Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
P2
Agenda
Outcome The Market Customer Requirements Solutions Income Streams Accounting for Leases Risk Management Conclusions
P3
Outcomes
Maturity of the Australian Market Understand the life cycle Diversity of Income streams Income levers can be managed Multiple products for different business segments Risk management takes a lead role Cashflows of a lease explained
P4
The Market
P5
The Market
The Australian Fleet Lessors Association (AFLA) members represent the major share of the leasing and fleet management market in Australia
Members of AFLA:
Alphabet Fleet (BMW) GE Custom Fleet Fleetcare FleetPartners FleetPlus Interleasing / Holden Leasing LeasePlan et Management NLC ORIX Q Fleet SG Fleet NSW State Fleet Summit Auto Lease Toyota Fleet Management
P6
P7
2010 July August Sept Oct Nov Dec 2011 Jan Feb Mar April May June July August Sept % to total
40,867 40,690 41,807 41,895 41,665 41,473 41,329 41,166 40,472 39,863 39,445 39,558 39,121 39,042 38,780 11%
184,773 185,654 184,413 184,470 184,901 185,739 185,411 185,107 186,200 185,194 186,067 185,593 186,398 186,444 186,453 52%
29,326 30,217 30,857 31,021 35,144 36,051 37,512 37,219 37,666 37,874 38,130 38,496 39,013 39,076 39,301 11%
75,855 75,864 75,842 75,822 75,786 76,191 75,859 76,204 75,754 76,140 75,313 76,143 74,645 74,782 74,827 21%
12,808 12,987 13,347 13,411 13,505 13,949 14,171 14,176 14,155 14,608 14,819 15,075 15,496 15,911 16,280 5%
343,629 345,412 346,266 346,619 351,001 353,403 354,282 353,872 354,247 353,679 353,774 354,865 354,673 355,255 355,641 100%
149,484 148,091 150,932 157,446 158,475 155,260 155,640 153,681 154,133 155,396 155,654 156,253 159,792 160,375 162,390
493,113 493,503 497,198 504,065 509,476 508,663 509,922 507,553 508,380 509,075 509,428 511,118 514,465 515,630 518,031
4,615 4,600 4,574 4,760 4,754 4,892 4,935 5,108 5,077 5,110 5,065 4,897 5,465 5,511 5,455
P8
Oct Nov Dec DEC 10 QTR 2011 Jan Feb Mar MAR 11 QTR April May June JUNE 11 QTR July August Sept SEPT 11 QTR
441 405 398 1244 363 513 441 1317 292 382 419 1093 364 372 400 1136 401 439 417 1257
N.B. Some AFLA estimates have been made in completing this table
P9
2010 July August Sept Oct Nov Dec 2011 Jan Feb Mar April May June July August Sept
751 761 779 789 877 901 924 925 935 948 958 964 978 976 989
5,306 5,269 5,277 5,275 5,358 5,342 5,297 5,297 5,314 5,307 5,311 5,317 5,331 5,355 5,369
1,735 1,711 1,709 1,708 1,711 1,708 1,699 1,692 1,694 1,700 1,683 1,676 1,672 1,675 1,674
78 72 70 65 73 69 72 58 59 57 57 57 54 56 55
1,813 1,783 1,779 1,773 1,784 1,777 1,771 1,750 1,753 1,757 1,740 1,733 1,726 1,731 1,729
460 469 488 488 491 515 516 534 547 572 586 604 629 655 676
37 37 38 38 38 40 41 41 41 40 39 38 37 35 33
8,367 8,319 8,361 8,363 8,548 8,575 8,549 8,547 8,590 8,624 8,634 8,656 8,701 8,752 8,796
N.B. Some AFLA estimates have been made in completing this table
P 10
P 11
Customer Requirements
P 12
Customer Requirements
The AFLA statistics clearly show that customers have requirements that their bank cannot fulfill A financier can provide funding but this ignores the management of the asset during its life Fleet Management Organisations (FMOs) bring funding and management together; from purchasing an asset, managing it operationally and finally disposal FMOs also deliver to the customer:
Knowledge via its experienced staff Systems to manage and report Buying power
P 13
Owned, Operating lease, finance lease, CHP, chattel mortgage, novated lease
Fuel, insurance, maintenance, tyres, registration / CTP, infringements, e-tags, roadside assistance, accident management, driver training
P 14
P 15
P 16
P 17
Solutions
P 18
P 19
P 20
P 21
Income Streams
P 22
Income Streams
Incom S e tream s
M agem t an en fees & D isposal 33% Fin ce an 34%
Income streams more than interest margin! Finance brokerage / interest margin Management fees & disposal income
Procurement & In-life services commissions, rebates, maintenance & tyre margins
Asset management earns income across diverse areas, reducing reliance on one primary income source. Targeting a one-third split in each category group is a general aim of Asset Managers.
P 23
Income Streams
Finance spread or brokerage
o Banks have exited the operating lease market o A limited number of financiers provide novated leases (no services) Management (including disposal) o Customers need the fleet on the road to produce income o Customers do not have reporting systems capable of end to end management Procurement & In-Life Services o Scale delivers financial benefits which are shared between the customer and FMO o Management of the supply chain delivers volume rebates to the FMO
P 24
Risk Management
Interest Rate Risk (refer Appendix) Credit Risk (refer Appendix) Residual Value Risk Managing In Life Service Risks
P 25
P 26
P 27
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
10.00%
20.00%
0.00%
Jun-99 Sep-99 Dec-99 Mar-00 Jun-00 Sep-00 Dec-00 Mar-01 Jun-01 Sep-01 Dec-01 Mar-02 Jun-02 Sep-02 Dec-02 Mar-03 Jun-03 Sep-03 Dec-03 Mar-04 Jun-04 Sep-04 Dec-04 Mar-05 Jun-05 Sep-05 Dec-05 Mar-06 Jun-06 Sep-06 Dec-06 Mar-07 Jun-07 Sep-07 Dec-07 Mar-08 Jun-08 Sep-08 Dec-08 Mar-09 Jun-09 Sep-09 Dec-09 Mar-10 Jun-10 Sep-10 Dec-10 Mar-11 Jun-11
VT
VX
VSII
VTII
Despite the rising RRP and new models the trend is clearly in one direction (i.e. predictable)
P 28
P 29
P 30
Ultimately a contract re-write provides the FMO an opportunity to improve its risk (residual position and in-life components) and pricing of the contract
P 31
Pull forward of excess km charge avoid surprise to customer at end of lease + cash flow benefits to FMO
P 32
P 33
To determine A-IFRS treatment the output of the Portfolio Revaluation is used to calculate at contract level the NPV of contract cash flows, future rentals and RV proceeds, to determine if an impairment provision is required.
P 34
P 35
P 36
Risks Other
Early Terminations
Customers early terminate vehicles for many reasons (e.g. restructuring) In the event of an early termination the lease contract allows a fee to be levied to cover any residual value exposure, loss of future interest margin and other costs
Total Loss
Comprehensive insurance is a requirement of all lease contracts. Self-insured subject to credit assessment
Excess Kilometres
If a vehicle travels beyond its contracted kilometres then an excess kilometre fee is payable by the lessee. Excess kilometre rates are disclosed on each contract and cover components of depreciation and in-life services
P 37
Revenue
($700*12)
Less: Depreciation ([$25,000 - $14,200]/36) Less: Interest Less: Vehicle Expenses paid Profit before Income Tax
BALANCE SHEET
Assets under operating Leases At Cost Less Accumulated depreciation $25,000 ($3,600)
$21,400
Cash Flow Statement Open - Cash / (Debt) Position Capital - 20% Acquire Vehicle Rental Income Interest Expense Vehicle Expenses Disposal Proceeds Close - Cash / (Debt) Position
P 41
P 42
Cash Flow Statement Open - Cash / (Debt) Position Capital - 20% Acquire Vehicle Rental Income Interest Expense Vehicle Expenses Disposal Proceeds Close - Cash / (Debt) Position
P 43
Funding Types
Securitisation
Form of funding but assets on balance sheet from accounting perspective Motor vehicles are a highly desirable class to invest given strong liquidity (ie: turn into cash fast) Novated leases, Finance lease and CHP the most easily securitised MMS Invest in lesser credit rated classes
P 48
Conclusions
P 49
Conclusions
Income streams are diverse and adjustable Fleet management is an outsourced activity which is growing Leasing is one form of finance and addresses part of the customer landscape. Risks are well managed and can be addressed during the lease term Fleet management and financing combined provide a variety of predictable and sustainable cashflows
P 50
Appendicies
- Products and Services Risk Management (interest rate and credit risk) Accounting for Finance Leases
P 51
P 52
Benefits
Off balance sheet (removal of RV & in life service (operational cost) risks)
Tax effective/ fixed monthly costs No fixed contract / flexible terms Immediate cash injection / known future monthly lease costs Benefit from FMOs buying power Cost effective, leverage FMO systems and knowledge plus pre-agreed discount structures
Sale & Leaseback Fleet Management Services (All in life costs associated with running motor vehicles)
P 53
Finance Leases Non-maintained generally operating costs are recharged to the customer Maintained may include all operating costs but generally fuel is recharged each month 100% tax deductible (subject to Luxury Car Tax) On balance sheet for the lessee RV risk to Lessee normally FMO sells
P 54
Chattel Mortgage Non-maintained & maintained generally operating costs are recharged to the customer On balance sheet for tax and accounting (a Loan) Very little market penetration and will reduce significantly once CHP input tax credit rules change on 1/7/2012
P 55
P 56
Risk Management
- Interest Rate Risk - Credit Risk
P 57
ACCORDINGLY: Negligible interest rate risk results Monthly interest margin in the lease is protected
How interest rate SWAPS assist to match the term of monies borrowed to the term of the asset?
SWAPS are derivative instruments which have the effect of changing previously agreed payment terms on debt Used where monies are borrowed under a floating rate facility - interest rate locked in for short term (generally up to 90 days) Short term money is used to fund leases for contracts with customers locked in for longer terms (ie: 3 years). Hence an initial mismatch in the timing of interest rates being locked in Accordingly if there is little tolerance to this mismatch, the floating-rate obligation must be transformed or Swapped into a fixed-rate obligation. An interest SWAP means the borrower promises to pay a counterparty(generally a Bank) a fixed rate of interest for a given period, in exchange for the Bank promising to pay a floating rate for the same period. This has the net effect of now changing the floating rate exposure into a fixed rate commitment. Risks associated with SWAPS are that the Borrower is now exposed to a counterpartys ability to repay the floating rate of interest. If the counterparty defaults, the SWAP falls over. Hence contracting with AA + rated banks is the minimum standard
Bank Bank
Borrower
Borrower has loan agreements which are based on floating interest rates. However, the finance contract with their customer is based on fixed monthly installments, meaning, interest rate in the lease is fixed. As floating rates change so does the profit margin to the Lessor. If bank interest rates increase, the Lessor profit margin drops and vice versa if bank interest rates decrease.
Bank Bank
Borrower
Step 1
Step 1 is to enter into a SWAP agreement with a bank who agrees to receive a fixed payment of interest
SWAP Counterparty
P 61
Step 2
Borrower
Bank
SWAP Counterparty
Step 2 exchanges the payment of a fixed rate for receiving a floating interest stream which matches the floating interest stream owed to the bank on the floating rate debt
Credit Risk
The risk that customers can not pay their lease installments or do not pay on time, resulting in losses on collecting monies owed
Review all new business proposals prior to credit advanced, in accordance with proven credit techniques Undertake annual reviews of all credit line facilities and more often if a customers requirements expand OR if there is negative news on the customer or the industry in which they operate Monitor closely credit default experience Obtain appropriate securities such as guarantees, security deposits where required Utilise Direct bank Credit to as high degree as possible, increasing surety of payment Active Credit Committee monitoring risks and establishing guidelines for maximum concentration risks to a customer, an industry, an asset class etc Defaults mitigated by fact that assets can be sold in liquid resale markets Use 3rd party agencies to validate credit worthiness (eg: VEDA; Dun and Bradstreet)
P 63
P 64
Proceeds on assets sold at termination are included in REVENUE (Proceeds from sale of Leased Assets) Income earned through supply chain management is included in REVENUE (Lease Rental Services) An asset FINANCE LEASE RECEIVABLES is recorded at inception of the Finance Lease and comprises a current (amounts due from customers in the next 12 months) and an non-current receivable.
Less: Interest Less: Vehicle Expenses paid Profit before Income Tax