Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
TITLE '
A Gritibal Analysis of the Operations of
the French 42d Division in the Battle of
Montdidler, 8 August 1918.
(Based primarily on a digest of "Montdidier"
by Colonel A. Grasset.)
Submitted by:
' T H I S SOLUTION MUST BE RETURNED FOR POWANSNT FILE DY 5:00'?>.M., OM THE DATS BUOZll L'ELO^. PLEACa PLACE \Q\1R IMk Oil COVO* *AG3 fcHOJ RE iirujnro FOR FILE BUT DO KOT PLACE YOUR KAIS1 ON SOLUTIOH'mm REQUSSTIKG A
MEMORANDUM FOR:
SUBJECT:
-A Crltibal ^ a l y s i s of the Operations of '"* ~ * 42d Di vis ion >in the Battle oi^ p!rimariiy on a digest of "Montdidier" by'Colbnel A. Graeset)
^ 8 ^ g u s t 1918. : .%;, .,. ^,%^,\
I.
PAPEHS ACCOMPANYING:
1. 2. 3. A Bibliography for this study.
Map sketones, numbered 1 to 14, lnolusive.f
Appendioee A, B , C , and D,
i <
"
The organi
\
of the regiments had three rifle and one maohine gun company.
Eaoh maohine gun company possessed four platoons, eaoh having
three maohine guns. 1) 2) Eaoh regiment had three 37 mm guns and six
-1
. . ' . . .
fled, in substanoe:
(1) The objeot of the operation is to relieve the
orltioal situation with respect to Amiens and the Pario-
Aaiens railroad, and also to defeat and drive baok the enemy
between the Soanne and Avre Rivers.
(2) The offensive, proteotad on the north by the Somme,
to be pushed as far as possible in the direction of Poye.
(3) The offensive to be executed by the British Fourth
Army and the Frenoh First Army, the former north of the Roye
road. and the latter south of 1t. (9)
Gra, Gra, Gra, Ora, Gra, XV; Trans, 60. 61, 62.
1; How, 262-255, 263-265, 275, 276, 268, 269.
1; How. 349
1 and 2; Trans 7,
2; Trans> 10-13.
- 3
- 4
, ' . . : ' , ' - < v '' , . : . \ . , ..;; . , , . ' ; . ' . ' ' ' ' : ; , ' . <
:
v
'
V . ' '
an3TTJ
"
of the approaching offensive, stated to the commanding gen eral of the 42d Division: "The affair ie taking quite
another ehap?. The English attack the Bois de Hangard.
For us it i'i a question of preparing the attaok against
Moreuil, but we will not be ready before the 29th. n (16)
As a result of the foregoing information the command ing general of the 42d Division oalled in his "division
infantry" and division artillery commanders. The "division
infantry" commander had already prepared a plan for the
attaok. This plan was briefly: A sudden attaok, at day light, without artillery preparation, but behind a rolling
barrage, with the 94th Infantry and 8th Battalion of Chas seurs in front line, and the 332d Infantry and 8th Battalion
of Chasseurs in seoond line. Line of departure about 200
meters from tho enemy outpost line of observation. (17)
Rivers, to oapture the heights between Moreuil and Villers aui-Erables, and push rapidly in the direotion of Hangest en-Santerre, Arville^s, and Roye. Having taken the western
part of the plateau of Snnterre, the army to advanoe on its
left, in liaison with the British. (80)
bourg" trenoh,
..;, .'-..'. ;< [ -, ; .'. .'. .. - ''- .. ..'...' . . . i...''-; ' , W : \ - . . ' : . / 1 i /
(27)
'"':
/';'i
' V
' y
''
; '
'
1*4)
(33) Or a, 45
, i
, - , f
From the line CD to the line HI was a bound of 2 kilo meters, to be executed, aooording to program, betwee. 5:23
' A , '
Dodu (whioh had not yet been oaptured by the Canadian Divi sion). This resistance was reduoed with no difficulty, and
the trenohes of Cecilie and Magdebourg were taken by out flanking them. The right battalion of the 94th Infantry
encountered strong enemy maohine gun resistance In front of
Bois de Moreuil* Thla resistance was also reduoed without
great difficulty.
The 8th Battalion of Chasseurs also enoountered machine
gun, and artillery fire from Bols de Moreuil. Although the
firing caused a great deal of confusion, the resistance, on
the whole, was not great, and by the effective use of machine
guns the battalion suooeeded in:outflanking the north corner
of Bols de Moreuil from the left. (45)
/
:
(Maps 8,9,10,11)
When the Infantry arrived on the line HI, the enemy was
no longer resisting, and the advanoe could have been pushed
forward had it not been for the fixed artillery barrage 300
Ora, 98-108, 111-119; Trans 92 and 93
Ora, 1C8-111, 119-188.
Gra, 111.
- 17
The
(48)
. ' .
Boia des Mouettes was taken! and the left of the battalion
advanced to the line JK, The right of the battalion skirted
the northeastern edge of the park of Viliers-aux-Erabies,
but by 10:00AM had been unable to reach the line JK because
of enemy machine gun fire from Mezieres.
The right (3d) battalion of the 94th advanced with the
mission of making a frontal attaok on Villers-aux-Erables,
assisted by British tanks. Early during Its advance it was,
for some minutes, under artillery fire coming from the rear,
presumably artillery of the 42d Division. With some confu sion, but with very little enemy resistance, the battalion
advanoed to within about 400 meters of Villers-aux-Erables,
where it met stronger/resistance in the form of machine gun
fire from the southwest part of the village and from the
park at the north. By the skillful use of machine guns the
left and center of the battalion were able to gain the eastern
edge of Villers-aux-Erables, where further progress was im possible on aocount of the machine gun fire from Mezieres.
The right of the battalion, caught by maohlne gun fire from
its front and right, was unable to advanoe past the southwest
corner of the village.
On the right of the 94th Infantry the 8th Battalion of
Chasseurs was stopped at about 400 meters from Bois du De by
rifle and machine gun fire coming from that locality* Unable
to advanoe it beoame badly mixed with elements of the 16th
Battalion of Chasseurs, (49)
the 1558, had ceased firing, and were either changing posi tlon or preparing to ohange position. The 220s continued
to fire on Fresnoy. Their fire was soon to cease, however,
sinoe they had readied the limit of their range and worn too
heavy to move forward.
Thus, at 10:00 AM *;he division was without artillery
support, since it hed not attained its prescribed objeotive.
(For dispositions of the division at 10-00 AM, sue
Map No. 10).
Between 10:00 AM and 11:00 AM, the leading battalion
of the 1st Moroccan Tirailleurs (of the 153d Division),
assisted the 94th Infantry by attacking Villers-aux-Erables
from the south. By about 11:00 AM both the village and the
park to the north were completely in the possession of the
division.
At 11:03 AM, the hour at which the 42d Division was
soheduled to reaoh the line LM, dispositions were as shown
on Map No. 11 (50)
'
..
'
V--.
11:30 AM the barrage was ageIn ordered back, held five min utes on the edge of Mezleres, and then fixed, until 12:15
PM on a line 300 meters east of Mezleres. At 12:15 PM, it
again advanoed.
Around noon, one battalion of the 94th Infantry and
the Moroccan battalion of the 153d Division assaulted
Mezleres. They found it deserted by the enemy. (51)
outposts were engaged along the Avre River with other troops;
and finally the leat reserves of the German 192d Division,
all available troops of which were fighting toward Moreuil.
Toward noon the remnants of the 4th Bavarian Infantry
. . . .
:
.... '''' . > : ' < \ U \ . . .', : . < ' V / : : . - , . ' ! " > . '' ' :
<
'
"
'
* .
<
'
',
'
>
'
'
' ,
of the 42d Division! and the two battalions of the 1st Moroo can Tirailleurs which were participating in the attack of the
42d Division,, were grouped as shown on Map No* 13. (53)
At 3:10 PM the commanding general of the 42d Division
had received an order, by telephone, from the XXXI Corps, in
substance, as follows:
"By order of the army commander the XXXI Corps will
push on this evening: - the 42d Division from Fresnoy-en-
Chaussee on Arvillers; the 153d from Hangest on Erchers; the
37th from Plessier on Bois des Corettes and the crest south
of Arvillers. It is absolutely necessary that the XXXI
Corps* reach the front of Arvillers this evening."
"Do not reassemble on successive lines, but push for ward without halting.n
The commander of the 42d Division sent a message at
once to his "division infantry** commander to push on toward '
Arvillere as soon as Fresnoy had been taken. The message
was followed by the following division order, issued at 3:50 PM.
"I. The 42d Division reoelves the order to push for The artillery of the 42d Division will support
the infantry, when the movement on Arviiiere Is resumed*
II. At night-fall the "division infantry" oommander
<
The Germans were completely surprised by the attack on 8 August. (60) However, a fog or haze on the morning of the (61) attaok covered the Initial movements of the division. Tactics; Tactical operations as laid down in the directives of
12 July 1918 were carried out.
It is to be noted-that the outflanking of an obstaole
was the general procedure throughout the day, and that machine
gun fire was constantly being used to overcome resistance
that was holding up the advanoe.
The attaok on the flank of the Moreuil salient took in
flank three German divisions, surprising these divisions by
the direction of the attaok. (62) This would indicate that
a salient may be dangerous unless properly held.
In the attack of woods the procedure of the 42d Division
was to outflank it. This procedure was effective in the case
of woods of small area. Against woods of relatively large
area, it would appear that the woods must, in addition, be
assaulted and penetrated. (63)
Twice during the days operations, units of the 42d Divi sion continued their efforts beyond the objectives assigned.
This prooedure runs the risk of plaoing the higher commander
in the position of being unable to control his units in combat;
on the other hand, it takes advantage of the opportunity to
gain further suooess. (64) Acts of initiative were formally
encouraged by the division oommander. (65)
60] 61 .* * 63 64 (65] Ore., 90; Hiri. 395| Bal, 287
Ora, 95 and 96j Lud, 327; Bal, 287
Ora, 249
Ora, 252
ura, con
fir* a 253
Ora, 2Rft
Ora, 72
- 28
. . i.
',
- \ A
;,,
:,
Up to 7:00 A the; powerful artillery support of the M division had conquered the terrain, and the infantry had l i t t l e to do but march. (68) However, the plan of artillery The rolling barrage con This might have been support was lacking in flexibility.
tinued to advance regardless of the looation of the Infantry, leaving the artillery without support. avoided by 66) Ora, 67 Ora, 68) Ora, having some light artillery in direct support of 265
251 and 862
110
-31
B I D L I O b U f H T
-32
R g rB ag N 0g
A, ,B B R g V I A T I 0 N 3
7. Trant - Daillt U: "La Dataille d Uontdiiier n , translation by Major W. R. Wheeler, 8, Pet - Petaln'e Report,
-33
A P P E N D I C E S Appendix A.
4 August 1918
- '64
* * * *
* *
Appendix B
A. ATTACK ORDER OF FRENCH 42d DIVISION: XXXI Corps 42d Infantry Division
3d Section.
Speoial Order No. 524
(Only Speoial Orders copied by officers
to be sent to lower echelons)
ABSOLUTE SECRECY
I. Information of the enemy: See special bulletin.
II. ObjeoV of the operation:
1. The XXXI Army Corps will attaok on D-day in
order to capture the heights of Bois de Moreuil. It will
carry on its attack on Kezieres and the Bois de Genouville
and continue Its offensive in the direction of Hangest-en-
Santerre. Moreuil will be reduced by being outflanked.
The XXI Corps will be flanked:
(a) On the left, by a British division which
will attaok north of the road: Amlens-Roye.
(b) On the right, by the IX Corps which will
attaok against Saint-Ribert and Braches. General direotion:
Hangest-en-Sariterre.
2* Suooessive intermediate objectives:
"First Intermediate objeotive: Exit of Bois
de Moreuil on plateau 104, the capture of the woods being
' . . ' : ,
l i ; : ;
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
>
'
'
'
.-
'
<
'
'
'
A ' \
In addition:
7 battalions of 75 mm
3 battalions of 155 howitzers
4 battalions of 220 rapid-fire
Special artillery: 1 battalion
(b) Positions:
Initial Situation:
- 40
Berteaucourt Ravin Titus Ravin Hlppolyte 75 155 How 820 Rapid Fire 8 bns 1 bn 1 bn 5 bns 8 bns 8 bns 3 bns 1 bn 1 bn
220B,,
and "Oretenen".
i \ '
VIII.
f
Cavalry:
The division squadron (returned to Bois Jeanne
General D e v i l l e , commanding 42d Division DEVILLE (2) Ora, 28, 29, 30, 31, 33 / - 43 (S)
Thennes -- Villers-aux-ttrables
The 3d regiment
The' 14th Bavarian Division, in seo'tor since 24 July with the 4th, 8th, and 25th Bavarian regiments, extends to Moreuii, inoiusiveV according to declarations of prisoners.
" . ' .
.'
' '
j > v : ' -
"
" '
"
/ .
' . . . .
'
;.
'
',.
. . . . "
'
. , '
''''.!.
. ' .
. ' / V / . .
Appendix C
CHANGES IN ATTACK ORDER (SPECIAL ORDEK NO.524)
OF 42d DIVISION:
XXXI Corps 42d Division Staff, 3d Seotion Changes In Speolel Order No. 524. C.P., 6 August 1918, 6:00 PM
of Bo is de Moreull.
II. Par.llV.
- 47
Appendix D
A. SPECIAL ORDER NO. 423, XXXI CORPS.
XXXI Corps,
D-day
8 August
H-hour= 4^20 AM
The advanoed CP of the XXXI Corps (general, staff, 2d
and 3d seotiona) will function at Bel Air farm today, be ginning at 10:00 PM. Easerteaux.
Acknowledge reoeipt by telephone, on reoeipt of present
dooument.
By order: JOYBKRT (5)
The staff (1st seotlon) remains at
- 50
1B too "dangerous.
The general commanding the 42d Division
DEVILLE (6)