Al l i ance f or Devel opment of Adul t Educat i on and Li f el ong Lear ni ng
i n t he Republ i c of Macedoni a PROVI DERS OF NON-FORMAL EDUCATI ON Resear ch Repor t Mar ch, 2012 R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 2 About t he All i ance for Development of Adul t Educat i on and Li fel ong Lear ni ng i n t he Republi c of Macedoni a as a pr ogr am of t he Communi t y Devel opment I nst i t ut e- Tet ovo Today as never befor e t he sayi ng t hat PERSON LEARNS UNTI L HE I S ALI VE has nev er been t r uer . I n t he l ast f ew decades t he w hol e concep t about t h e mean i ng of educat i on and l ear n i n g has changed. A per son t o educat e hi msel f doesnt mean t hat t he educat i on w i l l st ar t i n pr i mar y school and f i ni sh at uni ver si t y, t o t he cont r ar y, a per son l ear ns i n di f fer ent manner s t hr oughou t l i f e. Fol l ow i ng t he w or l d and t he Eur opean t r ends i n educat i on, i n t he Repub l i c of Macedoni a t he need t o d o somet h i ng concer ni ng adul t educat i on and l i f el ong l ear ni ng ar oused. Namel y , w i t h t h e cr eat i on of t he Law on Adul t Educat i on i n 2008, as w el l as t he St r at egy and t he Act i on Pl an i n 2010 f or t he f i r st t i me t he bot h t he for mal and t h e non -f or mal educat i on w er e put i n one l egal f r ame. Af t er w e got w i t h t hi s l egi sl at i on i t i s much easi er t o u se l i fel ong l ear ni ng and adul t educat i on as t ool s t hat w i l l hel p t ow ar ds d ecr easi ng t he unempl oyment and t he pover t y i n Macedoni a. I t w as t hi s exact moment w hen t he Commu ni t y Devel opmen t I nst i t u t e ( CDI ) not ed t he need t o w or k i n t he f i el d of adul t edu cat i on and l i f el ong l ear ni ng and i n May 2011 cr eat ed t he Al l i ance for Li f el ong Lear n i ng and Ad ul t Educat i on i n t he Rep ubl i c of Macedon i a ( ADAE) t hat f unct i ons w i t hi n CDI . ADAE i s a pr ogr am based on f r ee member shi p. I t s ai m i s t o dev el op and adv ance t h e adu l t educat i on and t hr ough t hat t o act on unemp l oyment and pover t y decr ease i n Macedon i a. Apar t f r om t hat ADAE w an t s t o sup por t i nst i t ut i ons, st r uct ur es and or gan i zat i ons f or t he cr eat i on of su st ai nabl e adul t educat i on and l i fel ong l ear ni ng. Th e I n st i t ut e f or Communi t y Devel opment i s a ci vi l soci et y or gani zat i on t hat w or k s i n t he spher e of i nt er -et hn i c under st andi ng and t ol er ance, capaci t y bui l di ng of i ndi vi dual s, or gan i zat i ons and i nst i t u t i ons, as w el l as i mpr ov i ng t he l i v i n g condi t i on s and t he l i vi ng st andar d of t he ci t i zens. CDI f or alr eady 15 y ear s w or k s i n t he commu ni t y i n or der t o addr ess t he needs of t he ci t i zens. R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 3 About t he Resear ch I n or d er t o r ecogni ze and map t he pr ovi der s of non-f or mal educat i on, t hei r ar ea and scope of w or k , as w el l as t he t r en ds concer ni n g t he v er i f i cat i on of pr ogr ams f or n on-f or mal educat i on, ADAE conduct ed i ni t i al r esear ch t hat w i l l ser ve as a base not onl y for get t i ng basi c i nfor mat i on but al so f or conduct i ng mor e det ai l ed acad emi c r esear ch i n t he sph er e of l i f el ong l ear n i n g and adu l t educat i on. Th e r esear ch conduct ed f r om December 20 11 t o Jan uar y 2012 consi st ed of cr eat i on of qu est i onn ai r e, i t s di st r i but i on v i a emai l t o t he pr ovi der s of non-for mal educat i on ( NGOs and educat i onal cent er s) , dat a col l ect i on an d i t s t echni cal pr ocessi ng and anal ysi s. Th e q uest i onnai r e i s composed o f t w o p ar t s and t ot al of 20 q uest i ons. Fi r st p ar t : gener al an d cont act i nf or mat i on about t h e pr ovi der of non-f or mal educat i on and second par t : con cr et e quest i ons f or t he pr ov i d er s spher e and scope of w or k . T he quest i onnai r e t hat w as di st r i bu t ed t hr ough CDI s ow n mai l i ng l i st s, as w el l as mai l i ng l i st s of p ar t ner or gani zat i on an d TAKSO 1 w as an sw er ed by 53 pr ovi der s of non-f or mal educat i on. Th e composi t i on of t he quest i onnai r e w as most l y di r ect ed t ow ar d s CSOs as pr ovi der s of non-f or mal educat i on, al t hou gh f eedback w as as w el l pr ov i ded f r om educat i onal cent er s, pr i vat e compani es, and l ocal i nst i t ut i ons. Th e quest i onn ai r e used i n conduct i ng t he r esear ch , as w el l as t h e l i st of or gani zat i ons t hat pr ovi ded an sw er s ar e at t ached i n t he end as appendi ces. 1 Quest ionnaires were sent t o more t han 1000 emails of CSOs, educat ional cent ers, municipalit ies, f oundat ions and privat e companies R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 4 Resul t s fr om t he Anal ysi s Th e quest i ons f r om 1 t o 7 ar e l ocat ed i n t he f i r st par t of t he qu est i onn ai r e. 1. Name of t he or gani zat i on 2. Addr ess 3. Of f i ce p hone, Mobi l e phone 4. Fax 5. E-mai l 6. Web-si t e 7. Cont act Per son Th ese q uest i ons r efer t o t he gener al i nfor mat i on concer ni ng t he educat i on pr ov i der and ar e not pr esent ed i n t hi s an al ysi s. Questi on no. 8 Servi ces On t he quest i on what type of ser vi ces do you pr ovi de f our choi ces w er e gi ven: t r ai ni ngs, w or k shops, on-j ob t r ai ni ng and o t h er . The an sw er s ar e t he f ol l ow i ng: Most of t he pr ov i der s of fer t r ai ni ngs and w or k shop s as f or m of non -f or mal educat i on. Namel y, w or k shops ar e pr ovi ded by 89%, t r ai ni ngs by 87%, on-j ob t r ai ni ng 42% and ot her t ype of ser vi ces ar e of f er ed by 28% of t he pr ov i der s. R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 5 Questi on no. 9 Ar eas i n which you offer ser vices (ex. Admi ni st r at ion, banking, agr i cul tur e, busi ness management , secur i ty, qual i ty, languages, IT, PR) Th e quest i on ar eas i n whi ch you offer ser vi ces w as an open-ended qu est i on. The answ er s w er e cl assi f i ed i n 17 cat egor i es. Even 3 7% of t he pr ov i der s of f er t r ai n i ngs of busi ness char act er . Fur t her mor e, t he ar eas of i nf or mat i on t ech nol ogy an d l angu ages ar e as w el l p opu l ar . Tr ai ni n gs f r om t he spher e of hu man r i ght s and i nt er cul t ur al t ol er ance ar e of fer ed by 22% of t he pr ovi der s. 20 % of f er vocat i onal qu al i f i cat i ons. Commun i cat i on sk i l l s and pub l i c r el at i ons ar e pr ovi ded by 18% of t he pr ovi der s. Ser v i ces fr om t h e spher e od admi ni st r at i on and t he NGO sect or ar e of f er ed by 14 % of t he pr ov i der s. 12% of f er ser v i ces f r om t he spher e of agr i cul t ur e and advanci n g t he qual i t y st an dar ds. 10% of f er ser vi ces f r om t he spher e of ecol ogy. The l east of f er ed ar e ser v i ces f r om t he spher e of ar t , heal t h , t our i sm, i nst i t ut i onal devel opment and publ i shi ng. R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 6 Questi on no. 10. Year l y number of par ti ci pants I n t er ms of t he year l y number of par t ici pants, 34% of t he pr ovi der s hav e up t o 100 par t i ci pant s on year l y l evel . The most of t he pr ovi der s, 48 %, have bet w een 100 and 500 par t i ci pant s. 10% of t he or gani zat i ons hav e bet w een 50 0 and 100 and 8% have or e t han 100 0 par t i ci p ant s. Questi on no.11 Year ly budget al locat ed for r eal i zat i on of t he ser vi ces? When i t comes t o t he year ly budget al l ocated for r eal i zati on of the ser vi ces, 2 1% of t h e pr ov i der s have year l y budget up t o 1 00 00 0 MKD. 3 6% al l ocat e bet w een 10 0 000 an d 500 00 0 MKD an d 28% of t he pr ov i der s al l ocat e over 500 000 MKD. 15 % di dn t pr ovi de an answ er t o t hi s quest i on. R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 7 Questi on no. 12 Do you char ge for t he ser vi ces (tr ai ni ngs)? On t he quest i on do you char ge for the ser vi ces, 42% of t he r espon den t s char ge f or t he ser vi ces, 38 % do not char ge f or t he ser vi ces, and 9% char ge f or some ser vi ces and f or ot h er dont . 11% of t he r espondent s di d n ot gi ve an answ er t o t hi s quest i on. Questi on no. 13 Geogr aphi c ar ea (muni ci pali t i es) wher e you offer ser vi ces? I n t er ms of t he geogr aphi c ar ea wher e t he pr ovi der s offer ser vi ces, 1 7% of t he r esponden t s of fer ser v i ces onl y i n r ur al ar eas, 40% onl y i n ur ban ar eas an d 42% of t he r esponden t s of f er ser vi ces bot h i n ur ban and r ur al ar eas. R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 8 Questi on no. 14 Tar get Gr oup Most of t he pr ovi der s hav e yout h as t hei r tar get gr oup t hat i s 86%. 67% f ocus on unempl oy ed, 47 % f r om of t he pr ov i d er s hav e t he emp loy ed as t ar get gr oup , 43 % d eal w i t h mar gi nal i zed gr oup s, 27 % w i t h si ngl e mot h er s, and 33% h ave ot her t ar get gr oups. R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 9 Questi on no. 16 For which occupati ons or ski l l s i s ther e demand for or gani zi ng tr ai ni ngs? I n t er ms of t he ar eas for whi ch t her e is demand for pr ovi di ng ser vi ces, t he an sw er s pr ovi ded by t he r esp ondent s w er e cl assi f i ed i n 16 ar eas. The l ar gest deman d i s f or t r ai ni n g i n t he spher e of econ omy. Ther e i s equal demand f or t r ai ni ng f r om t he spher e of I T, for ei gn l anguages and cr af t s. Th er e i s equal need ( 12%) f or admi ni st r at i ve t r ai ni ng and pr ot ect i on of human r i gh t s. Ar ound 8% i s t he demand f or ed ucat i on i n t he spher e of t he NGO sect or , commun i cat i on sk i l l s and ecol ogy. Th er e i s l ess demand f or t r ai ni ngs i n EU f un di ng, ar t s and heal t h, and t he l east d emand ( 2 %) i s for sp eci f i c ar eas such as pr oof r eadi ng. R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 10 Questi on no. 17 Do you have ver i fied pr ogr am in CAE? When i t comes t o ver i fi cati on of pr ogr ams, most of t he pr ov i der s t hat i s 86% do not hav e a ver i f i ed pr ogr am. Onl y 14 % have a pr ogr am t hat i s v er i f i ed. Questi on no. 18 Do you pl an on devel opi ng a pr ogr am for whi ch you wi ll ask for ver i fi cat i on fr om CAE? Th e pr ovi der s i nt end t o v er i f y t he pr ogr ams t h at t hey of fer . Namel y , 60 % gave a posi t i ve answ er t o t he qu est i on i f they wer e goi ng to devel op a pr ogr am that they i ntend to ver i fy. 25% do not pl an on any v er i f i cat i on , and 15 % di d n ot pr ov i de an answ er . R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 11 Questi on no. 19 Do you have a par t ner i n the impl ement at ion of the tr ainings? On t he l ast q uest i on , do you have par tner s i n the i mpl ementati on of the tr ai ni ngs, 66% an sw er ed t hat t hey do, 26% do not and 8% di d not pr ovi de an answ er . R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 12 Conclusi on I t can be not ed t hat most of t he pr ovi der s of non-f or mal educat i on of f er non-for mal educat i on i n f or m of t r ai ni ngs and w or k shop s, and t hei r t ar get gr oup i s usual l y focused on you t h an d unempl oyed. The busi ness t r ai ni ng, I T t r ai ni ng and f or ei gn l angu ages ar e t he most popul ar among t he pr ovi der s, but al so most demanded f r om t he user s of non -f or mal educat i on. Non-f or mal educat i on i s pr ovi ded bot h i n r ur al and ur ban ar eas. Most of t he pr ov i d er s do not have a ver i f i ed pr ogr am and t hey of f er and i mpl ement t h ei r ser vi ces t oget her w i t h par t ner or gani zat i ons. How ever , t h er e i s l ar ge i nt er est f or ver i f yi ng pr ogr ams. Th i s anal y si s i s somew hat hel pf ul i n t he scan ni ng of t he si t uat i on w i t h t h e non-for mal educat i on pr ov i der s, t hei r scope and spher e of w or k . Thi s r esear ch pr ovi des t he b asi s f or mappi ng t he pr ov i der s and cr eat es space f or f ur t her w or k and cooper at i on bet w een al l st ak ehol d er s i n or d er t o get ap pr opr i at e dat a t hat w i l l con t r i b ut e t ow ar ds nnqoprnpanoc1 concer ni ng t he t r ends i n t he non-f or mal educat i on i n t he Repub l i c of Macedoni a. R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 13 APPENDIX Cojys sa pasnoj ua opasonauue ua nospacuu u poxuno1uo yuene no Penynuka Makepouuja Lidhja pr zhvillimin e arsimit t t rriturve dhe msimit t prhershm n Republikn e Maqedonis Alliance for Development of Adult Education and Lifelong Learning in the Republic of Macedonia Tel: +389-44-340-677 www.srov.mk www.irz.org.mk Anaea sa neopmanno o6pasooanue - nonypyoauu na ycnyru - loreu 6po[ na npaunu ruua (spy+enu[a na rparanu, npenpu[au[a, [aunu opranusauuu u uncuyuuu) opranusupaa iypceuu u o6yiu co uer a ro narpaa snaeneo na uernaa rpyna, cuoue upa6oenu u copa6onuuu. Pa o[ naun, ue ce upeino uiryenu uo npoueco na neopuarno o6pasouanue u o+uuono yene. ouee unopuauuu sa snaeneo na o+uuono yene, saionciaa pauia uo eny6ruia Maieonu[a u cue pyru unopuauuu, uo+e a ru na[ee na crenaa unepne cpanuua: www.srov.mk Co uer a ce o6u[a unopuauuu sa nonyyuau na ycryru uo neopuarano o6pasouanue u a ce nouorne nuunaa pa6oa, Co[yso sa pasuo[ na o6pasouanue na uospacnu u o+uuono yene uo eny6ruia Maieonu[a (CC8) ro norouu ouo[ npauarnui/opuyrap. 8e uoruue, oioriy ce uo uo+noc, a ro nonornue ucuo u a nu ro ocauue nasa sa a 8e perucpupaue uo 6asaa na nonyyuau na ycryru, co uer a 6ueue uo uo+noc a ocuapyuaue copa6oia. 8e oxpa6pyuaue ucuo a ro cnoerue co uo e uo+no nororeu 6po[ na opranusauuu/uncuyuuu sa iou cueae eia ce nonyyuau na ycryru na neopuarno o6pasouanue. Co[yso sa pasuo[ na o6pasouanue na uospacnu u o+uuono yene uo eny6ruia Maieonu[a (CC8) e nporpaua uo pauiue na nncuyo sa pasuo[ na saenuuaa (n3)- 1eouo co uer a ro npououupa, pasuuua u ynanpeyua o+uuonoo yene u o6pasouanueo na uospacnu. 8o nporpauaa uo+e a renyuaa cue saunepecupanu npaunu u usuiu ruua iou uuaa unepec urur aiuunocu uo ouaa o6rac. 3a cue onornuernu unopuauuu uo upcia co nporpauaa, iaio u uo+noca a ce uiryue uo pearusauu[a na nporpauciue aiuunocu, 8e uoruue a [a noceue crenaa unepne cpanuua www.sr ov.mk uru a ionaiupae co nac na crenuo ereonciu 6po[ 044-340-677. nuue sa ionai Lur[ana Araunuocia. R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 14 4opuyrap 1. nue na opranusauu[aa 2. Apeca 3. 1ereon ianuerapu[a 3a) ereon uo6uren 4. 4aic 5. Lreiponcia apeca 6. nnepne cpanuua 7. nuue sa ionai 8. vcryru (8e uoruue saoipy+ee) a) o6yiu 6) pa6ournuuu u) noyyuane na pa6ono ueco r) pyro (8e uoruue naueee) _______________________________________ _______________________________________ 9. C6racu uo iou nyue ycryru (np. auunucpauu[a, 6aniapcuo, seu[oerue, 6usnuc uenauuen, o6es6eyuane iuarue, [asuuu, n1, onocu co [aunoc...) 10. louuen 6po[ na yecnuuu (ue uoruue saoipy+ee) a) <100 6) 100 - 500 u) 500 - 1000 r) 1000 > 11. louuen 6yue nauene sa pearusauu[a na ycryrue? (8e uoruue saoipy+ee) a) o 100 000en. 6) 100 000 - 500 000en. u) na 500 000en. 12. aru nanraae sa ycryrue (o6yiu)? a PL 13. leorpacio nopa[e (onuunu) uo iou nyue ycryru? A) pyparnu (naueee iou) L) yp6anu (naueee iou) R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 15 14. erna rpyna A) upa6oenu oiuaruuiauu[a L) neupa6oenu 8) uaprunarusupanu ______________ (naueu iou) l) cauoxpanu ua[iu l) xenuienupanu L) urau ) pyru ____________________ (naueee iou) 15. oroua cpyiypa na iopucnuuue na ycryrue/iypceuue Lpo[ na ua+u_________ Lpo[ na +enu_________ 16. 3a iou sanumana uru ueuunu nocou no6apyuane sa opranusupane na o6yiu? 17. aru uuae uepuuiyuana nporpaua uo enap sa o6pasouanue na uospacnu? A, io[a_______________________ PL 18. aru nranupae a pasuuee nporpaua sa io[a e no6apae uepuuiauu[a o enap sa o6pasouanue na uospacnu? A, io[a ________________________ PL 19. aru uuae napnepu npu cnopueyuane na o6yiue? A, iou _____________________________ PL 20. onornuernu unopuauuu iou uo cueae eia 6u 6ure o ua+noc u na pyru nonyyuau na neopurano o6pasouanue R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 16 APPENDIX B Li st of pr ovi der s t hat answ er ed t he q uest i onnai r e 1. SFERA Pr i l ep 2. Associ at i on REKA Kr at ovo 3. Emoci onal no Zdr avo Det st vo 4. AN- BLOK- Sk op j e 5. Humani t ar i an, cul t ur al , ar t associ at i on w omens or gan i zat i on Roman i Asvi n 6. Hel si nk i Commi t t ee on Human Ri ght s i n t he Repub l i c of Macedoni a 7. Local Devel op ment Agency, St r uga 8. MATA- Sk opj e 9. Nat i onal Roma Cent er 10 . Si ner gi j a Pl us 11 . Associ at i on for devel opment of t he Roma communi t y SUMNAL 12 . Or al Heal t h 13 . Nat i onal Counci l f or Gender Equal i t y ( SOZM) 14 . Yout h Cul t ur al Cent er - Bi t ol a 15 . Cent er f or I nst i t ut i onal Devel opment CI Ra 16 . Assosi at i on I ni t i at i v e for soci al change- I nSok 17 . HEPA Macedoni a 18 . Doser Gl obal Bi t ol a 19 . Associ at i on for ci vi l t ol er ance and coop er at i on- AGTI S 20 . Cent er f or n on-f or mal educat i on f or ch i l dr en and adul t s ATLANTI S- Tet ovo 21 . Cent er f or economi c anal ysi s 22 . Ci t i zens Associ at i on EKOVI TA 23 . Cent er f or commu ni t y d evel opment Ki cevo 24 . Semos Compu t er Edu cat i onal cen t er ( br and name Semos Ed ucat i on) R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 17 25 . Cent er f or app l i ed r esear ch and p er manent educat i on i n agr i cu l t ur e- CI POZ 26 . SS Demet r a 27 . Educat i on Soci et y Akad emi k 28 . Cent er f or cul t ur e, commun i cat i on and educat i on of Roma Svet l a I d ni na Kocani 29 . Ci t i zens Associ at i on f or mot i vat i on and communi cat i on devel opment DI JALOG Sk opj e 30 . Mun i ci pal i t y Aer odr om 31 . Associ at i on for i mpr ovi ng t he st at u s of w omen Womens Act i on - Radovi s 32 . I nst i t u t e for Sust ai n abl e Rur al Regi onal Devel opmen t 33 . Ecol ogy soci et y Gr ashni ca 34 . Associ at i on FOR EQUAL OPPORTUNI TI ES- SEMPER 35 . Ar t i st Associ at i on Cul t ur al Cent er Medi a Ar t es 36 . Foundat i on I n for mat i onal Cent er 37 . Associ at i on for Democr acy, Soci al I ncl usi on and Devel opment - DeSi De 38 . Ci t i zens Associ at i on Found at i on Ren ova 39 . NGO Opt i on Ohr i d 40 . Found at i on for devel op ment of t he local communi t y - St i p 41 . Educat i onal Cen t er M6 Sk opj e 42 . Roma Associ at i on AVENA, 43 . Cent er f or I nt er cu l t ur al Di al ogue 44 . Associ at i on Mana St r umi ca 45 . Associ at i on of pr oof -r eader s of Macedoni a 46 . Associ at i on You t h mu l t i cul t ur al commun i t y- Pr i l ep 47 . For u m Cent er f or st r at egi c r esear ch and document at i on- Sk opj e 48 . Associ at i on of agr i cul t u r al pr oducer s Kuman ovo 49 . Eur op ean Li nk Cent er 50 . Cent er f or Educat i on and Devel opment ( CED) R E SEA R CH RE P O RT : P r o v i d e r s o f n o n - f o r m a l e d u c a t i o n i n t h e R e p u b l i c o f M a c e d o n i a 18 51 . Associ at i on Roma Busi ness i nf or mat i onal cent er of Macedoni a 52 . Associ at i on Bel av i st a 53 . Associ at i on Nov a Zemj a