Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
com/
Published by:
http://www.sagepublications.com
On behalf of:
Additional services and information for Journal of Histochemistry & Cytochemistry can be found at: Email Alerts: http://jhc.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts Subscriptions: http://jhc.sagepub.com/subscriptions Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
Cytochemistry Society.
No.
5, pp.
Original
Article
Histochemical
GEORGE B. KOELLE,2
Demonstration
NAGENDRAN
of Neurotoxic
MATTHEW S. HAN,
Esterase
S. THAMPI,
and
Department Received
EUGENE
J.
OLAJOS3
Medical August 17, School, 1988 and University in revised ofPennsylvania, form November 14, Philadelphia,
1988;
accepted
for localizing neurophenylvalerate (PV)hydrolyzing esterase that is resistant 40 tM paraoxon to (A) but inactivated by paraoxon plus 0 iM impafox 5 (B). NTh is considered to be the target enzyme in the production
method as the
A but not in B. In the central nervous system chicken, NTh appeared to be present primarily mata of most neurons, but at sites indistinguishable those of the other inhibitor.resistant and -sensitive
in
thyl
guished
valerate-hydrolyzing
in the CNS of
esterases.
cat, probably
of organophosphorus
(OPIDN). Cryostat
ester-induced
delayed
neurotoxicity
taming
m-toluidine
a-naphthyl
the
with tivity.
sections were incubated in a medium convalerate and 6-benzamido-4-methoxydiazonium chloride (fast violet B) after treatment above-mentioned inhibitors, leading to formation
in the
1989)
CNS
system;
valerate; Neurotoxic
Cat;
nervous
Chicken;
esterase
Organophos-
of an aqueous
NTh
insoluble
activity was
precipitate
estimated
at sites
as staining
of enzymatic
detectable
ac- phates;
in(OPIDN).
Organophosphorus
ester-induced
delayed
neurotoxicity
Introduction
Organophosphorus ester-induced produced by certain delayed neurotoxicity compounds of that (OPIDN) category.
activity by 50 tM
is resistant DFP
to (diisopropyl
both
these
agents
but
is largely As with
inactivated most
phosphorofluoridate).
the not
substrate purified,
of NTh isolated,
is unknown.
by sequential
and flaccid is completely
development
paralysis unrelated after to
of axonal
a latent the
degeneraperiod
anticholinesterase
(Zech and Chemnitius, 1987). of We have sought to develop ization central of the ofNTE. nervous cat, Some success system (CNS) for the
(anti-ChE)
of human
action
OPIDN
of such
have
compounds.
been reported,
Several
usually
extensive
resulting
outbreaks
from
the
contamination
phate. (1981) The and Zech its
of beverages
subject and biochemical has been
or cooking
reviewed
oil with
thoroughly (1987).
triorthocresyl
by
phos-
probably
Abou-Donia
Chemnitius basis
Although
is still
unproven,
one
ofthe
most
generally
by lation) of
considered
neurotoxic
proposals
and esterase
at present
subsequent (NTh)
is that
aging Uohnson,
OPIDN
(partial 1969, as
is caused
dealky1977). the
determinations
Phenylvalerate and
alkylphosphorylation
by the
enzyme phenylvalerate
has
been
defined
empirically esterase
point,
(PV)-hydrolyzing
to 40 p.tM
WI)
paraoxon (0,0-diethyl-0-p-nitrophenyl phosphate; activated by paraoxon plus 50 sM mipafox fluorophosphorodiamide). An additional fraction
Ash
MO).
Stevens
Inc (Detroit,
was
MI).
obtained nerve,
a-Naphthyl
from ileum) were
valerate,
Sigma first
for the
Co with
subsequent
(St. scissors;
histochemical Certain
Chemical minced
Supported To whom US
by
Contract
Department
of
the
were homogenized in a motor-driven glass-glass homogenizer, in icc-cold buffer (50 mM Tris-0.2 mM EDTA, pH 8.0), 1 g wet weight tissue/SO ml. The homogenate was strained through one layer ofsurgical gauze, and 0.5ml aliquots final was were concentrations omitted, and added to of: 2 ml (a) of identical (b) blank blank buffer (d) (e), containing inhibitors sM homogsubsequent in zero, a reagent 40 paraoxon, .tM from
Army.
2
addressed. Engineering
and
from
(c)40
which
3 Present
Center,
paraoxon
enate
a homogenate
which
589
590
KOELLE,
THAMPI,
HAN,
OLAJOS
of
phenyl done
valerate in duplicate.
was The
omitted, mixtures
were were
included. incubated
All for
determinaexactly
mm at 37C with shaking. To each tube was then added ml of phenyl 2.5 valerate reagent (9 mg phenyl valerate dissolved 1.0 ml dimethylformain
mide
2.5
(Paraoxon and DFP were prepared as stock solutions in anhydrous acetone and propylene 20 glycol, respectively, and held in desiccators in the refrigerator for a maximum of weeks; 4 mipafox was prepared as an aqueous solution extemporaneously.) After two brief rinses in 0.9% NaCl, slides were
for 1 hr in the pH minute hood, then for a-NV and addition jars allowed jelly or hourly. to dry Permount immersed 1-4 (0.1 ofa-NV the slides After and hr: ml P/B, the were removal, examined. in the 40 in 20 ml following mg; 50 mM was Slides were were (The they They incubation Tris-0.2 somM (What. placed briefly mounted is at room One temperature 8.0, 32 ml; after Coplin and
plus were
30 ml 0.03%
0.3
for the
ml ofcold
in
M pcrchloric
cooled the
in cold,
for 10 mm
after
supernatants
solution added.
2 ml in immediate the
No. 1) into
incubation water in in final kidney, distilled
thorough
solution
overnight.
in a Beckman by plotting
was obtained
after
tical
reaction
with
with
those
aminoantipyrinc
described above.
and
ofchickcn
was employed in nine experiments with serial 5ccandtwo each with chicken spinal cord, sciatic nerve,
liver. Serial sections of cat CNS were studied in five
procedures that have been used for loexperiments. In each experiment a total of 16 slides, containing three to calization and Backing,1976; Pcarsc, 1973), the highly six sections each, were stained. sensitive, simultaneous coupling a.zo dye methods appeared to be the most By definition, NTh activity was estimated as staining detectable after promising. This approach was introduced by Menten ct(1944) for localal. pre-incubation in B but not in C; A shows all a-NV-hydrolyzing esterases; ization of alkaline phosphatase, and was first applied to carboxylic acid D shows a-NV-hydrolyzing esterases resistant to all three inhibitors, including csterases by Nachlas and Seligman (1949). Since then many improvements DFP and modifications have been proposed. a-Naphthyl esters generally are employed as substrates, because a-naphthol rapidly forms insoluble precipiHistochemical. tates with the diazonium salts of several amines. The disadvantage of this
Of the ofcstcrases(Deimling
several
method in the present case that hen brain has been shown is to hydrolyze a-naphthyl valcratc (a-NV) at only one sixth the velocity for PV, and the Quantitative paraoxon-rcsistant, mipafox-sensitive portion constitutes only of the 5% In the CNS ofthe chicken, the proportion ofPV-hydrolyzing activtotal in contrast to50% reported for PV Uohnson, 1975a). Twenty-one diazonium salts, all purchased from Sigma. were tested as ity designated as NTh was found to constitute approximately 6% coupling agents in histochemical experiments with chicken spinal cord orof the total (Table 1). As noted previously with respect to the hubrain similar to those described below. The list, with catalog (1987) numman brain (Lotti and)ohnson, 1980), there was no significant differbets, included: fist black K (7253), fast blue BB (3378), f.st blue RR (0500), ence between various regions. The values obtained here are approxfast bordeaux (1005), fast corinth V (6383), fast dark blue R (0750), fast imately half those reported by Novak and Padilla (1986) and garnet GBC (6504), fastorange GR (3137), fast red AL (5002), fast red B considerably lower than those found byJohnson (1975b) and Reveley (3262), fast red 3GL (0380), fast red (1375), ITR fast red KL (8379), fast et al. (1986); the reasons for these discrepancies are not apparent. red PDC (6876), fast red RC (2256), fast red RI. (1630), fast red TR (6760), The sciatic nerve was found to contain less than half the NTh acfast red violet LB(3381), fast scarlet GG (9379), fast scarlet R(1880), and tivity of the CNS. In the non-neural parenchymatous tissues anafast violet B (1631). The most satisfactory appeared to be the last mentioned, lyzed (ileum, kidney, liver), the PV-hydrolyzing activity two was which is chemically 6-benzamido-4-mcthoxy-m-toluidine diazonium chloride (fast violet B salt; P/B). This is consistent with the rating given for three to times that of the brain but only traces ofNTE activity were
this compound ofacid ofincubation; among 23 tested by Pcarsc Other mounting (1973), variables media. After as a coupling tested included agent fixatives for found. localization phosphatases. and
Results
and
conditions
of fixation;
concentrations
of reagents;
pH;
time
and
tern- of
experi-
cat ranged
between
only
1-3%
peraturc
29 preliminary
ments with serial sections of chicken spinal cord and seven with chicken brain, the following procedure was adopted. Histochemical The brain and spinal cord ofRhodc Island Red hens weighing 1.5-2.5 Figure 1 illustrates at low magnification kg (decapitated) and cats (sacrificed by means of sodium pentobarbital, employed on the total 50 mg/kg, iv, followed by thoracotomy) were removed and sectioned im- the inhibitors sections ofchicken cervical spinal cord. mediately or after a few days storage at - 70C. Sections were cut at 20 am in a cryostat and placed on slides coated with bovine 2% serum albuincubation for 4 hr resulted in intense mm the previous day. After drying for approximately 1 hr, slides were im-in what appeared to be the penikarya
messed in unbuffered 1% formaldehydc/0.9% NaCI at 5C for higher degree 10 mm and
effects
of
in crossesterase
the
axons
central
gray
matter
(Figure
1A).
all neurons in portions of their the white in this restaining were arteries, ad-
rinsed
ing
twice for 10 mm
in contrast
in cold 0.9%
sections; activity.) After drying
NaCI.
(This
distinctly
fixation, limited
improved caused
to unfixed of enzyme
concentrations of fixation
of formaldehyde,
inhibition
of glutaraldehyde structural
could sometimes be followed for short distances into matter adjacent to the anterior horns; however, staining
and
gion occurred
was
not in and
the prolonged
sarily compromised.
preservation
temperature,
pia-arachnoid
1 hr at room
for 20 mm at 37C in the following solutions, containing A, control; B, 40 isM paraoxon; C, 40 iM paraoxon plus 50 D, 40 tM paraoxon plus 50 piM mipafox plus 50laM DFP
HISTOCHEMISTRY
OF
NEUROTOXIC
ESTERASE
591
Table
Species
1.
Total
PV-hydrolyzing
Tissue
and
NTh
activities
Number of
oftissues
ofchicken
Total (smolIg
wet
and
PY-esterase
cat
Percent
NTE5
weight/mm) 0.33 0.25 0. 18 0.22 0.14 0.75 1.64 0.01 0.25 0. 12 0.52
0.15
NTh/total
Chicken
cortex
2.99 2.85 1 .97 2.19 1.20 1.84 5.82 5.00 6.17 1.97 1.43 0.68
equivalent to the range.
0. 170 0.188 0. 113 0.148 0.074 0.037 0.002 0.038 0.020 0.042 0.042
0.009
0.044
0.050
5.7 6.6 .8 6.8 6.2 2.0 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 2.1 2.9 1.3
0.018 0.016 0.010 0.019 0.002 0.004 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.001
cord
Sciatic
Ileum Kidney Liver
nerve
Cat
3 3
2 SEM
cord
-
SEM
to
ld21n
40 sM
(n paraoxon;
1)]#{189}; where
2,
is
inhibited
by
paraoxon
plus
50
sM
mipafox.
sites;
there
was
a distinct
further
reduction
after
treatment
lining with
cells,
heavy
staining
throughout
the
submucosa, muscle; As
(Figure detectable
rons of
staining
Auerbachs
ofthe
plexus
circular
were
and longitudinal
faintly stained.
non-neural minimal
tissues concentrations
(NTh) in
contain
comparison
high
of PVtissues.
PV-esterase
treatment
In the
tions to able in
cat,
any
no consistent and
several ofthe
differences C (paraoxon
regions ofthe
be detected mipafox-treated)
examined.
with slides
the
inhibitors
could In
examined
distribution and
of NTh (by definition, be identical with that esterases. The same stem, cerebral where staining progressively in D, but with
NTh in the
activity accat is a be
was true for the many cortex, and cerebellum of neuronal perikarya
areas of the medulla, brain- not distinct that were studied. In all cases,differential distinguishable. was intense in became it A usually Two as barely examples the fairly detectable are illusnervi stain- Discussion ester- The main the distribution
trated. As shown in Figure 3, identified hypoglossi ofthe medulla (Yoshikawa, 1968a), ing
ases)
of neurons
and less
is detectable
intense staining
in B (paraoxon-resistant
in C (paraoxon and
conclusion ofNTE
to of the
be
the
present and
mipafox-resistant
in the esterases.
chicken
a-NV
same
esterases),
comparisons
the
are
distribution
noted in Figure
ofstaining
4, B and
is identical.
C, identified
a-NV-hydrolyzing of these
nucleus to the
1968b), nucleus
et al., 1936). Staining of the but variable; here, tween B and C. Non-neural the a-NV same procedure esterase
By means of iterative elimination of superposed which is roughly equiva- able. curves with paraoxon, mipafox, and DFP, of mammals (Ariens Kap-inhibition and Zech (1983a) have demonstrated that hen brain was could extremely be detected stained staining
isoenzymes; NTh was identified as numbers 2 and light PV-hydrolyzing 3. approach (Chemnitius and Zech, 1983b) indicated that be- A similar primate brain contains eight such carboxylesterase isoenzymes, 3 is probably studies nervous ofthe system NTh. distribution of carboxylesterhave shown them to be lo-
of the
among which number by histochemical for Earlier marked, ases in the peripheral
staining in B and C after or 1 cells were stained uniformly. of most ileum tubule cells intense and exhibited
incubation.
The lighter
cated largely in the microsomes and endoplasmic reticulum of the perikarya (reviewed by Thomas, 1977), which is consisshowed neuronal tent with the present interpretation. It can be assumed that from of the epithelial these sites NTh and the other carboxylesterases are transported
staining
592
KOELLE, THAMPI,
HAN,
OLAJOS
iiJ
,;.
.1I
Figure 1. Transverse 2O-tm for 20 minutes at 37#{176}C with plus mipafox plus 50 sM DFR change can be detected in
sections of cervical spinal cord of chicken stained by incubation for 4 hr at 20#{176}Ca solution in containing a-NV plus RIB. Prior treatment the following inhibitors, from lower left, clockwise: (A) none; (B) 40 RM paraoxon; (C) paraoxon tM plus 50 mipafox; (D) paraoxon NTE is identified as staining detectable in B minusthat in C. Although staining is progressively lighter in A through D, no qualitative its distribution. Original magnification x 27. Bar tm. = 500
HIS1OCHEMISTRY
OF NEUROTOXIC
ESTERASE
593
..,
.-,
Figure
2.
Higher
magnification
of identical
regions
of the
anterior
horn
as shown
in sections
in Figure
lA-iD.
Original
magnification
594
KOELLE,
THAMPI,
HAN,
OLAJOS
Figure a Similarly stained sections of nucleus nervi hypoglossi ofthe chicken; B and C as in Figure 1. CV, cresyl violet. Original magnification x 27. Bar= 500 m.
HISTOCHEMISTRY
OF NEUROTOXIC
ESTERASE
595
Figure
4.
Similarly
stained
sections
of the
nucleus
isthmi
of the
chicken;
B and
C as in Figure
1. Original
magnification
x =
throughout the axon and dendrites. Recent evidence axonal rather than perikaryonal NTh is the target tion of OPIDN (Caroldi
(1977)
et
al.,
1984).
kinase indicates that protein site for produc- and Chemnitius, The present valuable
NTh appears to
may
be combined
in a single of the
macromolecule localization
alternative
(Zech of NTE
1987). demonstration
be more consistent
non-selective
with these
proposals
with
that
of the of
direct OPIDN.
role
of the
empirically
defined
production
ofcertain central
the
compounds, returns
period
NTh
of
activity normal
motor
system
latent
practically
before
to the that
Nicholas
D.
Gonatas
in interpreting the
some
ofthe
slides
W thank
CindiPatillofortyping
manuscript.
function
appear;
other
compounds
produce
near-
OPIDN (Johnson, 1975b). Literature Cited only by organophosphates Abou-Donia MD (1981): Organophosphorus ester.induced delayed neuthat undergo aging, or loss of an alkyl group from the phos-rotoxicity. Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol 21:511 phorylated enzymatic site. These observations have led to more reAriens Kappers CV, Huber CG, Crosby EC (1936): The comparative anatcent proposals that alkylphosphorylation ofNTE is only the initial omy of the nervous system ofvertebrates including man. 2.Vol New York, step that culminates in OPIDN, or that it is paralleled by the phos- Macmillan, 1170 phorylation of some other enzyme or macromolecule that is directly Caroldi 5, Lotti M, Masutti A (1984): Intra-arterial injection of diisopropylresponsible for the production ofOPIDN (Lotti et al., 1984;John. tluorophosphate or phenylmcthanesulfonyl fluoride produces unilateral neuor protection, respectively, in hens. Biochem Pharmacol 33:3213 son, 1980). It has also been suggested that NTh and an essential ropathy
596
KOELLE,
THAMPI,
HAN,
OLAJOS
Chemnitius 3M, Zech R (1983a): Inhibition of brain carboxylcstcrases by neurotoxic and non-neurotoxic organophosphorus compounds. Mol Pharmacol 23:717 Arch ChemnitiusJM,
acterization Deimling of OV,
Lotti Mjohnson (1978): MK Neurotoxicity predictions can be based onstudies in vitro Toxicol 41:215
Menten ML,JungeJ, phosphatase MM, Cancer for alkaline Nachlas j NatI
oforganophosphorus
with hen and human
pesticides:
enzymes.
Zech
multiple Bocking
R (1983b):
forms. A
Carboxylesterases
brain:
histochemical
azo
dye
mt
J Biochem
Esterases
the in
kidney.
J Biol
Histochem
(1976): 8:215 J
(1949): histochemical
MK (1980): MK (1977):
Neurotoxicity:
mechanisms
explored
and
exploited.
Novak R, Padilla S (1986): Anin vitro comparison neurotoxic esterase. Fundam Appl Toxicol
Pearse AGE (1973): Histochemistry.
ofrat
and
chicken
brain
6:464
Theoretical and applied. Vol 2. 3rd
Improved
for delayed
assay
of neurotoxic
potential.
esterase
Arch
for screening
Toxicol 37:113
organophosphatcs
neurotoxicity
ed. Edinburgh, Churchill Livingstonc, 761 for substrates and inPharmacol 24:797 RcveleyJW, Sabourin TD, Moore MT. Goss
organoToxicol rotoxic 3:289
LB(1986):
Distribution
of ncuphos-
MK (1975b): The
esters: mechanism
delayed
and
caused by some
CRC Crit Rev
challenge.
esterase activicy in the brain of control phorofluoridate-treatedhens: in vivo and in v#{252}m exposure. Histochemic der Enzyme
Organophosphorus
ofaction
Toxsity
in peripheren
Gustav
Press, F25 Atlas
Fischer
Verlag,
47,
62
animals. Tokyo,
ofdomcstic
Univer-
Johnson MK(1969): The delayed neurotoxic effrct compounds identification of the phosphorylation chem J 114:711
Lotti M, Becker CE, Aminoff
ofsome
organophosphorus
thy:
Lotti
pathogenesis
M,Johnson 34:747
and
F17,F18
(1987):
Neurotoxicant oforganophosphorus
29:193
sensitive
esterase. ester-induced
MK (1980): Neurotoxic
tissue.
J Neurochem