,)v(!'VO<!)L 0>�30 MU al,)C'O,t) Ov-
6M6Mo�L. l)aoLo,3nG avL 10Ao Ob(? � raao�l)M0 (?<l O>iJ61)o U(?O�O�M,
MMa �al.)33 Ma 'ao DMOJeo aa 'BOO 8.)0 M<i� (? I) al)O') MM(1)v30L L�3 \)Am30 -
�ML O[)[JMO?[JO'<JC' ��'83MM0(')0, A -oLno o L (? <l�80Ano(')O) MLa\)��� v o 6v
�aC?OO . n OMdM\:'.:'.:iOl ( ob. �MM<23, u.:ic,.:iMn �ol, f p aMOTbl I , 2 1 , 25) . M -o
Lo mo u a o6o GoAcnv �30M30�0 Go t?D(?M<z3�0L a �300A v�� Moo6ao (? v,
MMa %v30L 'doJ3M oG cpMML LvJvM003[) C' MU m�30L�tz3C'Q O OU "aaLl) bo;� �o
� o �'aoJM'O C'OOv'do 3oMMOv oJ86o oM(?I) 'aoOi)bO�O (JMM<[J. o\)3 vM[) C'O U
fpaMOTbl I , 24 (?I) 6yTK0Bb.. MaTepi aJibl I , 2 7 7) . UMC'MaM6Gvol,) (? �
.. O MD J<:'D a n cn o G \)u DoM 6"<»; MMa o tt:'I) J <"> 6�a e?3oe'�C? 0�oML0oM�6o 6
oa· L ilaba (?MM ��ba�MQO�U, MMao�L�o Ll)3\,)M0>3Q C'M \)Lo C?�a o 6o o ocn
GcnbMJ(?� ArJLoo>G. MM0>�3o a Lnb�M -o �no, Mado �0Ao30G o,�6b8 MO I)
&1)6�ub�(?DL oa 3oMM000) J O, MM8 M�Locn(")o o,�3<">L a �A o3 L�J0Aoo30-
�M'do 'L-:>Ja�M ,�MG 3\)8M3tl)360(?" (o�OJM3 0 I 2 7 7-2 78). 1
BO
T
1 7 70v. DMDJ�D aD'BD L\)A ��°'3D �"'L ,�Mn<nrJM<n {!)I) 6MO �a�a 6'n
M0 LoL f i':>M OO'>'[J M O'> \) b .:,t:'o o b oL L oez3.:>O ML ·aoo L 03 606 �h) l) V �0 MoL o o-
b ol, 8 0 1)� 0 606. L .:,8 0 (? (!>O� o M dM�oL '<lo8c.?oMa ��Gooo oL 1" Mol, ia<n
MM U8 \) d M rJ C' M�6o C'O(? o M dM C'Ol, . 30 C'L (? � �(!>a. L.: > 30Am3ot:'ML ,� ML
0>.:>30 8o i:> 6o Oo (?O 8o>o C'o 0>03 0L C'Odj M OO'>TIMO'> r)Jo6 aooA06c.?"' (b oM
b o TI �o do . 3 03. 264 , � DO· 4 9 1 (? O ByTKOBo I, 28 1-282).
mo3'boM(? o8uo 8 0 o::, M M0 L o cnoL 8 bo (?MM O oL 0CZJMML 0L o L �"��
� ol, 8 L3�3 L o L vJooo C'o C?I) o8 oOM 8 ,, 8ocno (')M vJ�O 8M \)30t::'Jj' o b 3ov6 ·;)"
'
O�o oo6 L, 8v0�,o8 ,,8�6 vM v 0 L 8 0 60'' (o b . .b O M bo0 C'o do. 3 o3. 264 ,
� (')
�'00· 4 9 1 ). v8a3vM 1J(? M 0 Lom0L v30 w��CMOOO? (? v M 0Lm� oTit:'0 Lo,30L
Mu8 i:>C'omm.:,6 M 8o o �•)O>M O��o \) (!>8 MU. L l)3.)Moo30 C'M /.,�Gom ou ioMoL
U l)M(? C'OU 8 ooM30 aA�3vt::'Aoo bM3�6 a�MoL v 060oo a'O b o 6�oo'QM � (?
8vM0Mc.?!.8vM0 Mc.? Otl M C? �O M3l)O'Oc>O· LocJo 6o C'o 8 (? 3M81)MQMOv 'Bo-
(1j8 6�, 8oaAv8 �a '0�(!>M :JL a\) 6L �o�o C'oL (?MMU�o Q M OJ�O 804noL (? 0-
(? 00 TI �av L �a b o (? MM 60380 ob u6v �3060 oA o C? � l,J8d M 0� M l, b 3o<t3M o3
�rJo o �ooo C'O ao6oC?ow"*'oo oL oao6: 8o oMo C'O<l3Aom� MO') 8v6 Gv8 b o (?
M(;() oo o8 oL v (? I) ba Mb ()G v���MOOO, M �Lmo ar)B8oC?o2>o cn 01)0')�8�aoo�
C' O ML 8o�O')o 8Mo3v C'Mo o bM3060 ioM O iolr,· O(?oO C'MOM03 , 'a oaC?o o
L . .:>L 3 o 6doLm.:,6 L o'a o 6 C'v 8 MUJ(""} (ob . b o Mb o
(? (!>vv8vMo � (? J am C' Jt?
b
t) C'o do. 303. 264-266, ��o. 4 9 1 -492 (?J ByrKOB'b MarepiaJl bl I ,
282).
M () L o,.:, f JM ()U 8 oo M 30 M oorJ C' O(? 8 oO M 300rJ C'Gvo a MG306oo �l, � M
od C'03 (? v aAoJC'O 8o<ao L M tJl>om oL 11 8 0 60LOAl)C? v�·aC"l3 C' o 6o C'o "
C'3M30 C? O ML a \) com o l, vo 6�(!,'a (? Oo L b 30 (?v l, 3v L voTicnoo o cn UJ M8 M � (?
b
\)Bo t oo <P o � Lv MM (? O ,, � 8 oLoL "' �03 000 " a o cno Q M OJ C' O 1 77 1 V· J3 C'l)3
\)b S�o oboL L v'l3vdML 4aoo Lo� (?v b 0 M m3 0 Lo l, o o b o (? " j vt:'vJ o ,:JO�("),
8.:>oM \)8 MM(? QGoo o o bo'Bo o,03 0Lo aooo bM3606 0 '<loo�jD 6 ,), M ':jGooo oL
v �M 8M8v(? o0 6o�ao v8�L v o 6v�(!>a (?O oM Ov ovTivo � n8nO M8, M\)JO ML a.:>t:'-
0).;, (?O� ,l)�(')l, 8ML3� 0L v O�ObM (? J, M MB 8M3 0 (? 06 (? " ,,d o C' ,)(? � a�A cn-
3.:,6 LOMo b 30�0 oMoL M " (o b. b 0 M bo0�od o . 3 03. 266, �DO· 4 92--493).
ao M�O (? vO 1 772 V· C' 3(\')380 J0(.!>03 0 8(? 0 60 8 Mvb o M b.), M M8 O M OJ
�o a o<BD U � �vo M 6v ,,oAmbo� J3v�v(? (? v3JvM b3v6roJA oL avaTI�LuM "
(? ll 8v6 1)o l, M � M8 M 6 ao<aoo 8 M o 8&M M (? " 'BooAmooDc()L �vOj�)OO, fD M
/1)3.:> bamnL v b v C'3vC'\)3l, o•)MUd00 MO MOtj 6 0 6 (? O U MC'M 8 M 6 ao<a D Uv M'lJ
eooo MM 8 oM 308 b (?oMOj M , �0(!)00 (?0 6 JO(? QO, oo8 C?oo M M (?OUvO ,)8
6. 81
aM�M��oL a�a(") �3ama�6 \)"���6'D6, 8(")'*>�no L v��� on�nL, ����vbO�
�h) f ..:,3..:,l\')Ol oli Mt:' E n&o ( o b. . b.'.) AbtJ �t'.'t> � . J oj. 26 7, �n &. 4 93).
raa�
v�30�0 � O�M va33vM MM�o&> aM3�060� 5v6l>vo(?[J�OL�3v6
cnv3oL �v(?V:J3v. &>Mcp oLvo :JMDJ� [J ao <nD a Ja &>o8b1)6oL q..vaMc_:� o
ooL v3ov3 0 dJ00tJM, nv&>v aooMoC? av�b'*>:J oJ36\), 3061)0�3-:,6 08:J(.?J-
0�806 ��Do,oLu a <ll � 3[J�MooLvav& ¢{ryv MO(?� o�dMC'v� l'l3u60,J�oL0
(Pl) vMU\) ... � v Ja("')Aio�oo {? v aM'1{.!)oO�[)Lv �\,)o 6oLvL v {!>u vd tJ�av{_? (?�
dM�D00CO O�M a'l)vM3J �MOv MwLomol>v'' (ob* baMbfJ':J�od3. 3034
268, � rJ �· 494).
t?>nuo018v o,u30L 8o°ov6L aov�voo, MUdl)C'O°'oL MaoL Lucn�cnbv °c'Ju-
3nl, 3vaM rldc3D �\)M v�LnoMO��. v8o�Ma Luju&>0>3[Jc::(")L\)u a0Goo30L
a6o'a360�("')0.) vM J8M6{?\) (?v �v6v3oMoo 8 <23 �3c.')�MOOU avV[J3v O')OO)
j("!').L �1)�30VtJ�v J0{!)[.)0·. Lb3v L�onv�[JOv v .._ 0tr> OjM, LvJvM003[J�ML
oLD3 o,030L L�Jt)O'lv&> d\)�00') �v i083&>ovbM&ocn rJ6 (!) v a(")DVtJM d�r,OM
an%MO�[JOO,v6 \)l, D a(")� <l30jMtJOt103 ov<ZJ'J3no��o �08MJO�[)O 'C) �DO�.
cnoJMoOt,� L.:.dbo(!>MM 3MJaJ�n0oL V:10 ..._ M6oo, DMDJC'D a oLo 'llJ.:, V '(jb.:,
(1v<4>LoL, O�n¢iDC>0Lv <!.''" ¢b..:>� ooboL Lv'{ll)dM[)OO �Ma Ln�6,)6o ,�d0-
� [)0'Q�O 0�(') G�uMLDcnoL 30Md�6oon�oL�0')30L (!)o�al)Aocv JO?bM3;;.,
M<"')a a\)L ('\')La��o,o l,l)Jvc(,o,3D �Mt. aD�oL 0')1)3(?vLbaoL�av6 c,v6Do->v30-
Lu'llt"tJOOb�. jDMo8bv6o� O'>bM3boo, [JMDJ�D I I-na 'bu30 iva("')vo�M ML ...
ai:>�omoL L'<J�6vbmv6, �M.ae'oL�a\)600 d30�<23 v�O Lv� '<:JJMoon �0
a:!
0 (J3:JM�OO'l3vb 8ubQ>u3 0L0<n C::'D��C'O jvhcn3oc::'D�O 8Mn3o�n 6 (ob. bJ&,
bnrJt::'odn. 303_ 2 70, � no. 4 95-4 96 (?v 6yTKOB'b, M a tep. I, 288 ,
289).
D M OJ�D aJ 'DJ J3�v3 8 u�)o(Y) O)u3ol, J3D�6ob d��OO) dJ'J(?ov L�
J i)M003Dt:��L Luao q]ML j('")t:>06()J0M a (? oMa�M OMOoL 3v686J0(3D0,)l, (?u
°cMcvb a(T)bnMboo0�'0 (.?0 3�C')a\)�'C)M O a M�i.)JuMDJDOOOOv �v �ucM6D
Oocn, tMc,v6 O'>v3 nL JOM-l(? Lv8bo(?MM 603()0'}-) �v J i)MO,, 1\)MoL . auavoM-
0<">00, 8v6 uMu3o OOr) dd30Q>M0nv6o �l)aMJO�non�oov �uaM�B(!)M 8n
°cMo�n ocnv5, vMv8D (!) <t>MoO a�°'ov6o 0Lo3 t18u�-6v<r3ouv� ovob�(?v,
0MJJ�D\Ju0 �6 0u6i ol> bu61)C? (?vC?oD 6o�o 'a�doL b\)60 8oLo 0[JM0?0 0�J
Lo a(')bvMJ[) () � C"') ooo, MM.8 ::,MJD<:::v�onMo 2>v(?vL\)bu(?OL ovM C,? u cn3ocn
cv6��<3o LvJ�Mcn3o�'ML 8o cnn o cn�30L VvM8v(?oJbQ<::'U 6o'B6v3· (? � (6yp
H awesb Ka pTllH a 1 3 ), oLo A�a ,,DMOOo �aol, (d;j dOL bv6ol,) Jvoo (? v
DMO"Jo cl3 cnol, ''OM�Jt:'OGci ov6voD0�6n 6 Ju�vJDv a�610GuLu'' ( M B. b oMbo
ut:10dJ, 303. 274, �'QO· 4 98). mo8ov 1 780 V· JMQ360L bu68 \) ul>�b��()
bvb8.) DM F>Mov ov0D�u �� b�MJOL dMuoau v�1)h 3Lnh�u, 8 uohv8 d :) '[30
DM;Jdt.l")n3 aoL vo6,)l)c,a�Do 3voe10 djMv (?µ OoO �un8�M�O�'>u� .. n:J3D�Mv
D M036ol} bubo �� �v0(?3u 30Q>MO Mcnbovcnuo O'>'C)86�8 (!>o &vM�vJ3Jo,oo,''
�(V)3D �V�\O"C)� bl)MJ � (? (("'):8 , bD�'bD0t ndo� 303. 2 73, � 'C) O , 4 97-4 98.
1
84
IV o, 4) 3 �.
86
aau�[JO M�uO> �\) ol>n3 08 d�onML �M�O �Mom oL L�bD�OVO<BML 3o3-
8\)AmDL·
(")<?)O(JOv�(.)�O mbM36\) oooet03G\) M 'rJLDoo'ao.
M00 0 �0L 800�3MMO¢L d��o\)6 0\)a\) n L �aov30. Ddl)�DMo6n I I -no
o)d l,.:,j 8003\)6 M�LooooL �cn30L �O(?G Uuh8D0�M�l)L 8MD�(Y).��o) (1783 V·
VDMO�O ob. ,UyopOBHH'b, HctopiH BOHHbl T. I I , 1 1 ). 24 oaC'oLL
1 7B3 V· -.)(:>a, lJ\)�vMooao<::MlJ (?.) M�Gnooou vl)h8M8\)�Z>D6�0�80 bn�'a3j
M�t:>D00U b0 r_,,·\ 1c-10voMnL.
J�bn o,oG) aD<lJDooL �MuL (?MMU u(ry �uaM�('t)M�nouoo" (§ 2). Ll)� u&>cn30-
C;('")U an<Bocnu D <B�no� 3nBJ30(?M[)MOOO, o��u30(?M(!?'ll �� M�Lncnou bn�-
3vo'BD v�00Ja0L0 u·�DO (?u, MMa DMD J�D aD<BD C,?v 8ol>o dcnvaMa�3����
. a n�0a, ao60��3D 6t;03 L�an<n(") 'O'n�oooo, aMLO�() · c1386ooov6 (§ 62).
L0j"M°'3D��L L�aocn('t) �vb�°6D ctouo aD({3DDoo aoaJ3o�Mo(V)ooL do)�ocn
0�()',)b, (:>\)d (')d 0(?l)2> uc>D 2> 0 M u L n cn oL . b o �avo cnnL 0 �� Lvj ->Mcnao�ML
aD <BO � 'aMMoL �a 3b&>o3 abMC1M(? oaoo, 51)8Moh��o oM��, hMd aoaJ30-
(?MDMOot ':J<tl�00()0) G�3l)M0?3DC'C?L 6vb�to \)b�u� . .:,lJu�L aD <B D l.,
I
�JM [lq:p'a o Loj� �0') 3D�ML aD 9.3D L <','tJ� O�� �va� �d o�n �o �n O�M (§ 6 3) .
r-;:,3 00> «<,�LncnoL btJc::avo<z:3ou JuA'to L�J l)�0')3DC'_"(Y)l>
•
aa �DL m�30Lo
ao 6oLtiMo. u6� h:J to(!>D 6�o j H�3 (?0 �·l M '[') Lncnol, b Dc:'avO<lJt)L.vo °'�3 oL
0�M(13 l. i vJ-.)�i0'>3J�Ml> t)ua l) �M J(:(,�bD /,· , nLoo,oL v oAat°Y) a,..\��DbD (o ao-
601Jo�o, �6-o Moto�n6oo 08� M'l3[) 0M�v (§ 5). L.:>� vMO>JQ�ML aacaoL
I JL)D hOivdr-)f-:r t)L M (?v8MJO(?DO��D�oL �<n�o o�o J3 (')bQ,) 0 $1 8bM�M� 08
abe!-,03 'Bo %(!:r.,cp30�0, .(;c,,8 �a �MO'>O[)MC>MOOUva>30L MrJl>n o,oL a oboL6M•
Mt:J°60�D66oL\) �� 8(").6v30MQO, - a0)1)JvMoov6 vo6\;)u vvMO d [J O>u6ban2>u
O;JM Lv3olf") M. Lb3v l,\}bD�8voqJMD<>oL C?oG3�6n�ols�cn3ou, �6 8o �n o n� o
\7oAor::'noolJ o �L�on a 3-: ': �1nL <':J l,�bno·)(J �r,i l,omoLs 08�3n VvM8n8� � .. _.
8Jbt:>D600vb o,�o,oo�o 0 6�\) AjM6M�u (§ 4).
l)v
i)<J to�'aDJM'tJ� D 2>oL ao°o\)60 Li)Ji:,hO'>ODC'M�0030� oav'ao a�3M8uMJ
MO(?u, MMa f'>'JLooooG L�ba�aw ocnM L\)Ji:,�0030 �ML 80 V ��ol, i), aa <t'JMO ...
�D oou� � � 80MoooL,)oi:,b C?oo3i)- \? i) �avMDOvL JOLMrJ �MO \? v· v80Gcn3nL
8,){., jv.hcn��;i �0'Bj Moli,)0)3()� 80G�'a30�02> C'u� i)�aMI.J l)3 �D O') l,\)J �A ...
OOJDc:?Mdo 2 LA rJ �O o �o��OM6(') jJ£)00,MO�, MO, �O i�Mo�'b6oo,ri�o,
'C)6�v JtjM�,Y)�\) (ov�JD �MooJ. § 2). o L ar) b t;o ��aMGv3e[JOi L\)j vM-
•
l,'03D�O bM Ol.)LJ .:,8� .:, M[J 0(? 1.) L.:,3 \)M0>30 � (")to, M M8o �oo d O 6\)oh at)&)(]) 3.:,-
3.:,830·('1')0�'ao, Jl.)6 M6a�oo�MO�d0 �\) L .:,[J J<:'oLo M L,'t)OM('T')"ao 00-080 UMj
�[J OOO) (? l.)a ML)JO (?:J OD�, 8.:,3M\)8 8.:) 060 aou 3vLLv�jM Lvbo�avoCB M �
b�oM� (Die volkerrechtliche Stellung der Republik Georgien Ein
Gutachten · von · Professor von Liszt-Berlin. Als Manuskript. ged
ruckt .. 33· 2). 0>00>J80L n303n \)tMo 3.:)8 M0>380�(') \)3 3L 'b. v3v�Ora3o�L\)o
(]).:)30L vo36do ,, flpHCoe,aHHeHie fpy3i H Kb Poccifi ". a\)L v�6o"a60-
�o \)33L, M M8 oL �M�oOoJLJMO �v8 MJO (?[J O'CJ�D Ov, MM8[J �OO UvJvM0'>-
3:J�ML.:) (? .:) M 'CJLnooL d�MoL 1 783 V· bot:" d [J JM'CJ�oooL dv�(')O) 'BooJa6\),
t
v·
800 603� (Bcryn�11e11ie fpy3iH B'h cocrae1> PocciHCKOH H MnepiH,
190 1 03. aa-89) .
. .:,Lncno .:)t&)O').:) Lb3.:)(?vLb3.:)MO� oa 3�M[J 8 M[J OOO> vobL6o o.:) M M 8 bo�
d[) JM'C) �[J O.:), �M3oe,8bM03 LM'C) �L n'QMn(?n LJ �L 6vvvM8M [J OU vM v\)M-
8 Mv�3n 6L (?.:) o3ocn 6.:) 6 oov6�8D�Mt">3D Uv[JMOO\}'cJ MMnU M (? � L,) bo�avo'tJM
l, .:, 8 .:, M cn�oL m3v�L\)tMol,ocn cn300>(")[J 0t:' to a<"')a M�3�60� d [J b[J ���o
ooL 3.:,Lvat)MO'l�[J O�v� UvO'C) OOnU 8 Mtl3v6� do od�o Ov.
1 «Bblna-nH fpy3iJJ (on 1 783- 1 80 1 r.) B'b BaccanbHOH s·aBHCHMOCTH OT'b Poc
ciH, HJIH H3XO,l{HJI3Cb IIO)l'h eff npoTeKTOp3TOM'h? f-l H TO, HH JJ.pyroe, HJJH, ny11111e
CK333Tbt OJ{HOBpeMeHHO H TO H JJ.pyroe" (&3· 1 1 1 ) . ,,HTaK'h, pa30HpaeMblii cJ1y 11aA '
11e IlO).I.XQJ,HT'b HH noJI.1> rIOHRTie BaccaJibHOCTH, HH JIOJl.'b IIOHRTie . npoTeKTOpara-B'h
CTpOrOM'b CMliCJl'h, H IIOAXO)I.HT'b 0Jl,HH3KOBO H 110)11> OJtHO, K JlOJl'b Jlpyroe, eCJJH
pa3yMeTb H X'b 6t>Jtee o6Ule'' 63· 1 43).
90
al)aM va V vM L0�0 L LvJ OO'>to o oL (!h)'l3vL O Ov, O'>r.J b (?v(J D L LvJ O aJ b o
L vavM O'> t:'oL aooorlo M o o oL Leno M (Y)L • o b o o c,')�oL, O'>vovao(? M M30 L v8 oo6o
O M M bMMaD o oL 8 oboC?30°'-JO v M cJood�o o v, � Mv ao C? v a oLmvbv ctDdm b -
3030 0d o o LOrw1M O 'C)�O O'>Jvt:'O'>L.:/bMoLo v'CJOO �o oo t:'O (? v o MO, v C?o�cno
n0 � 0 i:,Mo B'b;) vM oL. 0')0 Bva MMJ3D0�0 oJ 8 6o ov Mv m3ol10 0 0L (? va ('Y')
J O (?Q 0 0�D 0 0L �va�vM:J O v JL0M (? v0'> LuJvMm3o�MO �v M 'CJ l,oo,oL 8oov3-
M("') O o ol; , M M�o Lvo 1 ·7 83 V· b o�d OJM 0�o o vL L�o o � o 6, �v O'>vb00 •
2)300 (Y)� O bO Ov, 0)0 M\J Gv b ot:"L 0V M�O 0� o 6 oa ��(t')() 6�o c)o JvM m30-
C'Q O O (?0 (..)0LJ00o �8 �v8�,)M0 0 0� L1)Q M O,��MM O LM (?vaMJO (?[) O 'i:J t:'0-
I
0 0l.J, avctn b °'3 () O') L•vJ00, b oo vM Lo ()()O')�� 2,v8MM d30 'J� O oJa 60 O v.
to a{'!').0')380 (�1 ucn3u6 rJd3 D otv�o u, MMa Li)J0Mm30 <:'M MOLooooLvol)b
(? vb auM o o �L (?0 " a <n�M 30 t:1M O vL" 00') bM3�,). oa GA '0t:'·Mv8 'Cl 60 00C"0 00 L
J v� 0�(.?d0 , MM8i:._0 om00 8o<no O M OJ�oa 0,1)3ol) C?o L.3v6ooli b ot:)dOJ M 0-
C:'O O al., (?,)(O[J O � 8t)vb�(Y), 600,33v8 n0, (,,Ma oLo6o 'C) b � v OC? O �ot1360 b
v�8M-L, lJvJ,:., �013� 1::.·:�,L 8o<aoo o oLJ ,,ao�o o 0L.)0>30L . . . a <nvM30 t:'M0vUv J30-
d D Od(')GnlJ n8JJ!-106t.'T)MJ O OO') O{; �0�0 0 0 �'[) 0 0Uvlh)" (.3M . v. ovo..)M [) t:'00
f'p a !�fOT t-I I I 09). 00300, M vo60 2iLuo M 0Lo0>0L 8 cnv3 M M OO �vei,jb, M M
ei (Y) t'")o 0J:JO v(!?b()�6 [J � n 0£j (Y), liv(Y)�D� oLo O')o a o 6 (? M O O�('f) 0v 3j ('> b� v,
1
M (Y)a O f> DJ ('.2'0 80 9.J<)Ul)0')3 oL M 'JL [JO'>O Gv3v6 a cavM 30 ��oob a, b �3 bv DM � 00.
t'10L omtiL o3 (:2M (Y)() b � D� 0 D � � () GvJvM 0'>3D do o a �.)a('f)J O (? o o 'C �o
� � (Y)
b��() C?I,) LvnM[J C? ,:>a L�o�ooom0 �6 6!Jcn��C? L ��6L aoLo �tf>o A0Lo01-
Lo30Am3n�(T)L dMMoL a� Mq) 0 'B�QOM030 ��aMJ<,�QO'J(:1QOOL 'aaLoboo.
a�L 6�0033\)ao vj3l,: 3JoGA��MO ,, d ':J �a C?o(T)000).;) �0800, a(T)ao3M3MO)
92
,
(
ouC?uoaooAu. aoL �v2,M6oooo, ou6ioc:1no80 QM:JJ�D aacaoG aooM �u6o d-
6�(:'0 ol) 6ioG 00a30 o�>aMudo3ol> (03 3[,} )• �u%vb0Lv; (a,) ad��o�oLu �0
'cl03jMMOU a �aoou, MM3Q�Cf) uo0b Lv(1�1<4)())30�ML 6()0()-a�D Uur.JJOO)Q
LM o bo6{ryL060 ao2>MdM(:'0 n8o6[)6M�u bMc3o, v8030 JMe1060JrJM ao
°t>o °t>oG 2,u8M dr) �(")l, bv6L 3no3 bA6o6 (?,) a6MM00 �jov�oL ( Byp11 arne81)
I( a pt H Li a 1 6) .
�u�o L06J (:'DOoL taoaMG03,) MMd � J 'D o d oo� oAoJ �O ao cn oa LoJ � ·
1 78 7 V· jvMcn0 (:'0 �u M '£J U 'C) �O abo�MMO(')O')uMm 3u6ioL V o6vu�a e? D o
ovO�ura3A0. LMD �o ou3vM�3oou O�M 8MLu�M�6oc:'o, M,•132 �Lvu
DMDJt:iD aocnoG vo606�D <:'O L0bo �o 'J6�0 �r:o <Poo6o. 300M1Ja UM'J �o
oocn 8M'f)�M (? 6[J ��� MDUOU � �MoL D q)MMLL ao6oG6M-M [) °t>06 (? D 6� L
00M60cJ03L 3MOoMaJo6oGuou6 L0JuMO)JOt:1M0'>306 (?uOMD6o ooL <Jol>uboo
0Adv6000 aMD30 (? u. 3v6 3v6'C) u bu(?u ao<aol>t MM3 n (? �JU3D 0 6�u 303-
0MDb�JM'' (? v Mv8�o6o uM La,bM3v JMDJt:'oa, AM3 (:'u c}jMMOOU �va
cnv3Ao 2>0a�oL dvo6u aMo u0�0} �M ��M � u: Gv�J uMM(? \J0 tl 0Mv (? 0 00-
94
8M6MD6�0 �CBo�oGoGvJo 6, �(")�(') 03000306 MDGooo'cJo 8ooa2/b03M0
acno�o , �MOOO (Ma. boMbo0 �odD· 303. 275-276, .��0- 499. 5yTKOS'ha
MarepiaJJbI, I I , 1 94- 195).
1 783 v-oL b o �O[J JM0 �nool, v�v�MOOO? UvjvM0?3J�M ovdc:'onMo
t
ooL � 0 ovMo ao aohooouvav6 rJ°t>M� 63J��M qJoL a v300M G080L a bhocn
36 hoooro cl o 3 M-M 6� a 'CJ�O avb(?I) (?v ovb0V:J3 0 0�o3 l,l:,(")8 oM 0 06vjM
oo�oo�'ao ��3vM (? v oa cr>v3ol, 3 [) °6MO�[JO<nv6vu, MM8o�6ou vo6um ao-
uo OMO'>c'0c:'0 8Mj�300Mo 60 0�3 60 6. 0,300, O MOJt:iD ao 'BO U �v 88vM 0?-
3D �O vAo ooo bo (? v3�0 6, MMa va j("')�O�()JDM 6060�0L 30aMoLM�OO?
(
l,u30Acn3o �M oGoo>L L0 dobo�L 306"L,0uC?o �'do �030M (? �, MM8 � oL
au803uoo 00Jvo0°tlol., ooa C? oMa vM � M<2JO�v (5yT KOBb. Marepi aJlbl
I I , 1 88).
ML,8,:,�001a0 0 b0�uohol, cnv'BolJ jOMocn O MDJ�O ao 'B ol, 1J o8M 'C) 0? 3 °
�f>v, MM3 (")�Mb� ol, M'[J LomL �03M3dMM[) OM(?v �0 M'Q UOU i0Ao �0-
3vMa>3o �Mcn2>06 i00L6 naA00060, �v vMvau 0") 0 vo6�6C?n�o Jncno�
ao<t>Mo��MO (? v3MJO�[JO'J�oo� LvjvM 0? 3[Jc:'MLlITT�b vC:C?oo6o�o oJ8 fi'o ..
OM�0, 0M0ao� 0 0uo�ooom D<BMM aool) G0Mo[JO�M00u0u JjoM�QOM
�0. O MOJ�O ao<aoa 'O vMO dQ'C) 0'>3'0�0 0aoL a0aM 1 786 V·0?0MJ QOO <t3M-
000G0 (?v 00oo'B80L 0 08001ioo0L oo � �oD 6 . 1 2000 �l)C?n u�6o�ou L,��0M
m3o�MG vo6vue:a�D o O:::JM a�O') 8oo M 61'.>j nM03n oo. ·
D MDJc:'O aocao Av8 06�D OM (?u, MM8 MDLo a>oG �0ba0Ao o 0 �0 a ca 0M-
3D (:1<">0v oa�a 6v� aooAo �o (L'C)t::' 1 80G i0AoL Jvuo) OtJM, MMa ol,
3D M�'nJML ()d3Q (:'O�v. vao�('f')a MM8 3 3Jtj�61) 8MGvC'M(? 6[) � "ao8Ml,0 -
30L0i�6, (?v ML8uc.:'t)OJOU o'J �oLvjMM30Lv306 D bl,60, od () �OO t:J �O ()�(")
ob0�uobol, ez30'aol,00,3ol, �0't>03000L joMMOv� u�oa>J3v, MM8 oL ao�t
hr, GoL i0MG L�j 0Aoo3a�McJo v(;;vM (Bo8Mo�306�0. 803Mo8 MLao�oooa\)
oL LlvJ8vMOUvQ> vM (? vObvbu (!)v oa (!)ujOMJOOU l)LM 'CJ �oooL
•
l,�vo6(!) Mv(?
1 2 Uu'JJDcnoLM 0'>030�0'}1) l.,033uMDD�MO'>cv6 MMO voM8Mave?cD 60�0
,)80600lv(? 3Moo,b(")30. OMOJt:iO a o <BD o8�o 6v(!) uaV[JM a (? oM80MD MO�'ao
()�M, MM a odn�oon �o 30b (!) o 1 78 7 V. 03 6ol,'Bo aG 8 do8o � I) �l)auauo
MtJ OD �O 8Ma,bM360C'o00 0nGM 'CJ C"D0060 . (5yTKOB'b. Marepi 8J1 bl I I ,
1 9 1 - 1 93).'
M "J UDO)av 000301.,o �OMO Gvj vM003D�M0')8c.)6 oaooMa ol.)Otj3ubu, MM8
od r1 c-o o'O �O O�M MGau�[)0,0'>1)6 (")ado �,)Oa 'C) �OtjM. DMO?-JMO) aoio
i��, MM8o�8\)o ML80�30')0 M rJGomou aoMv� oJ uoo �u (")ao o�d(")ov-
•
95
30�, � oLoO'>oG L �J vM0030 <.:'(T)'do a cni)A30�0L Lvboo, 'Bo 8ML3�v Otj(T). 15
03�ol,L 1787 vn�lJ MLa��acr>8,.) M�bJO'>OU (? [)LJv6L ove?�3Moo, a('f)lJ
OJb�).3�, MM8 a�L L��vM013[J�ML0130L 0,.:,30 �vo6ooooo6�� �v �a J3Qj60UI)
�v L�boe;8vo<z3MlJ l,vJ8ooo'Eo i)(?vM oi.)Ma0�0�M. 8v�[) MU8,.)�oo,8v
M�LomoL vo6vv�ac.?Do 86M0�0 . a('r)J8ocpnov (?vOVtjM Jn(?nU, bM�M
7 o6J. 1787 Vr M�L0108,.)o trJU8�·�no,L ('r)ao 30'8('r)�obi.)(?i.) (6yTK0B'b.
MaTepiaJJbl II, 198).
vLom 60M(T)0tJ Orao 08 8ooho(? il)MOL avt13v60L a�oODM, M 'CJLomoLo�67
3001v�)oi) a�i)M30�0L 8bA03, LM 'CJ C\')000') o-o 6ooho30 O;jM Li:>J�oo3n
�ML(1)30L 'CJ 'BMM an�o t0AoL 8M'B3o�nov o8o�Ma, &)('r)a M�JO 00'l,.)6b-
8MoooL QMO'l-oMoo 80°60°61)(? L�JvM0030�(') oo,3�00M�v, MU8v�o010u
8b�)00') v8 J30tl6oL vo6i),v(!;8 C?.oo 86�)��() 8MJ8o(?00v o,�30�(?�0')�3v(?
8MLv�M(?bQc:?O o��. a�3Mu8 M'CJ Goo,oL Lv8b[)(?M� d�voa� lJ�8MJ8o(? (ry
0008,.) oLo 'ao�C?on6v, MM8 MLa��oools vo6vv(?a�oo OMdM<.:'� � 8b�>OOO
oc.)6 3v6t&,vb0�0 vM Oj ("). van�C")a M0Lo01ou 801v3M(').Ov8 LvJvM013o�m
aov�C1)3� (? v 3v(?vbv�306i.), MMa uvjvM<n3Q�ML0')30G 'DJDmaLo OJ 6l) OM-
{
v O')v3nL dv�OO') (?v vo6�6 Dt:1 a'B3(J C')Oov60 Jv3 80�)0G ��(?oo6oo;
(1)v30Lo 0'),.)30 �a M8ol, (?MC")L C11L8,.)�ncn0Lv3v6 r1tMrJ 63.o� Qj<"'?, (ByT-
(? (? (?
VI en � 3 n .
,, D d D Oi D u � l, � 0 0 L a 6 D Ir, () 3 () 6 a J 3 3 8 6 t D � � C9 (', -
0)
98
Mu Lo 01 0 L d 3D cJ03 M (? M8 MOoL ao�oo oL LnM3ne'oL 8 �a("')atl �\}3 bJOv L�o-d(')
t,)M C?t,)oM a ep\} (0330 � I I , 304) . J U Mi.)Ut,)J3 a M30 C' o i:, i.)t'> v't3Mv(!> a MJVMb\}
t,)�t,)-•a t,)J,ao e? bt,)6l,. 8,)6 OMd�6oo,) 8\}iUUt,), MM3 oOC't,)60 i:>O�Mm, 8,n� CY)!'tJ ...
'bi,)�() bt,)b() 8 MDJC::'t,)01, M0LO> \} ,)b,)�d OO o 6%oe'dO 8 M oLJ MO> �i:, MnL a L
[J
33ocJ03M (? M8000 t,)D j �MO) (0J30 I I , 309). aM03t,)C' o%0L o OMdM C' (')L cJo a
C?oM 8 a0M 01n%,)-,)�O-b,)60 o dn�D0ue'O OtjM U Jt)MUJ 01 0 012,vQ 8\}3oo
u�()�(1') (? t,) Mt,)JO t,)a\}dO a,)L M0Loo o obat,)MOO M (!)D 6, ,)�u-avJao(!).. b \}6L\}
(? t,) M0LooL dMMoL 8c.8JMue'O 2,06VtJ MOOCX)Ot,) ivaM3vM (?v (nJ30 I I '
323-326). '
99
• ,�libIHe OTnpaBJJJITb Bb rpy3i Kl BOHCKa_ 33 6... ,aroHe n pieMJteTCJI".
u�oo (? 60DMM(? UJt)MU[JOOOO v�D bo �av v6'> [J ��(V')0t)a �� �-a�38D�-b0 6L
1 792 V· UvO r) '-1�0 0� \)M 8ol, o'-1, M("t)a O')t)30Lo iMl)b31) ov6o bM�iuoo�o-
2>o6v: oG odo�D0j�O O�('") rao6 o ��MrJ bD �'CJ �O� M.
VI I \I) v 3. o .
1 7 94 v. v� v-SvJa o <? bv6a v Li d�ov O')V3 0 L 'O.d " 6vl.i .i6o� L a l")vo 6vv� 3-
.
C? D oo li C'.'.' (')6 <n-V� o -bv 6L , M (')ao�L00 013 u�aOo (? 00mbM 0 0 6.:l . 03ol.i do 3-
O M8 u� -30J3 .
J C?-bv 630 mv3 nlio i:nv3 o L 3vM L omo l.i oMm»C? -oM O') Ov6('). 6-
C? 0
.3v6M M 6vC? 02, M d 6M (?V mv30 L.3vML ocnol.i "ailJo L �O{!?OO"J clooaJ l"'l. Bv'<ln630
ol.i L .3vM L o cno.L L v3'bc::i3 MoOol.i 2,0<13 0Mcn M30 0v L clo 'OC?O V (?V .3nMo d3�"3
il(:?Q M Oot, u60L0 (? V L v3 vM cn30('.'.'Mli.) JO 6 oOMu 60 (o33D I I ' 327- 328) .
oa "3 D 1 7 94 v'· aD CZlD o MoJt:>o d M o LJcn'a o cnv30 L C?oL3v6v C? oo 6o M61::'o
o vML 03v6 J.:,3Jv3 il do ov2,'bv 360 (o33D I I , 335), M(') 8 D C'.'.'L oo, 3 0 010M o0
M-o Lo a,clo V0 600,vo 6v3� M<i)L , 3a�o MO 'O M ooli am.:i3 MM 0 0'bn OV3('.'.'D 6v '<lo
D d<:' M a MD b(? 060, M l")a boc::''CoJ M 'O<:'O 0 0 M r:i liom oG 8 bMom uL� 'J l::'0 O -
't.']
v.
c:'O tJ M <l3 0 �() tj M.
O <B ot:'ol,ol, v �o ool,\) (.? � a�6� C? o 'OM QOOL abMt:'M� 1 8 �c:, ob rana�-
oMa, 1 . Mj o MaOD �l,, aM� 30(? � h D l> n oooL 8M6�JOM D fvMoL rJ�hMl,L
OO_v3 nl, a0'>� 3MMOOL�3 �6 OMdv6oOv, MM8 b D �d :J J M 'CJ � DOOU d��OO') C?�
� 3 0 00 � OMU JO_ol>v (!>� o6onAD L o oo� mv6v�av(? LvJ�M.� 3D �ML an�nL
MMo UM 'J �O ovo ��OMbO , �Mom 8ono3n �D(nM. 8vl, v8vL<nvbv3n D<n�o
Ov o d C'a M � I) LvJOMM D O olJ�a Q oA . JO �D3 M&Jo 0 .:>6v� oM6o aoo a\)oo oo6v
I I , 344). • L
v�
(? vaba�M ,
D � � UO'>v t:'vraJM0Lv<1> 3 ol, (6yTK0B'b. Marep i aJi bl a
ao'o3J �O MMO C).)o��oM6 o ��a. LvdvM°'3Dt:_:'M'do 8bM�M� 1 795
� DJ n 8ohoL (?va C? o ol> 8M30(?\).
M
D DJ O � a �
o D J 3D � 6ol, vM h M oo ol, a\)a (T) · A'O l> n mo L 8 oov 3 �('1") 0 c:>l,
1 .000.000 a. �O,�MGC?v L o Gbv � � \} Lvvo6(?Mvep oov3 ol,o -�v °: �3 ol., uvb
�Mool, a�a'O �aoL od�:J M(? I), 3va c<i�a �aol, J�L'O to �M aM (?OM� t). \)8v3 0
� AMl, �La'-?�o oool, aoo�3 M{").o� vo �oLbL � vd�D 3 �v MvLvJ3 0M 3[J �nv oa
•
oaot? ocn t &>Ma L�j �M0')3D�ML, oTi eo oov301)6013 ol, . aMOc,Mcn � v M 't:JL o cno
L�& �6 �D � M D060 006�0,. M�JO M'tJ l,0000� G\)abn �MM � �bavM[J O�o a�'ao6-
C?D� 3oMMon oon an6�� a o oho � o O tl C"l �� LaLboL 'Bn��hnovo M 0 L,J O?OU
acn\)3MMool>v&v6 l)h�3 noouMO J�U 't} bo �M aC'lL (? OM �v, D M DJ �D a ocao L
o �a(Y) o� ot:'o ooL cv_aM Jj30 .a o o3�M�, MM.8 A � l>o cnol,� Bv? d Q J()hn o nc:i
d�O [J ML G\}aho� MM �vb3u� o o�L M � n tJ8a 8vr,cn C'.�0 J �OML[J O M � �. v8o-
6M8 D MJJ� D an<BD � M� a�6do O tj M, 'C) �MQ� M ooo \JMv Ml,8i:>�ocnnl, vo6�
(?�(!):JO� (0J30 I I , 34 5).
l 02
w� bamo1i o���1dt'>02,� ��� .. a.)!8:JG? b �6ob� s:e� b3�t'>bDmob
i06���all?ao. t 700 i., S ObO ScYlF.3360���0 �� 6�8tt!30�0
a o\D\a 2,o '!!� ��()�b���o.
°'3 �C'D o nL ul>� b303 �(!> �� 'd oL �o C!> D 6u(!> (')� M o�aM O bu(!>J 00 C'O. MaoG
6u8 � 3 0 C' O 3n°r>o°r>o t?� a o�u6o JO Lot:' L �3 u tJM<z30C'u·
1 795-- 1 796 v-oL i�aoo�M'do �e:�-a\)Jao �- b�6oL oMdu6ooom o6t o ·c
'd o M0Lcn� j 3D�� bMa��(?QOO �� 3ujMO O"' (?�Ojr'iMDL (E)'TKOB'b. Ma
Tepi aJi f-,l I I . 354). M'£J LomoL a\)d Ob C!> O�O am�3MMO� ao6�(!> ez3bo°r>t:'� (!>
�(!>03600�� m3�C'tJuML m�30L J 3Dd03M (? M8oonL Lu3u3MM o 6�oMoLooL,
ao� \)(!>MO L .� �MLocn'd o U�O(:'MO (!> � �q 8 bM03 aoJooo � «lJo boL aMJO�o�
Oul>, �,:) 0')3u6 uJ0003�6 80L q)�MO,M �� '<:)0�MoL�(!> 8 08%0�30�0 L�8M3 ...
J OJ
80 �(") \}L3,:>Mo%o o b�oo c M �v. t)aoo M a M�Looo oL aoo�3M MO�a toa(")��-
6o<a6 rJ�U '<lo8oo b303 t)L (? O (? O tj'e}M �C?� oc� 8ou3 uol) (oj33 ).
MnL omo L 8mu 3M M O,:, boC? \)3 (? 1), M M 8 L .3\)ML om'a o 8 M 8 b(? vMO \)acn co
oa 066 0M0 Loco l,om3 0L C?� 80%6 0Lucr> 3 0L, MM8 o�o o 8uL C?�l, �b �o
-o
jjM6 �u, 8X)u (? LubO <l)ucn M Otj M. 8uL- Jo J Ur.)M (? u, M M 8 MnL o cnoL 3 u3MM
Ov UJl) MLocn clo \ oLo aud� ooMo oo� ot,M, MM8 a�ho (") j-:>L 3ooL %�3 0L .3o
M�6- JO uM\), �Mu8 oQ? J3J� 6ol, m3000 d�u o'C)�doo � M �O�Oti M o �3MU O
�OC 'CJ �O. 81.)L 080 (? 0 JJ M 6Q?u , M M 8 \)a u (? oO� QCOO'> o�6 o6 M ocno L�Jo 6
Q>
0%oL oubL 6\) �<ljM M a�A� 3DC? 8Mb oAb (?D0M(? 4). O oO �uM v8 'CJ 6oo 'CJ �O
O� M , M M 8 u8bt) 0Mv(? MTIU DO')O O b(? M O O')OU a(? O(? uML 3 v3M M C�L J3M M-
jo � b u �bo o'b o �uoo�o c o o, 'O<lJf, M aMJ�D c,'b ooo � �Oo (?O O (? u bo�'ao,
Mucno�6 nLo6o u80Lro30L ,,JJO)O�O oaoC?o� JMbobL '' rJ3�)0 (? Qb bM�aJ.
v8nL Qua('() M�LooooL 8mu3M M CuU ua oo o8nL 0 �6b MM UO O�o ooL v�u �M
()()0) vrJMuobo�o Ln8
(? 0 (? MJ C?\) "' L�MoOO�MOv ob��[)O M (? u (6yTKOB1:,.
M a Tep i aJ1hI I I , 355)*.
M�Lomf)U acn�3MMCvL L,Ja()M M (? a o,)� 6�1J ! M\°Y)a La"�l.ocn'3o ·o �moL
8bMocn 8�3o� MOOub M Ov (?v voLooAoc� �M<l30�0�M, o8n6Ma MM8 nu8o
Lc,)� aoLo L �JM8ohooM cn�MO')M oD oaoL ou6b MM (3 0 Q�OC� dJr)d�oco�o
Oj 5QOM (? u, u8c)U0,30L di) d�oo�o ouD�)(])O�Goo 'CJ �O aoo�3MMC.:, rJ b��'>
� M <l30�0tj C") U j�MUQO')dO. auaM�a 80 01MoL 8bMocn A�Looo <noJ MMO�o 6,
f>r?a Li3�"1 MLomoL 0 �0MO')ou6ocu (?0 0 �d��0Moc\) M 'CJ LncnoLl)o130L . Lt)LvM
oO C�M JO uMu, LubocaumMu O� C"l * *. nL ��u-8 JJ8o (? -bv6oL a(')JanC?o ou
a � o o �v(?·J �("). u8o� Ma <'>TI L.aooa� o��i)lJV �306·J, MM8 ��� .. ai)JanC?- b� ...
6ol, oud�oohoo� C?� aoL LucMdi)6oc�oL l.1u8%�3Moccll 3u<l).:>MO,MQOu
M r) LomoL aoo\)3MM OOU cn�MO,M DJ M b M dOTIM C?� JMC" O(JOJ 'C) M cD oauL nvo
o� �� � C? O &D O M(? v �� L �a �J MM 060n�oL oooL�0i 30L (8�0�(? Lvbocn.:> O') (")
----·--
• ,,CnoKoiicTeie... B'h nepciH oTKpOOTb PocciH 6oraThlii 1opr1> lie TOJJbKO n p11
6e per ax'b Mo pS1 Kacni AcK'aro, H o H BH y1p H n pe.neJtOBb nepcH.i.'lCl<HXb o!:SJ1ac1cO;
nocpeJtCl'BO�f'b CHXb n ocJieJlHHX1-, y.no60B03 MO)KHO 6)1.lleTb OTKp blT!, nyTb Bb Hlr•
11.iK> H npHBJte'lb K'b H a Mb 6ora1ei!UJi A Toprb ceA K paTqaJilIIH MH ' n )'TH M u, \IC Mb
TOTb, KOeMy c...1e.ay10Tb ace 11 apoabr eeponeiicKie, oo xo.!l H M htcJI1, JJ.o6pol1 Ha.n.em
� bf u •
• ..,Cic. .. )laCTb cnoco6b ua pcTey ceM y 6e31) uameA n0Mom11 He TOKMO npo-
. ..
TitBOCTQj{Tb nparaM'h XPHCTlaHCKOH Bepbl, HO It y.lla'IHbte n poH3801lHTb Hallo HHMH
llOHCKH, HCCb-Ma J.t,11 ff Hac'b noJJC'3Hble n pH CJl }rqae BOHH bl C'b TypKaMH. lJ pe3b no
cpe.!\CTBO par.npoc1pa11eR1torr TaKHM'b o6paJoM'h rpyJiH. 6onee y1aepi.11TcJ1 H 06e3 ..
ncttHTcst Haw a 1c,proe.nst c� Ilepcieii " ( I I. 366) .
�· LI.ns cero rp,T3ist .ltOJl}l{H a 6blTb... pacnpoc1paHrHa H }ree.n ll'leHa Bb c11.naxo
cao HX'b. flc, ·ece .n.JJ H pacnpocTpaHeHi H B'b AJiH pocciitcKoii . Toproe.tlH h ( 1 1 � 368 ) .
• • �, n pCJ.lt\f eTOMb BBe,!l.eHi 8 B'b nepci 10 BOHCK"b Be.,'lHKo.ii EK� TepHH bl 6blJIQ, HC'
C)"CTuoe .>K•.\,'l aHie no6e..llo, -H H pacn pocTpaHeHie n peJJ.e.1J 0Bo Si 6e3'h Toro o6m Hp·
uruUJeH Bu ceeTe ,H Mnep\11. 110 t1To6n noJt'b n pe.. 1.noroM'bHaKaJaHist Ara-MaroMet'h·
X aua :i a rpy:i iIO, rnasneA111c ocHoeaTb 1aep.lb1Mb oopaJoM'b co [lepcie10 11a1uy
1opr0BJI10".
105
�"0,8v6 �a. (')BnL . ,, 'O a0')\)3 �DLo 8o't,\)6o 3\)�M M&oL ava�oocin&�,, ()�(T)(T)
(oJao I I , 367} •.
M 'O Lo<:noL aoo�3A(")ovL D fa(')6(")C?�, M(T) a m-cJ 30600C'lOvv 8oLo 6v8 (?30-
cio tAt)b3,) (?v O (?'O a.)cio 8Doav 3u8(T)o�dJvMv3 (?[JOM (? u, 8vL ..)M�306', vMU
b\)JvM0>3J�("f'l<Jo vMU doM3v60L\) (? v d\)JoL Lobv6Mn �'Bo, abvAL, �M (?v
.�30�C?v· �a (')6 (") a t)M \)30L D 6(? MOM (? v, 0>3 00, ao�o , [JM[J JC1JLvu JO OUi
n33nL °'3�ciom 'O�rJMJO(pv (? v MM a 00�30L cnv30 LvJ vM<:n3QC1MLv31)6
'O<t>M'063D �O�M, 8v6 [JMOOL, cn 'O a uu 'O Ju (? MoLL, a uoM,u a a o6u (? 8MbJM
bnoD�L Lv'B'Ou(:;JOuL 8oJ8uMO,u. av6 8ll (? uLv�306u, ' MMa LuJoA<:n3oci(")L
a o cn0Li.)3u6 Lb3\loov 'BMMoL oho,o M�DrJ�O uO,l)L J,)ul) a (? oL JuMOO'()C10
l,¢ 8bD (?MM 6uvo�oL dDC?oo6o a(T)oO') b(T)30, \ M(T)8nciou M w L °' v t 0-
A0Luoo30L n6C?\) 8oo8v6ooo6u<:n (? u 8vLm\'.)6 oAmvC? vuo�3u6vo, (T)8'Bo.
t) a 61,)vo�·ao 013000 o.:>0M6o'B3ocio oou � 6(? v �MCZ30�o�3 6a6 �vMoo_b�ci-
60 ou6LvJn°'MJ�rio, olJo<:nooo, MM8Jci6ou 8'B(T)o�oo0Lu<:n30L 'r)f8MM
d3ob ez3uL60 0�300 6, MMoMMO 8u3-, Ou6M6o<J3ociooo O-::J�M6o (?v (? u30-
o,o. u833uMvC?3D aMvo61)30 JvM013J�MOoL Lu0JD°'JLM VuM8M8vC?oD6J�-
6 o '0 6(? v u a Mui aao ·aoL0�0�3 606. MwLnmoL 801u3MMOvL ov (? vV�3Doo
�() 3J M6(? v, M°M a va M�J 'O C1 J 1.)MO'>'O C1 Lu8bJ (?MM 6vvo�L LuO(?'r) a �M (?
LuJuM0>3J �<'lL 8o ez30Lu, �O (?C'.')C[3(:'0Lu (? u JMoL [JM01orJ�oooL 8do3�v (?
�uL013�o(?v1 (6yTKOB1>. MaTepiaJibl I I , 368-369) • • . \)Lo n3t, MM0(">� v
JuM003JC1MOuL �L ,, a C!JuM3Jcio" M�Locno, MM8o�oo Lu%oo8M 8v6o
<t3DLodo L�JuM<:n30 C:'(T)L Onci0Looo3 ol, l.J31,)MLnooL (T)a L uu JO 'JO bv(?[J O(? v!
Lu8bJ (? MC'fl 8mJ8 Dt?Do u 'OJ3D o,030 Lo o !J 600M o30 0<t>oo, 8o8(? o6vMJ
Mi(? u (? ll 00030�6010 a(T) a\)3u� 3u8uM t300 0L o�aMLu�o 6oo� v (? M�L ooL
a A�3.:,cio · [J MO>O aJMMJ<t>o (.)CZ3MM LuMo 6ooM oD oaooo J bv6JO(T)(? u<n ,
MM8 1 796 V· .6c:r,n8ooM·d o OJuO[JMo 6n I I 3vM (? uou3u�u . 6 (? OJo a ooML
08u39 vo�L M 'O LoooL tuMno oL 80103u MLuM (?u�L 01030L aoo03M M00Lv 3u6
ovt?u3 Moc:,o OMdu6oou a M't:J30 (? v �M3DC:)o3uM O L\)a bJ (?M(T) 8MJ8J (?JOOL
dD �JMDOo Lu (? v aooo�o ,,)MOO'> fJ M(J) M fJ LJ01dO (? vOM fJ 6000L dDLuboo
---·--
• ,, r.na11 He0wi A >Ke npe.ztM er1), pacnpocTpaHe Hie Topros nH ...
•• ,,,Ua6bl HMeTb B'h pyKaX'b CBOHX'b 33J101K HHK0B'b B'b BCpliOC TH u a p H r py3HH ..
.cKaro, .iKe,Hhl. ,neTCH ero H Jryl{lllHX"b JJJO,nefi Ha po�a cero, H·Y)KHO 6y!leTh npncoe
.nHHHT b H B3HTb ·K'b BOHCK aM"b H3111 H M'b... XOT:R }10 I · T,. 1:te.l'JOB eK'b OTOOp HblX'h r p)'-
311 H'b H rrpH HRX"b TCX'h H3'b CblHOB Cl{ u·a pHUhl. K1, I{()TOp blM'b OH a H3H60Jtec llpH
BSl33H a ) T. e . 1.t-11a IOnoH a, To>Kc 11 u..1,a IlasH1ta ".
1 06
al en c:- c, 3: -,c. ,a ,o, ,a . c, o -o a3 c1, fJ CY ,a a3 C ')' 9 c- ,a 9 3'- -,c. �
I
8, c, c':, 3- i» 3- � � � rt· t, 3- c, �
o � � 3 ,a c, 3-
�
cJ g..
�c!i, � i» � 9 ,a :::; :, 3 a.3 � 3 c,
·3,.. � :,
g·
c.:,
-
Q)
0> � 3'- � ;: g.. c.c O"l 9 a.. a.3 3-
c., c:- 9 :, '0 g 3 c.u O C, '">... ::a � � ,a �"' Q) 'g :) Q 0.) tT C, 8"' :> :> _:) l.,U .,...
3-- c, -· O' c..., <..w .;,- 9: u,- __, "' J 9 CM <J3 J c, C..,
o.>
c.:, �� � i» Cl O ,a c, r:- ts> 3 o '1 g -..a en ,a o - g, oi 8' oP fl � 3 :> :-
C, 3 C,
� 3- '1 ,a ::i 't' :) c,:,
a, � 3- ,a � - C" 3 a... <l'3 (', CJ: 07 C, :, c.,
3 0 C, 2: o, '1 (j ' � � 0.) c:- 3' . � c.., � ,a o3 <1'3 :, 3'-- � :, :, 07 c- � ..i:a.
c:- �
Q)
c.:, c..., 3 9 � c.:, 9 � a3 ,.., u '0 .s:, <:.:> => C ,a c, ,a 9 rf:. -
O' � • � � 07 a-- C.§ ' j c, :, .,::... 0). c, o;> ' i f] c, f] • c., �· c., . r...:, �
� c, c, en
::::; Cl er _- 8' C� go, c., � � f" g> � '1 c, Cl � l '3 3- S f r:- � ':""
Q)
c- c- � c:- ,g �
J
:, � c:- 3 � '1 � � C, 0
. C,
� "':-" C, F � 0 � � 3 ,.� c- C�,, .cJ: Q;)·
O>
9 S , j \N ., a, ,'":I C, o.:> � C, (, ,f:'" � C,
:> 3 a3 C, ,l""l:j tv O cn c.., c::- ra O O> tT c- c..., . � 1"' 't;l! :(1:)' ')' ,"!';
� :, u> o3 C- '">...
J. a3 :, C- 07 c, re: :,
, :I tt c- 0 ,,.,:S '0
o, ·-·9 .t.,
0, 3 � O"\ <:.:) C, · Q) (T\ o:>. C, a3 �
I =i :) 0, 9 ...,.,) Q 9
C, :> � C.'.:> � � �
,- C C.:, c- Q) C, c- C:, ra n :,
tT o , c, Cl C � o e' ... � c. 3 ,. m en u
l' '1 c.:, '1 3- r:- � C ,a sf� r:- � � '0 �3 g 13 C � C @ C :, cc 8' t.') - � .fl 'J
cg � Cl � '1 c:., � g; � c:., 5 9 & <13 c:., c.:, � c.. Cl � <>" ,g1] 'J ...,:T o C
c- ' :1 � c.., c:..: � o c, :> en -,..,. 9 ,a c- � :, � o" c-
9 � 3-- o fl c, o a> !:i <:'"' c-
� a> c.:, C- c 0 o3 c..., c, C.. c.:, c, ,a .;,- & c.:> w :,
3- 4¼ lcJ ·2 S 9��� 3- C 11
:,
� cg ?"' 3- '] 3- o; 7i ? �
Q)
Q.) � � � c.:, c:- . 0 :> ... c- cc
� J � ? °i. � 3
c.c Cl � c- 9 � :, o, :. ,; 3' 0
'
0 · .
C':'
.:._, �-
,
c
{j J1 a., Q.) C, � ,a .,.
9. � � ,..
� � J'c3 !' .. ,a C:- Q) g! �
� 3 0 J :
9 ,a
...
-
I
'">... o c,
.;,- 07 )" 9
en -
:>
' c, ....... .., _, S -- """"' 3 � � c, c, .,..,.
"'" Cl.. ,a C>, Q) • <J3 .;,-
3 1..::, ��(, • f,' c..., �-
3 c..., ,a C1• en ,a O
/3 g_ c.:, � 3 c:,, .....
c.., .....a c:-
g.. ,.
'-1
� 3-- o>
Sc
c, cf 'g �" 3 �
c, en ,o g, g_
tT
� !' c.:, r:- f" ,a' tl
c-
f1 3
3 .,..,. Q.) c.:, & g, � 13 C,
c, "'Xf )
,a 07 g.. ra � C &� • :: " '" 3
� 3-
a 07 c, � ()7
:r � c<:. 9 3- ::r. 3" '1 &
c, � - 3- :, er CU c, c,
� Q)
f3 C.:, � t,
fJ
J :,
C.C
•
� C-
'l C� •,
C�,
5
3°- c, {] � 3°- ,a ,a � )"
g_ 13 � o>C, 9 :, <13
. • :J'- "'7 C,
"""" C, 0 3 tv ,a
c.:,
9 cg C- c.., 3 0> c..:>
11 C, 3 3 C,
J..R � 3- � (}; c.:, g 9:> c':, g, ,f c., w a3 � � � � � c� r] � 8 "� t>, �
3
8
3- " J' 3- J' 3 . � r�� 2'
cg � � � O> O"l � 0, I] 3 9 .:=: er� � cC::, � :, 0 g, 3 �t � :> 9 , ;.),· \...>
()JP
c:C:> '1 ,'":I Cl c.:, r:- c:- = r:-
c a ra s c,:, g g._ � g, R t; ' " 3- - '1 s � � � 2':
Q.S
0C,
0 en ,a' �
tT "'>,.,. (Mt C, C, c-
()7
0 3 C, C, ()JP c.c Q) tT ,-:a O Q) c.:, C1 c.:, o>
c., - c.., C, c.., g C, c.:, , :I .._, c::- � '< O' C,
tT c.:, J - 0 Q) :, <J'3 • ..�
,a C, C, g.. ,a g, g � r:- 3 . C, C, -i r:- 0, C, ,a 3- Cl c.. 9 0 3'- ., u:
3- 3- ,a
w e.:, a3 " " er " s - c,., g, 3- g- r ,, � e1 " 'J l"
s- c.,�� � 9 "r:- :> � ,a 3 3- Cl a, er 3,- r:- 3 8' c, r:- 3- r:- � en 3 c,
tT o,, o . ,1
a., c, � tT
3-- 3-- c:,3 9 Q) c,
9 C rr � ,a � 07 3 07 'r.a� c, :, �-D:., Q) ,-a
c, 0 ' CJ1 3-- :> • 3'- u
c, :, g
I
c:- & � '< � , g c.:, a> f1 :, t, J'c3 3 ol' � C- t & :> "
Cs, ....._
cn C.. o c, C:>,
I
: 6'1j�.), A<'m\Jo a.)L n6(!) M3mnL a (!)O ��t"n 3�aM MOnL bo�cao �•)a�!JOOL
11S·n�o JJM6��. O)'O oL 3Mb�:J?M(I?�, a�:an6 'OJ30 l,�d""anAonM t>60n�a
l,o�o MJ"�M oOoa "L v\)M8M"a3\)a�o6, �Mao�ou op�Ma<»oL �\)3::,hM
onl> a\)a\)a�Mcn�nooc::1 L�O'C) (J)\){P 3\)a(W)�oOOM(!>\). a\)�1,,�a MOLooL au 8bM..
��·� '3MM:J'e)�, 8M8 bno�.)3 8M8.)3.)�\)� nb�ono(')�i)O). a.)o,· bl)�b�M
•
th :�� tt�
�ooe,�1i� nQnoMa, MM8 8oLo aoaano;oL l,03Muo �\) Uf\-ob33 M�6�3��u
D �Mq>.:> n a�«'>Mo6l? D c:'" M�l,pmoL DJM liMa ('l�A d.:,�.:,l, . l?�
M t] O "� ��� oMoOo c:in V��M3 �0 �\) a��803n �0<')�3 \) cn\)3ol> ��t:'J-:
1 o',.8,
•
,,
�oL�(?a<">. �M�, M -oLomn L�B,)�0')3D C"ML oLn '0� rJMQ�(?v, MMcMMO J�McL
OvMv�L, MM8DC'0U Lvj OMMnooLu8ooM �ood�ooM�v ara30 603Mv(? cu
a('1')Dt1D6ooo6� 0>v3 0L LuLv<4> 300�('1')(? • oL �iMo m3om M 'C)LomoL 8cn,)3MM
OvL � uJ3L 0060J0MO, o'nc-'�b(? O�MOOO) cvaMm3 8-rJC70 oMuf80 6� 3o6o6n\J
r
Jr>MOO') o Mo,L Uu0(?wa e M 8 ovoMo�('l')0u do, MM8 DC'OO 8 v 6 LvboC'ad�3.,) --
1
60(:'M(? L�D\lM0'>30 C'Md0 8ttM<z3L M'rJ L o moL v�MaMa�� cn 6n�L on6oM� c:>
6M6 �ooo 6t ou8M'O otv3 6.) : n-6 C?v OOv (? Mffi Li=>38o LvJi=>M m3o� Mcao oL n
0(')\)VtJMOO, MM8 tj3DC'"'80�l0 �3060 ,,bo�8dc:,3v6o�MOOO") b (? D O(")�nL '',
013()0') d�Mcn3n �rioL JO oLn :JoM6Moo, 3omM8u ()Lo6o 0>u3ou60, a0'>�3MM-
ooL O u6JuMo 'O C'O o�L vL �D(:'D0 c.? D 6, 0030m 8mv3MMOvU . ��Mv8 'D 6n 0-r) C't1
o::,ML, 0,()0,JML t13 D �v � DMO aoLr) L�M30(TOL6 �0 6oooL 0')\)6vb8u(? b C? o -
OM(?Ot,, OMCOO Lo6�3001, � M3 0�0, �30 60 vu (? O�O &v6bMM 0() 0��oL ,
803Mv8 oa 6voM �(? JO, MMa ,, L 'r.) �O ..:>J,:>-cJMO (o . o. <4> -o LD C"O) ()�ML, L bo-
0C'>() JO jvM O>'J�n h -M *. au1J�L v(?v8o M-rJLom(")L 8mi:>3MMOvL '06 (?M � u
MM8 J uMm3o c:1000 0LD�M O �Mu�03()(Y) 3�aMotJ060006� mv3<)L JM�0-
60J �M o 8ot 6oo nLv �� t� �b3000L 8oL �C!?VD3 t:>C? ·
80cJo6�oQ:>O JvMOl30 �MOv J�M3u bv6L va, ovMQ8(1).[)0vL 3DM v8fl6n3�u
(? v o'O�V M � :J� � C? �vAvaD6oo -rJ�O OtjM, MM8 M-OUO'> u b3�avoez3DL �u
3mv3MMOuL L\)JuMm3o�M L0030L a�MO'> C"�O c () �O �0L6J03M(?v (? v a oL
8v t; b�M0 0u mv3<)L avDb�M [) Ov(? 8ovh6�u.. u803uMO 0 �60Lu%(!:3MDC'O �u
�v-cJdM060C'O MDLnooLu<,?80 6 (? M0u o8utn . 0�('1') (?�8 tj vMoo-o�o , MM8
Lv.� uMm3o ��L o8 (?M M06c.? o �o 86MQOO L3uMLom-ML8�C"OO'>O au!8� (? .0··
u5000 0�3 606, M�Loa>n JO, 300,vMO¢ .3�m30(:'0'>u oAm8MMV8 -rJ 6o Lv
bo i)dV (><l3 M, mv3ou6m 006 1JOM<>3 8MJv3cloM [) � 8ov�6 (? ,)0'>.
JuMm30� 00L dMM om 0u6 ' 0 00 M6o � o JJM6 ��o, M�L 01� 8 b�M3 1) �3 '
L;Mva �G('f).o(.)M03<> c,Md6("t) Ou (?u 0330 \)M ao�(? O OM��o,, M('1')a ?,�Lo a>o
jl'.>�0'> 30C"O>v L 'D e7 0L J3D°' oo�L \)(?3-0� v(? o�OoO O(?� (? v 8t:>mL mv3ov6v o
M 'r) C"L oMdMC'v�O L3�MLomoL� (? v ML 8ve'omoL vo6v��a{!)D O VM CB D�oL
<
�- .-......-
• 'nrnasneiiw aR H YlKJla, 11T0<5b fpy3HHbl HaM'b B'b eoAue nOMOr·aJIH TIKHM'b
()Opa30t.i'b,' 1ito6·b... MHHJIH McnOJIH 11Tb noBeJteHiSl CBOHX'b BJt a}leTeJJeA, a CiH p ae
H blMb o6p a30Mb OKa31iBaeMylO HaM'h ycnyry CBOeMy ycepAiIO co<5CTBeHHOMY no-
6y ,KA_eHi lO. npo_1IHTaTb, no B'b caMOM'b }leJle ace TO npOH380JlHJIOCb 3,J.leWHHM'b py
l,()B0.:lCTBO�tb H npoceemeHieM, - KOPOTKO CKa3aTb� <5h1Jta 6bl ,n,ywa 3}letUHffff,
rt T(\ilO rp)13HHCKOe" { J�(Y't�. ()�. Oilo->MO<':'oli rpaMOTbl etc (, 1 55-1 56).
Mu Lnm nL 80,u3 MM OoL � 0 � M ('.;'.'C'>6C'>J ML D Ol, oM O08(")3:3�3000, j oM o, -
, 3 D �o, u u8 03 oM O .3 (") � 06 0d'(J Mo O ';'.') e' uOM ::J 3 0 ('.;'.'M O u. a enD ('.;'.'O a 00') 0 .3M ('.;'.' (')-
60 J O li0Jot'>cn3o� (") L 808.;,Mcn, MM C!) o Luo JO Mu Ln m o L Lu8 bo�M M cn3ue>
L .:i 'bM o G ocn J .:i M cn aoe>cnu d o e>oL ou8 M�.lD 6n 0 u ·('l")L,a 0e'D 0'l<'L, 06 L.3 oMlino, o L
Vo 6uo(!' a (?D O Lo3o6(")� 8 oo � 6�vo, , LVMMD � J uM o,3D e'°'.:, .:i8 L 'C LO
aMd 6MOu'ho �o O�e>uOM ::i 3oc:::' M2'0°cin 01:J M b M ('.;'.' a D �u81:1 .:iM oOu ('.;'.'0- . ,, J oM
3D � o 0l, 8br:J M 3 .:i c:io l,uMV8 u6 M o OM 03 0 oMd6 M 0o 0J 30, �.:, o8u'bo,) �o-
°'
8 M JO (!lQ O 'C)c:::' O 8vo,o oue>8 M �oo 60 MO.;, l,fl'J ('.;'.'OO(!l M ';'.') l,:J o,o l, JU M o Lu(!>8o
�.:, Jo cn0 1::'.'8 ML 0M6a MOu. M wL b oc:::'boLu�3o"- M *, ul,D u8 0M0 � 6o6 M'c:J UD
O'>oL 8m or1MM 00L V\)MaMal)C!>oo 6o � 6o , - � u u8 J �Moo 3 [)�0?0 8 b r1 M3 0�0
W 0MV8 'C6<')D 2>M o 3o oM d 6M0 oL l, fcl u o c:::'aOo m o� o �M 0� :J 6 (? O obn Mbo0-
�n 6 J O C?no JuMo,3o�nOo l, 08::i �u� 3 MtU� (")3o O.:i L, M M 8 M-o Lno, oL .3M
� O� OJ� &1 0 ao<t>6oool, &o6uobMM o o D C:-)D � c:' 0 (? o o 8MD tt D 6n � o 6voo .
M Mo o Mu l, oa, ol,0')3ol, Wo30M M 0 ::J M , 8000 6 8 o l, ,)oMli (!) oO M�u , M Ma
J uMcn3a�. ) �>O 8 bw M3 o �n J 6ol,o oo6o 0o 01:13 60 6 � o 8o38ue? oo li d\':'.:' OD Mo
l, .:ibn c:i8V O � MD OoL 8d� o3 MM Ool,.:, oo 6 '(JJO � uMo Lo C? a D 3 M M300 -o � 60 (')v
01:J J 6n 6. u a �M (") l, , o l, 3o mM8 0�0 J 0 00?8 M 1:1 30M o M O o L c,M d 6M 0o m �Lu3-
U n .:,<', � 80 60 0 <,? U L.:iJ uMa,3De> M L , M Ma a u C?o a a ,o L (!)Ub8u Mo 0 o'bo M o 6n-
0 M0t � .:, 8o l, m3ol, 'bM ';'.') 6 .:i3L . .:iLo 0::J M b M i:'.' 80 Lo6.:ia LoJ uM o,3 .'.) �M L u/,,,
cln o o�n 6 � u � u m.:i3 0 L Lo 8bn � MM 000801,�u 8 o bo�300, M L8u�oo,mu 6 u6
L .3.:iMGo rocn.:i 6 M 80 o , M M 8n �Wuo 0 30 ou 6o 'b M ubu3�u, ol,,, � uMD3(?U. 8 .:i o M.:i a
Mo V.:i8l, Mu l, o o, L ci> o3oli o .3oMo�o . 8o'bu6(') ao'Cl i:::iv'nu c:::'u� 8 o u� 6�u, u li
M 8 ol, oooM d o � :J O ul, o,u3 o l, o,3 o l, bo �l,u::J MD �.:,I:? .:ii;::, uMu L o,3 c:::' o �.'.>, oL
l, uJ 0 M oo3o �M l, '(:11:J M::J 8 u6 M (? 8 0 .:>6 M300�u b(") c:::'a o (? O a o'"8 0 6 8 .:, L, tl 3 D �
.:,
<B oM o 03 0Vt, � J OM (? .:> , Q .:iM cna D «:'°'.:, JhoL6o .:>6M0 oo C?O &0J oM 30 0 uo .
vGn cn � cJ 0 80,b3a 3n ocJo oL r, al'.>°6D O JO 0(!: uM <B O� M(T)�Q_) I), MM8 l,�3 0M 0')3n -
. � M 1,v'MM o� 8ol, v�u «:'M O oo,.:, (? O aoG a Ma ao�o O(')o, y' o li.:i 6C?D «:'tn ';'.')(8-
MM 'C) l.')M QULI) (?I) 'CJa VO M a�o (Y)doMD MO�d () 3 0M� D �M�� bM�a o .
e�MD &6\:1 t::0 Q) MuGocnoL 80003M MOv 3 ()O')C,,a o Lv r.:J b�� MM8 L \l j'-'>MO'> -
------
• " Te nJi oT·a BCPbl Bb fpy31f H U 8 X'b BCJIH K. 3 R " 83· 7, " OJJ,HH a K OBOe Hcnoae;i_aHle
. ..
0(' p bI Cb rocnO l(CTB YIDute H Jl{eCb npoHC XOllRIJ lee 0Tb Toro Bb RHX'b K O ecepo cc1u-
Cl(OMY HMnepaTopcK oMy ABopy �'cepAie H .uo6poa<eJia TeJibC1·eo f<b PoccilicKOMy
�• n po�y. Hal(C}l{.Lla ... JI )'TMist noJi y q11Tb ycnex H ". ( P a3cy»<;ieHie o cnoco6ax'h, Ka-
K H !\!fI rp�'3HH Ubl npel<JIOlle Hbl 6b1Th M 9iyTb Kb BOCnpiHTiIO yqacTiff Cb nopTOIO
0 'fTO:\t UOli1He . .) M(T)qJ, s) ci, u,)�,.:iM:) �O f J) 3 M OTl:.1 !, o3· 7 (? ,'> 6).
11 0 ,
,3D �M JM �0 60J'r)M�� ��L -oG6n �� �o L�bn �8vnez3M OtlM � � (])O(])QMU
O(?O�MO Q) v, MM8 , 8 oL o Lva �Q(?MM d�nn&>no� &v'bM�O�Otj M �v LvDMO'>�
'aMMOUM 8�3M8vMQMOu o�a6JOOQO 't.J �Ot,M. M'rJLo'cnou Lv3uMDM LvJ 8no,�
L0806nL6MM 8v&., O'>v3 0L v\�Ma Mau QJ&o 6o �u u�a �Mm3[J �Mqo JM3��n 6-
LJ0L uvnM �v, MM8 8vL Lvj!)M003Q �MU 8D<[30Llv0">3ou DM�O\) 8 '0 �8 030
cuclJvMO �vDvMUQOo6v �v bn oMou6o \)M60�QMO� 'BnnJ 86v, MM8 �a
i3vMvQ) aQtBDU Lvd'tj v�QOv JJM 6M �� Lv30MMD00Uv8QOM 3v6vMv u �a-
bn�MM d��OO")vo L3v�>LO')v aA�3v�MnobM3v6n, O,v3tn boc:,iv�no'rJ �O .
OM2>MD 00Uv0,3 0L vo6�ue:8�DoMOv &vnvou. u8 U.:>J O OU a�6Lvb MMOOD�no
�v(? �'C)UQO'>OL bo �8vo<nn Lv3 vM0'>3, Q �ML 8n<BnL 6ao_vU ud�n3i!v u�
J vMm3n �Melo �v6o'd6u�O OQ o[)MO'>v JM�JOL 'r) <[3MMUO (?� M([300MD00
bn �8d�3v6D �v(? &v8 MQtjD 6ooo5u (11HCTpyK. I1 HOCT p . KoJIJieri1-1 Ko
saJieHCKOM3/, AKAfK. I . o3· 95, § 1 1). 8u3Mu8 nu 1 799 vn�u ovn
MQOM�v, MM�oLv o 0d 3D Lvt1 vM0'>3 [) �MU �va<'1't:JJO�:)O�MOOL on�o
m3om M0Lmv3 0 v� v�MOOO'> ' O')�vVtJ3D60�0 o::,.rt),, ol,n MM8 v8 M�Q3vL
a �]o6 vC:vMv300'>vMO 8 6ocJ3b[) �MOv vM 3JM6�\).
3v6L\)J'r.)O'>MQOOO'> Lv� -OMv��t)OM J o LvMMQ Q) OU a�MQ8MQ0vv, MMa
°'3 00') L vj vM0'>3D �MU 8mv3MMOv a 'l:) �ua o�o �MO�u QJuvO 6vrJM[J OrJ � 0
l,v8bn�MM 6o b6oJv �\) 8n6��MD tvMOv°66nooli . �v8 Mubav-8Mb 8vMnov
clonLvv3 �v, bM�M M�LnoooL 8cnv3MMOu O�'Oav�v� tjM3D� �M6nudo
-rJ�vL b8vMMO�v, MM8 UvJ vM0'>3Q�MU 0')\)30L DU vv�O�O 3DM 3v6obMM-
oonc:'D00bv. oLn MM8 O') � L�jvMa>3 [J �MU an- XVI I I L.-oL C!)vLvLM 't:) �L,
MM(?QLvo M 'OunmoL 80,v3MM00L °6n8M8Mtj3v60�0 M�D3� OtjM 'Bn �an 6o
�o, �nLv<t3QMOUO \)M6o �nMov vM no���, �avdO �ao,�3MnL v(? 01300,
MuLJO'>OU 80,v3MMOO� V vM8 Ma\)�an6�ooL rJdo3cn OM��o-
L1.)J vM0'>3Q �M dO d v� �nv6 J�Mav� n L8M�vO'> J�Mo �&>Oo�aMooU
'C)v�hn L'o 8 6o'd36Q �MO\) J3DtJ 6ou &vM[JdD 80M0L3v6 ��M�63n �tiM(80-
l,vm3ou � v uvMMQ� �a n6Mcb o vMoL MM8 QM[J J�D aDCZ3D u�� oaoL
u�v�O OtJM, MM8 30L&v68n °6 uMOv°66oooL &vJ[)OODOv �v b8�M [] Ov 'dnnL -
'tjv3 �v.
8v6 oL�MoQO�� JO�DO 'dn 80,b3n3 �0, MMa MrJLO'>\) ivM11o, MM8o �oo
a�...
(T)La���i) �o6u.ue:,a t? D& Lv�MdM�3D ��� a\)'Bo 6 LJ\)J \)M(])3D�M�O O � M
8M.0°6u3 60�0, vM6oe'nMnoG LvJ a oL .aOM�6n 3o�noo 3vM0'>3t)�QOO ot,3-
60 6 �v avO, 8o J3vM01v, MM8 o,�30Lo �ncpoL b6o� 6v03Mv vnLM-o t:'n oo-
6v. vM6 o�o Moo� JM�JM�JM3 6oJL � M �ytJv'a3o�L �v o,�3v� O')�Mbv6-
•
111
8M'C)Mv3l, L o�uM'r)�001 �JoL<4,o�o, oL G\)'1 80. nl>ob() °'0M3o QM :J JC'O
a::,caaL 'h�MOv°66nonL aMMOn�no(")L ct,v J-:,'t:)-OOOQO()L 3vJ[J Ol000Lv �v
�"'(?c1JB.vL�Lv v3�o (?Jb,
8c,,.n�M�6o�v� vaoL 3v8M amo�o ur,M'b\)-oAo v6t,C?�· 01'0aol)_ dv-
1106 ' nL juM013o�noL D'0o6v'OMl)OJ, a�oh� a M rJ Lamou · 1vMoL 'O<l}MMLav
0M6�ooab8v hMd oL &�&>08("):JOv �DO�tj(T'l, av'B..,630 � M���vcJ3n�Lvov
�v O'>v�b.)6'.. a M�Mv3L�o LvU60Jv� vTIJ�d\)t:v, 4,Ma .. 8voo a DCBD D {ry DJ
�a u013 nl, Lv\lM6o�DMOM bn �M 3 6J o � D���at:>n oob-:,0>.
va M�L jvM_m3o�L vMOo�aMnu. o L, <4,MoMMO � �:,6L, 6M��non 6o l.J
½
v833v< c, oMdvOJOv · oJvbM6M(!) 3ov � 6�v0') Q_)v · D ���Ov o��Vh 'lJtJ(:: v�
(!)vMyd�bJO��o O.tj 36nb, �Ma M 'QLo o->0Lv0>30Lvo hn�LJtj� [J �() n6tt: v
t,M'l)��OtJM, °'0 J O Lvjv�)0>3[J�ML aDCBfJL, 300>vMov &,nL�cnoL DMm-
0TI�'-> 8MJv3 Q()MOL �� aou a�\lM3DC;(Y')0o G 3 3 D d [) 8 ::, (Y,caL, U\l8boC?�(Tl L�3-
an JvMovC? cl0Gvv3�0�0 aJa6ooM�v. -:,dn6Ma Mho3 J 6n olio3 6<BO C'.::'<il•
clo (?vMF> 6o 6 C?� vo6v6�nc'CJMv(? oADJ�D ao�oL vLvu3�nt?D 6. 8 v'Bo6
?
�.)v
0 M6 CJO[J6a� cnaoo&13,:,�l, 1 770 VD �l, M 'L') U:) O">OL' acn,;>3MMOvU <l]M,)b
o�� l)C? [JMO�{) L.)<">(?'0a�M a{Y\bLob[J Ov au�ot u3 5�, �MaJ�do�u
v0�M006[JO(?v, &)Md �MC'v�ora3oc:'() (?v 01�Mbu 6-3M'tj�v3n O MDJ�D 8n-.
ca o L tvMOvt6oooL �va('Y')L�avL.) �v �v(.?38vL vlJv!)3�ovbM. cn'na(Ji> b.:>j \)h-
°'3D�M L aD<?JD, L vOM{?.) 0Mo�non6o 3c.n.)3MMOvL, MJLna,oL bn t�� v n
<B oL 8'lJ�M3Dc:>MooL J3D'a �MoL, av0M�a M rJ LooooL n66D�Junc c:, Lvm3o.G
L -?L,�c<,3Dc:"'O vfrJvv, LvJv�°'3D�Md(') � 'O Locno L h� �avo'8oL l>v�o\)t6noL
3vM(?� l,b3olJo 30Loan ti:>MCvt6o oo Otj (Y)LM. �aoc_;Ma 6('t)0�'80Db(") ao,,:,3-
M (Y).OvL LmhM3��, hMa u3D �I) jvhm3o�n M<lJOOMfJOO �,) 0')1)3,)�0 f'J),)(v'}-.
bv6-8 M'J&>,)3(') LvJv�0'>3DC:MO>l,v 6 <iL[) 3 M�L[J O> dO Vv[J � 3v6vm
ob. A. UarapeJI H . fpa MOTbl I , 20t 'd [J (? • 1 98----- 199)•.
<v o�o�o
• ,, f .•M. rpaqi0' ToT.neoeH'b oT·b 6 <Peep. 1 770 ro�a npe:'lCTaBJISl . .rtbc10,aa, r1To
aptt-J.,'IJiepiAcKiA 00Jlfl0JIK0BHHK� llOJIOKaeB� H e Ct.fOTpH Ha op.. 1eHI>l ero. rpa<f>a
ToTJie6eH8t ocTaeTC.R Bl> ·THq>JIHCe C'b H. c. KH. MoypaBOBb1Ml>t noKa3b1Ba.R llapJO
HpaK:JliJO .ne..1aT1:. MOpT11pbi 11 ray61111.u -•1 cTaBHTb nywKH ·Ha .'l acperbl; a no MHeHilO
ero, rpaq>a Torne6eaa, xorsr u-apb ·H KiH H3bH ero i, ecTyn 11.;1 n Bo npoTeKU.iJO C}I
11. B., o;J..u aKO>K'b JJ.Jla BwcoqaAWJfX'l-, HHTepccOB'b npe"1.oc;r,.1 1rTe..'TbftO, LITOC>'b Bo
fp}r3iH t>blJJH nyWKH KpOMe np·HHaJJ,..'le>KaIUHX'b CH H. 8., H T8K'b npOCJf.;l 'b OH'b 96'h
OT03BaHiH HaJ·a)l'l-.. ' B CeX'b Oq>HuepOB'b rpy3HHCKOH HaUiH H KHR3A Moypanona"
(A. U arapeJJH. . rpaMoTbl etc I, 1 98-1 99, <n�1o16anc-:'� a('l"\�Ls36'JoJ �(')O�n�36° 1J�
na�3D L.:,2,60G '<lnLvhn� odan, I, 205).
112
•
JvMm3ocn M'lJO(JMQ&o 0,\)30L ava'O �o'B3n � 'O MO c, Md6M&oL\) (? v
3(")�000J�Mn LoooooL\)o,30L LvLOOJ\)(? (? v0L\)i 6o 6. od 'O �o&ocn M 'O ·
1'oo>'13o V \) tj 3\)60�60 (? O t?\)3\)0o8MQ0 '0 �6o Lv3 8oL 3v8Mdoo ouL 0 UC? O
�a6, L\)6v8 a',)O)O '0 (? \)6\)'BIJ� �MOv t13D�\)L1Jcn30L obv (? O vM 'Boo386v.
ua L',)o�'0a e' M 8 MbL06o on0>3v6 ob\)�\)� L�\)6L, MMa M0Lo cnoL aoo',)3-
c<,MooL�3 0L Lv<t>M&',)C? M (? LvJ \)Moo3n�C'>L c,·)d�oo<4>oov LArJ�ooocn�o
t,�oMM vM (")� M. LvJvMcn3o � M oLoo, 8 (?c, M8�M [J MO�'ao r.Jb(? � tJ MCBOc:'O
tjM, MM8 M'C)UQO>nL (? ��b8vMQO�o3 8vL o,�30Lo 0>v30L (? OU3'-'> vM 'aoLd
�rJOM (? v (? v a'O��
8bC"l�M(? M�Lno,oL 'ao 8v3Q (? Mnon�n (? v bo�'ao
'30 a�0<4>0 jMC?J0�0tJf?· *
8\)'a\)L��\)ao tJM3:J�m30L oGo O b("l bMc:'ao , MM8 M�Loooo L " �\)b8vMQ
OvD'' (? �L�v�<iL'ao o�o o 6'0�\)Q1 LL)J30�6M (? (? O� O Lvbo�o (? '-'> Mobo
JJ M.6(? \) , "a o C?D oO-JO a �(? ,!a L �'a o 6o� o (? v (? v8e1:'033 n � o OtjM � 3n 60 l�
. o�Mv, 86MQOOO, 'ao8MM0::,84D �O J 3o tJ 60L\) (? v 0M0Lvoo30L.
M�LncnoL '0Jr;MM01) (?v L0J0M0>3Q �ML 'O aV[l M (? 8oOM3[) 0v 86<4>no
o,�6 OMdMc:'oG �,{1F1L �3� bt; J 30 �v6�L 8wM6M ,U vQMO>�'aMMOUM t?�aMJO..
C?DO��nowL-Jn vM �<Bti3oo t? \), 8vh6M 8oL ovMQdO ao<4>ooL jO vM �cn�-
8v8ooC?.:), �M\)80 (? 'ao6.:>0M obM3MQOildO(J vMQ3•(? vMn3\)Lu (? IJ Lb3v (? .:>Lb3v
3<"'l�nOoJ�M (? .:>Lmu 'aMMOU OMdM�bL �av3\)3QO (? v, "aocnoL� (? \) 80,v3MM-
00L 3�0o3f)Loo80Lv (? ll �'?J�o ooL 3\)J vMVtJ �oo�L bv�boL o,3v�·�o bo·�L
'0 VjMO (? v- 00 3c<i60 bo C? �3C?6o6, MMa 8cn\)3<41MOOU 8cno�o JM�06'0J',) Lv
J\)MC1>3Q C'ML 00D(?�MJOOU 8o6L vM�L 'O at\)�oo�v (?� i:;8oL 3,.)a(T), L3\)�..
LQO>O')\)b (? \) Ml>8v�:)0>00',)6 cloo,v6b8oooL 8<"8bc4,o 60 (? � '0 6 (? MO�.:Y(? QOMdM..
C? D6 08 VMoo oL, MM8o�6o·o M'O Lno,oL 8 cn \)MJD �MOOLt) (? O 8MJv3'ao<4>o
MOoL 8M8bc4,o 60 (? v af')0')\)30 60 ot,360 6. 0 L 'ao6�n Mo �o,�6b8Mno� (? v
Jo'a3MOu doAL 0mbMO (? \) nLo Q">vO Q)',)r]UM0 �0 00�0 M8o ooLu Q"> \) ao<4>o
ooL rao8ML030L;)3v6 (?�L�Looo0�L Lvbo �avncn(Y)L.
[J MDJ� D ao ca o (!:hauQ") 8Mb0ooon� o aM'[JL30 6',)M obM3M·[) OOL',) (? ',)
0') \)3 t?� D bo� � 1tJ Ot) (?�M[) OO U \)a �6 t? \)\)3 � (? D o��o or:J �OL OJOJ O C!:' 00') 'B n J
ttr.JM·O O(? \), MMc,·MM 063MDM-(? \) oL 3M�000J 'O MO (? \) L�abo (? MM Lod�o
O�D, J Mb[)OM<i3<"' JDO>O�(? �[) MO',)(j, MM8o�ou 8nL 8v8oL o,oo8�M',)<t>
��·,__..,
• . . ... . . . , ::
X a, � 3 n.
L�a o <n('t') o �b oto l)l,�� l, aoMM 30 a aCB oL vMO al)anu 6030 �\) •
3nM .)(!>�
Lo33n�n !jM6 (!> \), �Mo l,�oaoLM o�3 C'o6� aMOJM3 !)0M6.:) b\)�b'Bo, MMd
•
�M M l>33 3 MD0D �M000')\) �.) LQ<n/t,o,bo �no, L�3 \)MO'J3o�M L, �8'a3 O�MOML
01)8 Mt)tj 3�6�. 3n�nJoa, 'ao6��M n 'OVDL M-o.:> o \)d� no M(?\) • • M O OO 80t<i oo�
, av
'r)'l3M M 0�(1).)a� a� o 6, on�v"' ...
'!l o�o ao3MO�� �o c,Md6Mcfm � �� 0\)63 -l
M M Jo cnnea MU t) MO:) �Oc,a, o�au33�e�e o d cr, oMo 8M.j l)3anMnu a <n\)M-
30�M0 .) �� �.:>t>a.)M 0 o.)-J n �1,,\) �'1\)6�.:,.
t)UOCD &�t<inaMno�cJn ,atj �1.cz3l, o('M�o(') 8 ncn�L, M :�JL 00,r.l, a bM 03 dJD c::'� l,
1
0 80�0 .)�\)� \") -1JM6�.) �\) �anu o\)a (\"). a�6 3�.:,l>V�3"0" (?l)Mn�o l, J�<'> o
� 1)DJ30 � � v u \)ab<'>omn lJ l)Jn 6 3%.> A�L, oonl,�m3nL l,.:xa'O�l)a(")� �·.:>n b'a�.
a�.l, 33M61), M�a ol,03 M l.Jaa�[l0')0>\)6
• 3(")�()0 0J r)MO '00 01"6bcJJo� Ql� a nl>o
•
� � 0 � ,a C f] 3
3' � OJ _ - 3 0 � � � '2 CL 3 C, .g 3""' '°
J. g �
J� T1 c:;-
3 ,a
0 C- c, J- c, C CY Q.) - · a3 ,-:a 3'
· r,,,_,_ c, -�- ' j (3 __... c, ,.-:,
c, c- '-?' ,,::, Q) c, en c, c..... o <I3 c, o f1
a3 c- Q.)
9 c...> c;,
t:t d
•
'O c.S CT 3' c, c- c, c.c Q) ,a 3' Q) 3' c, Q) C,.J �
� w E. �3 ,rl j , c- o ' :S C>'
c.....
c": Q) v· :>
O"'\ c,., 3 9-3 c, c, D � cl 9
C.J .- r'l Q) 3 OJ c,, C,.J 3 3 c, Cl g_ o
C,
c.:, � c.:, ]' c, CJ
C,
, 0 c- 3' LJ c, a3 CY __... O:> or- o c Q) v,.
� c...:> c:
s n 3' ""'-l c:- s � 3 Cj c.....
C,
1
c, o a:, c...:> �
c..:> c..:> c.:, 8 <13 - &, c'., CY c- 3"" 3 en
3
c- (} or- , :t 9 '° C o, ,a
91
�l
�. ,
c-
i/,,n
OJ
M
nd
I 'I
nL
�D
·��
�3
·t'x,,3
no
l)j
3D
\)(J)
o
''BO
a�
QO>
M
n�
ol,I
630
Mr:n
M0 1
:M¢1
�M
Ii]�
c.:, n c- n c.:, c- c,
o c- C.J c- o c� o c,- CY cu
� __... c,
, j �3 � c;, o 'j o, n 3' C c, o> 01 � e> 9 e,., u :> .!J ,a
c..:>
� c, (] Q) 3' c.:,
C: t..) a, O O ' j ,a C, � r':1 � aP C.J � �
c..:> C ,a Cl c,
c- ()' � c-
3 OJ <:..')
3 ,;.... ,a
CY 9 3 9 3 n CY , ' ,o c,
c.:, a, c.,.., ..,- CY
Q)
a.> J- , '° n c, o
C, C,
0' C, c.,.., O c-
C)l
C.J
a, c.-: Ct C,
c- w C..J
D ,a �,
,J O �
c...:>:t 0'1 c c;, ...,_
c- . (...) , :t
CT
Q) c,> a... c..
C..J
d 3'
3 c, c- O Q) Q) Q afl c., C.J C-
r'l r <Ii. C- � 9 C- c, (Y v - c,_ c, a, 3 � 0 L:> � r"l c...:>
\,,.,,JI
'0 CL O a] c..:> g 9 O n
3' ' j J"- • C- U o3 c..:> Q) ' j ' :t
c.§
(I C.J 0> c, en
(j c- O c.:,
�" � � "°' g· � � g-' cf t:; cP 'l 2- � � c- d
3- 'l � ::: 9 � �
<I3 c- CY
�
c a...
(]
L.J
g>c- Cj� c, �= 1!8 3- �3- cgs c, c,. ... Q)
c- c, fl 8 � � c- , 8J c] �
c�. '1 c, v.. ai 3 3' fl c, O"'\ c, C Q) � <13 � 3' c, <;, 'J- C, 3 3' � cB 3 � � 3 or-
..... g_ CY 9 � C..:, c, c,
,a ,'1•
I�
g_ 3-- ,a a: cl' � � f] C Q.) C,j r e. 3 � '.) fJ c...:>
o? C,..) ,a o _.... c, c, C o:i
c;, ...,_ n
I 1
:>
c..:> Q) c, ....
<>' Q) C.J a,
c;, ,a c.:,
� o> u c, f3 en '0
3 CT n r ... r'l ... ,,...,
c- \..:J C- c-
c..:> n Q) 3 c,>
::) C, �
9 <J'3 :J'
0 ..., c.,.., a3 �
, j , j � '0 C, -.., � ' :j V CI> • cu
Q.) c..:>
C.J 0 9 Ql. �
C.J Q) ,a c-
O"'\ Q,) a, � � f] c.:, 3 c, Q) '1 3 3' 3 Q) 3' 3 ' c.:, C " 3 C <13
0 c.:, C,
J' 3 0 o c, � 3' 3 d 07 c, CY c...:> <>' 3 c, c, c1'., , CY 3'- 9 CZ � �
:)
c, c-
f] 13 � (] c- � 3' C X _07 <Jl ,a c5 c..... 9 0 (J 3 9 Q) l'3 Q) C, d ,a 9 9 (] c- �
3 3' en O ::> fu 3 ,a C,j c, 3 :> ::l fc3 C.J <13 o 3' D {] c, � D 9 �- ....-..
3 � 0 ,a
r3 Q) c...:> '-.J'
c, a.> 3 c, c!;f • CY 0 g-, g 3 01
,a
a... � 3'
9 (] :> 3' n J c, g,
j a,
� � ,a � 3' 0 ()' a.> � 9 C, C, 9" s c- c- � � � c., 3 , ...,.__ w '<
O " O 3
3' --� ct,
� '--..I -...,
3 c- ,a '0 0, ,a s (J J - u C, -I
C,
fu (} d c.:, C, c.,.., � c;, � 9 0 9 Q) O Q) ,,_. Q) '1 :) 3' cu c- � c..� 3' � ::r.
.:) (] s. d
3' C, C3 C, 3' c,. " � u . 0
,a 9 & 'g 3 g1 ,a � d3 cS c�
C..J
c� 9 c- 0 c- s , :j
Cl'
::> � � c..:>
C,
3' C � � (J � � c- ,a c� C..J � c..... 9 c� c.::,
,.. ,; 0 c.:, Q) 3 C>> ' :S 8 c:- c S:> C, 3 ° J- ::> ,a c- •tr
� � '3 c- ... a3 3 o, c, o c:., �
C, C
cu c.r C
::)
� c- ,a o en 9 '.)
C,
9 ,.o C,.) Q) :'.> ........,. C, 0'1 Jo fc3 C, C- CU 9
rC.: C,.) C.:, Q O 3' C- Q) g_
-., c..:> O c,r- CY 9 ,..... C>> 0 C.J 3
c..:> 9 c, c, �
c.:, c, aP \J'" c;- C..... J'C',i
c- «.:> C, Q3 3"'- C, c..:> C, 0 (...) .... C, c-
C, w � . g '.) � C,.)
9 a, 3' � <13 o> c- w <I3 (...) a, �
3' o . o,:, ;? 3' en f....:, c..... <f3 c.,.., -<f3
c- �
�
c- c- c- fJ en c,
C.J
aP e> c.:, o :>
C-
9 3' c:, • - � C
Q)
C:-
t1)
'o, � 0 c, � 01 > c, c, c, C- � C.C CJ L.,
c, (I C > f1 c., 0 � - 9
,... ,a � c, <f3 CY {] � Q) c;, C- � 9 C..J c, {J {] 3' c..:> c- � � r':'> r'l 9 ;:: � 3' ]' c - "O
- c, a.> 3 3 a.3 c, r'l c,r- D �--. c.,
9 u, c , ...__
� '0 J- 0 c, c, L �-
(J\ I I
a, ::,I
O
::) � J- I
CU C, I c..:> I '0 I I t..- :J t I L • l '0 c, c, 1 I ,. t J
C- • C:-
'
o3� MM� avcan& M1JL ncno a (? O�� M Bao��b� cao.oda6(? \) � v Jv3J�Loe:� 8cno-
J�O,\) <nu3(?�l,b8ol,u3�6 L�a.o C?�aM\? 'O°c>M't:) 63o��(")'l30�(") nd86oo cY>{?uM
oaooMa, MC")a M�<nu30 8 bMn3 � �3·o Mo�6 n nLn&n 3D�.uMo-L 3u.O�epv3epo·6,
Mli31)C:"OO,O,v6, v_6 LJuMLoo,cnl)6 . M8nL (?M0).l, �o MTI. L oo,l, �O (? O l,�8 bo(? ..
M�) �30�\)ooLC")O� oJa6ooMQ)\). 8v3M�a �a�� oi>M�u MOl,oool> l>3uML omn
l,\) � \) 06C?('f').00')oL 3\1JMMOol> <B,)MO,M vLJv:Mo°t>no ouo bLbooM(?v� *
(ByTKOB1>. Ma1epia.'1 bl l I , 463, 464). 8u'd �L��u8o �3D��D OM03G OJM•
bMa OrJML o bOoMoLnoG o�(? ·)., °t'.>�vJM'O � o6 (? M Q O">°t> Q M<J6nc�l,o,.� 6 D e(,,_
O">.)(?, �d 'J J3D c.)MJ 3D � � o : ' SM'C'06(')J 'J M O ooz..8 1'.:>(J\'>U cvm 3 �.�nL.v o 6 � ..
.
00 <::'(J·
o L u%Mo 3oon� o � M c,'3'1 a�v('l)6oo'a� od 8 61). 1 8 � Ddn aoM. 1 800 . V·
J�at:·a o8 3oM��('W")M d� bo�<) aMuVQM..> 8u6ocnn l>OL L�J uMcn3o·�ML M�
L o m0">,:>0 dQ QM<noon� 'BoL�boo C?i) � o a�D o J C°' ao M_h 3n O Q <t3 DL vn 6(.? �vo·6 3n
t?�ai J� no���o c�'CJ&%�3 60 L bo�8ML�voM ��, M M_a n��nuQ 3000M3 0,.3 000
8o cn o Lcnb('t)a � � M'n Lacno L �Q�8voCB6L, MMa a�L, Ll)d��°'3 D �M o hcnb o �
�u L�anQ'�aMQ) �1C)l,Q0')0'}�6 �DQJM0')DOo6.� �-u h 'CJ �Do,0l; o�b rJ 0 (")'8D c::1 \)I) �
vn�u (? oJo n� . a�0 M�a L�Jan oLo C?��Mn\) �<?�, M(V)a 8cn��o nL �J<nb°6 0-
�n oo oa� � voez3�'a�: on M �on d[)CZ3Q 2,�M� �O-OJv�� 22 t? OJo8oo ML 1 800 9.
oLo, M M8 bo�aM L�vQMo 3��"�(.?0 a�L cn3i) �(;O'>� (J �M 'C)b1Jb�3t.., M�O')ol)b
8ol,o a ('t)ao�66n �a (?MML 1DM ·L�J �M0,3 D � M�o �.)a�-.,.L rl � O vMO JO ot,3-
6 0'6 (ByTKOBn. Ma Tepi aa11 b1 I I , 465) . .
. .sG o oon d[)Gvdt:"D6t:'M0v M��[Jcnt:L 80,v3M\"l1,o utJ V n 6�vvn630 o�0?.3v-
�nl,vo5o O'r) C' O 3J (V)5� v Q) v u8 0L011)61) cJ08m;b,3 0 30L\)o,3 �L\)o 8vG 'OJ3D
1 5 6Mo8ooMG o,v3ol> Vt)Md M8�t?0D6�ol,\)o')3 n,L L,�Jvf,<n3 o�Mdo 6�oMdv-
6oon JJM,6�\) hMO Mv V v8G an,<';�.co a o.caD 8 vM (!) �1')031� D ;O � v, L uJ � <n -
1
3D �ML �· 0 ao cnm o\)bo<to v,L 3�0L- 5o_ o u � hv30� .m 30 . L 8 nn ol)Q'). oL ovMQ a ("').
[)0-.) 3D 6. j6'C")Mn638 v 30MM&o 8 o ezsol, 2>.>M(? v,(J3v�oool,v01vbo3 3 vo-6(")0.)
l,�d\)h; 3D�ML 8obM3 h oi000 �v mu61)o r,a Mcnb O v0v�o M6 fvh �l, c \)M(.? � ,
MMa:J·t:'OO M6Goo L �a Q):M Mr>L�=3oli � 3n 6L J3o �u6�ran d MQ ��3oo ri � um,
l,��J -:> M (Y)(!> JO �D 3 QMm o O�l)�O.M bn ��n_Ov�.\) (t;J3D I I , 465.-466) .
. .
--·----- • •
• QTKpOCTCH o6wHpuoe llOJlC Kb Topr08J11, nepCHD.CKOH lf llff.ll• •
HCKOH
( 1 1. 464 ) .
L16
M�0, �3D 8b � nL o,�SbaM oe,o, 'Bond�D OM�I) •. c<,�a,a�6 1 783 V· co a <:? a�a
��M�300,�Mn u·b3� bD�1DJ�'OC'D0� L�E·*>a, 3 [)C'<""U �� M'O LDO>L dMMoG
�.fry (!).>(?DO· � �I) (!'.) �A o �l) o an 03C'0�[)0-> � M eant:'!) 'a DO\)bO �n MMO'> �ao
8b\)M0 L o,�6ba ('t')� no,, .)a n6Ma <4,�G a oooL aa,�3 AM��{; 'CJ b � M(P.), "'('t')a a\)L>
M�oao G�o r1 mo JJ M6M�� oao.l., Q) �L�86Jo ono t::' � C?, 3omM8 0 00 3 00, L .:,j �Mm-
3 [) � M L JL r_j M(?� m�3o·l> o L�bDC'avotnnL' aMUJMO� � � ·"'oLoa,oL 3l)6'C)
�M 'l3D� b l)V() � I)� a���Joo3�. �-l)J(') 30MM00 ancnot. U OJ3(? 0� o l; 3\) a('tj oL
a ,:;O')t, aoaa� � olOJr)�>���o 3.:,6�bMM(J<">D c:'D"D �O ��M, �a1:0 M· a M-O Ln
o,o L aO'>�J MMO�.a ����o bo �'3[)J M�� oo oL ub � (?U (? �M� 303 �L (?� �M u
u�i·)i<, C°') Lo o l'0DL 8M o A0e90 �u ��v\)a t., a�6 30Mh80 a o,ez3 nG ·LoJ3,� o �oL
u86uJ O 'aaoO�M, a �clo63n i 8 o�b. 1 80 1 V· ��3 C'D �oM3n C' oL a � G"o <Bo L�o
8 " a M �J3D � f;", M �a D �d 0\)0 6.:,o,J31)ao�, 3 ncnMB(J 0,3 00, aD 'n D &0C">M3 OU�,
aMV<">bl)3D pMJ o o nL� � v c1�r<icn3 0 �0 o <',oG L'r) M J 0 � (')0,\) � " oobM3 or.o,
MoLoa,3v L�3 \)M0'>30 �M Ll)an (!_)l)aM (? 'an aMnaAcn� (ByTKOB'b. Marepi a.,, bl
I I , 4 6 6--·4 6 7) . �(½ u aD C8 D 80M �a o L, l)MO 8no, -oaoooL J-� M0?3D� b� �bu
j l) \) �·O G (!) (1) 8 D � • 1 0 Q) 1) l) Ml ) () 0, b M 3 0 � '
" � 3 � 0 I-I.· a��VVJ3D·0 0 �0 JJM6 (!? �, &><""la Loj �Mcn3o�('f") D M0,0.:>d .:>(!) .
M4j L o ooo u 8';JO Q �6o�C!) nJool) (!> \) Lo 6.,)0ol.,\) C? i) Lo-6M-�0Lvm30L {? �DaMA
� o � o 006.:, (n3 a o I I ' 469) . 1 2 a�Mo u 1 80 1 V · � �·a t:' D a �� C? �o o 3.:,�� .
8ol>a� 8 0 ·8J3 <')'�Mo·a ��D3Lo6(? MQ I - a \) 0 3M d 6M L�J�0'>3J�C"lL 'a3o·�cno ootJ
acnD�O �Jl)b M bMCI) (?� �ao6M·a a���v�a�6� 8 �aMD �J30� , �\) a �D 5\)Q)
a�MO>l)�ol), c<,(")a aO')a t:' L�31)<4>0')3 ot:'M, L oo�3 oL 6 0 o oo, aM0 u��3 ("').G �-
LJO?a>.)6' a�6n�M�C'\)� 'aoo«->moov (!' .) <4,Ma a�G o,1)30L o,�30L � � 03 � 8.)
M D ra D � \) d00t,)�M a oMn ooL 3 � 6 ()(,, d.:) � -o d1J. �a UvJ OO>bn ool, 3\)3MMJ3 D 3 "
av6'. 80 6 J bMMr.·&aG ao�b(!> M, c<,("')ao c:'a�o L�jl)M0'>3 D �("')dO ��aML 3 �0U0?\)-
6 v11D 3.:,�uJa� � 3D C'�ez3o M o, hvo o�booL aaaJ3 0(!)�0L o�OM6o'a3 0�() (? .)-
3 oa,0L oMd�oa ooa, Oi1M cJo8M�[JO�� o, � � O ez3 0 � 0Lc3n L \)E l)t4,0') 3D�
�t.
'C)�lD b\)o Lo a°'�3 �<"l0 � (? �v\)M L\) (Ey TKO B'b. Ma Tep iaJ1bl I I, 4 73-475).
�J3 D o L .a oLo 6\lOO � o u b\)�- J � M<z3V , °'rJ M Mc,M �o an'CJ�o Md �2,(")0') a.)
t::'
aM l)MJ303 C? � C?� Looua�3o�OC7? \)'CJVQ M (? � 030 '1 30 60 r>.) � boL o'�)'c:' OL
bl) (?D otJ C? v 3oLvM �· ca oo� L. bM � M, M Ma L\)j�Mcn3£} �M L a�h o'ao 86�n�o·L
-- ----
• ,, Ceii .no ro eo pll Ae .11a eT c11 H a ee <1H blS1 ep eM e11 a ;
PC H O 6 Y !{eT'b HY iK Hbl M'h ne pe Me H
H O elKeJJ 'ITO JJH (5o ycMoT·
H Tb HJI H np H 6 a BH Tb .!lJIB B 33 H M H
..1 a BO J"h HM ce n Me cr o no o6 oc To po uH
Oit no .i1 b3 bl ' oo oe
cMy corJJa w eH ilO ".
l l7
....... CF"' C- rl C- <J3 a3 � c., C- C- c.,..., � C- C- CT C-
.,_. a..J 9 ,a fc3 � 9 � � (), <13 c, � C-- .
(
,::j:l U v ' j c, u c, C...:, 3 r,
' c,c-- v Cl O C, C, a.:, (j (.1 '>.. -..J c,
Q.) (...) <Jl
:J CJ :>
.. c, c, r,"l cu c., 3 C1.,, c:- u c, . c, C>> O""\ C>> C,> C,> .) .:J
- CT Oi
C.C ....D
3 c, .,.. c;. ' 3j
r,., )
3 C- >..
,
CT en L:J ' . v,.) c.:>
)' 0 Q.) I D c, D C..:> Q.) c, C- J'- C,.) � 'J: I� j
ra � O
'<:1"3 07 � 3'
ra o.-i 1"- s c:·· i g,7 gJ cS rJ � g;:: s <::> c.:> Ll 11
3' g- a3 g, 5' �s g, 3 �
� C:- � � a., C, > cg 9 :J � C- 9 0:> � g_., O""\ c..:> I C- c, � g � 9 C- f3
U � 3 c.:> C- J
e..:>
0.) 3
::, cu ' j 3 ,-c c,'.> C>J -, c,
3� I 0.)
C- c, C1> � CJ c.:> c, ' j fc3 D O c, a... '-' <13 �
3. or- 0- '1 � . c, CY <13 0.) 3'- ::) 3" Ct O � ... � D � 3 0 c.:> (Y 3' CJ a.3 (.... - :> 3 0 C ,a
< 9 en V a.3 D ,a fJ
,.. c- D ::) a..J c ;> ,a O C, a3 3 c9 3'- f] 9 � c, > f] 9 a, OJ � c.9 3'- u c, c.:,
,d ,/ v ,n j c:_. 0_ c, .. n
' j a.:,
3' 3 07 3 D C.J c,
c.9 3 9 00 r, 3 0 °' C,..'.>
o
<", a.:, 0 c..... Ci o 3 c:.:, 3 c 3 O:>
· C- 3 3 ,� ;; 0 D 07
§� c- OJ rrlo ov 07 :;en "-:J-- c:J"
.'>..
:J - C- � CJ c- CJ �
" g' r::> ?""' <;"'" 3' r::>
c-.: C,.) 9 � 07 3 n ,a , :, :, c, 9 � o o.J :::,o ,o � ,o
I":)
.., <l3 � cu C, C,.) c.:, 0 c.:> ' :.J . .v 3 � � c- 0 C,.J 3 O:> .:J- c- C, ;-, c;. w 11 C, v... 9 , ,...
3°" L:J ,ac:;. C,
U C
3 C..JCl c..J Oi C.:>
c:,
C- 07 3 '0 � .:J- Cl.) D C- O""\ CU (:j 9 -.. L:J c, O""t D Oi (3 C- (.r CF'
v (] o, c � � � '"'-"' ra a3 � � g_, g3 � d c- o 11 3'- ,a c � c.:> d
3' g, 3' o· g., 3 Oi c:- 0 d ·�
en c:> c, cn , j ' ::S o � c:, � _,.., > c- c, G ' j c.§ 3 �
' j- c., v 3 07 �
1
c- c.:> 9 0.J 3'
c.:.:> '% � � J'c3 Q.J � ,..� 3 g
'- :;,:: c.:, ; J- (] Cl.) , � �.,55 ,,r- a:l Cr i 5 g._ D
1
3 a.3 c,
3 C.:,
9 � .,.. Oi r <.
9
:>
9 �
L:J 3 .-.j CU v :.S �
3 � . g...
0-' , j ">,.. Q ..:,- c, 3 )
c:- .:J - , j ' � 0 � Ct � L:, c:- cn c, c,
{, c..:, � - o, :'J 3 (j " :> � a:> cr o Q ... C3 o, c9 c.:> 3' n c..:>
G o, t; 07 _:_) (>J � a., � c;;- ,a - c- 3-- � c.S 3 c- o c,, � '� ci ,a 8-3 3-- � J' ra � o
� �
J
� 3'
o
� 3 � g-1 � � 3' � � en 3 c..:, Q c�,. '& f,"" o C 3' � c..:, & C c..:,
0 3'-
f ,a � �
:, � .. 3 ' ,a g � t; ' 0 C � 3'- 07
c- 3 g1 c- ,a en � f] ,.� CJ � C•7
dn
a3 � 3 a.) ' j C 3 : 3 o:> 9
"'" C,.... 0 .... ' ' 0 c, C>J c, v 9 C- C- c., � O' . -.. 0
W c;;- 0 i3 D 3 c.:, f] c, 9 CJ � c., (j O c, c.:, f8 J'
� '3 Q.) 3 n er
Q.) ' j � Cl>
>
c c., C.J 3' (j 3'-
0 v � c, c.:> c-' 0.J 07 j' 3 c, • 3 , J"- O' o, C;> CJ (r. c..:, � C.:> ,;' J' 07 cc:,
3 - u) 3
(] � 07 (] � c.:, '1 � o c..-> c, 'l � ra l" c;; g_ o '1 'g � � Q g, 3 g_ 3'- �3 � � 'J <13 c.:>
� c, CY d O c.:, C c, a.J C.:, � 3' � >e 9 07
3 ' V o. C 3' cn ,a d' 07 c �- (t) c.,_ c-- 9 �
'0 0, 3 C-' c- n
l j �
c..:> O' S
0 CU C,.:> 3' c- c- · · 3
D ci:> 0 � � c, oJ D ,a O c, & :, aJ C!> c., C- 3 � 3 I ....,.. C- 3 c..:> (.3 c, CT Id
w 07 3 g-7 � J' ,a 'g O en O' c, � � CL C O � f' uJ c.9 c�, 07 c- ....� g_ cu f], ,a f" c:-
)' 't c,
�a3 �c,
'g c:- c9 c, o c, c- � g i "? o 3 .3 g- g, C 3 o � �c., Z° � � 3 � 3' c<-:,
c:; ra 3 O Q.) � '? g' c.:,
C.:> � O n � 3' � 3' ,a ,a g c- c- fJ f1 c;, c, --..J c- o c:- g, � � o �
� ,a ' j :j O l j c- c � J c..:, c..:, ::,0 0 0 ....... <T O' (Jl c., 0, 3' Ct,..
c- o en ..en O'
, j c., o 3 - J' c.c en " I c,,
,:, y:) .... C-' c-- c- c- � ra Cj c;, o c.c .,........ n 3
o o C, O' s 3'"'�
<,
,a Q.) 9 c9 3 ...._ :1
'0 c.., c, c9 3 3 0
Q) � 0 en ·"- � cu r.t t1 t:) Cj C,
C,
(:,> D
3 C3 0 c
3 c.., " ,a 3' c, ..."" c..... ...- C c., ...- J- c..c " ' .
3 3 ° I� j
�
� c., n
c9 Ct.-. 1"'l g-, '>-. (3 , C- 0
J-. ..,.,,_ Q) CJJ 9
� C, � L3 'l! C- ()) 9 t3 p 1 > 10
, o fJ D 0 Q>
...- c., � Cl ,.0
,-c Q)
3 C.,' ' j
__...., 3 � 3
3 �3 3' cl � D 'J Cj 3 �- 0 3 .. c9 C o:> (j '- 3' 3"' a3 m c�, '" o '-;; rJ � c3 3
� � 3
C/ 0:> J1 (J � a,
� 07 � W e , or c- 11 ,a · 3 oP (j D � c o
�
c:, � d
� 9 o,:, a3 9 c- '1 �
� �� � 3 g_ 3 � cu 3' � � 'i § g, 3 o ,a g-' a3 �
CT
C � .3 � J' f3 c":, c, D eu
cT O fJ O c9 oo c3' r.t
� D � c, ra en CJ 9 .-- 3'- � c- g <13 J' (/ 0 3
3 � C- 'j
o. 0 3'
f'"'l S CT O ._... �
CJ � ">-... � D
07 9
· Ct CF I'd
� ....
c, c$ 0 ():> 0
(Y
._.C- C- � ' j C£ f c, fc3 c.:, cg C- • c.., c..:,
'1 • fc3 g' c5- � d1 3' 9
Q.) c..,
c, � C3 3' 3 3 C..:> <l3 c., {J c- D � c, a, <::> 1 ,a 9 ?
v c, o:> O, 9 C-
C 0 o:, 3 _ co •
-<13c, � ,,J
O
3" oP
�
�
�
t.>
C- D
er '>.. 3" cJ
:J D
Q) O' c9 c.:> c, a.::> Q.) .<>' c.:, " c.:, <.Jc-3 9
. v ,a f1 3' c, Cj 9 o3 C- tv 3 0 � 07
t·
� r.t (j OJ rO
C.AoV c.:,
C:, 0 ...._.. ,- c;; Q.) C- ... 0 CJ 3 _.
1
3:"' <f3 :'j- 9· C.. c.§ J'c3 3 � l,..J 3 a:> 9 CU () e.:> en .,,.,_ � �
8 ::
f 0: C.:>
c,
o3 · ,n :J
CJ , o , .:S ,-::a
QJ , j o D c- en C- 3 c.:> o
.:J- ·
u- . C-- r- > � -
'>... "'
c,
o r or; ,.. c.:> � C, CC 3""' O C.C 9 CJ 9 0 C1 >
'>,,.
.J-� Q;) O:> -- CJ U �
- .. � o c.:> 41 -<13 3 Q.) 0:7 c- ..,.,_ ..-:> o c:;.
,.. o:>· . 3 '-=' ,..:, 07 · ' :J c..:> ,.. o ,
C,..>,· <.1"\ i-- c, O c, 9 9 � '>... 1 0
m Cj 3
07 �- J 10 c.:> \..:, c, '0
� r:�
·- . . •-;, · � ';""' c, D
07 c.:,
-.J Jo (8 a:> Q3 � .:J- .J c...:, f'c3
- c, Ct 07 C- D CJ c.:,
C- 0.) ....,.. CJ -.,-
?:
P"' {)P �� • '1., ,a �
,
ct, 7 1' 1 ' t'/
O' 3'· c,
J I I
0
3 I en C o_ c, C- ,aC,
3
Qj
c;-: c:.:> c, C,.) 3'- o
I CT\ Qj C- :) C-
o
C- I
9 c3 07 o f] . C ....,.. :.1
• t I <, C, � C-
c,
UJ I
9
<13 9 c., ,aa:, � a:, 07 a., ,a C ,a et er 3' (J ,a a:, c..:, C c-
o> a., ::ro c a, 1n C- t.'.) OJ
D O
c.:, a:
..J r c;. c, 9 3 a...
tY c..:, C- C..:> er :$ g,
I
V
3' C..:, 3 er-· Cl O 3 c, c..:, f,/ Q) g:' 3 -. cf' C£ D :) 0
a, '-=' c, n Ct 9 c:t Cl c, c:- � 3
,
9 07 ::) a, c,> c- c- .. 07 a.:> Q)
Cw Ct C:- S?°7 q C/ � W
3' cS C,
,j
rd 9 Q) C- � en '3 c, :) J-i3 ::) '3::J ...,.,_
,J � , .:, .-,..,.
r li. C£ ,..� C, C,
c, � c, c, _,
10
3' O '-=' ">,,. ,o .J , c- -....
...,.J
� Q) 10 _,- 3 � 'o o 0 c.:, OJ � � c- �-
C..:>
J- l.u 3
3' - ,n.:j O""I ():» c- o c, c.:> C, ():»
- � � C..:> 0
� c..:, 3 9 ' :J � ()' CT"I ">,,. ,a 3' C1:, ,... c, en ' :J
c, 9
10 c C.> ()' :.) 3 ...., Oi c..:, 0
o O ()' 3 ,..� C..:> 0 C/ Ct
0
3' 3' 9
J' ' O:J C,
Cl 3 C C, Q) � C, c9 a., 9 .:, 0 Cl J- C, C..:>
� e�' c- � ... 07 c, ::, Q) a: cu g, ,a c- 07
v � c,
c- � e, ' C c, c..:> 3 e.> c- f]
C- � c, 0 C-
Q) f]
():»
<?
C � .,.
r- 8
er C-
g 3
3 (3 B
(3 er c.9 c.:,
(j ::! C, � f3 CF :.> �
,a C-
a:, a.)
3
c, O""I
9 � D
3 ... 3' � � 3 Z1 J'
't fJ � O""l '3
c, CF n
g c,
J J' � C/ � r3
9 07 3' , � � ...,.,,. 9 e.>
�6 '10 Q.) c-
a.:> 3' O 0
=7 c.:, ,.::, c:n e..:> D ..-
a3 ...,.,,. C.c, ...,.,,.
.;,- > _,-
Q.. c, , C <J'l �
C,
;3 3 cP ::>
C, c..:,
• g_ 'l,
o
c- 7 C0 c.:> CF c.:, � a3 '- cS c, o a.) n C � � C, 3 _,- D c.:)
3 c:n ,a 3'
c.:,
Q)
Q) �
"
3' c,, ">,,.
<J'l E a.... • e": , 3 � 3 '1 o " ,a a, 07 c.... C,
3 , o ,n :j a:, a.)
<13
o °
o>-
::, ::J > c..:, c.:, 0 D •
_,- Id ()' Q) ,�:J ,O:J c.:, 07 f3
c cf' c, g a.. 0 c.:, c .:, C- (9 0
'Q)
c, e, C-
" J'
3 � en Qa c.:,
3 c.:,
07 a... 9 c, c,
� c-
c:n cS
" g' 07 07 3' g,_ 3 f] � o,:, � 3 c-
3 f] c,, en c- '1
,
7 0 "O � c.S O .en � g-7 � f] 9 cg, 3' 9 3' ra � 0 � � e':> a3 a3 � en c:3 � C c.:, C..:> al
3' 0 ::> C- ':.:111' c, 0 O""I 0:» J - a3 O C-
Cl D C..:> r c; (j
c D
- c.:, r. c.:> 9 c.:,
(j - c.:>
c..
- <13 o, ::J
J- a3 �
a.:> �
0 n
'j � c-.,
a:, o;a en e
�' <>'
3 c.:>
� '-=' ..-
'- e..:> .:,
en � g c- e.>
c, Q)
c.:, 3'
o
-...
...... , o <13
c.:,
c-
c,
c-
c.:, � :: g_ c.:,
' :J
'1 c.:> �
'1
3 o a: e.> _,-
� '1 ? j C g
o:,
o g, 07 � J 9 '1:- ,a ,a3' if'
� a., 1 3 cJ � g
a:, c, ,a 3 2' a.... c.:,
9 ">,,. D It c, 0 c, ()- c, J' c, O ' :S c.:> 07 O:» c.:> 3 3 01
3' a.) <J3 07
-"' J- ,a � c- c- a, 3 C a: - a3 c- o 3' O' {J � cS � 3 07 c.... cS ,a " a: ...
0 C, ,
Q) j
c- �J C.> Q) CF 3 Q) I":>
10 J 3 .;' C£ <13 0 ::J � C, co Q) 3 C, C, ;?.. '1 '3 3 9
c9 , C '' .. c..:, ......,
Cc,
c c, 3 Cl en a.:> 3 _,- � 0 e.>
,a o:> c,
63 c, a.) c, c, 0 ' ::J � f8
:'.) 3' .. a.) 3 c, a:, � J' C- Q) a3 C- <13 D � (j
C1> 2; 9 (j J'8
c,, c....v c, c.:, f] 0 a.) 3' g' 9 en c, ,a g' 9 cf' C- D ._.... � J' 0 c':, Ct: c- '3
,a 07 3 g' � c.w
c. _, cf1 c, 3 c, O" c- � � ,:.: <J3 e � 3' t., 3 !:': o .-� 3'
� a, :: c- 3' "
0 3 f] � / c, _... C.> ...:, D O D ......., '- • ...,, c..:, -._ ......., 3
a3 • fJ c- c, ,a
c- ........ ()' C ::,
"" C 3 3' c...J Io c- � c- 9 n
, .:f g, 9J' 9 '°
. <>'
f'.r
o � .. D
c- uJ C "'� c- '-0 ,
c- OJ
c.:, C.... a:, c,
C> > 3 CF , :J
CT"I C.>
...... r-.. C, 'l..r"'
C..:> O""I 3 ,... CL
rt "-.J3 c.:,
..., ' 9 ():» OJ CF iO 0 .J
O Cl ,a c.:) _, C..:> � ... 3
a, c, a3 a.,
J' 3 �� ��� � g7 & ,a ,. c; 9 ?c f1 3' 3' ,a J' c$ � """? 3� 3'
•
IO 3' 07 3' 9 0 .J
� g, ,a .,. Q_) "
C, \...:II (...;J ra C, C.:,
g- a3 C, I ::J ...,.,,.
O � Qa 3 C .:,
3' c 3' C,
c.:J � �
V
J'8 C1:, r:, CJ""'I 9 u-1 5(_, .:, f'3 fc3
0
3' 3- '0 j J
3- (j
C, 7 V""" ,
3 a, .:) 0 9 �
C, C,... C,.._
� Co.'.)
a3 � O> ....-4 ()' ::,0
C- C,
D 0 D C..:> C-
OJ t.'.l
,a t.'.l r c; CT"I C..:> ' 0 J' C- I r C. C:, > _ c.:, C, c.:> ,.g,
a.,
3 Q) CF a3 0 C,
� c.:> ..,.._, '-=' 3 c.:> C, 1I":>
O C D ,.'( c.9
()' ....... Cp 3 CT"I O \...:II C, a., C, a:,
c.:> I 0
C, c:, c- ,..1 - 9 ...,.,,. C£ • 3 c.:> 3 ,a 07 C, 3' Qa '1 C,
C,
OJ C, c- (j 3'
3' � 8 cf' c- a., � g r:I
:) er � � C, .;,- cO""I C,:- ,a � 3' ()' 0 3' 0 9 {):» 0 3' 3 3 ._,.- I j ,j
c- c, � 3 3 g1 c- c- 3' ..., � .:, 3 c, ' :J 3' o .Y n c, c- c, , a.) a3 c.:, ,....., e,.._ o a3 al
c,
, 07 ... f3 · ' .:i C- t.'.l c, 0 7 v-- <13
Q) c, c.:>
c,
c- ,a c, c, D c, en 0 0 o � C- 0 c.;>
:> e.> en c,' 9 o:, c, '1 ·9 <J3 o c9 D " 0- g, en C c, C
c- ::J 3' g � 'g 3 3' 0 � c, C e..:>
�
o � o c::- t:g 3' a.) g' � f] g' f"
c9 c-. � 8
�
,a 9 3' c, ___..
c- a.:> � ,a
c, � 3 c.:, C C - o � c.:, e ,, � a.l c.:> c .:, er f]
Q) c.:, 0 0
C, O
O""I O> C,
a: 0 C <13 Q) c,' 3 � 3' a.) � 3' c:.:> c- V 3 ,a c- c-
� � � 9 a3 J' 3 C.> Cl ,a � 3 o:> g-7 0 � 3' � 3' � Qa � 9 � C, -- <13 g-- � '1
3 a: o 0- c.:, c.... o r.:t ,a c, c- c- 3 a: 0
..- t.'.l
3' e..:> er
c, Q)
n ° 9 Cj ,a 3' c.w :>
9 c.:, a:, a.) lc3 t; 07 a: � ,a 'Ji- c.:, � e":'
C,
� '9 '5 c- } o � � J-.. c, c.:> 3' ci 9
C,
0,, 'J.. Cl � f] .? (;.> c.:> 8 3' � � � lc3 ,a V (j C£ fJ
7 3' 3' g � , cg,. J 3 C,
3
Cl f] 7 0 c,
c- c, t.'.l 3 Q) 7 c o
o o:> c, 0 3' c f] § c,
d c, 3' 3 0 c,, c-
a., /3 c o
f] CF :-> en <".t 9 � ,a f] u.v ,a 3 e..:> a: c- 3'- g o:> c- (), ,a J' � 0 Ol a3 c�..,
3 � ci_ � � 8 � 9 3 3 C,> c, � ()' D a:, 3 9> c.:, n 9 c, ...,.,_ c.:, c, 07 9
0
Q.l 07
c:, 3 Q.l _,- 07 O C.> 9 l �
CY ' :J .-, c:JJ c, c, c, Q.l �
cS O f] 9 c.9 a3 J- _,-
J CF ...,.J
n
' :$ c, . C..:> /c3 f8 3 O Qa a) 3 C.> �
3 :.'.l O""I 0 0 c..:,
'o$ a:, 3
(j O f8 8 0 fc3 c,
e.> => 8
I I C- I
-- C:- C""" :- ::J I c, I C- I I O O I I C- C- I 8 C t I C- c, ... C- c,
..c, :.'.l
<[30U{) dGO�MO'). J�MmJoC"r'�O , v o�M 0060C"O �0 v(?'d�MOJ000C'n O�M
1
c/8 C"0.Gv .)(? O(:'O D ub�o O 6 (: br), M(t')d 8 0'ao b30 �30 C'v�D M0 2,::�J (").l,v(Y)M C) 6 'C)
C'0�0) (1\K1\Kf I I ) 304). ov8rf).u�oc:-'oo�a (?v M�unc.nnu aO')vJM('V}OOU
j0)�0�0dva l,�J06',o;3Q<::'Mdn 50m�0(? (?v0d(3)Jouv ,�a 0�6·ou�<t.)�3Mo�o
6 (?M60�0 (?u o�c:'D 6h �3 (1C"(r)OnL UM 'Jc:-'O 0 � 0�·0d3C"{"f'J 00! '.
120