Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
The Father is my hope. The Son is my refuge. The Holy Spirit is my Protector. Glory to the holy and undivided Trinity, now and forever. Let us praise the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit; let us bless and exalt God above all forever! Almighty and everlasting God, to whom we owe the grace of professing the true faith, grant that while acknowledging the glory of the eternal Trinity and adoring its unity, we may through Your majestic power be conrmed in this faith and defended against all adversities; through Jesus Christ our Lord, who lives and reigns with You in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, forever and ever. Amen.
The three subjects are aware of each other through one consciousness which is possessed in a different way by three of them.
Bernard Lonergan, A Second Collection
When it is asked Three what? then the great poverty from which our language suffers becomes apparent.
St. Augustine of Hippo, De Trinitate
Outline
Three Persons (a) Challenges (b) Trinitarian Persons The Trinitys Actions
Introduction
Problems can be solved, but divine (and human) mysteries are to be pondered. When we ponder a mystery and refuse to dismiss it as either an irrational contradiction or a mere problem, it inevitably deepens. Nowhere else does such deepening happen more dramatically than in the case of the mystery of the divine Trinity.
Three Persons
Challenges
Challenges
How does our nite language of personhood fare when applied to God? St Augustine, De Trinitate: For in truth, because the Father is not the Son, and the Son is not the Father, and the Holy Spirit, who is also called the Gift of God, is neither the Father nor the Son, then certainly there are three. Therefore it was said in plural number: I and my Father are One. (Jn 10:30). But when it is asked Three what? then the great poverty from which our language suffers becomes apparent. But the formula three persons has been coined, not in order to give complete explanation by means of it, but in order that we might not be obliged to remain silent.
Challenges (cont.)
Applying to our God is not a straightforward affair. If, however, we refuse to describe God in personal language we run the risk of understanding God to be less and not more personal. Personal language for God makes our prayer and deep relationship to God possible.
Challenges (cont.)
In the Old Testament, the nature of tripersonal God is foreshadowed with the demonstration of God the Father, which expressed his deep involvement in the story of Israel. The name conveyed the steadfast commitment and compassionate love of God in protecting, cherishing, and nourishing a people whose indelity could also call for discipline.
Challenges (cont.)
Naming God as Father, Son (Word or Wisdom), and Spirit found its roots in the OT. Both in the history of Israel and beyond, the OT understood Wisdom, Word, and Spirit to serve as personied agents of divine activity. As personications that were not yet formally recognized as persons, they operated with personal characteristics. God is utterly beyond our world. The creation and conservation of everything as well as the divine activity within the history of salvation must take place through the agency of Wisdom or the Logos.
Challenges (cont.)
Like Lady Wisdom, the Word is with God and is powerfully creative from the beginning. (Gn 1:1-2:4). At times, the OT scriptures set word in parallelism with spirit or breath as instruments of creation. Spirit shows up frequently as a third way of articulating the creative, revelatory, and redemptive activity of God. In their creative, revelatory, and redemptive involvement, Wisdom, Word, and Spirit took on divine roles, while staying clearly within Gods control.
Challenges (cont.)
The most valuable feature of Wisdom, Word, and Spirit as expressive of the divine activity toward the human race (and the whole world) lay in their being not abstract principles but vivid personications- something that was particularly true in the case of Wisdom. Wisdom called on men and women to listen to its message and to follow it, thus preparing the ground for the visible coming of Jesus and his Spirit.
Challenges (cont.)
The vivid personications of Wisdom/Word and Spirit, inasmuch as they were both identied with God and the divine activity and distinguished from God, opened up the way toward recognizing God to be tripersonal. Without these OT personications (and the Father/Son language applied to God), the acknowledgement of the Trinity would have been so well and providentially prepared- by foreshadowing and by an already existing terminology.
Challenges (cont.)
In order to know a personal language for the Trinity an account for the meaning of person is necessary.
Challenges (cont.)
A trajectory of development that led from Boethius (480-524 or 525 AD) to the Middle Ages arrived at St. Thomas Aquinass (1225-1274 AD) classical description of a person in his Summa Theologiae as a distinct subsistent in a rational nature (subsistens distinctum in natura rationali).
Challenges (cont.)
The philosophical input from Rene Descartes, Immanuel Kant, and John Locke in the 17th century leading into the Enlightenment led to the emergence of a (but not the) typically modern notion of person as the subject of self-awareness and freedom-person as a conscious and autonomous self. The notion of personhood when applied to the doctrine of the Trinity produces what looks like tritheism: three autonomous subjects living and working together in quasi social unity.
Challenges (cont.)
The rational worldview and method of Enlightenment thinkers reversed the Augustinian axiom of believe in order to understand (crede ut intelligas), and made it read If you believe, you will not understand. Belief in the tripersonal God revealed denitively in Jesus death and resurrection was put aside as an obstacle to honest though and true understanding.
Challenges (cont.)
German philosopher Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegels (1770-1831) identication of an Absolute Spirit embodying oneness while simultaneously full of contradictions in the dialectical progression of history was at the time the richest treatment of the Spirit ever found in Western philosophy.
Challenges (cont.)
The centrality of history in Hegelianism throws into question the redemptive and communal reality of the Spirit. If God is the world itself, then God cannot bring salvation to the world through the intratrinitarian dialogue and the life which humans share with it. Nevertheless, Hegel encouraged notable theologians to think of the Trinity in historical terms, and to examine the Christology in the Trinity.
Challenges (cont.)
In the twentieth century, various other forces, both beyond Christianity and within Christian scholarship and life, have exercised their impact on the latest developments in Trinitarian theology.
Challenges (cont.)
With the emergence of personalist philosophers, human beings were conceived as existing in and constituted by their relations to other self-aware objects.
Challenges (cont.)
Martin Buber (1878-1965) and others have offered theologians the language of I, Thou, and We when speaking about the relational reality of God. When I relates to the Thou, another person who addresses me and responds to me in love, a We emerges to unite us. This experience hints as the I of the Father, the Thou of the Son, and the We of the Spirit.
Challenges (cont.)
C.G. Jung (1875-1961) drew on the human experience of psychological growth. Jung associated Trinitarian belief with a threefold account of human development: submission (to the Father, self- assertion (of the Son, and then selfsurrender (to the Spirit).
Challenges (cont.)
Karlfried Graf Durckheims (1896-1961) studies the experiences and longings of people for Life, Meaning, and Love can be likened to the tripersonal God.
Challenges (cont.)
19th and 20th century emancipatory movements have had their impact on Trinitarian reection. Moral thinkers can point to Trinitarian faith as ultimate encouragement for those who cherish a true unity in diversity. The loving interrelatedness of the divine persons can vitalize human beings who seek the grounds for respecting one another and the natural world in a healing and wholesome way.
Trinitarian Persons
Trinitarian Persons
What Denes a person? A person is: Conscious Free
Conclusion
Text