The Impact and Outreach of Microfinance Instit

utions:c
The Effect of Interest Ratesc
by c
Sebastian Schwieckerc
(sebastian.schwiecker {at} helpedia {dot} org)c
www.helpedia.orgc
Revised November 2004c

cccccc 
 cccccccccc cc
ccc
c cc
cc
cc cc
 
 cccccc cccccc  cc cc
cc 
cc cc
!
cc" c#$$%&c

_c

vontentsc
vontents...........................................................................................
............. 1c
Figures .............................................................................................
............. 3c
Acronyms ........................................................................................
............. 4c
1. Introduction ................................................................................
............. 5c
2. The Development of Microfinance ...........................................
............. 7c

 
 

c
  
 

c
  
 
 

c
  
 



c

3. The Impact of Microcredit ........................................................

........... 13c
 
  !"#

c
  $
! #!%#


&c
   '#%(

)c
 & *#
+ %! "

c
 ) +,"-./$-01 

c
  #!#,
2c
  0!%, % 0!%

c

4. Microcredit Outreach ................................................................

........... 24c


0  


c
 #%%  


&c
   0
)c
   
 
+% 3
c

5. vredit Rationing.........................................................................
........... 31c
&
% 
-  

c
& $% 
 


c
&  !
+*  
 


&c

. Interest Rates ..............................................................................

........... 41c
)
-*

c
) + 
4
%#,*
)  #-*,#,5(
c

c

7. Empirical verification ................................................................

........... 4c

#%%
)c

#c
 %
c

-. vonclusions .................................................................................
........... 52c
Appendix .........................................................................................
........... 54c
$%%
6$!,

&c
$%%6  *3
&)c
$%%6
+
&c
$%%6  7(
)2c
$%%&6  ! '#
)2c
$%%)6-* *#
)
c
$%%6#,5-*87

)c
$%%6-*! 95! :!  $* 
)c
$%%6- ! 70 %+%
)&c

References .......................................................................................
........... 7c
Internet References ........................................................................
........... 71c
Ratings.............................................................................................
........... 7c
Other Sources .................................................................................
........... 7-c

(c

Figuresc
Figure 1: Expected Bank Return and the Interest Rate ...................................
........ 32c
Figure 2: The extended Model.............................................................................
........ 34c
Figure 3: Marginal Productivity
of vapital ............................................................... 3c
Figure 4: The extended Model.............................................................................
........ 39c
Figure 5: Loan Size vs.
Interest Rate.......................................................................... 4-c
Figure : Interest Rate vs.
PAR .................................................................................. 49c
Figure 7.: Interest Rate vs.
FSS................................................................................... 50c

%c

Acronymsc
''c
'c
c'c
'()*c
'

c(c)c* c
'(+c
'c( c+ cc
*,c
* c c,c
*)-c
* c c c)c
c- c
,..c
,c.. c
-c
 c c- c
/-c
 c/ c- c
+c
+c(c
+)'c
+)c c'c
++c
+c+ c
++c
+ c c+ c)

c
+-**c
+
c-c c*c*

c
0c
*1 c(c
22c
2 c2 c
''c
 '
c'c
c
c c c
,+c
 c+ c

/"c
/ c c"
1 c
/.c
/cc c.  c
-)(c
-   cc(c
)c
 c* c
/c
c/ c
.)c
c.c c)c

c

1. Introductionc
3
cc cc cc 4cc cccc
 cccc1 cccccc
 cc
cc
cccc cc
&3c
_c

+cc
cccccc cc cccc cc,c cc
cccc

cc
ccc
ccc c
c&c
,cccc
cc cc cc
cc cc cc
cc cc ccc
ccc
4cc


c
c
c c c 
ccc c c c c
c
cc
cc
cccccc cc cc cc cccccc
 cc
cc
 &cc
cccc cccccccc
cc  cc
cc 
cc
 cc,+cccccc cc
cc cc cc
cccc cc
cc
cc
cc &cc. cc
cc cc cc
cc
cccc
cccc cc
 c ccccccc 
c
ccc
c cc
c cc

c  c cc &c
cccc
ccc cc

c&c
+cc
cc cccc cc
cccccccccc
cc
cc


cc cc_$4
$$$cc

1 cc cc c 4c
#c

c
 cc cc c cc
cc

 cc c ccc&c
c ccc c

cc
 cc cc cc cccc cc&cc)cc5
cc
cc
c
c
 cc
 cc cc ccccccc
cc cc cccccccc

cccc
cc
 c
cc
c
c c
&c
c  cc,+
c cc

c
ccc cc5c
c c c
c

c c
 cc



c cc c c ccc&c
) 
c c6cc  c,+c7c
c
c c
 
ccc
c
 cc
 c
c
cc c
cc c
 
c 4c c

c cc
  cc&c&c&ccc
c c c  
 c  c
cc


cc
c cccc c5c8&c
(c

c+c
ccccc5cc
c
cc

cc cc

cccc cc  cccccc cccccccc

 cc cc
_

.c,c&&&c
#

.c'"
c#$$%&c
(

.c6cc  c_

4c&c#$
&c


c

c

c c  c&c, ccc c( c,+cccc
 c cc

cccc  4cc cc5
cc
cccc
cccccc
cc
cc
cc
c cc
c c &ccccc

'c

2. The Development of Microfinancec

2.1. What is Microfinance?c
) 
cc cc
cc9 cc cc cc
ccc
c7c

c
cc cc
 c
c cc
c c c
 c  7&c
%c

c
ccc
c cc

c c/ c /c

cc
c
c c#$$c cc
c
 cc
cc cc 4c
c

cc
cc
cccc. cc0 cc)cccccc#$$#4cc
cc

7:; cccc  c cccccc
c
&8c

c

6 ccc ccc7
cccc c 

c4cc cc
c cc
 cccc cc cc
cc 
cc cc cc
cccc cc
cc
cc
 c c
cccc c 
c c

c&8c
'c

c
cccc
 c 4ccc c  c5c
ccc
c cc
4c
<c

cc cc
 cc
cc  cc cc cc
cc,+&cc)


ccc
ccccc
cc
 c,+c c cc 4c cc
 cc 
c c
c c


cc
  cc cc cc cc cc 4c
c

cccc,+ccccc cccc cc cc cc

 &c
_$c

( 
cc.c
cc c
c &c
 cc 
ccX
cc
  cc cccccc
cc cccccccc
cc 4cc 
4cc cc
cccc c c
c c
cc ccc

 

cc

 cccc &8c

__c

cc6cccccc cc cc cc cc
cccc

 cc cc  cc
cc
cccc &cc+4cc cc54cccc
cc

cc
cccc=_$cc cc cc
cccc'cccc'

cc
cc cccc
cc cccc
%

.c>  
cc> 4c_



c.c c/ c_

4cc&c
&c

4c&c_&c

c)c#$$#&c
'

6 c#$$%&c
<

c.c
c c c&?c(  c#$$_4c& ?c" c_

4c&c<&c

c.c
c(c cc cc c c  &c

_$

c.c(  c#$$#4c&c#%(&c
__

cc.cc( 
cccc.cc#$$%4cc&cc#cc7cc'

cccccc-cc cc
,1
cccc.
4cc04cc@


cccc



cc!cc
>
4cccccc
AB
cc@

cc1cc,1
cc
cc

cc
,1 c
7&c

<c
 cccc cccc
cc4cccc   cc cc cccc
 cc cc
  c &c
_#c

)


c
c 
cc
c c c ccc 4c
ccc
c c
ccc c c,+&c+c c ccc
c cc
 cc=cc_4$$$4c

_(c

cc
cc cc

cc cc  cc  cccccc cc

c c cc
c c c
c c c c
c
 c c c
/-c
c
 c c c-ccc c
cc &c>
c
c c cc
=_4$$$cc c
c cc
c
c
c/-cccc
4cc
cc
c
c#$Cc c
c/-cccc5 &c
c '
c'c
''c
cc

1cc
cc
cccc cc,+cc cc
cc
cc 
cc cc
 cccccc

cc cc
cc/-cccccc

cc cc2 
cccc
cc#$Ccc cc.cc
'c c
c#$C&c
_%c

c c c
cc

 c cc c c  cc
c
c  c c
cccc
cc cc&c)



cc
,+cc5cccc1cc 4c
_c

cc cc cc cccc cccc cc

c c cc c

c
c#$Cc c
c/-cccc


 c cc
 cc,+c 
c c
c cc &c
2.2. The Origin of Microfinance c
)


cc
cc cc
cccc cc cc cccccccc

cccc
cc cc cc cccc cc cc
cc_ <$cc cc_ $4c
_
c

 4c
c c c 

ccc c c c c
c
cc
&cc
>
c
c
c c cc cc/
ccc c

c_c

c

 4c
_'c

c
 ccc
cc c

c
c_<c

c

c ccc c cc


c  ccc  cc
cc c
c5c cc
_
_<cDc
_#

cc.ccEcc#$$#4cc&cc_ cc cccc cccc cc cc
cccccc


cc cc
cc
c'c

c c5 c c c
c c
c cc ccc&
cccc
_(

c.c '
c'c_
_%

'4c&c
&c

c.c '
c'c#$$(4c&c%&c
_

c.cEc_
_

<4c&c## cc&c

c.c(  c#$$_4c&cFFF&c
_'

c.c.c#$$(4c&c_#&c

_
%<&c
_<c

c+c_'#$c
cc cc


c c cc cc+c c
cc

c9 
c.&c
_

c)ccccccc_<#(4c

c c
 cc

 c c c cccc cc cc

cc
c_<(
ccc
c cc&c
c 
ccGc c
c

cc
 ccc cccc_<%(&c)c
c4c
 c cc
cc
 c c#$Cc c+
c

&c
#$c

cc c

#_c

ccc cc_<%'c c,
c>
c(cc

cc_&%cc cc cc cc_ _$&c

##c

cc6cccc
cc
cccc Gcc cc
cc

 c7
cc c  c
ccc c  c c  c 
4cc
cc cc cc
cc cccc
cccc cc cccc 4cc
cc
cc cccc cc

&8c
#(c

+c
c_<<$c
c'
c  c
c ccc. 
c+4cc
 cc
cc
cc5cc cccc  cc

cccccc cc
cccc
 cc cc
+cc 

cc cccc cc cc_ %
&c

#%c

cc
cc
cccccc
cc
cc
  cc cc cccc cccc
cc cccc+
 cc
cc cc
cc(cc c
#c

cc

cc cccc'cc( cc+ cc

'(+4c c cc
c
c,+cc
c &c
#
c

2.3. Microfinance after the Second World Warc

'cc cc
cccc

 cccccc 4cc&
&cc



cccc
4cc
cc
cc cccc
cc cc cc cc5
cc
  cc
 
&cc  cc
ccccG  cc cc
cc1cc cc
cc
1cc
 cc
cccc cccccc
cc cc cc
cc
cc
cc cc
 c,+&c
#'c
_<

c.c.c#$$_4c&c_&c
_

c.c(  c#$$#4c&c
&c

#$

c.c.c#$$(4c&c_$&c
#_

cc cc
cc cc(c

##

c.c 
c_
#(

4c&c_'(&c

c(c_

4c ccc(
 c#$$$4c&c(&c

#%

c.c 
c_
#

4c&c_'%&c

c.c(  c#$$#4c&c '&c

#

c.c( 
4c.c#$$%4c&c(&c

#'

c.c.c#$$(4c&c__&c
c