Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Thomas Robb Dr. Ross Perkins, Boise State University Ed Tech 503, Instructional Design 10/20/2009
This project was created for the purposes of training the 160 teachers (hereafter, referred to as trainees) in the SC School District of Washington County to use the Blackboard Learning Management system to supplement their teaching and to support the learning of their students. Trainees will be trained in a computer lab with broadband access with a timeframe of one to three hours and will include handson activities including using the Blackboard Learning System with follow up activities. This training is intended to be delivered in two workshops, of which the first is 120minutes, with follow-up activities, then the second workshop is 60 minutes.
INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN MODEL (PART 1B)
Gustafson and Branch (2002) describe different models of instructional design. One of the models described is a product-oriented model. This will work best as a product needs to be developed, in this case, a training package. Also, a front-end analysis has already been conducted and a determination of the need of the school district has been decided to use a learning management system, Blackboard. The only thing left to determine is how the district will use the product. Lastly, productoriented models assume that a technically sophisticated product will be produced in the end. In this case, the need for instructional materials and a workshop is needed by the school district. The specific model chosen for this project is the Seels and Glasgow ID Model 2 (pictured below). This particular model was chosen because Blackboard the
2 Copyright 2009 Thomas Robb
Gustafson, K., & Branch, R. (2002). Survey of Instructional Development Models. Syracuse: ERIC.
3 Copyright 2009 Thomas Robb
The learning context includes several aspects that are in need of consideration. First, there are 160 trainees that need to be trained on a system that has already been procured, installed, and is available to trainees. The system is the Blackboard Learning Management System. The focus of this learning context will address the preworkshop deliverables, the workshop itself, and follow-up activities by the trainees as requested by the school district. Prior to the training (the pre-workshop phase), an interview of the IT department and/or administration will take place to ensure that the system is properly installed and configured, making sure that all trainees are already enrolled in training courses with dummy students enrolled in their classes. All trainees will also need to have access to their real course shells where students have the ability to login to the system. Trainees have a training facility consisting of 40 broadband, newer computers where trainees will participate in hands on training. We will need to determine whether these computers have browsers that are most compatible with Blackboard, what Java Run-time Environment is installed on the machines, and what type of access trainees have to a training environment. Next, the actual workshop is part of the learning context. Due to the nature of the change, we will use an innovation model of needs assessment, as the precipitating events underlying this change, dictate that trainees will be required to learn something new. The innovation model of the needs assessment will determine additional information necessary to proceed with designing instruction. The needs
4 Copyright 2009 Thomas Robb
The plan of learner analysis will consist of assumptions, and where we cannot make those assumptions, we will survey the trainees. The goal of the analysis will be to gain as much information about the trainees sensory capabilities, cognitive and affective characteristics, motivations, beliefs, values, and most importantly, specific prior knowledge. The intent of gathering this information is to assist in writing the objectives outlined in the next section as well as development of appropriate instructional materials. Since the audience is made up of trainees, assumptions in the learner characteristics will be made. We will assume that all learners have the general ability to read and write in the English language as they are trainees; therefore, some learning of the system will take place on the system where trainees will be expected to read and write with minimal technical terms (planned follow-up activities). We will also make some assumptions about their computer aptitudes as entry-level skills. Additional entry-level skills for trainees will be addressed in the task analysis section that follows.
SURVEY LINK:
http://tinyurl.com/yhsgxwa
As to affective characteristics, a surprising 80% felt confident when using computers in the classroom, while 22% percent reported having anxiety when learning about using computers. This suggests that this same confidence could shine through with the system, but consideration should be given to address the anxiety when these other learners are learning about the system. This data supports the previous data in the need for a scaffolded class. Trainees with this extra support will likely have much less anxiety learning the system. The deliverer of the workshop should also consider
This same 19% should be identified and grouped with more advanced
All students must know how to learn in this fashion Not all students can learn online Online learning can only work for specific types of learning Technology can never replace a teacher Teachers that use technology will replace teachers that do not Online learning lacks something that only the classroom can provide
As to specific prior knowledge, the following graph represents the number of trainees who had actually used similar web tools or performed similar web functions to those available and commonly used in Blackboard:
120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Uploading Downloading Content Blogs Discussion Boards Journals Wikis Hyperlinks Streaming Videos Email Messaging Plagiarism detection Grade Center Folders Content Areas Alerts Warnings Announcements Availability Settings Navigation Menus Text Box Editor Attachments # Teachers Reporting
The following graph displays the percentage of trainees and how they rated themselves with usage of common tools or skills that are often used in Blackboard. The blue lines represent experts, while intermediate is in green, and novice or never is represented in gold.
When given access to a blank Blackboard course shell with a default menu trainees will develop, publish, make available, and grade a fake lesson for their students consisting of an announcement, an assignment, a discussion board, and a 10question quiz. When given access to a real course shell (all students fully enrolled) in Blackboard, trainees will utilize a training course consisting of video tutorials and links to specific areas of the Blackboard Instructor Manual, and develop a lesson to use with their students consisting of an announcement, graded assignment, graded discussion board, and graded assessment in Blackboard where all lessons are fully graded using the Grade Center.
TASK ANALYSIS OVERVIEW
The tasks in both learning goals will be the same, but the later goal will not take place during the workshop, but during follow-up activities and the second workshop. During the first 120-minute workshop, teachers will participate as students in each area, then create their own area by navigating back and forth between classes. This approach will provide plenty of practice in navigating in the system. It will also free up cognition from developing real content and allow for learners to be
Given a class template with navigation, folders, and structure, trainees will develop a lesson in Blackboard consisting of an announcement, posting of an assignment, posting of homework, an upload area for student submission of assignments, and an assessment.
1.2
Formative, observations
1.3
Locate and identify navigation, edit mode, teacher/student view Locate chevrons/buttons to add content
Formative, observations
1.4
Formative, observations
2.0
Assessment
3.2
3.3
3.4
Navigate to assignments in trainer class, create an assignment and make it available to student view Type in student instructions for uploading their assignment.
When given verbal instructions and a rationale (ie, student role), trainees will navigate to a training course, review an assignment, and submit a file from their computer as a fake assignment into the training course. When given verbal instructions and a visual prompt, trainees will launch Word, type an assignment and save the document in a folder on their computer. When given a visual prompt, trainees will navigate to the assignments area of Blackboard, create complete the form, and attach the assignment from 3.2 into Blackboard. When given a visual prompt and practice item, trainees will type instructions for students to download their assignment, complete the assignment, and submit their assignment.
Formative, observations
Formative, observations Trainee self-assessment (rubric 1) Formative, observations Trainee self-assessment (rubric 1)
4.0
4.2
Formative, observations Trainee self-assessment (rubric 1) Formative, observations Trainee self-assessment (rubric 1)
4.3
4.4
Assessment
5.2
5.3
5.4
5.5
When given verbal instructions and a rationale (ie, student role), trainees will navigate to a training course, and take a five question assessment in Blackboard as a student. When given a visual prompt, and an Blackboard assessment quick-start guide, trainees will utilize the guide to create a 10 question assessment containing at least 1 multiple choice, 1 true/false, and 1 essay question. When given a visual prompt, verbal explanation, and using the Blackboard assessment quick-start guide, trainees will set their test options that best fit how they want to administer the test. When provided verbally and visually with instructions, trainees will deploy the test created in 5.3 in the Tests area of Blackboard and make the test available to student view. When provided with a locked exam, trainees will reset the attempt
Formative, observations
Trainee self-assessment
6.0
Trainees will use the grade center to electronically calculate grades and provide student feedback
6.1 Add, modify, and delete a manual grade book column When provided with a verbal and visual procedure and rationale, trainees will navigate to a training course and add a manual column in the grade-center, enter student grades, remove a manual column in a grade center, and When provided with a verbal and visual procedure, trainees will navigate to the grade center and enter grades for student discussion board submissions. Formative assessment (observations), trainee self-assessment
6.2
Task
Grade the test
Assessment
Formative assessment (observations), trainee self-assessment
6.4
6.5
6.6
Learning Goal # 2 will be the exact same tasks and objectives (with the exception of Task 6.0); however assessment will be using the self-assessment rubric.
The diagram above is color coded to represent each task. The colors coincide with each sub-task/objective (starting from left to right). The black boxes on the bottom represent entry level skills not outlined in the previous task analysis. The Appendix has a clearer view of this and a link to a web-based version can be found at http://mywebspiration.com/view/228004a30a85.
OUTCOMES REVIEW
Goals 1 thru 6 address a variety of outcomes. Smith and Ragan (2005) list various learning outcomes that should result from learning goals. These include declarative knowledge, concepts, principles, procedures, domain-specific problem solving, cognitive strategies, attitudes and psycho-motor skills. The table below summarizes each of these diagrams and lists the learning goal that has this type of outcome.
20 Copyright 2009 Thomas Robb
Assessment of learning will be conducted in two fashions. First, a formative assessment will be conducted at the initial workshop in the form of feedback, observation, and post-workshop review of the content created using the rubric in the next section. Feedback will be sent to each attendee participating in the workshop. Second, since teachers are well versed in assessment practices, this would suggest that they can self-assess their work. This self-assessment (considered the summative assessment) will be based on the same rubric in the next section and will be part of the feedback and question/answer session of the second workshop. Doing a selfassessment (or peer assessment if the teachers decide to do so) should allow for many questions about fine tuning each course and will allow for a good 60-minute round of questions and answers.
Exceeds Expectations
Able to login, navigate course, locate and identify navigation icons and state their purpose, independently. Announcement created, is available to student view, and announcement describes the location and description of assignments, discussion board, tests or a descriptive overview of lesson. Assignment is posted, available to student view, attached as a document, assignment appears in grade center, and there are clear instructions for students on how to submit their assignment.
2.0
3.0
4.0
Discussion board is posted, available to student view, contains an open-ended question, appears in grade center, and there are clear instructions for students on how to post a reply.
Assignment is NOT posted, and/or two or more of the following did not happen: unavailable to student view, lacks the attached word processed file, assignment is not set up as a graded assignment, or there are unclear instructions for students. Discussion board is not posted and/or two or more of the following: unavailable to student view, contains an closed-ended question, does not appears in grade center, and there are unclear or no instructions for students on how to post a reply.
Exceeds Expectations
Test has multiple choice, true/false, and at least one essay question, test items are checked, test is available to the students.
6.0
Trainees will use the grade center to electronically calculate grades and provide student feedback
Grade Center has at least four items (a manual column, a discussion board column, an assignment column, and an exam column) and teacher demonstrates to a peer that they can enter grades. All assignments are in a category with a weighted percentage (even if proportionate), all grade columns are set with multiple displays (one for instructor and one for student), and all columns have a different name for the instructor and the student.
At least one of the following are missing: Grade Center has at least four items (a manual column, a discussion board column, an assignment column, and an exam column) and teacher demonstrates to a peer that they can enter grades. All assignments are in a category with a weighted percentage (even if proportionate), all grade columns are set with multiple displays (one for instructor and one for student), and all columns have a different name for the instructor and the student.
Three or more of the following are missing: Grade Center has at least four items (a manual column, a discussion board column, an assignment column, and an exam column) and teacher demonstrates to a peer that they can enter grades. All assignments are in a category with a weighted percentage (even if proportionate), all grade columns are set with multiple displays (one for instructor and one for student), and all columns have a different name for the instructor and the student.
Sensory Capacities Information gathered in this section will help us develop appropriate workshop activities, seating arrangements, and activities to perform in Blackboard.
Do you difficulty visually with any of the following: * Check all that apply Reading a Computer Screen Watching videos on the Internet Seeing from a distance (such as from the back of a class) Visually discriminating images on a computer screen or when there are multiple visual elements on a page None of these Other:
Do you experience difficulty hearing in any of the following situations Check all that apply A lecturer in a large room From computer speakers When using headphones None of these Other:
Do you have difficulties with any of the following physical activities: * Check all that apply Difficulty sitting at a computer for a length of time Typing on a regular keyboard (commonly called a qwerty keyboard) Clicking on small areas on a screen? Other:
Which of the following ways do you feel you can process information best? * Check all that apply
When it comes to learning about computers, I require many examples for it to make sense to me. *
When it comes to computers, I require little or a lot of time to understand how to use them properly. *
Little time
A Lot of time
Which of the following best describes how you as a learner: when interpreting or understanding very visual or complex charts, tables, or diagrams. * I always require an explanation I usually require an explanation Sometimes I require an explanation I usually never require an explanation I never require additional explanation for these types of tasks
I feel confident when it comes to using computers in the classroom. * For those of you who don't use computers in the classroom, answer this question as it pertains to learning about how to use a computer in the classroom. Very confident Somewhat confident Somewhat unconfident
Novice
Expert
I have anxiety when learning about computers. * Very anxious Somewhat anxious Somewhat relaxed Very relaxed
Check any common beliefs you have about technology or online learning. * Check any opinions or beliefs you have below All students must know how to learn in this fashion Not all students can learn online Online learning can only work for specific types of learning Technology can never replace a teacher
Unitnerested
Motivated
Not excited
Cannot wait
Of the following tools commonly used online and in learning management systems, check the box for one you have actually used in the past. * Check any that apply. This will help us in deciding where to start with Blackboard Uploading files Downloading files Blogs Discussion Boards Journals Wikis Hyperlinks Streaming Videos Email Messaging Plagiarism detection
Expert
Discussion Boards *
Expert
Wikis *
Expert
Expert
Expert
Online Journals *
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Using You Tube, Teacher Tube, Google Video, or other streaming video services *
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Filling out electronic forms * Includes entering text, choosing dates/times, making choices from lists, etcetera
Expert
Using word processors to display mathematical formulas, equations, or problems (Math ML, etcetera) *
Expert
Using screen capture devices to record video or images of your computer screen *
Submit
Bottom of Form