Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
– Opportunity to move
up the value chain?
Thisuse
This report is solely for the report
ofisclient
solely for the use of client
personnel. Nopersonnel.
part of itNo maypart be
of itcirculated,
may be quoted, or reproduced
circulated, quoted, or reproduced for distribution outside the client
for distribution outside the client organization
organization without
without prior written prior
approval written
from approval
McKinsey & Company.from McKinsey & Company.
This material was used by ThisMcKinsey
material was&used Company during
by McKinsey an oral
& Company presentation;
during an oral it is not a complete record
of the discussion. presentation; it is not a complete record of the discussion.
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
E
96
99
93
95
98
01
4
97
00
20 2
19
03
9
0
vendor community
19
19
19
19
19
20
19
19
20
20
* Footnote
Source: Source Dataquest; Aberdeen group; McKinsey analysis
Gartner; 2
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
U.S. House
Sub-business
Committee
“Is your job next?”
“Can America Lose These – February 2003
Jobs and Still Prosper?”
* Footnote – July 2003
Source: Source 3
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
• Even if it survives,
moving up the value
chain will be difficult and
will take several years?
• Even if it survives,
moving up the value
chain will be difficult and
will take several years?
0.67
0.33
0.10
0.10
Offshoring sector
1 Estimated using the India offshored services industry case
2 Includes revenue accrued to the supplier industries less sales taxes, income taxes to employees and corporate
taxes
3 Includes income tax from labor employed in the offshored services sector and the supplier industries and
corporate tax on the supplier industries
4* Footnotesales tax on the supplier industries and revenue from the sale of power to offshored service providers
Includes
Source: Source:
Source McKinsey Global Institute 7
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
Number of workers
Millions, 2000-2015
Jobs Decline in
projected to working
go offshore population
due to aging
* Footnote
Source: Source:
Source U.S. Census; McKinsey Global Institute 8
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
1 Bureau of labor statistics defines mass layoffs as job loss actions leading to the displacement of 50 or more
workers by a given establishment during a 5-week period
2 Average 1996-99
3 Average 1989-2000
*
4 Footnote 2003-13
Average
Source: Source:
Source NBER; BLS; Kletzer; McKinsey Global Institute 9
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
* Footnote
Source: Source 10
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
• Even if it survives,
moving up the value
chain will be difficult and
will take several years?
Insurance
• Claims processing
Back
office
• Benefits administration
HR/ Admin
Business • Payroll processing
process
off-shoring
Support
Finance & • A/R and A/P management
services Acctg. • Reconciliation
• Database integration &
Research analytical services
• Secondary research
Outbound
• Telemarketing
• Collections (bucket one)
Voice • Telesales
Inbound
• Customer service
Customer • Technical support help desk
facing
• E-mail support
Non-voice • Fax responses
* Footnote • Live interaction (chat
room customer service)
Source: Source:
Source Vendor interviews, literature searches, vendor websites, McKinsey analysis 14
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
Original Factor Additi- Off-shore Consoli- Task Econo- Process New cost
cost cost onal location dation, reengi- mies of reengine- base
base savings telecom cost standar- neering scale ering
& manag- dization &
ement superior
costs skills
* Source:
Footnote Expert interviews; literature searches
Source: Source 16
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
Parent Midland
Bank
New
business
Transition • AmEx transitions internal • Columbia Bank & Trust • Management buyout of
processing unit into third- (later Synovus) transitions Midland Bank processing
party company (FDR) and internal credit-card unit following merger with
sells off majority ownership processing business into First Bank System (1984)
stake (1992) third-party company (1982) • IPO in 1986
• FDR merges with largest • CB&T sells 19% of • Grown to become leading
competitor and grows to company provider of technology and
become global leader in in IPO (1983) processing services for
transaction processing • TSYS grows to become the financial institutions
second largest processor in
the world
Value • $8 billion in market cap*, • $5 billion in market cap*, • $17 billion in market
creation growing at 31% CAGR in the growing at 5% CAGR in cap*, growing at 26%
U.S. last 5 years the last 5 years CAGR in the last 5 years
$ billion
** March
Footnote
1, 2002
Source: Sources:
Source
Hoovers; analyst reports; McKinsey analysis 18
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
Support • “Wait and watch” towards outsourcing • Increasing focus on rationalizing support
functions of business process through 2002 and function costs
early 2003 • Emergence of credible success stories and
• Numerous ongoing discussions in vendors for F&A and HR
2003 with vendors on finance & • Observed actions of competing players
accounting and HR offshoring • Many companies articulating “overall
aspiration” cutting across numerous
opportunities such as IT, BPO, R&D
Industrial
R&D Commercial Operations Support Functions
Operations
• Target • New production • Strategic and commercial busi- • Finance & Accounting
identification & development ness planning (pre-launch) • Information Technology
validation • Procurement • Product development and life • Human resources
• Lead generation • Planning and cycle management
• Legal
& optimization manufacturing • Pricing and health economics – Legal counseling
– Plant • Market a product (new and legacy) advocacy and litigation
• Preclinical/ maintenance • Customer relationship – Intellectual property
Toxicology – Quality management counseling
• Clinical management • Customer and consumer services • Sales force support
Development & – Process • Sales management
Trials control
• Logistics & distribution
• Supply chain
• After sales services
• Data management
Management • Performance
monitoring and
control
* Footnote
Source: Interviews; McKinsey analysis
Source: Source 20
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
* Footnote
Source: Source:
Source Interviews 21
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
• Even if it survives,
moving up the value
chain will be difficult and
will take several years?
% of total off
Model shored services Scale, scope and management model
• Captive operations 30% • Over 1600 FTEs
– Leverages brand, • Involved in high-end and low-medium-end,
– Important for regulatory proprietary/non proprietary services (e.g., A/C
issues reconciliation,A/C opening and closing, Ledger
– Preserves proprietary activities for credit cards, A/C planning and
process knowledge forecasting, Fraud and risk modeling)
• Third party – India 50% • Over 2000 FTEs across vendors such as
– Exclusive support to AMEX Spectramind, Daksh, EFunds
– Creates scale with minimal • Voice based customer support for credit card
investment operations
– Diversifies risk
– Competes with captive and
provides BCP
Unit of measure
DELETED PAGES
* Footnote
Source: Source 26
20030520DL-ZXE332(ITES, Board Pres.)(JS)-7
Unit of measure
3rd party provider 3rd party provider
1996 2002 2001 2002
BA set up captive BA sold captive to Conseco acquired Conseco sold
Warbug Pincus EXL Services as EXLServices to
captive center Oakhill Partners
Key events • Set up captive center • In April 2002, Warburg • Conseco acquired EXL • Conseco fully exited by
in 1996 as wholly Pincus, leading private in 2001 for about $ 52.6 selling out stake to
owned subsidiary to equity investor acquired million Oakhill Partners by Nov
reduce the airline's 70% majority stake 2002; however it has
operating cost • Strategy requires continued outsourcing its
• Processed about 80% investment to fully exploit transaction processing
of BA’s backend growing third party client • EXL Services named
operations base largest 3rd party IT-
• Largely focused on • Allotted $3 million to set enabled service company
airline clients up third business process in India in revenue terms
outsourcing (BPO) centre
by 2003
Rationale • BA sold out captive center to improve diversity of • Conseco was in financial distress due to
for sell- talent diminishing core business and sold out captive
out center to raise funds
Offshored • Customer complaints • Customer Care / CRM • Internet and voice • Critical Back Office
activities • Passenger/agent claims • Loyalty program support customer services Operations
• Tracking cargo • Revenue Accounting • Transaction processing
• Marketing program • Collections
development and
Revenue • 8.9 (FY1999) • management
16.0 (FY2001) • 25 • ~60
(USD mil.) (FY2001)
Employees
* •Footnote
Unavailable • 1,700 • 300 (FY2000) • 3,500
(FY2001) (FY2002)
Source:
Source: McKinsey,
Source Nasscom, press articles 30