Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Mark Setch
Peace Christian Community Redcliffe, Qld, Australia
Introduction
It is clear from the way that Paul addressed his letters that he saw one church in each city. He wrote to the church of God in Corinth, and to the church of the Thessalonians.12 The only place where the plural is used is when he wrote to the churches in Galatia.3 Galatia was a region, not a city, so it can be assumed that, consistent with his other letters, that there was one church in each of the cities within the region of Galatia. The expression of One City-One Church makes perfect sense when seen in light of Pauls image of the Church as the fullness of Christ. The letter to the Ephesians is a powerful treatise on the Church as fullness. In this paper I will examine how the institutional, franchised church is at odds with this vision of the Church, as defined by Paul and consistent with the life and ministry of Jesus. Some of the shifts that need to take place to develop more organic, non-franchised expressions of the church will be articulated.
It is one thing for the Christians in Ephesus to understand who they are in Christ and what He has done for them. However, it is critical that they understand their relationship with Christ is not something they live out in isolation. Rather as followers of Christ, they are part of a universal community of believers known as the Church. Paul likens the relationship between the ascended Christ and His earthly followers as that of a head and a body. A body cannot survive unless it is connected to a head. It will quickly die. Similarly, a head without a body is useless. For the ascended Christ to continue his ministry on earth, He needs a body. When Jesus walked the earth He shared the Good News with people: the Kingdom of God is at Hand7. He called people back to the Word of God, and taught them life-giving truth. He demonstrated the Kingdom through His indiscriminate love for all people who were lost to God. Jesus accepted and welcomed people that others rejected, such as children, women, people or other races and cultures, those who were sinners and who were unclean. As signs of the Kingdom He ministered healing and deliverance and performed all kinds of miracles. He genuinely cared for people, showing compassion in word and deed. Jesus death didnt spell the end of this ministry. Rather it heralded the expansion of His ministry. The risen Christ, before ascending to heaven to sit at the right hand of the Father, commissioned His disciples to continue to do what He had been doing. They would preach repentance and forgiveness of sins to all nations,8 and signs would follow their preaching.9 These disciples would continue to do all that he had taught and trained them to do, and they would in turn equip others to do it: they would make disciples of all nations.10 Jesus ministry would continue long after he left the planet. However, as His physical body was no longer on earth, He needed a body to continue His ministry He needed a heart to love, a voice to proclaim and teach; hands and feet to care for and guide lost people back to the Father. Jesus followers would collectively be this body11, and they would be called the Church. The body would be connected to the ascended Christ, the supreme authority, the head, through the indwelling Holy Spirit,12 who would guide13and empower14 them to continue Jesus ministry of proclaiming and demonstrating the Kingdom of God on earth. How is this ministry expressed? By filling every sphere of creation with the fullness of Jesus Christ the fullness of him who fills everything in every way15.
7 8
Matthew 4:17, Mark 1:15. Luke 24:47; John 20:21-23 9 Mark 16:15-18 10 Matthew 28:18-20 11 1 Corinthians 12:12-31 12 Ephesians 1:13, 3:16 13 John 16:13 14 Acts 1:8 15 Ephesians 1:23, Colossians 1:19-20
This is a defining statement in Pauls letter to the Ephesians. The Church that Jesus came to create, inaugurated at Pentecost, is a Spirit-filled body of believers who will be Gods instrument to bring His Kingdom to the world by filling every sphere of creation with the fullness of Jesus Christ.
Filling everything in every way means that marriages, families, neighbourhoods, workplaces, schools, community gatherings, cities, regions, and nationsevery place and every gatheringis filled with the fullness of Jesus. What a vision! This is the vision that we have been entrusted to pursue as Jesus says GO.and make disciples of all nations..16 The New Testament vision of church cannot abide any false dichotomy between church and world. Rather, it affirms a seamless flow between church and world, through Jesus being represented in every sphere. Conversely, much of what we have known as church for at least the last 1700 years operates within such a dichotomy to varying degrees. Instead of a Spirit filled body filling the world with the fullness of Jesus, church has often been deemed to be separate from the world; taking people out of the world, and keeping them busy through maintaining buildings, clergy, institutions, and programs. I refer to this as Churchworld.
2.
16
Matthew 28:18-20
Fantasyworld. Churchworld must also stay on the edge with new programs and services. Once, Churchworld members would keep showing up even if the old routines prevailed, but not anymore. 3. Fantasyworld continues to exist because a dedicated team works tirelessly to keep everything running smoothly, to ensure the thousands of visitors each week get good value for their entrance fee and go home happy. The Fantasyworld staff are always under pressure, because if the spectators arent happy, they will vote with their feet. No spectators = no money = no jobs. Churchworld is typically run by a small group of staff, either paid or voluntary, but usually a combination of both. They work hard to ensure the many weekly members/spectators are happy. Churchworld staff are often under a great deal of pressure to perform. If they dont perform, Churchworld spectators may withdraw their weekly membership fees and go to another branch of Churchworld, where they are better fed and get something out of the worship. Fantasyworld is a mega world, which draws visitors away from the smaller worlds which cannot offer the same range and quality of entertainment options due to their smaller financial bases. Smaller theme parks have closed or are barely surviving. Similarly, many smaller branches of Churchworld have closed or are in serious decline. Some survive only because their branch headquarters keep them afloat by liquidating assets. Mega Churchworld, on the other hand, appears to be booming. However, even many of these mega churches are finding it an enormous challenge to stay on the edge, as hardened Mega Church junkies flit from church to church, comparing different varieties of Mega Churchworld, to see which offers better value for money. Fantasyworld provides an escape from the real world. Life is not one big holiday, even though sometimes we wish it were. For most people, there is very little connection between life inside the Fantasyworld gates compared with life outside. Similarly, for many people, Churchworld does not have a great deal of connection with the rest of their lives. The church meetings, programs, activities, and sub-cultural ethos and language have little connection to work, family and community life.
4.
5.
This analogy is in no way intending to question the validity or integrity of any church or pastor. Nor is it casting dispersions on any one type or expression of church. If I was to define Churchworld I would say it refers to:
an overarching mindset and structure that predisposes congregations, denominations, house churches, ministry networks, and mission organisations to give priority to building, maintaining, and defending their distinctive expression of church. This is over and against the local, regional, national and global expression of the body of Christ.
There are many expressions of church in this construct that the Lord has used, and still is using in powerful ways to bring about His purposes here on earth. However, just because God is blessing something, we cannot assume that it is the most effective way of accomplishing what He wants to accomplish. It is too easy to conclude that because people are getting saved, healed and set free, that everything is OK. We conclude God is blessing the ministry, so its OK. But we need to
remember that it is in the very nature of God to bless people and ministries whose desire is to serve Him. Does this in turn mean that the structure or construct is the most effective means of accomplishing the purposes of God? Lets ask some different questions: - Is the way we are doing church effective in responding to the Great Commission? - Is the way we are doing church consistent with the New Testament vision of church?17 Yes, there are amazing things happening in and through many institutional churches of all sizes and shapes throughout the world. Wherever peoples hearts are open to God and the ministry of His Spirit, they will see His presence manifest and signs of His Kingdom, regardless of the label on the church door. However, the great stuff that is happening must be evaluated in perspective. In 2000 years of Christendom, what percentage of the worlds population have become followers of Christ? What percentage of people in our cities and nations are Christians? Do our cities and nations reflect more of the values and ethos of the Kingdom of God? Are there a greater number of stronger marriages and families? Is their less crime? Is their less poverty and injustice in the world? In spite of the tireless efforts of millions and millions of Christians who, in the last 2000 years, have faithfully served Jesus until their dying day, we have not seen lasting, growing transformation. In spite of the many revivals and reformation movements which had significant impact, in the big picture of things they have not resulted in a Church which looks more like Jesus and a world that looks more like Gods Kingdom. So long as we remain in Churchworld, we can never fully represent Jesus in cities and regions and nations in the way that He intended. Why? Because Churchworld affirms the false dichotomy between church and world, which is, and remains at odds with the biblical vision of a Spirit filled body, filling the world with the fullness of Jesus, representing Jesus in every sphere. Churchworld is the Old Testament Model re-badged. It is the Old Testament Temple reinvented. We have special buildings, special priests - clergy which are given various names, special seasons, etc. The church that Jesus came to create is a body of people18, a temple of living stones19, built by Jesus, on the foundation of the apostles and prophets with Jesus as the cornerstone.20 Churchworld is built on human wisdom and agendas, and as such is so often driven by the motivation to get people into the church. Conversely, Jesus commissioned us to take the church into the world21. Churchworld members often worry that the world will change the church. A Spirit-filled body, representing Jesus in every sphere, is a vision and expression of church that will change the world!
I say vision rather than pattern or blueprint, to avoid getting into fruitless debate over the role of elders, bishops, deacons, etc 18 1 Corinthians 12:12-27; Ephesians 1:22-23 19 1 Peter 2:5 20 Matthew 16:18; Ephesians 2:20 21 Isaiah 54:2 reads enlarge the site of your tent. Let the curtains of your habitation be stretched out. Lengthen the cords; strengthen the stakes. You dont enlarge a tent by cramming more people into it, but by lengthening the cords to expand it out.
17
Churchworld renders impossible the biblical vision of one church in the city. For example, I live in a small city of 60 000 people. There are around 30 Christian Church congregations in this city, representing at the most 6 percent of the total population, as a very conservative estimate. I would say that the churches in this city own at least $40 million worth of property at current values22. In addition to this, more than $3 million would be spent each year maintaining these systems: pastors wages, building maintenance, insurance, legals, consumables, etc. at least. So, we have $40 million of infrastructure, and say $3 million annual investment, to influence 6 percent of the population. There is something very wrong with this equation! This way of being church, which carves a city up into local churches whose first loyalty is to the congregation and the franchise i.e. the denomination/network over the city/regional church will thwart the synergy that would be released through a citywide vision. What we currently know and experience is Churchworld. It is church in institutional entrapment. God is graciously showing up here, because Godly people are worshipping, praying and serving Him. They are also investing a huge amount of time and effort in maintaining Churchworld, while a large percentage of the population and the various spheres of the cities in which we live are untouched by the Gospel and Kingdom values. In light of this, we see the contemporary implications of the words of the prophet Haggai: you expected much, but it turned out to be little. What you brought home, I blew away. Why? declares the Lord Almighty. Because of my house, which remains a ruin, while each of you is busy with his own house. Haggai 1:9
However, imagine if the people of God within our cities, instead of being so busy in the local congregations, gave priority to connecting with all believers in the spheres of life that we are part thereof. Imagine if we came together to be church in that sphere, to worship, pray, and respond to the question: how can we represent Jesus in this street, workplace, school and/or community group? Is this not a far more accurate expression of the church as the fullness of Jesus as articulated by Paul in Ephesians 1:22-23?
Can this happen? Can we again see a configuration of one church in the city, aimed at filling all spheres of the life of that city with the fullness of Jesus Christ? As we continue to work our way through the letter to the Ephesians, we read that Paul has given specific details of how the Church the body of Christ is to express the fullness of Jesus in the world. Here we find a blue print for developing organic non-franchising expressions of the Church in the city.
22
This refers to worship auditoriums and related buildings only. If we add to this church owned and run schools and retirement villages, the value is well over $150 million.
23 24
Ephesians 2:12-15 Ephesians 2:8-9 25 Ephesians 2:19-22; 1 Peter 2:4-10 26 Revelation 11:15 27 Revelation 21:3 28 Matthew 18:20 29 John 14:12
30 31
e.g. Matthew 9:9-12; Luke 19:1-10; John 8:1-11 e.g. Matthew 5-7; Mark 10:17-31; John 4:1-26 32 e.g. Matthew 25:31-46; Mark 10:13-16; Luke 10:25-37 33 Exodus 34:6 34 1 John 4:19 35 John 15:9 36 Jude 21
37 38
John 13:34-35 Scripture in Song, Book One, Songs of Praise, 1979, no.12 39 John 17:21-23
10
Greek apostolos one sent as an envoy/ambassador, having the full powers of the one who is sending. Luke 9:1-6; Luke 10:1-23 42 1 Corinthians 12
11
This is the strategy that enables the Church to complete the commission that Jesus gave the Church: to preach the Gospel to the whole world, making disciples of all nations.
Ephesians 3:16 Ephesians 4:17-5:20. 45 Ephesians 5:19-20; Colossians 3:6. 46 Ephesians 5:21-6:4 47 Ephesians 6:5-9. Although slavery is (thankfully) abolished in most places, these instructions can be equally applied to employer/employee relationships.
12
.put on the full armour of God, so that when the day of evil comes, you may able to stand your ground, and after you have done everything, to stand. Stand firm then, with the belt of truth buckled around your waist, with the breastplate of righteousness in place, and with your feet fitted with the readiness that comes from the gospel of peace. In addition to all this, take up the shield of faith, with which you can extinguish all the flaming arrows of the evil one. Take the helmet of salvation and the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God. And pray in the Spirit on all occasions with all kinds of prayer and requests. (6:13-18a) This armour is far more than a prayer we pray: it is a lifestyle to be lived. Do people within our orbit who are lost to God see us as people who stand and live for truth and righteousness? Are we known to be messengers of good news and peace, in word and action?48 Do people see us as secure in our salvation by grace we are saved through faith, not by works49 - or do they see us finding our value and identity in work and busyness in the church? Do people see our actions matching our words? Do they see us exercising faith in the face of struggle, or do they see us crumble under doubt? If our priority is to grow in our capacity to represent the character, message and faith of Jesus to lost people, we are wearing armour that will protect us from the wiles of the devil.
48 49
Paul no doubt was thinking of Isaiah 52:7 here. Ephesians 2:8 50 Neil Cole, Organic Church. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2005, 24.
13
Within Churchworld, priority is given to maintaining and growing the local church congregation or ministry/mission organisation according to the ethos, doctrine, polity and liturgical practice of the denomination or network. In terms of time, energy, money and skill, this takes priority over mission in the community. Mission is often undertaken through programs and activities that are conducted in church buildings. Many of these can be quite effective per se, but because they happen in an environment away from the spheres where life is pulsating, lost people do not always come. These programs and activities tend to keep dedicated believers very busy, leaving little time to be gathering as communities of faith in the world. While many Churchworld congregations and ministries do offer ministry in the community which again is very effective per se, the effectiveness is limited because believers who do not belong to that particular congregation are usually excluded from the ministry. Invitations are often sent to believers in other congregations to join in, but in most instances this is not encouraged by the leadership, as it takes their priority away from work in maintaining these other congregations. In many, in fact most instances there are often a number of believers present in streets, neighbourhoods, schools, universities, and workplaces. There is tremendous opportunity for these believers to gather as the Church within these spheres to be the temple of Gods dwelling, to demonstrate Jesus boundless love, and to model a oneness that the world is longing for. However, loyalty to their particular congregation within Churchworld often prohibits this. Leadership within these congregations often discourages such gatherings, demanding loyalty to the congregation and denomination/network to which it belongs. In short, the structure and organisation of Churchworld congregations inhibits, and I daresay destroys much Holy Spirit inspired synergy between believers who are the Church in streets, neighbourhoods, cities, regions and nations. Yes, Godly, Holy Spirit inspired and led ministries do result in revivals and Kingdom growth. However the separateness, and priority given to maintaining the institution, limits the capacity of these ministries to fill the world with the fullness of Jesus. What begins in the Spirit, often succumbs to the confines of the institution. What began as incarnational ministry succumbs to institutionalism.
Secondly, there is a shift from clergy-driven ministry to five-fold equipping for ministry. Apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and teachers within the city and beyond are able to equip people, regardless of which congregation they belong to. Within Churchworld, priority is not given to these ministries equipping people. The leadership in ministry comes from clergy (known as ministers, pastors, priests, bishops, etc, depending on the denomination). Clergy may fulfil one or more of these roles, but in many cases they do the work, rather than equip all believers to do the work of ministry. Rarely would one find all five of these equipping ministries in one local church. This need not be an issue, because it is likely all five are present in some form within the Church in the city or region. However, the Churchworld construct does not usually allow for the sharing of these leadership ministries for the equipping of the whole church in an area. Rather, it requires priority to be given to building the local church, according to
14
the doctrinal and ecclesiastical distinctives of the particular denomination or network with which it is associated. Fivefold ministries are accepted and valued in many parts of Churchworld. However, the expectation is often that they do the ministry rather than equip for ministry. Churchworld congregations invite celebrity prophets to prophesy, and celebrity evangelists to evangelise. This simply adds to the dependence on clergy. However where apostles are equipping people for apostolic ministry, prophets are equipping people for prophetic ministry, evangelists for evangelistic ministry, teachers for teaching ministry, and pastors for pastoral ministry, the church in the city will reflect more of the fullness of Jesus in the city, or as Paul says, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ.51
51 52
Ephesians 4:13 Ed Silvoso, That None Should Perish. Ventura CA: Regal Books, 1994, 154
15