Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
in
And now that we have understood the source of the problem, we can very well say that the problem was not with the derivatives. But, the problem was with the 1. The loose ends in the government/central bank policies that had provided for excess liquidity and didnt bother regulating the situation later on. 2. Faulty assumption involved while modelling the financial instruments. 3. The abuse of leverage by various investment banks. Here a few investment banks have leveraged themselves to the tune of 34 times the debt equity ratio 4. Uncertainties in economic conditions lead to apprehensions among the lenders, which in turn resulted in freezing of the funding markets. e.g. the LIBOR freeze in Europe 5. The inability of economists, analysts, central banks to predict the outcome of the events in such scenarios.
I would conclude by saying, had the derivatives been prudently used and had they not been used to excessively leverage the banks balance sheets, the situation wouldnt have been uncontrollable. The need for financial derivatives still exists, in the sense that their use should and can reap benefits not only to the financial institutions but also to the end consumers. And all that is needed from our part is to be wise enough so that the capabilities of these derivatives are not misused.
Rank 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Partners Pfizer Wyeth Merck ScheringPlough GSK Stiefel BMS Medarex Watson Arrow Group Varian Agilent Gilead CV Therapeutics J&J Cougar Lundbeck Ovation
Date
Value, US$m
Jan '09 $68,000 Mar '09 $41,000 Apr '09 $3,600 Jul '09 Jul '09 $2,400 $1,500 Jun '09 $1,750 Mar '09 $1,400 May '09 $970 Feb '09 $900
Consumer spending in America rose by 0.2% in July compared with June and personal income was unchanged as Americans swapped their old cars for new ones in a program meant to help steer the US economy out of recession, as commented by the US Commerce Department. According to Robert Morrice, chairman and CEO, Asia, Barclays PLC, there is a financial market large enough to back up such activities. Over the past few months the international credit markets have seen record volumes and a significant compression of credit spreads. With the compression of credit spreads and strong liquidity with real money accounts, the international credit markets are a viable option. Once credit becomes available, credit risk derivatives are sure to be used to hedge against defaults. Based on a Crisil assessment of over 500 projects and extensive interactions with stakeholders across 11 key sectors in India such as power, telecom, oil, gas, cement, metals, and automobiles, aggregate industrial capital expenditure is projected to be to the tune of Rs 10.5 trillion during 200910 to 201112. It is anything but over!
Buffets perspective may actually be just a reflection of his personal experience with derivatives positions that he held in 1998 that included 82 percent holding of Cologne Reinsurance. It seemed an excellent proposition; unfortunately Buffet had hard time finding a buyer and ultimately decided to close it down. He stated later that derivatives position is easy to enter and almost impossible to exit.
Undoubtedly, Lehmans bankruptcy and the crisis that followed raise doubts about future of marketing derivatives. The world witnessed how the instruments mutated, multiplied and morphed over the years to lead to a financial meltdown. Many analysts believe that dilution of strict controls and restrictions in the US financial market is the primary cause for the crisis. Markets have their highs and lows, and reputed financial institutions seemed to have forgotten this, in view of fast growth and greed.
Doubting future of marketing derivatives does not make much sense if appropriate norms and restrictions are in place. SEBI allows mutual funds to invest in the derivatives market, and it has done so with right kind of restrictions in place. It has allows mutual funds to have not more than 50 percent of its portfolio positions in the derivatives market. The total exposure of mutual funds in derivatives market in July 2009 end was approximately INR 1360 Crores.
There are several advantages of derivatives trading. Most of the managers invest in derivatives market for minimizing risk and for doing away with fluctuations in prices. This is the primary reason of investment for most managers. This phenomenon is visible in the bear phase since in the bull phase managers are less likely to hedge risks extensively. The worst of bear phase, between January 2008 and March 2009, saw a sharp rise of exposure in derivatives. The exposure grew from 1.77 percent of equity assets in January 2008 to 5.86 percent in March 2009.
Thus investors decision on whether to invest in derivatives market is a sensitive process which will determine success of marketing derivatives postLehman era. Multiple options will still be available and multiple chances of errors of judgment would still be there. However the world of derivatives market can only be remolded through more sophisticated instruments with better restrictions in place. Investor of future will be more aware of risks involved and would seek thorough information to comprehend the underlying risks. That is, research will find a more important position, which will perhaps be the best indicator of a more mature market of derivatives.
Rohit Agarwal
Sushovon Nayak,
Post the aftermath ,as far as the OTC (Over The Counter)derivatives are concerned , hedge funds realized the need to assess counterparty risk when trading them .They wondered if a mammoth entity such as Lehman could fail , so could the socalled safe counter parties .In India ,CRISIL became one of its own kind by proposing to rate listed securities unlike the IPOs and debt instruments earlier so as to satisfy the investor of the fundamentals of the company and in a way exploit the fear buried within him. But the question which now arises is that should derivatives be shunned altogether ? The fact is that there is more to it than what meets the eye .In a world of uncertain times when exchange rates and interest rates are highly unpredictable ,derivatives serve as effective instruments for hedging losses for the discreet and also innovative instruments to reap profits through arbitrage between the cash market ,OIS (Overnight Index Swaps) and the interest rate futures market for the adventurous traders .India has even proceeded to introduce interest rate futures in the NSE and BSE ,which shows the almost indispensable nature of the derivatives in the present scenario. In the word s of Warren Buffet that derivatives were economic weapons of mass destruction, might have been prescient as far as the housing mortgage market is concerned but then every asset has its own liabilities ,the final outcome depends on the way we use it.
So our DERIVcity will not only rise like a phoenix but survive too with the monsters of inflations and defaults tied with the chains of regulations. And wasnt this story better than any fiction
Vasant Kumar,
PGP25109@iiml.ac.in, PGP20092011
Vasant Kumar
Vinay P Vaswani
3 letters brought down the world. The same 3 letters which led to a number of bankers becoming superrich yuppies, came back to bite the hand of its creators and inturn, bite off huge chunks of the balance sheets in which these now broke and unemployed bankers worked. Call the 3 letters what you like CDS, MBS, CDO these portents which for a decade transformed how money was transacted now face another grim 3 letters RIP or do they? Financial weapons of mass destruction The catastrophic effects created by repackaging securities are well lamented. The vicious circle of pushing loans to anothers balance sheet (bringing in SPVs into the equation) triggered a recession. The Morgan mafia sitting in a posh Times Square office would never have dreamt their easywayout would bring down some of the most established banks. As the venerable Mr Buffett puts it, derivatives are financial weapons of mass destruction, and so right was he. Dont punish the tool However, it would be unfair to blame the credit crisis on one sole instrument. I prefer licking my wounds by lambasting the greedy but ingenious Wall Street slickers who misused derivatives to offload risks from their balance sheets. Dont blame the derivative for that. As Mr Buffett proceeded to caveat his comment but derivatives arent evil.; a security which derives its value from an underlying instrument/ contract is a remarkably handy apparatus. What once started off as a way for farmers who knew their yield but were unable to predict the future grain market prices and created a via media for that, a derivative is an instrument with huge financial potential, even today. The Nobel Prize for transforming our investment exchanges (ironically both positively and negatively) goes to the derivative. The benefits of an alternate trading platform cannot be overemphasized. Besides, derivatives are not just restricted to the credit ones. Imagine a world without interestrate swaps, futures or options. We would be stepping back a few decades in financial time if we castigated this happy little helper. Final settlement To balance the account, derivatives are useful and not bad. The lack of regulatory oversight and creative thinking led them to be misused. But the damage is done. The sheen associated with a derivative has been tarnished. Stakeholders now look at the Dword with disdain. And yes, only a fool would massively market a derivative product in these gloomy times.
But, derivatives are not dead, nor will they die out. They are just too useful to be locked up. Moreover, we human beings have very poor memories. The same tools used to defraud companies or create bubbles find their way in newer and costlier financial scams or crises. The return of the derivative in all its splendor is not far off probably 45 years. Till then, the attention will be shifted to another scapegoat which will grow into a bubble I smell a rat in the global emission trading instruments doing the rounds.