Office of Director Dam

I.D.R.,Jaipur

66590454.xls

DESIGN OF WING WALL

Name of project :

Example 5.15

DATA :

Units

Foundation level

160.50

Junction level of the wing wall with concrete

161.00

Top level of wing wall

174.00

U/S Slope Level

171.00

D/S Slope Level

171.00

Maximum Water Level (M.W.L.)

172.65

U/S Slope (H/V)

4/ 5

D/S Slope (H/V)

0.50

Top width of wing wall

1.00

0.30
0.30

M
M

11 Angle of internal friction ( )

30.00

Degree

12 Unit weight of Masonry

2.10

Ton/Cu m

13 Unit weight of dry earth

1.65

Ton/Cu m

14 Unit weight of wet earth

1.90

Ton/Cu m

15 Unit weight of saturated earth

2.00

Ton/Cu m

16 Unit weight of foundation concrete

2.40

Ton/Cu m

17 Bearing Capacity of soil

20.00

Ton/Sq m

18 Max. allowable compressive stress in masonry

70.00

Ton/Sq m

19 Max. allowable tensile stress in masonry

5.00

Ton/Sq m

20 Coeff of friction between concrete and masonry

0.65

10 Foundation concrete offsets

Program by- Sunil K Goyal

U/S
D/S

Office of Director Dam

I.D.R.,Jaipur

66590454.xls

WING WALL STABILITY AT JUNCTION LEVEL

R.L.

174.00

0 1.00

4
WET SOIL

R.L.

171.00

R.L.

171.00

5
WET SOIL

R.L.

172.65
SATURATED SOIL

2
2

10

1
R.L.

161.00

1
1
8.00

11

0 1.00

12

5.000

EARTH PRESSURE DIAGRAM

14.00
8

11.65

UPLIFT PRESSURE DIAGRAM

Program by- Sunil K Goyal

Office of Director Dam

I.D.R.,Jaipur

66590454.xls

(i) Checking the stability of wing wall section at junction level i.e. at R.L.

161.00

HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL FORCES AND MOMENTS

Condition : No water on the front face and earth fill saturated upto pond level and wet between pond
level and top of wing wall
S.No. Item
Description
Forces (t)
Lever arm
Moments in t-m
VM
HM
Vertical Horizontal
(m)
(A)
Vertical forces
1
Self weight of wing wall
1
1/2 X 10.00 X
8.000 X
2.10
84.000
5.333
448.000
2
13.00 X
1.00 X
2.10
27.300
8.500
232.050
3
1/2 X 10.00 X
5.000 X
2.10
52.500
10.667
560.000
2
Vertical weight due to earth retained on backfill
4
5.000 X
1.35 X
1.90
12.825
11.500
147.488
5
5.000 X
1.65 X
2.00
16.500
11.500
189.750
6
1/2 X
0.00 X
0.00 X
0.00
0.000
0.000
0.000
7
1/2 X 5.000 X
10.00 X
2.00
50.000
12.333
616.667
3
Uplift Pressure
8
1/2 X 11.65 X 14.000 X
1.00 -81.550
9.333 -761.133
(B)
Horizontal forces
1
Wet earth pressure
9
1/2 X
0.33 X
1.90 X
1.82
0.577
12.100
6.983
10
0.33 X
1.90 X
1.35 X 11.65
9.961
5.825
58.021
2
Saturated earth pressure
11
1/2 X
0.33 X
1.00 X 135.72
22.620
3.883
87.843
12
1/2 X
1.00 X
1.00 X 135.72
67.861
3.883
263.528
VM =
HM =
V=
H=
Total =
161.575 101.020
1432.821 416.375
VM
Net stabilizing moments =
M = 1432.821
M = 1016.446
b

14.00 ,

=
=

HM
416.375

M
1016.446
-------- = ----------- =
V
161.58

6.291

b/2 - X
0.709

Vertical stresses at Heel

= V/b(1-6e/b) =

8.034

t/m2

<

70.00
safe

t/m2

Vertical stresses at Toe

= V/b(1+6e/b) =

15.049

t/m2

<

70.00
safe

t/m2

<

0.65

Sliding factor =

H
V

101.020
=
161.575

0.625

Hence

safe

Factor of safety in overturning

=

Program by- Sunil K Goyal

VM
1432.82
HM = 416.38 =

3.44

>

1.5

Office of Director Dam

I.D.R.,Jaipur

Hence

Program by- Sunil K Goyal

66590454.xls

safe

Office of Director Dam

I.D.R.,Jaipur

66590454.xls

WING WALL STABILITY AT FOUNDATION LEVEL

R.L.

174.00

1 1.00

5
WET SOIL

R.L. 171.00

R.L.

171.00

6
WET SOIL

R.L.

12

172.65
SATURATED SOIL

9
10

2
2

13

1
R.L. 161.00
0.30
R.L. 160.50

1
1

8.00

14

1 1.00

5.000

15

0.30

4
EARTH PRESSURE DIAGRAM
14.60
11
12.15

UPLIFT PRESSURE DIAGRAM

Program by- Sunil K Goyal

Office of Director Dam

I.D.R.,Jaipur

66590454.xls

(ii) Checking stability of wing wall section at foundation level i.e. at R.L.

160.50

HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL FORCES AND MOMENTS

Condition : No water on the front face and earth fill saturated upto pond level and wet between pond
level and top of wing wall
S.No. Item

Description

Forces (t)

(m)

Moments in t-m
VM
HM

84.000
27.300
52.500

5.633
8.800
10.967

473.200
240.240
575.750

17.520

7.300

127.896

11.800
11.800
0.000
14.450
12.633
14.450

151.335
194.700
0.000
11.119
631.667
101.006

9.733

-863.298

Vertical
(A)
1
1
2
3

Vertical forces
Self weight of wing wall
1/2 X 10.00 X
8.000 X
13.00 X
1.00 X
1/2 X 10.00 X
5.000 X

2.10
2.10
2.10

Foundation concrete
14.60 X
0.500 X

2.40

3
5
6
7
8
9
10
5
11
(B)

Lever arm

Horizontal

Vertical weight due to earth retained on backfill

5.000 X
1.35 X
1.90
12.825
5.000 X
1.65 X
2.00
16.500
1/2 X
0.00 X
0.00 X
0.00
0.000
1.35 X
0.30 X
1.90
0.769
1/2 X 5.000 X
10.00 X
2.00
50.000
11.65 X
0.30 X
2.00
6.990
Uplift Pressure
1/2 X 12.15 X
14.60 X
1.00 -88.695
Horizontal forces

1
12
13

Wet earth pressure

1/2 X
0.33 X
0.33 X
1.90 X

1.82
12.15

0.577
10.388

12.600
6.075

7.272
63.109

14
15

Saturated earth pressure

1/2 X
0.33 X
1.00 X 147.62
1/2 X
1.00 X
1.00 X 147.62

24.604
73.811

4.050
4.050

99.645
298.936

1.90 X
1.35 X

V=
H=
179.710 109.380

Total =

VM
Net stabilizing moments =
M = 1643.614
M = 1174.653

Program by- Sunil K Goyal

14.60 ,

HM
468.961

M
1174.653
-------- = ----------- =
V
179.71
b/2 - X

6.536

VM =

HM =

1643.614

468.961

Office of Director Dam

I.D.R.,Jaipur

Program by- Sunil K Goyal

0.764

66590454.xls

Office of Director Dam

I.D.R.,Jaipur

66590454.xls

Vertical stresses at Heel

= V/b(1-6e/b) =

8.446

t/m2

<

20.00
safe

t/m2

Vertical stresses at Toe

= V/b(1+6e/b) =

16.171

t/m2

<

20.00
safe

t/m2

<

0.65

Sliding factor =

H
V

109.380
=
179.710

0.609

Hence

safe

Factor of safety in overturning

=

VM
HM

1643.61
468.96

3.50

>
Hence

*******************

Program by- Sunil K Goyal

1.5
safe