Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
e E
e EE. '| & E;E g iE F; =H: E EE HEI = ,-: -i rE : E TEE :E F =S E; = c d -: Ei. EE EI EeI sg f; iE$ pU =i Eg ?s IEI gB ;eEE=*EE EE Eg r! F
aO-ergl
3 E
(l,ec}
f:. f 5
TE
T' 6P
+
Ur
or5alL
O.P q=
{a
G u: <j'
;E
^ g
EL
[3 g5
*
F
I E.:
gEEE SE:;
O<_E o-oarS xr =
!3-o6fi O tu (t, tr -:. .5 oo
6O!sEo6-
scE
ErrggiEE
EE
==
EEE
HlJcrldoc
Ehsa iEo;
E
o-
bzt
2F ae
Ei;
bo drE L(!
E
.l}
?3 :o
s9 ca 6
6
.=
+i
io
et
L
Eg
6o,
JF
-.4
=o -o0
-o -G (5o
-v. (,
c s
rt,
Ei ;eE
PL
EE6 ggi,
.EEts
ootr 2c 6EF
E-s s;s
dHll,
fi
E
*lUoe z! c
si EE
MaE
E {.r
Eg at6
EE
!HE E Ht n
EE= E Eia
.E
EEg 6-zc
q
3
E
EEEE-$iEE
E +FEgfgE (ExO
g
(4 aq
iETE$ -Fg.:E
E,,.9,8,8,
,ru
E :
Ei g TEEEE E I
EEE;
IESE
E
.sa
qi
h"
a d
.-v
i]o O{u CE
u0
Eg
=F>c
= E
:f
ij
l/'l
{r} _OC
P.y 6a!
;
oo;
-o
;ETE.=EE
oq 5L !uo
=P
E.Y
e>H;
.s
{E >(u
=0 l!-
EisilEs
E$EgEgE
EE
EEE
El:+Y
3 v o o (,
c (o
eE H S s <rgtrog
; Up E s,
!,
ES
-o 6L FIE
s:-
e; oo
?x C|!
gE
PP
E
L
a,
oo
E,r# a E
EF U!:
2'n, FF tJ (J
'6
Eeeee
U
==
c
-9
q,,
{s
c
t
c
(u I
IJ IE
o u .lt a UI
x s, c (g o
0
tt
l!
.g .g
adE qsa
o
CL
.E
6
-c F
:,
si
E
P
E IJ
ta
6 L
L
t!
T
;
i6pfi
EE ;
EEEE -.=
c,
.9
.=
.:
0
(,
r! (l, L
v{A
so+ iP ao$
sig H.EE
Q*-C (r=P
th
o 0.
o*
u Cl H
ET
T-cl
crH 0, s h0 oo OU
'C a
L I
o (,
-cqc
trlEo
c t6
o+j orP ow g
gE= tt r
E"g E
iol
rEg
5El e;tEB
:t EgE
-
(}s (oC
L_
8,; &G' Oe
o9
E*
eEEe
=oc E L!P
:t6aa
orI
Ee6'tloEOtJ oodro
c'
ai3
*o Po ll,o
EEE;EEEEE E+ ! # : -=?jolatl
E: iEE
Bgs=B O 6l e
, L 5
EEisE$EE$
!rE
o= cIi=
EtttEt rr *t
=T,
EP=EE
q E q ,x
uo a!
.E8 ooE
to
o.ts
c
:, o
o
(U
v
E
:o =
(o
=f, E}
rto o, -oE (r.cc -Y9ro HEU
(6g{s tt.l'[lP CLl6 LL tlr,
0,
s c {E
(,
J 6 (!
(l,
EE E 83 E
E -o:rq639 g
b E
E
-E 3sp
=0,P
&8 E.c
s"i
*tJ
m
fr
H
ri
'X
E.s-8
J fr
o
{l, (J
ar]
c o,
6
oc,t/, 6u
?9E =6ru o
E EHEE 5''
*Ei-;-rgE ?.=9=EE-9so
g l!
E ;4
JZb
q-
ECL Eo} sE o;
og
E=
EE
=(u ot c
so P.E
9E.tit s^"3 5B i!
r r
cP-,?ira!c
e-9E Et': r 9
;t ',' .jE
c.t
.E = s
s* i#
or
eE
EEfEE;#iiEE;s
J 6 (E
s6 -s3F oo
(ELC
ga
!e' 6.*P
J='sEfr,E ;
-a;
x (U
EE ELEFEE
E;.Lc,=
8.3
H
iJC E!
L
E9 Tr6
E
(96
f E$ r
6
g
r\t o EP3 EJO'
:>6
E* EEEI H-;EI HE ba i gEeEf Ei sf fiEE EE:E gE';E $se$t Ejj g&g s Hfl#+f; #
to o d* L,:ILF
It
!; EE
I^-9pE
B.ar;(u o-=*-(,
q6=:
.s-E
EtE
s E*
EE TE iE *: PaiUrg
fGvLq
H; i
ru
t;
E.gr,'l q
9 LaTtor
.g.g P5 u 6rg,
cL =6 {=g -:a PI Htr EerPJ
EErtrl
Cr!06 -4
oi:
fi=
/r n
EE o,l9
PULL -!
eq
EE {u (l, f,
oC,
a
e_
frl
F-Ft.c
fr5 =3
6.
1. 2. 3.
Advantaqes/ strenqth of openinq Universitv l. Existing University was small old & in need of extensive repair 2. Due to civil war the country desperately needed educated & professional people for
3. 3. 4. 5. 7.
DisadvantaseF / Threats 1. Fear of foreign intervention in Loyka. 2. Target for critics of the Government.
This could be'b target of physical attack. Less secure than a hospital Large no. of students could become a cause of unrest.
FINAL DECISION TAKEN BY GENERAL DIANE The result of the CPM & the survey clearly indicated that Loyka was not a perfect place for university and a hospital was a better option even though opening a university would have long term benefits but people of Loyka didn't understand or caf,e for long term benefits but
short term only. Moreover the soldiers of UWP needed immediate change for re-motivation.
8,
KOS POLOUK'S OWN BUSINESS EXPANSTON As the construction of hospital was finalized, KOS polouk's could
of
expending his own business and he could choose between 3 options. Option to keep the same scale of operations Option 2 Increase the scale of operation of his business the officer's dining hall. Option Maximize the scale of operations.
The survey financial implication, & comparative study clearly indicated that option 2 is the best option for KOS because his net income after interest & before tax is increasing from $ 150 to $ 1500 & his total income is increasing from $ 650 to $ 1500. The option I would give no added benefit to him & option 3 would require lot of financial investment which was not possible for him. CONCLUSION
1. 2. 3. 4.
The case analysis indicates that the tall structure of UWP should change to flatter, flexible, democratic, decentralized structure in any organization The commandant or head of the organization autocratic style of leading should be replaced by a contingent situational employee friendly and participative style. Motivational techniques specially the non monitory should be used for re-motivation of
employees.
2.
3. 4.
Loyka is a small country with economy divided into primary sector 45% Secondary sector l5oh, tertiary sector 40o% 2006-2008 - Loyka was torn by civil war. After the war, a new coaliation govt. was formed but it was not very strong. In2009 - UWP sent 4000 peacekeepers to Loyka - Based in Beral. Organizational Structure of UWP - tall, centralized several levels of hierarchy & narrow span of control matched the military structure Autocratic not flexible, orders were to be followed.
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. l. 8. 9. 10. 1.
The formationof,g weak coalition government. Eruption of violence Rigid, tallorgaruzational structure of UWP. Autocratic leadership style of the Commandant. Threats to UWP from local people of Loyka. Lack of motivation of soldiers. Defective leadership qualities of the Commandant. Not fulfilling corporate social responsibilities of an organization. Whether to go ahead with a new projbct of opening a university or a hospital in Loyka. Decision about the three possible options of the produce distribution business of Kos.
ANALYSIS OF CASE
SWOT ANALYSIS FOR UWP Strengths - Centralized Authoritative Structure, discipline, fixed objective, sense of stability to local people, international support. Weaknesses - Lack of motivation of soldiers, resentment from local people. People didn't like foreign soldiers interfering in their work, inappropriate behaviour of the soldiers with local people, disagreement with general Meiri, , Autocratic leadership style of General Meiri. Opportunity -When they first arrived the local population was largely supportive they were expected to create stability, maintain order, peace & security. Threats - Unappreciation from local population, violence against the troops, lack of flexibility within UWP.
LEADERSHIP STYLE
The contrasting leadership styles of General Meiri as against the newly appointed general Diane Pierce as Commander
General Meiri
Get>ese).D)es>eP)esce
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
4.
Autocratic Style
Rigidity
Only one way to lead Only giving orders Standardized way of working
l. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Situational Style Flexible Change style according to situation Listening to people Customized way of working
1.
olive flats either by f. improving public relations 2. reduce conflicts with local people 3. improving safety of UWP troops
Strategico.bjective Which is lon'fiterm & required long term planning for improving the image of the
2.
3. 5. 7.
5.
2. responsibilities 4. sessions 6.
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
For building up the confidence & relations with local people general Diane also thought of an improvement of social infrastructure of Loyka by using thi resources of UWp to build either a hospital or a new Univ. campus. as a non-profit organization. This strategic decision would help the UWp in following ways Importance of presence of olive hats would be understood by local people. uwP Mission's corporate social responsibility would be catered to. Motivation of troops by change in routine. Sense of achievement for troops. Building of positive relationship with local people. Fulfilling of the strategic &tacticaldecision by General Diane.
.Y
:E v=
Pur
AB cJ o 'lL H2
s*? -i
o
E E I ''=,*
ll
..':::l ::
..
o o o L
L.' C
tr
a)
H U
H*
qH
Eu
XE
c !
!@
:...:l]#Ei:
:' .'
..
-==.
',...E
.9 .9
tr
_.
\rOt'
i v2 E2p
;ftqs
EEb;
o<o: =oul Dr!< 6 oo-oti,
= o
4 ! c
G
.g
(,r tr
o9:l'> k zf
@
><
l,
>E
6c
(,
G l 6
E.
z f
t,
o
E
5 u
6
o o o o
tr
o o lo
G
@
o (,
6 P
@
th
o
o o
.Y
ix cJ
o o EE
Ul
69
(.)6p u,= F;
fr
E3 o'E6
6'-
.2
6
2 o o
CL
dfidN I
2 qR lu
== 53
g:E
-g 9.>
! E
m
;U
&8
tE
E-v (r -! EP
U.E
o o
E
o. (^
l e
-oE >'=
E
6
H
f= @c
:;o
6i
6q CL
CLE
.e9
OC ts! 6.4 E c= 3.
APSE
f; -p
6
gA S"B
O
-g
J
u +E
.li irr hE :o 2U
3E
5p
'6c lr <c
oc '5
JJ.
.(
= 3
oo3E
iF hE
g
..
g 3
5E E;E "s:*e ir p $i; *E* n !i': nA gE .EE*e rt .2 F s#.:t EE= EOl !u tr 3 * = EEg i {, $g; ; e.FEfb 3R Eg$E FEEa
ce
e A .6-9 .e^ -E c b.E 'EE
;H; EE
=E Ee Jfle
eo.e
i$ t
a P
E! ==
;$ (jl8
Eog
!9 6P
i9
:--{
E'
zn
-fi
e* pE
iE
Efi'
e F!_laX
6 s0
o,
#
@
i, P -E
ei
Pi
H 5
5 i o u
E E EE i p $ i#
i & i'E
s E?
-6
s-$ EE od gE.
EX E S Hi I E a sg i i 26 E sEE S
;ge
t P E
E gi E; [E E:l E E
+ .8,
gE t+,=
EEE; EE .ej
!
3
E
.s
E
E
f;g;i i* i =-Hi
ti ;5 EtI EC
EE
tl
5fi3; !B 5E 5f$ EE E
o d
ni
o
@
.9
o o 'a
o J o U
os o
o-
o
@
.E3 '^o
@
o o
{:d
:n t=
Pul
66 cJ o 'lL uz
E g
@
o col
pd
oo d> o9 CZ !o oo Oo P@ o
.,
dR @e 5+ dE
dr
PH ;U
EO 9o o6
Ld
i {* g
ohod (odB"b
:gd-JF
od oo
oc da tro 6g !tru
6 +gr
3 :E z luo
Bi fi HE
--a
?'iq,
EEt a r f,
; E B-.. E :.4.8 e 6_ E\\ I Eco -to E 3 ,: '[+sE E g I EEEE
o
E E
Ehe
q v
O .=
.\1, C,
-'N +-l$i
>
Y)
Eg fi
o,: eE E9
;ftes =r=E
HUBg f ur< E
Ft
P g g
-q e Y,Pv> o
Eooo
L.,
o 9 @o-oLt o- d
i6
Ef
oflo o-uuo.
HEE
E.
ET ri5
aa
9e g?
@@
$ 65 r J 'o
I E2g
E fs E Et
I
P u otr .S=
E :E @= "o
gut
! c o U o o
6 =o .g o
s CL
o
E
@
o
f
o o o
i 6
E'fr L6
o!!
oti o
o o
3q
fi g EJ E .Bs g $E
9.E E o '3
Hl EE E s 5-, .tsE- E
--
s-
E o
o o o
o E o
3
-9
,9
@
o
(,l
E U
o e o o o
c 'tr
.;
d
o o
x
o
ts.8
o
@
=Ei
o 8E z
EE
f c
o; Fs: 6H EXE E ElH r: l;t Ei E;$ ET E?[ EE: &'.T l.EE HH Efr; E#
='.F
EEg *3 Ee Eb5
o6I
{E
.E Po
g&9
e n E.
o6
t -c
.s
6E gH Ca= E6 a3 co
=*s"
Eea Ef
q'.'tr >r
E".
5!lo
tH
OO
ES cg
OE v 6E-
5q 6 o
d = F ;
az g
?f +r-seEa,sg 5s i AHfgEf BE-EEI gB H E! !E#A *g}t "$';F5 "aE8 * EE gig* E;iE EEE
i:o
Y5Iu !!
Lc! foO !l o=
BEE
[Ef
TE.H [E QoE
ET;
oP.^
[f*
HE
ga
>:o9 .EEf
-o
5#J
a
E
E:iE 5r.! {$Bi $tEe gi$ f;H;; EstE E FtE FHE H Eii HfiB; EEE EpfB E5Efl EEE
sE##
ort b 6 .! h'a'6 E.f, E E
=^triE I
'd0 J
@
o c
o
t
i
.u
:_
5'E
o o o
@
a6 iJ
'ao
F9, t= Pur
E 3
a .s
EE'*'F=
E
:
O
TE +: .9U 3E
C H E I !
a
E
F tr.trt
-t [t
a: Pc
EtsEEEEE
UZ o6
qR
G.=
gE =H
*g E
'=P t; oiE -t
3? Hr
=5, Ei 6!
t Qo 6
s I
u
fEE;=gE -r$gEB[*
Et#EgE
I i
z
uJ :q c. -o = EE E U
r.lJo
X
irE; ea> e
EHB; e
o<o: 6 =cru f uJ<
loo-oI
Eg :o
a-a .Ys
F; s!
E-3
3&
:
HE <.=
>tr
tiI
E
',E Ef
tiEE=Ei E66E96
3.5E
:;utE;i .ti*Eeib9
o ,F
!t
I.f
E; E oE
q I6=
?g
c u
EgE,
P
tr
tL
= O
# ..E,EE E T: E}Eg
6
E
:
f
..
EEEE.*EEPE
o tJ
.e
Ei;HgESE=*
o (,
Hf5 ;lfEa
il rl :tl o
48u ot c.-
6*n
>
sg:E
E
o
'-c-f
iAEF E 16
EI !l o!.ql F!!
EIE E E
I E
9
C
@
EX cJ
b9
Eea xE E E :HE.!5
ot ,E.E
:l ,i, .= ul
:a
."1,
a
ts tr
: .il,"S.',6,,
.:..i=:a
q
e
q;Ff E EiE? i;
s=E
iifiEEEE
Ua ;2 f Purc
e(,,o
; g 2E 5 gi-o gb =i 6 s
iih 6--sO gb6E
& o
!c
6-
+ .3, i qs tu
U XE
=
,-,,-P
;EEg i I
=E3E
zi,p.=
=Xq
,G-
6
E
EEE SIsc
=fEd
IEEg.. H
EaH!
E.E-5.EE
* U
eEE g8B
E L
=-EE fiHB; I
=ouJ
da-a as
i
] s
E
I\aE BEE
E E =Ei$
5$g
g[E
;;Ec f'E
=
,E
iE E
f s *
tEEE
EqEE
-*r;
!3g+E
s f,E"
=iiEB igg$FgEEegBgFi
'ic t.: C O
-: -o E 6.ll
E
.-v
IE E.=
P
sseE
E;;E
cPP?
E! ig
6 C
F E.E J O
9 E E8O
F 5 06
{E
-o 6 c J F o
E9E9 i6 F a, * E =u=.
cr;: aE';b'
fri iJ ?
H
oo
E:i
.Y
c .9 q c
! E
R?E itr u
d
=
-99 lE
d! -liY
e o
f E
sE 5J B_r EE
;! e:E
@.=;
>
d
s=
o
E D-
-v E
ilP666o
qoo 5; u
Es o d
29 e-9
gH
@Q
E ui >
.
EE i
E :. !9+ F5
fS
SE
[*
6 E
s uiE
E co.q
-z
E
g
E Eg E;E
F
E E
e 6
F J : og9
1
lx i
O t:,
f fU
XEH
d =o = g, : = .o{ fl
t = tE * l.{ X
Hs E i' cR 3 H BE t4 r.u 5f; p (,
=?
eEe Pi o; P EE
:g *E}
8H&
E_o
Ex
E:E =iP t"* EEt E f 0 " 6E> g;[' Q-"*it E*P i sEI E:
_g
*5s
Eo nE
n.s PE a=
Ei {*Eg PE r$ Es",H;f
#9
[E
E
E
E
+
E
;' .EYA
Fo
frg;; itEeBsEa}Ei Et
gg
+$igEgsit,g
Hfi3E EgFgEE;6FA gE i#
IiI
gE; pT*$
o
v< c .!!
o
g q o E @ .g g l
.E* Pq
6L
oc -o
gG
,i -o.=r'
3E=1'.:E
o o
! = g
oo ':o
AP
Es ou
6E e.si
r66g
a @
';-o
..E
o o
6
<-g-+
6Y
E
@
r;
3'!o
u=
:9
@ @
,=aIfc
-g o 6
5
E
I E iT It E E
t6
E
qNs <
sEa e
E
ai
,r
9E
ax cJ 'ao uz o6
Fta t=
6 'ii o6 ,=O EO co
6 U o it h fc
z!
6 .U o ,o 0 E
,:
+a t i
.Ex o
E E
-c
2 i iH E H Eg
E i9
EE
g o
5 -
EE Eh xo
3.e x.E
ooLO oo
Pu,
-!9
et
E3 c2
En
tr S o 5F
z uJo
c 'a
(u
E'o 6E
=6 OE
o3 Fe --o oro EC
3'E 60
Es3E
_u
3E 3i o5x
90i5 bu9 '6.bb 'tr': o oltr Es-
B*-
ot
.E 9d
E@
3,E a6
o!
a2a3 ,! f ui < b E
OO-(,lr lL
s3i
E A2
g$T-i
:-
H,.E gf f E TE ;E Eg
-> 3
E q
g Eg E 5 E os y e u
> Er g : 3 lFd
is s * EE ig E s sE
2 c P E
E E
'E
[E qE 5E 60 =p ee E*
Er
E'i,r' 'o
F
E, o:
(,
a
=f5
,ET 3-8
o
E P c
o o
E=
:a
8..o oa Er .:*o o t ! --lo
9l-.8 c Oc 'E !
I 't
0
.E
.c
EE q 6 I
E.i
8....
@ '::::.':::..
5 t:
JJg
:<o 61.:,9
-Ea
yo ts G o g_
Vr P
U o
t
6 -o 9.
s I { I
la a
t.
,.r'
u: ;.aa:+. .a s ...4:*-:3, o ,4,j:1,. ..4::: _.. = =' c
o
tq !S
H= P * x -i Hl- :x
z Hi( ut =I
E
FE = ! +i oY
.E'P E'e'
?. e 6nP=o
:-F iE H E=
tsE .9 Es eE te vE
*I
3,8
ga gE o 6
5E
=-
:'E
-E pE l Gi 59
xr,HaEaH;EEE="
E
o .E
I
.9
t o
o o
; E
;
E
?: ;uaOa
ohE
sI
.2=
26 [ odE'
tr= i 3?
I hu^
2
E
U
2 4H # lu == zA:,
H = Xq Ep U XE
;ftqs *; :i !t?=h.=
91
ii o9> k
o d t,
UJ-g
5u E
qE
H'
-.,aari:
E <. J
tr
Y=E
EU S *FlE SS S U
H3EHEft
E*FER
I.EVEL \ \
.\\ -.\
2 hours 15 mirrutes
* Do notopn this examination paper **t*l instructed to d* so. t Bead tisE case study caref*lly. a S*c*ion A: arxwertwo questisr:s. i Sectior: * answerthe compulsory questior*" a *ctior"* e: ansrer the compr.llmry q*estion"
l------2
SECTION A
1.
(il public-private partnership (line 116) (iil economies of scale (line 121)
(2 marks) (2 marks)
(b) With reference to the UWP mission, distinguish between strategic (line 36) and (4 marks) operational objectives (line 39).
With reference to the organisational chart in appendix 1, examine 2 advantages and 2 disadvantages of a tall, centralised structure for the UWP Mission' (7 marks)
(c)
.:
.
\]\
(2 marks) (2 marks)
2.
Explain 2 advantages and 2 disadvantages to Kos of using a bank loan to fund (4 marks) the new lorry (line 130).
Use all of the PEST categories to examine 4 external forces upon the UWP Mission to Loyka.
(c)
3.
(a) (b)
(c) Examine the importance of workforce planning for UWP during the (7 marks) construction of the university or hospital.
SECTION B
4.
(a) Explain one cost and one benefit of the new hospital or university being operated (4 marks) as a non-profit organisation.
(b)To what extent would a change in the leadership style of the commander from
autocratic {line 8) to a situational leadership style help to remotivate the UWP (8 marks) troops?
(c) With reference to the case study and appendices 2to 4, discuss the 2 different options of building either a hospital or a university campus and recommend which you think will most contribute to a major improvement in the the social
i
nf rastrru ctu
'\
re of Loyka. (8 marks)
a.\
Section
5.
(a) ldentify 2 advantages for Kos of having a 'first-mover advantage' (line 135) if he (2 marks) utilizes his contacts with the UWP Mission. (b) Analyse the role and importance of General Pierce's experience in social (7 marks) marketing in helping to reduce the UWP Mission's
problems.
(c) Examine 3 economies of scale that Kos could benefit from in increasing the scale (9 marks) of his.business operations with the UWP
Mission.
.\
aL
(d) Using@vant motivational theory, the information in the case study and the information ih appendix 5, evaluate the 3 growth options available to Kos and recommend which option would positively impact on his overall motivation.
(12 marks)