Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
\
|
=
dV
f Eqn.4 becomes where is
the viscosity of liquid,
( ) ( )
7 / 4 7 / 1
7 / 4 7 / 1 7 / 4 7 / 4
2
* 87 . 2
L
d d L h g
V
+
=
(5)
3.1. Development of Mathematical equation for efflux time for a cylindrical tank
Substituting the value of
2
V from Eq.5 and
1
2
1
4
h D V
= (where D
1
is the diameter of the tank)
in Eq.2
|
\
|
1
2
1
4
( h D
dt
d
=
( ) ( )
4
* * 87 . 2
7 / 4 7 / 1
2 7 / 4 7 / 1 7 / 4 7 / 4
L
d d d L h g
+
=
(6)
For incompressible liquid, is constant and hence Eqn.6 becomes
|
\
|
1
2
1
4
1
h D
dt
d
=
( ) ( )
4
* 87 . 2
7 / 4 7 / 1
2 7 / 4 7 / 1 7 / 4 7 / 4
L
d d d L h g
+
=
(7)
Separating the variables and integrating between h
1
=H
1
(t=0 ) and to complete draining h
1
=0
and (t=t
1
, t
1
is the efflux time for cylindrical tank)
1
t =
2
2
1
7 / 3
1 7 / 3
* 1 1 *
87 . 2 * 3
7
d
D
L
H
L
(
(
\
|
+
7 / 4 7 / 1
|
\
|
|
|
\
|
d
L
d
7 / 4
1
g
(8)
1
t = * 1 1 * 813 . 0
7 / 3
1
2
2
1
(
(
\
|
+
L
H
d
D
|
\
|
|
|
\
|
d
L
g
d
7 / 1
4
2
(9)
7 / 1
4
2
1
|
|
\
|
g
d
t
= * 1 1 * 813 . 0
7 / 3
1
2
2
1
(
(
\
|
+
L
H
d
D
d
L
(10)
1
= * 1 1 * 813 . 0
7 / 3
1
2
2
1
(
(
\
|
+
L
H
d
D
d
L
(11)
64
Where
1
=
7 / 1
4
2
1
|
|
\
|
g
d
t
(12)
Where
1
is dimensionless time.
3.2. Development of Mathematical equation for efflux time for a spherical tank
As shown in the Figure (Fig.2), an open spherical tank has to be drained by means of an exit
pipe (when the flow in the exit pipe is turbulent). The dimensions are shown in the Figure.
The tank is filled with a Newtonian liquid and the liquid is drained from 2. It is desired to
find the efflux time required to drain the liquid from the storage vessel.
Applying mass balance equation for incompressible liquids
|
|
\
|
|
|
\
|
2
2
2
2 2
3
1 (
3
1
(
R
h
h rR
dt
d
=
( ) ( )
4
* * 87 . 2
7 / 4 7 / 1
2 7 / 4 7 / 1 7 / 4
2
7 / 4
L
d d d L h g
+
(13)
Where h
2
is the height of the liquid at any time t and R
2
is radius at height h
2
. The above
equation upon integration between the limits (h
2
=H
2
at t=0 and h
2
=0 at t=t
2
) and writing in
dimensionless form gives the following equation for efflux time
2
3
2
* 393 . 1 X
d
L
|
\
|
= (14)
Where
2
=
7 / 1
4
2
2
|
|
\
|
g
d
t
(15)
Where
2
is dimensionless time for spherical tank and
Where
=
2
X
(
(
|
|
\
|
+ +
(
(
|
|
\
|
+
(
(
|
|
\
|
+
(
(
\
|
+
(
(
|
|
\
|
+ 1 1
5
7
1 1
3
7
1 1
17
7
1
2
1
3
14
1 1
5
7
7 / 10
2
7 / 3
2
7 / 17
2
7 / 3
2
7 / 10
2 2
L
H
L
H
L
H
L
H
L
R
L
H
L
R
(16)
4. Results and discussion
To drain the same volume of liquid from both the tanks, the mathematical equations derived
are now compared to find out which of the tanks considered drain faster (i.e, whose efflux
time is the lowest).
66
4.1. Comparison of Efflux time of cylinder with that of a complete sphere
The efflux time equation for spherical tank is compared with that of a cylinder. This is
obtained by dividing Eq.11 with Eq.14
(
(
|
|
\
|
+
|
\
|
=
1
7 / 3
1
1 *
2
2
1
813 . 0
2
3
393 . 1
1
2
L
H
d
L
d
D
X
d
L
(17)
When same volume of liquid is to be drained, i.e
3
2 1
2
1
6
1
4
D H D
= (18)
The following two cases can be considered
a) When the diameter of cylinder is same as Diameter of cone i.e D
1
=D
2
)
Eq23. becomes
3
2
2
1
H
H = and eq.17 can be written in terms of H
2
and length of exit pipe
L as
1
7 / 3
3
2
2
1
2
2
2
* 713 . 1
1
2
|
|
\
|
+
|
|
\
|
=
L
H
X
H
L
(19)
The ratio is a function of H
2
/L (since for complete spherical tank R
2
=H
2
) and H
2
/L is
always >0 for all values of H & L, a plot of
L
H
2
vs
1
2
is shown in fig.3
Fig.3. Ratio of efflux time for different values of H
2
/L ( D
1
=D
2
)
The plot suggests that the ratio is <1 for all values of H
2
/L suggesting the efflux time for
cylindrical tank is greater than spherical tank. Hence cylindrical tank drains faster than a
complete spherical tank when the diameter of sphere is same as that of cylinder.
b) When the height of liquid in both the tanks is same i.e H
1
=H
2
In this case, Eq.23 becomes
1 2
866 . 0 D D = (20)
1 1
* 321 . 0
1
7 / 3
2
2
2
2 2
|
|
\
|
+
|
|
\
|
=
L
H
X
H
L
(21)
A plot of
L
H
2
vs
1
2