PV Elite 2012 Licensee: L&T HED FileName : Combined load calc_Head Only ------------------ Page 1 of 2 Stress due to Combined

Loads : Step: 13 11:37a Jun 23,2012

Stress Combination Load Cases for Vertical Vessels: Load Case Definition Key

IP EP HP NP EW OW HW WI EQ EE HI HE WE WF CW VO VE VF FW FS BW BS BN BU

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =

Longitudinal Stress due to Internal Pressure Longitudinal Stress due to External Pressure Longitudinal Stress due to Hydrotest Pressure No Pressure Longitudinal Stress due to Weight (No Liquid) Longitudinal Stress due to Weight (Operating) Longitudinal Stress due to Weight (Hydrotest) Bending Stress due to Wind Moment (Operating) Bending Stress due to Earthquake Moment (Operating) Bending Stress due to Earthquake Moment (Empty) Bending Stress due to Wind Moment (Hydrotest) Bending Stress due to Earthquake Moment (Hydrotest) Bending Stress due to Wind Moment (Empty) (no CA) Bending Stress due to Wind Moment (Filled) (no CA) Longitudinal Stress due to Weight (Empty) (no CA) Bending Stress due to Vortex Shedding Loads ( Ope ) Bending Stress due to Vortex Shedding Loads ( Emp ) Bending Stress due to Vortex Shedding Loads ( Test No CA. ) Axial Stress due to Vertical Forces for the Wind Case Axial Stress due to Vertical Forces for the Seismic Case Bending Stress due to Lat. Forces for the Wind Case, Corroded Bending Stress due to Lat. Forces for the Seismic Case, Corroded Bending Stress due to Lat. Forces for the Wind Case, UnCorroded Bending Stress due to Lat. Forces for the Seismic Case, UnCorroded

General Notes: Case types HI and HE are in the Un-Corroded condition. Case types WE, WF, and CW are in the Un-Corroded condition. A blank stress and stress ratio indicates that the corresponding stress comprising those components that did not contribute to that type of stress. For Division 2, stress Sigma1 is the hoop stress due to internal pressure. Stress Sigma2 is the max(abs( positive stress, 0.0 )). The positive magnitude of Sigma3 is the 0.5 times the pressure. The stresses are combined per equation 4.3.44 to determine the overall stress intensity. An asterisk (*) in the final column denotes overstress. Note: Performing Combined Stress Analysis per VIII-2 paragraph 4.3.10.2.

Analysis of Load Case 1 : IP

From Node 10 20 30

Stress Intensity 0.00 100.02 103.78

All. Stress Intensity 136.47 136.47 136.47

Compressive Stress 0.00

All. Comp. Stress Fxa 122.57 122.57 72.31

S. I. Ratio 0.0000 0.7329 0.7605

Comp. Ratio 0.0000

PV Elite 2012 Licensee: L&T HED FileName : Combined load calc_Head Only ------------------ Page 2 of 2 Stress due to Combined Loads : Step: 13 11:37a Jun 23,2012
Analysis of Load Case 2 : IP+BW

From Node 10 20 30

Stress Intensity 84.03 110.25 120.47

All. Stress Intensity 136.47 136.47 136.47

Compressive Stress -84.03

All. Comp. Stress Fxa 122.57 122.57 72.31

S. I. Ratio 0.6158 0.8078 0.8827

Comp. Ratio 0.6856

Analysis of Load Case 3 : IP+BW+FW

From Node 10 20 30

Stress Intensity 87.53 111.37 123.68

All. Stress Intensity 136.47 136.47 136.47

Compressive Stress -80.53

All. Comp. Stress Fxa 122.57 122.57 72.31

S. I. Ratio 0.6414 0.8161 0.9063

Comp. Ratio 0.6570

Absolute Maximum of the all of the Stress Ratio's

0.9063
Results as per manual calculation shows higher stress in head than calculated by software

Element From : 30 to : 40 Governing Load Case 3 : IP+BW+FW Additional Results per Section 4.4, see 4.4.15

Nomenclature : L - Section Length mm Fxa - Allowable comp mem stress due to compression with lamc <= 0.15, MPa Fba - Allowable all comp mem stress due to bending moment, MPa Fva - Allowable shear stress when only shear is present, MPa Fha - Allowable hoop comp memb stress under ext pressure alone, MPa Fxha - Allowable axial comp w/hoop compression and lamc <= 0.15, MPa Fhxa - Allowable hoop comp w/axial compression and lamc <= 0.15, MPa Faha - Allowable axial comp w/hoop compression and lamc > 0.15, MPa Fbha - Allowable axial comp from bending w/hoop compression, MPa Fhba - Allowable hoop comp w/long compression due to moment, MPa Allowable Stress Results for Case 1 : IP From Lamc L Fxa Fba 10 0.093 5000 122 131 20 0.093 5000 122 141 30

Fva 62 62

Fha 70

Fxha 6895 6895 6895

Fhxa 122 122

Faha 6895 6895 6895

Fbha 6895 6895 6895

Fhba 6895 6895 6895

Allowable Stress Results for Case 2 : IP+BW From Lamc L Fxa Fba Fva 10 0.093 5000 122 131 62 20 0.093 5000 122 141 62 30

Fha 70

Fxha 6895 6895 6895

Fhxa 122 122

Faha 6895 6895 6895

Fbha 6895 6895 6895

Fhba 6895 6895 6895

Allowable Stress Results for Case 3 : IP+BW+FW From Lamc L Fxa Fba Fva Fha 10 0.093 5000 122 131 62 20 0.093 5000 122 141 62 70 30

Fxha 6895 6895 6895

Fhxa 122 122

Faha 6895 6895 6895

Fbha 6895 6895 6895

Fhba 6895 6895 6895

PV Elite is a trademark of Intergraph CADWorx & Analysis Solutions, Inc. 2012