Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
• On the basis of the sector performance, level of associated Risk & returns and
investment feasibility, sector trend, Selection of 5 sectors out of 34 sectors in
KSE (Excluding mutual funds)
• AS our main objective is to study the shares prices of the company, to check for
the Risk and return associated with the securities in which we are to invest
afterwards. Our Analysis of securities starts from 1st January 2001 to 30th October
2008. 1st January and 31st December in each year are considered to be the
opening & closing dates in each year respectively.
Table of Contents
• Industry Analysis
• Company Analysis
• Technical Analysis
• Summary
• Relative Return
• Actual Risk
o Forecasted Returns
• Expected Risk
• Observation
GNP
1
Consumption 100% of GDP There is reported less NI
growth as compared to the
Investment 21.6% of GDP previous year. The reason
Govt. Expenditures might be the insolvency
position of the country
Development $496 billion
8 Unemployment rise
Unemployment 16% subsequently drag the people
Rate to below poverty line. People
can not fulfill their necessities.
11 Debts
$ 14.2 Billion & 945
Domestic Billion from SBP
Foreign $45.00bn
Interpretation:
Almost all the indicators are showing that the country is in a severe economic recession
now a days, and there are least chances that the investor can have good returns out of
stocks. Keeping in view all of the above stated factors, we have decided 5 sectors in
which we think that we can have some good returns. We think that our perceived
sectors will at least be affected by current economic conditions. Which are discussed in
the succeeding pages.
Industry Analysis
1. Banking Sector:
Particulars Description
Stabilizing stage, for some companies there has been the declining
stage, going for mergers and acquisitions with some foreign as well
as some domestic banks to ensure their existence in the market.
Sector Life Cycle Even an international bank ABN Amro is being acquired by RBS
another international bank. MCB is going for merger with Barclays to
maintain economic capital limit of 12%, set by state bank of Pakistan.
In the past few year, banking sector had a boom with an annual
growth rate of 20%. Showing robust performance. But from the
Historical declaration of insolvency position of Pakistan in May 2008 and
performance grading it to CCC-, a huge amount of F.D.I. has out flowed, now the
banking sector’s overall growth is reduced to 11% for this year.
Market players HBL, NIB, MCB, NBP ABP, UBL, Bank Al-Habib, Saudi Pak Bank,
Meezan Bank, Bank al Islami
Risk & mitigation Inflation rate, Interest Rate, Rise in Economic Capital Limit.
Interpretation:
Banking industry is most affected by interest hike, foreign direct investment outflow,
inflation rate rise and risk of default. Therefore, a significant decrease in growth rate and
profitability is addressed.
2.Fertilizer Industry
Particulars Description
Expansion Stage, rising farming is resulting to rising needs of
fertilizers. Therefore, there have been a rising sales growth trend
Sector Life Cycle in the sector.
Competitors of
Engro Dawood Hercules, fauji fertilizers, Chemicals
Risk & mitigation Inflation rate, Interest Rate, Environmental problems, political
instability.
Interpretation:
Although the industry has shown a positive trend in growth, sales and profits. But
due to the economic downfall, there will be a set back for the company is shape
of decreasing demand for fertilizers. Subsequently, the company’s stock prices
are decreasing down, which may affect the company’s growth rate.
3.Cement Industry
Particulars Description
Sector Life Cycle Stabilizing, Domestic shortfall in demand but rising production is
offset by exporting more in the foreign market.
Competitors of
Lucky Cements Bestway cements, Fauji Cements
Risk & mitigation Inflation rate, Interest Rate, Downfall in developmental projects
Interpretation:
The current decrease in cement demand as compared to rising production to
utilize optimize capacity, has been offset by exporting to the other countries. This
means in case of any set back, company can stay in market due to steps
embossed in the foreign market.
4. Oil Sector(Oil Marketing Companies)
Particulars Description
Sector Life Cycle Stabilizing to expansion stage. As there has been more
exploration of oil fields in Pakistan by Exploration and production
companies, there will be more chances for the oil marketing
companies to expand by rising sales through availability of
reduced price oil, offsetting importing prices by the domestic
production.
Risk & mitigation Inflation rate, Interest Rate, Rise in oil prices, oil shortages.
Financial the oil consumption in the country posted a slight decline of 2.9
Indicators percent. 52 percent of the total consumption was met through
local refineries and the remaining 48 percent met through
imports. Among the companies, PSO occupied the largest slice of
68.2 percent
Interpretation:
The rising demand of oil in the market has given the OMCs a chance to again establish
themselves on the floor of market. The oil prices crunch had made many companies to
abolish their existence. In future it is expected that there will be growth in the sector.
5.Commodities Sector
Particulars Description
Expansion stage. There is a rising demand for the commodities,
Sector Life Cycle as these are the basic necessities for the people. The rising
population at a rate of 1.8 contributes towards more sales of the
commodities. And giving a backhand to flourish the industry. The
industry has although growth at lesser rate as compared to
previous year.
In the past years the industry has performed well, with ever
increasing sales growth. Even now in such an economic set back,
Historical the industry is performing well as the commodities are the need
performance of every person.
Risk & mitigation Inflation rate, Interest Rate, Rise in oil prices, decreasing
purchasing power of consumers
Financial Sales growth by 25%, Gross profit margin of the industry is 24%
Indicators while the net profit margin is 5%. Reduced Net profit margin is
due to increased debt cost and rising tax rate.
Interpretation:
The Commodities sector has although flourished but at a lesser pace as compared to
previous year. The rising demand for the commodities might be handy in the
development of the sector.
Company Analysis
Muslim Commercial Bank
Particulars Description
Net Revenues 28,235,393 (20% growth)
Profit after Tax 15,266 Million (25.8% increase)
Dividends 7854 Million (98% increase), Per share
12.5
Ratios:
Interpretation:
The company’s overall profitability is showing that it is going with a good growth rate. It
future it is expected that the company will give more better profits.
Nestle Pakistan
Particulars Description
Net Revenues (Recent) 28,235,393 (26% growth)
Profit after Tax 1,805,212 (27.14% increase)
Dividend per share 10
Ratios:
Interpretation:
Nestle Pakistan is fastly growing company, with a growth rate of 25%. It is expected that
it will give good returns.
Engro Chemicals:
Lucky Cements
Interpretation:
Particulars Description
Net Revenues (Recent) 23183 Million (37.1% growth)
Profit after Tax 3155 Million (23.9% increase)
Dividend per share 7
Ratios:
Engro chemicals has given good returns in the current year. It is expected that it will
give better profits in future irrespective of current economic spoil.
Interpretation:
PSO is expected to have loss in the current quarter. But it is supposed that its loss will
be changed into profits to give good returns.
Engro Chemicals
2001
Act.
Period Opening Closing Dividends Return R.R Risk
Cash Stock
First Quarter 70.12 66.32 0 0 -5.42% 0.95
(Avg)
Second Quarter
(Avg) 58.93 58.75 0 0 -0.31% 1.00
Third Quarter
(Avg) 53.58 49.87 0 0 -6.94% 0.93
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 52.38 54.33 7.5 0 18.04% 1.18
Average 58.75 57.32 1.88 0.00 1.34% 1.01 11.49%
2002
Act.
Period Opening Closing Dividends Return R.R Risk
Cash Stock
First Quarter
(Avg) 62.52 69.68 0 0 11.46% 1.11
Second Quarter
(Avg) 65.90 61.45 0 0 -6.75% 0.93
Third Quarter
(Avg) 61.08 62.15 0 0 1.75% 1.02
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 68.45 78.10 7.5 0 25.05% 1.25
Average 64.49 67.85 1.88 0.00 7.88% 1.08 13.66%
2003
Act.
Period Opening Closing Dividends Return R.R Risk
Cash Stock
First Quarter
(Avg) 87.65 84.67 0 0 -3.40% 0.97
Second Quarter
(Avg) 81.30 82.55 0 0 1.54% 1.02
Third Quarter
(Avg) 91.47 89.52 0 0 -2.13% 0.98
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 82.37 86.30 8 0 14.49% 1.14
Average 85.70 85.76 2.00 0.00 2.62% 1.03 8.18%
2004
Act.
Period Opening Closing Dividends Return R.R Risk
Cash Stock
First Quarter
(Avg) 95.28 97.12 0 0 1.92% 1.02
Second Quarter
(Avg) 98.52 98.25 0 0 -0.27% 1.00
Third Quarter
(Avg) 95.77 93.58 0 0 -2.28% 0.98
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 100.15 112.93 8.5 0 21.25% 1.21
Average 97.43 100.47 2.13 0.00 5.16% 1.05 10.87%
2005
Act.
Period Opening Closing Dividends Return R.R Risk
Cash Stock
First Quarter
(Avg) 126.33 126.18 0 0 -0.12% 1.00
Second Quarter
(Avg) 120.43 115.90 0 0 -3.76% 0.96
Third Quarter
(Avg) 118.05 125.80 0 0 6.57% 1.07
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 154.80 163.45 11 0 12.69% 1.13 7.29%
Average 129.90 132.83 2.75 0.00 3.84% 1.04 7.29%
2006
Act.
Period Opening Closing Dividends Return R.R Risk
Cash Stock
First Quarter
(Avg) 196.62 211.13 0 0 7.38% 1.07
Second Quarter
(Avg) 193.00 180.13 3 0 -5.11% 0.95
Third Quarter
(Avg) 175.37 178.60 3 0 3.55% 1.04
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 177.75 174.38 3 0 -0.21% 1.00
Average 185.68 186.06 2.25 0.00 1.40% 1.01 5.34%
2007
Act.
Period Opening Closing Dividends Return R.R Risk
Cash Stock
First Quarter
(Avg) 178.62 184.22 0 0 3.14% 1.03
Second Quarter
(Avg) 200.18 222.58 2 0 12.19% 1.12
Third Quarter
(Avg) 244.17 246.47 2 0 1.76% 1.02
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 272.05 274.00 3 0 1.82% 1.02
Average 223.75 231.82 1.75 0.00 4.73% 1.05 5.02%
2008
Act.
Period Opening Closing Dividends Return R.R Risk
Cash Stock
First Quarter
(Avg) 291.52 310.90 0 0 6.65% 1.07
Second Quarter
(Avg) 310.65 296.29 2 0 -3.98% 0.96
Third Quarter -14.05
(Avg) 223.86 190.40 2 0 % 0.86
Average 275.34 265.86 1.33 0.00 -0.04 0.96 10.35%
Interpretation:
Engro Pakistan is giving negative returns in securities. The current economic downfall
has affected it positions of giving good returns a lot.
Lucky Cements
2001
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 7.52 6.83 0 0 -9.09 0.91
(Avg) %
Second Quarter 13.76
(Avg) 6.78 6.97 0.75 0 % 1.14
Third Quarter -12.1
(Avg) 6.43 5.65 0 0 8% 0.88
Fourth Quarter 12.11
(Avg) 6.47 7.25 0 0 % 1.12
0 1.15 13.68
Average 6.80 6.68 0.19 .00 % 1.01 %
2002
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 0 10.73
(Avg) 9.78 10.83 0.00 .00 % 1.11
Second Quarter 0 1.45
(Avg) 9.17 8.55 0.75 .00 % 1.01
Third Quarter 0 5.86
(Avg) 8.82 9.33 0.00 .00 % 1.06
Fourth Quarter 0 4.91
(Avg) 9.85 10.33 0.00 .00 % 1.05
0 5.74 3.83
Average 9.40 9.76 0.19 .00 % 1.06 %
2003
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 0 -3.03
(Avg) 10.18 9.80 0.00 .08 % 0.97
Second Quarter 0 29.58
(Avg) 11.55 14.22 0.75 .00 % 1.30
Third Quarter 0 4.21
(Avg) 20.60 21.47 0.00 .00 % 1.04
Fourth Quarter 0 6.44
(Avg) 20.70 22.03 0.00 .00 % 1.06
0 9.30 14.11
Average 15.76 16.88 0.19 .02 % 1.09 %
2004
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 0 11.10
(Avg) 26.13 29.03 0.00 .00 % 1.11
Second Quarter 0 6.89
(Avg) 38.70 40.62 0.75 .00 % 1.07
Third Quarter 0 -1.24
(Avg) 38.83 38.35 0.00 .00 % 0.99
Fourth Quarter 0 2.72
(Avg) 36.75 37.75 0.00 .00 % 1.03
0 4.87 5.32
Average 35.10 36.44 0.19 .00 % 1.05 %
2005
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 0 6.01
(Avg) 43.55 46.17 0.00 .00 % 1.06
Second Quarter 0 -2.31
(Avg) 43.27 42.27 0.00 .00 % 0.98
Third Quarter 0 5.07
(Avg) 45.35 47.65 0.00 .00 % 1.05
Fourth Quarter 0 16.22 7.62
(Avg) 64.72 75.22 0.00 .00 % 1.16 %
0 6.25 7.62
Average 49.22 52.83 0.00 .00 % 1.06 %
2006
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 111.1 0 13.03
(Avg) 98.35 7 0.00 .00 % 1.13
Second Quarter 110.2 103.9 0 -4.78
(Avg) 3 7 1.00 .00 % 0.95
Third Quarter 102.8 101.9 0 -0.89
(Avg) 8 7 0.00 .00 % 0.99
Fourth Quarter 0 -15.3
(Avg) 88.67 75.03 0.00 .00 8% 0.85
100.0 0 -2.00 11.74
Average 3 98.03 0.25 .00 % 0.98 %
2007
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 0 10.11
(Avg) 63.98 70.45 0.00 .00 % 1.10
Second Quarter 117.4 0 21.17
(Avg) 97.93 2 1.25 .00 % 1.21
Third Quarter 126.0 122.8 0 -2.51
(Avg) 3 7 0.00 .00 % 0.97
Fourth Quarter 126.1 122.2 0 -3.10
(Avg) 8 7 0.00 .00 % 0.97
103.5 108.2 0 6.42 11.57
Average 3 5 0.31 .00 % 1.06 %
2008
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 120.7 128.4 0 6.42
(Avg) 0 5 0.00 .00 % 1.06
Second Quarter 130.4 116.5 0 -9.73
(Avg) 7 3 1.25 .00 % 0.90
Third Quarter 0 -12.8
(Avg) 77.87 67.84 0.00 .00 8% 0.87
109.6 104.2 0 10.35
Average 8 7 0.42 .00 -0.05 0.95 %
Interpretation:
At the start of 2008, lucky cements had given good returns, but the economic downfall
has affected the company’s returns a lot.
MCB
2001
Openi Closin Dividend Act.
Period ng g s Return R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter -9.71
(Avg) 30.73 27.75 0.00 0.00 % 0.90
Second Quarter
(Avg) 25.52 25.83 0.00 0.00 1.24% 1.01
Third Quarter -4.76
(Avg) 22.75 21.67 0.00 0.00 % 0.95
Fourth Quarter -2.33
(Avg) 22.90 22.37 0.00 0.00 % 0.98
-3.89
Average 25.48 24.40 0.00 0.00 % 0.96 4.60%
2002
Openi Closin Dividend Act.
Period ng g s Return R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter
(Avg) 22.87 25.13 0.00 0.00 9.91% 1.10
Second Quarter
(Avg) 26.82 27.88 0.00 0.00 3.98% 1.04
Third Quarter -2.55
(Avg) 26.12 25.45 0.00 0.00 % 0.97
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 30.97 33.05 0.00 0.00 6.73% 1.07
Average 26.69 27.88 0.00 0.00 4.52% 1.05 5.30%
2003
Period Openi Closin Dividend Return R.R Act.
ng g s Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter
(Avg) 33.71 33.68 1.50 0.00 4.35% 1.04
Second Quarter
(Avg) 34.20 35.63 0.00 0.00 4.19% 1.04
Third Quarter
(Avg) 45.03 47.45 1.25 0.00 8.14% 1.08
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 44.23 46.43 0.00 1.00 7.23% 1.07
Average 39.29 40.80 0.69 0.25 5.98% 1.06 2.01%
2004
Openi Closin Dividend Act.
Period ng g s Return R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter
(Avg) 51.42 50.52 1.00 0.00 0.19% 1.00
Second Quarter
(Avg) 53.90 54.53 0.00 0.00 1.18% 1.01
Third Quarter
(Avg) 51.40 51.17 1.50 0.00 2.46% 1.02
Fourth Quarter
(Avg) 50.00 52.93 0.00 1.00 7.87% 1.08
Average 51.68 52.29 0.63 0.25 2.93% 1.03 3.42%
2005
Openi Closin Dividend Act.
Period ng g s Return R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter
(Avg) 67.53 69.30 1.75 0.00 5.21% 1.05
Second Quarter
(Avg) 69.08 74.18 0.00 0.00 7.38% 1.07
Third Quarter 105.7 19.05
(Avg) 90.10 7 1.50 0.00 % 1.19
Fourth Quarter 143.1 156.9 11.76
(Avg) 3 7 1.00 2.00 % 1.12
101.5 10.85
Average 92.46 5 1.06 0.50 % 1.11 6.11%
2006
Openi Closin Dividend Act.
Period ng g s Return R.R Risk
Cash Stoc
k
First Quarter 215.2 234.3
(Avg) 7 5 2.00 0.00 9.79% 1.10
Second Quarter 220.4 215.5 -1.32
(Avg) 8 7 2.00 0.00 % 0.99
Third Quarter 215.8 230.7
(Avg) 0 0 2.00 0.00 7.83% 1.08
Fourth Quarter 261.5 258.5
(Avg) 0 3 1.50 1.50 0.01% 1.00
228.2 234.7
Average 6 9 1.88 0.38 4.08% 1.04 5.55%
2007
Openi Closin Dividend Act.
Period ng g s Return R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 279.0 287.2
(Avg) 2 0 2.50 0.00 3.83% 1.04
Second Quarter 303.2 334.6 11.20
(Avg) 0 5 2.50 0.00 % 1.11
Third Quarter 333.7 323.0 -2.45
(Avg) 0 3 2.50 0.00 % 0.98
Fourth Quarter 361.8 384.1
(Avg) 0 2 5.00 0.00 7.55% 1.08
319.4 332.2
Average 3 5 3.13 0.00 5.03% 1.05 5.82%
2008
Openi Closin Dividend Act.
Period ng g s Return R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 408.9 414.1
(Avg) 5 3 1.50 0.00 1.63% 1.02
Second Quarter 368.3 338.6 -7.25
(Avg) 0 0 3.00 0.00 % 0.93
Third Quarter 280.4 252.5 -9.94
(Avg) 6 7 0.00 % 0.90
352.5 335.1
Average 7 0 2.25 0.00 -0.05 0.95 6.06%
Interpretation:
MCB has given all time good returns. It the current year it had initially given very good
return. The economic downfall has somewhat affected the company initially, but
afterwards it stabilize it by again showing positive returns. But being an interest
sensitive company, the outflow of F.D.I and interest rate hike again dropped its returns
to losses
PSO
2001
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 143.5 140.4 0 -2.17
(Avg) 3 2 0.00 .00 % 0.98
Second Quarter 139.4 138.8 0 -0.42
(Avg) 5 7 0.00 .00 % 1.00
Third Quarter 127.9 119.0 0 -7.01
(Avg) 7 0 0.00 .00 % 0.93
Fourth Quarter 105.3 100.9 0 -4.18
(Avg) 3 3 0.00 .00 % 0.96
129.0 124.8 0 -3.44 2.83
Average 7 0 0.00 .00 % 0.97 %
2002
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 116.6 138.2 0 18.51
(Avg) 3 2 0.00 .00 % 1.19
Second Quarter 150.0 144.3 0 -3.81
(Avg) 5 3 0.00 .00 % 0.96
Third Quarter 161.1 180.2 0 11.85
(Avg) 5 5 0.00 .00 % 1.12
Fourth Quarter 189.7 194.4 0 2.49
(Avg) 2 5 0.00 .00 % 1.02
154.3 164.3 0 7.26 9.88
Average 9 1 0.00 .00 % 1.07 %
2003
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 199.7 196.9 0 -1.43
(Avg) 9 3 0.00 .00 % 0.99
Second Quarter 207.3 215.8 0 4.08
(Avg) 3 0 0.00 .00 % 1.04
Third Quarter 266.4 283.2 0 6.28
(Avg) 8 2 0.00 .00 % 1.06
Fourth Quarter 267.4 270.7 0 1.25
(Avg) 2 7 0.00 .00 % 1.01
235.2 241.6 0 2.55 3.36
Average 6 8 0.00 .00 % 1.03 %
2004
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 289.7 288.7 0 -0.36
(Avg) 7 3 0.00 .00 % 1.00
Second Quarter 275.8 266.2 0 -3.47
(Avg) 2 5 0.00 .00 % 0.97
Third Quarter 256.5 254.3 0 -0.84
(Avg) 3 8 0.00 .00 % 0.99
Fourth Quarter 258.7 270.8 0 4.70
(Avg) 2 7 0.00 .00 % 1.05
270.2 270.0 0 0.01 3.41
Average 1 6 0.00 .00 % 1.00 %
2005
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 336.6 373.6 0 11.02
(Avg) 0 8 0.00 .00 % 1.11
Second Quarter 375.0 371.0 0.00 0 -1.07 0.99
(Avg) 0 0 .00 %
Third Quarter 383.2 382.8 0 -0.09
(Avg) 2 8 0.00 .00 % 1.00
Fourth Quarter 403.8 414.4 0 2.63
(Avg) 3 5 0.00 .00 % 1.03
374.6 385.5 0 3.12 5.49
Average 6 0 0.00 .00 % 1.03 %
2006
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 416.1 401.5 0 -3.51
(Avg) 2 0 0.00 .00 % 0.96
Second Quarter 339.6 318.3 0 -0.98
(Avg) 7 3 18.00 .00 % 0.99
Third Quarter 333.8 334.9 0 0.30
(Avg) 8 0 0.00 .00 % 1.00
Fourth Quarter 304.0 300.0 0 0.65
(Avg) 2 0 6.00 .00 % 1.01
348.4 338.6 0 -0.88 1.89
Average 2 8 6.00 .00 % 0.99 %
2007
Openi Closi Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng ng ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 329.7 350.0 0 7.38
(Avg) 3 8 4.00 .00 % 1.07
Second Quarter 361.8 373.9 0 6.39
(Avg) 5 8 11.00 .00 % 1.06
Third Quarter 365.3 355.0 0 -1.45
(Avg) 2 2 5.00 .00 % 0.99
Fourth Quarter 399.1 414.5 0 3.85
(Avg) 7 2 0.00 .00 % 1.04
364.0 373.4 0 4.04 3.95
Average 2 0 5.00 .00 % 1.04 %
2008
Period Openi Closi Dividen Retur R.R Act.
ng ng ds n Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 447.5 489.8 0 10.79
(Avg) 2 0 6.00 .00 % 1.11
Second Quarter 492.1 453.4 0 -7.87
(Avg) 5 1 .00 % 0.92
Third Quarter 356.8 311.1 0 -12.8
(Avg) 6 1 .00 2% 0.87
432.1 418.1 0 12.45
Average 8 1 6.00 .00 -0.03 0.97 %
Interprettion:
PSO has given all time good returns. During the current year it had initially given very
good return. The economic downfall has somewhat affected the company initially, but
afterwards it stabilize it by again showing positive returns. But being a cyclical nature
company, the rise and fall in prices of petroleum has greatly affected the current
p[performance of PSO. PSO is at 12.2 loss per share in the quarter. But hoping to
change losses into profits in the remaining year.
Nestle
2001
Openi Closin Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng g ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 143.0 139.6 0 -2.33
(Avg) 0 7 0.00 .00 % 0.98
Second Quarter 132.3 131.3 0 -0.76
(Avg) 3 3 0.00 .00 % 0.99
Third Quarter 142.6 148.6 0 4.21
(Avg) 7 7 0.00 .00 % 1.04
Fourth Quarter 159.0 158.6 0 -0.21
(Avg) 0 7 0.00 .00 % 1.00
144.2 144.5 0 0.23 2.80
Average 5 8 0.00 .00 % 1.00 %
2002
Openi Closin Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng g ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 167.3 174.6 0 4.38
(Avg) 3 7 0.00 .00 % 1.04
Second Quarter 183.0 187.6 0 2.55
(Avg) 0 7 0.00 .00 % 1.03
Third Quarter 189.8 190.5 0 0.35
(Avg) 3 0 0.00 .00 % 1.00
Fourth Quarter 199.0 207.8 0 4.44
(Avg) 0 3 0.00 .00 % 1.04
184.7 190.1 0 2.93 1.93
Average 9 7 0.00 .00 % 1.03 %
2003
Openi Closin Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng g ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 205.5 200.3 0 -2.51
(Avg) 3 7 0.00 .00 % 0.97
Second Quarter 216.0 231.6 0 7.25
(Avg) 0 7 0.00 .00 % 1.07
Third Quarter 266.2 275.6 0 3.51
(Avg) 7 0 0.00 .00 % 1.04
Fourth Quarter 274.3 307.0 0 13.36
(Avg) 7 3 4.00 .00 % 1.13
240.5 253.6 0 5.40 6.66
Average 4 7 1.00 .00 % 1.05 %
2004
Openi Closin Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng g ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 436.6 471.3 0.00 0 7.94 1.08
(Avg) 5 2 .00 %
Second Quarter 483.0 482.6 0 -0.07
(Avg) 0 7 0.00 .00 % 1.00
Third Quarter 461.6 455.3 0 -1.37
(Avg) 7 3 0.00 .00 % 0.99
Fourth Quarter 465.0 485.0 0 5.37
(Avg) 2 0 5.00 .00 % 1.05
461.5 473.5 0 2.97 4.42
Average 8 8 1.25 .00 % 1.03 %
2005
Openi Closin Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng g ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 509.9 511.6 0 0.33
(Avg) 8 7 0.00 .00 % 1.00
Second Quarter 537.0 540.0 0 0.56
(Avg) 8 8 0.00 .00 % 1.01
Third Quarter 542.2 549.8 0 1.41
(Avg) 2 8 0.00 .00 % 1.01
Fourth Quarter 562.3 577.3 0 5.33
(Avg) 3 3 15.00 .00 % 1.05
537.9 544.7 0 1.91 2.33
Average 0 4 3.75 .00 % 1.02 %
2006
Openi Closin Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng g ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 697.0 771.3 0 10.66
(Avg) 0 3 0.00 .00 % 1.11
Second Quarter 990.6 1083. 0 9.34
(Avg) 7 19 0.00 .00 % 1.09
Third Quarter 1030. 975.8 0 -5.26
(Avg) 07 8 0.00 .00 % 0.95
Fourth Quarter 930.0 965.0 0 4.30
(Avg) 2 0 5.00 .00 % 1.04
911.9 948.8 0 4.76 7.22
Average 4 5 1.25 .00 % 1.05 %
2007
Openi Closin Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng g ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 1275. 1487. 0 16.59
(Avg) 98 67 0.00 .00 % 1.17
Second Quarter 1586. 1541. 0 -2.84
(Avg) 33 33 0.00 .00 % 0.97
Third Quarter 1513. 1498. 0 -0.99
(Avg) 33 33 0.00 .00 % 0.99
Fourth Quarter 1621. 1721. 0 6.78
(Avg) 67 67 10.00 .00 % 1.07
1499. 1562. 0 4.89 8.85
Average 33 25 2.50 .00 % 1.05 %
2008
Openi Closin Dividen Retur Act.
Period ng g ds n R.R Risk
Stoc
Cash k
First Quarter 1696. 1600. 0 -5.66
(Avg) 97 97 .00 % 0.94
Second Quarter 1405. 1448. 0 3.03
(Avg) 84 50 .00 % 1.03
Third Quarter 1640. 0 0.00
(Avg) 00 7.00 .00 % 1.00
1580. 1524. 0 4.41
Average 93 74 7.00 .00 -0.01 0.99 %
Interpretation:
Neslte Pakistan has given all time good returns. Even in the current economic spoil,
nestle was initially had a downfall, but being an international company, it has made it
stabilized to give expected returns at good rate.
Expected Risk & Return
Engro
δA = √∑(R-
ṜA)2P 5.29%
Interpretation:
The expected returns of the company are depicted to be
negative with a high risk involvement.
δB = √∑(R-
ṜB)2P 4.57%
Interpretation:
MCB is expected to give good returns in future with a least
rate of risk associated with it.
Lucky Cements
δE = √∑(R-
ṜE)2P 5.79%
Interpretation:
Probability
Return (R) (P)
10.00% 0.08
5.00% 0.12
3.00% 0.15
-5.00% 0.25
-10.00% 0.4
1
From May 2008 onwards, there have been a decreasing trend in the security’s prices of Engro
Chemicals. In the past years, the security’s prices were rising steadily, showing a good growth
rate. But the first set back occurred in May 2008 when there has been a drastic decrease in the
prices. While after that the prices are constantly decreasing. Showing all time negative returns.
The last return given by the security in September was. As now a days there have been a cash
outflow of $8.84 billion out of stock market by the foreign investors, so it can be easily
interpreted that the stock prices will go down. There is a rise in interest rate (13.33%), although
somewhat money appreciation is seen now a days but the discount rate is still very high (10.2%)
depicting that the company is affected highly by the current economic disaster.
• IMF loan of $3.5 billion for maintaining the solvency position of the country
• IMF loan of $3.5 billion for maintaining the solvency position of the country
Lucy Cements
From May 2008 onwards, there have been a decreasing trend in the security’s prices of Lucky
Cements. In the past years, there was a pretty fair rise in prices, showing a fair growth rate. But
the first set back occurred in May 2008 when there has been a drastic decrease in the prices ().
But the matter does not end here; there was a constant decrease in prices until the prices
reached almost the half of the peak value, giving negative returns. The company didn’t give
stable positive returns at any period. As now a days there have been a cash outflow of $8.84
billion out of stock market by the foreign investors, so it can be easily interpreted that the stock
prices will go down. There is a rise in interest rate (15%), although somewhat money
appreciation is seen now a days but the discount rate is still very high (10.2%). The statistics are
depicting that the company is affected highly by the current economic disaster.
• IMF loan of $3.5 billion for maintaining the solvency position of the country
From May 2008 onwards, there have been a decreasing trend in the security’s prices of
Pakistan State Oil. In the past years, there was a healthy rise in prices, showing a robust growth
rate. But the first set back occurred in May 2008 when there has been a drastic decrease in the
prices ().While after that the prices had decreasing trend until the prices reached almost the half
of the peak value, giving negative returns. In the current quarter the company had a heavy loss
of -48.88 EPS, depicting that company will not be able to give progress in the current scenario.
As now a days there have been a cash outflow of $8.84 billion out of stock market by the foreign
investors, so it can be easily interpreted that the stock prices will go down. There is a rise in
interest rate (13.33%), although somewhat money appreciation is seen now a days but the
discount rate is still very high (10.2%). The statistics are depicting that the company was
affected highly by the current economic disaster.
• IMF loan of $3.5 billion for maintaining the solvency position of the country
Nestle Pakistan
Return Probability
(R) (P)
15.00% 0.1
10.00% 0.15
5.00% 0.3
2.00% 0.4
-2.00% 0.05
1
There was a slight deviation in prices of Nestle in May 2008, but the decrease didn’t last for
long. And the company, being an international company, grew at a robust rate irrespective of the
current economic conditions of the country. So it can be interpreted that the company will give
high positive returns in future. As the Company have grown at a steady rate, so somewhat less
but constant returns are expected.
Portfolio Risk & Return
Let Returns of; Expected risk are:
Engro =
A -3.40% 5.29%
MCB =
B 2.86% 4.57%
L.C. =
C 0.01% 2.51%
PSO =
D -1.30% 6.86%
Nestle =
E 5.20% 5.79%
Portfolios = {AB,AC,AD,AE,BC,BD,BE,CD,CE,
DE}
So examining all of the above stated portfolios one by one:
S. no A B A.B A2 B2
1 0.1000 0.1000 0.0100 0.0100 0.0100
2 0.0500 0.0800 0.0040 0.0025 0.0064
3 0.0300 0.0500 0.0015 0.0009 0.0025
-0.001
4 -0.0500 0.0200 0 0.0025 0.0004
5 -0.1000 -0.0500 0.0050 0.0100 0.0025
Total 0.0300 0.2000 0.0195 0.0259 0.0218
Expected Portfolio Risk (δP1)
r1 = 0.9714
δA = 5.29%
δB = 4.57%
δP1 = 0.038%
S. no A C A.C A2 C2
1 0.1000 0.0500 0.0050 0.0100 0.0025
2 0.0500 0.0300 0.0015 0.0025 0.0009
3 0.0300 0.0100 0.0003 0.0009 0.0001
4 -0.0500 -0.0200 0.0010 0.0025 0.0004
5 -0.1000 -0.0500 0.0050 0.0100 0.0025
Total 0.0128 0.0259 0.0064
S. no A D A.D A2 D2
1 10.00% 10.00% 0.0100 0.0100 0.0100
2 5.00% 7.00% 0.0035 0.0025 0.0049
3 3.00% 3.00% 0.0009 0.0009 0.0009
4 -5.00% -5.00% 0.0025 0.0025 0.0025
5 -10.00% -15.00% 0.0150 0.0100 0.0225
Total 3.00% 0.00% 0.0319 0.0259 0.0408
S. no A E A.E A2 E2
1 10.00% 15.00% 0.0150 0.0100 0.0225
2 5.00% 10.00% 0.0050 0.0025 0.0100
3 3.00% 5.00% 0.0015 0.0009 0.0025
-0.001
4 -5.00% 2.00% 0 0.0025 0.0004
5 -10.00% -2.00% 0.0020 0.0100 0.0004
Total 3.00% 30.00% 0.0225 0.0259 0.0358
S. no B C B.C B2 C2
1 10.00% 5.00% 0.0050 0.0100 0.0025
2 8.00% 3.00% 0.0024 0.0064 0.0009
3 5.00% 1.00% 0.0005 0.0025 0.0001
-0.000
4 2.00% -2.00% 4 0.0004 0.0004
5 -5.00% -5.00% 0.0025 0.0025 0.0025
Total 20.00% 2.00% 0.0100 0.0218 0.0064
S. no B D B.D B2 D2
1 10.00% 10.00% 0.0100 0.0100 0.0100
2 8.00% 7.00% 0.0056 0.0064 0.0049
3 5.00% 3.00% 0.0015 0.0025 0.0009
-0.001
4 2.00% -5.00% 0 0.0004 0.0025
5 -5.00% -15.00% 0.0075 0.0025 0.0225
Total 20.00% 0.00% 0.0236 0.0218 0.0408
S. no B E B.E B2 E2
1 10.00% 15.00% 0.0150 0.0100 0.0225
2 8.00% 10.00% 0.0080 0.0064 0.0100
3 5.00% 5.00% 0.0025 0.0025 0.0025
4 2.00% 2.00% 0.0004 0.0004 0.0004
5 -5.00% -2.00% 0.0010 0.0025 0.0004
Total 20.00% 30.00% 0.0269 0.0218 0.0358
S. no C D C.D. C2 D2
1 5.00% 10.00% 0.0050 0.0025 0.0100
2 3.00% 7.00% 0.0021 0.0009 0.0049
3 1.00% 3.00% 0.0003 0.0001 0.0009
4 -2.00% -5.00% 0.0010 0.0004 0.0025
5 -5.00% -15.00% 0.0075 0.0025 0.0225
Total 2.00% 0.00% 0.0159 0.0064 0.0408
S. no C E C.E. C2 E2
1 5.00% 10.00% 0.0050 0.0025 0.0100
2 3.00% 7.00% 0.0021 0.0009 0.0049
3 1.00% 3.00% 0.0003 0.0001 0.0009
4 -2.00% -5.00% 0.0010 0.0004 0.0025
5 -5.00% -15.00% 0.0075 0.0025 0.0225
Total 2.00% 0.00% 0.0159 0.0064 0.0408
S. no D E D.E. D2 E2
1 5.00% 10.00% 0.0050 0.0025 0.0100
2 3.00% 7.00% 0.0021 0.0009 0.0049
3 1.00% 3.00% 0.0003 0.0001 0.0009
4 -2.00% -5.00% 0.0010 0.0004 0.0025
5 -5.00% -15.00% 0.0075 0.0025 0.0225
Total 2.00% 0.00% 0.0159 0.0064 0.0408
Risk on Return:
A,A 1 -0.0136
B,B 1 0.01144
C,C 1 4E-05
D,D 1 -0.0052
E,E 1 0.0208