Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 13

GENDER AND THE RISE OF THE FEMALE EXPERT DURING THE BELLE POQUE

Anne R. Epstein Presses de Sciences Po | Histoire@Politique


2011/2 - n14 pages 84 96

ISSN 1954-3670

Article disponible en ligne l'adresse:

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------http://www.cairn.info/revue-histoire-politique-2011-2-page-84.htm
Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Pour citer cet article :

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------R. Epstein Anne , Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique, 2011/2 n14, p. 84-96. DOI : 10.3917/hp.014.007

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Distribution lectronique Cairn.info pour Presses de Sciences Po. Presses de Sciences Po. Tous droits rservs pour tous pays.

La reproduction ou reprsentation de cet article, notamment par photocopie, n'est autorise que dans les limites des conditions gnrales d'utilisation du site ou, le cas chant, des conditions gnrales de la licence souscrite par votre tablissement. Toute autre reproduction ou reprsentation, en tout ou partie, sous quelque forme et de quelque manire que ce soit, est interdite sauf accord pralable et crit de l'diteur, en dehors des cas prvus par la lgislation en vigueur en France. Il est prcis que son stockage dans une base de donnes est galement interdit.

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque
Anne R. Epstein

Gabriel Tarde, Laction inter-mentale, La Grande Revue, 1 November 1900, p. 316-317.

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

In a 1900 article in the widely read Grande revue, French sociologist Gabriel Tarde wrote that the capacity to shape others thinking what he termed [l]aptitude exercer laction inter-spirituelle depended the most on two factors: age and sex. A change had taken place since ancient times when the elderly had held the most power to influence. In Tardes Europe, this aptitude was more likely to be found in the middle-aged: lge mr, sans nul doute, est rput le plus autoris, le meilleur conseiller. Women were more often subject to mens influence than the other way around, although Tarde acknowledged historical and national variations in degree, sometimes with significant effects: Au XVIIIe sicle franais, o, dans les classes aristocratiques..., la femme a t moins suggestible et plus suggestive que jamais, cette fminisation relative des esprits sest traduite par une transformation des ides et des murs qui a eu des consquences infinies. But the gender hierarchy had never in his view been entirely overturned. 1 Although Tarde may have been right in correlating age and the power to shape others opinions, by the time he wrote his essay women in France had actually started to acquire expertise that when reinforced by traditional feminine attributes such as femininity and motherliness would endow them with a gender-specific authority to which men completely lacked access. This article analyses the emergence of such womanly expertise in Belle poque France as a social and cultural process conditioned both by structural changes in the French public sphere and by transnational influences. We will first examine how the gradual politicisation of issues arising from evolving perceptions of gender difference and relations and from womens entry into the professions contributed to the emergence of a kind of feminine expertise in the late nineteenth century. The next section will demonstrate how French women experts participation in transnational networks both built on and reinforced their authority at home. Finally we will discuss the transformation of womanly expertise into a broader, yet still gender-specific form of public authority. It is my contention that certain French women, despite their marginal political status, were able to convert this gender-specific authority into a political resource they could use to shape opinions, policies, and institutions on the eve of World War I and beyond.

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

The emergence of womanly expertise


By the end of the nineteenth century, in spite of limitations on their access to higher education and professional training, Frenchwomen had begun to make inroads into professions understood as extensions of traditionally feminine domains such as childrearing, homemaking, charity and philanthropy, and what today might be termed care work. The specialist knowledge they began to acquire in their new roles as teachers, nurses, or social workers appeared specifically feminine, rather than gender-neutral, because it derived from experience in areas of life about which they, either simply because they were women or because they exercised appropriately womanly professions, were thought to know more about than men. These areas of feminine expertise included being female and the female life course (including maternity and childbirth); educating children, caring for the family, and managing a household, the traditional social and civic functions of the Republican mother; and womanly vocations such as teaching, social work, nursing, moral reform, and philanthropy. By the first decade of the twentieth century, feminism and womens rights constituted additional areas of feminine expertise and eventually, authority. 2 Some early examples illustrate how this gender-specific expertise functioned. The support of Olympe Gevin-Cassal, Inspector General in the Department of Childrens Services from 1896, was eagerly sought by a variety of enterprises aimed not only at children but also at mothers welfare and education. 3 During this period women in positions of responsibility also began to attend national and international congresses in the capacity of experts: for example, a handful of Interior Ministry prison inspectresses debated with male politicians and civil servants and with philanthropists of both sexes at the Congrs pnitentiaire international and at national congresses on released prisoners between 1895 and 1900. 4 These womens expertise and credentials came from their professional experience with the penal system and with female prisoners in particular. In keeping with the logic of the times, their gender gave them wider authority to pronounce on the potential moral dangers and psychological consequences of the incarceration, treatment and release of female criminals than their male counterparts might have, and it was for this reason that they were selected to report on such concerns. But their authority did not extend to
On womens entry into the professions, see Juliette Rennes, Le mrite et la nature. Une controverse rpublicaine: laccs des femmes aux professions de prestige, 1880-1940, Paris, Fayard, 2007; also Sara L. Kimble, No Right to Judge: Feminism and the Judiciary in Third Republic France, French Historical Studies 31, no. 4, Fall 2008, p. 609-641; Rebecca Rogers, From the Salon to the Schoolroom: Educating Bourgeois Girls in Nineteenth-Century France, University Park, PA, Penn State University Press, 2005, esp. Part II; Evelyne Diebolt, Les femmes dans laction sanitaire, sociale et culturelle, 19012001: Les associations face aux institutions, Paris, Femmes et associations, 2001; Katrin Schultheiss, Bodies and Souls: Politics and the Professionalization of Nursing in France, 1880-1922, Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press, 2001; Linda Clark, The Rise of Professional Women in France: Gender and Public Administration Since 1830, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2000; and Jo Burr Margadant, Madame le Professeur: Women Educators in the Third Republic, Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1990. 3 L. Clark, Rise of Professional Women, op. cit., p. 101. 4 Ibid, p. 79-82.
2

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

Bibliothque Marguerite Durand (BMD), Dossier CNFF. Liste des membres du Congrs, in Congrs international de l'ducation sociale, 2630 septembre 1900, Exposition universelle de 1900, Paris, Flix Alcan, 1901, p. XXVI-XLII. 7 See Karen Offens pioneering article Depopulation, Nationalism, and Feminism in Fin-de-Sicle France, American Historical Review, 89 (1984), p. 648-676; Elinor A. Accampo, Rachel G. Fuchs, and Mary Lynn Stewart (eds.), Gender and the Politics of Social Reform in France, 1870-1914, Baltimore and London, The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1995; and Mary Louise Roberts, Disruptive Acts: The New Woman in Fin-de-Sicle France, Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 2002.
5 6

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

the condition of male prisoners, nor did it give them the wide latitude they would have needed to criticize the prison system as a whole, the judicial process, or political decision-making. The division of responsibilities at major congresses, including those where most of the participants were women, and in large womens organizations such as the Conseil national des femmes franaises, also confirms that credentials, expertise and professional experience were becoming as important as social prominence in determining the extent of a womans public authority. Though she might participate in the work of many sections of a congress, the respected and experienced educator Pauline Kergomard was the natural choice to head the section on Education of the CNFF, just as specialists in other fields might head other sections. 5 The founding board of the Congrs de lducation sociale in 1900 comprised a significant minority of women, about half of whom had teaching credentials, and many of whom were school administrators. 6 Like men, women had begun to be chosen on the basis of professional expertise to lend specific kinds of symbolic legitimacy to civic projects. Changes in the gendered structure of the French public sphere by the beginning of the twentieth century also contributed to the emergence of female expertise and the recognition of woman as experts. What might have seemed like feminine interests and issues maternal and child welfare, reproduction and birth control, and womans work had started to attract the attention of national politicians, civil servants, and academics due to the governments growing alarm about French population decline, venereal disease, and social cohesion whereas French women were increasingly concerned about seemingly manly issues of war, peace, and colonialism. Both Marguerite Durands daily newspaper La Fronde, produced by and for women, and the Dreyfus affair contributed to this sea change: on the one hand, as Mary Louise Roberts has suggested, helping raise the visibility and political value of the feminine by modifying the publics understanding of womanhood and femininity, and on the other hand, by enabling intellectuals to make explicit the connection between womens rights, human rights, national interests, and social progress. 7 Because many of these questions ultimately came down to ethics and morality, which were understood as gendered, the cultural authority of highly regarded professional women became useful to those at the French political and intellectual center despite the institutionally and politically marginal position of such women.

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

Transnational networks and national expertise


The restructuring of French public discourse and concomitant emergence of womanly expertise did not take place in isolation from trends in the wider world. International displays of Frenchness at forums such as Worlds Fairs provided evidence of the rising national and international value of gender in public life. At the Paris Worlds Fair of 1900, a major showcase for French culture which had been in the works for many years, two womens congresses, one feminist and one not, exhibited feminine social action and the achievements and aims of the French womens rights movement (though these womens congresses had precedents, and female delegates from France had attended such meetings held in other locations). Women also participated in other Congresses such as the solidarist Congrs pour lducation sociale; indeed, the Worlds Fairs organizing committee had placed education, a field in which women were exceptionally well represented, at the top of the conference agenda from the beginning. 8 Three years later, in preparation for the Worlds Fair of 1904, peace activist and Radical politician Lucien Le Foyer wrote feminist leader Caroline Kauffmann to solicit her cooperation in an initiative called the Comit central d'organisation des bourses de voyage au Canada et aux tats-Unis, l'occasion de l'exposition de SaintLouis en 1904. The purpose of the organization, which had the support of considerable personalities, was to enable a certain number of French men and women of limited means to travel to St. Louis, in order to transmit les ides et les sentiments franais, et recevoir, en change, l'enseignement par les faits que pourra leur donner le spectacle de l'activit amricaine. Many organizations had already backed the project and the organizers did not want women's and feminist organizations to be left behind. French women as well as French men must be present in St. Louis, affirmed Le Foyer. 9 Not only would support from the leader of a women's rights group add legitimacy to the enterprise, it was also of crucial political importance that the image France projected to the world comprise ordinary citizens of both sexes. Women as well as men of modest means could also convey what they learned from their American experience to other members of their own social milieu. Heightened international awareness of gender issues also created opportunities for French women experts to participate in transnational intellectual networks, both enhancing their personal visibility and authority and also contributing to the reinforcement and recognition of womanly expertise in France. 10 The case of the
8 Marcel Fournier, Les Congrs internationaux de lExposition de 1900 , Revue politique et parlementaire, 24, 1900, p. 740-750; A. Barthlemy, LExposition de 1900 , La Grande revue, 1 April 1900, p. 194-211. 9 Bibliothque historique de la ville de Paris (BHVP), Fonds Caroline Kauffmann, Fonds Bougl, Lucien Le Foyer to Caroline Kauffmann (16 December 1903), Correspondance 1893-1910. 10 On transnational networks and the emergence of international womens movements, see Margaret H. McFadden, Golden Cables of Sympathy: The Transatlantic Sources of Nineteenth Century Feminism, Lexington, KY, University of Kentucky Press, 1999; Leila Rupp, Worlds of Women: The Making of An International Womens Movement, Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press, 1998, and Constructing Internationalism: The Case of Transnational Womens Organizations, 1888-1945,

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

American Historical Review, 99, December 1994, p. 1571-1600; and Offen (ed.), Globalizing Feminisms. On French participation in international organizations see, Christine Bard, La France dans les internationales fministes de la Belle poque la Seconde Guerre mondiale, in Yolande Cohen et Franoise Thbaud (ed.), Fminismes et identits nationales, Lyon, Programme Rhne-Alpes de recherche en sciences humaines, 1998, p. 141-152. 11 Revue de morale sociale (RMS), 5, no. 15, 1903, p. 246. 12 The rest were Swiss, Italian, British, German, Finnish, Norwegian, and American. See Groupe dinitiative, RMS, no. 1, 1899, p. 5-8. 13 Not all the founding members ever published articles in the review, but it is significant that they put their reputations behind the enterprise. 14 On Gevin-Cassal and Kergomard see Feminist Maternalists and the French State: Two Inspectresses General in the Pre-World War Third Republic, Journal of Womens History, 12, no. 1, Spring 2000, p. 32-59.

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Revue de morale sociale (RMS) provides a window on the role French specialists of both sexes played in circulating knowledge about gender and feminism across borders in the specific political context of the fin-de-sicle. Founded in 1899 in Geneva by an international group of reformist intellectuals that included numerous members of the new French Ligue des droits de lhomme (LDH), the journals aim was to identify, analyze scientifically and propose solutions to the problem of the moral and social relations of the sexes, which its editors termed the intersexual question. The first issue of the journal appeared just months after the Dreyfus Affair erupted in France, and featured a four-page list of members of the publications groupe dinitiative, later described as [an] imposing group of men and women [my emphasis], all thinkers and workers, filling for the most part some important social function, who responded enthusiastically to our appeal. 11 Forty-three of the original 166 founding members hailed from France. 12 Eleven of these were women; and about thirteen of the actual contributors from France were women, compared to approximately 25 men. 13 Given the restrictions on womens access to the professions at the time, the professional profiles of the Frenchwomen who contributed to the RMS were impressive and varied. Maria Martin and Marie Maugeret both edited feminist newspapers, respectively, the moderate Journal des Femmes, and Fminisme chrtien, a Catholic feminist publication. Jeanne OddoDeflou and Jeanne Chauvin had been among the first women to obtain law degrees. Olympe Gevin-Cassal served in the Interior Ministry as Inspectress General of Childrens Services and wrote childrens books. Pauline Kergomard, Inspector General of Nursery Schools, was the first woman to serve on the Conseil suprieur de linstruction publique, and an advocate of expanded roles for women in public services. 14 Ghnia de Sainte Croix (who wrote as Savioz and held Swiss nationality until her marriage to a Frenchman in 1900) was a widely published Paris-based journalist, essayist, and international activist, and a co-founder and secretary-general of the Conseil national des femmes franaises (CNFF). Isabelle Bogelot, also active in the Protestant womens movement, had since 1881 directed luvre des Libres de Saint-Lazare, a philanthropic work aimed at aiding prostitutes. Bogelot and de Sainte-Croix both campaigned actively against state-regulated prostitution, a cause they had in common with such male compatriots as M. J. Gaufrs, general secretary of the Ligue franaise de la moralit publique, as well as with Swiss co-collaborators

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

who had been followers of Josephine Butler. 15 Marie Bonnevial, a schoolteacher who wrote on womens economic position and education, was involved in socialist politics, served as secretary-general and later president of the Ligue franaise pour le droit des femmes, and eventually became the first woman to sit on the Conseil suprieur du travail. Maria Pognon feminist, pacifist, suffragist was president of the Ligue franaise pour le droit des femmes and a member of the Ligue pour larbitrage international. A number of the women wrote La Fronde, a Dreyfusard daily founded two years before, produced entirely by women, and sympathetic to feminism. These included Savioz, Maria Martin, Marie Maugeret, Louise Georges-Renard, Elisabeth-J. Hudry-Menos, and Olympe Gevin-Cassal. Jeanne Oddo-Deflou contributed to both publications as well as to fellow RMS collaborator Maria Martin's Journal des Femmes. 16 Thus the French women whose collaboration the editors of the Revue de morale sociale sought in 1899 were clearly selected because they were already considered specialists in gender relations, moral reform, or feminism at home. But these French contributors and founding members, both women and men, also added value to the Revue de morale sociales project as members of a celebrated new group of moral experts: the intellectuels, or public intellectuals. The Dreyfus case had fed the
On de Sainte-Croix/Savioz, see Karen Offen, La plus grande fministe de France : Mais qui est donc Madame Avril de Sainte-Croix?, Bulletin des Archives du Fminisme, 9, December 2005, and Madame Ghnia Avril de Sainte Croix, the Josephine Butler of France, Womens History Review, 17, 2, 2008, p. 239-255. Bogelot is discussed in Florence Rochefort, Feminism and Protestantism in nineteenthcentury France: first encounters, 1830-1900, in Karen Offen (ed.), Globalizing Feminisms, 1789-1945, London and New York, Routledge, 2009, p. 73. On the links among the European branches of Butlers International Abolitionist Federation see Anne Summers, Liberty, equality, morality: The attempt to sustain an international campaign against the double sexual standard, 1875-1906, in Globalizing Feminisms, op. cit., p. 26-35. Many, though not all, of the French affiliates of the review also belonged to the Protestant minority.Trans-border cooperation in Protestant social action and moral reform from the 1880s onward, particularly in the context of campaigns by Josephine Butler and French pastor Tommy Fallot, cemented the links between French and French-speaking Swiss members. On Protestantism and French feminism see Rochefort, Feminism and Protestantism, p. 67-77. On Tommy Fallots influence, see Florence Rochefort, The Abolitionist Struggle of Pastor Tommy Fallot: Between Social Christianity, Feminism and Secularism (1882-1893), Womens History Review, 17, no. 2, 2008, p. 179-194; and Steven C. Hause, Social Control in Late Nineteenth-Century France: Protestant Campaigns for Strict Public Morality, in Christopher E. Forth and Elinor Accampo (ed.), Confronting Modernity in Fin-de-Sicle France: Bodies, Minds and Gender, Houndmills, Basingstroke (UK), Palgrave Macmillan, 2010, p. 139-142. 16 The French male contributors included political economists, legal scholars, theologians, physicians, leading members of the newly formed Ligue des droits de lhomme, as well as moral reformers, journalists, editors and philanthropists. Members of the founding board included professors from Parisian and provincial faculties of law, theology, and medicine, from the Collge de France, and from the Sorbonne, as well as editors and directors of high-visibility reformist, political, and scientific periodicals including Yves Guyot (the political journal Le Sicle), Gabriel Monod (Revue historique), F. Pillon (LAnne philosophique), George Renard (just retired from the Revue socialiste), douard Toulouse (Revue de psychiatrie), and Louis Comte (Le Relvement social). Numerous academic contributors and sponsors had links to social science milieux, among them political economist Charles Gide, anthropologist Lonce Manouvrier, and social economist Alexis Delaire. For further information on these connections and the sources used to map them Anne R. Epstein, Gender, Intellectual Sociability, and Political Culture in the French Third Republic, 1890-1914, Ph.D. thesis, Indiana University, 2004.
15

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

From expertise to authority


The period after 1900 witnessed an increase in womens civic activism in France, and the politicization of gender issues drew in their male colleagues also. Women were invited to lecture before scholarly societies, at peoples universities, and at the independent institutions of higher learning that emerged beginning in the late nineteenth century: they organized and participated in meetings and congresses on civic education or philanthropy; founded civic associations to promote womens interests and eventually suffrage; published articles in womens, feminist, and literary-political publications; and joined reformist discussion forums. Organizations such as the CNFF lobbied parliament and worked their connections to get reform proposals onto the political agenda. By the end of the first decade of the 20th century, some women had begun converting their expertise in womens fields into a broader public authority on women and the feminine. In 1908 Jane Misme, a journalist and editor of La Franaise, was invited by the Socit de sociologie de Paris to speak not about women in journalism, but
W. Van der Vlugt, Pour La Finlande, Paris, ditions de lHumanit nouvelle, 1900, p. 19-27. Histoire dun plbiscite, RMS 2, no. 5, 1900, p. 4-25. 19 Groupe dinitiative, RMS, no. 1 (1899), p. 5-8.
17 18

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

international image of French intellectuals, notably but not only the members of the Ligue des droits de lhomme, as champions of human rights and justice and bearers of the legacy of the French Revolution. Members of the Ligue were sought-after partners for foreign intellectuals: for example, the Senator Ludovic Trarieux, president of the Ligue, was asked to head the six-member European delegation that traveled to St. Petersburg in June 1899 to protest the threat to Finnish sovereignty. 17 Because the supporters of the RMS saw the transnational project of eradicating the sexual double standard like the Dreyfus affair, the Armenian genocide, the Boer War, Finlands fight to keep its autonomy, and the failed effort to abolish stateregulated prostitution in Geneva as a problem of human rights, 18 the endorsement of 12 active members of the French LDH, in particular the female activists Ghnia de Sainte-Croix, Maria Pognon, Marie Bonnevial, and Jeanne Schmahl, provided a significant moral boost to the cause. 19 Juxtaposing articles on gender issues in France with texts on other countries, all by purported national experts, with the support of an illustrious groupe dinitiative, became a strategy for creating a transnational discourse on gender injustice and embedding the combat to eradicate it in the universal moral project of defending human rights. In this sense, the review bears a striking resemblance to the form of action favored by intellectuals throughout Europe at this time: the petition. The key difference here was that both male and female signatories and authority were needed to make the appeal for gender justice. Participation in such enterprises in turn reinforced French women contributors status as experts at home, by demonstrating their implication in a transnational network of recognized authorities on gender issues and reform.

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

20 Linstitutrice (Sance du 11 mars 1908), Revue internationale de sociologie (RIS), 16, 1908, p. 273296; and La femme de lettres (Sance du 9 dcembre 1908), RIS 17, 1909, p. 11-46. See also Anne R. Epstein, Women on the margins? Intellectual sociability and citizenship in Belle poque France, International Review of Sociology 20, no. 2, July 2010, p. 276-277. 21 La Mnagre et le fminisme (Sance du 8 juin 1910), RIS 18, 1910, p. 499-515; Lvolution et la femme (Sance du 10 mai 1911), RIS, 19, 1911, p. 408-435. 22 Union pour la vrit, Libres entretiens, 1st series, 9, 1905; and Libres entretiens, 5th series, 1-6, 19081909. See also Epstein, Women on the Margins, p. 275-276.

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

about female schoolteachers and women of letters as social types. 20 August MollWeiss, director of the cole des mres, lectured to the society in 1910 on Housewives and feminism, and Union de pense fminine founder Lydie Martial the following year on Evolution and women. 21 During the same period, Louise Compain, inspectress for a private child welfare agency, syndicalist, novelist, and publicist became a regular at the series of discussions, known as Libres entretiens, sponsored by Paul Desjardins Union pour la vrit. Here, along with Ccile Brunschvicg, Pauline Kergomard, Augusta Moll-Weiss, Hlne Porgs and other female experts, Compain discussed and debated subjects not always directly related to their professional profiles such as internationalism, the impact of the separation of church and state on the family (for which home economist Moll-Weiss was called in as an expert), suffrage reform and depopulation with prominent academics, lawyers, and government administrators. A special series on the economic and legal position of women featured several leaders of the CNFF. 22 As in the case of the RMS, the endorsement of prominent intellectuals and political figures in the organizations that invited women to participate in their debates enhanced the womens public profiles and drew attention to their ideas. With the political importance of gender issues on the rise, the womens own feminine or feminist expertise, conveyed through their identification with specific causes, associations, or publications, made them soughtafter collaborators for groups keen to display their openness to discussion of gender injustice. That female expertise in specific domains could now be generalized to encompass the broader implications of gender relations testifies to the structural changes taking place in both French society and the public sphere. Moroever, once women had begun to appear as experts, their specialized knowledge and opinions, whether feminist or feminine, could be mobilized not only to enrich public debate, but also to support scientific findings or political positions. Works by feminine experts in particular attracted attention from scholars seeking scientific justification for the maintenance of traditional gender hierarchies in the family and society. The educator Anna Lamprire provides an emblematic example. The former director of a training program for nursery school teachers, she was working as a journalist and publicist to support her two young daughters when she became involved with Lon Bourgeoiss solidarist movement in the mid-1890s. She soon became one of the most active proponents of solidarist civic education, first creating the Socit dtudes fminines in 1898, then organizing and serving as Secretary General of the Congrs de l'ducation sociale in 1900), and later Secretary General of the Socit pour l'ducation sociale, both presided over by Bourgeois. By 1898, she had published a full-length manifesto on female solidarism, Le rle social de la femme, which

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

Anna Lamprire, Le rle sociale de la femme, Paris, F. Alcan, 1898. The reviews are: Edmond Gosse, The Reverses of Britomart, North American Review, June 1899, cited by Lamprire in La Femme et son pouvoir, p. 12-13 and mile Durkheim, Anna Lamprire, Le rle social de la femme, Anne sociologique, 3, 1900, p. 390-391. Predictably, Durkheim criticized Lamprires method and some of her findings. But a review in by Durkheim in the Anne, an important vehicle for the transnational circulation of social scientific research, was still excellent publicity. 24 La cration dun enseignement suprieur fminin, Revue internationale de lenseignement, 46, 1903, p. 312-322. 25 La Femme et son pouvoir, Paris, V. Giard et E. Brire, 1909. On Lamprire see Anne R. Epstein, Anna Lamprire, solidarit et citoyennet fminine sous la Troisime Rpublique, Genre & Histoire [en ligne], n 3, Autumn 2008 [URL: http://genrehistoire.revues.org/index394]. 26 On Perriers use of Lamprires work, see Marion Thomas, Les femmes sont-elles dvoues naturellement ?: les tudes sur linstinct maternel animal en France sous la Troisime Rpublique, Revue dhistoire des sciences humaines, forthcoming. I thank the author for sharing this information. 27 Ellen Key, De lamour et du mariage, Prface Gabriel Monod, Paris, E. Flammarion, 1907; Le Sicle de lenfant Paris, E. Flammarion, 1910; and LIndividualisme (Images idales), Prface Pierre de Quirielle, Paris, E. Flammarion, 1910.
23

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

attracted attention both at home and abroad through reviews in publications such as the North American Review and sociologist mile Durkheims Anne sociologique. 23 Now a recognized expert on womens social role, as well as a seasoned educator, she was chosen by the Minister of Education to conduct an exploratory study on the creation of a program of feminine university studies, the conclusions of which were published in 1903. 24 By the time she followed up with a second book in 1909, her professional credentials, social resources, and identification with the movements leadership had established Lamprire as an authority on solidarism from a female perspective. 25 Her works became a reference for scholars close to Bourgeoiss solidarist movement, such the zoologist Edmond Perrier, who sought, by drawing parallels between human and animal behavior or between modern and traditional societies, to defend scientifically the status quo in gender relations and civic life against more liberal, feminist political visions of the Republic. 26 As these examples also show, intellectual men could be instrumental in fostering womanly expertise and authority when it complemented their own ideological and/or political projects. During the Belle poque, more and more texts by women recognized as experts began to circulate and gain public recognition, sometimes with a boost by a prominent male mentor. Texts by foreign female authorities also appeared in translation, their circulation in French-speaking milieux set into motion by men of letters or academics sympathetic to their ideas who either translated or wrote prefaces for their works. For example, in 1900, RMS collaborator and LDH member Yves Guyot wrote the preface for the French translation of Josephine Butlers memoirs, Souvenirs personnels d'une grande croisade, which dealt with the international campaign against state-regulated prostitution, a campaign in which a number of RMS supporters and collaborators took part. One of three texts by the Swedish writer and educator Ellen Key that appeared in French during the first decade of the 20th century, De lAmour et du Mariage was prefaced by another RMS founding member the noted historian and LDH member Gabriel Monod. 27 Keys work, which reflects the tension in her thought between individualism and the good of society or, as she puts it, between the interests of the individual and those of the

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

race, 28 as well as her ambivalence about feminism, appeared at a time when intellectual debates about solidarism and the role of the individual in society continued to preoccupy thinkers and activists in France. Monods preface placed it within this context and gave the book a certain cultural legitimacy. A second work by Key, LIndividualisme, later received a prize from the Acadmie franaise. By the end of the first decade of the twentieth century, several French former RMS contributors, now actively promoting various womens causes, had published essays or books on feminism, moral reform, or social relations, among them Ghnia de Sainte-Croix (Savioz), Isabelle Bogelot, Kthe Schirmacher, Olympe Gevin-Cassal, Margueritte de Schlumberger, and Jeanne Schmahl. Though some books appeared in print at their authors expense, most were published by reputable publishing houses, which might send them out to relevant journals to be reviewed or at least included on a list of books received. 29

Conclusion: Womanly expertise as a political resource


In 1908, philosopher Lon Brunschvicg, as moderator of the Union pour la vrits first Libre entretien of the season, on maternal authority, explained the groups choice of discussion format by saying that rather than taking up issues of principle, which would have certainly brought a lively exchange, they had:
decided ... to formulate a few well-defined questions as they appeared to us in the facts about the current state of societys evolution. On the basis of these questions, already considered and discussed in previous studies and in womens or feminist meetings, especially of the Conseil national des femmes franaises, we could expect precise solutions that could later be expressed clearly in a legislative text. 30

In other words, even if associations such the Socit de sociologie de Paris or the Union pour la vrit did not frequently sponsor lectures and debates on gender issues by female experts, their significance should not be underestimated. These were not just private discussions where friends and colleagues with similar worldviews got together to discuss topical issues although they obviously served that function also. The minutes of these meetings were published, and some of those present or those who read the proceedings might be in a position to propose or influence current or future legislation. It was thus not a coincidence that the Union scheduled discussions
Ellen Key, De lamour et du mariage, op. cit., p. 143. See for example, Ghnia (Avril) de Sainte-Croix, Une morale pour les deux sexes, Paris, 1900; La serve : iniquit sociale, Paris, 1901; and Le fminisme, Paris, V. Giard & E. Brire, 1907; Isabelle Bogelot, Trente ans de solidarit, 1877-1906, Paris, 1908; Kthe Schirmacher, Le travail des femmes en France, Paris, A. Rousseau, 1902; Olympe Gevin-Cassal, La fraternit en action, Prface William Poulin, Paris, Fischbacher, 1904; Marguerite de Witt de Schlumberger, Une femme aux femmes : pourquoi les femmes doivent tudier la question des murs ?, Genve, Secrtariat gnral de la Fdration abolitionniste internationale, 1908 (second of four editions). 30 LAutorit maternelle , Libres entretiens 5, no. 1 (15 November 1908), p. 2-3.
28 29

10

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

31 For details on the suffrage campaigns before 1914, see Laurence Klejman and Florence Rochefort, L'galit en marche : Le fminisme sous la Troisime Rpublique (Paris: Presses de la Fondation nationale des sciences politiques/Des femmes, 1989), Chapter 8; and Steven Hause with Anne R. Kenney, Women's Suffrage and Social Politics in the French Third Republic (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1984). 32 See for example Jean Elisabeth Pedersen, Legislating the French Family: Feminism, Theater, and Republican Politics, 1870-1920, New Brunswick, NJ and London, Rutgers University Press, which underlines the overwhelming male dominance not only of parliamentary but also of literary-theatrical debates over marriage and the family.

11

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

of the economic, social, political and legal status of women in beginning in 19081909. Different measures affecting womens citizenship were on the agenda. Most notably, the previous year, in 1907, CNFF leader Avril de Sainte-Croix had convinced LDH leaders to endorse the suffrage petition the moderate womens group was about to submit to Parliament, which was considering electoral reform. During this time, the CNFF converted to suffragism and a French suffragist organization, the Union franaise pour le suffrage des femmes (UFSF), formed in 1909. In fact, the most active female participants in these Entretiens were Brunschvicgs wife Ccile, Louise Compain, and Pauline Kergomard, two of whom were ranking members of the CNFF, which had the previous year petitioned Parliament to add womens suffrage to the proposed reform bill. Also at this time Jane Misme a founding member of the UFSF, of which Ccile Brunschvicg would become a leader and for which Louise Compain would later become publicist began lecturing on womens social role at the Socit de sociologie de Paris, whereas men connected with the Muse Social had previously done so. 31 These are just a few examples of how Republican politics and the enhanced public value of the feminine enabled well-connected professional women to expand their expertise into public authority. As sought-after collaborators, they drew on their newfound expertise in feminism and the feminine to gain access to various civic forums, influence political agendas, shape public discourse on the woman question, or publicize the specific political goals of organizations like the CNFF and the UFSF or of other, non-feminist, reformist associations. Moreover, the authority these women experts possessed could not be acquired by their male counterparts: it was gender specific. But because of the gendered structure of the public sphere, womanly expertise still functioned best as a complement to the masculine authority of the intellectuals who welcomed women as collaborators. Furthermore, womanly authority did not yet have the universal reach that mens authority did, nor could it always replace manly authority, even or perhaps especially, Tarde might have argued in debates over marriage, divorce, and the family. 32 In these areas, where womens rights and womens interests seemed to compete with those of men or worse, of society or the family the continued superiority of middle-aged mens capacity to exercise intermental action, reinforced of course by law and custom, was revealed. Nonetheless, as gender issues and sexuality moved to the center of public attention in France during the Belle poque, the opinions and specialist knowledge of female experts could inform public debate about citizenship, education, population issues, child welfare, marriage, family life, and even international relations. Their

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, mai-aot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

participation in the transnational circulation of knowledge about gender issues and feminism both enhanced and drew upon their status as national specialists. Womens expertise had become a political resource both for feminists and for their opponents, within the government and in civil society by the end of the first decade of the twentieth century, as women and men of diverse ideological leanings began to share and circulate knowledge about gender relations to combat gender injustice, both in France and abroad.
Lauteur Anne R. Epstein est chercheure post-doctorante lUniversit de Strasbourg, associe au PRISME-GSPE et au Network for European Studies de lUniversit dHelsinki, et charge de cours Sciences Po Paris. Ses recherches portent sur la sociabilit intellectuelle, le genre, et la citoyennet au tournant du XXe sicle, la circulation transnationale du savoir sur le genre et le fminisme, et lhistoire transnationale des coles europennes. Rsum La coopration intellectuelle transnationale et lemergence de lexperte en France la Belle poque Le tournant du vingtime sicle voit lmrgence dune expertise fminine en France, grce la restructuration de lespace public, laccs des femmes aux professions, et lintensification de la coopration intellectuelle transnationale. Cet article dmontre que certaines franaises, malgr leur statut politique marginal russissent transformer cette expertise fminine spcifique en resource politique dont elles peuvent se servir pour influencer lopinion, la politique et les institutions la veille de la premire guerre mondiale. Abstract The turn of the twentieth century witnessed the rise of the female expert in France, as a result of structural changes in the French public sphere, the entry of women into certain professions, and transnational developments. This article contends that certain French women, despite their marginal political status, transformed this gender-specific expertise into a political resource they could use to shape public opinion, politics, and institutions on the eve of World War I. Mots cls : femmes et expertise, histoire du genre, espace public, pratiques citoyennes, circulation transnationale des savoirs. Keywords : women and expertise, gender history, public sphere, citizenship practices, transnational circulation of knowledge. Pour citer cet article : Anne Epstein, Gender and the rise of the female expert during the Belle poque , Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, socit, n 14, maiaot 2011, www.histoire-politique.fr

12

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po

Document tlcharg depuis www.cairn.info - - - 83.103.180.245 - 22/12/2011 17h43. Presses de Sciences Po